New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.

[faithlilly]

Correct. And?

Martin Smith’s description.

‘As regards the description of the individual who was carrying the girl he said: Caucasian, around 175 to 180cm in height. ( 5ft 9in ) He appeared to be about 34/35 years old. He had a normal complexion, rather slim. His hair was short, in a normal male cut, brown in colour.’

[Mr Gray]

He’s only “the real culprit” in your opinion. To not add that caveat is surely libellous?

Hi Billy.....I used that phrase on purpose knowing it would offend some but make interesting debate and thats part of what this forum is about.  I did say i think they have found the real culprit...so its clear its opinion. To use the defence of "honest opinion" it salso necessary to iclude the raesons I think hes guilty which I did do in a previous post. The reasons have to be reasonable.

I wonder why you find this so offensive but when spam says ...its the parents wot dunnit...not  a murmur...when amaral says no abduction...the body was hidden..etc etc..not a murmur

[Anthro]

Martin Smith’s description.

‘As regards the description of the individual who was carrying the girl he said: Caucasian, around 175 to 180cm in height. ( 5ft 9in ) He appeared to be about 34/35 years old. He had a normal complexion, rather slim. His hair was short, in a normal male cut, brown in colour.’

Brückner:
Caucasian/tick
Height, 182 cm/tick
30 years old/tick
Normal complexion/tick
Slim/tick
Short, brown hair/tick

[Mr Gray]

Brückner:
Caucasian/tick
Height, 182 cm/tick
30 years old/tick
Normal complexion/tick
Slim/tick
Short, brown hair/tick

Smith didn't get a, good look at smithman... And he had his head bowed... Could very well be CB

[Robittybob1]

Smith didn't get a, good look at smithman... And he had his head bowed... Could very well be CB

Could be hundreds of people with those characteristics.

[faithlilly]

Brückner:
Caucasian/tick
Height, 182 cm/tick
30 years old/tick
Normal complexion/tick
Slim/tick
Short, brown hair/tick

6ft,
 34-35, some of the Smiths put him as old as 40
Hair not brown.

[Robittybob1]

6ft,
 34-35, some of the Smiths put him as old as 40
Hair not brown.

IMO Smithman does not equal Brückner.

[The General]

IMO Smithman does not equal Brückner.

Unless he's put on 4" in height in the interim. Might be a late developer.

[Brietta]

He’s only “the real culprit” in your opinion. To not add that caveat is surely libellous?

If you read the posts carefully you will see that no-one here has made any claim that Brueckner is the 'real culprit'.
I think either your interpretation skills are somewhat lacking or you are suggesting that I have libelled Brueckner merely for arguments sake?
If so you have just lost the argument.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Hi Billy.....I used that phrase on purpose knowing it would offend some but make interesting debate and thats part of what this forum is about.  I did say i think they have found the real culprit...so its clear its opinion. To use the defence of "honest opinion" it salso necessary to iclude the raesons I think hes guilty which I did do in a previous post. The reasons have to be reasonable.

I wonder why you find this so offensive but when spam says ...its the parents wot dunnit...not  a murmur...when amaral says no abduction...the body was hidden..etc etc..not a murmur

I believe if you don’t use the caveat that it is only opinion then certain statements are potentially libellous. It doesn’t matter who the accusation is aimed at. In this case there are reasonable grounds and enough public information to debate a whole host of possible scenarios.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

the caveat is “I have to agree it looks as though” - does this REALLY need pointing out.

My post was to Dave not Brietta.... and the phrase used was ....”it looks  as though the Germans with the help of SY have found the real culptrit.“. ..” I have to agree “ added by Brietta is obviously fine because it’s clearly opinion.

Now as you want a debate... let’s debate why CM ignored Smithman for so long. Did Smithman even get a mention at the LSE event (Jan 2008) . This may, imo, have potentially led to a positive ID on the German sex offender years ago. IMO Smithman is obviously not the German sex offender but there could be a link between the two.

[Vertigo Swirl]

My post was to Dave not Brietta.... and the phrase used was ....”it looks  as though the Germans with the help of SY have found the real culptrit.“. ..” I have to agree “ added by Brietta is obviously fine because it’s clearly opinion.

Now as you want a debate... let’s debate why CM ignored Smithman for so long. Did Smithman even get a mention at the LSE event (Jan 2008) .

"It looks as though" is opinion.  "I have to agree" is opinion.  You had a go at both Davel and Brietta without seeming to understand when an opinion is being expressed. 
As for Smithman, you're asking me enter a debate when I don't have any answer for you - I have absolutely no idea why, but I expect there is a perfectly logical reason.  Please note "I expect" is an opinion.

[The General]

"It looks as though" is opinion.  "I have to agree" is opinion.  You had a go at both Davel and Brietta without seeming to understand when an opinion is being expressed. 
As for Smithman, you're asking me enter a debate when I don't have any answer for you - I have absolutely no idea why, but I expect there is a perfectly logical reason.  Please note "I expect" is an opinion.

Sorry, are you Davel's PR person?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Sorry, are you Davel's PR person?

No, I am actually Davel.  I thought you knew this?

[The General]

No, I am actually Davel.  I thought you knew this?

I don't know what anything is in the gaff any more. Except Rob. Rob's the only constant.
Does anyone actually think this German animal is the culprit, aside from the polizei?