Do you think the German Police are going to lie and say Madeleine's 100% DNA was found in his camper van and the dogs alerted to it? Or maybe that he was seen with a black bag? Maybe they will say he had had a black out and he can't remember taking Madeleine? All of which the Portuguese Police presented to Kate, which was why she was advised to say nothing. Anyone would have taking the advice of lawyers in that position.
Quite obviously whether or not Kate responded to questions she was advised not to is neither here nor there. It is just an intensely boring device to further abuse her. She had nothing to hide. She had been co-operating with the police and answering all their questions for months.
A period during which she realised when she was made arguida that the Amaral investigation was not the least bit interested in Madeleine. All of their interest was in framing her or Gerry ~ but preferably her.
The fact that in interview when trying to deflect attention from the prime suspect Brueckner Amaral was at pains to insist on the idiocy that Gerry was Smithman.
Utter nonsense indicative of something. Either corruption or incompetence. I'm leaning towards the former.
Brueckner has the right to maintain his silence. But as Davel has pointed out, under competent interrogation it is likely that his silence on specific questions could prove to be compelling.