Author Topic: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.  (Read 2847215 times)

0 Members and 147 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14835 on: January 06, 2022, 01:28:50 PM »
Guys, guys, at least try to use a case that is remotely comparable:
The forensic evidence presented by the prosecution included Danielle's blood stains on Westerfield's jacket and on the floor of his motor home, Danielle's fingerprints in the motor home, hairs from the van Dam family dog on Westerfield's motor home bed comforter, hairs consistent with Danielle's on the sheet of his bed, and matching acrylic fibers found on Danielle's body and in Westerfield's home, among other evidence

...in other words, the prosecution didn't have to demonstrate how he abducted her, the forensic evidence alone was overwhelming, notwithstanding all of the other evidence compiled. If there had been an absence of forensics, then they would almost certainly have had to at least posit a plausible hypothesis as to how he got her out. But again, this is a poor choice of case to use as an example, as really the facts speak for themselves - the alarm, the proximity to their house, his camper van, etc, etc.

But an interesting read that, nonetheless.
The case will not come to trial without strong evidence to convict.  At the moment we don;t know if there is any or if there is what it might be, so the comparison remains quite valid.  If the case rested solely or mainly on the prosecution putting forward a plausible scenario of how he may have committed the crime but without any sort of strong supporting evidence then they may as well not bother trying him at all. 
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline The General

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14836 on: January 06, 2022, 01:39:55 PM »
The case will not come to trial without strong evidence to convict.  At the moment we don;t know if there is any or if there is what it might be, so the comparison remains quite valid.  If the case rested solely or mainly on the prosecution putting forward a plausible scenario of how he may have committed the crime but without any sort of strong supporting evidence then they may as well not bother trying him at all.
HCW has stated that there is a complete absence of forensic evidence, so not eggs with eggs.
With no body, which the stated case also had, and a lack of forensics, then it may well be crucial for the prosecution to show how they think CB got her out, got her away and what was likely to happen next (although if he did do it, then the means of access and egress were pretty obvious)
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14837 on: January 06, 2022, 01:41:46 PM »
HCW has stated that there is a complete absence of forensic evidence, so not eggs with eggs.
With no body, which the stated case also had, and a lack of forensics, then it may well be crucial for the prosecution to show how they think CB got her out, got her away and what was likely to happen next (although if he did do it, then the means of access and egress were pretty obvious)

The most important word in your post is... may

Offline The General

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14838 on: January 06, 2022, 01:47:33 PM »
The most important word in your post is... may
That's a caveat inserted for the pedants.
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14839 on: January 06, 2022, 01:51:50 PM »
HCW has stated that there is a complete absence of forensic evidence, so not eggs with eggs.
With no body, which the stated case also had, and a lack of forensics, then it may well be crucial for the prosecution to show how they think CB got her out, got her away and what was likely to happen next (although if he did do it, then the means of access and egress were pretty obvious)
Let's say (for argument's sake) that the only evidence is a video of him abusing Madeleine in his camper van.  Would it be necessary to demonstrate how he got her out of Apartment 5a in order to convict him of (at a minimum) abduction?
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Mr Gray

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14840 on: January 06, 2022, 01:54:18 PM »
That's a caveat inserted for the pedants.

I don't mind being referred to as, a pedant... To me it's someone who has, a critical eye for detail.
Amaral thinks they have to prove how abduction took place.. What a dunce

Offline Eleanor

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14841 on: January 06, 2022, 01:57:16 PM »
Do you know what Eleanor - I think it is perfectly possible there may be a jostling queue of individuals trying to get their oar in before someone beats them to it.

I think Breuckner had an accomplice involved in the abduction to whom Breuckner could pass the buck, himself not being the last person to see Madeleine alive.

Offline barrier

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14842 on: January 06, 2022, 02:03:57 PM »
I think Breuckner had an accomplice involved in the abduction to whom Breuckner could pass the buck, himself not being the last person to see Madeleine alive.

The key here is the friends of CB who it seems are willing to dob him in it, easy isn't it, he's behind bars Wolters says its him what better way than to keep putting the boot in, it'll come out if it ever reaches court, which isn't likely imo.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline The General

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14843 on: January 06, 2022, 02:05:18 PM »
Let's say (for argument's sake) that the only evidence is a video of him abusing Madeleine in his camper van.  Would it be necessary to demonstrate how he got her out of Apartment 5a in order to convict him of (at a minimum) abduction?
Isn't that my argument in a nutshell? In the case quoted I agreed that it wasn't necessary as the evidence was overwhelming - and I mean a total slam dunk by the way. The prosecution had no requirement to even go there, as 'reasonable doubt' was totally dispelled.
If we take your example, the same would apply. However there may still be a need to put some meat on the bones of how he disposed of her / killed her, if they were going for a murder charge, otherwise it could be argued that it was proven unequivocally that he abducted her, but not that he killed her (although I would venture that it's hardly a stretch).
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline barrier

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14844 on: January 06, 2022, 02:09:27 PM »
Let's say (for argument's sake) that the only evidence is a video of him abusing Madeleine in his camper van.  Would it be necessary to demonstrate how he got her out of Apartment 5a in order to convict him of (at a minimum) abduction?

Roll the argument on, did he take her out of 5a ?, some else could then be at least an accessory.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14845 on: January 06, 2022, 03:14:53 PM »
Roll the argument on, did he take her out of 5a ?, some else could then be at least an accessory.
Immaterial to securing a conviction of CB for abduction.  There would be no need to prove HOW only that he DID.  You could apply the "might have had an accessory" to the case I quoted.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline The General

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14846 on: January 06, 2022, 03:21:01 PM »
Immaterial to securing a conviction of CB for abduction.  There would be no need to prove HOW only that he DID.  You could apply the "might have had an accessory" to the case I quoted.
For abduction perhaps.
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14847 on: January 06, 2022, 03:21:24 PM »
Isn't that my argument in a nutshell? In the case quoted I agreed that it wasn't necessary as the evidence was overwhelming - and I mean a total slam dunk by the way. The prosecution had no requirement to even go there, as 'reasonable doubt' was totally dispelled.
If we take your example, the same would apply. However there may still be a need to put some meat on the bones of how he disposed of her / killed her, if they were going for a murder charge, otherwise it could be argued that it was proven unequivocally that he abducted her, but not that he killed her (although I would venture that it's hardly a stretch).
So you now agree then that as we don't know what the evidence is against Bruckner that my point stands and the comparison with the case quoted could be considered valid?
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline The General

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14848 on: January 06, 2022, 03:30:14 PM »
So you now agree then that as we don't know what the evidence is against Bruckner that my point stands and the comparison with the case quoted could be considered valid?
No. The cases are in no way comparable. As I stated, and I suppose will do again, we know HCW has stated that there is no forensic evidence - none. The case quoted had a veritable mountain of forensic evidence, so much so that the prosecutor didn't even need to explain 'how' - as clear cut a case as it gets probably.
HCW may well have to show 'how', as the evidence he will have will be almost entirely, if not completely, circumstantial.
The only parallels are that they involve a male suspect and a female child victim. Evidentially - well, I suppose whatever CB is charged with, if he's ever charged, will clear that up. There's phone records I suppose, albeit technology has moved on now and GPS on phones now can pinpoint the movements of a suspect to within a few feet, whereas in 2007 - a few thousand square feet with some decent triangulation data.
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #14849 on: January 06, 2022, 04:11:21 PM »
No. The cases are in no way comparable. As I stated, and I suppose will do again, we know HCW has stated that there is no forensic evidence - none. The case quoted had a veritable mountain of forensic evidence, so much so that the prosecutor didn't even need to explain 'how' - as clear cut a case as it gets probably.
HCW may well have to show 'how', as the evidence he will have will be almost entirely, if not completely, circumstantial.
The only parallels are that they involve a male suspect and a female child victim. Evidentially - well, I suppose whatever CB is charged with, if he's ever charged, will clear that up. There's phone records I suppose, albeit technology has moved on now and GPS on phones now can pinpoint the movements of a suspect to within a few feet, whereas in 2007 - a few thousand square feet with some decent triangulation data.
OK have it your way, I really can't be bothered to argue the toss anymore.  Of course you know best as usual.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".