Author Topic: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013  (Read 181231 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #270 on: September 03, 2013, 12:18:29 PM »
1) That Amaral's claims were false.

Amaral claimed Madeleine was driven dead in the Renault.  That is demonstrably false

Amaral claimed he contradicted Prior on the forensic results.  If the McCanns have Prior's report, that will established demonstrably false

Amaral claims the Smiths saw Gerry whisking Madeleine past their noses.  The final PJ report says Gerry was in the Tapas Restaurant at the time of the Smith sighting.

    2) That, in addition, the claims had caused enormous psychological and behavioural damage to the couple which deserved financial compensation.

I can understand why a dunderhead like Blacksmith would find it incomprehensible that a couple whose daughter has been aducted would suffer pshchological damage.  But you aren't that thick, are you?

    3) And that the "search for Madeleine" had been, and was continuing to be, damaged by the inference from Amaral's "thesis" that the child was dead.

Again I can see that a dunderhead like Blacksmith would be unable to comprehend that a book which says Madeleine is definitely dead would harm the search for Madeleine.

But you aren't that thick, are you?

Offline Albertini

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #271 on: September 03, 2013, 12:48:03 PM »
1) That Amaral's claims were false.

Amaral claimed Madeleine was driven dead in the Renault.  That is demonstrably false

Amaral claimed he contradicted Prior on the forensic results.  If the McCanns have Prior's report, that will established demonstrably false

Amaral provides the evidence he had at the time to show this. He uses the defence that was used against him that he thought it was true.

He also has other officers on the case at that time who will testify that they were all of the same opinion, just as they did in the book case.

Amaral also provides the ruling of the orignal book banning case where the judges said his was a valid interpretation of the same facts as the final report.

Amaral claims the Smiths saw Gerry whisking Madeleine past their noses.  The final PJ report says Gerry was in the Tapas Restaurant at the time of the Smith sighting.

Amaral provides the ruling of the orignal book banning case where the judges said his was a valid interpretation of the same facts as the final report.

 
   2) That, in addition, the claims had caused enormous psychological and behavioural damage to the couple which deserved financial compensation.

I can understand why a dunderhead like Blacksmith would find it incomprehensible that a couple whose daughter has been aducted would suffer pshchological damage.  But you aren't that thick, are you?

Amaral provides all the photos that are out there and transcripts from a variety of interviews which strongly refute this.

    3) And that the "search for Madeleine" had been, and was continuing to be, damaged by the inference from Amaral's "thesis" that the child was dead.

Again I can see that a dunderhead like Blacksmith would be unable to comprehend that a book which says Madeleine is definitely dead would harm the search for Madeleine.

But you aren't that thick, are you?

The search had stopped as a result of the PJ's final report, which did not subscribe to Amaral's thesis, so  Nothing to do with Amaral's thesis. The search has resumed through SY's review, again nothing to do with Amaral's thesis.

Not only no proof but direct evidence to the contrary.
« Last Edit: September 03, 2013, 12:49:43 PM by Albertini »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #272 on: September 03, 2013, 01:34:03 PM »
Amaral provides the evidence he had at the time to show this. He uses the defence that was used against him that he thought it was true.

I'm no expert on Portuguese law , just as albertini isn't. Can Amaral use such a simple defence? I think not. Even if he did think it was true he certainly should have reconsidered once the final report showed no evidence against the MCCanns. But he didn't he just went on libelling them. His defence that this was merely a thesis is contradicted by the fact that he called his book the "Truth". if the case is so cut and dried in his favour, why does he look so ill.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #273 on: September 03, 2013, 01:35:52 PM »
Can't be bothered to take your post apart comprehensively, even though I could.

I'll settle for this:

    Amaral claimed Madeleine was driven dead in the Renault.  That is demonstrably false

    Amaral claimed he contradicted Prior on the forensic results.  If the McCanns have Prior's report, that will established demonstrably false


And you reply:


Amaral provides the evidence he had at the time to show this. He uses the defence that was used against him that he thought it was true.

Let's see.

Amaral was sacked from the investigation for incompetence in October.

John Lowe wrote his early report in early September.

Amaral had full access to Prior's report while he was still coordinator and simply had to read it.  Either he didn't, or he ignored what it said.

Similarly, Amaral will have had Lowe's report, available to read, while he was still coordinator.

What's his excuse?
« Last Edit: September 03, 2013, 01:38:18 PM by ferryman »

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #274 on: September 03, 2013, 01:37:35 PM »
In writing a book accusing the McCanns of criminal activity, Amaral has breached their rights under article 37 of the Portuguese constitution. 

Offline Carana

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #275 on: September 03, 2013, 01:48:52 PM »
Just found this on an old thread.

http://www.dgsi.pt/jtrl.nsf/33182fc732316039802565fa00497eec/8ae65886ef70827180257b63003d7a75?OpenDocument


Thanks for that. The cases aren't identical, but the legal summary on Murat's case looks quite interesting.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #276 on: September 03, 2013, 02:02:39 PM »
In writing a book accusing the McCanns of criminal activity, Amaral has breached their rights under article 37 of the Portuguese constitution.

And surely it could be argued that the balancing part of the constitution, guaranteeing the right of free speech to inform, is a very specific antithesis of misinform, which Amaral's book emphatically and unreservedly does.

Couldn't it?

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #277 on: September 03, 2013, 02:18:24 PM »
The guarantee of freedom of speech and expression, enshrined in many constitutions, is designed to prevent the state and institutions from surpressing dissent or critisism.

It is emphatically not designed to allow unrestrained comment on fellow citizens.  Who have the right to reputation and a good name. 

 

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #278 on: September 03, 2013, 02:25:56 PM »
The guarantee of freedom of speech and expression, enshrined in many constitutions, is designed to prevent the state and institutions from surpressing dissent or critisism.

It is emphatically not designed to allow unrestrained comment on fellow citizens.  Who have the right to reputation and a good name. 

 

Thank you ...

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #279 on: September 03, 2013, 02:32:04 PM »
I am so sorry, Ferryman - I should have added "and here endeth the sermon..."

My humble apologies.  8)--))


icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #280 on: September 03, 2013, 06:29:01 PM »
I am so sorry, Ferryman - I should have added "and here endeth the sermon..."

My humble apologies.  8)--))

Given your knowledge of Portuguese law,  I wonder could you tell me  ...  Should Amaral win this libel case,  would he be in a position to counter-sue the McCanns for damages incurred by him as a consequence of a false libel claim  ? 

Offline Angelo222

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #281 on: September 04, 2013, 11:11:04 AM »
It isn't looking too good at the moment.  First the court removes the embargo on the Amaral book and then the McCanns offer to settle out of court.  And now they are being advised not to attend the court in person.  Is this a build up to something else?

De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #282 on: September 04, 2013, 12:36:01 PM »
Given your knowledge of Portuguese law,  I wonder could you tell me  ...  Should Amaral win this libel case,  would he be in a position to counter-sue the McCanns for damages incurred by him as a consequence of a false libel claim  ?

If he considers that he has suffered damage, then yes, of course. 

Offline faithlilly

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #283 on: September 04, 2013, 01:04:09 PM »
If he considers that he has suffered damage, then yes, of course.

I think there's a very strong possibility that's exactly what he'll feel.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Cudge

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #284 on: September 04, 2013, 01:44:19 PM »
It isn't looking too good at the moment.  First the court removes the embargo on the Amaral book and then the McCanns offer to settle out of court.  And now they are being advised not to attend the court in person.  Is this a build up to something else?

I didn't realise The McCanns had made an offer to Amaral to settle out of court. Perhaps you could direct me to the source of this fact