Innocentman came forward in 2007!

[Mr Gray]

No sightings then at all in thatcase

 
Scuppers all circumstantial evidence for abduction

You really don't have a clue...do you think that SY are basing the abduction theory purely on the smith sighting?
As Redwood has said...smithman may be innocent..........and probably is imo......makes not a scrap of difference to the abduction theory

[Anna]

I'm a bit out of touch(been away) and trying to catch up and I'm sure this has been discussed.....
A man(Dad) carrying a child after having dinner or drinks at OC Where are the Mums ? Seems strange to me there were two separate men alone carrying a child around the same time. Probably just me though!

[Eleanor]

Does it really matter if there was no sighting at all?

[Mr Gray]

Does it really matter if there was no sighting at all?

absolutely not...doesn't make abduction more or less likely either way

[Mr Gray]

The night is young. Dave may well be thinking our way by morning

I would be more than happy to change my mind if evidence came to light

[AnneGuedes]

Was there any mention of a car in Crimewatch, davel? Aren't you going completely off message? You're jettisoning both sightings now? >@@(*&)

Why do you bother with the mention of a car, Lyall ? If there's none, create it !

[Lyall]

I would be more than happy to change my mind if evidence came to light

How much evidence do you need of reputation management? Yet you deny that.

[Redblossom]

I'm a bit out of touch(been away) and trying to catch up and I'm sure this has been discussed.....
A man(Dad) carrying a child after having dinner or drinks at OC Where are the Mums ? Seems strange to me there were two separate men alone carrying a child around the same time. Probably just me though!

And no buggies....what parents of toddlers do not use buggies!

[Redblossom]

Statistics say it is possible. Does a porker on an Airbus count?

LOL

Err no not really, well, not at all actually to be precise!

[AnneGuedes]

I'm a bit out of touch(been away) and trying to catch up and I'm sure this has been discussed.....
A man(Dad) carrying a child after having dinner or drinks at OC Where are the Mums ? Seems strange to me there were two separate men alone carrying a child around the same time. Probably just me though!

The mum might stay with the other kids at home, or feeling tired or... separate parents.
You're right, the probability that one father having carried his child on top of his stretched arms and keeping silent though destroyed parents scream on all possible international media for a clue about a man carrying a child on his stretched arms is almost nul.
Now 2...

[Mr Gray]

How much evidence do you need of reputation management? Yet you deny that.

reputation management?...yes evidence of reputation management exists

[Anna]

And no buggies....what parents of toddlers do not use buggies!

True RB I think they rented them out, but I don't think the mcCanns had them as they carried Madeiline home when she was overtired on that fateful day

[Mr Gray]

The mum might stay with the other kids at home, or feeling tired or... separate parents.
You're right, the probability that one father having carried his child on top of his stretched arms and keeping silent though destroyed parents scream on all possible international media for a clue about a man carrying a child on his stretched arms is almost nul.
Now 2...

could we have that in english

[Redblossom]

True RB I think they rented them out, but I don't think the mcCanns had them as they carried Madeiline home when she was overtired on that fateful day

I was talking about the parents taking their kids home from the creche at night not the mccanns ie innocentman and or smithman

[Anna]

I was talking about the parents taking their kids home from the creche at night not the mccanns

Sorry I was also talking about the parents. I was trying to say not all parents used buggies because McCanns didn't