Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[Carana]

Adverbs at the end of sentences? I prefer verbs at the end as in Latin and German; it adds to the suspense and excitement.

In which version of the English language would the title even be deemed correct?

[Carana]

I couldn't possibly say it might start a flame war 

 

[slartibartfast]

I fully expect Slartibartifast to step in here and reprimand you for pre-judging the videos and not allowing others to make up their own minds - not.

You seem to be getting very upset about this, I merely pointed out that Carana stated a logical fallacy in dismissing an argument based on who was proposing it.

[stephen25000]

Just glimpsed a tad of number 4, where he accuses Mrs. Fenn of colluding with the mccanns.

Have a look at the end of video 4 when he summaries.

I am surprised Sadie is not a fan of him.

[Mr Gray]

Just glimpsed a tad of number 4, where he accuses Mrs. Fenn of colluding with the mccanns.

Have a look at the end of video 4 when he summaries.

I am surprised Sadie is not a fan of him.

some people are so stupid...confirms everything I have thought

[slartibartfast]

some people are so stupid...confirms everything I have thought

Who are you directing that at?

[Alfred R Jones]

You seem to be getting very upset about this, I merely pointed out that Carana stated a logical fallacy in dismissing an argument based on who was proposing it.

Very upset?!  Don't be daft (oops, ad hominem, self-reported, prolly worth about 10 points ;-) )

[Alice Purjorick]

You seem to be getting very upset about this, I merely pointed out that Carana stated a logical fallacy in dismissing an argument based on who was proposing it.

Quite erroneously, on his part, in my case as I have made no comment on the videos except for the 4 hour running time.......................I fell asleep in JFK which was marginally shorter as I recall.

[Carana]

You seem to be getting very upset about this, I merely pointed out that Carana stated a logical fallacy in dismissing an argument based on who was proposing it.

One person's genetic fallacy is another's back-check as to overall credibility. ;)

If this had been a programme produced by Panorama or similar, it would have had more a priori credibility than one produced by a well-known conspiracy theorist, IMO.

Not that one is necessarily totally accurate nor the other one total rubbish.

I'm happy to wade through a few more minutes of it...

[Alfred R Jones]

Quite erroneously, on his part, in my case as I have made no comment on the videos except for the 4 hour running time.......................I fell asleep in JFK which was marginally shorter as I recall.

So you didn't say that you didn't need to watch the video to know it was rubbish?  I must have hallucinated that bit then!

[Alice Purjorick]

So you didn't say that you didn't need to watch the video to know it was rubbish?  I must have hallucinated that bit then!

I was parrot phrasing one of the witnesses at the libel trial and taking the p**s as is my wont.
Now it Saturday. Time for us upper class to join the lower and go out and get spiffled and chase the crumpet while the middle class intelligentsia look on in disapproval and jealousy.
Catch you raters

[Carana]

Right.

So...

"The True Story of Madeleine McCann - When Madeleine Died?

it doesn't actually start until nearly 2 mins in.

Someone I presume to be Richard Hall is standing in front of a monument to St Gonçalo de Lagos, with fish decorating the top part of it.

Ok.

Then he gets on to the media as "information prostitutes". For some reason, he doesn't mention the PT tabloids.

OK.

Then he moves on the Polish guy 'holidaying in PdL'.

No he wasn't.

I'm up to 5 mins so far.

[Eleanor]

Right.

So...

"The True Story of Madeleine McCann - When Madeleine Died?

it doesn't actually start until nearly 2 mins in.

Someone I presume to be Richard Hall is standing in front of a monument to St Gonçalo de Lagos, with fish decorating the top part of it.

Ok.

Then he gets on to the media as "information prostitutes". For some reason, he doesn't mention the PT tabloids.

OK.

Then he moves on the Polish guy 'holidaying in PdL'.

No he wasn't.

I'm up to 5 mins so far.

The less said about St. Goncalo the better.  Especially since Mr. Hall can't even pronounce his name.

[slartibartfast]

Right.

So...

"The True Story of Madeleine McCann - When Madeleine Died?

it doesn't actually start until nearly 2 mins in.

Someone I presume to be Richard Hall is standing in front of a monument to St Gonçalo de Lagos, with fish decorating the top part of it.

Ok.

Then he gets on to the media as "information prostitutes". For some reason, he doesn't mention the PT tabloids.

OK.

Then he moves on the Polish guy 'holidaying in PdL'.

No he wasn't.

I'm up to 5 mins so far.

I think I would give up...

[Eleanor]

If I had to suffer 35 minutes then so should everyone else.