What Happened To Madeleine McCann? - by Ian Horrocks.

[Robittybob1]

The dogs weren't able to tell us how strong the scent was - strong, medium or light so we are unable to tell from their actions whether or not she was wearing shoes at the time.

Amy Tierney asked Kate if Madeleine's shoes were still there and she records in her statement  that they were present.

[Robittybob1]

No verification Rob, means precisely that.

Second, she wasn't there when Madeleine disappeared, was she.

1 and 2, by the other scenarios.

Oh, by the way, what photos are there of Madeleine holding this cuddlecat ?

Second, she wasn't there when Madeleine disappeared, was she.  so she didn't do it then - thanks for confirming your belief of that.

[John]

The dogs weren't able to tell us how strong the scent was - strong, medium or light so we are unable to tell from their actions whether or not she was wearing shoes at the time.

Both Portuguese search dogs independently indicated the same route while searching for Madeleine which is a positive result and highly significant.  Neither dog followed the route taken by Tannerman.

[John]

i have read where bodies have been weighed  down  in the ocean or  water  by rocks or bricks hence  where  bodies are never  found because the body cant float  sorry to be graphic

And it is recorded that there were boats out that night.

[John]

Second, she wasn't there when Madeleine disappeared, was she.  so she didn't do it then - thanks for confirming your belief of that.

Very true, she was sat at the tapas restaurant all night.

[Mr Gray]

Well, that's abduction out of the window.

Abduction wasn't and isn't out of the window
Horrocks has been there and along with other experts have said how easy abduction would have been
Even sil has said abduction is the most likely in the latest newspaper article

[Robittybob1]

And it is recorded that there were boats out that night.

Were the skippers questioned?

[Eleanor]

And it is recorded that there were boats out that night.

So which one of The Tapas 9 could that have been?  And where would they have found a boat?  Unless you think they had one lined up ready

Or perhaps it was Robert Murat.

[Miss Taken Identity]

These articles by rent-a-cops are irrelevant. These retired cops are paid by the editors of the newspapers to write what they are told, just like the journalists do nowadays.  No matter what the opinion of the person they will never be allowed to write something which shows the McCanns in a bad light or even in the slightest suggest that they could be responsible for the disappearance of their daughter.

Indeed and that about sums it up. Perhaps that is why there was such a huge 10 year anniversary media blast,which was unplanned(?)apparently &%+((£
After Amaral Won!, the media had to report it and this opened up a whole new audience,questioning the Tapas and their behaviour.... rushing in PR -Reputation Management.

[stephen25000]

Second, she wasn't there when Madeleine disappeared, was she.  so she didn't do it then - thanks for confirming your belief of that.

The truth is, none of us know what actually happened.

There is absolutely no verification of Kate Mccann's accounts of events.

Her comments outside the court, don't make sense.

We have our beliefs, or if you prefer theories.

[stephen25000]

Very true, she was sat at the tapas restaurant all night.

Only from the time she arrived there.

Hardly all night.

Barely a hour and a half in fact.

Oh, by the way, is there any evidence at all, other than the night Madeleine disappeared, Kate McCann actually checked on the children on any other night ?

Remembering the claim, both the mccanns made, that they regularly checked on the children.

[Eleanor]

Only from the time she arrived there.

Hardly all night.

Barely a hour and a half in fact.

Lots of time to plan a cover up then.

[John]

Were the skippers questioned?

These were row boats operated by lone fishermen.  They can be seen often out at night.  As to questioning, unsure?

[Miss Taken Identity]

Only from the time she arrived there.

Hardly all night.

Barely a hour and a half in fact.

It would have been easier if the Tapas had a'child checkig' schedule they stuck to.... alas this wasn't a consideration for their 'listening' checks. How remis. I wonder why they bothered with that system as they knew their children were prone to wake up, and the mobile ones could wonder and get themselves into difficulties of sorts. Hence why Kate left a door unlocked. Hence why a woke and wondered scenario is so hated and denied because it would apportion blame to the mother.  Over to you Ian... want to change your mind again?

[Robittybob1]

The truth is, none of us know what actually happened.

There is absolutely no verification of Kate Mccann's accounts of events.

Her comments outside the court, don't make sense.

We have our beliefs, or if you prefer theories.

So would you care to explain your theory then instead of just rubbishing mine.
You say "there is absolutely no verification of Kate Mccann's accounts of events" yet I repeatedly tell you that Gerry and Amy Tierney do confirm Kate's account.

Her comments do make sense to me.

Put up your theory for scrutiny please?