UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 03:13:33 PM

Title: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 03:13:33 PM
Robert Murat has recently voiced an opinion that is shared by others  ... that a reconstruction of the night's events would be useful to the investigation

In what way  might a reconstruction be helpful  ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 03:24:06 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 03:28:31 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?   
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 03:37:46 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 03:50:57 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?   
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 03:54:17 PM
Robert Murat has recently voiced an opinion that is shared by others  ... that a reconstruction of the night's events would be useful to the investigation

In what way  might a reconstruction be helpful  ?


I'm wondering if some quotes were actually in context in terms of the general conversation.

Some of the statements taken at the time (and search reports) are so vague as to be virtually useless.

I understand his point that the police should be searching in the area from which she disappeared - but it's the same old Catch-22 situation (unless anyone knows any different).

The investigation can't be reopened unless there are credible new leads, but they are unlikely to fall into a waiting police dormant case desk officer's lap (presuming he's even open-minded), unless the inquiry (and thus the investigation) is reopened.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 04:09:37 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

Could you elaborate on this conclusion a bit further?

Quote
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

I'm going by witness statements

Gerry left the tapas bar to do his check at just before 9.05pm

His walk to the apartment, entering through the patio, seeing the children's bedroom door open wider than he left it, going into his and Kate's room first to see if Madeleine was there,  going back to the children's room,  veryfying that all three children were asleep, spending a moment looking at Madeleine and thinking how beautiful she was,  going to the toilet, leaving the apartment closing the patio doors, and meeting Jez Wilkins juast as he exits the little gate at thje bottom of the steps

Allowing just two minutes for all that to have happened,  we would have Gerry on the pavement meeting Wilkins at 9.07pm

Jane Tanner is walking up the hill at 9.10pm  ( according to her witness statement )  when she passes Gerry and Jez, and sees the abductor up ahead, crossing the road

That allows the abductor a very generous 3 minute window of opportunity   ( a reconstruction might allow him even less time than that )
 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 04:16:30 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.


Six years later seems totally implausible. People will be relying either on really vague memories, or their statements (which the police could do just as easily).

There may have been some dubious people around the area at that time, who may not have given statements at all, or whose statements may not appear in the files for certain reasons.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 04:31:42 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.


Six years later seems totally implausible. People will be relying either on really vague memories, or their statements (which the police could do just as easily).



I agree that there is no reason for anyone to be brought back to Portugal,  and that their witness statements could be followed by police personel in their roles

I do think it would be helpful if Scotland Yard were to propose just such a reconstruction
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 04:34:29 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?
Icabodcrane, even Mr McCann said this wasn't plausible and deduced the abductor was already inside when he got in.
I can understand Robert M would want his name really cleaned of any doubt. Many people don't know that he couldn't be freed from his arguido statute before the case was shelved.
I wonder why he dropped the case against sustained accusations of sneaking around on the fatal night, that were in fact the origin of his troubles. Proving the man the 3 witnesses saw wasn't him shouldn't be so difficult (I believe the witnesses saw a man speaking fluently English and Portuguese).
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 04:39:04 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?
Icabodcrane, even Mr McCann said this wasn't plausible and deduced the abductor was already inside when he got in.
I can understand Robert M would want his name really cleaned of any doubt. Many people don't know that he couldn't be freed from his arguido statute before the case was shelved.
I wonder why he dropped the case against sustained accusations of sneaking around on the fatal night, that were in fact the origin of his troubles. Proving the man the 3 witnesses saw wasn't him shouldn't be so difficult (I believe the witnesses saw a man speaking fluently English and Portuguese).

What case against the 3 witness's? There never was one!

Like the case Amaral said Murat was taking against Jane Tanner, I expect, Lies.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 04:41:12 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.


Six years later seems totally implausible. People will be relying either on really vague memories, or their statements (which the police could do just as easily).



I agree that there is no reason for anyone to be brought back to Portugal,  and that their witness statements could be followed by police personel in their roles

I do think it would be helpful if Scotland Yard were to propose just such a reconstruction
More than "helpful", "imperative". Who wants it now ? Robert M ? The McCann ? The PGR ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 04:46:00 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

Could you elaborate on this conclusion a bit further?

Quote
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

I'm going by witness statements

Gerry left the tapas bar to do his check at just before 9.05pm

His walk to the apartment, entering through the patio, seeing the children's bedroom door open wider than he left it, going into his and Kate's room first to see if Madeleine was there,  going back to the children's room,  veryfying that all three children were asleep, spending a moment looking at Madeleine and thinking how beautiful she was,  going to the toilet, leaving the apartment closing the patio doors, and meeting Jez Wilkins juast as he exits the little gate at thje bottom of the steps

Allowing just two minutes for all that to have happened,  we would have Gerry on the pavement meeting Wilkins at 9.07pm

Jane Tanner is walking up the hill at 9.10pm  ( according to her witness statement )  when she passes Gerry and Jez, and sees the abductor up ahead, crossing the road

That allows the abductor a very generous 3 minute window of opportunity   ( a reconstruction might allow him even less time than that )
 

Are you allowing for the possibility that the abductor may already have entered the apartment prior to Gerry's check or is that an impossibility in your view?

Gerry walked through the living room  ( no abductor there ).  He checked his and Kate's bedroom looking for Madeleine  ( no abductor there ).  He used the bathroom  ( no abductor there )

Gerry himself concedes that if an abductor was in the apartment whilst he did his check,  then he was probably hiding behind the door of the children's bedroom

Another good reason to do a reconstruction ...  it would demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it,  and if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine   
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 04:47:29 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?
Icabodcrane, even Mr McCann said this wasn't plausible and deduced the abductor was already inside when he got in.
I can understand Robert M would want his name really cleaned of any doubt. Many people don't know that he couldn't be freed from his arguido statute before the case was shelved.
I wonder why he dropped the case against sustained accusations of sneaking around on the fatal night, that were in fact the origin of his troubles. Proving the man the 3 witnesses saw wasn't him shouldn't be so difficult (I believe the witnesses saw a man speaking fluently English and Portuguese).

What case against the 3 witness's? There never was one!

Like the case Amaral said Murat was taking against Jane Tanner, I expect, Lies.
If someone tells the police you were in a certain place where a horrible crime had been perpetrated whereas you were elsewhere and if that person confirms this to the police in your presence, you just don't mind ? May be martyrdom is your vocation.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 04:51:03 PM
if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine
Not visible, I think it was possible. Now not smelling, not breathing ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 04:53:28 PM
Whilst we're doing the (hypothetical) reconstruction how would you tackle the Smith sighting?  Would a reconstruction be able to demonstrate or clarify anything with that regard?

A reconstruction would clarify the time the abductor had left  the apartment assuming he had made his way directly to the location where the Smiths saw him

That would be helpful, wouldn't it ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 04:54:10 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.


Six years later seems totally implausible. People will be relying either on really vague memories, or their statements (which the police could do just as easily).



I agree that there is no reason for anyone to be brought back to Portugal,  and that their witness statements could be followed by police personel in their roles

I do think it would be helpful if Scotland Yard were to propose just such a reconstruction

Quote
icabodcrane

Re: The reconstruction
« Reply #2 on: April 26, 2013, 02:19:28 AM »


There should have been a reconstruction early in the investigation   ... not with  'actors'  in the crime-watch style that the McCanns prefered  ...  but a genuine reconstruction for police purposes only,  with the  real people involved

That it didn't happen is just one of the mistakes the Portuguese police  must take responsibility for
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 04:54:53 PM

If someone tells the police you were in a certain place where a horrible crime had been perpetrated whereas you were elsewhere and if that person confirms this to the police in your presence, you just don't mind ? May be martyrdom is your vocation.

Sorry, what exactly are you referring to?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:00:42 PM
I can't imagine.

The purpose of reconstructions is to prompt memories, encourage people to come forward with new leads, generate new lines of inquiry.

Now, 6 years after Madeleine's abduction, it's all too late.

I think that is the purpose of  televised  ( crime-watch style ) reconstructions, I am talking about a police reconstruction, the purpose of which is to aid the investigation

How might a reconstruction be helpful in that regard  ?

It wouldn't, it doesn't and it can't.


Six years later seems totally implausible. People will be relying either on really vague memories, or their statements (which the police could do just as easily).



I agree that there is no reason for anyone to be brought back to Portugal,  and that their witness statements could be followed by police personel in their roles

I do think it would be helpful if Scotland Yard were to propose just such a reconstruction

Quote
icabodcrane

Re: The reconstruction
« Reply #2 on: April 26, 2013, 02:19:28 AM »


There should have been a reconstruction early in the investigation   ... not with  'actors'  in the crime-watch style that the McCanns prefered  ...  but a genuine reconstruction for police purposes only,  with the  real people involved

That it didn't happen is just one of the mistakes the Portuguese police  must take responsibility for

There is no anomaly in my posts

Early in the investigation, when most of those involved were actually still  in  Portugal, of course a reconstruction with real people would have been preferable ...  with events still fresh in their minds they may recalled something not thought of previously

Now,  six years later,  hauling them all back would have no point at all,  and  any reconstruction could be adequately  carried out by police personel following witness statements 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:03:22 PM
it could even be done on a computer using the witness statements - which I believe SY have done.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:06:12 PM
it could even be done on a computer using the witness statements - which I believe SY have done.

Holmes is specifically designed for that sort of determination.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:06:19 PM
Quote
when most of those involved were actually still  in  Portugal

staff, waiters, holiday makers, local people etc.

Or just tapas group?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:07:25 PM
it could even be done on a computer using the witness statements - which I believe SY have done.

Scotland Yard could propose a reconstruction, using police personel,  done in real life and in actual time

What harm would it do to at least try  that method  ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 05:09:12 PM
Quote
Another good reason to do a reconstruction ...  it would demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it,  and if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine   


No need to demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it.

There's ample room to hide behind the door, and the wardrobe makes it even more possible, as it sticks out across the doorway. 

(http://i307.photobucket.com/albums/nn315/itsonlyme_08/Gonc%20crap/Wardrobe.jpg)
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:10:31 PM
it could even be done on a computer using the witness statements - which I believe SY have done.

Scotland Yard could propose a reconstruction, using police personel,  done in real life and in actual time

What harm would it do to at least try  that method  ?

I think that we all know that the reconstruction was not aimed at anything other than fitting up the McCanns. It was never going to happen as I pointed out from day one because there is no method of forcing people to travel to police enquiries abroad against their will- god the [ censored word ]s wasted so much bandwidth trying to prove that the Tapas 9 could be forced to return.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:13:59 PM
it could even be done on a computer using the witness statements - which I believe SY have done.

Scotland Yard could propose a reconstruction, using police personel,  done in real life and in actual time

What harm would it do to at least try  that method  ?

The authorities in Portugal would have to agree.

Do you know that they have not asked?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:15:06 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:17:03 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:18:12 PM
so you just want it done by police (as actors)

fine let them get on with it - you do not know if SY have suggested that or not.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:19:17 PM
In fact I would go so far as to saying that YOU don't know if it has already been done do you?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:22:43 PM
I am sure the police experts will decide.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 05:24:19 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

What is there to *lose* by doing one? 20 years after the murder of Stephen Lawrence the police did yet another one. In any cold case, everything possible should be tried as no one can foresee what might come out of it.

There is nothing to gain.

You certainly won't shed light on how Gerry and Jez Wilkins (as they undoubtedly did!) missed seeing Jane Tanner when she passed them, because everyone present will be cued and knowing what to expect,rendering impossible a faithful reproduction of what happened on the night.

Complete waste of time ...
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:24:25 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

I agree that the 'call'  for the McCanns and their friends to brought back to Portugal to do a reconstruction has a threatening air to it

At this point I see no purpose at all in even asking them to return  ....  in fact, I believe asking Kate to relive that night would be callous and heartless in the extreme

That is not what I have been talking about at all  ...  my question was,  how might a reconstruction  (  using police personel )  be helpful to the investigation

I have pointed out ways in which I think it might 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:25:37 PM
fine speculate away.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:31:34 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:33:49 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

Because it would be meaningless. Everything can be done cheaply by computer.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 05:36:29 PM

If someone tells the police you were in a certain place where a horrible crime had been perpetrated whereas you were elsewhere and if that person confirms this to the police in your presence, you just don't mind ? May be martyrdom is your vocation.

Sorry, what exactly are you referring to?
I'm referring to three of the TP stating they saw Robert M around the G5A on the third of May and later (in July I think) sustaining it in front of him in spite of his denying.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:37:22 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:37:50 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

how do you know a real one, using police as actors, hasn't been done?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:39:16 PM
I must have missed the SY twitter and blog updates on progress of their investigation. They probably have a FB group too.

Maybe DCI plod posts videos with music eh?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:42:11 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

how do you know a real one, using police as actors, hasn't been done?

I don't and I never said it hadn't

acknowledged but icabodcrane seems to think differently
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 05:42:25 PM
I must have missed the SY twitter and blog updates on progress of their investigation. They probably have a FB group too.

Maybe DCI plod posts videos with music eh?

No I don't  @)(++(*

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:45:00 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.

You may be correct  (  although in what way  'flexibility'  woud be useful in a fact driven re-enactment, escapes me )

Nevertheless,  it remains the case that a reconstruction using real people, in real time,  is the one avenue of investigation that has not been utilised

For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:48:25 PM
Quote
In what way  might a reconstruction be helpful  ?

you don't know if one has been done (in the terms that you have specified)

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:49:16 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.

You may be correct  (  although in what way  'flexibility'  woud be useful in a fact driven re-enactment, escapes me )

Nevertheless,  it remains the case that a reconstruction using real people, in real time,  is the one avenue of investigation that has not been utilised

For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

WHat would it do that a computer model would not. The original people are not going to be there. They have a list of timings and routes which all have massive potential error factors. The ideal method of dealing with such information is a computer, not people walking round in the real world. A computer can walk the people infinite numbers of times; the most you would get from a reconstruction would be half a dozen variants.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 05:49:45 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.

You may be correct  (  although in what way  'flexibility'  woud be useful in a fact driven re-enactment, escapes me )

Nevertheless,  it remains the case that a reconstruction using real people, in real time,  is the one avenue of investigation that has not been utilised

For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

WHat would it do that a computer model would not. The original people are not going to be there. They have a list of timings and routes which all have massive potential error factors. The ideal method of dealing with such information is a computer, not people walking round in the real world. A computer can walk the people infinite numbers of times; the most you would get from a reconstruction would be half a dozen variants.

I wonder if they would be able to find the key witness, that went into hiding, after fleeing Portugal?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:50:48 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.

You may be correct  (  although in what way  'flexibility'  woud be useful in a fact driven re-enactment, escapes me )

Nevertheless,  it remains the case that a reconstruction using real people, in real time,  is the one avenue of investigation that has not been utilised

For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

WHat would it do that a computer model would not. The original people are not going to be there. They have a list of timings and routes which all have massive potential error factors. The ideal method of dealing with such information is a computer, not people walking round in the real world. A computer can walk the people infinite numbers of times; the most you would get from a reconstruction would be half a dozen variants.

I wonder if they would be able to find the key witness, that went into hiding, after fleeing Portugal?

Only if they ran the program in the Twilight Zone.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 05:51:00 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 05:52:57 PM
Exactly, but for some reason, without even knowing - someone thinks it hasn't been done.

A computer generated reconstruction can never replace a real physical one imo, how can the two even be compared

You are right. A computer generated one is both more flexible and more accurate.

You may be correct  (  although in what way  'flexibility'  woud be useful in a fact driven re-enactment, escapes me )

Nevertheless,  it remains the case that a reconstruction using real people, in real time,  is the one avenue of investigation that has not been utilised

For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

WHat would it do that a computer model would not. The original people are not going to be there. They have a list of timings and routes which all have massive potential error factors. The ideal method of dealing with such information is a computer, not people walking round in the real world. A computer can walk the people infinite numbers of times; the most you would get from a reconstruction would be half a dozen variants.

I wonder if they would be able to find the key witness, that went into hiding, after fleeing Portugal?

Only if they ran the program in the Twilight Zone.

But he was their trump card, Debunker  ?{)(**
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 05:54:51 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:00:54 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 06:06:08 PM
The Mccanns were never in favour of a reconstruction in early 2008, that much is loud and clear from all their interviews on the matter, neither were any of their friends, you have to wonder why they did not do anything that might help, turn every stone, as they professed all the time, rather seek guarantees in advance if it could help, demand that arguido status were lifted before they might consider it, the arrogance, non cooperation and control freakery is breathtaking to the extreme

JMHO you understand

Possibly because they had reason to believe that the Portuguese investigation was a crock of shit and they were being fitted up to take the blame.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:06:17 PM
The Mccanns were never in favour of a reconstruction in early 2008, that much is loud and clear from all their interviews on the matter, neither were any of their friends, you have to wonder why they did not do anything that might help, turn every stone, as they professed all the time, rather seek guarantees in advance if it could help, demand that arguido status were lifted before they might consider it, the arrogance, non cooperation and control freakery is breathtaking to the extreme

JMHO you understand

ah you see the real reason for this thread now.

you are wrong as usual redblossom
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 06:07:26 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)

I said  some members  ...  I am aware that you have not raised objections

I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainty, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:10:25 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:12:22 PM
or are you saying, not a reconstruction but an attempt to replicate what may have happened?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 06:13:32 PM
The Mccanns were never in favour of a reconstruction in early 2008, that much is loud and clear from all their interviews on the matter, neither were any of their friends, you have to wonder why they did not do anything that might help, turn every stone, as they professed all the time, rather seek guarantees in advance if it could help, demand that arguido status were lifted before they might consider it, the arrogance, non cooperation and control freakery is breathtaking to the extreme

JMHO you understand

I think you will find the McCann's were quite willing to return. It was cancelled by the Rebelo, because the friends weren't going.
If you can find an email from the McCann's saying they were not returning, I'll eat my hat!

The reconstruction is cancelled
Letter to Stuart Prior from Paulo Rebelo

27th May 2008 10.25 a.m.

Table of Contents: Vol XVI Page 4354

From : Paulo Fernando Gaspar Rebelo.
Date : 27th May 2008 10.25 a.m.
To : "Prior Stuart"
Subject : Re-enactment cancelation

(( Inserted here is an attachment labelled : Anulação da reconstitutição.doc....))

Dear Stuart:

As agreed, here I send the Prosecutor's decision regarding the re-enactment cancelation. In a few words, it says that due the absence of the witnesses Matthew Oldfield, Rachael Mampilly, Russell O'Brien and Jane Tanner, there are no conditions to perform the diligence.

I kindly request you to urgently transmit this decision to each one of the witnesses (Matthew, Rachael, Russell, Jane, Dianne, David, Fiona and Jeremy).

Thank you, again, for your cooperation.

Best regards
Paulo Rebelo
CSIC

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id279.html
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 06:15:52 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did 

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:16:13 PM
The Mccanns were never in favour of a reconstruction in early 2008, that much is loud and clear from all their interviews on the matter, neither were any of their friends, you have to wonder why they did not do anything that might help, turn every stone, as they professed all the time, rather seek guarantees in advance if it could help, demand that arguido status were lifted before they might consider it, the arrogance, non cooperation and control freakery is breathtaking to the extreme

JMHO you understand

ah you see the real reason for this thread now.

you are wrong as usual redblossom

You are whistling in the wind, the thread is about a reconstruction full stop, there are at least three types under discussion,  and no, I am not wrong *as usual* but behappy to think so

see my earlier post

Quote
are you saying, not a reconstruction but an attempt to replicate what may have happened?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 06:18:41 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 06:23:36 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.

Well yes,  that's exactly what I am talking about  ...  a reconstruction of events that are claimed to have  happened that night

It is claimed that an abductor struck just after Gerry left the apartment, and that he was seen making off with Madeleine by Jane  a few minutes later

That  'event'  should be re-enacted to see if it would have been possible in the few minutes allowed
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 06:25:09 PM
DCI they couldnt refuse as arguidos so there cannot be any email showing they did so, their tv interviews *prove* the idea was an anathema to them, get it now?

No, I know that, and they didn't refuse. So how can anyone say, they refused to go back?.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 06:34:00 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)
Has anyone here e-mailed SY and got an answer ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 07, 2013, 06:39:00 PM
[

Gerry walked through the living room  ( no abductor there ).  He checked his and Kate's bedroom looking for Madeleine  ( no abductor there ).  He used the bathroom  ( no abductor there )

Gerry himself concedes that if an abductor was in the apartment whilst he did his check,  then he was probably hiding behind the door of the children's bedroom

Another good reason to do a reconstruction ...  it would demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it,  and if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine
[/quote]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What about the kitchen - the entrance is opposite Madeleine's bedroom door.  Could he have hidden in there, where Gerry didn't look?

Also Jez Wilkins said he was talking to GM for 3 to 5 mins - if it was nearer 5 mins before Jane passed them by then that gives a longer time for the abductor  - say 4 mins before JT saw him.

There may have been 2 abductors and Madeleine could have been handed over the wall to the other one in the carpark.  That would cut down the distance to the carpark entrance and also explain why Madeleine's head was on the L/h side of the man Jayne saw.

I honestly don't see how a physical reconstruction would be helpful.  Apart from Gerry - everyone else could only give approximate times for their movements.   Normally to be a couple of minutes adrift  here and there in a reconstruction wouldn't matter but in this case precise timing is vital and they could not give exact times.  Also they would need to remember exactly what speed they walked at - how long exactly they spent checking etc.   They can't be expected to remember all that with precision.     Therefore there is no way they could guarantee a faithful reproduction of their movements.

On the other hand SY have the expertise and the equipment to conduct a forensic analysis of the timelines given, and no doubt could key in all the possible variables.   They are satisfied that there was a clear opportunity for Madeleine to have been abducted.   If it was not possible, then I don't think they would confirm, as they have, that it was.


 


Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 07, 2013, 06:41:07 PM
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)
Has anyone here e-mailed SY and got an answer ?

What for?, its nothing to do with anyone but SY.

I think they have enough lunatic's emailing them, to last a lifetime.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 06:41:54 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

I agree that the 'call'  for the McCanns and their friends to brought back to Portugal to do a reconstruction has a threatening air to it

At this point I see no purpose at all in even asking them to return  ....  in fact, I believe asking Kate to relive that night would be callous and heartless in the extreme

That is not what I have been talking about at all  ...  my question was,  how might a reconstruction  (  using police personel )  be helpful to the investigation

I have pointed out ways in which I think it might

Six years later...

If you had been there as a tourist that night, would you remember exactly where you were at every moment? Could you be sure that your memory of an after-dinner walk, or drink, was THAT night or at the important time?

Or even as a casual staff employee?

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 06:48:59 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

Which could be done cheaper and better using Holmes.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 06:51:21 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

The timeframe was certainly short - if JT's man was actually carrying Madeleine. But I can't see why the actual people need to go there yet again in order to do a timeline reconstruction. That can't be too difficult to reconstruct virtually these days, surely?


NB The Met seem to have done one (cf Redwood). Presumably, they're not totally dense, and would have tried out various versions.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 07, 2013, 06:54:28 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

Which could be done cheaper and better using Holmes.

Could you tell us more about 'Holmes' please Db?

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 06:57:00 PM
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the [ censored word ]s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 07, 2013, 06:59:53 PM
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Thankyou.  Have to go now - but will look at it later.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 07:09:37 PM
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 07:17:46 PM
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.

Hamster driven Amstrad Spectrum complete with tape recorder input?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Carana on May 07, 2013, 07:29:10 PM
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.

Hamster driven Amstrad Spectrum complete with tape recorder input?

I have no doubt that many decent cops did their best, but there was simply no system in place, let alone training.

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 07:34:57 PM
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

I agree that the 'call'  for the McCanns and their friends to brought back to Portugal to do a reconstruction has a threatening air to it

At this point I see no purpose at all in even asking them to return  ....  in fact, I believe asking Kate to relive that night would be callous and heartless in the extreme

That is not what I have been talking about at all  ...  my question was,  how might a reconstruction  (  using police personel )  be helpful to the investigation

I have pointed out ways in which I think it might

Six years later...

If you had been there as a tourist that night, would you remember exactly where you were at every moment? Could you be sure that your memory of an after-dinner walk, or drink, was THAT night or at the important time?

Or even as a casual staff employee?
I remember exactly where I was, who was around, which time it was when I heard that JFK had been shot. I remember who said it, what I was going to do, what I was doing before.
And I was a little girl.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 07:40:34 PM


What for?, its nothing to do with anyone but SY.

I think they have enough lunatic's emailing them, to last a lifetime.
Oh it just passed my mind because they e-mailed me. They had read something I wrote on the Web and they wanted me to develop.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 08:47:20 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.

Well yes,  that's exactly what I am talking about  ...  a reconstruction of events that are claimed to have  happened that night

It is claimed that an abductor struck just after Gerry left the apartment, and that he was seen making off with Madeleine by Jane  a few minutes later

That  'event'  should be re-enacted to see if it would have been possible in the few minutes allowed

yes - you want a police officer (or someone) to pretend to be an abductor to see if it "works"

that is not a reconstruction
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 08:50:05 PM
Quote
I agree that there is no reason for anyone to be brought back to Portugal,  and that their witness statements could be followed by police personel in their roles

did the abductor make a statement?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 08:54:39 PM
Quote
   icabodcrane
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?   
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 08:54:49 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.

Well yes,  that's exactly what I am talking about  ...  a reconstruction of events that are claimed to have  happened that night

It is claimed that an abductor struck just after Gerry left the apartment, and that he was seen making off with Madeleine by Jane  a few minutes later

That  'event'  should be re-enacted to see if it would have been possible in the few minutes allowed

yes - you want a police officer (or someone) to pretend to be an abductor to see if it "works"

that is not a reconstruction

What harm would it do to try ?

If there is any chance at all that it could lead to a clearer picture of what was possible that night, and what was not,  surely it is worth doing  ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 08:59:14 PM
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.

Well yes,  that's exactly what I am talking about  ...  a reconstruction of events that are claimed to have  happened that night

It is claimed that an abductor struck just after Gerry left the apartment, and that he was seen making off with Madeleine by Jane  a few minutes later

That  'event'  should be re-enacted to see if it would have been possible in the few minutes allowed

yes - you want a police officer (or someone) to pretend to be an abductor to see if it "works"

that is not a reconstruction

What harm would it do to try ?

If there is any chance at all that it could lead to a clearer picture of what was possible that night, and what was not,  surely it is worth doing  ?

going nto debumker mode - where did I say harm?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:07:00 PM
Its a fact none of the tapas group want or ever wanted to or will ever want do a reconstruction with any police, just their own little enid blyton one, whats there to discuss unless and until SY ask them

Their blank refusal raises alot of questions, first being why did they lie when theysaid they would do anything to raise every stone, seems they stampes the stones down here

wrong - but it has been said so many times
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:08:32 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:12:47 PM
Its a fact none of the tapas group want or ever wanted to or will ever want do a reconstruction with any police, just their own little enid blyton one, whats there to discuss unless and until SY ask them

Their blank refusal raises alot of questions, first being why did they lie when theysaid they would do anything to raise every stone, seems they stampes the stones down here

wrong - but it has been said so many times

its not wrong, its the truth, all nine AVERSE to it, not rocket science, proof of pudding will now be if SY ask them to, lets see shall we?

they were willing to go back until it was explained that it was to prove there innocence.

like this thread - nothing to do with finding a missing child.

Pathetic
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: registrar on May 07, 2013, 09:16:11 PM
Whilst we're doing the (hypothetical) reconstruction how would you tackle the Smith sighting?  Would a reconstruction be able to demonstrate or clarify anything with that regard?

 UNLIKELY the PJ didn't even cotton on to the fact that the Smiths were in a different judiciary area to the McCanns

rendering their papers immaterial
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 09:17:12 PM
until it was explained that it was to prove there innocence.

Was it really said ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:19:59 PM
until it was explained that it was to prove there innocence.

Was it really said ?

yes
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 07, 2013, 09:30:10 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

I think it is important to demonstrate whether or not it was possible for the  man who Jane saw to be the abductor, in the limited time frame allowed

If a re-enactment demonstrated that it was  not possible, for instance  (  that there simply wasn't enough time for the abductor to have carried out the crime in the time allowed )  then everyone  ( including the McCanns )   could eliminate that scenario, and concentrate on the next three quarters of an hour  ...  when an abduction really was possible

On the other hand, If it was demonstrated that it was entirely possible for the man Jane saw to have been the abductor,  (  because it had been established that there was, indeed, enough time to carry out the crime ) then the McCanns could be reassured that the man they have been highlighting as the abductor, almost certainly was

I really do believe that such a re-enactment would be helpful in that regard
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
Post by: registrar on May 07, 2013, 09:32:38 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
Post by: registrar on May 07, 2013, 09:34:01 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow

You've not had a lovely dinner - ever

is that your beef?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
Post by: registrar on May 07, 2013, 09:37:27 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow

Did you get so overexcited again inyour rush to  attack you forgot to sayanything? LOL

in English please
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:38:17 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow

Quote
icabodcrane
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 09:39:44 PM
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

I think it is important to demonstrate whether or not it was possible for the  man who Jane saw to be the abductor, in the limited time frame allowed

If a re-enactment demonstrated that it was  not possible, for instance  (  that there simply wasn't enough time for the abductor to have carried out the crime in the time allowed )  then everyone  ( including the McCanns )   could eliminate that scenario, and concentrate on the next three quarters of an hour  ...  when an abduction really was possible

On the other hand, If it was demonstrated that it was entirely possible for the man Jane saw to have been the abductor,  (  because it had been established that there was, indeed, enough time to carry out the crime ) then the McCanns could be reassured that the man they have been highlighting as the abductor, almost certainly was

I really do believe that such a re-enactment would be helpful in that regard

Quote
icabodcrane
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Chinagirl on May 08, 2013, 12:13:26 AM
The Scotland Yard review has already established that an abduction was possible in the time frame allowed, so Icabod's reasons for wanting a real life reconstruction would be a pointless and expensive exercise.

Neither an in situ reconstruction nor a computer generated model can establish who the abductor was, what happened to Madeline or where she is now. 
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 08, 2013, 12:39:31 AM
The Scotland Yard review has already established that an abduction was possible in the time frame allowed, so Icabod's reasons for wanting a real life reconstruction would be a pointless and expensive exercise.

Neither an in situ reconstruction nor a computer generated model can establish who the abductor was, what happened to Madeline or where she is now.

I don't think Scotland Yard have done that at all !

They have said  (  through Andy Redwood )  that there was an opportunity for abduction that night  ...  and we must all agree with that ...  but they most certainly have  not  said that Jane Tanner saw the abductor, and that an abduction may have occured between the time Gerry last saw Madeleine and Jane Tanner made her sighting of a  man carrying a child

That is misleading, and simply not true
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Chinagirl on May 08, 2013, 01:56:19 AM
Have it your way, but my second point about not being able to identify the abductor or ascertain what happened to Madeleine stands.

I suspect that the only reason the [ censored word] have insisted on calling for a reconstruction for the last six years is because they hope for more ammunition to cast suspicion on the McCanns and their friends, especially Jane Tanner.  Let the reconstruction deviate by one millimetre or one minute from one of the statements and there would be cries of, "See - lies!!" from the [ censored word ] brigade.

Scotland Yard have said that an abduction by a stranger is the most likely scenario, and that there was time for such an occurrence, and that should be good enough for most people.  Establishing whether or not Tanner saw the abductor is pretty irrelevant at this stage, given the lack of identification, or what happened after she saw that particular figure.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 08, 2013, 03:00:57 AM
Have it your way, but my second point about not being able to identify the abductor or ascertain what happened to Madeleine stands.

I suspect that the only reason the [ censored word] have insisted on calling for a reconstruction for the last six years is because they hope for more ammunition to cast suspicion on the McCanns and their friends, especially Jane Tanner.  Let the reconstruction deviate by one millimetre or one minute from one of the statements and there would be cries of, "See - lies!!" from the h..... brigade.

Scotland Yard have said that an abduction by a stranger is the most likely scenario, and that there was time for such an occurrence, and that should be good enough for most people.  Establishing whether or not Tanner saw the abductor is pretty irrelevant at this stage, given the lack of identification, or what happened after she saw that particular figure.

Who cares whether a reconstruction would be grist to the mill of  '[ censored word]'   ...  is there a chance ...  just a chance that it might  help find Madeleine ?

That is all that really matters, surely  ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Chinagirl on May 08, 2013, 04:54:09 AM
It can't "help Madeleine" for the reasons I have outlined.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Angelo222 on May 08, 2013, 08:42:39 AM
One does wonder which version of their timelines (one, two or three) and which versions of their statements (to many to count) did (smiler) Redwood load into that computer.

Let's not forget that the McCann's have already carried out a reconsruction (sort of) where they tried to explain the claimed checks of Tanner and Oldfield (why) the best that they could come up with in Tanner's case was that it didn't matter that Wilkins didn't see her walk by and if only Oldfield had just walked a few steps further into the room blah blah blah, they even linked Tanner's sighting to that of the Smiths to the extent of altering the carrying style as reported by the Smith family members to that of Tanner's claimed style.. now why would they do that?  Which part of this reconstruction was to help find Madeleine?

Bottom line is that the timelines and statements for that evening are lies pure and simple!

There will always be discrepancies and inconsistencies in any timeline and especially when nine people are involved.  The initial time-line was put together in haste and at a time of high anxiety in an attempt to assist the Portuguese authorities so attempting to use it by armchair sleuths some six years later is laughable.  Bottom line is Peter, you haven't got a baldy clue mate.    8(0(*
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Angelo222 on May 08, 2013, 09:18:46 AM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 09:51:36 AM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

For what reason would she take such a massive risk for someone she hardly knew and had only met half a dozen  times or so previously -  over a period of 3/4years.   The Paynes were her friends - not the McCanns.    IMO She would have to be mentally deranged to put her family at such risk - and not the normal intelligent person she clearly is.    Your claim makes no sense to me whatsoever.  Would you care to elaborate?




     


Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Angelo222 on May 08, 2013, 10:04:06 AM
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: peter claridge on May 08, 2013, 10:10:05 AM
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*
That would be the scripted acting scene you're refering to there.  The bigger picture folks.. always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Angelo222 on May 08, 2013, 10:17:56 AM
I do concede that a reconstruction which attempts to portray Gerry McCann as the man carrying a child through the streets of PdL (having changed his clothes in order to do so and then back again) in the time frame would be a valuable exercise in order to silence once and for all the "sceptics" who think Gerry has superhuman powers.

Gerrys presence in and around the tapas bar from 9pm onwards is established from the evidence of at least a dozen people.  There only ever was one person missing from the table for any length of time and that was Russell.  Gerry never left the Ocean Club grounds except for the short walk up the street to the apartment gate and even then his presence is evidenced by Jez Wilkins and Jane Tanner.

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 10:25:19 AM
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.

Thank you to Astro for the translation.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Chinagirl on May 08, 2013, 10:47:48 AM
I imagine that every issue raised above could be simulated with many variables by a computer programme (HOLMES), and has already been undertaken by Scotland Yard.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 10:54:10 AM
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*

Exactly Angelo, and talking about the 'bigger picture'  - surely if something had happened to Madeleine and the McCanns decided to dispose of her body, then they could have easily come up with a better plan.   All they had to do was

go to dinner as usual,
say nothing to anyone,
wait until the middle of the night -
dispose of the body, and go to bed.
 
Then in the morning call the police and say they woke up to find the front door ajar and their daughter gone.
 
Job done, and no need for all the convoluted plotting and planning involving the rest of the group and the dangerous risks that the involvement of so many other people could cause.

(And that's just one scenario I can think of - and I'm no rocket scientist)




 

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 10:55:25 AM
Who would be brave enough to attempt a reconstruction of Peter Voisey's crime?

He strolled into a ground-floor flat while the whole family was in, entered the bathroom, enticed an 8 year old girl out of the bath, out of the flat, into the freezing night air, into his car and away.

The first the family knew was when they heard a screech of tires as the car sped away ...

A predatory paedophile was convicted today of raping a six-year-old girl he snatched from her bath two days after Christmas Day last year.
Peter Voisey, 35, was convicted at Newcastle crown court of abducting the girl and putting her through two serious sexual assaults in a car before dumping her, naked, in a freezing cold lane 20 minutes later.

Judge David Hodson warned Voisey he would be jailed for life or for an indefinite period when he sentences him on December 1. The judge said sentencing was being adjourned for the preparation of a sex offender assessment.

The judge said the sentence would be decided after "the court can have a proper assessment of the risk you pose to the public at large".

Voisey, also known as Smith, had snatched the girl from the bathroom of the ground floor flat in North Tyneside where she lived, after getting in through an unlocked back door.

After today's verdict, a statement from the girl's mother said the attack was "every mother's nightmare".

She said: "My little girl was in the bath in her own home within earshot of everyone else in the flat, the back door was shut and I'd only just left the bathroom to go to another room when she was snatched.

"It's every mother's nightmare to think your children aren't safe in their home. You wouldn't think you would have to lock all your doors this early in the evening to protect your children from anyone entering your home uninvited."

She praised police for their work on the case. Some had questioned whether the attack had happened but the police always took the report of the attack seriously, and detectives knew of injuries the girl had suffered and the proximity of the unlocked door to the bathroom.

Swabs were taken and tiny amounts of DNA were recovered from the victim. The samples were too small to provide an exact match, but Voisey was found later to have a similar DNA profile to the elements recovered.

Crucially, a footprint found in the bathroom in the girl's two-bedroom downstairs flat partially matched his Diadora trainer. Mobile phone mast analysis also proved his handset was in the North Tyneside area, and not at his home in Blyth, Northumberland, at the time of the offence. His alibis, at first that he was away from the area, then that he was buying cannabis in North Tyneside, did not stand up.

The jury also heard a life-long friend recall Voisey confiding he wanted to "do something" to a child after the pair drove past two youngsters aged around six and eight.

The prosecution successfully applied for bad character evidence under the 2003 Criminal Justice Act to be put before the jury, who were told of a similar sex attack on a vulnerable 12-year-old stranger at a swimming bath.

Voisey had been jailed for three years, reduced on appeal to two years, for the 2001 attack, the jury in the latest case heard.

He told the jury at Newcastle crown court that he was sorry for the previous attack and was "utterly ashamed ... disgusted with myself".

He had denied having a sexual interest in children, and, weeping in the witness box, told the jury he had "most definitely not" attacked the six-year-old.

But the jury rejected his evidence and convicted him today on the 14th day of the trial.

The court also heard that Voisey, who spent much of his childhood in care, had carried out two break-ins involving a sexual element.

Detective Chief Inspector Jim Napier said: "There is no doubt that Voisey is a serial sexual predator who preys on young and vulnerable children."

He said his view was that Voisey had been in the area looking for somewhere to burgle when he went into the flat and came across the girl.

"As the evidence built up against him, we became more and more convinced that he had committed this crime, which I can only describe as horrific. He was a total stranger to this family, he violated their home, he kidnapped a little girl to satisfy his own perverted desires and he has shown neither guilt nor remorse. Today's conviction should ensure that he is not in a position to harm anyone else for many years to come."

DCI Napier said, given the circumstances, the girl was making good progress in her recovery from the attack. "She proved to be a first-class witness, especially considering her age, and the traumatic experience she had been through. "I was convinced very early on that the girl's account of what happened to her was not only credible, but also entirely feasible, and the investigation proceeded on that basis."

He said that the sex offenders' register was a very important tool in helping to catch Voisey. He said he could not comment on the supervision Voisey had been under at the time of the attack as the council was reviewing this.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 11:11:58 AM
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:13:27 AM
I imagine that every issue raised above could be simulated with many variables by a computer programme (HOLMES), and has already been undertaken by Scotland Yard.

You imagine ? In other words you have no idea really.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 11:16:30 AM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:17:11 AM
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.

Thank you for reminding me to credit the translator Anne. I have edited my post accordingly.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:20:52 AM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.

But an opinion nevertheless that carries as much weight as your own.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 11:21:44 AM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:27:32 AM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:49:19 AM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

The AG also made it clear that the reconstruction could have uncovered new evidence and who's to say how that would have impacted on his opinion.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: insider on May 08, 2013, 11:54:01 AM

Exactly Angelo, and talking about the 'bigger picture'  - surely if something had happened to Madeleine and the McCanns decided to dispose of her body, then they could have easily come up with a better plan.   All they had to do was

go to dinner as usual,
say nothing to anyone,
wait until the middle of the night -
dispose of the body, and go to bed.
 
Then in the morning call the police and say they woke up to find the front door ajar and their daughter gone.
 
Job done, and no need for all the convoluted plotting and planning involving the rest of the group and the dangerous risks that the involvement of so many other people could cause.

(And that's just one scenario I can think of - and I'm no rocket scientist)


A very sensible post Benice.

The McCanns are intelligent sensible individuals who could have put together a much better plan had they chosen to do so.  Their reaction when they realised that Madeleine had probably been taken was typical of bereaved parents and something which is nigh impossible for two people to fake at the same time. The sceptics will always claim otherwise but then again that is why they are called sceptics.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 11:54:57 AM
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.

Thank you for reminding me to credit the translator Anne. I have edited my post accordingly.
Good, Faithlilly ! From now on and since the "unprofessional" translations have been if not depreciated at least treated here like "amateur" work,  I find it a good idea to credit the translators whenever the files are quoted. However "off with her head" is one of them (not Astro), translating was a heavy job.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: peter claridge on May 08, 2013, 11:59:46 AM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.
Where does biase come into it?  I simply do as others do, that is read available information from the files (untranslated timelines) and form an opinion; my opinion is that the Tapas group are lying about events of that evening.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 12:05:51 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.
It's only too bad (in a long run perspective) he wasn't able to conclude this after the implementation of a reconstruction that would "eventually dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents", don't you think ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 12:12:18 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

The AG also made it clear that the reconstruction could have uncovered new evidence and who's to say how that would have impacted on his opinion.

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!
You made the question and answered it, Martha !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: peter claridge on May 08, 2013, 12:13:19 PM
Peter, I see you have decided not to expand on your previous bold statements - any  reason why not?
Timelines and statements Martha it's all there!
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:14:03 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.

But an opinion nevertheless that carries as much weight as your own.

I rarely express any opinion other than that we know too little about most of this car crash to have any valid opinion other than 'I don't know.'
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:14:50 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

That the Tapas 7 and the McCanns do disagree does carry weight!
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:15:43 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

He did not conclude that.

He concluded that there was no INDICATION of a crime- a very different matter!
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:18:49 PM
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.
Where does biase come into it?  I simply do as others do, that is read available information from the files (untranslated timelines) and form an opinion; my opinion is that the Tapas group are lying about events of that evening.

Do you feel that Madeleine could have been abducted?

Do you feel that Madeleine could have woke and wandered?

Do you believe that the McCanns or Tapas 7 could have harmed her?

Do you believe that they could have concealed her body after an accident>

Which of those is a possibility?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:20:22 PM

Exactly Angelo, and talking about the 'bigger picture'  - surely if something had happened to Madeleine and the McCanns decided to dispose of her body, then they could have easily come up with a better plan.   All they had to do was

go to dinner as usual,
say nothing to anyone,
wait until the middle of the night -
dispose of the body, and go to bed.
 
Then in the morning call the police and say they woke up to find the front door ajar and their daughter gone.
 
Job done, and no need for all the convoluted plotting and planning involving the rest of the group and the dangerous risks that the involvement of so many other people could cause.

(And that's just one scenario I can think of - and I'm no rocket scientist)


A very sensible post Benice.

The McCanns are intelligent sensible individuals who could have put together a much better plan had they chosen to do so.  Their reaction when they realised that Madeleine had probably been taken was typical of bereaved parents and something which is nigh impossible for two people to fake at the same time. The sceptics will always claim otherwise but then again that is why they are called sceptics.

That deserves a thread of its own so that it can be fully addressed.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 01:07:25 PM
Do you feel that Madeleine could have been abducted?

Do you feel that Madeleine could have woke and wandered?

Do you believe that the McCanns or Tapas 7 could have harmed her?

Do you believe that they could have concealed her body after an accident>

Which of those is a possibility?
No

No

Don't know how she died

Yes

There- that's your bias- you only believe one possible cause, therefore all your contentions are affected by this bias.

Thank you for helping me demonstrate this simple fact.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 01:32:37 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

He did not conclude that.

He concluded that there was no INDICATION of a crime- a very different matter!
Not at all. As Martha says, the PGR shelved the case because no evidence was found that the arguidos RM, GMC and KMC had perpetrated any crime.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 01:45:45 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

That the Tapas 7 and the McCanns do disagree does carry weight!

No it doesn't, or at least shouldn't.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: insider on May 08, 2013, 02:01:45 PM
Peter, I see you have decided not to expand on your previous bold statements - any  reason why not?
Timelines and statements Martha it's all there!

So lets see >>>  which statement says they were lying??

I believe the term evidence is lost on Peter somehow.   @)(++(*
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 02:15:16 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

That the Tapas 7 and the McCanns do disagree does carry weight!

No it doesn't, or at least shouldn't.

It does and it should.

It carries weight because they have the final decision.

It should carry weight because it is important that the power of the state be limited to allow individual liberty.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 02:17:27 PM
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

He did not conclude that.

He concluded that there was no INDICATION of a crime- a very different matter!

Better tell the BBC that you know better then Deb http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7516585.stm

Read the actual document, not a summary of it in the media.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 02:22:26 PM
Regarding 'no evidence of any crime':

Therefore, after all seen, analysed and duly pondered, with all that is left exposed, it is determined:
 
a) The archiving of the Process concerning arguido Robert James Queriol Eveleigh Murat, because there are no indications of the practise of any crime under the dispositions of article 277 number 1 of the Penal Process Code;
 
b) The archiving of the Process concerning arguidos Gerald Patrick McCann and Kate Marie Healy, because there are no indications of the practise of any crime under the dispositions of article 277 number 1 of the Penal Process Code.
 
Article 277 number 3 of the Penal Process Code is to be fulfilled.
 
Under article 214 number 1 item a) of the Penal Process Code, the coercion measures that have been imposed on the arguidos are declared extinct.


in: Processo 201/07.0 GALGS - Volume XVII - pages 4639-4649 (Public Prosecutor's Archiving Dispatch)

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id136.html#adi9
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 02:31:28 PM
"indications" translates "indícios" which means "evidence".
In the case of RM : "de ter praticado qualquer crime" = that he practised any crime
In the case of GMC and KMC : "de terem (plural) praticado qualquer crime" = that they practised any crime
Got it now ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 02:59:05 PM
The mistake of assuming a reconstruction would shed light on how Jane passed Jez and Gerry without either noticing her is that one thing you can't recreate is the circumstances and knowledge (or absence thereof) of any of the participants in the original.  In a reconstruction, all the key "players" will be keyed up, knowing what's going to happen, knowing that someone, (whether Jane or a standin) will pass them.

Given that, how can you reliably test what actually occurred on the night, when all the "real" participants in "real" time were deprived of that hindsight?  You can't.

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 08, 2013, 03:39:04 PM
"indications" translates "indícios" which means "evidence".
In the case of RM : "de ter praticado qualquer crime" = that he practised any crime
In the case of GMC and KMC : "de terem (plural) praticado qualquer crime" = that they practised any crime
Got it now ?

Ah, thank you once again Anne.  It's as I thought, though I would still like to see a link to the original document if you have one.

I think Anne should have a word with Astro, as he/she says the same, as Debunker posted from the McCann files.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

Therefore, after all seen, analysed and duly pondered, with all that is left exposed, it is determined:

a) The archiving of the Process concerning arguido Robert James Queriol Eveleigh Murat, because there are no indications of the practise of any crime under the dispositions of article 277 number 1 of the Penal Process Code;

b) The archiving of the Process concerning Arguidos Gerald Patrick McCann and Kate Marie Healy, because there are no indications of the practise of any crime under the dispositions of article 277 number 1 of the Penal Process Code.

Article 277 number 3 of the Penal Process Code is to be fulfilled.

Under article 214 number 1 item a) of the Penal Process Code, the coercion measures that have been imposed on the arguidos are declared extinct.

Portimão, 21.07.08

The Republic's Prosecutor

(José de Magalhaes e Menezes)

The Joint General Prosecutor

(signature)

(Joao Melchior Gomes))
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: DCI on May 08, 2013, 03:53:38 PM
I may be wrong but I suspect the phrase "no evidence" rather stuck in the craw of Morais and Astro so they used the slightly more nebulous "indications" instead.

I don't think you are wrong, Martha.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 03:59:23 PM
We are talking semantic fields here- in fact a semantic minefield.

Although "indícios" translates to evidence, "Evidence" translates to provas, indications translates to indicações.

It is difficult to determine exactly what the report actually means- a problem with all translations.

I am pretty certain that although the AG might well believe that there was no evidence to show that the McCanns committed a crime, there was evidence against them to be considered.

See the long thread on the matter!
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 08, 2013, 04:04:21 PM
Quote
See the long thread on the matter!

not for the faint hearted
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 04:09:00 PM
 8-)(--)
The mistake of assuming a reconstruction would shed light on how Jane passed Jez and Gerry without either noticing her is that one thing you can't recreate is the circumstances and knowledge (or absence thereof) of any of the participants in the original.  In a reconstruction, all the key "players" will be keyed up, knowing what's going to happen, knowing that someone, (whether Jane or a standin) will pass them.

Given that, how can you reliably test what actually occurred on the night, when all the "real" participants in "real" time were deprived of that hindsight?  You can't.
If "you couldn't", then the "reconstruction of the facts" wouldn't be contemplated by the article 150 of the CPP.
If they had accepted, this simple fact would have changed the global mood and, everybody trying to do his/her best, some clarification could have come out, don't you think ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 04:21:19 PM
I may be wrong but I suspect the phrase "no evidence" rather stuck in the craw of Morais and Astro so they used the slightly more nebulous "indications" instead.
"Indício" can mean "indication", "sign", symptom", but here and imo the meaning is clue, piece of evidence, established fact.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 04:33:51 PM
8-)(--)
The mistake of assuming a reconstruction would shed light on how Jane passed Jez and Gerry without either noticing her is that one thing you can't recreate is the circumstances and knowledge (or absence thereof) of any of the participants in the original.  In a reconstruction, all the key "players" will be keyed up, knowing what's going to happen, knowing that someone, (whether Jane or a standin) will pass them.

Given that, how can you reliably test what actually occurred on the night, when all the "real" participants in "real" time were deprived of that hindsight?  You can't.

If "you couldn't", then the "reconstruction of the facts" wouldn't be contemplated by the article 150 of the CPP.
If they had accepted, this simple fact would have changed the global mood and, everybody trying to do his/her best, some clarification could have come out, don't you think ?

This rather curious notion that you can demonstrate by simulation something that occurred in real time to establish its plausibility or implausibility is one I've never come across before.

And I think the concept is poorly founded.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 04:48:16 PM
8-)(--)
The mistake of assuming a reconstruction would shed light on how Jane passed Jez and Gerry without either noticing her is that one thing you can't recreate is the circumstances and knowledge (or absence thereof) of any of the participants in the original.  In a reconstruction, all the key "players" will be keyed up, knowing what's going to happen, knowing that someone, (whether Jane or a standin) will pass them.

Given that, how can you reliably test what actually occurred on the night, when all the "real" participants in "real" time were deprived of that hindsight?  You can't.

If "you couldn't", then the "reconstruction of the facts" wouldn't be contemplated by the article 150 of the CPP.
If they had accepted, this simple fact would have changed the global mood and, everybody trying to do his/her best, some clarification could have come out, don't you think ?

This rather curious notion that you can demonstrate by simulation something that occurred in real time to establish its plausibility or implausibility is one I've never come across before.

And I think the concept is poorly founded.
Suggest to the Portuguese authorities an alteration of the article 150 of the CPP as poorly founded !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 04:56:32 PM
I may be wrong but I suspect the phrase "no evidence" rather stuck in the craw of Morais and Astro so they used the slightly more nebulous "indications" instead.
"Indício" can mean "indication", "sign", symptom", but here and imo the meaning is clue, piece of evidence, established fact.

As I said, a problem of mismatched semantic fields and variations in usage
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 05:27:51 PM
Everybody knows that semantic fields never match exactly from a language to another one. This is one of the facts that explain translator robots are inaccurate.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 05:36:59 PM
Everybody knows that semantic fields never match exactly from a language to another one. This is one of the facts that explain translator robots are inaccurate.

And why any translation is a poor reflection of the original.

We do not really no what was meant by Indício in Portuguese, let alone in English.

Can you tell from the text or is it uncertain.

No formal forensic report in English would be likely to say:

"No evidence was found to suggest that the suspect committed the crime"

it is more likely to say something like

"Investigations of the case provided no reason to believe that the person should be charged."

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:05:34 PM

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!

7 - The re-enactment will only turn out to be efficient if performed by the participants in the events, once the information provided by the same participants needs to be tested and efficiently compared on-site, and that can only be achieved by means of their own performances. Thus, the possibility of using actors has to be put aside;
Paulo Rebelo

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm

That is a strange quote. Confused.com.

WHat has Paulo Rebelo got to do with the AG's opinion.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:11:52 PM
Everybody knows that semantic fields never match exactly from a language to another one. This is one of the facts that explain translator robots are inaccurate.

And why any translation is a poor reflection of the original.

We do not really no what was meant by Indício in Portuguese, let alone in English.

Can you tell from the text or is it uncertain.

No formal forensic report in English would be likely to say:

"No evidence was found to suggest that the suspect committed the crime"

it is more likely to say something like

"Investigations of the case provided no reason to believe that the person should be charged."
Sorry but it's not what the PGR wrote ! The time might have come to teach yourself Portuguese !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:14:31 PM
Everybody knows that semantic fields never match exactly from a language to another one. This is one of the facts that explain translator robots are inaccurate.

And why any translation is a poor reflection of the original.

We do not really no what was meant by Indício in Portuguese, let alone in English.

Can you tell from the text or is it uncertain.

No formal forensic report in English would be likely to say:

"No evidence was found to suggest that the suspect committed the crime"

it is more likely to say something like

"Investigations of the case provided no reason to believe that the person should be charged."
Sorry but it's not what the PGR wrote ! The time might have come to teach yourself Portuguese !


I was not talking about the PGR.

Try reading the post before replying.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:15:30 PM

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!

7 - The re-enactment will only turn out to be efficient if performed by the participants in the events, once the information provided by the same participants needs to be tested and efficiently compared on-site, and that can only be achieved by means of their own performances. Thus, the possibility of using actors has to be put aside;
Paulo Rebelo

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm

If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?
The PJ didn't believe they were all lying but found it better to have the discrepancies cleared, at least partly. Do you find this abusive ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:24:56 PM
If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?

****

I dont know that the PJ thought they were all lyng, do you?

And even if they did, the PP states they missed this opportunity to remove any remnant suspiciions about their version of events.

Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.
Martha, the PGR's objective was to understand what had happened to Madeleine. The question of guilt was secondary (imo), a fortiori because murder was discarded by the investigation. As no trace of Madeleine had been found, the PGR wished 1) to make sure the possible parents' involvement wasn't a lead and 2) by chance to find a clue towards a new lead.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:32:26 PM
Anne, do you know if the PP shelved the case and removed arguido status because they shelved the case as no crime could be identified in the case, and arguido status of the three had to be removed,  or was the arguido status removed because there was no evidence against the arguidos. IE can a case be shelved but still keep people as arguidos?
They had to either charge or not, because the Robert M's arguido status had exhausted all possible extensions. As he had no evidence, or not enough to charge, the PGR couldn't but shelf the case. This is very clear in his dispatch where he indicates how the case can be open before the prescription.
When a case is shelved the arguido status are also "shelved" !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:34:15 PM

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!

7 - The re-enactment will only turn out to be efficient if performed by the participants in the events, once the information provided by the same participants needs to be tested and efficiently compared on-site, and that can only be achieved by means of their own performances. Thus, the possibility of using actors has to be put aside;
Paulo Rebelo

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm

If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?
The PJ didn't believe they were all lying but found it better to have the discrepancies cleared, at least partly. Do you find this abusive ?

Why would I find it abusive?

Who did the PJ believe were lying and who did they believe weren't lying, can you tell me?
No idea, Martha ! I don't have friends there who could tell me !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:36:23 PM
Anne, do you know if the PP shelved the case and removed arguido status because they shelved the case as no crime could be identified in the case, and arguido status of the three had to be removed,  or was the arguido status removed because there was no evidence against the arguidos. IE can a case be shelved but still keep people as arguidos?
They had to either charge or not, because the Robert M's arguido status had exhausted all possible extensions. As he had no evidence, or not enough to charge, the PGR couldn't but shelf the case. This is very clear in his dispatch where he indicates how the case can be open before the prescription.
When a case is shelved the arguido status are also "shelved" !

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:39:18 PM
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 06:44:07 PM
... the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality.

I think we all understand that's the purpose, Anne.

But I think the premise (that it is possible to do that) is flawed, precisely because, however honest the endeavour and the intent, you can never faithfully reproduce second time around what actually happened, live and in real time on first instance.

It is just a flawed concept ...
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:48:25 PM

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:50:00 PM

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:51:14 PM
... the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality.

I think we all understand that's the purpose, Anne.

But I think the premise (that it is possible to do that) is flawed, precisely because, however honest the endeavour and the intent, you can never faithfully reproduce second time around what actually happened, live and in real time on first instance.

It is just a flawed concept ...
That's what you think ! I have no opinion, these reconstructions are not public.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 06:55:41 PM

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!
I did'nt write that but "extinction of the coercion measures" : declaram-se extinctas as medidas de coacção impostas aos arguidos.
The files concerning the arguidos are shelved, archived.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 08, 2013, 07:00:04 PM
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.

In this country I don't think we make the victims of terrible and traumatic crimes re-live their experiences in a reconstruction, nor for that matter do we expect suspects to take part in reconstuctions in  the hope that they will incriminate themselves as far as I'm aware, though I may be wrong...
I don't think that reconstructions are made very often. Sometimes people denounce themselves and tell implausible stories. In this case a reconstruction might be useful.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 07:06:16 PM

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!
I did'nt write that but "extinction of the coercion measures" : declaram-se extinctas as medidas de coacção impostas aos arguidos.
The files concerning the arguidos are shelved, archived.

I repeat:

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 07:54:32 PM
Would you expect a rape victim to do a reconstruction of the events leading up to their assault?  I wouldn't, and frankly I don't think this is any different.  It was a deeply traumatic and devastating event and I can fully understand the McCanns not exactly jumping for joy at the prospect of re-enacting that night's events, so it's to their credit that they actually agreed to take part in my view.

They had no choice as they were arguidos, only the tapas 7 had a choice.

I dont think your likening this reconstruction to victims of a crime is helpful or relevant here as at the time they were still suspects, not the  same is it?

Arguido status means little in English law. It would have taken a year to enforce  EAW on the McCanns to do a reconstruction.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 08:05:46 PM
They could be forced back to Portugal, but not forced to do a reconstruction which would transgress their right to silence.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 08:50:57 PM
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.

In this country I don't think we make the victims of terrible and traumatic crimes re-live their experiences in a reconstruction, nor for that matter do we expect suspects to take part in reconstuctions in  the hope that they will incriminate themselves as far as I'm aware, though I may be wrong...

Actors are always used for reconstructions on Crimewatch.


Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Chinagirl on May 08, 2013, 09:56:24 PM
This is a very confusing thread to come to as a new reader, or one who has been absent from the board for a while.  Part of it is discussing the value or otherwise of a reconstruction, and also the merits/meaning of words in the final report.

 8)><(
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: John on May 08, 2013, 11:18:38 PM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 08, 2013, 11:47:19 PM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 11:48:28 PM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

Agreed.  And the only way a reconstruction would have been of any use to anyone was if the 10 people involved could each guarantee reproducing their exact movements that night with total and precise accuracy regarding the times - and that is simply not possible for ONE human being -  let alone 10 of them to do.

 

Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: puglove on May 09, 2013, 12:00:14 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 09, 2013, 12:01:07 AM
they believed the police were out to get them and that the reconstruction was designed to help the police establish guilt, not to clear them or uncover new leads. 
I wish I could believe that, Martha. But belief is belief, it has virtues and defaults. I wish the MC could find peace, I really do. No one can blame them more than they do.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 12:04:54 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 09, 2013, 12:05:37 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

Agreed.  And the only way a reconstruction would have been of any use to anyone was if the 10 people involved could each guarantee reproducing their exact movements that night with total and precise accuracy regarding the times - and that is simply not possible for ONE human being -  let alone 10 of them to do.

 
John and Benice, you're dreaming ! But it's all right and good once in a while !
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: puglove on May 09, 2013, 12:16:28 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 12:22:39 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: puglove on May 09, 2013, 12:29:08 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

You're probably right. But...cliché alert.... you can't turn the clocks back. I'd rather have a cross, resentful sprog who wants to go tadpoling down the river just as it's getting dark, and I've said "no", than wondering where they are and calling the police when it's too late. I like my chicks to be in the nest.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 09, 2013, 12:30:42 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.
My father-to-be bought a car just before WW2, with earned money from the State.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 12:35:37 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.
My father-to-be bought a car just before WW2, with earned money from the State.

Yawn. Very few people compared with now had cars in say 1950. You could play in the street with no cares as they were mostly empty. Don't make me dig out statistics to prove it. Remember that anecdote is not the singular of data. Take your stories, meaningless as they are, away with you.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: icabodcrane on May 09, 2013, 12:52:59 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

You're probably right. But...cliché alert.... you can't turn the clocks back. I'd rather have a cross, resentful sprog who wants to go tadpoling down the river just as it's getting dark, and I've said "no", than wondering where they are and calling the police when it's too late. I like my chicks to be in the nest.

I love the way you express yourself shona  ...  no agenda honesty is so refreshing
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 09, 2013, 01:00:20 AM
Would you expect a rape victim to do a reconstruction of the events leading up to their assault?  I wouldn't, and frankly I don't think this is any different.  It was a deeply traumatic and devastating event and I can fully understand the McCanns not exactly jumping for joy at the prospect of re-enacting that night's events, so it's to their credit that they actually agreed to take part in my view.


They had no choice as they were arguidos, only the tapas 7 had a choice.

I dont think your likening this reconstruction to victims of a crime is helpful or relevant here as at the time they were still suspects, not the  same is it?

I think the McCanns DID have the choice actually.
They didn't, as they were arguidos. But they could of course influence the TPs' choice.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 01:05:53 AM
Would you expect a rape victim to do a reconstruction of the events leading up to their assault?  I wouldn't, and frankly I don't think this is any different.  It was a deeply traumatic and devastating event and I can fully understand the McCanns not exactly jumping for joy at the prospect of re-enacting that night's events, so it's to their credit that they actually agreed to take part in my view.


They had no choice as they were arguidos, only the tapas 7 had a choice.

I dont think your likening this reconstruction to victims of a crime is helpful or relevant here as at the time they were still suspects, not the  same is it?

I think the McCanns DID have the choice actually.
They didn't, as they were arguidos. But they could of course influence the TPs' choice.

The Portuguese legal system could have asked them to return for questioning but would have no way to make them answer questions or to take part in a reconstruction. It would have taken the best part of a year to process an appealed EAW- just not worth the hassle.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 06:48:56 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.
But that would require entering the room and making visual contact.. imagine if Matty had done that on his (cough) 9.30 check or even listened at the window on said check, but then neither check existed until after the "alarm" was raised did they!

In your biased bunny opinion only.

Different strokes for different folks- a concept that is hard to grasp for tunnel vision narrow minded thinkers.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 07:08:49 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.
But that would require entering the room and making visual contact.. imagine if Matty had done that on his (cough) 9.30 check or even listened at the window on said check, but then neither check existed until after the "alarm" was raised did they!

In your biased bunny opinion only.

Different strokes for different folks- a concept that is hard to grasp for tunnel vision narrow minded thinkers.
8)><(

I can understand how upsetting it must be for you, lacking a moral compass and any empathy for others. No wonder you are tearful.
Title: Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
Post by: Joanne on May 09, 2013, 07:36:15 AM
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   (http://images.zaazu.com/img/digital-camera-animation-animated-camera-smiley-emoticon-000420-medium.gif)

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

You're probably right. But...cliché alert.... you can't turn the clocks back. I'd rather have a cross, resentful sprog who wants to go tadpoling down the river just as it's getting dark, and I've said "no", than wondering where they are and calling the police when it's too late. I like my chicks to be in the nest.

I love the way you express yourself shona  ...  no agenda honesty is so refreshing


Thats our Shona for you!  8@??)( 8((()*/