Author Topic: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?  (Read 62550 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Chinagirl

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #105 on: May 08, 2013, 10:47:48 AM »
I imagine that every issue raised above could be simulated with many variables by a computer programme (HOLMES), and has already been undertaken by Scotland Yard.
A

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #106 on: May 08, 2013, 10:54:10 AM »
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*

Exactly Angelo, and talking about the 'bigger picture'  - surely if something had happened to Madeleine and the McCanns decided to dispose of her body, then they could have easily come up with a better plan.   All they had to do was

go to dinner as usual,
say nothing to anyone,
wait until the middle of the night -
dispose of the body, and go to bed.
 
Then in the morning call the police and say they woke up to find the front door ajar and their daughter gone.
 
Job done, and no need for all the convoluted plotting and planning involving the rest of the group and the dangerous risks that the involvement of so many other people could cause.

(And that's just one scenario I can think of - and I'm no rocket scientist)




 

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #107 on: May 08, 2013, 10:55:25 AM »
Who would be brave enough to attempt a reconstruction of Peter Voisey's crime?

He strolled into a ground-floor flat while the whole family was in, entered the bathroom, enticed an 8 year old girl out of the bath, out of the flat, into the freezing night air, into his car and away.

The first the family knew was when they heard a screech of tires as the car sped away ...

A predatory paedophile was convicted today of raping a six-year-old girl he snatched from her bath two days after Christmas Day last year.
Peter Voisey, 35, was convicted at Newcastle crown court of abducting the girl and putting her through two serious sexual assaults in a car before dumping her, naked, in a freezing cold lane 20 minutes later.

Judge David Hodson warned Voisey he would be jailed for life or for an indefinite period when he sentences him on December 1. The judge said sentencing was being adjourned for the preparation of a sex offender assessment.

The judge said the sentence would be decided after "the court can have a proper assessment of the risk you pose to the public at large".

Voisey, also known as Smith, had snatched the girl from the bathroom of the ground floor flat in North Tyneside where she lived, after getting in through an unlocked back door.

After today's verdict, a statement from the girl's mother said the attack was "every mother's nightmare".

She said: "My little girl was in the bath in her own home within earshot of everyone else in the flat, the back door was shut and I'd only just left the bathroom to go to another room when she was snatched.

"It's every mother's nightmare to think your children aren't safe in their home. You wouldn't think you would have to lock all your doors this early in the evening to protect your children from anyone entering your home uninvited."

She praised police for their work on the case. Some had questioned whether the attack had happened but the police always took the report of the attack seriously, and detectives knew of injuries the girl had suffered and the proximity of the unlocked door to the bathroom.

Swabs were taken and tiny amounts of DNA were recovered from the victim. The samples were too small to provide an exact match, but Voisey was found later to have a similar DNA profile to the elements recovered.

Crucially, a footprint found in the bathroom in the girl's two-bedroom downstairs flat partially matched his Diadora trainer. Mobile phone mast analysis also proved his handset was in the North Tyneside area, and not at his home in Blyth, Northumberland, at the time of the offence. His alibis, at first that he was away from the area, then that he was buying cannabis in North Tyneside, did not stand up.

The jury also heard a life-long friend recall Voisey confiding he wanted to "do something" to a child after the pair drove past two youngsters aged around six and eight.

The prosecution successfully applied for bad character evidence under the 2003 Criminal Justice Act to be put before the jury, who were told of a similar sex attack on a vulnerable 12-year-old stranger at a swimming bath.

Voisey had been jailed for three years, reduced on appeal to two years, for the 2001 attack, the jury in the latest case heard.

He told the jury at Newcastle crown court that he was sorry for the previous attack and was "utterly ashamed ... disgusted with myself".

He had denied having a sexual interest in children, and, weeping in the witness box, told the jury he had "most definitely not" attacked the six-year-old.

But the jury rejected his evidence and convicted him today on the 14th day of the trial.

The court also heard that Voisey, who spent much of his childhood in care, had carried out two break-ins involving a sexual element.

Detective Chief Inspector Jim Napier said: "There is no doubt that Voisey is a serial sexual predator who preys on young and vulnerable children."

He said his view was that Voisey had been in the area looking for somewhere to burgle when he went into the flat and came across the girl.

"As the evidence built up against him, we became more and more convinced that he had committed this crime, which I can only describe as horrific. He was a total stranger to this family, he violated their home, he kidnapped a little girl to satisfy his own perverted desires and he has shown neither guilt nor remorse. Today's conviction should ensure that he is not in a position to harm anyone else for many years to come."

DCI Napier said, given the circumstances, the girl was making good progress in her recovery from the attack. "She proved to be a first-class witness, especially considering her age, and the traumatic experience she had been through. "I was convinced very early on that the girl's account of what happened to her was not only credible, but also entirely feasible, and the investigation proceeded on that basis."

He said that the sex offenders' register was a very important tool in helping to catch Voisey. He said he could not comment on the supervision Voisey had been under at the time of the attack as the council was reviewing this.
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 11:10:43 AM by ferryman »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #108 on: May 08, 2013, 11:11:58 AM »
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #109 on: May 08, 2013, 11:13:27 AM »
I imagine that every issue raised above could be simulated with many variables by a computer programme (HOLMES), and has already been undertaken by Scotland Yard.

You imagine ? In other words you have no idea really.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #110 on: May 08, 2013, 11:16:30 AM »
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #111 on: May 08, 2013, 11:17:11 AM »
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.

Thank you for reminding me to credit the translator Anne. I have edited my post accordingly.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #112 on: May 08, 2013, 11:20:52 AM »
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.

But an opinion nevertheless that carries as much weight as your own.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #113 on: May 08, 2013, 11:21:44 AM »
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #114 on: May 08, 2013, 11:27:32 AM »
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #115 on: May 08, 2013, 11:49:19 AM »
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.

The AG also made it clear that the reconstruction could have uncovered new evidence and who's to say how that would have impacted on his opinion.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline insider

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #116 on: May 08, 2013, 11:54:01 AM »

Exactly Angelo, and talking about the 'bigger picture'  - surely if something had happened to Madeleine and the McCanns decided to dispose of her body, then they could have easily come up with a better plan.   All they had to do was

go to dinner as usual,
say nothing to anyone,
wait until the middle of the night -
dispose of the body, and go to bed.
 
Then in the morning call the police and say they woke up to find the front door ajar and their daughter gone.
 
Job done, and no need for all the convoluted plotting and planning involving the rest of the group and the dangerous risks that the involvement of so many other people could cause.

(And that's just one scenario I can think of - and I'm no rocket scientist)


A very sensible post Benice.

The McCanns are intelligent sensible individuals who could have put together a much better plan had they chosen to do so.  Their reaction when they realised that Madeleine had probably been taken was typical of bereaved parents and something which is nigh impossible for two people to fake at the same time. The sceptics will always claim otherwise but then again that is why they are called sceptics.
Liars come in all shapes and sizes. No profession is without them.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #117 on: May 08, 2013, 11:54:57 AM »
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
Perfectly translated by Astro. Thank you, Faithlilly.
I'm only wondering whether "principle of contiguity of evidence" is clear for an Anglophone.
It's according to this basic principle that the PGR requires the reconstruction. There's no trap there. The need of "physical confirmation" would be tricky if and only if the eventual contradictions weren't normal and acceptable side effects. Reading this, the fears of the TPs appear to have been overevaluated. The trouble is they underevaluated the effects of a refusal, not in the short but in the long run.

Thank you for reminding me to credit the translator Anne. I have edited my post accordingly.
Good, Faithlilly ! From now on and since the "unprofessional" translations have been if not depreciated at least treated here like "amateur" work,  I find it a good idea to credit the translators whenever the files are quoted. However "off with her head" is one of them (not Astro), translating was a heavy job.

Offline peter claridge

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #118 on: May 08, 2013, 11:59:46 AM »
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

In your own entirely insignificant and biased opinion.
Where does biase come into it?  I simply do as others do, that is read available information from the files (untranslated timelines) and form an opinion; my opinion is that the Tapas group are lying about events of that evening.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #119 on: May 08, 2013, 12:05:51 PM »
On the whole, the prosecutors were sound.

But they were p*ssing in the wind on the reconstruction, except as a means of generating new leads or prompting memories, impossible by Portuguese law because of secrecy ...

The AG explained why a reconstruction was needed, to clarify facts. That you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever.

The AG also concluded that there was a lack of evidence that the arguidos committed any crime - that you disagree carries absolutely no weight whatsoever either.
It's only too bad (in a long run perspective) he wasn't able to conclude this after the implementation of a reconstruction that would "eventually dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents", don't you think ?