UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 12:28:29 PM

Title: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 12:28:29 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 12:55:41 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?

Excellent post. 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 01:34:16 PM
my input on this ...hoping i have the right end of your excellent post is

why did they need to spend thousands and thousands and still are on top of the range lawyers...

why did they have there own pr spokes man who are designed to white wash and cover up with propaganda

like the majority of the press stories on the mccs ...have at the botton ...no comments available on this story ...yet you can comment on every other

like your radio stations when featuring a programme[phone in] on the mccs ...never ring you back for comment if you are against the mccs ....and that is only a tip in the ocean about what really goes on ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 01:58:31 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?

I actually think it's a good question and I don't think they are.

I think that the miscontents (unquestionably accurately labelled) are confined to their own sphere of influence.

I don't think their poison and bile permeates much more widely.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 02:44:46 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?
The "Sceptic" community's influence on the GP is negligible.  Most people imo neither give a toss about the McCanns nor the weirdos that support and slag them off on the internet.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 02:46:56 PM
The "Sceptic" community's influence on the GP is negligible.  Most people imo neither give a toss about the McCanns nor the weirdos that support and slag them off on the internet.

Don't forget the weirdos in the McCann supporters.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 02:48:35 PM
Don't forget the weirdos in the McCann supporters.
Re-read my post Stephen. 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 02:50:17 PM
Re-read my post Stephen. 8((()*/

Fair point. 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 04:23:02 PM
I actually think it's a good question and I don't think they are.

I think that the miscontents (unquestionably accurately labelled) are confined to their own sphere of influence.

I don't think their poison and bile permeates much more widely.

Could you please explain what you mean by 'own sphere of influence' FM?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 07:58:33 PM
Firstly, what is propaganda? From my understanding of it it's an attempt to persuade others to believe something. It is spread by different methods; public relations techniques and biased newspaper reports, for example.

Propaganda uses ad hominem attacks instead of valid arguments; ad nauseam repeating of the 'message' in the hope that if you say it often enough it'll be accepted; appeals to authority by citing prominent figures to support an idea or argument; appeals to prejudice by using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition.

Although some sceptics use some of the above techniques on twitter, the ones using them in the media are Team McCann via their PR mouthpieces.

Most of the facts in this case are in the PJ Files, which sceptics tend to direct people to look at. I have never seen a supporter tell someone to read the files and make their own minds up.

Most of the personal attacks,appeals to authority (SY) and emotive language on this forum do not come from those labelled as 'sceptics'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 08:04:34 PM
Firstly, what is propaganda? From my understanding of it it's an attempt to persuade others to believe something. It is spread by different methods; public relations techniques and biased newspaper reports, for example.

Propaganda uses ad hominem attacks instead of valid arguments; ad nauseam repeating of the 'message' in the hope that if you say it often enough it'll be accepted; appeals to authority by citing prominent figures to support an idea or argument; appeals to prejudice by using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition.

Although some sceptics use some of the above techniques on twitter, the ones using them in the media are Team McCann via their PR mouthpieces.

Most of the facts in this case are in the PJ Files, which sceptics tend to direct people to look at. I have never seen a supporter tell someone to read the files and make their own minds up.

Most of the personal attacks,appeals to authority (SY) and emotive language on this forum do not come from those labelled as 'sceptics'.


Yup
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 14, 2015, 08:06:24 PM
Firstly, what is propaganda? From my understanding of it it's an attempt to persuade others to believe something. It is spread by different methods; public relations techniques and biased newspaper reports, for example.

Propaganda uses ad hominem attacks instead of valid arguments; ad nauseam repeating of the 'message' in the hope that if you say it often enough it'll be accepted; appeals to authority by citing prominent figures to support an idea or argument; appeals to prejudice by using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition.

Although some sceptics use some of the above techniques on twitter, the ones using them in the media are Team McCann via their PR mouthpieces.

Most of the facts in this case are in the PJ Files, which sceptics tend to direct people to look at. I have never seen a supporter tell someone to read the files and make their own minds up.

Most of the personal attacks,appeals to authority (SY) and emotive language on this forum do not come from those labelled as 'sceptics'.

Do you have a link to a pro-McCann blog on the internet, please?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 08:08:21 PM
Do you have a link to a pro-McCann blog on the internet, please?

No, sorry.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 08:09:34 PM
I believe there is a garish pink one somewhere, but I don't have a link.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 14, 2015, 08:12:39 PM
No, sorry.

Would a person be hard-pushed to find at least half a dozen anti-McCann blogs on the internet?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 08:18:48 PM
Could you please explain what you mean by 'own sphere of influence' FM?

Cause celebres among their own kind ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 08:21:15 PM
Firstly, what is propaganda? From my understanding of it it's an attempt to persuade others to believe something. It is spread by different methods; public relations techniques and biased newspaper reports, for example.

Propaganda uses ad hominem attacks instead of valid arguments; ad nauseam repeating of the 'message' in the hope that if you say it often enough it'll be accepted; appeals to authority by citing prominent figures to support an idea or argument; appeals to prejudice by using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition.

Although some sceptics use some of the above techniques on twitter, the ones using them in the media are Team McCann via their PR mouthpieces.

Most of the facts in this case are in the PJ Files, which sceptics tend to direct people to look at. I have never seen a supporter tell someone to read the files and make their own minds up.

Most of the personal attacks,appeals to authority (SY) and emotive language on this forum do not come from those labelled as 'sceptics'.
Would you describe something like the 60 Reasons pamphlet by Tony Bennett  as propaganda or not?  If not, how would you describe it? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 08:27:53 PM
Firstly, what is propaganda? From my understanding of it it's an attempt to persuade others to believe something. It is spread by different methods; public relations techniques and biased newspaper reports, for example.

Propaganda uses ad hominem attacks instead of valid arguments; ad nauseam repeating of the 'message' in the hope that if you say it often enough it'll be accepted; appeals to authority by citing prominent figures to support an idea or argument; appeals to prejudice by using loaded or emotive terms to attach value or moral goodness to believing the proposition.

Although some sceptics use some of the above techniques on twitter, the ones using them in the media are Team McCann via their PR mouthpieces.

Most of the facts in this case are in the PJ Files, which sceptics tend to direct people to look at. I have never seen a supporter tell someone to read the files and make their own minds up.

Most of the personal attacks,appeals to authority (SY) and emotive language on this forum do not come from those labelled as 'sceptics'.

Good post G-Unit.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 08:29:41 PM
Would a person be hard-pushed to find at least half a dozen anti-McCann blogs on the internet?

No idea, sorry. What is the point of all these questions? Are you trying to say there are more anti-McCann sites on the internet than pro ones? Does that mean anti's outnumber pro's then, do you think? Or could it be that the 'anti' viewpoint is only able to be presented on the internet due to the McCann stranglehold on the media.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 08:30:19 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?


The propaganda happened in the early years when people believed the lies coming out of Portugal leaked by the Portuguese police.  The damage was done. Only this week I spoke to someone who thought the McCanns were involved...because she believed maddie's blood had been found in the hire car and that dogs had signalled the scent of cadaver in the apartment. If these things were true I would be calling for the arrest of the MCCanns...but they are not true.
You are wrong to think a small band hold sway over the british public. It is still only a small percentage of the population who think the parents covered up maddie's death. Those that do doubt the mccanns because of the lies continually being told. You only have to look at HDH on CMOM to see what I am talking about.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 08:35:14 PM
No idea, sorry. What is the point of all these questions? Are you trying to say there are more anti-McCann sites on the internet than pro ones? Does that mean anti's outnumber pro's then, do you think? Or could it be that the 'anti' viewpoint is only able to be presented on the internet due to the McCann stranglehold on the media.

The McCanns do not have a stranglehold on the press....that is an ill informed myth.....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 08:36:03 PM
Good post G-Unit.

Is it?

I tend to see sceptics direct others to things like the Almeida interim report (admittedly a part of the files) but a part superseded by the PJ final report, seldom, if ever, referred to by sceptics; AND, of course, NEVER the prosecutors' archiving dispatch which makes very plain that the McCanns have no case to answer.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 08:39:01 PM
Do you have a link to a pro-McCann blog on the internet, please?

Didn't ferryman have one at some point ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 08:39:58 PM
Cause celebres among their own kind ...

Their own kind ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 08:43:17 PM
The McCanns do not have a stranglehold on the press....that is an ill informed myth.....
It's the same argument used by all conspiracy theorists - Sandy Hook hoax theorists, 9/11 Truthers, Holohoax proponents etc...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 08:44:02 PM
Their own kind ?

Dedicated to denigrating and maligning the McCanns ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 14, 2015, 08:44:14 PM
No idea, sorry. What is the point of all these questions? Are you trying to say there are more anti-McCann sites on the internet than pro ones? Does that mean anti's outnumber pro's then, do you think? Or could it be that the 'anti' viewpoint is only able to be presented on the internet due to the McCann stranglehold on the media.

If you understand real journalism, you will know that it has to be an unbiased presentation of facts. MSM is only allowed to publish information which does not compromise the ongoing investigation in any way. That is not, as you put it, a McCann stranglehold.
On the internet, however, there is a plethora of unregulated propaganda, orchestrated by sceptics, often on an almost daily basis (hence you cannot immediately direct me to any pro-McCann blogs). Most supporters have already educated themselves simply by reading the files and need no prompting to do so. The same cannot be said of those who still believe in syringes & disposed refrigeration products.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 08:46:43 PM
Dedicated to denigrating and maligning the McCanns ...

Or simply doubting the story they have told.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 08:48:00 PM
If you understand real journalism, you will know that it has to be an unbiased presentation of facts. MSM is only allowed to publish information which does not compromise the ongoing investigation in any way. That is not, as you put it, a McCann stranglehold.
On the internet, however, there is a plethora of unregulated propaganda, orchestrated by sceptics, often on an almost daily basis (hence you cannot immediately direct me to any pro-McCann blogs). Most supporters have already educated themselves simply by reading the files and need no prompting to do so. The same cannot be said of those who still believe in syringes & disposed refrigeration products.

In fairness, there is a pro-McCann blog, still on the net, that no longer writes articles, and there was another, no longer on the net, which was officially sanctioned by findmadeleine.

I wrote articles for both.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 08:48:46 PM
Would you describe something like the 60 Reasons pamphlet by Tony Bennett  as propaganda or not?  If not, how would you describe it?

I haven't read it, Alfred, but it was clearly an attempt to persuade.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 08:49:18 PM
Or simply doubting the story they have told.

Maligning, denigrating and seeking to alter the truth.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 08:50:01 PM
Good post G-Unit.

thank you Faithlilly.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 08:53:40 PM
Maligning, denigrating and seeking to alter the truth.

I wasn't aware that one could alter the truth.  One can perhaps alter the perception of  truth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 09:01:14 PM
If you understand real journalism, you will know that it has to be an unbiased presentation of facts. MSM is only allowed to publish information which does not compromise the ongoing investigation in any way. That is not, as you put it, a McCann stranglehold.
On the internet, however, there is a plethora of unregulated propaganda, orchestrated by sceptics, often on an almost daily basis (hence you cannot immediately direct me to any pro-McCann blogs). Most supporters have already educated themselves simply by reading the files and need no prompting to do so. The same cannot be said of those who still believe in syringes & disposed refrigeration products.

Well, if you think journalists write unbiased presentations of facts there's no hope for you I'm afraid. How about all the wild 'arrests imminent' headlines when Redwood was around? Was that compromising or not? I have not been impressed by supporter's familiarity with the files. A quick skim is ne thing, a proper study another. There are those who insist on referring constantly to an 'abduction' and an 'abductor' when there is no evidence that such a person ever existed.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 09:04:13 PM
I wasn't aware that one could alter the truth.  One can perhaps alter the perception of  truth

There is truth.

Perceptions of truth can be accurate or inaccurate: sometimes inaccuracies are because of fallibility (despite honest endeavour to be accurate); sometimes, because of distortion, manipulation and intent to deceive.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:05:56 PM
Well, if you think journalists write unbiased presentations of facts there's no hope for you I'm afraid. How about all the wild 'arrests imminent' headlines when Redwood was around? Was that compromising or not? I have not been impressed by supporter's familiarity with the files. A quick skim is ne thing, a proper study another. There are those who insist on referring constantly to an 'abduction' and an 'abductor' when there is no evidence that such a person ever existed.

I'm not impressed with your understanding an interpretations of the files......as I have said before ...if the parents are telling the truth then abduction is almost a certainty
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 09:06:58 PM
Maligning, denigrating and seeking to alter the truth.

The files are on the Internet for all to read. Obviously amongst those who have read them, the majority doubt the McCanns version of events. The number of. individuals joining sceptic sites makes this self-evident.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 09:08:14 PM
I'm not impressed with your understanding an interpretations of the files......as I have said before ...if the parents are telling the truth then abduction is almost a certainty

If, is the operative word.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 09:11:27 PM
If, is the operative word.


I wa going to post exactly the same.  None of us know what the truth is - we all choose our own version.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:14:58 PM
The files are on the Internet for all to read. Obviously amongst those who have read them, the majority doubt the McCanns version of events. The number of. individuals joining sceptic sites makes this self-evident.

I would say that most of those who have read the files have no understanding of assessing evidence..I would also say that the majority of those who have read the files did not start with an open mind
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 14, 2015, 09:16:44 PM
Well, if you think journalists write unbiased presentations of facts there's no hope for you I'm afraid. How about all the wild 'arrests imminent' headlines when Redwood was around? Was that compromising or not? I have not been impressed by supporter's familiarity with the files. A quick skim is ne thing, a proper study another. There are those who insist on referring constantly to an 'abduction' and an 'abductor' when there is no evidence that such a person ever existed.
True journalism is exactly what I previously stated.
Were any of the sensationalist headlines attributed to the more respected newspapers in the UK or were they in the ones the sceptics use for much of their anti-McCann propaganda?
You believe the evidence in the files points to parental involvement. I don't - and I have seen a lot in the files which points to stranger means, motive & opportunity. That doesn't mean either of us is right or wrong as the truth has yet to be determined.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:17:26 PM

I wa going to post exactly the same.  None of us know what the truth is - we all choose our own version.

we all choose our own version based on our interpretation of the evidence..some of us are better at assessing evidence than others........SY have shown they believe the mccanns...that is evidence they are telling the truth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 09:18:46 PM
It doesn't mean it is true, though - it is only their belief.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:20:46 PM
It doesn't mean it is true, though - it is only their belief.

Doesn't mean its true but it is another vote for the mccanns innocence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:22:44 PM
It doesn't mean it is true, though - it is only their belief.

do you feel you have evidence of the mccanns guilt or is it just a belief
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 09:27:01 PM
Just a belief - like everybody else.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:28:26 PM
The files are on the Internet for all to read. Obviously amongst those who have read them, the majority doubt the McCanns version of events. The number of. individuals joining sceptic sites makes this self-evident.

the sceptic sites promote lies...and exclude those who question the lies...sounds a bit like a religion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:30:46 PM
Just a belief - like everybody else.

I think you need more than a belief to accuse someone as the mccanns are accused .....to abuse the McCanns as they are abused...but you are right, that's all the sceptics have ...a belief
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 09:33:58 PM
I think you need more than a belief to accuse someone as the mccanns are accused .....to abuse the McCanns as they are abused...but you are right, that's all the sceptics have ...a belief


That's all any of us have, so don't kid yourself otherwise.  We shall never agree, but that doesn't bother me in the slightest.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 09:39:57 PM
the sceptic sites promote lies...and exclude those who question the lies...sounds a bit like a religion

People find devotion to the McCann's, quasi religious.

 Bearing in mind they are responsible for setting in motion the chain of events which led to Madeleine's disappearance.

The lack of proper care of their children is at the core vof this case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:42:47 PM
People find devotion to the McCann's, quasi religious.

 Bearing in mind they are responsible for setting in motion the chain of events which led to Madeleine's disappearance.

The lack of proper care of their children is at the core vof this case.

You think I'm devoted...I'm not...again I blame the abductor
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:44:48 PM

That's all any of us have, so don't kid yourself otherwise.  We shall never agree, but that doesn't bother me in the slightest.

as it doesn't bother me whether you or others agree with me....I don't kid myself...I felt there was evidence of abduction.......and it seems SY agree with me
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 09:49:13 PM
You think I'm devoted...I'm not...again I blame the abductor


Fascinating.

You believe in a person for which there exists no evidence worth a pinch of salt.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 09:50:58 PM

Fascinating.

You believe in a person for which there exists no evidence worth a pinch of salt.

so I will ask you again...what are the odds Maddie was abducted...lets see if you can give an estimate
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 10:11:46 PM
Well, if you think journalists write unbiased presentations of facts there's no hope for you I'm afraid. How about all the wild 'arrests imminent' headlines when Redwood was around? Was that compromising or not? I have not been impressed by supporter's familiarity with the files. A quick skim is ne thing, a proper study another. There are those who insist on referring constantly to an 'abduction' and an 'abductor' when there is no evidence that such a person ever existed.
Do you view yourself as a bit of a McCann case scholar?  It certainly seems so from the above post.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:23:23 PM
Do you view yourself as a bit of a McCann case scholar?  It certainly seems so from the above post.

Didn't SY read all the files and then decide the McCanns were not suspects...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 14, 2015, 10:25:48 PM
so I will ask you again...what are the odds Maddie was abducted...lets see if you can give an estimate

Odds in favour or odds against?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:28:09 PM
Odds in favour or odds against?


what were the odds...the question is quite clear but Stephen couldn't provide an answer.....can you
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 10:35:34 PM
Didn't SY read all the files and then decide the McCanns were not suspects...
Apparently according to G-Unit that sort of argument from authority is not valid.  the fact that the Met have spent thousands of man hours translating and analysing the files and have come to the conclusion that Madeleine's disappearance was likely due to stranger abduction means diddly-squat to real scholars like G-Unit who obviously know better.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 10:40:51 PM
Do you view yourself as a bit of a McCann case scholar?  It certainly seems so from the above post.

I've read the files quite carefully and I find people post things which are contradicted in the files, which suggests a less than thorough reading of them by some.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:43:18 PM
Apparently according to G-Unit that sort of argument from authority is not valid.  the fact that the Met have spent thousands of man hours translating and analysing the files and have come to the conclusion that Madeleine's disappearance was likely due to stranger abduction means diddly-squat to real scholars like G-Unit who obviously know better.

perhaps gunit could tell us why she doesn't accept SY's findings and give us the evidence to support her doubts and tell us why we should accept her conclusion rather than that of the experts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:48:23 PM
I've read the files quite carefully and I find people post things which are contradicted in the files, which suggests a less than thorough reading of them by some.

The fact that you have read the files is neither here nor there...if your ability to analyse the evidence is poor then your conclusions will be poor. SY have read the files and concluded the McCanns are not suspects... I have seen plenty of posts here from sceptics quoting the files...when what they quote is simply not what the files say
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 14, 2015, 10:50:28 PM

what were the odds...the question is quite clear but Stephen couldn't provide an answer.....can you

The question re odds is meaningless until you define whether you mean odds in favour of abduction or odds against abduction.
It's simple enough so why not stop procrastinating and state what you mean?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 10:52:57 PM
Apparently according to G-Unit that sort of argument from authority is not valid.  the fact that the Met have spent thousands of man hours translating and analysing the files and have come to the conclusion that Madeleine's disappearance was likely due to stranger abduction means diddly-squat to real scholars like G-Unit who obviously know better.

Leaning towards an ad hominem attack there Alfred. You'll be accusing me of lacking empathy for two suffering innocent parents in a minute lol.

Answer me just one question. How would it be possible to forensically examine a timeline six years after the event when the timeline can't be independently verified? First you verify, then you examine. Without independent witnesses how can you verify? When people report a twenty minute difference between events how can you verify? SY, by the way, said there was an opportunity for a stranger to abduct. They never said it happened.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:55:26 PM
The question re odds is meaningless until you define whether you mean odds in favour of abduction or odds against abduction.
It's simple enough so why not stop procrastinating and state what you mean?

then you do not understand statistics or odds ...state either....they are simply the inverse of each other...so lets say...for your benefit...what are the odds on...abduction...and what are the odds on...parental cover up
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 10:57:06 PM
The fact that you have read the files is neither here nor there...if your ability to analyse the evidence is poor then your conclusions will be poor. SY have read the files and concluded the McCanns are not suspects... I have seen plenty of posts here from sceptics quoting the files...when what they quote is simply not what the files say

Your superiority complex is showing again! I have seen many posts here from supporters quoting the files when what they quote is simply not what the files say.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:57:52 PM
Leaning towards an ad hominem attack there Alfred. You'll be accusing me of lacking empathy for two suffering innocent parents in a minute lol.

Answer me just one question. How would it be possible to forensically examine a timeline six years after the event when the timeline can't be independently verified? First you verify, then you examine. Without independent witnesses how can you verify? When people report a twenty minute difference between events how can you verify? SY, by the way, said there was an opportunity for a stranger to abduct. They never said it happened.

SY said they believed it happened...first you have to establish who is telling the truth...from their statement it is obvious SY believe the parents are telling the truth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:58:25 PM
Your superiority complex is showing again! I have seen many posts here from supporters quoting the files when what they quote is simply not what the files say.

cite
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 10:58:48 PM
Leaning towards an ad hominem attack there Alfred. You'll be accusing me of lacking empathy for two suffering innocent parents in a minute lol.

Answer me just one question. How would it be possible to forensically examine a timeline six years after the event when the timeline can't be independently verified? First you verify, then you examine. Without independent witnesses how can you verify? When people report a twenty minute difference between events how can you verify? SY, by the way, said there was an opportunity for a stranger to abduct. They never said it happened.
Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public.  I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.

Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go  - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 11:02:52 PM
Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public.  I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.

Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go  - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?

excellent post
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 11:07:13 PM
The files are on the Internet for all to read. Obviously amongst those who have read them, the majority doubt the McCanns version of events. The number of. individuals joining sceptic sites makes this self-evident.

Among the non-doubters are PJ Inspector Joao Carlos and the Portuguese prosecutors.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 11:24:18 PM
Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public.  I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.

Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go  - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?

Experts (that's real experts!) are (in my opinion) notoriously reluctant to commit themselves (to any darned thing).

The prosecution in the Ian Huntley trial introduced an expert witness to demolish Huntley's own account of how Holly and Jessica met their deaths.  According to Huntley (who pleaded guilty to manslaughter) all three landed up together in his bathroom.  One girl developed a nosebleed and he went for some toilet tissue to stem the flow of blood; the other girl slipped, fell into a bath he had run to wash his dog and drowned, while Huntley held his hand over the mouth of the first girl to stop her screaming (and she suffocated).

The expert witness did a good job of demolishing the account.

But at the end of his testimony, asked if he thought Huntley's account impossible, he replied, no.

Huntley was convicted on a majority verdict. 

Did one juror accord benefit of doubt?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 14, 2015, 11:28:23 PM
No idea, sorry. What is the point of all these questions? Are you trying to say there are more anti-McCann sites on the internet than pro ones? Does that mean anti's outnumber pro's then, do you think? Or could it be that the 'anti' viewpoint is only able to be presented on the internet due to the McCann stranglehold on the media.

What stranglehold on the media?    The McCanns were the victims of a vile smear campaign in the Portuguese press  which was then picked up and repeated in UK media.      Nowadays the newspapers are more careful not to repeat that  - after having to pay compensation and apologise for their previous disgusting behaviour.    Deciding not to smear the McCanns since then was their decision and is nothing to do with the McCanns -  who have no power whatsoever over the media as long they stay within the law.   

IMO you should show evidence of this 'stranglehold' which you believe is operating -  or withdraw what I think is a libellous allegation.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 14, 2015, 11:39:09 PM
Among the non-doubters are PJ Inspector Joao Carlos and the Portuguese prosecutors.

Also this man;-

Quote

ANTONIO MARINHO PINTO: (translated) I’m convinced the McCann case will feature in Portuguese judicial history as a bad example. What a criminal investigation should not be.
Unquote 


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 11:44:07 PM
Also this man;-

Quote

ANTONIO MARINHO PINTO: (translated) I’m convinced the McCann case will feature in Portuguese judicial history as a bad example. What a criminal investigation should not be.
Unquote

The Portuguese Attorney-General at the time.

Quite right.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 11:54:18 PM
Also this man;-

Quote

ANTONIO MARINHO PINTO: (translated) I’m convinced the McCann case will feature in Portuguese judicial history as a bad example. What a criminal investigation should not be.
Unquote

Is this the man who had the photographs of Cipriano's alleged injuries in his possession, photographs that a photographic expert later testified had been manipulated ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 12:06:28 AM
perhaps gunit could tell us why she doesn't accept SY's findings and give us the evidence to support her doubts and tell us why we should accept her conclusion rather than that of the experts

Not only SY's findings but also the findings of all the other experts in this case   I'm thinking in particular of the FLO officers, the trauma specialists -  even the body language expert (Dr Leal?) who are all trained professionals in their field and none of whom found anything suspicious in relation to the McCanns.     And neither have those other extremely important 'experts'  -  i.e. the parents of other abducted children who all support the McCanns.   But apparently, according to sceptics  - all those experts without exception are completely wrong and they are right.   

 


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 12:11:27 AM
Not only SY's findings but also the findings of all the other experts in this case   I'm thinking in particular of the FLO officers, the trauma specialists -  even the body language expert (Dr Leal?) who are all trained professionals in their field and none of whom found anything suspicious in relation to the McCanns.     And neither have those other extremely important 'experts'  -  i.e. the parents of other abducted children who all support the McCanns.   But apparently, according to sceptics  - all those experts without exception are completely wrong and they are right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EyT-7Zi5HM
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 12:15:54 AM
Is this the man who had the photographs of Cipriano's alleged injuries in his possession, photographs that a photographic expert later testified had been manipulated ?

There shouldn't have been any injuries on Leonor Cipriano's body to be photographed in the first place. 

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 15, 2015, 06:24:39 AM
Is this the man who had the photographs of Cipriano's alleged injuries in his possession, photographs that a photographic expert later testified had been manipulated ?

Oh dear Faith.  Wasn't this the case where the heroic Amaral got his conviction for covering up?  Eighteen months suspended as I recall?

I really think you need to provide a cite for that fact you have quoted, because what you say does not seem to correspond to the facts of the case. 

So - cite or delete your post.  Forum rules and all that, and you reminded Eleanor only yesterday.  8(0(* 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 07:44:03 AM
Is this the man who had the photographs of Cipriano's alleged injuries in his possession, photographs that a photographic expert later testified had been manipulated ?

this statement is a very good example of sceptic propaganda...well done faith
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 08:01:01 AM
Not only SY's findings but also the findings of all the other experts in this case   I'm thinking in particular of the FLO officers, the trauma specialists -  even the body language expert (Dr Leal?) who are all trained professionals in their field and none of whom found anything suspicious in relation to the McCanns.     And neither have those other extremely important 'experts'  -  i.e. the parents of other abducted children who all support the McCanns.   But apparently, according to sceptics  - all those experts without exception are completely wrong and they are right.

Dr. Leal, was she the one on tv ?

Hardly likely to say anything there, was she.

Yet the arriving police officers on the scene found the mccanns behaviour extremely unusual, to put it mildly.

When did the others examine the mccanns behaviour ?

Have you asked any police officers in this country about their behaviour ?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 08:06:56 AM
Dr. Leal, was she the one on tv ?

Hardly likely to say anything there, was she.

Yet the arriving police officers on the scene found the mccanns behaviour extremely unusual, to put it mildly.

When did the others examine the mccanns behaviour ?

Have you asked any police officers in this country about their behaviour ?

SY seem happy with them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 08:07:54 AM
Experts (that's real experts!) are (in my opinion) notoriously reluctant to commit themselves (to any darned thing).

The prosecution in the Ian Huntley trial introduced an expert witness to demolish Huntley's own account of how Holly and Jessica met their deaths.  According to Huntley (who pleaded guilty to manslaughter) all three landed up together in his bathroom.  One girl developed a nosebleed and he went for some toilet tissue to stem the flow of blood; the other girl slipped, fell into a bath he had run to wash his dog and drowned, while Huntley held his hand over the mouth of the first girl to stop her screaming (and she suffocated).

The expert witness did a good job of demolishing the account.

But at the end of his testimony, asked if he thought Huntley's account impossible, he replied, no.

Huntley was convicted on a majority verdict. 

Did one juror accord benefit of doubt?
There are of course those who believe Ian Huntley is innocent, incredibly. 8(8-))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 08:10:39 AM
SY seem happy with them

So which members of SY would that be ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 08:14:52 AM
So which members of SY would that be ?

The official view... Redwood spoke of "we"
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 08:19:59 AM
The official view... Redwood spoke of "we"

So how many is we ?

and let's face it , it's one less 'we' now, as he has retired.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 08:23:00 AM
So how many is we ?

and let's face it , it's one less 'we' now, as he has retired.

the official view...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 08:28:44 AM
the official view...

So the 'official' view has solved the crime then ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 09:28:21 AM
What stranglehold on the media?    The McCanns were the victims of a vile smear campaign in the Portuguese press  which was then picked up and repeated in UK media.      Nowadays the newspapers are more careful not to repeat that  - after having to pay compensation and apologise for their previous disgusting behaviour.    Deciding not to smear the McCanns since then was their decision and is nothing to do with the McCanns -  who have no power whatsoever over the media as long they stay within the law.   

IMO you should show evidence of this 'stranglehold' which you believe is operating -  or withdraw what I think is a libellous allegation.

Due to irresponsible journalism in the beginning, the McCann's were able to get payouts from the media because of what they said. I may be wrong but in my opinion the media will be very wary of what they say now. The PJ Files were released to journalists, but not one of the UK media outlets has quoted from them as far as i know. They have printed e-fits and rumours at the behest of the parents, however. The 'libel' trial was reported by quoting the parent's viewpoint. Anyone who has an alternative view is a 'troll'. Amaral's appeal was funded largely by 'trolls' according to the media. Anyone in the public eye would love to have the coverage the McCanns have. It may be purely accidental, but it looks like an organised campaign to ensure the press are 'onside' to me.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 09:31:54 AM
cite

Your turn first, you said it first.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 09:36:28 AM
Due to irresponsible journalism in the beginning, the McCann's were able to get payouts from the media because of what they said. I may be wrong but in my opinion the media will be very wary of what they say now. The PJ Files were released to journalists, but not one of the UK media outlets has quoted from them as far as i know. They have printed e-fits and rumours at the behest of the parents, however. The 'libel' trial was reported by quoting the parent's viewpoint. Anyone who has an alternative view is a 'troll'. Amaral's appeal was funded largely by 'trolls' according to the media. Anyone in the public eye would love to have the coverage the McCanns have. It may be purely accidental, but it looks like an organised campaign to ensure the press are 'onside' to me.

Particularly in light of the Prosecutors' report (who admittedly almost certainly underestimated the frequency of checks) and PJ Inspector Joao Carlos' final PJ report, why would you think that?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 09:37:06 AM
Due to irresponsible journalism in the beginning, the McCann's were able to get payouts from the media because of what they said. I may be wrong but in my opinion the media will be very wary of what they say now. The PJ Files were released to journalists, but not one of the UK media outlets has quoted from them as far as i know. They have printed e-fits and rumours at the behest of the parents, however. The 'libel' trial was reported by quoting the parent's viewpoint. Anyone who has an alternative view is a 'troll'. Amaral's appeal was funded largely by 'trolls' according to the media. Anyone in the public eye would love to have the coverage the McCanns have. It may be purely accidental, but it looks like an organised campaign to ensure the press are 'onside' to me.

so no stranglehold...irresponsible journalism...much better

In my view the press are just printing things as they are...what is true....they now see the McCanns as victims of a crime...which is as it should be. As for being labelled trolls...that's because of the behaviour of people like Brenda...who the sceptics have championed
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 09:43:38 AM
Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public.  I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.

Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go  - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?

I just don't understand how the timeline could be set in stone as truth unless they verified it. According to some witnesses in the files, for example, no-one was late for the meal. According to the group the Paynes were late. Did SY decide to believe one set of people over another? Why? Fiona Payne said the meal 'came quickly' that night, but they were still eating at 9.30 - 9.40. On Tuesday night when the aerobics instructor sat with them they were all finished by 9.30 and they had managed to do a quiz also.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 09:47:20 AM
I just don't understand how the timeline could be set in stone as truth unless they verified it. According to some witnesses in the files, for example, no-one was late for the meal. According to the group the Paynes were late. Did SY decide to believe one set of people over another? Why? Fiona Payne said the meal 'came quickly' that night, but they were still eating at 9.30 - 9.40. On Tuesday night when the aerobics instructor sat with them they were all finished by 9.30 and they had managed to do a quiz also.


your problem is that you are not used to assessing witness statements ...SY are. You say you have closely studied the files...this is the first time you have seen all the witness statements for a case...SY will have seen thousands and understand how to interpret them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 09:48:28 AM
so no stranglehold...irresponsible journalism...much better

In my view the press are just printing things as they are...what is true....they now see the McCanns as victims of a crime...which is as it should be. As for being labelled trolls...that's because of the behaviour of people like Brenda...who the sceptics have championed

She had broken no laws.

As to trolls though, they exist on both sides. Yet the newspapers never show the behaviour of trolls supporting the mccanns.

Definitely bias there.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 09:54:16 AM
Due to irresponsible journalism in the beginning, the McCann's were able to get payouts from the media because of what they said. I may be wrong but in my opinion the media will be very wary of what they say now. The PJ Files were released to journalists, but not one of the UK media outlets has quoted from them as far as i know. They have printed e-fits and rumours at the behest of the parents, however. The 'libel' trial was reported by quoting the parent's viewpoint. Anyone who has an alternative view is a 'troll'. Amaral's appeal was funded largely by 'trolls' according to the media. Anyone in the public eye would love to have the coverage the McCanns have. It may be purely accidental, but it looks like an organised campaign to ensure the press are 'onside' to me.


And yet it is only 14 months ago that the press had to pay £55,000 compensation to the McCanns for libelling them.   How does that fit in with 'an organised campaign' to keep  the press onside'?

Anyone who thinks that  Editors sit waiting for instructions from the McCanns as to what they can and cannot print about them is severely deluded IMO.

If the McCanns were in that powerful position - then why would they want any changes made - and yet they support the Leveson recommendations to the hilt.

The press know that Madeleine's name sells papers and so don't miss the slightest chance to mention her - even to the extent of re-hashing old news imo. 



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 09:55:08 AM
She had broken no laws.

As to trolls though, they exist on both sides. Yet the newspapers never show the behaviour of trolls supporting the mccanns.

Definitely bias there.

The papers see the McCanns as victims of crime...it's not surprising they support them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:00:43 AM
The papers see the McCanns as victims of crime...it's not surprising they support them

Madeleine was the victim dave.

So do you deny there are trolls supporting the mccanns ?

Should they be on sky news as well, as you claim Brenda was a troll. So,  shouldn't the mccann trolls should be treated in the same way ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 10:03:48 AM
Madeleine was the victim dave.

So do you deny there are trolls supporting the mccanns ?

Should they be on sky news as well, as you claim Brenda was a troll. So,  shouldn't the mccann trolls should be treated in the same way ?

the whole McCann family are victims...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:06:54 AM
the whole McCann family are victims...

and who is responsible for this case dave ?

and don't bother with 'abductor'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 15, 2015, 10:08:47 AM
Madeleine was the victim dave.

So do you deny there are trolls supporting the mccanns ?

Should they be on sky news as well, as you claim Brenda was a troll. So,  shouldn't the mccann trolls should be treated in the same way ?

You claim that there are "trolls" (in the loose sense of the word) supporting the McCanns. 

Having had a quick trawl trough the internet, I cannot see any evidence of such activity.  Can you provide examples please?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 15, 2015, 10:13:00 AM
I read some Propaganda this morning,  I am just going to say it was a very known anti forum.   A person there was posting about the word 'cowering'  which Kate used when saying that when she was searching 5a for Madeleine looking in cupboards etc.  just in case she was cowering inside.   The poster on this forum is questioning the word 'cowering'   the poster says that if Madeleine heard Kate arrive at 5a that she would have come out of hiding and called Mummy.    Now,  if a child had been frightened half to death by an abductor who may had chased her and she hid in a cupboard,  shaking and petrified wouldn't she be 'cowering'  and do you think that maybe she would be too scared to speak even when she heard Kate in case it was the abductor.   This person is trying to make out that Kate was a nasty cruel mother whose daughter would be cowering because she was used to  cowering from Kate.   The bruises the poster says on Kate's arms they look as though they had been caused by restraining someone,  so now this poster is trying to make out that Kate had been restraining Madeleine. 

You see how someone can try and portray another as being this evil person who could have harmed her child and killed her?

This is Propaganda at its worst.

Just want to add,   another poster on that site as now said that Kate wouldn't have known about an abductor,  well if I saw a window open and couldn't find my child, I would think about an abductor.   Honestly the things these people come up with to try and find things to make Kate McCann look as if she is lying.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 10:13:21 AM
and who is responsible for this case dave ?

and don't bother with 'abductor'.

the abductor
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:29:06 AM
You claim that there are "trolls" (in the loose sense of the word) supporting the McCanns. 

Having had a quick trawl trough the internet, I cannot see any evidence of such activity.  Can you provide examples please?

I have this 'conversation' with mccann supporters before.

So yet again, take a look at:

'David bet is god' ; 'stop the myths' ; 'jatjy2' , to name but three.

Then we have the dossier compilers as well, who hide behind anonymity, yet were happy to pass Brenda Leyland and other people's names to to sky, the mccanns and the police.



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 10:32:08 AM
Madeleine was the victim dave.

So do you deny there are trolls supporting the mccanns ?

Should they be on sky news as well, as you claim Brenda was a troll. So,  shouldn't the mccann trolls should be treated in the same way ?

I don't know of any trolls supporting the McCanns - as you obviously do then please elaborate.

The sceptic who spends her time slagging off the McCanns on line and  who had an article about herself in a newspaper not only admitted to but actually glorified in being a troll.   Can you come up with an 'equivalent' troll who supports the McCanns?



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 10:32:50 AM

your problem is that you are not used to assessing witness statements ...SY are. You say you have closely studied the files...this is the first time you have seen all the witness statements for a case...SY will have seen thousands and understand how to interpret them

As you don't know me, how do you know your assertions are correct? Maybe I deal with witness statements all the time....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:41:12 AM
I don't know of any trolls supporting the McCanns - as you obviously do then please elaborate.

The sceptic who spends her time slagging off the McCanns on line and  who had an article about herself in a newspaper not only admitted to but actually glorified in being a troll.   Can you come up with an 'equivalent' troll who supports the McCanns?

Of course you are going to say that.

Now go on those sites.

By the way, when are mccann supporter trolls in this paper ?

Now If I state 'names' on here, I know what will happen.

However, some of the screen names of those people are available. I suggest you go on Amazon in that regard.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 15, 2015, 10:47:22 AM
Madeleine was the victim dave.

So do you deny there are trolls supporting the mccanns ?

Should they be on sky news as well, as you claim Brenda was a troll. So,  shouldn't the mccann trolls should be treated in the same way ?

i personally think the term troll is immature and childish a opinion is a opinion  calling  someone a troll for   not  beleving the mcanns story is very  very immature imo
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:49:21 AM
i personally think the term troll is immature and childish a opinion is a opinion  calling  someone a troll for   not  beleving the mcanns story is very  very immature imo

It is done for effect Carly, and quite deliberately to target anyone who doesn't belive the mccanns.

Essentially, pure propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 15, 2015, 10:50:39 AM
It is done for effect Carly, and quite deliberately to target anyone who doesn't belive the mccanns.

Essentially, pure propaganda.

so in other words shut  up or  you  are a troll basically?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 10:53:35 AM
I read some Propaganda this morning,  I am just going to say it was a very known anti forum.   A person there was posting about the word 'cowering'  which Kate used when saying that when she was searching 5a for Madeleine looking in cupboards etc.  just in case she was cowering inside.   The poster on this forum is questioning the word 'cowering'   the poster says that if Madeleine heard Kate arrive at 5a that she would have come out of hiding and called Mummy.    Now,  if a child had been frightened half to death by an abductor who may had chased her and she hid in a cupboard,  shaking and petrified wouldn't she be 'cowering'  and do you think that maybe she would be too scared to speak even when she heard Kate in case it was the abductor.   This person is trying to make out that Kate was a nasty cruel mother whose daughter would be cowering because she was used to  cowering from Kate.   The bruises the poster says on Kate's arms they look as though they had been caused by restraining someone,  so now this poster is trying to make out that Kate had been restraining Madeleine. 

You see how someone can try and portray another as being this evil person who could have harmed her child and killed her?

This is Propaganda at its worst.

I can't post the worst example I saw as it is so libellous.    However suffice it to say that GM was not convicted of sex offences  in 2002 and is not on the sex offenders register.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 10:58:35 AM
so in other words shut  up or  you  are a troll basically?

That would seem to be the case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 15, 2015, 10:58:42 AM
i personally think the term troll is immature and childish a opinion is a opinion  calling  someone a troll for   not  beleving the mcanns story is very  very immature imo

The word troll was brought about to describe some people who rather than debate will post abuse and intimidate.  It is not used for people who don't believe the McCann's story but for those who choose to stalk and abuse.

By the way,  you do know it wasn't the pro McCann's who started the word troll for these people don't you,  it was brought in to use way before the McCann case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 15, 2015, 11:03:28 AM
She had broken no laws.

As to trolls though, they exist on both sides. Yet the newspapers never show the behaviour of trolls supporting the mccanns.

Definitely bias there.

In many ways BL was a troll Stephen,   she did debate but a lot of what she said was abusive and she attacked another poster claiming her to be one of the nanny's  then laughed and hoped she was scared.   The poor girl left twitter.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 15, 2015, 11:03:44 AM
The word troll was brought about to describe some people who rather than debate will post abuse and intimidate.  It is not used for people who don't believe the McCann's story but for those who choose to stalk and abuse.

By the way,  you do know it wasn't the pro McCann's who started the word troll for these people don't you,  it was brought in to use way before the McCann case.

Spot on Lace.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 11:19:18 AM
In many ways BL was a troll Stephen,   she did debate but a lot of what she said was abusive and she attacked another poster claiming her to be one of the nanny's  then laughed and hoped she was scared.   The poor girl left twitter.

I have not seen that, and if true, it was inexcusable.







Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 15, 2015, 11:31:44 AM
Oh dear Faith.  Wasn't this the case where the heroic Amaral got his conviction for covering up?  Eighteen months suspended as I recall?

I really think you need to provide a cite for that fact you have quoted, because what you say does not seem to correspond to the facts of the case. 

So - cite or delete your post.  Forum rules and all that, and you reminded Eleanor only yesterday.  8(0(*

A perfect example of the efficacy of propaganda.

The true story can be found here ... http://database.statewatch.org/article.asp?aid=29207

The propaganda version is as posted elsewhere on this thread and is firmly believed by some others on the internet.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 15, 2015, 11:59:05 AM
then you do not understand statistics or odds ...state either....they are simply the inverse of each other...so lets say...for your benefit...what are the odds on...abduction...and what are the odds on...parental cover up

I understand it that's why I asked you the question!
OK so odds in favour of abduction = probability/(1-probablity)
Probability = 0.00015% give or take.
Work the rest out for yourself.
As for parental involvement, to work out the odds either way we need to know the probability.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 15, 2015, 12:04:31 PM
Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public. I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.

Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go  - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?

It will be as good as the data input. GI = GO
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 15, 2015, 12:06:17 PM
So how many is we ?

and let's face it , it's one less 'we' now, as he has retired.
And then there were four!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 15, 2015, 12:21:25 PM
I have not seen that, and if true, it was inexcusable.

A lot of what Brenda Leyland had to say was inexcusable, but she did have long term mental health issues.

Has no one noticed that all of The Trolls brought to book cite mental health issues as their defence?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 12:50:21 PM
I understand it that's why I asked you the question!
OK so odds in favour of abduction = probability/(1-probablity)
Probability = 0.00015% give or take.
Work the rest out for yourself.
As for parental involvement, to work out the odds either way we need to know the probability.

you are not taking into account all the factors...the probability that maddie was abducted is incredibly high if the parents are ruled out
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 15, 2015, 01:11:30 PM
you are not taking into account all the factors...the probability that maddie was abducted is incredibly high if the parents are ruled out

Don't go applying for a job as an investigator anytime soon davel because you let your own beliefs overcome the facts.  If the parents are taken out of the equation the woke and wandered possibility is just as likely as any abduction.  Whichever way you look at it the parents have to accept blame.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 01:21:37 PM
Don't go applying for a job as an investigator anytime soon davel because you let your own beliefs overcome the facts.  If the parents are taken out of the equation the woke the wandered possibility is just as likely as any abduction.  Whichever way you look at it the parents have to accept blame.

Read Kate's book ...

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 15, 2015, 01:25:28 PM
Read Kate's book ...

read Goncalo Amarals book .......the truth of the lie
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 01:26:41 PM
Read Kate's book ...

Her book is irrelevant as regards that.

The facts are facts.

The McCann's left their children unattended for prolonged periods on 5 successive nights in a foreign country and in what they claimed was unlocked accommodation.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 15, 2015, 01:39:18 PM
read Goncalo Amarals book .......the truth of the lie

I've read it and it is full of innuendos and he has no right to call it the truth of the lie as it was his theory,  he didn't know what had happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 01:44:37 PM
read Goncalo Amarals book .......the truth of the lie

Unfortunately I have.

That Amaral (apparently) contradicted and corrected Prior on forensic results is almost certainly a lie.

That Harrison switched the enquiry to one for a little girl assumed dead is a lie.

That Eddie 'scented death' all over the place is a lie.

Meanwhile, Joao Carlos says in his final report for the PJ that woke and wandered was considered by the shelved enquiry  but discounted.

You know ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 15, 2015, 01:46:07 PM
I've read it and it is full of innuendos and he has no right to call it the truth of the lie as it was his theory,  he didn't know what had happened to Madeleine.



neither do you
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 01:47:13 PM
Unfortunately I have.

That Amaral (apparently) contradicted and corrected Prior on forensic results is almost certainly a lie.

That Harrison switched the enquiry to one for a little girl assumed dead is a lie.

That Eddie 'scented death' all over the place is a lie.

Meanwhile, Joao Carlos says in his final report for the PJ that woke and wandered was considered by the shelved enquiry (for which he wrote the final report) but discounted.

You know ....

The bottom line, neither SY or the PJ have enough evidence of any criminal activity to mount any prosecution, since the crime remains unknown.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 01:53:10 PM
You claim that there are "trolls" (in the loose sense of the word) supporting the McCanns. 

Having had a quick trawl trough the internet, I cannot see any evidence of such activity.  Can you provide examples please?

I'm not allowed to post links here as far as I know, but I've pm'd you.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 02:05:44 PM
The bottom line, neither SY or the PJ have enough evidence of any criminal activity to mount any prosecution, since the crime remains unknown.

So you finally admit the McCanns are innocent?

Progress (of sorts) I suppose ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 02:15:57 PM
So you finally admit the McCanns are innocent?

Progress (of sorts) I suppose ...

I thought you would not understand my last post.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 15, 2015, 02:35:26 PM

I haven't read either of these books.  Did I miss something important?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 15, 2015, 02:43:25 PM
I'm not allowed to post links here as far as I know, but I've pm'd you.

Thank you. And I have responded.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 15, 2015, 02:56:10 PM
Unfortunately I have.

That Amaral (apparently) contradicted and corrected Prior on forensic results is almost certainly a lie.

That Harrison switched the enquiry to one for a little girl assumed dead is a lie.

That Eddie 'scented death' all over the place is a lie.

Meanwhile, Joao Carlos says in his final report for the PJ that woke and wandered was considered by the shelved enquiry  but discounted.

You know ....


mmmmm........there are two books fman.......

so you think ..........G.A...full of lies....... Macs full of inconsistency .............same thing ..in my book   8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 15, 2015, 03:10:31 PM
I'm not allowed to post links here as far as I know, but I've pm'd you.

If relative to a discussion you may post links.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 15, 2015, 03:13:02 PM
I haven't read either of these books.  Did I miss something important?

dont tell fibs you  read kates book i can gurentee it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 03:21:06 PM

mmmmm........there are two books fman.......

so you think ..........G.A...full of lies....... Macs full of inconsistency .............same thing ..in my book   8(0(*

The one (the book by Kate) is an honest account by a traumatised mother.

Note that honest dosen't necessarily mean accurate in every last detail, but honest to the best of Kate's recollection.

Remember the ho-ha about the mileage the Renault Scenic clocked up (cited as 'evidence' of something suspicious about the trip to Spain)?  Kate was able to account, just about to the last kilometre, for all distance travelled in the car.

And we (now) know that there was nothing remotely suspicious about the trip to Spain.

As a former coordinator of the investigation, Amaral's recollection of events of that investigation ought to have been vastly better than it was, particularly events he was personally involved in such as the briefing by Mark Harrison to the PJ about a plan of action following the searches by the (genuinely excellent) GNR dog-handler teams ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 03:27:30 PM
Her book is irrelevant as regards that.

The facts are facts.

The McCann's left their children unattended for prolonged periods on 5 successive nights in a foreign country and in what they claimed was unlocked accommodation.

whilst thy dined 50 yds away ....returning every 30 mins to check them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 15, 2015, 03:28:39 PM
dont tell fibs you  read kates book i can gurentee it

No, Lovey, I didn't.  So you cannot guarantee anything on that score.  But I bet half a Tasmanian Dollar  that you did. 
What did you think?  Please do give us your opinion of Kate's book.  And then throw in your opinion on Amaral's book. 
I shall wait with great interest.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 03:40:56 PM
whilst thy dined 50 yds away ....returning every 30 mins to check them

Not quite dave.

That has never been independently verified.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 03:56:47 PM
Not quite dave.

That has never been independently verified.

Are you accusing them of lying
What evidence do you have
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 04:06:21 PM
Are you accusing them of lying
What evidence do you have

What a poor reply.

Do really expect people to believe the McCann's checked their children every 30 minutes on the ball ?

If memory serves neither of them actually saw Madeleine directly that night, after they left for the tapas.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 15, 2015, 04:13:42 PM
What a poor reply.

Do really expect people to believe the McCann's checked their children every 30 minutes on the ball ?

If memory serves neither of them actually saw Madeleine directly that night, after they left for the tapas.

Do you believe the statement of an independent witness from the accurately/poorly translated files as proof that members of the group intermittently left the dining table that night?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN-CARPENTER.htm
snipped
DCF: He was going to take a plane the next day to Switzerland, given that the children's mother lived there, I had never seen him before that night, but he ended up joining us for a coffee, he was a MW tourist. Another couple whose names I do not remember, sat at the table opposite us. A man was sitting on the esplanade having a drink whilst waiting for a take away, I spoke to them briefly, I hadn't realised that the Tapas bar had a take away service. At that time i didn't know their names. At approximately half past eight, Gerry and Kate and their group of approximately ten people were already seated at their table, which was so close to ours that it was possible to converse with them, we spoke of tennis amongst other things, I vaguely remember that Gerry and Kate and other people from the group would leave the table in intervals (inaudible), I think it was to check on the children , but I do not remember with what frequency or how many times the people left the table to check on the children. We did not talk about the system for checking the children or the fact that they had left them alone in the apartment, it was only later upon hearing the news that I realised that they had left the children alone in the apartment and that they were regularly checking to see if they were all right.
__________________________________________________________________________________________

If you feel you have to remain here to correct our "inaccurate" propaganda, please back up your own claims  with cites.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 04:19:00 PM
As you don't know me, how do you know your assertions are correct? Maybe I deal with witness statements all the time....
We can all play that game.  Maybe I am closely connected to the investigation and know more than I am able to let on, eh...? 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 04:34:48 PM
As you don't know me, how do you know your assertions are correct? Maybe I deal with witness statements all the time....

you don't
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 04:44:11 PM
Don't go applying for a job as an investigator anytime soon davel because you let your own beliefs overcome the facts.  If the parents are taken out of the equation the woke and wandered possibility is just as likely as any abduction.  Whichever way you look at it the parents have to accept blame.

I won't be applying for any job as I have a very good one already...if maddie woke and wandered it is quite possible she was abducted.....making abduction the most likely scenario. for some reason the authorities don't seem to rate the idea......and they have a lot more facts than you do

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 05:09:38 PM
Woke and wandered, bloody hell, do I have to wreck a few more million brain-cells (I am keenly trying to preserve) looking for the exact quote in Joao Carlos' final PJ report where he says woke and wandered was considered as an option but ruled out?

ETA: this is, ironically, a thread about propaganda ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 05:11:50 PM
Woke and wandered, bloody hell, do I have to wreck a few more million brain-cells (I am keenly trying to preserve) looking for the exact quote in Joao Carlos' final PJ report where he says woke and wandered was considered as an option but ruled out?

let me know when you find it...I thought it was in the archiving report....perhaps one of the "files experts" could help us
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 15, 2015, 05:18:38 PM
Do you believe the statement of an independent witness from the accurately/poorly translated files as proof that members of the group intermittently left the dining table that night?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN-CARPENTER.htm
snipped
DCF: He was going to take a plane the next day to Switzerland, given that the children's mother lived there, I had never seen him before that night, but he ended up joining us for a coffee, he was a MW tourist. Another couple whose names I do not remember, sat at the table opposite us. A man was sitting on the esplanade having a drink whilst waiting for a take away, I spoke to them briefly, I hadn't realised that the Tapas bar had a take away service. At that time i didn't know their names. At approximately half past eight, Gerry and Kate and their group of approximately ten people were already seated at their table, which was so close to ours that it was possible to converse with them, we spoke of tennis amongst other things, I vaguely remember that Gerry and Kate and other people from the group would leave the table in intervals (inaudible), I think it was to check on the children , but I do not remember with what frequency or how many times the people left the table to check on the children. We did not talk about the system for checking the children or the fact that they had left them alone in the apartment, it was only later upon hearing the news that I realised that they had left the children alone in the apartment and that they were regularly checking to see if they were all right.
__________________________________________________________________________________________

If you feel you have to remain here to correct our "inaccurate" propaganda, please back up your own claims  with cites.

So who saw them checking at 30 minute intervals?

You have provided anecdotes, but not substantial facts.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 15, 2015, 05:22:31 PM
So who saw them checking at 30 minute intervals?

You have provided anecdotes, but not substantial facts.

If somebody had been watching the checkers actually doing their checking then they would have seen the abductor doing his abducting and we wouldn't be having this conversation.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 15, 2015, 05:41:03 PM
let me know when you find it...I thought it was in the archiving report....perhaps one of the "files experts" could help us

Here we are, Dave:

Quote
As a remote hypothesis, the possibility of the minor leaving the apartment by her own means was explored – that would be highly unlikely physically – and after, because of an accident or by a third person intervention, she would have disappeared.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/P_J_FINAL_REPORT.htm

(PJ Inspector Joao Carlos, final PJ report)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 15, 2015, 06:03:26 PM
I read some Propaganda this morning,  I am just going to say it was a very known anti forum.   A person there was posting about the word 'cowering'  which Kate used when saying that when she was searching 5a for Madeleine looking in cupboards etc.  just in case she was cowering inside.   The poster on this forum is questioning the word 'cowering'   the poster says that if Madeleine heard Kate arrive at 5a that she would have come out of hiding and called Mummy.    Now,  if a child had been frightened half to death by an abductor who may had chased her and she hid in a cupboard,  shaking and petrified wouldn't she be 'cowering'  and do you think that maybe she would be too scared to speak even when she heard Kate in case it was the abductor.   This person is trying to make out that Kate was a nasty cruel mother whose daughter would be cowering because she was used to  cowering from Kate.   The bruises the poster says on Kate's arms they look as though they had been caused by restraining someone,  so now this poster is trying to make out that Kate had been restraining Madeleine. 

You see how someone can try and portray another as being this evil person who could have harmed her child and killed her?

This is Propaganda at its worst.

Just want to add,   another poster on that site as now said that Kate wouldn't have known about an abductor,  well if I saw a window open and couldn't find my child, I would think about an abductor.   Honestly the things these people come up with to try and find things to make Kate McCann look as if she is lying.

I think you are mixing up opinion with propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 06:11:44 PM
It has been suggested on another thread that sceptics are mere victims of propaganda directed at the McCanns. While I accept that towards the end of 2007 and early in 2008 there were many scurrilous articles written about the couple, with their success in suing of the Express the scales were well and truly rebalanced and it would be a foolish editor who would now publish anything that was less than supportive towards the McCanns.

My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?
Your opening post is arse about face IMO.  "Sceptics" are not victims of propaganda, they are perpetrators of it, and largely ignored or ridiculed by the majority of the GBP.  And by "sceptic" I am referring specifically to the hardcore band that have been at this since the start, the organised pressure group that has been going more or less since 2007, gathering only a small raggle-taggle  band along with it over the years.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 15, 2015, 06:19:05 PM
Your opening post is arse about face IMO.  "Sceptics" are not victims of propaganda, they are perpetrators of it, and largely ignored or ridiculed by the majority of the GBP.  And by "sceptic" I am referring specifically to the hardcore band that have been at this since the start, the organised pressure group that has been going more or less since 2007, gathering only a small raggle-taggle  band along with it over the years.

If you read my post correctly Alfie it wasn't me who said sceptics were victims of propaganda. The rest of your post is simply nonsense.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 15, 2015, 06:28:02 PM
If somebody had been watching the checkers actually doing their checking then they would have seen the abductor doing his abducting and we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Only one person was seen near the apartments by an independent witness. Gerald Mccann was seen by Jeremy Wilkins between 8.45pm and 9.15pm. No-one else was seen, so there is no possibility of an independent verification of the timeline.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 06:33:36 PM
If you read my post correctly Alfie it wasn't me who said sceptics were victims of propaganda. The rest of your post is simply nonsense.
No it's not.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 06:38:13 PM

pressure group
noun [C] uk    us     
       
› a ​group of ​people who ​work together to ​try to ​influence what other ​people or the ​government ​think about a ​particular ​subject, in ​order to ​achieve the things they ​want

Now tell me that there has never been a pressure group of sceptics dedicated to achieving "Justice For Maddie" for the last nearly 9 years, a group that has often used the most blatant of propaganda techniques in order to try and achieve their aim.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 15, 2015, 06:50:10 PM
Only one person was seen near the apartments by an independent witness. Gerald Mccann was seen by Jeremy Wilkins between 8.45pm and 9.15pm. No-one else was seen, so there is no possibility of an independent verification of the timeline.

Do you know if Crecheman saw JT? Rhetorical question.
Not being seen in a location seems to have been proof of innocence for certain other people.
What about the waiters & Tapas staff who saw members of the party leave the premises on various occasions?



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 15, 2015, 06:51:29 PM
you are not taking into account all the factors...the probability that maddie was abducted is incredibly high if the parents are ruled out

The probability MM was abducted by a stranger is 0.00015% give or take.
If you think it is another number tell us what you think that number is.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 15, 2015, 06:54:13 PM
pressure group
noun [C] uk    us     
       
› a ​group of ​people who ​work together to ​try to ​influence what other ​people or the ​government ​think about a ​particular ​subject, in ​order to ​achieve the things they ​want

Now tell me that there has never been a pressure group of sceptics dedicated to achieving "Justice For Maddie" for the last nearly 9 years, a group that has often used the most blatant of propaganda techniques in order to try and achieve their aim.


Would the GoFundMe appeal launched by certain sceptics be classed as anti-McCann propaganda?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 06:54:30 PM
The probability MM was abducted by a stranger is 0.00015% give or take.
If you think it is another number tell us what you think that number is.
Can you please publish your calculations for this figure thanks.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 06:55:51 PM

Would the GoFundMe appeal launched by certain sceptics be classed as anti-McCann propaganda?
Strictly speaking no, but it was certainly motivated by a desire to get back at the McCanns and not because of a deep seated love and respect for the man at the centre of the appeal.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 15, 2015, 07:06:55 PM
The word troll was brought about to describe some people who rather than debate will post abuse and intimidate.  It is not used for people who don't believe the McCann's story but for those who choose to stalk and abuse.

By the way,  you do know it wasn't the pro McCann's who started the word troll for these people don't you,  it was brought in to use way before the McCann case.

Though it is not the correct definition for troll.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 15, 2015, 07:13:42 PM
Can you please publish your calculations for this figure thanks.

I didn't calculate it I just took it from that tinternet on "generic" child abduction figures from various places hence my give or take constraint.
The same comment applies to you as I made to davel:
if you believe the number is incorrect give us a number you believe is correct and we can run the odds calculation based on that figure.
I am not fussed which number we use. Using yours would be best then there can be no accusations of me being partisan. So what's your number?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 07:17:04 PM
I didn't calculate it I just took it from that tinternet on "generic" child abduction figures from various places hence my give or take constraint.
The same comment applies to you as I made to davel:
if you believe the number is incorrect give us a number you believe is correct and we can run the odds calculation based on that figure.
I am not fussed which number we use. Using yours would be best then there can be no accusations of me being partisan. So what's your number?
I don't have one, statistics are not my thing, I just wanted to know how you calculated the odds.  You obviously didn't bother, just got a number off the internet.  I thought you were cleverer than that.... &%+((£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 07:23:42 PM
I didn't calculate it I just took it from that tinternet on "generic" child abduction figures from various places hence my give or take constraint.
The same comment applies to you as I made to davel:
if you believe the number is incorrect give us a number you believe is correct and we can run the odds calculation based on that figure.
I am not fussed which number we use. Using yours would be best then there can be no accusations of me being partisan. So what's your number?

what generic abduction figures did you use...sounds a bit odd...are you looking at the probability of a child being abducted...that's obviously very low. In Maddie's case she is missing so there are only a limited number of possibilities. if the parents are ruled out that leaves abduction or woke and wandered....the archiving report didn't seem to think woke and wandered was possible...that leaves abduction as the odds on favourite
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 15, 2015, 07:35:40 PM
If you were tasteless enough to ask a bookie for odds on Madeleine's disappearance being down to abduction and they were tasteless enough to take your bet, do you think they'd give you odds of 1,000,000 to one?  I think that would foolish of them if they were to do so, personally.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 15, 2015, 09:43:45 PM
Here we are, Dave:

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/P_J_FINAL_REPORT.htm

(PJ Inspector Joao Carlos, final PJ report)

It is highly unlikely for a 3 year old to open and climb onto that window without leaving any evidence and jump in bare feet without injuring herself. If somebody lied about the window and shutters then they are involved.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 09:45:07 PM
It is highly unlikely for a 3 year old to climb onto that window without leaving any evidence and jump in bare feet without injuring herself. If somebody lied about the window and shutters then they are involved.

and if the mccanns are telling the truth...as Sy said they were....then the open window pretty well proves abduction
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 15, 2015, 09:47:30 PM
and if the mccanns are telling the truth...as Sy said they were....then the open window pretty well proves abduction

If there was an open window when Kate arrived then yes it suggests abduction. But they need to reveal Smithman first.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 10:29:17 PM
If there was an open window when Kate arrived then yes it suggests abduction. But they need to reveal Smithman first.

the whole investigation hinges on whether kate is telling the truth.....surely before spending 11 mill they would have sorted this first
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 15, 2015, 10:46:14 PM
the whole investigation hinges on whether kate is telling the truth.....surely before spending 11 mill they would have sorted this first

Maybe they are trying to sort that...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 15, 2015, 10:51:43 PM
If there was an open window when Kate arrived then yes it suggests abduction. But they need to reveal Smithman first.

New vexatious FOI requests about Operation Grange and Madeleine McCann's case have been submitted by an individual who apparently believes his own propaganda on the case.

I don't think anything like windows or the Smith sighting is of interest to him ... which is probably quite a good thing because I don't think they will be of much concern to the investigative authority either.

What strikes me about it is the arrant nonsense of demanding information on an active case ... particularly one which has been reopened to investigate what happened to a missing child who may very well be alive.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 15, 2015, 10:56:20 PM
Maybe they are trying to sort that...
I would say they already have...remember...parents not suspects
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 15, 2015, 11:06:29 PM
the whole investigation hinges on whether kate is telling the truth.....surely before spending 11 mill they would have sorted this first

Sort of explains why the average Portuguese tax payer doesn't complain too hard about the 4 man/2 ashtray approach to solving crime.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 16, 2015, 12:09:02 AM
the whole investigation hinges on whether kate is telling the truth.....surely before spending 11 mill they would have sorted this first

Is Kate telling the truth? Eddie alerted to her clothes. She refused to answer questions. She cleaned CC. She wants Amaral to feel fear. She was worried at the table before she disappeared. She got Dianne to tamper with shutters and tried to get Fiona to. She checked the twins were breathing but did not get them tested. She didn't call the police. She cleaned an urgent stain. She didn't go with the others to the beach. She slept in the spare bed. She didn't take the kids out to play that evening. She said DP didn't enter the apartment. She made phone calls just before Mrs. Fenn reported crying. She called Mrs Fenn names. She wanted a priest. She self-harmed herself. She called Paiva a............
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 16, 2015, 12:12:11 AM
Is Kate telling the truth? Eddie alerted to her clothes. She refused to answer questions. She cleaned CC. She wants Amaral to feel fear. She was worried at the table before she disappeared. She got Dianne to tamper with shutters and tried to get Fiona to. She checked the twins were breathing but did not get them tested. She didn't call the police. She cleaned an urgent stain. She didn't go with the others to the beach. She slept in the spare bed. She didn't take the kids out to play that evening. She said .... ...... didn't enter the apartment. She made phone calls just before Mrs. Fenn reported crying. She called Mrs Fenn names. She wanted a priest. She self-harmed herself. She called Paiva a............

Why are outright and damnable lies such as the one I underline tolerated on this forum?

Eddie barked and picked stuff up in his mouth (the same stuff he ignored when it was laid out, first time, in the villa).

So I repeat my question, why are outright and damnable lies permitted on this forum?

(On a thread about propaganda, that is singularly on-topic, except that I'm not sure if outright and damnable lies actually counts as 'propaganda', a semantic point) ....

Bloody hell.  I hadn't even bothered to read the rest of the post.

Kate washed cuddle-cat.

So what?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 16, 2015, 12:35:59 AM

Are we wandering Off Topic?   Please don't do this.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 16, 2015, 12:54:18 AM
Are we wandering Off Topic?   Please don't do this.

A question of propaganda?

I would say that's pretty much on-topic ...

Second paragraph of the opening post:

Quote
My question is this, if a propaganda campaign is being waged against the McCanns how is it being achieved ? How is, we are told, a small minority of individuals able to convince the numbers who are joining groups on social media and posting comments on newspaper comment sections that the McCanns are involved in their daughter's disappearance ? With the full might of the British of the British media on their side and the McCanns innocence, we are told, self-evident how are a tawdry, dissatisfied band of miscontents ( we are lead to believe ) holding such sway over the British public ?


I'm not sure that it is being achieved.

But it is being attempted by the promulgation of disinformation such as that contained in the post of Pathfinder's I reply to above ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:30:31 AM
Is Kate telling the truth? Eddie alerted to her clothes. She refused to answer questions. She cleaned CC. She wants Amaral to feel fear. She was worried at the table before she disappeared. She got Dianne to tamper with shutters and tried to get Fiona to. She checked the twins were breathing but did not get them tested. She didn't call the police. She cleaned an urgent stain. She didn't go with the others to the beach. She slept in the spare bed. She didn't take the kids out to play that evening. She said .... ...... didn't enter the apartment. She made phone calls just before Mrs. Fenn reported crying. She called Mrs Fenn names. She wanted a priest. She self-harmed herself. She called Paiva a............

so as you confirm...no real evidence against kate....just a load of innuendo...which confirms that they have been ruled out
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:07:06 AM
so as you confirm...no real evidence against kate....just a load of innuendo...which confirms that they have been ruled out

No innuendo, just facts.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:14:08 AM
No innuendo, just facts.


could you tell me what..." she didn't take the kids out to paly in the evening" points to...that's one of the facts path has raised
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:15:39 AM
and..."she called mrs Fenn names...she wanted a priest....


these are the facts used to condemn the mccanns....baloney
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:18:38 AM
and..."she called mrs Fenn names...she wanted a priest....


these are the facts used to condemn the mccanns....baloney

What did she and her mate call Mrs. Fenn ?

Why did she need her priest, when her mother admitted she wasn't religious ?

Now when it comes to baloney, the mccanns saying they were devout Catholics, certainly is baloney.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:20:18 AM
What did she and her mate call Mrs. Fenn ?

Why did she need her priest, when her mother admitted she wasn't religious ?

Now when it comes to baloney, the mccanns saying they were devout Catholics, certainly is baloney.

Cite for mccanns saying they were devout catholics..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:23:53 AM
Cite for mccanns saying they were devout catholics..

Pull the other one.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560116/Madeleine-claims-pile-torment-on-McCanns.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:32:11 AM
Pull the other one.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560116/Madeleine-claims-pile-torment-on-McCanns.html

is that roman or anglo...do you understand the difference and it is not a direct quote
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:38:58 AM
is that roman or anglo...do you understand the difference and it is not a direct quote

This will suffice and you are splitting hairs.

' In an interview to be broadcast today, Mr McCann, a devout Catholic, said that God would be the judge of the person who had taken his daughter.

Asked if he could forgive the abductor, he told the BBC's Heaven and Earth programme: "Obviously, we've had incredible pain over the past three months and we pray that Madeleine hasn't. Ultimately it will be God who judges." '

P.S. I am a Catholic.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 16, 2015, 08:39:55 AM
is that roman or anglo...do you understand the difference and it is not a direct quote

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 08:53:53 AM

could you tell me what..." she didn't take the kids out to paly in the evening" points to...that's one of the facts path has raised
It probably means she was too busy covering up a death to play with the kids.  That is the obvious inference - there is an inference behind every "fact" presented in Pathfinder's list of "damning evidence". 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 16, 2015, 08:57:18 AM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)

You don't need to read further than the first 3 words of the article (published in October 2007)

According to reports, ...

Even the bloody moderators are at it now (that is, disseminating propaganda) ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:59:27 AM
You don't need to read further than the first 3 words of the article (published in October 2007)

According to reports, ...

Even the bloody moderators are at it now (that is, disseminating propaganda) ....

Are you saying it is untrue ferryman ?

As to propaganda, that is what you spread.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 16, 2015, 09:31:06 AM
I think you are mixing up opinion with propaganda.


Propaganda is a form of communication, often biased or misleading in nature, aimed at influencing and altering the attitude of a population toward some cause, position or political agenda in an effort to form a consensus to a standard set of belief patterns.


I don't think I am.    The poster on that forum is trying to convince people that Kate is a violent cruel mother who had punished Madeleine and made her cower in the past.

The subject has now gone on to Madeleine being dangerous around the twins and because she could have ended up like her mother she 'had to go'.

All the pictures and video's of Madeleine have shown a happy contented loved child,   a child who is beaten and threatened into cowering is a very reserved quiet child who wouldn't want to upset the parent,  video's show that Madeleine was far from that.

It is also normal for a child to be jealous of a new brother or sister let alone one of each,   the poster refers to Madeleine's odd prod or pinch and the baby sitter saying that Madeleine hit Sean on the head with a toy stethoscope twice,  as a 'red flag'   for god's sake!!  Do these people have children?   A child who has been loved for 22 months without having any competition will obviously be jealous,  if not there is something wrong.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 09:39:28 AM

Propaganda is a form of communication, often biased or misleading in nature, aimed at influencing and altering the attitude of a population toward some cause, position or political agenda in an effort to form a consensus to a standard set of belief patterns.


I don't think I am.    The poster on that forum is trying to convince people that Kate is a violent cruel mother who had punished Madeleine and made her cower in the past.

The subject has now gone on to Madeleine being dangerous around the twins and because she could have ended up like her mother she 'had to go'.

All the pictures and video's of Madeleine have shown a happy contented loved child,   a child who is beaten and threatened into cowering is a very reserved quiet child who wouldn't want to upset the parent,  video's show that Madeleine was far from that.

It is also normal for a child to be jealous of a new brother or sister let alone one of each,   the poster refers to Madeleine's odd prod or pinch and the baby sitter saying that Madeleine hit Sean on the head with a toy stethoscope twice,  as a 'red flag'   for god's sake!!  Do these people have children?   A child who has been loved for 22 months without having any competition will obviously be jealous,  if not there is something wrong.
The people who brain dump onto public online fora like the example above clearly have issues IMO.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 16, 2015, 09:40:47 AM
Though it is not the correct definition for troll.

You are right,   the word troll that we use for the type of person I described is the shortened version of 'trolling'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 16, 2015, 10:43:37 AM

Propaganda is a form of communication, often biased or misleading in nature, aimed at influencing and altering the attitude of a population toward some cause, position or political agenda in an effort to form a consensus to a standard set of belief patterns.


I don't think I am.    The poster on that forum is trying to convince people that Kate is a violent cruel mother who had punished Madeleine and made her cower in the past.

The subject has now gone on to Madeleine being dangerous around the twins and because she could have ended up like her mother she 'had to go'.

All the pictures and video's of Madeleine have shown a happy contented loved child,   a child who is beaten and threatened into cowering is a very reserved quiet child who wouldn't want to upset the parent,  video's show that Madeleine was far from that.

It is also normal for a child to be jealous of a new brother or sister let alone one of each,   the poster refers to Madeleine's odd prod or pinch and the baby sitter saying that Madeleine hit Sean on the head with a toy stethoscope twice,  as a 'red flag'   for god's sake!!  Do these people have children?   A child who has been loved for 22 months without having any competition will obviously be jealous,  if not there is something wrong.

I couldn't agree more Lace although according to some sceptics elsewhere the tennis ball photo shows a hunched, marked, thin and  bruised child and she looks miserable or left out in all other photographs!   Why would anyone believe such blatent rubbish - and also want other people to believe it?

There are 22 months between my daughter and son.  At first, every time I sat down to feed my son - daughter would announce that she needed me to put him down and take her to the loo.     Jealousy is quite normal at that stage.  It soon passes.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 16, 2015, 10:59:23 AM
The people who brain dump onto public online fora like the example above clearly have issues IMO.

Can't disagree with you there however it is one deluded individual's opinion, it is not propaganda in the context we are discussing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:16:03 AM
This will suffice and you are splitting hairs.

' In an interview to be broadcast today, Mr McCann, a devout Catholic, said that God would be the judge of the person who had taken his daughter.

Asked if he could forgive the abductor, he told the BBC's Heaven and Earth programme: "Obviously, we've had incredible pain over the past three months and we pray that Madeleine hasn't. Ultimately it will be God who judges." '

P.S. I am a Catholic.

You claimed the McCanns said they were devout Catholics then provide a quote where someone else is saying it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 11:17:32 AM
Can't disagree with you there however it is one deluded individual's opinion, it is not propaganda in the context we are discussing.
Maybe this is one example of a deluded individual who has been influenced by propaganda then.  Where are all the "sceptic" voices disagreeing with this delusional person?  They don't speak up because " all opinions are equally valid" (when criticising the mcCanns) and anyone who dares suggest that Kate McCann wasn't physically and mentally abusing her daughter must br a McCann supporting troll.  That's how it works on sceptic forums and that is all part and parcel of the propaganda effect.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:17:59 AM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)

This story re the priest has been shown to be bogus
More propaganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 11:23:57 AM
You claimed the McCanns said they were devout Catholics then provide a quote where someone else is saying it

You really need to get a grip, and read around. Then follow up with what Susan Healy said on the issue.

It would seem that certain parties try every trick in the book .

Do you think the mccanns will answer to God on this dave ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:31:16 AM
You really need to get a grip, and read around. Then follow up with what Susan Healy said on the issue.

It would seem that certain parties try every trick in the book .

Do you think the mccanns will answer to God on this dave ?

You said the McCanns claimed to be devout Catholics
Do you have a cite for them saying this
The answer is no
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 11:39:53 AM
You said the McCanns claimed to be devout Catholics
Do you have a cite for them saying this
The answer is no

You sound desperate dave.

By the way, do you think what Susan Healy said on this issue is correct ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:48:08 AM
You sound desperate dave.

By the way, do you think what Susan Healy said on this issue is correct ?

You are dreaming
Tell me what SH said and I will comment
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 11:48:25 AM
...and by the way dave, the claims of mccanns being 'devout catholics' hasn't come form those people who don't believe them.


They both of course come form families with Catholic backgrounds.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 11:49:40 AM
You are dreaming
Tell me what SH said and I will comment
 

Her comments and directly from there are freely available on the internet, as you know well.

So stop prevaricating.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:55:04 AM
 

Her comments and directly from there are freely available on the internet, as you know well.

So stop prevaricating.

Just googled it
She confirms they were not devout but have clung to religion since the tragedy
Absolutely normal
What's wrong with that

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 11:57:05 AM
...and by the way dave, the claims of mccanns being 'devout catholics' hasn't come form those people who don't believe them.


They both of course come form families with Catholic backgrounds.

Where have the claims come from then
I came from a catholic background but left it behind
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 11:57:46 AM
 

Her comments and directly from there are freely available on the internet, as you know well.

So stop prevaricating.

As a general point, if you are going to base your argument on a quote or an article, then it is a courtesy as well as a forum rule to provide a link or a quote from that article.

To make a statement about the article and then tell a fellow poster to go and look it for themselves is the height of bad manners. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 12:14:22 PM
As a general point, if you are going to base your argument on a quote or an article, then it is a courtesy as well as a forum rule to provide a link or a quote from that article.

To make a statement about the article and then tell a fellow poster to go and look it for themselves is the height of bad manners.

I did.

From the Telegraph article.

Why don't you read the article ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 12:15:51 PM
Just googled it
She confirms they were not devout but have clung to religion since the tragedy
Absolutely normal
What's wrong with that

So where do  the claims of being devout Catholics come from ?

The tooth fairy ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 12:28:56 PM
So where do  the claims of being devout Catholics come from ?

The tooth fairy ?

the same place as all the other myths have come from....you have been unable to show the claims came ffrom the mccanns as you calimed
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 12:30:27 PM
the same place as all the other myths have come from....you have been unable to show the claims came ffrom the mccanns as you calimed

No dave, they only came from one source.


...any reader on here can check for themselves on the internet as regards that.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 12:33:40 PM
I did.

From the Telegraph article.

Why don't you read the article ?


You said, upthread "Now when it comes to baloney, the mccanns saying they were devout Catholics, certainly is baloney"

And then cite an article where Olga Craig, a journalist,  refers to Gerald McCann as a devout catholic. 


This has about as much relevance as McKenzie reporting on the rodent munching habits of a comic.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 12:37:24 PM

You said, upthread "Now when it comes to baloney, the mccanns saying they were devout Catholics, certainly is baloney"

And then cite an article where Olga Craig, a journalist,  refers to Gerald McCann as a devout catholic. 


This has about as much relevance as McKenzie reporting on the rodent munching habits of a comic.

Haven't you got the message yet jp ?

Now what did mccann say himself on the quote from the BBC program ?

''Ultimately it will be God who judges."

Do you think the mccanns are Buddhists ? 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 12:45:42 PM
Haven't you got the message yet jp ?

Now what did mccann say himself on the quote from the BBC program ?

''Ultimately it will be God who judges."

Do you think the mccanns are Buddhists ? 8)-)))

No but devout catholics do not have a monoply on god.

Stephen - you have said the MCcanns claim to be devout cathoics.  You have been asked for a cite for the McCanns claiming to be devout catholics.  You have failed to provide such a cite.

So unless you can provide such a cite...   [ moderated ]
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 12:47:53 PM
Haven't you got the message yet jp ?

Now what did mccann say himself on the quote from the BBC program ?

''Ultimately it will be God who judges."

Do you think the mccanns are Buddhists ? 8)-)))

it's figure of speech........used by Einstein and Steven Hawkins....both atheists....there is no god in Buddhism
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 12:49:03 PM
No dave, they only came from one source.


...any reader on here can check for themselves on the internet as regards that.

cite
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 01:16:12 PM
One poster even made a claim (on another thread) that "Is this the man who had the photographs of Cipriano's alleged injuries in his possession, photographs that a photographic expert later testified had been manipulated ? "

- a statement of "fact" but unable to back it up.

 

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 16, 2015, 01:23:34 PM
I don't have one, statistics are not my thing, I just wanted to know how you calculated the odds.  You obviously didn't bother, just got a number off the internet.  I thought you were cleverer than that.... &%+((£

I have shown you how to calculate odds in a previous post.
Odds in favour = Probability/(1 - Probability).
It does pay if you know the difference between odds and probability though as it was the probability of the event I looked up not the odds.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 01:25:32 PM
No but devout catholics do not have a monoply on god.

Stephen - you have said the MCcanns claim to be devout cathoics.  You have been asked for a cite for the McCanns claiming to be devout catholics.  You have failed to provide such a cite.

So unless you can provide such a cite, then you are making an ass of yourself.  Again.

What a pathetic comment.

... and yet another mccann supporter mantra insult to the poster, and indicative of the obsessive nature of mccann backers such as yourself.


By the way, you are reported again.




Is the Daily Mail lying ?

'............In the days after Madeleine vanished on May 3, the McCanns, both 39 and devout Catholics.....'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html#ixzz3uUREVz00
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 01:27:58 PM
I have shown you how to calculate odds in a previous post.
Odds in favour = Probability/(1 - Probability).
It does pay if you know the difference between odds and probability though as it was the probability of the event I looked up not the odds.
Didn't Davel ask you for the odds?  You seem to be mistaking the odds of any child anywhere being abducted by a stranger and the odds of Madeleine mcCann having been abducted, taking into account the circumstances and known facts. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 16, 2015, 01:32:54 PM
Didn't Davel ask you for the odds?  You seem to be mistaking the odds of any child anywhere being abducted by a stranger and the odds of Madeleine mcCann having been abducted, taking into account the circumstances and known facts.

Known facts -  are you suggesting that being left to her own devices increased the odds on her disappearing ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 01:35:26 PM
Known facts -  are you suggesting that being left to her own devices increased the odds on her disappearing ?
Of course they did.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 16, 2015, 01:54:03 PM
Of course they did.

So leaving them was a bad idea, then
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 02:12:08 PM
So leaving them was a bad idea, then
Have I ever said it was a good idea?  Of course it was an ill-advised move on their part, shall we talk about the neglect thing again now, it must be a few hours since it was last mentioned.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 02:17:09 PM

Propaganda is a form of communication, often biased or misleading in nature, aimed at influencing and altering the attitude of a population toward some cause, position or political agenda in an effort to form a consensus to a standard set of belief patterns.


I don't think I am.    The poster on that forum is trying to convince people that Kate is a violent cruel mother who had punished Madeleine and made her cower in the past.

The subject has now gone on to Madeleine being dangerous around the twins and because she could have ended up like her mother she 'had to go'.

All the pictures and video's of Madeleine have shown a happy contented loved child,   a child who is beaten and threatened into cowering is a very reserved quiet child who wouldn't want to upset the parent,  video's show that Madeleine was far from that.

It is also normal for a child to be jealous of a new brother or sister let alone one of each,   the poster refers to Madeleine's odd prod or pinch and the baby sitter saying that Madeleine hit Sean on the head with a toy stethoscope twice,  as a 'red flag'   for god's sake!!  Do these people have children?   A child who has been loved for 22 months without having any competition will obviously be jealous,  if not there is something wrong.



...why have you brought it on here ..and then analysed in your own way what the poster said ....if the above is what you ...in your own words thought it meant ...why did you not tell the poster who made the post ....why come running on here to voice your opinion.....that the person who wrote it had every right to do if that was there thoughts on the matter ... [ moderated ]

i did think of telling/showing the poster your original post ...but thought better of it...

i don't know about you and others who have so much support/compassion for the mccs... [ moderated ] ....i would think that type of person sees the good in everyone ....IMO .....the .........t posts i have seen over the years ...have always come from the mcc supporters by far. %£&)**#

think you should look up the meaning of propaganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 02:21:42 PM
What a pathetic comment.

... and yet another mccann supporter mantra insult to the poster, and indicative of the obsessive nature of mccann backers such as yourself.


By the way, you are reported again.




Is the Daily Mail lying ?

'............In the days after Madeleine vanished on May 3, the McCanns, both 39 and devout Catholics.....'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html#ixzz3uUREVz00
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

read this carefully...you said the mccanns claimed to be devout catholics....now you quote the mail...not the mccanns...papers print a lot of rubbish...have you not realised yet
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 02:30:16 PM
read this carefully...you said the mccanns claimed to be devout catholics....now you quote the mail...not the mccanns...papers print a lot of rubbish...have you not realised yet

The 'devout catholics' did not originate from the sceptics.

So by your logic  if the papers print abduction, then that is pure rubbish as well, isn't it.

...it won't change either the bull given out on or by the McCann's themselves or their 'associates'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 16, 2015, 02:37:29 PM
Susan Healy: 'Kate phoned me, errm… about an hour after Gerry and asked me to get in touch with, errm… Paul Seddon, who is the priest, Father Seddon, who married her, who baptised Madeleine, errm… and I didn't have his mobile phone so I rang a friend of Kate's and got… got him and he rang Kate right away and I think as soon as this happened, as soon as Kate realised what had happened, it was as if, errm.. she started to ask God right away to give her Madeleine. Errm… because Kate and Gerry were not the most devout family. We do have Catholic faith, errm… it's… it's the religion that we were brought up in, but I would never describe myself as a devout person. We're just ordinary people, errm… but Kate certainly has… has clung to her religion, errm.. since this happened. Possibly she feels that, you know, it has to be a greater thing that helps us to get Madeleine back. Errm… something with more power than… than we have.'
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 16, 2015, 02:52:29 PM
No but devout catholics do not have a monoply on god.

Stephen - you have said the MCcanns claim to be devout cathoics.  You have been asked for a cite for the McCanns claiming to be devout catholics.  You have failed to provide such a cite.

So unless you can provide such a cite...   [ moderated ]

No cite needed on this occasion.  The McCanns established they were devout the moment they asked for a priest to attend them.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 03:01:06 PM
No cite needed on this occasion.  The McCanns established they were devout the moment they asked for a priest to attend them.


With respect, that is tosh.

When my mother died I went to see the local priest, and found him very helpful.  But I could never be described as a devout christian or even remotely pious.   
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 03:02:13 PM
Announced visits and other secret, keys provided against the wishes of the Bishop, the priest wife agitated, finished constructions and searches never made​​. What is it that the church of Praia da Luz has?

by Hernâni Carvalho

On the night of their daughter's disappearance, the McCann couple asked for a priest. The priest of the Luz church, José Pacheco, did not respond. The couple knew, even before they had gone to Praia da Luz, that the Anglican priest Haynes Hubbard celebrated masses there and lived with his wife. He had a friendship with McCann's family members. It was with him whom they spoke with. Some days later, Gerry and Kate received the church keys, and since then they were able to enter and leave at any time. A situation that was criticized by the Bishop of the Algarve at the time. When questioned on this discretionary act, the priest José Pacheco said: "Do I decide that?!"

McCanns visited the church in secret

"Although our pain feels much rawer here, it is comforting at the same time since we feel closer to Madeleine - we can read in a press statement sent to Lusa news agency in 12th December 2009, by the McCann's Portuguese PR, in connection to the couple's visit to the church. During the day, the visits were announced and followed by the media. The exception was made in the early hours of January 14, 2010 [issues with date/see references bellow]. At 5am they were seen and photographed leaving the church from a side door. In the afternoon they gave a press conference.

Wife of Priest worried

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 16, 2015, 03:09:03 PM
Would you kindly stop calling my posts "absolute nonsense" - of course I am expressing an opinion, one based on personal observation and experience of McCann bashing forums.  If you can provide evidence that what I have posted is absolute nonsense then kindly present it, otherwise please stop being so rude.

No need to prove it Alfie. Anyone with a modicum of common sense will be aware that it is you that is trying to spread propaganda with  your previous post. BTW continue to post nonsense and I will continue to call you out on it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 03:12:24 PM
No need to prove it Alfie. Anyone with a modicum of common sense will be aware that it is you that is trying to spread propaganda with  your previous post. BTW continue to post nonsense and I will continue to call you out on it.
What absolute nonsense you spout.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 16, 2015, 03:13:34 PM
This story re the priest has been shown to be bogus
More propaganda

You asked for a cite, I gave you one.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 03:20:35 PM
With respect, that is tosh.

When my mother died I went to see the local priest, and found him very helpful.  But I could never be described as a devout christian or even remotely pious.

Totally different circumstances.  Kate McCann especially is well known for her religious devoutness.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 03:27:54 PM
Totally different circumstances.  Kate McCann especially is well known for her religious devoutness.
So Kate McCann is religiously devout.  And this is relevant to the question of propaganda because...?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 03:33:53 PM

Can't remember now, but if you look back, you'll probably find it was some argumentative chunt who raised it as a diversionary side issue.
I'm sure Pathfinder won't appreciate you calling him (her?) that!

ETA beg your pardon, it was Stephen.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 03:40:07 PM
No cite needed on this occasion.  The McCanns established they were devout the moment they asked for a priest to attend them.


Calling for a priest does not make anyone a devout catholic
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Carana on December 16, 2015, 03:50:27 PM
Announced visits and other secret, keys provided against the wishes of the Bishop, the priest wife agitated, finished constructions and searches never made​​. What is it that the church of Praia da Luz has?

by Hernâni Carvalho

On the night of their daughter's disappearance, the McCann couple asked for a priest. The priest of the Luz church, José Pacheco, did not respond. The couple knew, even before they had gone to Praia da Luz, that the Anglican priest Haynes Hubbard celebrated masses there and lived with his wife. He had a friendship with McCann's family members. It was with him whom they spoke with. Some days later, Gerry and Kate received the church keys, and since then they were able to enter and leave at any time. A situation that was criticized by the Bishop of the Algarve at the time. When questioned on this discretionary act, the priest José Pacheco said: "Do I decide that?!"

McCanns visited the church in secret

"Although our pain feels much rawer here, it is comforting at the same time since we feel closer to Madeleine - we can read in a press statement sent to Lusa news agency in 12th December 2009, by the McCann's Portuguese PR, in connection to the couple's visit to the church. During the day, the visits were announced and followed by the media. The exception was made in the early hours of January 14, 2010 [issues with date/see references bellow]. At 5am they were seen and photographed leaving the church from a side door. In the afternoon they gave a press conference.

Wife of Priest worried


 "The couple knew, even before they had gone to Praia da Luz, that the Anglican priest Haynes Hubbard celebrated masses there and lived with his wife."

 The Hubbards hadn't even arrived in PdL when Madeleine disappeared.



13-Processos Volume XIII, pages 3418 to 3420

TRANSLATION BY INES
13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3418
13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3419
13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3420
Witness Statement of Susan Hubbard


Date: 2007.11.13
Time: 11H30
Nationality: Canadian

' That she comes to the process as a witness
' Is married to Anglican Father Haynes
' Has known the McCann family since three days after the disappearance (Sunday). That she went to Portugal on this date (06 May 2007), not to accompany the family but due to work related to the church, which was previously organized.
' That it is the truth that she only knows them through the church and never met them before.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SUSAN_HUBARD.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 03:57:03 PM
Totally different circumstances.  Kate McCann especially is well known for her religious devoutness.

it is not unusual to become religious...or even devoutly religious when your situation is so dire
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 04:07:34 PM
it is not unusual to become religious...or even devoutly religious when your situation is so dire

...or your sins have caught up with you?  Which one is it Dave??
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 04:10:37 PM
...or your sins have caught up with you?  Which one is it Dave??

I would say kates actions are totally normal for a distraught mother whose daughter has been abducted
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 04:12:54 PM
KATE McCann’s request to see a priest on the night of her daughter Madeleine’s disappearance was used as evidence against her, it has been revealed.

The devout Roman Catholic claims she came under suspicion because of the belief that people in Portugal ‘only called for a priest when they wanted their sins to be forgiven   &%+((£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 04:15:52 PM
KATE McCann’s request to see a priest on the night of her daughter Madeleine’s disappearance was used as evidence against her, it has been revealed.

The devout Roman Catholic claims she came under suspicion because of the belief that people in Portugal ‘only called for a priest when they wanted their sins to be forgiven   &%+((£


there you are...in the Uk people call for a priest in times of crisis...not just death
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 04:43:01 PM
KATE McCann’s request to see a priest on the night of her daughter Madeleine’s disappearance was used as evidence against her, it has been revealed.

The devout Roman Catholic claims she came under suspicion because of the belief that people in Portugal ‘only called for a priest when they wanted their sins to be forgiven   &%+((£

Just another example of the propaganda directed against the Drs McCann most of which was as utter tosh as the rubbish promulgated about the priest being destroyed ~ deceived ~ ruined ~ by hearing their confession.

It never happened.  But there are still a lot of people out there who believe it did.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 04:57:00 PM
What a pathetic comment.

... and yet another mccann supporter mantra insult to the poster, and indicative of the obsessive nature of mccann backers such as yourself.


By the way, you are reported again.




Is the Daily Mail lying ?

'............In the days after Madeleine vanished on May 3, the McCanns, both 39 and devout Catholics.....'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html#ixzz3uUREVz00
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

However, his friendship with the couple appeared to spectacularly backfire after police became convinced Kate had told him she had killed her daughter during confession.





But he has vowed to take whatever she had said to the grave, despite being quizzed by detectives.


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html#ixzz3uVHaVN6w
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook



In his statement to the PJ father pacheo said he never heard their confession...so someone is certainly lying
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 05:04:40 PM

there you are...in the Uk people call for a priest in times of crisis...not just death

Not me, a policeman will suffice every time.  In fact I cannot think of a scenario where I would ever want a priest regardless of his religion.  Aren't priests only called in the UK to give the last rites to a dying person?  What did Kate want a priest for anyway, she doesn't speak Portuguese??
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 05:07:34 PM

there you are...in the UK people call for a priest in times of crisis...not just death


well there you are  then,,,,,,,[mayby should be on the searching page]...but ....while every one was searching she wanted a priest.

normally in UK ...usually a priest is called for last rites etc etc ...very similar i would say R C religion every where
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 05:09:03 PM

well there you are  then,,,,,,,[mayby should be on the searching page]...but ....while every one was searching she wanted a priest.

normally in UK ...usually a priest is called for last rites etc etc ...very similar i would say R C religion every where

snap 8((()*/   ...and what about the two episodes of the wailing mullaghs, was that normal too?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 05:13:04 PM
Just another example of the propaganda directed against the Drs McCann most of which was as utter tosh as the rubbish promulgated about the priest being destroyed ~ deceived ~ ruined ~ by hearing their confession.

It never happened.  But there are still a lot of people out there who believe it did.




It never happened.  But there are still a lot of people out there who believe it did.


that's what i always think about the abduction
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 05:16:16 PM
snap 8((()*/   ...and what about the two episodes of the wailing mullaghs, was that normal too?

 @)(++(*,,,,exactly same time too  8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 05:21:26 PM
@)(++(*,,,,exactly same time too  8((()*/

Be careful Xtina, last time I mentioned that about the McCann's prostrating themselves, Alfred said I was being racist, or the equivalent.

 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 05:32:41 PM
Not me, a policeman will suffice every time.  In fact I cannot think of a scenario where I would ever want a priest regardless of his religion.  Aren't priests only called in the UK to give the last rites to a dying person?  What did Kate want a priest for anyway, she doesn't speak Portuguese??

You seem to have a strange idea about the relationship between clergy and laity in British parishes.  So little wonder the Portuguese allegedly had cultural differences if you think as they seemed to that a priest is only contacted in the event of death.

Father Pacheho carried out his pastoral duties in the way one would expect when he did meet with the Drs McCann and their friends.  I am sure had he been able to attend when requested the language difficulty would have been overcome with the help of an interpreter.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 05:36:20 PM
You seem to have a strange idea about the relationship between clergy and laity in British parishes.  So little wonder the Portuguese allegedly had cultural differences if you think as they seemed to that a priest is only contacted in the event of death.

Father Pacheho carried out his pastoral duties in the way one would expect when he did meet with the Drs McCann and their friends.  I am sure had he been able to attend when requested the language difficulty would have been overcome with the help of an interpreter.

How do you know how the father carried out his duties ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 16, 2015, 05:38:47 PM
Not me, a policeman will suffice every time.  In fact I cannot think of a scenario where I would ever want a priest regardless of his religion.  Aren't priests only called in the UK to give the last rites to a dying person?  What did Kate want a priest for anyway, she doesn't speak Portuguese??

If, as you contend, the McCanns were devout cathoics, then why would there be a language problem? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 05:41:35 PM



It never happened.  But there are still a lot of people out there who believe it did.


that's what i always think about the abduction


I think that the majority of the promoted misconceptions which have arisen around this case have their basis in the sort of propaganda typified by the Father Pacheco myths ... of which there are a few ... all of them entirely false.

Perhaps it is true that the pen is mightier than the sword when patently false propaganda retains adherents despite compelling evidence to the contrary.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Carana on December 16, 2015, 05:42:11 PM

well there you are  then,,,,,,,[mayby should be on the searching page]...but ....while every one was searching she wanted a priest.

normally in UK ...usually a priest is called for last rites etc etc ...very similar i would say R C religion every where


Last rites aren't the only reason for calling a priest, otherwise that's like saying the only reason to call a GP is to get a death certificate.

How would calling a priest to perform the last rites fit into the alleged scenario of a faked abduction?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 05:42:47 PM
How do you know how the father carried out his duties ?

Sigh ... I read his witness statement.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 05:43:35 PM


I think that the majority of the promoted misconceptions which have arisen around this case have their basis in the sort of propaganda typified by the Father Pacheco myths ... of which there are a few ... all of them entirely false.

Perhaps it is true that the pen is mightier than the sword when patently false propaganda retains adherents despite compelling evidence to the contrary.

Can you provide a breakdown of these myths ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 05:45:57 PM
Can you provide a breakdown of these myths ?

Yes ... and depending on how long this thread lasts, no doubt I shall hit on quite a few.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 05:57:13 PM
Not me, a policeman will suffice every time.  In fact I cannot think of a scenario where I would ever want a priest regardless of his religion.  Aren't priests only called in the UK to give the last rites to a dying person?  What did Kate want a priest for anyway, she doesn't speak Portuguese??

as you are asking the question you obviously don't know.....priests provide support in many situations
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 05:59:24 PM
Be careful Xtina, last time I mentioned that about the McCann's prostrating themselves, Alfred said I was being racist, or the equivalent.

 8(0(*

I find it quite repugnant that you post in such a way to a parents distress when you admit that it's possible Kate and Gerry were both distraught at the loss of their daughter...absolutely repugnant
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 05:59:35 PM
as you are asking the question you obviously don't know.....priests provide support in many situations

Are you a religious man Dave?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:02:59 PM
Are you a religious man Dave?

that's my business...and certainly none of yours...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 06:03:46 PM
I find it quite repugnant that you post in such a way to a parents distress when you admit that it's possible Kate and Gerry were both distraught at the loss of their daughter...absolutely repugnant

I find it repugnant and in fact nauseating,  that you  defend the parents in what they did in leaving children by themselves in a foreign country, or for that matter anywhere, whilst they wined and dined.

They called that exhibiting 'responsible parenting skills'?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:07:20 PM
as far as I can remember Father Pacheo completely denied having said all that the mail reported...perhaps someone has a link to the article. Certainly in his statement to the PJ made in oct 07 his attitude is supportive
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 06:10:12 PM
You seem to have a strange idea about the relationship between clergy and laity in British parishes.  So little wonder the Portuguese allegedly had cultural differences if you think as they seemed to that a priest is only contacted in the event of death.

Father Pacheho carried out his pastoral duties in the way one would expect when he did meet with the Drs McCann and their friends.  I am sure had he been able to attend when requested the language difficulty would have been overcome with the help of an interpreter.

In that case she should have asked for Robert Murat  @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:10:24 PM
I find it repugnant and in fact nauseating,  that you  defend the parents in what they did in leaving children by themselves in a foreign country, or for that matter anywhere, whilst they wined and dined.

They called that exhibiting 'responsible parenting skills'?

I don't have any problem with that whatsoever
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 16, 2015, 06:11:14 PM
If, as you contend, the McCanns were devout cathoics, then why would there be a language problem?

It was a quip
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 06:12:46 PM
I don't have any problem with that whatsoever

It was never responsible.

The outcome of their 'responsible parenting skills' was the disappearance of Madeleine.

However she disappeared, they laid the foundations for that.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:13:46 PM
It was never responsible.

The outcome of their 'responsible parenting skills' was the disappearance of Madeleine.

However she disappeared, they laid the foundations for that.

so you accept she may have ben abducted
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:17:27 PM
You're very angry tonight.

As to your motives, extremely blatant.

so that you understand how far awy from reality you are with regards to the motive of posters on here..... If the MCCanns were arrested tomorrow I would not be at all concerned... all I would like to see is the truth come out...I'm sure every sceptic on here feels exactly the same
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 06:19:55 PM
so that you understand how far awy from reality you are with regards to the motive of posters on here..... If the MCCanns were arrested tomorrow I would not be at all concerned... all I would like to see is the truth come out...I'm sure every sceptic on here feels exactly the same

Rubbish.

You would not be concerned... &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:21:29 PM
Rubbish.

You would not be concerned... &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+

you are so wrong it's absolutely wonderful ...it shows how poor your judgement is
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 06:22:30 PM
Can I make a suggestion?  That we drop the pretence of having different threads on different subjects and just have one big free-for-all thread where we can just post endless snide insinuations about the McCanns, criticise their parenting skills, and insult each other?  A bit like this one in fact!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 06:28:29 PM
you are so wrong it's absolutely wonderful ...it shows how poor your judgement is

If you weren't concerned, you would not be commenting.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 16, 2015, 06:36:57 PM
Can I make a suggestion?  That we drop the pretence of having different threads on different subjects and just have one big free-for-all thread where we can just post endless snide insinuations about the McCanns, criticise their parenting skills, and insult each other?  A bit like this one in fact!

Right on baby; but deal me out of the snide insinuations about the McCanns.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:44:19 PM
If you weren't concerned, you would not be commenting.

I find the case fascinating
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 06:45:58 PM
Maybe Dave can add that to his many talents.  Only a religious person would ask for a priest.

would that be a slightly religious person....moderate.....or only devout
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 16, 2015, 06:48:59 PM
I noticed the one who got them the church keys and housed the car was never even interviewed.

"On the Sunday two weeks ago when the McCanns left for home, Mr Geraghty was with other friends at Faro airport to see them off."
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 16, 2015, 06:51:55 PM
The McCann's attended Mass at their local church in Leicester,   Kate would go to a meeting on Tuesday too.

They were despairing over the disappearance of Madeleine,  they felt helpless,  in that position who wouldn't if they were Christian turn to God?   

People regularly say 'oh please God help him/her'    'oh please God let him/her be safe'.    What is wrong with them asking for a Priest?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 06:53:25 PM
The McCann's attended Mass at their local church in Leicester,   Kate would go to a meeting on Tuesday too.

They were despairing over the disappearance of Madeleine,  they felt helpless,  in that position who wouldn't if they were Christian turn to God?   

People regularly say 'oh please God help him/her'    'oh please God let him/her be safe'.    What is wrong with them asking for a Priest?
It's wrong because it's the McCanns - do you really need any other explanation?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 16, 2015, 06:55:25 PM
It's wrong because it's the McCanns - do you really need any other explanation?


Oh,  it's the 'they wanted to confess that they had hidden Madeleine'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 06:58:12 PM

Last rites aren't the only reason for calling a priest, otherwise that's like saying the only reason to call a GP is to get a death certificate.

How would calling a priest to perform the last rites fit into the alleged scenario of a faked abduction?


Christ......................i wasn't thinking abduction............i don't believe maddie was abducted ,,...for god sake
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 06:59:39 PM

Christ......................i wasn't thinking abduction............i don't believe maddie was abducted ,,...for god sake
Religious are you?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 07:00:46 PM

Oh,  it's the 'they wanted to confess that they had hidden Madeleine'.
Of course.  They find their child dead.  They hide the body.  They phone the local priest to tell him what they did.  All makes sense now.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:04:09 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)


Praia da Luz priest denies reports in UK newspaper By: CECÍLIA PIREScecilia@portugalresident.comPRAIA DA Luz church is receiving the image of Our Lady of Fátima on Monday, December 18, in a special visit to the region and this is the reason why ribbons and images of Madeleine McCann have been temporarily removed from its interior, according to father José Manuel Pacheco, the local catholic priest .Praia da Luz’s community “has not forgotten the little British girl and special prayers are still being held every Friday,” father José Manuel Pacheco told The Resident.The catholic priest was reacting to reports in the UK’s Daily Express in which he is said to have “ordered the removal of scores of green and yellow ribbons which were put up as a symbol of hope in the days after Madeleine vanished”. The British newspaper quotes a “close friend to the priest” as saying that the latter “can’t even hear the Madeleine case mentioned without becoming irate.” A statement that father José Manuel Pacheco describes as “barbarity” and a “lie”. “I do not know who that ‘friend’ might be, but I doubt such person is my friend”, he told The Resident.Father José Manuel Pacheco ensures that “priests have no power to order anything in our churches. We have an entity for that, which is the Conselho Pastoral, where the catholic community is represented”.Church keyWith regards to the key to Praia da Luz church that the McCanns were given after Madeleine went missing, so that the couple could pray in privacy, “that was a decision made by the Conselho Pastoral and I only knew about it three days later”.Father José Manuel Pacheco said: “Madeleine McCann’s parents know that we support them and that is the most important thing. The family kept very close and good relations with the church and its representatives in Praia da Luz”.Madeleine McCann has now been missing for 225 days and her parents renew appeals every day looking for “that piece of information” that will lead to her being found. In contrast, the police investigation being carried out in Portugal continues to focus on the couple as the main suspects for her probable death.If you have any information on the whereabouts of Madeleine McCann, please contact the McCann helpline on +34 902 300 213 or the Portuguese Police on +351 282 405 400. Do you have a view on this story? Email: editor@portugalresident.com


this is an article in the Portugal Resident with direct Quotes from the priest




http://portugalresident.com/praia-da-luz-priest-denies-reports-in-uk-newspaper
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 07:07:17 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)


Praia da Luz priest denies reports in UK newspaper By: CECÍLIA PIREScecilia@portugalresident.comPRAIA DA Luz church is receiving the image of Our Lady of Fátima on Monday, December 18, in a special visit to the region and this is the reason why ribbons and images of Madeleine McCann have been temporarily removed from its interior, according to father José Manuel Pacheco, the local catholic priest .Praia da Luz’s community “has not forgotten the little British girl and special prayers are still being held every Friday,” father José Manuel Pacheco told The Resident.The catholic priest was reacting to reports in the UK’s Daily Express in which he is said to have “ordered the removal of scores of green and yellow ribbons which were put up as a symbol of hope in the days after Madeleine vanished”. The British newspaper quotes a “close friend to the priest” as saying that the latter “can’t even hear the Madeleine case mentioned without becoming irate.” A statement that father José Manuel Pacheco describes as “barbarity” and a “lie”. “I do not know who that ‘friend’ might be, but I doubt such person is my friend”, he told The Resident.Father José Manuel Pacheco ensures that “priests have no power to order anything in our churches. We have an entity for that, which is the Conselho Pastoral, where the catholic community is represented”.Church keyWith regards to the key to Praia da Luz church that the McCanns were given after Madeleine went missing, so that the couple could pray in privacy, “that was a decision made by the Conselho Pastoral and I only knew about it three days later”.Father José Manuel Pacheco said: “Madeleine McCann’s parents know that we support them and that is the most important thing. The family kept very close and good relations with the church and its representatives in Praia da Luz”.Madeleine McCann has now been missing for 225 days and her parents renew appeals every day looking for “that piece of information” that will lead to her being found. In contrast, the police investigation being carried out in Portugal continues to focus on the couple as the main suspects for her probable death.If you have any information on the whereabouts of Madeleine McCann, please contact the McCann helpline on +34 902 300 213 or the Portuguese Police on +351 282 405 400. Do you have a view on this story? Email: editor@portugalresident.com

this is an article in the Portugal Resident with direct Quotes from the priest

So 'quotes' from the Priest in the Mail.

Is there a signed statement from him in regard to these quotes ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 07:07:45 PM
Religious are you?



what made u think that was it the Christ
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 07:10:43 PM


what made u think that was it the Christ
Bless you child, I was just being wry.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 07:15:59 PM
Bless you child, I was just being wry.


don't mention it father... 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 16, 2015, 07:17:09 PM
Of course.  They find their child dead.  They hide the body.  They phone the local priest to tell him what they did.  All makes sense now.

If it was an accident you usually get help. You usually hide a dead body as a last resort for a serious offence or be banged up for a long time.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 07:18:00 PM
In that case she should have asked for Robert Murat  @)(++(*

I wasn't thinking of him specifically ... it was alleged in some newspapers that he had translated for members of the Tapas seven ... and although he translated for Fiona Payne's mother, at the time it would probably not have been considered inappropriate and would have remained unremarked if he had not been constituted arguido.

But even if he had acted as translator for the Drs McCann, their friends and Father Pacheco ... it would have made no difference ... there would still have been no confession.


**Snip
Sources say Murat translated for Mrs Oldfield, 36, when she was questioned at Portimao police station. His lawyer Francisco Pagarete yesterday denied this - but admitted Murat had translated for Mrs Webster in police interviews.

He added: "He helped the police translate for one person only. That was the elderly lady from the group. He was not involved any more."
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/murat-helped-cops-quiz-tapas-528799

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:18:54 PM
So 'quotes' from the Priest in the Mail.

Is there a signed statement from him in regard to these quotes ?


the source was not named in the mail....the resident quotes the priest as the source
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 07:20:52 PM

the source was not named in the mail....the resident quotes the priest as the source

Anyone can say they quoted someone else.

Means nothing, as is often said, 'about sources close to the mccanns'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:22:39 PM
Anyone can say they quoted someone else.

Means nothing, as is often said, 'about sources close to the mccanns'.

so do you have any quote from the McCanns...signed or otherwise where they say they are devout catholics...the answers no
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 07:24:06 PM
If it was an accident you usually get help. You usually hide a dead body as a last resort for a serious offence or be banged up for a long time.
Right so it wasn't an accident.  My mistake.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 16, 2015, 07:24:48 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-488262/I-deceived-says-Portuguese-priest-comforted-Gerry-Kate-McCann.html)


Praia da Luz priest denies reports in UK newspaper By: CECÍLIA PIREScecilia@portugalresident.comPRAIA DA Luz church is receiving the image of Our Lady of Fátima on Monday, December 18, in a special visit to the region and this is the reason why ribbons and images of Madeleine McCann have been temporarily removed from its interior, according to father José Manuel Pacheco, the local catholic priest .Praia da Luz’s community “has not forgotten the little British girl and special prayers are still being held every Friday,” father José Manuel Pacheco told The Resident.The catholic priest was reacting to reports in the UK’s Daily Express in which he is said to have “ordered the removal of scores of green and yellow ribbons which were put up as a symbol of hope in the days after Madeleine vanished”. The British newspaper quotes a “close friend to the priest” as saying that the latter “can’t even hear the Madeleine case mentioned without becoming irate.” A statement that father José Manuel Pacheco describes as “barbarity” and a “lie”. “I do not know who that ‘friend’ might be, but I doubt such person is my friend”, he told The Resident.Father José Manuel Pacheco ensures that “priests have no power to order anything in our churches. We have an entity for that, which is the Conselho Pastoral, where the catholic community is represented”.Church keyWith regards to the key to Praia da Luz church that the McCanns were given after Madeleine went missing, so that the couple could pray in privacy, “that was a decision made by the Conselho Pastoral and I only knew about it three days later”.Father José Manuel Pacheco said: “Madeleine McCann’s parents know that we support them and that is the most important thing. The family kept very close and good relations with the church and its representatives in Praia da Luz”.Madeleine McCann has now been missing for 225 days and her parents renew appeals every day looking for “that piece of information” that will lead to her being found. In contrast, the police investigation being carried out in Portugal continues to focus on the couple as the main suspects for her probable death.If you have any information on the whereabouts of Madeleine McCann, please contact the McCann helpline on +34 902 300 213 or the Portuguese Police on +351 282 405 400. Do you have a view on this story? Email: editor@portugalresident.com

this is an article in the Portugal Resident with direct Quotes from the priest




http://portugalresident.com/praia-da-luz-priest-denies-reports-in-uk-newspaper

Father José Manuel Pacheco said: “Madeleine McCann’s parents know that we support them and that is the most important thing. The family kept very close and good relations with the church and its representatives in Praia da Luz”.Madeleine McCann has now been missing for 225 days and her parents renew appeals every day looking for “that piece of information” that will lead to her being found.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 07:32:12 PM
so do you have any quote from the McCanns...signed or otherwise where they say they are devout catholics...the answers no

Haven't you read what Admin said earlier ?

Not forgetting what was said by gerry mccann on the BBC program and quote in the Telegraph.

No 'sceptic' would have any reason to make that up.

Likewise we know by quotation what Susan Healy said in regard to this matter.

For the record, it is empirically obvious the mccanns are not devout, and never were.

Probably at the time, ir was they thought a good tool for PR.

IMO , of course.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:36:33 PM
Haven't you read what Admin said earlier ?

Not forgetting what was said by gerry mccann on the BBC program and quote in the Telegraph.

No 'sceptic' would have any reason to make that up.

Likewise we know by quotation what Susan Healy said in regard to this matter.

For the record, it is empirically obvious the mccanns are not devout, and never were.

Probably at the time, ir was they thought a good tool for PR.

IMO , of course.

admin was wrong.....I have never known the mccannns to claim they are devout

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 07:39:44 PM
admin was wrong.....I have never known the mccannns to claim they are devout

Why, do you know them personally ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 07:45:23 PM
Why, do you know them personally ?

What do you think

Come on Stephen
What do you think
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 16, 2015, 08:14:42 PM
admin was wrong.....I have never known the mccannns to claim they are devout

devout >> having or showing deep religious feeling or commitment

All the evidence I have seen supports the notion that Kate is devout in her religioius beliefs and derives much comfort and succour from her visits to the church in Praia da Luz.  Could all be propaganda though?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:15:08 PM
What do you think

Come on Stephen
What do you think

I asked you the question. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 16, 2015, 08:24:21 PM
devout >> having or showing deep religious feeling or commitment

All the evidence I have seen supports the notion that Kate is devout in her religioius beliefs and derives much comfort and succour from her visits to the church in Praia da Luz.  Could all be propaganda though?
I think the point is that the "sceptics" believe the McCanns' religious devotion was a sham, unless I have misunderstood?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:24:29 PM
I asked you the question. 8**8:/:
Whatever I say you don't believe so what's the point
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 16, 2015, 08:25:08 PM
I asked you the question. 8**8:/:

didnt the portugese police  find it weird when they arrived at the scene that gerry and kate were on their knees on the floor??
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:25:52 PM
I think the point is that the "sceptics" believe the McCanns' religious devotion was a sham, unless I have misunderstood?

You're on the ball tonight then. 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:27:51 PM
devout >> having or showing deep religious feeling or commitment

All the evidence I have seen supports the notion that Kate is devout in her religioius beliefs and derives much comfort and succour from her visits to the church in Praia da Luz.  Could all be propaganda though?

All the evidence I have seen....... Suggests they were not devout but like many desperate people turn to religion when they are desperate..... That isn't devout to me.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:29:04 PM
didnt the portugese police  find it weird when they arrived at the scene that gerry and kate were on their knees on the floor??

I don't think that's abnormal
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:30:15 PM
didnt the portugese police  find it weird when they arrived at the scene that gerry and kate were on their knees on the floor??

Indeed they did.

Quite abnormal.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 08:37:30 PM
I don't think that's abnormal

So you would have done the same then  ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 16, 2015, 08:39:34 PM
So you would have done the same then  ?

Quite possibly
I think many would
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 16, 2015, 10:05:59 PM
How many people haven't dave ?

Propaganda always has a purpose.

In Madeleine's case it did not have the desired effect of assisting replicating the 'successful' outcome of Joana's case as no 'confession' resulted.

However, not all was lost as a value was perhaps retained to sell a book ~ and to cover up a failed and inadequate investigation where no alternative to the central theory can be deviated from.

As a propaganda job goes ... it must rank as one of the best.


**Snip
you had 2 goals: 1- find Maddie, or discover what happened to her, you have failed both, you failed your mission and you failed your chance.
   >>>    >>>    >>>
The team you conducted failed both goals.
Miguel Sousa Tavares

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 16, 2015, 10:17:37 PM
Propaganda always has a purpose.

In Madeleine's case it did not have the desired effect of assisting replicating the 'successful' outcome of Joana's case as no 'confession' resulted.

However, not all was lost as a value was perhaps retained to sell a book ~ and to cover up a failed and inadequate investigation where no alternative to the central theory can be deviated from.

As a propaganda job goes ... it must rank as one of the best.


**Snip
you had 2 goals: 1- find Maddie, or discover what happened to her, you have failed both, you failed your mission and you failed your chance.
   >>>    >>>    >>>
The team you conducted failed both goals.
Miguel Sousa Tavares

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234

The current investigation has faired no better or worse than the original.

If you think it has succedded , you are going to be terribly disappointed.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 16, 2015, 11:08:49 PM
as i ask  again why the fixation of one child by mcann supporters? theres missing children all around the world  do they not matter?

It wasn't McCann supporters who donated over 50,000Euros into the fund of a Portuguese ex-cop rather than the Find Ben Needham Fund.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 16, 2015, 11:43:23 PM
Processos Volume XII
 
Pages 3281 - 3284
 
Witness Statement
 
José María Batista Roque
 
Date: 17 – 10 - 2007
 
He comes to the process as a witness. He is an officer with the Lagos GNR and has worked for the Guarda for 21 years.
 
He confirms the integrity of his previous statements.
 
As regards the facts on the night of 3rd May, when he was on patrol with his colleague Costa in Odiaxere, he received a radio communication from the central telling him to go to P da L, specifically to the reception of OC resort where the father of a girl who had disappeared was. When they were on their way to this place and had reached the zone of Valverde he received another communication saying that this was a very young girl and that her father had called again. They continued on their way, now with urgency, heading for the main reception of the resort.
 
When they arrived, they saw the girl's father, a friend whom he cannot describe, an OC employee and a translator who was also an OC employee, named Silvia Batista.
 
After hearing about the circumstances of the disappearance (from the father with the help of translation) at a determined moment he thinks it was the father who told the translator that it was an abduction, at least this is how it was translated. He then went to the apartment, accompanied by his colleague, the father and friend as well as the translator. When he arrived at the apartment he saw the mother there, who opened the wooden door, now referred to as the main door. When he entered, apart from the mother, there were three individuals, one female and two male, whom he cannot identify.
 
Then, while his colleague remained in the hall, and the others were in the living room, the witness went through the entire apartment. He opened all the cupboards in the bedrooms, living room and kitchen and checked under the beds and inside the washing machine. He did not see the fridge.
 
During the search he did not find anything strange apart from the bedclothes on Madeleine's bed, which were too tidy, it appeared that she had been picked up from or had left the bed with great care. There was a mark on the sheet that appeared to be made by a child's body.
 
After the search, he noticed a situation that seemed unusual to him, when at a determined moment, the girl's parents kneeled down on the floor of their bedroom and placed their heads on the bed, crying. He did not notice any comments or expression from them, just crying. He says that at the main reception the father also knelt down, placing his head on the floor and crying. He did not hear the father say anything.
 
He never heard the parents ask to see a priest.
 
After the search he told his colleague to wait by the door while he went to the area around the apartments and the Tapas Restaurant. Whilst he was doing this he noticed the presence of many local people who were searching for the girl.
 
Meanwhile the post commander arrived at the scene and he joined him in a vehicle and travelled around the whole resort. At about 02.30 after having been replaced by two colleagues, he left the scene as the police had already arrived.
 
When questioned about the windows in the bedroom, he only remembers that the window in the girl's bedroom was closed with the blind raised up the space of the width of a hand. He does not remember the existence of curtains. The father indicated, through the translator, alleging that when the disappearance was discovered, the windows and blinds were open.
 
He says there were two children in cots placed in Madeleine's room in a transversal position to the beds. The children never woke up, were in a ventral position, they did not even move during or after the search.
 
He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying. He did not feel that this was an abduction, although this was the line indicated by th faether.

 
As regards the sofa next to the window, he thinks, but is not sure, that it was against the wall.
 
He also refers to a situation when he was searching outside, near the pool, that someone from the Ocean Club whom he cannot identify, passed him a mobile phone, as a British Consulate employee who spoke in Portuguese, wanted to talk to the authorities. Upon speaking to him, he told him that the investigation and subsequent actions were under the responsibility of the PJ.
 
He has nothing to add.
 
Reads, ratifies, signs.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 08:27:11 AM
So the McCanns were not devoutly religious before Maddie's abduction but since the tragedy Kate has turned to God. Initially on finding maddie gone...and the window open they both collapsed on the floor distraught. Strangely the sceptics find all this unbelievable when to many there behaviour in the circumstances is quite normal
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 08:37:54 AM
So the McCanns were not devoutly religious before Maddie's abduction but since the tragedy Kate has turned to God. Initially on finding maddie gone...and the window open they both collapsed on the floor distraught. Strangely the sceptics find all this unbelievable when to many there behaviour in the circumstances is quite normal

Allegedly found the window open dave.

No independent verification of that before kate mccanns return to the apartment.

'He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying. He did not feel that this was an abduction, although this was the line indicated by th faether.'

NO TEARS......
 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 08:53:31 AM
Is Public Relations propaganda?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/hanoversite.jpg&target=tlx_picwrkn
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 09:14:40 AM
The Chartered Institute of Public Relations accepts that propaganda is part of their work, which is primarily about;

Every organisation, no matter how large or small, ultimately depends on its reputation for survival and success.

Terms

The following terms are used in the definition of PR:

'Organisation' can be a government body, a business, a profession, a public service or a body concerned with health, culture, education - indeed any corporate or voluntary body large or small.
'Publics' are audiences that are important to the organisation. They include customers - existing and potential; employees and management; investors; media; government; suppliers; opinion-formers.
'Understanding' is a two-way process. To be effective, an organisation needs to listen to the opinions of those with whom it deals and not solely provide information. Issuing a barrage of propaganda is not enough in today's open society.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 17, 2015, 09:30:44 AM
Allegedly found the window open dave.

No independent verification of that before kate mccanns return to the apartment.

'He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying. He did not feel that this was an abduction, although this was the line indicated by th faether.'

NO TEARS......


Strange if he found their behaviour to be so abnormal that he didn't mention that in his first two statements given on 5th and 16 May - when his memory would be fresh - even though he was  urged to reveal anything else which might help.   

Quote from 16th May statement:-

Urged to reveal other details that may be considered relevant to the investigation, the deponent reveals that he has no other knowledge of any elements that may help contribute to that end;
unquote

In fact apparently it wasn't until 6 months later on 17 October that he remembered what was - according to some   - extremely abnormal behaviour.

In the meantime a vile propaganda campaign against the McCanns was being conducted in the Portuguese press.

 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:37:00 AM

Strange if he found their behaviour to be so abnormal that he didn't mention that in his first two statements given on 5th and 16 May - when his memory would be fresh - even though he was  urged to reveal anything else which might help.   

Quote from 16th May statement:-

Urged to reveal other details that may be considered relevant to the investigation, the deponent reveals that he has no other knowledge of any elements that may help contribute to that end;
unquote

In fact apparently it wasn't until 6 months later on 17 October that he remembered what was - according to some   - extremely abnormal behaviour.

In the meantime a vile propaganda campaign against the McCanns was being conducted in the Portuguese press.

Are you calling him a liar ?

After all, he was there, you weren't.

..and I presume you believe the mccanns prostrating themselves was normal behaviour ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 17, 2015, 09:39:01 AM
So the McCanns were not devoutly religious before Maddie's abduction but since the tragedy Kate has turned to God. Initially on finding maddie gone...and the window open they both collapsed on the floor distraught. Strangely the sceptics find all this unbelievable when to many there behaviour in the circumstances is quite normal

Is it normal for non devout catholics to seek an audience with the Pope or was this yet another PR opportunity or exercise in propaganda?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 17, 2015, 09:46:16 AM
Are you calling him a liar ?

After all, he was there, you weren't.

..and I presume you believe the mccanns prostrating themselves was normal behaviour ?

So you don't think a policeman who was apparently witnessing  'fake crying'  would have wanted to report that fact to his superiors ASAP?    You seem to think it was vital info - so  why didn't he at the time?

I wouldn't find any behaviour from any parents who have just discovered their child is missing to be abnormal.  We are all different.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:48:40 AM
So you don't think a policeman who was apparently witnessing  'fake crying'  would have wanted to report that fact to his superiors ASAP?    You seem to think it was vital info - so  why didn't he at the time?

I wouldn't find any behaviour from any parents who have just discovered their child is missing to be abnormal.  We are all different.

I would imagine at the time with all the hullabaloo going on, writing down everything was not his top priority.

So again, are you saying he was lying, yes or no ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 17, 2015, 09:49:25 AM
Are you calling him a liar ?

After all, he was there, you weren't.

..and I presume you believe the mccanns prostrating themselves was normal behaviour ?

wouldnt be normal at a  crime scene here in australia
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 09:50:40 AM
It appears that the McCanns have used Public Relations professionals from the beginning. Their job seems to be to enhance the reputation of their clients using propaganda. They give out stories, manage requests for interviews and, no doubt, set limits on the questions to be asked. The McCanns appear to have had training in how to get their message across, I have seen interviewers  asking a question which is completely ignored as 'the message' is delivered.

Can a few people on the internet actually compete with these expensive professional reputation managers who have access to the mass media to spread their message? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 17, 2015, 09:53:11 AM
So you don't think a policeman who was apparently witnessing  'fake crying'  would have wanted to report that fact to his superiors ASAP?    You seem to think it was vital info - so  why didn't he at the time?

I wouldn't find any behaviour from any parents who have just discovered their child is missing to be abnormal.  We are all different.

I have great difficulty with the wailing mullah image when days later a laughing Gerry was snapped by an undercover photographer.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:53:53 AM
It appears that the McCanns have used Public Relations professionals from the beginning. Their job seems to be to enhance the reputation of their clients using propaganda. They give out stories, manage requests for interviews and, no doubt, set limits on the questions to be asked. The McCanns appear to have had training in how to get their message across, I have seen interviewers  asking a question which is completely ignored as 'the message' is delivered.

Can a few people on the internet actually compete with these expensive professional reputation managers who have access to the mass media to spread their message?

Well said. 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 10:00:07 AM
I have great difficulty with the wailing mullah image when days later a laughing Gerry was snapped by an undercover photographer.


I don't
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:01:29 AM
I have great difficulty with the wailing mullah image when days later a laughing Gerry was snapped by an undercover photographer.


The last time I posted that clip, I was yold by a mccann supporter, it wasn't real laughter. Just gm responding to a sarcastic remark.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:02:01 AM
I don't

Surprise......................
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 10:02:41 AM
It appears that the McCanns have used Public Relations professionals from the beginning. Their job seems to be to enhance the reputation of their clients using propaganda. They give out stories, manage requests for interviews and, no doubt, set limits on the questions to be asked. The McCanns appear to have had training in how to get their message across, I have seen interviewers  asking a question which is completely ignored as 'the message' is delivered.

Can a few people on the internet actually compete with these expensive professional reputation managers who have access to the mass media to spread their message?

the mccanns needed someone to handle the press who would have besieged them from day one...they are educated professionals and would want professionals to help them cope with  the aftermath...I don't see any problem but perhaps that's because I come from the same background
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 10:07:19 AM
so no real evidence against them...because they are innocent....so sceptics have to imagine Gerry laughing on avideo is a sign of guilt...pathetic
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:16:42 AM
so no real evidence against them...because they are innocent....so sceptics have to imagine Gerry laughing on avideo is a sign of guilt...pathetic

Innocent of what dave ?

The crime is unknown.

and do you really think that video is the only strange aspect to the mccanns behaviour ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 10:17:53 AM
Surprise......................


there is nothing abnormal about the McCanns behaviour...you are imagining there is to try and make it fit your agenda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 10:25:06 AM
Allegedly found the window open dave.

No independent verification of that before kate mccanns return to the apartment.

'He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying. He did not feel that this was an abduction, although this was the line indicated by th faether.'

NO TEARS......





Oh for god's sake Stephen,   many saw them crying and yes with real tears!!  He heard them crying,   people who are traumatised like that make sounds such as gulping back tears and trying not to cry.   You show you haven't a clue about these situations all you want to do is make out these parents are lying.    Why wouldn't they be crying?   Their child had DISAPPEARED!!   or as you want to make out they had got rid of her body.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 10:27:05 AM
The last time I posted that clip, I was yold by a mccann supporter, it wasn't real laughter. Just gm responding to a sarcastic remark.

Yes, it was me Stephen,  and as you can see by the video he shrugs his shoulders,  and that is not proper laughing,  it is obvious that he is being sarcastic.   He also looks as though he may cry any minute,  as laughing is sometimes a replacement for crying.

You have no empathy Stephen,  you wouldn't understand.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 10:28:25 AM
the mccanns needed someone to handle the press who would have besieged them from day one...they are educated professionals and would want professionals to help them cope with  the aftermath...I don't see any problem but perhaps that's because I come from the same background

They did have people helping them,  of course they did,  they were parents who had just had a child disappear,  they couldn't cope with things like that in their state of mind.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:29:10 AM

there is nothing abnormal about the McCanns behaviour...you are imagining there is to try and make it fit your agenda

I have no agenda dave.

I am not acting om someone else's behalf.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:30:15 AM

Oh for god's sake Stephen,   many saw them crying and yes with real tears!!  He heard them crying,   people who are traumatised like that make sounds such as gulping back tears and trying not to cry.   You show you haven't a clue about these situations all you want to do is make out these parents are lying.    Why wouldn't they be crying?   Their child had DISAPPEARED!!   or as you want to make out they had got rid of her body.

Don't put words in my mouth.


The officer was there, neither you or I was.


Why would he lie ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:32:22 AM
Yes, it was me Stephen,  and as you can see by the video he shrugs his shoulders,  and that is not proper laughing,  it is obvious that he is being sarcastic.   He also looks as though he may cry any minute,  as laughing is sometimes a replacement for crying.

You have no empathy Stephen,  you wouldn't understand.

No, it is not obvious he is being sarcastic.

That is your biased viewpoint.

As to empathy, I have it for people who deserve and need it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 17, 2015, 10:41:10 AM
I would imagine at the time with all the hullabaloo going on, writing down everything was not his top priority.

So again, are you saying he was lying, yes or no ?

Why on earth would he need to write down such a massively important observation?  Surely such seriously abnormal behaviour as 'faked crying' would be uppermost in his mind?   It's not something you would forget in those particular circumstances.

I have never said he lied, however the whole purpose of propaganda is to influence people's perceptions of events.  So who knows whether the sustained smear campaign in the press had an affect on this officer or not.  Only he knows that.   

In the meantime I still find it odd that he apparently considered their behaviour - (which if - like yourself -he thought was highly suspicious at the time) was NOT important enough to even mention in his first 2 statements). That makes no sense to me.   




Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:47:51 AM
Why on earth would he need to write down such a massively important observation?  Surely such seriously abnormal behaviour as 'faked crying' would be uppermost in his mind?   It's not something you would forget in those particular circumstances.

I have never said he lied, however the whole purpose of propaganda is to influence people's perceptions of events.  So who knows whether the sustained smear campaign in the press had an affect on this officer or not.  Only he knows that.   

In the meantime I still find it odd that he apparently considered their behaviour - (which if - like yourself -he thought was highly suspicious at the time) was NOT important enough to even mention in his first 2 statements). That makes no sense to me.

Well if you call other information propaganda, then everyting you post in favour of the mccanns is precisely that as well.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 11:03:45 AM
No, it is not obvious he is being sarcastic.

That is your biased viewpoint.

As to empathy, I have it for people who deserve and need it.

Look at this video Stephen,   the parents of Grace who died in the Connecticut shootings at her school,   they are talking about Grace,   their daughter who had just been murdered.   They are smiling!!!   they are laughing!!! are you going to be one of the conspiracy lunatics who believe the Connecticut shootings didn't happen because the parents were able to laugh and smile?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToQNVJE4xgk
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 17, 2015, 11:05:20 AM
Well if you call other information propaganda, then everyting you post in favour of the mccanns is precisely that as well.

The usual deflective post rather than discuss the points made.   
 
Don't you think it was strange that this officer - even when pressed to think about whether there was anything else  (other than what he had already mentioned) that he saw that night which could be relevant - still  didn't mention that he had observed 'faked crying' by the parents?   



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:08:08 AM
I have no agenda dave.

I am not acting om someone else's behalf.

I find it hilarious that you think I am
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 11:09:47 AM
The usual deflective post rather than discuss the points made.   
 
Don't you think it was strange that this officer - even when pressed to think about whether there was anything else  (other than what he had already mentioned) that he saw that night which could be relevant - still  didn't mention that he had observed 'faked crying' by the parents?   

No deflection.

By the way, that is one of your stock phrases.

I have already responded to that question.

Perhaps you should ask a police officer, if witnesses don't always give precise detail the first time they write a statement.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 11:10:43 AM
I find it hilarious that you think I am

I find it naff that you are pretending otherwise.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:13:31 AM
I find it naff that you are pretending otherwise.

so you actually admit that you think I am posting on someone else's behalf...you don't think I could be just a member of the public with no connection to the mccanns
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:20:17 AM
looks like stephens left the building
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:24:27 AM
Is it normal for non devout catholics to seek an audience with the Pope or was this yet another PR opportunity or exercise in propaganda?

I think it's a completely natural thing to do...kate may well have been brought up as a Roman Catholic so at such an awful time they would grasp at anything for help.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 11:24:49 AM
looks like stephens left the building

Wrong again dave.

8(0(*


Your rampant illogic and backing of the mccanns says everything.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:26:46 AM
Wrong again dave.

8(0(*


Your rampant illogic and backing of the mccanns says everything.

says everything to you perhaps....I'm not connected to the McCannns and it just shows how illogical your thinking is if you assume I am
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 11:28:38 AM
the mccanns needed someone to handle the press who would have besieged them from day one...they are educated professionals and would want professionals to help them cope with  the aftermath...I don't see any problem but perhaps that's because I come from the same background

They already had help from day one. Hanover were engaged to change public perceptions of them after they were made arguidos. In other words, reputation management. That's a proactive, not a reactive role.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 11:29:04 AM
says everything to you perhaps....I'm not connected to the McCannns and it just shows how illogical your thinking is if you assume I am

Not at all.

Anyway dave, I live in the real world where adoration of the mccanns is not required.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:32:51 AM
They already had help from day one. Hanover were engaged to change public perceptions of them after they were made arguidos. In other words, reputation management. That's a proactive, not a reactive role.

I  don't see anything wrong with that. We know the PJ were doing everything they could to get them to confess...the McCanns knew they had to defend themselves and their reputation to stop people believing the lies that were..and still are...being spread against them otherwise the public would assume Maddie was dead...they needed to be pro active
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:34:16 AM
Not at all.

Anyway dave, I live in the real world where adoration of the mccanns is not required.

I see having made an accusation you are shying away now...I don't know the mccanns... I support them because I believe they are innocent...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 11:38:30 AM
I see having made an accusation you are shying away now...I don't know the mccanns... I support them because I believe they are innocent...

Who is shying away ?

Your defense of the mccanns knows no bounds.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:39:36 AM
Not at all.

Anyway dave, I live in the real world where adoration of the mccanns is not required.

I do not adore the McCanns and find your accusations insulting and ridiculous
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:40:44 AM
Who is shying away ?

Your defense of the mccanns knows no bounds.

why do you feel the need to constantly make ridiculous accusation s that are merely your opinion..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 11:44:50 AM
I  don't see anything wrong with that. We know the PJ were doing everything they could to get them to confess...the McCanns knew they had to defend themselves and their reputation to stop people believing the lies that were..and still are...being spread against them otherwise the public would assume Maddie was dead...they needed to be pro active

It's one thing defending yourself, it's another thing to hire a company to change negative perceptions into positive ones.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 11:48:32 AM
Processos, Volume 12, Page 231

Snippet From the Statement by Nelson Filipe Pacheco de Costa  about the events of the night of 3rd May.

GNR Officer

One of the group contacted Sky News and the Embassy that night. He does not know if the parents made the call.

Upon leaving the apartment he saw various photographs of the little girl printed on normal A4 paper which had been printed at the reception as well as other photos printed on 10 x 15 photographic poster paper which could not have printed at the reception. This seemed unusual to him and he later confirmed that they could not have been printed at the reception.


Yes it's amazing how ready they were for something that no one could have foreseen happening, ready with the photos, the international media campaign BEFORE actually looking for their daughter.

 a normal parent would run frantic around the apartment ...  street,[ti was a main road] thinking how far could a 3 year old get That kmcc left the twins alone only shows that she KNEW they were in no danger. I don’t know anyone who doesn't keep their mobile on them .... Plus the PR almost immediately. 

The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:56:29 AM
It's one thing defending yourself, it's another hiring spin doctors, which is what PR people are. They don't use transparency and truth, they use smoke and mirrors and propaganda. The use of spin doctors is one of the reasons why their innocence is questioned, because  their job is to manipulate people's opinions, not to tell the whole truth. Hiring professional liars did them no favours imo.

A ridiculous statement..you totally ignore the lies being told by the PJ ...which have been proven...and accuse their spin doctors of lying of which there is no proof...try and be  a little more balanced...

AFAIAC....there is only a small group of fanatics on the net who think the McCanns are not innocent...yes many question their childcare.......but not many question their innocence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 11:57:35 AM
Processos, Volume 12, Page 231

Snippet From the Statement by Nelson Filipe Pacheco de Costa  about the events of the night of 3rd May.

GNR Officer

One of the group contacted Sky News and the Embassy that night. He does not know if the parents made the call.

Upon leaving the apartment he saw various photographs of the little girl printed on normal A4 paper which had been printed at the reception as well as other photos printed on 10 x 15 photographic poster paper which could not have printed at the reception. This seemed unusual to him and he later confirmed that they could not have been printed at the reception.


Yes it's amazing how ready they were for something that no one could have foreseen happening, ready with the photos, the international media campaign BEFORE actually looking for their daughter.

 a normal parent would run frantic around the apartment ...  street,[ti was a main road] thinking how far could a 3 year old get That kmcc left the twins alone only shows that she KNEW they were in no danger. I don’t know anyone who doesn't keep their mobile on them .... Plus the PR almost immediately. 

The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO

The window was open...they knew Maddie had been taken
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: lordpookles on December 17, 2015, 11:59:42 AM
It's one thing defending yourself, it's another hiring spin doctors, which is what PR people are. They don't use transparency and truth, they use smoke and mirrors and propaganda. The use of spin doctors is one of the reasons why their innocence is questioned, because  their job is to manipulate people's opinions, not to tell the whole truth. Hiring professional liars did them no favours imo.

Given the circumstances hiring a PR firm is a sane thing to do. Without the PR firm they would probably be much worse off imo. PR isn't just about managing people's perceptions but having a professional handle the British and international press for you.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 12:01:00 PM
Given the circumstances hiring a PR firm is a sane thing to do. Without the PR firm they would probably be much worse off imo. PR isn't just about managing people's perceptions but having a professional handle the British and international press for you.

absolutely...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 12:04:08 PM
why do you feel the need to constantly make ridiculous accusation s that are merely your opinion..

Mere observation of your behaviour on here.

Total defense of the mccanns, and no criticism of them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 12:15:53 PM
Mere observation of your behaviour on here.

Total defense of the mccanns, and no criticism of them.

if you are going to keep making assumptions about me I will tell you what I think of your situation...and why you post. You claim to be a chemistry teacher but are on here 24/7... I work part time and can post from work if I'm not too busy...you don't seem to work at all...now why would that be..???????
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 12:22:30 PM
It might be called retirement - an enviable  state to attain.  8(>((
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 12:28:02 PM
The window was open...they knew Maddie had been taken

No they didn't.

Never verified before 10 pm.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 12:29:46 PM
if you are going to keep making assumptions about me I will tell you what I think of your situation...and why you post. You claim to be a chemistry teacher but are on here 24/7... I work part time and can post from work if I'm not too busy...you don't seem to work at all...now why would that be..???????

No Dave,  I am not on here 24/7.

Get your facts right.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 12:45:40 PM
Processos, Volume 12, Page 231

Snippet From the Statement by Nelson Filipe Pacheco de Costa  about the events of the night of 3rd May.

GNR Officer

One of the group contacted Sky News and the Embassy that night. He does not know if the parents made the call.

Upon leaving the apartment he saw various photographs of the little girl printed on normal A4 paper which had been printed at the reception as well as other photos printed on 10 x 15 photographic poster paper which could not have printed at the reception. This seemed unusual to him and he later confirmed that they could not have been printed at the reception.


Yes it's amazing how ready they were for something that no one could have foreseen happening, ready with the photos, the international media campaign BEFORE actually looking for their daughter.

 a normal parent would run frantic around the apartment ...  street,[ti was a main road] thinking how far could a 3 year old get That kmcc left the twins alone only shows that she KNEW they were in no danger. I don’t know anyone who doesn't keep their mobile on them .... Plus the PR almost immediately. 

The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO



 Witness Statement

Date : 2008-04-17
Time. 10.00

 Place: Praia da Luz

 Name: Amy Tierney


 Has made previous statements in May last year.

 Given that she does not speak Portuguese, Silvia Batista acted as interpreter.

When questioned and shown the photographs referred to in the previous statements, depicting the English girl, on 'Kodak Xtra Life ' paper, 10 x 15, she said they were printed on her printer, also of Kodak brand.

 When on the night of 3rd May, at about 24.00, she was at her desk at the Tapas bar, inside the resort, when at a certain time, one of the friends of the McCann couple, Russell, asked for a USB memory stick reader, in order to print photographs of Madeleine. Immediately the deponent replied that she did not have an USB reader, but that she had a printer with this hardware, which could read from memory sticks.


 She went to her room and returned to the Tapas with the printer where  she printed out 20 to 30 photographs of the girl, using her own paper, in 10x15 format mentioned previously. The memory stick containing the photos belonged to the McCann couple, and came from their camera.

 She thinks that all of this took place at about 24.00 on 3rd May 2007. She presumes that she handed all of the photos to Russell, who distributed some to those present, the rest would be for the police authorities.

 As regards her printer, she says that it is no longer in her possession as it is now with her boyfriend in France, she says, after consultation, and in accordance with her previous statements, that is was a 'Kodak', model Easy Share G60, of thermal ink transfer, with continuous tonality.

 In annex, is documentation about the printer, describing its technical characteristics, which she recognises as being identical to her printer.

 No more is said. She signs the statement together with the interpreter.



Note the time,  she said this happened about 12o'clock hardly before any searching.

Also the photo was an old one,  so they were hardly 'ready' as you say.

You would do yourself a favour if you read the statements in the Police files.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 17, 2015, 12:46:18 PM
Speaking of propaganda, Richard Hall exposes some really interesting issues.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 17, 2015, 12:51:37 PM
Speaking of propaganda, Richard Hall exposes some really interesting issues.


looks like there isa set of conjoined twins  @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 12:57:25 PM
Speaking of propaganda, Richard Hall exposes some really interesting issues.


Interesting?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 17, 2015, 01:00:53 PM
I hadn't watched that video in its entirety previously but I would recommend doing so for anyone who is interested in the case.  The only part I would take issue with is the suggestion that Maddie died prior to the 3rd May.

Another curious point raised by Hall is why the Smiths are so reluctant to answer the simplest of questions?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 01:02:11 PM


 Witness Statement

Date : 2008-04-17
Time. 10.00

 Place: Praia da Luz

 Name: Amy Tierney


 Has made previous statements in May last year.

 Given that she does not speak Portuguese, Silvia Batista acted as interpreter.

When questioned and shown the photographs referred to in the previous statements, depicting the English girl, on 'Kodak Xtra Life ' paper, 10 x 15, she said they were printed on her printer, also of Kodak brand.

 When on the night of 3rd May, at about 24.00, she was at her desk at the Tapas bar, inside the resort, when at a certain time, one of the friends of the McCann couple, Russell, asked for a USB memory stick reader, in order to print photographs of Madeleine. Immediately the deponent replied that she did not have an USB reader, but that she had a printer with this hardware, which could read from memory sticks.


 She went to her room and returned to the Tapas with the printer where  she printed out 20 to 30 photographs of the girl, using her own paper, in 10x15 format mentioned previously. The memory stick containing the photos belonged to the McCann couple, and came from their camera.

 She thinks that all of this took place at about 24.00 on 3rd May 2007. She presumes that she handed all of the photos to Russell, who distributed some to those present, the rest would be for the police authorities.

 As regards her printer, she says that it is no longer in her possession as it is now with her boyfriend in France, she says, after consultation, and in accordance with her previous statements, that is was a 'Kodak', model Easy Share G60, of thermal ink transfer, with continuous tonality.

 In annex, is documentation about the printer, describing its technical characteristics, which she recognises as being identical to her printer.

 No more is said. She signs the statement together with the interpreter.



Note the time,  she said this happened about 12o'clock hardly before any searching.

Also the photo was an old one,  so they were hardly 'ready' as you say.

You would do yourself a favour if you read the statements in the Police files.

If it came off the McCanns camera, as stated, one wonders why they didn't choose a more  current one, either from thePDL  holiday, or from the recent Donegal trip.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:10:03 PM
I hadn't watched that video in its entirety previously but I would recommend doing so for anyone who is interested in the case.  The only part I would take issue with is the suggestion that Maddie died prior to the 3rd May.

Another curious point raised by Hall is why the Smiths are so reluctant to answer the simplest of questions?

Hall is a conspiracy fruitloop.

Why would the Smiths answer questions?   They give their statements to the police,   the investigation is on going.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:11:03 PM
If it came off the McCanns camera, as stated, one wonders why they didn't choose a more  current one, either from thePDL  holiday, or from the recent Donegal trip.

They would have needed a photo showing Madeleine's full face,  a lot of the others show her from the side.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 01:13:11 PM
The McCanns curious behaviour as witnessed by Inspector Ricardo Paiva

Processos Vol X
Pages 2533 - 2534

Date: 2007/09/03

For : Goncalo Amaral

From Ricardo Paiva, Inspector

Subject: Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

During the course of the ongoing investigation, various personal contacts were made by the undersigned with Kate and Gerald McCann, within my task of serving as communication element between the police and the McCann couple.

Within this context, the undersigned was present during various "strange" behaviours by the couple, who gradually began to react in a very negative manner to the increased investigative activity carried out by this police force, especially during the use of the English sniffer dogs for detecting cadaver odour, when more evidence arose in the investigation for the hypothesis of the death of Madeleine McCann.

Several times, the McCann couple said that the attention of the police should be maintained focussing on the abduction hypothesis, which, in the couple's opinion, was the only scenario that occurred and that the police should not forget to continue to investigate the suspect Robert Murat.

Strangely, Kate also made several requests, three months after the disappearance of Madeleine, that the police should take blood, hair and nail tests of Madeleine's twin siblings, because, as she said, she remembered that on the day of Madeleine's disappearance, in spite of all the commotion and noise made by the authorities and other persons who were looking for Madeleine in apartment 5ª of the Ocean Club, the twins never woke up, having been transported to another apartment, they remained asleep, due to which she now presumes that they were under the effect of some sedative drug that a presumed abductor had administered to the three children in order to be able to abduct Madeleine, a situation which Kate refers to being possible according to what she read in a criminal investigation manual given to her by the British authorities, that would have been the procedure of the abductor in the real case involving abduction, rape and murder of the girl.

Today, when the undersigned went to the McCann's temporary residence to notify them of the need to present themselves at the police station to make statements, being able to take their lawyer with them, Kate McCann immediately reacted in a negative manner, making comments such as "what are my parents going to think" and "what is the press going to say when they find out" and that "the Portuguese police is under pressure from the government to finish the investigation quickly".

With regard to Gerald McCann, he constantly insisted in giving the undersigned letters and emails that he was receiving, mostly from psychics and mediums, whom he had selected and which mainly contained information without much credibility about the possible whereabouts of Madeleine and her presumed abductor.

More recently, and even before Kate's interrogation, during a telephone call between Gerald McCann and the undersigned, he made a reference regarding the investigation, that he was certain that the police did not have any proof that could incriminate them with regard to the death of Madeleine McCann and he said that the police were wasting their time in directing the investigation around the parents.

I bring this to your knowledge.
Inspector
Ricardo Paiva
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 01:15:35 PM
Hall is a conspiracy fruitloop.

Why would the Smiths answer questions?   They give their statements to the police,   the investigation is on going.

Have you watched this latest video ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 01:20:14 PM
They would have needed a photo showing Madeleine's full face,  a lot of the others show her from the side.

How fortunate, then, that they just happened to conveniently have one with them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:22:24 PM
How fortunate, then, that they just happened to conveniently have one with them.

No not really,  they had their camera with them,  I have many photo's on mine that I haven't put on to the computer or printed off,  nothing unusual about that.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:23:15 PM
Have you watched this latest video ?

I don't watch anything by that man.   Is that where you get your info @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 01:29:31 PM
It might be called retirement - an enviable  state to attain.  8(>((

I think it's something quite different...based on the evidence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:30:53 PM
The McCanns curious behaviour as witnessed by Inspector Ricardo Paiva

Processos Vol X
Pages 2533 - 2534

Date: 2007/09/03

For : Goncalo Amaral

From Ricardo Paiva, Inspector

Subject: Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

During the course of the ongoing investigation, various personal contacts were made by the undersigned with Kate and Gerald McCann, within my task of serving as communication element between the police and the McCann couple.

Within this context, the undersigned was present during various "strange" behaviours by the couple, who gradually began to react in a very negative manner to the increased investigative activity carried out by this police force, especially during the use of the English sniffer dogs for detecting cadaver odour, when more evidence arose in the investigation for the hypothesis of the death of Madeleine McCann.

Several times, the McCann couple said that the attention of the police should be maintained focussing on the abduction hypothesis, which, in the couple's opinion, was the only scenario that occurred and that the police should not forget to continue to investigate the suspect Robert Murat.

Strangely, Kate also made several requests, three months after the disappearance of Madeleine, that the police should take blood, hair and nail tests of Madeleine's twin siblings, because, as she said, she remembered that on the day of Madeleine's disappearance, in spite of all the commotion and noise made by the authorities and other persons who were looking for Madeleine in apartment 5ª of the Ocean Club, the twins never woke up, having been transported to another apartment, they remained asleep, due to which she now presumes that they were under the effect of some sedative drug that a presumed abductor had administered to the three children in order to be able to abduct Madeleine, a situation which Kate refers to being possible according to what she read in a criminal investigation manual given to her by the British authorities, that would have been the procedure of the abductor in the real case involving abduction, rape and murder of the girl.

Today, when the undersigned went to the McCann's temporary residence to notify them of the need to present themselves at the police station to make statements, being able to take their lawyer with them, Kate McCann immediately reacted in a negative manner, making comments such as "what are my parents going to think" and "what is the press going to say when they find out" and that "the Portuguese police is under pressure from the government to finish the investigation quickly".

With regard to Gerald McCann, he constantly insisted in giving the undersigned letters and emails that he was receiving, mostly from psychics and mediums, whom he had selected and which mainly contained information without much credibility about the possible whereabouts of Madeleine and her presumed abductor.

More recently, and even before Kate's interrogation, during a telephone call between Gerald McCann and the undersigned, he made a reference regarding the investigation, that he was certain that the police did not have any proof that could incriminate them with regard to the death of Madeleine McCann and he said that the police were wasting their time in directing the investigation around the parents.

I bring this to your knowledge.
Inspector
Ricardo Paiva

Again look at the date of that statement.   After Amaral had stated he believed the McCann's guilty,  you really have to wonder.

The McCann's were exasperated that they didn't seem to be searching for Madeleine and instead were trying to frame them.

Kate was worried how her father would take the news as he is very ill,  no doubt she thought it would make his condition worse.

Amaral lied about the DNA he said that they had DNA that matched Madeleine's 100 %  that was a cruel thing to say to them,   they thought Madeleine was dead indeed Kate asked them if she was dead.

If I had been in their shoes I think I would have attacked Amaral,  and been locked up for it.   I think they behaved extremely well in the circumstances.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 01:33:03 PM
I don't watch anything by that man.   Is that where you get your info @)(++(*


you get yours from other forums don't you   8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 17, 2015, 01:37:18 PM
Hall is a conspiracy fruitloop.

Why would the Smiths answer questions?   They give their statements to the police,   the investigation is on going.

That's not a fair assessment of his work but never mind.  I found the video to be a fair assessment of the statements and media reports without being judgemental.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 01:47:08 PM
I think it's something quite different...based on the evidence

Do you not look forward to retirement? You must be that sort of age.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 01:49:10 PM

you get yours from other forums don't you   8**8:/:

Some,   but most is from the Police files, which I read when I first became interested in the case.   Now I am able to ignore what I know to be untrue.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 01:52:09 PM
I don't watch anything by that man.   Is that where you get your info @)(++(*

Well before you criticize the video, watch it.

Second, no  I do not get my information just from him.

Do you get yours from the mccanns ? 😉
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 02:00:47 PM
That's not a fair assessment of his work but never mind.  I found the video to be a fair assessment of the statements and media reports without being judgemental.

have you seen any of his other work.....alien abductions reported as fact...crop circles....a serious journalist should be unbiased
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 02:01:17 PM
Well before you criticize the video, watch it.

Second, no  I do not get my information just from him.

Do you get yours from the mccanns ? 😉

No thanks,   thing is I know what's true by reading the Police Files,  he just takes something and puts his own view onto it,  adds a bit of mystery and 'what do you think'  so that you will watch his video's.

No one can add anything new to this case Stephen,  we have it all in the Police Files.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 02:09:06 PM
Again look at the date of that statement.   After Amaral had stated he believed the McCann's guilty,  you really have to wonder.

The McCann's were exasperated that they didn't seem to be searching for Madeleine and instead were trying to frame them.

Kate was worried how her father would take the news as he is very ill,  no doubt she thought it would make his condition worse.

Amaral lied about the DNA he said that they had DNA that matched Madeleine's 100 %  that was a cruel thing to say to them,   they thought Madeleine was dead indeed Kate asked them if she was dead.

If I had been in their shoes I think I would have attacked Amaral,  and been locked up for it.   I think they behaved extremely well in the circumstances.

If I had been in their shoes I think I would have attacked Amaral,  and been locked up for it.

thought you had a bit of a vicious streak

it was not only Amaral ....you all keep blaming him ...it was the opinion of is officers also .....[just for you ] bit long but I'm sure you will have time to read it


Intercalary report compiled by chief inspector Tavares de Almeida, for the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator, 10 September 2007
    
Intercalary report compiled by chief inspector Tavares de Almeida, for the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator, Gonçalo Amaral PJ Files

page 2601, Vol. X, of Process NUIPC-201/07.0 GALGS

For the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator

Madeleine Beth Maccann was born on the 12th of May 2003.

She has been missing since the 3rd of May 2007, a fact that took place in Praia da Luz, in Lagos.
If the information wouldn’t be counting on said witness (?), then the disappearance would have taken place between 9 and 10 p.m., widening the time period (presuming that the father speaks the truth).

But there is another question about the timing which is:

The last time that the child was seen outside of the group, by someone who can prove that moment, was at around 5.35 p.m., when the parents went to pick her up at the crèche, which may widen the time lapse between the disappearance and the alert, into four hours.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic34.html?sid=be27e23f8d46f6e11b76a3c60630d4fd#p422

CONCLUSION

On the tenth of September, two thousand and seven

Chief Inspector

(Tavares de Almeida)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 02:14:18 PM
No thanks,   thing is I know what's true by reading the Police Files,  he just takes something and puts his own view onto it,  adds a bit of mystery and 'what do you think'  so that you will watch his video's.

No one can add anything new to this case Stephen,  we have it all in the Police Files.

Rollocks

Just watch and then give an appraisal.

Otherwise, what you said is pointless.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 02:16:43 PM
have you seen any of his other work.....alien abductions reported as fact...crop circles....a serious journalist should be unbiased

Have you watched them dave ?

Can't say they are my cup of tea, but he is not the only program maker looking at crop circles, is he ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 02:29:08 PM
Processos, Volume 12, Page 231

Snippet From the Statement by Nelson Filipe Pacheco de Costa  about the events of the night of 3rd May.

GNR Officer

One of the group contacted Sky News and the Embassy that night. He does not know if the parents made the call.

Upon leaving the apartment he saw various photographs of the little girl printed on normal A4 paper which had been printed at the reception as well as other photos printed on 10 x 15 photographic poster paper which could not have printed at the reception. This seemed unusual to him and he later confirmed that they could not have been printed at the reception.


Yes it's amazing how ready they were for something that no one could have foreseen happening, ready with the photos, the international media campaign BEFORE actually looking for their daughter.

 a normal parent would run frantic around the apartment ...  street,[ti was a main road] thinking how far could a 3 year old get That kmcc left the twins alone only shows that she KNEW they were in no danger. I don’t know anyone who doesn't keep their mobile on them .... Plus the PR almost immediately. 

The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO

Taken from Goncalo Amaral interview with Miguel Sousa Tavares.


  ... I cannot speak about the book, but you doctor can
(Miguel: yes I can, I was not forbidden, when you talk about evidences, you speaks about the hypothesis of her being killed by her parents, to hide her body)

GA: no, no I never said that,
Miguel says: but it is what is in the book,

GA: what I say in the book, let me explain
(Miguel: but you had fun yourself).

GA: I don´t say,
(Miguel: the final conclusion),

GA: no, no, then you had not read the book, that book is the English truth and there is nothing there.
Miguel: I have not read it? Oh yes I have read it, the book ends with 4 conclusions marked in black.

GA says: conclusions which are not talking about murder by the parents.
(Miguel: I didn´t said murder by her parents, could been killed accidentally).

GA repeats: no, no,accidentally is not killed by someone, an accident is an accident, it´s not any murder.
Miguel says: it is involuntary murder, you always told that they hid their daughter´s body, is that not in your book? Miguel repeats this question, Is this not in your book?)

GA says: this is where you Miguel is wrong, what´s in the book is six month of investigation, during which I was in charge and where it concludes with reports which are there, the suspicions at that time and has you Miguel knows, criminal investigation has it´s time, a beginning, a middle and an end, and so on, and in that moment there was suspicion, which doesn´t mean later, but, but
(Miguel says: but the suspicions were mostly yours, you know GA, another thing that is impressive is, let´s get back, shall we)

GA: you are putting words in my mouth, you are forbidden
(Miguel continues: no no, the words are mine, my conclusions and taken from your book and taken from the process)

GA says: no the suspicions, you are putting words in my mouth or what, no, you are talking about the injunction, it is an interpretation of the book
(Miguel: it is an interpretation of the book, you receive the news, gives the order to PJ picket, go to your home,
(GA: yes, like in any other case).

Miguel continues: you go to your home, wake up in the morning, this is in your book, and the first thing that comes to your brain is to ask the British who are the McCanns?
And you start immediately to suspect and ask questions, the questions you ask are:
and then, much ahead you say is common sense in these cases to suspect of the parents, so,
and you´re already suspect them? Is it, or is it not. You´re a master). 

GA says: yes, then says, listen, I or any other, yes, yes, it´s normal, to suspect, you´re wrong, it´s common sense, listen doctor, you are making fantasies, something,
Miguel says: no, I´m not making fantasies, I read your book).

GA repeats: the issue is this: the national and international laws in any of these cases and we were criticised by the FBI about this, is the issue of suspect or not of parents, or the closest in these types of cases and I can tell you, (Miguel says: you believe, but I don´t say suspect, at a certain time now, the first suspicions is that it?).
GA says: it´s not the first suspicion, we have to know first who those people are. 

Miguel says: Was it not most urgent to know if the borders were all closed? Are all the marinas under surveillance? All the cars who left there under control?).
GA says: But we knew. We took care of that. No, it cannot know all cars who left there. And look, we reached the conclusion that for example the Via of Infant has some TV cameras which didn´t work, we talked with Spanish colleagues to control the border of Cádiz, in terms of access to Morocco, all those, Tenerife, and so on
(Miguel says: the marinas were not immediately controlled, because I know who left for example of Lagos marina one day after, quietly).

GA: but we have all that information.
We know that.
From a place where some occurrence happens, we analyze it, if there are CCTV, if there are no CCTV, if there are any CCTV, what can be seen, what cannot be seen, all of that, at the same time, look, saying that we aimed immediately to, it´s not like that, that question is relativity to the parents, excuse me, that first question, that, was answered, it is the first, was never answered, it is the first, it is important to understand...

(Miguel: since the first day, anyone who read your book concludes immediately that in the first meeting, at the end of the first day, is the strongest hypothesis you have, and I believe that has been created at a certain time of the investigation, but now, is the first hypothesis of work, it is the first hypothesis of work you pick and seems to be the only.
GA says: it´s not
(Miguel insists: it looks to be the only one).

GA repeats: not it´s not.
Miguel insists again: it is, it is.

GA says: doctor read the book.
Miguel says: I read the book.

GA says: notice, there are at the book , there are the investigations for the abduction, there we have the abduction, what has been done.
Miguel says: in terms of abduction, yes).

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234


It seems your opinion was wrong "The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO" 

Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory.

The most elementary error it is possible for an investigator to make is to formulate a theory then look for the evidence to fit.  The evidence has primacy ... not the uninformed notion of the police.

That this inept investigation has in some people's minds been turned into the textbook operation it demonstrably was not and its co-ordinator considered a Sherlock Holmes surely must represent the propaganda coup of the last couple of centuries.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 02:36:24 PM
Taken from Goncalo Amaral interview with Miguel Sousa Tavares.


  ... I cannot speak about the book, but you doctor can
(Miguel: yes I can, I was not forbidden, when you talk about evidences, you speaks about the hypothesis of her being killed by her parents, to hide her body)

GA: no, no I never said that,
Miguel says: but it is what is in the book,

GA: what I say in the book, let me explain
(Miguel: but you had fun yourself).

GA: I don´t say,
(Miguel: the final conclusion),

GA: no, no, then you had not read the book, that book is the English truth and there is nothing there.
Miguel: I have not read it? Oh yes I have read it, the book ends with 4 conclusions marked in black.

GA says: conclusions which are not talking about murder by the parents.
(Miguel: I didn´t said murder by her parents, could been killed accidentally).

GA repeats: no, no,accidentally is not killed by someone, an accident is an accident, it´s not any murder.
Miguel says: it is involuntary murder, you always told that they hid their daughter´s body, is that not in your book? Miguel repeats this question, Is this not in your book?)

GA says: this is where you Miguel is wrong, what´s in the book is six month of investigation, during which I was in charge and where it concludes with reports which are there, the suspicions at that time and has you Miguel knows, criminal investigation has it´s time, a beginning, a middle and an end, and so on, and in that moment there was suspicion, which doesn´t mean later, but, but
(Miguel says: but the suspicions were mostly yours, you know GA, another thing that is impressive is, let´s get back, shall we)

GA: you are putting words in my mouth, you are forbidden
(Miguel continues: no no, the words are mine, my conclusions and taken from your book and taken from the process)

GA says: no the suspicions, you are putting words in my mouth or what, no, you are talking about the injunction, it is an interpretation of the book
(Miguel: it is an interpretation of the book, you receive the news, gives the order to PJ picket, go to your home,
(GA: yes, like in any other case).

Miguel continues: you go to your home, wake up in the morning, this is in your book, and the first thing that comes to your brain is to ask the British who are the McCanns?
And you start immediately to suspect and ask questions, the questions you ask are:
  • if they hurt children,
  • if the have a serious problem with law,
  • if they have psychological problems,
  • if they are in fact doctors in full time,
and then, much ahead you say is common sense in these cases to suspect of the parents, so,
  • you have not yet seen the McCanns,
  • you have not yet been at the crime scene
and you´re already suspect them? Is it, or is it not. You´re a master).

GA says: yes, then says, listen, I or any other, yes, yes, it´s normal, to suspect, you´re wrong, it´s common sense, listen doctor, you are making fantasies, something,
Miguel says: no, I´m not making fantasies, I read your book).

GA repeats: the issue is this: the national and international laws in any of these cases and we were criticised by the FBI about this, is the issue of suspect or not of parents, or the closest in these types of cases and I can tell you, (Miguel says: you believe, but I don´t say suspect, at a certain time now, the first suspicions is that it?).
GA says: it´s not the first suspicion, we have to know first who those people are.

Miguel says: Was it not most urgent to know if the borders were all closed? Are all the marinas under surveillance? All the cars who left there under control?).
GA says: But we knew. We took care of that. No, it cannot know all cars who left there. And look, we reached the conclusion that for example the Via of Infant has some TV cameras which didn´t work, we talked with Spanish colleagues to control the border of Cádiz, in terms of access to Morocco, all those, Tenerife, and so on
(Miguel says: the marinas were not immediately controlled, because I know who left for example of Lagos marina one day after, quietly).

GA: but we have all that information.
We know that.
From a place where some occurrence happens, we analyze it, if there are CCTV, if there are no CCTV, if there are any CCTV, what can be seen, what cannot be seen, all of that, at the same time, look, saying that we aimed immediately to, it´s not like that, that question is relativity to the parents, excuse me, that first question, that, was answered, it is the first, was never answered, it is the first, it is important to understand...

(Miguel: since the first day, anyone who read your book concludes immediately that in the first meeting, at the end of the first day, is the strongest hypothesis you have, and I believe that has been created at a certain time of the investigation, but now, is the first hypothesis of work, it is the first hypothesis of work you pick and seems to be the only.
GA says: it´s not
(Miguel insists: it looks to be the only one).

GA repeats: not it´s not.
Miguel insists again: it is, it is.

GA says: doctor read the book.
Miguel says: I read the book.

GA says: notice, there are at the book , there are the investigations for the abduction, there we have the abduction, what has been done.
Miguel says: in terms of abduction, yes).

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234


It seems your opinion was wrong "The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO" 

Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory.

The most elementary error it is possible for an investigator to make is to formulate a theory then look for the evidence to fit.  The evidence has primacy ... not the uninformed notion of the police.

That this inept investigation has in some people's minds been turned into the textbook operation it demonstrably was not and its co-ordinator considered a Sherlock Holmes surely must represent the propaganda coup of the last couple of centuries.

can you point out what i am suppose to look at ...what had to do with my post ty
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 02:50:46 PM


Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - Gonçalo Amaral says that he is not a victim of the Maddie case but acknowledges that he has been dealing with the consequences of a battle for the past seven years, a battle he was forced to fight by virtue of being a policeman.

Gonçalo Amaral - We are part of the collateral damages and in fact that’s all we are. Mere extras in a tragedy... a tragedy that affects that family, no question about it, but mainly the victim, that is the child who disappeared and who may be, as all points to, dead.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - The setbacks due to the case were translated into family, affective and material losses, nevertheless Gonçalo Amaral guarantees that he would write the book again in which he responsibilizes the McCann couple for their daughter's disappearance.

Gonçalo Amaral - Maybe even do a second... a second volume but...

Helena Figueiras- Would you have more to say?

Gonçalo Amaral - ...Actually, that is already written, it is written but I don't believe I'll publish any further books about this case.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - As to the investigation, he speaks of avenues of investigation that he would follow again, with only one difference, he would never have let down the guard in relation to Kate and Gerry.

Gonçalo Amaral - It was due to those diplomatic issues, the ambassador’s intervention and all else, who promptly wanted to push towards the abduction thesis. That limited the police action in the sense that they [McCanns] would have been treated as suspects from the start otherwise. What does that imply? That means, that they and those close to them would have been the target of direct, personal surveillance, and also of electronic surveillance. We were lead to consider other paths and only later did we return to that starting point. In some way we wanted to be considerate, we wanted to be somewhat friendly, diplomatic, when that isn’t part of a police investigation.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - As to the Scotland Yard operation in Praia da Luz practically overlapping the trial in which the McCanns accuse him of defamation, he says that is no coincidence.

Gonçalo Amaral - The issue of paying or not paying the one million two hundred thousand euros, that's not what they are really waiting for. They are using the trial to suggest something like "see, we're not guilty". Which is actually what has been taking place. The whole of the Scotland Yard investigation is heading towards that goal. It's a farce. By being politically correct, or by defending something that in my view it's not only the McCanns. It's something more. It's that whole group and everything that went on within that group of doctors, a reflection of the English society itself.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - After all that remains to be said…

Gonçalo Amaral - Those who held the custody of that child are responsible for her disappearance, at the very least for her disappearance, nothing more than that.

broadcast by RTP (Radio and Television of Portugal, is Portugal's public service broadcasting), 17 June, 2014
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 17, 2015, 03:09:18 PM
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CV9wBZXVAAAMLPn.jpg:large)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 03:17:06 PM
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CV9wBZXVAAAMLPn.jpg:large)

I think that is very good advice.....who would want casual conversation relayed
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 17, 2015, 03:37:09 PM
I think that is very good advice.....who would want casual conversation relayed

No it isn't unless you've got something to hide.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 03:43:59 PM
No it isn't unless you've got something to hide.

rubbish......
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 03:44:17 PM
No it isn't unless you've got something to hide.

Precisely.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 03:47:24 PM
Precisely.

so the only possible reason is they have something to hide and are guilty...case solved
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 03:53:06 PM
I think that is very good advice.....who would want casual conversation relayed

Or even the wrong thing to be said. She did have a talent for that. Who mentioned murder? Oh yes, it was Kate;


"They want me to lie - I'm being framed.

"Police don't want a murder in Portugal and all the publicity about them not having paedophile laws here, so they're blaming us."

Shell-shocked Kate McCann has given a dramatic, impassioned interview to the Irish Sunday Mirror

http://newsoutlines.blogspot.co.uk/2007/09/police-dont-want-paedophile-murder-here.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 03:56:45 PM
Or even the wrong thing to be said. She did have a talent for that. Who mentioned murder? Oh yes, it was Kate;


"They want me to lie - I'm being framed.

"Police don't want a murder in Portugal and all the publicity about them not having paedophile laws here, so they're blaming us."

Shell-shocked Kate McCann has given a dramatic, impassioned interview to the Irish Sunday Mirror

http://newsoutlines.blogspot.co.uk/2007/09/police-dont-want-paedophile-murder-here.html

of course...it could have been many things...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 03:59:39 PM
so the only possible reason is they have something to hide and are guilty...case solved

Just one reason.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 17, 2015, 04:05:46 PM
"So fearful are the McCanns that they are being framed they got a message through to Gordon Brown's office on Friday about the cruel twist of events."

Amaral was removed not long after. SY need to take control of this farce.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 04:12:14 PM
I would love to hear what amaral may have said after some of his interviews if he had forgotten to take his mike off
Look what happened to Gordon Brown
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 04:19:58 PM
I think that is very good advice.....who would want casual conversation relayed



why would you have a casual conversation after obviously discussing something about your missing daughter


pity they didn't do that when after a interview ....when they removed microphones were in fits of giggles an laughing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:24:03 PM

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - Gonçalo Amaral says that he is not a victim of the Maddie case but acknowledges that he has been dealing with the consequences of a battle for the past seven years, a battle he was forced to fight by virtue of being a policeman.

Gonçalo Amaral - We are part of the collateral damages and in fact that’s all we are. Mere extras in a tragedy... a tragedy that affects that family, no question about it, but mainly the victim, that is the child who disappeared and who may be, as all points to, dead.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - The setbacks due to the case were translated into family, affective and material losses, nevertheless Gonçalo Amaral guarantees that he would write the book again in which he responsibilizes the McCann couple for their daughter's disappearance.

Gonçalo Amaral - Maybe even do a second... a second volume but...

Helena Figueiras- Would you have more to say?

Gonçalo Amaral - ...Actually, that is already written, it is written but I don't believe I'll publish any further books about this case.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - As to the investigation, he speaks of avenues of investigation that he would follow again, with only one difference, he would never have let down the guard in relation to Kate and Gerry.

Gonçalo Amaral - It was due to those diplomatic issues, the ambassador’s intervention and all else, who promptly wanted to push towards the abduction thesis. That limited the police action in the sense that they [McCanns] would have been treated as suspects from the start otherwise. What does that imply? That means, that they and those close to them would have been the target of direct, personal surveillance, and also of electronic surveillance. We were lead to consider other paths and only later did we return to that starting point. In some way we wanted to be considerate, we wanted to be somewhat friendly, diplomatic, when that isn’t part of a police investigation.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - As to the Scotland Yard operation in Praia da Luz practically overlapping the trial in which the McCanns accuse him of defamation, he says that is no coincidence.

Gonçalo Amaral - The issue of paying or not paying the one million two hundred thousand euros, that's not what they are really waiting for. They are using the trial to suggest something like "see, we're not guilty". Which is actually what has been taking place. The whole of the Scotland Yard investigation is heading towards that goal. It's a farce. By being politically correct, or by defending something that in my view it's not only the McCanns. It's something more. It's that whole group and everything that went on within that group of doctors, a reflection of the English society itself.

Helena Figueiras [Voice Over] - After all that remains to be said…

Gonçalo Amaral - Those who held the custody of that child are responsible for her disappearance, at the very least for her disappearance, nothing more than that.

broadcast by RTP (Radio and Television of Portugal, is Portugal's public service broadcasting), 17 June, 2014

He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.

To say that SY investigation is a farce because they are not following his theory again says it all about Amaral,  he is  an arrogant man. 

What does he means when he said 'what went on in that group a reflection of the English society itself'.   He slags of the British because he's not getting his own way.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:25:35 PM
"So fearful are the McCanns that they are being framed they got a message through to Gordon Brown's office on Friday about the cruel twist of events."

Amaral was removed not long after. SY need to take control of this farce.

Sorry Amaral was removed because he slagged the British police off it's in his book.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 04:26:19 PM
He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.

To say that SY investigation is a farce because they are not following his theory again says it all about Amaral,  he is  an arrogant man. 

What does he means when he said 'what went on in that group a reflection of the English society itself'.   He slags of the British because he's not getting his own way.

yes...what a totally xenophobic attitude
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:30:37 PM


why would you have a casual conversation after obviously discussing something about your missing daughter


pity they didn't do that when after a interview ....when they removed microphones were in fits of giggles an laughing

What casual conversation?    Gerry reminded Kate to not say anything more until the microphones were removed,  what's so suspicious about that?   If she had said something such as 'I'm glad that's over with'  it would have spoilt everything they had just said wouldn't it,   even though it probably would have been a relief to get it over with,  no one likes to hear someone speaking when an interview has finished. 

What fits of giggles?   Nervous laughter?   again you don't have a clue if someone said something to them or not, you are just trying to make out they were laughing because they had got away with hiding their child's body aren't you?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 04:30:44 PM
Sorry Amaral was removed because he slagged the British police off it's in his book.

He was sacked after he protested that the case was being interfered with  from the UK.

Which was true.


More Brown sauce, it would seem. 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:31:14 PM
He was sacked after he protested that the case was being interfered with  from the UK.

Which was true.


More Brown sauce, it would seem. 8)-)))

it was the Portuguese who sacked him.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 17, 2015, 04:31:30 PM
"Gerry hardly ever sent text messages until after Madeleine was taken (laughing)" KM

Hilarious Kate.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 04:32:17 PM
yes...what a totally xenophobic attitude

The clear cut xenophobia was from the mccanns and the UK tabloid press.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:33:12 PM
He was sacked after he protested that the case was being interfered with  from the UK.

Which was true.


More Brown sauce, it would seem. 8)-)))

If Gordon Brown had so much authority in Portugal why didn't he stop Amaral making Kate and Gerry arguidos
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:34:07 PM
"Gerry hardly ever sent text messages until after Madeleine was taken (laughing)" KM

Hilarious Kate.

Full conversation please not cherry picking.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 04:34:46 PM
it was the Portuguese who sacked him.

Yes, after UK interference.

Brown sauce.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 04:35:45 PM
Yes, after UK interference.

Brown sauce.

Rubbish,  Amaral and his poor me act.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 04:36:31 PM
Rubbish,  Amaral and his poor me act.

No, it was UK interference in the case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 17, 2015, 04:38:07 PM
If Gordon Brown had so much authority in Portugal why didn't he stop Amaral making Kate and Gerry arguidos

This is of course the fly in the ointment for the "political cover up" fans.

One thing the Brits are pretty good at is political intrigue, and if the politicians or civil servants had wanted it covered up, there would have been nothing to see.  Zilch.  Nada. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 17, 2015, 04:39:11 PM
No, it was UK interference in the case.

You are claiming UK interference?  And "brown sauce"?

I assume you have some rational basis for that claim, Stephen?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 17, 2015, 04:42:42 PM
Full conversation please not cherry picking.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 17, 2015, 04:45:21 PM
This is of course the fly in the ointment for the "political cover up" fans.

One thing the Brits are pretty good at is political intrigue, and if the politicians or civil servants had wanted it covered up, there would have been nothing to see.  Zilch.  Nada.

I agree with that, JP. The McCanns & their entourage would have been quickly removed from Portugal & all investigation of them would have had to have been undertaken via SY.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 04:46:21 PM
You are claiming UK interference?  And "brown sauce"?

I assume you have some rational basis for that claim, Stephen?

More than you it would appear.
It is known the mccanns got in touch with Brown.

Brown 'discussed' the case with Socrates.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 04:48:08 PM


Thank you. So much better than one of   those interminable and wearisome cut and paste jobs
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 05:01:57 PM
He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.

To say that SY investigation is a farce because they are not following his theory again says it all about Amaral,  he is  an arrogant man. 

What does he means when he said 'what went on in that group a reflection of the English society itself'.   He slags of the British because he's not getting his own way.

He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.


excuse me.....lol............[god the mentality of that remark]........the mccs were in charge of maddies safety..wellfare ....protection ....trust ...  your like the mccs...blame everyone.................for what they failed to do...in the first place ...they the mccs left maddie to her fate ...her so called parents the mccs.... not Goncalo Ameral
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 17, 2015, 05:08:38 PM
I don't watch anything by that man.   Is that where you get your info @)(++(*

A strategic error of the first water is that!
Whichever side one is on in any "conflict" one should always keep tabs on what the enemy is up to  8(>((
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 17, 2015, 05:10:21 PM
He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.


excuse me.....lol............[god the mentality of that remark]........the mccs were in charge of maddies safety..wellfare ....protection ....trust ...  your like the mccs...blame everyone.................for what they failed to do...in the first place ...they the mccs left maddie to her fate ...her so called parents the mccs.... not Goncalo Ameral

Why do you suppose Amaral chose to write a book which served to highlight the inadequacies of his own force's investigation?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 05:16:45 PM
If I had been in their shoes I think I would have attacked Amaral,  and been locked up for it.

thought you had a bit of a vicious streak

it was not only Amaral ....you all keep blaming him ...it was the opinion of is officers also .....[just for you ] bit long but I'm sure you will have time to read it


Intercalary report compiled by chief inspector Tavares de Almeida, for the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator, 10 September 2007
    
Intercalary report compiled by chief inspector Tavares de Almeida, for the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator, Gonçalo Amaral PJ Files

page 2601, Vol. X, of Process NUIPC-201/07.0 GALGS

For the attention of the Criminal Investigation Coordinator

Madeleine Beth Maccann was born on the 12th of May 2003.

She has been missing since the 3rd of May 2007, a fact that took place in Praia da Luz, in Lagos.
If the information wouldn’t be counting on said witness (?), then the disappearance would have taken place between 9 and 10 p.m., widening the time period (presuming that the father speaks the truth).

But there is another question about the timing which is:

The last time that the child was seen outside of the group, by someone who can prove that moment, was at around 5.35 p.m., when the parents went to pick her up at the crèche, which may widen the time lapse between the disappearance and the alert, into four hours.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic34.html?sid=be27e23f8d46f6e11b76a3c60630d4fd#p422

CONCLUSION

On the tenth of September, two thousand and seven

Chief Inspector

(Tavares de Almeida)

I believe you may have chosen the wrong person to use in your post when criticising violence ...


Madeleine McCann Detective on Trial for Torturing Suspect in Unrelated Case

A senior Portuguese detective who interviewed Kate McCann and accused her of being involved in the death of her daughter is facing trial for trying to torture a suspect into confessing.

Leaked court papers reveal that Tavares Almeida is one of three officers accused of beating Virgolino Borges, a railway worker, during nearly eight hours of interrogation.

According to witness testimony the officers bound him with handcuffs behind his back, beat his bare feet with a fence post until it splintered and punched him repeatedly in the stomach, kidneys and back.

Almeida is the second leading detective to be accused of torture. Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, the investigation’s former co-ordinator, stepped down earlier this month amid separate allegations that he concealed evidence of the torture of a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter.

Last week the appointment of a fresh police officer to head the inquiry raised Gerry and Kate McCann’s hopes that it could be refocused on to the search for their daughter.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/2007/10/14/madeleine-mccann-detective-on-trial-for-torturing-suspect-in-unrelated-case.html


The wheels of justice grind slowly in Portugal it seems ... but they do eventually get there.

**Snip
Two chief inspectors of the PJ were sentenced on Friday to two years and six months imprisonment with suspended sentence for torture against official Virgolino CP Borges, told Lusa the victim's lawyer.
http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/pena-suspensa-para-dupla-da-pj-condenada-por-tortura
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 05:42:14 PM

Thank you. So much better than one of   those interminable and wearisome cut and paste jobs

Care to share what you may have found of interest ... I find it quite useful if the relevant spot on the timeline is used as a marker.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 05:44:09 PM
Care to share what you may have found of interest ... I find it quite useful if the relevant spot on the timeline is used as a marker.

I didn't say I found it interesting, I said I found it far better than endless cut and paste jobs.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 05:50:32 PM
He blames everyone but himself,  he was the in charge  of the case if things weren't done it was his fault no one else's.


excuse me.....lol............[god the mentality of that remark]........the mccs were in charge of maddies safety..wellfare ....protection ....trust ...  your like the mccs...blame everyone.................for what they failed to do...in the first place ...they the mccs left maddie to her fate ...her so called parents the mccs.... not Goncalo Ameral

What the McCann's did regarding their children has NOTHING to do with the Police investigation to find her.  Madeleine had the right to be looked for and to have a competent person in charge of that.   LOL
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 05:56:19 PM
I believe you may have chosen the wrong person to use in your post when criticising violence ...


Madeleine McCann Detective on Trial for Torturing Suspect in Unrelated Case

A senior Portuguese detective who interviewed Kate McCann and accused her of being involved in the death of her daughter is facing trial for trying to torture a suspect into confessing.

Leaked court papers reveal that Tavares Almeida is one of three officers accused of beating Virgolino Borges, a railway worker, during nearly eight hours of interrogation.

According to witness testimony the officers bound him with handcuffs behind his back, beat his bare feet with a fence post until it splintered and punched him repeatedly in the stomach, kidneys and back.

Almeida is the second leading detective to be accused of torture. Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, the investigation’s former co-ordinator, stepped down earlier this month amid separate allegations that he concealed evidence of the torture of a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter.

Last week the appointment of a fresh police officer to head the inquiry raised Gerry and Kate McCann’s hopes that it could be refocused on to the search for their daughter.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/2007/10/14/madeleine-mccann-detective-on-trial-for-torturing-suspect-in-unrelated-case.html


The wheels of justice grind slowly in Portugal it seems ... but they do eventually get there.

**Snip
Two chief inspectors of the PJ were sentenced on Friday to two years and six months imprisonment with suspended sentence for torture against official Virgolino CP Borges, told Lusa the victim's lawyer.
http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/pena-suspensa-para-dupla-da-pj-condenada-por-tortura

oh not that old chestnut again .........when all else fails  this is what happens....its a pity there is nothing else you can dish on him ....internet not full of wrong doing is it by G A .....unlike the mccs
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 05:57:20 PM
I didn't say I found it interesting, I said I found it far better than endless cut and paste jobs.

I would have thought there must be something in it worth posting about if you had over an hour to sit through it ... perhaps you really don't have much of an opinion to express on the content ... which I would find no surprise at all.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 05:59:39 PM

Some nice footage of the 'very unpopular within Portugal' Amaral at a well attended book signing.

Kate, the other hand, decided not to take part in a book signing event due to her.........fear of being mobbed by adoring supporters perhaps ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 06:04:14 PM
What the McCann's did regarding their children has NOTHING to do with the Police investigation to find her.  Madeleine had the right to be looked for and to have a competent person in charge of that.   LOL


What the McCann's did regarding their children has NOTHING to do with the Police investigation to find her.


well if that is what lace thinks  @)(++(*

they should have maybey answered the 48 questions dontcha think ,,,you know ,,,to help the investigation ...done the reconstruction ....etc etc
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 06:08:15 PM
Some nice footage of the 'very unpopular within Portugal' Amaral at a well attended book signing.

Kate, the other hand, decided not to take part in a book signing event due to her.........fear of being mobbed by adoring supporters perhaps ?


your right there especially with all the support they have ...probably people chucking money in a bucket if she took one as well
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 06:13:04 PM
Some nice footage of the 'very unpopular within Portugal' Amaral at a well attended book signing.

Kate, the other hand, decided not to take part in a book signing event due to her.........fear of being mobbed by adoring supporters perhaps ?
You can pay people to attend book signings to make the author appear more popular than they actually are you know.... 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 06:15:00 PM
You can pay people to attend book signings to make the author appear more popular than they actually are you know.... 8(0(*

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 06:15:15 PM
oh not that old chestnut again .........when all else fails  this is what happens....its a pity there is nothing else you can dish on him ....internet not full of wrong doing is it by G A .....unlike the mccs

The art of propaganda is founded on such old chestnuts which have been made to go away by ignoring or denial. 
In the interim the opinion of convicted criminals are promoted without let or hindrance to impugn the innocent ... the work which must have gone into that is surely staggering and the chutzpah behind the motivation one of the most amazing phenomena ever.
Propaganda skills like that are surely wasted on the case of one missing child ... or are they??  Must be more to it than that to justify the effort.

Your post has hit the nail bang on the head.  Goncalo Amaral's internet propaganda is indeed short on the peccadilloes attributed to him ... but who knows what the future may hold.   
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 06:17:35 PM

What the McCann's did regarding their children has NOTHING to do with the Police investigation to find her.


well if that is what lace thinks  @)(++(*

they should have maybey answered the 48 questions dontcha think ,,,you know ,,,to help the investigation ...done the reconstruction ....etc etc

Kate was advised not to answer the questions by her lawyer,   I don't blame her either,  they would have twisted everything she said.   Amaral lying about the DNA what was stopping him framing her.

Amaral cancelled the first reconstruction,  too many tourists,  so there you are dontcha think.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 17, 2015, 06:19:16 PM
Taken from Goncalo Amaral interview with Miguel Sousa Tavares.


  ... I cannot speak about the book, but you doctor can
(Miguel: yes I can, I was not forbidden, when you talk about evidences, you speaks about the hypothesis of her being killed by her parents, to hide her body)

GA: no, no I never said that,
Miguel says: but it is what is in the book,

GA: what I say in the book, let me explain
(Miguel: but you had fun yourself).

GA: I don´t say,
(Miguel: the final conclusion),

GA: no, no, then you had not read the book, that book is the English truth and there is nothing there.
Miguel: I have not read it? Oh yes I have read it, the book ends with 4 conclusions marked in black.

GA says: conclusions which are not talking about murder by the parents.
(Miguel: I didn´t said murder by her parents, could been killed accidentally).

GA repeats: no, no,accidentally is not killed by someone, an accident is an accident, it´s not any murder.
Miguel says: it is involuntary murder, you always told that they hid their daughter´s body, is that not in your book? Miguel repeats this question, Is this not in your book?)

GA says: this is where you Miguel is wrong, what´s in the book is six month of investigation, during which I was in charge and where it concludes with reports which are there, the suspicions at that time and has you Miguel knows, criminal investigation has it´s time, a beginning, a middle and an end, and so on, and in that moment there was suspicion, which doesn´t mean later, but, but
(Miguel says: but the suspicions were mostly yours, you know GA, another thing that is impressive is, let´s get back, shall we)

GA: you are putting words in my mouth, you are forbidden
(Miguel continues: no no, the words are mine, my conclusions and taken from your book and taken from the process)

GA says: no the suspicions, you are putting words in my mouth or what, no, you are talking about the injunction, it is an interpretation of the book
(Miguel: it is an interpretation of the book, you receive the news, gives the order to PJ picket, go to your home,
(GA: yes, like in any other case).

Miguel continues: you go to your home, wake up in the morning, this is in your book, and the first thing that comes to your brain is to ask the British who are the McCanns?
And you start immediately to suspect and ask questions, the questions you ask are:
  • if they hurt children,
  • if the have a serious problem with law,
  • if they have psychological problems,
  • if they are in fact doctors in full time,
and then, much ahead you say is common sense in these cases to suspect of the parents, so,
  • you have not yet seen the McCanns,
  • you have not yet been at the crime scene
and you´re already suspect them? Is it, or is it not. You´re a master).

GA says: yes, then says, listen, I or any other, yes, yes, it´s normal, to suspect, you´re wrong, it´s common sense, listen doctor, you are making fantasies, something,
Miguel says: no, I´m not making fantasies, I read your book).

GA repeats: the issue is this: the national and international laws in any of these cases and we were criticised by the FBI about this, is the issue of suspect or not of parents, or the closest in these types of cases and I can tell you, (Miguel says: you believe, but I don´t say suspect, at a certain time now, the first suspicions is that it?).
GA says: it´s not the first suspicion, we have to know first who those people are.

Miguel says: Was it not most urgent to know if the borders were all closed? Are all the marinas under surveillance? All the cars who left there under control?).
GA says: But we knew. We took care of that. No, it cannot know all cars who left there. And look, we reached the conclusion that for example the Via of Infant has some TV cameras which didn´t work, we talked with Spanish colleagues to control the border of Cádiz, in terms of access to Morocco, all those, Tenerife, and so on
(Miguel says: the marinas were not immediately controlled, because I know who left for example of Lagos marina one day after, quietly).

GA: but we have all that information.
We know that.
From a place where some occurrence happens, we analyze it, if there are CCTV, if there are no CCTV, if there are any CCTV, what can be seen, what cannot be seen, all of that, at the same time, look, saying that we aimed immediately to, it´s not like that, that question is relativity to the parents, excuse me, that first question, that, was answered, it is the first, was never answered, it is the first, it is important to understand...

(Miguel: since the first day, anyone who read your book concludes immediately that in the first meeting, at the end of the first day, is the strongest hypothesis you have, and I believe that has been created at a certain time of the investigation, but now, is the first hypothesis of work, it is the first hypothesis of work you pick and seems to be the only.
GA says: it´s not
(Miguel insists: it looks to be the only one).

GA repeats: not it´s not.
Miguel insists again: it is, it is.

GA says: doctor read the book.
Miguel says: I read the book.

GA says: notice, there are at the book , there are the investigations for the abduction, there we have the abduction, what has been done.
Miguel says: in terms of abduction, yes).

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234


It seems your opinion was wrong "The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO" 

Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory.

The most elementary error it is possible for an investigator to make is to formulate a theory then look for the evidence to fit.  The evidence has primacy ... not the uninformed notion of the police.

That this inept investigation has in some people's minds been turned into the textbook operation it demonstrably was not and its co-ordinator considered a Sherlock Holmes surely must represent the propaganda coup of the last couple of centuries.
I hadn't seen this stuff before so it was very interesting, and many thanks to you.

"Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory."

Just before he was removed from the enquiry, he was trying to chase up an analysis on human blood found outside Quinta dos Figos, blood discovered shortly after Madeleine disappeared.  This has, AFAIK, nothing to do with the McCanns, or Madeleine.  However, we are not going to know for certain, as Amaral got hoiked, and this diligence was not followed through in the time of the PJ files.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 17, 2015, 06:19:31 PM
The art of propaganda is founded on such old chestnuts which have been made to go away by ignoring or denial. 
In the interim the opinion of convicted criminals are promoted without let or hindrance to impugn the innocent ... the work which must have gone into that is surely staggering and the chutzpah behind the motivation one of the most amazing phenomena ever.
Propaganda skills like that are surely wasted on the case of one missing child ... or are they??  Must be more to it than that to justify the effort.

Your post has hit the nail bang on the head.  Goncalo Amaral's internet propaganda is indeed short on the peccadilloes attributed to him ... but who knows what the future may hold.

Well said Brietta    8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 06:23:35 PM
@)(++(*
Bet you can't prove he didn't... 8(>((
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 06:24:17 PM
You can pay people to attend book signings to make the author appear more popular than they actually are you know.... 8(0(*

Saatchi sent someone round the bookstores to buy up copies of his ...
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/dec/13/charles-saatchi-elisabetta-grillo-bought-book-bestseller-list
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 06:33:35 PM
Saatchi sent someone round the bookstores to buy up copies of his ...
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/dec/13/charles-saatchi-elisabetta-grillo-bought-book-bestseller-list
LOL.  Cilla Black turned up at HMV Liverpool to sign copies of her new album a few years ago, and because the store forgot to publicise the event, no one turned up.  So, unbenownst to our Cilla, the store manager paid the staff of a nearby fast food restaurant, and neighbouring shop to queue up pretending to be Cilla fans. @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 06:37:51 PM
Bet you can't prove he didn't... 8(>((

And you can't prove he did so isn't it innocent until proven guilty ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 06:39:14 PM
I find it quite fascinating today that mccanns supporters were questioning the account of an officer who recalled that the mccanns crying without any tears, months after he had witnessed them on the evening of Madeleine's disappearance.

Yet Jane Tanner, kept adding to her story about her sighting, and it became more embellished each time she told it.

Presumably mccann supporters thought that was OK.

Mmmm.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 06:40:57 PM
And you can't prove he did so isn't it innocent until proven guilty ?
@)(++(* @)(++(* Priceless!!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 17, 2015, 06:42:35 PM
Coming up on the rails it's Alan Freed on Payola  8(>((
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 06:45:10 PM
@)(++(* @)(++(* Priceless!!

You disagree ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 06:52:12 PM
You disagree ?
The hypocrisy is breath-taking.  In case you had forgotten, every time I mention the massive support the McCanns enjoy on Facebook (by comparison to the support enjoyed by Amaral or "sceptic" pages) you never fail to tell us that likes can be bought.  Just playing you at your own game, and now you want us to abide by the principle of innocent until proven guilty?!  Well what does that even mean, exactly in your book? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 06:55:22 PM
The hypocrisy is breath-taking.  In case you had forgotten, every time I mention the massive support the McCanns enjoy on Facebook (by comparison to the support enjoyed by Amaral or "sceptic" pages) you never fail to tell us that likes can be bought.  Just playing you at your own game, and now you want us to abide by the principle of innocent until proven guilty?!  Well what does that even mean, exactly in your book?


As discussed before, the facebook page is irrelevant, as it does not allow messages disagreeing with the mccanns accounts of events, and likewise there are no 'dislikes'.

So basically, a one sided irrelevance. 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 07:09:59 PM
Can I make a suggestion?  That we drop the pretence of having different threads on different subjects and just have one big free-for-all thread where we can just post endless snide insinuations about the McCanns, criticise their parenting skills, and insult each other?  A bit like this one in fact!

Yea, great idea, you and other mccann suporters would be right in your element posting such thngs as

- sceptics are less intelligent
- they do not understand evidence but nstead msrepresent it/lie blah blah blah
- they all dropped out of school
- they are all unemployed
- all trolls
- have mental problems
- are in drugs legal and illegal
- have similar mindsets to serial murderers
- are cold unfeeling b......s
- all easily brainwashed
- post h ate and bile all the time
- jealous of the mccanns
- are terrorist supporters
- are holocaust deniers
- support pedos
- and if course all [ censored word ] propagandists
The list is endless sunshine and if you cant see how utterly absurd and laughable your mindsets have become there is really no hope for you.....do note i refer to all sceptics as maybe you might come to understand the paucity of your so called arguments
As for your comment about the pretense of different subjects, dont be so utterly ridiculous (but thankfully it proves what a black and white person you are) and also do not presume to have the right to be so audacious all the time making extremely sweeping statements on mutiple issues then crying and complaining when the shoe is on the other foot, as well as crying and complaining about goading, sarcasm, ad homs, being derogatory, rudeness, when you live in a such a lovely, or not, glass house

Good luck sunshine and that goes to all your compatriots, the usual suspects


Ps the censored word seems to have been c onspiraloons....now who uses that word and why is it the fifth wird used by exactly the same people and have all been censored..seems tis you who have the major problems


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 17, 2015, 07:14:13 PM
Gosh, are we all those things?  I hadn't realised   @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 07:19:36 PM
The hypocrisy is breath-taking.  In case you had forgotten, every time I mention the massive support the McCanns enjoy on Facebook (by comparison to the support enjoyed by Amaral or "sceptic" pages) you never fail to tell us that likes can be bought.  Just playing you at your own game, and now you want us to abide by the principle of innocent until proven guilty?!  Well what does that even mean, exactly in your book?

At the time of the Crimewatch 'reconstruction' the McCanns had accrued around 160,000 'likes' on their Facebook page in 6 years. Virtually overnight that total had risen to almost half a million. In the two years since the total has risen by just over 100,000. If you can explain how that happened without bying 'likes' then be my guest.

You have absolutely no reason to believe that Amaral isn't well respected in his own country ( other than a 7 year old video ). On the contrary the fact that supporters sites have very few members, either native Portuguese  or expats, who reside in Portugal suggests otherwise.

As to innocent until proven guilty I was using your own argument against you. Perhaps it was too subtle for you eh ?  @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 07:19:52 PM
Gosh, are we all those things?  I hadn't realised   @)(++(*

You learn something new every day. &%5y% %&5%£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 07:22:29 PM
Yea, great idea, you and other mccann suporters would be right in your element posting such thngs as

- sceptics are less intelligent
- they do not understand evidence but nstead msrepresent it/lie blah blah blah
- they all dropped out of school
- they are all unemployed
- all trolls
- have mental problems
- are in drugs legal and illegal
- have similar mindsets to serial murderers
- are cold unfeeling b......s
- all easily brainwashed
- post h ate and bile all the time
- jealous of the mccanns
- are terrorist supporters
- are holocaust deniers
- support pedos
- and if course all [ censored word ] propagandists
The list is endless sunshine and if you cant see how utterly absurd and laughable your mindsets have become there is really no hope for you.....do note i refer to all sceptics as maybe you might come to understand the paucity of your so called arguments
As for your comment about the pretense of different subjects, dont be so utterly ridiculous (but thankfully it proves what a black and white person you are) and also do not presume to have the right to be so audacious all the time making extremely sweeping statements on mutiple issues then crying and complaining when the shoe is on the other foot, as well as crying and complaining about goading, sarcasm, ad homs, being derogatory, rudeness, when you live in a such a lovely, or not, glass house

Good luck sunshine and that goes to all your compatriots, the usual suspects


Ps the censored word seems to have been c onspiraloons....now who uses that word and why is it the fifth wird used by exactly the same people and have all been censored..seems tis you who have the major problems

You forgot the ones who had a quick smoke behind the bike shed when they were at school. 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 07:22:51 PM
Gosh, are we all those things?  I hadn't realised   @)(++(*

There is at least as long a list with other descriptions but you get the idea and I can't be bothered to expand it LOL, got go get back to my kitchen "where I belong" and "watch Jeremy Kyle and Coronation Street" ....and maybe I will have a guilty rumble in my  draws for my educational certificates and graduation photos, just to convince myself they are not, a figment of my imagination...LOL you never know I might find a fan letter to sutcliffe to boot and a giro or a payslip from a factory where I MUST be working....

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 07:27:24 PM
You forgot the ones who had a quick smoke behind the bike shed when they were at school. 8(0(*

And the ones that don't say 'bless you' when someone sneezes !
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 07:28:20 PM
And the ones that don't say 'bless you' when someone sneezes !

Naughty me. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 07:29:26 PM
There is at least as long a list with other descriptions but you get the idea and I can't be bothered to expand it LOL, got go get back to my kitchen "where I belong" and "watch Jeremy Kyle and Coronation Street" ....and maybe I will have a guilty rumble in my  draws for my educational certificates and graduation photos, just to convince myself they are not, a figment of my imagination...LOL you never know I might find a fan letter to sutcliffe to boot and a giro or a payslip from a factory where I MUST be working....

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

I wouldn't go rumbling in my drawers Merc. Nothing good ever comes from that !!! 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 07:32:48 PM
More than you it would appear.
It is known the mccanns got in touch with Brown.

Brown 'discussed' the case with Socrates.

perhaps it was Brown who suggested they turn off their microphones
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 07:37:31 PM
At the time of the Crimewatch 'reconstruction' the McCanns had accrued around 160,000 'likes' on their Facebook page in 6 years. Virtually overnight that total had risen to almost half a million. In the two years since the total has risen by just over 100,000. If you can explain how that happened without bying 'likes' then be my guest.

You have absolutely no reason to believe that Amaral isn't well respected in his own country ( other than a 7 year old video ). On the contrary the fact that supporters sites have very few members, either native Portuguese  or expats, who reside in Portugal suggests otherwise.

As to innocent until proven guilty I was using your own argument against you. Perhaps it was too subtle for you eh ?  @)(++(*

do you have a cite for this or is it an unsubstantiated claim
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 07:58:51 PM
Yea, great idea, you and other mccann suporters would be right in your element posting such thngs as

- sceptics are less intelligent
- they do not understand evidence but nstead msrepresent it/lie blah blah blah
- they all dropped out of school
- they are all unemployed
- all trolls
- have mental problems
- are in drugs legal and illegal
- have similar mindsets to serial murderers
- are cold unfeeling b......s
- all easily brainwashed
- post h ate and bile all the time
- jealous of the mccanns
- are terrorist supporters
- are holocaust deniers
- support pedos
- and if course all [ censored word ] propagandists
The list is endless sunshine and if you cant see how utterly absurd and laughable your mindsets have become there is really no hope for you.....do note i refer to all sceptics as maybe you might come to understand the paucity of your so called arguments
As for your comment about the pretense of different subjects, dont be so utterly ridiculous (but thankfully it proves what a black and white person you are) and also do not presume to have the right to be so audacious all the time making extremely sweeping statements on mutiple issues then crying and complaining when the shoe is on the other foot, as well as crying and complaining about goading, sarcasm, ad homs, being derogatory, rudeness, when you live in a such a lovely, or not, glass house

Good luck sunshine and that goes to all your compatriots, the usual suspects


Ps the censored word seems to have been c onspiraloons....now who uses that word and why is it the fifth wird used by exactly the same people and have all been censored..seems tis you who have the major problems

I thought it was against the rules to attack people personally? How on earth did they get all those past the mods? They seem very fond of name-calling just like their alleged idols.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 17, 2015, 08:03:18 PM
Yea, great idea, you and other mccann suporters would be right in your element posting such thngs as

- sceptics are less intelligent
- they do not understand evidence but nstead msrepresent it/lie blah blah blah
- they all dropped out of school
- they are all unemployed
- all trolls
- have mental problems
- are in drugs legal and illegal
- have similar mindsets to serial murderers
- are cold unfeeling b......s
- all easily brainwashed
- post h ate and bile all the time
- jealous of the mccanns
- are terrorist supporters
- are holocaust deniers
- support pedos
- and if course all [ censored word ] propagandists
The list is endless sunshine and if you cant see how utterly absurd and laughable your mindsets have become there is really no hope for you.....do note i refer to all sceptics as maybe you might come to understand the paucity of your so called arguments
As for your comment about the pretense of different subjects, dont be so utterly ridiculous (but thankfully it proves what a black and white person you are) and also do not presume to have the right to be so audacious all the time making extremely sweeping statements on mutiple issues then crying and complaining when the shoe is on the other foot, as well as crying and complaining about goading, sarcasm, ad homs, being derogatory, rudeness, when you live in a such a lovely, or not, glass house

Good luck sunshine and that goes to all your compatriots, the usual suspects


Ps the censored word seems to have been c onspiraloons....now who uses that word and why is it the fifth wird used by exactly the same people and have all been censored..seems tis you who have the major problems

I have never said all sceptics support pedos (sic)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 08:25:28 PM
At the time of the Crimewatch 'reconstruction' the McCanns had accrued around 160,000 'likes' on their Facebook page in 6 years. Virtually overnight that total had risen to almost half a million. In the two years since the total has risen by just over 100,000. If you can explain how that happened without bying 'likes' then be my guest.

You have absolutely no reason to believe that Amaral isn't well respected in his own country ( other than a 7 year old video ). On the contrary the fact that supporters sites have very few members, either native Portuguese  or expats, who reside in Portugal suggests otherwise.

As to innocent until proven guilty I was using your own argument against you. Perhaps it was too subtle for you eh ?  @)(++(*
So does that mean you don't subscribe to the idea of innocent until proven guilty after all then?  Fair enough.  And yes, some actual evidence of your claim above would be nice, together with a link to any company that claims it can increase your number of FB page likes by half a million overnight.  Breathless with anticipation....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 08:34:30 PM

Madeleine McCann - The truth about the propaganda machine against Madeleine and her family
Robert Guest

Published on May 21, 2015
Social media and in particular facebook has seen the development of an anti-McCann family movement which feeds the suspicions that were created through the way the media have told the story. Unbeknown to the media they were being fed a targeted smear from the police department that had been tasked to find Madeleine. These facebook groups are administered by people who will go to great lengths in misinforming the general public to stir up hatred, tarnishing Madeleine's memory, harming the search for Madeleine and creating an environment that will affect Madeleine's brother and sister as they grow up.

Enough is enough, it's time these groups were stopped and those involved were dealt with by the authorities.

Please share this short film to highlight the way these groups operate.

Spread the word that it is still necessary to look for Madeleine.

Don't give up hope and stop the hate

#hopenothate

The Madeleine McCann Debate Group will welcome your polite discussion about the case and will answer all of your questions

https://www.facebook.com/groups/15294...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 08:46:22 PM

Madeleine McCann - The truth about the propaganda machine against Madeleine and her family
Robert Guest

Published on May 21, 2015
Social media and in particular facebook has seen the development of an anti-McCann family movement which feeds the suspicions that were created through the way the media have told the story. Unbeknown to the media they were being fed a targeted smear from the police department that had been tasked to find Madeleine. These facebook groups are administered by people who will go to great lengths in misinforming the general public to stir up hatred, tarnishing Madeleine's memory, harming the search for Madeleine and creating an environment that will affect Madeleine's brother and sister as they grow up.

Enough is enough, it's time these groups were stopped and those involved were dealt with by the authorities.

Please share this short film to highlight the way these groups operate.

Spread the word that it is still necessary to look for Madeleine.

Don't give up hope and stop the hate

#hopenothate

The Madeleine McCann Debate Group will welcome your polite discussion about the case and will answer all of your questions

https://www.facebook.com/groups/15294...

Ah, yet more than one sided propaganda.

Par for the course.

and rather appropriately a link to a page with no content. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 09:03:01 PM

Madeleine McCann - The truth about the propaganda machine against Madeleine and her family
Robert Guest

Published on May 21, 2015
Social media and in particular facebook has seen the development of an anti-McCann family movement which feeds the suspicions that were created through the way the media have told the story. Unbeknown to the media they were being fed a targeted smear from the police department that had been tasked to find Madeleine. These facebook groups are administered by people who will go to great lengths in misinforming the general public to stir up hatred, tarnishing Madeleine's memory, harming the search for Madeleine and creating an environment that will affect Madeleine's brother and sister as they grow up.

Enough is enough, it's time these groups were stopped and those involved were dealt with by the authorities.

Please share this short film to highlight the way these groups operate.

Spread the word that it is still necessary to look for Madeleine.

Don't give up hope and stop the hate

#hopenothate

The Madeleine McCann Debate Group will welcome your polite discussion about the case and will answer all of your questions

https://www.facebook.com/groups/15294...


how pathetic is this ....that is not even maddie

you just think it is  because you are told it is

prime example ....how you believe everything fed to you ragarding the mccs
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:05:27 PM

how pathetic is this ....that is not even maddie

you just think it is  because you are told it is

prime example ....how you believe everything fed to you ragarding the mccs

Indeed.

Part of the propaganda machine gone mad................
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 09:17:41 PM

how pathetic is this ....that is not even maddie

you just think it is  because you are told it is

prime example ....how you believe everything fed to you ragarding the mccs

'Tarnishing Madeleine's memory', odd choice of words for a 'findable' child. Sometimes I don't know who the supporters are trying to convince that Madeleine ' has come to no harm' us or themselves.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 09:20:14 PM
Indeed.

Part of the propaganda machine gone mad................

i know

there is one thing though for sure stephen ....

that sweet little Innocent child aged three...will never ever be seen again.....because a cheap meal in a tapas bar was more important than three babies safety...a three year old was left baby sitting

wonder what they thought maddie would do if the twins woke up.......
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 09:22:05 PM
You forgot the ones who had a quick smoke behind the bike shed when they were at school. 8(0(*

Cant think of anythng much to say to that lol.......unless someone wants to come on and make a link between juvenile smokers and...well...not sure


 @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 09:23:18 PM
I have never said all sceptics support pedos (sic)

Thats good of you
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:26:24 PM
Cant think of anythng much to say to that lol.......unless someone wants to come on and make a link between juvenile smokers and...well...not sure


 @)(++(*

Now if a sceptic was to something about a McCann supporter which some view as derogatory, would we allowed to say it, or would we be told NOT TO ? £5%4%
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 17, 2015, 09:30:38 PM
I thought it was against the rules to attack people personally? How on earth did they get all those past the mods? They seem very fond of name-calling just like their alleged idols.
Ahem.  They poster you are addressing in this post has called me all manner of names in the past, none of which are repeatable here as they don't get through the swear filter.  I have learned to ignore her and do not respond directly to her posts. Just so as you're fully aware of the facts. 8(0(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 09:31:13 PM

Madeleine McCann - The truth about the propaganda machine against Madeleine and her family
Robert Guest

Published on May 21, 2015
Social media and in particular facebook has seen the development of an anti-McCann family movement which feeds the suspicions that were created through the way the media have told the story. Unbeknown to the media they were being fed a targeted smear from the police department that had been tasked to find Madeleine. These facebook groups are administered by people who will go to great lengths in misinforming the general public to stir up hatred, tarnishing Madeleine's memory, harming the search for Madeleine and creating an environment that will affect Madeleine's brother and sister as they grow up.

Enough is enough, it's time these groups were stopped and those involved were dealt with by the authorities.

Please share this short film to highlight the way these groups operate.

Spread the word that it is still necessary to look for Madeleine.

Don't give up hope and stop the hate

#hopenothate

The Madeleine McCann Debate Group will welcome your polite discussion about the case and will answer all of your questions

https://www.facebook.com/groups/15294...

Following on from my previous post.....See, this your massive problem, you are of the school of h ate or hope as that pathetic little hashtag proves

You have unfortunately created a sectarian scenario in your head, for reasons unknown...but if you have any modicum of intelligence you should know both sides cancel each other out in that context....it shouldnt even really be an issue for you seeing as it is said there is only an extremely tiny minority against the vast majority of the country.....so maybe you/others/the mccanns do have a real and present problem that has NOT been solved by nearly a decades use of pr merchants...that ALONE should also tell you something very very important



and whilst it is fine to highlight excesses and wrong doings in the old  internet about some issues, (as it is perfectly fine to highlight mccann abuses) it has not gone unnoticed that you have disingenuously "used"  this forum as a platform to do nothing  at all except denigrate, accuse, and yes, ...errr, use the best propaganda practices known (most weak thou as they are so seethrough) ...trying to convince people of your viewpoint is a million miles away from calling them evil and everythng else you have said for not agreeing with your viewpoint, which apparently  IS the truth.... you see? Your little mission failed before it even started.

I have some sympathy and respect for "some"  people here who just "believe" the mccanns 100 per cent and apologise for them, mostly in a fairly reasonable  manner though sometimes even they must wonder about their own thoughts/beliefs


Alfred is another one whose raison detre here is to blacken people whatever it takes though you are more religious and fanatical about it

Now, who ARE the extremists here? I ask, though I know the answer as it is crystal clear, I just wonder why you dont go argue your points at the internet source of your grievance rather than swipe at everyone ....oh hang on...rhetorical, no answers required

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 17, 2015, 09:33:19 PM
'Tarnishing Madeleine's memory', odd choice of words for a 'findable' child. Sometimes I don't know who the supporters are trying to convince that Madeleine ' has come to no harm' us or themselves.

its a fact Faithlilly ....they will never convince me..........so i would say themselves

i don't know why they think they have to support them anyway ....they have enough lawyers etc etc doing that...but there again they cant do anything for themselves ...apart from keeping the protection money going IMO
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:36:00 PM
its a fact Faithlilly ....they will never convince me..........so i would say themselves

i don't know why they think they have to support them anyway ....they have enough lawyers etc etc doing that...but there again they cant do anything for themselves ...apart from keeping the protection money going IMO

Indeed, one gets the impression that other people do the dirty work for them, so they can't be blamed for the nastiness which oozes from certain quarters of the supporters.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 09:36:15 PM

Madeleine McCann - The truth about the propaganda machine against Madeleine and her family
Robert Guest

Published on May 21, 2015
Social media and in particular facebook has seen the development of an anti-McCann family movement which feeds the suspicions that were created through the way the media have told the story. Unbeknown to the media they were being fed a targeted smear from the police department that had been tasked to find Madeleine. These facebook groups are administered by people who will go to great lengths in misinforming the general public to stir up hatred, tarnishing Madeleine's memory, harming the search for Madeleine and creating an environment that will affect Madeleine's brother and sister as they grow up.

Enough is enough, it's time these groups were stopped and those involved were dealt with by the authorities.

Please share this short film to highlight the way these groups operate.

Spread the word that it is still necessary to look for Madeleine.

Don't give up hope and stop the hate

#hopenothate

The Madeleine McCann Debate Group will welcome your polite discussion about the case and will answer all of your questions

https://www.facebook.com/groups/15294...

Robert Guest? Is he one of your 'sauces'? Not such a nice man in my opinion.  %56&

https://twitter.com/robert_d_guest
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 09:36:54 PM

how pathetic is this ....that is not even maddie

you just think it is  because you are told it is

prime example ....how you believe everything fed to you ragarding the mccs

#2 Joseph Carson and age progression
(http://media.bizarrepedia.com/images/Joseph-Carson-age-progression.jpg)
Joseph Carson was abducted by his non-custodial dad when he was 3 years old.
Missing for five years, a customer at an auto parts store saw a poster of age progressed child, strikingly similar to a kid, who just happened to be in the store at that exact time.
The image on the right shows Joseph when he was recovered at the age 9.
The similarity is remarkable. Probably his father had a similar chin structure.
https://www.bizarrepedia.com/age-progression-reliability/

How nice it would be if the image you deplore actually were Madeleine McCann and not merely an age progression image constructed for the purpose of assisting in her recovery.

However ... you digress.

We are discussing ... propaganda.

You may have failed to notice that the video I posted deals precisely with that subject.  It is a short video, but it rather opens doors to discussion of other propaganda videos which deal with what might be badly distorted and inaccurate information.

Perhaps constructive ... fact based discussion ... may not be to your liking.  Who knows, you could develop a taste for it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 09:38:56 PM
Robert Guest? Is he one of your 'sauces'? Not such a nice man in my opinion.  %56&

https://twitter.com/robert_d_guest



Actually, could he judged as a McCann supporting troll ???



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 09:39:50 PM
I thought it was against the rules to attack people personally? How on earth did they get all those past the mods? They seem very fond of name-calling just like their alleged idols.

They do. Some of them do it vaguely, some more openly, some use round about means..which very very iften are far worse than just name calling.....but  mostly fall just short of breaking forum rules technically so they get away with it alot of the time because no one reports the abuse

And on top is the icing and the cherry....they bleat they have never name called, they always post in a civilised polite manner, which is a lie, have hissy fits when answered as theyve questioned, etc etc . Sometimes the moderators are around and control it, main problem is not enough people report them......as its somehow considered snitching or cowardly but sometines its the only  way to stop someone becoming a forum hitler.....zzzzz
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 17, 2015, 09:40:10 PM
i know

there is one thing though for sure stephen ....

that sweet little Innocent child aged three...will never ever be seen again.....because a cheap meal in a tapas bar was more important than three babies safety...a three year old was left baby sitting

wonder what they thought maddie would do if the twins woke up.......

Propaganda??

I think we may have mentioned the McCann parenting skills or lack of once or twice before.

In fact, if memory serves me well ... we have at least one thread devoted to it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 09:49:01 PM
Moderated

Apart from continuously wondering why you cant put all your thoughts in one  reply  to the same post but have to quote it twice or three tines to add more thoughts....thinking knee jerk and not thinking before posting....well, its no surprise as you have said several of things on that list and if you are under the ikkusiin im going go spend my eveing argung the toss with you you must be delusional...sorry jack


 @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 17, 2015, 10:02:16 PM
Ahem.  They poster you are addressing in this post has called me all manner of names in the past, none of which are repeatable here as they don't get through the swear filter.  I have learned to ignore her and do not respond directly to her posts. Just so as you're fully aware of the facts. 8(0(*

Please dont lie exaggerate

a) it is a lie I have called you ALL manner of names
b) calling you a swear filtered name is no big deal if you  were behaving exactly as what I called you, wheres the credit for honesty then? If you value truth? lol, besides I did the crime and paid for it, what more do you want? If you cant take it dont dish utter rubbish and abuse out, simple as

These are the facts and the other facts are a) you DO respond to me, albeit mostly in a cowardly by answering my questions and asking another but not addressing me personally, maybe you have a short term memory problem? B) you tend not to respond alot  because you KNOW I will demolish your pathetic arguments....those are the facts


 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 17, 2015, 10:11:52 PM


Actually, could he judged as a McCann supporting troll ???

Some of his comments on the link I gave are iffy, that's for sure. Apparently he's writing a book which will be a best-seller. Oh; and he makes soft porn comments too. Nice company some of us keep.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 17, 2015, 10:13:38 PM
Will that be a best seller in the same way as the Summers and Swan  ? @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 17, 2015, 10:32:41 PM
Some of his comments on the link I gave are iffy, that's for sure. Apparently he's writing a book which will be a best-seller. Oh; and he makes soft porn comments too. Nice company some of us keep.

Birds of a feather. I believe a tweeter called Barbara, who is supporter  tweeted that she hoped that a paedophile was pleasuring himself ( changed the word to make it less offensive ) over a photo of the sceptic's child ( or words to that effect ). Despicable comment from anyone but particularly from a group member who believe they occupy the moral high ground.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 08:49:56 AM
 it seems there is no tragedy on earth that some conspiracy theorist won't home in on - with no regard at all for the pain they cause.   

 IIRC there are sceptics whose first reaction on seeing BL on TV was to immediately accuse her of being an actress or a deliberate plant.   Such is the mindset of some people. 

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 08:59:38 AM
Here's one for you dave. Do you recognize this couple and their 'crocodile tears' ?

(http://www.channel4.com/media/images/CorporatePortal/Benji/2013/Factual/Catching%20a%20Killer%20Crocodile%20Tears_A2.jpg)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 09:35:02 AM
Here's one for you dave. Do you recognize this couple and their 'crocodile tears' ?

(http://www.channel4.com/media/images/CorporatePortal/Benji/2013/Factual/Catching%20a%20Killer%20Crocodile%20Tears_A2.jpg)


And  ................................................? 


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 09:37:59 AM

And  ................................................?

 8)><( 8)><( 8)><( 8)><(

people can fake GRIEF.


As if you didn't know.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 09:41:25 AM
8)><( 8)><( 8)><( 8)><(

people can fake GRIEF.


As if you didn't know.


It was the police who spent time with the Philpotts who first noticed their behaviour was not that of genuinely grieving parents.    It was the police in the Shannon Matthews case who also noticed similar inappropriate behaviour from her mother.

In the McCann case - none of the UK FLO's or any other professional who spent time with them noticed anything at all in their behaviour that would give them cause for suspicion. 

That should tell you something.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 18, 2015, 09:42:27 AM

And  ................................................?


He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying. He did not feel that this was an abduction, although this was the line indicated by th faether.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 09:46:55 AM

It was the police who spent time with the Philpotts who first noticed their behaviour was not that of genuinely grieving parents.    It was the police in the Shannon Matthews case who also noticed similar inappropriate behaviour from her mother.

In the McCann case - none of the UK FLO's or any other professional who spent time with them noticed anything at all in their behaviour that would give them cause for suspicion. 

That should tell you something.

NOT AT ALL.

What about the Police who first saw them on their arrival at the scene and the mccanns highly unusual behaviour, including of course the 'praying and prostrating' ?

By the time the UK FLO team had arrived, they had time to compose themselves.

YOU, AS USUAL ARE TRYING TO HAVE YOUR CAKE AND EAT IT.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 09:52:04 AM
Here's one for you dave. Do you recognize this couple and their 'crocodile tears' ?

(http://www.channel4.com/media/images/CorporatePortal/Benji/2013/Factual/Catching%20a%20Killer%20Crocodile%20Tears_A2.jpg)

we have all seen this before......no  relevance
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 09:58:23 AM
we have all seen this before......no  relevance

Absolute relevance.

That is why you cannot give a logical and coherent reply.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 18, 2015, 10:00:01 AM
only public backlash stopped them making a film ...7 months after maddie went missing

The McCanns' Movie


On 08 January 2008, it was announced that the McCanns planned to make a movie about Madeleine's disappearance.
 
The resultant uproar saw them quickly revise the story to insist that any such project, if it went ahead, would be a documentary rather than a film.



   
GMTV report (original link)
    
Madeleine movie? GMTV
 
Last updated: 8 January 2008
 
The parents of Madeleine McCann are considering giving the go-ahead to a film about their missing daughter
Following an approach by a major entertainment firm, Kate and Gerry McCann may approve a movie about missing Madeleine's disappearance.

The couple's spokesman, Clarence Mitchell, confirmed that a meeting with the agency IMG took place last month but he added that Gerry and Kate McCann did not attend and nothing has yet been agreed.

Mr Mitchell said a film would be considered only if the McCanns believed it would help raise awareness of the case or if it could help fund the search for the missing four-year-old.

Madeleine's Fund

The matter is expected to be discussed further when directors of the Madeleine Fund meet later this week. It is believed that IMG, the firm behind the award-winning drama-documentary Touching The Void, made the initial.

A resulting meeting in mid-December discussed the possibility of making the story of Madeleine - who vanished from her family's Praia da Luz holiday apartment in May - into either a film or a TV drama.

Mr and Mrs McCann were aware of the meeting but did not attend in person. Instead, Mr Mitchell and another representative of the McCanns met IMG at the firm's London offices.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 10:07:15 AM
NOT AT ALL.

What about the Police who first saw them on their arrival at the scene and the mccanns highly unusual behaviour, including of course the 'praying and prostrating' ?

By the time the UK FLO team had arrived, they had time to compose themselves.

YOU, AS USUAL ARE TRYING TO HAVE YOUR CAKE AND EAT IT.

I posted on this only yesterday.   My opinion hasn't changed since then.    I presume you believe that all those people who described the terrible state the McCanns were in are all lying?

IIRC the FLO's arrived very quickly - within 48 hours? (from memory).   They also spent many hours with the McCanns - but not once did they notice anything unusual in their behaviour - even though as police officers they are trained to observe.

LOL It's not me who is trying to have their cake and eat it.     According to sceptics the McCanns are Oscar winning actors who duped all the professional people they had contact with - with their amazing acting skills -- but who are also such lousy actors that after just seconds into any video of them and the sceptics KNOW they are acting/lying.      If that's not trying to have your cake and eat it - I don't know what is.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 10:17:40 AM
only public backlash stopped them making a film ...7 months after maddie went missing

The McCanns' Movie


On 08 January 2008, it was announced that the McCanns planned to make a movie about Madeleine's disappearance.
 
The resultant uproar saw them quickly revise the story to insist that any such project, if it went ahead, would be a documentary rather than a film.



   
GMTV report (original link)
    
Madeleine movie? GMTV
 
Last updated: 8 January 2008
 
The parents of Madeleine McCann are considering giving the go-ahead to a film about their missing daughter
Following an approach by a major entertainment firm, Kate and Gerry McCann may approve a movie about missing Madeleine's disappearance.

The couple's spokesman, Clarence Mitchell, confirmed that a meeting with the agency IMG took place last month but he added that Gerry and Kate McCann did not attend and nothing has yet been agreed.

Mr Mitchell said a film would be considered only if the McCanns believed it would help raise awareness of the case or if it could help fund the search for the missing four-year-old.

Madeleine's Fund

The matter is expected to be discussed further when directors of the Madeleine Fund meet later this week. It is believed that IMG, the firm behind the award-winning drama-documentary Touching The Void, made the initial.

A resulting meeting in mid-December discussed the possibility of making the story of Madeleine - who vanished from her family's Praia da Luz holiday apartment in May - into either a film or a TV drama.

Mr and Mrs McCann were aware of the meeting but did not attend in person. Instead, Mr Mitchell and another representative of the McCanns met IMG at the firm's London offices.

So a company approached them wanting to make a film.    The McCanns would only agree if they thought it would raise awareness of the case.    Obviously they were not convinced that it would do that - and so turned the offer down.  The end.





Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:24:33 AM
I posted on this only yesterday.   My opinion hasn't changed since then.    I presume you believe that all those people who described the terrible state the McCanns were in are all lying?

IIRC the FLO's arrived very quickly - within 48 hours? (from memory).   They also spent many hours with the McCanns - but not once did they notice anything unusual in their behaviour - even though as police officers they are trained to observe.

LOL It's not me who is trying to have their cake and eat it.     According to sceptics the McCanns are Oscar winning actors who duped all the professional people they had contact with - with their amazing acting skills -- but who are also such lousy actors that after just seconds into any video of them and the sceptics KNOW they are acting/lying.      If that's not trying to have your cake and eat it - I don't know what is.

The police on the scene saw the mccanns reactions.

They did not believe the tears were real, or that there had been an abduction.

So, get over it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 10:25:42 AM
8)><( 8)><( 8)><( 8)><(

people can fake GRIEF.


As if you didn't know.

we know...if the mccanns had wanted to fake it...it would have been easy
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:34:36 AM
we know...if the mccanns had wanted to fake it...it would have been easy

and that is what the police who first saw the mccanns thought they were doing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 18, 2015, 10:35:39 AM
Thank you Xtina - what an excellent example for this thread about Propaganda.



The propaganda:

"only public backlash stopped them making a film ...7 months after maddie went missing

The McCanns' Movie


On 08 January 2008, it was announced that the McCanns planned to make a movie about Madeleine's disappearance.
 
The resultant uproar saw them quickly revise the story to insist that any such project, if it went ahead, would be a documentary rather than a film."

_______________________________
What really happened:

    Madeleine movie? GMTV
     
    Last updated: 8 January 2008
     
    The parents of Madeleine McCann are considering giving the go-ahead to a film about their missing daughter
    Following an approach by a major entertainment firm, Kate and Gerry McCann may approve a movie about missing Madeleine's disappearance.

    The couple's spokesman, Clarence Mitchell, confirmed that a meeting with the agency IMG took place last month but he added that Gerry and Kate McCann did not attend and nothing has yet been agreed.

    Mr Mitchell said a film would be considered only if the McCanns believed it would help raise awareness of the case or if it could help fund the search for the missing four-year-old.

    Madeleine's Fund

    The matter is expected to be discussed further when directors of the Madeleine Fund meet later this week. It is believed that IMG, the firm behind the award-winning drama-documentary Touching The Void, made the initial.

    A resulting meeting in mid-December discussed the possibility of making the story of Madeleine - who vanished from her family's Praia da Luz holiday apartment in May - into either a film or a TV drama.

    Mr and Mrs McCann were aware of the meeting but did not attend in person. Instead, Mr Mitchell and another representative of the McCanns met IMG at the firm's London offices.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 18, 2015, 10:38:13 AM
we know...if the mccanns had wanted to fake it...it would have been easy

bit like this do you mean......


    
Grief, 10 April 2008
    
Grief, 10 April 2008

Excerpts the Rogatory interviews of Rachael Oldfield, Fiona Payne and Russell O'Brien, in which they comment on the McCanns' grief in the minutes immediately following Madeleine's reported disappearance.




Rachael Oldfield in an interview with the Leicestershire Police, April 2008

Q: "On realising Madeleine had not been found in the first ten minutes, how did Kate react?"

RO: "She was really upset, she was hysterical, really distressed, crying and screaming, there's no way she could have acted that, or anyone could have in fact, I don't think, not even an actress."

Q: "On realising Madeleine had not been found in the first ten minutes, how did Gerry react?"

RO: "Very similar to Kate, it was, you know, screaming, shouting, errm... crying, just, you know, he was very much a... you know, a father whose child had disappeared, as Kate was a mother whose child had disappeared or wouldn't you know?"


Fiona Payne, in an interview with the Leicestershire Police, April 2008

Q: "How was Kate?"

FP: "Awful, errm... I've never seen such horrible raw emotion in my life and I've seen a lot of it in my job. Errm... tut, she... she was just bereft, she didn't know what to do, she was just panicking, extremely frightened, extremely frightened for Madeleine and, errm... was wondering where she was or what was happening to her. And the helplessness, errm... of not being able to do anything, what should she be doing, what could they do? Errm... she was angry, really angry, tut, punching walls, kicking walls, she was covered in bruises the next day, because she just didn't know what, what else to do. She was angry at herself, she kept saying 'I've let her down. We've let her down Gerry', you know, 'We should have been here'. Errm... tut, she was praying a lot. Errm... I just don't think she knew what to do, what to do. And she was just howling. It was just, just awful. I think as time went on it just seemed a massive delay from when we said to Matt to phone the Police, errm... that hour, it was an hour, it just seemed like an eternity, where nothing was happening, tut. Errm... you know, we're all intelligent people, we were all trying to think what we should be doing and, you know, what's going to make a difference. And Kate's ringing, Gerry's ringing anybody under the sun, family, they just don't, they honestly just didn't know what to do. So there was a lot of, Gerry's in and out, I mean, they were just sobbing, going between sobbing and then feeling helpless and then ringing people and this frantic activity. Kate was desperate to have a Priest, which, you know, people find weird, but I think that was just her way of thinking 'At least I can pray for Madeleine' and her way of feeling that she was doing something. Errm... tut, but she wasn't functioning."

"No, and that was the other thing, she kept going into the twins, she kept putting her hands on the twins to check they were breathing, she was very much concerned in checking that they were okay. But they were okay, I mean, they were fine, they didn't... they were asleep, but at the time it did seem weird, I remember thinking, you know, when the Police came they turned the lights on, there was loads of noise, obviously from the moment Kate discovered that Madeleine was gone, the screaming and the shouting and there was a lot of noise and they, they didn't, you know, so much as blink."

Q: "Okay and realising that Madeleine had not been found in the first ten minutes, how did Kate react?"

FP: "Oh, as I said earlier, she was hysterical, it upsets me very much to even think about how she was, cos it was, errm... she was so terrified, absolutely inconsolable, she was rampaging round the... the room, she's up and down, pacing, kicking walls, just on, for most part, just imagining where or what might be happening to Madeleine and angry at herself and them for having left her, not being there and just, she was shouting a lot, I can't, 'We've, we've let her down Gerry, we've let her down, we weren't there for her', errm... you know, the pain that was causing her that she hadn't been there, was just very raw, errm... anger at the... the whole, I say the system that nobody was seemed to be arriving and, you know, what was being done and the feeling of just nothing, nothing being done, the helplessness and that, that raw, raw emotion of just grief, of just terror and just praying, she was praying, she kept kneeling everywhere just praying and praying and praying and asking for a Priest and just wanted, you know, everybody to be praying for Madeleine for her to be safe."
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 10:39:48 AM

It was the police who spent time with the Philpotts who first noticed their behaviour was not that of genuinely grieving parents.    It was the police in the Shannon Matthews case who also noticed similar inappropriate behaviour from her mother.

In the McCann case - none of the UK FLO's or any other professional who spent time with them noticed anything at all in their behaviour that would give them cause for suspicion. 

That should tell you something.

Several statements have already been posted from Portuguese police officers who believed the parents were acting strangely, arguably the most compelling being that of Pavia who spent more time with the McCanns than any other 'professional' in the case. Or doesn't he count as he is Portuguese ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 10:42:24 AM
Several statements have already been posted from Portuguese police officers who believed the parents were acting strangely, arguably the most compelling being that of Pavia who spent more time with the McCanns than any other 'professional' in the case. Or doesn't he count as he is Portuguese ?

The thing is he thinks the McCann's praying was strange.   That they made sounds like they were crying,  well that sounds to me as though they were stifling sobs and trying to keep it together,  but that was strange to him.

All these 'strange' things appear to have been noted after Amaral came up with his theory.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 10:43:46 AM
8)><( 8)><( 8)><( 8)><(

people can fake GRIEF.


As if you didn't know.

I tend to believe what the trained experts said myself.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:45:47 AM
I tend to believe what the trained experts said myself.

Of course you would.

However, they saw them after the events.

They had time to compose themselves.

Initial reactions tend to be the most reliable.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 10:46:42 AM
They do. Some of them do it vaguely, some more openly, some use round about means..which very very iften are far worse than just name calling.....but  mostly fall just short of breaking forum rules technically so they get away with it alot of the time because no one reports the abuse

And on top is the icing and the cherry....they bleat they have never name called, they always post in a civilised polite manner, which is a lie, have hissy fits when answered as theyve questioned, etc etc . Sometimes the moderators are around and control it, main problem is not enough people report them......as its somehow considered snitching or cowardly but sometines its the only  way to stop someone becoming a forum hitler.....zzzzz

Mercury,  do you have a halo around your head?

I was posting politely to you until you started ridiculing my posts and laughing about what I said with other posters.

Please don't get on your high horse and complain about others when you are far from squeaky clean yourself.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:47:25 AM
The thing is he thinks the McCann's praying was strange.   That they made sounds like they were crying,  well that sounds to me as though they were stifling sobs and trying to keep it together,  but that was strange to him.

All these 'strange' things appear to have been noted after Amaral came up with his theory.



Is that rather like all the 'strange' things Jane tanner came up with, after her initial statement ?

Or do we take hers at face value ? 8)-))) 8)--))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 10:48:13 AM
and that is what the police who first saw the mccanns thought they were doing.

do you have a cite for that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 10:50:21 AM
Of course you would.

However, they saw them after the events.

They had time to compose themselves.

Initial reactions tend to be the most reliable.

They hadn't composed themselves that is the point,   they were described as behaving in the typical manner that one would expect after such a traumatic event.

Now if you wish to argue with people who are trained and worked for years in counselling people Stephen that is up to you,  perhaps another hat for you to wear,  along side Detective.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 10:50:48 AM
The thing is he thinks the McCann's praying was strange.   That they made sounds like they were crying,  well that sounds to me as though they were stifling sobs and trying to keep it together,  but that was strange to him.

All these 'strange' things appear to have been noted after Amaral came up with his theory.

Did Pavia say that or was it Jose Batista Roque, one of the first officers at the scene ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 10:51:46 AM


Is that rather like all the 'strange' things Jane tanner came up with, after her initial statement ?

Or do we take hers at face value ? 8)-))) 8)--))

What 'strange' things?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 18, 2015, 10:52:17 AM
The police on the scene saw the mccanns reactions.

They did not believe the tears were real, or that there had been an abduction.

So, get over it.

And yet they didn't immediately go to their superiors to inform them of this massively important observation?  Explain that Stephen.

(Although I have to go out now - so won't read your 'explanation' until later. ) 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:52:50 AM
do you have a cite for that


Read the thread. 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 10:53:25 AM
Thank you Xtina - what an excellent example for this thread about Propaganda.



The propaganda:

"only public backlash stopped them making a film ...7 months after maddie went missing

The McCanns' Movie


On 08 January 2008, it was announced that the McCanns planned to make a movie about Madeleine's disappearance.
 
The resultant uproar saw them quickly revise the story to insist that any such project, if it went ahead, would be a documentary rather than a film."

_______________________________
What really happened:

    Madeleine movie? GMTV
     
    Last updated: 8 January 2008
     
    The parents of Madeleine McCann are considering giving the go-ahead to a film about their missing daughter
    Following an approach by a major entertainment firm, Kate and Gerry McCann may approve a movie about missing Madeleine's disappearance.

    The couple's spokesman, Clarence Mitchell, confirmed that a meeting with the agency IMG took place last month but he added that Gerry and Kate McCann did not attend and nothing has yet been agreed.

    Mr Mitchell said a film would be considered only if the McCanns believed it would help raise awareness of the case or if it could help fund the search for the missing four-year-old.

    Madeleine's Fund

    The matter is expected to be discussed further when directors of the Madeleine Fund meet later this week. It is believed that IMG, the firm behind the award-winning drama-documentary Touching The Void, made the initial.

    A resulting meeting in mid-December discussed the possibility of making the story of Madeleine - who vanished from her family's Praia da Luz holiday apartment in May - into either a film or a TV drama.

    Mr and Mrs McCann were aware of the meeting but did not attend in person. Instead, Mr Mitchell and another representative of the McCanns met IMG at the firm's London offices.

It would seem the article was true ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 10:53:46 AM
They hadn't composed themselves that is the point,   they were described as behaving in the typical manner that one would expect after such a traumatic event.

Now if you wish to argue with people who are trained and worked for years in counselling people Stephen that is up to you,  perhaps another hat for you to wear,  along side Detective.

How do you know that ?

You weren't there.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 10:57:13 AM

Read the thread. 8)-)))

I haven't seen any statement by any officer saying they thought they were faking it....another myth is born
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 11:00:06 AM
I haven't seen any statement by any officer saying they thought they were faking it....another myth is born

You read what was said.

It isn't a myth.

Crying with no tears.

..and let's not forget, the prostrating of the mccanns.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:01:45 AM
How do you know that ?

You weren't there.

I know it by reading the statement of the counsellor sent to them.   Really Stephen you need to read all the Police files.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 11:03:38 AM
I know it by reading the statement of the counsellor sent to them.   Really Stephen you need to read all the Police files.

So was it Roque rather than Pavia who mentioned the crying with no tears ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:04:14 AM
You read what was said.

It isn't a myth.

Crying with no tears.

..and let's not forget, the prostrating of the mccanns.

He didn't say they were crying without tears,  he said they were making noises like crying and there were no tears.   Now what do you think that might have been?   think hard,  can you imagine a time where you wanted to cry but tried not to?   

Prostrating?  was that when they were praying and crying by the bed by any chance?

You do try and make out these are big deals don't you,   but they have nothing at all to do with the disappearance of Madeleine.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:04:49 AM
So was it Roque rather than Pavia who mentioned the crying with no tears ?

???
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 11:05:51 AM
He didn't say they were crying without tears,  he said they were making noises like crying and there were no tears.   Now what do you think that might have been?   think hard,  can you imagine a time where you wanted to cry but tried not to?   

Prostrating?  was that when they were praying and crying by the bed by any chance?

You do try and make out these are big deals don't you,   but they have nothing at all to do with the disappearance of Madeleine.

Oh yes it does.

You are not going to convince me, you realize that don't you, anymore than I will convince you.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 11:06:57 AM
???

This :

'The thing is he thinks the McCann's praying was strange.   That they made sounds like they were crying,  well that sounds to me as though they were stifling sobs and trying to keep it together,  but that was strange to him.

All these 'strange' things appear to have been noted after Amaral came up with his theory.'

So was it Roque or Pavia who noticed the 'non crying' ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 11:09:39 AM
I know it by reading the statement of the counsellor sent to them.   Really Stephen you need to read all the Police files.

and you really believe counselor's can't be fooled ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:13:30 AM
This :

'The thing is he thinks the McCann's praying was strange.   That they made sounds like they were crying,  well that sounds to me as though they were stifling sobs and trying to keep it together,  but that was strange to him.

All these 'strange' things appear to have been noted after Amaral came up with his theory.'

So was it Roque or Pavia who noticed the 'non crying' ?

Pavia
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:14:46 AM
and you really believe counselor's can't be fooled ?

One of them said they couldn't have kept it up for so long,  he was an expert Stephen.

Everyone has to be either lying or fooled according to you.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 11:16:02 AM
Pavia

Do you have a cite ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 11:19:18 AM
One of them said they couldn't have kept it up for so long,  he was an expert Stephen.

Everyone has to be either lying or fooled according to you.

So just how many experts examined them ?


By the way, as a reminder, Pike is irrelevant.

He worked for the mccanns.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:21:28 AM
i know

there is one thing though for sure stephen ....

that sweet little Innocent child aged three...will never ever be seen again.....because a cheap meal in a tapas bar was more important than three babies safety...a three year old was left baby sitting

wonder what they thought maddie would do if the twins woke up.......

We all feel the same about Madeleine,  she was a gorgeous little girl who disappeared,   but how ever we feel about her,  she was the McCann's daughter so how ever we feel you must magnify it for how the McCann's must be feeling.   They have the guilt to carry with them for the rest of their lives.

They did leave Madeleine,   but that doesn't mean they would fake an abduction and hide her body.   Madeleine as you can see from photo's and video's was a much loved child,  they had baby sitters at home,  they made a stupid decision to leave the children and now they are paying for it.

I support them in their fight to find Madeleine,  what is done is done,  finding Madeleine is what counts now.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 18, 2015, 11:23:13 AM
It would seem the article was true ?

Probably.  Around 8th Jan 2008 there was a flurry of press comment.

No idea why the idea was dropped - possibly something to do with the "secrey of justice" that the PJ were so keen on. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 11:23:23 AM
i know

there is one thing though for sure stephen ....

that sweet little Innocent child aged three...will never ever be seen again.....because a cheap meal in a tapas bar was more important than three babies safety...a three year old was left baby sitting

wonder what they thought maddie would do if the twins woke up.......

We all feel the same about Madeleine,  she was a gorgeous little girl who disappeared,   but how ever we feel about her,  she was the McCann's daughter so how ever we feel you must magnify it for how the McCann's must be feeling.   They have the guilt to carry with them for the rest of their lives.

They did leave Madeleine,   but that doesn't mean they would fake an abduction and hide her body.   Madeleine as you can see from photo's and video's was a much loved child,  they had baby sitters at home,  they made a stupid decision to leave the children and now they are paying for it.

I support them in their fight to find Madeleine,  what is done is done,  finding Madeleine is what counts now.


Out comes the cliche, yet again.

' finding Madeleine is what counts now '

Where would that be ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:23:38 AM
Do you have a cite ?

xtina posted his statement on this thread a few pages back.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:25:58 AM
So just how many experts examined them ?


By the way, as a reminder, Pike is irrelevant.

He worked for the mccanns.

Pike didn't work for the McCann's when he first went to see them.   There was one other who was first to see them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 11:37:57 AM
Oh yes it does.

You are not going to convince me, you realize that don't you, anymore than I will convince you.

You have convinced me... Convinced me you do not know what you are talking about
No mention of faking it
Just you promoting your opinion as fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 18, 2015, 11:48:50 AM

Statement by: Stephen Markley

 Occupation: Police Officer

 This statement (composed of 2 pages and signed by me) is true and in accordance with my understanding.

 Date: 25th April 2008
 Signature____________________________________________________


 I am police officer Markley of the Leicestershire Police currently working in the criminal unit.

 In 2007 and in relation to the Portuguese investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, I was detached to Portugal in the role of family communication officer.

 According to the Portuguese PJ Letter of Request, I was asked to respond to the following question:

 Was there anything done or said by Kate or Gerry McCann in your presence or during your various meetings that could raise any suspicion that they had any knowledge about what could have happened to Madeleine, beyond the circumstances described to the Portuguese investigators?

 My reply to the question was: No.

 However, in relation to the above, I would like to add the following: At about 20.00 on Saturday 5th May 2007, I arrived at the apartment where Kate and Gerry were staying, with other officers. During the meeting Gerald and Kate had a number of questions to which they wanted follow up and responses from the PJ.

 One of these questions was that they wanted the PJ to be aware of was Madeleine's revelation about Wednesday night, when she said that she was left alone during the night. She told Kate and Gerry that she remembered the twins crying and that she wanted to know why neither her mother nor her father had gone to the room to see what was happening.

 They also wanted to know whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction.


 This statement was made by me and is truthful in accordance with my understanding.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 12:06:46 PM
Pike didn't work for the McCann's when he first went to see them.   There was one other who was first to see them.

Ah, so one other.

 8)-)))

So where these counsellors with them 24 hours a day ?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 18, 2015, 12:14:15 PM
This is a final warning to members who think they can constantly disrupt the boards on a daily basis.  Starting right now, any further instances of abuse, goading or personal insults will incur a three day ban.

Admin
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 01:17:15 PM
Here's one for you dave. Do you recognize this couple and their 'crocodile tears' ?

(http://www.channel4.com/media/images/CorporatePortal/Benji/2013/Factual/Catching%20a%20Killer%20Crocodile%20Tears_A2.jpg)

Another example of PROPAGANDA in its truest form
  ... and the very sad thing about it is that the poster has not grasped that by posting it on a thread about propaganda what an ideal illustration of the dark art it was and is.

Pairing the parents of a missing child with the parents who killed five of theirs is really a rather clumsy and transparent attempt and not up to the usual standard ... but propaganda designed to malign nonetheless however ineffective.

Cites can be found very easily ... I googled ~ compare mccanns and philpotts ~ check it out if you require confirmation.

Facebook Group Plans Orchestrated Attack against McCann family
https://ordinisrubricrucis.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/facebook-group-plans-orchestrated-attack-against-mccann-family/

There are concerted attacks on the McCann family in which propaganda of the vilest sort has been used.  It seems to be related to their campaign to keep their daughter in the public domain and to have the official investigation into her disappearance reopened ... in which they have been successful.

Why has their campaign on Madeleine's behalf attracted such ire?  Why is there a PM petition in existence?  Why have new FOIs been submitted?

Perhaps those are among the questions the 'questioners' should be asking as well as wondering why there are those attacking Operation Grange who are merely fulfilling the the mission statement they apparently masquerade under if their actions are looked at critically. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 18, 2015, 01:18:33 PM
Several statements have already been posted from Portuguese police officers who believed the parents were acting strangely, arguably the most compelling being that of Pavia who spent more time with the McCanns than any other 'professional' in the case. Or doesn't he count as he is Portuguese ?

Roque, da Costa and Pavia were not real welders policemen  @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 01:27:56 PM
Another example of PROPAGANDA in its truest form
  ... and the very sad thing about it is that the poster has not grasped that by posting it on a thread about propaganda what an ideal illustration of the dark art it was and is.

Pairing the parents of a missing child with the parents who killed five of theirs is really a rather clumsy and transparent attempt and not up to the usual standard ... but propaganda designed to malign nonetheless however ineffective.

Cites can be found very easily ... I googled ~ compare mccanns and philpotts ~ check it out if you require confirmation.

Facebook Group Plans Orchestrated Attack against McCann family
https://ordinisrubricrucis.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/facebook-group-plans-orchestrated-attack-against-mccann-family/

There are concerted attacks on the McCann family in which propaganda of the vilest sort has been used.  It seems to be related to their campaign to keep their daughter in the public domain and to have the official investigation into her disappearance reopened ... in which they have been successful.

Why has their campaign on Madeleine's behalf attracted such ire?  Why is there a PM petition in existence?  Why have new FOIs been submitted?

Perhaps those are among the questions the 'questioners' should be asking as well as wondering why there are those attacking Operation Grange who are merely fulfilling the the mission statement they apparently masquerade under if their actions are looked at critically.

It wasn't propaganda showing those crocodile tears of those parents.

It made a clear point, that people can put on an act.

I could have easily given other examples as well.

Meanwhile, you seem to forget, that mccann supporters mount attacks on the sceptics, THE DOSSIER, being the obvious example, the aftermath of which, resulted in the death of Brenda Leyland.

What help, including counselling was offered her ?

None, it would seem.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 01:40:44 PM

It was the police who spent time with the Philpotts who first noticed their behaviour was not that of genuinely grieving parents.    It was the police in the Shannon Matthews case who also noticed similar inappropriate behaviour from her mother.

In the McCann case - none of the UK FLO's or any other professional who spent time with them noticed anything at all in their behaviour that would give them cause for suspicion. 

That should tell you something.

The input of the  specialist UK FLOs who spent a lot of time with the family ... some of whom were high ranking officers has been rejected ... in preference for the fleeting and somewhat prejudicial opinions of officers who apparently had such a loose grasp of the situation that they failed to cordon the apartment off.

It has all been woven into the cloth of other misinterpretations (the priest for example) and deliberate misinformation (swingers for example) which typify the outright propaganda attack which took, and continues to take place on the family of a missing child.
It seems to have been occurring since the morning of the 4th when Mr Amaral awoke having slept on it and formulated his thesis from which it seems he never deviated.

One wonders if the ranking officers doing the legwork were aware that their bosses were following evidence to 'convict', which must therefore have entailed following evidence which might 'find' taking a subsidiary position.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: John on December 18, 2015, 01:42:24 PM
It wasn't propaganda showing those crocodile tears of those parents.

It made a clear point, that people can put on an act.

I could have easily given other examples as well.

Meanwhile, you seem to forget, that mccann supporters mount attacks on the susceptible, THE DOSSIER, being the obvious example, the aftermath of which, resulted in the death of Brenda Leyland.

What help, including counselling was offered her ?

None, it would seem.

Crossing boards here for a moment, your comment reminded me of yet another actor who murdered his family.  The photo below shows him in full grief mode except, even he couldn't produce tears.  A short time later he boasted to his girlfriend (girl in the picture) that he should have been an actor.

For his performance, he dyed his hair jet black and powdered his face.  Witnessed remarked that the moment he got into the funeral car his whole demeanor changed instantly.

(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-iii7pacihjc/UuVvP7rxlKI/AAAAAAAAKR4/apB8WlOb6w4/s1600/El+funeral+(008).jpg)

Jeremy Bamber (centre foreground) with Julie Mugford and Colin Caffell (right) at the funeral of June and Nevill Bamber.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 01:49:58 PM
It wasn't propaganda showing those crocodile tears of those parents.

It made a clear point, that people can put on an act.

I could have easily given other examples as well.

Meanwhile, you seem to forget, that mccann supporters mount attacks on the sceptics, THE DOSSIER, being the obvious example, the aftermath of which, resulted in the death of Brenda Leyland.

What help, including counselling was offered her ?

None, it would seem.

You chose a propaganda tool which was discussed openly on many internet platforms.  Not least on one which you and I have both posted on ... which is where I had first hand experience of the duplicity associated with this particular example among others.
Nothing and no-one was considered too vile with which to associate the innocent parents of a missing child.

You obviously posted without realising that your post illustrated exactly the insidious propaganda in use against Madeleine McCann and her family.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: John on December 18, 2015, 01:54:59 PM
You chose a propaganda tool which was discussed openly on many internet platforms.  Not least on one which you and I have both posted on ... which is where I had first hand experience of the duplicity associated with this particular example among others.
Nothing and no-one was considered too vile with which to associate the innocent parents of a missing child.

You obviously posted without realising that your post illustrated exactly the insidious propaganda in use against Madeleine McCann and her family.

I agree Brietta, it can be a double edged sword.  In the McCann case when do you think the propaganda started?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 01:55:20 PM
Crossing boards here for a moment, your comment reminded me of yet another actor who murdered his family.  The photo below shows him in full grief mode except, even he couldn't produce tears.  A short time later he boasted to his girlfriend (girl in the picture) that he should have been an actor.

For his performance, he dyed his hair jet black and powdered his face.

(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-iii7pacihjc/UuVvP7rxlKI/AAAAAAAAKR4/apB8WlOb6w4/s1600/El+funeral+(008).jpg)

Jeremy Bamber (centre foreground) with Julie Mugford and Colin Caffell (right) at the funeral of June and Nevill Bamber.



The initial criticism of the Drs McCann was that they showed no emotion ... Dr Kate McCann being criticised in particular for being "cold".

No consideration given either to shock or the British stiff upper lip.

What I saw was a broken couple ... then I didn't have an agenda (propaganda) to push.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 01:57:37 PM
I agree Brietta, it can be a double edged sword.  In the McCann case when do you think the propaganda started?

I think the propaganda started with the first leak to the Portuguese press from 'a source close to the investigation'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 18, 2015, 02:00:27 PM
You chose a propaganda tool which was discussed openly on many internet platforms.  Not least on one which you and I have both posted on ... which is where I had first hand experience of the duplicity associated with this particular example among others.
Nothing and no-one was considered too vile with which to associate the innocent parents of a missing child.

You obviously posted without realising that your post illustrated exactly the insidious propaganda in use against Madeleine McCann and her family.

The police brought in English specialist dogs and they alerted to everything connected to the McCanns and nobody else. No alerts to Murat or the other apartments or vehicles. Are the dogs part of it?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 18, 2015, 02:00:44 PM
Another example of PROPAGANDA in its truest form
  ... and the very sad thing about it is that the poster has not grasped that by posting it on a thread about propaganda what an ideal illustration of the dark art it was and is.

Pairing the parents of a missing child with the parents who killed five of theirs is really a rather clumsy and transparent attempt and not up to the usual standard ... but propaganda designed to malign nonetheless however ineffective.

Cites can be found very easily ... I googled ~ compare mccanns and philpotts ~ check it out if you require confirmation.

Facebook Group Plans Orchestrated Attack against McCann family
https://ordinisrubricrucis.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/facebook-group-plans-orchestrated-attack-against-mccann-family/

There are concerted attacks on the McCann family in which propaganda of the vilest sort has been used.  It seems to be related to their campaign to keep their daughter in the public domain and to have the official investigation into her disappearance reopened ... in which they have been successful.

Why has their campaign on Madeleine's behalf attracted such ire?  Why is there a PM petition in existence?  Why have new FOIs been submitted?

Perhaps those are among the questions the 'questioners' should be asking as well as wondering why there are those attacking Operation Grange who are merely fulfilling the the mission statement they apparently masquerade under if their actions are looked at critically.

Good post, Brietta.

The because some people do, everyone does (fake stuff!) line of non-thinking and propaganda really is a disgrace to this board, as well as (more important!) a disgraceful slur on an innocent couple, hovering between hope, despair and grief for a missing little girl, who is their daughter and whom they love very much
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 02:27:50 PM
It wasn't propaganda showing those crocodile tears of those parents.

It made a clear point, that people can put on an act.

I could have easily given other examples as well.

Meanwhile, you seem to forget, that mccann supporters mount attacks on the sceptics, THE DOSSIER, being the obvious example, the aftermath of which, resulted in the death of Brenda Leyland.

What help, including counselling was offered her ?

None, it would seem.

It's not a good idea to introduce Brenda Leyland into the debate and make accusations re the cause of her death
She had a history of psychiatric illness and had attempted suicide before
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 02:32:58 PM
The police brought in English specialist dogs and they alerted to everything connected to the McCanns and nobody else. No alerts to Murat or the other apartments or vehicles. Are the dogs part of it?

Unfortunately the dogs were made "part of it" when misunderstanding, misinterpretation or just downright wishful thinking became part of the propaganda message.

Look up 'blood spatter' and no doubt you will find a reference to the walls and floor of apartment 5.
Look up the nonsense of 100% DNA and no doubt there will be a picture (worth more than words) of Eddie posing at the front door of the Renault baying at ... what we now know is ... a key fob.

If you find it credible there was ~ not ~ a ~ single ~ drop ~ of ~ blood ~ spilled anywhere in Luz other than in areas associated with the McCann family, that's fine.
Please don't think it extraordinary that I'm not buying it.

Apparently not all the Murat associated vehicles were checked by the dogs ... the one in the garage having a deep clean was missed.  Unless you know different ??
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 18, 2015, 02:37:27 PM
He didn't say they were crying without tears,  he said they were making noises like crying and there were no tears.   Now what do you think that might have been?   think hard,  can you imagine a time where you wanted to cry but tried not to?   

Prostrating?  was that when they were praying and crying by the bed by any chance?

You do try and make out these are big deals don't you,   but they have nothing at all to do with the disappearance of Madeleine.

think hard,  can you imagine a time where you wanted to cry but tried not to? 


think hard ??????.....why the hell fgs ...would you want to compose yourself they said they thought maddie had been abducted...

i don't care what you say it is an unbelievable comment ......your child has gone ....so your more worried about ...you want to cry ..but think better of it ......why does any one do that then ...or is it ,,.then the charade had  started...the act


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 18, 2015, 02:38:45 PM
Unfortunately the dogs were made "part of it" when misunderstanding, misinterpretation or just downright wishful thinking became part of the propaganda message.

Look up 'blood spatter' and no doubt you will find a reference to the walls and floor of apartment 5.
Look up the nonsense of 100% DNA and no doubt there will be a picture (worth more than words) of Eddie posing at the front door of the Renault baying at ... what we now know is ... a key fob.

If you find it credible there was ~ not ~ a ~ single ~ drop ~ of ~ blood ~ spilled anywhere in Luz other than in areas associated with the McCann family, that's fine.
Please don't think it extraordinary that I'm not buying it.

Apparently not all the Murat associated vehicles were checked by the dogs ... the one in the garage having a deep clean was missed.  Unless you know different ??

You don't get it. Eddie doesn't go in first to find blood. Keela is the blood dog. Eddie was EVRD and his training was to detect cadaver scent. He didn't go to the body farm to detect blood.

McCann's Apartment.

The apartment in which the McCann's had stayed may present further
opportunities to search. The use of a specialist EVRD (Enhanced Victim
Recovery Dog) and CSI dog (human blood detecting dog) could potentially indicate on whether Madeline's blood is in the property or the scent of a dead body is present. In relation to the dead body scent if such a scent is indicated by the EVRD and no body is located it may suggest that a body has been in the property but removed. This search process could be repeated in all the apartments that were occupied by the friends holidaying with the McCann's.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARK_HARRISON.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 18, 2015, 03:07:36 PM
It wasn't propaganda showing those crocodile tears of those parents.

It made a clear point, that people can put on an act.

I could have easily given other examples as well.

Meanwhile, you seem to forget, that mccann supporters mount attacks on the sceptics, THE DOSSIER, being the obvious example, the aftermath of which, resulted in the death of Brenda Leyland.

What help, including counselling was offered her ?

None, it would seem.

Yeah good post Brie, and opening e link we find: “we must link the McCanns to the Philpotts to encourage more anger towards them”

Now if we rewrite that a  little.
“we must link the McCanns[Sceptics] to the Philpotts[anything scurrilous you fancy] to encourage more anger towards them”

Same meat different gravy as they say in the better parts of Dalston.
Propaganda's good innit ?

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 03:11:04 PM
You chose a propaganda tool which was discussed openly on many internet platforms.  Not least on one which you and I have both posted on ... which is where I had first hand experience of the duplicity associated with this particular example among others.
Nothing and no-one was considered too vile with which to associate the innocent parents of a missing child.

You obviously posted without realising that your post illustrated exactly the insidious propaganda in use against Madeleine McCann and her family.

I find your comments hypocritical.

Propaganda exists on both sides in this case, a point you singularly ignore.

It is quite clear, whether you wdmit or not, that emotions can be faked as can tears.

I don't believe the mccanns and never will.

Perhaps it is time you adnit that there is no natural law saying the mccanns should be supported, come what may.

They still remain the last known people to see her alive.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 18, 2015, 03:17:56 PM
I find your comments hypocritical.

Propaganda exists on both sides in this case, a point you singularly ignore.

It is quite clear, whether you wdmit or not, that emotions can be faked as can tears.

I don't believe the mccanns and never will.

Perhaps it is time you adnit that there is no natural law saying the mccanns should be supported, come what may.

They still remain the last known people to see her alive.

the thing too is i think it i is a  class issue    with brietta  if the mcanns  were not doctors she wouldnt care about maddie   she  calls  gerry and kate  dr gerry and kate instead of just gerry and kate she thinks they are   above  the  law  becasse they are doctors  kate has not beena  dr for nearly 9 years her licence would have expired long ago if this was a poor class   family brietta wouldnt care less just imo
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 03:18:18 PM
Crossing boards here for a moment, your comment reminded me of yet another actor who murdered his family.  The photo below shows him in full grief mode except, even he couldn't produce tears.  A short time later he boasted to his girlfriend (girl in the picture) that he should have been an actor.

For his performance, he dyed his hair jet black and powdered his face.  Witnessed remarked that the moment he got into the funeral car his whole demeanor changed instantly.

(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-iii7pacihjc/UuVvP7rxlKI/AAAAAAAAKR4/apB8WlOb6w4/s1600/El+funeral+(008).jpg)

Jeremy Bamber (centre foreground) with Julie Mugford and Colin Caffell (right) at the funeral of June and Nevill Bamber.

Thank you for that John.

That rather reinforces the points I have and others have made.

Emotions can be faked, as can tears.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 03:19:36 PM
the thing too is i think it isa  class issue    with brietta  if the mcanns  were not doctors she wouldnt care about maddie   she  calls  gerry and kate  dr gerry and kate instead of just gerry and kate she thinks they are infer becasse they are doctors  kate has not beena  dr for nearly 9 years her licence would have expired long ago if this was a poor class   family brietta wouldnt care less just imo

That they were Doctors is irrelevant.

What is relevant, is what they failed to do.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 18, 2015, 03:20:16 PM
Thank you for that John.

That rather reinforces the points I have and others have made.

Emotions can be faked, as can tears.

maddies little tears were not  faked  and the mcann supporters dont care  about that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 18, 2015, 03:25:29 PM


There is no misunderstanding. Eddie was professionally trained to detect cadaver scent whether a body is still present or not.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 18, 2015, 03:25:55 PM
That they were Doctors is irrelevant.

What is relevant, is what they failed to do.
8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: carlymichelle on December 18, 2015, 03:27:34 PM
There is no misunderstanding. Eddie was professionally trained to detect cadaver scent whether a body is still present or not.

isnt it  funny how they   slander dogs  who cant    talk back  oh if  only they  could they would have lots  to say!!!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 18, 2015, 03:37:04 PM
isnt it  funny how they   slander dogs  who cant    talk back  oh if  only they  could they would have lots  to say!!!

Kate loved telling that joke from her friend in the book. What are they gonna do? Take the stand and it's one bark for yes and two for no. They should have been concerned that their daughter could be deceased but they'd rather take the piss out of them like arrogant fools. They brought body finder in before the dogs so why are they later dissing the dogs and not that barmy machine  @)(++(* SY are using them so we know what they think.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 18, 2015, 03:52:29 PM
No matter how much those who support the McCanns cry about 'sceptic propaganda' the fact remains that it was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for professional PR people to manage their reputation over the last 8 and a half years.

It was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for top flight lawyers to silence anyone with a different view on the case.

It would be very interesting to be able to add up the amount of Fund money spent on actual searching and to compare it with the total spent on silencing those who 'harmed the search'.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 04:17:51 PM
Yeah good post Brie, and opening e link we find: “we must link the McCanns to the Philpotts to encourage more anger towards them”

Now if we rewrite that a  little.
“we must link the McCanns[Sceptics] to the Philpotts[anything scurrilous you fancy] to encourage more anger towards them”

Same meat different gravy as they say in the better parts of Dalston.
Propaganda's good innit ?

If that is your take ... I bow to your superior knowledge on the workings of the propaganda vehicle.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 04:20:02 PM
No matter how much those who support the McCanns cry about 'sceptic propaganda' the fact remains that it was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for professional PR people to manage their reputation over the last 8 and a half years.

It was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for top flight lawyers to silence anyone with a different view on the case.

It would be very interesting to be able to add up the amount of Fund money spent on actual searching and to compare it with the total spent on silencing those who 'harmed the search'.

they can only silence those who libel them....anyone claiming Maddie is already dead is harming the search
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 18, 2015, 04:25:15 PM
This is a good example of McCann bashing propaganda as written by leading "sceptic" Tony Bennett (I think this was widely circulated prior to his conviction), fully rebutted and exposed for the misleading trash it is by a bunch of McCann supporters.  Now, I know some of you will insist that the rebuttal is simply another version of propaganda, but for that to be so you will need to show in what way it misleads, with evidence to support your argument:

http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39076140/Main-Page
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 04:26:29 PM
Kate loved telling that joke from her friend in the book. What are they gonna do? Take the stand and it's one bark for yes and two for no. They should have been concerned that their daughter could be deceased but they'd rather take the piss out of them like arrogant fools. They brought body finder in before the dogs so why are they later dissing the dogs and not that barmy machine  @)(++(* SY are using them so we know what they think.

I think it's quite a good joke
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 04:26:42 PM
I find your comments hypocritical.

Propaganda exists on both sides in this case, a point you singularly ignore.

It is quite clear, whether you wdmit or not, that emotions can be faked as can tears.

I don't believe the mccanns and never will.

Perhaps it is time you adnit that there is no natural law saying the mccanns should be supported, come what may.

They still remain the last known people to see her alive.

I am not required to search for examples of scurrilous propaganda directed towards the McCann family ... other posters on this thread are providing fine enough examples.

The thread concerns propaganda ... unfortunately the example you chose to deflect from that topic, was a shot into an open goal being in itself an example par excellence of the mentality traducing innocent parents by associating with ones guilty of the most heinous crime imaginable.

Well done, that poster!!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 04:33:46 PM
the thing too is i think it i is a  class issue    with brietta  if the mcanns  were not doctors she wouldnt care about maddie   she  calls  gerry and kate  dr gerry and kate instead of just gerry and kate she thinks they are   above  the  law  becasse they are doctors  kate has not beena  dr for nearly 9 years her licence would have expired long ago if this was a poor class   family brietta wouldnt care less just imo

Yet another classic example of the propaganda directed towards the Drs McCann.

They didn't live on a sink estate ... and they weren't 'chavs'.

Fortunately they were able to develop and make use of contacts and skills in their attempt to find their daughter and keep her name in the public domain which I doubt very many other parents ... whatever their social strata ... could have achieved.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 04:40:56 PM
There is no misunderstanding. Eddie was professionally trained to detect cadaver scent whether a body is still present or not.

Eddie was trained on pig and blood and would alert to both.

Keela alerted only to blood.  Therefore when Keela and Eddie alerted in the same place and forensics found blood ... that was what was being alerted to.
Read what Mr Grime has to say on the subject, that is where I got my information.

The notion that Eddie alerts only to cadaver is just so much dis-informative propaganda which some have fallen hook line and sinker for.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 04:41:21 PM
No matter how much those who support the McCanns cry about 'sceptic propaganda' the fact remains that it was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for professional PR people to manage their reputation over the last 8 and a half years.

It was and is the McCanns who hired and paid for top flight lawyers to silence anyone with a different view on the case.

It would be very interesting to be able to add up the amount of Fund money spent on actual searching and to compare it with the total spent on silencing those who 'harmed the search'.

Amaral and the PJ used the press to build a case against...that's what this thread is about. You and the sceptics swallowed the lies.....the McCannns had to fight back. the PJ wanted to pin the case on the McCanns. RThey could have been arrested and held on remand for a year...taht's why they needed the best extradition lawyers...it really is a simple as that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 18, 2015, 04:43:24 PM
isnt it  funny how they   slander dogs  who cant    talk back  oh if  only they  could they would have lots  to say!!!

Didn't you know ... "Dogs don't lie!" ... which tells me exactly what the dogs would say if they could talk, you might find such a conversation highly informative.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 18, 2015, 04:43:40 PM
Yet another classic example of the propaganda directed towards the Drs McCann.

They didn't live on a sink estate ... and they weren't 'chavs'.

Fortunately they were able to develop and make use of contacts and skills in their attempt to find their daughter and keep her name in the public domain which I doubt very many other parents ... whatever their social strata ... could have achieved.

Some American Social Scientists might disagree. They call it MWWS.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 04:48:10 PM
You don't get it. Eddie doesn't go in first to find blood. Keela is the blood dog. Eddie was EVRD and his training was to detect cadaver scent. He didn't go to the body farm to detect blood.

McCann's Apartment.

The apartment in which the McCann's had stayed may present further
opportunities to search. The use of a specialist EVRD (Enhanced Victim
Recovery Dog) and CSI dog (human blood detecting dog) could potentially indicate on whether Madeline's blood is in the property or the scent of a dead body is present. In relation to the dead body scent if such a scent is indicated by the EVRD and no body is located it may suggest that a body has been in the property but removed. This search process could be repeated in all the apartments that were occupied by the friends holidaying with the McCann's.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARK_HARRISON.htm

nice piece of sceptic propaganda...."may suggest" becomes..."there was a body in5a"....absolute baloney of the highest order
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 18, 2015, 04:48:40 PM
they can only silence those who libel them....anyone claiming Maddie is already dead is harming the search

Let's for the moment say she was abducted and remains alive.
8 years of the most publicised missing child case since the Lindbergh kidnapping resulting in no credible sighting.
Someone somewhere  is going to an awful lot of trouble to ensure she isn't found.................. &%+((£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 18, 2015, 04:52:47 PM
This is a good example of McCann bashing propaganda as written by leading "sceptic" Tony Bennett (I think this was widely circulated prior to his conviction), fully rebutted and exposed for the misleading trash it is by a bunch of McCann supporters.  Now, I know some of you will insist that the rebuttal is simply another version of propaganda, but for that to be so you will need to show in what way it misleads, with evidence to support your argument:

http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39076140/Main-Page

JayElles.

Unfailingly clinical and thorough in her rebuttals ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 18, 2015, 05:04:03 PM
Anybody who wants to witness the Anti McCann propaganda machine in full swing should take a look at the #McCann tag on twitter - of course these twitter tw..s are preaching to the converted and no one pays them the blindest bit of notice but still they earnestly tweet their tawdry, morbid and often apparently deranged trash day in, day out, 24/7.  It's kind of sad, and certainly pathetic. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 05:06:15 PM
they can only silence those who libel them....anyone claiming Maddie is already dead is harming the search

More propaganda.

The mccanns aren't 'searching'.

That is being done by SY. Isn't it ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 05:12:31 PM
I am not required to search for examples of scurrilous propaganda directed towards the McCann family ... other posters on this thread are providing fine enough examples.

The thread concerns propaganda ... unfortunately the example you chose to deflect from that topic, was a shot into an open goal being in itself an example par excellence of the mentality traducing innocent parents by associating with ones guilty of the most heinous crime imaginable.

Well done, that poster!!

Perhaps you should remember a key point.

You believe the mccanns told the truth.

That does not make it true, no matter how many times you type to that effect.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 05:13:33 PM
More propaganda.

The mccanns aren't 'searching'.

That is being done by SY. Isn't it ?

it is now
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 05:14:11 PM
JayElles.

Unfailingly clinical and thorough in her rebuttals ....

That is a matter of opinion.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 05:15:44 PM
it is now

So that made a nonsense of your previous post.

They have of course found nothing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 05:22:39 PM
So that made a nonsense of your previous post.

They have of course found nothing.

no it doesn't
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 05:25:39 PM
no it doesn't

Please quantify how any search has been harmed.

There is no law saying though shalt believe the mccanns story of abduction.  Is there ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 05:58:02 PM
Please quantify how any search has been harmed.

There is no law saying though shalt believe the mccanns story of abduction.  Is there ?

search..off topic...not interested...there is a law saying that thou shall not libel the McCanns ...that's the relevant one
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 18, 2015, 05:59:52 PM
xtina posted his statement on this thread a few pages back.

Then you'll be able to find it easily then.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 06:13:08 PM
search..off topic...not interested...there is a law saying that thou shall not libel the McCanns ...that's the relevant one

So you are therefore saying by your 'logic', if you don't believe the mccanns story, then that's libel ?

Om that basis any criminal investigation would falter at the start, as regards any potential criminal.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 06:17:34 PM
So you are therefore saying by your 'logic', if you don't believe the mccanns story, then that's libel ?

Om that basis any criminal investigation would falter at the start, as regards any potential criminal.

But it's not what I said
It's what you think I might have said
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 06:31:56 PM
But it's not what I said
It's what you think I might have said

It is about time you admitted that the crime is unknown, no matter what you state as regards abduction.

and it isn't a crime or libel to suggest that Madeleine's disappearance can be explained by other scenarios.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 18, 2015, 06:34:13 PM
Amaral and the PJ used the press to build a case against...that's what this thread is about. You and the sceptics swallowed the lies.....the McCannns had to fight back. the PJ wanted to pin the case on the McCanns. RThey could have been arrested and held on remand for a year...taht's why they needed the best extradition lawyers...it really is a simple as that

Did the McCanns sue any Portuguese newspapers or didn't they care about the damage to their reputations in Portugal?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 06:47:30 PM
Did the McCanns sue any Portuguese newspapers or didn't they care about the damage to their reputations in Portugal?

It seems they couldn't sch is Portuguese libel law
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 18, 2015, 06:49:38 PM
Did the McCanns sue any Portuguese newspapers or didn't they care about the damage to their reputations in Portugal?
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/6057918/McCanns-drop-libel-case-against-Portuguese-newspaper.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 07:04:47 PM
It is about time you admitted that the crime is unknown, no matter what you state as regards abduction.

and it isn't a crime or libel to suggest that Madeleine's disappearance can be explained by other scenarios.

What I have already stated is absolutely correct
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 18, 2015, 07:11:20 PM
What I have already stated is absolutely correct

Read what I said.

IT IS NOT LIBEL TO SUGGEST OTHER SCENARIOS.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 18, 2015, 07:12:05 PM
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/6057918/McCanns-drop-libel-case-against-Portuguese-newspaper.html

Hmmm, short memory?

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6147.0

The Drs Mccann had no case and not a fat cats chance in hell of winning...all that debacle proved was that the Drs Mccann  were willing so early on to spend donators' monies to control reportingrefute true facts! There must be a word for that....any ideas?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 07:21:25 PM
Read what I said.

IT IS NOT LIBEL TO SUGGEST OTHER SCENARIOS.

depends what those scenarios are...eg... is libellous to say they lied to the police and covered up an accidental death
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 18, 2015, 07:23:14 PM
Hmmm, short memory?

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6147.0

The Drs Mccann had no case and not a fat cats chance in hell of winning...all that debacle proved was that the Drs Mccann  were willing so early on to spend donators' monies to control reportingrefute true facts! There must be a word for that....any ideas?

they cannot refute facts but they can refute lies told about them...and they are quite right in doing so
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 18, 2015, 07:34:36 PM
they cannot refute facts but they can refute lies told about them...and they are quite right in doing so
I repeat, the Drs Mccann had no case whatsoever in any way shape or form as regards libel against that newspaper as they reported true facts.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 18, 2015, 08:55:28 PM
JayElles.

Unfailingly clinical and thorough in her rebuttals ....

Wasnt  it her who was responsible for the "sky dossier" ?
I have read that rebuttal website and most of it is true or fair comment, some of it apologetic, some of it whitewashng....but I find it quite  horrendous and shocking that you champion the forum where she is from when it is so hateful...thought you were different to some extent....
if no one has heard of it here is a link, if allowed, if not, mods you can delete

http://www.stopthemyths.info/index.php?sid=c8da7e4ad9e942019c9d47d5c78c16fd

these are the open boards, if these werent enough, the worst of it goes "hidden"...you have join to read....but no sane person would....talk of hunting people down and getting them sacked from their jobs and such stuff...pathetic vile hypocrites....and lets not forget the facebook stalking of many they conduct....as I said, pathetic
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 12:18:13 AM
Perhaps you should remember a key point.

You believe the mccanns told the truth.

That does not make it true, no matter how many times you type to that effect.

What I believe or don't believe doesn't alter by one iota the horrendous and so easily provable unprecedented propaganda campaign which has been mounted and sustained for nearly nine years on the parents of a missing child.

You fell into the trap of using a photograph of murderers who have been used in propaganda campaigns to denigrate the Drs McCann by comparison.

That is fact. 
Nothing at all to do with who or what I believe. 
Nothing at all to do with the Drs McCann. 
All to do with people wilfully using unrelated people and circumstances to denigrate them.

It would be difficult to find a more blatant example of propaganda ... which is only one of many.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 12:21:34 AM
I hadn't seen this stuff before so it was very interesting, and many thanks to you.

"Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory."

Just before he was removed from the enquiry, he was trying to chase up an analysis on human blood found outside Quinta dos Figos, blood discovered shortly after Madeleine disappeared.  This has, AFAIK, nothing to do with the McCanns, or Madeleine.  However, we are not going to know for certain, as Amaral got hoiked, and this diligence was not followed through in the time of the PJ files.

Didnt they find it was animal blood

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PORTUGUESE-FORENSIC.htm


Eta. Ok, ignore, my mistake......
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 12:41:29 AM
What I believe or don't believe doesn't alter by one iota the horrendous and so easily provable unprecedented propaganda campaign which has been mounted and sustained for nearly nine years on the parents of a missing child.

You fell into the trap of using a photograph of murderers who have been used in propaganda campaigns to denigrate the Drs McCann by comparison.

That is fact. 
Nothing at all to do with who or what I believe. 
Nothing at all to do with the Drs McCann. 
All to do with people wilfully using unrelated people and circumstances to denigrate them.

It would be difficult to find a more blatant example of propaganda ... which is only one of many.

who was the evil genius who started this campaign 9 years ago? And in a similar vein who is the evil scarlet pimpernel that "snatched' Madeleine...and evaded 3 police forces and 8 sets of PIs investigations for so long....

And why do the Dr Mccanns think they have a chance of finding out and "holding money back to do so" when the best of the best SY as well as ALL others have found nothing?

...
Ps you could well do better for your credibility than casting aspersions on people on this board...that behaviour is very disturbing luv
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 01:03:59 AM
who was the evil genius who started this campaign 9 years ago? And in a similar vein who is the evil scarlet pimpernel that "snatched' Madeleine...and evaded 3 police forces and 8 sets of PIs investigations for so long....

And why do the Dr Mccanns think they have a chance of finding out and "holding money back to do so" when the best of the best SY as well as ALL others have found nothing?

...

You ask ... "who was the evil genius who started this campaign 9 years ago?"

Perhaps the answer lies in working out who benefits from the virulent propaganda campaign directed against the Drs McCann.  Once that is ascertained many more pieces of the jigsaw may slot into place.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 01:08:05 AM
You ask ... "who was the evil genius who started this campaign 9 years ago?"

Perhaps the answer lies in working out who benefits from the virulent propaganda campaign directed against the Drs McCann.  Once that is ascertained many more pieces of the jigsaw may slot into place.

And the answer is? Spit it out darling....I dont do cryptic.. But dont forget to answer all my previous post!!!!! You wouldnt want anyone to think you were avoiding issues now would you? Of course not.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 02:08:36 AM
And the answer is? Spit it out darling....I dont do cryptic.. But dont forget to answer all my previous post!!!!! You wouldnt want anyone to think you were avoiding issues now would you? Of course not.

If I knew the answer to who the "evil genius was" who instigated the scurrilous propaganda campaign against the Drs McCann and by association, Madeleine ... the case might be well on the way to being solved and the only people I would be sharing with are Scotland Yard.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 02:47:06 AM
If I knew the answer to who the "evil genius was" who instigated the scurrilous propaganda campaign against the Drs McCann and by association, Madeleine ... the case might be well on the way to being solved and the only people I would be sharing with are Scotland Yard.

Do yu not   realise how stupid you come across when you accuse people  of being against a missing child and her being found?

Utterly stupid or if not stupid then worst than stupid....now perhaps you might be able to address my  previous question better

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 03:02:42 AM

There is no misunderstanding. Eddie was professionally trained to detect cadaver scent whether a body is still present or not.

That is 100 per cent it...whatever the apologists say and spin  day after day, poor them.....

Must have been fertiliser in the garden, or clipped toenails in the bedroom etc etc

Got a 25 point list of possibilites provided that arent from a body  but wont embarass them by reminding them lol cos the apologist deniers have already done it themselves  in the most  ridiculous of ways imaginable.....oops..l  have all the suggestions saved,best pray I dont post them dears and remind you of your utter stupidities and wshful thoughts lol
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 19, 2015, 03:24:09 AM
hibrietta



maybe you can save the day out of this McCann DEBACLE by answerng pst 103 here

Well?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6876.90



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 08:05:28 AM
What I believe or don't believe doesn't alter by one iota the horrendous and so easily provable unprecedented propaganda campaign which has been mounted and sustained for nearly nine years on the parents of a missing child.

You fell into the trap of using a photograph of murderers who have been used in propaganda campaigns to denigrate the Drs McCann by comparison.

That is fact. 
Nothing at all to do with who or what I believe. 
Nothing at all to do with the Drs McCann. 
All to do with people wilfully using unrelated people and circumstances to denigrate them.

It would be difficult to find a more blatant example of propaganda ... which is only one of many.

Now let's see you prove there has been an orchestrated campaign against the mccanns.

I didn't fall into any trap as regards the photo I  pasted on this forum. It has been done before, and John gave another one.

As for the rest of the post, you forget the mccanns denigrated themselves by their own actions, and decided to assume the mantle of displaying 'responsible parenting skills'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 08:23:39 AM
You ask ... "who was the evil genius who started this campaign 9 years ago?"

Perhaps the answer lies in working out who benefits from the virulent propaganda campaign directed against the Drs McCann.  Once that is ascertained many more pieces of the jigsaw may slot into place.


Dear oh dear. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 08:46:04 AM
That is 100 per cent it...whatever the apologists say and spin  day after day, poor them.....

Must have been fertiliser in the garden, or clipped toenails in the bedroom etc etc

Got a 25 point list of possibilites provided that arent from a body  but wont embarass them by reminding them lol cos the apologist deniers have already done it themselves  in the most  ridiculous of ways imaginable.....oops..l  have all the suggestions saved,best pray I dont post them dears and remind you of your utter stupidities and wshful thoughts lol

There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 08:47:15 AM

Dear oh dear. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+

What does that mean Stephen?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 08:50:15 AM
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?

I assume you will know tell us what a dead pig was doing in the apartment?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 08:53:10 AM
I assume you will know tell us what a dead pig was doing in the apartment?

Are you being facetious Slartibarfast,   I have never said there was a dead pig in the apartment.   I have said that pig blood could have been in the fertiliser used on the garden,   as the dog alerted to the garden I don't see why that is so unbelievable,  it could have been walked in.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 08:55:00 AM
of course the McCanns are victims of propaganda. initially it was lies in leaks from the PJ...now it is  a small group of fanatics on the net. There are several sites where lies are promoted and anyone who dares to question their version is silenced. The main piece of propaganda is the dog alerts. Many posters on this and other sites simply do not understand them.  Grime was asked twice by the PJ if the alerts confirmed the presence of cadaver odour and each time he failed to answer the question. I don't believe there ever was a body in 5a...and there is no evidence to contradict me.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 08:55:56 AM
I assume you will know tell us what a dead pig was doing in the apartment?

Perhaps we  ask members of the Bullingdon Club.  8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 08:58:06 AM
of course the McCanns are victims of propaganda. initially it was lies in leaks from the PJ...now it is  a small group of fanatics on the net. There are several sites where lies are promoted and anyone who dares to question their version is silenced. The main piece of propaganda is the dog alerts. Many posters on this and other sites simply do not understand them.  Grime was asked twice by the PJ if the alerts confirmed the presence of cadaver odour and each time he failed to answer the question. I don't believe there ever was a body in 5a...and there is no evidence to contradict me.

As you are fond of saying, your opinion is of no importance.

As to propaganda, every time the case is featured in the news since the Express libel trial, the public have been fed with pro mccann propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 08:58:29 AM
Are you being facetious Slartibarfast,   I have never said there was a dead pig in the apartment.   I have said that pig blood could have been in the fertiliser used on the garden,   as the dog alerted to the garden I don't see why that is so unbelievable,  it could have been walked in.

More propaganda?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:04:32 AM
As you are fond of saying, your opinion is of no importance.

As to propaganda, every time the case is featured in the news since the Express libel trial, the public have been fed with pro mccann propaganda.

as your opinion is of no importance...at least I realise the truth and don't believe that this board and others like it shape public opinion.

More propaganda from you...do you have any examples of this pro mccann propaganda. It is simply the truth...the papers no longer dare print lies
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 09:08:17 AM
as your opinion is of no importance...at least I realise the truth and don't believe that this board and others like it shape public opinion.

More propaganda from you...do you have any examples of this pro mccann propaganda. It is simply the truth...the papers no longer dare print lies

What truth dave ?

The crime is unknown.

There is no evidence of abduction.

The mccanns version of events has not been subjected to a court case and them under oath.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 09:11:03 AM
More propaganda?

In what way?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 09:13:03 AM
In what way?

Cite for alerting to Pig Blood?
Cite for fertiliser containing Pig Blood used?

Just wild supposition hence propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:15:17 AM
What truth dave ?

The crime is unknown.

There is no evidence of abduction.

The mccanns version of events has not been subjected to a court case and them under oath.

according to SY there is evidence of abduction..
The mccannns have not been tested in court because the evidence does not exist to take them to court
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:17:46 AM
Cite for alerting to Pig Blood?
Cite for fertiliser containing Pig Blood used?

Just wild supposition hence propaganda.

the most important thing is what the dogs actually alerted to...the answer is ...apart from the blood on the key card...no one knows. When we have confirmation that the alerts were to cadaver odour then they can be taken more seriously ...at the moment they are meaningless
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 09:19:46 AM
according to SY there is evidence of abduction..
The mccannns have not been tested in court because the evidence does not exist to take them to court

No forensics, no evidence.

Just supposition.

and just as I predicted a long time ago, they would find NOTHING.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:22:36 AM
No forensics, no evidence.

Just supposition.

and just as I predicted a long time ago, they would find NOTHING.

and nothing against the McCanns....yet you believe in an accident...which has no evidence to support it..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 09:24:31 AM
and nothing against the McCanns....yet you believe in an accident...which has no evidence to support it..

As much as abduction.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 09:25:51 AM
Cite for alerting to Pig Blood?
Cite for fertiliser containing Pig Blood used?

Just wild supposition hence propaganda.

You only have to read what Grime says about Eddie,   he says he  was trained on pig cadaver,   he also says it was impossible for Eddie to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.

I said 'could have been the fertiliser'   as the PJ didn't test the soil for it then it cannot be proved,  that doesn't mean it wasn't used.

Eddie alerted in the garden,  why didn't they test the soil?   That is not wild supposition or propaganda.

It's just like someone saying the McCann's could have drugged the children.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 09:27:20 AM
and nothing against the McCanns....yet you believe in an accident...which has no evidence to support it..

Can Stephen give a theory on how the McCann's would have had time to hide Madeleine's body?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:28:49 AM
You only have to read what Grime says about Eddie,   he says he  was trained on pig cadaver,   he also says it was impossible for Eddie to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.

I said 'could have been the fertiliser'   as the PJ didn't test the soil for it then it cannot be proved,  that doesn't mean it wasn't used.

Eddie alerted in the garden,  why didn't they test the soil?   That is not wild supposition or propaganda.

It's just like someone saying the McCann's could have drugged the children.

the alert in the garden was the most ridiculous of all...remnant scent would not last 3 months outside...the scent would only be present if actual physical remains were there
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:33:25 AM
As much as abduction.


so you don't believe abduction because there is no evidence but you believe in an accident...that has no evidence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 09:51:19 AM

so you don't believe abduction because there is no evidence but you believe in an accident...that has no evidence

There is as regards the dogs.

Neither confirmed or dismissed by the forensic analysis.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:54:26 AM
There is as regards the dogs.

Neither confirmed or dismissed by the forensic analysis.

not confirmed by forensic analysis....therefore the alertsa re meaningless...if you don't agree...tell us what the alerts tell us
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 10:03:17 AM
What does that mean Stephen?

LOL ... were there no emoticons and smileys some would be struck dumb.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:04:37 AM
LOL ... were there no emoticons and smileys some would be struck dumb.

some being the operative word
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:13:44 AM
LOL ... were there no emoticons and smileys some would be struck dumb.

Let's just see you justify your claims of a conspiracy against the mccanns.

WITH SOME SOLID HARD INDISPUTABLE FACTS.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:14:29 AM
Let's just see you justify your claims of a conspiracy against the mccanns.

WITH SOME SOLID HARD INDISPUTABLE FACTS.

just read HDH posts on CMOMM
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 19, 2015, 10:16:17 AM

You DON'T know if there was contamination of pig blood in the fertiliser as there was no test done on the floor of the bedroom in 5a or the soil in the garden.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 10:26:36 AM


We have no idea what or if there was any contamination.  Suffice to say there were alerts from a dog with a recorded history of giving false alerts ... in Praia da Luz there was no forensic evidence to explain the mysterious alerts to the apartment or clothing ... in Haute de la Garenne there was forensic evidence confirming the dog was in error.

That a very successful propaganda campaign has been constructed around the "dogs don't lie" clanger is a matter of wonder to me ... and in my opinion a belief which is founded on evidence to the contrary evidences gullibility and would be amusing were it not being used to impugn and denigrate the parents of a missing child.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:27:00 AM
just read HDH posts on CMOMM

That is not a conspiracy.

Pray tell how did they interfere in the 'search' ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:28:28 AM
We have no idea what or if there was any contamination.  Suffice to say there were alerts from a dog with a recorded history of giving false alerts ... in Praia da Luz there was no forensic evidence to explain the mysterious alerts to the apartment or clothing ... in Haute de la Garenne there was forensic evidence confirming the dog was in error.

That a very successful propaganda campaign has been constructed around the "dogs don't lie" clanger is a matter of wonder to me ... and in my opinion a belief which is founded on evidence to the contrary evidences gullibility and would be amusing were it not being used to impugn and denigrate the parents of a missing child.

Not in PDL there wasn't.

Now what did kate mccann joke in her book as regards the dogs ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:30:49 AM
Not in PDL there wasn't.

Now what did kate mccann joke in her book as regards the dogs ?

The alerts are a joke
Grime should have been more clear in his appraisal of them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:31:57 AM
That is not a conspiracy.

Pray tell how did they interfere in the 'search' ?

The thread is nothing to do with the search and nothing to do with conspiracy
Read the opening post
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:36:08 AM
The alerts are a joke
Grime should have been more clear in his appraisal of them

The alerts are not a joke.

If they were, you would not comment on them.

The more you type about them, the more credence you give.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:37:07 AM
The alerts are not a joke.

If they were, you would not comment on them.

The more you type about them, the more credence you give.

The alerts and the sceptics understanding of them is a joke
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:38:48 AM
The alerts and the sceptics understanding of them is a joke

A sublimely simple answer.

Read my last post.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:40:04 AM
A sublimely simple answer.

Read my last post.

Not only have I read it
I have replied to it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 10:57:00 AM
The alerts are a joke
Grime should have been more clear in his appraisal of them

He didn't know his statement was going to be pored over and misinterpreted by amateurs who totally missed the central points he made.  Perhaps it would have been in order for him to have attempted to clarify the situation when he saw the propaganda usage being made of his dogs. 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 11:08:44 AM
He didn't know his statement was going to be pored over and misinterpreted by amateurs who totally missed the central points he made.  Perhaps it would have been in order for him to have attempted to clarify the situation when he saw the propaganda usage being made of his dogs.


It was you who posted that Eddie had a history of false alerts, a grossly untrue statement. It would seem that is you who is using Grime, his dogs and his work as propaganda not the members who doubt the McCanns.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:12:46 AM

It was you who posted that Eddie had a history of false alerts, a grossly untrue statement. It was seem that is you that is using Grime, his dogs and his work as propaganda not the members who doubt the McCanns.
You are obviously aware of the false claims made all over the net about the alerts by sceptics but you are in denial about them...that makes the whole of your post valueless...like the alerts themselves...pity Grime did not admit this
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 11:17:28 AM
You are obviously aware of the false claims made all over the net about the alerts by sceptics but you are in denial about them...that makes the whole of your post valueless...like the alerts themselves...pity Grime did not admit this

Perhaps you have forgot to remind posters that Redwood before his departure stated that Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

Likewise, BHH double slip of the tongue.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 11:19:23 AM
Perhaps you have forgot to remind posters that Redwood before his departure stated that Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

Likewise, BHH double slip of the tongue.

And let us not forget this from Redwood :

'
'Redwood said the assumption that Madeleine was abducted "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case.'
The Guardian 19th March 2014'

What can that mean ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 11:21:44 AM
And let us not forget this from Redwood :

'
'Redwood said the assumption that Madeleine was abducted "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case.'
The Guardian 19th March 2014'

What can that mean ?

Indeed.

Something the mccann supporters and the mccanns would not want to here.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:23:25 AM
Perhaps you have forgot to remind posters that Redwood before his departure stated that Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

Likewise, BHH double slip of the tongue.

redwood certainly said that...and he also said the parents are not suspects...don't forget that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 11:25:20 AM
redwood certainly said that...and he also said the parents are not suspects...don't forget that

I am well aware of what he said and the inherent contradictions therein.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:27:48 AM
I am well aware of what he said and the inherent contradictions therein.

what contradictions...there are non
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 19, 2015, 11:30:59 AM
Perhaps you have forgot to remind posters that Redwood before his departure stated that Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

Likewise, BHH double slip of the tongue.

DCI Redwood's comment was made in relation to the perpetrator who assaulted several UK children in their own bedrooms whilst their parents were in another room.    IMO anyone who thinks he was giving 'coded' messages to the public re the McCanns when he made that remark is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them.

Also - clinging onto a 'slip of the tongue' as evidence of anything at all denotes quite a remarkable degree of desperation IMO.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 11:38:51 AM
• This article was amended on 21 March 2014. The earlier version stated that Detective Chief Inspector Andy Redwood had said the assumption that Madeleine had been alive when she left the apartment "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case. To clarify: those quoted words actually came after Redwood had referred to the assumption that Madeleine had been abducted. However, Redwood did say during the same press conference that police were considering the possibility that Madeleine was not alive when taken from the apartment as well as the possibility that she was.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve


Another example of a sentence taken out of context from a lengthy press report on the investigation of numerous assaults on children in their bedrooms.  There is no evidence either way ... but the propaganda demands that Madeleine is dead.
Why that option is seized with particular relish by some remains a mystery to me ... particularly as anyone with a grain of common sense, in particular her parents and family, cannot dismiss the possibility.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 11:46:17 AM
DCI Redwood's comment was made in relation to the perpetrator who assaulted several UK children in their own bedrooms whilst their parents were in another room.    IMO anyone who thinks he was giving 'coded' messages to the public re the McCanns when he made that remark is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them.

Also - clinging onto a 'slip of the tongue' as evidence of anything at all denotes quite a remarkable degree of desperation IMO.

This is what Redwood said :

'"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann.'
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 19, 2015, 11:47:18 AM
• This article was amended on 21 March 2014. The earlier version stated that Detective Chief Inspector Andy Redwood had said the assumption that Madeleine had been alive when she left the apartment "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case. To clarify: those quoted words actually came after Redwood had referred to the assumption that Madeleine had been abducted. However, Redwood did say during the same press conference that police were considering the possibility that Madeleine was not alive when taken from the apartment as well as the possibility that she was.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve


Another example of a sentence taken out of context from a lengthy press report on the investigation of numerous assaults on children in their bedrooms.  There is no evidence either way ... but the propaganda demands that Madeleine is dead.
Why that option is seized with particular relish by some remains a mystery to me ... particularly as anyone with a grain of common sense, in particular her parents and family, cannot dismiss the possibility.

Taking a sentence or even a few words out of context in order to change its meaning to one detrimental to the McCanns is another form of propaganda which is popular with some sceptics IMO.





Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 19, 2015, 11:50:22 AM
This is what Redwood said :

'"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann.'

Anyone who thinks from that statement - that SY have got the McCanns in their sights is going to be very disappointed IMO.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 11:54:36 AM
• This article was amended on 21 March 2014. The earlier version stated that Detective Chief Inspector Andy Redwood had said the assumption that Madeleine had been alive when she left the apartment "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case. To clarify: those quoted words actually came after Redwood had referred to the assumption that Madeleine had been abducted. However, Redwood did say during the same press conference that police were considering the possibility that Madeleine was not alive when taken from the apartment as well as the possibility that she was.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve


Another example of a sentence taken out of context from a lengthy press report on the investigation of numerous assaults on children in their bedrooms.  There is no evidence either way ... but the propaganda demands that Madeleine is dead.
Why that option is seized with particular relish by some remains a mystery to me ... particularly as anyone with a grain of common sense, in particular her parents and family, cannot dismiss the possibility.

Basically what it means, is that SY does not have a clue as to what happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 12:01:48 PM
Anyone who thinks from that statement - that SY have got the McCanns in their sights is going to be very disappointed IMO.

Neither The Met nor the PJ have arrested or charged the Drs McCann.
Neither The Met nor the PJ have arrested or charged anyone else.
With the caveats on both "that we know of".
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 12:04:06 PM
Taking a sentence or even a few words out of context in order to change its meaning to one detrimental to the McCanns is another form of propaganda which is popular with some sceptics IMO.

But if Madeleine 'was not alive' when she left the apartment is it really being suggested that the dogs alerted to 'another' body because Madeleine's would certainly not have been dead long enough, if killed by an intruder, for cadaver scent to develop ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 12:10:00 PM
You only have to read what Grime says about Eddie,   he says he  was trained on pig cadaver,   he also says it was impossible for Eddie to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.

I said 'could have been the fertiliser'   as the PJ didn't test the soil for it then it cannot be proved,  that doesn't mean it wasn't used.

Eddie alerted in the garden,  why didn't they test the soil?   That is not wild supposition or propaganda.

It's just like someone saying the McCann's could have drugged the children.

Do you understand the difference between cadaver and blood?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 12:16:19 PM
DCI Redwood's comment was made in relation to the perpetrator who assaulted several UK children in their own bedrooms whilst their parents were in another room.    IMO anyone who thinks he was giving 'coded' messages to the public re the McCanns when he made that remark is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them.

Also - clinging onto a 'slip of the tongue' as evidence of anything at all denotes quite a remarkable degree of desperation IMO.


No link has been established with other cases.

Not one iota.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 19, 2015, 12:31:35 PM
Indeed, every strand of investigation has drawn a blank - as far as we know.

They don't even seem to have led to conviction for any other crime.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 12:39:57 PM
This is what Redwood said :

'"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann.'

if you wish to continually quote redwood then so shall I....parents are not suspects...he could not have been clearer
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 12:43:48 PM
But if Madeleine 'was not alive' when she left the apartment is it really being suggested that the dogs alerted to 'another' body because Madeleine's would certainly not have been dead long enough, if killed by an intruder, for cadaver scent to develop ?

there is no evidence that there was ever a body in 5a
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 12:45:39 PM
Basically what it means, is that SY does not have a clue as to what happened to Madeleine.

 %£&)**# 8@??)(
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 12:48:01 PM
if you wish to continually quote redwood then so shall I....parents are not suspects...he could not have been clearer

Old news Dave and not in line with what the Portuguese found.  Those unanswered 48 questions certainly raised a lot more!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 19, 2015, 12:51:30 PM
of course the McCanns are victims of propaganda. initially it was lies in leaks from the PJ...now it is  a small group of fanatics on the net. There are several sites where lies are promoted and anyone who dares to question their version is silenced. The main piece of propaganda is the dog alerts. Many posters on this and other sites simply do not understand them.  Grime was asked twice by the PJ if the alerts confirmed the presence of cadaver odour and each time he failed to answer the question. I don't believe there ever was a body in 5a...and there is no evidence to contradict me.

maddie is the victim of propaganda.....

the meaning all in my opinion of propaganda

IMO ...the abduction is propaganda....

the minuet kmcc entered the room she knew maddie had been abducted...why...
yet left the twins on there own again.......

when asked she couldn't divulge because of Portuguese secrecy...yet it didn't bother her when there was some thing she wanted to get across............

all the sightings that came to nothing ....and common sense tells you ....why would it be front page news ...forwarning the abductor they knew where he was ...putting maddie in grave danger ...if it were true

the abduction evidence is ...the mccs say so tannerman...similar like saying aliens came down and took her...haw haw haw

propaganda is a tool ..to hide some thing like IMO ...the truth....and its rife in politicians governments




is that the reason of Clarence Mitchell being the frontman,,,,,

could that be the reason of the dedicated supporters day in day out responding to posts that continually put bad light on the mccs...or anything that goes against the abduction





The English follow the principle that when one lies, one should lie big, and stick to it. They keep up their lies, even at the risk of looking ridiculous.
..............
If you tell the same lie enough times, people will believe it; and the bigger the lie, the better
.....................
Think of the press as a great keyboard on which the government can play.
..........................

...the rank and file are usually much more primitive than we imagine. Propaganda must therefore always be essentially simple and repetitious.


prime example ..of propaganda/ brainwashing

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Haw-Haw
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 12:53:16 PM
Old news Dave and not in line with what the Portuguese found.  Those unanswered 48 questions certainly raised a lot more!

not as old as the 48 questions you are referring to and if you read the Portuguese archiving report Redwoods view is perfectly in line with the Portuguese findings once amarals investigation had been discredited
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 12:54:37 PM
maddie is the victim of propaganda.....

the meaning all in my opinion of propaganda

IMO ...the abduction is propaganda....

the minuet kmcc entered the room she knew maddie had been abducted...why...
yet left the twins on there own again.......

when asked she couldn't divulge because of Portuguese secrecy...yet it didn't bother her when there was some thing she wanted to get across............

all the sightings that came to nothing ....and common sense tells you ....why would it be front page news ...forwarning the abductor they knew where he was ...putting maddie in grave danger ...if it were true

the abduction evidence is ...the mccs say so tannerman...similar like saying aliens came down and took her...haw haw haw

propaganda is a tool ..to hide some thing like IMO ...the truth....and its rife in politicians governments




is that the reason of Clarence Mitchell being the frontman,,,,,

could that be the reason of the dedicated supporters day in day out responding to posts that continually put bad light on the mccs...or anything that goes against the abduction





The English follow the principle that when one lies, one should lie big, and stick to it. They keep up their lies, even at the risk of looking ridiculous.
..............
If you tell the same lie enough times, people will believe it; and the bigger the lie, the better
.....................
Think of the press as a great keyboard on which the government can play.
..........................

...the rank and file are usually much more primitive than we imagine. Propaganda must therefore always be essentially simple and repetitious.


prime example ..of propaganda/ brainwashing

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Haw-Haw
kate knew Maddie had been taken because the window was open...simple
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:11:47 PM
not as old as the 48 questions you are referring to and if you read the Portuguese archiving report Redwoods view is perfectly in line with the Portuguese findings once amarals investigation had been discredited

That's the funny bit in all of this, attempts to discredit Amaral's basic theory have failed miserably.  Kate McCann wrote her book in an attempt to justify her actions while Goncalo Amaral wrote another to justify his.  I call that a Mexican standoff.  Nobody knows the truth of what happened the night Maddie disappeared so all theories are still on the table.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:14:44 PM
That's the funny bit in all of this, attempts to discredit Amaral's basic theory have failed miserably.

all amarals evidence on which he based his thesis has shown to be false....as it says in the archiving report...amarals theory has been totally discredited as has he...the UK press refer to him as a disgraced cop...he doesn't sue because it's true
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:17:32 PM
That's the funny bit in all of this, attempts to discredit Amaral's basic theory have failed miserably.  Kate McCann wrote her book in an attempt to justify her actions while Goncalo Amaral wrote another to justify his.  I call that a Mexican standoff.  Nobody knows the truth of what happened the night Maddie disappeared so all theories are still on the table.

amaral's book is banned...Kate's is still on sale...I'd call that a victory for the McCanns
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:20:25 PM
all amarals evidence on which he based his thesis has shown to be false....as it says in the archiving report...amarals theory has been totally discredited as has he...the UK press refer to him as a disgraced cop...he doesn't sue because it's true

Maybe you should read the archiving report again since it stated no such thing.  Your attempt at propaganda is noted.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:22:10 PM
amaral's book is banned...Kate's is still on sale...I'd call that a victory for the McCanns

The Truth of the Lie can be read any time on the internet at any time, the McCanns have scored an own goal on that one.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:23:04 PM
Maybe you should read the archiving report again since it stated no such thing.  Your attempt at propaganda is noted.

the archiving report states that all the evidence used to make the mccanns arguidos turned out to be baseless...perhaps you should read the report again. Do not accuse me of propaganda when  am stating facts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 19, 2015, 01:23:50 PM
Old news Dave and not in line with what the Portuguese found.  Those unanswered 48 questions certainly raised a lot more!

Have you actually read the 48 questions?   If so can you explain how - by not answering question  No.16. What does 'we let her down' mean? ...... Kate jeopardised the PJ's investigation?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:24:43 PM
I'd call it temporary.

you can call it what you like but the book is banned
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:26:16 PM
you can call it what you like but the book is banned

Only hard copies and then only until the appeal court hands down its judgement.  I look forward to the time when Amaral returns the compliment.  Maybe its time you accepted that the vast majority of people believe the McCann's are hiding something.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 19, 2015, 01:29:19 PM
amaral's book is banned...Kate's is still on sale...I'd call that a victory for the McCanns


I see the McCanns only as losers, in every sense of the word.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:32:08 PM

I see the McCanns only as losers, in every sense of the word.

Their attacks on the Portuguese police, Amaral and Paiva included, have backfired spectacularly.  They have spent a small fortune using funds derived from Maddie's disappearance to launch an assault on anyone who criticises and accuses them but haven't received a penny from Portugal.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:32:24 PM
Only hard copies and then only until the appeal court hands down its judgement.  I look forward to the time when Amaral returns the compliment.
the book is banned...no one knows what the future holds....you can speculate but that's all it is..speculation...


as far as the archiving process...here is the quote..

To this can be added that, in reality, none of the indications that led to their constitution as arguidos was later confirmed or consolidated. If not, let us see: the information concerning a previous alert of the media before the polices was not confirmed, the traces that were marked by the dogs were not ratified in laboratory, and the initial indications from the above transcribed email, better clarified at a later date, ended up being revealed as innocuous.


so no propaganda from me...just hard facts

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:34:25 PM
Their attacks on the Portuguese police, Amaral and Paiva included, have backfired spectacularly.

amaral's attack on he mccanns has backfired spectacularly...he is basically destitute
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:36:16 PM
the book is banned...no one knows what the future holds....you can speculate but that's all it is..speculation...


as far as the archiving process...here is the quote..

To this can be added that, in reality, none of the indications that led to their constitution as arguidos was later confirmed or consolidated. If not, let us see: the information concerning a previous alert of the media before the polices was not confirmed, the traces that were marked by the dogs were not ratified in laboratory, and the initial indications from the above transcribed email, better clarified at a later date, ended up being revealed as innocuous.


so no propaganda from me...just hard facts

That's not what you stated, Amaral's thesis has not been disproved.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 01:36:42 PM
the book is banned...no one knows what the future holds....you can speculate but that's all it is..speculation...


as far as the archiving process...here is the quote..

To this can be added that, in reality, none of the indications that led to their constitution as arguidos was later confirmed or consolidated. If not, let us see: the information concerning a previous alert of the media before the polices was not confirmed, the traces that were marked by the dogs were not ratified in laboratory, and the initial indications from the above transcribed email, better clarified at a later date, ended up being revealed as innocuous.


so no propaganda from me...just hard facts

So the evidence wasn't false as you stated just was not strong enough, so yes you are spouting propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:37:43 PM
That's not what you stated, Amaral's thesis has not been disproved.

I never stated it had been disproved...you need to read the post again and you will se I am right
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:37:56 PM
amaral's attack on he mccanns has backfired spectacularly...he is basically destitute

 ...and Madeleine still missing.  Well done the McCanns 8@??)(
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:39:56 PM
I never stated it had been disproved...you need to read the post again and you will se I am right

I'll remind you..

all amarals evidence on which he based his thesis has shown to be false....as it says in the archiving report...

You are WRONG, it hasn't been shown to be false.  The truth being the Archive Report determined insufficient evidence exists to come to a conclusion.  The parents were most certainly not cleared as some claim.

Remember, the AG stated the parents lost the opportunity to demonstrate their innocence.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 19, 2015, 01:41:59 PM
kate knew Maddie had been taken because the window was open...simple

don't call me simple  8**8:/:


kate knew Maddie had been taken because the window was open.


yet she still left the twins ...open apartment ...open window ....abductor on the loose ..think we know who the simple one is


there again they are doctors highly intelligent .....so the simple logic answer to that is there was no abductor she knew thay was safe ....same as putting then in the creche the next day ....not as simple as you think
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:42:35 PM
I'll remind you..

You are WRONG, it hasn't been shown to be false.

you used the word disproved...you are wrong
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:45:28 PM
So the evidence wasn't false as you stated just was not strong enough, so yes you are spouting propaganda.

the evidence as stated by amaral is false..read the archiving statement...do not accuse me of spouting propaganda when I am backing up my statements with cites...

your post is goading and is reported
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:46:45 PM
you used the word disproved...you are wrong

Back to splitting words and playing games again?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:47:41 PM
I'll remind you..

You are WRONG, it hasn't been shown to be false.  The truth being the Archive Report determined insufficient evidence exists to come to a conclusion.  The parents were most certainly not cleared as some claim.

Remember, the AG stated the parents lost the opportunity to demonstrate their innocence.

it would have been impossible to demonstrate innocence...it is a ridiculous concept
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:47:55 PM
the evidence as stated by amaral is false..read the archiving statement...do not accuse me of spouting propaganda when I am backing up my statements with cites...

your post is goading and is reported

You are posting rubbish davel, Amaral's thesis has never been found false.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 01:49:13 PM
it would have been impossible to demonstrate innocence...it is a ridiculous concept

..especially if guilty   £4%4%
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:49:30 PM
Back to splitting words and playing games again?

not at all...I'm being precise....and when you are looking at evidence that may point to a serious crime it is important to be precise
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:50:43 PM
You are posting rubbish davel, Amaral's thesis has never been found false.

Your post is goading and innaccurate...I have never posted his thesis has been found to be false.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:52:19 PM
..especially if guilty   £4%4%

you may note Barry George has been unable to demonstrate his innocence despite two trials...is he therefore guilty
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 01:53:06 PM
..especially if guilty   £4%4%

are you suggesting the mccanns are guilty...that is libellous and against forum rules
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 19, 2015, 01:56:40 PM
Your post is goading and innaccurate...I have never posted his thesis has been found to be false.

no you just call him a lie er   ....same thing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:40:02 PM
kate knew Maddie had been taken because the window was open...simple

...but we don't know for sure the window was open.

NO ONE had verified that the window was open before kate mccann returned to the apartment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 02:42:55 PM
...but we don't know for sure the window was open.

NO ONE had verified that the window was open before kate mccann returned to the apartment.

The question was...how did Kate know immediately an abduction had taken place...answer the open window..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:43:00 PM
you can call it what you like but the book is banned

Too late, it's already put there.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:44:52 PM
don't call me simple  8**8:/:


kate knew Maddie had been taken because the window was open.


yet she still left the twins ...open apartment ...open window ....abductor on the loose ..think we know who the simple one is


there again they are doctors highly intelligent .....so the simple logic answer to that is there was no abductor she knew thay was safe ....same as putting then in the creche the next day ....not as simple as you think

Nice one Xtina. 8((()*/ 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 02:46:50 PM
Nice one Xtina. 8((()*/ 8((()*/

that question was answered eight years ago
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:48:40 PM
you may note Barry George has been unable to demonstrate his innocence despite two trials...is he therefore guilty

What happened in the  appeal ?

NOT EVERY TRIAL IS THE SAME.

Likewise key witnesses ignored by the police gave descriptions of a man, in no way resembling George.

..and before you ask for a cite, this was done last time this matter came up.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:50:16 PM
The question was...how did Kate know immediately an abduction had taken place...answer the open window..

Her evidence has never been tested in court.

Her account is uncorroborated.

The only fingerprints identified are HERS.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 02:55:27 PM
Her evidence has never been tested in court.

Her account is uncorroborated.

The only fingerprints identified are HERS.

none of the so called evidence has been tested in court....yet you believe in much of it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 02:56:58 PM
none of the so called evidence has been tested in court....yet you believe in much of it

You mean like saying the window was open ? 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 19, 2015, 03:06:08 PM

This is getting dangerously close to Libel.  So be careful.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 03:15:59 PM
The question was...how did Kate know immediately an abduction had taken place...answer the open window..

A general factual statement regarding police investigations, You can't use the statements of anyone under suspicion of a crime to eliminate them from that suspicion.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 03:16:45 PM
You mean like saying the window was open ? 8**8:/:
Kate said the window was open
We have no reason to disbelieve her
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 03:17:43 PM
You can't use the statements of anyone under suspicion of a crime to eliminate them from that suspicion.

The McCanns are not under suspicion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 03:18:06 PM
Kate said the window was open
We have no reason to disbelieve her

...or believe her
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 03:21:23 PM
...or believe her

SY have said they are not suspects and therefore believe them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 03:29:05 PM
The question asked...how did kate know maddie had been abducted...answer the open window...
If you think Kate is lying...then the question would not be asked...because there is no abduction...is that simple logic so difficult to follow
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 04:00:04 PM
Kate said the window was open
We have no reason to disbelieve her

Speak for yourself.

NO independent verification.

NO forensic backup of abduction.

ONLY fingerprints identified were hers......
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 04:00:53 PM
SY have said they are not suspects and therefore believe them

As with Barry George then ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 04:34:19 PM
Speak for yourself.

NO independent verification.

NO forensic backup of abduction.

ONLY fingerprints identified were hers......

As far as I am concerned the McCanns are telling the truth
The window was open
Indicating a abduction
You believe what you want to
Doesn't matter
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 19, 2015, 04:54:30 PM
As far as I am concerned the McCanns are telling the truth
The window was open
Indicating a abduction
You believe what you want to
Doesn't matter


Gerry McCann doesn't know whether the window was open or not when his wife arrived. He might believe it to be so, but he doesn't know for sure.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 05:14:56 PM
If kate is telling the truth then abduction is odds on..
That's the decision SY and the PJ have to make...it looks like they have made it...hopefully we will eventually find out on what basis they made this decision.....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 05:18:16 PM
As far as I am concerned the McCanns are telling the truth
The window was open
Indicating a abduction
You believe what you want to
Doesn't matter

Actually your opinion is of no matter.

It is inherently blatantly obvious that there is no evidence of abduction and SY have found nothing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 05:21:09 PM
Actually your opinion is of no matter.

It is inherently blatantly obvious that there is no evidence of abduction and SY have found nothing.

we have already decided no ones opinion on here makes any diference...that doesn't mean we should not express it...again...it seems SY have found enough to rule out the parents
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 05:23:07 PM
we have already decided no ones opinion on here makes any diference...that doesn't mean we should not express it...again...it seems SY have found enough to rule out the parents

Appearances can be deceptive.

It would seem more apparent at the start, they had only one directive, look for an abductor, and if there was never one in the first place.........
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 05:24:54 PM
Appearances can be deceptive.

It would seem more apparent at the start, they had only one directive, look for an abductor, and if there was never one in the first place.........

more likely they concentrated on abduction having ruled out the parents..it was all that was left and therefore proven by default
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 05:28:10 PM
If kate is telling the truth then abduction is odds on..
That's the decision SY and the PJ have to make...it looks like they have made it...hopefully we will eventually find out on what basis they made this decision.....

If Kate was telling the whole truths then it is stating the bl***ing obvious.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 05:29:41 PM
more likely they concentrated on abduction having ruled out the parents..it was all that was left and therefore proven by default

Nope.

It was supposed to be a thorough investigation.

It has turned out to be a waste of time and resorces .
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 19, 2015, 05:31:38 PM
Nope.

It was supposed to be a thorough investigation.

It has turned out to be a waste of time and resorces .

It could still be thorough.  Can cannot find what is not there to be found, however hard one tries.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 07:57:26 PM
SY have said they are not suspects and therefore believe them

Not any more they haven't.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 07:59:35 PM
As far as I am concerned the McCanns are telling the truth
The window was open
Indicating a abduction
You believe what you want to
Doesn't matter

Opinion based on nothing more than sentiment are worthless, let's have some real evidence for a change.

Kate's claim about the open window for instance is not borne out by any evidence.  Matt said the window wasn't open and Jane never saw it open when she walked into the car park. Add to that the fact that only Kate's fingerprint was found on the window and hey presto things just don't appear as was claimed.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 08:04:49 PM
Opinion based on nothing more than sentiment are worthless, let's have some real evidence for a change.

Redwood said the McCanns were not suspects...that's evidence...do you have ay evidence that new facts have come to light to change that...the answer is no...you are just speculating. How about you supply some evidence to show that situation has changed
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 19, 2015, 08:08:59 PM
Redwood said the McCanns were not suspects...that's evidence...do you have ay evidence that new facts have come to light to change that...the answer is no...you are just speculating. How about you supply some evidence to show that situation has changed

Redwood is yesterdays man and proved nothing in the case one way or another.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 08:10:13 PM
Redwood is yesterdays man and proved nothing in the case one way or another.

Redwood was speaking for SY...do you have any evidence the situation has changed or are you just speculating based on nothing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 08:10:28 PM
A general factual statement regarding police investigations, You can't use the statements of anyone under suspicion of a crime to eliminate them from that suspicion.

Dr Kate McCann is under no suspicion of a crime.

How appropriate was it that she figured so prominently in the thesis of an investigator who was at the time himself under suspicion of a crime, was an arguido and who was subsequently found guilty of a criminal offence for which he received a suspended prison sentence.

The propaganda machine which was able to turn that on its head is rather awesome don't you think.  But it does not alter the facts only ignores them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 19, 2015, 08:21:34 PM
Redwood was speaking for SY...do you have any evidence the situation has changed or are you just speculating based on nothing

I don't suppose the police often broadcast what they really think in an investigation. If they named their suspects the suspects would be long gone when they went to get them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 08:24:50 PM
I don't suppose the police often broadcast what they really think in an investigation. If they named their suspects the suspects would be long gone when they went to get them.

you don't suppose...so just speculation...where do you think the mccanns would run to?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 19, 2015, 08:52:53 PM
you don't suppose...so just speculation...where do you think the mccanns would run to?


The nearest lawyer probably   @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 08:58:32 PM

The nearest lawyer probably   @)(++(*

And you don't need a lawyer if you're innocent do you
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 09:14:10 PM
Dr Kate McCann is under no suspicion of a crime.

Cut out irrelevant off topic propaganda.

The propaganda machine which was able to turn that on its head is rather awesome don't you think.  But it does not alter the facts only ignores them.

She was.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 09:15:53 PM
She was.

Good to see you accept that Kate is no longer under suspicion of any crime
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 09:31:15 PM
Dr Kate McCann is under no suspicion of a crime.

How appropriate was it that she figured so prominently in the thesis of an investigator who was at the time himself under suspicion of a crime, was an arguido and who was subsequently found guilty of a criminal offence for which he received a suspended prison sentence.

The propaganda machine which was able to turn that on its head is rather awesome don't you think.  But it does not alter the facts only ignores them.

Yet you use propaganda all the time. %&5%£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 09:38:58 PM
She was.

LOL ... why on earth do people keep on making my point for me as you have perfectly just done in your post.

I said ... that the propaganda machine which sidetracks the arguido status, the charges laid which were later proven in a criminal court against the co-ordinator of Madeleine McCann's case is awesome in the way it ignores facts.

You have censored it and cut it out in your reply to my post as " irrelevant off topic propaganda " Which it actually is not ... every word being true.

Are all sorts of supposition and scurrilous innuendo OK in your book as long as it is directed at the McCann family.

But a line is drawn under the unpalatable truth about Mr Amaral's criminal conviction.  You prove my point.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 09:40:44 PM
Yet you use propaganda all the time. %&5%£

Cite ... or withdraw your post.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 09:50:59 PM
LOL ... why on earth do people keep on making my point for me as you have perfectly just done in your post.

I said ... that the propaganda machine which sidetracks the arguido status, the charges laid which were later proven in a criminal court against the co-ordinator of Madeleine McCann's case is awesome in the way it ignores facts.

You have censored it and cut it out in your reply to my post as " irrelevant off topic propaganda " Which it actually is not ... every word being true.

Are all sorts of supposition and scurrilous innuendo OK in your book as long as it is directed at the McCann family.

But a line is drawn under the unpalatable truth about Mr Amaral's criminal conviction.  You prove my point.

As it was totally irrelevant to the discussion at that point, it was a deflection and I don't have to waste any more space to your propaganda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:03:30 PM
why are sceptics suddenly accusing others of spouting propaganda...is this a new sceptic campaign
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:05:28 PM
why are sceptics suddenly accusing others of spouting propaganda...is this a new sceptic campaign

Now that's a classic faux pas. 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 10:27:56 PM
If you do not already know about Mr Amaral's conviction for perjury ... please find the cite you require.


**Snip
One of the two officers who was convicted, Chief Inspector Gonçalo Amaral, led the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, the British girl who went missing in May 2007 from the nearby resort of Praia da Luz. Amaral was not present during the alleged assault, but was accused of having covered up for other officers; he was convicted of perjury in May 2009 for having falsified documents in the case and received an 18-month suspended sentence.[7]       https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 19, 2015, 10:39:37 PM
If you do not already know about Mr Amaral's conviction for perjury ... please find the cite you require.


**Snip
One of the two officers who was convicted, Chief Inspector Gonçalo Amaral, led the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, the British girl who went missing in May 2007 from the nearby resort of Praia da Luz. Amaral was not present during the alleged assault, but was accused of having covered up for other officers; he was convicted of perjury in May 2009 for having falsified documents in the case and received an 18-month suspended sentence.[7]       https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano

He was found guilty of making a statement based on the reports of his subordinates when he couldn't know what they said was true. He was also acquitted of not reporting the alleged torture as it wasn't proved he was aware of it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:40:56 PM
He was found guilty of making a statement based on the reports of his subordinates when he couldn't know what they said was true. He was also acquitted of not reporting the alleged torture as it wasn't proved he was aware of it.

where is your cite for this
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 19, 2015, 10:47:29 PM
He was found guilty of making a statement based on the reports of his subordinates when he couldn't know what they said was true. He was also acquitted of not reporting the alleged torture as it wasn't proved he was aware of it.
So he's not a criminal then?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:50:19 PM
He was found guilty of making a statement based on the reports of his subordinates when he couldn't know what they said was true. He was also acquitted of not reporting the alleged torture as it wasn't proved he was aware of it.

its called perverting the course of justice which is a serious offence hence the suspended sentence...what you are quoting is some amaral apologist....propaganda.....not the court judgement....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 10:58:24 PM
its called perverting the course of justice which is a serious offence hence the suspended sentence...what you are quoting is some amaral apologist....propaganda.....not the court judgement....

Were it considered that serious by the court he would have been banged up. Presumably the sentence was suspended because he was of previous good character with a good police record?
What other reasons would you suggest fro the suspension of sentence?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:11:29 PM
Were it considered that serious by the court he would have been banged up. Presumably the sentence was suspended because he was of previous good character with a good police record?
What other reasons would you suggest fro the suspension of sentence?

so now you are speculating...seeing as Almeida was found guilty of torture and not banged up...and kept his job... I would suggest portugals justice system still has fascist tendencies and is soft on its police force. It seems that even if amaral had been found guilty of personally kicking Cipriano from one side of the city to another...he would not have been banged up..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 11:31:51 PM
so now you are speculating...seeing as Almeida was found guilty of torture and not banged up...and kept his job... I would suggest portugals justice system still has fascist tendencies and is soft on its police force. It seems that even if amaral had been found guilty of personally kicking Cipriano from one side of the city to another...he would not have been banged up..

Your post does not address the matter I raised. It merely exposes your prejudices.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:45:59 PM
Your post does not address the matter I raised. It merely exposes your prejudices.

It addresses your post but not in the manner you would like and exposes your prejudices
How can a police officer found guilty of tortire keep his job
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 11:49:58 PM
It addresses your post but not in the manner you would like and exposes your prejudices
How can a police officer found guilty of tortire keep his job

You introduced that in a discussion about Sr Amaral who was not found guilty of torture.
Now to repeat my question. Why do you think Sr Amaral was only given a suspended sentence?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 11:54:05 PM
You introduced that in a discussion about Sr Amaral who was not found guilty of torture.
Now to repeat my question. Why do you think Sr Amaral was only given a suspended sentence?
g

I've answered the question
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 19, 2015, 11:59:23 PM
You introduced that in a discussion about Sr Amaral who was not found guilty of torture.
Now to repeat my question. Why do you think Sr Amaral was only given a suspended sentence?
Davel wrote above: "I would suggest portugals justice system still has fascist tendencies and is soft on its police force".  That is the answer to your question.  The fact that you don't like the answer is your problem, but he has answered it, so why the need to keep on badgering?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 20, 2015, 12:08:25 AM
He was found guilty of making a statement based on the reports of his subordinates when he couldn't know what they said was true.


If his subordinates lied to him  - and so were responsible for him now having a criminal record  - then why hasn't he sued them?  He must know who they are.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 12:11:37 AM
If his subordinates lied to him  - and so were responsible for him now having a criminal record  - then why hasn't he sued them?  He must know who they are.

If his subordinates lied to him
It would be them who would be charged
Not amaral
Total propaganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 20, 2015, 12:35:12 AM
If his subordinates lied to him  - and so were responsible for him now having a criminal record  - then why hasn't he sued them?  He must know who they are.

I have read someone ridiculous nonsense on this forum Benice but that just about rakes the biscuit.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 12:46:07 AM
I have read someone ridiculous nonsense on this forum Benice but that just about rakes the biscuit.

Ridiculous post... Rakes the biscuit...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 20, 2015, 12:47:30 AM
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?

Don't worry  Lace, I will put as much thought as I can into the possibility that a cadaver dog smelt mushrooms in the last place a missing child was seen...and nowhere else....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 12:50:20 AM
Don't worry  Lace, I will put as much thought as I can into the possibility that a cadaver dog smelt mushrooms in the last place a missing child was seen...and nowhere else....

I will take note of what the expert.... Grime ... Says about the alerts
Basically meaningless without forensic corroboration
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 20, 2015, 12:54:22 AM
I have read someone ridiculous nonsense on this forum Benice but that just about rakes the biscuit.

Why?   If (according to Starti)  he ended up with a criminal conviction because his subordinates submitted false reports to him - and he could prove it - then why wouldn't he want to take action against them?    It wasn't just a slap on the wrist his men caused - it was an actual prison sentence (suspended) and a criminal record.

I wonder what his subordinates thought - when they found out he was offloading the blame for his perjury onto them.



   

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 20, 2015, 12:56:44 AM
Why?   If (according to Starti)  he ended up with a criminal conviction because his subordinates submitted false reports to him - and he could prove it - then why wouldn't he want to take action against them?    It wasn't just a slap on the wrist his men caused - it was an actual prison sentence (suspended) and a criminal record.

I wonder what his subordinates thought - when they found out he was offloading the blame for his perjury onto them.



   

You seriously cannot be so naive.....its ok if you are, life is a large rich tapestry LOL!!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:00:51 AM
You seriously cannot be so naive.....its ok if you are, life is a large rich talestry LOL!!

There can be no doubt amaral was convicted of a criminal offence for which he was responsible
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 20, 2015, 01:04:21 AM
Why?   If (according to Starti)  he ended up with a criminal conviction because his subordinates submitted false reports to him - and he could prove it - then why wouldn't he want to take action against them?    It wasn't just a slap on the wrist his men caused - it was an actual prison sentence (suspended) and a criminal record.

I wonder what his subordinates thought - when they found out he was offloading the blame for his perjury onto them.



   

But his subordinates were found not guilty, so in the eyes of the law they didn't submit false reports being not guilty and all. So what would Amaral sue them for ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:09:54 AM
But his subordinates were found not guilty, so in the eyes of the law they didn't submit false reports being not guilty and all. So what would Amaral sue them for ?

That's right it was amaral who told the lies and who was found guilty
You are mixed up with his criminal associates
They were not charged with perjury
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 20, 2015, 01:24:43 AM
But his subordinates were found not guilty, so in the eyes of the law they didn't submit false reports being not guilty and all. So what would Amaral sue them for ?

 @)(++(*

excellent point made here.

Lets not forget it has never been disproved that that child murderer was not beaten up by her inmates...in fact there is more evidence that this is what happened....than the "evidence" that the police did it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:28:33 AM
@)(++(*

excellent point made here.

his subordinates were not charged with making false reports...thats why they were not found guilty of the charge...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:30:31 AM
@)(++(*

excellent point made here.

Lets not forget it has never been disproved that that child murderer was not beaten up by her inmates...in fact there is more evidence that this is what happened....than the "evidence" that the police did it

the court accepted she was beaten in custody of the police...the police claimed she fell down the stairs...these are the facts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:32:12 AM
@)(++(*

excellent point made here.

Lets not forget it has never been disproved that that child murderer was not beaten up by her inmates...in fact there is more evidence that this is what happened....than the "evidence" that the police did it

do not try to claim she was not beaten by the police...it has been proved in court
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 01:36:24 AM
what is astonishing that police officers who were arguidos in the Cipriano torture case were not suspended and allowed to investigate maddie's disappearance
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 20, 2015, 01:51:56 AM
what is astonishing that police officers who were arguidos in the Cipriano torture case were not suspended and allowed to investigate maddie's disappearance

This is something that I will never understand.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 20, 2015, 09:11:37 AM
You seriously cannot be so naive.....its ok if you are, life is a large rich tapestry LOL!!


Actually it was Starti who claimed he was given false reports by his subordinates which he couldn't be expected to know were a pack of lies.    I was running with that scenario.    IMO Amaral knew exactly what was happening to Leonor Cipriano over a period of 2 days.   As Lead Investigator and chief co-ordinator then IMO he would be the one who arranged for her to be brought the the police station in the first place.

A Court found that LC had been tortured at his police station by officers of the PJ.   LC's 'crime' was that she could not identify the men who tortured her - probably because she had a bag over her head and blood in her eyes. 

Amaral falsified documents to cover up the torture.  It all went pear-shaped for him when the Governor of the prison refused to lie and say LC had been beaten up in prison.  Good for her.

Amaral was found guilty of perjury and his appeal against his conviction was thrown out.  Anyone who can even attempt to claim he was some kind of  'innocent victim' in the face of that fact-  is seriously in denial IMO.

The fact that LC is still in prison and the police officers who tortured her have not been identified and punished is a disgrace IMO.   Although apparently there has never been a single 'miscarriage of justice' case in Portugal as the police have never once made a mistake.   And if you believe that you will believe anything.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 20, 2015, 09:14:36 AM

Actually it was Starti who claimed he was given false reports by his subordinates which he couldn't be expected to know were a pack of lies.    I was running with that scenario.    IMO Amaral knew exactly what was happening to Leonor Cipriano over a period of 2 days.   As Lead Investigator and chief co-ordinator then IMO he would be the one who arranged for her to be brought the the police station in the first place.

A Court found that LC had been tortured at his police station by officers of the PJ.   LC's 'crime' was that she could not identify the men who tortured her - probably because she had a bag over her head and blood in her eyes. 

Amaral falsified documents to cover up the torture.  It all went pear-shaped for him when the Governor of the prison refused to lie and say LC had been beaten up in prison.  Good for her.

Amaral was found guilty of perjury and his appeal against his conviction was thrown out.  Anyone who can even attempt to claim he was some kind of  'innocent victim' in the face of that fact-  is seriously in denial IMO.

The fact that LC is still in prison and the police officers who tortured her have not been identified and punished is a disgrace IMO.   Although apparently there has never been a single 'miscarriage of justice' case in Portugal as the police have never once made a mistake.   And if you believe that you will believe anything.

You are probably committing libel there' I suggest you stop.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Eleanor on December 20, 2015, 09:24:30 AM

Actually it was Starti who claimed he was given false reports by his subordinates which he couldn't be expected to know were a pack of lies.    I was running with that scenario.    IMO Amaral knew exactly what was happening to Leonor Cipriano over a period of 2 days.   As Lead Investigator and chief co-ordinator then IMO he would be the one who arranged for her to be brought the the police station in the first place.

A Court found that LC had been tortured at his police station by officers of the PJ.   LC's 'crime' was that she could not identify the men who tortured her - probably because she had a bag over her head and blood in her eyes. 

Amaral falsified documents to cover up the torture.  It all went pear-shaped for him when the Governor of the prison refused to lie and say LC had been beaten up in prison.  Good for her.

Amaral was found guilty of perjury and his appeal against his conviction was thrown out.  Anyone who can even attempt to claim he was some kind of  'innocent victim' in the face of that fact-  is seriously in denial IMO.

The fact that LC is still in prison and the police officers who tortured her have not been identified and punished is a disgrace IMO.   Although apparently there has never been a single 'miscarriage of justice' case in Portugal as the police have never once made a mistake.   And if you believe that you will believe anything.

I am entirely with you on this Benice.  But please could we take it to the right Thread?

A lot appears to have been said over the last few days by Admin, which most posters appear to be ignoring.

I have never been a hard  and fast Moderator because I genuinely don't want to be.  But some sort of order has to be made.  Although this is not a criticism of you in particular.

So, to all of you, please could you make an effort.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 09:24:59 AM
You are probably committing libel there' I suggest you stop.

It isn't libel because it is all true...are you now suggesting posters are not allowed to post the truth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 20, 2015, 09:26:25 AM
Ah, what is truth?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 20, 2015, 09:27:30 AM
It isn't libel because it is all true...are you now suggesting posters are not allowed to post the truth

It's libel because Benice stated things for which she had no proof.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 09:28:59 AM
It's libel because Benice stated things for which she had no proof.

she does not need proof if the facts are in the public domain...and talking of proof you have not provided a cite to back up your claim
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 20, 2015, 10:30:43 AM
Davel wrote above: "I would suggest portugals justice system still has fascist tendencies and is soft on its police force".  That is the answer to your question.  The fact that you don't like the answer is your problem, but he has answered it, so why the need to keep on badgering?

I do not "like" or "dislike" answers, I am indifferent to them. They are what they are.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 10:31:56 AM
I do not "like" or "dislike" answers, I am indifferent to them. They are what they are.

then you were given an answer ...why do you then accuse me of not giving an answer...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 20, 2015, 10:36:57 AM
I do not "like" or "dislike" answers, I am indifferent to them. They are what they are.
You ignore them you mean, to pursue your own mischief-making agenda.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 20, 2015, 11:21:08 AM
And you don't need a lawyer if you're innocent do you

??????................

don't need a lawyer if you're innocent

how many lawyers have the mccs got... not only lawyers [but top of the range lawyers at that ......costing thousands +thousands]
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 11:25:28 AM
??????................

don't need a lawyer if you're innocent

how many lawyers have the mccs got... not only lawyers [but top of the range lawyers at that ......costing thousands +thousands]

I was being ironic
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 20, 2015, 12:11:42 PM
So he's not a criminal then?

The use of this term has to be carefully considered.  Goncalo Amaral is a criminal by definition in that he broke the law in Portugal but he is not of criminal tendency and has not made a career out of criminal activity.  It should be borne in mind that many criminals have not been convicted before sprinkling the term around so generously.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 12:32:04 PM
I'm suggesting mods should not imply a forum member is lying. Have you ever seen Angelo or Starti do that ?

i have never seen them have reason to call anyone a liar
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 20, 2015, 01:39:55 PM
No, I don't have to justify anything.  Everyone knows by now of what Amaral did to his brother, long before The McCanns ever set foot in Portugal.
And everyone knows about his fiscal and mortgage debts, the likes of which neither you or I would have persistently  gotten away with.  Long before The McCanns ever set foot in Portugal.

Or are you suggesting that this just a minor aberration that only lasted for a minute or ten, rather than ten years?

Tell me Eleanor how many other people have financial problems ?

Saying he has made a career out of criminal activity doesn't cut the mustard.

Are you therefore implying he has made money from criminal activity ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 20, 2015, 02:22:20 PM
The use of this term has to be carefully considered.  Goncalo Amaral is a criminal by definition in that he broke the law in Portugal but he is not of criminal tendency and has not made a career out of criminal activity.  It should be borne in mind that many criminals have not been convicted before sprinkling the term around so generously.
I'm not going to pussyfoot around the subject because it may upset his fanclub.  Amaral is a criminal as you have just agreed so it is perfectly reasonable to refer to him as such, no caveats, or excuses.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: John on December 20, 2015, 02:26:04 PM
I'm not going to pussyfoot around the subject because it may upset his fanclub.  Amaral is a criminal as you have just agreed so it is perfectly reasonable to refer to him as such, no caveats, or excuses.

As long as it is in context and is not repeated in a manner which would indicate contempt for forum rules.

I have removed several posts which breach forum rules.  Members must NOT make spurious allegations of criminal activity by any individual without proof to back it up. TY
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 20, 2015, 02:57:23 PM
I'm not going to pussyfoot around the subject because it may upset his fanclub.  Amaral is a criminal as you have just agreed so it is perfectly reasonable to refer to him as such, no caveats, or excuses.

He was convicted of a criminal offence and served his time for it, albeit a suspended sentence.
The end.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 20, 2015, 03:15:06 PM
He was convicted of a criminal offence and served his time for it, albeit a suspended sentence.
The end.

That would probably be quite appropriate ... were the same consideration given to the Drs McCann, their family, their friends and any with the slightest association to them against whom the propaganda war has been relentless.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 20, 2015, 03:21:33 PM
That would probably be quite appropriate ... were the same consideration given to the Drs McCann, their family, their friends and any with the slightest association to them against whom the propaganda war has been relentless.

So it's purely tit for tat?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 20, 2015, 03:34:52 PM
He was convicted of a criminal offence and served his time for it, albeit a suspended sentence.
The end.
Yes, he's a convicted criminal.  The end.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 20, 2015, 03:39:43 PM
If only   @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 20, 2015, 04:07:53 PM
So it's purely tit for tat?

Not at all.

One = propaganda because it is untrue, manufactured to be pejorative and cast doubt on innocent individuals.

One = truth; because the facts have not been subject to manipulation.

Therefore one situation does not equate to the other as far as 'tit for tat' or disseminating propaganda goes.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 20, 2015, 06:26:23 PM
Honest opinion has several conditions applied to it...it is not a defence simply to believe something. As I undersatnd it must be based on facts....and that an honest person could reach the same conclusion based on those facts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 20, 2015, 10:07:18 PM
I know it is the season for silliness but be warned, any serious breaches of forum rules will attract an instant ban.   There will be no exceptions and no further warning.

Admin
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 22, 2015, 04:52:48 PM
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?




THE DOG WAS EDDIE ...........it secured a conviction



Car fire

Separately to this, Mr Mooney told the jury, the Fire Brigade had been called to a car fire at 12.57pm on December 11 to Hamilton’s home.

He said that the call had been made by the an aunt of the accused, who was not at 3 Concess Road at the time she made the call on behalf of her nephew, while Hamilton, who claimed to police investigating the fire that he had not left home all day, had access to his own telephone at home.

Mr Mooney said that when the Fire Brigade arrived to deal with the blaze they were alarmed to find it close to an oil tank. Hamilton’s car was a red Hyundai Lantra.

“There were a number of people present, and one person was the young man Trevor Hamilton. Hamilton will say he told the fire officers and later told the police the car had not moved all day from 3 Concess Road. That was untrue, because the police later uncovered evidence. In fact the car had been driven by Hamilton around and into Sion Mills and on some roads between Sion Mills and Strabane that day,” he said, adding: “The assertion made that day by Hamilton when asked, was a lie. He said he was not out of the house.”

In a subsequent police examination no source of combustion could be discovered, yet forensic science examination showed that the fire probably began in the front passenger compartment.

On February 20, 2004, police employed the use of the Victim Recovery Unit dogs from England, which were highly trained to detect and alert handlers to the presence of human remains. A video without sound was shown in the court showing a Springer Spaniel dog examining two cars and a small van before being taken to the Lantra that had been driven by Hamilton and subsequently burned out, allegedly maliciously.

The video clearly showed the spaniel examining the other vehicles without reacting, and as soon as it entered the Lantra it began barking and refused to get out. Its search of the vehicle focused on the front passenger and rear seats.

Further forensic examination was carried out in the rear and passenger compartments of the vehicle and blood was detected from material taken from the car for examination. A car mat from the rear of the car was also shown to contain blood, and because of that, the investigation focused on Hamilton, Mr Mooney said, which included a comprehensive search of the property at Concess Road and in particular the sites of fires in the garden.



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 04:56:14 PM



THE DOG WAS EDDIE ...........it secured a conviction



Car fire

Separately to this, Mr Mooney told the jury, the Fire Brigade had been called to a car fire at 12.57pm on December 11 to Hamilton’s home.

He said that the call had been made by the an aunt of the accused, who was not at 3 Concess Road at the time she made the call on behalf of her nephew, while Hamilton, who claimed to police investigating the fire that he had not left home all day, had access to his own telephone at home.

Mr Mooney said that when the Fire Brigade arrived to deal with the blaze they were alarmed to find it close to an oil tank. Hamilton’s car was a red Hyundai Lantra.

“There were a number of people present, and one person was the young man Trevor Hamilton. Hamilton will say he told the fire officers and later told the police the car had not moved all day from 3 Concess Road. That was untrue, because the police later uncovered evidence. In fact the car had been driven by Hamilton around and into Sion Mills and on some roads between Sion Mills and Strabane that day,” he said, adding: “The assertion made that day by Hamilton when asked, was a lie. He said he was not out of the house.”

In a subsequent police examination no source of combustion could be discovered, yet forensic science examination showed that the fire probably began in the front passenger compartment.

On February 20, 2004, police employed the use of the Victim Recovery Unit dogs from England, which were highly trained to detect and alert handlers to the presence of human remains. A video without sound was shown in the court showing a Springer Spaniel dog examining two cars and a small van before being taken to the Lantra that had been driven by Hamilton and subsequently burned out, allegedly maliciously.

The video clearly showed the spaniel examining the other vehicles without reacting, and as soon as it entered the Lantra it began barking and refused to get out. Its search of the vehicle focused on the front passenger and rear seats.

Further forensic examination was carried out in the rear and passenger compartments of the vehicle and blood was detected from material taken from the car for examination. A car mat from the rear of the car was also shown to contain blood, and because of that, the investigation focused on Hamilton, Mr Mooney said, which included a comprehensive search of the property at Concess Road and in particular the sites of fires in the garden.

so the dog found evidence   blood...excellent...taht's where they are invaluable...teh alerts themselves are meaningless
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 22, 2015, 05:11:42 PM
so the dog found evidence   blood...excellent...taht's where they are invaluable...teh alerts themselves are meaningless


teh..................teh alerts themselves are meaningless

good job customs don't think like that then
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 22, 2015, 05:16:56 PM
Customs,  do you mean drugs?   Well that is a bit different from cadaver,   they really don't know yet what the dog smells when they alert to cadaver,  it is a mix of scents of a dead body which is smelt after a while the exact time is unknown.    With drugs they are able to give the dog the exact scent.  Then still they are sometimes wrong.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 05:18:03 PM

teh..................teh alerts themselves are meaningless

good job customs don't think like that then

They do....I was stopped at Sydney airport by a dog alert....customs found nothing and I was allowed to go...the alerts themselves are meaningless
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 22, 2015, 05:18:42 PM
Eddie alerted to blood in that case.    Any dog would find a dead body.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 22, 2015, 05:40:42 PM
so the dog found evidence   blood...excellent...taht's where they are invaluable...teh alerts themselves are meaningless

What is so remarkable about Eddie alerting?  He was trained to alert to human blood which he did as proven by forensics.

What is the relevance of Eddie's part in Mrs Harron's case to the thread?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 22, 2015, 05:45:32 PM
Eddie alerted to blood in that case.    Any dog would find a dead body.


ye .........................if it was findable
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 22, 2015, 05:47:58 PM
Further searches identified a location where the EVRD alerted in the front bedroom of the offender's empty next door dwelling house.
When interviewed the suspect admitted that the body had laid in the room for 1 hour prior to disposal.
Forensic teams were unable to extract any forensic evidence despite being shown the exact position.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_PERSONAL.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 06:17:44 PM

ye .........................if it was findable

so if its not findable...no one can prove it exists
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 22, 2015, 06:25:43 PM
so if its not findable...no one can prove it exists



wellll......it could be very well hidden.............or got rid of all together
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 06:27:06 PM


wellll......it could be very well hidden.............or got rid of all together

it could be anything...which is useless as regards evidence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 06:30:56 PM


wellll......it could be very well hidden.............or got rid of all together

or never there in the first place
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 06:34:33 PM
There  is no evidence that unconfirmed alerts have any meaning... grime certainly doesn't claim they do
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 22, 2015, 06:35:28 PM
or never there in the first place


no but we don't know that do we .....

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 06:54:48 PM

no but we don't know that do we .....

no we don't...that's why as far as evidence is concerned it is taken it wasn't....for conspiracy theories ...cue David icke...it could have been
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 22, 2015, 08:21:53 PM
Eddie alerted to blood in that case.    Any dog would find a dead body.

Eddie alerted to cadaver scent  in the bedroom which was confirmed and also found the body 4 months after she went missing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 08:26:00 PM
Eddie alerted to cadavert scent  in the bedroom which was confirmed and also found the body 4 months after she went missing.

nothing confirmed in PDL and in essence just a coconut in jersey...There is no scientific evidence that the alerts have any value....fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 22, 2015, 08:36:35 PM
nothing confirmed in PDL and in essence just a coconut in jersey...There is no scientific evidence that the alerts have any value....fact

They are spending a lot to try and confirm them and building a tight case no doubt. It is no coincidence that the investigation is back to Smithman and everything has gone quiet.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 22, 2015, 08:41:36 PM
They are spending a lot to try and confirm them and building a tight case no doubt. It is no coincidence that the investigation is back to Smithman and everything has gone quiet.

i think there is every doubt
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 22, 2015, 11:57:18 PM
The misunderstanding of the significance of the dogs has leached into yet another thread. 

I think their value to those who chose to fill their time in making pejorative statements against the McCann family and who have woven the dogs into their lexicon of propaganda have chosen badly.

If the dogs is all they rely on to confirm their suspicion they have nothing.
Which has been confirmed time and time again.

If even half of the propaganda they promulgate had any basis in 2007 or now the objects of their opprobrium would be under lock and key.  The fact they are not must sometimes give them food for thought???     
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 12:03:09 AM
Perfect example of propaganda...spammng threads with the same post full of falsehoods oops

Ps you did well Brietta but you lost the battles and the war Im afraid

Truth and facts are simple, you neednt have over complicated, spun, misdirected, misrepresented and embroidered so much, your loss

Ps lets face the facts...what gerry mccann said about cadaver dogs being "incredibly unreliable" was a lie!

The fact a cadaver dog did alert does not seem to have worried him one bit vis a vis the indication that Madeleine could have been dead, at least if it did he made no mention,...but went in the total opposite direction of misrepresenting these kinds of dogs...and more or less sayng theyre useless.....the question. Why?? .that is a red flag imo, please explain why it cant be
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 23, 2015, 12:34:41 AM
Perfect example of propaganda...spammng threads with the same post full of falsehoods oops

Ps you did well Brietta but you lost the battles and the war Im afraid

Truth and facts are simple, you neednt have over complicated, spun, misdirected, misrepresented and embroidered so much, your loss

Propaganda coups spinning misinformation after 'the dogs' visit to Luz, such as "100% Madeleine's DNA" should really have been forgotten about with a shamefaced shuffling of feet as soon as the final FSS results became known and understood.
For some people that progression didn't happen.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 12:44:42 AM
Propaganda coups spinning misinformation after 'the dogs' visit to Luz, such as "100% Madeleine's DNA" should really have been forgotten about with a shamefaced shuffling of feet as soon as the final FSS results became known and understood.
For some people that progression didn't happen.

We all know it wasnt 100 per cent dna profle match, according to Lowes report, we are talking facts and actual events now and not tabloids.You might want to revisit my edited post and have a think about denials aversions and misrepresentations

As for the online wars, I blame two people and their appointed entourages for that, and no one else.....they started it, they could have stopped it, they are supposed to be intelligent people , indeed they are to some extent,they chose not to IMO....bad news IMHO
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 23, 2015, 01:00:08 AM
Perfect example of propaganda...spammng threads with the same post full of falsehoods oops

Ps you did well Brietta but you lost the battles and the war Im afraid

Truth and facts are simple, you neednt have over complicated, spun, misdirected, misrepresented and embroidered so much, your loss

Ps lets face the facts...what gerry mccann said about cadaver dogs being "incredibly unreliable" was a lie!

The fact a cadaver dog did alert does not seem to have worried him one bit vis a vis the indication that Madeleine could have been dead, at least if it did he made no mention,...but went in the total opposite direction of misrepresenting these kinds of dogs...and more or less sayng theyre useless.....the question. Why?? .that is a red flag imo, please explain why it cant be

It's all quite simple, Mercury.
Gerry knew that Madeleine was alive when he & Kate went out. He knew that he hadn't transported a cadaver in the Scenic. He learned about the minimum post-mortem time before cadavers start releasing cadaverine.
There simply wasn't the time for remnant scent to be left - therefore the interpretation of the death scent alerts were erroneous.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 01:23:53 AM
It's all quite simple, Mercury.
Gerry knew that Madeleine was alive when he & Kate went out. He knew that he hadn't transported a cadaver in the Scenic. He learned about the minimum post-mortem time before cadavers start releasing cadaverine.
There simply wasn't the time for remnant scent to be left - therefore the interpretation of the death scent alerts were erroneous.

Well
A) if he had done all that research he should have talked about it, seeing as he talks alot
B) whats the reason for declaring cadaver dogs so incredibly unreliable, a lie
C) of course your answer relies on your belief he told the whole truth, something you cant know
D) GMs movements from 9.15 to 10 pm are unknown, no witness testimonies..except for one waiter who said one of the men was gone for 30 minutes..who was that?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 23, 2015, 01:33:21 AM
Well
A) if he had done all that research he should have talked about it, seeing as he talks alot
B) whats the reason for declaring cadaver dogs so incredibly unreliable, a lie
C) of course your answer relies on your belief he told the whole truth, something you cant know
D) GMs movements from 9.15 to 10 pm are unknown, no witness testimonies..except for one waiter who said one of the men was gone for 30 minutes..who was that? By all their witness statements no man was gone for  30 mins

No mercury  it's not a lie.  Independent testing has proved that what the dog handler believes can affect their dogs responses and can result in  wrong alerts because of unconscious cueing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 01:39:05 AM
No mercury  it's not a lie.  Independent testing has proved that what the dog handler believes can affect their dogs responses and can result in  wrong alerts because of unconscious cueing.

Yes it is a lie to declare all cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable a total lie as operationally and in studies they have been proven to be the exact opposite of incredibky unreliable... Gerry lied, get over it Benice




Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 23, 2015, 01:40:39 AM
Well
A) if he had done all that research he should have talked about it, seeing as he talks alot
B) whats the reason for declaring cadaver dogs so incredibly unreliable, a lie
C) of course your answer relies on your belief he told the whole truth, something you cant know
D) GMs movements from 9.15 to 10 pm are unknown, no witness testimonies..except for one waiter who said one of the men was gone for 30 minutes..who was that?
a) Why did he need to talk about it? Why risk upsetting the very people who were supposed to be helping his family?
b) When you know something is a lie, you have to challenge it. This was literally a matter of life or death.
c) I don't need to know, it's what GM knew which mattered.
d) ROB was missing for quite a while, dealing with his sick daughter.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 23, 2015, 01:49:47 AM
Yes it is a lie to declare all cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable a total lie as operationally and in studies they have been proven to be the exact opposite of incredibky unreliable... Gerry lied, get over it Benice


No he didnt' lie.  It is a proven fact that dogs can wrongly alert as a result of unconcious cueing by their handlers.   AFAIK Martin Grime has never taken part in one of these tests - so no-one can say whether he unknowingly cued his dogs or not.   I'm sure the dog handlers who did take parrt in those test and failed, were very surprised because  they would have no idea they were unconsciously cueing  their dogs.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 01:56:54 AM

No he didnt' lie.  It is a proven fact that dogs can wrongly alert as a result of unconcious cueing by their handlers.   AFAIK Martin Grime has never taken part in one of these tests - so no-one can say whether he unknowingly cued his dogs or not.   I'm sure the dog handlers who did take parrt in those test and failed, were very surprised because  they would have no idea they were unconsciousy cueing  their dogs.

Youre still avoiding the issue Benice....a blanket statement by GM that cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable is a lie, unless you can cite the "incredibly" unreliable
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 02:00:00 AM
a) Why did he need to talk about it? Why risk upsetting the very people who were supposed to be helping his family?
b) When you know something is a lie, you have to challenge it. This was literally a matter of life or death.
c) I don't need to know, it's what GM knew which mattered.
d) ROB was missing for quite a while, dealing with his sick daughter.
exactly,  its what GM knew or didnt and what he did with it, thanks

Oh and it was not ROB who the waiter said was gone for  half an hour

You should try read the facts alone without presumptions of innocence or guilt and see where your thoughts lead, the media and other ridiculous forces have planted both possibilities, better to think  independently
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 23, 2015, 02:01:46 AM
exactly,  its what GM knew or didnt and what he did with it, thanks

Oh and it was not ROB who the waiter said was gone for  half an hour

One man was missing from the table for quite a while. Not two.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 23, 2015, 02:10:34 AM
One man was missing from the table for quite a while. Not two.
Rob was gone for 15 mins or so, the 30 mins missing man was not him, neither by time nor by description...have to go, will try find the ref tomorrow

Hang on, here it is

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm

SVETLANA
-------  STARIKOVA VITORINO (Russian citizen, with the telephone No "96635 ####) - kitchen assistant:
- Said that, yesterday, one individual, purportedly the father of the missing, left the dinner table where a group of friends (in number 8 or 9), for about 30 minutes. After having returned, a woman whom she believed to be his wife, also left the table, there having passed a few moments, all the guests left the table in question, except one elderly lady, who told her [Svetlana's] colleagues that that child had disappeared.



JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;

The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 23, 2015, 02:23:40 AM
Youre still avoiding the issue Benice....a blanket statement by GM that cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable is a lie, unless you can cite the "incredibly"
Ple  is a lie

How can it be a lie when independent testing has proved that quite a large percentage of dogs and their handlers failed to correctly alert under test conditions because of what the handler believed.   No matter how inconvenient  'unconscious cueing' may be - independent testing has proved it to be fact of life when it comes to  dog handlers.   Obviously it is not a crime because handlers are not aware they are doing it.      But it is stilll a FACT which cannot be dismissed simply because it doesn't fit in with what some people want to believe.


 

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 23, 2015, 07:11:51 AM
Rob was gone for 15 mins or so, the 30 mins missing man was not him, neither by time nor by description...have to go, will try find the ref tomorrow

Hang on, here it is

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm

SVETLANA
-------  STARIKOVA VITORINO (Russian citizen, with the telephone No "96635 ####) - kitchen assistant:
- Said that, yesterday, one individual, purportedly the father of the missing, left the dinner table where a group of friends (in number 8 or 9), for about 30 minutes. After having returned, a woman whom she believed to be his wife, also left the table, there having passed a few moments, all the guests left the table in question, except one elderly lady, who told her [Svetlana's] colleagues that that child had disappeared.



JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;

The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;

Strangely Gerry didn't seem to know that Russell had been with his sick daughter, despite the others referring to the joking about Jane going to 'relieve' him.

 After MATHEW arrived and before KATE left, he does not recall if anyone else was absent, although it was very probable that such had happened. He thinks that, on that night none of the adults nor children were ill. Asked, he relates that the daughter of RUSSELL and of FIONA would have been ill on Tuesday.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 23, 2015, 07:44:17 AM
Yes it is a lie to declare all cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable a total lie as operationally and in studies they have been proven to be the exact opposite of incredibky unreliable... Gerry lied, get over it Benice

the dogs have never been proven to be reliable...there is absolutely no proof re their abilities at all...that would make what you are saying  a lie
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 23, 2015, 08:26:03 AM
It's all quite simple, Mercury.
Gerry knew that Madeleine was alive when he & Kate went out. He knew that he hadn't transported a cadaver in the Scenic. He learned about the minimum post-mortem time before cadavers start releasing cadaverine.
There simply wasn't the time for remnant scent to be left - therefore the interpretation of the death scent alerts were erroneous.

You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 23, 2015, 08:31:22 AM
You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?
It's quite a coincidence that a dog alerted to a dead body in the search for a missing child, in exactly the same room where she was found alive, don't you think?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 23, 2015, 08:42:16 AM
It's quite a coincidence that a dog alerted to a dead body in the search for a missing child, in exactly the same room where she was found alive, don't you think?

Not when an explanation was found.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 23, 2015, 08:43:02 AM
You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?

5a  was the only apartment where the dogs were encouraged to alert...according to the PJ ..it's in the files...so no surprise at all... the only surprise is how sceptics take the alerts so seriously
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 08:51:34 AM
It is quite remarkable on a day to day, month by month basis, the story of abduction gets promulgated, yet nothing has actually been found to support this rather strange belief.

Certainly no forensic back-up , in fact , b....r all.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 23, 2015, 08:52:53 AM
It's quite a coincidence that a dog alerted to a dead body in the search for a missing child, in exactly the same room where she was found alive, don't you think?

Sorry you'll have to elaborate.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 09:08:03 AM
Eddie alerted to cadaver scent  in the bedroom which was confirmed and also found the body 4 months after she went missing.

Are you sure they said cadaver scent?    He said he left the body for an hour in the bedroom,   an hour is not long enough for cadaver scent to be alerted to.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 09:11:04 AM
It is quite remarkable on a day to day, month by month basis, the story of abduction gets promulgated, yet nothing has actually been found to support this rather strange belief.

Certainly no forensic back-up , in fact , b....r all.

They have DNA which as far as I know hasn't been matched to anyone.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 09:14:25 AM
They have DNA which as far as I know hasn't been matched to anyone.


.....and ?

It doesn't mean it belonged to anybody  of interest to this case.

I would suggest if samples of organic material were taken from your house it would reveal D.N.A. from unknown sources.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 23, 2015, 09:15:44 AM
Are you sure they said cadaver scent?    He said he left the body for an hour in the bedroom,   an hour is not long enough for cadaver scent to be alerted to.

Confirmed?  Really?

What forensic evidence was found then?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 23, 2015, 09:44:50 AM
Confirmed?  Really?

What forensic evidence was found then?

Certainly nothing that excludes Madeleine dying in the apartment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 10:32:35 AM

.....and ?

It doesn't mean it belonged to anybody  of interest to this case.

I would suggest if samples of organic material were taken from your house it would reveal D.N.A. from unknown sources.

On the other hand,  in my opinion it could be from an abductor.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 23, 2015, 10:33:20 AM
Not when an explanation was found.
If Shannon Matthews were still missing to this day you'd be convinced the dog was alerting to her dead body.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 10:37:45 AM
On the other hand,  in my opinion it could be from an abductor.

Is that the return of 'Mr. Swarthy Nasty Freckled Spotty Faced' Man from Never-Never land perhaps...... 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 10:50:33 AM
Is that the return of 'Mr. Swarthy Nasty Freckled Spotty Faced' Man from Never-Never land perhaps...... 8**8:/:

Are you saying that man isn't real Stephen?   Honest people said they saw him!!!  were they actors brought in to pretend they saw someone?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 23, 2015, 10:56:11 AM
If Shannon Matthews were still missing to this day you'd be convinced the dog was alerting to her dead body.

Ah that old chestnut. The mattress the dogs alerted to was the beathbed of some poor unfortunate. Do you know of any such person who had died in 5a ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 10:57:27 AM
Are you saying that man isn't real Stephen?   Honest people said they saw him!!!  were they actors brought in to pretend they saw someone?

There have been descriptions of men and women in PDL, which is of course quite un-amazing as people lived there, and of course visited or passed through.

Likewise, with previous occupants of the apartment, well could they have had visitors as well ?

As to any of them being an abductor, well you need a lot more than supposition.

Yoiu can walk down many streets anywhere in the world and see suspicious people,
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 23, 2015, 11:11:46 AM
Ah that old chestnut. The mattress the dogs alerted to was the beathbed of some poor unfortunate. Do you know of any such person who had died in 5a ?
Who knows?  Was any of the provenance of any of the fixtures and fittings in the apartment checked out?  But kind of beside the point.  You raised the question of coincidence and I have just provided one.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 23, 2015, 11:27:40 AM
Are you sure they said cadaver scent?    He said he left the body for an hour in the bedroom,   an hour is not long enough for cadaver scent to be alerted to.

If you put a dead body in a room for an hour and remove it then a cadaver dog would alert to the scent. That doesn't mean forensics will find anything being a scent the dog has alerted to. She was already deceased when stored in the room until he picked a place to hide the body. Mute Smithman's deep sleeping child fits with the dog alerts. Any detective should be able to see it. You won't see Smithman reveal himself, it's up to SY/PJ to do it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:33:46 AM
There have been descriptions of men and women in PDL, which is of course quite un-amazing as people lived there, and of course visited or passed through.

Likewise, with previous occupants of the apartment, well could they have had visitors as well ?

As to any of them being an abductor, well you need a lot more than supposition.

Yoiu can walk down many streets anywhere in the world and see suspicious people,

Strange how this man was seen staring at 5a on two occasions and has never been seen since don't you think?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 11:38:01 AM
Strange how this man was seen staring at 5a on two occasions and has never been seen since don't you think?

That is truly amazing Lace. Someone staring at a building.

Well, I've never seen that before. %£5&%
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:41:01 AM
That is truly amazing Lace. Someone staring at a building.

Well, I've never seen that before. %£5&%

Well thank god you're not a detective because they thought it was suspicious.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:43:02 AM
If you put a dead body in a room for an hour and remove it then a cadaver dog would alert to the scent. That doesn't mean forensics will find anything being a scent the dog has alerted to. She was already deceased when stored in the room until he picked a place to hide the body. Mute Smithman's deep sleeping child fits with the dog alerts. Any detective should be able to see it. You won't see Smithman reveal himself, it's up to SY/PJ to do it.

Do they actually say cadaver scent?   It could have been blood Eddie alerted to.

The sleeping child could have been just that,  a sleeping child.

I'm sorry PF but I can't help remembering Jersey,  Eddie give a false alert there.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 11:43:49 AM
Well thank god you're not a detective because they thought it was suspicious.

Just because they thought it was 'suspicious' does not mean it was an abductor.

and if I was in the police, I would first halls in the mccanns and group for questioning.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 11:44:56 AM
Well thank god you're not a detective because they thought it was suspicious.

and as we know Lace, they have found a big fat zero.

 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 23, 2015, 11:46:52 AM
Strange how this man was seen staring at 5a on two occasions and has never been seen since don't you think?

Do we know for certain that this individual has not been identified, by either the MPS or the PJ current investigation team, and ruled out?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:47:13 AM
Just because they thought it was 'suspicious' does not mean it was an abductor.

and if I was in the police, I would first halls in the mccanns and group for questioning.

They had been questioned their statements are in the police files.

Do you honestly believe that when SY went right back to the beginning they didn't interview Kate and Gerry and their friends?   How do you think they eliminated them from the investigation?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:47:58 AM
and as we know Lace, they have found a big fat zero.

 8)-)))

Why are you so happy about that?   Not hiding him are you   8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 11:49:45 AM
Do we know for certain that this individual has not been identified, by either the MPS or the PJ current investigation team, and ruled out?

There has been nothing said about this man with regards to him being identified as far as I know.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 23, 2015, 11:52:14 AM
There has been nothing said about this man with regards to him being identified as far as I know.

As both investigation teams have been remarkably silent for about 12 months we don't know for certain then.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 23, 2015, 11:58:22 AM
Just because they thought it was 'suspicious' does not mean it was an abductor.

and if I was in the police, I would first halls in the mccanns and group for questioning.

Just because they thought it was 'suspicious' does not mean it was suspicious.
Remember the happy days about 10 to 12 years ago when Tone wanted to introduce a law whereby someone could be arrested for "looking as though they were going to do something dodgy" ?. It was just as well that idea was given the bums rush  ?>)()<
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 23, 2015, 01:32:21 PM
Do they actually say cadaver scent?   It could have been blood Eddie alerted to.

The sleeping child could have been just that,  a sleeping child.

I'm sorry PF but I can't help remembering Jersey,  Eddie give a false alert there.

Where is the sleeping child then? I don't believe in fantasy talk, I follow facts and it all fits. Smithman can come forward and sue me right now. Come and take me on if you dare! If I sprayed perfume in a room and removed it I can't prove it's there but I know 100% it is. Collagen was in that item and I know abuse happened there.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/03/25/article-1000855-00B2617E00000578-246_470x286.jpg)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 23, 2015, 01:45:41 PM
Where is the sleeping child then? I don't believe in fantasy talk, I follow facts and it all fits. Smithman can come forward and sue me right now. Come and take me on if you dare! If I sprayed perfume in a room and removed it I can't prove it's there but I know 100% it is. Collagen was in that item and I know abuse happened there.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/03/25/article-1000855-00B2617E00000578-246_470x286.jpg)

there was no collagen in the coconut...its a myth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 23, 2015, 02:08:11 PM
Where is the sleeping child then? I don't believe in fantasy talk, I follow facts and it all fits. Smithman can come forward and sue me right now. Come and take me on if you dare! If I sprayed perfume in a room and removed it I can't prove it's there but I know 100% it is. Collagen was in that item and I know abuse happened there.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/03/25/article-1000855-00B2617E00000578-246_470x286.jpg)

Pathfinder - I hear what you say but I fear you may have been taken in by a fraud. 

The "fact that is bone was provided by a forensic anthropologist, Julie Roberts after an onsite analysis.  She was under some pressure to provide this prior to a press conference that afternoon.

The sample was then exhaustively analysed by the Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit, under Dr Tom Higham.  They found that it was a small piece of wood or coconut shell.

The only proponent of the theory that it was of human origin is Lenny Harper, who was the investigating officer.  He also announced that at the time of the discovery that quantities of clothing and other items had been found.  Later it emerged that this was a piece of cloth and a leather toggle. 

So you may be convinced by Lenny Harper's insistence, but that does seem to be contrary to the reports and forensic investigations.

I can understand why it is so important to some that the fragment is of human origin, because it is very important to the belief that the McCanns are guilty that Eddie is seen to be infallible - and a false alert like this would mean that ongoing hate campaign may be seriously flawed.   


http://www.standard.co.uk/news/human-bone-at-centre-of-jersey-childrens-home-inquiry-is-actually-a-piece-of-wood-or-coconut-shell-6658362.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 23, 2015, 02:13:43 PM
Well thank god you're not a detective because they thought it was suspicious.

well good job your not a detective ....remember the pig blood ...you see you are only giving opinions based on your intellect on things ...it doesn't mean it is true ...or the mccs are innocent of anything

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Quote from lace
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?
OFFICIAL INQUIRY FILES and DOCUMENTS
MARTIN GRIME PERSONAL PROFILE

This information belongs to the Ministério Público in Portimão, Portugal.
It was released to the public on 4 August 2008 in accordance with Portuguese Law


POINTS TO ASSIST

Whilst it is stated that the E.V.R D. is originally trained using pig the following notes

of guidance should be considered when assessing indications:

P In six years operational deployment in over 200 cases the dog has never

alerted to meat based foodstuffs.

> The dog has never alerted to 'road kill'

P Alerts given by the dog where no obvious human remains are found are

supported by forensic evidence I anecdotal witness accounts.> Pseudo scent is a chemically produced product that its manufacturers claim to

resemble 'dead body scent'. Although some trainers have had limited success

when tested on my dogs they showed no interest.

> Operational finds backed by forensic corroboration have shown that the

system adopted by me in the training of the dogs is both effective and

efficient. Acting in my role of advisor to the U.S. Justice Department I have
facilitated assessment of numerous cadaver search dog teams in the United
 
 States. These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced
pig based products into training assessments 100%! of the animals alerted to the medium.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 23, 2015, 02:15:27 PM
Pathfinder - I hear what you say but I fear you may have been taken in by a fraud. 

The "fact that is bone was provided by a forensic anthropologist, Julie Roberts after an onsite analysis.  She was under some pressure to provide this prior to a press conference that afternoon.

The sample was then exhaustively analysed by the Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit, under Dr Tom Higham.  They found that it was a small piece of wood or coconut shell.

The only proponent of the theory that it was of human origin is Lenny Harper, who was the investigating officer.  He also announced that at the time of the discovery that quantities of clothing and other items had been found.  Later it emerged that this was a piece of cloth and a leather toggle. 

So you may be convinced by Lenny Harper's insistence, but that does seem to be contrary to the reports and forensic investigations.

I can understand why it is so important to some that the fragment is of human origin, because it is very important to the belief that the McCanns are guilty that Eddie is seen to be infallible - and a false alert like this would mean that ongoing hate campaign may be seriously flawed.   


http://www.standard.co.uk/news/human-bone-at-centre-of-jersey-childrens-home-inquiry-is-actually-a-piece-of-wood-or-coconut-shell-6658362.html

Also confirmed by the Wiltshire Police Force enquiry into the Haut de la Garenne debacle, so not press hearsay or tittle-tattle ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 02:29:09 PM
well good job your not a detective ....remember the pig blood ...you see you are only giving opinions based on your intellect on things ...it doesn't mean it is true ...or the mccs are innocent of anything

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Quote from lace
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?
OFFICIAL INQUIRY FILES and DOCUMENTS
MARTIN GRIME PERSONAL PROFILE

This information belongs to the Ministério Público in Portimão, Portugal.
It was released to the public on 4 August 2008 in accordance with Portuguese Law


POINTS TO ASSIST

Whilst it is stated that the E.V.R D. is originally trained using pig the following notes

of guidance should be considered when assessing indications:

P In six years operational deployment in over 200 cases the dog has never

alerted to meat based foodstuffs.

> The dog has never alerted to 'road kill'

P Alerts given by the dog where no obvious human remains are found are

supported by forensic evidence I anecdotal witness accounts.

What about the pig blood?   Grime himself said Eddie could not be trained to tell the difference between pig and human.    Pig blood and bone could have been in the fertiliser are you saying it couldn't have?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 02:36:34 PM
Where is the sleeping child then? I don't believe in fantasy talk, I follow facts and it all fits. Smithman can come forward and sue me right now. Come and take me on if you dare! If I sprayed perfume in a room and removed it I can't prove it's there but I know 100% it is. Collagen was in that item and I know abuse happened there.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/03/25/article-1000855-00B2617E00000578-246_470x286.jpg)

I am sorry pathfinder but it was not a piece of skull,  read JP's post,  it has been put about there was collagen in the item but there wasn't.

You have however highlighted what I have been saying,  when you said you could spray perfume in a room and remove the bottle of perfume but the scent would still be there.   I believe Eddie alerted to a scent that had been removed,  most probably blood which could have been on any of the clothes that had been in that wardrobe,  three families stayed in 5a after the McCann's.

Or of course it could have been a scent left by someone walking in from the garden as I have said before but was laughed at.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 23, 2015, 02:40:20 PM
well good job your not a detective ....remember the pig blood ...you see you are only giving opinions based on your intellect on things ...it doesn't mean it is true ...or the mccs are innocent of anything

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Quote from lace
There you go again Mercury,   you post about pro's being abusive etc. and here you are saying we are stupid, you are such an hypocrite.

It won't embarrass me if you do post the list you have,   it is staggering that you won't even imagine the possibility that the dog reacted to one of them,   staggering as Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.    Staggering because forensic scientists [one of which you are not]   have said that cadaver dogs will react to other scents such as mushrooms,   decaying vegetation etc.  because you know better.

Post your list it is you who will embarrassed when each one is proved right with a cite to a scientist.

Grime covered himself extremely well when he said that every alert has to be backed up with evidence didn't he?
OFFICIAL INQUIRY FILES and DOCUMENTS
MARTIN GRIME PERSONAL PROFILE

This information belongs to the Ministério Público in Portimão, Portugal.
It was released to the public on 4 August 2008 in accordance with Portuguese Law


POINTS TO ASSIST

Whilst it is stated that the E.V.R D. is originally trained using pig the following notes

of guidance should be considered when assessing indications:

P In six years operational deployment in over 200 cases the dog has never

alerted to meat based foodstuffs.

> The dog has never alerted to 'road kill'

P Alerts given by the dog where no obvious human remains are found are

supported by forensic evidence I anecdotal witness accounts.> Pseudo scent is a chemically produced product that its manufacturers claim to

resemble 'dead body scent'. Although some trainers have had limited success

when tested on my dogs they showed no interest.

> Operational finds backed by forensic corroboration have shown that the

system adopted by me in the training of the dogs is both effective and

efficient. Acting in my role of advisor to the U.S. Justice Department I have
facilitated assessment of numerous cadaver search dog teams in the United
 
 States. These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced
pig based products into training assessments 100%! of the animals alerted to the medium.

You appear to have a problem with the right to the presumption of innocence.  It is a failing shared with Mr Amaral which he discovered is frowned upon by the Portuguese Judicial System and that of every democracy I can think of.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 23, 2015, 02:40:53 PM
What about the pig blood?   Grime himself said Eddie could not be trained to tell the difference between pig and human.    Pig blood and bone could have been in the fertiliser are you saying it couldn't have?


 Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.   


What we should understand with this dog is that he only barks when he finds something, he won't bark at any other times. He won't bark at other dogs, he won't bark at strangers, he won't bark when somebody knocks on the door or anything like that. The only times I've ever known him bark since I've got him as a small puppy a) for his dinner and that's just excitement and that's one of the training methods we use to teach to bark when we want him to and when he actually finds something, he won't bark at other dogs, he won't bark at strangers, he won't bark when somebody knocks on the door or something like that, so again I would say that's a positive indication.

The second dog that we've seen work today is the crime scene dog Keela. She will only indicate to me when she has found human blood, only human blood and it is only blood and there must be something there physically for her to be able to alert to me that's she has actually found something. At this point over here where the victim recovery dog has indicated, as you saw on the video, the crime scene dog had actually given me what we call a passive indication where she freezes in this spot here which would indicate to me that there is some human blood there. She will find blood that's historically very old and she will find anybody's blood, any human blood, which is important to make sure that everybody knows.

The fact that there is other scientific methods being used may stop you recovering any DNA but if you try we'll see what happens. But she is very, very good and when she indicates there is always blood there.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 23, 2015, 02:41:44 PM
What about the pig blood?   Grime himself said Eddie could not be trained to tell the difference between pig and human.    Pig blood and bone could have been in the fertiliser are you saying it couldn't have?

Yet again you seem to be struggling between blood/bone and cadaver.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 23, 2015, 02:44:31 PM
You appear to have a problem with the right to the presumption of innocence.  It is a failing shared with Mr Amaral which he discovered is frowned upon by the Portuguese Judicial System and that of every democracy I can think of.

oh right .....whatever babe

you have your opinion ...Ill have mine....OK
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 23, 2015, 02:44:39 PM
With abduction the deniers (of abduction!) have nothing ....

Wrong again.

I leave you to your fantasy of abduction.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 23, 2015, 02:47:29 PM
Pathfinder - I hear what you say but I fear you may have been taken in by a fraud. 

The "fact that is bone was provided by a forensic anthropologist, Julie Roberts after an onsite analysis.  She was under some pressure to provide this prior to a press conference that afternoon.

The sample was then exhaustively analysed by the Oxford Radiocarbon Accelerator Unit, under Dr Tom Higham.  They found that it was a small piece of wood or coconut shell.

The only proponent of the theory that it was of human origin is Lenny Harper, who was the investigating officer.  He also announced that at the time of the discovery that quantities of clothing and other items had been found.  Later it emerged that this was a piece of cloth and a leather toggle. 

So you may be convinced by Lenny Harper's insistence, but that does seem to be contrary to the reports and forensic investigations.

I can understand why it is so important to some that the fragment is of human origin, because it is very important to the belief that the McCanns are guilty that Eddie is seen to be infallible - and a false alert like this would mean that ongoing hate campaign may be seriously flawed.   


http://www.standard.co.uk/news/human-bone-at-centre-of-jersey-childrens-home-inquiry-is-actually-a-piece-of-wood-or-coconut-shell-6658362.html

Lenny Harper was in charge of the case.

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals). The evidence also strongly suggests that the item (JAR/6) that left Jersey for further examination was not the same item that returned as Mr. Harper has explained on many of occasion including in a comment he left on an earlier posting (below)

“There should be no problem whatsoever with accounting for the movements and whereabouts of this fragment, JAR/6, at any time. Each time it moves from or to the police store it should be carefully logged. We found the item on 23rd February. It remained with us, until from memory, the 6th March when it was taken to the Carbon Dating Lab in Oxford. We logged it out. We logged it back in again on 8th April when our Anthropologist again examined it and noticed that its appearance had changed considerably, and she was now not so sure of her verdict, although she could not reach a definite conclusion. The item should have been in the presence of the Oxford lab throughout the time it was there but it seems, that in breach of the rules of evidence they 'passed it around.' They seem to have got themselves into a real tangle, first of all stating it was too old for finding collagen, then finding it, then saying it was too degraded to date. Somewhere in all of this, a lab technician made the throwaway comment that it looked like a piece of coconut. (Funny how it was an unqualified technician and none of the experts who had examined it closely) This is the origin of the "ILM coconut" theory and of course encouraged by Warcup and Gradwell, along with their other public declarations such as the cellars not being cellars but only three feet voids. The item JAR/6 came back to us without a log of its movements from Oxford. As soon as it returned then we commenced again logging its movements and it should be no problem whatsoever to account for it from there on. Lenny Harper” END
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 02:53:59 PM

 Grime himself said that it is impossible for the dog to tell the difference between pig and human cadaver.   


What we should understand with this dog is that he only barks when he finds something, he won't bark at any other times. He won't bark at other dogs, he won't bark at strangers, he won't bark when somebody knocks on the door or anything like that. The only times I've ever known him bark since I've got him as a small puppy a) for his dinner and that's just excitement and that's one of the training methods we use to teach to bark when we want him to and when he actually finds something, he won't bark at other dogs, he won't bark at strangers, he won't bark when somebody knocks on the door or something like that, so again I would say that's a positive indication.

The second dog that we've seen work today is the crime scene dog Keela. She will only indicate to me when she has found human blood, only human blood and it is only blood and there must be something there physically for her to be able to alert to me that's she has actually found something. At this point over here where the victim recovery dog has indicated, as you saw on the video, the crime scene dog had actually given me what we call a passive indication where she freezes in this spot here which would indicate to me that there is some human blood there. She will find blood that's historically very old and she will find anybody's blood, any human blood, which is important to make sure that everybody knows.

The fact that there is other scientific methods being used may stop you recovering any DNA but if you try we'll see what happens. But she is very, very good and when she indicates there is always blood there.

That is Keela not Eddie.

Forensic scientist talking about cadaver dogs -   

Unfortunately, in such a situation the trier of fact may easily be misled as to both the accuracy and precision of the dog's actions: Accuracy in the sense that the dog (depending upon its level of training) may be reacting to something other than residual scent from decomposed human tissue; precision in that the dog may be reacting correctly to the scent of decomposed human tissue, but imprecise in the sense that the dog is not differentiating between whose decomposed human tissue is giving the scent. Further, there may be legitimate reasons for the scent being there: someone may have been injured and left bloody clothing there, someone may have left a used sanitary napkin, etc. Our research demonstrates that residual scent from decomposed human tissue persists in a closed building for many months at levels sufficient to cause a trained dog to alert.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 23, 2015, 02:58:15 PM
Who knows?  Was any of the provenance of any of the fixtures and fittings in the apartment checked out?  But kind of beside the point.  You raised the question of coincidence and I have just provided one.

Not beside the pointat all and I remember reading that there had been no deaths in the apartment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 03:00:17 PM
Lenny Harper was in charge of the case.

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals). The evidence also strongly suggests that the item (JAR/6) that left Jersey for further examination was not the same item that returned as Mr. Harper has explained on many of occasion including in a comment he left on an earlier posting (below)

“There should be no problem whatsoever with accounting for the movements and whereabouts of this fragment, JAR/6, at any time. Each time it moves from or to the police store it should be carefully logged. We found the item on 23rd February. It remained with us, until from memory, the 6th March when it was taken to the Carbon Dating Lab in Oxford. We logged it out. We logged it back in again on 8th April when our Anthropologist again examined it and noticed that its appearance had changed considerably, and she was now not so sure of her verdict, although she could not reach a definite conclusion. The item should have been in the presence of the Oxford lab throughout the time it was there but it seems, that in breach of the rules of evidence they 'passed it around.' They seem to have got themselves into a real tangle, first of all stating it was too old for finding collagen, then finding it, then saying it was too degraded to date. Somewhere in all of this, a lab technician made the throwaway comment that it looked like a piece of coconut. (Funny how it was an unqualified technician and none of the experts who had examined it closely) This is the origin of the "ILM coconut" theory and of course encouraged by Warcup and Gradwell, along with their other public declarations such as the cellars not being cellars but only three feet voids. The item JAR/6 came back to us without a log of its movements from Oxford. As soon as it returned then we commenced again logging its movements and it should be no problem whatsoever to account for it from there on. quote]Lenny Harper” END






 


 




 























 



Sniffer Dogs 'Can Hinder Police Work'


08:57, UK,  Thursday 24 March 2011
 




Eddie the sniffer dog
Sniffer dog Eddie was relieved of his police duties




Share on Twitter



Share on Facebook



Share on Google+






Share by email
 

By Gerard Tubb, Sky News correspondent

Police sniffer dogs used to find missing people and dead bodies "urgently" need better training and monitoring, according to an official report.


The Government's National Policing Improvement Agency (NPIA) said specialist victim recovery dogs are not trained to approved standards, with no way of gauging their competence.

The NPIA reviewed the use of the specialist sniffer dogs two years ago, but its report has only now surfaced following a request by Sky News.

"There is no consistency in what the dogs can do and how it is done," the report states.

"Furthermore, there is no national standard for accrediting dogs and handlers or record keeping of the success rate they achieve."

The report added the dogs, which are trained to detect the smell of dead bodies, have "the potential to cause complications in an inquiry".

"There is an urgent need to have national policy on their training, accreditation and deployment," it concluded.


The review uses a kidnap investigation to highlight how dogs have tied up valuable police time.

The animals detected human remains in old furniture that had been bought from houses where the owner had died.

The use of victim recovery, or cadaver dogs, has proved to be controversial in a number of high-profile cases in recent years.


A South Yorkshire Police spaniel called Eddie was said to have sniffed out the "scent of death" at the Haut de la Garenne children's home in Jersey and the apartment from which Madeleine McCann disappeared in Portugal.

But in both cases nothing more was found and South Yorkshire Police say Eddie is no longer working with them.


Victim recovery dogs from four different police forces were used during searches for kidnapped schoolgirl Shannon Matthews in Dewsbury in West Yorkshire in 2008.

The dogs found evidence of dead bodies, but officers later discovered the corpses were nothing to do with her disappearance.

"The properties searched contained a high level of second-hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died," according to the NPIA report.

"This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture."

The Association of Chief Police Officers told Sky News it was consulting individual police forces and hoped to have national training standards for the dogs later this year.





   


   


   


   


   

   



   






















 





© 2015 Sky UK
         



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 23, 2015, 03:03:00 PM
Not beside the pointat all and I remember reading that there had been no deaths in the apartment.
this was the point I was responding to:

You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?

The discussion was about coincidence.  The coincidence that in the hunt for a missing child a cadaver dog alerted in a room in which she had been but which turned out not to be her at all.  So, coincidences of this type can happen, for whatever reason.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 23, 2015, 03:04:28 PM
Lenny Harper was in charge of the case.

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals). The evidence also strongly suggests that the item (JAR/6) that left Jersey for further examination was not the same item that returned as Mr. Harper has explained on many of occasion including in a comment he left on an earlier posting (below)

“There should be no problem whatsoever with accounting for the movements and whereabouts of this fragment, JAR/6, at any time. Each time it moves from or to the police store it should be carefully logged. We found the item on 23rd February. It remained with us, until from memory, the 6th March when it was taken to the Carbon Dating Lab in Oxford. We logged it out. We logged it back in again on 8th April when our Anthropologist again examined it and noticed that its appearance had changed considerably, and she was now not so sure of her verdict, although she could not reach a definite conclusion. The item should have been in the presence of the Oxford lab throughout the time it was there but it seems, that in breach of the rules of evidence they 'passed it around.' They seem to have got themselves into a real tangle, first of all stating it was too old for finding collagen, then finding it, then saying it was too degraded to date. Somewhere in all of this, a lab technician made the throwaway comment that it looked like a piece of coconut. (Funny how it was an unqualified technician and none of the experts who had examined it closely) This is the origin of the "ILM coconut" theory and of course encouraged by Warcup and Gradwell, along with their other public declarations such as the cellars not being cellars but only three feet voids. The item JAR/6 came back to us without a log of its movements from Oxford. As soon as it returned then we commenced again logging its movements and it should be no problem whatsoever to account for it from there on. Lenny Harper” END

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals).

The only thing right about that sentence is that the word evidence is in inverted commas ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 23, 2015, 03:21:05 PM
this was the point I was responding to:

You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?

The discussion was about coincidence.  The coincidence that in the hunt for a missing child a cadaver dog alerted in a room in which she had been but which turned out not to be her at all.  So, coincidences of this type can happen, for whatever reason.
Given that both dogs alert to dead blood, and Keela supposedly only to human blood, then there is no need to hunt for a body within 5A, merely a source of human blood.

The Scenic key fob proves that.  And the alert by both dogs in the sand bucket test, thereby indicating human origin, and the forensics showing the material to be Gerry's, shows that both dogs react to dead blood from a live human being.

There is no proof of a dead body in the Madeleine McCann case, merely of a disappearance.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 23, 2015, 04:30:39 PM


 


 




 























 



Sniffer Dogs 'Can Hinder Police Work'


08:57, UK,  Thursday 24 March 2011
 




Eddie the sniffer dog
Sniffer dog Eddie was relieved of his police duties




Share on Twitter



Share on Facebook



Share on Google+






Share by email
 

By Gerard Tubb, Sky News correspondent

Police sniffer dogs used to find missing people and dead bodies "urgently" need better training and monitoring, according to an official report.


The Government's National Policing Improvement Agency (NPIA) said specialist victim recovery dogs are not trained to approved standards, with no way of gauging their competence.

The NPIA reviewed the use of the specialist sniffer dogs two years ago, but its report has only now surfaced following a request by Sky News.

"There is no consistency in what the dogs can do and how it is done," the report states.

"Furthermore, there is no national standard for accrediting dogs and handlers or record keeping of the success rate they achieve."

The report added the dogs, which are trained to detect the smell of dead bodies, have "the potential to cause complications in an inquiry".

"There is an urgent need to have national policy on their training, accreditation and deployment," it concluded.


The review uses a kidnap investigation to highlight how dogs have tied up valuable police time.

The animals detected human remains in old furniture that had been bought from houses where the owner had died.

The use of victim recovery, or cadaver dogs, has proved to be controversial in a number of high-profile cases in recent years.


A South Yorkshire Police spaniel called Eddie was said to have sniffed out the "scent of death" at the Haut de la Garenne children's home in Jersey and the apartment from which Madeleine McCann disappeared in Portugal.

But in both cases nothing more was found and South Yorkshire Police say Eddie is no longer working with them.


Victim recovery dogs from four different police forces were used during searches for kidnapped schoolgirl Shannon Matthews in Dewsbury in West Yorkshire in 2008.

The dogs found evidence of dead bodies, but officers later discovered the corpses were nothing to do with her disappearance.

"The properties searched contained a high level of second-hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died," according to the NPIA report.

"This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture."

The Association of Chief Police Officers told Sky News it was consulting individual police forces and hoped to have national training standards for the dogs later this year.





   


   


   


   


   

   



   






















 





© 2015 Sky UK
       

By Gerard Tubb, Sky News correspondent

Police sniffer dogs used to find missing people and dead bodies "urgently" need better training and monitoring, according to an official report.

The Government's National Policing Improvement Agency (NPIA) said specialist victim recovery dogs are not trained to approved standards, with no way of gauging their competence.



grimes dogs

Licensing is derived from anecdotal cases and is scenario based conducted
over a period of a week, twice annually, it is conducted utilising independent
A.C.P.O. authorised assessors. Continuation training is conducted on a dialy
basis and includes simple scent discrimination testing to large scale scenario
based exercises.

Both dogs and I are licensed as two separate working teams. We are
independently tested and licensed annually, normally at six monthly intervals
as a 'rolling' programme to ensure best practice is maintained. They are
tested to units of assessment prepared as a stand-alone system as these
dogs are unique. Training records are maintained and are available if
required.




Eddie the sniffer dog
Sniffer dog Eddie was relieved of his police duties....

probably because he was retired,,,of old age ...the report was 2011...five years after they retire them 7/8
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Lace on December 23, 2015, 04:45:22 PM
MERRY CHRISTMAS ALL.

BACK 2016    8((()*/

Sorry off topic  ?{)(**
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 23, 2015, 05:27:23 PM
Lenny Harper was in charge of the case.

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals). The evidence also strongly suggests that the item (JAR/6) that left Jersey for further examination was not the same item that returned as Mr. Harper has explained on many of occasion including in a comment he left on an earlier posting (below)

“There should be no problem whatsoever with accounting for the movements and whereabouts of this fragment, JAR/6, at any time. Each time it moves from or to the police store it should be carefully logged. We found the item on 23rd February. It remained with us, until from memory, the 6th March when it was taken to the Carbon Dating Lab in Oxford. We logged it out. We logged it back in again on 8th April when our Anthropologist again examined it and noticed that its appearance had changed considerably, and she was now not so sure of her verdict, although she could not reach a definite conclusion. The item should have been in the presence of the Oxford lab throughout the time it was there but it seems, that in breach of the rules of evidence they 'passed it around.' They seem to have got themselves into a real tangle, first of all stating it was too old for finding collagen, then finding it, then saying it was too degraded to date. Somewhere in all of this, a lab technician made the throwaway comment that it looked like a piece of coconut. (Funny how it was an unqualified technician and none of the experts who had examined it closely) This is the origin of the "ILM coconut" theory and of course encouraged by Warcup and Gradwell, along with their other public declarations such as the cellars not being cellars but only three feet voids. The item JAR/6 came back to us without a log of its movements from Oxford. As soon as it returned then we commenced again logging its movements and it should be no problem whatsoever to account for it from there on. Lenny Harper” END

So the quick judgement made by the forensic anthopologist on the scene supports the dramatic "skull" theory.

When the sample is exhaustively tested at a professional laboratory and the result is that it is plant based sample, his reaction is not "ok - not what we thought then" and pursue enquiries elsewhere - no - he decides that the sample has been tampered with and he was right all along.

In this respect he displays similar qualities to Amaral, and it is no surprise that he receives support from the "sceptic" community.



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 23, 2015, 05:31:59 PM
Lenny Harper was in charge of the case.

The “evidence” clearly points to the item being the partial remains of a child’s skull containing 1.6% collagen (0nly found in mammals). The evidence also strongly suggests that the item (JAR/6) that left Jersey for further examination was not the same item that returned as Mr. Harper has explained on many of occasion including in a comment he left on an earlier posting (below)

“There should be no problem whatsoever with accounting for the movements and whereabouts of this fragment, JAR/6, at any time. Each time it moves from or to the police store it should be carefully logged. We found the item on 23rd February. It remained with us, until from memory, the 6th March when it was taken to the Carbon Dating Lab in Oxford. We logged it out. We logged it back in again on 8th April when our Anthropologist again examined it and noticed that its appearance had changed considerably, and she was now not so sure of her verdict, although she could not reach a definite conclusion. The item should have been in the presence of the Oxford lab throughout the time it was there but it seems, that in breach of the rules of evidence they 'passed it around.' They seem to have got themselves into a real tangle, first of all stating it was too old for finding collagen, then finding it, then saying it was too degraded to date. Somewhere in all of this, a lab technician made the throwaway comment that it looked like a piece of coconut. (Funny how it was an unqualified technician and none of the experts who had examined it closely) This is the origin of the "ILM coconut" theory and of course encouraged by Warcup and Gradwell, along with their other public declarations such as the cellars not being cellars but only three feet voids. The item JAR/6 came back to us without a log of its movements from Oxford. As soon as it returned then we commenced again logging its movements and it should be no problem whatsoever to account for it from there on. Lenny Harper” END

so where did this article come from..no reference...its a load of rubbish....lenny harper was sacked my memory serves me well...we have been through all this before
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 23, 2015, 05:47:15 PM
so where did this article come from..no reference...its a load of rubbish....lenny harper was sacked my memory serves me well...we have been through all this before

Indeed we have ...seems the discussion has had no effect though ... as usual, if you don't like official conclusions, wait a bit and come back with what you do like.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3694.1655;wap2
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 23, 2015, 05:50:27 PM
MERRY CHRISTMAS ALL.

BACK 2016    8((()*/

Sorry off topic  ?{)(**


Merry Christmas/New Year to you,,,,,,,,,,,,, 8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 23, 2015, 05:55:27 PM
Operation Havern was an investigation into child-abuse.

It wasn't an investigation into murder.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 03:25:23 AM
Given that both dogs alert to dead blood, and Keela supposedly only to human blood, then there is no need to hunt for a body within 5A, merely a source of human blood.

The Scenic key fob proves that.  And the alert by both dogs in the sand bucket test, thereby indicating human origin, and the forensics showing the material to be Gerry's, shows that both dogs react to dead blood from a live human being.

There is no proof of a dead body in the Madeleine McCann case, merely of a disappearance.

Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 09:26:15 AM
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still

not only should be ignored....they have been ignored...for very...very obvious reasons that have been discussed a million times
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 09:29:26 AM
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still



just to add...there is no evidence that eddie did not alert to RBC ....but no evidence he did...taht makes the alerts useless as I have pointed out many times
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 24, 2015, 09:45:19 AM
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still

There are very good scientific and common sense reasons why residual scent should not be taken as 'proof' that a particular person's remains have lain at the position of an alert.

The dog may very well be capable of identifying exactly to whom the scent belongs ... but it cannot relay that information to the investigators.

A quick check of the internet or the very many dog threads already on the forum will confirm that there are many VOCs which replicate the scent of human remains which will cause the animal's trained response.
Residual scent has many components and science hasn't yet worked out exactly what or which combination it is that enables the dog to detect and alert.

Please try to understand that a stand alone alert won't be accepted even in a Scottish court where such evidence has been allowed without other compelling evidence for the consideration of a court.

Therefore Eddie's 'alerts' mean nothing without corroboration and his unreliability having been demonstrated in the Haute de la Garenne investigation should make him less of a pin up boy for promoting a seriously flawed hypothesis.   
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 10:26:35 AM
There are very good scientific and common sense reasons why residual scent should not be taken as 'proof' that a particular person's remains have lain at the position of an alert.

The dog may very well be capable of identifying exactly to whom the scent belongs ... but it cannot relay that information to the investigators.

A quick check of the internet or the very many dog threads already on the forum will confirm that there are many VOCs which replicate the scent of human remains which will cause the animal's trained response.
Residual scent has many components and science hasn't yet worked out exactly what or which combination it is that enables the dog to detect and alert.

Please try to understand that a stand alone alert won't be accepted even in a Scottish court where such evidence has been allowed without other compelling evidence for the consideration of a court.

Therefore Eddie's 'alerts' mean nothing without corroboration and his unreliability having been demonstrated in the Haute de la Garenne investigation should make him less of a pin up boy for promoting a seriously flawed hypothesis.   

Eddie was trained and his work speaks for itself. He detected cadaver scent in a garage and then the house next door. He amazed the authorities when checking that a kid had died in the house. Eddie alerted to cadaver scent. That's his job. Don't even bring the Jersey fiasco into it as an argument. Child abuse happened there and god knows what else.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 24, 2015, 11:14:46 AM
this was the point I was responding to:

You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?

The discussion was about coincidence.  The coincidence that in the hunt for a missing child a cadaver dog alerted in a room in which she had been but which turned out not to be her at all.  So, coincidences of this type can happen, for whatever reason.

So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 11:20:06 AM
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

Scotland Yard think Madeleine's abductor might have murdered Madeleine in the apartment (please God they wrong)!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 11:23:17 AM
Scotland Yard think Madeleine's abductor might have murdered Madeleine in the apartment (please God they wrong)!

The abductor yet again.

I will remind you yet again, not one iota of forensic evidence to show one ever existed.

Repeatedly typing it won't make it true.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 24, 2015, 12:08:38 PM
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

When police use dogs they are checking to see what may have been on the premises, whether it's drugs, explosives, bodies or whatever. If the dogs don't alert it's back to square one. If the dogs do alert the search intensifies. If nothing is found do the police;
a) Sack the dogs.
b) Apologise for suspecting the people whose premises they are searching.
c) Conclude that there probably was something there but it's been moved/disposed of.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 12:35:56 PM
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

dog alerted in 5a...SY think Maddie may still be alive...amaral's lawyer saying maddie may still be alive...
dog alert....absolutely meaningless
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 12:38:46 PM
It isn't just me ferryman.

Now tell me, have they found Madeleine or how she disappeared ?

so  who else ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 12:45:38 PM
so  who else ...

You really believe I'm the only person who does not believe an abduction took place ?

 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 12:50:54 PM
When police use dogs they are checking to see what may have been on the premises, whether it's drugs, explosives, bodies or whatever. If the dogs don't alert it's back to square one. If the dogs do alert the search intensifies. If nothing is found do the police;
a) Sack the dogs.
b) Apologise for suspecting the people whose premises they are searching.
c) Conclude that there probably was something there but it's been moved/disposed of.

the fact that you think it's that simple shows you do not understand the alerts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 24, 2015, 12:52:23 PM
Eddie was trained and his work speaks for itself. He detected cadaver scent in a garage and then the house next door. He amazed the authorities when checking that a kid had died in the house. Eddie alerted to cadaver scent. That's his job. Don't even bring the Jersey fiasco into it as an argument. Child abuse happened there and god knows what else.

As far as "God knows what else" may have occurred at Haute de la Garenne there is no evidence which supports the speculation despite a long and expensive investigation. 

There is evidence however that Eddie's false alerts contributed to the chaos.  Ignoring the fact won't make it go away.

There is a problem the propagandists may find themselves landed in.

Catchy as the "Dog's don't lie" slogan is there is just so much accurate information available about the work these dogs are capable of and the protocols under which they and their handlers operate that it knocks what we have seen on video of what happened in Luz into a cocked hat.

Eddie was a victim recovery dog, trained like all the others on pig and human blood, who in my opinion was well past his usefulness by the time he was deployed in Luz ... unless playing with the evidence and tossing it around was his trained response.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 01:01:52 PM
This was Harrison's specific recommendation:

McCann's Apartment.

The apartment in which the McCann's had stayed may present further
opportunities to search. The use of a specialist EVRD (Enhanced Victim
Recovery Dog) and CSI dog (human blood detecting dog) could potentially indicate on whether Madeline's blood is in the property or the scent of a dead body is present. In relation to the dead body scent if such a scent is indicated by the EVRD and no body is located it may suggest that a body has been in the property but removed. This search process could be repeated in all the apartments that were occupied by the friends holidaying with the McCann's.
Murat's House and Garden.


I'm sure you all understand what "may suggest" means...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 01:03:06 PM
You really believe I'm the only person who does not believe an abduction took place ?

 8**8:/:

where did I even suggest that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 01:05:12 PM
As far as "God knows what else" may have occurred at Haute de la Garenne there is no evidence which supports the speculation despite a long and expensive investigation. 

There is evidence however that Eddie's false alerts contributed to the chaos.  Ignoring the fact won't make it go away.

There is a problem the propagandists may find themselves landed in.

Catchy as the "Dog's don't lie" slogan is there is just so much accurate information available about the work these dogs are capable of and the protocols under which they and their handlers operate that it knocks what we have seen on video of what happened in Luz into a cocked hat.

Eddie was a victim recovery dog, trained like all the others on pig and human blood, who in my opinion was well past his usefulness by the time he was deployed in Luz ... unless playing with the evidence and tossing it around was his trained response.

You really love the 'p' word don't you.

Meanwhile , what do you do here on a daily basis ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 01:28:06 PM
dog alerted in 5a...SY think Maddie may still be alive...amaral's lawyer saying maddie may still be alive...
dog alert....absolutely meaningless

What were they doing with dogs in PDL then? Taking them for walkies  @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 01:29:36 PM
What were they doing with dogs in PDL then? Taking them for walkies  @)(++(*

no...they were looking for evidence.....that's what all these dogs are used for...they didn't find any...as they didn't in jersey
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 01:36:31 PM
no...they were looking for evidence.....that's what all these dogs are used for...they didn't find any...as they didn't in jersey

Searching for evidence of death like Eddie close to the Smithman sighting with the deep sleeping clone child.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 01:46:21 PM
Searching for evidence of death like Eddie close to the Smithman sighting with the deep sleeping clone child.

no...proper evidence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 01:49:44 PM
no...proper evidence

That applies to the 'abduction'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 01:53:30 PM
That applies to the 'abduction'.

so you would accept there is no evidence of anything to accuse teh mccanns
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 01:56:36 PM
so you would accept there is no evidence of anything to accuse teh mccanns


I have said repeatedly this case will not be solved.

The only firm piece of evidence we have, is that the mccanns were the last people to see her before they went to wine and dine.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 01:58:04 PM
What were they doing with dogs in PDL then? Taking them for walkies  @)(++(*

Or waiting for the experts on here to drag themselves away from their keyboards to give a "toolbox talk" about how the handlers and dogs should best be deployed. Not to mention defining the meaning of the word evidence just in case no one else has Googled it too... 8(>((
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 02:08:55 PM
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!
Of course it's conceivable.  Why wouldn't it be?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 02:17:23 PM
It's propaganda or a lack of understanding.....it really is quite simple....tell us what we have learn't from the alerts...you will find the alerts tell us nothing..


the important point is NOT that the alerts are not admissible in court..it's WHY they are not admissable
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 02:18:36 PM
What do the alerts tell us then? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 02:43:00 PM
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still
Let me try this again.

Keela alerts to blood and supposedly to human blood only, to be specific.  Assuming this is accurate, then Keela's alert indicates the presence of human blood, in the living room.  Clearly, that blood is dead.  So if Keela is infallible, we have dead human blood in apartment 5A.

Eddie alerts to a range of dead sources.  One of the sources he alerts to is dead blood, whether human in origin or not.  So where both dogs alerted, we have dead blood of human origin.  We do not yet have sufficient to even indicate a dead human body, merely dead human blood.

I could go through the rest of the evidence step by step but this is not a 'dogs' thread it is a 'propaganda' thread.

To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate.  They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda.

We have, at this point in time, no evidence that Madeleine is dead.  So discussing time for cadaver odour to develop from a human corpse is meaningless.

If someone bled in 5A, whether such person was Madeleine, before Madeleine, or after Madeleine, no matter how long it takes for 'cadaver odour' to develop, there was ample time, from days to months, before the dogs were deployed.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 02:54:37 PM
Scotland Yard think Madeleine's abductor might have murdered Madeleine in the apartment (please God they wrong)!
If that is what happened then it is necessary to account for the remaining factors.

No sign of a struggle.

Eddie and Keela alerted behind the couch.  Now if that was to a Madeleine based source, how did that source get there?  Could it have got behind the couch after an intruder murder?

Personally, I think not, therefore based on what we know, I am of the opinion that IF Madeleine was killed in 5A it left no forensic evidence, or none that has been found.  That's very low probability, so I have no compelling reason to believe Madeleine died in apartment 5A.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 02:57:16 PM
Let me try this again.

Keela alerts to blood and supposedly to human blood only, to be specific.  Assuming this is accurate, then Keela's alert indicates the presence of human blood, in the living room.  Clearly, that blood is dead.  So if Keela is infallible, we have dead human blood in apartment 5A.

Eddie alerts to a range of dead sources.  One of the sources he alerts to is dead blood, whether human in origin or not.  So where both dogs alerted, we have dead blood of human origin.  We do not yet have sufficient to even indicate a dead human body, merely dead human blood.

I could go through the rest of the evidence step by step but this is not a 'dogs' thread it is a 'propaganda' thread.

To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate.  They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda.

We have, at this point in time, no evidence that Madeleine is dead.  So discussing time for cadaver odour to develop from a human corpse is meaningless.

If someone bled in 5A, whether such person was Madeleine, before Madeleine, or after Madeleine, no matter how long it takes for 'cadaver odour' to develop, there was ample time, from days to months, before the dogs were deployed.

apart from the fact that the blood does not need time to develop scent because in that case the dog is not alerting to cadaver odour your post is correct...and is what many of us have been saying for many years.
the sceptics simply do not want to accept the truth re the alerts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 03:03:02 PM
The alerts are of no use because the dogs were wrongly deployed.

And before anyone increases my sin-bin points (still further) consider the damage to the reputation of Kate and Gerry McCann from propagating the myth that anything (whatsoever) of worth can be inferred from the deployment of the dogs in PdL.

Oh, apart from establishing beyond doubt (and with forensic corroboration) that Madeleine was never transported anywhere (dead or alive!) in the Renault Scenic.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 03:04:34 PM
Searching for evidence of death like Eddie close to the Smithman sighting with the deep sleeping clone child.
I cannot prove or disprove it, but IMO, that is what they were doing.  Combining Smithman with a large expanse of open ground nearby and achieving little. Other than that we can reasonably assume an extensive search of the area in June 2014 found nothing of significance.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 03:07:29 PM
The alerts are of no use because the dogs were wrongly deployed.

And before anyone increases my sin-bin points (still further) consider the damage to the reputation of Kate and Gerry McCann from propagating the myth that anything (whatsoever) of worth can be inferred from the deployment of the dogs in PdL.

Oh, apart from establishing beyond doubt (and with forensic corroboration) that Madeleine was never transported anywhere (dead or alive!) in the Renault Scenic.

That is the opinion of an amateur, and irrelevant.

You weren't there, and have you seen the unedited videos of what happened with the dogs deployment ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 03:12:28 PM
That is the opinion of an amateur, and irrelevant.

You weren't there, and have you seen the unedited videos of what happened with the dogs deployment ?

PJ Inspector Dias has (seen the unedited videos)

He agrees with me.

He said so in his report (not that he agreed with me; rather, that he had grave disquiet about the deployment of the dogs).

Harrison, also, disowned any incriminating inference from the dogs' deployment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 24, 2015, 03:15:14 PM
What do the alerts tell us then?

It doesn't matter what they tell us, it's how investigators view them. Do they ignore them and wipe them from their memories if no body is found or do they keep the alerts in mind as an indication of one possible scenario?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 03:16:50 PM
It doesn't matter what they tell us, it's how investigators view them. Do they ignore them and wipe them from their memories if no body is found or do they keep the alerts in mind as an indication of one possible scenario?

Harrison ignored them.

And Dias (admittedly not an expert) questioned them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 03:23:09 PM
I cannot prove or disprove it, but IMO, that is what they were doing.  Combining Smithman with a large expanse of open ground nearby and achieving little. Other than that we can reasonably assume an extensive search of the area in June 2014 found nothing of significance.

That's because Smithman was going towards the sea not the wasteland. He had passed a wasteland before passing the Smiths.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 03:26:38 PM
PJ Inspector Dias has (seen the unedited videos)

He agrees with me.

He said so in his report (not that he agreed with me; rather, that he had grave disquiet about the deployment of the dogs).

Harrison, also, disowned any incriminating inference from the dogs' deployment.

One man , one view.

So you have not seen them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 03:32:35 PM
apart from the fact that the blood does not need time to develop scent because in that case the dog is not alerting to cadaver odour your post is correct...and is what many of us have been saying for many years.
the sceptics simply do not want to accept the truth re the alerts
AFAIK, Eddie does not alert to live or fresh blood, therefore time is required for whatever the dog smells to develop.  If the origin of some or all of Eddie's alerts is blood, time is required.  I neither know nor care what that time is.  Given the long period before the dogs were deployed, there was more than enough time.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 03:33:24 PM
It doesn't matter what they tell us, it's how investigators view them. Do they ignore them and wipe them from their memories if no body is found or do they keep the alerts in mind as an indication of one possible scenario?
I was asking Slarti what they meant as he questioned the logic of Davel's point that they tell us nothing.  If they tell us (or the investigators) something then what is it, exactly?  Nothing to hang a hat on, that's for sure.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 03:38:04 PM
I was asking Slarti what they meant as he questioned the logic of Davel's point that they tell us nothing.  If they tell us (or the investigators) something then what is it, exactly?  Nothing to hang a hat on, that's for sure.

They tell them to look for a body as they were doing in PDL.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 04:04:08 PM
That's because Smithman was going towards the sea not the wasteland. He had passed a wasteland before passing the Smiths.
I take it you mean nothing was found in the first place they dug, as Smithman was not heading in that direction?  If so, one has to wonder why OG failed to twig this.

Was Smithman going towards the sea?  I would class that as a statement that cannot be supported.  In the Crimewatch of Oct 2013, the presenter has Smith come down the hill then turn to his left towards the Chinese Restaurant.  If the source of this nugget was OG, then there was no need for them to dig up the mound.

There is a video of Eamon Holmes interviewing Paul Luckman (local newspaper editor) about the content of Crimewatch 2013.  Luckman said that 2 years earlier (thus 2011) he had gone over the Smithman sighting with Gonçalo Amaral on site in Luz.  Amaral indicated that he thought Smithman had headed on down the street of steps that the Smiths had just come up.  So neither 'to the sea' nor 'to the mound'.  This is, of course, hardly evidence as to what happened, as opposed to what Luckman said Amaral had said.

I have no idea of the origin of the 'to the sea' idea.  All I know is that it seems to have emerged quite early, and at least a year before the PJ Files were released.

And what is in those files does not indicate 'to the mound' or 'to the sea'.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 04:05:46 PM
They tell them to look for a body as they were doing in PDL.
Why didn't the infallible dogs find a body then?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 24, 2015, 04:11:38 PM
That is the opinion of an amateur, and irrelevant.

You weren't there, and have you seen the unedited videos of what happened with the dogs deployment ?

Have you seen unedited videos of the dogs deployment Stephen? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 04:15:36 PM
I take it you mean nothing was found in the first place they dug, as Smithman was not heading in that direction?  If so, one has to wonder why OG failed to twig this.

Was Smithman going towards the sea?  I would class that as a statement that cannot be supported.  In the Crimewatch of Oct 2013, the presenter has Smith come down the hill then turn to his left towards the Chinese Restaurant.  If the source of this nugget was OG, then there was no need for them to dig up the mound.

There is a video of Eamon Holmes interviewing Paul Luckman (local newspaper editor) about the content of Crimewatch 2013.  Luckman said that 2 years earlier (thus 2011) he had gone over the Smithman sighting with Gonçalo Amaral on site in Luz.  Amaral indicated that he thought Smithman had headed on down the street of steps that the Smiths had just come up.  So neither 'to the sea' nor 'to the mound'.  This is, of course, hardly evidence as to what happened, as opposed to what Luckman said Amaral had said.

I have no idea of the origin of the 'to the sea' idea.  All I know is that it seems to have emerged quite early, and at least a year before the PJ Files were released.

And what is in those files does not indicate 'to the mound' or 'to the sea'.

I've told you he went to the church then the sea. It is all in my theory thread.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 04:18:14 PM
Why didn't the infallible dogs find a body then?

When did these dogs arrive in PDL? And they alerted to ONE car and the police removed part of the boot nevermind the reported open boot.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 04:22:10 PM
When did these dogs arrive in PDL? And they alerted to ONE car and the police removed part of the boot nevermind the reported open boot.
If the dogs told their handler there was a body to find it strikes me as rather odd that they were not then deployed all over PdL within a walking distance radius of Apt 5a.  Why weren't they?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 04:26:05 PM
If the dogs told their handler there was a body to find it strikes me as rather odd that they were not then deployed all over PdL within a walking distance radius of Apt 5a.  Why weren't they?

They were working on the theory that the body was hidden and later moved away in the boot of the car. They wanted to find where it could have been hidden.

Furious at the astounding claims, Kate, 39, said of the police: "They are basically saying, 'If you confess Madeleine had an accident, and that I panicked and hid the body in a bag for a month then got rid of it in a hire car, I'd get two or three years' suspended sentence.'
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 04:38:01 PM
They were working on the theory that the body was hidden and later moved away in the boot of the car. They wanted to find where it could have been hidden.

Furious at the astounding claims, Kate, 39, said of the police: "They are basically saying, 'If you confess Madeleine had an accident, and that I panicked and hid the body in a bag for a month then got rid of it in a hire car, I'd get two or three years' suspended sentence.'
Didn't they think it was worth bothering trying to find where the body had lain hidden for 4 weeks then?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 24, 2015, 04:50:29 PM
If the dogs told their handler there was a body to find it strikes me as rather odd that they were not then deployed all over PdL within a walking distance radius of Apt 5a.  Why weren't they?

Well, it says in the files that Eddie was;

Sniffer Dog Report

Location: Areas surrounding Rua da Figueira and Rua Rosmaninho (area close to apartment 5 A in the Ocean Club) Praia da Luz, Lagos

Participants:
1. PJ - Ricardo Paiva
2. UK Mark Harrison
3. UK Martin Grime, UK Forensic Canine P SM Expert
4. Eddy - English Springer

The entire activity was filmed.

On this date at 18.30 sniffer dog inspections were carried out in the areas mentioned above, using the sniffer dog Eddy, who detects cadaver odour and it was observed that in these areas, the dog did not signal anything.


Date: August 1st - 6am

After evaluation of the area surrounding the Ocean Club tourist village, based in Praia da Luz, taking account of the characteristic topography of the ground and the distance from where the small child Madeleine McCann disappeared, an inspection was carried out with the help of dogs specialised in the detection of cadaver odour, in various places, such as described:

1 - At 6.40am, an area between the "Piteira" road and the "Oliveira" road, was inspected. At 7.15am the inspection was completed with nothing being detected by the dogs.

2 - At 7.25am, an area adjacent to the "BEIJAFLOR" property on the "Figueira," road, defined by the "Ramalhete" road. An inspection of the whole area was made and nothing abnormal was noted. The inspection was completed at 7.45am.

3 - At 7.55am, an area between the "Casa Azul" residence on the "Figueira" road and the "Casa Pandora" residence as well as a dirt road on the left of the "Figueira" road was inspected by the dogs without anything abnormal being noted. The inspection ended at 8.05am.

4 - At 8.20am, an area between the residences "Casa Pandora" on the "Figueira" road, "Quinta Mimosa" and "Casa Ladeira" without anything abnormal being noted. The inspection ended at 8.40am.

A photographic report of the places inspected is attached.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 04:59:35 PM
Well, it says in the files that Eddie was;

Sniffer Dog Report

Location: Areas surrounding Rua da Figueira and Rua Rosmaninho (area close to apartment 5 A in the Ocean Club) Praia da Luz, Lagos

Participants:
1. PJ - Ricardo Paiva
2. UK Mark Harrison
3. UK Martin Grime, UK Forensic Canine P SM Expert
4. Eddy - English Springer

The entire activity was filmed.

On this date at 18.30 sniffer dog inspections were carried out in the areas mentioned above, using the sniffer dog Eddy, who detects cadaver odour and it was observed that in these areas, the dog did not signal anything.


Date: August 1st - 6am

After evaluation of the area surrounding the Ocean Club tourist village, based in Praia da Luz, taking account of the characteristic topography of the ground and the distance from where the small child Madeleine McCann disappeared, an inspection was carried out with the help of dogs specialised in the detection of cadaver odour, in various places, such as described:

1 - At 6.40am, an area between the "Piteira" road and the "Oliveira" road, was inspected. At 7.15am the inspection was completed with nothing being detected by the dogs.

2 - At 7.25am, an area adjacent to the "BEIJAFLOR" property on the "Figueira," road, defined by the "Ramalhete" road. An inspection of the whole area was made and nothing abnormal was noted. The inspection was completed at 7.45am.

3 - At 7.55am, an area between the "Casa Azul" residence on the "Figueira" road and the "Casa Pandora" residence as well as a dirt road on the left of the "Figueira" road was inspected by the dogs without anything abnormal being noted. The inspection ended at 8.05am.

4 - At 8.20am, an area between the residences "Casa Pandora" on the "Figueira" road, "Quinta Mimosa" and "Casa Ladeira" without anything abnormal being noted. The inspection ended at 8.40am.

A photographic report of the places inspected is attached.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm
Thank you.  So do those searches cover every conceivable location within walking distance from Apt 5a where a body may have been hidden by someone who did not readily have access to private property?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 24, 2015, 05:00:32 PM
To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate.  They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda.

... As is to state they didn't.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 05:06:41 PM
From the screening of the videos, referred previously, done when the dogs were working, some doubts arise. We don't want and we can't take the place of the trainer, we only wish to alert, with this paragraph, to some facts, that according to us, need further clarification.

 If the dog is trained to react when he detects what he is looking for, why, in most of the cases, we see the dog passing more than once by that place in an uninterested way, until he finally signals the place where he had already passed several times'


An excerpt from the files...put's the so called alerts into context....how can anyone explain this
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 05:08:53 PM
... As is to state they didn't.

so we don't know either way...so they tell us nothing...perfect logic...it is your logic that is flawed
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 05:12:39 PM
They were working on the theory that the body was hidden and later moved away in the boot of the car. They wanted to find where it could have been hidden.

Furious at the astounding claims, Kate, 39, said of the police: "They are basically saying, 'If you confess Madeleine had an accident, and that I panicked and hid the body in a bag for a month then got rid of it in a hire car, I'd get two or three years' suspended sentence.'

perhaps they convinced Grime...so Grime went on a fishing expedition/...hoping he might strike lucky with one of his alerts...all IMO of course
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 05:28:03 PM
I've told you he went to the church then the sea. It is all in my theory thread.
Personally, I don't have an issue with it being in your theory thread, as I consider debate of alternative possibilities or scenarios as a way of being able to make progress.

However, it is not in the PJ Files.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 05:37:52 PM
From the screening of the videos, referred previously, done when the dogs were working, some doubts arise. We don't want and we can't take the place of the trainer, we only wish to alert, with this paragraph, to some facts, that according to us, need further clarification.

 If the dog is trained to react when he detects what he is looking for, why, in most of the cases, we see the dog passing more than once by that place in an uninterested way, until he finally signals the place where he had already passed several times'


An excerpt from the files...put's the so called alerts into context....how can anyone explain this
An explanation is simple.

Do sniffer dogs (in total or in general) home in with the precision of a laser guided bomb, or do they sniff round about more than once until they have worked out the likely source?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 24, 2015, 05:51:20 PM
Thank you.  So do those searches cover every conceivable location within walking distance from Apt 5a where a body may have been hidden by someone who did not readily have access to private property?

Who knows? Try this;

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Luz+Ocean+Club/@37.0885233,-8.7310622,17z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0xd1b28f2dcd22291:0xb0d18afc2e533981
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 05:57:06 PM
An explanation is simple.

Do sniffer dogs (in total or in general) home in with the precision of a laser guided bomb, or do they sniff round about more than once until they have worked out the likely source?


we see the dog passing more than once by that place in an uninterested way
   ...passing more than once in a uninterested way...that's a lot more sniffing around and homing in
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 06:08:07 PM
'Is there any chance, however remote, of any confusion'

The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained.

'Can the dog mix up traces of human odours with others that are non-human''

I cannot comment on what the dogs think. However, from a forensic point of view and from confirmations of scientific testimonies, the dogs appear to be extremely exact. But, forensic confirmation is required in all cases so as to be included as proof. The CSI dog is trained using only human blood. And using a wide spectrum of donors to ensure that the dog does not individualize them.
EVRD used to be trained using swine (pigs) as their odour is the closest to that of humans. But most of the time, however, the dog was trained using the odour of a human cadaver. Operationally, the dog has ignored large amounts of animal remains/bones when locating human decomposition.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_RIGATORY.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 24, 2015, 06:11:35 PM
An explanation is simple.

Do sniffer dogs (in total or in general) home in with the precision of a laser guided bomb, or do they sniff round about more than once until they have worked out the likely source?

I have seen a video of a sniffer dog being tested in a TV studio.  If I remember correctly, the handler was unaware of the location of the scent source which was above the dog's head height.  The dog went directly to the source after a cursory search.

Dogs trained to locate a body underwater also alert as soon as the boat passes over the resting place ... I think it was Carana who posted that video on one of our doggy threads.

There is also a video showing a dog locating a scent source which had been placed in a large field ... he encountered it at the first pass.

The scent can also travel and pool in a different location carried either on the wind or in water ... but there is always a body to be found by tracking back.

I have seen such pooled scent used to justify Eddie's behaviour in 5A ... but I don't think there was an accompanying explanation about how such an effect could have been achieved in that location without a primary source enabling it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 06:26:45 PM
'Is there any chance, however remote, of any confusion'

The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained.

'Can the dog mix up traces of human odours with others that are non-human''

I cannot comment on what the dogs think. However, from a forensic point of view and from confirmations of scientific testimonies, the dogs appear to be extremely exact. But, forensic confirmation is required in all cases so as to be included as proof. The CSI dog is trained using only human blood. And using a wide spectrum of donors to ensure that the dog does not individualize them.
EVRD used to be trained using swine (pigs) as their odour is the closest to that of humans. But most of the time, however, the dog was trained using the odour of a human cadaver. Operationally, the dog has ignored large amounts of animal remains/bones when locating human decomposition.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_RIGATORY.htm


martin Grime was asked on two occasions if an alert gave a positive confirmation...on each occasion he failed to answer the question
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 06:31:03 PM
Who knows? Try this;

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Luz+Ocean+Club/@37.0885233,-8.7310622,17z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0xd1b28f2dcd22291:0xb0d18afc2e533981
The answer would appear to be no then.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 06:43:43 PM
On HdLg this (from the Operation Rectangle enquiry) is not exactly what I was looking for, but it serves to illustrate a point: Eddie alerted to a coconut:

Quote
 Conclusion 18a
2.142 CO POWER neglected his duty to provide strategic oversight of States of
Jersey Police media policy following receipt of confirmation that Exhibit
JAR/6 was not human bone, as previously portrayed by the States of Jersey
Police within its media releases.

Somewhere in the same report is a scathing analysis of Grime's performance.

Note, that is the handler's performance, not the dog's, though the dog doesn't come out favourably, either.

http://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Government%20and%20administration/R%20WiltshireOperationHavenRedacted%2020081112%20JN.pdf
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 24, 2015, 07:03:54 PM
The answer would appear to be no then.

Did you look at all the streets searched then? What did they miss?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 24, 2015, 07:07:27 PM
On HdLg this (from the Operation Rectangle enquiry) is not exactly what I was looking for, but it serves to illustrate a point: Eddie alerted to a coconut:

Somewhere in the same report is a scathing analysis of Grime's performance.

Note, that is the handler's performance, not the dog's, though the dog doesn't come out favourably, either.

http://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Government%20and%20administration/R%20WiltshireOperationHavenRedacted%2020081112%20JN.

Libel again. I suggest you read what the  report actual says rather than your preferences. The criticism is directed at the officers running the investigation not Grime. Please desist.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 07:09:46 PM
On HdLg this (from the Operation Rectangle enquiry) is not exactly what I was looking for, but it serves to illustrate a point: Eddie alerted to a coconut:

Somewhere in the same report is a scathing analysis of Grime's performance.

Note, that is the handler's performance, not the dog's, though the dog doesn't come out favourably, either.

http://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Government%20and%20administration/R%20WiltshireOperationHavenRedacted%2020081112%20JN.pdf

Report says following the suspension of Chief Officer Graham Power.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/jun/28/jersey-secrecy-culture

Graham Power: 'I was suspended by the very government whose institutions were being investigated. You cannot get much more conflicted than that."

Before moving to Jersey to take charge of the island's police in 2000, Graham Power had served in the senior ranks of four other forces in a career spanning more than 30 years. A recipient of the Queen's Medal for distinguished service, he had been vetted by UK authorities to "top secret" level and was so well regarded that he had also been appointed an assessor for the body that selects chief officers for UK constabularies.

The initial suspension, which related to Power's management and supervision of a child abuse inquiry centred around Haut de la Garenne, a children's home on the island, continues to be a hugely controversial topic in Jersey. It's an episode which Jersey's critics see as a prime example of the way the island's elite treats those who dare to challenge their authority.

Power, as well as child abuse survivors the Guardian has spoken to on the island, claim that after his suspension, some victims lost faith in the investigation. He said: "After my suspension a police officer working in the incident room approached me in the street and told me that incident room staff were busy dealing with calls from victims who were distressed after hearing that I had been suspended and were saying that 'it would all be covered up again'. I have had similar messages from people close to victims and from individual victims who do not wish to be named."
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 07:19:54 PM
Libel again. I suggest you read what the  report actual says rather than your preferences. The criticism is directed at the officers running the investigation not Grime. Please desist.

Yeah! We did all this about three months ago. It's like trying to chuck away a boomerang.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 07:20:45 PM

Some interesting LBTR.

http://nevergetbusted.com/2014/07/20/university-study-tricked-certified-police-dogs-to-false-alert-200-times/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 07:22:33 PM
Did you look at all the streets searched then? What did they miss?
They obviously missed the place where the body was hidden for 4 weeks before being transported in the Scenic!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 24, 2015, 07:25:28 PM
Some interesting LBTR.

http://nevergetbusted.com/2014/07/20/university-study-tricked-certified-police-dogs-to-false-alert-200-times/
Not helpful to the "Dogs Don't Lie" brigade.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 24, 2015, 08:03:05 PM
I feel sure I may get criticized for saying this, but why not have a rest from this discussion, and relax with friends and family.

Seasons greetings to friends or foes.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 24, 2015, 08:15:31 PM
Good idea. Happy Christmas Everyone  8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 08:27:44 PM
Let me try this again.

Keela alerts to blood and supposedly to human blood only, to be specific.  Assuming this is accurate, then Keela's alert indicates the presence of human blood, in the living room.  Clearly, that blood is dead.  So if Keela is infallible, we have dead human blood in apartment 5A.

Eddie alerts to a range of dead sources.  One of the sources he alerts to is dead blood, whether human in origin or not.  So where both dogs alerted, we have dead blood of human origin.  We do not yet have sufficient to even indicate a dead human body, merely dead human blood. One does not necessarily follow from the other but I will go with that for now

I could go through the rest of the evidence step by step but this is not a 'dogs' thread it is a 'propaganda' thread. Quite, we have done it all a million times before, but there is a reason that alot of people will just not accept the directive to ignore the cadaver dog......well, many reasons least of all a child went missing, a cadaver dog alerted, it alerted nowhere else but somehow we are led to believe its all down to mushrooms and fraudulent dog handlers? and if it isn't then "just forget about it"...thats not how it works...if there was an unbiased and proven credible argument it mght happen but never has been one that has convinced me......the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive

To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate.  They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda. As is to state that the cadaver dog alerting means nothing at all/useless/not evidence of anything

We have, at this point in time, no evidence that Madeleine is dead.  So discussing time for cadaver odour to develop from a human corpse is meaningless. Not really, its an exploration of a possibility and not without cause for concern...presumption of innocence notwithstanding...its a spanner in the works..***see article at end

If someone bled in 5A, whether such person was Madeleine, before Madeleine, or after Madeleine, no matter how long it takes for 'cadaver odour' to develop, there was ample time, from days to months, before the dogs were deployed. No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood


Answers in red SIL

***  http://www.policek9.com/Fleck/Cadaver%20Dogs.pdf

Sorry to party poop all, have a good one
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 08:29:53 PM
Report says following the suspension of Chief Officer Graham Power.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/jun/28/jersey-secrecy-culture

Graham Power: 'I was suspended by the very government whose institutions were being investigated. You cannot get much more conflicted than that."

Before moving to Jersey to take charge of the island's police in 2000, Graham Power had served in the senior ranks of four other forces in a career spanning more than 30 years. A recipient of the Queen's Medal for distinguished service, he had been vetted by UK authorities to "top secret" level and was so well regarded that he had also been appointed an assessor for the body that selects chief officers for UK constabularies.

The initial suspension, which related to Power's management and supervision of a child abuse inquiry centred around Haut de la Garenne, a children's home on the island, continues to be a hugely controversial topic in Jersey. It's an episode which Jersey's critics see as a prime example of the way the island's elite treats those who dare to challenge their authority.

Power, as well as child abuse survivors the Guardian has spoken to on the island, claim that after his suspension, some victims lost faith in the investigation. He said: "After my suspension a police officer working in the incident room approached me in the street and told me that incident room staff were busy dealing with calls from victims who were distressed after hearing that I had been suspended and were saying that 'it would all be covered up again'. I have had similar messages from people close to victims and from individual victims who do not wish to be named."

Wiltshire police wrote the report and they were independent.

When I've time I will dig out the exact reference from the report that confirms, from the report of a technician of an Oxford Laboratory, that the piece of coconut Eddie reacted to was just that, a piece of coconut.

The exact reference is in the report I link to above.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 08:36:02 PM
Libel again. I suggest you read what the  report actual says rather than your preferences. The criticism is directed at the officers running the investigation not Grime. Please desist.

I have read precisely what the report says.  When I've time, I will dig out the precise reference of where Grime, specifically, is criticised.

In fact, I know I have given the reference to Brietta, and she may have it?

I am a little busy at the moment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 09:13:44 PM
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 09:20:09 PM
.
Mercury posted..


.the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive .


That really is absolute rubbish...it is quite valid to believe that eddie did not alert to cadaver scent when...

1. His handler has not confirmed it...even when asked a direct question
2. There is no proof to support that he did
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 09:30:48 PM
Not helpful to the "Dogs Don't Lie" brigade.

I thought it rather like San Diego*. "It has something for everyone".*
"A K-9 cannot properly separate odors if s/he is rushed or hurried through this process".

*If you remember your ALF that is.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 09:33:19 PM
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to
Do you work for BBC news? You ask a question then give the answer.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 24, 2015, 09:35:48 PM
Do you work for BBC news? You ask a question then give the answer.

I give my answer and invite others to give theirs...it seems no one  including you can give an answer...all you can do is make sarcastic comments.

As no one has been able to give an answer it is fair to conclude I am right
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 10:32:08 PM
.
Mercury posted..


.the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive .


That really is absolute rubbish...it is quite valid to believe that eddie did not alert to cadaver scent when...

1. His handler has not confirmed it...even when asked a direct question
2. There is no proof to support that he did

That really is absolute rubbish as neither is possible

But, all people are free to believe what they want (a right you seem to deny in a totalitarian way to some)

Merry xmas though
And have FUN


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 24, 2015, 11:18:01 PM
Quote
3.10.11 We now deal with the introduction of Martin GRIME and his Enhanced
Victim Recovery Dog (EVRD) to Operation Rectangle. Operation
Haven has established through enquiry with the NPIA, that
Martin GRIME was an ACPO accredited dog handler whilst he was a
serving police officer, but forfeited accreditation upon his retirement in
July 2007. We mentioned that Mr GRIME remains on the ACPO
accredited list of experts though his EVRD is no longer accredited by
ACPO. Whilst Martin GRIME’s original contract to Jersey was for five
days, his actual deployment lasted for 130 days.
3.10.12 The forensic review carried out by    X of the NPIA
questioned the presence of Martin GRIME on site for such a long
time. X , was informed that Martin GRIME had been
acting as a Deputy Crime Scene Manager to Forensic Service
Manager X , at the request of DCO HARPER. The forensic
review noted Martin GRIME’s lack of formal training or qualifications
to perform the role of Deputy Forensic Service Manager and that to
utilise him in this role ‘cannot be recognised as good practice’. The
review also noted that ‘there was concern from some persons
interviewed that too much reliance had been placed on the dogs’. It is
accepted that dogs are ‘presumptive screening assets’ only and that
any alerts or indications they give must be forensically corroborated.
In addition, it is a fact that there were no concise terms of reference
for the deployment of Martin GRIME and his EVRD or his subsequent
use as a search advisor, apparently with the support of
DCO HARPER.
3.10.13 CO POWER himself states ‘the search dog seemed to play a
significant role in determining whether a specific location needed to
be examined further. I am not an expert on dogs or what they do’.
3.10.14 Again, there is a distinct lack of documentary evidence to show any
intrusive supervision of the SIO with regard to the continued search.
This Inquiry concludes that the actions of DCO HARPER and
Martin GRIME went unsupervised for some considerable time. To
Page 116 of 383


Supervision Highly Confidential – Personal Information
CO POWER’s credit, there is an e-mail exchange between him and
DCO HARPER dated 10 May 2008 in which CO POWER raises the
question of the continued use of Martin GRIME and his EVRD. He
says ‘Lenny, it has struck me for some time that he [Mr GRIME] is an
expensive resource who has more than his fair shared of down time’.
DCO HARPER replied in the same e-mail string ‘to be fair to him
though, he hasn’t got much down time as he is also the NPIA search
coordinator and is fully employed’. CO POWER replies ‘Thanks.
Better understood now’. CO POWER does not appear to pursue the
matter further.
3.10.15 However, DCO HARPER’s reply was not factually accurate.
Martin GRIME was neither an NPIA search advisor nor fully
employed. In his statement, Martin GRIME states that ‘I am a Subject
Matter Expert registered with the UK National Policing Improvement
Agency and specialist homicide canine search advisor… I advise
Domestic and International Law enforcement agencies on the
operational deployment of police dogs in the role of homicide
investigation. I develop methods of detecting forensically recoverable
evidence by the use of dogs and facilitate training’. His expertise lay
purely in the use of dogs in searching, not as a 'search co-ordinator'.
3.10.16 OFFICER X notes that during conversation with X, CO POWER
accepted that ‘the dog was ‘probably unreliable’ and that the dog
handler, GRIME, had too much influence over the enquiry, again,
Mr POWER didn’t say how he managed or dealt with that issue’. This
Inquiry has been unable to establish whether CO POWER made any
further attempts to supervise the SIO in this key part of the
investigation.
3.10.17 OFFICER X concludes ‘decisions should be made based on
professional policing judgement and evidence. When you look at the
facts, the excavation and searching of Haut De La Garenne… was
not justified’.

(Operation Havern)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 11:18:30 PM
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to
Just cos dogs cant speak doesnt mean ther indications are meaningless...they are at the very very least intellgence,get over it and stop makng a fool of yourself day in day out..time for new years resolutions? Stop coming across as a dictator...its quite  unpalatable lol...not even sure why im responding to your rubbsh...probably the last thread of hope of making you see a little or more sense, pontless task,now stop stalking cos youre getting creepy


Merry xmas
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 24, 2015, 11:29:01 PM
Answers in red SIL

***  http://www.policek9.com/Fleck/Cadaver%20Dogs.pdf

Sorry to party poop all, have a good one
"No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood."

If you have a source that shows Keela in -
the parent's bedroom
the veranda outside the parents' bedroom
the garden underneath the parents' bedroom
then -
would you kindly provide a link to it as I would be most interested.  At least at the moment, I am not aware of any.

I have seen the longer video in which Martin Grime states that an alert, in this case Eddie, can be because of the way wind blows or perhaps because some source was there, but now is not.

The clothes that were alerted to after the search of 27 Rua da Flores are one option.  Kate's clothes, stored in the wardrobe of apartment 5A.  That happens to be a complex option, as the dogs did not alert to where these clothes were between 5A and 27 Rua das Flores.  In summary, probably no.

So let me think through the simple solution.  There is dead human blood in the living room and the air currents waft this into the parents' bedroom.  Eddie gets it in both places.  Keela gets it only in the living room.  I will let you decide if this is more likely.



 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 11:35:21 PM
"No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood."

If you have a source that shows Keela in -
the parent's bedroom

the veranda outside the parents' bedroom
the garden underneath the parents' bedroom
then -
would you kindly provide a link to it as I would be most interested.  At least at the moment, I am not aware of any.

I have seen the longer video in which Martin Grime states that an alert, in this case Eddie, can be because of the way wind blows or perhaps because some source was there, but now is not.

The clothes that were alerted to after the search of 27 Rua da Flores are one option.  Kate's clothes, stored in the wardrobe of apartment 5A.  That happens to be a complex option, as the dogs did not alert to where these clothes were between 5A and 27 Rua das Flores.  In summary, probably no.

So let me think through the simple solution.  There is dead human blood in the living room and the air currents waft this into the parents' bedroom.  Eddie gets it in both places.  Keela gets it only in the living room.  I will let you decide if this is more likely.

Keela is shown in the dog search video as searchng the parents bedroom, the rest, no, dont have video footage

PS Mr Grime  said an alert at a certain place by the cadaver dog  doesnt necessarily mean that was the source...just that possibly the elements of the source had gathered in a certain place....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 24, 2015, 11:56:05 PM
I give my answer and invite others to give theirs...it seems no one  including you can give an answer...all you can do is make sarcastic comments.

As no one has been able to give an answer it is fair to conclude I am right

Incorrect. You have failed to take into account that some may feel it pointless to debate with you. Not you understand because they feel you have a towering intellect which is always correct rather that you sound like an old fashioned gramophone record with the needle stuck and tend to be abusive.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 24, 2015, 11:59:01 PM
Incorrect. You have failed to take into account that some may feel it pointless to debate with you. Not you understand because they feel you have a towering intellect which is always correct rather that you sound like an old fashioned gramophone record with the needle stuck and tend to be abusive.


 *&*%£

Nail on head

Merry xmas alice have a good one x

Nite all

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 25, 2015, 01:38:07 AM
.
Mercury posted..


.the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive .


That really is absolute rubbish...it is quite valid to believe that eddie did not alert to cadaver scent when...

1. His handler has not confirmed it...even when asked a direct question
2. There is no proof to support that he did

This is the truth. When you find Madeleine McCann alive then you can say Eddie was wrong in his cadaver alerts but until then the police will try and find the body.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 08:21:59 AM
Incorrect. You have failed to take into account that some may feel it pointless to debate with you. Not you understand because they feel you have a towering intellect which is always correct rather that you sound like an old fashioned gramophone record with the needle stuck and tend to be abusive.

it seems the majority of the posters. here including yourself have been actively debating with me..so your assertion is false.

The fact is no one can answer the question...what do the dogs tell us...the answer really is b****r all and taht's why I refer to them as useless. 

I am more than happy to be corrected but no one has managed and I doubt anyone will.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 08:23:23 AM
This is the truth. When you find Madeleine McCann alive then you can say Eddie was wrong in his cadaver alerts but until then the police will try and find the body.

No ..finding maddie alive will not prove eddie wrong...how little you understand about the dogs
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 25, 2015, 10:20:56 AM
No ..finding maddie alive will not prove eddie wrong...how little you understand about the dogs

Clearly Eddie alerted to something.  All we know for sure is that he was trained to alert to cadaver odour, dried blood and other biological substances.   To infer that he alerted to a dead child is an inference too far at least until other evidence is found.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 11:16:32 AM
Clearly Eddie alerted to something.  All we know for sure is that he was trained to alert to cadaver odour, dried blood and other biological substances.   To infer that he alerted to a dead child is an inference too far at least until other evidence is found.

so ...what do the alerts tell us...absolutely nothing..
The much lauded alerts by eddie tell us nothing...

What use is that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 25, 2015, 11:37:51 AM
so ...what do the alerts tell us...absolutely nothing..
The much lauded alerts by eddie tell us nothing...

What use is that

They tell me the prime suspect was carrying a dead body towards the sea. You know the one who has never came forward to clear himself.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 11:39:44 AM
They tell me the prime suspect was carrying a dead body towards the sea. You know the one who has never came forward to clear himself.

with respect...thats hows how poor your logic is
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 25, 2015, 11:42:41 AM
with respect...thats hows how poor your logic is

All witnesses agree the child on a cold night around 10pm was in a DEEP sleep. My logic is spot on!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 11:43:50 AM
All witnesses agree the child on a cold night around 10pm was in DEEP sleep.

so were the twins and they are still alive
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 25, 2015, 11:46:01 AM
so were the twins and they are still alive

Yes and they weren't tested but the mother was checking they were still breathing. How unusual.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 11:48:16 AM
Yes and they weren't tested but the mother was checking they were still breathing. How unusual.

your theories are wild speculation with nothing to support...not interested
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 11:50:16 AM
back on topic...Propaganda... The Dogs alerts...absolutely meaningless..

no one can tell us what information the alerts by eddie have given us...nothing...the alerts tell us nothing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 25, 2015, 01:08:49 PM
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CXEjeBjWEAAewaX.jpg:large)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 25, 2015, 01:58:44 PM
so ...what do the alerts tell us...absolutely nothing..
The much lauded alerts by eddie tell us nothing...

What use is that

Its all propaganda   @)(++(*   nice doggie btw
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 02:06:16 PM
Its all propaganda   @)(++(*   nice doggie btw

This one's lovely too...part of my childrens Christmas present
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 02:34:28 PM
Its all propaganda   @)(++(*   nice doggie btw

seriously..the alerts are all propaganda...have to check the turkey now
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 25, 2015, 02:50:30 PM
seriously..the alerts are all propaganda...have to check the turkey now

In fairness, the alert to spots of Gerry's blood on the ignition key was spot-on; but still used for propaganda purposes (not remotely the fault of the dog, of course) ...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 25, 2015, 04:42:48 PM
This one's lovely too...part of my childrens Christmas present

AAAAaaaaaaw ... so gorgeous ... I hope you and the family enjoy him (and he you) for many years to come  8((()*/
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 25, 2015, 05:04:26 PM
AAAAaaaaaaw ... so gorgeous ... I hope you and the family enjoy him (and he you) for many years to come  8((()*/

Thanks Brietta ,
 I want to get the children off the Xbox and running round the park....he's  a she and is going to need plenty of exercise
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 27, 2015, 09:14:22 AM
so back on track....the biggest piece of propaganda is the alerts by eddie...when in reality they are worthless because they tell us nothing...they are pure hype...

can any sceptic counter this?.....can any sceptic tell us what the alerts tell us that we did not already know before the dogs were brought in
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 27, 2015, 03:23:50 PM
Have said many times its not only G A that doubted the mccs.......both English and Portuguese officer's

thought because it is quiet .its something to mull over.along with the mulled wine

to start with especially Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida,


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id315.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 27, 2015, 03:28:13 PM
Have said many times its not only G A that doubted the mccs.......both English and Portuguese officer's

thought because it is quiet .its something to mull over.along with the mulled wine

to start with especially Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida,


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id315.html

Not a shred of evidence to support that assertion ....
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 27, 2015, 03:35:25 PM
Have said many times its not only G A that doubted the mccs.......both English and Portuguese officer's

thought because it is quiet .its something to mull over.along with the mulled wine

to start with especially Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida,


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id315.html

more propaganda...not a shred of evidence to say that UK police doubted the McCanns.....they said they should be investigated...which is routine
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 27, 2015, 04:11:58 PM
Thanks Brietta ,
 I want to get the children off the Xbox and running round the park....he's  a she and is going to need plenty of exercise


aww wonderful idea davel ..really cute when they are young .so much responsibility too.....................dread to think what they got you to keep u ff hear ...hopefully not another dog lol...all the best
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 27, 2015, 09:33:24 PM
Have said many times its not only G A that doubted the mccs.......both English and Portuguese officer's

thought because it is quiet .its something to mull over.along with the mulled wine

to start with especially Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida,


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id315.html

Lee Rainbow, a  top UK criminal profiler, his report brought up in in court in Lisbon.....talking about " possible homicide*** ".... and....."a couple united in covering up a tragedy"

No doubting what was said and quoted in a court of law!

I cant think of a single LE officer , British or Portuguese, on the case, who actually said they thought they were not involved or telling the whole truth.....I stand to be corrected though

Lets not forget  it was the British who suggested bringing in the  lood and cadaver dogs to the Mccanns and friends apartments and cars..if that is not testament to possible suspicion dont know what it is....



***

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/mccanns-should-be-treated-as-suspects-brit-200689
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 27, 2015, 10:30:04 PM
Have said many times its not only G A that doubted the mccs.......both English and Portuguese officer's

thought because it is quiet .its something to mull over.along with the mulled wine

to start with especially Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida,


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id315.html

As well as being convicted of torture ...  http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/dois-inspetores-da-pj-condenados-por-tortura=f782292 ... a crime which under normal circumstances should have dented his street cred just a little ... Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida's interim report and his opinion were merely the half time score in a game of two halves.

Amazing that his misinterpretations are still in use for propaganda purposes.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 27, 2015, 10:42:28 PM
As well as being convicted of torture ...  http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/dois-inspetores-da-pj-condenados-por-tortura=f782292 ... a crime which under normal circumstances should have dented his street cred just a little ... Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida's interim report and his opinion were merely the half time score in a game of two halves.

Amazing that his misinterpretations are still in use for propaganda purposes.
Leaving aside your own propaganda and not a shred of proof that the Portuguese teams interpretations of all evidence was false,
What was the full score then? Have the Mccanns been cleared by the Portuguese authorities? Or are still awaiting a full time score?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 27, 2015, 11:33:00 PM
Lee Rainbow, a  top UK criminal profiler, his report brought up in in court in Lisbon.....talking about " possible homicide ".... and....."a couple united in covering up a tragedy"

No doubting what was said and quoted in a court of law!

I cant think of a single LE officer , British or Portuguese, on the case, who actually said they thought they were not involved or telling the whole truth.....I stand to be corrected though

Lets not forget  it was the British who suggested bringing in the  lood and cadaver dogs to the Mccanns and friends apartments and cars..if that is not testament to possible suspicion dont know what it is....

what a load of propaganda...do you have a cite for your claim in red...why are lies allowed on this forum
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:07:52 AM
Where did this quoted sentence come from then einstein? Someones imagination?
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"

Coupled with the cited and quoted to Rainbow  possibility of homicide, not a million miles is it?




Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:10:10 AM
Where did this quoted sentence come from then einstein? Someones imagination?
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"

Coupled with the cited and quoted to Rainbow  possibility of homicide, not a million miles is it?

I would say its from someone's imagination...as you cannot provide a cite...and I would say you are posting lies
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:12:05 AM
Where did this quoted sentence come from then einstein? Someones imagination?
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"

Coupled with the cited and quoted to Rainbow  possibility of homicide, not a million miles is it?

you are providing perfect examples of lies/propaganda...well done
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:14:28 AM
you are providing perfect examples of lies/propaganda...well done

And you are proving a perfect example of a totalitarian no debate despot who spiels propaganda and abuse and never answers the points or is interested n any debate whatsoever


Wrll done

 8@??)(

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:15:04 AM
And you are proving a perfect example of a totalitarian no debate despot who spiels propaganda and abuse and never answers the points or is interested n any debate whatsoever


Wrll done

 8@??)(

so still no cite for your lies
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:17:02 AM
And you are proving a perfect example of a totalitarian no debate despot who spiels propaganda and abuse and never answers the points or is interested n any debate whatsoever


Wrll done

 8@??)(

you have made a statement that isn't true and can't provide a cite to support it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:18:35 AM
so still no cite for your lies

I dont need to provide cites for your abuse lol....as for lies you have to prove they are lies otherwise youre talking nonsense...the fact that you are is reinforced by the fact that you have knee jerk reactions and have to post then repost quotng the same post lol....its u go yu to prove what i posted is untrue before you call it a lie and me a liar
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:19:58 AM
I dont need to provide cites for your abuse lol....as for lies you have to prove they are lies otherwise youre talking nonsense...

you have been caught telling lies
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:21:52 AM
you have been caught telling lies

only in your worthless little opinion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:25:59 AM
so SY have said the McCANNS are totally innocent...as have the Portuguese police...simple...no evidence against them and they are totally cleared
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:27:34 AM
only in your worthless little opinion

the evidence is there for all to see
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:29:11 AM
so SY have said the McCANNS are totally innocent...as have the Portuguese police...simple...no evidence against them and they are totally cleared

lol at the person who accusers others of lyng.....what a BIG lie

Nite ...bored with low iq posters
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:30:47 AM
lol at the person who accusers others of lyng.....what a BIG lie

Nite ...bored with low iq posters

its called irony
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:38:00 AM
Fact remains lee rainbow suggested possible homicide..a British element recommended sending in a cadaver dog....says it all...vis a vis xtinas post that it was both britishand portuguese suspected them....Undeniable FACT....despite apologists teting to say theres not a shred of evidence for it.....busted....davel and ferryman
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:41:06 AM
Fact remains lee rainbow suggested possible homicide..a British element recommended sending in a cadaver dog....says it all...vis a vis xtinas post that it was both brigish and portuguese suspected them....Undeniable FACT

lee rainbow suggested possible homicide ...I agree with him 100%...british suggest cadaver dogs...agree 100%...its the rest of your post that's baloney
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:43:53 AM
Fact remains lee rainbow suggested possible homicide..a British element recommended sending in a cadaver dog....says it all...vis a vis xtinas post that it was both britishand portuguese suspected them....Undeniable FACT....despite apologists teting to say theres not a shred of evidence for it.....busted....davel and ferryman

so Rainbow suggested homicide...are you suggesting homicide by the mccanns
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:44:47 AM
lee rainbow suggested possible homicide ...I agree with him 100%...british suggest cadaver dogs...agree 100%...its the rest of your post that's baloney

Then i  suggest you reread your own posts ie 1039 before attemptng to backtrack
....duh


have fun rereading your hypocrisy
Tara
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:45:38 AM
so Rainbow suggested homicide...are you suggesting homicide by the mccanns

No HE was, do keep up luv

'The contradictions in Gerald McCann's statement might lead us to suspect a homicide. This is a lead that should be investigated.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1250084/How-letter-UK-police-turned-spotlight-Kate-Gerry-McCann.html#ixzz3vZWbR1v6
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:48:44 AM
No HE was, do keep up luv

no he wasn't...lee rainbow never suggested maddie died as a result of homicide by the mccanns .....and anyone who thinks he did..is a bit simple
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:49:52 AM
No HE was, do keep up luv

'The contradictions in Gerald McCann's statement might lead us to suspect a homicide. This is a lead that should be investigated.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1250084/How-letter-UK-police-turned-spotlight-Kate-Gerry-McCann.html#ixzz3vZWbR1v6
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

lee rainbow never said that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:53:45 AM
no he wasn't...lee rainbow never suggested maddie died as a result of homicide by the mccanns .....and anyone who thinks he did..is a bit simple

So
When lee rainbow says inconsistencies in Gerrys statements might lead him to thnk of homicide its a third party? Thats a perfect example of simple at the very best... Loool...knock yourself  out  now einstein.... Bye!!

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 12:55:17 AM
So
When lee rainbow says inconsistencies in Gerrys statements might lead him to thnk of homicide its a third party? Thats a perfect example of simple at the very best... Loool...knock yourself  out  now einstein.... Bye!!

where is the quote by lee rainbow...its a myth...its propaganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 12:56:48 AM
lee rainbow never said that

It was read out IN COURT under oath but for some INSANE reason we should all believe the little davel poster who says no its not true rotf

 @)(++(*
 @)(++(*

Had enough of this  uttef rubbish >>>>>
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 01:01:42 AM
It was read out IN COURT under oath but for some INSANE reason we should all believe the little davel poster who says no its not true rotf

 @)(++(*
 @)(++(*

Had enough of this  uttef rubbish >>>>>

I know exactly what was said in court....amarals lawyer added his liitle piece on the end and you have swallowed the propaganda...

you have no record of Rainbow's statement
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 01:03:05 AM
It was read out IN COURT under oath but for some INSANE reason we should all believe the little davel poster who says no its not true rotf

 @)(++(*
 @)(++(*

Had enough of this  uttef rubbish >>>>>

it wasn't under oath.....you've got that wrong as well
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 01:25:09 AM
where is the quote by lee rainbow...its a myth...its propaganda

Its been quoted by several uk newspapers  in QUOTES so the propaganda that it does not exist and is a myth  is ALL  YOURS
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 01:26:11 AM
I know exactly what was said in court....amarals lawyer added his liitle piece on the end and you have swallowed the propaganda...

you have no record of Rainbow's statement

prove it then and make us all believers loooool

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 28, 2015, 01:37:34 AM
For you, Mercury. Happy reading.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1163.0
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 28, 2015, 10:57:29 AM
Fact remains lee rainbow suggested possible homicide..a British element recommended sending in a cadaver dog....says it all...vis a vis xtinas post that it was both britishand portuguese suspected them....Undeniable FACT....despite apologists teting to say theres not a shred of evidence for it.....busted....davel and ferryman

What Lee Rainbow actually said ... yet again an example of the propagandists lifting an out of context sentence from ... it would appear the summary of a thirty page report.

There is surely something terribly wrong with a case reliant on such subterfuge.



In the summary of the 30-page report Mr Rainbow wrote: “The potential involvement of the family in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann cannot be discarded, and it can be considered that, when pondering the basis for research, this hypothesis deserves as much attention as the criminal with sexual motivations that has been previously prioritised.


“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family, yet given the absence of decisive evidence to prove the contrary, such a scenario has to be explored.” At court last week, Mr Amaral’s lawyer, Antonio Cabrita, read out a section of 37-year-old Mr Rainbow’s report which said: “The family is a lead that should be followed.”
http://justice4mccannfam.5forum.biz/t2450-what-lee-rainbow-actually-said


http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1163.msg32653#msg32653
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 28, 2015, 10:59:27 AM
For you, Mercury. Happy reading.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1163.0

Snap! Misty ... hadn't reached here yet, still catching up.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 11:23:06 AM
Fact remains lee rainbow suggested possible homicide..a British element recommended sending in a cadaver dog....says it all...vis a vis xtinas post that it was both britishand portuguese suspected them....Undeniable FACT....despite apologists teting to say theres not a shred of evidence for it.....busted....davel and ferryman

what an excellent example of sceptic propoganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 28, 2015, 01:20:51 PM
Lee Rainbow also said in his report that RM "90% fitted the criminal profile of an abductor".
Why is that opinion conveniently overlooked by the sceptics when they promote the idea the UK police suggested possible homicide by the parents because of their behaviour?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 28, 2015, 02:30:16 PM
I know exactly what was said in court....amarals lawyer added his liitle piece on the end and you have swallowed the propaganda...

you have no record of Rainbow's statement

I know exactly what was said in court


was you sat in there then ........................

the thing about all this is it has been said....by top profiles police officers  ...etc etc etc etc

it was there first reaction at what they saw and knew about the case ........they were involved in it [not you it is only ypour own opinion ..a nobody in this case]

why do you think the mccs .hired the top best lawyers ......and what do you think lawyers do ...fgs



This is not the first time that the parents of British girl, who disappeared in Praia da Luz in May 2007, try to silence the theories that contradict the version of the abduction 



mark Harrison

Overall Summary.

This report has highlighted the extensive and professional efforts made by the Portuguese authorities regarding the search to locate Madeleine McCann alive. It has now begun to consider further opportunities to re search locations in order to address the possibility that she has been murdered and concealed nearby. This would be a proportionate and appropriate response given the elapsed time since her disappearance and previous experience in such similar cases. Should the investigators wish to discuss and develop the issues raised in this initial assessment I would be happy to do so. Should further advisory “in country” support be required of the National Search Advisor following this initial assessment phase formal approval must be sought from the NPIA.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id293.html





Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 02:41:48 PM
I know exactly what was said in court


was you sat in there then ........................

the thing about all this is it has been said....by top profiles police officers  ...etc etc etc etc

it was there first reaction at what they saw and knew about the case ........they were involved in it [not you it is only ypour own opinion ..a nobody in this case]

why do you think the mccs .hired the top best lawyers ......and what do you think lawyers do ...fgs



This is not the first time that the parents of British girl, who disappeared in Praia da Luz in May 2007, try to silence the theories that contradict the version of the abduction 



mark Harrison

Overall Summary.

This report has highlighted the extensive and professional efforts made by the Portuguese authorities regarding the search to locate Madeleine McCann alive. It has now begun to consider further opportunities to re search locations in order to address the possibility that she has been murdered and concealed nearby. This would be a proportionate and appropriate response given the elapsed time since her disappearance and previous experience in such similar cases. Should the investigators wish to discuss and develop the issues raised in this initial assessment I would be happy to do so. Should further advisory “in country” support be required of the National Search Advisor following this initial assessment phase formal approval must be sought from the NPIA.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id293.html

there is a misunderstanding by sceptics that UK police thought the McCanns were involved...there is simply no evidence to support that.....all you are doing is reinforcing that fact...the sceptics misunderstand


I would say the McCanns hired top lawyers because they realised  amaral's involvement in the  cipriano case...convicted on next to no evidence
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 28, 2015, 03:28:15 PM
there is a misunderstanding by sceptics that UK police thought the McCanns were involved...there is simply no evidence to support that.....all you are doing is reinforcing that fact...the sceptics misunderstand


I would say the McCanns hired top lawyers because they realised  amaral's involvement in the  cipriano case...convicted on next to no evidence


I would say the McCanns hired top lawyers because they realised  amaral's involvement in the  cipriano case...convicted on next to no evidence

yes well you would say that ....no suprise there then................but it is iyo...oh and cipriano case pathetically brought up

now what statements ..evidence can you show .for the abduction .statements who were there in the first place ...with initial reaction of what they are paid to do .........just show one that says ...yes she was defiantly abducted  because ..............

, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in maddies  disappearance

there is nothing to back up abduction ......nothing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 03:29:18 PM
The last person to see Madeleine looks like SY's prime suspect.

Criminal profiler Lee Rainbow recommended that police on the Algarve investigate the doctor and his wife Kate because of 'contradictions' in his statement.

The report by Mr Rainbow, of the National Policing Improvement Agency, was sent to Portugal in June 2007, a month after the three-year-old disappeared.

Lawyer Antonio Cabrita, reading from a Portuguese translation of the previously- confidential report, said: 'The family is a lead that should be followed.

'The contradictions in Gerald McCann's statement might lead us to suspect a homicide. This is a lead that should be investigated.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1250084/How-letter-UK-police-turned-spotlight-Kate-Gerry-McCann.html

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2010/02/10/article-1250084-083BE5D2000005DC-35_468x382.jpg)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 28, 2015, 03:59:53 PM
The British government's Foreign & Commonwealth Office also made their view clear, post-arguido, in December 2009, when responding to a Freedom of Information request about the missing child, Ben Needham. They wrote: 'You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted.'

It could not be clearer. There is 'no evidence' to support the claim that Madeleine McCann was abducted.


ast week, as part of Scotland Yard's decision to update the public on the progress of their 'investigative review' into the Madeleine McCann case, Detective Chief Inspector Andy Redwood stated: "Neither her parents or any of the member (sic) of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects."

There will be many who will be greatly surprised at those words. Not least the Assistant Chief Constable of Leicestershire Police, who stated in July 2008 that "While one or both of them [the McCanns] may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance." At that time the McCanns were attempting to gain access to all the documents held by Leicester Police regarding the disappearance of their daughter. The request was denied.

But that wasn't the first or last time that British authorities had placed a question mark against the parents insistence that Madeleine was abducted.

Less than a month after Madeleine's reported disappearance, Lee Rainbow, who was at that time Senior Behavioural Investigation Consultant for the NPIA (National Policing Improvement Agency), wrote a report in which he stated: "The potential involvement of the family in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann cannot be discarded, and it can be considered that, when pondering the basis for research, this hypothesis deserves as much attention as the criminal with sexual motivations that has been previously prioritised.

"It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family, yet given the absence of decisive evidence to prove the contrary, such a scenario has to be explored." That report led directly to the arrival of the two operational specialist search dogs which indicated at a number of locations, as well as items, connected to the McCanns. As a result of that intervention, and what the Portuguese police believed to be conclusive DNA evidence, the McCanns were made arguidos (suspects).

The British government's Foreign & Commonwealth Office also made their view clear, post-arguido, in December 2009, when responding to a Freedom of Information request about the missing child, Ben Needham. They wrote: 'You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted.'

It could not be clearer. There is 'no evidence' to support the claim that Madeleine McCann was abducted.

So, are Scotland Yard playing an elaborate game of cat and mouse or are they looking to blindly stick the abduction tail on some unsuspecting donkey? Or are they simply running around like headless chickens in the last throes of their 'investigative review'? Only time will tell. However, it is worth remembering that the words of Chief Inspector Andy Redwood are far from unique.

Countering increased press speculation, in August 2007, about the possible involvement of Madeleine's parents in her disappearance, Portuguese Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa stepped in to clarify the situation. Speaking to the BBC, his words of support mirrored those of Mr Redwood last week. The McCanns, he assured, were "victims of this crime because they have lost their little child" and were not being considered as "suspects in the case". But, as we now know, they were.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 04:23:37 PM
The last person to see Madeleine looks like SY's prime suspect.

Criminal profiler Lee Rainbow recommended that police on the Algarve investigate the doctor and his wife Kate because of 'contradictions' in his statement.

The report by Mr Rainbow, of the National Policing Improvement Agency, was sent to Portugal in June 2007, a month after the three-year-old disappeared.

Lawyer Antonio Cabrita, reading from a Portuguese translation of the previously- confidential report, said: 'The family is a lead that should be followed.

'The contradictions in Gerald McCann's statement might lead us to suspect a homicide. This is a lead that should be investigated.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1250084/How-letter-UK-police-turned-spotlight-Kate-Gerry-McCann.html

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2010/02/10/article-1250084-083BE5D2000005DC-35_468x382.jpg)

The mail quoted a 100% DNA match as well...remember...

You are quoting amarals lawyers words...not Lee rainbow..
rainbow said teh McCanns should be investigated...it is standard practice... I cannot believe he suggested the mccanns should be investigated for homicide...that is utterly ridiculous...and without seeing his report we don't know that he did
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 05:32:57 PM
The mail quoted a 100% DNA match as well...remember...

You are quoting amarals lawyers words...not Lee rainbow..
rainbow said teh McCanns should be investigated...it is standard practice... I cannot believe he suggested the mccanns should be investigated for homicide...that is utterly ridiculous...and without seeing his report we don't know that he did

That is from the report and it was contradictions in his statements not standard practice. It's against the law to lie in court so they didn't get the police files because "While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 28, 2015, 05:53:56 PM
The last person to see Madeleine looks like SY's prime suspect.

Criminal profiler Lee Rainbow recommended that police on the Algarve investigate the doctor and his wife Kate because of 'contradictions' in his statement.

The report by Mr Rainbow, of the National Policing Improvement Agency, was sent to Portugal in June 2007, a month after the three-year-old disappeared.

Lawyer Antonio Cabrita, reading from a Portuguese translation of the previously- confidential report, said: 'The family is a lead that should be followed.

'The contradictions in Gerald McCann's statement might lead us to suspect a homicide. This is a lead that should be investigated.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1250084/How-letter-UK-police-turned-spotlight-Kate-Gerry-McCann.html

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2010/02/10/article-1250084-083BE5D2000005DC-35_468x382.jpg)

Quote
Lawyer Antonio Cabrita, reading from a Portuguese translation of the previously- confidential report, said: 'The family is a lead that should be followed. pathfinder73
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6877.msg296269#msg296269

Quote
Are you sure Lee Rainbow said "The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"? AnneGuedes        http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1163.msg32955#msg32955



Mr Amaral's lawyer did not present Lee Rainbow's alleged opinion in court ... merely dropped it in during closing statements at a time when it was inadmissible as evidence ... wonder why that would have been.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 28, 2015, 05:58:13 PM
That is from the report and it was contradictions in his statements not standard practice. It's against the law to lie in court so they didn't get the police files because "While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

Lee Rainbow was not questioned about his confidential report in open court ... so what point are you making?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 06:09:23 PM
Lee Rainbow was not questioned about his confidential report in open court ... so what point are you making?

The truth will come out in court. The rest is meaningless about non suspects etc.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 06:16:46 PM
That is from the report and it was contradictions in his statements not standard practice. It's against the law to lie in court so they didn't get the police files because "While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

you don't know what was from the report and what was added as opinion by amarals lawyer......
there is no clear evidence that eliminates the mccanns  just as there is no clear evidence that eliminates the needhams..


your post is typical sceptic propaganda.... amarals lawyer didn't lie he gave his opinion...which he is perfectly entitled to in court
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 06:27:00 PM
Cabrita added: "This report has never been published before but is part of the investigation."

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id308.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 06:40:09 PM
Cabrita added: "This report has never been published before but is part of the investigation."

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id308.html

if the sceptics want to believe what cabrita said was accurate ...that's up to them. My perception is that rainbow said the McCanns should be investigated and the cabrita added his own comment.
Without seeing the actual report no one knows the truth
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 28, 2015, 07:15:07 PM
Lee Rainbow was not questioned about his confidential report in open court ... so what point are you making?


you are ok dissing every thing.......calling every one who supports a non abduction

now what proof have you got there was a abduction sweetie

can you show us ...............................anything

or do you just make up the numbers
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 07:46:32 PM
So what do we have here

- statements that no one has seen Rainbows report so cannot say what is true or not in the court  quotes published in the media

- coupled with statements that Amarals lawyer committed perjury, that Rainbow didnt say this or that but did say this

 @)(++(*

- coupled with Amarals lawyer did quote a correct and correctly translated part of Rainbows report but that he added his own comments ....makes as much sense as previous illogical assertions/claims

Then backtracking from bold statements of blatant lies myths and propaganda   to "that is my perception"

All a little confuddled and disjointed IMO

You cant have your cake and eat it








Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 07:50:37 PM
So what do we have here

- statements that no one has seen Rainbows report so cannot say what is true or not in the court  quotes published in the media

- coupled with statements that Amarals lawyer committed perjury, that Rainbow didnt say this or that but did say this

 @)(++(*

- coupled with Amarals lawyer did quote a correct and correctly translated part of Rainbows report but that he added his own comments ....makes as much sense as previous illogical assertions/claims

Then backtracking from bold statements of blatant lies myths and propaganda   to "that is my perception"

All a little confuddled and disjointed IMO

You cant have your cake and eat it
Not really
We were having a civilised debate
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 08:04:55 PM
Not really
We were having a civilised debate

That ^ is not an answer by any stretch and the words you posted do one thing only - evade the issues...not a good "debating technique"

Never mind hey?

lol

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 08:15:18 PM
That ^ is not an answer by any stretch and the words you posted do one thing only - evade the issues...not a good "debating technique"

Never mind hey?

lol

I've explained everything already
If you still don't understand best left
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 08:24:51 PM
I've explained everything already
If you still don't understand best left

Oh I understand  perfectly, make no mistake...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 08:30:24 PM
Oh I understand  perfectly, make no mistake...

As well as you understand Grime perhaps
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 08:37:03 PM
As well as you understand Grime perhaps

There is nothng at all that Mr Grime has said that I do not understand, stop goading and changing the subject

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 08:39:44 PM
There is nothng at all that Mr Grime has said that I do not understand, stop goading and changing the subject

You recently posted that Grime said the dogs "probably " alerted to cadaver odour
A complete fabrication
But part of the propaganda
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 09:08:29 PM
You recently posted that Grime said the dogs "probably " alerted to cadaver odour
A complete fabrication
But part of the propaganda


Did I, where? Because that is impossible luv, I dont doctor police  statements
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 09:11:46 PM
Did I, where?

You might have forgotten but I haven't
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: mercury on December 28, 2015, 09:13:02 PM
You might have forgotten but I haven't

i certainly never posted thatyou accuse, you prove luv
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 09:15:24 PM
work began, with the dog Eddy, that detects cadaver odour, examining the whole level of the underground car park where the vehicles were parked, it having been verified the following result:
15h27 - the dog 'marked' car number 4 - Renault Scenic - rental vehicle currently used by Gerry and Kate McCann.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm

My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

Processos Vol X
Pages 2533 - 2534

Date: 2007/09/03

For : Goncalo Amaral

From Ricardo Paiva, Inspector

Subject: Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

During the course of the ongoing investigation, various personal contacts were made by the undersigned with Kate and Gerald McCann, within my task of serving as communication element between the police and the McCann couple.

Within this context, the undersigned was present during various "strange" behaviours by the couple, who gradually began to react in a very negative manner to the increased investigative activity carried out by this police force, especially during the use of the English sniffer dogs for detecting cadaver odour, when more evidence arose in the investigation for the hypothesis of the death of Madeleine McCann.

Several times, the McCann couple said that the attention of the police should be maintained focussing on the abduction hypothesis, which, in the couple's opinion, was the only scenario that occurred and that the police should not forget to continue to investigate the suspect Robert Murat.

Strangely, Kate also made several requests, three months after the disappearance of Madeleine, that the police should take blood, hair and nail tests of Madeleine's twin siblings, because, as she said, she remembered that on the day of Madeleine's disappearance, in spite of all the commotion and noise made by the authorities and other persons who were looking for Madeleine in apartment 5ª of the Ocean Club, the twins never woke up, having been transported to another apartment, they remained asleep, due to which she now presumes that they were under the effect of some sedative drug that a presumed abductor had administered to the three children in order to be able to abduct Madeleine, a situation which Kate refers to being possible according to what she read in a criminal investigation manual given to her by the British authorities, that would have been the procedure of the abductor in the real case involving abduction, rape and murder of the girl.

Today, when the undersigned went to the McCann's temporary residence to notify them of the need to present themselves at the police station to make statements, being able to take their lawyer with them, Kate McCann immediately reacted in a negative manner, making comments such as "what are my parents going to think" and "what is the press going to say when they find out" and that "the Portuguese police is under pressure from the government to finish the investigation quickly".

With regard to Gerald McCann, he constantly insisted in giving the undersigned letters and emails that he was receiving, mostly from psychics and mediums, whom he had selected and which mainly contained information without much credibility about the possible whereabouts of Madeleine and her presumed abductor.

More recently, and even before Kate's interrogation, during a telephone call between Gerald McCann and the undersigned, he made a reference regarding the investigation, that he was certain that the police did not have any proof that could incriminate them with regard to the death of Madeleine McCann and he said that the police were wasting their time in directing the investigation around the parents.

I bring this to your knowledge.
Inspector
Ricardo Paiva
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 09:22:35 PM
work began, with the dog Eddy, that detects cadaver odour, examining the whole level of the underground car park where the vehicles were parked, it having been verified the following result:
15h27 - the dog 'marked' car number 4 - Renault Scenic - rental vehicle currently used by Gerry and Kate McCann.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm

My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

Processos Vol X
Pages 2533 - 2534

Date: 2007/09/03

For : Goncalo Amaral

From Ricardo Paiva, Inspector

Subject: Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

During the course of the ongoing investigation, various personal contacts were made by the undersigned with Kate and Gerald McCann, within my task of serving as communication element between the police and the McCann couple.

Within this context, the undersigned was present during various "strange" behaviours by the couple, who gradually began to react in a very negative manner to the increased investigative activity carried out by this police force, especially during the use of the English sniffer dogs for detecting cadaver odour, when more evidence arose in the investigation for the hypothesis of the death of Madeleine McCann.

Several times, the McCann couple said that the attention of the police should be maintained focussing on the abduction hypothesis, which, in the couple's opinion, was the only scenario that occurred and that the police should not forget to continue to investigate the suspect Robert Murat.

Strangely, Kate also made several requests, three months after the disappearance of Madeleine, that the police should take blood, hair and nail tests of Madeleine's twin siblings, because, as she said, she remembered that on the day of Madeleine's disappearance, in spite of all the commotion and noise made by the authorities and other persons who were looking for Madeleine in apartment 5ª of the Ocean Club, the twins never woke up, having been transported to another apartment, they remained asleep, due to which she now presumes that they were under the effect of some sedative drug that a presumed abductor had administered to the three children in order to be able to abduct Madeleine, a situation which Kate refers to being possible according to what she read in a criminal investigation manual given to her by the British authorities, that would have been the procedure of the abductor in the real case involving abduction, rape and murder of the girl.

Today, when the undersigned went to the McCann's temporary residence to notify them of the need to present themselves at the police station to make statements, being able to take their lawyer with them, Kate McCann immediately reacted in a negative manner, making comments such as "what are my parents going to think" and "what is the press going to say when they find out" and that "the Portuguese police is under pressure from the government to finish the investigation quickly".

With regard to Gerald McCann, he constantly insisted in giving the undersigned letters and emails that he was receiving, mostly from psychics and mediums, whom he had selected and which mainly contained information without much credibility about the possible whereabouts of Madeleine and her presumed abductor.

More recently, and even before Kate's interrogation, during a telephone call between Gerald McCann and the undersigned, he made a reference regarding the investigation, that he was certain that the police did not have any proof that could incriminate them with regard to the death of Madeleine McCann and he said that the police were wasting their time in directing the investigation around the parents.

I bring this to your knowledge.
Inspector
Ricardo Paiva

Grime said it was suggestive...not that it was
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 28, 2015, 09:30:23 PM
Eddie goes in first to detect cadaver odour. Keela goes in second to detect any blood.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 28, 2015, 09:35:40 PM
Eddie goes in first to detect cadaver odour. Keela goes in second to detect any blood.

and the alerts are meaningless without forensic confirmation
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 28, 2015, 09:42:58 PM

you are ok dissing every thing.......calling every one who supports a non abduction

now what proof have you got there was a abduction sweetie

can you show us ...............................anything

or do you just make up the numbers

(http://i843.photobucket.com/albums/zz357/JillyCL/DailyWail/Daily%20Wail%202/mccannlindyMS1509_468x377.jpg)

                   
There is only one truly solid fact out in the open, and that is that Madeleine has gone missing.
Too many of our ideas about investigations come from TV programmes and novels. Within an hour of watching, viewers have seen all the forensic evidence and solved the crime. Better still, we have been led to feel we know the answer from early on.

Real life is not like that. Sometimes, as in my case, it can take years of hard work to establish the truth for all to see.

In the long run it cost us £2.3million in a country where you are supposedly innocent before being proved guilty.
Lindy Chamberlain

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic1046.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 28, 2015, 10:17:18 PM
(http://i843.photobucket.com/albums/zz357/JillyCL/DailyWail/Daily%20Wail%202/mccannlindyMS1509_468x377.jpg)

                   
There is only one truly solid fact out in the open, and that is that Madeleine has gone missing.
Too many of our ideas about investigations come from TV programmes and novels. Within an hour of watching, viewers have seen all the forensic evidence and solved the crime. Better still, we have been led to feel we know the answer from early on.

Real life is not like that. Sometimes, as in my case, it can take years of hard work to establish the truth for all to see.

In the long run it cost us £2.3million in a country where you are supposedly innocent before being proved guilty.
Lindy Chamberlain

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic1046.html

This article was published long before the release of the files and while Lindy Chamberlain, along with most of the rest of the world, had no idea what evidence against the McCanns the PJ had in their possession and while she may be the much-wronged victim of an over-enthusiastic justice system, she is not clairvoyant and her opinion, at that time, carried no more weight than any other individual commenting on the case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 28, 2015, 11:55:06 PM
This article was published long before the release of the files and while Lindy Chamberlain, along with most of the rest of the world, had no idea what evidence against the McCanns the PJ had in their possession and while she may be the much-wronged victim of an over-enthusiastic justice system, she is not clairvoyant and her opinion, at that time, carried no more weight than any other individual commenting on the case.
This is the main crux of her argument - as true today as the day she wrote it, or do you disagree, and if so on what basis?

"The rush to judgment seems irresistible; but if I have learned anything it is this: that, from our position in front of the TV screens or outspread newspapers, we ordinary members of the public do not - and cannot - know the truth of what occurred that May night in Praia da Luz".
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 12:20:48 AM
This is the main crux of her argument - as true today as the day she wrote it, or do you disagree, and if so on what basis?

"The rush to judgment seems irresistible; but if I have learned anything it is this: that, from our position in front of the TV screens or outspread newspapers, we ordinary members of the public do not - and cannot - know the truth of what occurred that May night in Praia da Luz".

I don't disagree with the main crux of her argument. What I do disagree with is supporters suggesting that Lindy in some way supported the innocence of the McCanns when she could have had no way of knowing the evidence against them at the time of the piece. It's the old 'you see other parents of missing children support the McCanns and they should know ' trick.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 08:38:28 AM
I don't disagree with the main crux of her argument. What I do disagree with is supporters suggesting that Lindy in some way supported the innocence of the McCanns when she could have had no way of knowing the evidence against them at the time of the piece. It's the old 'you see other parents of missing children support the McCanns and they should know ' trick.
Well there's several parents of missing children who have vocally supported the McCanns since the files were published so it's not really a trick is it?  It's undeniable.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 10:33:08 AM
Well there's several parents of missing children who have vocally supported the McCanns since the files were published so it's not really a trick is it?  It's undeniable.

every parent of  a missing child I can think of supports the McCanns....in fact it's hard to think of anyone in the public eye who doesn't support them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 10:34:09 AM
work began, with the dog Eddy, that detects cadaver odour, examining the whole level of the underground car park where the vehicles were parked, it having been verified the following result:
15h27 - the dog 'marked' car number 4 - Renault Scenic - rental vehicle currently used by Gerry and Kate McCann.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm

My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.

snipped



Why have you taken just that one sentence out of context?

The full context is :-

Quote
My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.       This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.

unquote

IMO the sentence should be read in context - to ensure that a different 'meaning ' to the one intended by M.Grime in that part of his statement  - will not be conveyed to the reader. 


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 10:39:53 AM
Why have you taken just that one sentence out of context?

The full context is :-

Quote
My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.       This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.

unquote

IMO the sentence should be read in context - to ensure that a different 'meaning ' to the one intended by M.Grime in that part of his statement  - will not be conveyed to the reader.

it's called propaganda Benice...and we are seeing lots of examples of it from the sceptics
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 10:47:44 AM
Why have you taken just that one sentence out of context?

The full context is :-

Quote
My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.       This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.

unquote

IMO the sentence should be read in context - to ensure that a different 'meaning ' to the one intended by M.Grime in that part of his statement  - will not be conveyed to the reader.


so the alerts are not evidence or intelligence...they are therefore absolutely useless and tell us nothing
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 29, 2015, 10:56:58 AM
Why have you taken just that one sentence out of context?

The full context is :-

Quote
My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.       This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.

unquote

IMO the sentence should be read in context - to ensure that a different 'meaning ' to the one intended by M.Grime in that part of his statement  - will not be conveyed to the reader.

So you can tell me how certain items of clothes got contaminated? Let's hear it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 11:19:05 AM
Well there's several parents of missing children who have vocally supported the McCanns since the files were published so it's not really a trick is it?  It's undeniable.

And how many of those parents have read those files do you think ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 11:19:45 AM

so the alerts are not evidence or intelligence...they are therefore absolutely useless and tell us nothing

In the real world in a real investigation they would have merited hardly a mention ... there must be many instances when similar investigative occurrences have failed to produce the required evidence, forcing a different tack.

In this instance looking for fresh investigative avenues was not pursued.  The 'findings' of the dogs were added to the pejorative propaganda of 'swingers' and '100% Madeleine's DNA' in the hope that what had worked in Cipriano would work yet again in McCann.

That it is nonsense is proved by lack of charge of the targets.

That it is efficacy as propaganda is proved by a quick glance at any sceptic website or comment arena such as Mr Amaral's Go fund me appeal.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 11:22:35 AM
And how many of those parents have read those files do you think ?

b....r all, in all likelihood.

Also, how many of these other parents actually know, there is no evidence which shows an abduction took place ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 11:25:24 AM
So you can tell me how certain items of clothes got contaminated? Let's hear it.

That is indeed a bit of a mystery.

I think the question may actually be were they contaminated at all by anything?  Eddie did not take any notice of them although he had free access to them in the villa and the places where they had been.

Picking them up in his mouth and throwing them around in the gymnasium most certainly was not his trained response.

What was it Mark Harrison said about that?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 11:28:08 AM
So you can tell me how certain items of clothes got contaminated? Let's hear it.
[/b]

LOL why do  I get the feeling you are shooting the messenger?   Cross- contamination is MG's claim not mine.

IMO it was interesting that even Martin Grime thought it important enough  to mention that out of all of the boxes/cases required to pack up all their clothes etc -  that all the items 'alerted' to by Eddie just happened to have been packed into the same one box at the villa.      What are the chances of that happening by sheer chance?   Must be millions to one IMO.   What do you think?




Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 11:33:45 AM
[/b]

LOL why do  I get the feeling you are shooting the messenger?   Cross- contamination is MG's claim not mine.

IMO it was interesting that even Martin Grime thought it important enough  to mention that out of all of the boxes/cases required to pack up all their clothes etc -  that all the items 'alerted' to by Eddie just happened to have been packed into the same one box at the villa.      What are the chances of that happening by sheer chance?   Must be millions to one IMO.   What do you think?

I can think of no logical reason why the clothing was taken to the gymnasium.  As far as I can see it is one of the strangest conundrums in the bizarre conduct of this investigation.

Eddie did not alert to it in the villa.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 11:34:37 AM
And how many of those parents have read those files do you think ?
No idea.  One doesn't need to have read the files, the conclusion of the PT AG which was published when the case was shelved tells everyone what they need to know - no evidence of any crime committed by the McCanns or Robert Murat.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 11:40:05 AM
In the real world in a real investigation they would have merited hardly a mention ... there must be many instances when similar investigative occurrences have failed to produce the required evidence, forcing a different tack.

In this instance looking for fresh investigative avenues was not pursued.  The 'findings' of the dogs were added to the pejorative propaganda of 'swingers' and '100% Madeleine's DNA' in the hope that what had worked in Cipriano would work yet again in McCann.

That it is nonsense is proved by lack of charge of the targets.

That it is efficacy as propaganda is proved by a quick glance at any sceptic website or comment arena such as Mr Amaral's Go fund me appeal.

The similarities in pattern are unmistakeable IMO - even down to the claimed usage of a fridge.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 11:44:13 AM
So you can tell me how certain items of clothes got contaminated? Let's hear it.

you have everything back to front...as did the pj....its up to grime to explain the alerts...not us or the McCanns...so tell us what explanation Grime gave and we can go from there
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 11:45:23 AM
b....r all, in all likelihood.

Also, how many of these other parents actually know, there is no evidence which shows an abduction took place ?

they know there is no evidence against the McCANNS that's what's important
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 29, 2015, 11:52:04 AM
Why have you taken just that one sentence out of context?

The full context is :-

Quote
My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant.       This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.

unquote

IMO the sentence should be read in context - to ensure that a different 'meaning ' to the one intended by M.Grime in that part of his statement  - will not be conveyed to the reader.

Grime trained and worked with his dogs and was very sure about their abilities;

The dogs' passive CSI alert provides an indication as per their training and does not vary. They only give an alert when they are 'positive' that the target of the odour is present and immediately accessible.....EVRD does not make a distinction; he responds with a certain behaviour for which he was trained when he recognizes an odour. He does not identify the reasons for the presence of the odour nor does he identify suspects......The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained..It also should be taken into account that the procedures for forensic testing are still less discriminating than the system of dogs' smell. ....
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_RIGATORY.htm

When he gives his professional opinion, therefore, it is based on the above belief in his dogs. When it comes to the legal position he reminds that there is a burden of proof which must be met; dog alerts or their handler's opinion won't stand up in court, forensics are required.

The question to be addressed is whether to dismiss the expert's opinion because the forensic team didn't get sufficient evidence for a court case. If investigators dismiss alerts completely which can't be verified they would look silly if the dogs were later proved correct. if they rely on the alerts completely they would again look silly if another scenario is proved correct. The sensible approach seems to be to keep the alerts in mind during the investigation as they suggest one possible scenario.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 29, 2015, 11:58:56 AM
No idea.  One doesn't need to have read the files, the conclusion of the PT AG which was published when the case was shelved tells everyone what they need to know - no evidence of any crime committed by the McCanns or Robert Murat.

And, as the Assistant Chief Constable of Leicestershire Constabulary pointed out, no evidence of innocence either. So they are still at square one. No evidence they did anything, no evidence that anyone else did anything.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 12:03:06 PM
Looking at the reports that concentrated on the dog searches what I find interesting is where the dogs DIDN'T alert as much as where the did. So many properties and not one alert yet multiple alerts in properties and objects connected to the McCanns. Does anyone really believe that this is a coincidence ?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 12:18:34 PM
And, as the Assistant Chief Constable of Leicestershire Constabulary pointed out, no evidence of innocence either. So they are still at square one. No evidence they did anything, no evidence that anyone else did anything.

IMO that quote from 2008 (which took into account the fact that the McCanns were still arguidos) -  has long been superseded by SY's statement that the McCanns are not suspects.



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 12:26:39 PM
And, as the Assistant Chief Constable of Leicestershire Constabulary pointed out, no evidence of innocence either. So they are still at square one. No evidence they did anything, no evidence that anyone else did anything.
I wasn't aware he had said this - do you have the exact quote, and the date when he said it?  Thanks.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 12:27:00 PM
Looking at the reports that concentrated on the dog searches what I find interesting is where the dogs DIDN'T alert as much as where the did. So many properties and not one alert yet multiple alerts in properties and objects connected to the McCanns. Does anyone really believe that this is a coincidence ?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
No.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 12:31:23 PM
Looking at the reports that concentrated on the dog searches what I find interesting is where the dogs DIDN'T alert as much as where the did. So many properties and not one alert yet multiple alerts in properties and objects connected to the McCanns. Does anyone really believe that this is a coincidence ?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

IMO it was down to the amount of time spent at each location. 

If not then we are supposed to believe that not a drop of blood or any other alertable cellular material had been deposited in any of those other apartments/cars for years and years on end.   I simply don't buy that.

IMO If the same attention and time had been given to other locations -  then in view of the dog's remarkable abilities to detect the tiniest of odours even from decades ago - more alerts would have occurred.


Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 12:39:26 PM
Grime trained and worked with his dogs and was very sure about their abilities;

The dogs' passive CSI alert provides an indication as per their training and does not vary. They only give an alert when they are 'positive' that the target of the odour is present and immediately accessible.....EVRD does not make a distinction; he responds with a certain behaviour for which he was trained when he recognizes an odour. He does not identify the reasons for the presence of the odour nor does he identify suspects......The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained..It also should be taken into account that the procedures for forensic testing are still less discriminating than the system of dogs' smell. ....
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_RIGATORY.htm

When he gives his professional opinion, therefore, it is based on the above belief in his dogs. When it comes to the legal position he reminds that there is a burden of proof which must be met; dog alerts or their handler's opinion won't stand up in court, forensics are required.

The question to be addressed is whether to dismiss the expert's opinion because the forensic team didn't get sufficient evidence for a court case. If investigators dismiss alerts completely which can't be verified they would look silly if the dogs were later proved correct. if they rely on the alerts completely they would again look silly if another scenario is proved correct. The sensible approach seems to be to keep the alerts in mind during the investigation as they suggest one possible scenario.

Grime said...in my opinion...the alerts are suggestive... grime could have said...in my opinion the dogs ARE alerting to cadaver scent..he didn't...

That doesn't sound very sure to me and that is an actual quote from Grime...he cannot change that..if ever he appears in any case in court he will be reminded of that.

As regards looking silly...that's absolute rubbish again. Redwood has said Maddie may still be alive...he is prepared to disregard the alert and he is on record as saying so.

The so called alerts are used by the sceptics as propaganda

without confirmation the alerts are useless because they tell us nothing...that's a fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 29, 2015, 12:39:44 PM
every parent of  a missing child I can think of supports the McCanns....in fact it's hard to think of anyone in the public eye who doesn't support them


what sort of propaganda is this then

every parent of  a missing child I can think of supports the McCanns....in fact it's hard to think of anyone in the public eye who doesn't support them

how do you know they support the mccs ...they are not going to come out and say they don't are they ...and i think in reality ...they have there own child missing ...so i think you might find the mccs are not on there priority list...

as for the public eye ....get real ....half of them are fed the abduction theory .....that's all they are allowed to know .. ..the other side most of the % of the public aren't bothered and fed up of the mccs whining.because [the mccs sowed there own seed when they left there babies alone].....

the other side of the coin is censored....all the time this is happening ......you will never ...never know what actual support the mccs have babe.....you only think you know
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 01:05:52 PM

what sort of propaganda is this then

every parent of  a missing child I can think of supports the McCanns....in fact it's hard to think of anyone in the public eye who doesn't support them

how do you know they support the mccs ...they are not going to come out and say they don't are they ...and i think in reality ...they have there own child missing ...so i think you might find the mccs are not on there priority list...

as for the public eye ....get real ....half of them are fed the abduction theory .....that's all they are allowed to know .. ..the other side most of the % of the public aren't bothered and fed up of the mccs whining.because [the mccs sowed there own seed when they left there babies alone].....

the other side of the coin is censored....all the time this is happening ......you will never ...never know what actual support the mccs have babe.....you only think you know

I am going by what they have stated publicly...you can assume they are all liars that's up to you
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 01:07:34 PM
And, as the Assistant Chief Constable of Leicestershire Constabulary pointed out, no evidence of innocence either. So they are still at square one. No evidence they did anything, no evidence that anyone else did anything.

square one is innocence..as I have pointed out...there is no evidence the Needhams are innocent...yopu are simply throwing mud and hoping some of it sticks
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 01:14:49 PM
they know there is no evidence against the McCANNS that's what's important


Really.

How do you know what they have been told, bearing in  mind the crime is yet unknown, and it has not been determined how Madeleine was removed from the apartment.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 29, 2015, 01:18:17 PM

Really.

How do you know what they have been told, bearing in  mind the crime is yet unknown, and it has not been determined how Madeleine was removed from the apartment.

How much effort was made to investigate abduction as a thesis?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 01:21:48 PM
I am going by what they have stated publicly...you can assume they are all liars that's up to you

In the meantime who is the beneficiary of the on-going diatribe of propaganda directed against the parents, family and friends of Madeleine McCann?
I think until the success of the campaign being waged by her parents to have Madeleine's case reviewed and Scotland Yard finding the real inconsistencies enabling it to be reopened ... the perpetrators must have slept soundly.

Now that after all these years of being brutally ignored by the investigative authorities why are there those who still ill wish any progress made in the attempt to find out what happened to Madeleine McCann?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 01:22:19 PM

Really.

How do you know what they have been told, bearing in  mind the crime is yet unknown, and it has not been determined how Madeleine was removed from the apartment.

crime unknown...so did the McCanns decide to murder Maddie..no accident ...just first degree murder...do you think that is possible
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 29, 2015, 01:22:34 PM
How much effort was made to investigate abduction as a thesis?

Isn't that what SY are supposed to have been doing for several years, now?

With no apparent success.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 01:31:40 PM
Isn't that what SY are supposed to have been doing for several years, now?

With no apparent success.

The 'golden hours' when an investigation into a missing child has most chance of being found had been squandered many years before the present involvement of Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria.

The ongoing propaganda campaign directed against Madeleine's parents may in some measure be a deflection from that dereliction of the original investigation.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 29, 2015, 01:36:51 PM
The 'golden hours' when an investigation into a missing child has most chance of being found had been squandered many years before the present involvement of Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria.

The ongoing propaganda campaign directed against Madeleine's parents may in some measure be a deflection from that dereliction of the original investigation.

In light of that, do you consider that the current round of investigation is a waste of time ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 01:50:37 PM
Isn't that what SY are supposed to have been doing for several years, now?

With no apparent success.

at least they have discovered enough to rule out the parents
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 01:51:35 PM
How much effort was made to investigate abduction as a thesis?

Well there was the first investigation, which found nothing to support abduction, and the current ones have found.................
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 01:52:55 PM
at least they have discovered enough to rule out the parents

Well all we have discovered to date, is that the current teams have found nothing at all.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 01:54:29 PM
How much effort was made to investigate abduction as a thesis?

Well SY seem to have investigated it to the nth degree 'as a thesis' and still come up empty handed after nearly 5 years.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 29, 2015, 02:06:23 PM
crime unknown...so did the McCanns decide to murder Maddie..no accident ...just first degree murder...do you think that is possible




seems like this is entrapment post to me ......

mind you though it does show your mentality ...

same as in your reply to me

davel quote

I am going by what they have stated publicly...you can assume they are all liars that's up to you


you used the word liars ....not me

why all this twisting of posters words ...whats your agenda ....

because to me it only makes you loose credibility ......for anyone who reads your posts or what you say in them
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 02:18:39 PM
In light of that, do you consider that the current round of investigation is a waste of time ?

From what I have read of your posts you appear to be the one with negative expectation for the current investigation.

Perhaps I have not allowed myself to be indoctrinated by the negative propaganda which might or might not have had an effect upon you.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 02:24:28 PM
Well all we have discovered to date, is that the current teams have found nothing at all.

We have all discovered to date that we haven't a clue as to what the current teams have found.  Which is as it should be.  The fact they continue to investigate shows there is something still to be investigated.
They do not operate in a vacuum.  They have to justify expenditure.  As long as they continue looking in my opinion means there is justification to do so.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:28:58 PM



seems like this is entrapment post to me ......

mind you though it does show your mentality ...

same as in your reply to me

davel quote

I am going by what they have stated publicly...you can assume they are all liars that's up to you


you used the word liars ....not me

why all this twisting of posters words ...whats your agenda ....

because to me it only makes you loose credibility ......for anyone who reads your posts or what you say in them

i have no credibility to you or some others on this forum yet a lot of respect and credibility from others so your opinion of me is of no importance.
i am simply saying I am going by what these poeple say....it doesn't uit your agenda so you don'tw ant to believe it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:29:34 PM
Well all we have discovered to date, is that the current teams have found nothing at all.

no..wrong..they have ruled out the parents
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:32:22 PM
We have all discovered to date that we haven't a clue as to what the current teams have found.  Which is as it should be.  The fact they continue to investigate shows there is something still to be investigated.
They do not operate in a vacuum.  They have to justify expenditure.  As long as they continue looking in my opinion means there is justification to do so.

If they had found what happened to Madeleine, it would be very clear cut.

The mere fact that they still request help from people contacting them says everything.

They literally and metaphorically don't have a clue.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:34:49 PM
no..wrong..they have ruled out the parents

No matter what you type the facts remain.

CRIME UNKNOWN.

THE MCCANNS REMAIN THE LAST KNOWN PEOPLE TO SEE HER ALIVE.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Benice on December 29, 2015, 02:36:57 PM
If they had found what happened to Madeleine, it would be very clear cut.

The mere fact that they still request help from people contacting them says everything.

They literally and metaphorically don't have a clue.

In your own words Stephen:-

''After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on.''
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:37:42 PM
No matter what you type the facts remain.

CRIME UNKNOWN.

THE MCCANNS REMAIN THE LAST KNOWN PEOPLE TO SEE HER ALIVE.

I have ruled out Maddie being the victim of murder by her parents.......every sane person would agree with me...that proves certain scenarios can be ruled out ..fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:37:56 PM
In your own words Stephen:-

''After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on.''

Judgement by results Benice.

There aren't any.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 29, 2015, 02:40:49 PM
Judgement by results Benice.

There aren't any.


Did anyone really expect there to be any?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:41:58 PM
I have ruled out Maddie being the victim of murder by her parents.......every sane person would agree with me...that proves certain scenarios can be ruled out ..fact

Your views are irrelevant, however, the facts I listed remain , no matter your propaganda.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 29, 2015, 02:42:29 PM
Judgement by results Benice.

There aren't any.

You are consistently critical of Operation Grange.

How would you judge the investigation by the PJ, coordinated by G Amaral?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:43:15 PM
Judgement by results Benice.

There aren't any.

since when have the police been judged purely on results.....in line with other professions results in one case are not representative of anyones ability...you do spout some rubbish sometimes
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:44:11 PM
Your views are irrelevant, however, the facts I listed remain , no matter your propaganda.

you havent stated a fact...you have stated an opinion....do you not realise that
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:44:50 PM
since when have the police been judged purely on results.....in line with other professions results in one case are not representative of anyones ability...you do spout some rubbish sometimes

They have found nothing.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:46:35 PM
You are consistently critical of Operation Grange.

How would you judge the investigation by the PJ, coordinated by G Amaral?

How long was he coordinator ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:49:14 PM
They have found nothing.

you do not know that...fact...that is your opinion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 02:50:52 PM
you do not know that...fact...that is your opinion

Have they found Madeleine ?

You and your fellows can type what you wish.

Madeleine has not been found and the investigation is at a dead end.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 29, 2015, 02:51:56 PM
How long was he coordinator ?

A few months, then whoosh, gone.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:52:11 PM
Have they found Madeleine ?

You and your fellows can type what you wish.

Madeleine has not been found and the investigation is at a dead end.

you posted..

They have found nothing...that is not a fact its your opinion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 02:59:10 PM
A few months, then whoosh, gone.

yes...he was sacked because he was critical of the UK police for supporting the McCanns...that's a fact and on record
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: jassi on December 29, 2015, 03:09:54 PM
yes...he was sacked because he was critical of the UK police for supporting the McCanns...that's a fact and on record


I don't doubt it.   However, his removal hasn't led to any resolution of Madeleine's disappearance.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 03:15:59 PM

I don't doubt it.   However, his removal hasn't led to any resolution of Madeleine's disappearance.

perhaps if we had had a decent investigation from the start there would have been a resolution. There can be no argument that amarals handling of the case was pitiful
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 04:06:59 PM
perhaps if we had had a decent investigation from the start there would have been a resolution. There can be no argument that amarals handling of the case was pitiful

He was coordinator for a short time.

He was quite right in objecting into interference.

It was also the UK police who told the PJ to investigate the parents.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 04:08:30 PM
you posted..

They have found nothing...that is not a fact its your opinion

They haven't found Madeleine or how she disappeared.

Do try and keep up with events.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 29, 2015, 04:11:59 PM
perhaps if we had had a decent investigation from the start there would have been a resolution. There can be no argument that amarals handling of the case was pitiful


G.A. did the best ...........he was allowed to do

he was there................he read the doubters reports to the abduction theory,,,both UK/Portuguese

IMO .he was on the right track.............he is not to blame he is just another mcc casualty...

same as maddie..................the mccs are responsible for her fate ...not Goncalo Ameral




http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 04:13:31 PM

G.A. did the best ...........he was allowed to do

he was there................he read the doubters reports to the abduction theory,,,both UK/Portuguese

IMO .he was on the right track.............he is not to blame he is just another mcc casualty...

same as maddie..................the mccs are responsible for her fate ...not Goncalo Ameral




http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html

he misunderstood the dogs and the dna..that is an absolute fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 04:14:15 PM
They haven't found Madeleine or how she disappeared.

Do try and keep up with events.

you posted..

They have found nothing...that is not a fact its your opinion
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 04:19:33 PM
you posted..

They have found nothing...that is not a fact its your opinion

Read my previous reply. 8)--))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 04:22:15 PM
Read my previous reply. 8)--))

none of us know what SY have or haven't found..fact...none of your posts have addressed that fact
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 04:35:41 PM
none of us know what SY have or haven't found..fact...none of your posts have addressed that fact

Unless you are living on fantasy island, it is undeniable they haven't found Madeleine or how she disappeared.

Any reply denying those points is merely propaganda.

Amy guest reading the forum can ascertain that for themselves.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: xtina on December 29, 2015, 04:47:46 PM
he misunderstood the dogs and the dna..that is an absolute fact




why do you think the mccs....let 20 or so people in the apartment .destroying evidence...when k MC knew straight away maddie had been abducted.........evidence lost forever....if there was any cos they certainly wasn't any when they had all gone,was there



what is a fact............................i don't think he will loose any sleep over what you think ov him  8**8:/:



   
Conversation among policemen...


He would, later on and as a natural and logical consequence of his professional career and his life, apply to become a Criminal Investigation Coordinator, and as expected, he was promoted to that functional category soon afterwards.

Then...

Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?

Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.

Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.

None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.

If this strategy catches in the future, tomorrow, when facing powerful, well connected arguidos, it could be other investigators who suffer this ordeal. It could be any one of us. And that may, in a way, mean the end of criminal investigation. At least in the way that we see it and develop it.

May this case be an object for reflection. And an example. And may it allow for us to create ways to avoid its repetition. The ASFICPJ should, maybe, analyse all of this situation, in a serious, conscientious and exhaustive manner. It is its obligation, too.

My friend Gonçalo, I sincerely regret your leaving the Polícia Judiciária, which seems precocious to me, because I admit that you still had a lot to give to the cause of Society, of Justice and of Public Service. Furthermore, our "House" does not own that many resources, both in quality and in quantity, to be able to afford not profiting from them, or, even worse, wasting them.

The only thing that is left for me, facing the reality of facts, is to thank you for your friendship, and to wish you the best of happiness and of success in the new stage of your life that you decided to start now.

Lisboa, July 3, 2008,
João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711



to read full article below
   
Conversation among policemen...,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,some interesting reading

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 04:49:29 PM
Unless you are living on fantasy island, it is undeniable they haven't found Madeleine or how she disappeared.

Any reply denying those points is merely propaganda.

Amy guest reading the forum can ascertain that for themselves.

we don't know what SY have found or not found...a very simple fact which you cannot seem to grasp.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 04:53:31 PM



why do you think the mccs....let 20 or so people in the apartment .destroying evidence...when k MC knew straight away maddie had been abducted.........evidence lost forever....if there was any cos they certainly wasn't any when they had all gone,was there



what is a fact............................i don't think he will loose any sleep over what you think ov him  8**8:/:



   
Conversation among policemen...


He would, later on and as a natural and logical consequence of his professional career and his life, apply to become a Criminal Investigation Coordinator, and as expected, he was promoted to that functional category soon afterwards.

Then...

Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?

Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.

Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.

None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.

If this strategy catches in the future, tomorrow, when facing powerful, well connected arguidos, it could be other investigators who suffer this ordeal. It could be any one of us. And that may, in a way, mean the end of criminal investigation. At least in the way that we see it and develop it.

May this case be an object for reflection. And an example. And may it allow for us to create ways to avoid its repetition. The ASFICPJ should, maybe, analyse all of this situation, in a serious, conscientious and exhaustive manner. It is its obligation, too.

My friend Gonçalo, I sincerely regret your leaving the Polícia Judiciária, which seems precocious to me, because I admit that you still had a lot to give to the cause of Society, of Justice and of Public Service. Furthermore, our "House" does not own that many resources, both in quality and in quantity, to be able to afford not profiting from them, or, even worse, wasting them.

The only thing that is left for me, facing the reality of facts, is to thank you for your friendship, and to wish you the best of happiness and of success in the new stage of your life that you decided to start now.

Lisboa, July 3, 2008,
João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711



to read full article below
   
Conversation among policemen...,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,some interesting reading

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html

sorry but your post is gibberish but as you do not care what I think it doesn't matter
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 29, 2015, 05:00:54 PM
I wasn't aware he had said this - do you have the exact quote, and the date when he said it?  Thanks.

Always happy to expand your knowledge Alfred;


"While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

- The assistant chief constable of Leicestershire, in an official submission of Leicester Police to the Family Division of the High Court, in July 2008

For good measure;

"You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the [Ben] Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted."

- The Foreign and Commonwealth Office responding to a Freedom of Information request in connection with missing Ben Needham
http://www.mccannfiles.com

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 29, 2015, 05:04:28 PM
How long was he coordinator ?

May 2007 to October 2007.  So five months plus a bit
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 05:06:19 PM
Always happy to expand your knowledge Alfred;


"While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

- The assistant chief constable of Leicestershire, in an official submission of Leicester Police to the Family Division of the High Court, in July 2008

For good measure;

"You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the [Ben] Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted."

- The Foreign and Commonwealth Office responding to a Freedom of Information request in connection with missing Ben Needham
http://www.mccannfiles.com

and these statements demonstrate what exactly
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:09:02 PM
perhaps if we had had a decent investigation from the start there would have been a resolution. There can be no argument that amarals handling of the case was pitiful

I think that stands out as being amongst one of the the most heartbreaking aspects of Madeleine's case. 

Despite the valiant efforts put in by many of the police personnel ... the evidence is that Mr Amaral had decided on the morning of the 4th, prior even to visiting the crime scene, that the Drs McCann 'dunnit'.

The propaganda emanating from a 'source close to the investigation' was unleashed.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:09:58 PM
we don't know what SY have found or not found...a very simple fact which you cannot seem to grasp.

They haven't found Madeleine.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:10:49 PM
I think that stands out as being amongst one of the the most heartbreaking aspects of Madeleine's case. 

Despite the valiant efforts put in by many of the police personnel ... the evidence is that Mr Amaral had decided on the morning of the 4th, prior even to visiting the crime scene, that the Drs McCann 'dunnit'.

The propaganda emanating from a 'source close to the investigation' was unleashed.

What evidence ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:12:58 PM
They haven't found Madeleine or how she disappeared.

Do try and keep up with events.

You do not know what may or may not have been found ... perhaps you should add that such statements are only your opinion.  Unless you are privy to a source no-one else is.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:15:10 PM

G.A. did the best ...........he was allowed to do

he was there................he read the doubters reports to the abduction theory,,,both UK/Portuguese

IMO .he was on the right track.............he is not to blame he is just another mcc casualty...

same as maddie..................the mccs are responsible for her fate ...not Goncalo Ameral




http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html

In my opinion Goncalo Amaral made a dog's breakfast out of Madeleine's case ... he simply was not up to the job.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 29, 2015, 05:15:29 PM
and these statements demonstrate what exactly

Leicestershire Police, having been heavily involved in the early investigation, still had an open mind about what happened.
The Foreign Office are not prepared to advertise any 'abductions' for either the McCanns or the Needhams.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:18:05 PM
In my opinion Goncalo Amaral made a dog's breakfast out of Madeleine's case ... he simply was not up to the job.

The people not up to the job were the parents who did not take care of their children. IMO of course.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 05:28:54 PM
I think the supporters forget that Amaral's alleged incompetence works both ways. His mistakes may have contributed to Madeleine not being found but conversely his mistakes may have lead to the McCanns 'getting away' with their daughter's disappearance.

You pays your money.........!
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:29:43 PM



why do you think the mccs....let 20 or so people in the apartment .destroying evidence...when k MC knew straight away maddie had been abducted.........evidence lost forever....if there was any cos they certainly wasn't any when they had all gone,was there



what is a fact............................i don't think he will loose any sleep over what you think ov him  8**8:/:



   
Conversation among policemen...


He would, later on and as a natural and logical consequence of his professional career and his life, apply to become a Criminal Investigation Coordinator, and as expected, he was promoted to that functional category soon afterwards.

Then...

Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?

Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.

Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.

None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.

If this strategy catches in the future, tomorrow, when facing powerful, well connected arguidos, it could be other investigators who suffer this ordeal. It could be any one of us. And that may, in a way, mean the end of criminal investigation. At least in the way that we see it and develop it.

May this case be an object for reflection. And an example. And may it allow for us to create ways to avoid its repetition. The ASFICPJ should, maybe, analyse all of this situation, in a serious, conscientious and exhaustive manner. It is its obligation, too.

My friend Gonçalo, I sincerely regret your leaving the Polícia Judiciária, which seems precocious to me, because I admit that you still had a lot to give to the cause of Society, of Justice and of Public Service. Furthermore, our "House" does not own that many resources, both in quality and in quantity, to be able to afford not profiting from them, or, even worse, wasting them.

The only thing that is left for me, facing the reality of facts, is to thank you for your friendship, and to wish you the best of happiness and of success in the new stage of your life that you decided to start now.

Lisboa, July 3, 2008,
João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711



to read full article below
   
Conversation among policemen...,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,some interesting reading

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html

A quick search for ~ João Fernandes Figueira ~ didn't reveal anything other than your link to the mccannfiles and a blog.  So João's 'conversation' strikes me as being just another clumsy example of propaganda unless you can supply independent corroboration that I am wrong ???

Similarly the fiction that it is the victims' responsibility to secure the crime scene and not the policing authority is simply just another piece of propaganda promulgated
(a) to distract from police failure
(b) to excoriate the Drs McCann

Two classic examples of propaganda ... unless you can identify and substantiate João.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 05:30:16 PM
They haven't found Madeleine.

we don't know what SY have found or not found...a very simple fact which you cannot seem to grasp.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:33:06 PM
May 2007 to October 2007.  So five months plus a bit

Enough time to follow entirely the wrong tack in relation to the disappearance of a child ... particularly not making sure the golden hours were given proper consideration.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 05:36:18 PM
What evidence ?

You post here on a very regular basis ... why am I assuming that you do not read as well.
That link was posted very recently.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:39:42 PM
You post here on a very regular basis ... why am I assuming that you do not read as well.
That link was posted very recently.

Well funnily enough, I do not read every post, as I do have a life beyond this forum. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:40:50 PM
Enough time to follow entirely the wrong tack in relation to the disappearance of a child ... particularly not making sure the golden hours were given proper consideration.

That is a matter of opinion.

Nothing has been found to prove an abduction took place.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 05:42:43 PM
That is a matter of opinion.

Nothing has been found to prove an abduction took place.

i would say it has

If SY have ruled out the parents...taht basically proves abduction
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:46:05 PM
i would say it has

Cite.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 05:47:01 PM
Cite.

its above ...pure logic
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 05:52:30 PM
its above ...pure logic

Oh dear. *&*%£
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 05:54:23 PM
Oh dear. *&*%£

if you can't follow the simple logic that's your problem.....point any flaw if you are able...I rather doubt it
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:00:12 PM
if you can't follow the simple logic that's your problem.....point any flaw if you are able...I rather doubt it

Cite the evidence for abduction.

Do not mention the other thread.  There is no evidence there.



Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 06:10:05 PM
Cite the evidence for abduction.

Do not mention the other thread.  There is no evidence there.

i've just given you proof...on the balance of probabilities...or even beyond reasonable doubt...the fact you do not understand is your problem
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 06:13:32 PM
Always happy to expand your knowledge Alfred;


"While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

- The assistant chief constable of Leicestershire, in an official submission of Leicester Police to the Family Division of the High Court, in July 2008

For good measure;

"You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the [Ben] Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted."

- The Foreign and Commonwealth Office responding to a Freedom of Information request in connection with missing Ben Needham
http://www.mccannfiles.com
Thanks, I remember it now, though I don't recall seeing the full submission (if such a thing exists to read) nor what the submission was for specifically.  I guess then that there is no clear evidence which eliminates the Needham family from involvement in Ben's disappearance either, though I don't recall this fact being used to criticise and attack them in the manner that the McCanns have been.

ETA: I've checked out this quote from the assistant chief constable and it appears that this information has only come to light because Kate McCann herself chose to reveal it in her book.  Makes you wonder why she would share this information with the world if she truly was guilty, and not simply an indignant, perplexed mother of a missing child desperate to get their hands on any and all information concerning the investigation to enable their PIs to pursue their own lines of enquiry.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 06:20:02 PM
That is a matter of opinion.

Nothing has been found to prove an abduction took place.

You appear to have issues with "abduction" at the moment ... this thread is actually mainly concerned with propaganda.

Unfortunately the ineptitude of the first forensic harvest might very well have destroyed evidence pointing to an abductor. 

Disregarding the GNR dogs would not have helped.

How difficult would it have been to bag the cigarette ends found at a possible vantage point to have the DNA recorded.

Jane Tanner's sighting wasn't taken to conclusion ~ and the man carrying a child right outside the building it was subsequently discovered a child had gone missing from ~ still probably has not been identified.

How many independent witness statements were followed up and the strange men lurking around the McCann apartment traced and eliminated?

Etc ... etc ...

However your insistence that no abduction occurred is consistent with Mr Amaral's much promoted, closed minded, theory which allowed no deviation ... and would lead me to determine that you are evidencing the efficacy of the propaganda system used to promote it.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:23:58 PM
i've just given you proof...on the balance of probabilities...or even beyond reasonable doubt...the fact you do not understand is your problem

No.

There is no evidence, let alone proof of abduction

Never has been.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:27:14 PM
You appear to have issues with "abduction" at the moment ... this thread is actually mainly concerned with propaganda.

Unfortunately the ineptitude of the first forensic harvest might very well have destroyed evidence pointing to an abductor. 

Disregarding the GNR dogs would not have helped.

How difficult would it have been to bag the cigarette ends found at a possible vantage point to have the DNA recorded.

Jane Tanner's sighting wasn't taken to conclusion ~ and the man carrying a child right outside the building it was subsequently discovered a child had gone missing from ~ still probably has not been identified.

How many independent witness statements were followed up and the strange men lurking around the McCann apartment traced and eliminated?

Etc ... etc ...

However your insistence that no abduction occurred is consistent with Mr Amaral's much promoted, closed minded, theory which allowed no deviation ... and would lead me to determine that you are evidencing the efficacy of the propaganda system used to promote it.

All that is evidently obvious, is that you are here defending abduction.

For which, there is no evidence to show one happened, which can't be explained by other scenarios.

Namely, Madeleine disappeared.

Meanwhile you post is hypocritical, since you ignore the other scenarios.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 29, 2015, 06:30:15 PM
Cite the evidence for abduction.

Do not mention the other thread.  There is no evidence there.
The facts...
"Officers have investigated more than 60 persons of interest, considered 650 sex offenders....."

That's an awful lot of possibilities considering there was no evidence of an abduction
                               ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

And then the propaganda.....

"That all seems clear enough, but to many sceptics who have followed the case closely it is all a show, a sham, a cover-up, a whitewash, a conspiracy to hide the truth. They allege the claim that Madeleine was abducted, which her parents have always been adamant about and which the police and mainstream press in the UK seem to accept, is a fabrication.
The Met, of course, will have none of it."

All courtesy of Len Port http://portugalresident.com/madeleine-case-slips-into-its-ninth-year
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 06:38:03 PM
The facts...
"Officers have investigated more than 60 persons of interest, considered 650 sex offenders....."

That's an awful lot of possibilities considering there was no evidence of an abduction
                               ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

And then the propaganda.....

"That all seems clear enough, but to many sceptics who have followed the case closely it is all a show, a sham, a cover-up, a whitewash, a conspiracy to hide the truth. They allege the claim that Madeleine was abducted, which her parents have always been adamant about and which the police and mainstream press in the UK seem to accept, is a fabrication.
The Met, of course, will have none of it."

All courtesy of Len Port http://portugalresident.com/madeleine-case-slips-into-its-ninth-year

you would have to question the mentality of someone who thinks SY have spent 12 million on a whitewash.....and have not ruled the parents out first
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:38:22 PM
The facts...
"Officers have investigated more than 60 persons of interest, considered 650 sex offenders....."

That's an awful lot of possibilities considering there was no evidence of an abduction
                               ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

And then the propaganda.....

"That all seems clear enough, but to many sceptics who have followed the case closely it is all a show, a sham, a cover-up, a whitewash, a conspiracy to hide the truth. They allege the claim that Madeleine was abducted, which her parents have always been adamant about and which the police and mainstream press in the UK seem to accept, is a fabrication.
The Met, of course, will have none of it."

All courtesy of Len Port http://portugalresident.com/madeleine-case-slips-into-its-ninth-year

and not one iota of evidence to show any of these people were linked to Madeleine's disappearance.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:39:41 PM
you would have to question the mentality of someone who thinks SY have spent 12 million on a whitewash.....and have not ruled the parents out first

By the way Misty, can you cite any forensic evidence which shows abduction ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 06:40:07 PM
and not one iota of evidence to show any of these people were linked to Madeleine's disappearance.
You know this for a fact do you?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:41:40 PM
you would have to question the mentality of someone who thinks SY have spent 12 million on a whitewash.....and have not ruled the parents out first

I question the mentality of those who blindly believe in abduction, despite the lack of evidence.

Unless of course they have a clear motive in doing so.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:42:42 PM
You know this for a fact do you?

Well come on Alfred, you cite evidence that undeniably shows an abduction took place.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 29, 2015, 06:45:27 PM
By the way Misty, can you cite any forensic evidence which shows abduction ?

Have you watched those videos John recently posted - the shutter one in particular?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 06:47:34 PM
Thanks, I remember it now, though I don't recall seeing the full submission (if such a thing exists to read) nor what the submission was for specifically.  I guess then that there is no clear evidence which eliminates the Needham family from involvement in Ben's disappearance either, though I don't recall this fact being used to criticise and attack them in the manner that the McCanns have been.

ETA: I've checked out this quote from the assistant chief constable and it appears that this information has only come to light because Kate McCann herself chose to reveal it in her book.  Makes you wonder why she would share this information with the world if she truly was guilty, and not simply an indignant, perplexed mother of a missing child desperate to get their hands on any and all information concerning the investigation to enable their PIs to pursue their own lines of enquiry.

Conversely there is nothing to implicate the Needhams in Ben's disappearance such as statement anomalies or cadaver dog alerts.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:51:02 PM
Have you watched those videos John recently posted - the shutter one in particular?

...and ?

That is not evidence for abduction.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 06:51:28 PM
Conversely there is nothing to implicate the Needhams in Ben's disappearance such as statement anomalies or cadaver dog alerts.

none of those implicate the mccanns...

plus of course we have not seen the Needham statements and the dogs were not taken to Greece
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 06:53:17 PM
I question the mentality of those who blindly believe in abduction, despite the lack of evidence.

Unless of course they have a clear motive in doing so.

I would question the mentality of those who blindly believe anything...
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 06:53:33 PM
All that is evidently obvious, is that you are here defending abduction.

For which, there is no evidence to show one happened, which can't be explained by other scenarios.

Namely, Madeleine disappeared.

Meanwhile you post is hypocritical, since you ignore the other scenarios.

Actually, on this thread I am more interested in the use of propaganda to mould opinion.

I find it fascinating the manner in which you and other sceptics insist with almost every post the effectiveness of propaganda as a tool in Madeleine McCann's case.

I am convinced that had the innocent Drs McCann been innocent Portuguese they would have been barracked next door to the Cipriano case convicts.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:57:15 PM
I would question the mentality of those who blindly believe anything...

Yet you repeatedly type abduction. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 29, 2015, 06:57:54 PM
Actually, on this thread I am more interested in the use of propaganda to mould opinion.

I find it fascinating the manner in which you and other sceptics insist with almost every post the effectiveness of propaganda as a tool in Madeleine McCann's case.

I am convinced that had the innocent Drs McCann been innocent Portuguese they would have been barracked next door to the Cipriano case convicts.

Quite comical really, berating propaganda then going full tilt in your last sentence.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 06:59:02 PM
Well come on Alfred, you cite evidence that undeniably shows an abduction took place.
Hang on, don't ask me for evidence for something I haven't stated, you've stated that the Met have found nothing to link any of those they've interviewed to Madeleine's disappearance and all I want to know is - do you know this for a fact, or are you assuming?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 06:59:08 PM
Actually, on this thread I am more interested in the use of propaganda to mould opinion.

I find it fascinating the manner in which you and other sceptics insist with almost every post the effectiveness of propaganda as a tool in Madeleine McCann's case.

I am convinced that had the innocent Drs McCann been innocent Portuguese they would have been barracked next door to the Cipriano case convicts.

Staggering reply, when all you attempt to do on here, is to try and show the mccanns in a good light, and dismiss anything but abduction.

THAT IS PURE PROPAGANDA.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 06:59:48 PM
Yet you repeatedly type abduction. 8**8:/:

I would say based on the evidence abduction is odds on favourite...which is just about what Redwood said..
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 29, 2015, 07:00:28 PM
i would say it has

If SY have ruled out the parents...taht basically proves abduction

If "ifs" and "buts" were candy and nuts, we'd all have a merry Christmas.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 07:00:39 PM
Hang on, don't ask me for evidence for something I haven't stated, you've stated that the Met have found nothing to link any of those they've interviewed to Madeleine's disappearance and all I want to know is - do you know this for a fact, or are you assuming?

Simple Alfred.

They clearly haven't found Madeleine.

Are you pretending they have ? 8)-)))
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 07:00:58 PM
Conversely there is nothing to implicate the Needhams in Ben's disappearance such as statement anomalies or cadaver dog alerts.
So why did the PT AG say that there was a lack of evidence of any crime having been committed by either Murat or the McCanns when archiving the case?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 07:01:32 PM
Quite comical really, berating propaganda then going full tilt in your last sentence.

hardly propaganda ...more the truth...which was the portuguese who said taht had the mccanns been portuguese they would have already been arrested
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 07:02:16 PM
I would say based on the evidence abduction is odds on favourite...which is just about what Redwood said..

What a load of rollocks.

What evidence ?

Redwood was a believer, and has now b....red off into retirement.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 29, 2015, 07:02:39 PM
Simple Alfred.

They clearly haven't found Madeleine.

Are you pretending they have ? 8)-)))

Of course I'm not pretending that Madeleine has been found, but do you not concede that the Met may have found evidence, circumstantial at least, that may link one or more of these individuals with Madeleine's disappearance?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 07:02:46 PM
Simple Alfred.

They clearly haven't found Madeleine.

Are you pretending they have ? 8)-)))

just so you understand...we all know Maddie has not been found...why do you continue with those stupid posts
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 29, 2015, 07:03:09 PM
hardly propaganda ...more the truth...which was the portuguese who said taht had the mccanns been portuguese they would have already been arrested

I am sure you will provide a cite?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 07:04:42 PM
What a load of rollocks.

What evidence ?

Redwood was a believer, and has now b....red off into retirement.

Redwood said "we" when he talked of the evidence. im not sure how short your memory is but we have discussed taht the whole justice system is based on belief...but it was a  week ago
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 07:05:42 PM
I am sure you will provide a cite?

i'm rather shocked that you have asked me to...have you not been following the case
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 29, 2015, 07:06:37 PM
i'm rather shocked that you have asked me to...have you not been following the case

So that's a no?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 07:08:58 PM
Quite comical really, berating propaganda then going full tilt in your last sentence.

My opinion only ... but based on the facts available of each case.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 07:09:47 PM
So that's a no?

Tapas Seven would have been arrested, if they were Portuguese - 24Horas
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 29, 2015, 07:11:22 PM
Tapas Seven would have been arrested, if they were Portuguese - 24Horas

So we now take all media reports as fact?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 07:12:33 PM
My opinion only ... but based on the facts available of each case.

So pray tell, what 'facts' support abduction.

Beliefs don't count.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: misty on December 29, 2015, 07:13:08 PM
...and ?

That is not evidence for abduction.

I take it that's a "no" then, you haven't watched them.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 29, 2015, 07:15:33 PM
I take it that's a "no" then, you haven't watched them.

Now explain how they support abduction, when the only fingerprints identified are kate mccann.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Brietta on December 29, 2015, 07:21:16 PM
So that's a no?

I think it may very well be Tavares de Almeida who had a thing about throwing people into jail, lucky for him it was not carried through to conclusion when he was convicted of a heinous offence. (do you require a cite for that well known fact?)
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 29, 2015, 08:50:17 PM
So why did the PT AG say that there was a lack of evidence of any crime having been committed by either Murat or the McCanns when archiving the case?

Perhaps because Amaral had so hopelessly compromised the investigation by his incompetence that the AG had no choice ?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: ferryman on December 29, 2015, 09:28:58 PM
Always happy to expand your knowledge Alfred;


"While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

- The assistant chief constable of Leicestershire, in an official submission of Leicester Police to the Family Division of the High Court, in July 2008

For good measure;

"You will also be aware of the Madeleine McCann case. Both this and the [Ben] Needham case are categorised as a missing persons, rather than child abduction cases, as there is no evidence in either case to support whether the children were or were not abducted."

- The Foreign and Commonwealth Office responding to a Freedom of Information request in connection with missing Ben Needham
http://www.mccannfiles.com

Quote
Always happy to expand your knowledge Alfred;


"While one or both of them may be innocent, there is no clear evidence that eliminates them from involvement in Madeleine's disappearance."

- The assistant chief constable of Leicestershire, in an official submission of Leicester Police to the Family Division of the High Court, in July 2008[/b]

I have underlined the vital part, the date, July 2008.

The investigation was shelved in August 2008.

After that, the position (of the McCanns' innocence) became crystal clear.

So why do you keep quoting it?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 29, 2015, 09:36:09 PM
I have underlined the vital part, the date, July 2008.

The investigation was shelved in August 2008.

After that, the position (of the McCanns' innocence) became crystal clear.

So why do you keep quoting it?

very well spotted ferryman...how could uk police supply information to the mccanns when they were still arguidos in portugal
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 30, 2015, 08:33:08 AM
Not talking to the journalist that indirectly got him moved off of the case would be my top choice.
My top choice would be giving up the search in PdL for Madeleine's body in just a few days.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: faithlilly on December 30, 2015, 08:38:53 AM
My top choice would be giving up the search in PdL for Madeleine's body in just a few days.

If the body was still in PDL and had been found it would certainly have answered the sedation question once and for all.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 30, 2015, 08:48:59 AM
If the body was still in PDL and had been found it would certainly have answered the sedation question once and for all.
so would you agree that the PJ gave up the search far too quickly?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 30, 2015, 08:53:48 AM
so would you agree that the PJ gave up the search far too quickly?

Thorough search.

No Madeleine.

No trace of abduction.

NOTHING CHANGED since then.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 30, 2015, 08:55:14 AM
My top choice would be giving up the search in PdL for Madeleine's body in just a few days.

What do you class as a 'few days'? The searches took seven days. How many days more should they have searched?

The searches were based on a strategy of searching in "rescue and recovery mode? to locate the missing girl alive or if dead, not as a victim of crime. This search phase lasted for 7 days from the date M McCann went missing.

The first zone extended 3km to the EN125 road at Espiche. W?hin this zone, sectors were drawn using the natural boundaries that exist and included the entire village. Officers were briefed and debriefed before and after deployments and records of activity collected. Each sector was repeatedly searched on 3 separate occasions over the 7 days using officers conducting line searches and supported by air scenting dogs.

The next Zone 2 was extended out to a radius of 7km to the boundary of the N120 road at Bensafrim. As the sectors were larger and in order to support the line searches 2 GNR officers on motorcycles and 6 GNR officers on horse-back were deployed. These sectors were all searched on 2 separate occasions over the 7 day period.

The outer zone 3 was extended to 15km at Barragem de Odiaxere a dammed lake. This zone is in a mountainous region subject to flash forest fires.
Therefore Fire officers who routinely patrol and have local knowledge of the area were tasked to drive the tracks, visit empty properties to look for the missing girl. Additionally the fire brigade used a boat to visually inspect the surface water of the lake.

Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 30, 2015, 08:57:16 AM
What do you class as a 'few days'? The searches took seven days. How many days more should they have searched?

The searches were based on a strategy of searching in "rescue and recovery mode? to locate the missing girl alive or if dead, not as a victim of crime. This search phase lasted for 7 days from the date M McCann went missing.

The first zone extended 3km to the EN125 road at Espiche. W?hin this zone, sectors were drawn using the natural boundaries that exist and included the entire village. Officers were briefed and debriefed before and after deployments and records of activity collected. Each sector was repeatedly searched on 3 separate occasions over the 7 days using officers conducting line searches and supported by air scenting dogs.

The next Zone 2 was extended out to a radius of 7km to the boundary of the N120 road at Bensafrim. As the sectors were larger and in order to support the line searches 2 GNR officers on motorcycles and 6 GNR officers on horse-back were deployed. These sectors were all searched on 2 separate occasions over the 7 day period.

The outer zone 3 was extended to 15km at Barragem de Odiaxere a dammed lake. This zone is in a mountainous region subject to flash forest fires.
Therefore Fire officers who routinely patrol and have local knowledge of the area were tasked to drive the tracks, visit empty properties to look for the missing girl. Additionally the fire brigade used a boat to visually inspect the surface water of the lake.
7 days is nothing.  How many weeks did the police in Wales spend looking for April?  Or that poor girl who went missing on the towpath in Ealing?
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: G-Unit on December 30, 2015, 11:41:07 AM
7 days is nothing.  How many weeks did the police in Wales spend looking for April?  Or that poor girl who went missing on the towpath in Ealing?

It's a lot in a small area. They repeated the searches more than once too.
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 30, 2015, 11:46:08 AM
It's a lot in a small area. They repeated the searches more than once too.
In the disappearance of Alice Gross there was a month of intense searching in a very concentrated area indeed.  Do you think the search for Madeleine's body was as thorough or as intense? 
Title: Re: A Question of Propaganda.
Post by: Admin on December 31, 2015, 12:32:03 AM
This thread is currently being edited.  Please keep comments relative to the header.

Thank you
Admin