well everyone on here seems to ...but anyone with any intelligence...which will exclude some on here...would know that had the mccanns been portuguese they would have not only been arrested... but beaten to a pulp...cite cipriano
Pure propaganda.
Pure propaganda.
cipriano was beaten to a pulp by the pj...proved in court not propaganda
Which members of the PJ dave ?
we don't know...she had a bag placed over head
we don't know...she had a bag placed over head
Irrelevant.
Then there is no proof they did this.
and what about the claim the prisoners made about this 'beating up' ?
it was proved in court...the PJ accepted she sustained the injuries in their custody
they calimed she fell down the stairs...not she was attacked by other prisoners
the court ruled she had been beaten by the Pj and taht they had lied..amaral was convicted
Well name the officers involved.
Otherwise the Portuguese judgement holds no water at all and neither does yolur propaganda.
The mccanns were never in danger.
They came back to England and broke their promise.
absolutely spot on...
...everyone knows the court found torture proved
Very original.
She had injuries, by persons unknown.
The Portuguese judgement would not have been upheld in the UK.
the court ruled the injuries were caused by the PJ...absolute fact
what evidence do you have that the judgement would not have been upheld in the Uk...none
Very original.
She had injuries, by persons unknown.
The Portuguese judgement would not have been upheld in the UK.
http://www.dn.pt/portugal/interior/caso-joana-relacao-mantem-penas-a-exinspectores-1882361.html
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline
All the PJ officers previously accused by the murderess Leonor Cipriano were immediately considered innocent in her Court Sentence session.
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline)
Re: The beating and conviction of Leonor Cipriano
« Reply #14 on: April 10, 2013, 08:39:17 PM »
Quote
It's an open document in FARO Court of Law, go there and look for yourself - I did.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read what Luz posted.
Very original.
She had injuries, by persons unknown.
The Portuguese judgement would not have been upheld in the UK.
http://www.dn.pt/portugal/interior/caso-joana-relacao-mantem-penas-a-exinspectores-1882361.html
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline
All the PJ officers previously accused by the murderess Leonor Cipriano were immediately considered innocent in her Court Sentence session.
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline)
Re: The beating and conviction of Leonor Cipriano
« Reply #14 on: April 10, 2013, 08:39:17 PM »
Quote
It's an open document in FARO Court of Law, go there and look for yourself - I did.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
you have criticised posters for cutting and pasting things they do not understand...
100% you do not understand what the article you have provided a link to means...not even an inkling...not a clue
The torture of Cipriano was proved in court and never overturned...as amarals conviction was never overturned...more evidence of the dishonest propaganda in this case
Why don't you ask Luz.
She appears quite neutral in this case.
' Three officers, Leonel Marques, Paulo Pereira Cristovao and Paulo Marques Bom, were acquitted of torture.'
............and from elsewhere
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2013/04/leonor-cipriano-condemned-to-seven-more.html
could you provide a cite which shows they were acquitted...the one you have posted makes no mention of an acquittal...you obviously haven't read it
your claims are totally untrue and pure propaganda
just to clarify...the court accepted that cipriano was tortured in police custody but could not identify those responsible as cipriano had a bag over her head. Amarals conviction for covering up the torture has never been overturned. Those are the undisputed facts.
Now read my link as you have made an accusation.
I expect an apology
an apology for what .......your link is in portuguese....do you have a translation
' Three officers, Leonel Marques, Paulo Pereira Cristovao and Paulo Marques Bom, were acquitted of torture.'
You denied this.
HERE IS THE LINK AGAIN.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano
APOLOGIZE.
I didnt deny it... I asked for a link...read the post again..and this time read it slowly...and copy and paste the denial...you wont be able to
You have the link.
If you fail to do so, it merely reveals what you are.
You have the link.
If you fail to do so, it merely reveals what you are.
this is the link you posted...could you explain to us all what it means..... @)(++(* @)(++(*
PortugalCASO JOANA: RELAÇÃO MANTÉM PENAS A EX-INSPECTORES
17º
17º
14º
17º
14º
16º
17º
Caso Joana: Relação mantém penas a ex-inspectores
PUB
A Relação de Évora refutou a existência de "nulidades e inconstitucionalidades" no acórdão que confirmou a condenação de ex-inspectores da Polícia Judiciária (PJ) no processo de agressões a Leonor Cipriano, mãe de Joana, criança desaparecida no Algarve, em 2004.
A 18 de Março deste ano, o Tribunal da Relação confirmou a condenação dos ex-inspectores da PJ Gonçalo Amaral e António Cardoso Nunes, com penas suspensas, pelo Tribunal de Faro em 2009, mas este último antigo agente requereu "a reforma e aclaração do acórdão".
De acordo com fonte judicial, a Relação de Évora entendeu que "carece de razão" o requerimento de António Cardoso Nunes, condenado a dois anos e três meses de prisão com pena suspensa pelo crime de falsificação de documento. Entendeu ainda o tribunal de segunda instância de Évora que o recurso "extravassa por completo o âmbito permitido a um requerimento de aclaração ou arguição de erros, lapsos, obscuridades ou nulidades".
Na decisão dos recursos dos ex-inspectores, comunicada a 18 de Março de 2011, a Relação também manteve a pena de um ano e seis meses de prisão por crime de falsidade de depoimento, suspensa na sua execução, aplicada a Gonçalo Amaral, ex-coordenador do Departamento de Investigação Criminal de Portimão.
Na sequência da decisão da Relação, Marcos Aragão Correia, advogado de Leonor Cipriano, interpos uma queixa contra o Estado português na Organização das Nações Unidas por violação "grosseira dos mais básicos Direitos Humanos". O advogado referiu à agência Lusa que pediu a condenação e expulsão de Portugal da Comissão dos Direitos Humanos das Nações Unidas.
O caso das agressões a Leonor Cipriano foi julgado em Faro, em 2009, mas o Tribunal de Faro não determinou a autoria das agressões à mãe de Joana. Além de Gonçalo Amaral, absolvido do crime de omissão de denúncia, e de António Nunes Cardoso, também foram julgados os ex-inspectores Paulo Pereira Cristovão e Leonel Morgado Marques e o agente ainda no activo Paulo Marques Bom. Paulo Pereira Cristovão, Leonel Morgado Marques e Paulo Marques Bom foram absolvidos.
Joana desapareceu a 12 de Dezembro de 2004 da aldeia de Figueiró, Portimão, e Leonor Cipriano e o irmão, João Cipriano, foram condenados em 2006 a 16 anos de prisão cada um pelos crimes de homicídio e ocultação de cadáver, após recurso da pena de 18 anos.
O caso voltou à Justiça em finais de 2008, com a mãe de Joana a acusar cinco catuais e ex-inspectores da PJ, num processo envolvendo crimes de tortura, omissão de denúncia e falsificação de documento
Pathetic.
here is the link I was referring to, as regards the 3 officers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano
NOW READ AND APOLOGIZE.
perhaps you could explain what your first link means before moving to the second... @)(++(* @)(++(*
Ask Luz.
You have had your last chance to apologize.
What you are, will be abundantly clear to any reader of this forum.
Perhaps because Amaral had so hopelessly compromised the investigation by his incompetence that the AG had no choice ?Amaral busted a gut trying to cobble together a case against the McCanns but failed. Do you really believe the lack of evidence was soley down to Amaral's incompetence as an investigator?
ask luz...are you serious...Luz lied about amaral...do you remember...obviously not...luz claimed amaral had been cleared in court...and when pressed for evidence left the forum...words fail me
You have no morals or honour.
You got it wrong and you haven't the b###s to admit it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano
READ IT and the three detectives mentioned.....
' Three officers, Leonel Marques, Paulo Pereira Cristovao and Paulo Marques Bom, were acquitted of torture '
those three officers were acquitted but the court accepted that cipriano was tortured by the pj and amaral lied to cover it up...those are the facts and you should agree
those three officers were acquitted but the court accepted that cipriano was tortured by the pj and amaral lied to cover it up...those are the facts and you should agree
what stephen show is how the sceptic propaganda works ...even when something is true..deny..deny ...deny
Completely wrong.
It has merely shown tonight what people like you will do to try and defend the McCann's.
...the officers were not convicted because cipriano had a bag over her head....but torture was proved
Cipriano.
CONVICTED MURDERER AND LIAR.
That is who you are defending.
Amaral busted a gut trying to cobble together a case against the McCanns but failed. Do you really believe the lack of evidence was soley down to Amaral's incompetence as an investigator?
I have not said one word in defence of cipriano....your homework is to read the post and see what a fool you have made of yourself...your grasp of the facts is truly awful
Guests reading this forum will decide who has made a fool of himself, and that isn't me.
Cipriano.
CONVICTED MURDERER AND LIAR.
That is who you are defending.
your grasp of facts is really quite poor... I have not made one post in support of cipriano this evening...but in your mind I have
Supporters really can't have it both ways. If Amaral was incompetent enough to miss evidence that pointed to an abductor he could just as easily have missed evidence that pointed to the McCann's guilt.And you can't have it both ways - either Amaral was a competent, experienced, honest cop, or he was an incompetent, unreliable cop out of his depth. Which is it?
You, in effect are defending Ciprian's claims.
She is a murderer and convicted liar.
Neither you or anyone can name any officer who 'tortured' her, without commuting libel.
And you can't have it both ways - either Amaral was a competent, experienced, honest cop, or he was an incompetent, unreliable cop out of his depth. Which is it?
You have no morals or honour.
You got it wrong and you haven't the b###s to admit it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Joana_Cipriano
READ IT and the three detectives mentioned.....
' Three officers, Leonel Marques, Paulo Pereira Cristovao and Paulo Marques Bom, were acquitted of torture '
You are getting rather shrill Stephen. Not good for the blood pressure.
Now - to start with - What were Amaral and Cardoso convicted of?
Not sure what honesty has to do with experience and competence but maybe that's just me.you don't think honesty should be a prerequisite of a decent cop? Maybe it's just me then...
Every police officer makes mistakes and I'm sure Amaral was no different. The question is were those mistakes helpful to the McCanns or to the alleged abductor ?
You get so many, many things wrong.
My blood pressure is fine.
Do you believe that Cipriano, a convicted murderer and liar, whose sentence has been extended because of her proven lies, can be trusted to have told the truth ?
You get so many, many things wrong.
My blood pressure is fine.
Do you believe that Cipriano, a convicted murderer and liar, whose sentence has been extended because of her proven lies, can be trusted to have told the truth ?
you don't think honesty should be a prerequisite of a decent cop? Maybe it's just me then...
You obviously don't want to discuss my main point. Fair enough.It's an impossible question to answer. I think his incompetence aided the abductor, you have decided if you can't beat Amaral's detractors you may as well join them (a novel tactic) and are using his incompetence to strengthen your own argument. We're unlikely to get beyond this point in the discussion are we?
It's an impossible question to answer. I think his incompetence aided the abductor, you have decided if you can't beat Amaral's detractors you may as well join them (a novel tactic) and are using his incompetence to strengthen your own argument. We're unlikely to get beyond this point in the discussion are we?
I know I'm putting you in an uncomfortable position but perhaps you could answer my question ? If Amaral was as imcompetent as some believe don't you think that that could have worked for the McCanns, if guilty, as well as for the abductor ?Yes potentially it could have. I felt not one scintilla of discomfort writing that sentence much as I'm sure you'd be absolutely fine agreeing that Amaral's incompetence has potentially aided a child sex offender / abductor / murderer to evade justice for the last nearly nine years.
I know I'm putting you in an uncomfortable position but perhaps you could answer my question ? If Amaral was as imcompetent as some believe don't you think that that could have worked for the McCanns, if guilty, as well as for the abductor ?
You get so many, many things wrong.
My blood pressure is fine.
Do you believe that Cipriano, a convicted murderer and liar, whose sentence has been extended because of her proven lies, can be trusted to have told the truth ?
whatever you say torture was proved
In court. The actual perpetrators could not be positively identified and so the three defendants were acquitted.
Whatever the facts of the case turn out to be, a defendant tortured into a confession was not Portugal's finest hour.
We shall never know the true facts because as the judge at her torture trial said Cipriano is somewhat of a stranger to the truth.Yet despite this torture was proven. Fact.
Yet despite this torture was proven. Fact.
And so was the murder of her daughter by her brother and her.I don't think anyone is disputing that fact.
What could and should Amaral have done to ensure that he got his man / woman, that he clearly did not do?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQhGJxs19-k
Omg, no wonder some call them pigs though thats disrespectful to pigs
I am concerned about you.
Do you know what Amaral and Cardoso were convicted of?
The prison director
Correia then spoke to Odemira prison director Ana Maria Calado, who confirmed Leonor Cipriano's account, noting how shocked she was about her conditions, with black marks, haematomae and bruising in her face, mainly around her eyes, her head and ribs, mainly on her sides. She assured that the physical marks clearly indicated a violent aggression and not a fall down some stairs, something the legal-medical report also confirmed. She noted that Cipriano's conditions worsened a week after she was tortured, as the blood that had gathered at the height of her brows was so much that it ended up falling over her eyes, leaving her practically blind for almost a month, and the director regrets not having ordered photographs of this period to be taken. She also said that relations between Cipriano and the prison guards and other prisoners were good, and that she did not believe that she had attempted suicide.
Calado expressed her surprise for a number of facts: a) that the judicial police did not take Cipriano to a health centre in Faro to certify that she had fallen down some stairs; b) that the day of her interrogation was chosen during Calado's week of holidays, when she would never have allowed her to be picked up at 6 a.m. without a formal request by the judicial police; and c) that judicial police officers who arrived from Lisbon to investigate the allegations of torture proposed sharing the blame between the judicial police and prison, something she refused. Correia praised the director, describing her as "courageous" and as prizing "values" more highly than "corporate interests".
Conclusion
The report concludes that the testimony of Leonor Cipriano and of the prison director, as well as other available evidence, are convincing in terms of proving that a crime of torture was committed by officers of the Portuguese judicial police. It condemns the use of "medieval methods" to "extract confessions at all cost, even if they are false", as "inadmissible" and as harmful for Portugal's image as an EU member that defends human rights and has a modern legal order and, as such, argues that these practices must be punished in "exemplary" fashion, or the Portuguese citizenry will lose faith in the judicial system.
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2008/may/02portugal-report.htm
Surely a blot on any civilised European country and those who think it did not happen are deluding themselves.
I defy anyone suffering the torture to which Leonor Cipriano was subjected for two days not to sign whatever was put in front of them.
As soon as she had access to a lawyer she withdrew her 'confession'.
The only "exemplary" punishment that seems to have been handed down was an increase in Leonor's sentence ... because she could not identify her assailants.
Difficult when there is a plastic bag over your head.
Cipriano, the MURDERER and LIAR, changed her story about her 'beating'.
I wonder how much Correia had to do with that ?
Her sentence was extended for her LYING TO THE COURT.
you don't think honesty should be a prerequisite of a decent cop? Maybe it's just me then...
I really don't know why Brietta posts such nonsense. It is common knowledge signed her confession the day before the alleged torture and that her lawyer was present at the time. Besides I believe a confession in Portugal is only valid as evidence if repeated in court.
Do we have honest cops? Are the Metropolitan Police models of honesty and fair dealing? Do we weed out the bad ones? It would appear not, we just remind them of how they should behave and let them carry on policing.
four detective constables were found guilty of mishandling property seized during searches by the Enfield crime squad, which has since been disbanded. DVD players, iPods and flat-screen TVs were distributed among some of the staff at Edmonton police station in north London....One officer received a written warning. There were no sanctions for the other three.
John Feavyour, deputy chief constable of Cambridgeshire and the chair of the misconduct board, said the officers had fully illustrated that they now understood the appropriate processes for handling property....
http://www.channel4.com/news/met-corruption-inquiry-finds-nine-guity-but-no-dismissals
Alf, you suggest honesty is a desirable quality in a Police officer, and I agree. There are bad apples in every barrel though. UK Police Officers are not above reproach, so it's somewhat hypocritical to denigrate the police officers of other countries imo.
Alf, you suggest honesty is a desirable quality in a Police officer, and I agree. There are bad apples in every barrel though. UK Police Officers are not above reproach, so it's somewhat hypocritical to denigrate the police officers of other countries imo.
Cipriano, the MURDERER and LIAR, changed her story about her 'beating'.
I wonder how much Correia had to do with that ?
Her sentence was extended for her LYING TO THE COURT.
Torture and other ill-treatment
Criminal investigations into allegations of torture and other ill-treatment by law enforcement officials
continued in 2009.
On 22 May the Criminal Court of Faro issued its sentence in the case of the torture of Leonor Cipriano.
The court recognized that she had been tortured in police custody in 2004, but acquitted all three police officers, claiming that it was impossible to identify exactly who had been responsible.
A fourth officer was convicted of giving false testimony and another was convicted of falsifying documents.
Leonor Cipriano’s appeal was pending at the end of the year.
By the end of the year, no trial date had been set for three judicial police officers accused of torturing Virgolino Borges in March 2000.
The case was due to go to trial in November 2008 but was delayed pending further medical examinations requested by the defence.
Virgolino Borges said that he had been tortured by police officers who punched him and beat him on the soles of his feet with a wooden post while in custody. The investigation had been closed in 2005 by the public prosecutor, who stated that Virgolino Borges’ injuries could have been self-inflicted.
Virgolino Borges appealed against this decision to the Lisbon region courts: first to the Tribunal de Instrução and then to the Tribunal da Relação, which in November 2005 ordered that the case go to trial.
https://www.essex.ac.uk/armedcon/story_id/elsalvadorreport2010.pdf
Propaganda comes in many forms ... one of which in my opinion is not only promoting falsehoods and half truths but in silencing the truth.
I am going to be very careful about what I post on this subject as it is indicative of the sensitivity surrounding any mention of the horrific torture
suffered by Leonor Cipriano and those convicted as a result ... particularly as something which I posted yesterday earned me a warning.
As far as I am concerned I have posted nothing which is not documented and I am not best pleased at receiving a warning when watching day and daily ad hominem attacks being perpetrated ad nauseam by one or two other posters who appear to be bomb proof from censure of any kind.
If you wish to find out what happened to Leonor Cipriano, don't read Morais or Levy.
Virgolino Borges, mentioned above in the Amnesty International document) another who self inflicted a beating on the soles of his feet won his case after many years of perseverance ... unlike Cipriano he was able to identify his three torturers.
if I had claimed that dishonest cops existed only in Portugal then you may have had a point but as I didn't then you don't. Your argument is pure straw man
Sorry Alfred. Given what was being said at the time I assumed you were having a go at the Portuguese Police. Obviously no Police Force is squeaky clean.I was responding to Faithlilly's contention that it was Amaral's incompetence that let the McCanns off the hook. I wrote:
So if it came to pass that the SY lead investigator in the McCann case was accused of a crime and successfully prosecuted - sceptics would simply shrug it off on the grounds that '' there are bad apples in every barrel? ''
Pull the other one G.
I was replying to Alfred's point that honesty is a desirable quality in a Police officer. I pointed out that the UK hadn't managed to ensure the honesty of it's Police Officers. No shrugging at all, it's very serious when Police Officers abuse their position by stealing.Totally irrelevant.
condone
/kənˈdəʊn/
verb
gerund or present participle: condoning
accept (behaviour that is considered morally wrong or offensive).
"the college cannot condone any behaviour that involves illicit drugs"
synonyms: deliberately ignore, not take into consideration, disregard, take no notice of, take no account of, accept, allow, make allowances for, let pass, turn a blind eye to, overlook, forget, wink at, blink at, connive at
you have given me points for libel when what I have said is not libel and I provided adefinituion of condone to show it.
Stephen called me a liar three times and received no points.
Your unfair moderating is ruining the forum
posters on here have made excuses for the torture of cipriano...that falls under the definition of condoning...they have therefore condoned torture
Cite posters or withdraw your accusation.
posters who have made excuses for ciprianos beatings..
stephen claimed she was beaten by fellow inmates......faith saying the picture had been photoshopped
now lets have your cite or the apology you promised
posters who have made excuses for ciprianos beatings..
stephen claimed she was beaten by fellow inmates......faith saying the picture had been photoshopped
now lets have your cite
I do not and never have condoned torture.
You said I did.
Likewise, neither you or any mccann supporter has naswered why CIPRIANOS sentence was extended.
I do not and never have condoned torture.
You said I did.
Likewise, neither you or any mccann supporter has naswered why CIPRIANOS sentence was extended.
I see Angelo is online...could I ask you if you think cipriano deserved her beating
I seem to think Angelo has said cipriano deserved the beating...more than happy to apologise if i am wrong
Well why didn't you say that? Is the argument more important than getting anywhere?
lets see what angelo says and then perhaps you can remove my points..
I would say that several posters on here condone the torture of Cipriano...the simplest way to prove me wrong is for posters to state their position... so who thinks the beating of Cipriano was wrong
You said posters and have failed to demonstrate anyone condoning torture.
That's not how it works.
if you could understand the meaning of condoning... I have explained what context i am using it in...you would see that i am correct. But lets take it further...how many posters are willing to state their position on the torture ..
Are you going to accept the right to silence?
its exactly how it works...lets start with you...do you condemn the torture of cipriano..
so stephens online...do you condemn the torture of cipriano by the pj
Try reading what I have said time and again, including today.
I condemn torture.
Now do you condemn torture of potential terrorists ?
so you condemn the torture of cipriano
I do not and never have condoned torture.
You said I did.
Likewise, neither you or any mccann supporter has naswered why CIPRIANOS sentence was extended.
I've answered the question.
Now you answer mine.
Why was cipriano's sentence lengthened. ?
Unequivocal.
Because she lied.
I've answered the question.
Now you answer mine.
Why was cipriano's sentence lengthened. ?
no it isnt...stephen has made excuses for the torture of cipriano and therefore condoned it
no it isnt...stephen has made excuses for the torture of cipriano and therefore condoned it
Expressing doubts is not condoning.
What excuses do you say I have made ?
Because I certainly haven't.
Justify another accusation against me, by you.
making excuses is
you have tried to maintain it didnt happen even though proved in court
No, I asked for proof it was members of the PJ.
Her accounts are not consistent.
There were claims fellow prisoners beat her up.
So again, I don't condone torture.
Also, the woman is a CONVICTED MURDERER AND LIAR.
what was amaral convicted of....covering up the torture of cipriano...stop making excuses... that is condoning
...for repeating the statements of his subordinates without checking on their truth regarding the injuries suffered by Cipiano whilst in PJ custody.
There you are, two different sides to of propaganda.
injuries suffered whilst in pj custody...thats torture
So every injury suffered by a prisoner in one of HMPs is torture?
you have tried to maintain it didnt happen even though proved in court
Im using the words from the amnesty website...it was considered serious enough for them to describe it as such...are you trying to make excuses and thereby condoning the torture...taken from the judgement ...source the mccann files...
It was taken as proven that Leonor Cipriano was beaten by elements of the Judicial police who could not be identified, and she didn't fall on the stairs, as was suggested. However, the court failed to ascertain the perpetrators of the aggressions.
Im using the words from the amnesty website...it was considered serious enough for them to describe it as such...are you trying to make excuses and thereby condoning the torture...taken from the judgement ...source the mccann files...
It was taken as proven that Leonor Cipriano was beaten by elements of the Judicial police who could not be identified, and she didn't fall on the stairs, as was suggested. However, the court failed to ascertain the perpetrators of the aggressions.
Yet you and other mccann supporters are unhappy Cipriano's conviction was through the court ?
So Amnesty used the word torture, not the court?
your post makes no sense...not surprising
so what
?
So making sure your terminology is correct in future.my terminology is correct
So every injury suffered by a prisoner in one of HMPs is torture?
So making sure your terminology is correct in future.
in stating posters on here have condoned torture...in stating exactly the meaning of condoning I meant.. I have not committed any libel
So making sure your terminology is correct in future.
Torture means any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity. It does not include pain or suffering arising only from, inherent in or incidental to lawful sanctions."
you are showing your ignorance
Then you have to cite evidence that people have condoned torture.
...and we are still waiting for that.
So every injury suffered by a prisoner in one of HMPs is torture?
Gonçalo Amaral receives a one and a half year suspended sentence Jornal de Noticias
22 May 2009 16h41m
Translation by Nigel Moore
Gonçalo Amaral was sentenced to a year and a half in prison, suspended, for misrepresentation of evidence in the case of aggressions against Leonor Cipriano.
The ruling, read this afternoon, also ordered the acquittal of Gonçalo Amaral on the crime of omission of denunciation.
All defendants who were accused of the crime of torture - Paulo Pereira Cristóvão, Leonel Marques and Paulo Marques Bom - were acquitted.
The inspector António Cardoso, accused of the crime of forgery of a document, was sentenced to two years and three months, also a suspended penalty.
The ruling in the case of alleged attacks on Leonor Cipriano was read this afternoon in the Court of Faro.
It was taken as proven that Leonor Cipriano was beaten by elements of the Judicial police who could not be identified, [because she was beaten while tied to a chair with a bag over her head] and she didn't fall on the stairs, as was suggested. However, the court failed to ascertain the perpetrators of the aggressions.
The judges pointed out the importance of Teresa Magalhães' deposition, from the Institute of Forensic medicine, who clarified the origin of Leonor Cipriano's lesions. On the negative side, they highlighted the lack of credibility of the victim's testimony due to the constant change of versions that prevented them ascertaining who was responsible for the aggressions.
The case dates back to 2004
The process of alleged aggressions against Leonor Cipriano by inspectors of the PJ is related to the "Joana case, which dates back to September 12, 2004, the day when the eight-year-old girl disappeared from the village of Figueira, Portimão, in Algarve.
The accusations of the prosecutor against five ex-inspectors and inspectors of the Judicial police emerged following interrogation of the PJ in Faro in 2004, when Leonor had appeared with lesions on her face and body in Odemira prison, where she was in custody.
Eight months after the date the trial commenced - on 27 October 2008 - it would be known, on the 14th session of the trial, if the five ex-inspectors and inspectors of the Polícia Judiciária (PJ) were to be acquitted or convicted by a court of jury.
Joana's mother, Leonor Cipriano, and uncle, João Cipriano (siblings) were sentenced by the Supreme Court to 16 years in prison each, for crimes of murder and concealment of the child's corpse.
For four days, the lawyer for Leonor Cipriano, Aragão Correia, requested the opening of a new investigation in the "Joana case" and the acquittal of the girl's mother, after João Cipriano confessed in writing that he had tried to sell her.
language is THE component of the forum...what a ridiculous post
So why do you witter vacuously about English prisoners beaten by fellow inmates?
stephen has excused the torture on the basis it did not happen...making excuses is within the meaning of condoning and that is why I stand by my statement
CITE.
you have repeatedly made excuses for the torture on the basis it was carried out by other inmates
stephen posted..
She had injuries, by persons unknown.
The Portuguese judgement would not have been upheld in the UK.
that is clearly trying to excuse the torture and is thus condoning it
That is not condoning.
You seem to be to unable to comprehend previous posts.
the judgement
It was taken as proven that Leonor Cipriano was beaten by elements of the Judicial police who could not be identified, and she didn't fall on the stairs, as was suggested. However, the court failed to ascertain the perpetrators of the aggressions.
I have not denied she was beaten/tortured, have I ?
You've have serious problems in comprehension.
Meanwhile a Portuguese Court judged her guilty of her daughter's murder.
Do you have anything to say about that.
Remember, I have read some of your previous posts as regards that verdict.
The court said she suffered aggressions while in the custody of the PJ. Stephen's claim does not excuse let alone condone torture. If the picture had been Photoshopped then there would have been no torture to condone. Maybe time you admitted defeat.m
posters on here have made excuses for the torture of cipriano...that falls under the definition of condoning...they have therefore condoned torture
Neither Stephen, nor Faithlilly accept that their precious PJ ever stooped so low. They are in denial about the torture of Cipriano, much as holocaust deniers deny the Nazis gassed Jews in order to excuse their crimes and cite supposedly doctored photos and documents and "lies" by concentration camp survivors to attempt to convince non-deniers. It's the same mentality and you too are making excuses for it.
Link to it then.
Total bullshit. Neither Stephen, nor Faithlilly accept that their precious PJ ever stooped so low. They are in denial about the torture of Cipriano, much as holocaust deniers deny the Nazis gassed Jews in order to excuse their crimes and cite supposedly doctored photos and documents and "lies" by concentration camp survivors to attempt to convince non-deniers. It's the same mentality and you too are making excuses for it. It's sickening. 4 of us have agreed to boycott this forum for one week in protest at your biased modding, let's see how you enjoy a forum which just comprises of "sceptics" McCann bashing for a week and massaging each others egos.
Neither Stephen, nor Faithlilly accept that their precious PJ ever stooped so low. They are in denial about the torture of Cipriano, much as holocaust deniers deny the Nazis gassed Jews in order to excuse their crimes and cite supposedly doctored photos and documents and "lies" by concentration camp survivors to attempt to convince non-deniers. It's the same mentality and you too are making excuses for it.
angelo has just admitted to condoning torture as you can see...at least he has the guts to post exactly what he thinks unlike a lot on this forum ...stephen in particular.
angelo has just admitted to condoning torture as you can see...at least he has the guts to post exactly what he thinks unlike a lot on this forum ...stephen in particular.
Because she lied.
Thanks for the link Mercury. So these accused officers are part of the same police division investigating Madeleine's disappearance. Well I never !!
They are. Just goes to show the hypocrisy when painting the uk police white and the portuguese black.
In any case, the mccanns were not tortured, there is no possibility they ever could have been, as there is no possiblity the uk police could ever torture someone arrested in portugal, so struggling to see the relevance anywhere of any of this.....
&%+((£
IMHO it is a device created by supporters to justify the Drs McCann legging it back to the UK at the first opportunity after being made arguido(a) having allegedly previously said they would stay in Portugal as long as necessary to find Madeleine. Well you wouldn't want to stay in a country where the fuzz would lay into you with belaying pins and such just to extract a confession would you? Then of course the SIO was common in both cases so there's a few legs in that.Imo No supporters give a toss about the cipriano case any further than using it for their own ends....
The acid test is how many supporters were there on the protest line outside the courtrooms in 2004/2005 when Leonor Cipriano was being "fitted up"? &%+((£
There was a lad of Bengal who had a mathematical ball...........................
Imo No supporters give a toss about the cipriano case any further than using it for their own ends....
I disagree there are legs in the idea/fear of torture, not with the wide barage of support, attention, from many quarters, govt help, etc etc the parents had
Ps dont understand the mathematical bengal ball bit
But im sure its spot on as per normal
@)(++(*
That's correct, the additional sentence was for perjury before the court.
Lied?
Beaten to a point of near blindness while tied to a chair with a bag over her head, she was doubtless terrified and not thinking very clearly ....
Her accounts of events changed several times.
She lied.
....and why ferryman no mention of her murdered daughter ?
You obviously support the verdict against Amaral, but not Cipriano.
Why is that ?
' amaral torture case '
Amaral did not torture anyone.
Are you implying he did ?
That was not the courts opinion.
IMHO it is a device created by supporters to justify the Drs McCann legging it back to the UK at the first opportunity after being made arguido(a) having allegedly previously said they would stay in Portugal as long as necessary to find Madeleine. Well you wouldn't want to stay in a country where the fuzz would lay into you with belaying pins and such just to extract a confession would you? Then of course the SIO was common in both cases so there's a few legs in that.
The acid test is how many supporters were there on the protest line outside the courtrooms in 2004/2005 when Leonor Cipriano was being "fitted up"? &%+((£
There was a lad of Bengal who had a mathematical ball...........................
on topic... I think it is quite probable that had the McCanns been portuguese they could have been tortured...when we look at what happened in the cipriano and other cases. Obviously as they were english then there was no chance of them being tortured
there was overwhelming evidence in the amaral torture case...as featured on the amnesty international site...but little or no real evidence against cipriano in her trial
As per usual you have grasped the wrong nettle. Cipriano was beaten because she admitted killing her daughter albeit accidentally. The McCanns didn't!!
Wrong again...there was real evidence as you put it, unless you call a recording of a confession imaginary?
the recording was extracted under duress and not admissable in court...yet it was allowed...a clear breach of the law
Wrong again...there was real evidence as you put it, unless you call a recording of a confession imaginary?
You really shouldn't believe everything you read in the British press davel.
I haven't. The PJ are on record as having used torture to extract confessions...The torture of the ciprianos is not relevant to the McCanns...the fact that they were jailed on so little evidence is
She confessed again after the trial or are you going to use the torture excuse again? You can't have it both ways davel so stop posting rubbish.
I am not posting rubbish...you have your views I have mine....the evidence against cipriano is extremely weak ..apart from the forced confessions...imo...
You can't answer that point can you? Thought not!
I certainly can..could you provide links and proof of her confessions...we have been through all this before
She was complicit, get over it.
Wrong again...there was real evidence as you put it, unless you call a recording of a confession imaginary?
You really shouldn't believe everything you read in the British press davel.
The uncertainty regarding what had
happened to Joana provided an ongoing dramatic series of news reporting. Forensic science and
DNA technology received considerable attention in the news coverage, particularly in the
Correio da Manhã, as several news articles voiced high expectations towards the results of the
449
analysis made to the allegedly large number of stains collected in the crime scene. Nevertheless,
it was not possible to match any of the stains to Joana. In an editorial article of 12 November
2005, it is said that: “Only science, CSI style, could have provided the decisive contribution. (...)
I’m convinced that Leonor and João Cipriano are guilty. But what the heck… Couldn’t they have
managed any tiny piece of evidence that would leave me with a clear conscience? (Catarino,
2005).
this is a portuguese source
https://repositorium.sdum.uminho.pt/bitstream/1822/25449/1/Santos%20Filipe%20-%20The%20Dissemination%20and%20Popularisation%20of%20Surveillance.pdf
and makes interesting reading
Its all there in the boards. Correia could help you out, he drafted the last one. @)(++(*
Unlike you I'm not interested in speculative reporting, I prefer my facts from the horses mouth.
I'm off out, Happy New Year.
As per usual you have grasped the wrong nettle. Cipriano was beaten because she admitted killing her daughter albeit accidentally. The McCanns didn't!!
She was beaten to extract a 'confession'.
Or, just for a moment, suppose (as is widely supposed by those who defend the indefensible) that Leonor was beaten after she had confessed.
What would the mere fact of the beating tell you about the nature of the interrogation Leonor was subjected to?
An interrogation with menaces, perhaps? An interrogation where it was made abundantly plain to Leonor what would happen if she didn't tell her interrogators just exactly what they wanted to hear?
Always with the myopia ferryman? Everyone knows the beating came after her initial admission that she had killed Joana by accident. Nobody beat that out of her but then you just go on posting nonsense if it makes you happy.
For the sake of the topic I think the McCanns would have had much more pressure put on them and very possibly put on trial had they been Portuguese with Martin Smith being a key witness.
could you show a cite for the confession... I haven't seen one.
i agree that had the mccanns been portuguese they would have been tried and probably convicted..based on what happened in the cipriano case
Leonor Cipriano makes a new statement about the killing of Joana.
16 January 2009
Leonor Cipriano, mother of the seven-year-old girl missing from the village of Figueira, Portimão on the 12 September 2004, decided to reveal how her daughter was killed by her uncle João (John) Cipriano.
According to the witness, João Cipriano, convinced his sister Leonor to deliver her daughter to the care of persons outside the family, in exchange for a monetary amount. The delivery did not go as planned, and resulted in the murder of Joanna by the uncle.(http://i.imgur.com/bp50zgj.jpg?2)
Leonor Cipriano appeals for information about her daughter Joana after her disappearance.
The witnesses statement, documented and signed by Leonor, who is serving time for murder and concealment of the body of her daughter in Beja prison, was delivered this Friday to the Court of Faro, her lawyer Mark Aragão Correia reported to the CM.
This afternoon, Marcos Aragão Correia, accompanied by her stepfather of Joana, Leandro da Silva, will make a statement on the door of the Court of Faro.
This is not the first time that Leonor's brother has been accused of killing her daughter. During investigations, Joana's mother told the inspectors of the Judicial Police (PJ) that the girl's death would have resulted from a slap given by João Cipriano. But during the trial, Leonor changed version, denying the accusation.
Marcos Aragão Correia defends Leonor in the case of the alleged assaults that claims to have been the target by PJ inspectors, whose trial resumes this Friday at the Court of Faro.
www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/leonor-acusa-joao-cipriano-de-matar-joana
You really must keep up davel.
www.miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3343.msg127258#msg127258
If they had gone to a restaurant in England leaving their kids at home, would they have been tortured by UK police?
The title of this thread is oddly anti-portuguese IMO.
It is obvious that this happened because the adults were out eating at a restaurant - something not a single member of this forum would ever do - it would not have happened if they had stayed in - and all attempts to blame it on the portuguese police are strange IMO.
Dunno about that Peggy but it does not make much sense.
"Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese"?
They are not Portuguese they are British so anything around "had they been Portuguese" is pure speculation. About as useful as "what would have happened if the Titanic had had radar"?
any comments on the mountain of speculation directed at the McCanns
Yes! a lot of the stuff printed down the years has been puerile blx.
Dunno about that Peggy but it does not make much sense.
"Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese"?
They are not Portuguese they are British so anything around "had they been Portuguese" is pure speculation. About as useful as "what would have happened if the Titanic had had radar"?
Any speculation that the mccanns would have been tortured is pure drivel, and no more than that.
It remains very clear cut, that the murderers, i.e. the Cipriano's got their just desserts, and Joanna's mother committed PURJURY.
Any speculation that the mccanns would have been tortured is pure drivel, and no more than that.
It remains very clear cut, that the murderers, i.e. the Cipriano's got their just desserts, and Joanna's mother committed PURJURY.
Unfortunately, you can get away with describing the Ciprianos as "murderers", because the Portuguese judicial system, in its unwisdom, has not seen the folly of regarding (at least one) "confession", extracted under duress, then withdrawn, as unsafe.
Neither has it flinched from extending the prison sentence of Leonor despite the circumstances of her conviction.
To say that this was (and is!) not the finest hour of Portuguese justice would be an understatement.
Unfortunately, you can get away with describing the Ciprianos as "murderers", because the Portuguese judicial system, in its unwisdom, has not seen the folly of regarding (at least one) "confession", extracted under duress, then withdrawn, as unsafe.
Neither has it flinched from extending the prison sentence of Leonor despite the circumstances of her conviction.
To say that this was (and is!) not the finest hour of Portuguese justice would be an understatement.
I don't have to get away with anything.
They are convicted murderers.
No twisting by you will change that, yet were happy and gloating with the verdict against Amaral.
I wonder why. £5%4%
The only reason you and your fellows have tagged onto this case is because of Amaral.
Did you forget to add your reply?
I was I supposed to be tricked into thinking that your signature was your reply?
Unfortunately, you can get away with describing the Ciprianos as "murderers", because the Portuguese judicial system, in its unwisdom, has not seen the folly of regarding (at least one) "confession", extracted under duress, then withdrawn, as unsafe.
Neither has it flinched from extending the prison sentence of Leonor despite the circumstances of her conviction.
To say that this was (and is!) not the finest hour of Portuguese justice would be an understatement.
I don't have to get away with anything.
They are convicted murderers.
No twisting by you will change that, yet were happy and gloating with the verdict against Amaral.
I wonder why. £5%4%
The answer of course and only reason you and your fellows have tagged onto this case, is because of Amaral.
Nah! they were there with their placards and bullhorns outside the court when the case was being tried then had the trial transcripts professionally translated so they knew which end was up and could make representations to the Portuguese Ministry of Justice cos they really care about the case. It would be good if some of this court documentation they undoubtedly have were made available to the rest of us rather than speculative opinion.
That is your opinion and rather predictable, to put it mildly.
As I said, you will say anything to attack him and in any case he has been involved in.
As to being a disgrace, think of two parents whose behaviour led to this case.
Fact is: no witness in this case has been tortured.
Malinka claimed he'd been roughed up during questioning.Source? Does it justify the false insinuation of this thread title that Mr Amaral's PJ/LP/MET team tortured anyone? Anyway that witness was not portuguese. There were dozens of portuguese witnesses and none of them were tortured. The thread's insinuation that portuguese witnesses would have been tortured is completely incorrect.
You have an interesting understanding of mathematics. In either case they are not independent events as they would likely have an overriding cause. If a genetic or environmental trigger can be identified then there will be correlation between cause and effect.
Source? Does it justify the false insinuation of this thread title that Mr Amaral's PJ/LP/MET team tortured anyone? Anyway that witness was not portuguese. There were dozens of portuguese witnesses and none of them were tortured. The thread's insinuation that portuguese witnesses would have been tortured is completely incorrect.
You haven't quite got the hang of how this works (or doesn't work). I will explain.
Independent variables can have a causal link; for example, ice cream sales and temperature.
In hot weather, people are more inclined to eat ice cream than in cold. So we can reasonably predict that as it gets hotter, people will eat more ice cream; and as temperatures drop, they will eat less.
You haven't quite got the hang of how this works (or doesn't work). I will explain.
Independent variables can have a causal link; for example, ice cream sales and temperature.
In hot weather, people are more inclined to eat ice cream than in cold. So we can reasonably predict that as it gets hotter, people will eat more ice cream; and as temperatures drop, they will eat less.
interesting point...they are convicted murderers...but are they murderers
Don't know what the Portuguese call it but here in Ye Olde Blighty we call it joint enterprise.
here in australia if you are convicted as a murderer thats what you are and rightly get jail etc
Like Lindy Chamberlaine, do you mean.
Very good point Eleanor.
I don't think Lindy Chamberlaine was physically tortured, but it was a massive Miscarriage of Justice due to very faulty forensics and a police investigation that refused to consider any other option.
Dare I point out that Lindy Chamberlain never confessed to any involvement in her babies disappearance unlike Leonor Cipriano who did so on numerous occasions.
Dare I point out that Lindy Chamberlain never confessed to any involvement in her babies disappearance unlike Leonor Cipriano who did so on numerous occasions.
Still waiting for a sight of this confession. A second hand account won't do I'm afraid.IS it true that the UK gov arranged for meetings between the PJ and parents to be held at a UK gov building in Portimão instead of at a police station which is what noneramoc folks like you and me would get?
But of course The McCanns were never going to be tortured, not with The British Ambassador close at hand.
IS it true that the UK gov arranged for meetings between the PJ and parents to be held at a UK gov building in Portimão instead of at a police station which is what noneramoc folks like you and me would get?
Still waiting for a sight of this confession. A second hand account won't do I'm afraid.
But of course The McCanns were never going to be tortured, not with The British Ambassador close at hand.
Not as far as I have seen. I have understood that all meetings were held at a PJ Police StationThe PJ were persuaded to give the parents special treatment by locating the regular informal meetings between PJ and parents not at a police station (which is what ordinary people like you or me would have got), but at the UK consulate building. Source is the book by KM page 154.
...(snip)
The PJ were persuaded to give the parents special treatment by locating the regular informal meetings between PJ and parents not at a police station (which is what ordinary people like you or me would have got), but at the UK consulate building. Source is the book by KM page 154.
The PJ agreed to this special arrangement on 24th May. BTW a top blair govt person had a couple of phonechats with a parent on the 23rd, but that can't possibly be connected can it.
The PJ were persuaded to give the parents special treatment by locating the regular informal meetings between PJ and parents not at a police station (which is what ordinary people like you or me would have got), but at the UK consulate building. Source is the book by KM page 154.
The PJ agreed to this special arrangement on 24th May. BTW a top blair govt person had a couple of phonechats with a parent on the 23rd, but that can't possibly be connected can it.
She had injuries, by persons unknown.
The Portuguese judgement would not have been upheld in the UK.
http://www.dn.pt/portugal/interior/caso-joana-relacao-mantem-penas-a-exinspectores-1882361.html
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline
All the PJ officers previously accused by the murderess Leonor Cipriano were immediately considered innocent in her Court Sentence session.
Offline Luz
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 1316
View Profile Personal Message (Offline)
Re: The beating and conviction of Leonor Cipriano
« Reply #14 on: April 10, 2013, 08:39:17 PM »
Quote
It's an open document in FARO Court of Law, go there and look for yourself - I did.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Erm, the article states the opposite of what Luz was saying: all the officers' convictions were upheld.
Are you sure ?
Can you provide back up for that ?
As regards the other three officers.
I was examining the article that you'd cited.
The convictions of Amaral and Cardoso were upheld.
Here we go (the original):
A Relação de Évora refutou a existência de "nulidades e inconstitucionalidades" no acórdão que confirmou a condenação de ex-inspectores da Polícia Judiciária (PJ) no processo de agressões a Leonor Cipriano, mãe de Joana, criança desaparecida no Algarve, em 2004.
A 18 de Março deste ano, o Tribunal da Relação confirmou a condenação dos ex-inspectores da PJ Gonçalo Amaral e António Cardoso Nunes, com penas suspensas, pelo Tribunal de Faro em 2009, mas este último antigo agente requereu "a reforma e aclaração do acórdão".
De acordo com fonte judicial, a Relação de Évora entendeu que "carece de razão" o requerimento de António Cardoso Nunes, condenado a dois anos e três meses de prisão com pena suspensa pelo crime de falsificação de documento. Entendeu ainda o tribunal de segunda instância de Évora que o recurso "extravassa por completo o âmbito permitido a um requerimento de aclaração ou arguição de erros, lapsos, obscuridades ou nulidades".
Na decisão dos recursos dos ex-inspectores, comunicada a 18 de Março de 2011, a Relação também manteve a pena de um ano e seis meses de prisão por crime de falsidade de depoimento, suspensa na sua execução, aplicada a Gonçalo Amaral, ex-coordenador do Departamento de Investigação Criminal de Portimão.
Na sequência da decisão da Relação, Marcos Aragão Correia, advogado de Leonor Cipriano, interpos uma queixa contra o Estado português na Organização das Nações Unidas por violação "grosseira dos mais básicos Direitos Humanos". O advogado referiu à agência Lusa que pediu a condenação e expulsão de Portugal da Comissão dos Direitos Humanos das Nações Unidas.
O caso das agressões a Leonor Cipriano foi julgado em Faro, em 2009, mas o Tribunal de Faro não determinou a autoria das agressões à mãe de Joana. Além de Gonçalo Amaral, absolvido do crime de omissão de denúncia, e de António Nunes Cardoso, também foram julgados os ex-inspectores Paulo Pereira Cristovão e Leonel Morgado Marques e o agente ainda no activo Paulo Marques Bom. Paulo Pereira Cristovão, Leonel Morgado Marques e Paulo Marques Bom foram absolvidos.
Joana desapareceu a 12 de Dezembro de 2004 da aldeia de Figueiró, Portimão, e Leonor Cipriano e o irmão, João Cipriano, foram condenados em 2006 a 16 anos de prisão cada um pelos crimes de homicídio e ocultação de cadáver, após recurso da pena de 18 anos.
O caso voltou à Justiça em finais de 2008, com a mãe de Joana a acusar cinco catuais e ex-inspectores da PJ, num processo envolvendo crimes de tortura, omissão de denúncia e falsificação de documento.
http://www.dn.pt/portugal/interior/caso-joana-relacao-mantem-penas-a-exinspectores-1882361.html
I wasn't talking about those two.
The other three officers, we're the ones I referred to.
One did not have to be Portuguese to be subjected to torture while being questioned by the Policia Judiciaria.
Quote:
The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook.
He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty.
Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process).
He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces.
Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”
http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/
I'm not too sure what category of mental torture might be considered when showing a mother a video tape alleged to demonstrate that her daughter's remains had been in the boot of a car ~ behind a sofa ~ in a corner of a bedroom ~ in a garden, while demanding to know what she knew about it.
That the assertions flew in the face of forensic results amateurishly and wrongly interpreted by the PJ makes it all the more risible but nonetheless dangerous in the attempt to secure an unsafe conviction.
Another case solved!!!!
Does anyone know their success rate? must have matched Eddie's 200.
Bottom line,. the mccanns were never going to be 'tortured' .
Don't you agree ?
Bottom line,. the mccanns were never going to be 'tortured' .
Don't you agree ?
Some might say they have spent the last 8 years being tortured.
Why?
And with no apparent end in sight.
I don't need God to see logic and to hold to account which two people are responsible for their own misfortune.
Can we stop the WWJD arguments, they don't really add to the debate.
Can we stop the WWJD arguments, they don't really add to the debate.
I'm fine with that I think, but can you please clarify what WWJD arguments are.
What Would Jesus Do, it's a bit of an appeal to authority.
What Would Jesus Do, it's a bit of an appeal to authority.
Isn't that a propaganda technique?
Every police force will have used heavy-handed interrogation techniques at some point in their history - the PJ is hardly alone.
Torturing a confession out of someone doesn't appear to have been reserved for just the Portuguese, though: Mick Cook was English.
Kidnap, murder and justice in the Algarve
The Guardian
Published August 1993
"...The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook. He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty. Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process). He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces. Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”
http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1749.105
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1354.0
Every police force will have used heavy-handed interrogation techniques at some point in their history - the PJ is hardly alone.
Torturing a confession out of someone doesn't appear to have been reserved for just the Portuguese, though: Mick Cook was English.
Kidnap, murder and justice in the Algarve
The Guardian
Published August 1993
"...The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook. He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty. Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process). He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces. Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”
http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1749.105
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1354.0
The court did accept that Leonor Cipriano was tortured but what it didnt identify was the reason for that torture.
The Oxford Dictionary defines torture as the action or practice of inflicting severe pain on someone as a punishment or in order to force them to do or say something.
We know that Leonor admitted to having killed her daughter prior to her arrest, arraignment and detention so on that basis confession can be excluded. It is most unlikely that the Portuguese police would torture Leonor just for the hell of it so this again can be excluded. That only leaves one possible reason why she was tortured and that reason has already been touched on by Angelo earlier.
The police had a missing child to find, a mother who admitted to killing her and asking her brother to hide the body. The same brother took the police out on several goose chases but untimately failed to recover the child dead or alive. The emphasis then shifted back to the mother and an attempt to extract information from her which might save the child even at that point. In those terrible circumstances were the police justified in what they did?
The Cipriano case differs from that of Madeleine McCann in that in the latter, neither parent admitted at any time to having had an involvement in their child's disappearance, unlike the Cipriano case.
In the Cipriano case the police were acting on what they assumed to be reliable information from a parent which led them to believe the child could be recoverable. In the McCann case, no such admission was made.
In those circumstances therefore I can see no reason why torture would have been used against the McCanns had they been Portuguese and not from the British Isles.
I think it's telling that you have to go back over 25 years to find a case of police brutality in Portugal before the alleged torture of Cipriano.
Erm, one doesn't.
- The allegations of torture concerning the Cipriano case date back to 2003.
Although Cristovão was acquitted of torturing Leonor due to a lack of proof, he got 120 days of suspension from duties following an investigation by the equivalent of the IPPC. His appeal against that suspension (which can have financial consequences) was rejected. He resigned / retired shortly thereafter to write a book about the case, many aspects of which don't appear to be founded in the available factual evidence to double-check.
He is currently involved in trials involving numerous, serious, but unrelated allegations, regarding his subsequent activities related to a PT football club.
- There is also the issue of Vitor Tavares de Almeida in the Virgolino Borges torture case (which dates back to 2000), for which he got a suspended sentence and a daily fine to be paid to the victim of the beating. For some reason, this took 13 years to resolve.
http://www.dnoticias.pt/actualidade/pais/366745-dois-inspectores-da-pj-condenados
http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/dois-inspetores-da-pj-condenados-por-tortura=f782292
IMO, the Portuguese authorities have made valiant attempts to move forward from past practices of a dubious nature in the past few years, so all kudos to their efforts. Changing institutional culture is complex and takes time.
THE disgraced ex-boss of the Madeleine McCann probe has been charged with torturing a witness in another missing child case.
Goncalo Amaral, 49, is accused of punching and slapping Leandro Silva — who wants £430,000 compensation — during the 2004 hunt for Joana Cipriano, eight.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/madeleine/2512208/Maddie-cop-torture-rap.html
Portugal has indeed made huge strides in sorting out attitudes which appear to have been endemic in the culture of policing and public life.
Some of it down to 'the old order changeth ...' but mainly concerted effort and determination with people who once must have been untouchable facing the full force of the law and being prosecuted.
I think it is against much of the backdrop of the old culture that Madeleine's case was conducted with many of the old order still in positions of influence.
THE disgraced ex-boss of the Madeleine McCann probe has been charged with torturing a witness in another missing child case.
Goncalo Amaral, 49, is accused of punching and slapping Leandro Silva — who wants £430,000 compensation — during the 2004 hunt for Joana Cipriano, eight.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/madeleine/2512208/Maddie-cop-torture-rap.html
Portugal has indeed made huge strides in sorting out attitudes which appear to have been endemic in the culture of policing and public life.
Some of it down to 'the old order changeth ...' but mainly concerted effort and determination with people who once must have been untouchable facing the full force of the law and being prosecuted.
I think it is against much of the backdrop of the old culture that Madeleine's case was conducted with many of the old order still in positions of influence.
Yes, I agree that institutional change is a long process...
Concerning the allegations or charges mentioned in the press or in court rulings that I have mentioned above have nothing to do with the arrival on the scene of Aragão, who appears to be a somewhat controversial figure.
So a Sun article of 2009 about a charge to which he was found not guilty. Clutching at straws there.
I have often wondered about the conclusion of the case taken out by Leandro. Do you have a cite?
It's obvious, if he had been found guilty it would have been splashed around all over.
Isn't that a propaganda technique?
Thirty odd years.
The Met seem to be taking a similar amount of time to change.
I have no idea whether other, less press-worthy cases, of allegedly beating suspects to get "confessions", or other he /she blinked-and-is-therefore-guilty cases have occurred since 2003.
IMO, the issue isn't just about the PJ (or Met for the UK), but about how all of the related institutions - including the relationship with the media - function as a whole in the interest of justice.
Justice is for everyone, even for those we do not like and those who are convicted criminals.
I am content with that as a principle.
The press however will always single out the guy with glasses, long hair, odd way of dressing, lives on his own, the woman on the game or anyone who is different then dress it up to sell copy. In fact if you are not middle class WASP forget justice where the press and possibly some other institutions are concerned. IMHO of course.
Justice is for everyone, even for those we do not like and those who are convicted criminals.
I am content with that as a principle.
The press however will always single out the guy with glasses, long hair, odd way of dressing, lives on his own, the woman on the game or anyone who is different then dress it up to sell copy. In fact if you are not middle class WASP forget justice where the press and possibly some other institutions are concerned. IMHO of course.
Very recently we have seen the exact reason why the press and public opinion are not competent to determine the guilt or innocence of "the guy with glasses, long hair, odd way of dressing, lives on his own, ... ... who is different."
Finding and following the evidence to be presented in a court of law is probably a better way of doing things ... certainly preferable to deciding who 'dunnit' and making the 'evidence' or lack of it, suit.
Justice is for everyone, even for those we do not like and those who are convicted criminals.
I am content with that as a principle.
The press however will always single out the guy with glasses, long hair, odd way of dressing, lives on his own, the woman on the game or anyone who is different then dress it up to sell copy. In fact if you are not middle class WASP forget justice where the press and possibly some other institutions are concerned. IMHO of course.
The "landlord" would appear to fit into that category in the UK.
Leonor, a mother from a modest background who'd had children by previous relationships would seem to fit into that category as well.
I can honestly find nothing that merited that trial even going to court... let alone the life sentences.
The "landlord" would appear to fit into that category in the UK.
Leonor, a mother from a modest background who'd had children by previous relationships would seem to fit into that category as well.
I can honestly find nothing that merited that trial even going to court... let alone the life sentences.
The "landlord" would appear to fit into that category in the UK.
Leonor, a mother from a modest background who'd had children by previous relationships would seem to fit into that category as well.
I can honestly find nothing that merited that trial even going to court... let alone the life sentences.
You should never discount the possibility she was evil and guilty.
You should never discount the possibility she was evil and guilty.
I haven't, in fact. I wasn't born yesterday and I'm aware of some horrific cases of child abuse / faked abduction scenarios.
But I simply haven't found anything in the Cipriano affair to substantiate what they were accused of.
And, no, I'm not blamely everything on Amaral's doorstep.
The idea that a court could rule that a rule of common experience is that as children normally arrive home and that therefore it can be accepted as fact that she did as well is simply... beyond words, for me.
I can think of no other modern democracy where a travesty such as the Cipriano case would have even reached the stage of being considered by a court.
OK let's assume Leonor Cipriano and her brother are innocent and the Portuguese legal system is the most bent you can conceive of. Now where do you wish to go from there?
I would take into account that possibly up to five men had subjected her to beatings over a period of two days to her severe injury.
I can think of no other modern democracy where a travesty such as the Cipriano case would have even reached the stage of being considered by a court.
I haven't, in fact. I wasn't born yesterday and I'm aware of some horrific cases of child abuse / faked abduction scenarios.
But I simply haven't found anything in the Cipriano affair to substantiate what they were accused of.
And, no, I'm not putting all the blame on Amaral's doorstep (even though he was the coordinator of that affair as well, without any previous experience of such cases).
The idea that a court could rule that a rule of common experience is that as children normally arrive home and that therefore it can be accepted as fact that she did as well is simply... beyond words, for me.
OK let's assume Leonor Cipriano and her brother are innocent and the Portuguese legal system is the most bent you can conceive of. Now where do you wish to go from there?
Many countries have had their moments of bungled investigations and wrongful convictions. A number of them hitting the press recently are from the US, where the Innocence Project appears to be quite steadfast in wading through evidence.
Poor and black seems to be a red flag in the US. There are too many cases of innocent people of all ethnicities spending most of their lives on death row in that country and we have our share of miscarriages here too although I believe the introduction of PACE has had a beneficial effect.
Doesn't alter the fact that the Cipriano case did nothing to promote the reputation of Portugal's justice system.
And child abuse which goes unpunished in any country does nothing to promote a justice system. Justice is a hit and a miss anyway.
Poor and black seems to be a red flag in the US. There are too many cases of innocent people of all ethnicities spending most of their lives on death row in that country and we have our share of miscarriages here too although I believe the introduction of PACE has had a beneficial effect.
Doesn't alter the fact that the Cipriano case did nothing to promote the reputation of Portugal's justice system.
There is no evidence of child abuse of either Madeleine or Joana. The two children simply vanished not far from each other.
It could be coincidence, or there could be a link to some weirdo still at large or in prison for other offences. There is also the potential connection of other offences against children in the same area.
Whoever was responsible for Madeleine's disappearance or the attacks on other children since late September 2003 can't be either Leonor or João.
Both children were neglected. One was subjected to abuse that we know of as per witnesses of people in the village. The mother was known to be cruel towards her daughter.
If there is a local child snatcher, then he would never have snatched those children if they were with their parents!
Are you suggesting this 'child snatcher' grabbed little Maddie a she wanderd out to look for her parents?
i don't think there is any real evidence she was cruel to her daughter
Yet I believe witnesses in the area say she was.
what you believe is not evidence...do you not realise that
i don't think there is any real evidence she was cruel to her daughter
Davel, people do not come forward to the police in that country willy nilly. I have no reason to belive all these witnesses were lying. They had nothing to gain.
which witnesses
Read up on the case.
Both children were neglected. One was subjected to abuse that we know of as per witnesses of people in the village. The mother was known to be cruel towards her daughter.
If there is a local child snatcher, then he would never have snatched those children if they were with their parents!
Are you suggesting this 'child snatcher' grabbed little Maddie a she wanderd out to look for her parents?
When I skimmed through the Supreme Court ruling in Portuguese, I could find no trace of cruelty towards Joana.
The numerous neutral-to-positive statements about Leonor didn't, erm, get translated for some reason.
The only points (from memory) against Leonor from all of the witness statements were that she didn't accompany her to her first day of school (but the reason wasn't clarified); that supermarket-lady took her to be checked at a hospital for a cough (but I have found nothing to indicate that Leonor could drive, yet had two babies to look after). One school-related person found that she sometimes turned up inappropriately clothed for the weather. When social services visited (unannounced), there was nothing to report other than the children were seen to be eating crackers while lunch was being cooked. Joana had been seen sweeping the house on occasion, but she had also been seen playing outside with friends.
That's it, from memory. Hardly cruelty, nor even mistreatment.
Ae you suggesting the witnesses all collaberated together in a hate campaigne of sorts against leonor?
BabyP.......in a perfect world all was fine. that turned out to be the fault of the head of Social Services not the parents.. ah well.
Read up on the case.
according to Carana who knows more about this case than anyone on here...there are no such witnesses...you are believing myths again
I read about the case before.
As to Carana, that is her opinion.
No more, no less.
I suggest not mixing up the Baby P case with the Cipriano one.
I searched through all the witness statements in the Cipriano case and found nothing more that what I've just said.
Numerous statements stated that she'd been a caring mother to Joana, and no one had ever seen her even shout at her, let alone slap her, but Astro / Joana Morais never found time to translate them...
there are no witnesses
there are no witnesses
The comparison I am making is quite valid. no one thought baby P was in danger as there was no witneses.
Anyone who showed concern for Joana is deemed to be petty and nasty AND had it in for the mother? How many people who are sexually, mentally, pyisically abused have witneses? I believe people came forward because they were concerned for the childs welfare, but well , as you are the expert in this case I will accept they are innocent and everyone else are liars .
I have never claimed to be an expert on the case.
There are numerous "parents" who have indeed battered / abused their children to death. That's a sad fact. When the facts have been established beyond reasonable doubt, then prison is where they should be.
I had originally assumed that the Ciprianos were actually guilty based on skim reading media reports at the time... and it wasn't until I started attempting to decipher the Supreme Court ruling that I realised that very little of what appeared in the media was more than salacious gossip based, yet again, on half-baked leaks.
I don't know whether one or both are guilty of anything related to her disappearance... perhaps they are, after all, who knows? However, as it stands, the case really does not appear to have served justice to this little girl by any means.
I find the total lack of probative evidence of any kind to be astonishing. IMO, it should never have gone to trial. let alone have led to two simple rural folk being banged up for lengthy sentences primarily o n the basis of a "reconstruction" presented on the last day and which was of a very dubious nature.
interesting reading:This would mean no bank transactions, use of a mobile phone, visits to their friends, relatives or their GP".
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-17464298
"Det Ch Insp Howard Groves, who led the Met investigation, said he had "no nagging doubts" that Mr Banfield was dead, but admitted missing body murders were extremely difficult to prove.
He said: "You have to satisfy the jury that someone is dead and therefore not going to walk into a police station and say, 'I believe my wife and daughter have been convicted of my murder, but here I am alive and well'."
He said two particular lines of enquiry form the cornerstone of missing body murder investigations.
Police have to prove an individual was alive in the first instance. Officers then have to prove that normal behaviour by the victim has stopped suddenly and completely.
This would mean no bank transactions, use of a mobile phone, visits to their friends, relatives or their GP".
This would mean no bank transactions, use of a mobile phone, visits to their friends, relatives or their GP".
That's an interesting test. It would appear on 4 fronts I'm dead. Only 1 to go.
This would mean no bank transactions, use of a mobile phone, visits to their friends, relatives or their GP".
That's an interesting test. It would appear on 4 fronts I'm dead. Only 1 to go.
In the case of Karlie Pearce-Stevenson, 3 of the 5 tests were passed as the murderer + accomplice went to great lengths to make the victim appear alive.
http://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2015/oct/27/texts-karlie-pearce-stevenson-phone-sent-family-years-after
Have the Cipriano case files been released? Do we take the case files in the McCann case for granted and struggle with the lack of information available in other cases where the files have not been released?
Not scoring points, just genuine questions.
I presume that the files are available for consultation on a dusty bookshelf somewhere, but they don't appear to be online, neither do journalists appear to have pored over them. The ruling from the original trial doesn't appear to have been uploaded, either, but the SC one appears to have repeated the "facts" (proven or not) and the witness court testimony made at the time.
Handing out a DVD of the accessible McCann files appears to have been an unprecedented decision due to the anticipated rush of media interest.
You didn't read the link then? as that type of cover up is referred to in the article.
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
I did read the link but perhaps I was confused about which aspect you were highlighting. I'm just surprised you didn't pick up on the last sentence "One of the things that has prevented the perfect murder is just how difficult it is to get rid of the corpse. Most of the time it will turn up."
I posted the link for all to read and form their own conclusions. I high lighted a taster which I found interestingDifficult especially to get rid of a body successfully in a foreign country, in a very short time frame, in the dark and without the aid of transport I'm sure you'd agree. Well you probably won't but there we are...
No matter how difficult it may be to dispose of a body there remain a considerable number of convictions without a corpse and a number of corpses fail to materialise even in the fullness of time. You need only be a bit diligent on Google to find the cases. Well one is mentioned in the article I linked, Muriel McKay allegedly shoved through a mutrator and fed to pigs. Now where did that idea crop up 30+ years later?
There is one killing in this country where it took 8 years for the body to turn up and to my knowledge the bodies of Jack McVitie and Frank Mitchell have never showed up.
Difficult yes impossible no; that much is self evident.
If there had not been such Media interest, and the immediate presence of The British Ambassador then I do believe that at least Kate McCann would have been tortured into some kind of confession. But Amaral saw his nemesis, and then proceeded to do the only other thing he could, in some vague hope of justifying the treatment of The Ciprianos.
Michael Cook was tortured and left in his own excretement, appearing in court with black eyes and broken teeth. And absolutely no one did anything about it. Not even Britain. This was not going to be allowed again.
Meanwhile, Rebelo was fiercely criticised (in certain quarters!) for leading a separate (Portuguese) investigation (the name of which escapes me) which led to no arrests and no successful conclusion, let alone convictions.
Which reinforces my impression (of Rebelo) that he conducts his investigations where the evidence leads (or doesn't!), not where his prejudices and personal inclinations takes him.
Rebelo is a real policeman.
Rebelo was stymied before he even began. Which leads me to suspect that absolutely no one in The PJ on the Algarve was being monitored. They were a law unto themselves. No one was even remotely interested in what they were up to.LP were working with Rebelo's PJ as proven by communications between them in Feb 2008.
What has transpired since would suggest that steps are being taken. But short of seriously castigating all of them at the time, then there wasn't much Rebelo could do. More coward him. He crept his way around it all.
LP were working with Rebelo's PJ as proven by communications between them in Feb 2008.
Difficult especially to get rid of a body successfully in a foreign country, in a very short time frame, in the dark and without the aid of transport I'm sure you'd agree. Well you probably won't but there we are...
I agree it would be especially difficult but not impossible, however the bit that was being discussed at the beginning of this particular conversation was Cipriano.
You know, the old: well there wasn't a body, she had seven bells knocked out of her, there were no "forensics", there was only circumstantial evidence, the guy in charge was the same one who was in charge of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
I was merely observing that there have been cases, in this country, where a verdict of murder was brought in where no body had been recovered there was no "forensics" and only circumstantial evidence. In fact a large number of criminal convictions rely on the cumulative effect of circumstantial evidence for their success rather than direct evidence.
There doesn't seem to be any circumstantial evidence in the cipriano case
I agree it would be especially difficult but not impossible, however the bit that was being discussed at the beginning of this particular conversation was Cipriano.
You know, the old: well there wasn't a body, she had seven bells knocked out of her, there were no "forensics", there was only circumstantial evidence, the guy in charge was the same one who was in charge of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
I was merely observing that there have been cases, in this country, where a verdict of murder was brought in where no body had been recovered there was no "forensics" and only circumstantial evidence. In fact a large number of criminal convictions rely on the cumulative effect of circumstantial evidence for their success rather than direct evidence.
I'd agree that there may be the odd case in which sufficient evidence exists to convict someone, beyond a reasonable doubt, for murder without a body.
However - and this is my own criteria - I would have thought that whatever evidence did exist would need to be overwhelming in order to demonstrate, beyond a reasonable doubt that:
a) substantial evidence existed that the victim was in fact dead;
b) any such death was due to a third-party;
c) in the event of a) and b) that the death was more than an accident or manslaughter / negligent homicide (whichever definition is used in a particular jurisdiction);
d) investigative procedure had been diligently followed throughout;
e) sufficient evidence existed as to the perpretators in the event of the above;
f) the right to a fair trial had not been compromised.
What, in any of the above, supports how these convictions were arrived at?
Edited to add a further point.
Judge by your own criteria by all means however that way lies anarchy if we all want to do it and impose our own mores and punishments accordingly. I remain content that on balance individual cases will be judged on the basis of what ever law prevails in that particular jurisdiction. It ain't perfect but it's better than a bunch of yahoos who can't tell the difference between a paediatrician and a paedophile calling the shots.
I don't think the McCanns would have been tortured. The PJ would not have dared tortured two intelligent British subjects because they would have known they'd never have gotten away with it, ignorant Portuguese peasants are much easier game.
So you don't agree that the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants then? Interesting...
XENOPHOBIC COMMENT.
So you don't agree that the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants then? Interesting...
Judge by your own criteria by all means however that way lies anarchy if we all want to do it and impose our own mores and punishments accordingly. I remain content that on balance individual cases will be judged on the basis of what ever law prevails in that particular jurisdiction. It ain't perfect but it's better than a bunch of yahoos who can't tell the difference between a paediatrician and a paedophile calling the shots.
Three different questions, intelligent vs ignorant, British vs Portuguese and professional vs peasant.not questions, facts. The McCanns are intelligent British professionals and the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants.
not questions, facts. The McCanns are intelligent British professionals and the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants.
Three different questions, intelligent vs ignorant, British vs Portuguese and professional vs peasant.
But which is the key factor in torture or not torture?The key factors are: British, intelligent, professonal vs Portuguese, ignorant, peasant.
I would amend "intelligent vs ignorant" to educated v uneducated.
Again, I'd agree in principle, but to take even my first point: there is no evidence that couldn't be successfully questioned by an averagely bright 10-year-old that she actually got home, let alone that she was massacred within it.
The "evidence" that she got home is one witness (not cross-examined) who stated the he/she saw her walking towards home while the witness was having a fag on a balcony somewhere in the vicinity of the church area. It was accepted by the court that, as a rule of common experience, children normally arrive home, and that therefore it was classified as a proven fact that she did as well.
- Could the witness have mistaken her for someone else? (Possibly not in a small village.)
- Could the witness have been lying? (Who knows?)
- While child abduction may be rare, seeing a child walking towards home is not a guarantee that the child actually did arrive back home.
That's for starters.
ETA: to remain on topic, in a police investigation without checks and balances (e.g, CCTV, recorded interviews with start and end times), recorded police brutality... the judicial system seems to have been dysfunctional.
Would the McCanns have been tortured had they been Portuguese? People had been beaten up in 2004 and Madeleine disappeared only 3 years later. So I don't find that implausible. On the other hand, I'm not aware of any cases of beatings in police custody since then.
Without the full translated transcripts and ditto police files we are shooting in the dark.
I say tomayto you say tomarto.
We don't need anymore than we already have to know this is a strong case for a miscarriage of justice
Then explain why no successful appeal has been lodged? without using the word "Montclair".
poor ...uneducated... disgraceful justice system that sentenced someone to basically a life sentence based on no evidence...
poor ...uneducated... disgraceful justice system that sentenced someone to basically a life sentence based on no evidence...
Then explain why no successful appeal has been lodged? without using the word "Montclair".Are you trying to tell us that whether or not you appeal your sentence is a pointer as to whether or not you have been a victim of a miscarriage of justice? Have there never been individuals incarcerated who have not appealed their sentences who have later been found to have not been guilty of the crimes they were put away for?
Then explain why no successful appeal has been lodged? without using the word "Montclair".
Without the full translated transcripts and ditto police files we are shooting in the dark.
I say tomayto you say tomarto.
I doubt that anything substantial of an incriminating nature would have been left out of the prosecution case, which was reflected in the SC ruling.
If anything, the reverse might be true - i.e., the defence appears to have been little more than an assumption that the case would be thrown out due to lack of evidence. What is not clear to me is whether they had - or could have applied for - the resources at their disposal to mount an effective defence or not.
The full SC ruling is online, albeit in Portuguese. Concerning the transcripts (if you mean of the witness testimony), 45 witnesses gave testimony during the course of under three days, which allowing for lunch breaks, appears to have been quite a marathon, so I doubt that the full transcripts would have revealed much more.
The police files might have been interesting, but once the Faro boys took over from Portimão (after only 4 days), with 11 arguidos, heavy-handed interrogations for at least some of them, summary statements in reported speech - there might not be a lot that was officially recorded.
Out of curiosity, I would have been interested in the forensic lab report - but the bottom line would still have been the same.
This isn't an appropriate thread to make a list of all the things that I find jaw-dropping about what IS contained in the ruling as it is.
I mean the entire record of the proceedings in the court.