A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[The General]

The problem you have with that is that what Amaral wrote in his book detailing what he thought was evidence quite simply was not.  It was just his belief.
He based his book, his theories, his contribution as coordinator on Madeleine's case on ephemera which lasted only in his fevered certainty for as long as it was not subject to scrutiny and when it was, simply vanished like a puff of smoke.

There is absolutely no evidence that the McCanns "were up to something".  If there had been one or both of them would probably still be doing time in a Portuguese jail and like Joana before her, there would have been no need for anyone to bother keeping the flame alight in the search for Madeleine.

Please bear in mind that tagging a libel with 'opinion' doesn't make it less of a libel.

Good read though, lid.

[The General]

What is Vista do Mar?

Where's the [rolleyes] emoji?

[Erngath]

You asked for 'something'. I mean, there's dozens more, as you know.

Actually, you've inspired me to do a 'We Didn't Start the Fire' parody.
It's gonna be epic!
Do do be doo be doo doo....(that's not it by the way, Ern)

 

[carlymichelle]

can i just say im not in the fire areas here in australia but  can you  all   think of those in australia  affected it is a shocking  thing and im so sad   about it

[Eleanor]

can i just say im not in the fire areas here in australia but  can you  all   think of those in australia  affected it is a shocking  thing and im so sad   about it

Most of us are Carly.  We just don't have any real idea.  We do get fires here in France, but Brittany got very shirty about this some time ago.  No Bloody Garden Bonfires from March until October.

But nasty people do start these fires, although perhaps not always.

Is Tasmania more wet than Australia?

Sorry.  I am ignoring the Off Topic because the whole thing is awful.

[ShiningInLuz]

can i just say im not in the fire areas here in australia but  can you  all   think of those in australia  affected it is a shocking  thing and im so sad   about it

Conjola.

[sadie]

Conjola.

Oh, dear

So much fear; so much pain; so much loss of life to both wild animals and humans.   Poor kangeroo.

[Erngath]

Oh, dear

So much fear; so much pain; so much loss of life to both wild animals and humans.   Poor kangeroo.

It's dreadful.
Heartbreaking!

[G-Unit]

The problem you have with that is that what Amaral wrote in his book detailing what he thought was evidence quite simply was not.  It was just his belief.
He based his book, his theories, his contribution as coordinator on Madeleine's case on ephemera which lasted only in his fevered certainty for as long as it was not subject to scrutiny and when it was, simply vanished like a puff of smoke.

There is absolutely no evidence that the McCanns "were up to something".  If there had been one or both of them would probably still be doing time in a Portuguese jail and like Joana before her, there would have been no need for anyone to bother keeping the flame alight in the search for Madeleine.

Please bear in mind that tagging a libel with 'opinion' doesn't make it less of a libel.

I didn't mention Amaral; I'm afraid I don't share the McCann/supporter's obsession with the man. All the evidence has been discussed ad infinitum. I've seen no evidence that Madeleine is alive and findable, that's for sure.

Please explain how you think I've libelled someone.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Where's the [rolleyes] emoji?

Well?

[Mr Gray]

I didn't mention Amaral; I'm afraid I don't share the McCann/supporter's obsession with the man. All the evidence has been discussed ad infinitum. I've seen no evidence that Madeleine is alive and findable, that's for sure.

Please explain how you think I've libelled someone.

I don't think you are in any position to describe other posters, as obsessed.  How many hours have you spent poring over the files and posting on this and other forums

[barrier]

It will.  But then Madeleine's life might not have been ruined.  That is the difference between you and me.

By not being brought up by her parents,hmmm.

[G-Unit]

I don't think you are in any position to describe other posters, as obsessed.  How many hours have you spent poring over the files and posting on this and other forums

I can recommend reading the files. It helps to clear up myths/miconceptions, many of which were spread by the media such as;

Amaral being in charge of the investigation
Telecinco had obtained leaked copies of the McCann's police statements
No police searched Praia da Luz during the night of 3/4th May 2007
Kate McCann told the police of her worries that her children had been sedated
That the patio doors were left unlocked in case of fire
That dining at the Tapas restaurant was similar to dining in one's garden
That the bar quiz run by the aerobics instructor took place on 3rd

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-474656/Madeleine-missing-hour-did-McCanns-check-children.html

[Mr Gray]

I can recommend reading the files. It helps to clear up myths/miconceptions, many of which were spread by the media such as;

Amaral being in charge of the investigation
Telecinco had obtained leaked copies of the McCann's police statements
No police searched Praia da Luz during the night of 3/4th May 2007
Kate McCann told the police of her worries that her children had been sedated
That the patio doors were left unlocked in case of fire
That dining at the Tapas restaurant was similar to dining in one's garden
That the bar quiz run by the aerobics instructor took place on 3rd

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-474656/Madeleine-missing-hour-did-McCanns-check-children.html

That could be described as obsessive. Perhaps best not to describe others as obsessive when the same description could be applied to yourself

[G-Unit]

That could be described as obsessive. Perhaps best not to describe others as obsessive when the same description could be applied to yourself

Why do you see reading the files as 'obsessive'? Therin lies the evidence, which the media and a lot of supporters seem to be oblivious to.