Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42775 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Redblossom

  • Guest
And I have yet to come across ANYONE who can explain Jenny Murat's

VW van on the seaside - inviting folks to give info about Madeleine's disappearance

who would not go to the police

THAT, frankly does not compute on any level

and what information did she get and what did she do with it - no mention of it anywhere!

Yep just like Antonio Cardoso's testimony (the cab driver) certain facets have been expunged down the Algarve

Which one? The original one that he saw her evening 3rd May or the revised version printed years later that he saw her 4th May, all in context of Pj doing nothing about it of course pffft

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Did Murat do an interview with the Express about Birch?

debunker

  • Guest
And you don't understand the law about torts either. It was not an 'out ofcourt' settlement, it was a settlement agreed brfore a judge- a different thing entirely.

***

So sorry debunker I dont understand tort, I havent studied it, but do pls explain if the express journalists would face jail after an out of court settlement which was the question if they printed another unhelpful story

The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

But your comment about the McCann Express Case is wrong in fact.

If an action is brought in court and started, it becomes a concern of the court- the court nneds to ensure that the matter is settled once it is raised. In this case the Express decided not to defend the case and in orser to bring the action to a close, their lawyers went before the judge in open court, admitted that the complained about items were defamatory and described the offer they had made to the McCanns of Apology and Compensation.

Your statement that 'the McCanns got an out of court settlement' is in error. It is a myth promulgated by the [ censored word ]s in order to ameliorate the damage done to their cause by the Express judgement which showed that the headlines and stories were libel.

If a case is settled following a solicitors letter, that is an out of court settlement. This ettlement was a finding of defamation before a court- with the admission by the Express being comparable to a guilty plea in a criminal case.

Words matter.

ferryman

  • Guest
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

debunker

  • Guest
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.

ferryman

  • Guest
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.

The case would have been heard in the Crown Court (criminal) if it had been a criminal matter.

It was heard in the High Court which is civil ...

debunker

  • Guest
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.

The case would have been heard in the Crown Court (criminal) if it had been a criminal matter.

It was heard in the High Court which is civil ...

Wrong. In almost every aspect.

The High Court has three parts: Chancery, Queens Bench Division, and the Family Division.

Part of the Queen's Bench Division is Criminal appeals, and QBD Judges travel to Crown Courts to hear the most important criminal Trials.

Crown Courts are local courts which replaced the previous circuit courts and hear most criminal matters above the Magistrates competence.

Cite:

http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/you-and-the-judiciary/going-to-court/high-court

I do not believe that you can any longer be imprisoned for a non criminal offence.


Corrected cite URL
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 08:17:20 AM by debunker »

ferryman

  • Guest
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 08:07:11 AM by ferryman »

debunker

  • Guest
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.

ferryman

  • Guest
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.

No he was not!

debunker

  • Guest
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.

No he was not!

From your own quote of the Liverpool Echo:

"Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court...."


ferryman

  • Guest
Contempt of court

April 2004

13.28 Contempt of court - background and description

The term "contempt of court" is of ancient origin having been used in England certainly since the thirteenth century and probably earlier. At common law, a contempt is an act or omission calculated to interfere with the due administration of justice.

A person guilty of contempt is described as a contemnor.

 

13.29 Types of contempt


Contempt may be civil or criminal. The criminal standard of proof i.e. beyond reasonable doubt, applies to both (Dean v Dean [1987] 1 FLR 517 CA). A typical civil contempt might be conduct involving a breach, or assisting a breach, of a court order. Criminal contempts include assaulting a judge, or anyone else in court.
Failure to co-operate in the course of a public examination despite attendance at it may also constitute a contempt (Official Receiver v Cummings-John [2000] BPIR 320).

 

13.30 Penalties for contempt

The court's power to punish for contempt of court may be exercised by an order for committal to prison or by other means including a fine.

[Contempt of Court Act 1981]

Superior courts, e.g. the High Court can imprison for a fixed period of up to two years. The county and magistrates’ courts can imprison for up to one month.

 

13.31 Application for committal


Where a contempt occurs at court (sometimes called in the face of the court), the judge involved will generally deal with it. The High Court has jurisdiction to make an order of committal for contempt in the face of the court by its own motion , as does a judge of the county court. A district judge only has the power to make a committal order where it is specifically provided for under an enactment.
Notes: [CPR98 sch 1 RSC order 52 and practice direction RSC 52, CPR 98 sch 2 CCR order 29]

[County Court Act 1984 s118]

Otherwise, a written application must be made for committal (for contempt) on which the official receiver should consult Technical Section.

The application must state exactly what the alleged contemnor has done or omitted to do which constitutes a contempt of court with sufficient detail to enable him to meet the charge. The necessary information must be given in the notice itself. If lengthy particulars are required it is permissible to include them in a schedule or addendum to the notice, provided that they form part of the notice itself. It is not permissible to refer in the notice to a witness statement or other separate document for particulars which ought to be in the notice (Chiltern District Council v. Keane [1985] 1 W.L.R. 619, Harmsworth v. Harmsworth [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1676).

 

13.32 Purging

When a person is in contempt of court, he/she may cease to be so by apologising to the court, or "purging the contempt".

 

[Back to Part 2 - Persons required to co-operate] [Onto Part 4 - Public examination]


http://www.insolvencydirect.bis.gov.uk/freedomofinformation/technical/technicalmanual/Ch13-24/Chapter13/part3/part_3.htm

debunker

  • Guest
A little learning is a dangerous thing.

There are two 'forms' of contempt- civil and criminal, but only one disposal- criminal.

The question to ask yourself is "Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record"

ferryman

  • Guest
A little learning is a dangerous thing.

There are two 'forms' of contempt- civil and criminal, but only one disposal- criminal.

The question to ask yourself is "Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record"

No.  Because his transgression was a civil one, for which he received a suspended prison sentence.

13.30 Penalties for contempt

The court's power to punish for contempt of court may be exercised by an order for committal to prison or by other means including a fine.

[Contempt of Court Act 1981]

Superior courts, e.g. the High Court can imprison for a fixed period of up to two years. The county and magistrates’ courts can imprison for up to one month.


Further Edit: the County Court is also civil (lower than the High Court).  It also has power to pass custodial sentences.
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 08:57:12 AM by ferryman »

debunker

  • Guest
Exactly.

Now answer the question- Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record?