Author Topic: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?  (Read 62564 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #60 on: May 07, 2013, 06:23:36 PM »
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

sorry but you are just wrong - do you have a statement from the man walking across the top of the road?

you are talking about an attempt to recreate the abduction - not a reconstruction.

Well yes,  that's exactly what I am talking about  ...  a reconstruction of events that are claimed to have  happened that night

It is claimed that an abductor struck just after Gerry left the apartment, and that he was seen making off with Madeleine by Jane  a few minutes later

That  'event'  should be re-enacted to see if it would have been possible in the few minutes allowed

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #61 on: May 07, 2013, 06:25:09 PM »
DCI they couldnt refuse as arguidos so there cannot be any email showing they did so, their tv interviews *prove* the idea was an anathema to them, get it now?

No, I know that, and they didn't refuse. So how can anyone say, they refused to go back?.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #62 on: May 07, 2013, 06:34:00 PM »
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)
Has anyone here e-mailed SY and got an answer ?

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #63 on: May 07, 2013, 06:39:00 PM »
[

Gerry walked through the living room  ( no abductor there ).  He checked his and Kate's bedroom looking for Madeleine  ( no abductor there ).  He used the bathroom  ( no abductor there )

Gerry himself concedes that if an abductor was in the apartment whilst he did his check,  then he was probably hiding behind the door of the children's bedroom

Another good reason to do a reconstruction ...  it would demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it,  and if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine
[/quote]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What about the kitchen - the entrance is opposite Madeleine's bedroom door.  Could he have hidden in there, where Gerry didn't look?

Also Jez Wilkins said he was talking to GM for 3 to 5 mins - if it was nearer 5 mins before Jane passed them by then that gives a longer time for the abductor  - say 4 mins before JT saw him.

There may have been 2 abductors and Madeleine could have been handed over the wall to the other one in the carpark.  That would cut down the distance to the carpark entrance and also explain why Madeleine's head was on the L/h side of the man Jayne saw.

I honestly don't see how a physical reconstruction would be helpful.  Apart from Gerry - everyone else could only give approximate times for their movements.   Normally to be a couple of minutes adrift  here and there in a reconstruction wouldn't matter but in this case precise timing is vital and they could not give exact times.  Also they would need to remember exactly what speed they walked at - how long exactly they spent checking etc.   They can't be expected to remember all that with precision.     Therefore there is no way they could guarantee a faithful reproduction of their movements.

On the other hand SY have the expertise and the equipment to conduct a forensic analysis of the timelines given, and no doubt could key in all the possible variables.   They are satisfied that there was a clear opportunity for Madeleine to have been abducted.   If it was not possible, then I don't think they would confirm, as they have, that it was.


 


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #64 on: May 07, 2013, 06:41:07 PM »
Quote
For the life of me, I cannot think why it is being objected to here !

who's objecting?

Discussing relevancy and facts that you don't know about.

I am getting the clear message that some members do not want a reconstruction to take place  (  even one with police personel playing the key roles )

I am bound to wonder why

 

have you sent an email to SY?

I am happy for them to do it your way - no problem at all - clear as anything - can I convince you more?

In fact if tapas group said now they would go back i would be happy too - no problems - airspace may be a problem but nevermind.

I have no objection at all

(note to self - can I make it any clearer?)
Has anyone here e-mailed SY and got an answer ?

What for?, its nothing to do with anyone but SY.

I think they have enough lunatic's emailing them, to last a lifetime.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

Offline Carana

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #65 on: May 07, 2013, 06:41:54 PM »
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

I agree that the 'call'  for the McCanns and their friends to brought back to Portugal to do a reconstruction has a threatening air to it

At this point I see no purpose at all in even asking them to return  ....  in fact, I believe asking Kate to relive that night would be callous and heartless in the extreme

That is not what I have been talking about at all  ...  my question was,  how might a reconstruction  (  using police personel )  be helpful to the investigation

I have pointed out ways in which I think it might

Six years later...

If you had been there as a tourist that night, would you remember exactly where you were at every moment? Could you be sure that your memory of an after-dinner walk, or drink, was THAT night or at the important time?

Or even as a casual staff employee?


debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #66 on: May 07, 2013, 06:48:59 PM »
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

Which could be done cheaper and better using Holmes.

Offline Carana

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #67 on: May 07, 2013, 06:51:21 PM »
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

The timeframe was certainly short - if JT's man was actually carrying Madeleine. But I can't see why the actual people need to go there yet again in order to do a timeline reconstruction. That can't be too difficult to reconstruct virtually these days, surely?


NB The Met seem to have done one (cf Redwood). Presumably, they're not totally dense, and would have tried out various versions.

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #68 on: May 07, 2013, 06:54:28 PM »
Quote
I feel that a reconstruction would help enormously in determining whether the man Jane saw could, with certainly, have been the abductor

Playing out events in real time would surely demonstrate whether or not the window of opportunity that existed was sufficient for the crime to have taken place in those few minutes

so using an actor/police officer walker across the top of the road in accordance with Tanners statement would prove what?

What could be determined,  by a policeman playing the part of an abductor, is whether or not it would be possible for the crime to have been commited in the time-scale allowed him  ...  and whether Jane Tanner would have seen him where, and when,  she says she  did

Which could be done cheaper and better using Holmes.

Could you tell us more about 'Holmes' please Db?

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #69 on: May 07, 2013, 06:57:00 PM »
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the [ censored word ]s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #70 on: May 07, 2013, 06:59:53 PM »
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Thankyou.  Have to go now - but will look at it later.
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Carana

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #71 on: May 07, 2013, 07:09:37 PM »
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #72 on: May 07, 2013, 07:17:46 PM »
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.

Hamster driven Amstrad Spectrum complete with tape recorder input?

Offline Carana

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #73 on: May 07, 2013, 07:29:10 PM »
It is the Home Office Large Major Enquiry System

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOLMES_2

(if the h.....s will accept Wikipedia!!! lol

Somehow I doubt that the Portimão police station had anything even vaguely resembling this, let alone known how to use such a system.

Hamster driven Amstrad Spectrum complete with tape recorder input?

I have no doubt that many decent cops did their best, but there was simply no system in place, let alone training.


AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #74 on: May 07, 2013, 07:34:57 PM »
I am a bit taken aback by the responses to my thread question

At the very least, I expected some members to say  ...  "Yes,  it's worth a try,  lets hope they give it a shot"

Instead,  almost everyone who has responded seems to be  against  a reconstruction being done  (  even one that does not involve the real people concerned ) 

Why ?

because it has been a hammer to hit the tapas group on the head with for years and years.

But of course you don't know that.

I agree that the 'call'  for the McCanns and their friends to brought back to Portugal to do a reconstruction has a threatening air to it

At this point I see no purpose at all in even asking them to return  ....  in fact, I believe asking Kate to relive that night would be callous and heartless in the extreme

That is not what I have been talking about at all  ...  my question was,  how might a reconstruction  (  using police personel )  be helpful to the investigation

I have pointed out ways in which I think it might

Six years later...

If you had been there as a tourist that night, would you remember exactly where you were at every moment? Could you be sure that your memory of an after-dinner walk, or drink, was THAT night or at the important time?

Or even as a casual staff employee?
I remember exactly where I was, who was around, which time it was when I heard that JFK had been shot. I remember who said it, what I was going to do, what I was doing before.
And I was a little girl.