Summers & Swan - A new book - Looking For Madeleine

[Alfred R Jones]

If you want to make money from Madeleine's disappearance in this country you have to toe the McCann party line.  The authors being intelligent people would know that.

Now, how about you actually answer my question for a change?!

[faithlilly]

If you re-read what I wrote you will see that I did answer your question.  And as you swerve all my more taxing questions you really have some nerve!

I asked whether you thought the authors would have been able to sell a book in this country that suggested that the McCanns are complicit in their daughter's disappearance ? Of course you don't have to answer if you'd rather not.

[Mr Moderator]

I asked whether you thought the authors would have been able to sell a book in this country that suggested that the McCanns are complicit in their daughter's disappearance ? Of course you don't have to answer if you'd rather not.

That of course is the reason why a truly definitive book has not yet been written.  Until such time as there is proof as to what really happened to Madeleine all we have is suspicions and speculation.

[Alfred R Jones]

I asked whether you thought the authors would have been able to sell a book in this country that suggested that the McCanns are complicit in their daughter's disappearance ? Of course you don't have to answer if you'd rather not.

Well according to you they've only sold 25 books supporting the abduction theory.  If they'd written a scurrilous anti-McCann diatribe full of swinging allegations and Gaspar statement etc they could have sold thousands worldwide, if not in this country.  America would have lapped it up as would Portugal.

Now, are you going to answer my question or not?

[Mr Gray]

Well according to you they've only sold 25 books supporting the abduction theory.  If they'd written a scurrilous anti-McCann diatribe full of swinging allegations and Gaspar statement etc they could have sold thousands worldwide, if not in this country.  America would have lapped it up as would Portugal.

Now, are you going to answer my question or not?

Stevo actually wrote the book you describe...how many did he sell?

[faithlilly]

Well according to you they've only sold 25 books supporting the abduction theory.  If they'd written a scurrilous anti-McCann diatribe full of swinging allegations and Gaspar statement etc they could have sold thousands worldwide, if not in this country.  America would have lapped it up as would Portugal.

Now, are you going to answer my question or not?

Pat Brown wrote her book in America. Her book was withdrawn by Amazon due to pressure from the McCanns.
Amaral wrote his book for sale in Portugal. He is now embroiled in a libel case instigated by the McCanns.

So it seems you can cross America and Portugal off of your list.

And I will rephrase my question. Would Summers be able to sell a book suggesting the McCanns were complicit in their daughter's disappearance anywhere in the western world without facing legal action ?

[Alfred R Jones]

Pat Brown wrote her book in America. Her book was withdrawn by Amazon due to pressure from the McCanns.
Amaral wrote his book for sale in Portugal. He is now embroiled in a libel case instigated by the McCanns.

So it seems you can cross America and Portugal off of your list.

And I will rephrase my question. Would Summers be able to sell a book suggesting the McCanns were complicit in their daughter's disappearance anywhere in the western world without facing legal action ?

I'm not answering anymore of your questions until you have the courtesy to actually answer one of mine for a change.

[Alfred R Jones]

Stevo actually wrote the book you describe...how many did he sell?

I don't believe his book ever actually existed did it?

[faithlilly]

I'm not answering anymore of your questions until you have the courtesy to actually answer one of mine for a change.

Absolutely fine Alfred. I'm sure the other members will draw their own inferences from your refusal to answer my simple question.

[Eleanor]

That of course is the reason why a truly definitive book has not yet been written.  Until such time as there is proof as to what really happened to Madeleine all we have is suspicions and speculation.

Yer, well.  There you go.

[sadie]

I'm not answering anymore of your questions until you have the courtesy to actually answer one of mine for a change.

Faithlilly doesn't do answering questions, Alfred.  Not unless she can twist it to her advantage

Didn't you know?

[Wonderfulspam]

Absolutely fine Alfred. I'm sure the other members will draw their own inferences from your refusal to answer my simple question.

Best he can ever do is question, because he cannot explain.

[stephen25000]

Best he can ever do is question, because he cannot explain.

To expect logic from people who support parents who neglected their children, and then spent the best part of 7 years blaming others for what they failed to do, and anyone who really tried to solve the crime.

[Mr Gray]

Pat Brown wrote her book in America. Her book was withdrawn by Amazon due to pressure from the McCanns.
Amaral wrote his book for sale in Portugal. He is now embroiled in a libel case instigated by the McCanns.

So it seems you can cross America and Portugal off of your list.

And I will rephrase my question. Would Summers be able to sell a book suggesting the McCanns were complicit in their daughter's disappearance anywhere in the western world without facing legal action ?

Quite simply..they could if the evidence supported them..

[Alfred R Jones]

Absolutely fine Alfred. I'm sure the other members will draw their own inferences from your refusal to answer my simple question.

As they will from your refusal to answer my very simple question.