Wandering Off Topic

[Eleanor]

Read what Jim Gamble said about the case. I know you probably have already. But in the majority of missing children cases there is family involvement. You have to start there. I know that carrying a child out of the window is nigh on impossible then you have to ask why is it open? Changing entry method of checks has been described as a “red flag” by a retired criminal investigator. The two Tapas employee testimony that state Gerry was away for half an hour needed to be rigorously checked. The Smithman sighting is significant. I’ve read some reports that the PJ had accounted for Totman so why was a 9:15 abduction pursued for so long? Because the ground wasn’t cleared from under their feet we are now left with a mess!! The biggest irony is the PJ failure was actually pursuing an abductor before they had cleared the ground.

Who said that Gerry was away for half an hour?

[Brietta]

According to an earlier post, it's not in the public domain. Only the of Mr Carpenter is available.

Yes I did know that.  Which is why I was wondering why "Based on the statement of Mrs Carpenter, unless she was fantasizing." was said.

Of course we do know that the files Levy posted on the internet are not the whole story.  I think a bit of cherry picking took place.

My assumption is that we haven't seen Mrs Carpenter's statement not because she was fantasizing but because she wasn't and her statement didn't back up her husband's.  Simple as.

[Brietta]

Read what Jim Gamble said about the case. I know you probably have already. But in the majority of missing children cases there is family involvement. You have to start there. I know that carrying a child out of the window is nigh on impossible then you have to ask why is it open? Changing entry method of checks has been described as a “red flag” by a retired criminal investigator. The two Tapas employee testimony that state Gerry was away for half an hour needed to be rigorously checked. The Smithman sighting is significant. I’ve read some reports that the PJ had accounted for Totman so why was a 9:15 abduction pursued for so long? Because the ground wasn’t cleared from under their feet we are now left with a mess!! The biggest irony is the PJ failure was actually pursuing an abductor before they had cleared the ground.

You are going to have to come up with a couple of cites here.  Starting with the PJ accounting for Totman.

[Mr Gray]

Read what Jim Gamble said about the case. I know you probably have already. But in the majority of missing children cases there is family involvement. You have to start there. I know that carrying a child out of the window is nigh on impossible then you have to ask why is it open? Changing entry method of checks has been described as a “red flag” by a retired criminal investigator. The two Tapas employee testimony that state Gerry was away for half an hour needed to be rigorously checked. The Smithman sighting is significant. I’ve read some reports that the PJ had accounted for Totman so why was a 9:15 abduction pursued for so long? Because the ground wasn’t cleared from under their feet we are now left with a mess!! The biggest irony is the PJ failure was actually pursuing an abductor before they had cleared the ground.

I think its quite possible that Wolters has photo/video of Maddie in the hands of a paedophile..thats why I think what you are posting is totally irrelevant

[Vertigo Swirl]

Read what Jim Gamble said about the case. I know you probably have already. But in the majority of missing children cases there is family involvement. You have to start there. I know that carrying a child out of the window is nigh on impossible then you have to ask why is it open? Changing entry method of checks has been described as a “red flag” by a retired criminal investigator. The two Tapas employee testimony that state Gerry was away for half an hour needed to be rigorously checked. The Smithman sighting is significant. I’ve read some reports that the PJ had accounted for Totman so why was a 9:15 abduction pursued for so long? Because the ground wasn’t cleared from under their feet we are now left with a mess!! The biggest irony is the PJ failure was actually pursuing an abductor before they had cleared the ground.

I’ve read what Jim Gamble has said about the case.  I’m surprised you set any store by his opinion as he is quite clear that in his the parents had nothing to do with it.  How do you account for this, if you consider him worth reading?

[Eleanor]

Who said that Gerry was gone for half an hour?

We need to know this.

[jassi]

Do we?

[Eleanor]

Do we?

In that case we can discard this statement as exaggeration, or possibly even fibs?

[jassi]

All the timing is vague, deliberately so iMO, All we know is that Gerry was away for longer than was expected by other party members.

[Eleanor]

All the timing is vague, deliberately so iMO, All we know is that Gerry was away for longer than was expected by other party members.

He was talking to Jez.  According to Jez.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

I think its quite possible that Wolters has photo/video of Maddie in the hands of a paedophile..thats why I think what you are posting is totally irrelevant

If they have that evidence then why have they been pedalling him as the “prime suspect” for months but no charges?

[Vertigo Swirl]

If they have that evidence then why have they been pedalling him as the “prime suspect” for months but no charges?

Because the case they are building against him is not yet watertight presumably.

[Brietta]

If they have that evidence then why have they been pedalling him as the “prime suspect” for months but no charges?

What happened to the cite I requested?

[Mr Gray]

 

If they have that evidence then why have they been pedalling him as the “prime suspect” for months but no charges?

Ive posted the reason before.. If he is in the video his features may be pixellated. I dont think the Germans would announce evidence of maddies death if they did not have it

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

You are going to have to come up with a couple of cites here.  Starting with the PJ accounting for Totman.

His wife said so……
He was quizzed by the Guarda Nacional Republicana soon after Madeleine, three, vanished.

[Name removed]_TEM_07052018_tannerman.jpg
(Image: PA)
His wife Rachel told The Sun: "My husband had told the local police it could be him but we didn’t hear anything for years.