Author Topic: Was it all Amaral's fault?  (Read 45381 times)

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #255 on: September 15, 2016, 11:01:39 AM »
The question wasn't to quantify or judge the quality of the evidence, the question was is there evidence of abduction - the answer is yes.  It is at least equal to the evidence of a couple of dogs, which also is completely unverifiable at this time.

Well give evidence of 'abduction' which can't be explained by other possibilities.

Offline sadie

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #256 on: September 15, 2016, 11:03:55 AM »
They would both try to use it as evidence, but the evidence that it wasn't used as a way out, would win the argument.
I think on analysis it is evidence that Madeleine missing (the initial stages getting her out of the apartment) was not a child abduction, but I argue she was abducted from a position outside her apartment.
- The window was opened as a possible escape route, if trapped
- To give instructions and encouragement to a nervous lifter (probably a woman who Madeleine knew and trusted)
- To pass things thru, possibly the drugs, but not Madeleine,.  she was carried out via the front door
- To give a false impressiion that madeleine had opened the window jumped out and wanderd off.
-  To allow the person outside the ability to communicate if someone was coming.

All IMO but they fit.   There are another three reasons which I cant remember atm.


Way before SY made three peeps arguidos, i have thought that 3 peeps were involved in this abduction

Person 1:  On block 6 western balcony ... directing things probably by flashlight which could be seen from the front door and window area of 5A.  Also the get away driver, but he failed to connect ... he scarpered ... because JT witnessed Tannerman with Madeleine

Person 2:  Tannerman.  He stood outside the window passing things thru and giving the lifter encouragement and maybe also passing drugs to knock Madeleine out.  He was probably on the other side of the walkway wall (immediately in front of the apartments) by the time that the lifter appeared outside again .... and Madeleine was probably passed over that wall.    Her head would have been on the right arm of the lifter.  The little girl that JT saw, her head was on the left arm of Tannerman ... so a pass-over had occurred.  Being outside the window, he could see if anyone was coming from the torch beam of the first nman on the balcony and warn the lifter.

Person 3:  The lifter. 
Quite probably someone who Madeleine knew, so a member of OC staff ... or maybe someone who worked at Baptistas Supermarket and was very kind to Madeleine.  I prefer a member of OC staff, because it links in with Tannerman with Madeleine making a stop at the Staff quarters in Rua D'Escola ... just 50 metres above where the first Smith sighting, ... but I do find it interesting how people linked with John the Baptist keep popping up


The group that i think are currently supporting the mastermind also are connected with John the Baptist.  I think this was a planned abduction for a mastermind, an elite.  Planned in precise detail... but it was almost foiled by JT suddenly appearing.

All IMO only.

Bet the last part of this deleted ... and maybe all

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #257 on: September 15, 2016, 11:08:01 AM »
Well yes, but evidence is evidence.  It can be accurate, inaccurate, made up or mistaken.  It is still evidence.  If Gerry and Kate and their friends were called in court to give evidence then much of what is in their statements would be repeated in court as evidence, evidence to support their contention that an abductor took Madeleine.  It would be for a jury to decide whether the evidence was compelling enough to come to a verdict but it is still evidence.  To say that evidence given by these people, in particular about the way the room was left on their return to the apartment, is not evidence of abduction, but that a few barks by a dog is evidence of something other than abduction is simply nonsense.

Criminal trials in Portugal don't have jury trials in the way the UK does;

Jury trials are rare in criminal cases.
When the crime in question is punishable by a prison sentence with a maximum limit of more than eight years, either the public prosecutor, the victim or the defendant may request a jury trial. Juries consist of three judges (juizes de direito) and four jurors (jurados, who are Portuguese nationals, aged 18-65, and who are registered voters).
https://www.fairtrials.org/arrested-abroad/arrested-in/arrested-in-portuga/
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #258 on: September 15, 2016, 11:18:36 AM »
Criminal trials in Portugal don't have jury trials in the way the UK does;

Jury trials are rare in criminal cases.
When the crime in question is punishable by a prison sentence with a maximum limit of more than eight years, either the public prosecutor, the victim or the defendant may request a jury trial. Juries consist of three judges (juizes de direito) and four jurors (jurados, who are Portuguese nationals, aged 18-65, and who are registered voters).
https://www.fairtrials.org/arrested-abroad/arrested-in/arrested-in-portuga/
Do criminal trials in Portugal rely on evidence being given?  If so, would the evidence given by Kate and Gerry McCann concerning the way they found the children's bedroom be considered at any point, either as part of the case for the prosecution or defence? 
« Last Edit: September 15, 2016, 03:09:58 PM by Angelo222 »

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #259 on: September 15, 2016, 11:22:51 AM »
Thankfully there aren't many abductions from 'home', but I think you would find in most cases like this that the open shutters and window would be considered a clue.

For some reason Amaral decided immediately.... immediately .... that the Mccanns were responsible. 

The unthinking man said that it would have been impossible to get into the apartment via the bedroom window ... or the front door cos it was locked ... or the patio door cos it was overlooked

Heriberto has disproved the window scenario, although it would be mighty difficult to get in that way ... and marks would inevitably have been left IMO

The burglaries in other apartments via the front door have disproved his front door theory ...and the keys went missing.  So easy to cast a spare. 

The front door was almost certainly the way in.  Before all the felling of the beautiful trees and the new lamp, the front door was in complete darkness .... and no-one passed by. 

It was also within easy signalling view of the balcony opposite as mentioned below.  For a young athletic person there was an easy escape route over the wall


I agree with Amaral about the patio door.,  The patio area was bathed in light (a pale light) from the street lamp opposite and an abductor would have been very concerned about being seen by the tapas group who were just over 50 metres away.. 

Also houses in the little side street opposite the Tapas reception and the little parking area would, I think, have had a good view of anyone trying to get in.  It is difficult to be certain if they would have had a good view, or not, because of a highish wall and the ground slope of the area.  The main windows of these houses are upstairs ... and obviously I could not physically go up someones outside steps to check.

Also this patio area was well overlooked by anyone coming up the street on the eastern pavement and by several windows and balconies in block 6 opposite.   


In fact I think it likely that the whole abduction was orchestrated by someone watching the comings and goings from the balcony on the western side of block 6.  Probably the one on the first floor which also looked straight across into the patio area and into the Mccann apartment living room.  Fag ends were found there, so someone had loitered there.


The front door was almost certainly the way in and out.  The window was opened as an escape route and for several other reasons, which I have covered before.

The open window and the dog alerts are both clues. The rest of your post seems to be your hypothesis of how a possible abduction may have been carried out, it's not evidence that an abduction happened.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #260 on: September 15, 2016, 12:43:15 PM »
Do criminal trials in Portugal rely on evidence being given?  If so, would the evidence given by Kate and Gerry McCann concerning the way they found the children's bedroom be considered at any point, either as part of the case for the prosecution or defence? 

You're just asking questions as usual Alfie. Why you think I'm an expert on the nature of evidence in a Portuguese Criminal Trial escapes me. The only way I can answer is to google. You can find the answers you need using the same method, so I don't quite understand why you're asking me to do it? This may help you to inform yourself;

http://www.gddc.pt/codigos/code_criminal_procedure.html

I have, however,  read it through and the procedures leading to trial seem somewhat different to the UK. As I read it;

The Public Prosecutor decides to arrest someone.
A judge presides over a hearing and decides if the case goes to trial.
If the judge decides it does, the defendant is given access to the evidence which will be produced against them [usually in time to prepare a defense but not always].
The defendant and their lawyer then prepare their defense case.
Witnesses must appear in person unless they really really can't, when permission to use previous statements may be given.

So the evidence used in court would be chosen depending on what the defendant was being accused of and what both sides decided to use.

I found it difficult to work out whether the defendants give evidence or not.

All proceedings take place in Portuguese. Interpreters are provided for those who don't understand the language.
« Last Edit: September 15, 2016, 03:11:58 PM by Angelo222 »
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #261 on: September 15, 2016, 12:58:34 PM »
You're just asking questions as usual Alfie. Why you think I'm an expert on the nature of evidence in a Portuguese Criminal Trial escapes me. The only way I can answer is to google. You can find the answers you need using the same method, so I don't quite understand why you're asking me to do it? This may help you to inform yourself;

http://www.gddc.pt/codigos/code_criminal_procedure.html

I have, however,  read it through and the procedures leading to trial seem somewhat different to the UK. As I read it;

The Public Prosecutor decides to arrest someone.
A judge presides over a hearing and decides if the case goes to trial.
If the judge decides it does, the defendant is given access to the evidence which will be produced against them [usually in time to prepare a defense but not always].
The defendant and their lawyer then prepare their defense case.
Witnesses must appear in person unless they really really can't, when permission to use previous statements may be given.

So the evidence used in court would be chosen depending on what the defendant was being accused of and what both sides decided to use.

I found it difficult to work out whether the defendants give evidence or not.

All proceedings take place in Portuguese. Interpreters are provided for those who don't understand the language.
Do you think in a prosecution against an individual for breaking and entering the apartment and taking a child that some evidence about how this was may have been achieved might be presented in court and considered?  Just wondering, no pressure to actually give me a straight yes or no answer, beat around the bush as much as you need.  8(0(*

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #262 on: September 15, 2016, 01:03:44 PM »
    &%+((£ Was it all Amaral's fault?

Perhaps it is time to have a new look at the OP and catch up on some of what has been said there to take the discussion forward.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #263 on: September 15, 2016, 01:19:06 PM »
    &%+((£ Was it all Amaral's fault?

Perhaps it is time to have a new look at the OP and catch up on some of what has been said there to take the discussion forward.
What I don't understand about this thread is that the OP doesn't really relate to the title of the thread.  Was what all Amaral's fault?  We've already discussed the short-comings of the investigation many times, just as the neglect issue has been discussed a million times.  Apportioning blame over and over again either to Amaral, or the McCanns is pointless, except as a way of triggering off yet another barney between the two camps.  Then again, I'm always up for a barney... @)(++(*

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #264 on: September 15, 2016, 01:39:08 PM »
What I don't understand about this thread is that the OP doesn't really relate to the title of the thread.  Was what all Amaral's fault?  We've already discussed the short-comings of the investigation many times, just as the neglect issue has been discussed a million times.  Apportioning blame over and over again either to Amaral, or the McCanns is pointless, except as a way of triggering off yet another barney between the two camps.  Then again, I'm always up for a barney... @)(++(*

In my opinion we should perhaps just cut to the chase and sub-title each thread to include the topic we always return to ... it would save a tremendous amount of off topic posts being deleted.

My take on the OP is that it is now being realised that Amaral is actually not as brilliant a detective as was once believed ... so the 'blame' for the botched initial investigation has to be shared out a bit ... very soon I think it will eventually be revealed that as he was only following orders it really will become a case of "a big boy dunnit and ran away".

The fly in that ointment is that he has written a book in which he apportioned blame to all and sundry (Gordon Brown ... MI6 ... etc) for his failures in the conduct of Madeleine's case ... but never his superiors.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #265 on: September 15, 2016, 02:00:54 PM »
Do you think in a prosecution against an individual for breaking and entering the apartment and taking a child that some evidence about how this was may have been achieved might be presented in court and considered?  Just wondering, no pressure to actually give me a straight yes or no answer, beat around the bush as much as you need.  8(0(*

What a lot of possibilities. A potential abductor is found, interrogated and arrested. To make an arrest evidence  must be collected. The window area yielded no forensic evidence which could be matched to the suspect. No evidence of forced entry was found [even if it was he's unlikely to still be carrying his jemmy around]. No identifiable suspect was seen near the window area. I'm struggling to see how testifying to seeing an open window would help to nail him, her or them.
« Last Edit: September 15, 2016, 02:06:49 PM by G-Unit »
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #266 on: September 15, 2016, 02:39:08 PM »
In my opinion we should perhaps just cut to the chase and sub-title each thread to include the topic we always return to ... it would save a tremendous amount of off topic posts being deleted.

My take on the OP is that it is now being realised that Amaral is actually not as brilliant a detective as was once believed ... so the 'blame' for the botched initial investigation has to be shared out a bit ... very soon I think it will eventually be revealed that as he was only following orders it really will become a case of "a big boy dunnit and ran away".

The fly in that ointment is that he has written a book in which he apportioned blame to all and sundry (Gordon Brown ... MI6 ... etc) for his failures in the conduct of Madeleine's case ... but never his superiors.

He was part of a team, but for some reason he was the one singled out and vilified by the (mostly) UK media;

Conversation among policemen... ASFIC-PJ Blog (union of the PJ)

Thursday, July 3, 2008
Thanks to Astro for translation

Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?

Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.

Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.

None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.

João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711

It was precisely due to the lack of support by those above him and the need to defend himself that Amaral resigned and wrote his book. He says so in the Foreword. Perhaps if the media had restrained itself he never would have written it.


Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #267 on: September 15, 2016, 02:41:18 PM »
What a lot of possibilities. A potential abductor is found, interrogated and arrested. To make an arrest evidence  must be collected. The window area yielded no forensic evidence which could be matched to the suspect. No evidence of forced entry was found [even if it was he's unlikely to still be carrying his jemmy around]. No identifiable suspect was seen near the window area. I'm struggling to see how testifying to seeing an open window would help to nail him, her or them.
You don't think that evidence given by the parents that they left the window shut and returned to find it open would be evidence of a break in to be considered then?  The once shut, subsequently opened window wouldn't even merit a mention in court in your view?  OK, if you say so.... &%+((£


Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #268 on: September 15, 2016, 02:47:09 PM »
If you leave a room in which the window is shut and you return to find that the window is open, is that evidence of anything at all, or is it a completely worthless piece of information that tells you nothing at all about anything?

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #269 on: September 15, 2016, 02:54:05 PM »
In my opinion we should perhaps just cut to the chase and sub-title each thread to include the topic we always return to ... it would save a tremendous amount of off topic posts being deleted.

My take on the OP is that it is now being realised that Amaral is actually not as brilliant a detective as was once believed ... so the 'blame' for the botched initial investigation has to be shared out a bit ... very soon I think it will eventually be revealed that as he was only following orders it really will become a case of "a big boy dunnit and ran away".

The fly in that ointment is that he has written a book in which he apportioned blame to all and sundry (Gordon Brown ... MI6 ... etc) for his failures in the conduct of Madeleine's case ... but never his superiors.

Amaral, Grime, dogs and Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Ltd...............usually.

Regardless of all the old blx so beloved by all, the bottom line as they say is:
In May 2007 a little girl went on holiday then disappeared never to be seen again. The nature of her disappearance to this day is unknown, despite best efforts by two police forces.
Tragically but not unsurprisingly sides are drawn up "Black 'ats and White 'ats" just as in a Hopalong Cassidy movie.
That's the human race for you  8)><(
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey