In my opinion we should perhaps just cut to the chase and sub-title each thread to include the topic we always return to ... it would save a tremendous amount of off topic posts being deleted.
My take on the OP is that it is now being realised that Amaral is actually not as brilliant a detective as was once believed ... so the 'blame' for the botched initial investigation has to be shared out a bit ... very soon I think it will eventually be revealed that as he was only following orders it really will become a case of "a big boy dunnit and ran away".
The fly in that ointment is that he has written a book in which he apportioned blame to all and sundry (Gordon Brown ... MI6 ... etc) for his failures in the conduct of Madeleine's case ... but never his superiors.
He was part of a team, but for some reason he was the one singled out and vilified by the (mostly) UK media;
Conversation among policemen... ASFIC-PJ Blog (union of the PJ)
Thursday, July 3, 2008
Thanks to Astro for translation
Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?
Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.
Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.
None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.
João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711
It was precisely due to the lack of support by those above him and the need to defend himself that Amaral resigned and wrote his book. He says so in the Foreword. Perhaps if the media had restrained itself he never would have written it.