Could all three children have been sedated by an intruder?

[faithlilly]

Speaking as a gran, I would like to think I know my grandchildren very well but I believe their parents are far more familiar with them
And Gerry's mother lived a distance away and would not spend nearly as much time with her grandchildren as fortunately I do.

Why do you think that the McCanns asked the FLOs if anything had been used to facilitate Madeleine’s abduction if they didn’t believe  she would have to have been sedated for it to be achieved ?

[Erngath]

Why do you think that the McCanns asked the FLOs if anything had been used to facilitate Madeleine’s abduction if they didn’t believe  she would have to have been sedated for it to be achieved ?

I've no doubt that they considered everything and anything which could have been a contributing factor in Madeleine's abduction. IMO.
Why not share their concerns with those who were there to help and support.

[Robittybob1]

Why do you think that the McCanns asked the FLOs if anything had been used to facilitate Madeleine’s abduction if they didn’t believe  she would have to have been sedated for it to be achieved ?

Did the FLOs past that concern to the PJ?

I've no doubt that they considered everything and anything which could have been a contributing factor in Madeleine's abduction. IMO.
Why not share their concerns with those who were there to help and support.

Name one if you can.

[Erngath]

Did the FLOs past that concern to the PJ?

Name one if you can.

Name who?

[faithlilly]

I've no doubt that they considered everything and anything which could have been a contributing factor in Madeleine's abduction. IMO.
Why not share their concerns with those who were there to help and support.

Indeed but you have to agree that her parents hadn’t ruled out the fact that Madeleine may have needed to be sedated in order to abduct her?

[John]

Thanks for the cite but it doesn’t say that Madeleine would have kicked up a fuss in the process of being abducted, only that she would currently (ie in 2007/08) be giving her abductor a hard time.  Now, if I was really childish I would keep on demanding a cite that confirms what John wrote, thankfully for all concerned I’m not.

Kate was making the point that Madeleine was not a push over.  But if you want to split hairs and engage in yet another marathon safari into the cite jungle so be it.

[Robittybob1]

Name who?

Whoever falls into the category "Why not share their concerns with those who were there to help and support."

[Sunny]

John wrote that Kate was adamant Madeleine would have kicked up a fuss on being picked up from her bed, not Gerry’s mum.  I have no doubt if Davel had written what John did and you’d asked for a cite you would have rejected it on the same grounds.

Where did my post go? From the cite given earlier. Not John it was Eileen McCann

Mrs McCann, who lives in Scotland and runs a pub, said: “I really believe they (whoever took her) gave her a drug.

“There is no way they carried her out of there without her awakening.

“If she was taken when she was sleeping by somebody she did not know, she would have screamed the place down.”

[Erngath]

Indeed but you have to agree that her parents hadn’t ruled out the fact that Madeleine may have needed to be sedated in order to abduct her?

I have no idea of what they ruled in and ruled out.
I would imagine they went through various scenarios but what was ruled in or out , I do not know.

[Robittybob1]

Indeed but you have to agree that her parents hadn’t ruled out the fact that Madeleine may have needed to be sedated in order to abduct her?

That is not a question,  it is more a statement of fact that you are asking someone to agree with you.  It is really opinion at best.

I have no idea of what they ruled in and ruled out.
I would imagine they went through various scenarios but what was ruled in or out , I do not know.

Erngath's response seems to show what you say is a fact is faulty.

[Erngath]

Whoever falls into the category "Why not share their concerns with those who were there to help and support."

I assume they did share all their concerns with those who were there to help and support but I can't name any of the FLOs .

[faithlilly]

I have no idea of what they ruled in and ruled out.
I would imagine they went through various scenarios but what was ruled in or out , I do not know.

I understand that but to ask the question they must have at least considered that it was possible. Agreed ?

[Erngath]

I understand that but to ask the question they must have at least considered that it was possible. Agreed ?

I have no doubt they considered every eventuality.
Off to watch the tennis.
The two German brothers opposing each other!

[Robittybob1]

I assume they did share all their concerns with those who were there to help and support but I can't name any of the FLOs .

OK so you were talking about the FLOs.  OK so they did share their concerns with them, that bit is in the file, but what is the benefit of that unless the FLO then do something about those concerns, and that bit is not covered in the file.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Kate was making the point that Madeleine was not a push over.  But if you want to split hairs and engage in yet another marathon safari into the cite jungle so be it.

I have already made it very clear that that is not my style, I leave that sort of behaviour to the sticklers for the forum rules.