I must have asked for at least 6 cites in the last few days and received NONE. Brietta perhaps you could chase them up with the consistency you have chased this one.
Do you have a cite that Goncalo Amaral decided Madeleine was dead on Day 1 please?http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10257.msg496038#msg496038
Do you have a cite for the windows and doors being open and that remnant scent wouldn't last unless the room was completely sealed.http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10257.msg495849#msg495849
Do you have a cite that Eddie did still alert to pigs as Martin Grime is quite clear that he didn't in 2007.http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=post;quote=494912;topic=10257.165
Do you have a cite to show that ashes give off cadaver odour and also one which shows that pyjamas were left on the bedside cabinet following the grandfather's death.http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10257.msg494866#msg494866
Cadaver odour scent will move around a room and pool, Martin Grime has already explained that the part of a room where Eddie alerted may not be the exact location of where a cadaver may have been placed.
Perhaps someone should have told "a friend" then Davel. He seems explicit that they have not be interviewed by Scotland Yard. - unless you can say otherwise (with a cite) of course.http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10244.msg493989#msg493989
Supporters don't have to give cites! ^*&&
They can just make it up.
Well, I just hope no muslims or jewish people were in that apartment or the hire car- as a dead pig was hiding in a wardrope. behind a sofa and in a car.. bejeesus
For my part, I did answer the question about Eddie alerting to pig cadaver. Had Eddie not been capable of doing so, he wouldn't have passed any ACPO tests as only pig cadaver can be used in the UK. A fail=no licence. Quite simple.
This always makes me smile... Did you know the Christian bible forbids the eating of pork.....Was this because bacon sarnies would confound cadaver dog alerts in the 21st century?
Was this because bacon sarnies would confound cadaver dog alerts in the 21st century?
This always makes me smile... Did you know the Christian bible forbids the eating of pork.....
Who knows?
Yes, it is a cultural thing. due to the outbreak of swine disease in the middle east way back in the da and carcases lying in sunlight to rot. Hence why the drain the blood from animals before consumption. halal and kosher.
that is why the kill and eat fresh! Nothing mystical about it. superstition meets food science.
My post of course was to Sadie but you did respond Misty with more or less what you said here. Do you have evidence of what the ACPO test is in the UK? I won't say cite obviously as you have kindly responded to me earlier.http://library.college.police.uk/docs/J_Homicide_MII/J_Homicide_7.2.pdf Page 56.
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/J_Homicide_MII/J_Homicide_7.2.pdf Page 56.
John Ellis, who worked with Grime, collaborated in this document.
The use of human cadaver or body parts for testing of dogs is currently forbidden in the UK. How do you envisage ACPO instructors testing cadaver dogs if not with decomposing pork?
Page 53 also makes interesting reading.
This always makes me smile... Did you know the Christian bible forbids the eating of pork.....
Well parts of the Old Testament, mainly the Pentateuch.I’m only surprised no one has yet asked Davel for a cite about it.
I have just about had enough of this. Sceptics are raising spurious arguments, and Supporters are arguing the point, neither of which is doing much for the credibility of this Forum.
There are times when I try really hard to be fair, more fool me. But I do have the Delete Button whether or not any of you like it.
So we will cut the nastiness, or else I will do what I am charged to do. Don't ever underestimate me. I love you all. But I ain't half daft.
Bloody well behave yourselves.
I’m only surprised no one has yet asked Davel for a cite about it.
Only needed if you didn’t know.IMO cites are usually only asked for by people who already think they know.
IMO cites are usually only asked for by people who already think they know.
You have my support on this Eleanor. This nit picking will stop now otherwise there will be sanctions applied.
It is convention to provide a cite where possible so please endeavor to do so guys.
IMO they are usually asked when a poster hasn’t seen a cite for the claim in question themselves and wants to know if there is one. Which is what cites are for.It’s all about trying to score points IMO. And stifle debate.
How many times do you think a Cite should be necessary, John? I personally can't handle that either. This demand is just another way to derail anything that might be said, when a Cite has often been already given.
It’s all about trying to score points IMO. And stifle debate.Can I quote you on this the next time you are hunting me for a cite when I have made clear I won't provide one,
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/J_Homicide_MII/J_Homicide_7.2.pdf Page 56.Indeed it does given that apparently Eddie's use was for 'residual scent' and given the way clothing items were packed to be taken to be taken from the villa where they had undergone inspection to the gymnasium where they underwent another inspection.
John Ellis, who worked with Grime, collaborated in this document.
The use of human cadaver or body parts for testing of dogs is currently forbidden in the UK. How do you envisage ACPO instructors testing cadaver dogs if not with decomposing pork?
Page 53 also makes interesting reading.
How desperate and twee sunny, especially as you have not given cites when requested.I think Sunny is doing really well. Most of those cites she is asking for, the disputed statement should have been written as "IMO" and then there wouldn't have been such an issue
But nobody has been twee enough to gather them and list them.
There is no hard and fast rule about this but common sense should prevail. If a cite has previously been given then it should be obtainable following a short search. It is good practice however to provide a cite wherever possible which will circumvent this needless disruption.
I will start by giving a cite for my own post
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10264.msg496064#msg496064
Cite requests
1http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10257.msg496038#msg496038
"Do you have a cite that Goncalo Amaral decided Madeleine was dead on Day 1 please?"
Can I quote you on this the next time you are hunting me for a cite when I have made clear I won't provide one,I did not hunt you or demand a cite, unless you can provide a cite that proves your point, in the spirit of “if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em”?
so you can deal with my post on a take it or leave it basis? As per the Porto farce?
It’s all about trying to score points IMO. And stifle debate.
In discussions people use both fact and opinion to make their points. The reader needs to know which are which in order to reply. I will use an example.
A poster posted that the people who left apartment 5J on the morning of 4th weren't interviewed by the Police.
That post is saying that there were people staying in 5J, that they left oh 4th, and that the police failed to speak to them.
As far as I know none of that is true. The cleaner of Block 5 said;
when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
The booking sheets also show no occupancy of 5J, so where did the poster get the information that 5J was occupied? I have asked but have been ignored.
The poster was posting as fact something that was clearly not a fact in my opinion. They were using this invented fact to criticise the Portuguese police too.
I don't think it's acceptable to mislead others about the facts of the case. Without cites being required that would happen all the time. It puts the onus on the reader to go and find information to refute the misleading information when the onus should be on the one who posted it.
Can I just observe that I have been a member of numerous forums over the years and this is the only one where discussion has been continually stifled and disrupted by demands for cites. Can I suggest we all follow Shining’s advice and deal with all posts on a take it or leave it basis? If someone posts something you clearly think is lies or unproven, say so, give your reasons for saying so, provide cites of your own if you so wish and leave it to the other to stump up the counter cite if they so wish. We can then all make up our own minds about the veracity of the claim. Or is that too sensible?
In discussions people use both fact and opinion to make their points. The reader needs to know which are which in order to reply. I will use an example.
A poster posted that the people who left apartment 5J on the morning of 4th weren't interviewed by the Police.
That post is saying that there were people staying in 5J, that they left oh 4th, and that the police failed to speak to them.
As far as I know none of that is true. The cleaner of Block 5 said;
when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
The booking sheets also show no occupancy of 5J, so where did the poster get the information that 5J was occupied? I have asked but have been ignored.
The poster was posting as fact something that was clearly not a fact in my opinion. They were using this invented fact to criticise the Portuguese police too.
I don't think it's acceptable to mislead others about the facts of the case. Without cites being required that would happen all the time. It puts the onus on the reader to go and find information to refute the misleading information when the onus should be on the one who posted it.
note to gunit....so it seems you are happy when sceptics dont give cites but only criticise supporters.....that does indicate quite a heavy bias in your views
One thing which is a problem regarding bona fide cites is when they are truncated or taken out of context to present a particular entrenched point of view.
Maria Julia Serafim da Silva: cleaner
Regarding her job, she points out that she is the person who is responsible for cleaning Block 5,
more specifically apartments A, B, C, D, H, I, K, L, M and P,
and also states that when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
The cleaner's statement about occupation refers only to the apartments which she cleaned ... one of which is NOT listed is apartment 5J.
Therefore what the cleaner is reported as saying in the files is accurate.
But to use it as a cite maintaining which apartments were occupied or not occupied is misleading and inaccurate since her comment is only about the areas of her responsibility ... she makes absolutely no reference to the status of the other apartments in the block.
I haven't said I'm happy when 'sceptics' don't give cites. That's just your assumption. I interact mostly with 'supporters', so it's their lack of cites that I notice, just as you notice the lack of 'sceptic' cites.
I don't believe you.... You are happy to condemn supporters but not sceptics Re cites.... It's this bias you display that causes the whole thing to break down... Could you give a cite that I don't notice lack of supporters cites
I replied yo your accusation and will leave it there if you don't mind. I have no desire to enter into pointless arguments with you about my thoughts and motives.
I am still awaiting a cite to support the original statement that 5J was occupied and that those occupants left on 4th May 2007. Had that cite been provided mine would not have been needed.So easily resolved by an "in my opinion" in my opinion ... which doesn't address the conundrum of your misleading cite.
So easily resolved by an "in my opinion" in my opinion ... which doesn't address the conundrum of your misleading cite.
The cite you chose to provide is inaccurate because it did not provide all the information required to properly allow for independent assessment of the part you were making it say.
You used it to mistakenly confirm that the only apartments occupied in block 5 were A, B, C, D, H, I, K, L, M and P.
Whereas we know Mr and Mrs Moyes were in residence as was Mrs Fenn ... so who else? I doubt we will ever know that.
But what we do know is that the cleaner referred only to those apartments associated with her employment with Mark Warner and which she cleaned.
Did Thomas Cook have a similar arrangement with owners in that block? and what about owners two of whom we know were in residence because they came forward and identified themselves?
In my opinion you are blinkered to the fact that you supplied correct information to the forum but you rendered it inaccurate and misleading because of your presentation of it and that must be a consideration when supplying cites ~ they must be supplied in a trustworthy manner or they are worse than useless.
In discussions people use both fact and opinion to make their points. The reader needs to know which are which in order to reply. I will use an example.When you watch the news on TV or read the newspapers they don't stop after every piece of information to provide a cite. If you dispute what is said and can be bothered to find out more, do it yourself in your own time, otherwise it gets tiresome, repetitive and disruptive. In any case this is only a chat forum, not a court of law, it would help if everyone didn't take themselves and their research oh so seriously all the time. It's perfectly possible to research this case without interacting with a single McCanns supporter you know! All in my opinion.
A poster posted that the people who left apartment 5J on the morning of 4th weren't interviewed by the Police.
That post is saying that there were people staying in 5J, that they left oh 4th, and that the police failed to speak to them.
As far as I know none of that is true. The cleaner of Block 5 said;
when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
The booking sheets also show no occupancy of 5J, so where did the poster get the information that 5J was occupied? I have asked but have been ignored.
The poster was posting as fact something that was clearly not a fact in my opinion. They were using this invented fact to criticise the Portuguese police too.
I don't think it's acceptable to mislead others about the facts of the case. Without cites being required that would happen all the time. It puts the onus on the reader to go and find information to refute the misleading information when the onus should be on the one who posted it.
When you watch the news on TV or read the newspapers they don't stop after every piece of information to provide a cite. If you dispute what is said and can be bothered to find out more, do it yourself in your own time, otherwise it gets tiresome, repetitive and disruptive. In any case this is only a chat forum, not a court of law, it would help if everyone didn't take themselves and their research oh so seriously all the time. It's perfectly possible to research this case without interacting with a single McCanns supporter you know! All in my opinion.
When I first noticed this forum I was surprised to see how many posters were posting their opinions as if they were facts. Misquoting the files was also common.How very noble of you. But I dispute your claim that many posters posted their opinions as if they were facts. I think most people can tell the difference between the two, even without the dreaded IMO attached. Does this cite mania occur on other parts of the forum I wonder...?
What purpose is served by winning an argument using such means, I wondered? My conclusion was that winning the argument was more important than accuracy.
I joined the forum and began correcting the misleading posts because I believe accuracy to be important.
When I first noticed this forum I was surprised to see how many posters were posting their opinions as if they were facts. Misquoting the files was also common.
What purpose is served by winning an argument using such means, I wondered? My conclusion was that winning the argument was more important than accuracy.
I joined the forum and began correcting the misleading posts because I believe accuracy to be important.
How very noble of you. But I dispute your claim that many posters posted their opinions as if they were facts. I think most people can tell the difference between the two, even without the dreaded IMO attached. Does this cite mania occur on other parts of the forum I wonder...?
There's nothing noble about disliking false information being spread. I would expect most 'decent'people to agree with me. Whether you dispute my opinion or not that was my conclusion.Especially if it isn't common knowledge.
If someone told you that 5J was occupied during that week and that the people left on 4th May how would you know if that was fact or opinion?
There's nothing noble about disliking false information being spread. I would expect most 'decent'people to agree with me. Whether you dispute my opinion or not that was my conclusion.This issue is of so little interest to me personally and of little or no relevance IMO to the case that it simply wouldn’t register on my list of things to worry about either way. Are you suggesting I am not decent btw? I take great exception to that inference if you were. Who here is guilty of deliberately spreading false information then?
If someone told you that 5J was occupied during that week and that the people left on 4th May how would you know if that was fact or opinion?
It is forum etiquette to provide a cite when an important claim is made. Furthermore, if someone asks for a cite it is acknowledged practise to provide one if possible or to point the requester in the appropriate direction. One member in particular is always reminding us not to spread myths.So is it OK to direct readers to google instead of providing a cite? In addition is it permissable to state up front when making a post that you refuse to provide a cite to back up your assertion? Or is life really too short to care about it one way or the other?
Failure to comply with the above could see the original claim removed as gossip.
Are you saying that the original post was an opinion, even though it seemed to be being posted as a fact?
So is it OK to direct readers to google instead of providing a cite? In addition is it permissable to state up front when making a post that you refuse to provide a cite to back up your assertion? Or is life really too short to care about it one way or the other?If I see a post like that I will delete it in future. (Where a post states up front when making a post that you refuse to provide a cite to back up your assertion).
Those are my thoughts too G-Unit.
Whether some of the posters treat it as "fun" to post on here or not, it is a very serious subject and should be treated as such.
When a claim is made by anyone here, then a cite should either be provided at the time of posting or upon request. Not all posters seem to care that their claims should be factual.
This makes a mockery of this forum, but that may be some posters intention, IMO.
When I first noticed this forum I was surprised to see how many posters were posting their opinions as if they were facts. Misquoting the files was also common.Out of interest do you correct ALL misleading posts, or only the ones it suits you to do so? Exactly how important is accuracy to you? Would you correct a sceptic who posted opinion as fact, or posted misleading information? Because I’m sure that this issue is not limited to one side of the debste, yet I don’t recall your determination for accuracy resulting in admonishments and demands for cites of any members other than supporters.
What purpose is served by winning an argument using such means, I wondered? My conclusion was that winning the argument was more important than accuracy.
I joined the forum and began correcting the misleading posts because I believe accuracy to be important.
It is forum etiquette to provide a cite when an important claim is made. Furthermore, if someone asks for a cite it is acknowledged practise to provide one if possible or to point the requester in the appropriate direction. One member in particular is always reminding us not to spread myths.
Failure to comply with the above could see the original claim removed as gossip.
The original post appears to have made quite an impact on you since you appear to keep revisiting it vociferously ... I'm terribly sorry if it didn't do the same for me.
However there are inherent risks in continually revisiting past posts which distance of time takes the full discussion out of context.
For example in my opinion you cover yourself in no glory when reading back from ...
Quote
In your acknowledgement that you have cherry picked and lifted an out of context quote from an entirely different subject ~ Danny Collins book to be exact ~ rather reveals the paucity of your argument in a thread asking "Why do some people doubt the McCanns version of events?."
Now provide a cite showing that I am attempting to 'tar' you with 'my' brush.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10141.msg489255#msg489255
Did you ever come up with that cite?
Why not just answer my questions instead of deflecting? I can assure you that it will then be forgotten.
If you think about it logically, there was much air & surface disturbance in the immediate aftermath of Madeleines disappearance. Both front & rear doors were being opened & closed, police officers who'd attended other crime scenes were on site - notwithstanding the 4 re-lets of the apartment before the dogs arrived in August. Cleaning took place.
Given that Grime (mistakenly) thought the apartment had been sealed off since 4th May, how much did that lack of information contribute to his "scent pooling" remark when no obvious forensics were in situ?
All IMO etc etc.
Do you know whether Martin Grime thought the apartment had been empty since 4th May 2007, I can't find him saying a length of time that 5a had been undisturbed. How long does a room have to be disturbed before cadaver scent "pools" misty, do you know?http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
*snipped*
"What we have to be able to understand in a situation such as this is in a hot climate with the apartment being closed down, the scent will build up in a particular area."
I think you need to ask the question as to how long a very recently deceased cadaver needs to be in a particular place before it produces enough molecular odour to remain detectable 3 months later in the bedroom, lounge & garden - unseen & within a limited time_frame. Any pooling would depend on the concentration of odour from the original source.
All IMO etc etc.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htmAnd if there was still a cadaver scent source in 5A?
*snipped*
"What we have to be able to understand in a situation such as this is in a hot climate with the apartment being closed down, the scent will build up in a particular area."
I think you need to ask the question as to how long a very recently deceased cadaver needs to be in a particular place before it produces enough molecular odour to remain detectable 3 months later in the bedroom, lounge & garden - unseen & within a limited time_frame. Any pooling would depend on the concentration of odour from the original source.
All IMO etc etc.
So he doesn't say it was empty since 4th May simply that it was "closed down". I believe 3 months is a short time for cadaver odour to remain if they some of these dogs can find bodies of people who were buried hundreds of years ago. With respect to scent pooling I am not sure it depends upon the concentration although clearly the more concentrated the odour in one place the larger the scent pool in that same place.
I would expect a cadaver dog to be able to locate a body buried years ago, under the right conditions. The clue there is that there would be actual remains to find. I remember reading somewhere that a few centuries ago Luz was the scene of many beach battles between locals & invaders from the sea (will have to find the exact history again). Where were the dead buried? OC was only built in the 1990's.
What effort did the PJ make to uncover the source of any scent contained in the bedroom of 5A? Did they remove the wardrobe panels, the floor tiles, check the base of the divan, back of the headboard? There is no evidence that scent was not already in the apartment before the McCanns arrived in Luz.
If there was a burial ground under the apartment then the dogs would alert in the adjoining apartments I would think but that is an interesting thought though. As regards the rest of your post I agree it would probably be better if the had removed wardrobe doors etc and I have seen nothing to say that they did.
I wonder just how long does cadaver odour lasts, I have read that dogs will alert to bones from hundreds of years which I do find amazing.
And if there was still a cadaver scent source in 5A?Was there?
Amaral claimed
These dogs, have solved 200 case
These dogs have never been wrong
Eddie alerted to a body under a, slab of concrete in Jersey
All untrue... Yet those demanding truth and accuracy on this, site support his, right to make, those untrue claims... Claims made to millions of people
It's a fact that Amaral said certain things. We know what he said because cites are available showing what he said. The truth of his statements are open to debate, the fact that he made them isn't.
Posters claiming 'Amaral said' should, under forum rules, provide cites showing where that information can be found. The reason for that is that people sometimes post what they think was said rather than what was actually said.
You don't know if GA is right or wrong...
Why do you have to always include GA etc to your argument...
If it wasn't for the mccs....and there supporters ....
that book would never have seen the light of day....
IMO you all publicized that book...for it to be as popular as it is...
IMO that book took over the mccs.....not maddie being missing.....
It still seems that way even to this day...
What you have posted is untrue and you surely must know it.
The three statements I quoted from amaral are not open to debate but clearly untrue.... So your claim that you wish to correct untrue statements is untrue and questions your motives and sincerety
For all those who seem unsure what a fact is let me enlighten you. I have been told that apartment 5J was occupied that week and that the occupants left on 4th May. That is a statement of fact, as no IMO was included. I'm unable to
discover the source of the fact because no cite has been provided. That's a pity because it's very interesting and worth discussing if it's true.
This is obviously an issue of grave importance to you so I think it may be worth having a look at to settle it one way or the other.
To that end I have carried out a search for the offending post and have been unsuccessful in locating it.
Please provide a link. Thank you
Snip/
There is no record of it. Nor is there any record of Mr and Mrs Moyes who were in the apartment above Mrs fenn being interviewed either.
Or the people who left apartment 5J on May 4th. Does anyone even know who they were, where they went or where they are now?
Is it a fact that people left 5J on 4th May? I think a cite could be required.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9683.msg469449#msg469449
ReplyQuoteNotify
Sunny's next cite request was from a statement Davel made.
"Quote from: Davel on October 15, 2018, 10:20:21 PM
Surrounding air and out through windows and doors..remnant scent lasts in a completely sealed room but would not in one with open windows and doors....and certainly not an outside flower bed
Sunny's request:
Do you have a cite for the windows and doors being open and that remnant scent wouldn't last unless the room was completely sealed."
I'm ruling that Davel's comment is at best a guess based on physics. It is obviously his opinion based on his scientific knowledge.
So he doesn't say it was empty since 4th May simply that it was "closed down". I believe 3 months is a short time for cadaver odour to remain if they some of these dogs can find bodies of people who were buried hundreds of years ago. With respect to scent pooling I am not sure it depends upon the concentration although clearly the more concentrated the odour in one place the larger the scent pool in that same place.
I shall amend that accordingly to meet with what we know of the occupants of apartment 5J who did exist at some point in time in my opinion ... well ... long enough to stock the fridge with food prior to leaving without bothering to take time to close the fridge door.
So what do we know of them?
- who are they?
- were they the owners? were they the owners' guests?
- when did they arrive?
- were they in residence on the morning of 4th May
- when did they depart?
- was it the norm for rotting food to be left in an open fridge?
- who was tasked with cleaning the apartment? we know it wasn't a Mark Warner cleaner.
In my opinion 5J was an interesting apartment. The GNR dogs certainly thought so. Is there any evidence it was even given a cursory glance by the PJ?
In other words you don't know if 5J was occupied and you don't know if anyone left that apartment on 4th May. I'm happy to leave it there, thank you.
Amaral claimed
These dogs, have solved 200 case
These dogs have never been wrong
Eddie alerted to a body under a, slab of concrete in Jersey
All untrue... Yet those demanding truth and accuracy on this, site support his, right to make, those untrue claims... Claims made to millions of people
These are not all easy to find. I have found the 200 case one but I cannot find the other two. Could you please provide a link to where I can read them.
I asked the same question here and have been promised an answer 'later';
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7275.msg496788#msg496788
So we have two separate requests for the same cite and no response from the poster in question.
In accordance with forum rules I expect the response will arrive 'later' as promised.
So we have two separate requests for the same cite and no response from the poster in question.
Its arrived
Later may have but the cite(s) haven't Davel.
I never said I was interested in the truth of Amaral's claims. I said I was interested in the truth of claims made by posters on this forum.Why should claims made by anonymous internet forum members be of more conseqence to you than claims made by higher profile individuals that some people actually take seriously such as Amaral? I find that bizarre.
Why should claims made by anonymous internet forum members be of more conseqence to you than claims made by higher profile individuals that some people actually take seriously such as Amaral? I find that bizarre.
I responded immediately and provided the cites later as promised......I confirm that. I read them but don't ask me where in which thread.
Sunny's fifth cite request is rejected as it isn't clear whether a cite is requested now or in the future.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10244.msg493989#msg493989
Sunny asks: "Perhaps someone should have told "a friend" then Davel. He seems explicit that they have not be interviewed by Scotland Yard. - unless you can say otherwise (with a cite) of course."
These are not all easy to find. I have found the 200 case one but I cannot find the other two. Could you please provide a link to where I can read them.
it is sunnys opinion that he seems explicit...thats why she uses the word seems...I dont agree...it is my opinion that they will have been interviwed by SY...as its my opinion it does not need a cite...next
The 200 case one is a Grime statement that says 200 case searches.
Why did it take you so long to say it was your opinion.
The 200 case one is a Grime statement that says 200 case searches.
I have never stated anything different...cite if you disagree...we dont know for sure if the mccanns have been interviewed by grange...I would say they certainly have
It is absolutely totally ridiculous to suggest SY has not interviewed the mcCanns..
You said?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7204.msg329443#msg329443
but according to a freedom of information request posted here eddie has only been involved in 37 casesSnip
it is...is that the best you can do...that post was made 2 and a half years ago whe no one put imo on any post
Davel I believe the post I cited was somewhat stronger than one which needed an IMO
It is absolutely totally ridiculous to suggest SY has not interviewed the mcCanns..
Snip
Grime claims that in a 6 year period in Britain, Eddie was deployed over 200 times. This disclosure under Freedom of Information (FOI) indicates just 37 deployments in the 5 year period 2003-2007.
http://www.southyorks.police.uk/foi/disclosurelog/20090062 Link no longer live
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6271.msg237337#msg237337
Does anyone have a copy?
Does anyone have a copy?
Taken from the ACPO Homicide Working Group Manual published in 2011....
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/J_Homicide_MII/J_Homicide_7.2.pdf (page 45)
The South Yorkshire Police dog team have been at the forefront of the training
and operational running of Victim Recovery (body) and Forensic Evidence
(human blood) Search dogs for over 12 years. Within that time they have had
over 500 hundred deployments throughout the UK.
"
Taken from John Ellis's CV http://www.criteriontrainingsolutions.co.uk/john-ellis.html
2000 he qualified as a Victim Recovery Dog (Body Dog) Handler and Instructor (and continues in this role to date).
2001 he qualified as an ACPO (Now NPCC) Explosive Detection Dog Instructor.
2002 he was seconded to the National Crime and Operations Faculty as a Victim Recovery Dog Handler providing cover and advice on a worldwide basis.
2004 he qualified at the University of Glasgow in the Identification of Human Remains in the field.
2004 he was awarded UK Police Dog Action of the Year (Victim Recovery).
2005 John was promoted to Temporary Sergeant of South Yorkshire Police Dog School responsible for the training of 45 Police Dog Handlers and 70+ Police Dogs.
In 2006 John retired from the Police but continued as a civilian Instructor in the Police Dog School and an Operational Victim Recovery Search Dog Handler. In 2009 John prepared the Units of Assessment for The Forensic Evidence Search Dogs for inclusion in the ACPO Training and Care Manual, which is still used today by every Police Dog Section in the UK.
I'll leave the statistical probability of Eddie/Grime being involved in 200 of the circa 500 cases spanning a 12 year period to someone more capable than me.
I don't recall saying that Eddie was involved in 200 cases I simply said he was involved (and found bodies) in more than was on the FOI answer. I would imagine he quite possibly did 200 searches as Rob said earlier with 6 or so searches per case, that would work.
The fourth cite Sunny wanted:
"4
Quote from: Sunny on October 12, 2018, 10:14:34 PM
Do you have a cite to show that ashes give off cadaver odour and also one which shows that pyjamas were left on the bedside cabinet following the grandfather's death.
Cadaver odour scent will move around a room and pool, Martin Grime has already explained that the part of a room where Eddie alerted may not be the exact location of where a cadaver may have been placed.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10257.msg494866#msg494866 "
to my knowledge:
1. Dogs can be trained to find bodies and ashes of victims of fires. Whether Eddie was trained to do so we are not told.
2. I think it originally was only suggested that the ashes and pyjamas were on the bedside table.
Eddie doesn't appear to have a problem identifying cremation remains ... which in my opinion makes Sadie's thoughts on the matter valid ones.
Snip
VT / 9 Trench and gun emplacement containing small personnel shelter. Forensic examination revealed recently deposited tissues that appeared to have been used to ‘clean up following sexual intercourse’. It would appear that the shelter had been used as a venue for courting couples. This alert is within the trained parameters of the dog’s repertoire and is a satisfactory explanation of the alert.
Base of an oak tree planted as a memorial to the two sons of Mr Hamon, Flat 2 Delborgho Lodge, Upper Clarendon Road, St Hellier. The cremated remains of the two adult sons had been previously scattered just under the surface of the ground and the tree planted as a permanent memorial together with a plaque. This alert is within the trained parameters of the dog’s repertoire and is a satisfactory explanation of the alert.
There being no other points of interest, intelligence led excavation of the site commenced to locate and investigate defensive positions by excavation, forensic examination and canine screening.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3566.msg135051#msg135051
I accept that the dogs will alert to cremated ashes but I still haven't seen any evidence of a cite for this and as I cannot see why anyone would keep their dead husbands pyjamas or cremated remains on a bedside cabinet, I think it is important.
If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall. Same with Grandpas ashes
.
If I was looking to keep someone's cremated remains in my house then that is not where I would keep them, nor his pyjamas.
To me it looks like clutching at straws to explain a dog's alert, that is, unless evidence is provided to show it was indeed true.
I accept that the dogs will alert to cremated ashes but I still haven't seen any evidence of a cite for this and as I cannot see why anyone would keep their dead husbands pyjamas or cremated remains on a bedside cabinet, I think it is important.Where is the correct place to put your Grandpa’s ashes then?
If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall. Same with Grandpas ashes
.
If I was looking to keep someone's cremated remains in my house then that is not where I would keep them, nor his pyjamas.
To me it looks like clutching at straws to explain a dog's alert, that is, unless evidence is provided to show it was indeed true.
but according to a freedom of information request posted here eddie has only been involved in 37 cases
...and?
Where is the correct place to put your Grandpa’s ashes then?
So is it 37 cases, or 200 ..unlikely the FOI is, wrong... So Grime probably made a mistake and meant case searches
I think it was her husband's ashes. Of course there is no particular place to put them but a bedside table seems strange to me. As there is no evidence for it actually happening either as no one appears to be able to provide any cite to that so called fact.
Davel I thought I'd made it clear.
The FOI request asked for cases between 2003 and 2007.
Eddie started working on cadaver searching before 2003 so there would be more cases and results than contained within the FOI answer. I gave an example in my post. The FOI was probably correct within those constraints but the dates requested by the questioner didn't cover all of Eddie's working life.
Therefore there were certainly more searches and at least one more body found by Eddie than shown in the FOI results.
(http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2103/2323/collections/AGE-URN-52-3_2048x2048_f0fea675-77b4-4e76-8407-c034281ddde9_2048x2048.jpg?v=1526390901)Would a pretty funerary urn such as the above look out of place on a bedside table?
So when did Eddie start working
He was working in 2002 as he and Frankie found a body. He could have started as far back as 2001 if he worked from the age of 6 months as Keela did.
(http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2103/2323/collections/AGE-URN-52-3_2048x2048_f0fea675-77b4-4e76-8407-c034281ddde9_2048x2048.jpg?v=1526390901)Would a pretty funerary urn such as the above look out of place on a bedside table?
So you think it's possible he did 37 cases in 5 years and 163 in a year or two before that... Makes no sense
I think it was her husband's ashes. Of course there is no particular place to put them but a bedside table seems strange to me. As there is no evidence for it actually happening either as no one appears to be able to provide any cite to that so called fact.
Where is the correct place to put your Grandpa’s ashes then?A couple of ideas here
In common parlance it is what is known as a myth.
A couple of ideas hereI believe Paula Yates kept Michael Hutchence’s ashes sewn up in a pillow that she went to bed with every night, if only she’d known this was not correct.
You may choose to bury the ashes in a cremation plot or simply a regular plot. There may not be any additional cost if you choose to bury or entomb the remains in the burial plot of another family member.
Holding the remains in a cremation memorial in the form of a cremation bench, memorial rock, or grave marker with an integrated repository is another popular idea. These memorials can be placed in a cemetery.
It is not a Myth. It was offered as a suggestion.
It is a myth, it is regularly brought out and there is no form of evidence of it ever happening.
It is a myth, it is regularly brought out and there is no form of evidence of it ever happening.Is it referred to as a fact or a theory?
Then IMO you could refer to the detection of cadaver odour as s myth
It is not a Myth. It was offered as a suggestion.
If you want to consider a dog trained to alert to cadaver odour alerting as a myth that is up to you.it's a myth that the alert confirms cadaver odour
It is not a Myth. It was offered as a suggestion.
I believe this was certainly not offered as a suggestion but as a fact
If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall. Same with Grandpas ashes
Perhaps Grandpas ashes were moved around from time to time even spending the summer holidays in the garden, thus accounting for all the alerts in and around 5a? Just an attempt to give a reason for the alerts IMO.
Read Sadie's last several posts again. It's not difficult. You can pick up her posts by clicking on her name which goes to her profile.
But in any case the most likely source of that alert .... and let's make it clear, there was only one, was the ashes or the deceased pyjamas on the bedside table. There to comfort the widow in a foreign country
It's a bit fanciful, though because we don't know if the grandfather ever even lived in the apartment.Certainly not at the same time as his remains might have been there.
I believe this was certainly not offered as a suggestion but as a fact
If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall. Same with Grandpas ashes
Perhaps Grandpas ashes were moved around from time to time even spending the summer holidays in the garden, thus accounting for all the alerts in and around 5a? Just an attempt to give a reason for the alerts IMO.
Thank you for explaining how to search others peoples posts, Eleanor.That just goes to show how problematic dog alerts can be.
Here is another one by sadie
That is still one very strong suggestion. So a hypothetical urn of ashes placed on a bedside table then becomes "the most likely source of the alert", quite amazing really considering there is no evidence of this urn of ashes.
All IMO.
That just goes to show how problematic dog alerts can be.
In what way Rob. IMO the most problematic thing appears to be that some supporters seem to be desperate to make up reasons for the alerts.Did you see the post where Eddie barked near a tree, but someone claimed there had been ashes scattered there so that alert had to be discounted. It could not be proved whether Eddie alerted to the ashes or not.
Did you read my further post where said says that the ashes on the bedside table were the most likely reason for the alert in the bedroom. How can some hypothetical ashes be a reason for an alert, let alone the most likely reason.
In what way Rob. IMO the most problematic thing appears to be that some supporters seem to be desperate to make up reasons for the alerts.What do you think was the reason for the alert to cuddle cat
Did you read my further post where said says that the ashes on the bedside table were the most likely reason for the alert in the bedroom. How can some hypothetical ashes be a reason for an alert, let alone the most likely reason.
Certainly not at the same time as his remains might have been there.
What do you think was the reason for the alert to cuddle catWas it he loves playing with toys?
Did you see the post where Eddie barked near a tree, but someone claimed there had been ashes scattered there so that alert had to be discounted. It could not be proved whether Eddie alerted to the ashes or not.Snip
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10278.msg496924#msg496924
A bit of Moorcroft would look better and show a bit more class!
A couple of ideas here
You may choose to bury the ashes in a cremation plot or simply a regular plot. There may not be any additional cost if you choose to bury or entomb the remains in the burial plot of another family member.
Holding the remains in a cremation memorial in the form of a cremation bench, memorial rock, or grave marker with an integrated repository is another popular idea. These memorials can be placed in a cemetery.
Sadie - what makes you think Eddie alerted to something up the wall?You haven't been reading the posts Rob. There is evidence, posted to day or yesterday, that Eddie was trained on Pig (Cadavar).
We are talking about the alert that happened in the main bedroom aren't we?
You are still talking about cooked pork. The dogs were trained not to alert to food.
The video I saw Eddie was sniffing the wardrobe and the moment the camera operator goes behind Martin Grime Eddie starts barking so it is unsure where he last sniffed but the decision to bark isn't immediate the dog has to think about it first. So IMO he was alerting to the wardrobe.
You haven't been reading the posts Rob. There is evidence, posted to day or yesterday, that Eddie was trained on Pig (Cadavar).Even if there was a slight amount of cadaverine production in a slaughtered pig the dogs are trained to not alert to food. As I said many times it is not just the detection of cadaverine that the EVRD cadaver dogs are detecting but human cadaver. Food would have additional smells to it that let the dog know that is food not human cadaver IMO. It could be odours associated with processing e.g. smoking, salts, spices etc which assist the dog to distinguish food from decomposed cadaver.
Now we know that modern supervised methods of hygeinically (Spelling ?) killed and prepared pig are free from cadavar odour, but we are talking here of ordinary and peasant type people with a pig in their shed / back garden. I think it is very doubtful that their standards would be the same as those overseen by the Authorities.
I think that I read that cadavareine starts formig in less than an hour, in fact I think I have read that it starts virtually immediately after death. These ordinary, non commercial, pig keepers are not going to throw away meat because there is a tiny amount of cadavareine in it, but the ultra keen nose of a search dog will spot it.
We know that cadavar dogs alert to burnt people. These dogs are used in fires to find charred bodies, even the dust of burnt bodies. There is a similarity between pig cadavar odour and human cadavar odour, cos Eddie as trained on pig cadavar odour and uses his expertise on human cadavars.
From all this, it is reasonable to question whether the odour on the wall is Cadavar odour from a pork sandwich etc
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4201303/I like this reference Misty for it shows in some way the dogs think about what they are doing, and at times when the odour are less than obvious they sniff longer but still get it wrong more often. Well that is how I think of it. At all times there will be a delay between sniffing and alerting IMO.
snipped
In detection dogs, the accuracy of the detection depends on both the dog’s olfactory capability to identify the target odor and the interpretation of the dog’s behavior by a handler. Earlier studies in detection dogs have not directly analyzed the relationship between sniffing behavior and accuracy of odor discrimination in detection tasks, concentrating instead on the total duration of the search (Thesen et al. 1993; Jezierski et al. 2008). Our results indicate that sniffing behavior can be used alongside the trained alert response to more effectively assess detection. Specifically, we found that the sniffing duration of detection dogs used in this study is shortest when the target odor is not present and the dogs indicate this by not offering an alert response (true negative), and the dogs only ever performed one sniffing episode towards these samples compared with the other responses (true positive, false positive, and false negative). In particular, samples that resulted in true positive, false positive, and false negative decisions were sniffed for approximately twice the amount of time of true negatives. In other words, the detection dogs used in this study sniffed for twice the amount of time when the target odor was present or when it was indicated as present on a negative sample.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The full paper is worth reading, despite not being specific to cadaver dogs.
If anyone sees fit, perhaps a comparison of Eddie's alerts seen on the video could be compared to the findings detailed in this report, especially as it demonstrates the inconsistency between Eddie's alert at the wardrobe & the alert behind the sofa (or at the end of the sofa, take your pick).
Yep, but she was a widow abroad ... and it seems likely that she would have gained comfort from having what reamined of her hubby close to her in bed. Likewise the pjays that he died in (washed but with the residual very slight odour of cadavarine) might well have been on the bedside table, where she could touch them and gain comfort from them.
How else do you, or your side, account for the smell of cadavarine being up the wall ?
There was no reasonable excuse for removing my flying pigs thesis from this post. I was merely pointing out as to why pigs blood could be up the walls.
all a bit Pathetic and sad really..... but for me very entertaining!
Another thought is that Keela being a smaller placid dog, may not have been close enough to smell a blood spot up there, whilst the bigger, younger bouncy Eddies nostrils came closer. In that case the scent could have been from a spot of dessicatd blood on the wall from a living person.
Or it could posibly have been from cooked pork
We just don't know and without any forensic evidence it is, imo, foolhardy and unjust to make suggestions that the alert was to Madeleines cadavar odour.
As I said before, JUST HOW COULD MADELEINES DEAD BODY ODOUR HAVE GOT SO HIGH UP THAT WALL?
Any suggestions?
Yep, but she was a widow abroad ... and it seems likely that she would have gained comfort from having what reamined of her hubby close to her in bed. Likewise the pjays that he died in (washed but with the residual very slight odour of cadavarine) might well have been on the bedside table, where she could touch them and gain comfort from them.
How else do you, or your side, account for the smell of cadavarine being up the wall ?
Another thought is that Keela being a smaller placid dog, may not have been close enough to smell a blood spot up there, whilst the bigger, younger bouncy Eddies nostrils came closer. In that case the scent could have been from a spot of dessicatd blood on the wall from a living person.
Or it could posibly have been from cooked pork
We just don't know and without any forensic evidence it is, imo, foolhardy and unjust to make suggestions that the alert was to Madeleines cadavar odour.
As I said before, JUST HOW COULD MADELEINES DEAD BODY ODOUR HAVE GOT SO HIGH UP THAT WALL?
Any suggestions?
Sadie, sorry but that post is rubbish. Martin Grime was explicit that Eddie wouldn't alert to cooked pork. The alert was not up the wall but in the area of the wardrobe. You are making excuses by using some hypothetical ashes and pyjamas. Keela had an excellent nose for detecting the smallest drop of blood. All in all I have to disagree with everything you have posted.
From Martin Grime.
"'Eddie' The Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog (E.V.R.D.) will search for and
locate human remains and body fluids including blood in any environment or
terrain. The initial training of the dog was conducted using human blood and
stil born decomposing piglets. The importance of this is that the dog is
introduced to the scent of a decomposing body NOT FOODSTUFF. This
ensures that the dog disregards the 'bacon sandwich' and 'kebab' etc that is
ever present in the background environment. Therefore the dog would
remain efficient searching for a cadaver in a café where the clientele were sat
eating bacon sandwiches. He has additionally trained exclusively using
human remains in the U.S.A. in association with the F.B.I. The enhanced
training of the dog has also involved the use of collection of 'cadaver scent'
odor from human corpses using remote technical equipment which does not
contact the subject. This method is comparable to the simulation of cross
contamination. It does however differ in that the remote scent samples
recovery does not involve subject matter and therefore is a 'pure' scent
sample. The dog has since initial training gained considerable experience in
successfully operationally locating human remains and evidential forensic
material."
Feel a song coming on.
https://youtu.be/ZVIiQ8iNvKc
In my role as advisor to the U.S. Justice Department I have facilitated assessment of numerous cadaver search dog teams in the United States.
These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced decomposing pig cadavers into training assessments 100 % of the animals alerted to the medium. (The products were obtained from whole piglet cadaver not processed food for human consumption).
The result from scientific experiments and research to date is suggestive that the scent of human and pig decomposing material is so similar that we are unable to 'train' the dog to distinguish between the two.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
In my role as advisor to the U.S. Justice Department I have facilitated assessment of numerous cadaver search dog teams in the United States.
These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced decomposing pig cadavers into training assessments 100 % of the animals alerted to the medium. (The products were obtained from whole piglet cadaver not processed food for human consumption).
The result from scientific experiments and research to date is suggestive that the scent of human and pig decomposing material is so similar that we are unable to 'train' the dog to distinguish between the two.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
Surely the dog would respond to uncooked pork which had started to go off
If the dog could alert to a cube of burnt pork then it is logical it could alert to decomposing pig flesh (with or without bone & hide)
Where does it say they alert to burnt pork misty. I have asked Brietta but had no response.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P9/09_VOLUME_IXa_Page_2266.jpg
Half way down the page.
Thank you misty. Interesting cooking method that, soaking in petrol for a week then setting alight to it. That would make it more than burnt it would be cremated along the lines of a real cremation. I see he says "burnt until only a residue remains". Presumably ash.
As he was clear about cooked meat I believe he considers a slightly overdone pork chop as something that Eddie would not alert to.
Where does it say that Martin Grime introduced cooked pork and all the dogs alerted Brietta? Your post is pointless IMO.
Who is making that claim?
Surely the dog would respond to uncooked pork which had started to go offDifferent bacteria therefore different odour.
Different bacteria therefore different odour.
But grime said Eddie would respond to decomposing pork
Do you have a cite Davel?.
I have this
There were no alert indications from the remaining properties. I did however
see the dog search in the kitchen waste bins. These contained meat
foodstuffs including pork and did not result in any false alert response.
And
False' positives are always a possibility; to date Eddie has not so indicated
operationally or in training. In six years of operational deployment in over 200
criminal case searches the dog has never alerted to meat based and
specifically pork foodstuffs designed for human consumption.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
But grime said Eddie would respond to decomposing porkdid he define what pork was?
.
These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced decomposing pig cadavers into training assessments 100 % of the animals alerted to the medium. (The products were obtained from whole piglet cadaver not processed food for human consumption).
Davel that has nothing to do with my post. Martin Grime was clear that Eddie didn't alert to decaying pork in a waste bin and wouldn't alert to cooked pork.
The result from scientific experiments and research to date is suggestive that the scent of human and pig decomposing material is so similar that we are unable to 'train' the dog to distinguish between the two.That is a presumption.
So if we had a severed foot.... I presume the dog would alert
Why not a severed trotter..
Grime refers to Eddie not alerting to processed food
Davel that has nothing to do with my post. Martin Grime was clear that Eddie didn't alert to decaying pork in a waste bin and wouldn't alert to cooked pork.
That is a presumption.
That is a presumption.
Brietta we have already agreed that one, hopefully amicably.
The first paragraph is Grime... Then my extrapolationIt could be an interesting experiment. When does a pig carcass become a decomposed cadaver or pig meat?
It could be an interesting experiment. When does a pig carcass become a decomposed cadaver or pig meat?
Could part of the carcass become decomposed and another part be classed as meat?
In an abattoir the cadavers are chilled to 3°C & dried immediately after slaughter and remain chilled/frozen. This restricts microbiological activity as well as chemical & physical changes. I guess you'd have to experiment by leaving the meat in various states of storage & at different warmer temperatures then assess the levels of decomposition.I'm quite superstitious about that. I have only kind thoughts when I attend my stock.
Do your livestock know you are having these musings?