UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 03:57:28 PM

Title: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 03:57:28 PM
surely lack of evidence is evidence of innocence

123
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 15, 2017, 05:38:18 PM
surely lack of evidence is evidence of innocence

I would imagine that erelong an itinerant will pass by muttering " 'tis but a false dichotomy" or words to that effect.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: John on July 15, 2017, 05:40:51 PM
surely lack of evidence is evidence of innocence

Absolutely not, lack of evidence is neutral under the Law.  In the same way that a refusal by a suspect to cooperate with investigators is often wrongly perceived as guilt but cannot be viewed as evidence of guilt.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 06:05:24 PM
Absolutely not, lack of evidence is neutral under the Law.  In the same way that a refusal by a suspect to cooperate with investigators is often wrongly perceived as guilt but cannot be viewed as evidence of guilt.

Lack of evidence is not neutral John
Suspect s at trial are acquitted due to lack of evidence
That is certainly not neutral
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 15, 2017, 06:09:57 PM
Lack of evidence is not neutral John
Suspect s at trial are acquitted due to lack of evidence
That is certainly not neutral

Being acquitted isn't being declared innocent.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 06:35:44 PM
Being acquitted isn't being declared innocent.

Neither is being found not guilty
But both acquittal and not guilty verdicts are evidence of innocence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 15, 2017, 06:58:13 PM

Oh for God's sake.  Is anyone ever innocent?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 15, 2017, 07:03:33 PM
Everybody is innocent until proven guilty, which ain't going to happen in the absence of evidence, or even insufficient evidence.

To suggest otherwise is Libellous.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:03:43 PM
Absence of evidence results in a verdict of not guilty
That is evidence of innocence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 15, 2017, 07:03:57 PM
Neither is being found not guilty
But both acquittal and not guilty verdicts are evidence of innocence



Barry George was acquitted of the murder of Jill Dando at his second trial. He was denied compensation for wrongful incarceration, however. The High Court judges didn't see the acquittal as evidence of innocence;

 "There was indeed a case upon which a reasonable jury properly directed could have convicted the claimant of murder"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_George#Life_after_Dando_acquittal

Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:05:54 PM
Just calling something rubbish doesn't make it rubbish
You need to present a logical argument as I have done


I have yet to see you provide any argument of substance.  Acquittal does not prove innocence, just ask Sion Jenkins or Barry George.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:06:04 PM


Barry George was acquitted of the murder of Jill Dando at his second trial. He was denied compensation for wrongful incarceration, however. The High Court judges didn't see the acquittal as evidence of innocence;

 "There was indeed a case upon which a reasonable jury properly directed could have convicted the claimant of murder"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_George#Life_after_Dando_acquittal

Wrong wrong wrong
The acquittal is evidence of innocence but not proof
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:08:13 PM

I have yet to see you provide any argument of substance.  Acquittal does not prove innocence, just ask Soon Jenkins or Barry George.

I have provided an argument of substance it's just that you have misunderstood it as this post proves
Absence of evidence is evidence of innocence but not proof
As I have already posted
You are confusing evidence and proof
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:08:45 PM
Absence of evidence results in a verdict of not guilty
That is evidence of innocence

The law school of hard knocks doesn't count.  Being found not guilty has nothing to do with innocence.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:09:02 PM
I would imagine that erelong an itinerant will pass by muttering " 'tis but a false dichotomy" or words to that effect.

No because I have not used the word proof
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:10:48 PM
Wrong wrong wrong
The acquittal is evidence of innocence but not proof

 @)(++(*  @)(++(*  @)(++(* in your dreams...any lawyer reading this must be pissing themself laughing.

A failure to prove guilt can never imply innocence.  That is how our justice system works. 
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:11:55 PM
The law school of hard knocks doesn't count.  Being found not guilty has nothing to do with innocence.

Being not guilty has a lot to do with innocence
It doesn't prove innocence but it is evidence of innocence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:15:45 PM
@)(++(*  @)(++(*  @)(++(* in your dreams...any lawyer reading this must be pissing themself laughing.

A failure to prove guilt can never imply innocence.  That is how our justice system works.

If there is no evidence against someone that would imply innocence
But not prove it
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:20:27 PM
If there is no evidence against someone that would imply innocence
But not prove it

For the second time, British courts are concerned with GUILT and not innocence. A court has to establish guilt, it is unconcerned with innocence.  A not guilty verdict simply means that insufficient evidence has been adduced under the law to find them guilty.

Anyone seeking compensation has to demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that they are in fact innocent of the crime for which they were originally tried. That is a much more difficult task.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 07:21:14 PM
Perhaps an expert in the field of Law could clarify the position.

Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:22:18 PM
For the second time, British courts are concerned with GUILT and not innocence. A court has to establish guilt, there are unconcerned with innocence.  A not guilty verdict simply means that insufficient evidence has been adduced under the law to find them guilty.

Anyone seeking compensation has to demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that they are in fact innocent of the crime for which they were originally tried.

I've posted that fact many times
It doesn't affect the statement that absence of evidence is evidence of innocence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:24:15 PM
A person isn't innocent just because a jury fails to find them guilty.  Its called common sense!!
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:25:44 PM
Perhaps an expert in the field of Law could clarify the position.

You constantly post that absence of evidence of an abductor more than suggests there wasn't one
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:28:09 PM
I've posted that fact many times
It doesn't affect the statement that absence of evidence is evidence of innocence

An absence of evidence can come about for many reasons thus why it cannot ever be 'evidence of innocence'.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:29:04 PM
A person isn't innocent just because a jury fails to find them guilty.  Its called common sense!!
A not guilty verdict would suggest innocence but of course not prove it
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:29:50 PM
You constantly post that absence of evidence of an abductor more than suggests there wasn't one

He is right of course, nothing to do with innocence.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:30:19 PM
An absence of evidence can come about for many reasons thus why it cannot ever be 'evidence of innocence'.

You are confusing evidence and proof
Just because there is evidence of a person's innocence does not mean they are innocent
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:31:33 PM
A not guilty verdict would suggest innocence but of course not prove it

It is suggestive of many things but not evidence.

Reasons why a jury fail to convict.

1. It has been nobbled.
2. Lack of credible evidence.
3. Dislike of prosecution arguments.
4. Alibi.
5. Evidence of innocence.
6. Want to get home.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:34:00 PM
It is suggestive of many things but not evidence.

It is evidence
Anything that supports an argument is evidence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:37:45 PM
It is evidence
Anything that supports an argument is evidence

A verdict isn't an argument, it is a decision.  By extension the Portuguese Supreme Court ruled that the McCanns had not produced evidence of innocence.  Does that mean they are guilty or to use your words, suggestive of guilt?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 15, 2017, 07:40:06 PM
Oh for God's sake.  Is anyone ever innocent?

In absolute terms they can be.
Courts deal only in "Guilty" or "Not Guilty".
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:41:46 PM
Oh for God's sake.  Is anyone ever innocent?

That's just it Eleanor, we are all guilty of something.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:42:11 PM
A verdict isn't an argument, it is a decision.  By extension the Portuguese Supreme Court ruled that the McCanns had not produced evidence of innocence.  Does that mean they are guilty?

I wasn't referring to and didn't mention a verdict
Both you and Stephen regularly claim that the absence of evidence of an abduction means it didn't happen
You are using absence of evidence as evidence of absence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 15, 2017, 07:46:47 PM
No because I have not used the word proof

That is irrelevant.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:47:19 PM
A verdict isn't an argument, it is a decision.  By extension the Portuguese Supreme Court ruled that the McCanns had not produced evidence of innocence.  Does that mean they are guilty or to use your words, suggestive of guilt?

What evidence could they possibly produce
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:51:53 PM
What evidence could they possibly produce

Maybe answering a few simple questions and encouraging their pals to take part in a reconstruction would have been a good start.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 07:54:04 PM
Maybe answering a few simple questions and encouraging their pals to take part in a reconstruction would have been a good start.
As John has pointed out not answering questions is not evidence of guilt
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 15, 2017, 07:56:18 PM
That's just it Eleanor, we are all guilty of something.

You might be, but I'm not.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 07:58:22 PM
As John has pointed out not answering questions is not evidence of guilt

It can be suggestive of guilt and when taken with other evidence could very well point to guilt.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:01:54 PM
You might be, but I'm not.

Well for one thing you are guilty of being rude to members when the mood takes you.  *&*%£
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 15, 2017, 08:03:01 PM
And is evidence of innocence
Madeleine is missing, we presume as a result of a criminal act.  Who ever committed that presumed act is not innocent, but there is no proof as to who that is.  So there cannot be proof of innocence until some one else has been proven guilty IMO.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:03:39 PM
And is evidence of innocence

A decision by a jury cannot be considered evidence.   @)(++(*
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Benice on July 15, 2017, 08:03:55 PM
For the second time, British courts are concerned with GUILT and not innocence. A court has to establish guilt, it is unconcerned with innocence.  A not guilty verdict simply means that insufficient evidence has been adduced under the law to find them guilty.

Anyone seeking compensation has to demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that they are in fact innocent of the crime for which they were originally tried. That is a much more difficult task.

'Insufficient evidence' should not be interpreted as meaning that evidence exists, but it just hasn't been found yet.     A valid reason why  'insufficient evidence' is found  can simply be that no evidence exists and never did exist to be found in the first place.
AIMHO


Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 15, 2017, 08:04:48 PM
Well for one thing you are guilty of being rude to members when the mood takes you.  *&*%£

You and me both, our kid.  But you are fractionally better at it than I am.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:05:33 PM
Madeleine is missing, we presume as a result of a criminal act.  Who ever committed that presumed act is not innocent, but there is no proof as to who that is.  So there cannot be proof of innocence until some one else has been proven guilty IMO.

I don't presume a criminal act Rob.  I presume an act of neglect followed by an accident followed by an act of desperation.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 08:08:24 PM
I don't presume a criminal act Rob.  I presume an act of neglect followed by an accident followed by an act of desperation.

All your opinion with no evidence to support it
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:08:29 PM
You and me both, our kid.  But you are fractionally better at it than I am.

My vocabulary isn't as floral as yours  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:09:31 PM
All your opinion with no evidence to support it

I have already stated the evidence.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 15, 2017, 08:11:37 PM
My vocabulary isn't as floral as yours  ?{)(**

Thanks for the compliment.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 15, 2017, 08:14:33 PM
I don't presume a criminal act Rob.  I presume an act of neglect followed by an accident followed by an act of desperation.
OK and all that is perfectly legal?  So we are not correct in using the word "guilty" then but we should be using a softer word.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 08:19:50 PM
I have already stated the evidence.
It doesn't stand up
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Angelo222 on July 15, 2017, 08:30:42 PM
It doesn't stand up

in your opinion.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: misty on July 15, 2017, 09:07:52 PM
An absence of evidence means no grounds for prosecution therefore everyone is equal in the eyes of the law.

It has occurred to me that, if Madeleine is never found & Smithman is never identified, any suspect will always have a reasonable defence.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 09:45:06 PM
SY seem convinced and they have said the parents are not suspects

Which members of SY are convinced ? 
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 09:49:13 PM
Which members of SY are convinced ?

It's the official statement and no member has raised an objection
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: sadie on July 16, 2017, 12:43:38 AM
'Insufficient evidence' should not be interpreted as meaning that evidence exists, but it just hasn't been found yet.     A valid reason why  'insufficient evidence' is found  can simply be that no evidence exists and never did exist to be found in the first place.
AIMHO

A valid reason why  'insufficient evidence' is found  can simply be that no evidence exists and never did exist to be found in the first place.

Well put Benice.

An innocent party will leave NO EVIDENCE, so there will be no evidence to be found.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 16, 2017, 08:47:51 AM
Guilty people can be acquitted/found not guilty of crimes. In some cases it's because the prosecutors have been unable to present enough evidence to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The absence of evidence simply means the guilty were unable to be convicted.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 16, 2017, 08:50:37 AM
Guilty people can be acquitted/found not guilty of crimes. In some cases it's because the prosecutors have been unable to present enough evidence to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The absence of evidence simply means the guilty were unable to be convicted.

How do you explain innocent people being found guilty?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: jassi on July 16, 2017, 08:56:27 AM
dishonesty and/or incompetence.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 09:09:11 AM
Guilty people can be acquitted/found not guilty of crimes. In some cases it's because the prosecutors have been unable to present enough evidence to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The absence of evidence simply means the guilty were unable to be convicted.

That is one case
But the absence of evidence has to be evidence of innocence
Not proof but evidence
It is simple logic
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 09:24:23 AM
The absence of evidence against the McCann's supports the argument they are innocent. It doesn't prove innocence.
Anything that supports a conjecture is evidence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 09:26:25 AM
The absence of evidence against the McCann's supports the argument they are innocent. It doesn't prove innocence.
Anything that supports a conjecture is evidence

IYO,
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: jassi on July 16, 2017, 09:32:52 AM
The absence of evidence against the McCann's supports the argument they are innocent. It doesn't prove innocence.
Anything that supports a conjecture is evidence

Even if it might be false ?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 16, 2017, 09:47:55 AM
That is one case
But the absence of evidence has to be evidence of innocence
Not proof but evidence
It is simple logic

It only took the sighting of one black swan to destroy the theory that all swans were white. 

It destroys your idea that absence of evidence is evidence of innocence.

Your understanding of logic is faulty, by the way. 

Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 16, 2017, 09:49:47 AM
I cannot claim the parents have not been interviewed, without providing cites thereof.  A C Rowley appeared to confirm this, but he was a bit wobbly.

On the other hand, anyone claiming they have been interviewed should find it easy to provide cites to support this.  Let's see - Kate and Gerry of course, DCI Andy Redwood, DCI Nicola Wall, Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe, A C Rowley, what's his name above DCI Nicola Wall, Clarence Mitchell, any of the T9.  So it should be easy, but thus far, not a cheep.

So your opinion is seemingly completely unfounded.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 09:54:17 AM
I cannot claim the parents have not been interviewed, without providing cites thereof.  A C Rowley appeared to confirm this, but he was a bit wobbly.

On the other hand, anyone claiming they have been interviewed should find it easy to provide cites to support this.  Let's see - Kate and Gerry of course, DCI Andy Redwood, DCI Nicola Wall, Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe, A C Rowley, what's his name above DCI Nicola Wall, Clarence Mitchell, any of the T9.  So it should be easy, but thus far, not a cheep.

So your opinion is seemingly completely unfounded.

You claim Rowley seem to confirm this
You are wrong...quite wrong
He said clearly that they had not been interviewed under caution
He did not say they have not been interviewed
My claim is not unfounded
It is founded on normal police practice
To suggest the McCann's have not been interviewed by DAY is totally absurd imo
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 09:56:09 AM
You claim Rowley seem to confirm this
You are wrong...quite wrong
He said clearly that they had not been interviewed under caution
He did not say they have not been interviewed

The parents have not been investigated.

OG relied on their flawed interpretation of the shelving report.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: jassi on July 16, 2017, 10:01:24 AM
That's reviewing, not investigating - IMO
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: carlymichelle on July 16, 2017, 10:05:10 AM
OG didn't investigate.

They misunderstood the shelving report.

...and they were not the only ones who 'misunderstood'.

it  remains the fact that the mccans were the last to see maddie  doesnt it??
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:06:02 AM
OG didn't investigate.

They misunderstood the shelving report.

...and they were not the only ones who 'misunderstood'.

I would say they did investigate and they did understand the archiving report
It was quite simple
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 10:07:04 AM
it  remains the fact that the mccans were the last to see maddie  doesnt it??

The last known people Carly.

That hasn't changed in 10 years.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:07:55 AM
That's reviewing, not investigating - IMO
So you accept that SY review​ed the evidence against the mccanns
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:11:29 AM
The last known people Carly.

That hasn't changed in 10 years.
And that is why SY would have interviewed thrm
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:12:34 AM
This is true Stephen - but what you said yesterday is also true:-

Quote
"As we are often told, a lack of evidence does not mean innocence, and neither does it mean evidence may not  emerge or be found."
unquote

I think it's obvious that no evidence against the McCanns or their friends has 'emerged or been found' during the SY/Oporto team investigations otherwise it would have been acted upon.     IMO it's only barmy conspiracy theorists who think it would be ignored, hidden or destroyed.

Totally true
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 10:20:46 AM
And that is why SY would have interviewed thrm

Cite  when they were interviewed then.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: jassi on July 16, 2017, 10:31:36 AM
So you accept that SY review​ed the evidence against the mccanns

They said they did. Only they know what that actually entailed.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:31:54 AM
Cite  when they were interviewed then.

you stated yesterday that they had not been interviewed and provided no cite
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 10:33:49 AM
you stated yesterday that they had not been interviewed and provided no cite

There is no one to say they have, and they haven't investigated the parents.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:36:06 AM
There is no one to say they have, and they haven't investigated the parents.

I would say they have investihated the parents as they have stated they ahve looked at the evidence....that is investigating
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 16, 2017, 11:27:43 AM
No your understanding of logic is faulty
The fact that no black swans had been seen was evidence that all swans were white
But not proof
Your problem is you confuse evidence and proof
The fact that there is evidence all swans are white is not proof all swans are white
Think about it

Were we discussing proof? Legally cases are 'proved' on the balance of probability. If investigators gather enough evidence to convince juries/judges that someone is guilty the case is proved beyond a reasonable doubt or on the preponderance of the evidence.

If insufficient or inadequate evidence is presented the person will be judged to be not guilty.

They then continue to enjoy the presumption of innocence they are entitled to by law.

The lack of evidence to convict or the acquittal of the accused isn't evidence of innocence, however. If it was, Barry George would have been compensated for wrongful imprisonment.








Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 11:31:28 AM
Were we discussing proof? Legally cases are 'proved' on the balance of probability. If investigators gather enough evidence to convince juries/judges that someone is guilty the case is proved beyond a reasonable doubt or on the preponderance of the evidence.

If insufficient or inadequate evidence is presented the person will be judged to be not guilty.

They then continue to enjoy the presumption of innocence they are entitled to by law.

The lack of evidence to convict or the acquittal of the accused isn't evidence of innocence, however. If it was, Barry George would have been compensated for wrongful imprisonment.
You are showing your poor understanding of logic now
The acquittal of Barry George is evidence big his innocence
He has not been compensated because it is insufficient evidence
To be compensated he requires a level of proof of innocence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 11:39:55 AM
A conviction is evidence but not proof of guilt
An acquittal is evidence but not proof of innocence
That has to be true

If it isn't what value does a conviction or acquittal have
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 16, 2017, 12:15:50 PM
A conviction is evidence but not proof of guilt
An acquittal is evidence but not proof of innocence
That has to be true

If it isn't what value does a conviction or acquittal have

Legally speaking a conviction means that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the defendant. An acquittal means they failed. The acquitted person can claim the acquittal is evidence that they are innocent, but legally that means nothing. New evidence can lead to a retrial and a guilty verdict.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: jassi on July 16, 2017, 12:20:05 PM
Legally speaking a conviction means that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the defendant. An acquittal means they failed. The acquitted person can claim the acquittal is evidence that they are innocent, but legally that means nothing. New evidence can lead to a retrial and a guilty verdict.

The police can also say that they are not looking for anyone else in connection with the crime - which can be a pretty damning statement.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 16, 2017, 01:15:03 PM
Legally speaking a conviction means that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the defendant. An acquittal means they failed. The acquitted person can claim the acquittal is evidence that they are innocent, but legally that means nothing. New evidence can lead to a retrial and a guilty verdict.
even a conviction can be appealed.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 01:25:53 PM
Legally speaking a conviction means that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the defendant. An acquittal means they failed. The acquitted person can claim the acquittal is evidence that they are innocent, but legally that means nothing. New evidence can lead to a retrial and a guilty verdict.

So an acquittal means nothing as regards evidence of innocence
Could you therefore explain how the McCann's would have been able to prove their innocence to the satisfaction of the archiving process and the supreme court
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 01:27:32 PM
even a conviction can be appealed.

You should have said proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt
A guilty verdict is not absolute proof of guilt
It is obviously evidence of guilt
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 01:29:34 PM
Legally speaking a conviction means that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the defendant. An acquittal means they failed. The acquitted person can claim the acquittal is evidence that they are innocent, but legally that means nothing. New evidence can lead to a retrial and a guilty verdict.

An acquittal is evidence of innocence but not proof
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: John on July 16, 2017, 02:07:35 PM
Some interesting views but can we please restrict them to the topic under discussion.

Someone asked earlier how an innocent person can be convicted of a crime.  Actually it is quite easy given certain circumstances. In my own case the facts were manipulated and twisted by a rogue prosecutor.  Allegations were invented in order to support an otherwise weak case. Weak and incompetent defence lawyers failed to bring key witnesses to court despite them being notified. Add to this a system which allows simple majority verdicts and you have the pitiful consequence that eight people can convict even though seven voted not guilty. This is what passes for justice in Scotland my friends!
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 16, 2017, 02:14:05 PM
Some interesting views but can we please restrict them to the topic under discussion.

Someone asked earlier how an innocent person can be convicted of a crime.  Actually it is quite easy given certain circumstances. In my own case the facts were manipulated and twisted by a rogue prosecutor.  Allegations were invented in order to support an otherwise weak case. Weak and incompetent defence lawyers failed to bring key witnesses to court despite them being notified. Add to this a system which allows simple majority verdicts and you have the pitiful consequence that eight people can convict even though seven voted not guilty. This is what passes for justice in Scotland my friends!

Scotland sounds worryingly like Portugal.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: John on July 16, 2017, 02:23:41 PM
Scotland sounds worryingly like Portugal.

It is worse in some aspects.  I don't want to go off topic but have a look at the number of foreign workers and students who have been murdered in Scotland over recent years and you get a sense of the problem.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 02:34:44 PM
Some interesting views but can we please restrict them to the topic under discussion.

Someone asked earlier how an innocent person can be convicted of a crime.  Actually it is quite easy given certain circumstances. In my own case the facts were manipulated and twisted by a rogue prosecutor.  Allegations were invented in order to support an otherwise weak case. Weak and incompetent defence lawyers failed to bring key witnesses to court despite them being notified. Add to this a system which allows simple majority verdicts and you have the pitiful consequence that eight people can convict even though seven voted not guilty. This is what passes for justice in Scotland my friends!

I think John its mccann supporters who are concerned about innocents being found guilty and sceptics who naively think if you are innocent you have nothing to fear. thats why Kate was advised to answer no more questions...we have seen proof of amaral twisting the facts on the video on this site
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: G-Unit on July 16, 2017, 03:28:46 PM
So an acquittal means nothing as regards evidence of innocence
Could you therefore explain how the McCann's would have been able to prove their innocence to the satisfaction of the archiving process and the supreme court

They didn't have to. They never ceased to be entitled to the presumption of innocence before the law. The PJ suspected them but were unable to gather the evidence needed to prosecute them.


Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: sadie on July 16, 2017, 05:31:52 PM
They didn't have to. They never ceased to be entitled to the presumption of innocence before the law. The PJ suspected them but were unable to gather the evidence needed to prosecute them.

An innocent party will leave NO EVIDENCE, so there will be no evidence to be found.

According to S.Y. Chief, Assistant CommissionerRowley they are innocent.
No wonder Amaral couldn't gather evidence to convict them !   


But he tried his hardest
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 05:57:52 PM
Kate was advised not to answer the questions by her lawyer.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 06:40:00 PM
A QUESTION SHE DID ANSWER

Q.  Are you aware that in not answering the questions you are jeopardising the investigation, which seeks to discover what happened to your daughter?

A.  'Yes, if that’s what the investigation thinks.'
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 06:41:44 PM
A QUESTION SHE DID ANSWER

Q.  Are you aware that in not answering the questions you are jeopardising the investigation, which seeks to discover what happened to your daughter?

A.  'Yes, if that’s what the investigation thinks.'

weve all seen that a million times and discussed it...she was absolutely right not to answer those questions having already answerring 19 hours of questions
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 06:46:01 PM
weve all seen that a million times and discussed it...she was absolutely right not to answer those questions having already answerring 19 hours of questions

IYO and your fellows , not mine.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Brietta on July 16, 2017, 06:49:53 PM
A QUESTION SHE DID ANSWER

Q.  Are you aware that in not answering the questions you are jeopardising the investigation, which seeks to discover what happened to your daughter?

A.  'Yes, if that’s what the investigation thinks.'

43- In the case files you were forensic testing films, where you can see them marking due to detection of the scent of human corpse and blood traces, also human, and only human, as well as all the comments of the technician in charge of them. After watching and after the marking of the scent of corpse in your bedroom beside the wardrobe and behind the sofa, pushed up against the sofa wall, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

44- When the sniffer dog also marked human blood behind the sofa, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

45- When the sniffer dog marked the scent of corpse coming from the vehicle you hired a month after the disappearance, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

46- When human blood was marked in the boot of the vehicle, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

47- When confronted with the results of Maddie’s DNA, whose analysis was carried out in a British laboratory, collected from behind the sofa and the boot of the vehicle, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?


She had already answered all the questions asked by the PJ during the marathon questioning session lasting many hours the previous day.

How could she be expected to know what was in the FSS report ... she hadn't seen it.  When Gerry asked to have sight of the DNA evidence ... he was refused.
Could that possibly have been that as a result of his medical training he would have understood it?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: slartibartfast on July 16, 2017, 07:08:47 PM
43- In the case files you were forensic testing films, where you can see them marking due to detection of the scent of human corpse and blood traces, also human, and only human, as well as all the comments of the technician in charge of them. After watching and after the marking of the scent of corpse in your bedroom beside the wardrobe and behind the sofa, pushed up against the sofa wall, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

44- When the sniffer dog also marked human blood behind the sofa, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

45- When the sniffer dog marked the scent of corpse coming from the vehicle you hired a month after the disappearance, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

46- When human blood was marked in the boot of the vehicle, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?

47- When confronted with the results of Maddie’s DNA, whose analysis was carried out in a British laboratory, collected from behind the sofa and the boot of the vehicle, did you say you couldn’t explain any more than you already had?


She had already answered all the questions asked by the PJ during the marathon questioning session lasting many hours the previous day.

How could she be expected to know what was in the FSS report ... she hadn't seen it.  When Gerry asked to have sight of the DNA evidence ... he was refused.
Could that possibly have been that as a result of his medical training he would have understood it?

You wonder why she didn't just answer yes?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:09:52 PM
You wonder why she didn't just answer yes?

because she had been advised not to answer any questions...simple

let me explain...imo...by now the pj were simply trying to wear kate down. If she had answerred these there would ahve been 48 more...the only way to put a stop to the pjs tactic was the right to silence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: slartibartfast on July 16, 2017, 07:12:00 PM
because she had been advised not to answer any questions...simple

So, question 44, why not say yes?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:13:02 PM
So, question 44, why not say yes?


because she ahd been advised not to answer any questions...simple
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: slartibartfast on July 16, 2017, 07:14:17 PM

because she ahd been advised not to answer any questions...simple

Bad advice as has dogged them throughout this case IMO.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 07:14:45 PM

because she ahd been advised not to answer any questions...simple

What did she have to fear ?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:14:52 PM
Bad advice as has dogged them throughout this case IMO.

i think that was good advice
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:16:30 PM
What did she have to fear ?

after 10 years do you still not understand....see johns post ...i think its 88
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 07:20:11 PM
after 10 years do you still not understand....see johns post ...i think its 88

I understand why she didn't want to answer the questions.

Try not to tell me again what to think.

That is goading.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 16, 2017, 07:38:32 PM
because she had been advised not to answer any questions...simple

let me explain...imo...by now the pj were simply trying to wear kate down. If she had answerred these there would ahve been 48 more...the only way to put a stop to the pjs tactic was the right to silence

Why do you suppose that would be so?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:54:33 PM
Why do you suppose that would be so?

I think you know
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 07:58:05 PM
Well I read number 88 .

Can you explain it's relevance to the latter part of the thread ?

if you need me too although its quite simple...

john posted..
In my own case the facts were manipulated and twisted by a rogue prosecutor.

bu answerring questions the suspect gives answers that can be twisted and manipulated...and used as evidence against the suspect

Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:04:50 PM
if you need me too although its quite simple...

john posted..
In my own case the facts were manipulated and twisted by a rogue prosecutor.

bu answerring questions the suspect gives answers that can be twisted and manipulated...and used as evidence against the suspect

Not in this case.

She refused to answer the questions, bar one, and that said everything.

IMHO , of course.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 08:16:58 PM
Not in this case.

She refused to answer the questions, bar one, and that said everything.

IMHO , of course.

Yes in this case
Some of the questions included lies about the forensic evidence

It is obvious to see
When taking into account John's post
Exactly why she refused to answer
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:22:09 PM
Yes in this case
Some of the questions included lies about the forensic evidence

It is obvious to see
When taking into account John's post
Exactly why she refused to answer

I'm not talking about John's case.

She answered one question.

Her answer said everything I need to know.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 08:25:19 PM
I'm not talking about John's case.

She answered one question.

Her answer said everything I need to know.

I didn't mention John's case
Read the post again

Anyone who knows anything about how the police operate would understand exactly why Kate was advised not to answer questions
And it certainly isn't the reason you gave
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:32:38 PM
I didn't mention John's case
Read the post again

Anyone who knows anything about how the police operate would understand exactly why Kate was advised not to answer questions
And it certainly isn't the reason you gave

I gave my opinion.

Unless you are Kate Mccann, you gave yours, and do not know what she was thinking.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 08:35:00 PM
I gave my opinion.

Unless you are Kate Mccann, you gave yours, and do not know what she was thinking.

I know why a lawyer would give that advice
And why it is the correct advice in this situation
Kate was absolutely right to do what she did
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:37:29 PM
I know why a lawyer would give that advice
And why it is the correct advice in this situation
Kate was absolutely right to do what she did

IYO yet again.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 08:39:49 PM
IYO yet again.

No not my opinion
Probably in the opinion of just about every criminal lawyer
I've done some research
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:42:53 PM
No not my opinion
Probably in the opinion of just about every criminal lawyer
I've done some research

So you agree with me.

Good.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 08:51:03 PM
So you agree with me.

Good.

No
Absolutely not agree with you

Try doing some research as to whether innocent suspects should answer police questions
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: slartibartfast on July 16, 2017, 10:05:14 PM
Absolutely not agree with you

Try doing some research as to whether innocent suspects should answer police questions

... and if the police are trying to work out what happened to your daughter? Probably not the best tactic.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:08:53 PM
... and if the police are trying to work out what happened to your daughter? Probably not the best tactic.

The police had already worked out what they thought had happened to your daughter and they thought you were responsible
In that case by far the best tactic
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 16, 2017, 11:14:05 PM
The police had already worked out what they thought had happened to your daughter and they thought you were responsible
In that case by far the best tactic

Ony in your opinion I suspect. Unless, of course, you have an authoritative cite for such theory.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Eleanor on July 17, 2017, 02:43:06 AM
Ony in your opinion I suspect. Unless, of course, you have an authoritative cite for such theory.

It looks obvious by the nature of the questions, especially as they were being repeated from the previous day.  It is the suspicion that I would concluded.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 12:25:15 PM
Ony in your opinion I suspect. Unless, of course, you have an authoritative cite for such theory.

Any takers for Amaral?
He did write a book about it ... make a documentary about it ... and if Portuguese TV is anything to go by is still on about it ten years after the event.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 01:05:35 PM
Ony in your opinion I suspect. Unless, of course, you have an authoritative cite for such theory.

Amarals told us
He can prove Maddie died in the apartment
Sedated with calpol
Of course he cant
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 03:39:30 PM
Any takers for Amaral?
He did write a book about it ... make a documentary about it ... and if Portuguese TV is anything to go by is still on about it ten years after the event.

Yet OG can't just can't declare any thing that proves his theory wrong,they are still working on theories.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 03:47:13 PM
Calpol is not a sedative
Children do not have fatal accidents falling off a sofa

You might want to rethink the last bit although she never fell off of a sofa nonetheless she banged her head.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/toddler-died-sleep-after-slipping-6982555
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:11:43 PM
You might want to rethink the last bit although she never fell off of a sofa nonetheless she banged her head.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/toddler-died-sleep-after-slipping-6982555

No need to rethink as this has been posted before
The little girl didn't die immediately
It generally takes about 24 hrs
I would need to read this case again but as I remember the case isn't as simple as presented
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:13:55 PM
You might want to rethink the last bit although she never fell off of a sofa nonetheless she banged her head.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/toddler-died-sleep-after-slipping-6982555

Read the article
It's not clear cut
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 04:30:05 PM
No need to rethink as this has been posted before
The little girl didn't die immediately
It generally takes about 24 hrs
I would need to read this case again but as I remember the case isn't as simple as presented

An accident could have occurred 24 hours before or more, in this case.

Have you forgotten I have brought this up before ?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 04:30:52 PM
Read the article
It's not clear cut

Maybe, maybe not,but the coroner did not rule the bang to the head out as cause of death.So its possible,
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 05:56:06 PM
Maybe, maybe not,but the coroner did not rule the bang to the head out as cause of death.So its possible,

If you read the article
Mom says she fell forward
Post mortem reports bump on the back of the head
I think we can rule out accuracy of the factd
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 06:31:22 PM
Any takers for Amaral?
He did write a book about it ... make a documentary about it ... and if Portuguese TV is anything to go by is still on about it ten years after the event.

So?
How did that materially effect anything of relevance?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 06:51:15 PM
Amarals told us
He can prove Maddie died in the apartment
Sedated with calpol
Of course he cant

The trouble is old stick Sr Amaral has been yesterday's man for ten years and beyond a certain point his opinions ain't worth diddly squatt.
Now back to the 48 questions [there were 51 in all their actuality]. Do you have evidence that there was a procedural infringement of this part of the process ?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 17, 2017, 07:22:19 PM
The trouble is old stick Sr Amaral has been yesterday's man for ten years and beyond a certain point his opinions ain't worth diddly squatt.
Now back to the 48 questions [there were 51 in all their actuality]. Do you have evidence that there was a procedural infringement of this part of the process ?
That is a very interesting question.  Have you got a list of the things that might constitute a procedural infringement?  Then we will have a look.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:32:15 PM
The trouble is old stick Sr Amaral has been yesterday's man for ten years and beyond a certain point his opinions ain't worth diddly squatt.
Now back to the 48 questions [there were 51 in all their actuality]. Do you have evidence that there was a procedural infringement of this part of the process ?
Who has mentioned a procedural infringement
The only infringement I can see is posters drawing a negative  inference for Kate acting quite properly
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:34:38 PM
Who has mentioned a procedural infringement
The only infringement I can see is posters drawing a negative  inference for Kate acting quite properly

Well, she basically was refusing to cooperate in as part of an investigation trying to ascertain what happened to her daughter.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:39:47 PM
Well, she basically was refusing to cooperate in as part of an investigation trying to ascertain what happened to her daughter.

She took the advice of her solicitor which she had every right to do
As John has explained in this situation police can twist and manipulate innocent answers which may then give them evidence to arrest and charge
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:42:34 PM
She took the advice of her solicitor which she had every right to do
As John has explained in this situation police can twist and manipulate innocent answers which may then give them evidence to arrest and charge

I have already discussed this with John.

So you are basically saying davel, that any potential suspect should not answer police questions.

Now what do you think police forces around the world would think of a refusal to answer questions by a potential suspect ?
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:47:29 PM
I have already discussed this with John.

So you are basically saying davel, that any potential suspect should not answer police questions.

Now what do you think police forces around the world would think of a refusal to answer questions by a potential suspect ?

That seems to be the general advice from solicitors
John explained it very well in a post yesterday
Obviously it depends on the situation but where it is suspected that the police are intent on making a case against you and you are innocent....the advice seems to be silence
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:48:38 PM
That seems to be the general advice from solicitors
John explained it very well in a post yesterday
Obviously it depends on the situation but where it is suspected that the police are intent on making a case against you and you are innocent....the advice seems to be silence

Then police will make the inevitable conclusions.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:50:55 PM
Then police will make the inevitable conclusions.

They can make what conclusions they like but without evidence they cannot arrest
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:53:54 PM
They can make what conclusions they like but without evidence they cannot arrest

Are you sure about that davel ?

Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:55:29 PM
Are you sure about that davel ?

I'm sure they cannot arrest without evidence
Yes
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:03:23 PM
I'm sure they cannot arrest without evidence
Yes

I think you will find police can arrest people who are behaving in a suspicious way.

It does not mean they have committed a crime.

Then there is, 'stop and search'.
Title: Re: Is absence of evidence.... evidence of innocence
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 08:16:24 PM
Who has mentioned a procedural infringement
The only infringement I can see is posters drawing a negative  inference for Kate acting quite properly

The infringement to which you refer is a non infringement.
There have been suggestions in the past on this very forum that those nasty PJ Johnnies were trying to stitch up the McCanns which is why KM did not answer the questions.
I have my doubts about that proposition.