Does Madeleine have the right to be found?

[Snowgirl]

Sorry.  If you have been following World News about Child Abduction you would know this.

Probably not hanging about all over the place.  Just waiting for an opportunity should it arise.  Maybe even spur of the moment..
My entire Theory is actually quite simple, but contains too much possible Libel.

You were talking about replacing a child that had been lost . Do you mean by abduction or death ?
 I’m trying very hard to imagine what you suggest “ waiting for an opportunity”.
As in a holiday resort where you knew some children would be in situations where they could be snatched in other words  for instance ?
Spur of the moment ?
Wouldn’t that person/s have to know exactly which children were available  to facilitate an abduction?
How would they know that about Madeleine ?


 

[Brietta]

Sorry.  If you have been following World News about Child Abduction you would know this.

Probably not hanging about all over the place.  Just waiting for an opportunity should it arise.  Maybe even spur of the moment..
My entire Theory is actually quite simple, but contains too much possible Libel.

Do you remember this thread, Eleanor? http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6123.msg225598#msg225598 Serbia. French kidnappers claim abduction was part of a paternity scam.

The intention was to use the pass port of a look a like child to get the little kidnapped girl over borders and into France.  What their intention was thereafter is something I think only known to them.

I really do not think your theory is too far from the mark ... and we may have to wait only for Madeleine's next birthday to see if that bit fits.

[Eleanor]

You were talking about replacing a child that had been lost . Do you mean by abduction or death ?
 I’m trying very hard to imagine what you suggest “ waiting for an opportunity”.
As in a holiday resort where you knew some children would be in situations where they could be snatched in other words  for instance ?
Spur of the moment ?
Wouldn’t that person/s have to know exactly which children were available  to facilitate an abduction?
How would they know that about Madeleine ?

A child that had sadly died through no fault.

There appears to have been a few very dodgy characters hanging around.

[jassi]

A child that had sadly died through no fault.

There appears to have been a few very dodgy characters hanging around.

Indeed, and that child might be Madeleine

[Eleanor]

Do you remember this thread, Eleanor? http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6123.msg225598#msg225598 Serbia. French kidnappers claim abduction was part of a paternity scam.

The intention was to use the pass port of a look a like child to get the little kidnapped girl over borders and into France.  What their intention was thereafter is something I think only known to them.

I really do not think your theory is too far from the mark ... and we may have to wait only for Madeleine's next birthday to see if that bit fits.

Yes, I do remember that one.

Madeleine's next birthday is only relevant because the authorities would no longer need the permission of "The Parents" to gain a DNA Sample that can be directly attributed to Madeleine.  Although Madeleine could always refuse.  If indeed it could be Madeleine.

[Snowgirl]

Yes, I do remember that one.

Madeleine's next birthday is only relevant because the authorities would no longer need the permission of "The Parents" to gain a DNA Sample that can be directly attributed to Madeleine.  Although Madeleine could always refuse.  If indeed it could be Madeleine.

Perhaps then your mind was remembering  and using that to create this  situation you think might be a possibility ?
Who is the “ it “ who could be Madeleine ?

[Eleanor]

Perhaps then your mind was remembering  and using that to create this  situation you think might be a possibility ?
Who is the “ it “ who could be Madeleine ?

Of course I am using my mind, and my knowledge of the case.

"It" is just nit picking, and not insulting.  So please don't start on that.

[Snowgirl]

Of course I am using my mind, and my knowledge of the case.

"It" is just nit picking, and not insulting.  So please don't start on that.

I’m not understanding what you mean by don’t start on that .
I will rephrase to ask  is there a particular female child who has been mentioned in the past  who is possibly under surveillance and  from whom the DNA could be obtained ?

[Eleanor]

I’m not understanding what you mean by don’t start on that .
I will rephrase to ask  is there a particular female child who has been mentioned in the past  who is possibly under surveillance and  from whom the DNA could be obtained ?

So you haven't been reading my Theory.

[slartibartfast]

thats the absence of evidence argument..the argument would suggest taht as there is no evidence,,...it probably isnt true

You mean like the abduction?

[Mr Gray]

You mean like the abduction?

but there is lots of evidence to support abduction...remeber we are talking about evidence not proof....although enough indirect evidence can prove something on the balance of probabilities...
First I would say that there is overwhelming evidence the parents are not involved...which makes abduction likely

[G-Unit]

So you haven't been reading my Theory.

I have. A child died so Madeleine was stolen to replace her and is living with the dead child's parents as their child. Somehow (how?) OG have discovered where she is but are helpless to do anything about it (why?). When she reaches her 16th birthday, however, someone (who?) will be able to ask her to take a DNA test to prove who she really is. If she says no, I suppose that will be that.

[Sunny]

So was Madeleine herself stolen to order?  If so why not take her younger sister who would be more malleable and also didn't have an apparently noticeable eye defect which may stay with her for life.

[barrier]

I have. A child died so Madeleine was stolen to replace her and is living with the dead child's parents as their child. Somehow (how?) OG have discovered where she is but are helpless to do anything about it (why?). When she reaches her 16th birthday, however, someone (who?) will be able to ask her to take a DNA test to prove who she really is. If she says no, I suppose that will be that.

That must have happened in the last 4 yrs,Og officers were digging up the Portuguese countryside back in 2014,looking for a live child,I don't think so,imo.

[G-Unit]

That must have happened in the last 4 yrs,Og officers were digging up the Portuguese countryside back in 2014,looking for a live child,I don't think so,imo.

That was quite a strong hint as to what they were looking for, wasn't it?