Wandering Off Topic

[G-Unit]

It's perfectly acceptable... Then if you don't know if Kate us, telling the truth Re the window you are, sceptical... Which makes you a sceptic... No insult

I have said I don't know what happened to Madeleine and therefore I don't know who contributed to her disappearance. You want to talk about just one incident.

[barrier]

I have said I don't know what happened to Madeleine and therefore I don't know who contributed to her disappearance. You want to talk about just one incident.

That one incident is what the abduction theory stands on it seems.imo

[Mr Gray]

I have said I don't know what happened to Madeleine and therefore I don't know who contributed to her disappearance. You want to talk about just one incident.

It's a defining statement... You obviously  don't believe  her.. Fair enough

[Miss Taken Identity]

That one incident is what the abduction theory stands on it seems.imo

IMO It was the beginning of a narrative to cover the fact that they had left a door unlocked- To remove the woke and wandered version. which could have had them arrested. ALL the Tapas KNEW they had done wrong by their children, and were afraid of the consequenses. IF it were in the UK a whole different story would have emerged. The whole lot of them would have been invited to a police station. The social work would have been called immediately. This what they also knew, hence why they went down the 'we are victims here' the police are not doing anything oh help us find our child.

[Robittybob1]

It's a defining statement... You obviously  don't believe  her.. Fair enough

Why should she?

[Mr Gray]

Why should she?

She doesn't have to ...I believe  it because IMO ...based on the evidence... Kate is telling the truth

[Miss Taken Identity]

I suppose an open window carries the same weight in evidence as does the unlocked door for woke wandered and accident and body being hid...

All evidence I guess...

[Brietta]

At this stage it is probably appropriate to call to mind an interesting thread and the words of a member who contributed many worthwhile and interesting posts which won the respect of all ...


GA got this bit wrong. KM's prints were not "in a position of opening the window".
Her 5 prints were actually all on the glass.
Amaral and his break-in expert mistakenly used a photo of a GNR print from the edge of the lounge sliding door (thats how they get "in a position of opening") and treated it as KM's on the bedroom window.
KM is 100% innocent IMO she genuinely found the window already open and leaned on it exactly as she says.
JT likewise, 100% innocent, genuinely passed the chat and saw innocentman carrying his 2yr-old IMO.
Pegasus
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3539.msg147991#msg147991

[Miss Taken Identity]

Peg, was offering his opinion as we all do on certain  matters. It appears if your opinion is against the Tapas version/explanations  you are a 'not nice 'poster. Just my observation.

[jassi]

At this stage it is probably appropriate to call to mind an interesting thread and the words of a member who contributed many worthwhile and interesting posts which won the respect of all ...


GA got this bit wrong. KM's prints were not "in a position of opening the window".
Her 5 prints were actually all on the glass.
Amaral and his break-in expert mistakenly used a photo of a GNR print from the edge of the lounge sliding door (thats how they get "in a position of opening") and treated it as KM's on the bedroom window.
KM is 100% innocent IMO she genuinely found the window already open and leaned on it exactly as she says.
JT likewise, 100% innocent, genuinely passed the chat and saw innocentman carrying his 2yr-old IMO.
Pegasus
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3539.msg147991#msg147991

That sounds to be very much your personal opinion, which or may not be shared by others.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I have said I don't know what happened to Madeleine and therefore I don't know who contributed to her disappearance. You want to talk about just one incident.

In the past you have made it clear that in your opinion stranger abduction is virtually impossible, so that certainly narrows it down a bit.

[Brietta]

That sounds to be very much your personal opinion, which or may not be shared by others.

"At this stage it is probably appropriate to call to mind an interesting thread and the words of a member who contributed many worthwhile and interesting posts which won the respect of all ..."
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7060.msg481062#msg481062

Indeed it is my personal opinion I really don't care too much if it is shared by you and others or not.

It is my opinion that although on many counts Pegasus and I were coming from diametrically opposite sides of the board as far s/he and his posts everything he said was well thought out, well presented and never offensive.

It is my opinion that Pegasus actually is a highly intelligent truth seeker of the highest integrity who used his analytical mind to best advantage ~ always honest ~ never rude, unkind or disrespectful to other posters.

If others don't share my opinion that is entirely their prerogative but as far as I am concerned Pegasus was a huge asset to this forum and I miss his presence from it very much.

[barrier]

"At this stage it is probably appropriate to call to mind an interesting thread and the words of a member who contributed many worthwhile and interesting posts which won the respect of all ..."
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7060.msg481062#msg481062

Indeed it is my personal opinion I really don't care too much if it is shared by you and others or not.

It is my opinion that although on many counts Pegasus and I were coming from diametrically opposite sides of the board as far s/he and his posts everything he said was well thought out, well presented and never offensive.

It is my opinion that Pegasus actually is a highly intelligent truth seeker of the highest integrity who used his analytical mind to best advantage ~ always honest ~ never rude, unkind or disrespectful to other posters.

If others don't share my opinion that is entirely their prerogative but as far as I am concerned Pegasus was a huge asset to this forum and I miss his presence from it very much.

Before my time but who or what drove him away or did he just lose interest?
Looking back over various threads there have been a lot who have faded away.

[G-Unit]

In the past you have made it clear that in your opinion stranger abduction is virtually impossible, so that certainly narrows it down a bit.

I have questioned certain theories which have been put forward to explain it, but it was clearly possible for MBM to leave the apartment without anyone seeing if we accept that she entered it at 5.30 pm.

[Mr Gray]

I have questioned certain theories which have been put forward to explain it, but it was clearly possible for MBM to leave the apartment without anyone seeing if we accept that she entered it at 5.30 pm.

Is that as far as you have got in 11 years