UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 03:04:17 AM

Title: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 03:04:17 AM
"Newborn blood spot cards explained"
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/pregnancy-and-baby/Pages/newborn-blood-spot-cards.aspx
Quote
For police forensic work
In certain situations the police can apply for access to the blood spot cards of dead or missing individuals for forensic purposes. This happens very rarely. Current guidance is that samples from specific individuals who are alive and not missing can only be released with a court order.
The police are only allowed to apply for a court order to access blood spots for specific named persons. They do not have access to information from stored blood spot collections, and are not allowed to "trawl" through a collection of blood spots in the hope of identifying someone.

Were these blood spot cards used in the MM case?

Title: A Summary of McCann Forensics http://forum2.aimoo.com/MadeleineMcCann/Forensics/A-Summary-of-McCann-Forensics-1-808627.html

"On 12 October 2007, the Forensic Science Service received a blood spot in a cardboard frame (object JRB/1) from Leicestershire Constabulary. That object was inside a sealed package.
The DNA profile was the same as that obtained from possible spots of saliva existing on the pillowcase, and thus was born a true genetic profile of MM . "

94
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 04:07:59 AM

http://nottextusa.blogspot.co.nz/2013/06/ah-penny-drops.html
Quote
RB/1 Madeleine McCann
From this sample was obtained a DNA reference sample that was different from those of her immediate family, described above. This DNA profile was the same as that obtained from possible spots of saliva existing on the pillowcase (SJM/1).''

The pillowcase sample SJM/1 is the pillowcase collected from the house in Rothley

This therefore confirmed that the DNA profile recovered from the pillowcase, when compared to a known sample of Madeleine's blood, was a match.

( In the UK, once Guthrie cards used for new born screening have been processed they remain the property of the health authority under which the testing was conducted, rather than remaining with the patient's records. As such, it can take some time to recover the card relating to a named individual. This may explain why it was several months before this was available to the police)

So far so good.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 05:10:35 AM
Quote
from the files ; -

"Lesley Ann Denton
FORENSIC SCIENTIST
Date: 18 July 2007
Neither the DNA profile of Amelie McCANN nor Sean McCANN matches that from the pillowcase (SJM/1) and therefore in my opinion, neither Amelie McCANN nor Sean McCANN can be the source of this profile."


Also - JRB/1 - which was the Blood sample received on 12 October 2007. The FSS report was released in Sept. so all the tests had been completed by then.
"From this sample was obtained a DNA reference sample that was different from those of her immediate family, described above. This DNA profile was the same as that obtained from possible spots of saliva existing on the pillowcase (SJM/1)."

So I am told once again the stains on the pillow matched the blood sample (Blood sample received on 12 October 2007).  So we assume rightly that this becomes MM DNA profile.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 11:51:30 AM
As far as I know the pillowcase was retrieved by Gerry McCann on 21st May during his first return home from Portugal, although neither of the McCanns have ever confirmed this to my knowledge.

The FSS got a DNA profile from stains on the pillowcase which, they said, was from a child of the McCanns.

On 12 October 2007, the Forensic Science Service(R) received a blood spot in a cardboard frame (object JRB/1) from Leicestershire Constabulary. That object was inside a sealed package.

JRB/1 Madeleine McCann
From this sample was obtained a DNA reference sample that was different from those of her immediate family, described above. This DNA profile was the same as that obtained from possible spots of saliva existing on the pillowcase (SJM/1).
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm

So we have two matching samples. One from a pillowcase taken from Rothley and one from a blood spot in a cardboard frame provided by Leicestershire police.

In order to get Madeleine's heel prick Leicestershire Police would need a court order. Did the holders of the sample then give them just one of the spots collected? This is what the full sample is like;
(http://www.shookazist.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/card.jpg)

I can't find anything to say the blood spot from LP was Madeleine's.
I have found a reference to the pillowcase being taken from Madeleine's home, but not who collected it.

From Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard to Inspector Ferreira


Inspector Ferreira,


DNA profile of Madeleine McCann that was collected in her parents house in England.


Regards


Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm

All we know from this is that a blood spot from [?] matched dribbles on a pillowcase from the house in Rothley, and that the dribbler was a child of the McCanns, but not one of the twins.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 12:07:18 PM
Did the reference sample DNA march anything found in apartment 5A ?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 12:56:22 PM
As far as I know the pillowcase was retrieved by Gerry McCann on 21st May during his first return home from Portugal, although neither of the McCanns have ever confirmed this to my knowledge.

The FSS got a DNA profile from stains on the pillowcase which, they said, was from a child of the McCanns.

On 12 October 2007, the Forensic Science Service(R) received a blood spot in a cardboard frame (object JRB/1) from Leicestershire Constabulary. That object was inside a sealed package.

JRB/1 Madeleine McCann
From this sample was obtained a DNA reference sample that was different from those of her immediate family, described above. This DNA profile was the same as that obtained from possible spots of saliva existing on the pillowcase (SJM/1).
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm

So we have two matching samples. One from a pillowcase taken from Rothley and one from a blood spot in a cardboard frame provided by Leicestershire police.

In order to get Madeleine's heel prick Leicestershire Police would need a court order. Did the holders of the sample then give them just one of the spots collected? This is what the full sample is like;
(http://www.shookazist.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/card.jpg)

I can't find anything to say the blood spot from LP was Madeleine's.
I have found a reference to the pillowcase being taken from Madeleine's home, but not who collected it.

From Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard to Inspector Ferreira


Inspector Ferreira,


DNA profile of Madeleine McCann that was collected in her parents house in England.


Regards


Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm

All we know from this is that a blood spot from [?] matched dribbles on a pillowcase from the house in Rothley, and that the dribbler was a child of the McCanns, but not one of the twins.
I would be happy to say the blood sample taken from MM as a baby matched the pillowcase (sample) so that confirmed the pillowcase had been dribbled on by MM.
That seems fairly logical.

So would Gerry have been accompanied by an officer who bagged the evidence? 
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2016, 01:50:14 PM
Did the reference sample DNA march anything found in apartment 5A ?

Well there definitely was no match to the mythical "blood splatter".
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 02:05:51 PM
Did the reference sample DNA march anything found in apartment 5A ?

Not really according to the FSS.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 02:13:42 PM
I would be happy to say the blood sample taken from MM as a baby matched the pillowcase so that confirmed the pillowcase had been dribbled on by MM.
That seems fairly logical.

So would Gerry have been accompanied by an officer who bagged the evidence?

We haven't been told that it was a blood sample taken from MM as a baby, but make that leap if you wish. We haven't been told who collected the pillowcase, but Gerry was in Rothley on 21st and it was given to the FSS on 22nd May.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 02:13:56 PM
Not really according to the FSS.

Strange. Perhaps DNA analysis is not all its cracked up to be.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2016, 02:18:37 PM
I would be happy to say the blood sample taken from MM as a baby matched the pillowcase so that confirmed the pillowcase had been dribbled on by MM.
That seems fairly logical.

So would Gerry have been accompanied by an officer who bagged the evidence?

Is there any reason to assume that police procedures for collecting evidence were not followed in this instance or is there some question that Gerry may have piled the dirty washing into a bin bag and dropped it off at the nick on his way back to Portugal?

I would imagine the protocol to be that samples would be collected from the site by the relevant qualified personnel and sent for testing thus maintaining the chain of evidence.


**Snip
In reply to my request, Mr Jose de Freitas sent me the email, I am immediately sending a copy to the Director of the Scientific Police Laboratory, Sra Saudade Nunes.

Portimao 1st October 2007

Inspector Paolo Ferreira


Followed by email (with an attachment)

From Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard to Inspector Ferreira


Inspector Ferreira,


DNA profile of Madeleine McCann that was collected in her parents house in England.


Regards


Jose de Freitas
New Scotland Yard
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 05:40:38 PM
Did the reference sample DNA march anything found in apartment 5A ?

The initial forensic sweep (by the Portuguese) in the aftermath of Madeleine's abduction failed to establish Madeleine's DNA.

It was left to the British, picking over the remnants of a badly dilapidated crime-scene, never sealed off, and let out to other families after May 3rd, to establish Madeleine's DNA, which they did, by analysing a sample of saliva taken from Madeleine's pillow and comparing it with the DNA of her twin siblings and her parents.

By making those comparisons, they were able to state, certainly, that:

1. The profile (from the saliva supplied by Gerry) was that of a child of Kate's and Gerry's.

2. The profile was different from Kate's profile; different again from Gerry's profile and (yet again!) different from the profiles of either twin.

Ergo, the profile had to be that of Madeleine.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 07:06:01 PM
The initial forensic sweep (by the Portuguese) in the aftermath of Madeleine's abduction failed to establish Madeleine's DNA.

It was left to the British, picking over the remnants of a badly dilapidated crime-scene, never sealed off, and let out to other families after May 3rd, to establish Madeleine's DNA, which they did, by analysing a sample of saliva taken from Madeleine's pillow and comparing it with the DNA of her twin siblings and her parents.

By making those comparisons, they were able to state, certainly, that:

1. The profile (from the saliva supplied by Gerry) was that of a child of Kate's and Gerry's.

2. The profile was different from Kate's profile; different again from Gerry's profile and (yet again!) different from the profiles of either twin.

Ergo, the profile had to be that of Madeleine.

This saliva was from England. Was any DNA belonging to Madeleine found in the apartment?

Did anything found in Portugal match with the profile?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 07:53:34 PM
This saliva was from England. Was any DNA belonging to Madeleine found in the apartment?

Did anything found in Portugal match with the profile?

By the Portuguese, no.

From the files:

Letter to the National Forensics Institute (INML) from Goncalo Amaral


17th August 2007

The present inquiry is in relation to the investigation of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann on 3rd May from P da L.

The English authorities in possession of elements collected from the family home in Leicestershire, which are being examined in an unidentified laboratory, traced the girl's DNA profile, in annex to this document.

As it is necessary to the investigation we request the following:

1. Whether in the tests done by the INML Madeleine's profile was established?

2. In the case of a positive answer to point 1, that it should be determined whether the girl is the daughter of the parents identified ? Gerald Patrick McCann and Kate Healy.

3. Information about whether the profile obtained by the INML corresponds to the profile traced in the English laboratory, on the request of the British authorities.

4. If there are differences between the English and Portuguese profiles that a report should be drawn up for this inquiry.

5. In the follow-up of point 4, we request to be informed whether in the English profile the girl is the daughter of the McCann couple.

6. Other information that might be of use to the investigation.

Signed G. Amaral
09-Processos Vol IX Page 2419

Vol IX Page 2419

Reply from the Forensics Institute (INML) to Goncalo Amaral

22-08-2007


Reply to Queries

- We inform you that none of the samples received by this institute were designated as supposedly belonging to the missing girl and we therefore, cannot reply to this query.


- Samples were studied - hair and a piece of cloth - nuclear DNA profiles only being obtained from 4 samples, which upon comparison with the DNA profiles of Kate and Gerry, could not belong to the girl.

- The samples were then studied using mitochondrial DNA analysis, the same was done for the other samples, giving the results in accordance with our report of 9th July No. 2007/000226 LX-BC.

- As requested in point 5, it was determined that the profile obtained by the British lab could belong to a son/daughter of the McCanns.

- The comparison of the profiles obtained in autossomic STR from Kate and Gerry McCann with the profile obtained was carried out.
Signed


By the British (3 months later!) using saliva of Madeleine's provided by Gerry, yes!

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 07:58:44 PM
OK, so what samples collected from the apartment matched up with the profile obtained from the saliva sample ?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 08:03:28 PM
This saliva was from England. Was any DNA belonging to Madeleine found in the apartment?

Did anything found in Portugal match with the profile?

Some of the hairs might have belonged to her or the twins. Using mitochondrial DNA analysis Kate had the most hairs; 53, so some of them could have belonged to the children. Although some IVF processes result in male mitochondrial DNA surviving, whereas it's destroyed during natural conception. I don't know why the hairs weren't DNA tested for more exact matches.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 08:04:40 PM
OK, so what samples collected from the apartment matched up with the profile obtained from the saliva sample ?

Strawman!

By comparing the profile from the saliva with the profiles of Kate and Gerry, it was possible, certainly, to establish that the profile was a (female!) child of the couple.

Kate and Gerry have only one (other) daughter.  Her profile was different (from that of her older sister).

Ergo, they had Madeleine's DNA.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 08:10:27 PM
By the Portuguese, no.

From the files:

Letter to the National Forensics Institute (INML) from Goncalo Amaral


17th August 2007

The present inquiry is in relation to the investigation of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann on 3rd May from P da L.

The English authorities in possession of elements collected from the family home in Leicestershire, which are being examined in an unidentified laboratory, traced the girl's DNA profile, in annex to this document.

As it is necessary to the investigation we request the following:

1. Whether in the tests done by the INML Madeleine's profile was established?

2. In the case of a positive answer to point 1, that it should be determined whether the girl is the daughter of the parents identified ? Gerald Patrick McCann and Kate Healy.

3. Information about whether the profile obtained by the INML corresponds to the profile traced in the English laboratory, on the request of the British authorities.

4. If there are differences between the English and Portuguese profiles that a report should be drawn up for this inquiry.

5. In the follow-up of point 4, we request to be informed whether in the English profile the girl is the daughter of the McCann couple.

6. Other information that might be of use to the investigation.

Signed G. Amaral
09-Processos Vol IX Page 2419

Vol IX Page 2419

Reply from the Forensics Institute (INML) to Goncalo Amaral

22-08-2007


Reply to Queries

- We inform you that none of the samples received by this institute were designated as supposedly belonging to the missing girl and we therefore, cannot reply to this query.


- Samples were studied - hair and a piece of cloth - nuclear DNA profiles only being obtained from 4 samples, which upon comparison with the DNA profiles of Kate and Gerry, could not belong to the girl.

- The samples were then studied using mitochondrial DNA analysis, the same was done for the other samples, giving the results in accordance with our report of 9th July No. 2007/000226 LX-BC.

- As requested in point 5, it was determined that the profile obtained by the British lab could belong to a son/daughter of the McCanns.

- The comparison of the profiles obtained in autossomic STR from Kate and Gerry McCann with the profile obtained was carried out.
Signed


By the British (3 months later!) using saliva of Madeleine's provided by Gerry, yes!

The pillowcase was received by the FSS on 22nd May 2007. We don't know who provided it, but Gerry McCann was in Rothley on 21st May.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 08:12:24 PM
The pillowcase was received by the FSS on 22nd May 2007. We don't know who provided it, but Gerry McCann was in Rothley on 21st May.

What?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 08:19:16 PM
Strawman!

By comparing the profile from the saliva with the profiles of Kate and Gerry, it was possible, certainly, to establish that the profile was a (female!) child of the couple.

Kate and Gerry have only one (other) daughter.  Her profile was different (from that of her older sister).

Ergo, they had Madeleine's DNA.

That wasn't my original  question, which was - did they find any of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment ?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 08:22:08 PM
That wasn't my original  question, which was - did they find any of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment ?

The Portuguese didn't (see my quote above).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 14, 2016, 08:24:29 PM
The Portuguese didn't (see my quote above).

Jeez, this is like pulling teeth. Did ANYONE find conclusive and definitive evidence of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 08:28:58 PM
That wasn't my original  question, which was - did they find any of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment ?

Quote
An incomplete DNA result was obtained from cellular material on the swab (286A/2007 CRL 3a). The swab contained very little information and showed low level indications of DNA from more than one person. However, all of the confirmed DNA components within this result match the corresponding components in the DNA profile of Madeline McCann.

(John Lowe)

YES!
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 14, 2016, 08:38:41 PM
What?

We haven't been told who collected the pillowcase but Gerry McCann was in Rothley on 21st May and the FSS received it on 22nd. A few reasons have been given for the trip home, but the pillowcase hasn't been mentioned by the McCanns.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 08:39:38 PM
Jeez, this is like pulling teeth. Did ANYONE find conclusive and definitive evidence of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment?
As someone pointed out MM's DNA should have been in many locations in the apartment so they would not waste time looking for general DNA findings, just specific ones e.g DNA in a blood spot sample.
But I know what you mean for there is now this line of thought, by some, that Madeleine was never in the apartment at all.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 08:45:05 PM
Jeez, this is like pulling teeth. Did ANYONE find conclusive and definitive evidence of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment?

The Poruguese didn't.

The English (examining a badly contaminated crime-scene 3 months after the crime) might have.

Either way, that's irrelevant.

The British (certainly) established Madeleine's DNA by other means (the saliva of Madeleine's, given to them by Gerry from the pillow of Madeleine's bed at her home in Rothley).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 09:05:19 PM
Strange. Perhaps DNA analysis is not all its cracked up to be.
It is always compared to an unrelated person.  DNA testing of this type would not be so good in closely related persons.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 09:12:14 PM
It is always compared to an unrelated person.  DNA testing of this type would not be so good in closely related persons.

What?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 09:44:22 PM
What? http://dna-view.com/profile.htm
the word "unrelated person" is always used in the DNA comparisons eg "either the suspect contributed the evidence, or an unlikely coincidence happened – the once-in-7000 coincidence that an unrelated person would by chance have the same DNA profile as that obtained from the evidence".
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 09:52:17 PM
Quote
FORENSIC REPORT

Officer in case: Det Supt Prior

Client: Leicestershire Police, New Parks

Police reference: 07/06085 Operation TASK

Laboratory reference: 300 655 190

Order reference: 400 922 755

Scientist: Lesley Denton

Number of pages: 2

Re: Abduction of Madeleine McCann on 3rd May 2007

A DNA profile has been obtained from the reference samples of Amelie Eve McCANN (SBM/2) and Sean Michael McCANN (SBM/3).

In this case, all of the bands present in the profiles of both Amelie McCANN and Sean McCANN are represented in the combined profiles of Kate HEALY and Gerald McCANN. This is what I would expect to find if Amelie McCANN and Sean Michael McCANN were their natural children.

Neither the DNA profile of Amelie McCANN nor Sean McCANN matches that from the pillowcase (SJM/1) and therefore in my opinion, neither Amelie McCANN nor Sean McCANN can be the source of this profile.

If I can be of further assistance or you require a CJA statement please do not hesitate to contact me at the laboratory on 01937 548287.

Yours sincerely,

Lesley Ann Denton

FSS report.

Couldn't be more clear.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 10:01:25 PM
FSS report.

Couldn't be more clear.
Lesley Ann Denton is not aware that Madeleine is the result of an IVF treatment or else she would need to include not only Sean and Amelie but also other unknown persons as well.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 14, 2016, 10:02:34 PM
We haven't been told who collected the pillowcase but Gerry McCann was in Rothley on 21st May and the FSS received it on 22nd. A few reasons have been given for the trip home, but the pillowcase hasn't been mentioned by the McCanns.

Auntie janet got some eyelashes off her pillow in the second week in june according to the book Madeleine to give to the southafrican body finder

?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 14, 2016, 10:04:23 PM
Lesley Ann Denton is not aware that Madeleine is the result of an IVF treatment or else she would need to include not only Sean and Amelie but also other unknown persons as well.
No she wouldnt seeing as ivf treatment was carried out for the parents and no one else!!! As proven by the dna profiles
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2016, 10:05:45 PM
Lesley Ann Denton is not aware that Madeleine is the result of an IVF treatment or else she would need to include not only Sean and Amelie but also other unknown persons as well.

Rubbish.

IVF is irrelevant.

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 14, 2016, 10:41:10 PM
Rubbish.

IVF is irrelevant.
I don't dismiss it so easily.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Brietta on August 15, 2016, 01:42:18 AM
Sigh ... I think that for once he was actually doing his job and eliminating all possible scenarios.  The majority of child abductions take place as the result of a custody dispute when a relationship or a marriage has broken down.
He was merely checking that out by ascertaining parentage and in doing so verified that Kate and Gerry are without doubt Madeleine's biological parents.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 15, 2016, 04:56:46 AM
Sigh ... I think that for once he was actually doing his job and eliminating all possible scenarios.  The majority of child abductions take place as the result of a custody dispute when a relationship or a marriage has broken down.
He was merely checking that out by ascertaining parentage and in doing so verified that Kate and Gerry are without doubt Madeleine's biological parents.

Beg to differ with you, there, Brietta.

Shortlyafter Amaral asked those questions of the Portuguese laboratory, (timing critical) the Gerry not Madeleine's father canard broke.

I think Amaral had pre-determined that he was going to spread that (malicious) rumour and didn't allow a pesky detail of an answer not remotely conducive to it to stop him.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2016, 05:35:16 AM
in #15 are the questions and answers relating to the DNA profiles
Quote
Reply to Queries

- We inform you that none of the samples received by this institute were designated as supposedly belonging to the missing girl and we therefore, cannot reply to this query.


- Samples were studied - hair and a piece of cloth - nuclear DNA profiles only being obtained from 4 samples, which upon comparison with the DNA profiles of Kate and Gerry, could not belong to the girl.

- The samples were then studied using mitochondrial DNA analysis, the same was done for the other samples, giving the results in accordance with our report of 9th July No. 2007/000226 LX-BC.

- As requested in point 5, it was determined that the profile obtained by the British lab could belong to a son/daughter of the McCanns.

- The comparison of the profiles obtained in autossomic STR from Kate and Gerry McCann with the profile obtained was carried out.
Signed

I find the answers a bit confusing for the first sentence says ..... "cannot reply to this query".  But then they do reply with a sentence that has  this in it "which upon comparison with the DNA profiles of Kate and Gerry, could not belong to the girl."  So there was some samples that did not belong to Madeleine or any daughter of Kate and Gerry.  Did I read that right?

But from the "mitochondrial DNA analysis" of the samples "it was determined that the profile obtained by the British lab could belong to a son/daughter of the McCanns".  So there was a child of the McCanns but it wasn't Madeleine.   Did I read that right?

So I stand by my theory there was another biological relation of Kate and Gerry that wasn't Madeleine in the apartment.
Yet that still doesn't seem to make sense, for the two sentences seem to contradict each other.  More research is required.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 15, 2016, 08:33:37 AM
What I was trying work out if Gerry has an officer with him so he is protected from the accusation that he contaminated that pillow case himself.  I'm not saying he did, but some are saying "he had experienced officers with him and his role was just to let them into his house" but that was total news to me.  It seems like the forum here is also not aware of this alleged Police presence yet it is clearly Gerry's intention to collect a sample of DNA crucial to this case. 
Maybe it was wrong for the PJ or the FSS to use this  reference sample, since a potential suspect had the chance to tamper with it.
But then again it is only at the level of a missing person investigation at this stage and that is about the normal level of security of evidence gathering in a missing person inquiry.
e.g When the parent or a missing child is asked to get something belonging to their child it would not be done as if it was a crime scene.  The parent would just go into the child's play areas or bedroom and take some items in order to help the inquiry.
So personally I do not find it suspect even if Gerry did this evidence collection unaccompanied.

I'm glad about that.

The results of the DNA profile obtained from the pillowcase is approximately 29
million times more likely if the profile originates form a natural child of theirs rather
than someone unrelated to them.

In my opinion, the results detailed above provide extremely strong support for the
view that the profile obtained from the pillowcase originated from a natural child of
Kate HEALY and GERALD McCANN.

Please note: I understand that the McCANN's have a second female child. It
therefore remains a formal possibility that the DNA on the pillowcase could
have originated from her as the genetics would be in keeping with those
described above.

If I can be of further assistance or you require a CJA statement please do not
hesitate to contact me at the laboratory on 01937 548287.

Yours sincerely


Lesley Anne Denton
FORENSIC SCIENTISTS
Date: 28 June 2007



The other bit of the equation (not completed at the point Leslie Anne Denton wrote the above, but assuredly completed) was to take the profile of the McCanns' (only) other (female) child and compare the profile with the profile from the pillow.

When they did that, they found the two profiles different, confirming that they had Madeleine's DNA.

To confirm, the (initial) sweep (by the Portuguese) forensic laboratory did not establish Madeleine's DNA.

The sweep 3 months later by the British didn't, either, but the saliva (from the pillow of Madeleine's Rothley home) certainly did.

And forget UVF (or whatever else).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2016, 08:45:28 AM
The answer to the thread question is that it's assumed that the blood spot was Madeleine's, but no-one ever actually said that it was, or that it was from her heel prick.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2016, 09:24:46 AM
....

The other bit of the equation (not completed at the point Leslie Anne Denton wrote the above, but assuredly completed) was to take the profile of the McCanns' (only) other (female) child and compare the profile with the profile from the pillow.

When they did that, they found the two profiles different, confirming that they had Madeleine's DNA.

To confirm, the (initial) sweep (by the Portuguese) forensic laboratory did not establish Madeleine's DNA.

The sweep 3 months later by the British didn't, either, but the saliva (from the pillow of Madeleine's Rothley home) certainly did.
...
Would you define what you mean by sweep?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2016, 09:26:14 AM
The answer to the thread question is that it's assumed that the blood spot was Madeleine's, but no-one ever actually said that it was, or that it was from her heel prick.
Seems a very correct answer.  I hope to fully study the DNA question.  You sound like your understanding will be invaluable.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Angelo222 on August 15, 2016, 10:01:21 AM
Does having Madeleine's DNA really bring anything to this mystery?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 15, 2016, 10:04:32 AM
Does having Madeleine's DNA really bring anything to this mystery?

Not at the moment, perhaps, but it would be useful for identification purposes of a child, dead or alive.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Angelo222 on August 15, 2016, 10:46:45 AM
Not at the moment, perhaps, but it would be useful for identification purposes of a child, dead or alive.

I suppose so in the case of skeletal remains being found in a drain in Praia da Luz.  So very sad.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 15, 2016, 10:48:23 AM
Would you define what you mean by sweep?

Read the files.

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 15, 2016, 10:51:26 AM
Does having Madeleine's DNA really bring anything to this mystery?

It scotches one or two rumours (such as that Madeleine never lived in the apartment).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Brietta on August 15, 2016, 04:18:15 PM
Beg to differ with you, there, Brietta.

Shortlyafter Amaral asked those questions of the Portuguese laboratory, (timing critical) the Gerry not Madeleine's father canard broke.

I think Amaral had pre-determined that he was going to spread that (malicious) rumour and didn't allow a pesky detail of an answer not remotely conducive to it to stop him.

(http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_mXbRBcSh0gs/SdBMwoo1_eI/AAAAAAAACzw/rLPzNZu3zSY/s400/24HorasPaiBiologico.jpg)

Indeed, it is a perfect example of the distortion of the actual facts of the case released throughout the investigation and since and which have been accepted as part of the pejorative narrative directed against Madeleine's parents.

(http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_p305OiLZRCU/SNDPKdmBZpI/AAAAAAAABRA/cU3vqAKTITY/s200/corpse_in_car.jpg)

Another example is the total misrepresentation of the forensic tests which leaks to the press asserting that the dogs had indicated that Madeleine's corpse had been carried in the hire car.
There are still people who adhere to belief in the wrong information which was fed to the public at that time.  It doesn't matter how lurid the headline was each and every one still colours people's opinion ... despite irrefutable proof that most of the newspaper headlines at the time were the result of malicious propaganda.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 15, 2016, 09:33:08 PM
As I understand it, police don't look for a victims dna in a crime scene, just the perpetrators' normally


Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 16, 2016, 08:56:21 AM
As I understand it, police don't look for a victims dna in a crime scene, just the perpetrators' normally


True, but you would want to check for process of elimination purposes.  If you were looking for presence of an intruder, you would want to account for traces of all other DNA, or at least try to.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 16, 2016, 11:55:02 AM
As I understand it, police don't look for a victims dna in a crime scene, just the perpetrators' normally

Depends.

Attracta Haron, it was her DNA (the victim) that put Hamilton behind bars.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 16, 2016, 11:50:30 PM
Depends.

Attracta Haron, it was her DNA (the victim) that put Hamilton behind bars.
Where was it found
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 18, 2016, 07:22:59 PM
Where was it found

In the car.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 18, 2016, 09:32:39 PM
http://politico.ie/archive/let-out-early-murder
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 18, 2016, 11:02:01 PM
In the car.
Exactly
Where it shouldnt have been
In 5a there was no need to look for MMs DNA, so the arguments that none of her dna was found in 5a is answered by the fact, that it wasnt looked for,there was no need to, which further crumbles the idea that because none was found she never lived there etc etc, anyway
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 22, 2016, 01:24:54 PM
Exactly
Where it shouldnt have been
In 5a there was no need to look for MMs DNA, so the arguments that none of her dna was found in 5a is answered by the fact, that it wasnt looked for,there was no need to, which further crumbles the idea that because none was found she never lived there etc etc, anyway

(for once!) I don't think there is any ground of quarrel or dispute (with what you say above).

Except that, I do believe one result (recovered from the apartment) was compatible with Madeleine' DNA.

(Entirely normal and to be expected as, from what you say above, I think you would agree)?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 22, 2016, 01:39:59 PM
(for once!) I don't think there is any ground of quarrel or dispute (with what you say above).

Except that, I do believe one result (recovered from the apartment) was compatible with Madeleine' DNA.

(Entirely normal and to be expected as, from what you say above, I think you would agree)?
" result (recovered from the apartment) was compatible with Madeleine' DNA" or someone closely related.  Don't limit the options.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2016, 07:05:52 PM
(snip)
In 5a there was no need to look for MMs DNA, so the arguments that none of her dna was found in 5a is answered by the fact, that it wasnt looked for,there was no need to, which further crumbles the idea that because none was found she never lived there etc etc, anyway

Try explaining that to the [ censored word ]s...
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 22, 2016, 10:56:21 PM
(for once!) I don't think there is any ground of quarrel or dispute (with what you say above).

Except that, I do believe one result (recovered from the apartment) was compatible with Madeleine' DNA.

(Entirely normal and to be expected as, from what you say above, I think you would agree)?

Well, we have agreed more than this once, but i agree, very rarely
Your second point is a bit arbitrary
If the possibility exists that the cadaver dog alerted to a body and the place it did so was also the place madelenes compatible dna was also found you cant rule out there was her dead body there

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 22, 2016, 11:00:29 PM
" result (recovered from the apartment) was compatible with Madeleine' DNA" or someone closely related.  Don't limit the options.
i dont think anyone here is so au fait with dna that they can categorically state which of the dna in the forensic report by robert lowe  was probably or probably not or possibly from any of the people mentioned in that report

Sometimes i think even lowe couldnt tell either...which is probably why he said of one result its impossible to tell...if it was impossible it were from MM he would have said so, thats not of course to say it was but you get my drift
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 22, 2016, 11:02:04 PM
Try explaining that to the [ censored word ]s...

I would try but im not on facebook or twitter or cmomm
I tried them but soon backed out
Same as for the old pfa n called somethng else
All pathetic places
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2016, 12:48:05 AM
i dont think anyone here is so au fait with dna that they can categorically state which of the dna in the forensic report by robert lowe  was probably or probably not or possibly from any of the people mentioned in that report

Sometimes i think even lowe couldnt tell either...which is probably why he said of one result its impossible to tell...if it was impossible it were from MM he wouod have said so, thats not of course to say it was but you get my drift
Well I will be looking at DNA shortly and I'll attempt a more definite answer shortly.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 12:06:41 PM
Well, we have agreed more than this once, but i agree, very rarely
Your second point is a bit arbitrary
If the possibility exists that the cadaver dog alerted to a body and the place it did so was also the place madelenes cmpatible dna was also found you cant rule out there was her dead body there

If you are referring to the flat, there were only a few alleles found (unspecified quantity in the Lowe report, but Amaral stated 5 - if ever his information was correct on that point). If that's the case, everyone on this board and anyone in that flat over time would share that many with her profile. It means nothing.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2016, 12:42:54 PM
Well I will be looking at DNA shortly and I'll attempt a more definite answer shortly.
From the summary"http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm
Quoted from the letter from the Lab
Quote
An incomplete DNA result was obtained from cellular material on the swab 3a. The swab contained very little information and showed low level indications of DNA from more than one person. However, all of the confirmed DNA components within this result match the corresponding components in the DNA profile of Madeline McCann. LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive, it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.
That is still not a positive match.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 05:52:20 PM
From the summary"http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm
Quoted from the letter from the Lab That is still not a positive match.

No, of course it's not. All it's saying is that amongst the few found behind the sofa, there were some alleles that happened to coincide with hers (amongst others which did not).

Big deal.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 06:07:08 PM
i dont think anyone here is so au fait with dna that they can categorically state which of the dna in the forensic report by robert lowe  was probably or probably not or possibly from any of the people mentioned in that report

Sometimes i think even lowe couldnt tell either...which is probably why he said of one result its impossible to tell...if it was impossible it were from MM he wouod have said so, thats not of course to say it was but you get my drift

The DNA issue really isn't that complicated. Even the 15/19 issue means nothing much in context. Tabloids and [ censored word ]s jumped on to a total misunderstanding and it became entrenched as a trooo factoid.

One of NotTextusa's blogs explained it quite simply (albeit in somewhat "colourful" language).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 06:26:36 PM
As I understand it, police don't look for a victims dna in a crime scene, just the perpetrators' normally

Hmmmm. In the Madeleiene case, they don't appear to have been looking for anyone's DNA in the first instance, but physical traces (hair, blood, visible traces of other substances of a potentially suspicious nature), which could then be tested for DNA in order to try to identify a potential perpretator. That was the immediate emergency.

Her DNA would have been all over the flat as she had stayed there, along with other members of her family.

It would have been different if there had been traces on walls or the ceiling or anywhere else of blood or whatever else that belonged to her and couldn't be explained in terms of the normal life of holidaymakers in a seaside flat. As it happened, there was nothing abnormal noticed concerning traces left by her.

At the time of the shelving, however, there were only a few hairs (4?) that could be identified as belonging to any particular person. Perhaps the Met has been able to take that further, no idea.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 06:36:55 PM
The basic idea is quite simple. Imagine that you have 3-5 people who'd all bought the same size socks in various colours or with distinctive markings (some of which are common to all). The new socks found by whomever was clearing up that day dumps the ones they find lying about into a washing basket.

Right. So you now have a whole bunch of socks, some of which are identical, and some which are not. And you don't have the whole lot, just whatever was lying around.

From that, you can't state which sock belongs to which person (except for the ones that no one else bought that day). On the other hand, you have a number of identical socks which could belong to any one of those people. And identical socks will only appear as one value: White sock, or blue sock with narrow white band.

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 23, 2016, 06:37:36 PM
Hmmmm. In the Madeleiene case, they don't appear to have been looking for anyone's DNA in the first instance, but physical traces (hair, blood, visible traces of other substances of a potentially suspicious nature), which could then be tested for DNA in order to try to identify a potential perpretator. That was the immediate emergency.

Her DNA would have been all over the flat as she had stayed there, along with other members of her family.

It would have been different if there had been traces on walls or the ceiling or anywhere else of blood or whatever else that belonged to her and couldn't be explained in terms of the normal life of holidaymakers in a seaside flat. As it happened, there was nothing abnormal noticed concerning traces left by her.

At the time of the shelving, however, there were only a few hairs (4?) that could be identified as belonging to any particular person. Perhaps the Met has been able to take that further, no idea.

Would that be considered normal for a family that had been there almost a week ?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 23, 2016, 06:43:40 PM
Would that be considered normal for a family that had been there almost a week ?

Jassi, there were lots of hairs found, but only very few that had roots to enable DNA analysis. MtDNA analysis doesn't actually mean much (Kate and one of the cops share the same mtDNA - in terms of the areas used for forensics - it's just a general grouping).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: ferryman on August 23, 2016, 06:55:56 PM
Would that be considered normal for a family that had been there almost a week ?

Normal for a holiday apartment examined 3 months after the crime when several other families had stayed there (following the crime) I would think, yes.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2016, 11:09:23 PM
I would like to know who understood the science of the DNA analysis the best, i.e. who is the most scientifically orientated member on this forum?  Did you recall which thread was the best for DNA analysis?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 24, 2016, 08:39:51 AM
The problem is that no DNA data is available for scrutiny.
All we have are interpretations by the scientists who looked at the results.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 09:10:36 AM
The problem is that no DNA data is available for scrutiny.
All we have are interpretations by the scientists who looked at the results.
Are you qualified to look at the finer detail?  I'm not. 
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 24, 2016, 09:17:21 AM
Are you qualified to look at the finer detail?  I'm not.

No, I'm not, but we haven't got the fine detail available to us anyway.

DNA analysis produces raw data, the results of which  are subject to interpretation by experts.
In court cases, this interpretation is regularly challenged by other experts.
The general public do not have access to the data and can only rely on what the experts say.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 09:25:01 AM
No, I'm not, but we haven't got the fine detail available to us anyway.

DNA analysis produces raw data, the results of which  are subject to interpretation by experts.
In court cases, this interpretation is regularly challenged by other experts.
The general public do not have access to the data and can only rely on what the experts say.
When the DNA has a mixed source 2 or 3 individual contributing the DNA  (as was the case) even the experts can't tell if there is a match.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 24, 2016, 09:29:31 AM
Allegedly, though different experts will always give different opinions.

As far as I'm aware, we only have Lowe's reports to go on. If there were ever to be a court case, I'm sure other experts would be produced to dispute his interpretation.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 24, 2016, 09:49:13 AM
Allegedly, though different experts will always give different opinions.

As far as I'm aware, we only have Lowe's reports to go on. If there were ever to be a court case, I'm sure other experts would be produced to dispute his interpretation.

This is true. For every expert that says "A" another will say "B".
That's why courts in general like to "do" law not science.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 12:34:35 PM
This is true. For every expert that says "A" another will say "B".
That's why courts in general like to "do" law not science.
There will be debatable points but a strong DNA match is not argued.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 24, 2016, 01:10:23 PM
There will be debatable points but a strong DNA match is not argued.

Its significance to the case may well be.

If a person's DNA is found somewhere that it shouldn't be, then that is significant.
If that DNA is not found where it should be, then that is also significant.
DNA found where it would be expected,  to be found , however strong a match, would not be significant.

Added - Everything dependent upon the quality and integrity  of the sample and the analytical procedure .

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 01:34:12 PM
Its significance to the case may well be.

If a person's DNA is found somewhere that it shouldn't be, then that is significant.
If that DNA is not found where it should be, then that is also significant.
DNA found where it would be expected,  to be found , however strong a match, would not be significant.

Added - Everything dependent upon the quality and integrity  of the sample and the analytical procedure .
That was a great post, a bit like the way I do it breaking it down into options.
As I read today it was that when they do DNA tests using the low copy number (LCN) method they can't tell where the DNA comes from.  Like you can't say it came from blood or it came from thaw drip (ex-frozen cadaver) so you can never tell whether it was in the tissue it was supposed to be.
I might have said that wrong for if they found her DNA match in a place where she had never visited that place could be significant.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 24, 2016, 02:01:45 PM
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 03:10:21 PM
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?
Yes in that case it would be significant.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 07:32:51 AM
If the DNA was a full match then the cadaver would have been Madeleine's as you say.
The DNA wasn't a full match, but the cadaver dog still alerted to a cadaver, so to me that means the cadaver was a closely related person to Madeleine using the same logic.

That doesn't necessarily follow.

The dog MAY have reacted to the scent of a dead person, just as he may have reacted to other substances within his training parameters. Aside from dried blood from a living person, Grime hasn't specified what other decaying human substances he would react to. For instance, he stated that Keela required the physical presence of blood to react, but he doesn't specify whether or not Eddie would react to molecules of blood that were airborne. There is still a question mark (IMO) concerning when Eddie reacted to sex clean-up tissues in Jersey and noted that his reaction was within his "training parameters", whether he meant that Eddie would react to decomposing sex fluids or whether he was referring to a speck of blood found on them (as Keela also reacted).

Therefore... it doesn't seem logical to me to assume that Eddie necessarily reacted to the scent of a deceased human being (whoever that might have been).

Ironically, the place in which the greatest amount of alleles compatible with hers was found is somewhere he didn't even react to.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 07:36:42 AM
The problem is that no DNA data is available for scrutiny.
All we have are interpretations by the scientists who looked at the results.

There is some (there are 3 profiles in the files), but I agree, not enough relevant profiles. In theory, those profiles shouldn't have been released with the files in the first place.


ETA:

Correction: there is a third profile, besides M's one. A DNA result from the apartment in Burgau. But it also belongs to a male, and can't be Gerry either.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 07:46:55 AM
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?

Yes, of course, it would be potentially significant. But even then, there might be innocent explanations to explore: her siblings could have been in that other apartment and her siblings' clothes might have been dumped in the same spot for whatever reason, a toy or a piece of clothing could have been lent to the occupant of the other apartment, her parents could have touched the same spot, etc. 

It would be much more significant if a full and uncontaminated match had been found in a place with no known potentially innocent explanation.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 25, 2016, 09:02:16 AM
There is some (there are 3 profiles in the files), but I agree, not enough relevant profiles. In theory, those profiles shouldn't have been released with the files in the first place.

We can't examine these profiles and make our own judgments, only go by what the written report about them says says.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 10:06:17 AM
We can't examine these profiles and make our own judgments, only go by what the written report about them says says.

Three DNA profiles are posted in the files, Jassi. Madeleine's, the Gordon baby and an unknown male profile found in a car (which I presume to be the Scenic).

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm#oa1v1p275

ETA: And another male DNA profile from a flat in Burgau.
And go right down near the bottom of
 http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PORTUGUESE-FORENSIC.htm#p11p2983

3- Study of the nuclear DNA

Autosomic STRs results were obtained from the following vestigios: root of one of the hairs collected from the bedroom floor of the Burgau apartment (Vg3) and in the lower zone of te fibre from the car boot. Table 1 includes, also, the profile of the spot from the counterpane, already sent previously.

Table 1 - Autosomic STRs of vestigios.


Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: jassi on August 25, 2016, 10:11:20 AM
You misunderstand me.

These are merely reports of findings, which we have to accept as true.
 Unless you have managed to hack into the various DNA data banks, you have nothing to compare them with.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 10:43:44 AM
You misunderstand me.

These are merely reports of findings, which we have to accept as true.
 Unless you have managed to hack into the various DNA data banks, you have nothing to compare them with.

They look incredibly like actual DNA results to me...

They aren't of much use in terms of the case as the male profiles aren't relevant, but I found them useful for anyone trying to understand the general gist of DNA profiles.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 25, 2016, 10:49:36 AM
You misunderstand me.

These are merely reports of findings, which we have to accept as true.
 Unless you have managed to hack into the various DNA data banks, you have nothing to compare them with.

You can compare M's profile with the irrelevant male ones. If you compare M's one with the unknown male one from the car, you can work out that whoever that belongs to can't be Gerry, for example. And, despite the fact that the Gordon baby shares quite a few alleles with M, there is no known link between the families, which (IMO) helps to illustrate the factor of coincidence (unless one is particularly attracted to far-fetched conspiracy theories, which I doubt you are).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 25, 2016, 11:54:40 PM
That doesn't necessarily follow.

The dog MAY have reacted to the scent of a dead person, just as he may have reacted to other substances within his training parameters. Aside from dried blood from a living person, Grime hasn't specified what other decaying human substances he would react to. For instance, he stated that Keela required the physical presence of blood to react, but he doesn't specify whether or not Eddie would react to molecules of blood that were airborne. There is still a question mark (IMO) concerning when Eddie reacted to sex clean-up tissues in Jersey and noted that his reaction was within his "training parameters", whether he meant that Eddie would react to decomposing sex fluids or whether he was referring to a speck of blood found on them (as Keela also reacted).

Therefore... it doesn't seem logical to me to assume that Eddie necessarily reacted to the scent of a deceased human being (whoever that might have been).

Ironically, the place in which the greatest amount of alleles compatible with hers was found is somewhere he didn't even react to.

Where was that carana? Re your last sentence.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on August 26, 2016, 12:08:45 AM
There is some (there are 3 profiles in the files), but I agree, not enough relevant profiles. In theory, those profiles shouldn't have been released with the files in the first place.


ETA:

Correction: there is a third profile, besides M's one. A DNA result from the apartment in Burgau. But it also belongs to a male, and can't be Gerry either.

Thatsreally wierd, only last night i was thinking about this and thinking, if MM is ever found her dna profile will be available to all,not that it means anything terrible that I can think of, but such very personal info shouldnt be in public domain
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 12:18:14 AM
Thatsreally wierd, only last night i was thinking about this and thinking, if MM is ever found her dna profile will be available to all,not that it means anything terrible that I can think of, but such very personal info shouldnt be in public domain
That will be the least of her worries.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: stephen25000 on August 28, 2016, 09:27:05 AM
The Poruguese didn't.

The English (examining a badly contaminated crime-scene 3 months after the crime) might have.

Either way, that's irrelevant.

The British (certainly) established Madeleine's DNA by other means (the saliva of Madeleine's, given to them by Gerry from the pillow of Madeleine's bed at her home in Rothley).

Incorrect ferryman, as per usual.

The P.F.I. (Portuguese Forensic Institute) was at that time an up to date and professional service following accepted rules as regards crime scenes. More than on a par with the UK equivalent.

You should check your 'facts' first, rather than type your biased opinion.

The following may help in your research.

http://www.euroforgen.eu/portugal/
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 28, 2016, 07:42:32 PM
Where was that carana? Re your last sentence.

The boot of the Scenic.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 07:53:44 PM
The boot of the Scenic.
He reacted to the booth of the Scenic not the boot.  Booth does not equal Boot.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 28, 2016, 07:54:57 PM
Thatsreally wierd, only last night i was thinking about this and thinking, if MM is ever found her dna profile will be available to all,not that it means anything terrible that I can think of, but such very personal info shouldnt be in public domain

For a police force that was repeatedly quoted in the media as stating that disseminating Madeleine's face in the media could somehow have placed her life in jeopardy (when it was actually GA who for once actually got something organised) to then happily provide her DNA profile seems a little odd to me. To be fair, it was mainly the rentagob PJ trade union guy, Carlos Anjos, who kept banging on about it, but anyway.

What I find even more strange is the fact that other people's DNA profiles are also in the public domain: two of unidentified males, but one identified (male) one. I can only presume that it was an oversight on the part of whoever got the unenviable task of sifting through the files to be made accessible on the DVD.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 28, 2016, 08:05:02 PM
He reacted to the booth of the Scenic not the boot.  Booth does not equal Boot.

I have personally never heard of a "booth" of a car.

boothnoun [ C ] uk ​ /buːð/ us ​ /buːθ/
​

a small space like a box that a person can go into:
a phone booth
a polling booth
​

a partly closed area or small tent at a fair, exhibition, or similar event
​

a place in a restaurant that is beside a wall and where there are two long seats, often with high backs, with a table between them
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/booth


The original Portuguese documents refer to the "mala da viatura" or to the "zona da bagageira" as captions to the rear area of a car in which one would normally place luggage.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/59-DA-27.htm


Besides which, Eddie only reacted to the outside of the driver's door, and subsequently to the key card placed in that door's storage area. Whatever you wish to call the luggage compartment at the rear - Eddie didn't react to it.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 28, 2016, 08:15:49 PM
Jeez, this is like pulling teeth. Did ANYONE find conclusive and definitive evidence of Madeleine's DNA in the apartment?

They weren't looking for DNA, as such, but any potentially suspicious items or substances that could be sent for analysis (hairs and stains). Plus the usual sweep for finger/hand prints.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 08:28:31 PM
I have personally never heard of a "booth" of a car.

....
Besides which, Eddie only reacted to the outside of the driver's door, and subsequently to the key card placed in that door's storage area. Whatever you wish to call the luggage compartment at the rear - Eddie didn't react to it.
It is the air that escapes at the lower portion of the door so the air comes from the "booth".  They didn't want dogs running over their sampling sites.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2016, 03:11:59 PM
I have personally never heard of a "booth" of a car.

boothnoun [ C ] uk ​ /buːð/ us ​ /buːθ/
​

a small space like a box that a person can go into:
a phone booth
a polling booth
​

a partly closed area or small tent at a fair, exhibition, or similar event
​

a place in a restaurant that is beside a wall and where there are two long seats, often with high backs, with a table between them
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/booth


The original Portuguese documents refer to the "mala da viatura" or to the "zona da bagageira" as captions to the rear area of a car in which one would normally place luggage.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/59-DA-27.htm


Besides which, Eddie only reacted to the outside of the driver's door, and subsequently to the key card placed in that door's storage area. Whatever you wish to call the luggage compartment at the rear - Eddie didn't react to it.

I never heard that expression either, but....

Man, sitting in the booth of his broken down car waiting for assistance and making a few phone calls, whilst traffic passes
http://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-man-sitting-in-the-booth-of-his-broken-down-car-waiting-for-assistance-49396598.html
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 31, 2016, 04:04:02 PM
I never heard that expression either, but....

Man, sitting in the booth of his broken down car waiting for assistance and making a few phone calls, whilst traffic passes
http://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-man-sitting-in-the-booth-of-his-broken-down-car-waiting-for-assistance-49396598.html


As far as I can work out, "zona da bagageira", particularly in context, means the boot (i.e. the luggage area in the back of the car).
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Carana on August 31, 2016, 04:07:53 PM
It is the air that escapes at the lower portion of the door so the air comes from the "booth".  They didn't want dogs running over their sampling sites.

I still have never hear of a "booth" of a car.

But, even so, they let Keela in to have a good sniff around.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2016, 05:23:26 PM
I still have never hear of a "booth" of a car.

But, even so, they let Keela in to have a good sniff around.
Only she can find the location of the microscopic sized sample points.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: sadie on August 31, 2016, 10:14:41 PM
Only she can find the location of the microscopic sized sample points.
The fact that Keela alerted in the back of the car indicates that whatever was being alerted to was NOT Cadavar Odour, but dried blood
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2016, 10:18:15 PM
The fact that Keela alerted in the back of the car indicates that whatever was being alerted to was NOT Cadavar Odour, but dried blood
Similar to the situation in the apartment 5A where both Eddie and Keela alert to different aspects of the same situation.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: sadie on September 01, 2016, 12:16:22 AM
Similar to the situation in the apartment 5A where both Eddie and Keela alert to different aspects of the same situation.
If Keela alert on her own it is dried blood
If Keela and Eddie both alert, then it is also Dried bklood

If Eddie alerts on his OWN after Keela has sniffed at the same spot, then it is likely Cadavar odour.  But it is important to note that both dogs must have sniffed at the same thing, otherwise it could be dried living blood that Eddie was alerting to

But it MUST BE verified by forensic means to be valid.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2016, 12:42:17 AM
If Keela alert on her own it is dried blood
If Keela and Eddie both alert, then it is also Dried bklood

If Eddie alerts on his OWN after (http://Keela has sniffed at the same spot), then it is likely Cadavar odour.  But it is important to note that both dogs must have sniffed at the same thing, otherwise it could be dried living blood that Eddie was alerting to

But it MUST BE verified by forensic means to be valid.
I still think you are wrong for when would Eddie be alerting to Cadaver Odour for every time it could just be dried blood.
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: sadie on September 01, 2016, 12:59:12 AM
I still think you are wrong for when would Eddie be alerting to Cadaver Odour for every time it could just be dried blood.

I think that it is just a myth.  The idea has been mooted that it is cadavar odour and there seems to be absolutely no proof that it is cadavar odour, cos Keela doesn't seem to have been employed tio check if it uis blood  ... and certainly there is no forensic back up


If Amaral hadn't gone on about Cadavars.  If the suspicion that lay in his mind hadn't been mooted, I doubt that anyone would have thought that Eddies alerts were for anything other than dried blood from a living person.

Unecessary suspicions warp peoples perceptions.  As far as we can see keela wasn't employed to check things, so it seems that the most likely thing is that Eddie was alerting to the dried blood of a living person.

All a myth, imo
Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: mercury on September 01, 2016, 01:27:00 AM
I think that it is just a myth.  The idea has been mooted that it is cadavar odour and there seems to be absolutely no proof that it is cadavar odour, cos Keela doesn't seem to have been employed tio check if it uis blood  ... and certainly there is no forensic back up


If Amaral hadn't gone on about Cadavars.  If the suspicion that lay in his mind hadn't been mooted, I doubt that anyone would have thought that Eddies alerts were for anything other than dried blood from a living person.

Unecessary suspicions warp peoples perceptions.  As far as we can see keela wasn't employed to check things, so it seems that the most likely thing is that Eddie was alerting to the dried blood of a living person.

All a myth, imo

The dogs came firstand then amaral talking about them
Youre deluding yourself

As for unnecessary suspicions
Tell that to the uk police wh recommended the dogs wh brought them in and said their indications could support a removed cadaver
The portuguese had noexperience with these dogs, never heard of them, they took the british advice...fast forward they are blamed

and as far as keela was not enloyed  to see, thats your personal subjective unsubstantiated twist...

Pls stop spreading misinformation on this forum
If you dont know what youre talking about best to not hit send
False info can confuse people

Title: Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2016, 06:21:00 AM
The dogs came firstand then amaral talking about them
Youre deluding yourself

As for unnecessary suspicions
Tell that to the uk police wh recommended the dogs wh brought them in and said their indications could support a removed cadaver
The portuguese had noexperience with these dogs, never heard of them, they took the british advice...fast forward they are blamed

and as far as keela was not enloyed  to see, thats your personal subjective unsubstantiated twist...

Pls stop spreading misinformation on this forum
If you dont know what youre talking about best to not hit send
False info can confuse people
One of the options brought about by Keela and Eddie's alert to the apartment and the McCann's rental car is that there has been a cadaver in both of those places.  Until it is proven otherwise we have to leave that option open.

I think I know what I'm talking about so I'll hit send.