Could all three children have been sedated by an intruder?

[Mr Gray]

It was a pretty traumatic time, so I remember that bit  "Dr Neumann" was the dentist.  I can't recall his first name.

40 hrs ago in the UK halothane and  flouthane were not ised to put children to sleep...it would be nitrous oxide then halothane to keep them asleep as an adjunct with nitrous oxide

[Robittybob1]

Alfred E?

Would that be Fred Neumann?  I can't remember but Fred Neumann runs well together.  What made you ask that?

[Miss Taken Identity]

What about the magic gas they use in France to put the whole household to sleep...seems to happen quite a lot
Yet doctors don't know what this gas is and it never seems to be used outside France...are french burglars expert anaesthetists

Gas was used in Scotland  many years ago. It could be administered by a qualified dentist, however a doctor and nurse had to be present to administer intravenously for difficult extractions or full extractions. My Uncle was a dentist.

[Mr Gray]

Gas was used in Scotland  many years ago. It could be administered by a qualified dentist, however a doctor and nurse had to be present to administer intravenously for difficult extractions or full extractions. My Uncle was a dentist.

Gas and intravenous agents...brietal...could be given by a dentist...no doctor necessary..the Poswillow report changed everything

[Brietta]

Brietta could you explain to me why a burglar would take a sleeping child and leave all the McCanns valuables in place. It doesn't make sense to me.

Whoever took Madeleine took one of the most valuable things in the apartment ... but your question to me is off topic since it makes no reference to whether or not Madeleine was drugged or not.

In my opinion there could have been a link to a burglar who might have been no stranger to substance abuse and therefore dealers who may have had access to something which could be used to subdue a child.

Drug users and drug dealers are not nice people ... and burglars with an expertise in invading homes and getting out without being seen ... are not terribly nice individuals either.

Madeleine may have been seen as a valuable commodity and ... money talks.

[Robittybob1]

Gas and intravenous agents...brietal...could be given by a dentist...no doctor necessary..the Poswillow report changed everything

So if sedation was involved we should include dentists as possible suspects, is that the conclusion?

[faithlilly]

Whoever took Madeleine took one of the most valuable things in the apartment ... but your question to me is off topic since it makes no reference to whether or not Madeleine was drugged or not.

In my opinion there could have been a link to a burglar who might have been no stranger to substance abuse and therefore dealers who may have had access to something which could be used to subdue a child.

Drug users and drug dealers are not nice people ... and burglars with an expertise in invading homes and getting out without being seen ... are not terribly nice individuals either.

Madeleine may have been seen as a valuable commodity and ... money talks.

Remember there was a huge reward. If this wasn’t done in isolation there would have been someone on the periphery  willing to talk for money.

[Mr Gray]

So if sedation was involved we should include dentists as possible suspects, is that the conclusion?

I don't think so

[Vertigo Swirl]

Remember there was a huge reward. If this wasn’t done in isolation there would have been someone on the periphery  willing to talk for money.

Is that a fact, or your opinion?

[Robittybob1]

Is that a fact, or your opinion?

It was a conditional statement "If this wasn’t done in isolation ...." 

[Brietta]

Remember there was a huge reward. If this wasn’t done in isolation there would have been someone on the periphery  willing to talk for money.

Yet again you are risking deflecting the thread from its topic.  We should be discussing whether or not Madeleine and the twins were drugged ... in my opinion it would be a good idea to stick to that subject.

[faithlilly]

Yet again you are risking deflecting the thread from its topic.  We should be discussing whether or not Madeleine and the twins were drugged ... in my opinion it would be a good idea to stick to that subject.

It was you who mentioned drug addicts. Drug addicts are very partial to easy money I’m told.

[Robittybob1]

It was you who mentioned drug addicts. Drug addicts are very partial to easy money I’m told.

Cite please.  "It was you who mentioned drug addicts"  show us the cite.

[slartibartfast]

Cite please.  "It was you who mentioned drug addicts"  show us the cite.

#409

[Robittybob1]

#409

"Drug users and drug dealers are not nice people ... and burglars with an expertise in invading homes and getting out without being seen ... are not terribly nice individuals either."

OK thanks "users and dealers" but not "addicts".