UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: gilet on June 16, 2014, 07:47:25 PM
-
The situation is simple.
Goncalo Amaral, we are told, is desperately short of money.
We are also told his money (a very substantial sum) is not available to him till this case is settled.
And his supporters are constantly re-iterating that he believes his case is strong.
Yet he is the one stalling and causing more expense for himself with the instruction of yet another lawyer.
Why?
I can only offer three possible suggestions as to why he has deliberately once again delayed the judgement in this case.
1) Perhaps he has not been paying attention to his lawyer's actions and only at literally the last moment has realised that his lawyer is incompetent and therefore has to be fired. In that case he is a fool who should have been paying attention as the delay is damaging him as much as anyone else (if he believes he will win that is).
2) Perhaps he actually knows he has lost the case and is simply dragging out the inevitable judgement against him. If so he is not only wasting court time, media time and the McCanns' time but also his own time. That would be totally stupid because the sooner an adverse judgement is made, the sooner he can start rebuilding his life.
3) Maybe he really does believe he will win the case but is enjoying the thrill of making the McCanns suffer more with every one of these cynical delays. If that is the case then he is a very sick and nasty individual.
I cannot work out which of the above might be the true reason.
Do other people have any opinions or possibly other suggestions as for the reason for this delay?
E
-
Or an item 5 - he has completely lost the plot and is suffering some sort of breakdown?
eta: his latest berserk theory regarding what he thinks the McCanns did with Madeleine's body suggests he's gone a bit loopy.
-
I think he might be hoping that Madeleine's body will be found, or proof of her death in PdL on that night. He might then think that he will have been proved right in his hypothesis, but was prevented from following it through.
Proof of who is responsible, would be another thing altogether, as at least he would be half way there.
-
Or an item 5 - he has completely lost the plot and is suffering some sort of breakdown?
eta: his latest berserk theory regarding what he thinks the McCanns did with Madeleine's body suggests he's gone a bit loopy.
Much as it pains me I think you may be correct and he may be mentally buckling under the constant pressure he has had to endure for the last seven years.
-
Much as it pains me I think you may be correct and he may be mentally buckling under the constant pressure he has had to endure for the last seven years.
nor the constant name calling ie bungling cop Amaral etc being accused of being connected to how maddie vanished by mcann supporters etc it would take its toul im sure especally since before all this GA was a police officer doing his job
-
Much as it pains me I think you may be correct and he may be mentally buckling under the constant pressure he has had to endure for the last seven years.
Not likely.
Amaral has stood his ground through God knows how many attempts to silence him.
He's hardly likely to fold like a wet tissue now, when the whole world is waking up to the truth about the McCanns and their priorities.
Oh Kate, kate, kate - you should've kept your MOUTH SHUT on those steps.
-
Not likely.
Amaral has stood his ground through God knows how many attempts to silence him.
He's hardly likely to fold like a wet tissue now, when the whole world is waking up to the truth about the McCanns and their priorities.
Oh Kate, kate, kate - you should've kept your MOUTH SHUT on those steps.
the supporters are saying it was not a meltdown by kate but it clearly was she was stamping her feet and cross because she wasnt getting her own way
-
Much as it pains me I think you may be correct and he may be mentally buckling under the constant pressure he has had to endure for the last seven years.
100% self inflicted
-
the supporters are saying it was not a meltdown by kate but it clearly was she was stamping her feet and cross because she wasnt getting her own way
Can someone tell me what THIS has to do with "searching" for Madeleine?
Kate McCann: Can I... can I just add, I mean, I think we need to make it clear to people we... we took on this case because of the pain and stress that Mr Amaral has brought to us and our children. And every time he postpones the case, like this, it brings us more pain and distress, Every time we come here we have to make arrangements for our children to be looked after, we have to book flights, we have to book hotels, we have to take time off work to come here. Now Mr Amaral handed that letter in, apparently, around 9 o'clock this morning. That letter could have been handed in before we left the country and this has happened now about four times, as Gerry said this can't be seen as anything but blatant and cynical. We just want justice. This is not fair.
She didn't say Madeleine's name ONCE in that diatribe. Not once.
-
Not likely.
Amaral has stood his ground through God knows how many attempts to silence him.
He's hardly likely to fold like a wet tissue now, when the whole world is waking up to the truth about the McCanns and their priorities.
Oh Kate, kate, kate - you should've kept your MOUTH SHUT on those steps.
I hope you are right truth but even the strongest among us can only endure a certain amount of pressure before they break.
Amaral has seen his job, his marriage and his reputation sacrificed to the vindictiveness and greed of the McCanns. Who would blame him if he was starting to crumble under the pressure ?
-
Can someone tell me what THIS has to do with "searching" for Madeleine?
Kate McCann: Can I... can I just add, I mean, I think we need to make it clear to people we... we took on this case because of the pain and stress that Mr Amaral has brought to us and our children. And every time he postpones the case, like this, it brings us more pain and distress, Every time we come here we have to make arrangements for our children to be looked after, we have to book flights, we have to book hotels, we have to take time off work to come here. Now Mr Amaral handed that letter in, apparently, around 9 o'clock this morning. That letter could have been handed in before we left the country and this has happened now about four times, as Gerry said this can't be seen as anything but blatant and cynical. We just want justice. This is not fair.
She didn't say Madeleine's name ONCE in that diatribe. Not once.
it was all about HER pain and gerrys PAIN not about maddies suffering
-
it was all about HER pain and gerrys PAIN not about maddies suffering
Truly unbelievable.
Let's not forget the INCONVENIENCE of the whole thing. Having to get babysitters for Gods sake, how SHOCKING.
Forgive me, but wasn't Amaral forced to cancel many family plans when he was looking for their daughter?
Including a much longed for holiday?
-
Truly unbelievable.
Let's not forget the INCONVENIENCE of the whole thing. Having to get babysitters for Gods sake, how SHOCKING.
Forgive me, but wasn't Amaral forced to cancel many family plans when he was looking for their daughter?
Including a much longed for holiday?
not to mention if they had got babysitters to start with they wouldnt be in this position now their reckless behaviour in that holiday caused what is happening now to them
-
nor the constant name calling ie bungling cop Amaral etc being accused of being connected to how maddie vanished by mcann supporters etc it would take its toul im sure especally since before all this GA was a police officer doing his job
That was the problem. He wasn't doing his job.
-
Truly unbelievable.
Let's not forget the INCONVENIENCE of the whole thing. Having to get babysitters for Gods sake, how SHOCKING.
Forgive me, but wasn't Amaral forced to cancel many family plans when he was looking for their daughter?
Including a much longed for holiday?
How could he afford a holiday? He was up to his eyeballs in debt. I should have thought he would have welcomed the overtime.
-
Much as it pains me I think you may be correct and he may be mentally buckling under the constant pressure he has had to endure for the last seven years.
The pressure he brought upon himself when he decided to write a book while a serving PJ officer, then (no doubt this was pure coincidence) he managed to resign and have the book released in the shops just a couple of days after the case was archived.
He chose to ditch his job as a cop to pursue fame and fortune as the man making a fast buck with unevidenced theories (fantasies more recently) about the possible death of a little missing girl and her parents.
He didn't have to endure anything. Unless he had to leave the PJ because of his criminal conviction then he could be just an everyday cop with none of this stress at all.
If he is feeling stress he has only one person to blame, that is HIMSELF and his greedy rush to make money from the case which he botched.
-
nor the constant name calling ie bungling cop Amaral etc being accused of being connected to how maddie vanished by mcann supporters etc it would take its toul im sure especally since before all this GA was a police officer doing his job
Yes and you seem to be forgetting HE CHOSE to ditch that job as a police officer so he could pursue the McCanns with his theories (fantasies) about them and their child.
Its really odd that you don't see the claims he made WITHOUT EVIDENCE about the McCanns and the claims he made WITHOUT EVIDENCE that Madleine was dead as being wrong but you seem to think that people defending the McCanns against these claims are wrong.
You don't seem to have ever considered the fact that claims made against the McCanns might take their toll (sic). Instead you support the criminal in the case.
You really do have a twisted sense of right and wrong, IMO of course.
-
The pressure he brought upon himself when he decided to write a book while a serving PJ officer, then (no doubt this was pure coincidence) he managed to resign and have the book released in the shops just a couple of days after the case was archived.
He chose to ditch his job as a cop to pursue fame and fortune as the man making a fast buck with unevidenced theories (fantasies more recently) about the possible death of a little missing girl and her parents.
He didn't have to endure anything. Unless he had to leave the PJ because of his criminal conviction then he could be just an everyday cop with none of this stress at all.
If he is feeling stress he has only one person to blame, that is HIMSELF and his greedy rush to make money from the case which he botched.
I do so love your visits here gilet.
It is always a sure sign that things aren't going well in McCannland.
Gilet's the name, damage limitation's my game !
-
the supporters are saying it was not a meltdown by kate but it clearly was she was stamping her feet and cross because she wasnt getting her own way
If you had spent time attending a court case and found that the defendant was playing stupid games to waste your time and the court's time as Amaral did today, you would rightly be annoyed. Expressing that annoyance openly is not having a meltdown. It is showing normal reactions to Amaral's disgusting behaviour.
-
100% self inflicted
Spot on. Amaral has only one person to blame if he is now suffering. He chose to ditch his job as a cop to pursue fame and fortune with his fantasies about the parents of Madeleine and about her death for which he provided no proof at all.
If that decision is now coming back to haunt him, that's karma.
-
I hope you are right truth but even the strongest among us can only endure a certain amount of pressure before they break.
Amaral has seen his job, his marriage and his reputation sacrificed to the vindictiveness and greed of the McCanns. Who would blame him if he was starting to crumble under the pressure ?
What a ridiculous claim?
It is not vindictive to seek libel damage from someone who claims without providing any evidence at all (other than his theories) that your missing daughter is dead and you covered up her death by burying her somewhere.
It is common sense.
It is pragmatic if you are seeking to find that child.
It is necessary to ensure that the lies don't multiply.
It is the action of any normal person who has the possibility of seeking damages from the person making the unfounded allegations.
Your claim that it is a vindictive action is bizarre.
What is vindictve is making such vile allegations without having proof.
What is greed is giving up your job to seek fame and fortune as the cop who failed to solve the case of a missing child. That is bound to backfire.
-
Amaral's marriage was looking quite healthy in Lisbon today.
-
Amaral's marriage was looking quite healthy in Lisbon today.
Most odd that. Mmm. Why do I feel there might be a reason for that?
Mmmm. Would it be because...? No, surely not?
-
What a ridiculous claim?
It is not vindictive to seek libel damage from someone who claims without providing any evidence at all (other than his theories) that your missing daughter is dead and you covered up her death by burying her somewhere.
It is common sense.
It is pragmatic if you are seeking to find that child.
It is necessary to ensure that the lies don't multiply.
It is the action of any normal person who has the possibility of seeking damages from the person making the unfounded allegations.
Your claim that it is a vindictive action is bizarre.
What is vindictve is making such vile allegations without having proof.
What is greed is giving up your job to seek fame and fortune as the cop who failed to solve the case of a missing child. That is bound to backfire.
Nope gilet. The excuses weren't convincing when the McCanns first put them forward and they certainly haven't gained any further resonance when coming from your fingers.
-
Most odd that. Mmm. Why do I feel there might be a reason for that?
Mmmm. Would it be because...? No, surely not?
What, What? I thought it was just proof of yet another lie.
-
Nope gilet. The excuses weren't convincing when the McCanns put then forward and they certainly haven't gained any further resonance when coming from your fingers.
The very fact that you cannot see that it is perfectly normal to defend your child and your family reputation against the vile unevidenced claims of a disgraced, criminal ex-cop is shameful in my opinion.
It matters not how many times you deny the fact but a libel action in this case was the natural reaction not a vindictive greedy action.
And it matters not how many times you try to pretend otherwise, the action of Amaral in originally throwing in the towel as a cop at precisely the moment he thought his book would make most money is greedy grabbing of blood money especially when he was the cop who failed abysmally to conduct a proper investigation in the first place.
It is clear that we don't agree on this issue but I know that supporting the criminal disgraced ex cop as you do is not the kind of thing I could ever do when he is making such fantastic claims as those he is making about a missing little girl and her parents without being able to provide evidence for those claims.
I prefer the rule of law and understand that such vile claims as were made by Amaral deservedly should be challenged in a court, which is precisely what the McCanns are doing.
Had they been guilty do you really think they would have brought this trial to court? Not a chance!
-
Amaral's marriage was looking quite healthy in Lisbon today.
Really?
I just hope no court official becomes aware that the divorce may have been a sham, and an attempt at deprivation of assets to shelter them from certain creditors. Good job they have been very very discrete, eh, what...
And no photographers were lurking. That would never do
-
You all must admit that his latest theory is a good one. The body in a coffin going to be cremated. Not a scrap of evidence, and never likely to be. All gone up in a puff of smoke. Now prove him wrong.
-
Really?
I just hope no court official becomes aware that the divorce may have been a sham, and an attempt at deprivation of assets to shelter them from certain creditors. Good job they have been very very discrete, eh, what...
And no photographers were lurking. That would never do
Well someone snuck a good un, Holding hands, they were, and laughing fit to bust. Something very amusing must have happened.
-
You all must admit that his latest theory is a good one. The body in a coffin going to be cremated. Not a scrap of evidence, and never likely to be. All gone up in a puff of smoke. Now prove him wrong.
I am hearing that the next move, once the case is won by the McCanns in Portugal, may well be a libel case brought in the UK where it will not be the responsibility of the McCanns to prove him wrong. He will be obliged to prove himself right.
And before anyone claims the book was never sold here. Not relevant. It has been made available here by Anna Silvestro in particular (and others) with his permission.
The newspaper stories from today will be nothing compared to the stories which will appear about Amaral and his cohorts if this goes ahead.
-
Well someone snuck a good un, Holding hands, they were, and laughing fit to bust. Something very amusing must have happened.
Surely they were not laughing hysterically all over the place when Amaral is so destitute and suffering so badly from the effects of the McCanns bringing this case? Surely not?
What will the body analysts and the amateur psychobabblers make of that?
-
The very fact that you cannot see that it is perfectly normal to defend your child and your family reputation against the vile unevidenced claims of a disgraced, criminal ex-cop is shameful in my opinion.
It matters not how many times you deny the fact but a libel action in this case was the natural reaction not a vindictive greedy action.
And it matters not how many times you try to pretend otherwise, the action of Amaral in originally throwing in the towel as a cop at precisely the moment he thought his book would make most money is greedy grabbing of blood money especially when he was the cop who failed abysmally to conduct a proper investigation in the first place.
It is clear that we don't agree on this issue but I know that supporting the criminal disgraced ex cop as you do is not the kind of thing I could ever do when he is making such fantastic claims as those he is making about a missing little girl and her parents without being able to provide evidence for those claims.
I prefer the rule of law and understand that such vile claims as were made by Amaral deservedly should be challenged in a court, which is precisely what the McCanns are doing.
Had they been guilty do you really think they would have brought this trial to court? Not a chance!
Slightly off topic - there is a pervasive school of thought in some quarters that if an allegation is made, and the subject of such allegation does not correct it or sue the author then they must accept it is true. afaik Bennett was of this opinion.
So those promulgating this school of thought should not be that surprised when they find themselves on the wrong end of a hefty claim for damages.
-
The newspaper stories from today will be nothing compared to the stories which will appear about Amaral and his cohorts if this goes ahead.
Well, they made their bed themselves..used the media for their sick claims.. It will be interesting to have the attention turned on them @)(++(*
-
It is an abusive claim about a fellow poster. No matter. I really don't care.
You have declared your support for the criminal, disgraced, ex-cop, Amaral in his efforts to besmirch the McCann family and his declaration without proof that the missing little girl, Madeleine is dead.
After that support its not altogether surprising that you prefer to abuse opposing posters here.
It's not really the fact that Amaral is saying that Madeleine may be dead that irks you is it gilet, SY have said something similar. It's the fact that he says that the McCanns are responsible that really rankles, isn't it ?
This isn't about finding a child for you or her parents, this is about saving reputations.
You know that and so do I.
-
It's not really the fact that Amaral is saying that Madeleine may be dead that irks you is it gilet, SY have said something similar. It's the fact that he says that the McCanns are responsible that really rankles, isn't it ?
This isn't about finding a child for you or her parents, this is about saving reputations.
You know that and so do I.
its like when the mcanns and supporters fantasise that maddie is alive and unharmed after all these years we would all love that but it isnt realistic at all
-
Surely they were not laughing hysterically all over the place when Amaral is so destitute and suffering so badly from the effects of the McCanns bringing this case? Surely not?
What will the body analysts and the amateur psychobabblers make of that?
It does seem a bit odd, doesn't it. No Money. No Marriage. No Home to go to. What on earth could be funny about that. He wants to be careful, his money donating fans might get the wrong idea, like, is he laughing at them? And what's The Lovely Sofa got to laugh at?
-
I am hearing that the next move, once the case is won by the McCanns in Portugal, may well be a libel case brought in the UK where it will not be the responsibility of the McCanns to prove him wrong. He will be obliged to prove himself right.
And before anyone claims the book was never sold here. Not relevant. It has been made available here by Anna Silvestro in particular (and others) with his permission.
The newspaper stories from today will be nothing compared to the stories which will appear about Amaral and his cohorts if this goes ahead.
If the McCanns could have sued Amaral here they would have done.
I'd be interested if you could provide some examples where this has actually happened.
-
It's not really the fact that Amaral is saying that Madeleine may be dead that irks you is it gilet, SY have said something similar. It's the fact that he says that the McCanns are responsible that really rankles, isn't it ?
This isn't about finding a child for you or her parents, this is about saving reputations.
You know that and so do I.
NO you are completely wrong.
There is a massive difference between what Amaral has said and what SY have said.
SY have claimed that there is a possibility that Madeleine is dead. Well all sane people know that is a possibility. But they also know that it is not a fact and we all know that SY are equally claiming that Madeleine could be alive.
Amaral on the other hand does not post this as a possibility. He premises his "theory" (which is becoming ever more fantastic with coffins and cremations now) on Madeleine being dead. He has no evidence for this claim. But he makes the claim nonetheless. He then goes on to make vile allegations about the parents which are nothing but guesswork on his part as he cannot support his ideas with evidence.
Unlike SY, Amaral is promulgating ONLY the idea that Madeleine is dead.
That is the difference which apparently you are blind to.
This is entirely about ensuring that the little missing girl is not declared dead by a failed copper because he thinks it will earn him a fortune and help defend his reputation (a reputation completely shattered anyway by his criminal conviction of course).
-
Clearly Carlymichelle is unaware that there have been cases of missing children being found years after their disappearance. You would have thought that in the last seven years or so she might have picked up this rather significant and heartwarming information. It is a shame that people make comments without having sought information on the subject prior to posting.
-
NO you are completely wrong.
There is a massive difference between what Amaral has said and what SY have said.
SY have claimed that there is a possibility that Madeleine is dead. Well all sane people know that is a possibility. But they also know that it is not a fact and we all know that SY are equally claiming that Madeleine could be alive.
Amaral on the other hand does not post this as a possibility. He premises his "theory" (which is becoming ever more fantastic with coffins and cremations now) on Madeleine being dead. He has no evidence for this claim. But he makes the claim nonetheless. He then goes on to make vile allegations about the parents which are nothing but guesswork on his part as he cannot support his ideas with evidence.
Unlike SY, Amaral is promulgating ONLY the idea that Madeleine is dead.
That is the difference which apparently you are blind to.
This is entirely about ensuring that the little missing girl is not declared dead by a failed copper because he thinks it will earn him a fortune and help defend his reputation (a reputation completely shattered anyway by his criminal conviction of course).
I am still trying to find the connection with Dr Amarals honour and reputation, and his actions this morning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYFefppqEtE
-
After learning about Amaral's coffin claims, it is clear to me that it is actually him who is feeding these sick theories about Madeline being dead this or that way to the internet forums. He is intentionally feeding the trolls probably using uneducated people who cannot sit down and read a book or a clearer information about his claims.
How many people in Portugal will tomorrow read Correiro Da Manha and will believe that Madeleine was hidden by her parents in a coffin in the church bellow the legs of a dead woman.
This man is sick. He needs treatment!
-
I am still trying to find the connection with Dr Amarals honour and reputation, and his actions this morning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYFefppqEtE
What an excellent summary of the actions of Amaral yesterday!
Well done for finding that.
In the absence of any other options from his supporters as to why Amaral might have done a runner yesterday from court, that is as likely a possibility as any.
So far we have cowardice, madness, incompetence, stupid delaying tactics for no particular reason or deliberate vindictive inconveniencing of the lawyers, court, media and McCanns as options for his behaviour.
And no Amaral supporter has offered a single reason which could put him in a favourable light. Somebody suggested an "unknown reason" but that hardly counts. If no supporter can even think of any reason at all that bodes badly for the man and his sad book in my opinion.
Perhaps the morning will bring a rush of inspiration to the Amaral fan club?
-
Dispensing of ones lawyer/advocate at the last minute is nothing new but the question could be asked as to why now?
It has been suggested that Amaral sacked Santos de Oliveira because he wanted to address the Court in the same way as the McCann's will do but Oliveira didn't concur. If when Amaral appoints a new lawyer and he then makes application for Amaral to be heard then we will know the truth.
The second thing I would say is that it is not appropriate for pursuers to make statements to the gathered Press outside Court before a case is settled. I would have thought that Isabel Duarte would have warned her clients of the perils of such conduct by now.
-
The situation is simple.
Goncalo Amaral, we are told, is desperately short of money.
We are also told his money (a very substantial sum) is not available to him till this case is settled.
And his supporters are constantly re-iterating that he believes his case is strong.
Yet he is the one stalling and causing more expense for himself with the instruction of yet another lawyer.
Why?
I can only offer three possible suggestions as to why he has deliberately once again delayed the judgement in this case.
1) Perhaps he has not been paying attention to his lawyer's actions and only at literally the last moment has realised that his lawyer is incompetent and therefore has to be fired. In that case he is a fool who should have been paying attention as the delay is damaging him as much as anyone else (if he believes he will win that is).
2) Perhaps he actually knows he has lost the case and is simply dragging out the inevitable judgement against him. If so he is not only wasting court time, media time and the McCanns' time but also his own time. That would be totally stupid because the sooner an adverse judgement is made, the sooner he can start rebuilding his life.
3) Maybe he really does believe he will win the case but is enjoying the thrill of making the McCanns suffer more with every one of these cynical delays. If that is the case then he is a very sick and nasty individual.
I cannot work out which of the above might be the true reason.
Do other people have any opinions or possibly other suggestions as for the reason for this delay?
E
You need to get your facts straight.
This is the first time the court has been postponed because of Mr Amaral.
Its also incorrect they have come 3 times and it was always postponed thats rubbish.
Read the transcripts from day one.
1. Kate McCann came the first time to simply accompany one of her friends Hubbard and Loaches Daughter.
2. Gerry McCann then attended but he wasnt called.
3. Gerry McCann then came another time and was accompanying I believe his sister and MIL and again he wasnt called.
So its not 4 times its only 1.
It seems its the done thing to postpone these cases.
Also if Mrs Healy for example came twice without being heard it's because of the Judge who cancelled an afternoon and then because of Duarte who forgot to notify Mrs Healy again. So can we not blame AMARAL for everything.
We dont know what happened everyone is summising AGAIN. He has every right to sack his team. Perhaps he had a fall out on Friday night courts dont open over the weekend so he could hardly put a letter in prior to that.
Everyone is just speculating.
He has had a breakdown.
Its spite.
Its strategy
so on and so forth.
Its all rollocks. He will have had his reasons he is not a stupid man.
IF the McCanns are so fired up about being put out then why did they take this case to court in the first place.
I bet you the majority of people going on about Amaral and his nasty book havent even read it.
Its actually very well written and although his THEORY is that the child died by accident and there was a cover up not once does he call the McCanns by nasty or vicious names. The book was not just about the child it was also about how it had affected his life, not only her, but other cases of children too.
There are far worse theorys out there about the McCanns are they being sued? NO.
I actually read Mrs McCanns book and found it highly disturbing.
They could have simply left it alone it would have just all fizzled out a long time ago. ITS them now that has brought all this suing to light as nearly all my friends didnt even know about Amarals book and are all off to try and buy it.
So stupidly they have opened themselves up to a can of worms.
I shall wait and see what happens.
WITHOUT all the speculation.
To be honest I could hardly blame Mr Amaral if he did have an anxiety attack his life has been ruined that day 3rd May 2007 just like the McCanns and anyone else touched by this story even innocent people gypsies and blond children dragged from beds, so much going on its been a flaming nightmare for many many many people including Murat.
-
Dispensing of ones lawyer/advocate at the last minute is nothing new but the question could be asked as to why now?
It has been suggested that Amaral sacked Santos de Oliveira because he wanted to address the Court in the same way as the McCann's will do but Oliveira didn't concur. If when Amaral appoints a new lawyer and he then makes application for Amaral to be heard then we will know the truth.
The second thing I would say is that it is not appropriate for pursuers to make statements to the gathered Press outside Court before a case is settled. I would have thought that Isabel Duarte would have warned her clients of the perils of such conduct by now.
perils of such conduct....perhaps amarals lawyers...all of them... have advised him of such and thats why he has sacked them...he is only delaying the inevitable total humilation
-
perils of such conduct....perhaps amarals lawyers...all of them... have advised him of such and thats why he has sacked them...he is only delaying the inevitable total humilation
John has it right.
It was also clear yesterday how self-righteous the mccanns are.
Another brief reminder dave, the mccanns are responsible for what happened to Madeleine and no one else.
-
John has it right.
It was also clear yesterday how self-righteous the mccanns are.
Another brief reminder dave, the mccanns are responsible for what happened to Madeleine and no one else.
no they are not
-
no they are not
That was a useless answer dave and completely wrong.
-
That was a useless answer dave and completely wrong.
it isn't its correct
-
John has it right.
It was also clear yesterday how self-righteous the mccanns are.
Another brief reminder dave, the mccanns are responsible for what happened to Madeleine and no one else.
what did you think of kates meltdown in front of the media not very doctor like is it and all she cared about was she had to make childcare arragments for the twins too bad she didnt think of that 7 years ago she wouldnt be in the mess she is in now
-
sorry truth it some how ended up in your post...just to clarify it was my words my post
well if this was a tactical move by Goncalo ...IMO it is certainly working .....they would have been better off keeping their mouth shut..[no wonder they had a spokesman]...
its brought this well and truly in the spotlight now to show people how selfish k g mcc are ME ME ME...
they have to arrange child care .....its by not doing that in the first place that has landed them there...
the statement comes across as ...its all about the expense the inconvenience...etc ..exactly what Goncalo probably wanted ...[give them enough rope]...
.
"We want to get justice for Madeleine....no g mcc, Goncalo Amaral wants justice for Madeleine. You and k mcc want $2,000,000.00
-
sorry truth it some how ended up in your post...just to clarify it was my words my post
well if this was a tactical move by Goncalo ...IMO it is certainly working .....they would have been better off keeping their mouth shut..[no wonder they had a spokesman]...
its brought this well and truly in the spotlight now to show people how selfish k g mcc are ME ME ME...
they have to arrange child care .....its by not doing that in the first place that has landed them there...
the statement comes across as ...its all about the expense the inconvenience...etc ..exactly what Goncalo probably wanted ...[give them enough rope]...
.
"We want to get justice for Madeleine....no g mcc, Goncalo Amaral wants justice for Madeleine. You and k mcc want $2,000,000.00
I guess they were caught on the hop and their little pink friend wasn't on hand.
-
Dispensing of ones lawyer/advocate at the last minute is nothing new but the question could be asked as to why now?
It has been suggested that Amaral sacked Santos de Oliveira because he wanted to address the Court in the same way as the McCann's will do but Oliveira didn't concur. If when Amaral appoints a new lawyer and he then makes application for Amaral to be heard then we will know the truth.
The second thing I would say is that it is not appropriate for pursuers to make statements to the gathered Press outside Court before a case is settled. I would have thought that Isabel Duarte would have warned her clients of the perils of such conduct by now.
Interesting that you make no criticism of Amaral who goes on chat shows on a regular basis elaborating his unevidenced claims against the McCanns, describing his motives for defending his "honour" and generally discussing the case.
I am suggesting that perhaps his lawyer didn't concur and advised him in no uncertain terms that his behaviour was actually damaging his chances in the case? And Amaral did not like this affront to his right to say what he likes when he likes so sacked him.
It has also been suggested by some that his motive in sacking the man was simply a bit of legal trickery and the comment was made that its rather odd that a sacked lawyer colludes with the defendant by going to court to explain that he has been sacked and the defendant cannot therefore continue. We will soon see what pans out.
But it is obviously important that you indicate to us that the McCanns expressing simply their natural indignation at this disgraced ex-cop's fourth or fifth cynical interruption of the case is somehow wrong in your opinion.
No sense of bias at all in that post above from you, oh deary me no!
-
no i think it is the other way round elenor....its because the mccs sue where ever they can ...and imo try to destroy anyone who does not belive there verson..or stand up to them
Such wilful exaggeration. The McCanns sue only when there is no other option to remove the lies about them and their daughter from circulation. They have conducted a tiny handful of cases in relation to the horrendous abuse they have received from Amaral and others over the years.
-
Such wilful exaggeration. The McCanns sue only when there is no other option to remove the lies about them and their daughter from circulation. They have conducted a tiny handful of cases in relation to the horrendous abuse they have received from Amaral and others over the years.
erm ....pity they didn't mention maddie by name in there on the steps speech ...all that showed was how put out they were...and inconvenienced...having to book flights time off work ...[expence probably out their own pocket]
also form gilet
Interesting that you make no criticism of Amaral who goes on chat shows on a regular basis elaborating his unevidenced claims against the McCanns, describing his motives for defending his "honour" and generally discussing the case.
....................................................
fgs ....the mccs are world class at doing that ....their claims are also evidenced as well
-
After learning about Amaral's coffin claims, it is clear to me that it is actually him who is feeding these sick theories about Madeline being dead this or that way to the internet forums. He is intentionally feeding the trolls probably using uneducated people who cannot sit down and read a book or a clearer information about his claims.
How many people in Portugal will tomorrow read Correiro Da Manha and will believe that Madeleine was hidden by her parents in a coffin in the church bellow the legs of a dead woman.
This man is sick. He needs treatment!
This hypothesis was actually put forward on SIC in the morning by Hernâni de Carvalho before Gonçalo Amaral mentioned it in Correio da Manhã. BTW, it was a possibility that was brought up during the investigation because the parents had 24 hour access to the church and the coffin was in the church during the night unattended, ready for cremation. Not so strange really.
-
erm ....pity they didn't mention maddie by name in there on the steps speech ...all that showed was how put out they were...and inconvenienced...having to book flights time off work ...[expence probably out their own pocket]
also form gilet
Interesting that you make no criticism of Amaral who goes on chat shows on a regular basis elaborating his unevidenced claims against the McCanns, describing his motives for defending his "honour" and generally discussing the case.
....................................................
fgs ....the mccs are world class at doing that ....their claims are also evidenced as well
Your post merely emphasises the bias in the earlier post by John. Amaral has made far more TV appearances than the McCanns or had you not noticed that fact? He appears to be addicted to the chat sofas for which he no doubt receives a substantial payment. So much for his penury!
-
The trial has been adjourned for 3 weeks! You could hardly call that stalling. Anyway, no matter what way the verdict goes, appeals will be made and it will drag on for another few months.
-
Your post merely emphasises the bias in the earlier post by John. Amaral has made far more TV appearances than the McCanns or had you not noticed that fact? He appears to be addicted to the chat sofas for which he no doubt receives a substantial payment. So much for his penury!
no sweetie i am not biast...[and why drag john into it] ....i don't believe the mccs version ..end of
we could go on for ever more with this ......but...the mccs have received a lot more substantial payments [what could be there perjury]...than goncalo ever will
-
Interesting that you make no criticism of Amaral who goes on chat shows on a regular basis elaborating his unevidenced claims against the McCanns, describing his motives for defending his "honour" and generally discussing the case.
I am suggesting that perhaps his lawyer didn't concur and advised him in no uncertain terms that his behaviour was actually damaging his chances in the case? And Amaral did not like this affront to his right to say what he likes when he likes so sacked him.
It has also been suggested by some that his motive in sacking the man was simply a bit of legal trickery and the comment was made that its rather odd that a sacked lawyer colludes with the defendant by going to court to explain that he has been sacked and the defendant cannot therefore continue. We will soon see what pans out.
But it is obviously important that you indicate to us that the McCanns expressing simply their natural indignation at this disgraced ex-cop's fourth or fifth cynical interruption of the case is somehow wrong in your opinion.
No sense of bias at all in that post above from you, oh deary me no!
Suggested ? By who ?
-
whatever gilet ....but at the end of the day ....it is what you assume ....happened ...nothing else
going back on topic ....it has been said goncalo want to have the same opportunity to speak as the mccs....that is understandable ....
k mcc is probably well rehearsed for the performance of her life .....there is afterall a $1,000,000.00. pay day
-
I love the way people throw in phrases like 'disgraced ex-cop' or 'convicted criminal' at every opportunity, as if it has any relevance to the issue in hand @)(++(*
What it does show is how they have developed a personal dislike for anyone who contradicts the McCann version of events.
Chill - your comments have no relevance in the real world.
-
I love the way people throw in phrases like 'disgraced ex-cop' or 'convicted criminal' at every opportunity, as if it has any relevance to the issue in hand @)(++(*
What it does show is how they have developed a personal dislike for anyone who contradicts the McCann version of events.
Chill - your comments have no relevance in the real world.
It is 100% relevant to the issue at hand.
Amaral in his cynical and contemptuous behaviour yesterday is simply continuing to demonstrate those aspects of his personality which brought him a criminal conviction and which got him thrown off the McCann case in disgrace for mouthing off to a journalist. It is a pattern of behaviour which has continued from day one of the case (coincidentally the day he was made arguidio in the case he would later be convicted in) to yesterday.
-
It is 100% relevant to the issue at hand.
Amaral in his cynical and contemptuous behaviour yesterday is simply continuing to demonstrate those aspects of his personality which brought him a criminal conviction and which got him thrown off the McCann case in disgrace for mouthing off to a journalist. It is a pattern of behaviour which has continued from day one of the case (coincidentally the day he was made arguidio in the case he would later be convicted in) to yesterday.
So? Do your little outbursts of venom do anything to change that?
-
Has Goncalo Amaral ever spoken publicly about the ongoing libel trial in the same way the McCanns appear to think it competent to do so?
Has he ever stood outside court publicly criticising his opponents?
Is the moon made of cheese Gilet?
-
Has Goncalo Amaral ever spoken publicly about the ongoing libel trial in the same way the McCanns appear to think it competent to do so?
Has he ever stood outside court publicly criticising his opponents?
Is the moon made of cheese Gilet?
Goncalo doesn't have the balls. Where was he yesterday? In Lisbon, laughing outrageously with his "Ex Wife."
-
I have no faith in any investigation based primarily on the botched efforts of the initial PJ team ever reaching a conclusion. They never searched properly. They completely misinterpreted the dog alerts (believing them to be evidential). They showed no understanding of the DNA results etc. That is why I am so supportive of the SY investigation which is attempting (albeit after a delay of years) to undertake proper searches and detailed investigations. Unfortunately they are hampered by the time delay and may not come be able to solve the case. Everyone understands the need for urgency and thoroughness in a missing child enquiry it seems except the initial PJ team.
The claim that the PJ never searched properly is a blatant lie and to compare the exhaustive land, sea and aerial searches with Scotland Yard's five minutes of glory is a complete joke. You really do have a bee in your bonnet Gilet.
And just for the record the mound west of Rua 25 de Abril was thoroughly searched by the GNR sniffer dogs on the morning after Madeleine disappeared.
It might have escaped you but they were looking for a live child and not bones.
-
Goncalo doesn't have the balls. Where was he yesterday? In Lisbon, laughing outrageously with his "Ex Wife."
Point being the McCanns could be seen to be in contempt of court. Kates outburst might well cost them dearly.
-
Goncalo doesn't have the balls. Where was he yesterday? In Lisbon, laughing outrageously with his "Ex Wife."
Is that a crime in your book?
-
With regard to your question about the McCanns having interrupted the investigation, are you seriously suggesting that it was the actions of the McCanns that led directly to the archival? I find such a statement quite bizarre and would like you to elaborate with details of how they managed this. If you meant that the PJ would have continued a full investigation of all the potential scenarios had Kate answered the questions her lawyers advised her not to answer I think you are barking up the wrong tree completely. Pleased do elaborate though.
It is stated in the archive report that the McCanns had the opportunity to clear their name but failed to take it. Maybe the archive report is flawed too?
-
Is that a crime in your book?
It is in the eyes of some if The McCanns are seen laughing.
-
Has Goncalo Amaral ever spoken publicly about the ongoing libel trial in the same way the McCanns appear to think it competent to do so?
Has he ever stood outside court publicly criticising his opponents?
Is the moon made of cheese Gilet?
In fact, he did it yesterday. On the national TV. He accused the McCanns of hiding Madeleine's body in a dead woman's coffin.
And he does it at any opportunity he is given.
-
In fact, he did it yesterday. On the national TV. He accused the McCanns of hiding Madeleine's body in a dead woman's coffin.
And he does it at any opportunity he is given.
He has been doing it ever since The Trial began. But yesterday was a brahma. And no doubt he will argue that no one can prove him wrong.
Although I gather there is a game of Hunt the Ashes going on in some places.
-
In fact, he did it yesterday. On the national TV. He accused the McCanns of hiding Madeleine's body in a dead woman's coffin.
And he does it at any opportunity he is given.
Has he ever spoken of the libel case specifically though? That's the big difference.
-
You are obviously ignorant of the law. Mr Amaral is legally within his right to dispense of his lawyer but the McCanns are not legally permitted to discuss the libel case in public and especially so outside the very court where the proceedings are taking place. If anyone has a big mouth.....
They discussed his absence, and not The Trial. There is a difference.
-
It is 100% relevant to the issue at hand.
Amaral in his cynical and contemptuous behaviour yesterday is simply continuing to demonstrate those aspects of his personality which brought him a criminal conviction and which got him thrown off the McCann case in disgrace for mouthing off to a journalist. It is a pattern of behaviour which has continued from day one of the case (coincidentally the day he was made arguidio in the case he would later be convicted in) to yesterday.
why should goncalo ...be at a unfair advantage which by all accounts is why he sacked his lawyer.....
why should he be abused all the time ...
lets face it .....the mccs left there babies on there own ....and want everyone else to pay ...for what they did wrong...
all it seems to me ...no ulterior motive no stalling ....just a fair hearing ....and he deserves that ....and if they don't like it tough ..
-
It is stated in the archive report that the McCanns had the opportunity to clear their name but failed to take it. Maybe the archive report is flawed too?
in that respect is certainly is..it is a totally ridiculous idea....If trhe mccanns ahd complied with the questioning...would that have completely cleared them...of course not ..it is a stupid idea from a stupid investigation and seems to stem from portugals fascist past
-
You are obviously ignorant of the law. Mr Amaral is legally within his right to dispense of his lawyer but the McCanns are not legally permitted to discuss the libel case in public and especially so outside the very court where the proceedings are taking place. If anyone has a big mouth.....
Of course "Dr" Amaral is entitled to dispense with the services of his lawyer at any time. It is a dangerous game as if the Judge suspects he is doing it as a device to delay the trial he may find himself as an LIP. He was allowed an adjournment this time but I suspect he has lost his "home advantage" now - Senior judges usually have a background in advocacy and the wool is not easily pulled.
But under which law are the McCanns not legally permitted to discuss the libel case? That is a new one on me.
-
why should goncalo ...be at a unfair advantage which by all accounts is why he sacked his lawyer.....
why should he be abused all the time ...
lets face it .....the mccs left there babies on there own ....and want everyone else to pay ...for what they did wrong...
all it seems to me ...no ulterior motive no stalling ....just a fair hearing ....and he deserves that ....and if they don't like it tough ..
Are you suggesting that Dr Amaral did not have a fair hearing in a Portuguese court? It is hardly the fault of his defence or the court if the witnesses he called on his behalf appeared to give less than definitive testimony.
If there is no ulterior motive why didn't Dr Amaral allow his lawyer to make the concluding arguments which would have allowed the judge to make her decision.
Dr Amaral had his fair hearing, but I fear his assessment of proceedings was that he had lost his case. His antics on Monday were designed to disallow the Drs McCann their fair hearing.
In this he was successful; but I think in the fullness of time it will be realised that he did his reputation a lot of damage while bringing the Justice system of Portugal into disrepute.
In my opinion he showed what a petty and vindictive man he is, so he may have won the battle but I think he has lost the war.
-
I very much doubt it. Amaral is the one who is treating The Court with contempt. Four times. No wonder The McCanns are exasperated.
Please give me the dates and circumstances of the other three delays in the trial which you can attribute to Gonçalo Amaral? You see I have a sneaking suspicion that Kate McCann is lying when she states this. And "everybody knows" will not be a good enough answer.
-
amarals lawyers secretary having suspected bird flu...amarals lawyers grown up son having a routine minor operation...there are almost certainly more
The bird flu incident was for the book ban hearing and this matter was concluded in October 2010 when the book ban was overturned. A completely separate trial BTW.
So you are inferring that the operation for the lawyer's son was a lie. You do know that they have to present proof to the court to justify any absence or delays.
Another delay was when the judge had a personal matter to resolve and called off the hearing in the afternoon.
Was that at the behest of Gonçalo Amaral?
If you have any others you can confirm, please go ahead.
-
The bird flu incident was for the book ban hearing and this matter was concluded in October 2010 when the book ban was overturned. A completely separate trial BTW.
So you are inferring that the operation for the lawyer's son was a lie. You do know that they have to present proof to the court to justify any absence or delays.
Another delay was when the judge had a personal matter to resolve and called off the hearing in the afternoon.
Was that at the behest of Gonçalo Amaral?
If you have any others you can confirm, please go ahead.
it was a lie that the lawyer needed to be there
-
it was a lie that the lawyer needed to be there
That's a serious accusation. Are you also implying that the judge is dishonest when she accepted the lawyer's request?
-
That's a serious accusation. Are you also implying that the judge is dishonest when she accepted the lawyer's request?
not as serious as amarals...it was a pathetic excuse..there is absolutely no reason why he had to go to hospital...how many 35 year old men have to have their father present when having minor day stay surgery
-
I agree with Montclair - I believe the position to be that the lawyer has an overriding duty to the court to enable the court to proceed with business, notwithstanding the fact that he has been sacked.
This would involve making the Judge aware of the circumstances, and making application for an adjournment.
By leaving things to the absolute last minute like this Amaral has showed great disrespect to the court, the professional legal teams involved, and to his opponents. In my view he is treading on dangerous ground - the Judge could have refused the adjournment but on this occasion allowed it.
For someone so keen to get the McCanns into court, his behavior is odd. Even odder is his statement regarding coffins. Unless substantiated this would appear to be further libel.
All in all this suggests to me that he has given up and is just out to cause maximum damage at whatever cost.
-
I agree with Montclair - I believe the position to be that the lawyer has an overriding duty to the court to enable the court to proceed with business, notwithstanding the fact that he has been sacked.
This would involve making the Judge aware of the circumstances, and making application for an adjournment.
By leaving things to the absolute last minute like this Amaral has showed great disrespect to the court, the professional legal teams involved, and to his opponents. In my view he is treading on dangerous ground - the Judge could have refused the adjournment but on this occasion allowed it.
For someone so keen to get the McCanns into court, his behavior is odd. Even odder is his statement regarding coffins. Unless substantiated this would appear to be further libel.
All in all this suggests to me that he has given up and is just out to cause maximum damage at whatever cost.
If theoretically, he has no money, what practical difference would that make? Can he be imprisoned for libel?
-
If theoretically, he has no money, what practical difference would that make? Can he be imprisoned for libel?
perhaps he realises that he has now lost all the money the court holds...makes sense...he can say what he likes now..he is penniless
-
If theoretically, he has no money, what practical difference would that make? Can he be imprisoned for libel?
What, in Portugal? Not in a civil case, I shouldn't think. Unless he deliberately set out to Libel someone, knowing that he couldn't afford to pay. But that would likely be a criminal case.
In England they have other options they can engage.
-
perhaps he realises that he has now lost all the money the court holds...makes sense...he can say what he likes now..he is penniless
That's what I was asking - are there any sanctions or can he say exactly what he wishes with impunity?
-
That's what I was asking - are there any sanctions or can he say exactly what he wishes with impunity?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffwFXGPRDu4&feature=kp
If they win the current libel case and are awarded the proceeds of the book in damages, this would in effect leave him broke. In theory they could bring further action against him. But whats the point?
If he loses the libel action who will take any notice of what he says? Even his most diehard supporters will drift away, leaving him muttering "i coulda beeen someone, I coulda been a contender" into his cup of meths.
-
And if they lose? Or win and are awarded 1 Euro damages?
You know that I like to base my opinions on evidence...I think the damages could be substantial...
First amaral has tried to strike out maddie from the writ to reduce the damages...he wouldn't di this if damages were 1 Eeuro.
Second...the court have frozen substantial assets...they must envisage substantial damages...
what do you base your 1 Euro on...
-
You know that I like to base my opinions on evidence...I think the damages could be substantial...
First amaral has tried to strike out maddie from the writ to reduce the damages...he wouldn't di this if damages were 1 Eeuro.
Second...the court have frozen substantial assets...they must envisage substantial damages...
what do you base your 1 Euro on...
And The Court seized one of his houses to make up any shortfall.
-
Goncalo Amaral is perfectly entitled to 'sack' his legal representatives at ANY STAGE during proceedings, as in any other person !
Morons will continue to bleat on about this perfectly acceptable course as "stalling", the fact of the matter is that he has done absolutely nothing illegal or immoral, he is merely using legal devices available to him to secure the best possible defence against the case levelled against him !
Simple as...... Next ?
I totally agree...like the mccanns perfectly acceptable childcare arrangement
-
like kates perfectly legal decision not to answer the stupid questions...their decision to leave Portugal...the ta[as decision not to return
-
What I don't understand is why the McCanns were furious yesterday ... they were both fuming ! ( especially Kate, it appeared to me )
I mean, if you are all right and the reason Amaral pulled that stunt is because he is 'running scared' then you'd expect Kate and Gerry to have appeared relaxed and quietly pleased, wouldn't you ?
A three week postponement is nothing, afterall, and the inconvenience of getting to Portugal pales into insignificance when measured against the ( according to some here ) capitulation of their nemesis as indicated by his 'no-show'
So why were they so enraged ?
-
What I don't understand is why the McCanns were furious yesterday ... they were both fuming ! ( especially Kate, it appeared to me )
I mean, if you are all right and the reason Amaral pulled that stunt is because he is 'running scared' then you'd expect Kate and Gerry to have appeared relaxed and quietly pleased, wouldn't you ?
A three week postponement is nothing, afterall, and the inconvenience of getting to Portugal pales into insignificance when measured against the ( according to some here ) capitulation of their nemesis as indicated by his 'no-show'
So why were they so enraged ?
That's the nature of their personalities.
When they couldn't get their way, like little children they had tantrums.
-
What I don't understand is why the McCanns were furious yesterday ... they were both fuming ! ( especially Kate, it appeared to me )
I mean, if you are all right and the reason Amaral pulled that stunt is because he is 'running scared' then you'd expect Kate and Gerry to have appeared relaxed and quietly pleased, wouldn't you ?
A three week postponement is nothing, afterall, and the inconvenience of getting to Portugal pales into insignificance when measured against the ( according to some here ) capitulation of their nemesis as indicated by his 'no-show'
So why were they so enraged ?
the answer is obvious
-
That's the nature of their personalities.
When they couldn't get their way, like little children they had tantrums.
But their lawyer would have told them that this action by Amaral was a clear indication that he was desperate and merely trying to avoid the inevitable ( losing the case )
That would have pleased the McCanns surely ? ... being told that their arch enemy was running scared and that in a mere three weeks he was finally going to get what he deserved
Yet they were fuming
I don't get it
-
But their lawyer would have told them that this action by Amaral was a clear indication that he was desperate and merely trying to avoid the inevitable ( losing the case )
That would have pleased the McCanns surely ? ... being told that their arch enemy was running scared and that in a mere three weeks he was finally going to get what he deserved
Yet they were fuming
I don't get it
Exactly. >@@(*&) >@@(*&)
-
But their lawyer would have told them that this action by Amaral was a clear indication that he was desperate and merely trying to avoid the inevitable ( losing the case )
That would have pleased the McCanns surely ? ... being told that their arch enemy was running scared and that in a mere three weeks he was finally going to get what he deserved
Yet they were fuming
I don't get it
It's because they had been made fools of.
-
But their lawyer would have told them that this action by Amaral was a clear indication that he was desperate and merely trying to avoid the inevitable ( losing the case )
That would have pleased the McCanns surely ? ... being told that their arch enemy was running scared and that in a mere three weeks he was finally going to get what he deserved
Yet they were fuming
I don't get it
So you'd be pleased if you had flown to another country to have your day in court, at considerable expense and inconvenience, only to be told (once again - remember it's happened before) that you had had a wasted trip and would have to do it all again in a few weeks time? Even if you believed the reason for the delay was the cowardice of your opponent surely this would not be pleasing to you? I'm sure the McCanns are under no illusions that Portuguese justice will certainly find in their favour anyway.
-
It's because they had been made fools of.
I disagree with that ... yes they were abused in the most cynical and calculated fashion ... but there was only one fool made on Monday, and that was Dr Amaral.
IMO he scored an enormous own goal and by his behaviour lost the remnants of any credibility he might have had.
-
I disagree with that ... yes they were abused in the most cynical and calculated fashion ... but there was only one fool made on Monday, and that was Dr Amaral.
IMO he scored an enormous own goal and by his behaviour lost the remnants of any credibility he might have had.
In your opinion.
Good to see how well and stress-free Amaral looks in this video from yesterday AFAIAAW.
http://www.rtp.pt/noticias/index.php?article=745785&tm=8&layout=122&visual=61
-
What I don't understand is why the McCanns were furious yesterday ... they were both fuming ! ( especially Kate, it appeared to me )
I mean, if you are all right and the reason Amaral pulled that stunt is because he is 'running scared' then you'd expect Kate and Gerry to have appeared relaxed and quietly pleased, wouldn't you ?
A three week postponement is nothing, afterall, and the inconvenience of getting to Portugal pales into insignificance when measured against the ( according to some here ) capitulation of their nemesis as indicated by his 'no-show'
So why were they so enraged ?
No, I would not expect them to feel relaxed. I know how precious time is when you have a family, when you have a career. I would be livid if this disgraceful specimen of Portuguese manhood deliberately played this game with my time.
You don't understand why somebody gets annoyed when somebody [...edit...] completely and deliberately wastes two or more days of your time and cannot be bothered to give a reason for that deliberate wasting of your time. Not to mention the court's time, the lawyer's time, the other defendants' time etc.
I really do feel sorry for you if you are not even able to empathise in a situation as blindingly obvious as that one from yesterday morning.
-
[quote removed]
Amaral simply played a very deliberate and very cynical move to delay the [...removed speculation...]. Nobody has managed to come up with any other motive for his disgusting action which wasted so many peoples' time yesterday.
And nobody has managed to explain yet why the lawyer who claims to have been sacked without reason on Friday was in fact working on behalf of Amaral yesterday morning.
[edited]
-
No, I would not expect them to feel relaxed. I know how precious time is when you have a family, when you have a career. I would be livid if this disgraceful specimen of Portuguese manhood deliberately played this game with my time.
You don't understand why somebody gets annoyed when somebody [...edited...] completely and deliberately wastes two or more days of your time and cannot be bothered to give a reason for that deliberate wasting of your time. Not to mention the court's time, the lawyer's time, the other defendants' time etc.
I really do feel sorry for you if you are not even able to empathise in a situation as blindingly obvious as that one from yesterday morning.
Can I point you to the thread about those '4 postponements' gilet ?
-
What I don't understand is why the McCanns were furious yesterday ... they were both fuming ! ( especially Kate, it appeared to me )
I mean, if you are all right and the reason Amaral pulled that stunt is because he is 'running scared' then you'd expect Kate and Gerry to have appeared relaxed and quietly pleased, wouldn't you ?
A three week postponement is nothing, afterall, and the inconvenience of getting to Portugal pales into insignificance when measured against the ( according to some here ) capitulation of their nemesis as indicated by his 'no-show'
So why were they so enraged ?
Also it makes no difference to the case as the rulings by the Judge are already in hand and will be discussed now on 8th July. The only difference is Amaral will have a new lawyer to hand in his defence. Now that is the difference, perhaps he wasnt happen in the way his lawyer was going to deal with that.
Furious McCanns poor McCanns, its makes me laugh all this fuss over child care, hey ho, now if they had done that on the 3rd May they would not be suing anyone and poor Madeleine would be at home.
They have really done it now though. There behavior especially KMC outside that courtroom has opened up a can of worms.
People are now reading things that havent been in media, like keys to churches, and kids left for 3 hours at night alone.
Yes obviously they would have been a tad fed up but they should have gone home and kept quiet. Its not like they cant afford the flights or a one night stay in a hotel. Hell I could afford to do that lol.
No they made a huge mistake.
Good article on http://www.mccannfiles.com/id232.html, written by Nigel Moore.
-
You're sure I'm right that you and your fellow doubters are obsessives about "Justice For Maddie" despite the fact that she is not your child, and none of you has any claim over her whatsoever? Well, good at least we can agree on something!
I believe in justice per se.
In this case the recipient of that justice just happens to be Madeleine.
-
As I said on another thread and as another poster has said on here; if what Amaral did was within the rules then it is OK whether we like it or not. Using your "ace" analogy if Amaral's actions caused the trumping of a McCann court card then the McCanns should have counted the cards better.
As I have said before...if you accept that argument then..
McCANNS not answering questions
leaving Portugal
not returning for recon...
all perfectly OK
-
I believe in justice per se.
In this case the recipient of that justice just happens to be Madeleine.
same with me maddie was a child kate and gerry are two adults who knew right from wrong and still at least neglected them by leaving them alone when it is illegal to leave children under 12 alone in most countries
-
As for the McCanns stating that the libel trial has been going on for 5 years, they seem to forget that the book ban was a separate trial. The book ban was made in September 2009 and was finally lifted in October 2010, a little more than a year later. Later, the McCanns appeal to the Supreme Court was rejected in January 2011. The question of the book ban was settled then.
The trial for damages in the civil court began on 12 September 2013 and it is now June 2014. Where are the 5 years for this case? Have I lived in a parallel universe? The only serious delay was when the parents asked for a postponement in order to obtain an out of court settlement.
-
How long did it take to get to court. Is it 5 years since they went into litigation mode over this issue?
-
As for the McCanns stating that the libel trial has been going on for 5 years, they seem to forget that the book ban was a separate trial. The book ban was made in September 2009 and was finally lifted in October 2010, a little more than a year later. Later, the McCanns appeal to the Supreme Court was rejected in January 2011. The question of the book ban was settled then.
The trial for damages in the civil court began on 12 September 2013 and it is now June 2014. Where are the 5 years for this case? Have I lived in a parallel universe? The only serious delay was when the parents asked for a postponement in order to obtain an out of court settlement.
Only a disingenuous berk would see these court cases as completely unlinked. A reasonable person would see that they are all part and parcel of the same action, which is to correct the grave injustice done to Madeleine McCann and her parents by an ex-cop who cashed in on her disappearance. It has taken 5 years so far in the quest for justice, hopefully not another 5 years until Amaral has the bottle to see the case through to the end.
-
The libel action started in 2009 with the ex parte action to (a) remove the book from sale to limit further damage and (b) ringfence the proceeds of the book pending the result of the libel action.
-
[quote removed ]
Please then, let us know exactly which delays there were and how were the McCanns inconvenienced?
-
Please then, let us know exactly which delays there were and how were the McCanns inconvenienced?
First delay to the libel trial itself was on the 8th September 2012
-
The Libel action between the McCanns and Amaral can be traced back and documented to 9 September 2009. That is the date of the first court documents.
-
The Libel action between the McCanns and Amaral can be traced back and documented to 9 September 2009. That is the date of the first court documents.
Oh My, Nearly five years. The fact that The Portuguese Judicial System has been pissing about since then is only aggravated by Amaral himself.
-
[quote removed by editor]
Certainly whatever happened to Madeleine McCann should not have happened but given the level of lawlessness which we now know was happening in the environs of Praia Da Luz it was only a matter of time until it happened to some other little girl either by accident or design.
Why not try to stick to the topic of the thread and discuss why Dr Amaral seems to be so desperate to spin this trial out for as long as possible.
Obviously there have been times when delays were not entirely due to him as on the occasion when his lawyer refused to continue until he was paid what was owing.
In my opinion if he was sure of his position he would not have used the bizarre ploy of dismissing his lawyer at the eleventh hour when all that remained were the closing statements.
So I think he is putting off the inevitable.
I think he knows the libel case has been won by the Drs McCann.
When that happens I think a closer look will be taken at the man and his works and I think he is worried about that scrutiny.
-
As for stalling tactics, how about Isabel Duarte taking months to return the books, after the appeals court decision, to the publisher. She had to be forced by the court.
-
To get back on topic..he is stalling because he knows he has lost the case and is trying to put off the humiliation the verdict will heap on him...I expect him to try more delaying tactics
-
Certainly whatever happened to Madeleine McCann should not have happened but given the level of lawlessness which we now know was happening in the environs of Praia Da Luz it was only a matter of time until it happened to some other little girl either by accident or design.
Why not try to stick to the topic of the thread and discuss why Dr Amaral seems to be so desperate to spin this trial out for as long as possible.
Obviously there have been times when delays were not entirely due to him as on the occasion when his lawyer refused to continue until he was paid what was owing.
In my opinion if he was sure of his position he would not have used the bizarre ploy of dismissing his lawyer at the eleventh hour when all that remained were the closing statements.
So I think he is putting off the inevitable.
I think he knows the libel case has been won by the Drs McCann.
When that happens I think a closer look will be taken at the man and his works and I think he is worried about that scrutiny.
Whatever GA's reasons to sack his lawyer at this late stage,....... it was his right to do so and as he's shown himself to act with dignity at every stage of the trial....
it's only right imo that he offered up the relevant documentation to the court at the appropriate time and did not hang around to make a fuss or to give an interview.
unlike some....
-
As for stalling tactics, how about Isabel Duarte taking months to return the books, after the appeals court decision, to the publisher. She had to be forced by the court.
In which case there will be a record of the court proceedings to force return of the books. Perhaps you could provide that to back up your statement?
as far as I recollect, following Amarals successful appeal the books were made available but he failed to collect them for some months.
-
Whatever GA's reasons to sack his lawyer at this late stage,....... it was his right to do so and as he's shown himself to act with dignity at every stage of the trial....
it's only right imo that he offered up the relevant documentation to the court at the appropriate time and did not hang around to make a fuss or to give an interview.
unlike some....
Do you know if the other defendants and their lawyers were present in the court on Monday?
I think you are blind to the effect that Dr Amaral's behaviour is having on the reputation of Portugal's Justice System and on the reputation of Portugal as a whole.
Almost single-handedly he is turning Portugal into the laughing stock of the world.
It was a gross discourtesy to allow the Drs McCann to travel to Portugal, it was a gross discourtesy to the court to disrupt proceedings on the final day.
I wonder that you do not recognise how bizarre his actions actually were ... dignified most certainly is not the word I would use to describe them.
What is dignified about running away like a naughty schoolboy?
-
It seems pretty clear that Amaral is reluctant to face the court.
It does beg the question - why is that?
-
I suppose we will just have to wait and see.
-
Do you know if the other defendants and their lawyers were present in the court on Monday?
I think you are blind to the effect that Dr Amaral's behaviour is having on the reputation of Portugal's Justice System and on the reputation of Portugal as a whole.
Almost single-handedly he is turning Portugal into the laughing stock of the world.
It was a gross discourtesy to allow the Drs McCann to travel to Portugal, it was a gross discourtesy to the court to disrupt proceedings on the final day.
I wonder that you do not recognise how bizarre his actions actually were ... dignified most certainly is not the word I would use to describe them.
What is dignified about running away like a naughty schoolboy?
To be honest Brietta I doubt very much that anyone of any intellectual standing consider what is happening in this isolated case as having any bearing at all on the standing of Portugal.
Of course I am excluding Sun/Star/Mirror/Mail readers in the above.
-
IMO Sacking his lawyer seemed rather an insulting thing for Amaral to do to him at this late stage,.
If I was his lawyer I wouldn't be very pleased. It's hardly complimentary to his legal skills to be so publically dismissed by his client is it?
-
IMO Sacking his lawyer seemed rather an insulting thing for Amaral to do to him at this late stage,.
If I was his lawyer I wouldn't be very pleased. It's hardly complimentary to his legal skills to be so publically dismissed by his client is it?
I expect he will get over it. A good lawyer will not get emotionally involved in any case (it clouds the judgement). I would hazard a guess that his main concern is getting paid.
I hope Amaral has some funds. His next one will want paying upfront, if hes got any sense.
Otherwise he is up sh1t creek
-
IMO Mr Amaral is justified in using every legal trick in the book to fight the concerted attack against him.
-
IMO Mr Amaral is justified in using every legal trick in the book to fight the concerted attack against him.
so you accept hes using tricks
-
IMO Mr Amaral is justified in using every legal trick in the book to fight the concerted attack against him.
and the mccans are equally justified in using the law to counter the attacks against them
-
I don't think there can be any justification for using tricks to wriggle off the hook of your lies.
That's what we've seen from Amaral, throughout the farce of this shambles of a 'libel trial' ...
-
IMO Mr Amaral is justified in using every legal trick in the book to fight the concerted attack against him.
I think his supporters did not expect him to have to sink so low as to use legal tricks to escape his fate..he really is showing how desperate his position has become
-
I cant help but feel there is more humiliation and ridicule on the way for amaral
-
I think his supporters did not expect him to have to sink so low as to use legal tricks to escape his fate..he really is showing how desperate his position has become
You all seem to forget that Gonçalo Amaral won the battle of the book ban! The McCanns lost that battle and the appeals court ruled that they were not libelled and that their rights were not infringed upon.
-
You all seem to forget that Gonçalo Amaral won the battle of the book ban! The McCanns lost that battle and the appeals court ruled that they were not libelled and that their rights were not infringed upon.
So we are all dreaming and The Libel Trial isn't happening at all. Thank God for that. Amaral hasn't made a plonker of himself after all.
-
So we are all dreaming and The Libel Trial isn't happening at all. Thank God for that. Amaral hasn't made a plonker of himself after all.
This trial is about damages.
-
This trial is about damages.
Damages for what?
-
Damages for what?
something is happening here and you don't know what it is
do you, Mr. Jones?
-
something is happening here and you don't know what it is
do you, Mr. Jones?
Spoken like a true James Bond villan! So, tell me what IS happening here?
-
what did you think of kates meltdown in front of the media not very doctor like is it and all she cared about was she had to make childcare arragments for the twins too bad she didnt think of that 7 years ago she wouldnt be in the mess she is in now
I thought it very interesting that Kate spoke over Gerry for once...Oh that must have gone down like a lead balloon. WTF. @)(++(*
On a serious note though, I would have been pissed if I had travelled out to a hearing in Portugal only to find out when I arrived that it had been effectively postponed.
-
I thought it very interesting that Kate spoke over Gerry for once...Oh that must have gone down like a lead balloon. WTF. @)(++(*
On a serious note though, I would have been pissed if I had travelled out to a hearing in Portugal only to find out when I arrived that it had been effectively postponed.
gerry was mad as about that !!!! and yeah in soome ways i can understand why the mcanns were annoyed but IMO they should be using technology anyway alot of stuff here in australia is done via skype could they have done that??
-
so you accept hes using tricks
I don't know what the reason for firing lawyer was, I would assume it was genuine.
-
and the mccanns are equally justified in using the law to counter the attacks against them
Yes each of those three people as individuals has the right to be protected by the law.
-
Goncalo Amaral has now stated that he does not intend to publish the 2nd book he has penned on the Madeleine case. In the words of Marjorie Dawes "Yeah, but how does it end?"
-
...its rather odd that a sacked lawyer colludes with the defendant by going to court to explain that he has been sacked and the defendant cannot therefore continue. We will soon see what pans out.
Not in the least, it is quite normal for a lawyer to attend court to advise that they have been discharged by their client..its called good practise and showing respect for the court.
-
There may have been something genius about that. He's certainly not as nervous as his opponents seem to be..
-
It was well within the remit of Goncalo Amaral to dispense of his legal representation, nothing untoward, he obviously felt that he wasn't benefiting of best defence !
He sacked his lawyer on the night of the 13th, the court did not attend until Monday.
The McCanns would have had to still travel surely as the judge could have still ruled her decision coudlnt she. It was up to the JUDGE to decide what the next course of action would be.
I agree OP yes he had every right.
Its purely hysterics by the pros trying to make him about to be some lunatic.
No one wins this case. The McCanns actually have done themsevles more harm then good with this case.
People i know who didnt follow are now angry at how greedy the seem and not only that how dare that women (is what they are saying) moan about CHILD CARE now when she didnt bother about it 3rd May.
The tide is turning either way.
Amaral hasnt any money anyway and lives a frugal life as his assets have been frozen since 2009. Once this is over he is looses, I expect that other book will go on the shelves lol.
-
I love the way people throw in phrases like 'disgraced ex-cop' or 'convicted criminal' at every opportunity, as if it has any relevance to the issue in hand @)(++(*
What it does show is how they have developed a personal dislike for anyone who contradicts the McCann version of events.
Chill - your comments have no relevance in the real world.
Why would such facts be irrelevant to the question at hand?
He is being sued to for libel.
If he can be established as a duplicitous liar, the burden on the McCanns to prove their case might be that little bit easier ...
-
Why would such facts be irrelevant to the question at hand?
He is being sued to for libel.
If he can be established as a duplicitous liar, the burden on the McCanns to prove their case might be that little bit easier ...
I don't suppose the judge will be paying attention to internet tittle-tattle.
-
I don't suppose the judge will be paying attention to internet tittle-tattle.
I doubt if the judge will take cognisance of anything which was not put in front of her in open court. I get the impression she was none too impressed with some of the evidence given particularly when she commented on the book not living up to the claims on its cover.
Having to reschedule the date for the closing arguments and the victim impact statements won't have made a particularly good impression either. In saying that I am sure she will be aware of the undercurrents directed against Madeleine and her family.
For example, I doubt if she will be unaware of Dr Amaral's recent interview in which he did himself no favours if the translations I have read are anything to go by. The recent graffiti episode in Praia Da Luz cannot have escaped the judge's attention and will serve only to enable Isabel Duarte's argument to be appreciated with more clarity.
Dr Amaral has seen the writing on the wall and believes he is going to lose this case and sees postponement as an option till something better turns up. Obviously the expensive excursion into Madeleine's Ward of Court status failed to achieve the desired effect, so a dig in till next September or October - which may be on the cards if his new lawyer is given time to prepare - was the only ace he had up his sleeve.
-
I doubt if the judge will take cognisance of anything which was not put in front of her in open court. I get the impression she was none too impressed with some of the evidence given particularly when she commented on the book not living up to the claims on its cover.
Having to reschedule the date for the closing arguments and the victim impact statements won't have made a particularly good impression either. In saying that I am sure she will be aware of the undercurrents directed against Madeleine and her family.
For example, I doubt if she will be unaware of Dr Amaral's recent interview in which he did himself no favours if the translations I have read are anything to go by. The recent graffiti episode in Praia Da Luz cannot have escaped the judge's attention and will serve only to enable Isabel Duarte's argument to be appreciated with more clarity.
Dr Amaral has seen the writing on the wall and believes he is going to lose this case and sees postponement as an option till something better turns up. Obviously the expensive excursion into Madeleine's Ward of Court status failed to achieve the desired effect, so a dig in till next September or October - which may be on the cards if his new lawyer is given time to prepare - was the only ace he had up his sleeve.
Sounds like it, Brieta. Amaral only had to wait thirty days to see if his WoC lark was going to work, so perhaps he already knows that it won't.
Meanwhile he is hoping that a body will be found, believing that this will make him right. Such a pity that he pursued the wrong people. But that won't matter to him.
-
I doubt if the judge will take cognisance of anything which was not put in front of her in open court. I get the impression she was none too impressed with some of the evidence given particularly when she commented on the book not living up to the claims on its cover.
Having to reschedule the date for the closing arguments and the victim impact statements won't have made a particularly good impression either. In saying that I am sure she will be aware of the undercurrents directed against Madeleine and her family.
For example, I doubt if she will be unaware of Dr Amaral's recent interview in which he did himself no favours if the translations I have read are anything to go by. The recent graffiti episode in Praia Da Luz cannot have escaped the judge's attention and will serve only to enable Isabel Duarte's argument to be appreciated with more clarity.
Dr Amaral has seen the writing on the wall and believes he is going to lose this case and sees postponement as an option till something better turns up. Obviously the expensive excursion into Madeleine's Ward of Court status failed to achieve the desired effect, so a dig in till next September or October - which may be on the cards if his new lawyer is given time to prepare - was the only ace he had up his sleeve.
That the McCanns chose to appeal her decision with regard to their victim impact states won't have impressed her much either nor indeed the McCanns grandstanding on the court steps or indeed their blatant distortion of the number of times Amaral, personally, has disrupted the trial. Indeed as one of those 'disruptions' was as a result of a personal matter that she had attend to she may not be very happy at all.
-
That the McCanns chose to appeal her decision with regard to their victim impact states won't have impressed her much either nor indeed the McCanns grandstanding on the court steps or indeed their blatant distortion of the number of times Amaral, personally, has disrupted the trial. Indeed as one of those 'disruptions' was as a result of a personal matter that she had attend to she may not be very happy at all.
I think the judge will fully understand the frustrations of the mccanns having to deal with the disgraced amaral....I'm just so looking forward to the judges decision...its clear what it will be
-
That the McCanns chose to appeal her decision with regard to their victim impact states won't have impressed her much either nor indeed the McCanns grandstanding on the court steps or indeed their blatant distortion of the number of times Amaral, personally, has disrupted the trial. Indeed as one of those 'disruptions' was as a result of a personal matter that she had attend to she may not be very happy at all.
Appealed her decision? That's what people do in Court Rooms. Like Amaral Postponed.
... removed inappropriate comment ...
-
That the McCanns chose to appeal her decision with regard to their victim impact states won't have impressed her much either nor indeed the McCanns grandstanding on the court steps or indeed their blatant distortion of the number of times Amaral, personally, has disrupted the trial. Indeed as one of those 'disruptions' was as a result of a personal matter that she had attend to she may not be very happy at all.
I think the judge will respect the fact that the Drs McCann exercised their legal right to appeal her decision using the appropriate channels and it probably didn't come as much of a surprise to her that they did so.
What might puzzle her is that Dr Amaral did not take advantage of the same legal process to have his day in court too, instead of employing cheap and nasty tricks to disrupt proceedings.
-
Appealed her decision? That's what people do in Court Rooms. Like Amaral Postponed.
The rest of your post is bullshit.
So the McCanns didn't try to blatantly misrepresent the reason for the delays ?
And the one session that was abandoned due to a personal problem of the judge's didn't happen ?
-
I think the judge will respect the fact that the Drs McCann exercised their legal right to appeal her decision using the appropriate channels and it probably didn't come as much of a surprise to her that they did so.
What might puzzle her is that Dr Amaral did not take advantage of the same legal process to have his day in court too, instead of employing cheap and nasty tricks to disrupt proceedings.
And as Mr Amaral exercised his legal right to dismiss his legal representative at any time in the trial by the same token she should also respect that decision.
-
In Portuguese law, is there any possibility that Amaral can represent himself in court, and give his own summing up ?
Does anyone know ?
-
In Portuguese law, is there any possibility that Amaral can represent himself in court, and give his own summing up ?
Does anyone know ?
I think have read somewhere that he can't Icabod but I've read so much over the last few days I could be wrong.
-
It was well within the remit of Goncalo Amaral to dispense of his legal representation, nothing untoward, he obviously felt that he wasn't benefiting of best defence !
No doubt, but why suddenly decide to present that on the last day of the trial? Did the lawyer have any other duty that day other than to sum up his client's case?
-
In Portuguese law, is there any possibility that Amaral can represent himself in court, and give his own summing up ?
Does anyone know ?
I do hope so. He is a Doctor of Law after all. And perhaps Bennett could help him get into even more trouble.
-
The question is..why is amaral stalling...which few appear to want to address... I think he has lost and is trying to delay the inevitable humiliation
-
The question is..why is amaral stalling...which few appear to want to address... I think he has lost and is trying to delay the inevitable humiliation
He is doing a pretty good job on himself at the moment.
-
I think the judge will fully understand the frustrations of the mccanns having to deal with the disgraced amaral....I'm just so looking forward to the judges decision...its clear what it will be
So you would like it to be.
Doesn't make true. 8((()*/
-
The question is..why is amaral stalling...which few appear to want to address... I think he has lost and is trying to delay the inevitable humiliation
Let's wait for the judgment and the following inevitable appeals.
-
The question is..why is amaral stalling...which few appear to want to address... I think he has lost and is trying to delay the inevitable humiliation
I suppose he must have some reason to fire his lawyer at the 12th hour, when all it seems that he had left to do was to summarise his client's case.
Was this a sudden dissatisfication with his services?
How would a new lawyer be able to do so without having been involved until now? Or is this part of some last minute bright idea?
-
And as Mr Amaral exercised his legal right to dismiss his legal representative at any time in the trial by the same token she should also respect that decision.
I have never disputed Dr Amaral's right to dismiss his lawyer, he certainly has sacked plenty of them.
I just wonder at the manner and the timing in which he did so on this occasion. IMO he showed contempt for the court.
-
I have never disputed Dr Amaral's right to dismiss his lawyer, he certainly has sacked plenty of them.
I just wonder at the manner and the timing in which he did so on this occasion. IMO he showed contempt for the court.
It would appear that the Court does not agree with you.
-
I have never disputed Dr Amaral's right to dismiss his lawyer, he certainly has sacked plenty of them.
I just wonder at the manner and the timing in which he did so on this occasion. IMO he showed contempt for the court.
AFAIAW Amaral has dismissed two lawyers so can we please get this in to perspective.
And as to him showing contempt for the court, just because you don't know the reason for his actions doesn't mean that he didn't have one and one, it seems that the judge was satisfied with.
-
Gonçalo Amaral was within his rights to dismiss his lawyer and I think that people, before bashing him, wait until you know the reason. I'm sure that the judge has held many other trials where lawyers have been sacked.
-
Gonçalo Amaral was within his rights to dismiss his lawyer and I think that people, before bashing him, wait until you know the reason. I'm sure that the judge has held many other trials where lawyers have been sacked.
we all know the reason..hes running scared...ii see you take exception to posters bashing amaral but are quite happy to bash the mccanns yourself...typical hypocrisy
-
we all know the reason..hes running scared...ii see you take exception to posters bashing amaral but are quite happy to bash the mccanns yourself...typical hypocrisy
Think what you want!
-
Gonçalo Amaral was within his rights to dismiss his lawyer and I think that people, before bashing him, wait until you know the reason. I'm sure that the judge has held many other trials where lawyers have been sacked.
You seem to recognise that Dr Amaral exercised his right to dismiss his lawyer and I doubt if we will ever know the reason. I imagine his lawyer will be bound by client confidentiality; but he is on record as saying he doesn't know anyway.
Although he must be annoyed as such a last minute public sacking is an implicit accusation of his professional incompetence. In the circumstances I think this makes it even more extraordinary that he delayed his departure to argue his ex-client's case before the judge.
You are capable of recognising the legal right of Dr Amaral to dismiss his lawyer at the concluding day of a long running trial, and you are prepared to argue that position.
Conversely you are incapable of recognising the legal right of Dr Kate McCann to refuse to answer questions on the advice of her lawyer and you are prepared to argue that position.
Can't you see the irony of that?
-
You seem to recognise that Dr Amaral exercised his right to dismiss his lawyer and I doubt if we will ever know the reason. I imagine his lawyer will be bound by client confidentiality; but he is on record as saying he doesn't know anyway.
Although he must be annoyed as such a last minute public sacking is an implicit accusation of his professional incompetence. In the circumstances I think this makes it even more extraordinary that he delayed his departure to argue his ex-client's case before the judge.
You are capable of recognising the legal right of Dr Amaral to dismiss his lawyer at the concluding day of a long running trial, and you are prepared to argue that position.
Conversely you are incapable of recognising the legal right of Dr Kate McCann to refuse to answer questions on the advice of her lawyer and you are prepared to argue that position.
Can't you see the irony of that?
'Conversely you are incapable of recognising the legal right of Dr Kate McCann to refuse to answer questions on the advice of her lawyer and you are prepared to argue that position.'
Yes, to avoid contradictions with her husbands testimony.
-
'Conversely you are incapable of recognising the legal right of Dr Kate McCann to refuse to answer questions on the advice of her lawyer and you are prepared to argue that position.'
Yes, to avoid contradictions with her husbands testimony.
Predictable - but actually no argument at all to justify one position and not the other.
Either one has legal rights which can be exercised with impunity. In other words what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
However when it comes to Dr Kate McCann - she can do no right, in the opinion of some.
When it comes to Dr Amaral - he can do no wrong, in the opinion of the same people.
A stance which is incompatible with the rule of law and the rights of the individual.
-
Predictable - but actually no argument at all to justify one position and not the other.
Either one has legal rights which can be exercised with impunity. In other words what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
However when it comes to Dr Kate McCann - she can do no right, in the opinion of some.
When it comes to Dr Amaral - he can do no wrong, in the opinion of the same people.
A stance which is incompatible with the rule of law and the rights of the individual.
They are 2 very different situations. I can understand many reasons why GA would sack his lawyer that would help him win his case, I can't see a single reason why KM not answering the questions would help find Maddie.
-
They are 2 very different situations. I can understand many reasons why GA would sack his lawyer that would help him win his case, I can't see a single reason why KM not answering the questions would help find Maddie.
Could you share a couple of the reasons where sacking his lawyer will help amaral win his case
-
Could you share a couple of the reasons where sacking his lawyer will help amaral win his case
His lawyer wanted to go down a route he didn't think would help.
His lawyer wanted to cut a good deal with the McCann team.
Another Lawyer suggested a better approach.
Now tell me how KM's silence helped the search.
-
His lawyer wanted to go down a route he didn't think would help.
His lawyer wanted to cut a good deal with the McCann team.
Another Lawyer suggested a better approach.
Now tell me how KM's silence helped the search.
again someone having a proper debate....
I think your first two reasons show the lawyer thought he couldn't win and I agree with that...of course it is remotely possible that amaral has found a new lawyer with a new approach but I seriously doubt it...
I never said kates silence would help the search because the pj were not looking...but I don't think it harmed the search in any way...I think the mccannns themselves have helped the search by getting sy involved
-
again someone having a proper debate....
I think your first two reasons show the lawyer thought he couldn't win and I agree with that...of course it is remotely possible that amaral has found a new lawyer with a new approach but I seriously doubt it...
I never said kates silence would help the search because the pj were not looking...but I don't think it harmed the search in any way...I think the mccannns themselves have helped the search by getting sy involved
The mccans didn't.
Rebekah Brooks did.
-
Amaral is The Defendant, you know.
And what would have been the point of The McCanns both appearing? Although I think that one of them was present at most hearings.
As for The Questions and The Reconstruction. No one in their right mind would have answered the questions put to Kate. And neither of them refused to attend The Reconstruction. Neither of them were guilty of anything illegal.
PS. Can someone explain exactly what Protagonist means?
First off, the pursuer(s) are as much obliged to be in attendance as the defendant.
Secondly, neither of them were present at the vast majority of the hearings.
Thirdly, only someone with something to hide would have refused to answer all the PJ questions. Gerry answered them so why didn't Kate?
Fourthly, along with the other protagonists they never attended the reconstruction.
Protagonist > a leading character
-
First off, the pursuer(s) are as much obliged to be in attendance as the defendant.
Secondly, neither of them were present at the vast majority of the hearings.
Thirdly, only someone with something to hide would have refused to answer all the PJ questions. Gerry answered them so why didn't Kate?
Fourthly, along with the other protagonists they never attended the reconstruction.
Protagonist > a leading character
they don't need to be present..and they are not obliged to be present....I saw one session where Gerry made the trip and the whole day was cancelled
as regards not answering questions..your remark is totally absurd ..colin stagg answered no questions ans was innocent
they were absolutely right not to attend the reconstruction
-
Gonçalo Amaral was within his rights to dismiss his lawyer and I think that people, before bashing him, wait until you know the reason. I'm sure that the judge has held many other trials where lawyers have been sacked.
Well, let's make one thing clear - you don't sack a lawyer if things are going your way @)(++(*
-
Well, let's make one thing clear - you don't sack a lawyer if things are going your way @)(++(*
of course you don't..and how many lawyers has amaral had up to now
-
of course you don't..and how many lawyers has amaral had up to now
We shall see on that one.
-
We shall see on that one.
we will see what his next delaying tactic is...new lawyer needs more time to prepare...remember you heard it here first..how long could he delay for...who knows
-
we will see what his next delaying tactic is...new lawyer needs more time to prepare...remember you heard it here first..how long could he delay for...who knows
The mccanns have delayed too.
-
The McCanns were never called to attend at any time. They just showed up...So why the moaning about being inconvenienced?
similar situation would be: wedding crashers complaining they didn't get a chunk of cake- well they were not invited!
They asked to give an statement which may provide further evidence after all other evidence has been heard, a change in the Law allows for this. The Judge allowed it- it is NOT the same as a victim statement as it is here in the UK. I am lead to believe.
-
Could it be that Amaral is delaying the decision hoping that things would change in the UK re Presumption of Death Act, i.e that the new rules might presume Madeleine dead even if the parents don't apply for it?
The Presumption of Death Act, due to be reformed in October following a campaign, is based on a seven-year rule.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/maddie-mccanns-parents-we-wont-3459122#ixzz35JR9vADq
-
Is this what Amaral is planning?
What if someone else makes an application another person does not agree with?
Where someone else has applied for a declaration of presumed death, or for a variation order,
you may intervene in the proceedings if you are the missing person's spouse, civil partner, parent,
child or sibling. If you are not the missing person's spouse, civil partner, parent, child or sibling,
you must ask the court for permission to intervene.
When will the Act come into force?
Although the Presumption of Death Act 2013 has been enacted, it has not yet been brought into
force. The Government said in March 2013 that the Ministry of Justice and the General Register
Office were starting work on creating the necessary rules and regulations to bring the scheme
into force. It cannot be brought into force until these rules and regulations are ready. Missing
People does not know, therefore, when it will come into force but is hopeful this will be soon.
Missing_People_Policy_Briefing_Presumption_of_Death_Act_2013.pdf
-
Is this what Amaral is planning?
Missing_People_Policy_Briefing_Presumption_of_Death_Act_2013.pdf
IMO this is not irrelevant to the stalling.
In fact is the most plausible explanation
-
Amaral may also want to use the arrest of baby Daniel's mother for simulating an abduction as another example of parental involvement in a disappearance.
From tomorrow's edition of CdM
http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dcorreia%2Bda%2Bmanha%26biw%3D1366%26bih%3D669
Amazing just how many of these terrible parenting incidents coincide with the libel trial hearings.
-
Amaral may also want to use the arrest of baby Daniel's mother for simulating an abduction as another example of parental involvement in a disappearance.
From tomorrow's edition of CdM
http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dcorreia%2Bda%2Bmanha%26biw%3D1366%26bih%3D669
Amazing just how many of these terrible parenting incidents coincide with the libel trial hearings.
That woman was chewing chewing gum while reporting about her son's disappearance.
-
The mccanns have delayed too.
When, exactly?
Unless you are referring to the postponement to see if an out of court settlement could be agreed?
Which is an obligation on all those engaged in civil litigation to keep court time to a minimum. And whichever side initiates that request, it is plaintiffs who must request the stay for obvious reasons.
-
Who is going to apply for this Presumption of Death Certificate? Goncalo Amaral? Anthony Bennett? I would seriously like to see them try.
One of them would be laughed out of court and the other one would wind up in prison. I will leave you all to decide which is which.
-
Is this what Amaral is planning?
Missing_People_Policy_Briefing_Presumption_of_Death_Act_2013.pdf
I would not be in the least bit surprised.
8(8-))
-
I would not be in the least bit surprised.
8(8-))
Nor me. It has been known for some time that something like this was going on. Someone has been feeding Amaral false information about The Presumption of Death Act.
In this case only The McCanns would be allowed to apply for this, and they ain't going to.
-
Nor me. It has been known for some time that something like this was going on. Someone has been feeding Amaral false information about The Presumption of Death Act.
In this case only The McCanns would be allowed to apply for this, and they in't going to.
Would it even apply retrospectively? Very few laws do.
-
Would it even apply retrospectively? Very few laws do.
I don't think it's even been passed yet. But Retrospective wouldn't alter the situation anyway. You would have to have a very good reason for applying if you weren't family. And i don't think Amaral's Libel Trial would count.
Mind you, I suppose he could try it on by trying to use the essence of seven years without a body being found. But that won't wash. Not even in Portugal.
-
I don't think it's even been passed yet. But Retrospective wouldn't alter the situation anyway. You would have to have a very good reason for applying if you weren't family. And i don't think Amaral's Libel Trial would count.
Mind you, I suppose he could try it on by trying to use the essence of seven years without a body being found. But that won't wash. Not even in Portugal.
So where is Madeleine Eleanor ???
-
So where is Madeleine Eleanor ???
I don't know, Stephen. I wish I did. But Amaral is making another pillock of himself by spouting off on Television about this.
According to him it is only five years in Portugal, but I have still to see any evidence that parents in Portugal can be forced to accept this on the say so of someone else.
But why is Amaral pursuing this if not to in part explain his stalling of The Libel Trial. Mayhap his WoC ploy didn't work.
-
I don't know, Stephen. I wish I did. But Amaral is making another pillock of himself by spouting off on Television about this.
According to him it is only five years in Portugal, but I have still to see any evidence that parents in Portugal can be forced to accept this on the say so of someone else.
But why is Amaral pursuing this if not to in part explain his stalling of The Libel Trial. Mayhap his WoC ploy didn't work.
So how long will it take to convince you, that if no trace of Madeleine is found, despite the worldwide publicity, she won't be found alive ?
-
So how long will it take to convince you, that if no trace of Madeleine is found, despite the worldwide publicity, she won't be found alive ?
A very long time, Stephen, if ever. My stance is that if no body or evidence of a body is found then Madeleine could still be alive.
-
A very long time, Stephen, if ever. My stance is that if no body or evidence of a body is found then Madeleine could still be alive.
So when will the tax payer stop funding the investigation ?
-
So when will the tax payer stop funding the investigation ?
I don't know that either, Stephen. Let's hope Scotland Yard find something.
But I have no doubt that The McCanns will go on searching, even if The Investigation ends.
-
So how long will it take to convince you, that if no trace of Madeleine is found, despite the worldwide publicity, she won't be found alive ?
Telll that to Ben Needham's mum - she's still hoping to find her son alive after over 20 years.
I just wish the UK government would re-open Ben's case. But no doubt you would be against that because of the cost to the taxpayer?
And please don't try to claim there is no comparison between the two cases.
Ben disappeared in a foreign country.
He was unsupervised when he disappeared.
No evidence was found of an abduction.
We only have the family's word for what happened.
His family know he may be dead, but until they receive confirmation of that - they will continue to hope he is still alive.
-
The McCanns were never called to attend at any time. They just showed up...So why the moaning about being inconvenienced?
similar situation would be: wedding crashers complaining they didn't get a chunk of cake- well they were not invited!
They asked to give an statement which may provide further evidence after all other evidence has been heard, a change in the Law allows for this. The Judge allowed it- it is NOT the same as a victim statement as it is here in the UK. I am lead to believe.
Just a small correction. The judge for the trial rejected the McCanns' request to make a statement. They then appealed and were allowed to do so. The judge will be allowed to question them and the other lawyers will also be able to ask for clarifications through the judge.
-
Just a small correction. The judge for the trial rejected the McCanns' request to make a statement. They then appealed and were allowed to do so. The judge will be allowed to question them and the other lawyers will also be able to ask for clarifications through the judge.
Thank you.
Sounds good to me.
-
Just a small correction. The judge for the trial rejected the McCanns' request to make a statement. They then appealed and were allowed to do so. The judge will be allowed to question them and the other lawyers will also be able to ask for clarifications through the judge.
So, effectively, the McCanns can be 'cross examined' in a court of law ?
-
So, effectively, the McCanns can be 'cross examined' in a court of law ?
...and they asked for it..
-
...and they asked for it..
About time too.
Now will they be under oath ?
-
The Judge said that even the title of his book was suspect. Personally, I think it is a downright lie.
Of course you do.
Doesn't make it true though.
-
Just a small correction. The judge for the trial rejected the McCanns' request to make a statement. They then appealed and were allowed to do so. The judge will be allowed to question them and the other lawyers will also be able to ask for clarifications through the judge.
Montclair. Do you happen to know why the judge refused permission in the first instance and to whom did Duarte make the appeal ?
-
Montclair. Do you happen to know why the judge refused permission in the first instance and to whom did Duarte make the appeal ?
I can only make conjectures but it is possible that the judge refused to give permission for the parents to speak because she believed that she already had enough evidence from the other witnesses in order to give her verdict. I suppose that the McCanns appealed to the Appeals Court.
-
the case is over once amaral stops being able to stall
That's my opinion, as well ...