UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Wonderfulspam on October 18, 2013, 11:40:22 AM

Title: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 18, 2013, 11:40:22 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?


Official Find Madeleine Campaign
17 October 2013 at 14:33 ·
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.

~FM Webmaster

http://m.facebook.com/Official.Find.Madeleine.Campaign/posts/10151905090784931





204
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: patb on October 18, 2013, 11:46:02 AM
I would want to beleive that he has to say this considering the political and PR situation re the case at the moment. Can you imagine if he came in with no new evidence, £5 mil in the budget funded by the PM and on day one named the parents as suspects? I would want and hope to believe that if he is a true detective, he will be treating them as suspects in his own mind (which is the important thing) and monitoring their behavoir etc and not from an intelectual perspective closing off the thought that it was  possibly them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: C.Edwards on October 18, 2013, 11:46:47 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

I think you're opening yourself up to a snipey comment along the lines of, "well I trust the police know what they're talking about. Don't you?" here...  8(0(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on October 18, 2013, 11:50:43 AM
DCI Redwood




"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

You would need to ask redwood, no one here has any real information of what they have
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 18, 2013, 11:52:00 AM
DCI Redwood is not going to be a happy man  8)><( How can you rule anything out lol.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Carew on October 18, 2013, 11:57:43 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

Not at this stage, perhaps?

Avenues other than parents and friends to investigate and eliminate first maybe?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: icabodcrane on October 18, 2013, 11:59:27 AM
I found it interesting that Redwood kept emphasising that the time they were concerned with was 8.30pm to 10pm

Since Gerry says he saw Madeleine alive and well at 9.05pm  you have to wonder why the crucial time is not from that point on

Have   the McCanns  'really'  been ruled out  ? 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 18, 2013, 12:24:21 PM
I found it interesting that Redwood kept emphasising that the time they were concerned with was 8.30pm to 10pm

Since Gerry says he saw Madeleine alive and well at 9.05pm  you have to wonder why the crucial time is not from that point on

Have   the McCanns  'really'  been ruled out  ?

I think he says 8.30 to 10 because next to nothing is known about the preceding three hours, in fact nothing now because DP's visit wasn't mentioned in Crimewatch. That's three hours it seems nobody wants to visit.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: patb on October 18, 2013, 12:25:16 PM
Am I correct in thinking that during the Crimewatch special, he was careful in his use of words , not actually saying that they were abducted but dissapeared.?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 18, 2013, 12:42:21 PM
Am I correct in thinking that during the Crimewatch special, he was careful in his use of words , not actually saying that they were abducted but dissapeared.?

I think so patb. And not just him, everyone was careful with their words. Undoubtedly lawyers were involved in the production and content of CW.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 18, 2013, 01:58:33 PM
Am I correct in thinking that during the Crimewatch special, he was careful in his use of words , not actually saying that they were abducted but dissapeared.?

In the german version of crimewatch,  after being pressed on the issue Redwood said Kate & Gerry are the parents of a child who is 'lost'.

That's not quite the same as 'abducted'.
And he doesn't definitively state that they are not suspects.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 18, 2013, 02:07:03 PM
In the german version of crimewatch,  after being pressed on the issue Redwood said Kate & Gerry are the parents of a child who is 'lost'.

That's not quite the same as 'abducted'.
And he doesn't definitively state that they are not suspects.

He also used the word lost in the Dutch version although he did also say they weren't suspects or persons of interest.

At this juncture if, as I and many others suspect, SY are playing the long game would you really expect Redwood to say that they were suspects ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: patb on October 18, 2013, 02:24:19 PM
I would hope that is not a legal motivation but he is making an effort within his own mindset to keep his options open. If you keep repeating something over and over again (just how many press conferences has he done?) there is a danger you start to beleive it. She has been lost, she has dissappeared and anthing else is under investigation. I think its a good sign.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 18, 2013, 05:20:20 PM
I would hope that is not a legal motivation but he is making an effort within his own mindset to keep his options open. If you keep repeating something over and over again (just how many press conferences has he done?) there is a danger you start to beleive it. She has been lost, she has dissappeared and anthing else is under investigation. I think its a good sign.

That's very true. If you keep repeating something over and over, like, say, for example, "The Mccanns are guilty, despite the lack of evidence", you do indeed start to believe it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2013, 05:26:33 PM
That's very true. If you keep repeating something over and over, like, say, for example, "The Mccanns are guilty, despite the lack of evidence", you do indeed start to believe it.

Similar things seems to have happened with 'abduction' as well.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 18, 2013, 05:28:29 PM
Similar things seems to have happened with 'abduction' as well.

Maybe so, but that is the line of enquiry Scotland Yard say they are following.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 18, 2013, 05:39:21 PM
I found it interesting that Redwood kept emphasising that the time they were concerned with was 8.30pm to 10pm

Since Gerry says he saw Madeleine alive and well at 9.05pm  you have to wonder why the crucial time is not from that point on

Have   the McCanns  'really'  been ruled out  ?

I think 8.30 has always been the starting point timewise, but now that the JT sighting has virtually been ruled out -  the time in which the abductor may have entered the apartment has been extended to 10.00.   i.e. Any time between 8.30 when the McCanns left 5A - and 10.00  - a few mins before the alarm was raised.





Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2013, 05:57:57 PM
Interesting, because for 8.30 to be within the time frame would mean that McCann's sighting of Madeleine at 9.05 would have to be false
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 18, 2013, 06:01:58 PM
Interesting, because for 8.30 to be within the time frame would mean that McCann's sighting of Madeleine at 9.05 would have to be false

Yes, cant imagine an abductor sitting there for half an hour!! Then some...I think the 8.30 time given is a general starting point, perhaps to include any sightings of lurkers or other strange behaviours around at the time? Not got a clue really....

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 18, 2013, 06:05:06 PM
depends how desperate he was to nick a child  >@@(*&)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 18, 2013, 06:05:19 PM
Well if she wasn't there at 8.30 she wasn't there when they left the apartment for the tapas bar.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 18, 2013, 06:07:16 PM
Interesting, because for 8.30 to be within the time frame would mean that McCann's sighting of Madeleine at 9.05 would have to be false

Not so Jassi - in theory - someone could have entered 5a at say 8.32 and be hiding there when Gerry did his 9.05 check.

It may not be likely, but because it is possible - SY cannot discount any of the time periods when the parents were not in the apartment.   

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2013, 06:08:31 PM
Yes, cant imagine an abductor sitting there for half an hour!! Then some...I think the 8.30 time given is a general starting point, perhaps to include any sightings of lurkers or other strange behaviours around at the time? Not got a clue really....

But don't forget that Jez has been wandering about the area since 8.30 and he apparently saw nothing (that he admitted to) until he saw McCann at - ( well, he's not really sure). It would be difficult for abductor man to secrete himself away in 5A with Jez on patrol
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 18, 2013, 06:18:38 PM
But don't forget that Jez has been wandering about the area since 8.30 and he apparently saw nothing (that he admitted to) until he saw McCann at - ( well, he's not really sure). It would be difficult for abductor man to secrete himself away in 5A with Jez on patrol

Plus all the tapas group going on their way to dinner and and other guests too

Going back to the previous discussion on Mr Redwood not mentioning abduction he did a few times, in the context of sayng Tannerman almost certainlywasnt Madeleines abductor and in another part saying the efit could be of the man who took her

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2013, 06:24:45 PM
It certainly does seem very difficult for abductor man to be able to get and out again without being seen by the one or other of the  people known to be in the immediate area throughout the time period.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 18, 2013, 07:16:44 PM
Not so Jassi - in theory - someone could have entered 5a at say 8.32 and be hiding there when Gerry did his 9.05 check.

It may not be likely, but because it is possible - SY cannot discount any of the time periods when the parents were not in the apartment.

Doing what????
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2013, 07:28:33 PM
Not so Jassi - in theory - someone could have entered 5a at say 8.32 and be hiding there when Gerry did his 9.05 check.

It may not be likely, but because it is possible - SY cannot discount any of the time periods when the parents were not in the apartment.

And then hang around for the best part of an hour before appearing before Mr Smith & his family?

The only way I can she for abductorman to be shoe-horned in and out of 5A is if some of the Tapas wanders were to admit that they hadn't made their visits when they said they did.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 18, 2013, 11:09:33 PM
And then hang around for the best part of an hour before appearing before Mr Smith & his family?

The only way I can she for abductorman to be shoe-horned in and out of 5A is if some of the Tapas wanders were to admit that they hadn't made their visits when they said they did.

It would take just a couple of minutes for someone to leave the apartment with a child and be well out of sight of people making checks.        The gaps inbetween the visits were ample time for someone to do that.    SY have proved it with their analylsis of all the timelines.

JT obviously did see the 'tourist' as her description of him was correct - even down to the hair, which was the one discrepancy between her description and the Smith's description.  Long and black down to the neck as opposed to their description of short and brown.    So she was there imo.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 18, 2013, 11:12:27 PM
Doing what????

I don't know, but SY cannot say 'We know that no-one went into 5A between 8.30 and 9.00''  and so they have to keep that possibility in the equation.




Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: TTSOFAFM on October 18, 2013, 11:33:13 PM
I don't know, but SY cannot say 'We know that no-one went into 5A between 8.30 and 9.00''  and so they have to keep that possibility in the equation.
Exactly Benice. Scotland Yard want the public's help, they need information, that is the reason for the Crimewatch programme.  Scotland yard will not be releasing the evidence they have gathered in an investigation outside of a court and any prat that thinks they should doesn't understand the workings of the UK police. 

Scotland Yard do not conduct inquiries, release people suspected of crimes from their bail when they have eliminated them and then archive the case and place all the evidence they have obtained on a disc for every internet ghoul to pick over and contact the witnesses that have been involved in the investigation.

That is exactly what has happened in this case.  People have obtained names, addresses and telephone details of witnesses in this investigation and they have contacted them for further information. 

That is wrong.  These people had no right to do this to witnesses in a Police Investigation.  They are not law enforcement and have no right to carry out such inquiries.  They are nothing but ghoulish internet sleuths who have no moral compass.

Plus the fact, it seriously makes you want to turn a blind eye should you ever find yourself witnessing something in Portugal, for fear that some internet ghoul is going to contact you later.  Or a person you have given evidence against goes one step further and threatens you or worse still harms you.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 18, 2013, 11:40:49 PM
SY are not stupid they only gunna tell ya what they want ya to know  8((()*/
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: icabodcrane on October 18, 2013, 11:49:22 PM
SY are not stupid they only gunna tell ya what they want ya to know  8((()*/

Quite right

...  and what it is that  they're not  'gunna'  tell us,  at this point,  is anyone's guess  (  including the McCanns, perhaps,  who do not appear to be quite as 'in the loop' as they would like us to think  ) 

 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Cariad on October 19, 2013, 09:08:18 AM
It would take just a couple of minutes for someone to leave the apartment with a child and be well out of sight of people making checks.        The gaps inbetween the visits were ample time for someone to do that.    SY have proved it with their analylsis of all the timelines.

JT obviously did see the 'tourist' as her description of him was correct - even down to the hair, which was the one discrepancy between her description and the Smith's description.  Long and black down to the neck as opposed to their description of short and brown.    So she was there imo.

So the guy has kept the same hair style for the last 6 years too? He's lucky he doesn't suffer from male pattern baldness or that might have messed up the photo!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 19, 2013, 09:28:24 AM
So the guy has kept the same hair style for the last 6 years too? He's lucky he doesn't suffer from male pattern baldness or that might have messed up the photo!

In theory I suppose that after 6 yrs the man could have been 20 stone and bald.      However, I'm sure SY police officers are intelligent enough to have checked with him about his hairstyle at the time he was in PdL - or maybe asked to see a photograph?     In the circumstances that would be the obvious thing to do IMO.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 19, 2013, 09:40:58 AM
So the guy has kept the same hair style for the last 6 years too? He's lucky he doesn't suffer from male pattern baldness or that might have messed up the photo!

He kept the clothes he had on from 6 years ago, kept his daughters rotten old pajamas( or a strange photographic record of them lying on the floor)  didn't change his hair style & he didn't remember he was in PDL at the same time Madeleine disappeared until just recently.
Strange man indeed.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 19, 2013, 10:02:45 AM
He kept the clothes he had on from 6 years ago, kept his daughters rotten old pajamas( or a strange photographic record of them lying on the floor)  didn't change his hair style & he didn't remember he was in PDL at the same time Madeleine disappeared until just recently.
Strange man indeed.

Quite a lot of speculation there W - being stated as fact.    The only people who know all the details regarding this man are the police - and they haven't told us what they are.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Cariad on October 19, 2013, 10:06:26 AM
Quite a lot of speculation there W - being stated as fact.    The only people who know all the details regarding this man are the police - and they haven't told us what they are.

Does nothing about Innocentman strike you as odd Benice?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 19, 2013, 10:22:10 AM
Does nothing about Innocentman strike you as odd Benice?

There are a lot of questions I would like answered Cariad  - for instance why was he walking in that direction?-  but I'm assuming that SY have asked the family all those questions and are satisfied with the answers.  And so that's good enough for me.     IMO they will have gone into all the aspects of this in great depth - and they are the experts after all.   

       
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 10:29:14 AM
There are a lot of questions I would like answered Cariad  - for instance why was he walking in that direction?-  but I'm assuming that SY have asked the family all those questions and are satisfied with the answers.  And so that's good enough for me.     IMO they will have gone into all the aspects of this in great depth - and they are the experts after all.   

       

Will you be content to accept SY's deductions, whatever they may turn out to be ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 19, 2013, 10:31:45 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

 @)(++(* you need to ask sy this question ..NOT posters on a forum  ?>)()<
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 10:36:15 AM
@)(++(* you need to ask sy this question ..NOT posters on a forum  ?>)()<

Absolutely correct, though they are unlikely to tell.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 10:37:51 AM
I don't know, there was a time everyone with an axe to grind against the Mccanns had a contact within the investigation.

Maybe the police would be willing to give exact details about an ongoing investigation to some poster on a forum.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 19, 2013, 10:43:02 AM
Will you be content to accept SY's deductions, whatever they may turn out to be ?

Yes - why wouldn't I?    I've got no time for conspiracy theories.  SY have been tasked to do the job, have been given the tools to do it and are in possession of all the known facts of the case - so I would accept their conclusions/deductions etc   - whatever they may be.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 10:50:00 AM
Will you be content to accept SY's deductions, whatever they may turn out to be ?

Like Benice, I'd accept their findings. I'd accept proof of guilt against the Mccanns were any established.

Would you do the same? The Mccanns and their friends are already "not persons of interest" to the investigation, and the campaign against them goes on.

Would you accept the findings of an investigation that declared them innocent?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 11:00:29 AM
Like Benice, I'd accept their findings. I'd accept proof of guilt against the Mccanns were any established.

Would you do the same? The Mccanns and their friends are already "not persons of interest" to the investigation, and the campaign against them goes on.

Would you accept the findings of an investigation that declared them innocent?

I'm not sure. 
I would find it difficult to believe a solution that pinned the blame on a convenient dead paedophile or an anonymous bunch of gypsies without there being a rigorous and irrefutable  evidence trail and I fear this will never be forthcoming.
I feel that without the evidence being tested in a court of law, there can never be a satisfactory conclusion.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 11:03:33 AM
I'm not sure. 
I would find it difficult to believe a solution that pinned the blame on a convenient dead paedophile or an anonymous bunch of gypsies without there being a rigorous and irrefutable  evidence trail and I fear this will never be forthcoming.
I feel that without the evidence being tested in a court of law, there can never be a satisfactory conclusion.

The issue is, there is no evidence against them that would withstand testing in a court of law.

These parents will never be left alone then, not to find their daughter or to grieve her loss. If they are found to be guilty, their torment might ease, people will no longer hound them in the way they are, but if they are found to be guilty, the rest of their lives will be as they are now.

Lynch mob "justice".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on October 19, 2013, 11:05:51 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

The words which Crimewatch presenter Kirsty Young actually used were "formally cleared".  Without sounding like a prize spoilsport can anyone tell me where the justification for this comment lies?

My own understanding is that the only authority who can pronounce such a judgement is the Portuguese Attorney General and the Portuguese Courts. The AG Archiving Report was inconclusive, the crime and those involved was undetermined. Scotland Yard has not concluded any investigation and are most certainly not in any position to make any judgements.

So who cleared them Mss Young?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 11:10:31 AM
The issue is, there is no evidence against them that would withstand testing in a court of law.

These parents will never be left alone then, not to find their daughter or to grieve her loss. If they are found to be guilty, their torment might ease, people will no longer hound them in the way they are, but if they are found to be guilty, the rest of their lives will be as they are now.

Lynch mob "justice".


I don't think we are in a position to say that - it is more a matter of opinion at present.

As for the rest of what you say, I agree entirely.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 11:12:07 AM
The words which Crimewatch presenter Kirsty Young actually used were "formally cleared".  Without sounding like a prize spoilsport can anyone tell me where the justification for this comment lies?

My own understanding is that the only authority who can pronounce such a judgement is the Portuguese Attorney General and the Portuguese Courts. The AG Archiving Report was inconclusive, the crime and those involved was undetermined. Scotland Yard has not concluded any investigation and are most certainly not in any position to make any judgements.

So who cleared them Mss Young?

John, may I ask you whether you believe, in common with a great many others here that the Mccanns are guilty of some crime regarding their child?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 11:21:02 AM
It seems to me that the future is not very bright for the Mccanns. Until they "prove their innocence" they will be forever tormented by those who fail to understand that it is guilt which must be proven. They are not persons of interest to Scotland Yard, and never arrested by the PJ, guilt was never established, why is it that logic does not allow for the next step? The absence of guilt surely leads to the presumption of innocence, and we all,  under law have that. It is impossible to prove innocence, you can't prove you didn't do something, it is guilt that can be proven.

This campaign against the Mccanns will never end, whatever the outcome of the police investigation.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 11:28:43 AM
I think a conviction in a court of law would draw a line under the affair - after the inevitable appeal process.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on October 19, 2013, 11:30:45 AM
John, may I ask you whether you believe, in common with a great many others here that the Mccanns are guilty of some crime regarding their child?

Truth is I don't know.  Only they know and the alleged abductor(s) of course.  The only authority who are legally competent to make a ruling is the Portuguese and their archiving decision was inconclusive.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 11:32:24 AM
Truth is I don't know.  Only they know and the alleged abductor(s) of course.  The only authority who are legally competent to make a ruling is the Portuguese and their archiving decision was inconclusive.

This is entirely an observation, would you agree that your comments are weighted towards their guilt?

Mine, I freely admit are not, they are in defence of them. This is for entirely the same reason as you. I don't know.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 11:42:30 AM
It seems to me that the future is not very bright for the Mccanns. Until they "prove their innocence" they will be forever tormented by those who fail to understand that it is guilt which must be proven. They are not persons of interest to Scotland Yard, and never arrested by the PJ, guilt was never established, why is it that logic does not allow for the next step? The absence of guilt surely leads to the presumption of innocence, and we all,  under law have that. It is impossible to prove innocence, you can't prove you didn't do something, it is guilt that can be proven.

This campaign against the Mccanns will never end, whatever the outcome of the police investigation.

What campaign? A few hundred people online? That noise will reduce inevitably, as it did every previous time.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 19, 2013, 11:59:31 AM

This campaign against the Mccanns will never end, whatever the outcome of the police investigation.
There is no campaign against the McCanns, Jazzy. If you think of the public opinion, the doubt (it's a passive one, people don't think of it 24 hours a day !) will certainly end, if SY finds out what happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:01:26 PM
There is no campaign against the McCanns, Jazzy. If you think of the public opinion, the doubt (it's a passive one, people don't think of it 24 hours a day !) will certainly end, if SY finds out what happened to Madeleine.

There is indeed a campaign, one of the most recent "ideas" on Facebook, for example, is a protest of parliament next May.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:02:44 PM
What campaign? A few hundred people online? That noise will reduce inevitably, as it did every previous time.

It hasn't reduced an iota in 6 years. A few hundred people online? You grossly underestimate Lyall. Grossly.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 12:03:04 PM
There is indeed a campaign, one of the most recent "ideas" on Facebook, for example, is a protest of parliament next May.

What is the nature of this protest?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on October 19, 2013, 12:03:21 PM
This is entirely an observation, would you agree that your comments are weighted towards their guilt?

Mine, I freely admit are not, they are in defence of them. This is for entirely the same reason as you. I don't know.

It's not as simple as that Jassy.  Like a lot of observers I waver between innocence in respect of Madeleine's disappearance and guilt in respect of a conspiracy to invent an abduction.  They can never be innocent Jassy because they were bloody stupid to have done what they did do.  But then again they know that all too well!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:05:24 PM
It's not as simple as that Jassy.  Like a lot of observers I waver between innocence in respect of Madeleine's disappearance and guilt in respect of a conspiracy to invent an abduction.  They can never be innocent Jassy because they were bloody stupid to have done what they did do.

They were worse than stupid to leave those children.

If I may say, I don't ever see you waiver. You believe there was a conspiracy to invent an abduction.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:07:10 PM
What is the nature of this protest?

The starting point is a bunch of [ censored word ]s protesting against the lack of Mccann arrests.

It's nature is a lynch mob expressing their distate at not seeing a pair of strangers proven guilty of nothing hauled off to jail.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 12:07:59 PM
There is indeed a campaign, one of the most recent "ideas" on Facebook, for example, is a protest of parliament next May.

Most people won't take them seriously Jazzy. Some of them are trying to provoke libel proceedings, but it's so crudely done I doubt it will work.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:11:34 PM
Most people won't take them seriously Jazzy. Some of them are trying to provoke libel proceedings, but it's so crudely done I doubt it will work.

They take themselves seriously, Lyall, that's the point. Anything and everything to do with the Mccanns is examined, found wanting and sneered at.  Emails are fired off to newspapers and other organisations, Scotland Yard are routinely informed of issues which the [ censored word ]s find to be proof of guilt. This week Denise Welch wrote about why the Mccanns turned down her offer of tickets to her show, they get mail bags full of hate mail if they are seen to be smiling in public.

There is a hate machine out there alright, and it's not confined to cyberspace.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 12:21:12 PM
They take themselves seriously, Lyall, that's the point. Anything and everything to do with the Mccanns is examined, found wanting and sneered at.  Emails are fired off to newspapers and other organisations, Scotland Yard are routinely informed of issues which the [ censored word ]s find to be proof of guilt. This week Denise Welch wrote about why the Mccanns turned down her offer of tickets to her show, they get mail bags full of hate mail if they are seen to be smiling in public.

There is a hate machine out there alright, and it's not confined to cyberspace.

Maybe. I noticed Jim Gamble asking why nothing has been done, but he doesn't seem to have considered that it might be in the interest of some people not to do anything, to let it build - politicians (and police doubtless) want changes in law. They need evidence for Parliament.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:22:50 PM
Maybe. I noticed Jim Gamble asking why nothing has been done, but he doesn't seem to have considered that it might be in the interest of some people not to do anything, to let it build - politicians (and police doubtless) want changes in law. They need evidence for Parliament.

I appreciate the rest of your post.

The issue I have is that there is no "maybe" about it. These people are hounded by strangers.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 12:26:50 PM
They take themselves seriously, Lyall, that's the point. Anything and everything to do with the Mccanns is examined, found wanting and sneered at.  Emails are fired off to newspapers and other organisations, Scotland Yard are routinely informed of issues which the [ censored word ]s find to be proof of guilt. This week Denise Welch wrote about why the Mccanns turned down her offer of tickets to her show, they get mail bags full of hate mail if they are seen to be smiling in public.

There is a hate machine out there alright, and it's not confined to cyberspace.

But you're writing four days after the change in perception of a witness statement was announced, a change that was always going to be a PR disaster for the McCanns.

I thought the reaction would be bigger, but there's still nobody brave enough to write about this in the press.

The facebook mob won't get anywhere until the press changes the nature of it's coverage. But there's no sign of that yet (apart from the cynicism of the Express and Star).

So it was a PR disaster but so far seems to have been managed. I think you're overreacting Jazzy.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 12:54:44 PM
But you're writing four days after the change in perception of a witness statement was announced, a change that was always going to be a PR disaster for the McCanns.

I thought the reaction would be bigger, but there's still nobody brave enough to write about this in the press.

The facebook mob won't get anywhere until the press changes the nature of it's coverage. But there's no sign of that yet (apart from the cynicism of the Express and Star).

So it was a PR disaster but so far seems to have been managed. I think you're overreacting Jazzy.

No, I'm writing after seeing the same thing for 6 years. Lyall, I'm not reacting at all, I am pointing out what the Mccanns have to live with.



I wouldn't advise you to look on Facebook, or MM or Jill Havern's foum, but it's all there, in plain sight.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 01:38:52 PM
Maybe people resort to facebook and the like because the main stream media refuse to report both sides of the matter honestly and without bias.

A great many people dislike the image that the mcCann's PR machine has generated, but I suspect very few genuinely hate them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:47:41 PM
Maybe people resort to facebook and the like because the main stream media refuse to report both sides of the matter honestly and without bias.

A great many people dislike the image that the mcCann's PR machine has generated, but I suspect very few genuinely hate them.

That makes the filth and the treats all the more despicable,, doesn't it?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 01:48:49 PM
That makes the filth and the treats all the more despicable,, doesn't it?

What threats?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 01:50:41 PM
That makes the filth and the treats all the more despicable,, doesn't it?

You can't stop people going to Parliament if that's what they want to do.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:51:32 PM
What threats?

Threats to kidnap the twins, threats to firebomb their home, threats to shoot Kate Mccann at the marathon, threats to picket that, dressed as her daughter, threats to torture both the Mccanns.................................................the list is endless.

Lyall,this exists. The filth, the accusations, the torment, the threats.

They are living their lives under siege.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:52:22 PM
You can't stop people going to Parliament if that's what they want to do.

No indeed, the question is, why do these [ censored word ]s want to?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 01:52:43 PM
That makes the filth and the treats all the more despicable,, doesn't it?

Not sure I'm following your logic.

You can't really know, of course, but how many people on this forum, who you would consider 'anti', would actually hate the McCanns ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:54:36 PM
Not sure I'm following your logic.

You can't really know, of course, but how many people on this forum, who you would consider 'anti', would actually hate the McCanns ?

As you say, I can't really know. This forum, anywhere.

How about you, how many do you think?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 01:54:39 PM
Threats to kidnap the twins, threats to firebomb their home, threats to shoot Kate Mccann at the marathon, threats to picket that, dressed as her daughter, threats to torture both the Mccanns.................................................the list is endless.

Lyall,this exists. The filth, the accusations, the torment, the threats.

They are living their lives under siege.

No, Jazzy, that is gross exaggeration.  8(0(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 01:55:45 PM
Threats to kidnap the twins, threats to firebomb their home, threats to shoot Kate Mccann at the marathon, threats to picket that, dressed as her daughter, threats to torture both the Mccanns.................................................the list is endless.

Lyall,this exists. The filth, the accusations, the torment, the threats.

They are living their lives under siege.

Am I right in assuming that none of these threats had led to any prosecution by the police. If this is so, then it is unlikely that there was any serious intent to carry them out.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:56:10 PM
No, Jazzy, that is gross exaggeration.  8(0(*

Take a little tour of facebook, Lyall, have a little look at davidbretisagod. Then tell me it's grossly exaggerated.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 01:57:15 PM
Am I right in assuming that none of these threats had led to any prosecution by the police. If this is so, then it is unlikely that there was any serious intent to carry them out.

Oh a few did, the [ censored word ] threatening to shoot Kate at the marathon had a few uncomfortable minutes with the police.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 01:58:03 PM
Take a little tour of facebook, Lyall, have a little look at davidbretisagod. Then tell me it's grossly exaggerated.

Yes there is hate there, but it's a handful of people. Before the Lisbon trial began they were just talking to each other all day. I've no idea who Bret is.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 01:59:06 PM
As you say, I can't really know. This forum, anywhere.

How about you, how many do you think?

I've not been on this forum for very long, but in that time I have seen no one who has expressed any hatred for the McCanns.
I have, however, seen a number of 'pros' raising the subject time & time again, with no evidence of its existence.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 19, 2013, 01:59:42 PM
Oh a few did, the p...... threatening to shoot Kate at the marathon had a few uncomfortable minutes with the police.

So they weren't charged then.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 02:00:54 PM
Oh a few did, the p...... threatening to shoot Kate at the marathon had a few uncomfortable minutes with the police.

Then, no doubt, you will be able to quote chapter and verse of these prosecutions.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on October 19, 2013, 02:12:01 PM
I don't think any of our members hate them per sé, they just hate what they did to Madeleine.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 19, 2013, 02:19:09 PM
So they weren't charged then.

Nope, not even cautioned. The grandmother was called by the police and had a very cordial conversation with an officer who she explained the situation to and that was that.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: CPN on October 19, 2013, 02:43:16 PM
No indeed, the question is, why do these [ censored word ]s want to?

 I thought "[ censored word ]s" was one of the words we had been asked not to use?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 19, 2013, 02:52:12 PM
I thought "[ censored word ]s" was one of the words we had been asked not to use?

the singular is a banned word, the plural goes through....

Admin have asked to not use the [ censored word ] word but many still do

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: CPN on October 19, 2013, 03:01:48 PM
the singular is a banned word, the plural goes through....

Admin have asked to not use the [ censored word ] word but many still do

Exactly.   But courtesy to admin, if not to other posters, means that the words should not be used.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 19, 2013, 05:29:42 PM
The words which Crimewatch presenter Kirsty Young actually used were "formally cleared".  Without sounding like a prize spoilsport can anyone tell me where the justification for this comment lies?

My own understanding is that the only authority who can pronounce such a judgement is the Portuguese Attorney General and the Portuguese Courts. The AG Archiving Report was inconclusive, the crime and those involved was undetermined. Scotland Yard has not concluded any investigation and are most certainly not in any position to make any judgements.

So who cleared them Mss Young?

Quite right john,
If the McCanns had been "formally cleared" or SY had uncovered evidence that "formally cleared" the McCanns since the Met review began, then the case would now have been reopened in Portugal, because that would be solid evidence relevant to the original investigation.
And since it has not reopened then the McCanns are not "formally cleared" at all.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 19, 2013, 05:50:18 PM
They didn't seem to live under threat in Lisbon court and they had no body guards, though they were in a country that hasn't many reasons to welcome them warmly.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 19, 2013, 06:48:32 PM
Nope, not even cautioned. The grandmother was called by the police and had a very cordial conversation with an officer who she explained the situation to and that was that.

That's not how I remember it Faith.   You don't make headlines in several tabloids and get called a Sick Internet Troll, A Cruel Troll, etc.  for nothing.      IIRC After a 'word' from the police she made a profuse public apology to Kate - so I doubt whether the conversation with them was anywhere near as 'cordial' as you would like people to believe.     
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 06:51:13 PM
I thought "[ censored word ]s" was one of the words we had been asked not to use?

I understood it was not to be used as a term of abuse against posters here. I used it in it's descriptive sense.  It perfectly describes what I was explaining.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: CPN on October 19, 2013, 07:02:44 PM
I understood it was not to be used as a term of abuse against posters here. I used it in it's descriptive sense.  It perfectly describes what I was explaining.

I find it unpleasant to read being used about anyone.   I had hoped that they kept to higher standards here and avoided ALL abuse being thrown around
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 19, 2013, 07:07:11 PM
That's not how I remember it Faith.   You don't make headlines in several tabloids and get called a Sick Internet Troll, A Cruel Troll, etc.  for nothing.      IIRC After a 'word' from the police she made a profuse public apology to Kate - so I doubt whether the conversation with them was anywhere near as 'cordial' as you would like people to believe.   

So, they didn't get charged then.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on October 19, 2013, 07:08:03 PM
I find it unpleasant to read being used about anyone.   I had hoped that they kept to higher standards here and avoided ALL abuse being thrown around

im not sure standards are that high if calling the McCanns shit parents goes uncensured
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: CPN on October 19, 2013, 07:12:31 PM
im not sure standards are that high if calling the McCanns shit parents goes uncensured

Agreed.  There are always other ways of expressing disagreement with people or things without using unpleasant words or phrases
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on October 19, 2013, 07:14:45 PM
Agreed.  There are always other ways of expressing disagreement with people or things without using unpleasant words or phrases

Agreed
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 08:36:28 PM
I find it unpleasant to read being used about anyone.   I had hoped that they kept to higher standards here and avoided ALL abuse being thrown around

It wasn't abuse, it was a description of a lynch mob planning to protest the Mccanns freedom at parliament.

How would you describe such "people"? People who send hatemail when the Mccanns are seen smiling? People who   send endless mails, messages, posts all explaining why the Mccanns are guilty and the police don't understand?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: CPN on October 19, 2013, 08:40:51 PM
It wasn't abuse, it was a description of a lynch mob planning to protest the Mccanns freedom at parliament.

How would you describe such "people"? People who send hatemail when the Mccanns are seen smiling? People who   send endless mails, messages, posts all explaining why the Mccanns are guilty and the police don't understand?

I would describe it as you have here, if that is how you feel about it (them) but not use the words you have used.  This is my last reply
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 08:43:08 PM
It wasn't abuse, it was a description of a lynch mob planning to protest the Mccanns freedom at parliament.

How would you describe such "people"? People who send hatemail when the Mccanns are seen smiling? People who   send endless mails, messages, posts all explaining why the Mccanns are guilty and the police don't understand?

If they turned up at Parliament like a 'lynch mob' they'd be arrested. We know that and they know that.

The main people doing what you describe are a handful - we all know who they are. Far more learned people than us know if what they do is breaking the law - maybe it isn't? It's libelous for sure, but is it illegal?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2013, 08:44:49 PM
If they turned up at Parliament like a 'lynch mob' they'd be arrested. We know that and they know that.

The main people doing what you describe are a handful - we all know who they are. Far more learned people than us know if what they do is breaking the law - maybe it isn't? It's libelous for sure, but is it illegal?

Presumably it can't be, else the law would act to stop it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 08:48:43 PM
If they turned up at Parliament like a 'lynch mob' they'd be arrested. We know that and they know that.

The main people doing what you describe are a handful - we all know who they are. Far more learned people than us know if what they do is breaking the law - maybe it isn't? It's libelous for sure, but is it illegal?

That "maybe" again. Is it right that a number of hard line....................insert your own name...........torment the Mccanns in this way?

I'd take issue with the handful it's not.

Not you Lyall, maybe.

May I ask you a question?

Are you truly unaware of the hate machine against the Mccanns? I mean truly? Did you not know posters asking for information about their child were defaced in Portugal? Are you unaware of the facebook pages? Truly?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 19, 2013, 08:52:51 PM
That "maybe" again. Is it right that a number of hard line....................insert your own name...........torment the Mccanns in this way?

I'd take issue with the handful it's not.

Not you Lyall, maybe.

May I ask you a question?

Are you truly unaware of the hate machine against the Mccanns? I mean truly? Did you not know posters asking for information about their child were defaced in Portugal? Are you unaware of the facebook pages? Truly?

I don't think facebook groups went all the way to PDL to deface posters of Madeleine somehow.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 08:55:19 PM
I don't think facebook groups went all the way to PDL to deface posters of Madeleine somehow.

No indeed, they didn't. Someone did, and boasted about it, all over cyberspace. I wouldn't embarrass anyone with the name of that person, would you?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: carlymichelle on October 19, 2013, 08:55:37 PM
I don't think facebook groups went all the way to PDL to deface posters of Madeleine somehow.

the problem is pros lump  everybody  together because of thier precived notion of hate against the mcanns   theres stuff as   someone who doesnt  believe  the mcanns that i think is too far some people push things way way to far but that doesnt make everybody like it
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 08:57:07 PM
That "maybe" again. Is it right that a number of hard line....................insert your own name...........torment the Mccanns in this way?

I'd take issue with the handful it's not.

Not you Lyall, maybe.

May I ask you a question?

Are you truly unaware of the hate machine against the Mccanns? I mean truly? Did you not know posters asking for information about their child were defaced in Portugal? Are you unaware of the facebook pages? Truly?

No,Jazzy, I'm not unaware. There's no point you getting upset over it. The McCanns have the best lawyers available, and I don't doubt they'd do something about it if they felt threatened.

But I'll repeat just a few weeks ago those people were taking to themselves all day, their group was going nowhere - it's events that have brought the new members, not the genius of the group's core. New members are fickle. Of course five days after a PR disaster interest in the case will be big online - wait and see how many of them are still around a few weeks from now. The reaction to CW is already receding.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Cariad on October 19, 2013, 08:58:04 PM
That "maybe" again. Is it right that a number of hard line....................insert your own name...........torment the Mccanns in this way?

I'd take issue with the handful it's not.

Not you Lyall, maybe.

May I ask you a question?

Are you truly unaware of the hate machine against the Mccanns? I mean truly? Did you not know posters asking for information about their child were defaced in Portugal? Are you unaware of the facebook pages? Truly?

I think I know to which FaceBook page you're referring and it is despicable. Saying that, even there it appears that it's a tiny minority making horrific posts.

With the crap they post, I think they're doing a disservice to the 'truth' that they claim to want to unearth. It only takes half an hour on Google to prove that some of those facts are false. As soon as that happens, they lose all credibility.

They'll end up alienating the people they want on their side.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 08:58:23 PM
No indeed, they didn't. Someone did, and boasted about it, all over cyberspace. I wouldn't embarrass anyone with the name of that person, would you?

That was two years later wasn't it? Two long years.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 08:59:08 PM
No,Jazzy, I'm not unaware. There's no point you getting upset over it. The McCanns have the best lawyers available, and I don't doubt they'd do something about it if they felt threatened.

But I'll repeat just a few weeks ago those people were taking to themselves all day, their group was going nowhere - it's events that have brought the new members, not the genius of the group's core. New members are fickle. Of course five days after a PR disaster interest in the case will be big online - wait and see how many of them are still around a few weeks from now. The reaction to CW is already receding.

I was certain you weren't unaware.

Any change registered with you over the last 6 years?

This is the life the Mccanns live.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 19, 2013, 08:59:58 PM
That was two years later wasn't it? Two long years.

Not as I remember, no.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 09:23:56 PM
I was certain you weren't unaware.

Any change registered with you over the last 6 years?

This is the life the Mccanns live.

I have noticed a big difference. In 2007/8 a lot of people were being extreme on forums - now it's comparatively few.

The mood of those few (relatively speaking) is not helped by claims that they planned violence at the Marathon and against the other McCann children - both claims ludicrous. One of these claims was made by themselves in the courtroom, and the other in the press - did 'a family source' or the McCanns themselves ever tell the tabloids the story was a gross exaggeration?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 19, 2013, 09:25:13 PM
Not as I remember, no.

Yes it was 2009 (I'm almost certain)

Two long years Jazzy.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 20, 2013, 01:39:13 PM
We'll never agree on this, Lyall, I feel the life the Mccanns have is hardly worth living. The spite, hate, vitriol they have to contend with is beyond endurance. Not going to watch a dancing show because if they are seen smiling the backlash from those who have no compassion makes it simply not worth it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 20, 2013, 01:50:59 PM
We'll never agree on this, Lyall, I feel the life the Mccanns have is hardly worth living. The spite, hate, vitriol they have to contend with is beyond endurance. Not going to watch a dancing show because if they are seen smiling the backlash from those who have no compassion makes it simply not worth it.

I hear you but I think you're being unduly pessimistic. Who cares what the spiteful few online say? I barely ever read what they say, so why would the McCanns? You can't be claiming they have no social life can you? They'll be completely unaware of our existence almost every day.

 I'd worry more about the newspapers if I were you Jazzy.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 20, 2013, 01:53:55 PM
I simply don't think anyone deserves to be treated in this way, Lyall. If they were proven to be guilty tomorrow I'd still be able to say, they were indeed innocent until proven guilty. They are aware of it Lyall they have referred to it many times. It isn't just cyberspace either, it happens in real life.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 20, 2013, 02:03:17 PM
I simply don't think anyone deserves to be treated in this way, Lyall. If they were proven to be guilty tomorrow I'd still be able to say, they were indeed innocent until proven guilty. They are aware of it Lyall they have referred to it many times. It isn't just cyberspace either, it happens in real life.

Well if it happens in real life it's not those online who are doing it.

I don't doubt the McCanns get hate mail and threats and all the rest that unfortunately comes with being in the spotlight, but that's a phenomena separate to online discussion - there are always irrational people out there who attach themselves to the famous.

But the McCanns are well protected Jazzy. Don't worry so much.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 20, 2013, 02:11:20 PM
That's not how I remember it Faith.   You don't make headlines in several tabloids and get called a Sick Internet Troll, A Cruel Troll, etc.  for nothing.      IIRC After a 'word' from the police she made a profuse public apology to Kate - so I doubt whether the conversation with them was anywhere near as 'cordial' as you would like people to believe.   

With the greatest respect Benice your knowledge comes from tabloid headlines, supporter sites etc, mine comes from being rather closer to the event, although I hasten to add, not directly involved.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 20, 2013, 02:26:20 PM
Well if it happens in real life it's not those online who are doing it.

I don't doubt the McCanns get hate mail and threats and all the rest that unfortunately comes with being in the spotlight, but that's a phenomena separate to online discussion - there are always irrational people out there who attach themselves to the famous.

But the McCanns are well protected Jazzy. Don't worry so much.

Lyall their physical safety doesn't worry me in the least. Living in a society  where this is allowed to happen does.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 20, 2013, 07:00:23 PM
Lyall their physical safety doesn't worry me in the least. Living in a society  where this is allowed to happen does.

I'm more concerned that I'm living in a society where two adults who, through their own lack of  care, lost a child yet are feted as they are.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 20, 2013, 07:05:52 PM
I'm more concerned that I'm living in a society where two adults who, through their own lack of  care, lost a child yet are feted as they are.

No, they made a catastrophically bad choice, that is theirs to live with and bear. Do you really think their choice doesn't torment them, every second, their guilt?

They could have lost her to a fire, an accident.

They didn't.

They lost her to a predator who made it's own choice.

Why would you want to help them with their suffering?

Why aren't you angry with whoever took a tiny child from her bed?

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 20, 2013, 07:10:20 PM
No, they made a catastrophically bad choice, that is theirs to live with and bear. Do you really think their choice doesn't torment them, every second, their guilt?

They could have lost her to a fire, an accident.

They didn't.

They lost her to a predator who made it's own choice.

Why would you want to help them with their suffering?

Why aren't you angry with whoever took a tiny child from her bed?



They lost her to a predator who made it's own choice. 

Although, at present there is no proof of this.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 20, 2013, 07:14:52 PM
No, they made a catastrophically bad choice, that is theirs to live with and bear. Do you really think their choice doesn't torment them, every second, their guilt?

They could have lost her to a fire, an accident.

They didn't.

They lost her to a predator who made it's own choice.

Why would you want to help them with their suffering?

Why aren't you angry with whoever took a tiny child from her bed?

I'm angry with however took her from that apartment, that much is true, I simply don't believe it was a predator.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jazzy on October 20, 2013, 07:35:44 PM
however?

Who was it, then?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Haskins on October 22, 2013, 12:27:33 AM
 I also think that it is most probable that Maddie was abducted by a predator, but we won't know the answer to that until she is found. That is where all efforts should be concentrated in my opinion, finding Maddie, and hopefully that's what the authorities in Portugal and the UK, and indeed anyone who can actually help in any practical sense, are now doing. If they succeed , then more light will be shed on the cause of the disappearance. I therefore think the police are absolutely right not to do anything to fuel salacious speculation. After all, if they do ever find any real evidence they can always change their mind later.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 12:53:21 AM
I'm angry with however took her from that apartment, that much is true, I simply don't believe it was a predator.
I don't believe it as well, but being angry ? For what he did ? Because doing so was an expedient the consequences of which could only be disastrous ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 22, 2013, 01:06:26 AM
I don't believe it as well, but being angry ? For what he did ? Because doing so was an expedient the consequences of which could only be disastrous ?

Angry that a little girl was not treated with the respect she deserved.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: icabodcrane on October 22, 2013, 01:12:46 AM
I also think that it is most probable that Maddie was abducted by a predator, but we won't know the answer to that until she is found. That is where all efforts should be concentrated in my opinion, finding Maddie, and hopefully that's what the authorities in Portugal and the UK, and indeed anyone who can actually help in any practical sense, are now doing. If they succeed , then more light will be shed on the cause of the disappearance. I therefore think the police are absolutely right not to do anything to fuel salacious speculation. After all, if they do ever find any real evidence they can always change their mind later.

I agree

Whilst there is still the slightest hope that this child may be found alive,  then all efforts should be directed there

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 01:27:12 AM
Angry that a little girl was not treated with the respect she deserved.
The Marquês de Pombal, just after the 1755 earthquake of Lisbon, quoted Matthew 8, 21 "let the dead bury their own" and added "let's take care of the living ones".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on October 22, 2013, 02:02:52 AM
The Marquês de Pombal, just after the 1755 earthquake of Lisbon, quoted Matthew 8, 21 "let the dead bury their own" and added "let's take care of the living ones".

While understanding the McCann's motivation I am still be appalled that they were guided by expediency rather than the paternal love they felt for Madeleine.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Cariad on October 22, 2013, 07:33:00 AM
The Marquês de Pombal, just after the 1755 earthquake of Lisbon, quoted Matthew 8, 21 "let the dead bury their own" and added "let's take care of the living ones".

What a perfect quote! You always find the right words Anne.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on October 22, 2013, 09:18:41 AM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?

Reverting to the opening post for a moment, I think it is more a case of not being able to rule them in than rule them out.  There is a lot of substantial evidence in the case which unfortunately is also neutral evidence and consequently can be taken both ways.

The confuddled statements, the Martin Smith supposed sighting of Gerry carrying a child, the Martin Grime dog alerts, the inconclusive DNA tests, the arguido status all combine to create an illusion of guilt. 

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 22, 2013, 09:30:53 AM
Reverting to the opening post for a moment, I think it is more a case of not being able to rule them in than rule them out.  There is a lot of substantial evidence in the case which unfortunately is also neutral evidence and consequently can be taken both ways.

The confuddled statements, the Martin Smith supposed sighting of Gerry carrying a child, the Martin Grime dog alerts, the inconclusive DNA tests, the arguido status all combine to create an illusion of guilt. 

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.

It remains to be seen if SY make any better progress in their investigation. By that I mean actually come up with an irrefutable result.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 22, 2013, 09:54:59 AM
Reverting to the opening post for a moment, I think it is more a case of not being able to rule them in than rule them out.  There is a lot of substantial evidence in the case which unfortunately is also neutral evidence and consequently can be taken both ways.

The confuddled statements, the Martin Smith supposed sighting of Gerry carrying a child, the Martin Grime dog alerts, the inconclusive DNA tests, the arguido status all combine to create an illusion of guilt. 

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.

Also SY have considered all the known facts of the case and we don't have all the known facts. 

And - most importantly IMO  - the facts considered by SY are not contaminated by the inclusion of  the myths, lies, distortions and disinformation which abound re this case, and on which many sceptics appear to base their own opinions.
IMO.       

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 11:37:21 AM
Also SY have considered all the known facts of the case and we don't have all the known facts. 

And - most importantly IMO  - the facts considered by SY are not contaminated by the inclusion of  the myths, lies, distortions and disinformation which abound re this case, and on which many sceptics appear to base their own opinions.
IMO.       
You're libelling us, Benice ;)
At least try to be more specific !
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 11:40:28 AM

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.
Just one vital and crucial ignored lead (and a date), please Angelo.
I promise not to inform Dra Duarte.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 11:46:12 AM

Thank you, Cariad !
Someone, in a panic, does a fatal choice thinking and hoping the essential still remaining will be secured thanks to that choice.
That choice implies a lie. Aren't those who believe it's the truth also responsible ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on October 22, 2013, 11:49:35 AM
Reverting to the opening post for a moment, I think it is more a case of not being able to rule them in than rule them out.  There is a lot of substantial evidence in the case which unfortunately is also neutral evidence and consequently can be taken both ways.

The confuddled statements, the Martin Smith supposed sighting of Gerry carrying a child, the Martin Grimes dog alerts, the inconclusive DNA tests, the arguido status all combine to create an illusion of guilt. 

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.

Angelo, it was the McCanns themselves who created the myth the police were out to get them.

September 7 2007:

(http://s24.postimg.org/wt92cdszp/Imagesn4.jpg)

(http://s23.postimg.org/e8ho19jrv/Imagesn6.jpg)

TV presenters confirmed police said nothing to them that day.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on October 22, 2013, 11:56:58 AM
Reverting to the opening post for a moment, I think it is more a case of not being able to rule them in than rule them out.  There is a lot of substantial evidence in the case which unfortunately is also neutral evidence and consequently can be taken both ways.

The confuddled statements, the Martin Smith supposed sighting of Gerry carrying a child, the Martin Grimes dog alerts, the inconclusive DNA tests, the arguido status all combine to create an illusion of guilt. 

In the final analysis however I do tend to agree that the police chose to ignore vital and crucial leads because they were too busy trying to crucify the parents.

And what were these vital and crucial leads you are talking about? The PJ followed the evidence they had at the time and it led them to the parents. After Gonçalo Amaral was taken off the case, it seems that Paulo Rebelo did not find any "vital and crucial" evidence that would have eliminated Kate and Gerry McCann from the investigation.

BTW, people here conveniently forget that the PJ and LP investigated exclusively the abduction scenario for the first 3 months and that it was the British who first suggested that Madeleine was dead and that the cadaver dogs be brought in.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 22, 2013, 12:00:33 PM
Nor, it would seem, did Rebelo find any additional evidence to point in a different direction.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 12:15:17 PM
Nor, it would seem, did Rebelo find any additional evidence to point in a different direction.
That is precisely why, in a desperate attempt, the MP requested a reconstitution of the events.
Vital and crucial lead for the McCanns ? The MP thought it could be, if they were indeed not involved.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 22, 2013, 02:48:43 PM
Also SY have considered all the known facts of the case and we don't have all the known facts. 

And - most importantly IMO  - the facts considered by SY are not contaminated by the inclusion of  the myths, lies, distortions and disinformation which abound re this case, and on which many sceptics appear to base their own opinions.
IMO.       

We were told only two weeks ago by Sky News  that SY are only half way through all the files, so no, they cant have considered all the facts...a couple months ago we were told by various media two thirds of the way through, which one is correct I dont know...but I doubt SY are on top of everything  yet and thats before delving into real media, watching their documentaries and reading Kates Book which are appendages to the process

As for your second paragraph, well it works both ways you know..and a bit of a accusatory and vague statement to make...but at least you used the word appear.....because you are making huge assumptions and presumptions on what any sceptic is basing any opinion on....
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 02:56:19 PM
The number of British people who have come forward  to say their evidence was ignored speaks volumes.  Heaven knows how many just gave up.  No wonder Jenny Murat set up a stall on the beach and drove around in her camper van trying to illicit help.  That really speaks for itself!!   The PJ must have been rightly pissed off at her.
This is pure speculation, Angelo. The world is full of people dreaming of their Andy Warhol 15 minutes of fame and ready to give it a little help.

 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 22, 2013, 03:00:05 PM
This is pure speculation, Angelo. The world is full of people dreaming of their Andy Warhol 15 minutes of fame and ready to give it a little help.

Yes I noticed none of these people came forward to complain before the Mccanns were made arguidos and Metodo 3 employed.....


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Kazcutt on October 22, 2013, 05:06:00 PM
Its amazing how many worshiped smithy when he said it was gerry now people are wondering if he lied .
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: imustpointout on October 22, 2013, 05:08:06 PM
as Smith said:

Quote
As he reached this artery, he saw an individual carrying a child, who walked normally and fitted in perfectly in that area, in that it is common to see people carrying children, at least during the holiday season.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on October 22, 2013, 05:09:06 PM
Its amazing how many worshiped smithy when he said it was gerry now people are wondering if he lied .

Why would anyone think that Mr. and Mrs. Smith would lie?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 22, 2013, 05:10:52 PM
he walked back and forth on one short part of a street  - he didn't walk throughout PDL.

and you know smithman walked through pdl, do you? how? You dont know his start and end of journey
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: imustpointout on October 22, 2013, 05:13:33 PM
and you know smithman walked through pdl, do you? how? You dont know his start and end of journey

I was referring to your comment about Gerry - who walked from Tapas up the street to the apt.

You broadened his comment to include other areas (i.e where the Smith sighting was)

Have you any proof that Gerry was referring to anywhere else apart from where he walked on his checks? 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 22, 2013, 05:17:37 PM
I was referring to your comment about Gerry - who walked from Tapas up the street to the apt.

You broadened his comment to include other areas (i.e where the Smith sighting was)

Have you any proof that Gerry was referring to anywhere else apart from where he walked on his checks?

No, do forgive my error, off to self flagelate and recharge my tablet
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 22, 2013, 06:44:37 PM
Why would anyone think that Mr. and Mrs. Smith would lie?
If there's a fact, a solid one, in this case, it is Smithman. If he was carrying Madeleine and was an abductor, he inaugurated an unprecedented way to abduct a child. May be he hated cars and all the gadgets of post modernity.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Cariad on October 22, 2013, 06:50:55 PM
If there's a fact, a solid one, in this case, it is Smithman. If he was carrying Madeleine and was an abductor, he inaugurated an unprecedented way to abduct a child. May be he hated cars and all the gadgets of post modernity.

an Amish abductor? That's brilliant!  ?{)(**
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 02:34:20 PM

“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

 Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsP9EVG4XHY&feature=youtu.be


 Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 02:38:37 PM
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

 Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsP9EVG4XHY&feature=youtu.be


Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.

How do you intend to do that, exactly ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 02:42:36 PM
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

 Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsP9EVG4XHY&feature=youtu.be


 Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.




Well yes but the e-fits do look like Gerry.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 02:43:52 PM
How do you intend to do that, exactly ?

its madeleine's facebook page ..but theres no exceptions for the likes of this forum page..trolls anywhere will not be tolerated..take heed.. ?>)()<
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 02:45:41 PM
Well yes but the e-fits do look like Gerry.


if you say so ... 8-)(--)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 02:46:26 PM
its madeleine's facebook page ..but theres no exceptions for the likes of this forum page..trolls anywhere will not be tolerated..take heed.. ?>)()<

Ah well, I don't do Facebook, but tell me, is that the stamping of a little foot I hear, or the sound of a dummy being spat out ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 02:48:05 PM

if you say so ... 8-)(--)

I do and so do many other people.
 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 02:55:01 PM
Well yes but the e-fits do look like Gerry.

Well the efit looks more like Cristoavo to me, but we both have our own opinions, that suit us, I suppose!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 03:00:47 PM
I do and so do many other people.

when you say many people..you obviously mean McCann bashers ...read the witness statements on Gerry's where about at the time of the smith sighting... 8(0(*


will leave you to burn yourselves out  8((()*/
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 03:16:54 PM
when you say many people..you obviously mean McCann bashers ...read the witness statements on Gerry's where about at the time of the smith sighting... 8(0(*


will leave you to burn yourselves out  8((()*/

.read the witness statements on Gerry's where about at the time of the smith sighting...

Yes of course, his whereabouts can also be confirmed by the reconstituion they all willingly took part in....
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 23, 2013, 03:26:53 PM
when you say many people..you obviously mean McCann bashers ...read the witness statements on Gerry's where about at the time of the smith sighting... 8(0(*


will leave you to burn yourselves out  8((()*/

But what do we know? When Fiona came to the apartment at around 10.05pm only Kate was there. All the others were outside searching for Madeleine.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 23, 2013, 04:25:15 PM
Well yes but the e-fits do look like Gerry.
No, Wonderfulspam, they don't. Actually I doubt they look like any real person. And they are two ! It looks like DCI Redwood likes to puzzle people.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Kazcutt on October 23, 2013, 04:38:36 PM
Tell you what if it was gerry in two places at one time he must have been clever to do what he did .are them pj really that crap ? They couldnt work out it was gerry but everyday joe bloggie can . 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)( and he hd a child on holday for 25 days then moved the body again right under their nose ,you got to hand it to him  8@??)(
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 04:42:23 PM
Tell you what if it was gerry in two places at one time he must have been clever to do what he did .are them pj really that crap ? They couldnt work out it was gerry but everyday joe bloggie can . 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)( and he hd a child on holday for 25 days then moved the body again right under their nose ,you got to hand it to him  8@??)(


 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 04:45:12 PM
Tell you what if it was gerry in two places at one time he must have been clever to do what he did .are them pj really that crap ? They couldnt work out it was gerry but everyday joe bloggie can . 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)( and he hd a child on holday for 25 days then moved the body again right under their nose ,you got to hand it to him  8@??)(

 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(

Glad you agree.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: icabodcrane on October 23, 2013, 04:48:03 PM
No, Wonderfulspam, they don't. Actually I doubt they look like any real person. And they are two ! It looks like DCI Redwood likes to puzzle people.

What troubles me about the e fits  is that they were produced by the McCanns private detectives  (  the  metodo 3 crooks  ?  )  and had been sittingin  the McCanns private files for years !

I mean,  why didn't  Scotland Yard interview the Smith family and produce their  own  officially sanctioned e fit  ? 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 04:53:25 PM
The Smith family are Irish citizens and may not wish to be questioned further by a foreign police service.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 04:54:47 PM
The Smith family are Irish citizens and may not wish to be questioned further by a foreign police service.


don't blame them really...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 04:58:01 PM
What troubles me about the e fits  is that they were produced by the McCanns private detectives  (  the  metodo 3 crooks  ?  )  and had been sittingin  the McCanns private files for years !

I mean,  why didn't  Scotland Yard interview the Smith family and produce their  own  officially sanctioned e fit  ? 

"sitting in  the McCanns private files for years !"

Indeed, a stone that appears to have been left unturned. But why?  What logical explanation can there be?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 23, 2013, 05:01:08 PM
I agree its impossible to be in 2 places at one time yes!! ...sy don't say it was Gerry in that e-fit .and that's good enough for me ...rather take their word than a few forkers anyday  ?{)(**

The old ladies at my local swimming pool will no doubt be pleased to be described as forkers
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: icabodcrane on October 23, 2013, 05:05:26 PM
The Smith family are Irish citizens and may not wish to be questioned further by a foreign police service.

You think the Smiths would refuse to assist Scotland Yard  ?  ...  I don't think there's any reason to asume that

What is worrying is that the Smiths have said they never provided anyone  with e fit descriptions previously  ...  so how did   the Metado 3 shower came up with them  ? 

What is even more worrying is that Scotland appear appear to be running with the information provided by a bunch of crooks who are now in jail ! 

If identifying the man  the Smiths saw is of such vital importance to the investigation,  then surely  all efforts should have made to procure an e fit  using Scotland Yard's own expertise and personel

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 05:27:12 PM
You think the Smiths would refuse to assist Scotland Yard  ?  ...  I don't think there's any reason to asume that

What is worrying is that the Smiths have said they never provided anyone  with e fit descriptions previously  ...  so how did   the Metado 3 shower came up with them  ? 

What is even more worrying is that Scotland appear appear to be running with the information provided by a bunch of crooks who are now in jail ! 

If identifying the man  the Smiths saw is of such vital importance to the investigation,  then surely  all efforts should have made to procure an e fit  using Scotland Yard's own expertise and personel

I really couldn't say how the Smiths feel about the whole thing 6 years on.

I,too, find it strange that SY should be placing so much emphasis on old e-fit pictures of dubious provenance.
 and I can't begin to understand   just what they are about.

I do wonder if they wanted the Crimewatch programme for some covert purpose of their own  and  they had to create some 'new breakthrough'  in order to justify screening the programme, Certainly a great deal has been put into the public domain as a consequence.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benita on October 23, 2013, 05:36:35 PM
McCann's cleared along with murat

1:07 in
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Uy6Pp6pek8
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 23, 2013, 05:41:46 PM
You think the Smiths would refuse to assist Scotland Yard  ?  ...  I don't think there's any reason to asume that

What is worrying is that the Smiths have said they never provided anyone  with e fit descriptions previously  ...  so how did   the Metado 3 shower came up with them  ? 

What is even more worrying is that Scotland appear appear to be running with the information provided by a bunch of crooks who are now in jail ! 

If identifying the man  the Smiths saw is of such vital importance to the investigation,  then surely  all efforts should have made to procure an e fit  using Scotland Yard's own expertise and personel
I find it worrying spreading e-fits dated September 2008 and apparently not done by the Smiths since they refused Mr Kennedy's suggestion.
They weren't made by Metodo 3 who were dismissed in March 2008. Surely the crook number 2 had better to do than having e-fits done, he was dismissed beginning of September 2008. By that time Edgar hadn't yet entered the scene. His mission seems to have been limited to PDL.
These two e-fits have a jamming taste..
Would the Smiths accept doing genuine e-fits ? I wonder if the Sr couple didn't go as far as they thought their duty to go, I don't think they'd like Aoife to be involved.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Myster on October 23, 2013, 06:10:10 PM
I may be way out here but if you say the Smiths didn't provide them, could the first e-fit have been rendered by the computer artist using the spottyman drawing from someone else's sighting as a reference. I mentioned before that this was more caricature than likeness, but IMO there are similarities in the features, especially the pointed jaw, longish nose, and downward slope of the mouth to the right.

The quiff, acne and hollow cheeks might have been over-exaggerated by the spottyman artist, which was then made more natural-looking in the e-fit render.

(http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/3206/me0d.jpg)
 
How prominent would pock marks be anyway, especially at night in the shadowy Primary School Street ?

Why is there such a big difference in facial shape between the two Crimewatch e-fits when it's supposed to be the same person identified by the same family?

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 06:13:32 PM
I really couldn't say how the Smiths feel about the whole thing 6 years on.

I,too, find it strange that SY should be placing so much emphasis on old e-fit pictures of dubious provenance.
 and I can't begin to understand   just what they are about.

I do wonder if they wanted the Crimewatch programme for some covert purpose of their own  and  they had to create some 'new breakthrough'  in order to justify screening the programme, Certainly a great deal has been put into the public domain as a consequence.

Well this is how they felt last week

Madeleine McCann: Key witness accuses Portuguese police of not taking his vital prime suspect evidence seriously

16 Oct 2013 07:59

Retired businessman Martin Smith provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man close to where Maddie vanished

A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case claimed yesterday that Portuguese police failed to take his evidence seriously.
 
Retired businessman Martin Smith, 64, provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man carrying a child at 10pm close to where the three-year-old vanished more than six years ago.
 
But he said his information was virtually ignored by local officers because they were too busy chasing up another sighting of a man near Kate and Gerry McCann’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz 45 minutes earlier.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-key-witness-accuses-2433328#ixzz2iZ9HqCcZ

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 06:17:26 PM
Where did spottyman come from?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 23, 2013, 06:17:59 PM
I may be way out here but if you say the Smiths didn't provide them, could the first e-fit have been rendered by the computer artist using the spottyman drawing from someone else's sighting as a reference. I mentioned before that this was more caricature than likeness, but IMO there are similarities in the features, especially the pointed jaw, longish nose, and downward slope of the mouth to the right.

The quiff, acne and hollow cheeks might have been over-exaggerated by the spottyman artist, which was then made more natural-looking in the e-fit render.

(http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/3206/me0d.jpg)
 
How prominent would pock marks be anyway, especially at night in the shadowy Primary School Street ?

Why is there such a big difference in facial shape between the two Crimewatch e-fits when it's supposed to be the same person identified by the same family?

Just to confuse things and someone will correct me if Im wrong, this is another efit done of spottyman...and this efit was also shown on crimewatch! Could they really be two of the same man? Wheres the latest ones glasses? If it was based on spottyman.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/T_M_S_AGE_12.htm

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 06:21:50 PM
I may be way out here but if you say the Smiths didn't provide them, could the first e-fit have been rendered by the computer artist using the spottyman drawing from someone else's sighting as a reference. I mentioned before that this was more caricature than likeness, but IMO there are similarities in the features, especially the pointed jaw, longish nose, and downward slope of the mouth to the right.

The quiff, acne and hollow cheeks might have been over-exaggerated by the spottyman artist, which was then made more natural-looking in the e-fit render.

(http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/3206/me0d.jpg)
 
How prominent would pock marks be anyway, especially at night in the shadowy Primary School Street ?

Why is there such a big difference in facial shape between the two Crimewatch e-fits when it's supposed to be the same person identified by the same family?

That is not the Smiths efit person, Myster.

A sketch of the ugly-looking man has been made in the hope that someone can identify him.
 
One British tourist said she saw him twice. She first noticed him four days before the three-year-old was snatched and then saw him again on May 2 – the day before the disappearance.
 
She said: “I saw a man acting suspiciously on two occasions. The first time I saw him I was walking along the road with my daughter.
 
“I grabbed my daughter’s hand and pulled her towards me because for some reason the man unnerved me.
 
“The next time I saw him he was standing on the opposite side to the apartment. He was watching it. I would describe him as very ugly, with pitted skin with a large nose.”
 
The second witness is a 12-year-old girl who said she saw a man outside the balcony of the McCanns’ flat at about 8.15am on April 30.
 
She said: “I was walking to the school bus stop. I go this way to school every day. I saw a man on the small path behind the block. He seemed to be looking at the balcony of the ground-floor apartment. My grandparents used to live in that apartment so I always look at it as I pass by.”
 
The girl saw the man staring at the flat again at lunchtime on May 2.
 
The third witness is a Cheshire man who was walking with his partner at about 11.30am on May 2 or 3.
 
He said: “I saw a man standing next to a wall. On the opposite side of the road was a white van.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-did-this-man-snatch-maddy-392507#ixzz2iZCT0LIR
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 23, 2013, 06:25:53 PM
An awful lot of people just hanging around looking suspicious.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on October 23, 2013, 06:27:02 PM
Well this is how they felt last week

Madeleine McCann: Key witness accuses Portuguese police of not taking his vital prime suspect evidence seriously

16 Oct 2013 07:59

Retired businessman Martin Smith provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man close to where Maddie vanished

A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case claimed yesterday that Portuguese police failed to take his evidence seriously.
 
Retired businessman Martin Smith, 64, provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man carrying a child at 10pm close to where the three-year-old vanished more than six years ago.
 
But he said his information was virtually ignored by local officers because they were too busy chasing up another sighting of a man near Kate and Gerry McCann’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz 45 minutes earlier.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-key-witness-accuses-2433328#ixzz2iZ9HqCcZ

After Gonçalo Amaral was taken off of the case, his successor, unfortunately, cancelled the plane tickets and hotel reservations that were being prepared so that the Smiths could make their statements in Portugal and opted for rogatory letters instead. AFAIK, Mr. Smith has never given any interviews to the newspapers and IMO the story from the Mirror is more than dubious.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 23, 2013, 06:37:03 PM
An awful lot of people just hanging around looking suspicious.

people do hang around when on holiday quite a bit.......waiting for their friends eg some even wear shorts and no tops (men that is).....as for "acting suspiciously" well that has to be one of the most subjective things.....
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Albertini on October 23, 2013, 06:38:22 PM
So here's what i don't understand.

Supporters of the family have always put discrepancies about timelines down to the natural way in which different people remember the timings of events.

Why is that principal now being thrown out of the window when it comes to getting around that awkward Smith sighting and ID of Gerry (60-80%)?

You cannot have it both ways. Either people remember timings differently in which case the alibi for Gerry is not as cast iron as some would have us believe or if timings are to be taken as absolutes, well, the Tapas lot have a lot of explaining to do.

So which is it? You can adopt one position or the other but not both and certainly not at the same time.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 06:50:33 PM
After Gonçalo Amaral was taken off of the case, his successor, unfortunately, cancelled the plane tickets and hotel reservations that were being prepared so that the Smiths could make their statements in Portugal and opted for rogatory letters instead. AFAIK, Mr. Smith has never given any interviews to the newspapers and IMO the story from the Mirror is more than dubious.

Why would they need hotel reservations, when they own a villa?

Where is your above quote from?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 23, 2013, 07:02:16 PM
Why would they need hotel reservations, when they own a villa?

Where is your above quote from?

They co owned an apartment in PDL...not a villa...perhaps PJ wanted them near Portimao for the day or so

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 07:27:34 PM
They co owned an apartment in PDL...not a villa...perhaps PJ wanted them near Portimao for the day or so

Ah see, easy done. Especially when his own son says he owns it.

States that his father owns an apartment in the town of Luz, Lagos, namely in Urban. Estrela da Luz, corresponding to A1C. His father comes to Portugal at least three times per year. The deponent went the first time that he travelled to Portugal.

And Martin says, co owned.

This apartment is co-owned by a friend whose name is Li** ON****.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 23, 2013, 07:29:04 PM
Ah see, easy done. Especially when his own son says he owns it.

States that his father owns an apartment in the town of Luz, Lagos, namely in Urban. Estrela da Luz, corresponding to A1C. His father comes to Portugal at least three times per year. The deponent went the first time that he travelled to Portugal.

Owned/co owned, no different....they both own it, together

 @)(++(*

no reason to get pedantic over nothing......
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Myster on October 23, 2013, 07:32:36 PM
OK then...scrub that idea. So the two new e-fits are based on what the Smiths saw even though they look to me like different men (pointy or lantern-jawed, take your pick) if one believes the Mirror... or not, if Montclair is correct that the Smiths had no direct contact with the Portuguese police other than through rogatory letters...
  >@@(*&)

DCI, I have seen the 4 or 5 McCann "Crimewatch Style Reconstructions" on which the Mirror transcript was based, but even the spottyman actor was only a vague impersonation, e.g. no teddy-boy haircut... http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html (http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on October 23, 2013, 08:02:51 PM
OK then...scrub that idea. So the two new e-fits are based on what the Smiths saw even though they look to me like different men (pointy or lantern-jawed, take your pick) if one believes the Mirror... or not, if Montclair is correct that the Smiths had no direct contact with the Portuguese police other than through rogatory letters...
  >@@(*&)

DCI, I have seen the 4 or 5 McCann "Crimewatch Style Reconstructions" on which the Mirror transcript was based, but even the spottyman actor was only a vague impersonation, e.g. no teddy-boy haircut... http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html (http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html)

The Smiths were never interviewed after GA was taken off the case because the rogatory letters were sent to the UK instead of Ireland and then nothing more was done. Don't ask me why, I don't know. Perhaps Paulo Rebelo didn't think the sighting was significant or just didn't want to go any further.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on October 23, 2013, 08:04:30 PM
Why would they need hotel reservations, when they own a villa?

Where is your above quote from?

It is possible that the PJ wanted him to stay in a hotel away from the curious eyes of the press who would find out where the Smiths had their apartment and closer to Portimão.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 23, 2013, 08:21:19 PM
OK then...scrub that idea. So the two new e-fits are based on what the Smiths saw even though they look to me like different men (pointy or lantern-jawed, take your pick) if one believes the Mirror... or not, if Montclair is correct that the Smiths had no direct contact with the Portuguese police other than through rogatory letters...
  >@@(*&)

DCI, I have seen the 4 or 5 McCann "Crimewatch Style Reconstructions" on which the Mirror transcript was based, but even the spottyman actor was only a vague impersonation, e.g. no teddy-boy haircut... http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html (http://findmadeleine.com/campaigns/unidentified_people.html)

They are 2 different men. As I said above.


A sketch of the ugly-looking man has been made in the hope that someone can identify him.
 
One British tourist said she saw him twice. She first noticed him four days before the three-year-old was snatched and then saw him again on May 2 – the day before the disappearance.
 
She said: “I saw a man acting suspiciously on two occasions. The first time I saw him I was walking along the road with my daughter.
 
“I grabbed my daughter’s hand and pulled her towards me because for some reason the man unnerved me.
 
“The next time I saw him he was standing on the opposite side to the apartment. He was watching it. I would describe him as very ugly, with pitted skin with a large nose.”
 
The second witness is a 12-year-old girl who said she saw a man outside the balcony of the McCanns’ flat at about 8.15am on April 30.
 
She said: “I was walking to the school bus stop. I go this way to school every day. I saw a man on the small path behind the block. He seemed to be looking at the balcony of the ground-floor apartment. My grandparents used to live in that apartment so I always look at it as I pass by.”
 
The girl saw the man staring at the flat again at lunchtime on May 2.
 
The third witness is a Cheshire man who was walking with his partner at about 11.30am on May 2 or 3.

They can't be the same men as these sightings were on the days leading up to May 3rd.

The picture shows a man that was seen several times by different witnesses during the days leading up to Madeleine's abduction on May 3rd 2007. He was described as ugly with pock-marked skin and was said to be watching the family's apartment intently.

(http://findmadeleine.com/images/witness_account2.png)

Martin did have direct contact with the PJ, before the rogatory's too

Processos Vol XI Page 2875

Policia Judiciaria

NUIPC 201-070 GALGS

NOTE

On this date I state for the files that at about 12.12 I had telephone contact with the witness Martin Smith, by means of phone number ********* who referred to the communication he made on 20-09-2007 to the British authorities, that confirms his sighting and showing his full availability to travel to Portugal with the aim of making statements and collaborating with this police in all the diligences that could be considered necessary concerning these events.

Portimao, 27th September 2007

Signed

Inspector Paiva
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 23, 2013, 08:24:54 PM
Biased sources are not on DCI.....then again perhaps its good etiquette to give links hey?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: gilet on October 24, 2013, 09:30:04 AM
After Gonçalo Amaral was taken off of the case, his successor, unfortunately, cancelled the plane tickets and hotel reservations that were being prepared so that the Smiths could make their statements in Portugal and opted for rogatory letters instead. AFAIK, Mr. Smith has never given any interviews to the newspapers and IMO the story from the Mirror is more than dubious.

Having personally heard part of a recorded interview done with Mr Smith by a journalist some time ago broadcast  on TV this last week I fear your knowledge is simply not complete.

Could you provide any evidence (from the files perhaps) of your claim regarding the preparations for the Smiths to return to Portugal. I have looked carefully and found none. 

What I have found is that Portimao Police received notification of the Martin Smith update to his statement on the day he contacted LP (20th September 2007).

Then Paiva, seven whole days later finally telephoned Mr. Smith who is reported in the conversation to have agreed to return to Portugal if necessary.

But there is nothing suggesting the PJ made any efforts to arrange this return.

Their next action was on the 10th of October. And this highlights dramatically the botched job done by Amaral's team. They finally got round to going to Kelly's bar where they at last managed to interview the staff and ask for till receipts to check the timing of the Smith sighting. Why on earth had this not been done before? What kind of police force in the case of a missing child fails so abjectly to undertake such basic inquiries as those needed to establish the exact timing of a potentially important sighting? No wonder Rebelo was so appalled at the state of the investigation when he took over from Amaral. Five months and such a basic task had not been completed.

Contact was indeed later made with the Irish police by Rebelo's team to have them interview the Smiths in Ireland and the results of that interview are in the files. This was done directly via the Gardai liaison based at the Madrid embassy.  But where is this evidence of the plane tickets being arranged as you claim?


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 24, 2013, 01:15:38 PM
So here's what i don't understand.

Supporters of the family have always put discrepancies about timelines down to the natural way in which different people remember the timings of events.

Why is that principal now being thrown out of the window when it comes to getting around that awkward Smith sighting and ID of Gerry (60-80%)?




You cannot have it both ways. Either people remember timings differently in which case the alibi for Gerry is not as cast iron as some would have us believe or if timings are to be taken as absolutes, well, the Tapas lot have a lot of explaining to do.

So which is it? You can adopt one position or the other but not both and certainly not at the same time.
Who was the man who left for half an hour ?
 The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 24, 2013, 02:15:32 PM
Who was the man who left for half an hour ?
 The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm)

IMO that was Russell  - who left the table at around 9.30 with Matt to check on the children, but who did not return because one of his children was unwell.    IIRC he remained there until JT went to relieve him so that he could go and finish his meal.   He had been gone so long that a fresh meal was provided by the staff on his return  - which he was still eating when the alarm was raised at 10.00.     That would tie in with ''shortly after he returned all left the table...''.   

 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 24, 2013, 02:19:42 PM
IMO that was Russell  - who left the table at around 9.30 with Matt to check on the children, but who did not return because one of his children was unwell.    IIRC he remained there until JT went to relieve him so that he could go and finish his meal.   He had been gone so long that a fresh meal was provided by the staff on his return  - which he was still eating when the alarm was raised at 10.00.     That would tie in with ''shortly after he returned all left the table...''.   

Couldnt have been russell as he had the most bulky hair! And the waiter says it wasnt either.

He  was referring to Oldfield IMO as he was very tall and had greying hair too...

--------- JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;
- The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;





Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 24, 2013, 02:43:47 PM
Couldnt have been russell as he had the most bulky hair! And the waiter says it wasnt either.

He  was referring to Oldfield IMO as he was very tall and had greying hair too...

--------- JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;
- The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;

There was only Russell's food reheated, unless you know of another member of the group that did?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Redblossom on October 24, 2013, 02:51:52 PM
There was only Russell's food reheated, unless you know of another member of the group that did?

Read back DCI......slowly...the question  was who was the second man
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 24, 2013, 03:05:10 PM
Read back DCI......slowly...the question  was who was the second man
A pity Mr Batista wasn't interviewed after Smithman had been possibly identified, to confirm who was the second man.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on October 24, 2013, 03:14:23 PM
A pity Mr Batista wasn't interviewed after Smithman had been possibly identified, to confirm who was the second man.

Perhaps he will be, though it's all a long time ago and he may not remember. though I'm sure the individual concerned does.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on October 24, 2013, 03:17:02 PM
Couldnt have been russell as he had the most bulky hair! And the waiter says it wasnt either.

He  was referring to Oldfield IMO as he was very tall and had greying hair too...

--------- JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;
- The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;

But was Matt gone for 15 mins Red ?    He checked on Madeleine and then on his own - and went back to the table.   Personally I think if he had been gone for 15 mins the McCanns would have been wondering why - and would have either gone to investigate or would at least have mentioned it on his return.

I thought it was only Russell's meal that was reheated(?) but went unfinished because the alarm was raised - which implies he did not return until fairly close to 10.00.

We know that 2 left - then Matt returned and much later Russell returned.  That moreorless fits with what the waiter remembered, except he may have got them both mixed up IMO - as he seems to have got mixed  up over whose meal was reheated.

This is from memory so could be wrong  - If I get time I'll have a look at the statements.




Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 24, 2013, 04:07:47 PM
No food was reheated, Mr O'Brien was served a new steak. He only ate 2 bits of it.
The second man might have left after eating his food.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on October 24, 2013, 05:12:01 PM
No food was reheated, Mr O'Brien was served a new steak. He only ate 2 bits of it.
The second man might have left after eating his food.

That kills this bit of his statement then.

The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;

How come a waiter had 45 minutes to stand and watch the group?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Admin on January 11, 2015, 03:32:54 PM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?


Official Find Madeleine Campaign
17 October 2013 at 14:33 ·
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.

~FM Webmaster

http://m.facebook.com/Official.Find.Madeleine.Campaign/posts/10151905090784931




Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 11, 2015, 03:50:53 PM
I think that SC are the only body, who can answer this, question.

There is a lot of things unknown to us and until the investigation is complete, we are unlikely to know the reasons for their findings and conclusions.

There is no concrete evidence of any wrongdoing by the McCanns, so why should we need concrete evidence of their innocence?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 11, 2015, 03:56:18 PM

In a word, Logistics.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: sadie on January 11, 2015, 04:08:54 PM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?


Official Find Madeleine Campaign
17 October 2013 at 14:33 ·
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.

~FM Webmaster

http://m.facebook.com/Official.Find.Madeleine.Campaign/posts/10151905090784931



Thank you Admin.

It has taken 15 months since that video [17 October 2013] but it is really good that you have made that ruling. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 11, 2015, 04:12:12 PM
DCI Redwood

"The McCanns & their group of friends are not suspects".

Can someone fill me in on exactly how they have been entirely ruled out?

What is the concrete evidence that proves their undoubtable lack of involvement in Madeleine's disappearance?


Official Find Madeleine Campaign
17 October 2013 at 14:33 ·
“Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects”
~DCI Andy Redwood

Listen at 1:07 on this video – Confirmation the McCanns are not suspects or persons of interest and neither are their friends.

Anyone continuing to carry on with the fallacy that the E-Fit is Gerry will be banned from this page. You've heard it directly from DCI Redwood that Gerry and Kate are not suspects and we will not tolerate the continued unfounded persecution of Gerry and Kate on this page.

~FM Webmaster

http://m.facebook.com/Official.Find.Madeleine.Campaign/posts/10151905090784931



The McCanns and their friends have been ruled out by SY according to Redwood...add to that SY are spending 10 mill investigating witnesses /suspects in Portugal...the archiving report said there is no evidence against the McCanns of any crime...looks pretty conclusive to me
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 06:13:33 PM
There is a belief on this forum and elsewhere that Op Grange has been issuing false statements with a deliberate intent to freak the McCanns out and/ or lull them into a false sense of security.  The view seems to be that they have been playing this game for at least 18 months.  Now, I don't know about you guys but I think this stretches  credulity more than a tad.  I know that Pat Brown Criminal Profiler happens to share my view (and it's just about the only thing we do agree on btw) but can anyone point to any other case in which the  police have played such a long and cunning game, stringing the suspects along for years, only to then pounce at the eleventh hour?  Can anyone tell me why emphatically ruling out the McCanns as suspects is a better tactic than emphatically stating that "no one has been ruled out at this stage", or even saying nothing at all, and remaining tight-lipped about the status of the McCanns?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 14, 2015, 06:46:20 PM
There is a belief on this forum and elsewhere that Op Grange has been issuing false statements with a deliberate intent to freak the McCanns out and/ or lull them into a false sense of security.  The view seems to be that they have been playing this game for at least 18 months. Now, I don't know about you guys but I think this stretches  credulity more than a tad.  I know that Pat Brown Criminal Profiler happens to share my view (and it's just about the only thing we do agree on btw) but can anyone point to any other case in which the  police have played such a long and cunning game, stringing the suspects along for years, only to then pounce at the eleventh hour?  Can anyone tell me why emphatically ruling out the McCanns as suspects is a better tactic than emphatically stating that "no one has been ruled out at this stage", or even saying nothing at all, and remaining tight-lipped about the status of the McCanns?

Is there?
Well it is stand up and be counted time then for as far as that postulation is concerned, in the immortal words of Sam Goldwyn (I think!), "Include me out".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 06:57:33 PM
Is there?
Well it is stand up and be counted time then for as far as that postulation is concerned, in the immortal words of Sam Goldwyn (I think!), "Include me out".
Yes there is.  There is also a view that Redwood was put on the spot by the interviewer at a "press conference" and had no option but to state categorically that the McCanns were not suspects, or risk being in big trouble, presumably of a legal nature.  I would like to see a clip of this incident, where Redwood is put on the spot at the press conference, which I presume was televised live, as if it had not been live he could have simply asked for the cameras to stop rolling and instructed the assembled throng of journalists that he was not at liberty to discuss certain elements of the case, this being one of them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Carana on January 14, 2015, 07:45:08 PM
Yes there is.  There is also a view that Redwood was put on the spot by the interviewer at a "press conference" and had no option but to state categorically that the McCanns were not suspects, or risk being in big trouble, presumably of a legal nature.  I would like to see a clip of this incident, where Redwood is put on the spot at the press conference, which I presume was televised live, as if it had not been live he could have simply asked for the cameras to stop rolling and instructed the assembled throng of journalists that he was not at liberty to discuss certain elements of the case, this being one of them.

I haven't seen any Q&A sessions (or don't recall any). However, I would find it quite likely that if there was one, that journos would ask him point blank if the McCanns or any of the T7 were suspects... hence the answer to clarify the point. It was a grumble in Leveson that LP hadn't briefed the press even off-the-record that the PJ interpretation of the forensics was crap - although LP did send two missives but which were so vague that no one knew what LP was referring to. Journos also asked point blank re the Jo Yeates case re the boyfriend and the point was clarified that he wasn't.

From a variety of press conferences that I've watched, if there is a serious doubt or a potential one, the police use their standard waffle of "a number of leads are being followed and no one can be excluded at this point".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 14, 2015, 07:58:25 PM
Yes there is.  There is also a view that Redwood was put on the spot by the interviewer at a "press conference" and had no option but to state categorically that the McCanns were not suspects, or risk being in big trouble, presumably of a legal nature.  I would like to see a clip of this incident, where Redwood is put on the spot at the press conference, which I presume was televised live, as if it had not been live he could have simply asked for the cameras to stop rolling and instructed the assembled throng of journalists that he was not at liberty to discuss certain elements of the case, this being one of them.

First off read my view on the postulation again and hold that firmly in your head and do not read into what I say anything that is not there.
I recall DCI Redwood being dealt one off the bottom the deck by a Dutch female interviewer when she asked four square about the Drs McCann having been suspects and did they remain suspects.
Now try to consider that question in the light of an investigation concerning people named Ramsbottom or Greenhalgh. What would you expect him to say regardless of whether the Ramsbottoms/Greenhalghs were suspects or not and what reliability would you place on his answer to that question ? At the time he said it, it may well have been true but the investigation was incomplete therefore that consideration could change and frankly he could scarcely have said much else could he?
The trouble with this case is, mention the name McCann and folk of all flavours start to look for things that simply are not there and to a degree good sense and logic fly out the through the window.
Just remember Bob Dylan and Robert Browning? "You make it mean whatever you want it to mean I was just looking for a word to rhyme with coat" and: "when I wrote it God and Robert Browning knew what it meant; now God knows".
Trying to second guess what the fuzz really mean when they go on telly or give press conferences is a bit futile but the oxygen of life to this forum because everyone always knows "what they really meant" and there will always be at least two stories that are correct.
Good fun innit? 8(>((
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 14, 2015, 08:04:47 PM
First off read my view on the postulation again and hold that firmly in your head and do not read into what I say anything that is not there.
I recall DCI Redwood being dealt one off the bottom the deck by a Dutch female interviewer when she asked four square about the Drs McCann having been suspects and did they remain suspects.
Now try to consider that question in the light of an investigation concerning people named Ramsbottom or Greenhalgh. What would you expect him to say regardless of whether the Ramsbottoms/Greenhalghs were suspects or not and what reliability would you place on his answer to that question ? At the time he said it, it may well have been true but the investigation was incomplete therefore that consideration could change and frankly he could scarcely have said much else could he?
The trouble with this case is, mention the name McCann and folk of all flavours start to look for things that simply are not there and to a degree good sense and logic fly out the through the window.
Just remember Bob Dylan and Robert Browning? "You make it mean whatever you want it to mean I was just looking for a word to rhyme with coat" and: "when I wrote it God and Robert Browning knew what it meant; now God knows".
Trying to second guess what the fuzz really mean when they go on telly or give press conferences is a bit futile but the oxygen of life to this forum because everyone always knows "what they really meant" and there will always be at least two stories that are correct.
Good fun innit? 8(>((

You are assuming the card was dealt from the bottom of the deck whereas in these interviews the questions are agreed beforehand...as you have made a  mistake in your first line the rest of your long post is irrelevant
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 08:16:31 PM
First off read my view on the postulation again and hold that firmly in your head and do not read into what I say anything that is not there.
I recall DCI Redwood being dealt one off the bottom the deck by a Dutch female interviewer when she asked four square about the Drs McCann having been suspects and did they remain suspects.
Now try to consider that question in the light of an investigation concerning people named Ramsbottom or Greenhalgh. What would you expect him to say regardless of whether the Ramsbottoms/Greenhalghs were suspects or not and what reliability would you place on his answer to that question ? At the time he said it, it may well have been true but the investigation was incomplete therefore that consideration could change and frankly he could scarcely have said much else could he?
The trouble with this case is, mention the name McCann and folk of all flavours start to look for things that simply are not there and to a degree good sense and logic fly out the through the window.
Just remember Bob Dylan and Robert Browning? "You make it mean whatever you want it to mean I was just looking for a word to rhyme with coat" and: "when I wrote it God and Robert Browning knew what it meant; now God knows".
Trying to second guess what the fuzz really mean when they go on telly or give press conferences is a bit futile but the oxygen of life to this forum because everyone always knows "what they really meant" and there will always be at least two stories that are correct.
Good fun innit? 8(>((
Did Redwood make this statement regarding the McCanns no longer being suspects on Dutch TV before anywhere else then?  Can you supply a link to the clip please?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 08:45:12 PM
I've just watched that Dutch clip, which took place after Redwood first revealed the McCanns were not suspects on British TV.  Also, the interviewer didn't even ask him if they were suspects, he volunteered that information freely.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 14, 2015, 09:01:21 PM
To davel and alf
Yeah OK you make it mean whatever you want to make it mean which was roughly the thrust of my post  8(>((
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 09:12:04 PM
To davel and alf
Yeah OK you make it mean whatever you want to make it mean which was roughly the thrust of my post  8(>((
The only people making it mean anything other than what was actually said are certain "sceptics".  Don't get stroppy with us for point out this very obvious fact.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 14, 2015, 09:23:46 PM
The only people making it mean anything other than what was actually said are certain "sceptics".  Don't get stroppy with us for point out this very obvious fact.
Well you seem to think it was a definitive statement made publicly on the telly defining the McCanns innocence. Do you seriously believe that it was at that moment cast in concrete?  apart from the fact they have not been charged with anything and even had they been it would not be up to old bill to pronounce upon it.
Sorry old son but what the faithful or unfaithful think is hardly important in the general scheme of things.
I posted my opinion which I am entitled to do. Whether any one agrees with it or not does not matter to me as  I am not majoring in being an anorak in McCann.
You all seem to be a trifle tetchy today if one may say.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 14, 2015, 09:34:34 PM
Well you seem to think it was a definitive statement made publicly on the telly defining the McCanns innocence. Do you seriously believe that it was at that moment cast in concrete?  apart from the fact they have not been charged with anything and even had they been it would not be up to old bill to pronounce upon it.
Sorry old son but what the faithful or unfaithful think is hardly important in the general scheme of things.
I posted my opinion which I am entitled to do. Whether any one agrees with it or not does not matter to me as  I am not majoring in being an anorak in McCann.
You all seem to be a trifle tetchy today if one may say.
Sorry if it comes across that way, but I am entirely chilled and probably as untetchy as it's possible to be @)(++(*. It is up to the Old Bill to say (if they so choose) who they suspect and who they don't, it certainly isn't up to a bunch of sceptics to "read between the lines" of what they say and jump to ill-informed conclusions.  At the end of the day there is a large body of evidence which lends weight to the conclusion that the McCanns are no longer suspects, and a complete absence of evidence that they are in any way suspects.  I'm sure, being a smart guy, you must agree with this 8(>((
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 14, 2015, 10:12:30 PM
 8()-000( He said hopefully !!!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 14, 2015, 11:14:35 PM
Sorry if it comes across that way, but I am entirely chilled and probably as untetchy as it's possible to be @)(++(*. It is up to the Old Bill to say (if they so choose) who they suspect and who they don't, it certainly isn't up to a bunch of sceptics to "read between the lines" of what they say and jump to ill-informed conclusions.  At the end of the day there is a large body of evidence which lends weight to the conclusion that the McCanns are no longer suspects, and a complete absence of evidence that they are in any way suspects.  I'm sure, being a smart guy, you must agree with this 8(>((

Until the case is resolved, everyone's a suspect %£&)**#
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 07:30:28 AM
Until the case is resolved, everyone's a suspect %£&)**#

Not according to Redwood
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 08:04:37 AM
Until the case is resolved, everyone's a suspect %£&)**#
Better tell that to the Met who have stated quite categorically that the McCanns and their friends are not.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 15, 2015, 09:05:09 AM
Better tell that to the Met who have stated quite categorically that the McCanns and their friends are not.

And to the PJ too - as they also no longer consider the McCanns to be suspects or persons of interest.

It couldn't be more clear and simple could it - unless of course it's something you desperately do NOT want to believe  - and then all manner of conspiracy theories etc etc are proposed by sceptics - until after a couple of years and a million posts later - they have successfully convinced themselves that what DCI Redwood was really saying was........ 'The McCanns are prime suspects'.    And there we have it -  Job done!

The power of 'Wishful Thinking' is truly amazing.



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 09:07:19 AM
And to the PJ too - as they also no longer consider the McCanns to be suspects or persons of interest.

It couldn't be more clear and simple could it - unless of course it's something you desperately do NOT want to believe  - and then all manner of conspiracy theories etc etc are proposed by sceptics - until after a couple of years and a million posts later - they have successfully convinced themselves that what DCI Redwood was really saying was........ 'The McCanns are prime suspects'.    And there we have it -  Job done!

The power of 'Wishful Thinking' is truly amazing.

'wishful thinking'

Indeed.

That's called the abduction.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 15, 2015, 09:40:57 AM
'wishful thinking'

Indeed.

That's called the abduction.

So you keep saying - but have yet to give any reason/explanation as to why you know you are right and SY and the PJ are wrong.

What is it you know which SY and  the PJ have missed?




Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 09:51:25 AM
So you keep saying - but have yet to give any reason/explanation as to why you know you are right and SY and the PJ are wrong.

What is it you know which SY and  the PJ have missed?

I judge by results.

Now pray tell what have SY'S endeavors resulted in ?

Other than £10 M down the drain and free trips to the Algarve, what has been achieved ?

Likewise, how much have the Portuguese paid for the incompetence of two UK parents ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 15, 2015, 09:57:41 AM
You are assuming the card was dealt from the bottom of the deck whereas in these interviews the questions are agreed beforehand...as you have made a  mistake in your first line the rest of your long post is irrelevant
Not too good at understanding English in its metaphoric and ironic forms are we?
Also the bold bit is complete balderdash as it does not follow.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 15, 2015, 10:00:48 AM
Did Redwood make this statement regarding the McCanns no longer being suspects on Dutch TV before anywhere else then?  Can you supply a link to the clip please?

Try Googling DCI Redwood Dutch TV interview. You should find a 30 second clip downloaded by Bren Ryan that illustrates the point. If you can't find it on that description try alternative combinations; its there somewhere.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 15, 2015, 10:25:32 AM
Try Googling DCI Redwood Dutch TV interview. You should find a 30 second clip downloaded by Bren Ryan that illustrates the point. If you can't find it on that description try alternative combinations; its there somewhere.

Here's the clip Alice.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Otjtz8C-_p8

Interesting Redwood says Madeleine is 'lost' and not abducted.

The Redwood interviews in the UK only show his answers and not the questions asked so I think it would be almost impossible at this juncture to prove categorically how the 'McCanns are not suspects' comment came about.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 15, 2015, 10:41:43 AM
And to the PJ too - as they also no longer consider the McCanns to be suspects or persons of interest.

It couldn't be more clear and simple could it - unless of course it's something you desperately do NOT want to believe  - and then all manner of conspiracy theories etc etc are proposed by sceptics - until after a couple of years and a million posts later - they have successfully convinced themselves that what DCI Redwood was really saying was........ 'The McCanns are prime suspects'.    And there we have it -  Job done!

The power of 'Wishful Thinking' is truly amazing.

(http://223c19d623f9d2d34ef0-e625f70d1d9c1939c1b905f888c7c97b.r59.cf3.rackcdn.com/144-Stop-McCann-circus-Furious-locals-spray-graffiti.jpg)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 11:39:16 AM
Here's the clip Alice.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Otjtz8C-_p8

Interesting Redwood says Madeleine is 'lost' and not abducted.

The Redwood interviews in the UK only show his answers and not the questions asked so I think it would be almost impossible at this juncture to prove categorically how the 'McCanns are not suspects' comment came about.


but...it is a fact that Redwood has said the mccanns are not suspects on more than one occasion
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on January 15, 2015, 12:09:44 PM

but...it is a fact that Redwood has said the mccanns are not suspects on more than one occasion

So what?  He and his band of merry warriors at SY also fingered Barry George for the murder of Jill Dando and we all know how that friggin fiasco played out.  His credibility was questionable imo and now that he has retired we will never know what he would have delivered other than yet another huge bill for the taxpayers of this country.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:13:19 PM
1. There is no evidence to suggest that the McCanns are involved in Maddie’s disappearance.

2. SC are not looking for any evidence that may implicate the McCanns

3.The leader of the investigation has said that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects.

What else does one need, to be convinced of their non involvement?
----------------------------

Of course!
I forgot…..Proof is of no consequence to those with an over. vivid imagination and perverse satisfaction of creating cruel scenerios to implicate the innocent.

If you have proof of their involvement………………..Lets have it!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 01:21:32 PM
1. There is no evidence to suggest that the McCanns are involved in Maddie’s disappearance.

2. SC are not looking for any evidence that may implicate the McCanns

3.The leader of the investigation has said that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects.

What else does one need, to be convinced of their non involvement?
----------------------------

Of course!
I forgot…..Proof is of no consequence to those with an over. vivid imagination and perverse satisfaction of creating cruel scenerios to implicate the innocent.

If you have proof of their involvement………………..Lets have it!

A lack of evidence does not mean people didn't commit a crime.

As it stands Anna, as we all know there is no proof of anything, including the cause of Madeleine's disappearance,

and that doesn't look like changing.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 15, 2015, 01:27:00 PM
1. There is no evidence to suggest that the McCanns are involved in Maddie’s disappearance.

2. SC are not looking for any evidence that may implicate the McCanns

3.The leader of the investigation has said that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects.

What else does one need, to be convinced of their non involvement?
----------------------------

Of course!
I forgot…..Proof is of no consequence to those with an over. vivid imagination and perverse satisfaction of creating cruel scenerios to implicate the innocent.

If you have proof of their involvement………………..Lets have it!

I would hope that SY are looking for evidence that solves the case, and not ignoring evidence that points one way or another.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:29:30 PM
I would hope that SY are looking for evidence that solves the case, and not ignoring evidence that points one way or another.

I think the immediate family and friends, would have already been covered, but who knows what they may find.
However the are not at present being treated as suspects.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 15, 2015, 01:31:24 PM
Everybody is a suspect until the case is solved.

PJ says 'everybody is a suspect'
 
The director of the Policia Judiciaria in Faro, Guilhermino da Encarnacao, confirmed with Sol that "we do not discard the possibility of having the family and friends as suspects". This is always done "without neglecting other clues. Everybody who was at the resort at the time are suspects". (30 June 2007)

McCanns 'heartened' not to be suspects - The Daily Telegraph (12 August 2007)

Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa told the BBC that fresh evidence had given new "intensity" to the possibility that she had been killed but confirmed that the McCanns were not suspects.
The couple said that they were pleased by that news and added: "We sincerely hope that Madeleine is still alive."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:34:59 PM
A lack of evidence does not mean people didn't commit a crime.

As it stands Anna, as we all know there is no proof of anything, including the cause of Madeleine's disappearance,

and that doesn't look like changing.

Very true Stephen,
 Maybe it was me or you or anybody else in the world, who are not being treated as suspects and have no evidence against them, who caused Maddie to disappear.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 01:38:46 PM
Very true Stephen,
 Maybe it was me or you or anybody else in the world, who are not being treated as suspects and have no evidence against them, who caused Maddie to disappear.

Why did Redwood never say the McCann's and associates have been interviewed and cleared ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:42:23 PM
Why did Redwood never say the McCann's and associates have been interviewed and cleared ?

I have no idea, Stephen, but surely you don't believe, that this avenue has not already been explored
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 01:45:22 PM
I have no idea, Stephen, but surely you don't believe, that this avenue has not already been explored

Well if Redwood had simply stated that, there would be fewer questions relating to that issue.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:47:25 PM
Well if Redwood had simply stated that, there would be fewer questions relating to that issue.

Well, he didn't Stephen and there's little can be done about that now.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 01:48:33 PM
Well, he didn't Stephen and there's little can be done about that now.

True.

However, what has ever stopped SY issuing a statement to that effect.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 01:51:23 PM
True.

However, what has ever stopped SY issuing a statement to that effect.

Maybe you could contact them and ask this question, since only they can answer it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 02:09:08 PM
Try Googling DCI Redwood Dutch TV interview. You should find a 30 second clip downloaded by Bren Ryan that illustrates the point. If you can't find it on that description try alternative combinations; its there somewhere.
Thanks for that but you will see if you read reply #216 that I had already located it - this is my comment again:

I've just watched that Dutch clip, which took place after Redwood first revealed the McCanns were not suspects on British TV.  Also, the interviewer didn't even ask him if they were suspects, he volunteered that information freely.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 02:12:50 PM
Here's the clip Alice.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Otjtz8C-_p8

Interesting Redwood says Madeleine is 'lost' and not abducted.

The Redwood interviews in the UK only show his answers and not the questions asked so I think it would be almost impossible at this juncture to prove categorically how the 'McCanns are not suspects' comment came about.
The UK clips very much prove that his comments were not from a live broadcast and so anything that was asked that Redwood did not feel comfortable about answering he could have refused to comment and insisted that his "no comment" was not broadcast.  Therefore it is very clear to me, and most sensible people, that his statement was not said in response to him having been put on the spot but a very deliberate one, even perhaps prepared in advance.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on January 15, 2015, 02:19:29 PM
The UK clips very much prove that his comments were not from a live broadcast and so anything that was asked that Redwood did not feel comfortable about answering he could have refused to comment and insisted that his "no comment" was not broadcast.  Therefore it is very clear to me, and most sensible people, that his statement was not said in response to him having been put on the spot but a very deliberate one, even perhaps prepared in advance.

Barry George must reckon he's a f..king tosser to use Kates words.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 02:23:52 PM
Barry George must reckon he's a f.....g tosser to use Kates words.

so is Barry George innocent
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on January 15, 2015, 02:37:43 PM
Barry George must reckon he's a f.....g tosser to use Kates words.

When did Kate call Barry George  a f.....g tosser?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 03:31:05 PM
so is Barry George innocent

Not innocent enough, according to the judges ?8)@)-)

(Or the politicians/police)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 03:37:42 PM
Not innocent enough, according to the judges ?8)@)-)

(Or the politicians/police)

so he's just a bit innocent then
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 03:41:20 PM
so he's just a bit innocent then

It's another extraordinary case in which the politicians have become involved, including the police/CPS amongst them.

The last government changed the law. Prior to that change he would have been compensated.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 15, 2015, 03:47:04 PM
Thanks for that but you will see if you read reply #216 that I had already located it - this is my comment again:

I've just watched that Dutch clip, which took place after Redwood first revealed the McCanns were not suspects on British TV.  Also, the interviewer didn't even ask him if they were suspects, he volunteered that information freely.

I understood the first time around!
In the clip posted by Bren Ryan it appears that the clip is of the beginning of the interview and that the interviewer clearly asks for clarification about the suggestion that the McCanns were implicated. He said they weren't. But back to my question posed to you earlier which you ducked (a characteristic which when displayed  by others you become snotty about).
Forgetting the name McCann what would you expect him to say?
There are three possibilities.
Give it a body swerve and a no comment.
Say yes they are persons of interest.
Give the answer he did.
In an ongoing investigation the latter is the most sensible. He may well be right but until the investigation is complete who really knows?
We then have the polarised versions coming out "cor blimey he is covering something up" and "if you don't believe that what he said is God's honest truth for ever and a day you are simpleton".
My view and only my view you understand is that both stances are equally as barmy.
That's pretty much it really.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 03:51:55 PM
I understood the first time around!
In the clip posted by Bren Ryan it appears that the clip is of the beginning of the interview and that the interviewer clearly asks for clarification about the suggestion that the McCanns were implicated. He said they weren't. But back to my question posed to you earlier which you ducked (a characteristic which when displayed  by others you become snotty about).
Forgetting the name McCann what would you expect him to say?
There are three possibilities.
Give it a body swerve and a no comment.
Say yes they are persons of interest.
Give the answer he did.
In an ongoing investigation the latter is the most sensible. He may well be right but until the investigation is complete who really knows?
We then have the polarised versions coming out "cor blimey he is covering something up" and "if you don't believe that what he said is God's honest truth for ever and a day you are simpleton".
My view and only my view you understand is that both stances are equally as barmy.
That's pretty much it really.

and I think your stance is barmy.....so there are several opinions but the only fact is that Redwood has said that the McCanns are not suspects
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 15, 2015, 03:58:06 PM
and I think your stance is barmy.....so there are several opinions but the only fact is that Redwood has said that the McCanns are not suspects

It doesn't mean anything as history shows in this case.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 04:00:02 PM
and I think your stance is barmy.....so there are several opinions but the only fact is that Redwood has said that the McCanns are not suspects

The Attorney General said the invasion of Iraq was legal, but few took his word for it: they looked at the evidence 8(0(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 15, 2015, 04:08:51 PM
The Attorney General said the invasion of Iraq was legal, but few took his word for it: they looked at the evidence 8(0(*

Why would an ordinary couple of parents from Leicester whose child had disappeared -  command the same level of importance as the Invasion of Iraq in our govenment's eyes - when it came to making a statement about them not being suspects?

Common sense please.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 04:12:23 PM
Why would a an ordinary couple of parents from Leicester whose child had disappeared -  command the same level of importance as the Invasion of Iraq in our govenment's eyes - when it came to making a statement about them not being suspects?

Common sense please.

How many 'ordinary' parents would have contact with two succssive prime ministers, including their spouses as well ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 04:15:02 PM
Why would an ordinary couple of parents from Leicester whose child had disappeared -  command the same level of importance as the Invasion of Iraq in our govenment's eyes - when it came to making a statement about them not being suspects?

Common sense please.

Behave Benice. You know the speculation would have gone through the roof if he hadn't said what he did.

The newspapers told the world they were exonerated in 2008, and that's that. Everyone has to stick to that line.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 04:16:18 PM
That may be Redwood's personal belief anyway. Who knows, but when speaking for the Met he knew what he had to say.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 04:29:27 PM
I understood the first time around!
In the clip posted by Bren Ryan it appears that the clip is of the beginning of the interview and that the interviewer clearly asks for clarification about the suggestion that the McCanns were implicated. He said they weren't. But back to my question posed to you earlier which you ducked (a characteristic which when displayed  by others you become snotty about).
Forgetting the name McCann what would you expect him to say?
There are three possibilities.
Give it a body swerve and a no comment.
Say yes they are persons of interest.
Give the answer he did.
In an ongoing investigation the latter is the most sensible. He may well be right but until the investigation is complete who really knows?
We then have the polarised versions coming out "cor blimey he is covering something up" and "if you don't believe that what he said is God's honest truth for ever and a day you are simpleton".
My view and only my view you understand is that both stances are equally as barmy.
That's pretty much it really.
Gosh, awfully sorry for forgetting to address your question before old bean.  As for getting "snotty" that only tends to happen when another member repeatedly answers my question with another question or gives an answer that in no way relates to my question.  I'm sure you've seen it happen time and time again, and how admirable of you not to pass comment, except on this occasion when it was little old me who failed to give your query my fullest and frankest answer when first asked.
What do I expect Redwood to say when asked about whether or not Joe Bloggs is a suspect?  Why, I expect him to tell me the truth of course!  How naïve and foolish I am, eh?  And if he is unable to tell the truth because it may compromise the investigation I expect him to give a completely non-committal reply.  Hope that answers your question satisfactorily.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 04:45:55 PM
Gosh, awfully sorry for forgetting to address your question before old bean.  As for getting "snotty" that only tends to happen when another member repeatedly answers my question with another question or gives an answer that in no way relates to my question.  I'm sure you've seen it happen time and time again, and how admirable of you not to pass comment, except on this occasion when it was little old me who failed to give your query my fullest and frankest answer when first asked.
What do I expect Redwood to say when asked about whether or not Joe Bloggs is a suspect?  Why, I expect him to tell me the truth of course!  How naïve and foolish I am, eh?  And if he is unable to tell the truth because it may compromise the investigation I expect him to give a completely non-committal reply.  Hope that answers your question satisfactorily.

and you really think the police always tell the truth ?

How often do we here about the PJ in that context ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 05:04:24 PM
McCanns heartened Not to be suspects

12th aug 2007
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa told the BBC that fresh evidence had given new "intensity" to the possibility that she had been killed but confirmed that the McCanns were not suspects.


http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: DCI on January 15, 2015, 05:12:44 PM
McCanns heartened Not to be suspects

12th aug 2007
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa told the BBC that fresh evidence had given new "intensity" to the possibility that she had been killed but confirmed that the McCanns were not suspects.


http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html)

12th August 2007? Before Amaral made them Arguido's.

Was that evidence put in the "not relevant box, that early on in the investigation?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 05:18:18 PM
12th August 2007? Before Amaral made them Arguido's.

Was that evidence put in the "not relevant box, that early on in the investigation?

I guess it was before the DNA results from the dogs were misunderstood and led to their Arquido status.

snippit of press reports. from same paper
Earlier, a Portuguese newspaper claimed that the hire car used by the McCanns may have been used to transport the toddler's dead body.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 05:27:48 PM
So....Redwood could come out...of his own free will...and say we have incontrovertible evidence that the McCanns are not suspects...they have been completely ruled them out and we consider them innocent...

but of course some would say...he's probably lying
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 05:32:27 PM
So....Redwood could come out...of his own free will...and say we have incontrovertible evidence that the McCanns are not suspects...they have been completely ruled them out and we consider them innocent...

but of course some would say...he's probably lying

If he said that they were in fact being investigated as suspects, would they still believe that he was lying.  &%+((£
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 05:35:25 PM
So....Redwood could come out...of his own free will...and say we have incontrovertible evidence that the McCanns are not suspects...they have been completely ruled them out and we consider them innocent...

but of course some would say...he's probably lying

Didn't say that though did he.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 05:36:53 PM
Behave Benice. You know the speculation would have gone through the roof if he hadn't said what he did.

The newspapers told the world they were exonerated in 2008, and that's that. Everyone has to stick to that line.
Why would "speculation going through the roof" be Redwood's concern anyway?  When Murat was re-questioned recently did speculation "go through the roof"?  Are you seriously telling me that if Redwood had not explicitly stated that the McCanns and their friends were no longer suspects" that speculation would be further through the roof than it is today?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 05:37:41 PM
12th August 2007? Before Amaral made them Arguido's.

Was that evidence put in the "not relevant box, that early on in the investigation?

We never did discover what this evidence was that decidedly made the Mccanns free of suspicion. Did we?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 05:39:01 PM
The bottom line remains absolute.

Redwood or any of his crew have never said they investigated, let alone interview the McCann's.

and the 'level' of their 'competence was adequately demonstrated in the Jill Dando case.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 05:39:49 PM
Why would "speculation going through the roof" be Redwood's concern anyway?  When Murat was re-questioned recently did speculation "go through the roof"?  Are you seriously telling me that if Redwood had not explicitly stated that the McCanns and their friends were no longer suspects" that speculation would be further through the roof than it is today?

In 2011 I've no doubt it would have.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 05:44:59 PM
In 2011 I've no doubt it would have.
And I've no doubt that it wouldn't have made much difference one way or the other.  If I recall correctly the investigation was a good 18 months in before he made that statement anyway - so was speculation "going through the roof" before that?  No.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 15, 2015, 06:02:34 PM
Behave Benice. You know the speculation would have gone through the roof if he hadn't said what he did.

The newspapers told the world they were exonerated in 2008, and that's that. Everyone has to stick to that line.

Anyone who thinks it is inconceivable that DCI Redwood was simply stating a fact is in denial IMO.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 06:06:53 PM
Anyone who thinks it is inconceivable that DCI Redwood was simply stating a fact is in denial IMO.

But it's not a fact for the rest of us until we've seen evidence. It's not yet a police state.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 06:07:59 PM
Anyone who thinks it is inconceivable that DCI Redwood was simply stating a fact is in denial IMO.
Absolutely - all the evidence (from Redwood's statement to the recent questioning of arguidos to the PJ's own focus on local individual(s)) points very convincingly to the fact that the McCanns are not suspects PLUS there is absolutely NO evidence whatsoever to suggest that they are suspects, yet this doesn't stop the topsy-turvy "sceptics" from spinning the evidence to mean the complete reverse of what it suggests.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 06:09:05 PM
But it's not a fact for the rest of us until we've seen evidence. It's not yet a police state.
What evidence will convince you that the McCanns are not suspects then?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on January 15, 2015, 06:10:50 PM
Doesn't matter if some disbelieve...Redwood meant it...that's it
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 06:11:56 PM
Doesn't matter if some disbelieve...Redwood meant it...that's it
Of course it doesn't matter, it just beggars belief that some people can be so wilfully obtuse (and that's the kind way of putting it).
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 06:15:58 PM
Doesn't matter if some disbelieve...Redwood meant it...that's it

Was he the one who didn't take note of the witness statements in the Jill Dando case, and got it wrong ?

Or was that someone else ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 06:19:36 PM
What evidence will convince you that the McCanns are not suspects then?

We're getting mixed up here. They may well not be suspects for the current investigations because they've decided not to look in that direction. Or have been influenced not to.

So in that case Redwood would have been telling the truth.

But if their investigations in the other direction don't get anywhere then they, the McCanns and everyone else is back to square one.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 06:31:06 PM

No, I'm not Icke &%&£(+ The PM created this thing and he made his feelings very obvious. There's really no mystery about it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 15, 2015, 06:51:31 PM
We're getting mixed up here. They may well not be suspects for the current investigations because they've decided not to look in that direction. Or have been influenced not to.

So in that case Redwood would have been telling the truth.

But if their investigations in the other direction don't get anywhere then they, the McCanns and everyone else is back to square one.

I would say the confusion is all yours.

The PJ spent 15 months investigating the McCanns, and could find nothing against them.

Since then, no new information has come to light to suggest that the PJ were to conclude that that the neither the McCanns nor their friends have any case to answer.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 06:54:37 PM
No, I'm not Icke &%&£(+ The PM created this thing and he made his feelings very obvious. There's really no mystery about it.
Right.  So it's the Prime Minister who is protecting the McCanns - yeah, that totally makes sense. @)(++(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 15, 2015, 07:17:18 PM
Right.  So it's the Prime Minister who is protecting the McCanns - yeah, that totally makes sense. @)(++(*

Not protecting. He and others are as they see it helping, because for them like you it's inconceivable that Madeleine's parents could have been involved. There's no conspiracy or anything like that.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 15, 2015, 08:00:37 PM
Not protecting. He and others are as they see it helping, because for them like you it's inconceivable that Madeleine's parents could have been involved. There's no conspiracy or anything like that.
What does the bit in bold mean then?

Quote
They may well not be suspects for the current investigations because they've decided not to look in that direction. Or have been influenced not to.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 15, 2015, 08:52:35 PM
Why did Redwood never say the McCann's and associates have been interviewed and cleared ?

You have made it patently clear that you do not have a terribly high opinion of NSY in general and DCI Redwood in particular.

However it really is extraordinary that you would think that a review of this type would be undertaken without reinterviewing material witnesses once officers had familiarised themselves with all aspects of the case ... I rather suspect you already know how preposterous it is to suggest that such an essential part of the investigation would be ignored.
 

Madeleine McCann detectives to call in Tapas 7

SCOTLAND YARD detectives are poised to interview the so-called Tapas Seven as their inquiry into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann steps up a gear.

Published: 00:00, Sun, February 5, 2012   By JAMES MURRAY

**snip
The friends of Kate and Gerry McCann, who accompanied them on their holiday to Portugal almost five years ago, are expecting interview requests as soon as officers feel they could assist the investigation.

So far, the Yard’s Maddie Squad has been concentrating on analysing every scrap of evidence in the case from files supplied by Leicestershire police, ­Portuguese detectives and Metodo 3, the Barcelona-based private investig­ators hired by the McCanns.

**snip 
After nine months of information gathering, officers are checking statements from key witnesses.

They include the Tapas Seven, so called because they were eating at a tapas bar with Kate and Gerry at the time Madeleine disappeared.

In some cases the Yard officers have asked for documents to be retranslated from ­Portuguese to English so that they are absolutely sure of what was said and meant.

**snip
A Yard spokesman declined to say who would be interviewed and when. “We are not going into that level of details,” he said. “We are not at the stage of speaking to individuals yet. We are laying the groundwork.”

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/300185/Madeleine-McCann-detectives-to-call-in-Tapas-7
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 08:56:11 PM
You have made it patently clear that you do not have a terribly high opinion of NSY in general and DCI Redwood in particular.

However it really is extraordinary that you would think that a review of this type would be undertaken without reinterviewing material witnesses once officers had familiarised themselves with all aspects of the case ... I rather suspect you already know how preposterous it is to suggest that such an essential part of the investigation would be ignored.
 

Madeleine McCann detectives to call in Tapas 7

SCOTLAND YARD detectives are poised to interview the so-called Tapas Seven as their inquiry into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann steps up a gear.

Published: 00:00, Sun, February 5, 2012   By JAMES MURRAY

**snip
The friends of Kate and Gerry McCann, who accompanied them on their holiday to Portugal almost five years ago, are expecting interview requests as soon as officers feel they could assist the investigation.

So far, the Yard’s Maddie Squad has been concentrating on analysing every scrap of evidence in the case from files supplied by Leicestershire police, ­Portuguese detectives and Metodo 3, the Barcelona-based private investig­ators hired by the McCanns.

**snip 
After nine months of information gathering, officers are checking statements from key witnesses.

They include the Tapas Seven, so called because they were eating at a tapas bar with Kate and Gerry at the time Madeleine disappeared.

In some cases the Yard officers have asked for documents to be retranslated from ­Portuguese to English so that they are absolutely sure of what was said and meant.

**snip
A Yard spokesman declined to say who would be interviewed and when. “We are not going into that level of details,” he said. “We are not at the stage of speaking to individuals yet. We are laying the groundwork.”

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/300185/Madeleine-McCann-detectives-to-call-in-Tapas-7

Ah groundwork.

So when were the interviews ?

and the reliability of express 'stories' is well known.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 15, 2015, 09:15:23 PM
Ah groundwork.

So when were the interviews ?

and the reliability of express 'stories' is well known.

Sigh ... you are seriously suggesting that SY did not check on key witness statements such as crèche man etc prior to recommending to the Home Secretary that there were grounds to reopen the case?

IMO that could be considered terribly remiss of them ... and since my opinion of their procedures is obviously higher than yours ... I think the suggestion is risible.

I think the quotation marks should possibly indicate something to you.

A Yard spokesman declined to say who would be interviewed and when. “We are not going into that level of details,” he said. “We are not at the stage of speaking to individuals yet. We are laying the groundwork.”
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/300185/Madeleine-McCann-detectives-to-call-in-Tapas-7
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 15, 2015, 09:25:10 PM
Sigh ... you are seriously suggesting that SY did not check on key witness statements such as crèche man etc prior to recommending to the Home Secretary that there were grounds to reopen the case?

IMO that could be considered terribly remiss of them ... and since my opinion of their procedures is obviously higher than yours ... I think the suggestion is risible.

I think the quotation marks should possibly indicate something to you.

A Yard spokesman declined to say who would be interviewed and when. “We are not going into that level of details,” he said. “We are not at the stage of speaking to individuals yet. We are laying the groundwork.”
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/300185/Madeleine-McCann-detectives-to-call-in-Tapas-7

The conduct and ability of the SY team was more than highly demonstrated by their inadequacies in the Jill Dando investigation.

and as you know all too well, the 'team' has found in this case.........

Go on, tell me  8**8:/:
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 15, 2015, 09:38:29 PM
The conduct and ability of the SY team was more than highly demonstrated by their inadequacies in the Jill Dando investigation.

and as you know all too well, the 'team' has found in this case.........

Go on, tell me  8**8:/:

 “Neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects” DCI Andy Redwood

So that was a progressive step, what a pity there are those who are still incapable of understanding that.

Unfortunately neither SY nor the PJ bothered to contact me with the details of the interviews carried out in Portugal, terribly remiss of them, however I am sure they were doing what they did in GB and clarified witness statements as part of the investigation.

My difficulty with this are the people who profess "Justice for Madeleine" who quite simply do not want her looked for nor do they hold onto the slightest hope that she may be found alive.

Go on ... do tell me about that ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 09:46:14 PM
Those of you who persist in disrupting this thread and posting Off topic, will have your posts deleted. Please be warned.

This thread is in relation to “McCanns and their friends are not suspects “
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: misty on January 15, 2015, 10:25:56 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2909652/Incredible-moment-man-abducted-four-year-old-reunited-father-24-YEARS-snatched-market-China.html


A young boy, snatched for a purpose, in a moment. It happens. Maybe the sceptics should look at the bigger picture and understand why the McCanns & their friends are not deemed suspects.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 15, 2015, 10:48:15 PM
The parents are not being treated as suspects, probably because.

There was no body found. 
There are many reasons why a child might disappear in a very short space of time.
There is no evidence to support the parents involvement.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 12:10:29 AM
This post has been deleted by the poster.

Answer no longer Valid
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: sadie on January 16, 2015, 01:41:21 AM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2909652/Incredible-moment-man-abducted-four-year-old-reunited-father-24-YEARS-snatched-market-China.html


A young boy, snatched for a purpose, in a moment. It happens. Maybe the sceptics should look at the bigger picture and understand why the McCanns & their friends are not deemed suspects.

What a joyous article and wonderful video.

Thank you misty


Another proof that abducted children go against the statistics and are not invariably murdered.


I believe that Madeleine is alive, well and looked after.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 16, 2015, 07:16:47 AM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2909652/Incredible-moment-man-abducted-four-year-old-reunited-father-24-YEARS-snatched-market-China.html


A young boy, snatched for a purpose, in a moment. It happens. Maybe the sceptics should look at the bigger picture and understand why the McCanns & their friends are not deemed suspects.

Off topic and nothing to do with this thread.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 16, 2015, 08:29:59 AM
The parents are not being treated as suspects, probably because.

There was no body found. 
There are many reasons why a child might disappear in a very short space of time.
There is no evidence to support the parents involvement.

Most chillingly, there is evidence, dating back to pre-May 2007, of a sexual predator of children who abused children in their beds ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 16, 2015, 09:10:05 AM
Most chillingly, there is evidence, dating back to pre-May 2007, of a sexual predator of children who abused children in their beds ...

and not even a shred of evidence to connect to this case.

Nice one ferryman.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 16, 2015, 09:11:19 AM
What a joyous article and wonderful video.

Thank you misty


Another proof that abducted children go against the statistics and are not invariably murdered.


I believe that Madeleine is alive, well and looked after.

Is that in the lawless village 10 miles from PDL ?

One of Edgar's classics.

P.S. Where has it been proved Madeleine was abducted ?

Remember beliefs and pointers don't count.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on January 16, 2015, 09:52:51 AM
Last night I watched an old episode of Law & Order and Olivia Benson says to one of the persons she was questioning: "No, that is wrong. The police never tell anyone they're off the hook until they have caught the real perpetrator".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on January 16, 2015, 09:54:57 AM
Most chillingly, there is evidence, dating back to pre-May 2007, of a sexual predator of children who abused children in their beds ...

How can you state that there is evidence when most of the parents, whose children were allegedly targeted, never reported the incidents to the police when they supposedly happened?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 16, 2015, 09:57:31 AM
Last night I watched an old episode of Law & Order and Olivia Benson says to one of the persons she was questioning: "No, that is wrong. The police never tell anyone they're off the hook until they have caught the real perpetrator".

It happens in tricky cases. They don't show their real hand until they have the evidence required. Behind the scenes could be a different story.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 16, 2015, 10:11:01 AM
It happens in tricky cases. They don't show their real hand until they have the evidence required. Behind the scenes could be a different story.

Scotland Yard have told the McCanns, not that they are off the hook, rather that there is no hint of suspicion against them.

Which British police don't say, either, unless they mean it!

Mid-way through the Joana Yeates enquiry, her boyfriend Grieg Reardon was commended by British police as an first-class  witness.

The police said it because they meant it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 16, 2015, 10:12:18 AM
Last night I watched an old episode of Law & Order and Olivia Benson says to one of the persons she was questioning: "No, that is wrong. The police never tell anyone they're off the hook until they have caught the real perpetrator".

Oh ... did Olivia Benson happen to mention the opinion of the Portuguese Prosecutors' in the Final Report, which attached no blame to Madeleine's parents ...

"This is not, unfortunately, a detective novel, a crime scenario fit for the investigative efforts of a Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot, guided by the illusion that the forces of law and justice can always re-establish order."
http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/aug/05/madeleinemccann.internationalcrime

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 16, 2015, 10:18:19 AM
How can you state that there is evidence when most of the parents, whose children were allegedly targeted, never reported the incidents to the police when they supposedly happened?

You are mistaken when you say the crimes were unreported at the time ... the police have in their possession a semen sample taken from the scene of one of the attacks.

The attacks were known about at the time ... as were the burglaries (two in BLOCK 5 in the months preceding the McCann's arrival).
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 16, 2015, 10:22:52 AM
You are mistaken when you say the crimes were unreported at the time ... the police have in their possession a semen sample taken from the scene of one of the attacks.

The attacks were known about at the time ... as were the burglaries (two in BLOCK 5 in the months preceding the McCann's arrival).

Where is there any proven link to this case ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 16, 2015, 10:25:49 AM
Where is there any proven link to this case ?

If you really are as obtuse as that, there is absolutely no point whatsoever in me trying to explain anything further to you ... obviously you would be unable to understand.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 16, 2015, 10:30:45 AM
If you really are as obtuse as that, there is absolutely no point whatsoever in me trying to explain anything further to you ... obviously you would be unable to understand.

Oh I understand what you are intending.

To find a link to other cases, where none exist.

Keep trying.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 16, 2015, 10:41:20 AM

We simply don't know if there is a link.

Now please can we stick to The Topic.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 16, 2015, 11:05:59 AM
You are mistaken when you say the crimes were unreported at the time ... the police have in their possession a semen sample taken from the scene of one of the attacks.

The attacks were known about at the time ... as were the burglaries (two in BLOCK 5 in the months preceding the McCann's arrival).

Probably reported to Paivia, who probably then filed them in the not relevant file ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 16, 2015, 11:25:48 AM
Probably reported to Paivia, who probably then filed them in the not relevant file ...

Or perhaps not.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 16, 2015, 04:45:10 PM
Probably reported to Paivia, who probably then filed them in the not relevant file ...

I think that whoever took the information regarding the criminal acts carried out against British children had his own Not Relevant file to maintain.

If Paiva did not know about them ... the question has to be asked why didn't he??  Too busy using that well known forensic technique of dreaming up dreams perhaps.

One must remember that neither burglaries or assault on children make for good publicity in a holiday resort; it is instructive people hadn't heard about them until the SY investigation and request for information;  I think that DCI Redmond's statement to victims not to assume that because the offences had been reported to the police SY knew about them and to get in touch again ... speaks volumes.


**snip
"If you have been a victim of a similar crime please come forward even if you reported the incident to police in Portugal, or anywhere else, please do not assume we have been made aware of it."

There was also a "very close resonance" to some features of Madeleine's disappearance, said Redwood.

"We really need to identify the offender, to bring to a close the trauma and the tragedy that these families have suffered, and then seek to establish whether this is connected to Madeleine's disappearance."
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Montclair on January 16, 2015, 05:36:28 PM
Probably reported to Paivia, who probably then filed them in the not relevant file ...

All new information was then handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva, it did not stay hidden away in a drawer.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 05:56:30 PM
12/08/2007
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa told the BBC that fresh evidence had given new "intensity" to the possibility that she had been killed but confirmed that the McCanns were not suspects.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html

So what was this new evidence, that was found that deemed the McCanns “Not to be suspects” ……before the McCanns were made Arquidos ? Anyone know?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 16, 2015, 05:59:36 PM
12/08/2007
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa told the BBC that fresh evidence had given new "intensity" to the possibility that she had been killed but confirmed that the McCanns were not suspects.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1560117/McCanns-heartened-not-to-be-suspects.html

So what was this new evidence, that was found that deemed the McCanns “Not to be suspects” ……before the McCanns were made Arquidos ? Anyone know?


None. That was a lie.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 06:05:58 PM
None. That was a lie.

By whom PF?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 16, 2015, 06:14:15 PM
By whom PF?

By the PJ. They were trying to get the McCanns to confess a week before that not suspects report. They don't want the circus coming to town.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 16, 2015, 06:17:41 PM
By the PJ. They were trying to get the McCanns to confess a week before that not suspects report. They don't want the circus coming to town.
How would that have worked then?  The PJ pretended to have evidence that exonerated the McCanns and this would make them confess? &%+((£
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 06:21:15 PM
By the PJ. They were trying to get the McCanns to confess a week before that not suspects report. They don't want the circus coming to town %£&)**#

Thanks PF,
Have I got this right..... So they announced that the" McCanns were not suspects", several times to the BBC, so that they could get a confession out of the McCanns without a media circus?........ Really?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/search?q=olegario%20sousa
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 16, 2015, 06:25:57 PM
Thanks PF,
Have I got this right..... So they announced that the" McCanns were not suspects", several times to the BBC, so that they could get a confession out of the McCanns without a media circus?........ Really?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/search?q=olegario%20sousa

They said they are not suspects to the public but it was a different behind the scenes. They want to do their job not deal with a circus.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 06:29:39 PM
They said they are not suspects to the public but it was a different behind the scenes. They want to do their job not deal with a circus.

Ok, PJ..... So they made this little fib, public at a later date then?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 16, 2015, 06:36:46 PM
Ok, PJ..... So they made this little fib, public at a later date then?

Pathfinder obviously knows!

S/he was obviously privy to the behind-the-scenes shenanigans ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 06:45:52 PM
Pathfinder obviously knows!

S/he was obviously privy to the behind-the-scenes shenanigans ...

So it appears that on the 12/08/2007 The Portuguese police deemed the McCanns "Not suspects" but shortly afterwards IMO, when the dogs video was revealed and misunderstood, the police made them Arquidos.
So they were said to be not suspects because of new evidence, which none of us seem to know about, way back in august 2007.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 16, 2015, 06:50:38 PM
So it appears that on the 12/08/2007 The Portuguese police deemed the McCanns "Not suspects" but shortly afterwards IMO, when the dogs video was revealed and misunderstood, the police made them Arquidos.
So they were said to be not suspects because of new evidence, which none of us seem to know about, way back in august 2007.

Now there's a point.  What happened to this New Evidence?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 16, 2015, 07:00:57 PM
I think you guys are misunderstanding the statement a little.  The new evidence that Madeleine was killed was obviously the dog alerts, the bit about the McCanns not being suspects was obviously a great whopper of a lie told by the police, you know just like Redwood's lie that neither the McCanns and nor their friends are suspects now, because obviously they are - tick-tock and all that. *&*%£
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 07:17:52 PM
I think you guys are misunderstanding the statement a little.  The new evidence that Madeleine was killed was obviously the dog alerts, the bit about the McCanns not being suspects was obviously a great whopper of a lie told by the police, you know just like Redwood's lie that neither the McCanns and nor their friends are suspects now, because obviously they are - tick-tock and all that. *&*%£

So the new evidence, was the dogs video, but the "not suspects" was a lie. How can we trust anything that they say?


24th aug 2007
McCanns 'innocent' .... Doesn't know where conflicting leaks have come from...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6962122.stm
But no more talk of the breakthrough new evidence
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 16, 2015, 07:42:19 PM
Pathfinder obviously knows!

S/he was obviously privy to the behind-the-scenes shenanigans ...

Read Madeleine. The McCanns were interrogated around the 6 August after the dog findings and asked to reveal the truth of what happened in the apartment on 3 May. So then the PJ are saying they're not suspects to the public and the McCanns are pleased. Do think the McCanns are that naive to believe it. I don't think so!

Day 96 - 07/08/2007 - Tuesday

Kate and I managed an early morning run today. It was pleasantly cooler, with a refreshing breeze, which made a nice change. The media presence in Praia da Luz is at its greatest since the first couple of weeks, as is the amount of speculation and rumour regarding the investigation.
This morning we agreed to do a short, pooled interview that was made available to all broadcasters worldwide.
We wanted to make it clear, that as far as we know, there is still absolutely no evidence that Madeleine has been seriously harmed and Kate and I have to believe she is still alive. The Portuguese police have assured us on numerous occasions that they are looking for Madeleine and not a corpse. Of course all possibilities are being considered and the police have to be certain before eliminating any of the scenarios. It is absolutely right that we are subject to the same high standards of investigation as anyone else. Kate and I have, and will continue to assist the police in every possible way.
We hope there is a breakthrough in the investigation very soon.
In the meantime the campaign to keep the public involved in the search for Madeleine continues. We are always trying to think of ideas that will reach people who may not have heard of Madeleines disappearance.
I spent a couple of hours this afternoon working on forthcoming events but did manage to squeeze in a much-needed haircut!

8 August

At our meeting with the Portuguese police today we reaffirmed that we have to believe Madeleine is alive until there is concrete evidence to the contrary.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 08:02:43 PM
Thank you, PF

ETA.
So they kept this lie up for a month. Did they eventually admit that they had lied or is this purely opinion.
  There is still the possibility that they believed in the McCanns innocence, until they received the analysis on the dogs findings, is there not?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 16, 2015, 09:34:31 PM
All new information was then handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva, it did not stay hidden away in a drawer.

The information which had been ignored over a period of two years was probably handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva ... copies were handed to the McCanns to 'enable' them to pursue Madeleine's case.

It was fortunate indeed they had the backing of the Madeleine Fund to enable them to do so.


** snip
"Every piece of information (in the dossier of potential new leads) was treated the same way - Ricardo Paiva writes on it 'this is not relevant to the investigation',” Mrs Duarte said from her office in the Portuguese capital on Thursday.

“He believed and to this day still believes that Madeleine is dead. I asked him: ‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

She said some of the leads seemed credible, including a cluster of sightings by independent eye witnesses in northern Italy, and had been forwarded by police forces in the UK, Spain, France and Italy but ignored by their Portuguese counterparts.

Copies of the files would now be passed to the McCanns to be followed up by private investigators hired to search for their daughter.

"But I am angry because it is the Portuguese investigative police who should be doing this job,” Mrs Duarte, added.

"They have the power and capability to do it. It is they who should be doing it not and not my clients."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7215353/Portuguese-police-ignored-Madeleine-McCann-leads.html


Senior Officers capable of such a dereliction of duty as ignoring evidence sent to them in a missing child case are probably also perfectly at ease with being the authors of the most terrible calumnies against innocent people or lying to innocent people.

That there are those who actually seem to think their dishonesty is a good thing when they assure us the Drs McCann were lied to seem to have got hold of the wrong end of the morality or even honour stick.

I think we have made efforts in Britain to lessen the effects of Gene Hunt attitudes in policing. 

Therefore when DCI Redwood made a statement in public that Madeleine's parents are neither persons of interest or suspects ... that is exactly what he meant. 


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Anna on January 16, 2015, 09:43:35 PM
The information which had been ignored over a period of two years was probably handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva ... copies were handed to the McCanns to 'enable' them to pursue Madeleine's case.

It was fortunate indeed they had the backing of the Madeleine Fund to enable them to do so.


** snip
"Every piece of information (in the dossier of potential new leads) was treated the same way - Ricardo Paiva writes on it 'this is not relevant to the investigation',” Mrs Duarte said from her office in the Portuguese capital on Thursday.

“He believed and to this day still believes that Madeleine is dead. I asked him: ‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

She said some of the leads seemed credible, including a cluster of sightings by independent eye witnesses in northern Italy, and had been forwarded by police forces in the UK, Spain, France and Italy but ignored by their Portuguese counterparts.

Copies of the files would now be passed to the McCanns to be followed up by private investigators hired to search for their daughter.

"But I am angry because it is the Portuguese investigative police who should be doing this job,” Mrs Duarte, added.

"They have the power and capability to do it. It is they who should be doing it not and not my clients."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7215353/Portuguese-police-ignored-Madeleine-McCann-leads.html


Senior Officers capable of such a dereliction of duty as ignoring evidence sent to them in a missing child case are probably also perfectly at ease with being the authors of the most terrible calumnies against innocent people or lying to innocent people.

That there are those who actually seem to think their dishonesty is a good thing when they assure us the Drs McCann were lied to seem to have got hold of the wrong end of the morality or even honour stick.

I think we have made efforts in Britain to lessen the effects of Gene Hunt attitudes in policing. 

Therefore when DCI Redwood made a statement in public that Madeleine's parents are neither persons of interest or suspects ... that is exactly what he meant.

Good post, Brietta.

It says it all, about why we believe DCI Redwood.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 17, 2015, 10:36:47 AM
The information which had been ignored over a period of two years was probably handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva ... copies were handed to the McCanns to 'enable' them to pursue Madeleine's case.

It was fortunate indeed they had the backing of the Madeleine Fund to enable them to do so.


** snip
"Every piece of information (in the dossier of potential new leads) was treated the same way - Ricardo Paiva writes on it 'this is not relevant to the investigation',” Mrs Duarte said from her office in the Portuguese capital on Thursday.

“He believed and to this day still believes that Madeleine is dead. I asked him: ‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

She said some of the leads seemed credible, including a cluster of sightings by independent eye witnesses in northern Italy, and had been forwarded by police forces in the UK, Spain, France and Italy but ignored by their Portuguese counterparts.

Copies of the files would now be passed to the McCanns to be followed up by private investigators hired to search for their daughter.

"But I am angry because it is the Portuguese investigative police who should be doing this job,” Mrs Duarte, added.

"They have the power and capability to do it. It is they who should be doing it not and not my clients."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7215353/Portuguese-police-ignored-Madeleine-McCann-leads.html


Senior Officers capable of such a dereliction of duty as ignoring evidence sent to them in a missing child case are probably also perfectly at ease with being the authors of the most terrible calumnies against innocent people or lying to innocent people.

That there are those who actually seem to think their dishonesty is a good thing when they assure us the Drs McCann were lied to seem to have got hold of the wrong end of the morality or even honour stick.

I think we have made efforts in Britain to lessen the effects of Gene Hunt attitudes in policing. 

Therefore when DCI Redwood made a statement in public that Madeleine's parents are neither persons of interest or suspects ... that is exactly what he meant.

A very interesting post Brietta the thrust of which seems to be that because Paiva was (in your opinion) bent. Redwood must (in your opinion) be straight.
Mmmmm  &%+((£
p.s. Gene Hunt was not real it was only acting.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 17, 2015, 11:04:13 AM
The information which had been ignored over a period of two years was probably handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva ... copies were handed to the McCanns to 'enable' them to pursue Madeleine's case.

It was fortunate indeed they had the backing of the Madeleine Fund to enable them to do so.


** snip
"Every piece of information (in the dossier of potential new leads) was treated the same way - Ricardo Paiva writes on it 'this is not relevant to the investigation',” Mrs Duarte said from her office in the Portuguese capital on Thursday.

“He believed and to this day still believes that Madeleine is dead. I asked him: ‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

She said some of the leads seemed credible, including a cluster of sightings by independent eye witnesses in northern Italy, and had been forwarded by police forces in the UK, Spain, France and Italy but ignored by their Portuguese counterparts.

Copies of the files would now be passed to the McCanns to be followed up by private investigators hired to search for their daughter.

"But I am angry because it is the Portuguese investigative police who should be doing this job,” Mrs Duarte, added.

"They have the power and capability to do it. It is they who should be doing it not and not my clients."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7215353/Portuguese-police-ignored-Madeleine-McCann-leads.html


Senior Officers capable of such a dereliction of duty as ignoring evidence sent to them in a missing child case are probably also perfectly at ease with being the authors of the most terrible calumnies against innocent people or lying to innocent people.

That there are those who actually seem to think their dishonesty is a good thing when they assure us the Drs McCann were lied to seem to have got hold of the wrong end of the morality or even honour stick.

I think we have made efforts in Britain to lessen the effects of Gene Hunt attitudes in policing. 

Therefore when DCI Redwood made a statement in public that Madeleine's parents are neither persons of interest or suspects ... that is exactly what he meant.

it would seems many years and 10 million pounds later SY argree with Pavia that the leads were 'not relevant to the enquiry'.

And while suggesting that Pavia could not have conducted a thorough investigation while beleiving Madeleine is dead you are ignoring that fact that it appears SY think the same fate has befallen her yet I hear not one whimper with regard to their professionalism.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 17, 2015, 12:08:57 PM
it would seems many years and 10 million pounds later SY argree with Pavia that the leads were 'not relevant to the enquiry'.

And while suggesting that Pavia could not have conducted a thorough investigation while beleiving Madeleine is dead you are ignoring that fact that it appears SY think the same fate has befallen her yet I hear not one whimper with regard to their professionalism.

It certainly appears that way, doesn't it.

Unless of course, those leads that Paiva trashed included that smoking gun which implicated Mrs Batista & a bus driver, two most likely culprits if ever there were.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 17, 2015, 12:18:57 PM
The information which had been ignored over a period of two years was probably handed over to the Ministério Público by Ricardo Paiva ... copies were handed to the McCanns to 'enable' them to pursue Madeleine's case.

It was fortunate indeed they had the backing of the Madeleine Fund to enable them to do so.


** snip
"Every piece of information (in the dossier of potential new leads) was treated the same way - Ricardo Paiva writes on it 'this is not relevant to the investigation',” Mrs Duarte said from her office in the Portuguese capital on Thursday.

“He believed and to this day still believes that Madeleine is dead. I asked him: ‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

She said some of the leads seemed credible, including a cluster of sightings by independent eye witnesses in northern Italy, and had been forwarded by police forces in the UK, Spain, France and Italy but ignored by their Portuguese counterparts.

Copies of the files would now be passed to the McCanns to be followed up by private investigators hired to search for their daughter.

"But I am angry because it is the Portuguese investigative police who should be doing this job,” Mrs Duarte, added.

"They have the power and capability to do it. It is they who should be doing it not and not my clients."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7215353/Portuguese-police-ignored-Madeleine-McCann-leads.html


Senior Officers capable of such a dereliction of duty as ignoring evidence sent to them in a missing child case are probably also perfectly at ease with being the authors of the most terrible calumnies against innocent people or lying to innocent people.

That there are those who actually seem to think their dishonesty is a good thing when they assure us the Drs McCann were lied to seem to have got hold of the wrong end of the morality or even honour stick.

I think we have made efforts in Britain to lessen the effects of Gene Hunt attitudes in policing. 

Therefore when DCI Redwood made a statement in public that Madeleine's parents are neither persons of interest or suspects ... that is exactly what he meant.


‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

Kate & Gerry been out & about looking for Madeleine recently?

Oh wait, I already know, No they haven't!

(Unless they think she's likely to be hiding in the civil courts)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 17, 2015, 12:22:14 PM
It certainly appears that way, doesn't it.

Unless of course, those leads that Paiva trashed included that smoking gun which implicated Mrs Batista & a bus driver, two most likely culprits if ever there were.

You do wonder who benefitted from these 'bash the PJ' articles, because it certainly wasn't Madeleine.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 12:23:05 PM

‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

Kate & Gerry been out & about looking for Madeleine recently?

Oh wait, I already know, No they haven't!

(Unless they think she's likely to be hiding in the civil courts)

Where do you think The McCanns should search?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on January 17, 2015, 12:28:13 PM
Same places they expect everyone else to
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 12:35:58 PM
Same places they expect everyone else to

There is a big difference between Looking and Searching.  As well you know.  After the first night when The McCanns did search around PdL, there wasn't anywhere sensible that could be searched.
This demand for The McCanns to Search is becoming tiresome.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on January 17, 2015, 12:37:22 PM
There is a big difference between Looking and Searching.  As well you know.  After the first night when The McCanns did search around PdL, there wasn't anywhere sensible that could be searched.
This demand for The McCanns to Search is becoming tiresome.


One night - big deal.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 12:40:16 PM

One night - big deal.

Where would you have wanted them to go after that?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 17, 2015, 12:43:40 PM
Where would you have wanted them to go after that?

Where have SY searched?

Well, Portugal strangely enough, not in a court room though.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 12:46:42 PM
Where have SY searched?

Well, Portugal strangely enough, not in a court room though.

Okay, enough of trying to derail this Thread.  This is a very silly conversation anyway.

So back on topic, if you please.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 17, 2015, 12:50:09 PM
Okay, enough of trying to derail this Thread.  This is a very silly conversation anyway.

So back on topic, if you please.

The McCanns are not suspects.

After stating that fact, there's really very little (on-topic) left to say ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 17, 2015, 12:55:52 PM
The McCanns are not suspects.

After stating that fact, there's really very little (on-topic) left to say ...

Can you explain ferryman why the nature of the crime has not been ascertained ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 17, 2015, 12:57:13 PM
The McCanns are not suspects.

After stating that fact, there's really very little (on-topic) left to say ...

Not even persons of interest, apparently.

Course, even after all this time we're still totally unenlightened as to how exactly SY have been able to completely eliminate the possibility of Mr & Mrs McShifty being in any way involved in Madeleine's disappearance.

How extraordinary.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 17, 2015, 01:04:53 PM
We can do all the boring bits that have been done countless times before and cite from the Prosecutor's archiving dispatch:

It seems evident to us and because the files contain enough elements for such, that the crime of exposure or abandonment according to article 138 of the Penal Code can be eliminated from that range:

"1 - Whoever places another person's life in danger,
a) By exposing her in a location where she is subject to a situation from which she, on her own, cannot defend herself against; or
b) Abandoning her without defence, whenever the agent had the duty to guard her, to watch over her or to assist her;"

This legal type of crime is only fulfilled with intent, and this intent has to cover the creation of danger to the victim's life, as well as the absence of a capacity to defend herself, on the victim's behalf. In the case of the files and facing the elements that were collected it is evident that none of the arguidos Gerald or Kate acted with intent. The parents could not foresee that in the resort that they chose to spend a brief holiday, they could place the life of any of their children in danger, nor was that demanded from them: it was located in a peaceful area, where most of the residents are foreign citizens of the same nationality and without any known history of this type of criminality.

The parents didn't even represent the realisation of the fact, they trusted that everything would go well, as it had gone on the previous evenings, thus not equating, nor was it demanded from them, the possibility of the occurrence of an abduction of any of the children that were in their respective apartments.


Or we could cite from Joao Carlos' final PJ report, where he says that, at the time of the Smith sighting, Gerry was in the Tapas Restaurant.

Cue for shrill shrieks from Faith Lilly: oh no he wasn't.  Gerry threw Madeleine's body in a bin ...

Of course, Faith knows ...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 17, 2015, 01:06:46 PM
We can do all the boring bits that have been done countless times before and cite from the Prosecutor's archiving dispatch:

It seems evident to us and because the files contain enough elements for such, that the crime of exposure or abandonment according to article 138 of the Penal Code can be eliminated from that range:

"1 - Whoever places another person's life in danger,
a) By exposing her in a location where she is subject to a situation from which she, on her own, cannot defend herself against; or
b) Abandoning her without defence, whenever the agent had the duty to guard her, to watch over her or to assist her;"

This legal type of crime is only fulfilled with intent, and this intent has to cover the creation of danger to the victim's life, as well as the absence of a capacity to defend herself, on the victim's behalf. In the case of the files and facing the elements that were collected it is evident that none of the arguidos Gerald or Kate acted with intent. The parents could not foresee that in the resort that they chose to spend a brief holiday, they could place the life of any of their children in danger, nor was that demanded from them: it was located in a peaceful area, where most of the residents are foreign citizens of the same nationality and without any known history of this type of criminality.

The parents didn't even represent the realisation of the fact, they trusted that everything would go well, as it had gone on the previous evenings, thus not equating, nor was it demanded from them, the possibility of the occurrence of an abduction of any of the children that were in their respective apartments.


Or we could cite from Joao Carlos' final PJ report, where he says that, at the time of the Smith sighting, Gerry was in the Tapas Restaurant.

Cue for shrill shrieks from Faith Lilly: oh no he wasn't.  Gerry threw Madeleine's body in a bin ...

Of course, Faith knows ...

Now what did the prosecutor say about the mccanns lack of cooperation with the investigation ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 17, 2015, 01:08:54 PM
We can do all the boring bits that have been done countless times before and cite from the Prosecutor's archiving dispatch:

It seems evident to us and because the files contain enough elements for such, that the crime of exposure or abandonment according to article 138 of the Penal Code can be eliminated from that range:

"1 - Whoever places another person's life in danger,
a) By exposing her in a location where she is subject to a situation from which she, on her own, cannot defend herself against; or
b) Abandoning her without defence, whenever the agent had the duty to guard her, to watch over her or to assist her;"

This legal type of crime is only fulfilled with intent, and this intent has to cover the creation of danger to the victim's life, as well as the absence of a capacity to defend herself, on the victim's behalf. In the case of the files and facing the elements that were collected it is evident that none of the arguidos Gerald or Kate acted with intent. The parents could not foresee that in the resort that they chose to spend a brief holiday, they could place the life of any of their children in danger, nor was that demanded from them: it was located in a peaceful area, where most of the residents are foreign citizens of the same nationality and without any known history of this type of criminality.

The parents didn't even represent the realisation of the fact, they trusted that everything would go well, as it had gone on the previous evenings, thus not equating, nor was it demanded from them, the possibility of the occurrence of an abduction of any of the children that were in their respective apartments.


Or we could cite from Joao Carlos' final PJ report, where he says that, at the time of the Smith sighting, Gerry was in the Tapas Restaurant.

Cue for shrill shrieks from Faith Lilly: oh no he wasn't.  Gerry threw Madeleine's body in a bin ...

Of course, Faith knows ...

Little did he know that Gerry was actually out searching at the time of the Smiths sighting (10:03), since the alarm was raised prior to 10pm, so it was.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on January 17, 2015, 01:09:50 PM
Now what did the prosecutor say about the mccanns lack of cooperation with the investigation ?

The McCanns and their friends lost a chance to demonstrate their innocence.

They didn't need the chance.

Scotland Yard shifted the time-line and demonstrated their innocence for them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 17, 2015, 02:12:20 PM
The McCanns and their friends lost a chance to demonstrate their innocence.

They didn't need the chance.

Scotland Yard shifted the time-line and demonstrated their innocence for them.

What they demonstrated is what we've known since Week 1: nothing is known about what happened to Madeleine after 5.30pm.

Redwood said in Crimewatch, we're focusing on the time after 8.30; which is convenient for them because everyone knows they still know next to nowt about what happened earlier.

Redwood's political solution? Ignore it.
Anthony Summers' solution? Ignore it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 17, 2015, 02:42:29 PM
The McCanns and their friends lost a chance to demonstrate their innocence.

They didn't need the chance.

Scotland Yard shifted the time-line and demonstrated their innocence for them.

Saying it is not a demonstration of innocence.

It's just words.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 02:56:58 PM
Saying it is not a demonstration of innocence.

It's just words.

As are yours.  There aren't going to be any winners in these Forum Games.  Just a bunch of idiots expressing opinions.  And that includes me.

The McCanns and Friends are never going to be indicted for any crimes, and you know this.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on January 17, 2015, 03:05:40 PM
As are yours.  There aren't going to be any winners in these Forum Games.  Just a bunch of idiots expressing opinions.  And that includes me.

The McCanns and Friends are never going to be indicted for any crimes, and you know this.

#and neither will anyone else.

Unless of course we see a 'Barry George'. &%+((£
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 03:27:34 PM
#and neither will anyone else.

Unless of course we see a 'Barry George'. &%+((£

I honestly don't know, Stephen.  If Scotland Yard, or rather, The PJ, arrest anyone in Portugal, The Sceptics won't believe they are guilty, and The Supporters probably will.  Excepting of course, that some of us will want to see some evidence.  I know I will.
It would probably be the best followed Trial ever.  And I will remain believing in Innocent Until Proven Guilty.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 17, 2015, 03:31:53 PM

‘How can you find a person when you are not looking for them?’”.

Kate & Gerry been out & about looking for Madeleine recently?

Oh wait, I already know, No they haven't!

(Unless they think she's likely to be hiding in the civil courts)


An eminently fatuous post even for you.

So in what fantasy land do the police stand down and expect the parents of a missing child to wander the streets of a foreign town physically looking for him/her and in the interim carefully file any information which may assist them as "NOT RELEVANT TO THE INQUIRY"?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 03:43:05 PM

An eminently fatuous post even for you.

So in what fantasy land do the police stand down and expect the parents of a missing child to wander the streets of a foreign town physically looking for him/her and in the interim carefully file any information which may assist them as "NOT RELEVANT TO THE INQUIRY"?

Yes, it is a fatuous remark.  It simply isn't possible for the parents of any missing child to physically search for that child.  Or even wanted by The Police.
This fact is never going to make The McCanns guilty or even suspects.  This is the problem with people who don't understand The Law.  It's an irrelevance.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 17, 2015, 04:19:08 PM
What they demonstrated is what we've known since Week 1: nothing is known about what happened to Madeleine after 5.30pm.

Redwood said in Crimewatch, we're focusing on the time after 8.30; which is convenient for them because everyone knows they still know next to nowt about what happened earlier.

Redwood's political solution? Ignore it.
Anthony Summers' solution? Ignore it.

The time; the place; the investigators; all contrived to come together to make up the perfect storm which has become the "Mystery of Madeleine McCann."

The time ... almost pre Logie Beard ... the start of the season in an on the surface sleepy little fishing village which seems to have missed out on CCTV coverage.

The place ... a holiday town anxious to promote an idyllic family friendly atmosphere but even more anxious to hide the dark underbelly of drugs - sexual assaults on British children  - burglaries, two of which had occurred in Block 5 in the month prior to the McCann's arrival, both of which had been entered via the window.

If you can carry a plasma TV unseen from an apartment ... you can carry a child unseen from an apartment.

The investigators ... the co-ordinator of the inquiry was himself being investigated for a criminal offence in the case of another missing child - made an arguido hours after Madeleine's disappearance - subsequently found guilty of the offence.
The destruction of the original forensics by inept gathering did not assist the McCanns and as the lead investigator was later to complain neither did the destruction of the one piece of evidence from it would appear the only working CCTV equipment in PDL ... because his officers ... hadn't collected it when he told them to.

Dear Lord! you really could not make it up.

Why it has been accepted and condoned that what amounts to IMO withholding evidence in the case of a missing child and is perhaps indicative of the attitude to and the value placed on the human rights and the life of Madeleine McCann among those whose duty was to look for her.  Just who gave them the right to declare her dead?

If the same situation had arisen regarding Holly and Jessica ... I wonder what the opinion of that would be?


'Ricardo Paiva lies and moreover he has the responsibility of searching for Maddie', she said during the closing arguments, revealing that she has consulted the process in Portimão, archived in July 2008 for lack of evidence, clearing Kate and Gerry McCann of the involvement into their daughters disappearence.

'The PJ has been archiving all the information given by the Spanish, French and Italian Police. There are several relevant pieces of information, pictures, car plate numbers. None had importance to the person in charge. Most of the information that I analysed deserved an investigation by the PJ', she said.  http://www.mccannfiles.com/id306.html


   ??Ricardo Paiva's solution??     IGNORE IT.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 04:39:32 PM
I honestly don't know, Stephen.  If Scotland Yard, or rather, The PJ, arrest anyone in Portugal, The Sceptics won't believe they are guilty, and The Supporters probably will.  Excepting of course, that some of us will want to see some evidence.  I know I will.
It would probably be the best followed Trial ever.  And I will remain believing in Innocent Until Proven Guilty.

...and if the McCs were hypothetically charged and found guilty then you could become the sceptics and us the believers....
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 04:44:35 PM
...and if the McCs were hypothetically charged and found guilty then you could become the sceptics and us the believers....

No.  I would just have been wrong.  But I wouldn't have spent the last seven years spewing bile when there has not been any proof that The McCanns deserved this.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on January 17, 2015, 04:53:04 PM
You equate disagreement with spewing bile ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 04:53:52 PM
No.  I would just have been wrong.  But I wouldn't have spent the last seven years spewing bile when there has not been any proof that The McCanns deserved this.

Wouldn't you regard it a miscarriage of justice?

P.S. I haven't been spewing bile just expressing doubts.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 17, 2015, 04:56:24 PM

An eminently fatuous post even for you.

So in what fantasy land do the police stand down and expect the parents of a missing child to wander the streets of a foreign town physically looking for him/her and in the interim carefully file any information which may assist them as "NOT RELEVANT TO THE INQUIRY"?

.....surrounded  by scores of reporters who were desperate for information and would have mobbed them on sight.   



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 05:05:41 PM
.....surrounded  by scores of reporters who were desperate for information and would have mobbed them on sight.

Fundamentally it is the actions or non actions of the McCann's that sparked the suspicions of the sceptics. Whether it was at the recommendation of the PR people or not is another question.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 17, 2015, 05:17:36 PM
Fundamentally it is the actions or non actions of the McCann's that sparked the suspicions of the sceptics. Whether it was at the recommendation of the PR people or not is another question.
What could the McCanns have done or not done that would not have sparked your suspicions?  The answer is nothing.  They could have done every single thing differently to what they actually did do and it would still have sparked your suspicions.  Guaranteed.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 05:21:16 PM
You equate disagreement with spewing bile ?

No.  But you know what I mean, and what has been happening.  Albeit, hopefully not you.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on January 17, 2015, 05:24:27 PM
Wouldn't you regard it a miscarriage of justice?

P.S. I haven't been spewing bile just expressing doubts.

I don't think you have been spewing bile, but it is inherent in what is being said.

A Miscarriage of Justice?   How so?  Show me proof.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 05:25:01 PM
What could the McCanns have done or not done that would not have sparked your suspicions?  The answer is nothing.  They could have done every single thing differently to what they actually did do and it would still have sparked your suspicions.  Guaranteed.

That's a load of twaddle.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on January 17, 2015, 05:25:28 PM
What could the McCanns have done or not done that would not have sparked your suspicions?  The answer is nothing.  They could have done every single thing differently to what they actually did do and it would still have sparked your suspicions.  Guaranteed.

Even the AG found nothing suspicious in their behaviour.

Quote
 ...........their normal behaviour up to that moment and afterwards, as witnessed by the statements of the witnesses,...............
Unquote
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 17, 2015, 05:26:56 PM
Fundamentally it is the actions or non actions of the McCann's that sparked the suspicions of the sceptics. Whether it was at the recommendation of the PR people or not is another question.

Fundamentally it was the continual dripping of lies and misinformation to the press that ignited the hatred of the sceptics ... that became more and more obvious as information became available which turned these myths on their head.

Suspicions ... a victim wants a priest ... so that is indicative of a heinous crime.

Downright lies are told about detritus from Madeleine's frozen decomposing body in the boot of a rental car splattering off kerbs as her parents jet around with a press entourage in tow - and if they weren't around Jon Corner filming them loading and unloading leaflets into the boot ... which conveniently sprouted a wheel well in a model which has none.

If there had been one iota of truth in the latter ... we would not be talking about the McCann's guilt or innocence ... a Portuguese court would have decided on that long ago.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 17, 2015, 05:33:41 PM
That's a load of twaddle.
Oh is it?  I don't think so.   You think copious amounts of their televised tears and dragging their bodies on their hands and knees through the streets of PdL banging on every single resident's front door for 7 years would make you less suspicious?  You think begging for your forgiveness for their 'child neglect' would make you less suspicious?  Do you think refusing donations, or help from prominent people, or appearing on TV would make you less suspicious?  Do you think if they'd completely sunk without trace after 2008, written no books, not petitioned to have the case re-opened it would make you less suspicious?  Do you think if they;d not challenged the libellous articles and the books written about it would make you less suspicious?  No, I don't think it would.    Most "sceptics", like Amaral, decided they were guilty from the outset even before most of these so-called suspicious actions on non-actions were even known about so don't talk twaddle yourself.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on January 17, 2015, 05:44:38 PM


There are protocols which are put in place immediately a child goes missing ... the fact that these were not applied in Portugal till many hours after the event ... means I have every confidence that any British police authority would have made a better job of it.
In fact I am firmly of the opinion that any traffic division in Portugal would have made a better job than the team tasked with it.

In what way, that was anything other than deliberate, did Ricardo Paiva file every piece of information regarding Madeleine McCann from 2008 onwards as "Not Relevant to the Inquiry" ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 06:11:22 PM
Oh is it?  I don't think so.   You think copious amounts of their televised tears and dragging their bodies on their hands and knees through the streets of PdL banging on every single resident's front door for 7 years would make you less suspicious?  You think begging for your forgiveness for their 'child neglect' would make you less suspicious?  Do you think refusing donations, or help from prominent people, or appearing on TV would make you less suspicious?  Do you think if they'd completely sunk without trace after 2008, written no books, not petitioned to have the case re-opened it would make you less suspicious?  Do you think if they;d not challenged the libellous articles and the books written about it would make you less suspicious?  No, I don't think it would.    Most "sceptics", like Amaral, decided they were guilty from the outset even before most of these so-called suspicious actions on non-actions were even known about so don't talk twaddle yourself.

More BS, as I said it was their actions and non actions which caused suspicions. I didn't detail them and it will differ for each sceptic.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 17, 2015, 06:19:38 PM
More BS, as I said it was their actions and non actions which caused suspicions. I didn't detail them and it will differ for each sceptic.
Yes, each sceptic will have their own particular list of favourite suspicions I realise that, however you cannot escape  from the fact that many sceptics decided the McCanns were guilty before the vast  majority of these actions or non-actions were even know about.  How do you account for that?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lyall on January 17, 2015, 06:37:55 PM

There are protocols which are put in place immediately a child goes missing ... the fact that these were not applied in Portugal till many hours after the event ... means I have every confidence that any British police authority would have made a better job of it.
In fact I am firmly of the opinion that any traffic division in Portugal would have made a better job than the team tasked with it.

In what way, that was anything other than deliberate, did Ricardo Paiva file every piece of information regarding Madeleine McCann from 2008 onwards as "Not Relevant to the Inquiry" ?

Every piece? &%+((£ Where does it say that?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 17, 2015, 07:08:47 PM
Yes, each sceptic will have their own particular list of favourite suspicions I realise that, however you cannot escape  from the fact that many sceptics decided the McCanns were guilty before the vast  majority of these actions or non-actions were even know about.  How do you account for that?

I think you have just made an unsubstantiated accusation.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 17, 2015, 10:36:01 PM
I think you have just made an unsubstantiated accusation.
@)(++(*. So I just imagined all the "sceptics" expressing suspicion of them in the Spring snd Summer of 2007?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 17, 2015, 10:49:36 PM
How many times have you seen some all-knowing "sceptic" announce in FB or twitter or forums "I knew there was something fishy about them as soon as I saw them on TV for the first time", or words to that effect?   Quit a few, I'll wager...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 18, 2015, 08:12:23 AM
@)(++(*. So I just imagined all the "sceptics" expressing suspicion of them in the Spring snd Summer of 2007?

More sweeping statements, "all"?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 18, 2015, 11:14:37 AM
More sweeping statements, "all"?


You seem not to have understood what I wrote.  I saw many expressions of suspicion concerning the McCanns in late spring early summer from a number of online"sceptics". Did I imagine them all?  Now do you understand?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 18, 2015, 11:51:19 AM
You seem not to have understood what I wrote.  I saw many expressions of suspicion concerning the McCanns in late spring early summer from a number of online"sceptics". Did I imagine them all?  Now do you understand?

BBC News 8th May 2007

Quote
She is believed to have been taken from her bed while her parents were eating at a nearby restaurant and regularly checking on her and their two-year-old twins Sean and Amelie.

Piques interest.

10th May

Quote
Madeleine's grandmother, Susan Healy, from Liverpool, said Portuguese police made mistakes at the start of their investigation, possibly because they were "inexperienced".

However, the British ambassador to Portugal, John Buck, said he had been assured by Portuguese authorities that "everything possible" was being done.

Petrol station near Praia da Luz where police have gathered CCTV
Police have taken CCTV footage from this petrol station close to Praia da Luz
Meanwhile, Madeleine's uncle, John McCann, from Glasgow, countered criticism from those who say the couple were wrong to leave their children alone in their apartment while they ate dinner at a nearby restaurant.

"If you look at the layout of that place, it was entirely safe. The issue at stake here was, that the flat was broken into, and wee Madeleine was abducted," he told BBC Radio Five Live.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on January 18, 2015, 12:00:17 PM
"If you look at the layout of that place, it was entirely safe. The issue at stake here was, that the flat was broken into, and wee Madeleine was abducted," he told BBC Radio Five Live.

Entirely safe ? Really ? On a public road with the patio doors left unlocked and possibly the windows too ( the parents weren't quite sure )
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 18, 2015, 12:12:24 PM
BBC News 8th May 2007

Piques interest.

10th May
And this substantiates your point that it was purely through the McCanns' own actions and inactions that gave rise to sceptics' suspicions how exactly?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 18, 2015, 12:55:50 PM
And this substantiates your point that it was purely through the McCanns' own actions and inactions that gave rise to sceptics' suspicions how exactly?

No that goes to counter your claims that there was nothing early on to cause anyone to think of the McCanns as anything but victims.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 18, 2015, 12:57:41 PM
No that goes to counter your claims that there was nothing early on to cause anyone to think of the McCanns as anything but victims.
When did I say that exactly and what in the items that you have just posted could lead anyone to think the McCanns invented an abduction?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 18, 2015, 01:00:11 PM
When did I say that exactly and what in the items that you have just posted could lead anyone to think the McCanns invented an abduction?

Did I say it did?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 18, 2015, 01:58:36 PM
Did I say it did?
This is getting tiresome.  When you say my suspicions were aroused by what the McCanns did and did not do, what exactly are you suspecting them of?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 18, 2015, 03:08:34 PM
Wednesday 8 August

João Carlos returned our car at lunchtime (albeit with a piece missing from the boot). He said that Neves and Encarnação were ready to see us later that afternoon. Thank goodness! Finally someone was going to explain to us exactly what was happening. João told us he would come and meet us at 3pm near the police station, to avoid the media – we wouldn’t be going to the British Consulate this time. On our way to Portimão we dropped Auntie Janet, Sean and Amelie at the home of Susan and Haynes Hubbard.
If we’d wondered about the change of venue for our regular informal meeting, the reason for it soon became clear: this wasn’t our regular informal meeting. We were taken to an upstairs room at the police station where we were greeted by Luís Neves and Guilhermino Encarnação. Our interpreter this time was a police officer, not Proconsul Angela Morado, as was usually the case. The whole demeanour of Neves and Encarnação was different. They looked serious and cold.
There had been a ‘shift’ in the investigation, they said. They had always been optimistic that Madeleine was alive, but now things had changed. Almost instantaneously I could feel my breathing pattern altering and that familiar constriction in my throat. Gerry asked if any evidence had come to light to suggest that Madeleine was dead but they wouldn’t reply. There was a lot of frowning going on which, combined with the language barrier, made it less obvious that they weren’t answering us. Gerry was then asked to leave the room. Now the sirens in my head were deafening. I was on my own and afraid. Please God, let my Madeleine be OK.
Tell us about that night, they said. Tell us everything that happened after the children went to bed. I gave them every detail I could remember, as I had before, but this time they responded by just staring at me and shaking their heads. I was reeling with confusion, disbelief and panic. What the hell was going on? Evidently not satisfied with my account, they pressed me. Was there anything else I wanted to add? Anything else unusual that had occurred that night?
Of course there wasn’t. If there had been I would have told them on 3 May. I’d recounted absolutely everything and anything – more than they wanted or needed to know, probably, just in case some triviality I recalled might be significant. How could they think I would hold something back that might help my daughter? Why were they asking me this? Why?
Neves stated bluntly that they didn’t believe my version of events. It ‘didn’t fit’ with what they knew. Didn’t fit? What did they know? I was sobbing now, well past the stage of silent tears and stifled sniffs. I began to wail hysterically, drawing breath in desperate gasps.
Why did I think Madeleine had been alive when she was taken from the apartment? they persisted. I explained between sobs that there had been nothing to suggest otherwise; no indication that she might have come to harm. Had I ever considered that she may be dead? Yes, of course. Early on that was all I thought, all the time: that some paedophile had grabbed her, abused her and later killed her. Then I’d begun to wonder if she was being held by pornographers, I told them, or had been taken for someone who wanted a child.
I was becoming more and more distressed and more and more scared. I wanted Gerry. Still they pushed me. They proposed that when I’d put Madeleine to bed that night, it wasn’t actually the last time I’d seen her. But it was. It was! I felt I was being bullied, and I suppose I was. I assume these tactics were deliberate: knock her off balance by telling her that her daughter is dead and get her to confess. Because I was in no doubt now that they were trying to make me say I’d killed Madeleine or knew what had happened to her. I might be naive but I’m not stupid.
On and on it went. They tried to convince me I’d had a blackout – a ‘loss of memory episode’, I think they called it. My denials, answers and pleas fell on deaf ears. This was their theory and they wanted to shoehorn me into it, end of story. At last they seemed to decide that the interview was over. They told me I could ring them any time, day or night, to give them the information they were waiting for.
I was allowed to spend a couple of minutes with Gerry, but I don’t think he was able to get much sense out of me. Then it was his turn to be interrogated. He managed to remain a little calmer than I had but he was still visibly upset and shaken afterwards. He gave the police his account of the events of 3 May and the reasons why he didn’t believe Madeleine had been killed in the apartment. Through his tears he pleaded with the two men: ‘Do you have evidence that Madeleine is dead? We’re her parents. You have to tell us.’
‘It’s coming,’ Neves told him. ‘It’s coming!’
Outside the room, I was praying – begging prayers. I was beginning to come unstuck. But if I thought the police had finished with me, I was mistaken. Before long I was ordered back into the room to join Gerry for round three.
Once again Gerry wanted to know if the case had now become a murder inquiry. The answer was indirect: ‘You can probably guess that from our lack of response.’ In a slightly threatening manner, Luís asked why I wasn’t looking him straight in the eye. There was no reason, other than that I was incapable of looking at anyone properly: my own eyes were so swollen and sore that I was struggling to keep them from closing completely. Finally, Gerry tried to establish when – and if – we would be having another meeting with them. ‘The next time we meet it will be across the table.’ The message behind this rather Delphic statement was clear: there would be no more informal meetings.
Outside the police station we were surrounded by the press. There was no need to ask how they knew we were there. On our way back to Luz we had a call from Angela Morado, who had been informed by the police that her services would not be required at our meeting that afternoon. She’d naturally been concerned by this departure from the norm. Gerry spoke to her. I was too upset to talk to anybody. (Madeleine)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on January 18, 2015, 03:35:46 PM
...After a brief chat with DP  Kate dismissed the assistance/support of someone  from the UK. She seemed to have recognized-  DP and was suspicious of their behavior- why would someone unrelated to them be suspicious of them? Why were/are so many people suspicious of them all? I believe it is their demenure, attitude.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on January 18, 2015, 05:48:57 PM
This is getting tiresome.  When you say my suspicions were aroused by what the McCanns did and did not do, what exactly are you suspecting them of?

Being not very good parents....I then looked at the case some more.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on January 18, 2015, 05:54:16 PM
Being not very good parents....I then looked at the case some more.
they were completely upfront about leaving their kids alone from the outset so no need for any suspicion, you didn't really mean that though, obviously.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:57:58 PM
Redwood said....based on the evidence maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...that'll do for me rather than the amateurs on the net
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 10:01:07 PM
Redwood said....based on the evidence maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...that'll do for me rather than the amateurs on the net

Well let's SY take that to court and see how far they get.

 %£5&%

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 10:02:00 PM
It would be ok if people said they believed this as it is ok for people to say that as well others to say they do not and others to say they dont know what to believe/think...no one can say either way, the problem is there are too many people saying it was an abduction as fact when they havent a clue as to the fact of it...it is them that piss me off as they have the brass neck to  assume some authority they just  do not have..fact remins NO official authority has stated this was an abduction
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 10:03:16 PM
Redwood said....based on the evidence maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...that'll do for me rather than the amateurs on the net

No he did not
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 10:03:48 PM
It would be ok if people said they believed this as it is ok for people to say that as well others to say they do not and others to say they dont know what to believe/think...no one can say either way, the problem is there are too many people saying it was an abduction as fact when they havent a clue as to the fact of it...it is them that piss me off as they have the brass neck to  assume some authority they just  do not have..fact remins NO official authority has stated this was an abduction

Well said Mercury. 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 05, 2015, 10:05:28 PM
No he did not

Conceding the (technical) possibility (without a shred of evidence) that might things might have changed since Redwood said that is one thing.

Outright denial that he said it is plain dishonest.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 10:07:13 PM
Well said Mercury. 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(

Well thank you stephen


dealing in facts is the name of the game
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 10:40:02 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27y_yIZTAeE

listen at 3.15..

redwood...it is our belief as experienced investigators  based on the evidence...maddie removed in a criminal act by a stranger...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 11:35:57 PM
It would be ok if people said they believed this as it is ok for people to say that as well others to say they do not and others to say they dont know what to believe/think...no one can say either way, the problem is there are too many people saying it was an abduction as fact when they havent a clue as to the fact of it...it is them that piss me off as they have the brass neck to  assume some authority they just  do not have..fact remins NO official authority has stated this was an abduction

Fair comment!

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 11:44:19 PM
the situation we have at the moment is


redwood has said the parents are not suspects
redwood has  said...it is our belief that based on the evidence that maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...that fits with everything I believe....if posters want to believe the earth is flat  then so be it...but don't expect to be taken seriously and expect to be called stupid
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 11:45:58 PM
the situation we have at the moment is


redwood has said the parents are not suspects
redwood has  said...it is our belief that based on the evidence that maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...that fits with everything I believe....if posters want to believe the earth is flat  then so be it...but don't expect to be taken seriously and expect to be called stupid

Wrong as usual
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 11:47:01 PM
I have posted exactly what Redwood said...

it is our belief ...based on the evidence that Maddie was taken in a criminal act by a stranger...and have provided  a link to support this...
Best listen again.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 11:47:26 PM
Wrong as usual

no its absolutely right with cites
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 11:48:30 PM
Best listen again.

then tell me where I am wrong
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 11:49:37 PM
no its absolutely right with cites

No cite given, and wrong when interpreted by a bsed and closed mnd

The only thng redwood said was there was a possbility madeleine was abducted
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 06, 2015, 12:01:26 AM
then tell me where I am wrong

Write down what yo have writ in your posts then write down what DCI Redwood says on the you-tube thingy then play spot the difference. It shouldn't be too difficile for an homie of your purported kaleyebuh to work it out.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 12:04:57 AM
Write down what yo have writ in your posts then write down what DCI Redwood says on the you-tube thingy then play spot the difference. It shouldn't be too difficile for an homie of your purported kaleyebuh to work it out.

then it should not be too difficult for you to tell me where I am wrong... you cannot because I am right
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 12:37:43 AM
Write down what yo have writ in your posts then write down what DCI Redwood says on the you-tube thingy then play spot the difference. It shouldn't be too difficile for an homie of your purported kaleyebuh to work it out.

Running to
google for kaleyebuh

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:13:27 AM
This is exactly what Redwood says.

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".

Ambiguous use of words and IMO absolutely deliberate.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 06, 2015, 11:22:53 AM
This is exactly what Redwood says.

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".

Ambiguous use of words and IMO absolutely deliberate.

Which words are ambiguous?  I can't see a single one.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:24:46 AM
Which words are ambiguous?  I can't see a single one.

No particular word but certainly the way they were spoken.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 06, 2015, 11:30:25 AM
No particular word but certainly the way they were spoken.

What way?   I'm really struggling here Faith to see anything ambiguous or anything which sticks out as 'suspect'.

It couldn't be more clear IMO.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 11:41:25 AM
This is exactly what Redwood says.

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".

Ambiguous use of words and IMO absolutely deliberate.


perhaps someone could tell us what Redwood means...apart from what he is obviously saying. last night mercury claimed he used the word possibility in relation to this...which is untrue. I don't think Redwood could have been any clearer
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Admin on December 06, 2015, 12:00:57 PM
Members are reminded not to post comments as fact which are unsubstantiated.  Comments which appear as condescending or goading will be removed.

Admin
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 12:38:43 PM

perhaps someone could tell us what Redwood means...apart from what he is obviously saying. last night mercury claimed he used the word possibility in relation to this...which is untrue. I don't think Redwood could have been any clearer
He could have said "cross my heart and hope to die if I tell a lie" but even then there would be sceptics...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 12:39:29 PM
This is exactly what Redwood says.

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".

Ambiguous use of words and IMO absolutely deliberate.

so Redwood is saying that a forensic analysis of the timeline has revealed an opportunity for Madeleine to be removed from that apartment alive. So an opportunity was revealed. He doesn't say it happened, he says there was an opportunity for it to happen.

What if it did happen? Then it is their belief that 'that is a criminal act...undertaken by a stranger'.

So if it happened it was a stranger wot done it. What if it didn't happen? He doesn't say.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 12:45:48 PM
so Redwood is saying that a forensic analysis of the timeline has revealed an opportunity for Madeleine to be removed from that apartment alive. So an opportunity was revealed. He doesn't say it happened, he says there was an opportunity for it to happen.

What if it did happen? Then it is their belief that 'that is a criminal act...undertaken by a stranger'.

So if it happened it was a stranger wot done it. What if it didn't happen? He doesn't say.

Exactly.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 12:54:33 PM
so Redwood is saying that a forensic analysis of the timeline has revealed an opportunity for Madeleine to be removed from that apartment alive. So an opportunity was revealed. He doesn't say it happened, he says there was an opportunity for it to happen.

What if it did happen? Then it is their belief that 'that is a criminal act...undertaken by a stranger'.

So if it happened it was a stranger wot done it. What if it didn't happen? He doesn't say.
Perhaps you can now explain why all their investigations post this statement have apparently been focused on "criminal act by a stranger" if there is any likelihood that they still cling to the notion that the parents dunnit?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 01:56:36 PM
Perhaps you can now explain why all their investigations post this statement have apparently been focused on "criminal act by a stranger" if there is any likelihood that they still cling to the notion that the parents dunnit?

Examples?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 01:57:10 PM
Examples?
All of it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 02:01:58 PM
so Redwood is saying that a forensic analysis of the timeline has revealed an opportunity for Madeleine to be removed from that apartment alive. So an opportunity was revealed. He doesn't say it happened, he says there was an opportunity for it to happen.

What if it did happen? Then it is their belief that 'that is a criminal act...undertaken by a stranger'.

So if it happened it was a stranger wot done it. What if it didn't happen? He doesn't say.

he does...he says it is our belief...based on the evidence....that this is a criminal act by a stranger...so what criminal act is he talking about...


you really cannot spin this to pretend it means something else
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 02:05:41 PM
so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Admin on December 06, 2015, 02:47:20 PM
he does...he says it is our belief...based on the evidence....that this is a criminal act by a stranger...so what criminal act is he talking about...


you really cannot spin this to pretend it means something else

I would be interested to know what evidence former DCI Redwood based that determination on since he has also stated that the man Jane Tanner saw carrying a child was an innocent tourist thus destroying any evidence of an abduction?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 02:48:53 PM
I would be interested to know what evidence former DCI Redwood based that determination on since he has also stated that the man Jane Tanner saw carrying a child was an innocent tourist thus destroying any evidence of an abduction?
Redwood seems to think Smithman is potential evidence of an abduction does he not?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 02:50:21 PM
I would be interested to know what evidence former DCI Redwood based that determination on since he has also stated that the man Jane Tanner saw carrying a child was an innocent tourist thus destroying any evidence of an abduction?

he is obviously not relying on the tanner sighting for his evidence then
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 02:51:29 PM
Redwood seems to think Smithman is potential evidence of an abduction does he not?

Does he ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 03:00:53 PM
he does...he says it is our belief...based on the evidence....that this is a criminal act by a stranger...so what criminal act is he talking about...


you really cannot spin this to pretend it means something else

Perhaps Redwood's English isn't perfect. Let me explain again what he actually said.

1. They have forensically examined the timeline.
2. They identified an opportunity for the child to be taken alive from the apartment.
3. If someone took that opportunity that would be a criminal act by a stranger.

Nowhere does he say that he believes anyone took that opportunity, but if they did, he believes that would be a criminal act by a stranger.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 03:01:14 PM
Does he ?
Yes it certainly seems so.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 03:02:34 PM
Perhaps Redwood's English isn't perfect. Let me explain again what he actually said.

1. They have forensically examined the timeline.
2. They identified an opportunity for the child to be taken alive from the apartment.
3. If someone took that opportunity that would be a criminal act by a stranger.

Nowhere does he say that he believes anyone took that opportunity, but if they did, he believes that would be a criminal act by a stranger.
Please highlight the use of the word "if" in the following as I can't find it -

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 03:22:59 PM
Yes it certainly seems so.

Then you will you a cite Alfie ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 03:26:49 PM
Please highlight the use of the word "if" in the following as I can't find it -

"We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".

If he had said ' this is a criminal act' then your interpretation may hold water. He didn't so obviously it doesn't.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 03:39:24 PM
Perhaps Redwood's English isn't perfect. Let me explain again what he actually said.

1. They have forensically examined the timeline.
2. They identified an opportunity for the child to be taken alive from the apartment.
3. If someone took that opportunity that would be a criminal act by a stranger.

Nowhere does he say that he believes anyone took that opportunity, but if they did, he believes that would be a criminal act by a stranger.

We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".


he does not say "if"...he says "has been".............your desperation is palpable
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 03:59:23 PM
Then you will you a cite Alfie ?
Google "Crimewatch Madeleine McCann" and watch it on youtube  - that should do it!  8((()*/
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 04:08:07 PM
Google "Crimewatch Madeleine McCann" and watch it on youtube  - that should do it!  8((()*/

It's forum etiquette for those who are making a claim to provide the evidence.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 04:16:55 PM
It's forum etiquette for those who are making a claim to provide the evidence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OZ8jmdWlB8Y
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 05:23:06 PM
We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".


he does not say "if"...he says "has been".............your desperation is palpable

He also said to the effect that miss not reflect all our thinking on the case.

Basically, he didn't have a clue.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 06:06:12 PM
He also said to the effect that miss not reflect all our thinking on the case.

Basically, he didn't have a clue.

I wondered how long it would be before the sceptics started attacking Redwood
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 06:20:01 PM
I wondered how long it would be before the sceptics started attacking Redwood

Judgement by results......................
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 06:21:35 PM
Judgement by results......................

what absolute rubbish
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 06:23:45 PM
what absolute rubbish

Well you are bound to say that.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 06:28:57 PM
Well you are bound to say that.

your approach is so simplistic
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 06:39:03 PM
your approach is so simplistic

Hardly.

SY has clearly got no leads in the case, and the investigation has gone nowhere, exactly as I predicted it would.

In actuality, it would be 'simplistic' to think otherwise.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 06:40:35 PM
Hardly.

SY has clearly got no leads in the case, and the investigation has gone nowhere, exactly as I predicted it would.

In actuality, it would be 'simplistic' to think otherwise.

I fully expected you to knock Redwood after he has shown so much support towards the McCanns
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 06:44:06 PM
I fully expected you to knock Redwood after he has shown so much support towards the McCanns

Irrelevant.

You back the mccanns in all of their actions.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 06:47:59 PM
Irrelevant.

You back the mccanns in all of their actions.

Of course I do...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 07:32:32 PM
We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to be removed from that apartment alive and it is our belief as experienced investigators on the evidence that um that, you know, that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger".


he does not say "if"...he says "has been".............your desperation is palpable

Waht do he and his investigators believe? They believe, on the evidence that 'that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger'. What is? Taking MM from that apartment alive. He doesnt say what you would like to hear, which would be along the lines of;

We believe that MM was taken alive from that apartment in a criminal act by a stranger. Simple and easy to say, but he didn't say it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: slartibartfast on December 06, 2015, 07:37:57 PM
Of course I do...

Interesting that you don't qualify that.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:15:55 PM
I support the McCanns because based on everything I have seen and read I do not think they are criminally involved...I think the accident scenario is ludicrous...etc etc etc...I have posted all this and more many times before
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 08:19:11 PM
I support the McCanns because based on everything I have seen and read I do not think they are criminally involved...I think the accident scenario is ludicrous...etc etc etc...I have posted all this and more many times before

You are hear to support the mccanns and nothing else.

As to everything you have 'seen'.

What have you seen ?

As to abduction, now that is completely ludicrous.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:25:58 PM
Waht do he and his investigators believe? They believe, on the evidence that 'that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger'. What is? Taking MM from that apartment alive. He doesnt say what you would like to hear, which would be along the lines of;

We believe that MM was taken alive from that apartment in a criminal act by a stranger. Simple and easy to say, but he didn't say it.

what he said is absolutely fine by me...

you do not have  a clue what I would like Redwood to have said....if you think you do you are severely deluded...
I would absolutely have loved him to say "today we have arrested suspects" and it would not have bothered me who those suspects were ...like a lot of people I would just like to know what really happenned
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 06, 2015, 08:36:00 PM
Waht do he and his investigators believe? They believe, on the evidence that 'that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger'. What is? Taking MM from that apartment alive. He doesnt say what you would like to hear, which would be along the lines of;

We believe that MM was taken alive from that apartment in a criminal act by a stranger. Simple and easy to say, but he didn't say it.

Good grief   -  having read that  - I can now see how some sceptics have managed to talk themselves into believing that...... 'Neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' .....  -   actually means ....' The McCanns are prime suspects'.      Mind-boggling stuff. 


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:36:50 PM
so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents

that's a pretty clear message
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 08:37:52 PM
Good grief   -  having read that  - I can now see how some sceptics have managed to talk themselves into believing that...... 'Neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' .....  -   actually means ....' The McCanns are prime suspects'.      Mind-boggling stuff.

Again.

Nature of crime unknown.

The mccanns remain the last people known to have seen Madeleine alive.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:39:31 PM
Again.

Nature of crime unknown.

The mccanns remain the last people known to have seen Madeleine alive.


so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 08:39:35 PM
so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents

that's a pretty clear message

Redwood found nothing.

Very clear cut and undeniable.

CRIME UNKNOWN and the parents, the last known people to see her alive.

Both of the above, CLEAR FACTS.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:40:06 PM
Redwood found nothing.

Very clear cut and undeniable.

CRIME UNKNOWN and the parents, the last known people to see her alive

so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 08:41:30 PM
so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents

Redwood is irrelevant.

No longer involved in the case.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 06, 2015, 08:43:07 PM
Redwood is irrelevant.

No longer involved in the case.

redwood was not talking solely for himself...listen to the tape again
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 06, 2015, 08:44:40 PM
redwood was not talking solely for himself...listen to the tape again

No need to.

HE AND HIS TEAM FOUND NOTHING.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 10:09:14 PM
Good grief   -  having read that  - I can now see how some sceptics have managed to talk themselves into believing that...... 'Neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' .....  -   actually means ....' The McCanns are prime suspects'.      Mind-boggling stuff.

That is a bit of a leap and disingenuous, IMO, its like putting words into people's mouths, so need to boggle your mind unnecessarily.

Just a matter of different interpretations of words uttered, sentence structure, time uttered and contexts.



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 10:20:35 PM
so we have Redwood saying

maddie may still be alive.....rules out the parents
parents not suspects...rules out the parents
maddie taken in criminal act by a stranger....rules out the parents

Nope, far too simplistic and unthinking...err,...did someone say something about echos and parrots the other day? Wtf?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pegasus on December 06, 2015, 10:30:39 PM
2007 ... August 11 ... Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa ... says the parents are not being considered as suspects. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 06, 2015, 10:34:17 PM
2007 ... August 11 ... Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa ... says the parents are not being considered as suspects.

Why did they keep it a secret from the case co-ordinator?  If they'd only told him it would have saved so much trouble and they might even not have had to sacked him.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 10:34:46 PM
2007 ... August 11 ... Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa ... says the parents are not being considered as suspects.
And within a couple of weeks they were.  Meanwhile how many months have elapsed since Redwood made his statement?  And how much Met focus has there been on investigating the parents?  And I don't mean how much do you think there might be, just give us some actual evidence that the Met are building a case against them, anything at all.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 10:39:12 PM
And within a couple of weeks they were.  Meanwhile how many months have elapsed since Redwood made his statement?  And how much Met focus has there been on investigating the parents?  And I don't mean how much do you think there might be, just give us some actual evidence that the Met are building a case against them, anything at all.

And why would SY tell the public they were building a case against the McCanns ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 10:40:45 PM
Why did they keep it a secret from the case co-ordinator?  If they'd only told him it would have saved so much trouble and they might even not have had to sacked him.

Sousa (ex PJ inspector hmself  iirc)was a spokesman for the PJ and Amaral was in the PJ and  in charge of the case as coordinator...there was no secret..what police state in public is not always the truth!! And for good reasons.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 10:50:28 PM
And why would SY tell the public they were building a case against the McCanns ?
When the PJ were busy building a case against the McCanns in the Summer of 2007 it was pretty obvious to everyone including those following the case from the comfort of their armchairs that this is what they were doing.  There were plenty of red flags to point out the direction in which the investigation was headed.  Not so this time round, in fact quite the opposite.  Now, either the Met are involving the general public in a shocking charade (pretending to be looking for burglars, sex offenders, blonde haired men lurking etc and appealing to us for info that may help them trace these individuals) and thus lying to us,  or they're not - which is it Faithlilly?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 10:57:03 PM
When the PJ were busy building a case against the McCanns in the Summer of 2007 it was pretty obvious to everyone including those following the case from the comfort of their armchairs that this is what they were doing.  There were plenty of red flags to point out the direction in which the investigation was headed.  Not so this time round, in fact quite the opposite.  Now, either the Met are involving the general public in a shocking charade, pretending to be looking for burglars, sex offenders, blonde haired men lurking etc and appealing to us for info that may help them trace these individuals and thus lying to us,  or they're not - which is it Faithlilly?

I think what you've failed to comprehend is that it is just as possible that SY have been looking for Uncle Tom Cobley and all to rule them out rather than in. And what would be wrong with that ? SY are leaving no loose ends.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 11:02:03 PM
I think what you've failed to comprehend is that it is just as possible that SY have been looking for Uncle Tom Cobley and all to rule them out rather than in. And what would be wrong with that ? SY are leaving no loose ends.
Ah, so you follow the belief that the Met are working through the entire population of PdL and further afield to rule each and every person out until all that is left is the McCanns do you?  I see.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 11:02:16 PM
I think what you've failed to comprehend is that it is just as possible that SY have been looking for Uncle Tom Cobley and all to rule them out rather than in. And what would be wrong with that ? SY are leaving no loose ends.

Good point
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:10:06 PM
Ah, so you follow the belief that the Met are working through the entire population of PdL and further afield to rule each and every person out until all that is left is the McCanns do you?  I see.

That's not what I said at all. They are working through sightings and possible scenarios to see whether they have legs. That's how investigations are carried out. If the evidence available does not support a scenario then it is ruled out. Simple really.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 11:10:38 PM
So Operation Grange have decided that it's the McCanns wot prolly did it, but before they can get onto building a case against them they've got the troublesome task of eliminating all these potentially suspicious characters first, not that they believe for a minute any of them could be remotely connected to Madeleine's disappearance.  That's why they sent ol' Redders on to Crimewatch to waffle on about witnesses seeing 2 men arguing with raised voices, sighthings of blond men in and around the OC, burglaries and break-ins, charity collectors and sex offences on young white girls in the Algarve. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 06, 2015, 11:11:26 PM
That's not what I said at all. They are working through sightings and possible scenarios to see whether they have legs. That's how investigations are carried out. If the evidence available does not support a scenario then it is ruled out. Simple really.
Exactly - and that is why the McCanns have been ruled out.  The end.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 11:12:12 PM
That's not what I said at all. They are working through sightings and possible scenarios to see whether they have legs. That's how investigations are carried out. If the evidence available does not support a scenario then it is ruled out. Simple really.

Another good point

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: misty on December 06, 2015, 11:17:49 PM
Exactly - and that is why the McCanns have been ruled out.  The end.

Cue round of applause (my emoticons don't work)
Hopefully Faithlilly can finally understand the contents of her own post.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:20:38 PM
Exactly - and that is why the McCanns have been ruled out.  The end.

Who knows ? They certainly aren't going to tell us.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 11:20:51 PM
Exactly - and that is why the McCanns have been ruled out.  The end.

There is no evidence or statement they have been ruled out so not the end...fat lady in the wings still dear
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 06, 2015, 11:29:05 PM
Sousa (ex PJ inspector hmself  iirc)was a spokesman for the PJ and Amaral was in the PJ and  in charge of the case as coordinator...there was no secret..what police state in public is not always the truth!! And for good reasons.

Well worth a read as it gives doubters an answer to many of their questions ... for example the need to employ PR ... the need to employ lawyers.
Most of all it explains in a way the difference between professionalism and unprofessional police investigative techniques.

Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa was embarrassed when not kept in the loop by the precipitate action taken against the Drs McCann a few days prior to a change in Portuguese law which would have required solid evidence to justify making them arguidos.
The forensic results weren't through at the time ... and any who cannot see the egg running down Mr Amaral's face when they did come through ... has a strange view of affairs imo.

It would be impossible for DCI Redwood who was leading Operation Grange to be subject to the embarrassment suffered by Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa.
Therefore using his official press release ... which in effect made him look foolish, which he liked not one little bit ... to make comparison to the Drs McCann status ~ official spokespersons' then and now ~ then and now is entirely the wrong analogy.


Madeleine McCann: police chief breaks silence


12:01AM BST 23 Sep 2007
It was a moment of quiet satisfaction for Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa.
In full: The Madeleine McCann case

Since making his sudden, dramatic announcement exactly one week ago, that he was no longer prepared to act as the official Portuguese police spokesman in the Madeleine McCann investigation, he had pretty much maintained his silence.

To a tight trio of trusted colleagues he had confided that he was ''unhappy" about the inquiry and ''exasperated" with the constant leaks from junior officers who, in exchange for extravagant meals, were willing to either reveal snippets of confidential information, or to embroider vague facts if they felt that was what their moles in the Portuguese media wanted.

In public he has said nothing.

But this weekend Mr Sousa, for four months the public face of the Portuguese inquiry into Madeleine's disappearance, has come clean.

He has made it clear to friends that he feels his resignation has been vindicated – and why.

He has acknowledged that the leaks were intended to push Kate and Gerry McCann into confessing they had killed their daughter.

More crucially, he believes that the concerted fightback by the McCanns will reveal that, for all the police posturing when they named the couple as suspects, their evidence was at best flimsy, at worst supposition.

''He has told me he always worried that the evidence against the McCanns was weak," says one former policeman.

''He was worried it would not bear scrutiny."

It has not been Mr Sousa's only concern over the investigation.

He also feels that he has been dragged into a war of words.
"He told me he felt caught in the middle of a propaganda war between his police colleagues and the McCanns," another investigator who has spoken to Mr Sousa confirmed.

He has complained that while fellow officers were leaking information illegally — Portugal has strict secrecy laws — the same officers would instruct him to deny the stories when printed.

The problem for Sousa was that the denials rarely got into the media.

The result has been endless column inches slandering the McCanns. ''Some Portuguese journalists were fairly convinced the so-called evidence passed on to them by police was nowhere near as concrete as their sources suggested," says Jose Lugios, a freelance reporter based in the Algarve.

"The way it works here is that we can't get official police comments so we have to rely on tip-offs from them. We know they use us at times?…?as they did when they drip-fed us snippets that might exert enough pressure on the McCanns to confess.
But that's the strange way it works. It's the only way we can get crime stories."

Such lax practice has shocked even the country's politicians. ''The leaks to the press of some details that are supposed to be classified have been used as an easy way to manipulate and shape public opinion," says Francisco Louçã, leader of a Portuguese opposition party.

''It is clear the leaks have been used in a battle to turn public opinion against the McCanns and convince people they are guilty when there is no concrete evidence to support this," said another politician, who asked to remain anonymous.

For months the McCanns have been angered by snide suggestions that their PR machine, dubbed Team McCann — a term they hate — is too slick.

The truth is that it has not been, until now.

In Praia da Luz it was little more than a borrowed fax, two mobile telephones and Gerry McCann's Apple laptop. And while friends and family in the UK did what they could, in Portugal the McCanns had only one official spokesman, provided and paid for initially by the Foreign Office.

Last week that became a six-strong team, top-heavy on legal experts and media representatives.

That transformation was borne of necessity.

Not least because Mr Sousa's observation is nearer to the truth than he may know.
What began as a tale of heartbreaking loss has become a fierce propaganda battle, punctuated by smears and in-fighting.
For an increasingly embittered Portuguese police force, to lose such a battle would mean world-wide ridicule, allegations that they have attempted to "fit up" an innocent mother and accusations from a £2.8 billion tourism industry that they were ruining the Algarve's reputation.

Yesterday there was additional embarrassment when it emerged unofficially that Robert Murat, the only other suspect in the case, is unlikely to face charges.

But the greater tragedy is that Madeleine's fate – to her parents' anguish – appears to have been forgotten.
Instead the propaganda war has led to lurid headlines such as "The DNA found in the McCanns' rented Renault Scenic, is 100 per cent positively that of Madeleine" and "McCanns killed Maddie with an accidental overdose of sedative".

Kate has been attacked as an unfit mother, who could not cope with her three toddlers and resented bearing the bulk of the child care; she had "lost control" in police interviews — proof, Portuguese officers concluded, that she was capable of having harmed her child; the sniffer dogs "reacted wildly to the scent of death" in the McCanns' car.

Then, on Friday, came the allegation that there were six hours of Madeleine's life unaccounted for on the afternoon of her disappearance.
It was an accusation swiftly denied by Kate McCann's friends, who have consistently substantiated the family's version of events.

"The Portimão police were definitely furious that they were depicted as bumbling and ineffectual," confirms a Portuguese officer from another force.
"They were especially furious about stories of their long, drunken lunches and their alleged willingness to force a confession to cover their ineffectual investigations.
The know they made mistakes – a whole catalogue – from failing to secure the crime scene, to leaving the border with Spain open for a further twelve hours after Madeleine vanished, to returning the hire car to the McCanns despite having allegedly found incriminating evidence inside.

But their own press would never write critically of them – they need to keep the relationship sweet.

It was a slap in the face and a shock when the British press not only branded them inept but heaped ridicule upon them, too."

Chief Inspector Sousa could only look on in despair. He knew that these leaks were long on exaggeration.
Then came the McCann retaliation which, Mr Sousa must have known, would be brisk, logical and based on sound facts.

Possibly unnerved by a recent British newspaper poll which revealed that only 20 per cent of the public considered them utterly innocent, and that almost half thought they could have been involved in their daughter's death, the couple's response was swift.

Within hours of an announcement by the Portuguese attorney general that local police had not gathered enough evidence yet to press charges against them, the McCanns had re-hired Clarence Mitchell, a former BBC reporter who had originally been assigned to them by the Foreign Office.

Mitchell, canny, erudite and well versed in media hardball — whose salary, it is believed, is being covered by Brian Kennedy, the millionaire owner of Sale Sharks rugby club — turned the couple from victims to combatants.

He succinctly rebuffed the flimsy evidence against them, telling the Portuguese authorities to "put up or shut up".

Perhaps more significantly, the couple also swiftly assembled a world-class team of lawyers

Privately they admitted to relatives that they had been against seeking legal counsel: now they had no option. "Was it naivety or just total belief in their own innocence that they didn't think they needed a lawyer?" asks Gerry's brother John.
"They were so convinced that because of their close collaboration with the police they didn't need one." Now, of course, they are all too aware that this "close collaboration" was a smokescreen: they did not realise was that the Portuguese police's efforts to find Madeleine had been lacklustre for some time.
Unbeknown to the McCanns, investigators had quickly decided Madeleine died the night she vanished.

All involved with the fightback are convinced of the McCanns' innocence.
But they acknowledge that the couple's public support has been battered by weeks of lurid allegations originating from the Portuguese police.

This weekend Kate and Gerry McCann are staying out of the media limelight.
"Let's call it regrouping, re-energising," says a friend. "But make no mistake: while their primary, vital, aim is to keep the hunt for their daughter alive, they are aware that if they are not to risk ending up doing so from behind prison bars they must clear their names.

For they know, and we know, that the McCanns did not kill their daughter."
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1563938/Madeleine-McCann-police-chief-breaks-silence.html
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:35:40 PM
Well worth a read as it gives doubters an answer to many of their questions ... for example the need to employ PR ... the need to employ lawyers.
Most of all it explains in a way the difference between professionalism and unprofessional police investigative techniques.

Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa was embarrassed when not kept in the loop by the precipitate action taken against the Drs McCann a few days prior to a change in Portuguese law which would have required solid evidence to justify making them arguidos.
The forensic results weren't through at the time ... and any who cannot see the egg running down Mr Amaral's face when they did come through ... has a strange view of affairs imo.

It would be impossible for DCI Redwood who was leading Operation Grange to be subject to the embarrassment suffered by Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa.
Therefore using his official press release ... which in effect made him look foolish, which he liked not one little bit ... to make comparison to the Drs McCann status ~ official spokespersons' then and now ~ then and now is entirely the wrong analogy.


Madeleine McCann: police chief breaks silence


12:01AM BST 23 Sep 2007
It was a moment of quiet satisfaction for Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa.
In full: The Madeleine McCann case

Since making his sudden, dramatic announcement exactly one week ago, that he was no longer prepared to act as the official Portuguese police spokesman in the Madeleine McCann investigation, he had pretty much maintained his silence.

To a tight trio of trusted colleagues he had confided that he was ''unhappy" about the inquiry and ''exasperated" with the constant leaks from junior officers who, in exchange for extravagant meals, were willing to either reveal snippets of confidential information, or to embroider vague facts if they felt that was what their moles in the Portuguese media wanted.

In public he has said nothing.

But this weekend Mr Sousa, for four months the public face of the Portuguese inquiry into Madeleine's disappearance, has come clean.

He has made it clear to friends that he feels his resignation has been vindicated – and why.

He has acknowledged that the leaks were intended to push Kate and Gerry McCann into confessing they had killed their daughter.

More crucially, he believes that the concerted fightback by the McCanns will reveal that, for all the police posturing when they named the couple as suspects, their evidence was at best flimsy, at worst supposition.

''He has told me he always worried that the evidence against the McCanns was weak," says one former policeman.

''He was worried it would not bear scrutiny."

It has not been Mr Sousa's only concern over the investigation.

He also feels that he has been dragged into a war of words.
"He told me he felt caught in the middle of a propaganda war between his police colleagues and the McCanns," another investigator who has spoken to Mr Sousa confirmed.

He has complained that while fellow officers were leaking information illegally — Portugal has strict secrecy laws — the same officers would instruct him to deny the stories when printed.

The problem for Sousa was that the denials rarely got into the media.

The result has been endless column inches slandering the McCanns. ''Some Portuguese journalists were fairly convinced the so-called evidence passed on to them by police was nowhere near as concrete as their sources suggested," says Jose Lugios, a freelance reporter based in the Algarve.

"The way it works here is that we can't get official police comments so we have to rely on tip-offs from them. We know they use us at times?…?as they did when they drip-fed us snippets that might exert enough pressure on the McCanns to confess.
But that's the strange way it works. It's the only way we can get crime stories."

Such lax practice has shocked even the country's politicians. ''The leaks to the press of some details that are supposed to be classified have been used as an easy way to manipulate and shape public opinion," says Francisco Louçã, leader of a Portuguese opposition party.

''It is clear the leaks have been used in a battle to turn public opinion against the McCanns and convince people they are guilty when there is no concrete evidence to support this," said another politician, who asked to remain anonymous.

For months the McCanns have been angered by snide suggestions that their PR machine, dubbed Team McCann — a term they hate — is too slick.

The truth is that it has not been, until now.

In Praia da Luz it was little more than a borrowed fax, two mobile telephones and Gerry McCann's Apple laptop. And while friends and family in the UK did what they could, in Portugal the McCanns had only one official spokesman, provided and paid for initially by the Foreign Office.

Last week that became a six-strong team, top-heavy on legal experts and media representatives.

That transformation was borne of necessity.

Not least because Mr Sousa's observation is nearer to the truth than he may know.
What began as a tale of heartbreaking loss has become a fierce propaganda battle, punctuated by smears and in-fighting.
For an increasingly embittered Portuguese police force, to lose such a battle would mean world-wide ridicule, allegations that they have attempted to "fit up" an innocent mother and accusations from a £2.8 billion tourism industry that they were ruining the Algarve's reputation.

Yesterday there was additional embarrassment when it emerged unofficially that Robert Murat, the only other suspect in the case, is unlikely to face charges.

But the greater tragedy is that Madeleine's fate – to her parents' anguish – appears to have been forgotten.
Instead the propaganda war has led to lurid headlines such as "The DNA found in the McCanns' rented Renault Scenic, is 100 per cent positively that of Madeleine" and "McCanns killed Maddie with an accidental overdose of sedative".

Kate has been attacked as an unfit mother, who could not cope with her three toddlers and resented bearing the bulk of the child care; she had "lost control" in police interviews — proof, Portuguese officers concluded, that she was capable of having harmed her child; the sniffer dogs "reacted wildly to the scent of death" in the McCanns' car.

Then, on Friday, came the allegation that there were six hours of Madeleine's life unaccounted for on the afternoon of her disappearance.
It was an accusation swiftly denied by Kate McCann's friends, who have consistently substantiated the family's version of events.

"The Portimão police were definitely furious that they were depicted as bumbling and ineffectual," confirms a Portuguese officer from another force.
"They were especially furious about stories of their long, drunken lunches and their alleged willingness to force a confession to cover their ineffectual investigations.
The know they made mistakes – a whole catalogue – from failing to secure the crime scene, to leaving the border with Spain open for a further twelve hours after Madeleine vanished, to returning the hire car to the McCanns despite having allegedly found incriminating evidence inside.

But their own press would never write critically of them – they need to keep the relationship sweet.

It was a slap in the face and a shock when the British press not only branded them inept but heaped ridicule upon them, too."

Chief Inspector Sousa could only look on in despair. He knew that these leaks were long on exaggeration.
Then came the McCann retaliation which, Mr Sousa must have known, would be brisk, logical and based on sound facts.

Possibly unnerved by a recent British newspaper poll which revealed that only 20 per cent of the public considered them utterly innocent, and that almost half thought they could have been involved in their daughter's death, the couple's response was swift.

Within hours of an announcement by the Portuguese attorney general that local police had not gathered enough evidence yet to press charges against them, the McCanns had re-hired Clarence Mitchell, a former BBC reporter who had originally been assigned to them by the Foreign Office.

Mitchell, canny, erudite and well versed in media hardball — whose salary, it is believed, is being covered by Brian Kennedy, the millionaire owner of Sale Sharks rugby club — turned the couple from victims to combatants.

He succinctly rebuffed the flimsy evidence against them, telling the Portuguese authorities to "put up or shut up".

Perhaps more significantly, the couple also swiftly assembled a world-class team of lawyers

Privately they admitted to relatives that they had been against seeking legal counsel: now they had no option. "Was it naivety or just total belief in their own innocence that they didn't think they needed a lawyer?" asks Gerry's brother John.
"They were so convinced that because of their close collaboration with the police they didn't need one." Now, of course, they are all too aware that this "close collaboration" was a smokescreen: they did not realise was that the Portuguese police's efforts to find Madeleine had been lacklustre for some time.
Unbeknown to the McCanns, investigators had quickly decided Madeleine died the night she vanished.

All involved with the fightback are convinced of the McCanns' innocence.
But they acknowledge that the couple's public support has been battered by weeks of lurid allegations originating from the Portuguese police.

This weekend Kate and Gerry McCann are staying out of the media limelight.
"Let's call it regrouping, re-energising," says a friend. "But make no mistake: while their primary, vital, aim is to keep the hunt for their daughter alive, they are aware that if they are not to risk ending up doing so from behind prison bars they must clear their names.

For they know, and we know, that the McCanns did not kill their daughter."
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1563938/Madeleine-McCann-police-chief-breaks-silence.html

Glad to see this post is up to your usual standard Brietta. Tell me is there one direct quote from the inspector himself in the whole of that article ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 11:39:02 PM
Wanst there some PR company that won an award for changing the negative  media stories into positive ones around late 2007?


I wonder how they did that and who paid them
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 07:50:41 AM
There is no evidence or statement they have been ruled out so not the end...fat lady in the wings still dear

plenty of evidence they have been ruled out....none they have been ruled back in
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 08:03:45 AM
Who knows ? They certainly aren't going to tell us.
One day they will spell it out for you, the question is - will you accept it or not?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 08:04:26 AM
Glad to see this post is up to your usual standard Brietta. Tell me is there one direct quote from the inspector himself in the whole of that article ?

like the McCann statements in the files....no direct quotes
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 07, 2015, 08:06:12 AM
like the McCann statements in the files....no direct quotes

Ah, but they signed them as being correct.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 08:10:18 AM
Ah, but they signed them as being correct.
Where is the angry response from Mr Sousa in the PT press denouncing this article?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 08:11:12 AM
Ah, but they signed them as being correct.

This sort of thing forms part of what I do every day...the signatures are worthless...ask a solicitor
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 08:17:20 AM
Where is the angry response from Mr Sousa in the PT press denouncing this article?

every piece of evidence....every newspaper article that supports the mccanns is bogus
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 08:45:26 AM
plenty of evidence they have been ruled out....none they have been ruled back in

What have they ruled out, when they don't even know the crime ?

After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 08:47:28 AM
every piece of evidence....every newspaper article that supports the mccanns is bogus

You mean the ones that have not questioned the 'full of holes abduction scenario'  ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 07, 2015, 09:17:21 AM
What have they ruled out, when they don't even know the crime ?

After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on.

Given that the same applies to you, Stephen, all that is said here is mere speculation. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 09:25:18 AM
Given that the same applies to you, Stephen, all that is said here is mere speculation.

No kidding.

So JP, speculating again, how do you see the SY investigation ending up ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 09:40:08 AM
No kidding.

So JP, speculating again, how do you see the SY investigation ending up ?

I don't expect them to find the culprit...but who knows.
What I do expect is a statement explaining exactly what they think happened and why...and I also expect them to re inforce the fact that the parents were not involved...I presume the files on the new investigation will be released
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 09:44:10 AM
As DCI Redwood never made any statement about Murat is it safe to assume that he has not been ruled out?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 07, 2015, 09:52:35 AM
This sort of thing forms part of what I do every day...the signatures are worthless...ask a solicitor

On what basis do you say the signatures are worthless?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 09:59:24 AM
I don't expect them to find the culprit...but who knows.
What I do expect is a statement explaining exactly what they think happened and why...and I also expect them to re inforce the fact that the parents were not involved...I presume the files on the new investigation will be released

The police do not know who was involved in her disappearance.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 10:08:12 AM
On what basis do you say the signatures are worthless?

if you go into hospital for surgery...you are presented with a form to sign to give consent. A court does not accept that because you signed the form you have given consent.......the signature is no proof that the treatment has been explained...just as the mccanns signature is no proof they understood what they have signed.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 07, 2015, 10:17:05 AM
The police do not know who was involved in her disappearance.

How could you know that? - You've just said:

''After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on''

Are you claiming that doesn't apply to you?

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 10:34:30 AM
I don't expect them to find the culprit...but who knows.
What I do expect is a statement explaining exactly what they think happened and why...and I also expect them to re inforce the fact that the parents were not involved...I presume the files on the new investigation will be released

I think they probably have a fair idea who took Madeleine and why. They won't be writing books speculating about it or to accuse anyone, they are working under the imperative of the burden of proof.

The people responsible have had over eight years to cover their tracks and don't tell me they haven't worked at doing exactly that.  Nonetheless if Madeleine is still alive I fervently hope she is capable of of being returned to her family by whatever means.

If the case isn't solved, I'm not sure what will happen to the case files or if we will ever see them.

In British terms the case won't be closed and until that happens I think it would be appropriate to keep the information under wraps.  Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria are in close collaboration and would I think protect the information from the SY side of things ... as was done in the original case files.
Next time round if the PJ are releasing their files I am certain there will be no repeat of the Levy fiasco ... forewarned is forearmed.  They and SY have been running a very tight ship without a single unauthorised leak of late which I think reflects the professionalism with which the present investigation is being conducted.

So the chances are that there will be no further expansion of DCI Redwood's statement as far as the Drs McCann and their friends are concerned.
It is already very clearly laid out and it is self evident from what we have seen of the investigation that nothing has changed since it was made.  That there may be a tiny rump dissatisfied with that is very much their problem ... the rest of the world has moved on apace.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 07, 2015, 11:02:24 AM
if you go into hospital for surgery...you are presented with a form to sign to give consent. A court does not accept that because you signed the form you have given consent.......the signature is no proof that the treatment has been explained...just as the mccanns signature is no proof they understood what they have signed.

In the first instance the consent will be valid provided the consent was voluntary, informed and the person signing had the capacity to sign.

In the second instance the signature will be valid if the contents of the statement were explained and the signatory had the capacity to sign. The signature in this case confirming authenticity of the statement.

So the signatures are only worthless if any of the conditions have not been satisfied and can be demonstrated as such.
In the second instance can that be stated with any degree of certainty? or is merely speculation?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 11:05:45 AM
Where is the angry response from Mr Sousa in the PT press denouncing this article?

It was in a British paper.mhow do you know he even knew about it ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 11:10:55 AM
As DCI Redwood never made any statement about Murat is it safe to assume that he has not been ruled out?

That's probably because Redwood was never asked a direct question about Murat's status within the investigation, as he was the McCanns.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 11:11:36 AM
In the first instance the consent will be valid provided the consent was voluntary, informed and the person signing had the capacity to sign.

In the second instance the signature will be valid if the contents of the statement were explained and the signatory had the capacity to sign. The signature in this case confirming authenticity of the statement.

So the signatures are only worthless if any of the conditions have not been satisfied and can be demonstrated as such.
In the second instance can that be stated with any degree of certainty? or is merely speculation?

Nope...its up to the defence...the hospital...to prove the consent was informed....something that is very difficult to do ...the signature is no proof that the consent was informed....hence the signature is worthless. These are not my words...they are the words of a medical expert witness

in the case of the McCAnns...it would be virtually impossible to prove they understood what they were signing
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 11:22:17 AM
It was in a British paper.mhow do you know he even knew about it ?
Do you think a long article about you could appear in a national Portuguese paper without you knowing about it?  Seriously??
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 11:38:38 AM
Do you think a long article about you could appear in a national Portuguese paper without you knowing about it?  Seriously??

Very possibly.

The fact remains that there is not one direct quote from Sousa in a very long article. Surely if he was that disgusted by what was happening he would have been champing at the bit to express his opinions directly ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Eleanor on December 07, 2015, 11:43:46 AM
I think they probably have a fair idea who took Madeleine and why. They won't be writing books speculating about it or to accuse anyone, they are working under the imperative of the burden of proof.

The people responsible have had over eight years to cover their tracks and don't tell me they haven't worked at doing exactly that.  Nonetheless if Madeleine is still alive I fervently hope she is capable of of being returned to her family by whatever means.

If the case isn't solved, I'm not sure what will happen to the case files or if we will ever see them.

In British terms the case won't be closed and until that happens I think it would be appropriate to keep the information under wraps.  Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria are in close collaboration and would I think protect the information from the SY side of things ... as was done in the original case files.
Next time round if the PJ are releasing their files I am certain there will be no repeat of the Levy fiasco ... forewarned is forearmed.  They and SY have been running a very tight ship without a single unauthorised leak of late which I think reflects the professionalism with which the present investigation is being conducted.

So the chances are that there will be no further expansion of DCI Redwood's statement as far as the Drs McCann and their friends are concerned.
It is already very clearly laid out and it is self evident from what we have seen of the investigation that nothing has changed since it was made.  That there may be a tiny rump dissatisfied with that is very much their problem ... the rest of the world has moved on apace.

Excellent Post.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 07, 2015, 11:57:32 AM
This sort of thing forms part of what I do every day...the signatures are worthless...ask a solicitor

Portuguese law may be different, but under UK law;

When you sign a witness statement you are saying that you agree the statement is a true account of your experience. Your witness statement may be used as evidence in court.
https://www.cps.gov.uk/victims_witnesses/reporting_a_crime/telling_police.html

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 12:02:30 PM
Portuguese law may be different, but under UK law;

When you sign a witness statement you are saying that you agree the statement is a true account of your experience. Your witness statement may be used as evidence in court.
https://www.cps.gov.uk/victims_witnesses/reporting_a_crime/telling_police.html

you seem to be missing the point...
I remember reading an article where Spanish doctors were refusing to treat Brits because of the difficulties in obtaining informed consent
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 07, 2015, 12:09:08 PM
Nope...its up to the defence...the hospital...to prove the consent was informed....something that is very difficult to do ...the signature is no proof that the consent was informed....hence the signature is worthless. These are not my words...they are the words of a medical expert witness

in the case of the McCAnns...it would be virtually impossible to prove they understood what they were signing

I wonder why the NHS state on their website that a consent is valid if certain conditions are satisfied then?
As far as the McCanns are concerned their statements were read ratified and signed by them and the interpreter. All the PJ would have to do would be demonstrate the competence of the interpreter to the judge bearing in mind that the Portuguese system is not adversarial.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 07, 2015, 12:14:44 PM
I think they probably have a fair idea who took Madeleine and why. They won't be writing books speculating about it or to accuse anyone, they are working under the imperative of the burden of proof.

The people responsible have had over eight years to cover their tracks and don't tell me they haven't worked at doing exactly that.  Nonetheless if Madeleine is still alive I fervently hope she is capable of of being returned to her family by whatever means.

If the case isn't solved, I'm not sure what will happen to the case files or if we will ever see them.

In British terms the case won't be closed and until that happens I think it would be appropriate to keep the information under wraps.  Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria are in close collaboration and would I think protect the information from the SY side of things ... as was done in the original case files.
Next time round if the PJ are releasing their files I am certain there will be no repeat of the Levy fiasco ... forewarned is forearmed.  They and SY have been running a very tight ship without a single unauthorised leak of late which I think reflects the professionalism with which the present investigation is being conducted.

So the chances are that there will be no further expansion of DCI Redwood's statement as far as the Drs McCann and their friends are concerned.
It is already very clearly laid out and it is self evident from what we have seen of the investigation that nothing has changed since it was made.  That there may be a tiny rump dissatisfied with that is very much their problem ... the rest of the world has moved on apace.

I have seen nothing which suggests SY have made any progress in determining what happened to Madeleine and who if anyone was responsible.  SY have spent a small fortune in police terms investigating Madeleine's disappearance and have effectively drawn a blank. It is very clear that they are still missing that crucial piece of evidence which would reveal what really happened to her. I suggest that without this breakthrough there can be no progress in the inquiry and any suggestion that they have identified those involved is but wishful thinking.

Yes, Redwood made certain small snippets available to the public, he suggested the evidence as he saw it rendered the parents free from suspicion and that an innocent tourist might be Tannerman but beyond this he gave very little away.  The Portuguese police for their part have had very little to say since the investigation was reopened which in itself speaks volumes.

They are no nearer to solving this case than they were in 2008 imo and all options are very much open.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 07, 2015, 12:18:04 PM
you seem to be missing the point...
I remember reading an article where Spanish doctors were refusing to treat Brits because of the difficulties in obtaining informed consent

Are you referring to healthcare? I'm referring to signed statements given to a Police investigation.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 12:28:42 PM
Very possibly.

The fact remains that there is not one direct quote from Sousa in a very long article. Surely if he was that disgusted by what was happening he would have been champing at the bit to express his opinions directly ?
He chose to speak through his mates, or do you think the Mail made the whole story up?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 12:36:06 PM
Where is the angry response from Mr Sousa in the PT press denouncing this article?

I think the article caught the flavour of the  circumstances and printed nothing which was not to Mr Sousa's liking ... a man of his reputation and position was hardly going to publicise his discontent with the investigation.

Anyone who thinks DCI Redwood was fed misinformation to lead him into the same entrapment Mr Sousa suffered is up a gum tree.
When the DCI spoke it was as the leader of the team who had found enough investigative avenues to allow Madeleine's case to be reopened ... when he said neither her parents or their companions were 'persons of interest or suspects' ... that is exactly what he meant.

Also there is no doubt that Mr Sousa knew exactly what was being printed about him and the case in the English language press and in the Portuguese ... being fluent in both languages as well as being an honourable and intelligent man with an interest in the case and how it reflected on his honour.


Madeleine case the Chief Inspector is away
Per  in September 17, 2007

The Portuguese daily Expresso reported, on Monday, the Chief Inspector of the Portuguese Judicial Police Olegario Sousa, the only link between the investigation of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and the media was removed from the function.

According to the British TV network Sky News, inspector would have been unhappy with the way the Portuguese police were treating the parents of the missing girl, considered suspect since last week. The TV says it may have been removed from the case because of a series of information leaked to the press.

Portuguese newspapers, however, say that Sousa gave up his functions complaining about the "level of information" about the case leaked to the international press. In Portugal, police investigations are confidential.

The trigger, according to the Express, when it was reported that the PJ had the results of tests performed on blood remains found in the car that had been rented by the parents of Madeleine. Sousa denied the information, but Sky News the dismissed confirming that the results actually were already with the police.

According to the newspaper, Sousa had complained that only received information about the investigation after the ask colleagues for being questioned by journalists earlier that he in many research situations.

Officially, says the Express, the decision was taken by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), which would have concluded that the Sousa job "no longer justified", since the file has been forwarded to prosecutors last week.

Sousa must return to the police investigation. According to the Daily News, he was chosen as spokesperson to speak English, have good physical presence and good placement of voice.

 Express, Chief Inspector, Madeleine, Olegario Souza, Portugal, Sky News
https://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://correiodobrasil.com.br/tags/portugal/page/9/&prev=search

Inspetor-chefe do caso Madeleine é afastado
Por  em setembro 17, 2007

O diário português Expresso informou, nesta segunda-feira, que o inspetor-chefe da Polícia Judiciária portuguesa Olegário Sousa, o único elo entre a investigação do desaparecimento de Madeleine McCann e os meios de comunicação, foi afastado da função.

Segundo a rede de TV britânica Sky News , inspetor teria ficado insatisfeito com a forma pela qual os policiais portugueses estavam tratando os pais da menina desaparecida, considerados suspeitos desde a última semana. A TV diz que ele pode ter sido afastado do caso devido a uma série de informações vazadas para a imprensa.

Os jornais portugueses, entretanto, dizem que Sousa desistiu de suas funções se queixando do “nível de informações” sobre o caso que vazavam à imprensa internacional. Em Portugal, as investigações da polícia são sigilosas.

O estopim, segundo o Expresso , foi quando se divulgou que a PJ já tinha os resultados dos exames realizados em restos de sangue encontrados no carro que havia sido alugado pelos pais de Madeleine. Sousa negou a informação, mas a Sky News o desmentiu, confirmando que os resultados realmente já estavam com a polícia.

Segundo o jornal, Sousa havia reclamado que só recebia informações sobre a investigação depois de as pedir aos colegas por ter sido questionado por jornalistas, mais adiantados que ele em muitas situações da investigação.

Oficialmente, diz o Expresso , a decisão foi tomada pelo Departamento de Investigação Criminal (DIC), que teria concluído que o trabalho Sousa “já não se justificava”, já que o processo foi transmitido ao Ministério Público na semana passada.

Sousa deve voltar à investigação policial. Segundo o Diário de Notícias , ele havia sido escolhido como porta-voz por falar inglês, ter boa presença física e boa colocação de voz.

 Expresso , inspetor-chefe , Madeleine , Olegário Souza , portugal , Sky News

https://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.correiodobrasil.com.br%2Finspetor-chefe-do-caso-madeleine-e-afastado%2F&anno=2

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 01:01:08 PM
He chose to speak through his mates, or do you think the Mail made the whole story up?

I certainly think someone did.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 01:05:38 PM
I think the article caught the flavour of the  circumstances and printed nothing which was not to Mr Sousa's liking ... a man of his reputation and position was hardly going to publicise his discontent with the investigation.

Anyone who thinks DCI Redwood was fed misinformation to lead him into the same entrapment Mr Sousa suffered is up a gum tree.
When the DCI spoke it was as the leader of the team who had found enough investigative avenues to allow Madeleine's case to be reopened ... when he said neither her parents or their companions were 'persons of interest or suspects' ... that is exactly what he meant.

Also there is no doubt that Mr Sousa knew exactly what was being printed about him and the case in the English language press and in the Portuguese ... being fluent in both languages as well as being an honourable and intelligent man with an interest in the case and how it reflected on his honour.


Madeleine case the Chief Inspector is away
Per  in September 17, 2007

The Portuguese daily Expresso reported, on Monday, the Chief Inspector of the Portuguese Judicial Police Olegario Sousa, the only link between the investigation of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and the media was removed from the function.

According to the British TV network Sky News, inspector would have been unhappy with the way the Portuguese police were treating the parents of the missing girl, considered suspect since last week. The TV says it may have been removed from the case because of a series of information leaked to the press.

Portuguese newspapers, however, say that Sousa gave up his functions complaining about the "level of information" about the case leaked to the international press. In Portugal, police investigations are confidential.

The trigger, according to the Express, when it was reported that the PJ had the results of tests performed on blood remains found in the car that had been rented by the parents of Madeleine. Sousa denied the information, but Sky News the dismissed confirming that the results actually were already with the police.

According to the newspaper, Sousa had complained that only received information about the investigation after the ask colleagues for being questioned by journalists earlier that he in many research situations.

Officially, says the Express, the decision was taken by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), which would have concluded that the Sousa job "no longer justified", since the file has been forwarded to prosecutors last week.

Sousa must return to the police investigation. According to the Daily News, he was chosen as spokesperson to speak English, have good physical presence and good placement of voice.

 Express, Chief Inspector, Madeleine, Olegario Souza, Portugal, Sky News
https://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://correiodobrasil.com.br/tags/portugal/page/9/&prev=search

Inspetor-chefe do caso Madeleine é afastado
Por  em setembro 17, 2007

O diário português Expresso informou, nesta segunda-feira, que o inspetor-chefe da Polícia Judiciária portuguesa Olegário Sousa, o único elo entre a investigação do desaparecimento de Madeleine McCann e os meios de comunicação, foi afastado da função.

Segundo a rede de TV britânica Sky News , inspetor teria ficado insatisfeito com a forma pela qual os policiais portugueses estavam tratando os pais da menina desaparecida, considerados suspeitos desde a última semana. A TV diz que ele pode ter sido afastado do caso devido a uma série de informações vazadas para a imprensa.

Os jornais portugueses, entretanto, dizem que Sousa desistiu de suas funções se queixando do “nível de informações” sobre o caso que vazavam à imprensa internacional. Em Portugal, as investigações da polícia são sigilosas.

O estopim, segundo o Expresso , foi quando se divulgou que a PJ já tinha os resultados dos exames realizados em restos de sangue encontrados no carro que havia sido alugado pelos pais de Madeleine. Sousa negou a informação, mas a Sky News o desmentiu, confirmando que os resultados realmente já estavam com a polícia.

Segundo o jornal, Sousa havia reclamado que só recebia informações sobre a investigação depois de as pedir aos colegas por ter sido questionado por jornalistas, mais adiantados que ele em muitas situações da investigação.

Oficialmente, diz o Expresso , a decisão foi tomada pelo Departamento de Investigação Criminal (DIC), que teria concluído que o trabalho Sousa “já não se justificava”, já que o processo foi transmitido ao Ministério Público na semana passada.

Sousa deve voltar à investigação policial. Segundo o Diário de Notícias , ele havia sido escolhido como porta-voz por falar inglês, ter boa presença física e boa colocação de voz.

 Expresso , inspetor-chefe , Madeleine , Olegário Souza , portugal , Sky News

https://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.correiodobrasil.com.br%2Finspetor-chefe-do-caso-madeleine-e-afastado%2F&anno=2

It would seem, from the article, that it was the CID who made the decision to remove Sousa from the case and it was not a decision he made himself.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 01:27:29 PM
I think they probably have a fair idea who took Madeleine and why. They won't be writing books speculating about it or to accuse anyone, they are working under the imperative of the burden of proof.

The people responsible have had over eight years to cover their tracks and don't tell me they haven't worked at doing exactly that.  Nonetheless if Madeleine is still alive I fervently hope she is capable of of being returned to her family by whatever means.

If the case isn't solved, I'm not sure what will happen to the case files or if we will ever see them.

In British terms the case won't be closed and until that happens I think it would be appropriate to keep the information under wraps.  Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria are in close collaboration and would I think protect the information from the SY side of things ... as was done in the original case files.
Next time round if the PJ are releasing their files I am certain there will be no repeat of the Levy fiasco ... forewarned is forearmed.  They and SY have been running a very tight ship without a single unauthorised leak of late which I think reflects the professionalism with which the present investigation is being conducted.

So the chances are that there will be no further expansion of DCI Redwood's statement as far as the Drs McCann and their friends are concerned.
It is already very clearly laid out and it is self evident from what we have seen of the investigation that nothing has changed since it was made.  That there may be a tiny rump dissatisfied with that is very much their problem ... the rest of the world has moved on apace.
Pure supposition.

if they knew who had 'removed' Madeleine from the apartment, they would not have been sending letters of request.

The case is at ground zero.

and with an unsolved case........................
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 07, 2015, 01:42:18 PM
Pure supposition.

if they knew who had 'removed' Madeleine from the apartment, they would not have been sending letters of request.

The case is at ground zero.

and with an unsolved case........................

Let's not forget it hasn't even been established if there was third party involvement or if there was, whether it occurred at the outset or later on.

My own feeling is that the key to this case (excuse pun) is very simple and might very well have been in front of our noses all along.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 01:46:31 PM
Let's not forget it hasn't even been established if there was third party involvement or if there was, whether it occurred at the outset or later on.

My own feeling is that the key to this case (excuse pun) is very simple and might very well have been in front of our noses all along.

Precisely.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 01:53:44 PM
I certainly think someone did.
So his unhappiness with the way the case had been handled WAS reported in Portugal, yet no clarification or retraction on his part.  Interesting...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 02:49:12 PM
So his unhappiness with the way the case had been handled WAS reported in Portugal, yet no clarification or retraction on his part.  Interesting...


And the Portuguese article also states that Sousa didn't leave his post due to the way information was being leaked, as we were lead to believe but was officially relieved of his post by the CID.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 02:56:25 PM
Let's not forget it hasn't even been established if there was third party involvement or if there was, whether it occurred at the outset or later on.

My own feeling is that the key to this case (excuse pun) is very simple and might very well have been in front of our noses all along.

The failure to track down and rule in or out the individuals seen by independent witnesses erased one line of enquiry which might have given relevant answers.

I agree that the answer to what happened to Madeleine, if we are every fortunate enough to have it revealed is very likely to be one of extreme simplicity and has probably been touched on already.

I think the case started in Luz and the answer to what happened to Madeleine never left Luz ... but I think Madeleine did and I think the most likely time for that to have happened was 3rd May 2007.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 07, 2015, 03:00:08 PM

And the Portuguese article also states that Sousa didn't leave his post due to the way information was being leaked, as we were lead to believe but was officially relieved of his post by the CID.
So, was he happy with the way the case had been handled by the PJ or not, according to the PT article?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 03:17:42 PM
So, was he happy with the way the case had been handled by the PJ or not, according to the PT article?

As we have no direct quotes from him we'll probably never know.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 03:37:58 PM
Let's not forget it hasn't even been established if there was third party involvement or if there was, whether it occurred at the outset or later on.

My own feeling is that the key to this case (excuse pun) is very simple and might very well have been in front of our noses all along.
When redwood said the parents were not suspects then that ruled in a third party
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 08, 2015, 11:21:57 AM
Now just for good measure, here's one .....................................

'There is something disturbing about the mentality of 'Justice Seekers' who pick and mix which laws of the land are applicable to them and not the populace at large.'


Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 08, 2015, 12:21:38 PM
Now just for good measure, here's one .....................................

'There is something disturbing about the mentality of 'Justice Seekers' who pick and mix which laws of the land are applicable to them and not the populace at large.'

No it is not ... unless you can point out where I question whether people should be posting here, I certainly don't see it. 
You seem to be capable of making the written word correspond to your train of thought ... for example DCI Redwood stating that that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects is transmogrified into the McCanns and their friends dunnit and we're coming to gettem ... once we've worked through a few million of taxpayers money to put them off the scent.

Try again ... mind you ... that is a pretty apt statement ... thanks for bumping it.  But remember, to qualify as a cite it has to say exactly what you accused me of ... reminder ~ I will paraphrase your accusation ... telling posters to go away and post elsewhere but not to post here.

Anything approaching that will suffice ... the sentence you have chosen won't do ... wonder what else the post was about.  Maybe you will copy in the link address next time
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 08, 2015, 01:05:51 PM
In the last analysis DCI Redwood could say anything he liked. Operation Grange can only investigate this case in Portugal with the permission and co-operation of the Portuguese Authorities. They cannot interview or arrest people in Portugal, that's up to the Portuguese Authorities also.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on December 08, 2015, 01:43:14 PM
Not much use if it was some swarthy foreign type.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 08, 2015, 05:49:50 PM
When redwood said the parents were not suspects then that ruled in a third party

Not necessarily Dave, Madeleine's disappearance might not have involved any third party.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 08, 2015, 05:58:22 PM
Not necessarily Dave, Madeleine's disappearance might not have involved any third party.
How would that be possible, exactly?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 08, 2015, 09:10:08 PM
How would that be possible, exactly?

Are you kidding?  We have discussed the woke and wandered theory in great detail already.  Such a scenario did not have to have any third party involvement.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 08, 2015, 09:14:43 PM
Are you kidding?  We have discussed the woke and wandered theory in great detail already.  Such a scenario did not have to have any third party involvement.

Only if she fell down some hole though
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 08, 2015, 09:22:39 PM
No it is not ... unless you can point out where I question whether people should be posting here, I certainly don't see it. 
You seem to be capable of making the written word correspond to your train of thought ... for example DCI Redwood stating that that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects is transmogrified into the McCanns and their friends dunnit and we're coming to gettem ... once we've worked through a few million of taxpayers money to put them off the scent.

Try again ... mind you ... that is a pretty apt statement ... thanks for bumping it.  But remember, to qualify as a cite it has to say exactly what you accused me of ... reminder ~ I will paraphrase your accusation ... telling posters to go away and post elsewhere but not to post here.

Anything approaching that will suffice ... the sentence you have chosen won't do ... wonder what else the post was about.  Maybe you will copy in the link address next time

What did I actually say, not paraphrased ?

Meanwhile, Don't you know what you type ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 08, 2015, 09:24:37 PM
This thread has been edited.  Gaspar related posts have been relaunched  here. (http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6847.msg291727#msg291727)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 08, 2015, 10:05:38 PM
Are you kidding?  We have discussed the woke and wandered theory in great detail already.  Such a scenario did not have to have any third party involvement.
Well we may have discussed it at great length but I've yet to read any remotely plausible explanation the didn't involve a 3rd party - perhaps you can describe one now?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: John on December 09, 2015, 12:44:58 PM
Well we may have discussed it at great length but I've yet to read any remotely plausible explanation the didn't involve a 3rd party - perhaps you can describe one now?

Please refer to relevant thread Alf.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 09, 2015, 08:11:46 PM
Pamela Fenn heard crying on TUE night.

The cleaner said one cot was in the parents bedroom when cleaning on WED morning.

 &%+((£

Both are mistaken according to the non-suspects.

5 rapid phone calls just before crying started. Work to be done SY. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 12:31:07 AM
Pamela Fenn heard crying on TUE night.

The cleaner said one cot was in the parents bedroom when cleaning on WED morning.

 &%+((£

Both are mistaken according to the non-suspects.

5 rapid phone calls just before crying started. Work to be done SY.

Interesting, in the Mccanns world we all know they always blame others, as do their supporters, now why would they say the cleaner was mistaken! Everyone seems to be mistaken  according to them!! nheir supporters, all the files are mistaken, the dogs are mistaken, mr amaral is mistaken, x y z etc is mistaken, quite a pattern
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 11, 2015, 07:26:15 AM
Interesting, in the Mccanns world we all know they always blame others, as do their supporters, now why would they say the cleaner was mistaken! Everyone seems to be mistaken  according to them!! nheir supporters, all the files are mistaken, the dogs are mistaken, mr amaral is mistaken, x y z etc is mistaken, quite a pattern

As there would be nothing odd about having a cot in their bedroom - why would the McCanns lie about it ?



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 11, 2015, 11:27:55 AM
As there would be nothing odd about having a cot in their bedroom - why would the McCanns lie about it ?

Why indeed ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 11:33:15 AM
Why indeed ?

The other question is why would the cleaner lie?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 11:41:55 AM
The other question is why would the cleaner lie?

Most likely no ones lied
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 11, 2015, 11:52:28 AM
The other question is why would the cleaner lie?


That's the relevant question.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on December 11, 2015, 11:53:52 AM
Perhaps its a bit like a Schrödinger's cot  - in two places at once    @)(++(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lace on December 11, 2015, 12:20:09 PM
That description matches David and Fiona Payne's apartment,  they had one cot in one bedroom and one cot in with them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 11, 2015, 12:34:09 PM
Perhaps its a bit like a Schrödinger's cot  - in two places at once    @)(++(*

Or even a dic(h)otomy.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 12:55:00 PM
That description matches David and Fiona Payne's apartment,  they had one cot in one bedroom and one cot in with them.

They were not, however, in a ground floor apartment. Neither did anyone sleep in Bedroom 2 because Dianne slept on a sofa bed in the living area.

While performing her work, she remembers having noticed that the couple was sleeping in the room located opposite the entrance, where she confirmed the presence of a child's bed (crib). The room gives onto an outdoor garden by means of a terrace, as it is on the ground floor,. In the room next to the entrance to the apartment there was a bed placed next to the wall (where she supposed the missing child slept), and also the second child's bed (crib). All these beds were untidy at the time, meaning that they had been used. She also declares that in the room next to the entrance was another bed that had not been used.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 11, 2015, 01:11:03 PM
The other question is why would the cleaner lie?
Maybe she's in on it...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 01:51:13 PM
Maybe she's in on it...

Yes part of the 200 involved in the cover up
And of course some of these must have talked to partners
There must be several hundred involved by now
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Admin on December 11, 2015, 01:58:43 PM
Members are reminded to consider carefully what they post and in which threads.  A lot of irrelevant postings have been removed recently along with several posts which were a clear breach of our rules.  Removing this material is a thankless and time consuming task for editors and moderators so please desist.

Admin
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Lace on December 11, 2015, 02:27:59 PM
They were not, however, in a ground floor apartment. Neither did anyone sleep in Bedroom 2 because Dianne slept on a sofa bed in the living area.

While performing her work, she remembers having noticed that the couple was sleeping in the room located opposite the entrance, where she confirmed the presence of a child's bed (crib). The room gives onto an outdoor garden by means of a terrace, as it is on the ground floor,. In the room next to the entrance to the apartment there was a bed placed next to the wall (where she supposed the missing child slept), and also the second child's bed (crib). All these beds were untidy at the time, meaning that they had been used. She also declares that in the room next to the entrance was another bed that had not been used.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm

Why on earth would the McCann's put one cot in their bedroom?   and why would this have anything to do with Madeleine disappearing?

I'm more inclined to think she mixed the McCann's and the Payne's apartments up.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 02:37:22 PM
Why on earth would the McCann's put one cot in their bedroom?   and why would this have anything to do with Madeleine disappearing?

I'm more inclined to think she mixed the McCann's and the Payne's apartments up.

You can think whatever you like, the statement remains.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 03:14:46 PM
You can think whatever you like, the statement remains.

The statement may remain but seems to be of no significance.... As are all the other discrepancies being pointed out
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 11, 2015, 04:25:15 PM
Yes part of the 200 involved in the cover up
And of course some of these must have talked to partners
There must be several hundred involved by now
What I meant was - maybe she was part of the abduction team.  After all - anything's possible.  Assume nothing, question everything and whatever the other thing is in G-Unit's sig line.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 11, 2015, 04:25:23 PM
There was enough space to add a cot.

(http://i778.photobucket.com/albums/yy69/HiDeHo1/crimescenevolI22a.jpg)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 11, 2015, 06:08:37 PM
Why indeed ?

Even if a cot was there.    I'm at a loss to understand why something so normal and ordinary as a cot in the parents's bedroom would be in any way regarded as suspicious by the PJ.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 11, 2015, 07:37:09 PM
Even if a cot was there.    I'm at a loss to understand why something so normal and ordinary as a cot in the parents's bedroom would be in any way regarded as suspicious by the PJ.

Both parents said no cot was ever in that bedroom. They also denied that Madeleine cried for 75 minutes. Sooner or later detectives start looking at them not others.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 07:45:56 PM
Why on earth would the McCann's put one cot in their bedroom?   and why would this have anything to do with Madeleine disappearing?

I'm more inclined to think she mixed the McCann's and the Payne's apartments up.

The whole layout/placement and items of furniture in 5H was different to 5A, so no......you can strike that one out

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 11, 2015, 08:03:17 PM
Both parents said no cot was ever in that bedroom. They also denied that Madeleine cried for 75 minutes. Sooner or later detectives start looking at them not others.

Having taken a very good look ... and following from the information passed on from the initial Amaral investigation Rebelo found nothing worthwhile about the parents 'dunnit' angle.

It is recognised that constituting the parents arguidos without a shred of evidence was precipitate.

Subsequently Scotland Yard found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case.

The Policia Judiciaria found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case. 

Neither law enforcement body have the slightest bit of interest in pursuing further Madeleine's parents. 
Both are looking at the evidence which was previously overlooked when investigating her parents became the be all and end all of the initial investigation and the hook upon which Mr Amaral hung his 'reputation'.

Why would you hope and suppose that "detectives will start looking at them"?  They already appear to be the most scrutinised couple ever.

What is it about Madeleine McCann's case that there is such resistance in some quarters to the possibility that a perp is still out there.
Why is there such resistance to looking for him and apprehending him?

That you pin your hopes on Mrs Fenn and the cot speaks volumes.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 11, 2015, 08:10:10 PM
Having taken a very good look ... and following from the information passed on from the initial Amaral investigation Rebelo found nothing worthwhile about the parents 'dunnit' angle.

It is recognised that constituting the parents arguidos without a shred of evidence was precipitate.

Subsequently Scotland Yard found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case.

The Policia Judiciaria found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case. 

Neither law enforcement body have the slightest bit of interest in pursuing further Madeleine's parents. 
Both are looking at the evidence which was previously overlooked when investigating her parents became the be all and end all of the initial investigation and the hook upon which Mr Amaral hung his 'reputation'.

Why would you hope and suppose that "detectives will start looking at them"?  They already appear to be the most scrutinised couple ever.

What is it about Madeleine McCann's case that there is such resistance in some quarters to the possibility that a perp is still out there.
Why is there such resistance to looking for him and apprehending him?

That you pin your hopes on Mrs Fenn and the cot speaks volumes.


So when did SY or the PJ re-interview the mccanns and co. ?

What is plainly self-evident, is that have found ZILCH.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 08:20:58 PM
Having taken a very good look ... and following from the information passed on from the initial Amaral investigation Rebelo found nothing worthwhile about the parents 'dunnit' angle.

It is recognised that constituting the parents arguidos without a shred of evidence was precipitate.

Subsequently Scotland Yard found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case.

The Policia Judiciaria found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case. 

Neither law enforcement body have the slightest bit of interest in pursuing further Madeleine's parents. 
Both are looking at the evidence which was previously overlooked when investigating her parents became the be all and end all of the initial investigation and the hook upon which Mr Amaral hung his 'reputation'.

Why would you hope and suppose that "detectives will start looking at them"?  They already appear to be the most scrutinised couple ever.

What is it about Madeleine McCann's case that there is such resistance in some quarters to the possibility that a perp is still out there.
Why is there such resistance to looking for him and apprehending him?

That you pin your hopes on Mrs Fenn and the cot speaks volumes.

Its a matter of so called evidence that always fails to actually lead anywhere...at all.....not even to step two.....just disparate events that "might"  have been connected.....that is exactly where both your so called new evidence that SY found (Im sure you would like to remind us all what it was) to reopen the case and the PJs so called new evidence aka the dead tractor man which lead nowhere...its not a matter of "resistance" to the possibility of an abductor, that is daft, its just the plain cold facts and those tell us absolutely nothing about hard evidence  about such a possibility

Apart from that there is also the matter of the parents behaviour and activities over the years...take your pick!

There are other reasons too as well you know

Your sarcastic peurile comment about  pinning hopes on cots has been noted
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 11, 2015, 08:38:37 PM
Its a matter of so called evidence that always fails to actually lead anywhere...at all.....not even to step two.....just disparate events that "might"  have been connected.....that is exactly where both your so called new evidence that SY found (Im sure you would like to remind us all what it was) to reopen the case and the PJs so called new evidence aka the dead tractor man which lead nowhere...its not a matter of "resistance" to the possibility of an abductor, that is daft, its just the plain cold facts and those tell us absolutely nothing about hard evidence  about such a possibility

Apart from that there is also the matter of the parents behaviour and activities over the years...take your pick!

There are other reasons too as well you know

Your sarcastic peurile comment about  pinning hopes on cots has been noted

You go with innuendo ~ speculation and myth if it suits you.

I'll go with the professional detectives of Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria, the evidence and the statement that neither Madeleine's parents or their friends are suspects or persons of interest.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 11, 2015, 08:44:35 PM
Both parents said no cot was ever in that bedroom. They also denied that Madeleine cried for 75 minutes. Sooner or later detectives start looking at them not others.
yes but first they've got to eliminate everyone else in the world so later is looking more likely than sooner.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 11, 2015, 09:00:36 PM
Its a matter of so called evidence that always fails to actually lead anywhere...at all.....not even to step two.....just disparate events that "might"  have been connected.....that is exactly where both your so called new evidence that SY found (Im sure you would like to remind us all what it was) to reopen the case and the PJs so called new evidence aka the dead tractor man which lead nowhere...its not a matter of "resistance" to the possibility of an abductor, that is daft, its just the plain cold facts and those tell us absolutely nothing about hard evidence  about such a possibility

Apart from that there is also the matter of the parents behaviour and activities over the years...take your pick!

There are other reasons too as well you know

Your sarcastic peurile comment about  pinning hopes on cots has been noted

What would you say Amaral based his accusation against the McCanns on?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 09:06:37 PM
What would you say Amaral based his accusation against the McCanns on?

Available concrete evidence taken from events on the ground at the time and soon after that his team put together and formed a theory whether right or wrong...."that is what police are supposed to do"

A bit different to chasing shadow after shadow I expect ad infinitum

I will catch up with you later on....
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 11, 2015, 09:24:12 PM
Available concrete evidence taken from events on the ground at the time and soon after that his team put together and formed a theory whether right or wrong...."that is what police are supposed to do"

A bit different to chasing shadow after shadow I expect ad infinitum

I will catch up with you later on....

Concrete evidence?

What would that be then?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 09:25:17 PM
We are often castigated for highlighting discrepancies in statements. We're reminded that people weren't clockwatching, they were on holiday, they were traumatised and so on.

I wonder if Cat Baker and Dan Stuk were traumatised too? Cat has the Lobster Mini's tennis written down as being on Monday 30th. Dan, the tennis coach, wrote it down as being on Tuesday 1st. As to the group's statements, Kate was nearest with Tuesday, Jane went for Wednesday and Rachael for Thursday.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 09:32:22 PM
We are often castigated for highlighting discrepancies in statements. We're reminded that people weren't clockwatching, they were on holiday, they were traumatised and so on.

I wonder if Cat Baker and Dan Stuk were traumatised too? Cat has the Lobster Mini's tennis written down as being on Monday 30th. Dan, the tennis coach, wrote it down as being on Tuesday 1st. As to the group's statements, Kate was nearest with Tuesday, Jane went for Wednesday and Rachael for Thursday.

so are Cat and Dan lying too
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 09:39:14 PM
so are Cat and Dan lying too

As well as whom? I would say that one or both of them didn't keep reliable records.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 11, 2015, 09:56:45 PM
Having taken a very good look ... and following from the information passed on from the initial Amaral investigation Rebelo found nothing worthwhile about the parents 'dunnit' angle.

It is recognised that constituting the parents arguidos without a shred of evidence was precipitate.

Subsequently Scotland Yard found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case.

The Policia Judiciaria found evidence to warrant reopening Madeleine's case. 

Neither law enforcement body have the slightest bit of interest in pursuing further Madeleine's parents. 
Both are looking at the evidence which was previously overlooked when investigating her parents became the be all and end all of the initial investigation and the hook upon which Mr Amaral hung his 'reputation'.

Why would you hope and suppose that "detectives will start looking at them"?  They already appear to be the most scrutinised couple ever.

What is it about Madeleine McCann's case that there is such resistance in some quarters to the possibility that a perp is still out there.
Why is there such resistance to looking for him and apprehending him?

That you pin your hopes on Mrs Fenn and the cot speaks volumes.

Do you have cites for those assertions?
They seem to be at variance with "not proven facts" in the libel - cum - damages trial.

m) that the criminal investigation had been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Anne  Guedes).

m) que the criminal investigation had Been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Google Translate from original document).

Take your pick.



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 10:07:36 PM
As well as whom? I would say that one or both of them didn't keep reliable records.

as well as everyone else you accuse of lying
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 10:28:19 PM
as well as everyone else you accuse of lying

cites?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 11, 2015, 10:33:16 PM
Do you have cites for those assertions?
They seem to be at variance with "not proven facts" in the libel - cum - damages trial.

m) that the criminal investigation had been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Anne  Guedes).

m) que the criminal investigation had Been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Google Translate from original document).

Take your pick.

It is a requirement of Portuguese law that a shelved investigation must have a basis of new evidence to be re-opened.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 10:34:04 PM
cites?

so you do not accuse the mccanns of lying...you think they have consistently told the truth
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 11, 2015, 10:40:30 PM
so you do not accuse the mccanns of lying...you think they have consistently told the truth

Cite?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 10:53:44 PM
Concrete evidence?

What would that be then?

evidence available put together rather than airless goose chases around the world nd everythng in between

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 10:58:15 PM
Cite?

the fact you cannot answer the question is proof
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 11, 2015, 11:04:51 PM
so you do not accuse the mccanns of lying...you think they have consistently told the truth

So what? If ANYONE thinks the mccanns are utter liars....ts a free country, we are all free to our opinions,  and jolly good, its about time you unstuck your nose from their derrieres dont you think? As the more you are there the more ridiculous you look, important and more interesting things beckon, toodles jack

 8((()*/
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 11, 2015, 11:12:48 PM
So what? If ANYONE thinks the mccanns are utter liars....ts a free country, we are all free to our opinions,  and jolly good, its about time you unstuck your nose from their derrieres dont you think? As the more you are there the more ridiculous you look, important and more interesting things beckon, toodles jack

 8((()*/

well you have got it all wrong again...if anyone thinks the mccanns are a bunch of liars then they are certainly free to do so...it seems mercury thinks it but is afraid to say it...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 11, 2015, 11:31:54 PM
Do you have cites for those assertions?
They seem to be at variance with "not proven facts" in the libel - cum - damages trial.

m) that the criminal investigation had been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Anne  Guedes).

m) que the criminal investigation had Been reopened by the emergence of new evidence. (Google Translate from original document).

Take your pick.


**Snip
In July, the Met said new evidence had come to light, and last week an appeal launched on BBC Crimewatch prompted 2,400 responses.

**Snip
Portugal's attorney general said "new elements of evidence" justified the "continuation of the investigation", which was shelved by police in 2008.

**Snip
On Wednesday, Met Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe defended the way Portuguese police had handled the initial investigation into Madeleine's disappearance.

"I'm sure for them that must have been a challenge. Anybody can go back after two, three, five, six years and say 'why didn't you do that'? That's easy in hindsight," he said.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24655826

I do wish you people would make up your minds:  my copy and paste seems to cause almighty annoyance:  when I post facts which anyone with a smidgen of knowledge about Madeleine's case is perfectly familiar ... a cite is demanded.  I do hope the cite I have provided meets with your requirement.

Madeleine's case was reopened because of the embarrassment of investigative opportunities which had not been investigated.  It was right and proper that was done although it highlights that the case may have been closed too early as a direct result of the highly charged atmosphere in which the involvement of her parents was concentrated on as the only possibility.

DCI Redwood's statement was necessary to allay that slur ... with Sir Bernard Hogan Howe's statement necessary to reassure the present investigation ... who must have been embarrassed by what they found, despite Rebelo tidying and trying to make sense of the files he took over once Mr Amaral had had to take a sideways move, if not a demotion from the case.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 11, 2015, 11:42:37 PM
It is a requirement of Portuguese law that a shelved investigation must have a basis of new evidence to be re-opened.

I thought the scuttlebutt said that too. So what's with the judges ruling then do you suppose ?.
Maybe she didn't know about that bit of Portuguese law ? or she was mistaken about it being not proven there was new evidence ?

Curiouser and curiouser as another Alice would have said.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 11, 2015, 11:45:41 PM

**Snip
In July, the Met said new evidence had come to light, and last week an appeal launched on BBC Crimewatch prompted 2,400 responses.

**Snip
Portugal's attorney general said "new elements of evidence" justified the "continuation of the investigation", which was shelved by police in 2008.

**Snip
On Wednesday, Met Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe defended the way Portuguese police had handled the initial investigation into Madeleine's disappearance.

"I'm sure for them that must have been a challenge. Anybody can go back after two, three, five, six years and say 'why didn't you do that'? That's easy in hindsight," he said.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24655826

I do wish you people would make up your minds:  my copy and paste seems to cause almighty annoyance:  when I post facts which anyone with a smidgen of knowledge about Madeleine's case is perfectly familiar ... a cite is demanded.  I do hope the cite I have provided meets with your requirement.

Madeleine's case was reopened because of the embarrassment of investigative opportunities which had not been investigated.  It was right and proper that was done although it highlights that the case may have been closed too early as a direct result of the highly charged atmosphere in which the involvement of her parents was concentrated on as the only possibility.

DCI Redwood's statement was necessary to allay that slur ... with Sir Bernard Hogan Howe's statement necessary to reassure the present investigation ... who must have been embarrassed by what they found, despite Rebelo tidying and trying to make sense of the files he took over once Mr Amaral had had to take a sideways move, if not a demotion from the case.

It is inexplicable that the judge should have made such a fundamental error don't you think?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 11, 2015, 11:48:25 PM
It is inexplicable that the judge should have made such a fundamental error don't you think?
What is the fundamental error you believe that the judge has made?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 07:53:29 AM
the fact you cannot answer the question is proof

I was asked if I was accusing Cat and Dan of lying. I answered. The remainder of your posts say I accuse others of lying. You need to provide examples of me saying people have lied. You don't seem able to do that. That makes your accusations groundless.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 08:08:45 AM

I was asked if I was accusing Cat and Dan of lying. I answered. The remainder of your posts say I accuse others of lying. You need to provide examples of me saying people have lied. You don't seem able to do that. That makes your accusations groundless.

I don't need to do anything....you have made it clear you think the McCanns covered up maddie death....that they have lied...point proved
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 08:23:39 AM
Both parents said no cot was ever in that bedroom. They also denied that Madeleine cried for 75 minutes. Sooner or later detectives start looking at them not others.

According to the cleaner the McCanns were in the apartment when she arrived on Wednesday.  If a cot was in their bedroom at that time - then they must have moved it at some time later that same day after she left.   If that happened why would they lie about it to the police - knowing that the cleaner would know they were lying? 

Unless you can think of a reason why the McCanns would lie when they said they moved the cots from their bedroom to the other bedroom on Day One and that's how they remained - then IMO common sense alone dictates that the cleaner must have been mistaken - albeit genuinely.   







Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 08:28:04 AM
I don't need to do anything....you have made it clear you think the McCanns covered up maddie death....that they have lied...point proved


Oh, so you've 'proved' that you know what I think? I thought you fancied yourself as a scientist, not a mind-reader. Telling me what I think is pure speculation. You will need to show that I posted what you accused me of.

I highlight inconsistencies by and between witnesses, it's up to the reader to decide what they mean.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 08:30:02 AM


Oh, so you've 'proved' that you know what I think? I thought you fancied yourself as a scientist, not a mind-reader. Telling me what I think is pure speculation. You will need to show that I posted what you accused me of.

I highlight inconsistencies by and between witnesses, it's up to the reader to decide what they mean.

you take all this far too seriously...it is absolutely clear you think the McCanns lied...I am right...all you have to do is deny it
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 08:36:57 AM
you take all this far too seriously...it is absolutely clear you think the McCanns lied...I am right...all you have to do is deny it

You don't know the mccanns told the truth of what happened.

Yet you regularly on this forum call other people liars.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 08:45:16 AM


Oh, so you've 'proved' that you know what I think? I thought you fancied yourself as a scientist, not a mind-reader. Telling me what I think is pure speculation. You will need to show that I posted what you accused me of.

I highlight inconsistencies by and between witnesses, it's up to the reader to decide what they mean.

your thought processes are muddled...I don't need to be a mind reader to know what you think re the McCanns...your posts are the evidence..everyone can see...
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 08:49:02 AM
your thought processes are muddled...I don't need to be a mind reader to know what you think re the McCanns...your posts are the evidence..everyone can see...

That applies to you.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 08:49:25 AM
As there were two people in that apartment at the same time. One saw something and the other didn't. What conclusions are possible if not lying?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 08:55:17 AM
your thought processes are muddled...I don't need to be a mind reader to know what you think re the McCanns...your posts are the evidence..everyone can see...

I don't think your 'evidence' would stand up in court, it's just your interpretation of what I think.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 09:25:37 AM
As there were two people in that apartment at the same time. One saw something and the other didn't. What conclusions are possible if not lying?

Why would you automatically believe someone had to be lying?  There are major discrepances between loads of witness statements - particularly when it comes to remembering times.   It doesn't mean anyone is lying.

The cleaner - who was mentioned earlier, said that on the day of the McCanns arrival 2 cots were delivered to 5A.   According to Kate 3 cots were delivered - one of which was later lent to the Paynes.    This doesn't mean anyone lied  - the cleaner simply related what she remembered - but that doesn't guarantee that her recall was completely accurate.   However  it seems to me that in your opinion one of them must have been lying?

Why anyone would expect so many different people to all have identical memories of every situation is a mystery to me. 

 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 12, 2015, 09:47:09 AM
Why would you automatically believe someone had to be lying?  There are major discrepances between loads of witness statements - particularly when it comes to remembering times.   It doesn't mean anyone is lying.

The cleaner - who was mentioned earlier, said that on the day of the McCanns arrival 2 cots were delivered to 5A.   According to Kate 3 cots were delivered - one of which was later lent to the Paynes.    This doesn't mean anyone lied  - the cleaner simply related what she remembered - but that doesn't guarantee that her recall was completely accurate.   However  it seems to me that in your opinion one of them must have been lying?

Why anyone would expect so many different people to all have identical memories of every situation is a mystery to me.

The still bigger mystery would be why anyone would not regard, apparently, identical memory recall as suspicious (ie, evidence of collusion and cover-up).

Who the hell, on holiday, remembers whether they entered or exited a building through the front door or the back door on a given occasion, particularly if it isn't clear, in context, what is the 'front' or 'back' door)?





 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 09:49:26 AM


isn't it remarkable that mccann supporters think inconsistent accounts are perfectly acceptable, and don't point to the possibility of people lying ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 12, 2015, 09:58:18 AM
isn't it remarkable that mccann supporters think inconsistent accounts are perfectly acceptable, and don't point to the possibility of people lying ?

Fortunately the police (for the most part) understand the difference between inconsistency and fallible memory recall.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 10:03:21 AM
isn't it remarkable that mccann supporters think inconsistent accounts are perfectly acceptable, and don't point to the possibility of people lying ?

The police regard inconsistencies between accounts from people witnessing the same 'scene' as perfectly normal. 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 10:06:00 AM
The police regard inconsistencies between accounts from people witnessing the same 'scene' as perfectly normal.

Really.

Now that would depend on the 'inconsistencies', wouldn't it.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 10:27:37 AM
S there were two people in that apartment at the same time. One saw something and the other didn't. What conclusions are possible if not lying?

so you are accusing one of them of lying...something you claim you do not do
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 10:30:11 AM
I don't think your 'evidence' would stand up in court, it's just your interpretation of what I think.

it won't be going to court......you are in denial.....everyone understands what you think......I believe the mccanns are not criminally involved...and that is why you and others attack me....you cannot bear anyone defending the mccanns
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 10:36:52 AM
it won't be going to court......you are in denial.....everyone understands what you think......I believe the mccanns are not criminally involved...and that is why you and others attack me....you cannot bear anyone defending the mccanns

The counter argument is applicable to you.

You defend the mccanns and attack those who don't believe them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 10:43:22 AM
Why would you automatically believe someone had to be lying?  There are major discrepances between loads of witness statements - particularly when it comes to remembering times.   It doesn't mean anyone is lying.

The cleaner - who was mentioned earlier, said that on the day of the McCanns arrival 2 cots were delivered to 5A.   According to Kate 3 cots were delivered - one of which was later lent to the Paynes.    This doesn't mean anyone lied  - the cleaner simply related what she remembered - but that doesn't guarantee that her recall was completely accurate.   However  it seems to me that in your opinion one of them must have been lying?

Why anyone would expect so many different people to all have identical memories of every situation is a mystery to me. 

 

Unless 2 cots were delivered and then they looked at the booking form again and returned with another one after the  cleaner had gone? The booking form was far from clear as 3 cots were ordered but 4 were used in the end.

(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_335.jpg)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 10:47:18 AM
Fortunately the police (for the most part) understand the difference between inconsistency and fallible memory recall.

All I can say is if one person saw an open window and shutters and the other didn't notice them there's more than fallible memory involved. Full blown memory loss more like, especially with the billowing curtains and chilly wind blowing in.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 10:49:12 AM
The counter argument is applicable to you.

You defend the mccanns and attack those who don't believe them.

no it isn't...I believe the mccanns and state it.....gunit doesn't believe but is reluctant to actually state it
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 10:59:49 AM
no it isn't...I believe the mccanns and state it.....gunit doesn't believe but is reluctant to actually state it

That says it all.

'you believe the mccanns', yet you doubt other people involved in the case, such as Mrs. Fenn.

and your dislike/hatred for Amaral, reeks from each time you type his name.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 11:01:44 AM
That says it all.

'you believe the mccanns', yet you doubt other people involved in the case, such as Mrs. Fenn.

and your dislike/hatred for Amaral, reeks from each time you type his name.

and you believe mrs fenn and doubt the mccanns
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 11:07:04 AM
All I can say is if one person saw an open window and shutters and the other didn't notice them there's more than fallible memory involved. Full blown memory loss more like, especially with the billowing curtains and chilly wind blowing in.

IMO Fiona's attention was focussed on Kate at the time - and not on the state of the room.      Breezes gust at varying levels and can change in  intensity from second to second.     This was not a gale blowing continuously at a consistent level.

One person noticed the open window - another one didn't.  Both were in the room for different reasons.   To assume that one must be lying is unrealistic IMO.



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 11:08:07 AM
The police regard inconsistencies between accounts from people witnessing the same 'scene' as perfectly normal.

Not necessarily. Some are simply minor mistakes, others are not. Each one has to be evaluated and a decision reached. Here is some advice for jurors concerning witness credibility;
https://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/1-General/CJI2d.Credibility.pdf
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 11:17:14 AM
and you believe mrs fenn and doubt the mccanns

Mrs Fenn had no reason to lie , did she ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 11:19:59 AM
IMO Fiona's attention was focussed on Kate at the time - and not on the state of the room.      Breezes gust at varying levels and can change in  intensity from second to second.     This was not a gale blowing continuously at a consistent level.

One person noticed the open window - another one didn't.  Both were in the room for different reasons.   To assume that one must be lying is unrealistic IMO.

fiona was so close she touched the webbing but didn't raise the shutters. So she is saying they were closed.


when I went into the room that Madeleine was sleeping in, the room was dark, Madeleine, erm, Madeleine's bed was sort of folded back, the sheets, quite kind of neatly really, erm, Sean and Amelie were fast asleep in their cots, they didn't stir, you know, I was opening the cupboards in the room and moving around the room, they didn't stir at all, which that was, that was odd. Erm, we were trying to ascertain whether Madeleine could have got out, and I've already said earlier the shutters were very heavy, and I was almost trying to convince Kate that she could have opened the shutter and climbed out, although knowing that wasn't a likely thing, but at that point we were just trying to pacify Kate in that Madeleine was going to be alright. Erm, and I, I think I touched the webbing in that room, but because Sean and Amelie were asleep, I didn't actually open the shutter in that room,
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 11:25:45 AM
Mrs Fenn had no reason to lie , did she ?
Who says she is lying
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 11:25:58 AM
Not necessarily. Some are simply minor mistakes, others are not. Each one has to be evaluated and a decision reached. Here is some advice for jurors concerning witness credibility;
https://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/1-General/CJI2d.Credibility.pdf

I'm not talking about jurors.    I'm referring to the people who give statements soon after an event.   According to the experts - i.e. the police - there may be no intention at all to lie - but due to the fallilbility of memory - they cannot automatically be relied upon to be accurate.    In fact sometimes they are wildly inaccurate.


Quote from DC Ferguson (JT's rogatory statement)

4078    “You know, we can take a statement from people, if an incident happened outside and there was a group of people watching it, everybody would have a different take on what they had seen”.



Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 11:30:11 AM
Who says she is lying

CAN YOU REMINDED US , WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT HER THE OTHER DAY, REGARDING HER AGE ?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 11:34:40 AM
CAN YOU REMINDED US , WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT HER THE OTHER DAY, REGARDING HER AGE ?

What has that got to do with lying
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 11:37:24 AM
fiona was so close she touched the webbing but didn't raise the shutters. So she is saying they were closed.


when I went into the room that Madeleine was sleeping in, the room was dark, Madeleine, erm, Madeleine's bed was sort of folded back, the sheets, quite kind of neatly really, erm, Sean and Amelie were fast asleep in their cots, they didn't stir, you know, I was opening the cupboards in the room and moving around the room, they didn't stir at all, which that was, that was odd. Erm, we were trying to ascertain whether Madeleine could have got out, and I've already said earlier the shutters were very heavy, and I was almost trying to convince Kate that she could have opened the shutter and climbed out, although knowing that wasn't a likely thing, but at that point we were just trying to pacify Kate in that Madeleine was going to be alright. Erm, and I, I think I touched the webbing in that room, but because Sean and Amelie were asleep, I didn't actually open the shutter in that room,
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm

But we know that Gerry closed the shutters to see if they could be opened from the outside - so nothing odd there if Fiona didn't see them open.    She THINKs she touched the webbing -  and as I said - at the time she was concentrating on trying to pacify Kate more than anything else.    On the other hand the other lady (Amy) was not  focussing on Kate - so was taking in more of the surroundings.

If Fiona had wanted to lie - then surely she would have said that she did see the shutters and window open - as that would have confirmed what Kate had said.





Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 12:00:46 PM
I'm not talking about jurors.    I'm referring to the people who give statements soon after an event.   According to the experts - i.e. the police - there may be no intention at all to lie - but due to the fallilbility of memory - they cannot automatically be relied upon to be accurate.    In fact sometimes they are wildly inaccurate.


Quote from DC Ferguson (JT's rogatory statement)

4078    “You know, we can take a statement from people, if an incident happened outside and there was a group of people watching it, everybody would have a different take on what they had seen”.

Which means that the police and courts have to make decisions all the time as to which statements are most likely to be correct. Otherwise they'd have to ignore all of them.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Benice on December 12, 2015, 12:32:19 PM
Which means that the police and courts have to make decisions all the time as to which statements are most likely to be correct. Otherwise they'd have to ignore all of them.

It means that when statements differ - it doesn't mean someone is lying - which IIRC is what you suggested because one person remembered the shutters being open and another person didn't.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 12, 2015, 12:53:27 PM
What is the fundamental error you believe that the judge has made?

I don't believe she has but ferryman and Brietta think she has.
It can be worked out from their posts about reopening the case and item m) of the "Not Proven" items in the judges ruling.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 12:58:59 PM
Which means that the police and courts have to make decisions all the time as to which statements are most likely to be correct. Otherwise they'd have to ignore all of them.

the whole justice system relies on belief...SY believe the McCanns...if you believe the McCanns then abduction is odds on
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on December 12, 2015, 01:22:07 PM
the whole justice system relies on belief...SY believe the McCanns...if you believe the McCanns then abduction is odds on

Truth is you don't know what SY believe because the individual officers have differing beliefs.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 12, 2015, 01:24:50 PM
It means that when statements differ - it doesn't mean someone is lying - which IIRC is what you suggested because one person remembered the shutters being open and another person didn't.

Both people entered and searched a room, including approaching the window. One reports the shutters open, the other reports them closed. Given the importance of the open shutters someone should have asked more questions to find out more about this imo.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 02:10:04 PM
I don't believe she has but ferryman and Brietta think she has.
It can be worked out from their posts about reopening the case and item m) of the "Not Proven" items in the judges ruling.
Clear as mud.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 02:23:33 PM
Truth is you don't know what SY believe because the individual officers have differing beliefs.

listen to what Redwood says...he talks about "we"....that means he is giving the official view...truth is you do not know that other officers have differing views...that's just speculation ...but we know what the official view was
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 12, 2015, 02:44:44 PM
the whole justice system relies on belief...SY believe the McCanns...if you believe the McCanns then abduction is odds on

So, you really think the whole of SY believes the McCann's ? %&5%£
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 02:47:01 PM
So, you really think the whole of SY believes the McCann's ? %&5%£

try reading the post again and se what it says....not what you think it says
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on December 12, 2015, 03:00:57 PM
listen to what Redwood says...he talks about "we"....that means he is giving the official view...truth is you do not know that other officers have differing views...that's just speculation ...but we know what the official view was

You're on the wrong thread again, ex DCI Redwood has absolutely nothing to do with SY and the Maddie inquiry now.  Old news Dave.  Until the truth is known about Maddie's disappearance all bets are off!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 12, 2015, 03:01:33 PM
Clear as mud.

OK let's try again. This refer to item m) in the judges ruling.
You posted to me:
"What fundamental error do you think the judge made" or words to that effect. (this in response to my post to Brietta which had a liberal dose of irony).
I said "I don't think she did make a mistake" or words to that effect.
What is difficult to understand about that ?.
If you don't understand what Ferryman and Brietta said and why I can't help; perhaps you should ask them?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Angelo222 on December 12, 2015, 03:06:47 PM
So, you really think the whole of SY believes the McCann's ? %&5%£

Most people believe they had some involvement so statistically Dave is up a gum tree.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 03:26:44 PM
Most people believe they had some involvement so statistically Dave is up a gum tree.

if you read my post again you will see that I am not..
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 03:28:02 PM
You're on the wrong thread again, ex DCI Redwood has absolutely nothing to do with SY and the Maddie inquiry now.  Old news Dave.  Until the truth is known about Maddie's disappearance all bets are off!

the title of the thread is DCI Redwood.......so that puts me on the right thread
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 03:29:04 PM
Most people believe they had some involvement so statistically Dave is up a gum tree.

do you have any proof of what most people believe or are you just making things up
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 03:36:37 PM
OK let's try again. This refer to item m) in the judges ruling.
You posted to me:
"What fundamental error do you think the judge made" or words to that effect. (this in response to my post to Brietta which had a liberal dose of irony).
I said "I don't think she did make a mistake" or words to that effect.
What is difficult to understand about that ?.
If you don't understand what Ferryman and Brietta said and why I can't help; perhaps you should ask them?
OK - where in the post below is Brietta saying the judge made a fundamental error, as you claim she said?


Quote
Quote from: Brietta on December 11, 2015, 11:31:54 PM


**Snip
In July, the Met said new evidence had come to light, and last week an appeal launched on BBC Crimewatch prompted 2,400 responses.

**Snip
Portugal's attorney general said "new elements of evidence" justified the "continuation of the investigation", which was shelved by police in 2008.

**Snip
On Wednesday, Met Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe defended the way Portuguese police had handled the initial investigation into Madeleine's disappearance.

"I'm sure for them that must have been a challenge. Anybody can go back after two, three, five, six years and say 'why didn't you do that'? That's easy in hindsight," he said.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24655826

I do wish you people would make up your minds:  my copy and paste seems to cause almighty annoyance:  when I post facts which anyone with a smidgen of knowledge about Madeleine's case is perfectly familiar ... a cite is demanded.  I do hope the cite I have provided meets with your requirement.

Madeleine's case was reopened because of the embarrassment of investigative opportunities which had not been investigated.  It was right and proper that was done although it highlights that the case may have been closed too early as a direct result of the highly charged atmosphere in which the involvement of her parents was concentrated on as the only possibility.

DCI Redwood's statement was necessary to allay that slur ... with Sir Bernard Hogan Howe's statement necessary to reassure the present investigation ... who must have been embarrassed by what they found, despite Rebelo tidying and trying to make sense of the files he took over once Mr Amaral had had to take a sideways move, if not a demotion from the case.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 12, 2015, 04:58:27 PM
OK - where in the post below is Brietta saying the judge made a fundamental error, as you claim she said?

I claimed no such thing.
I neither posted she stated nor was saying. I posted:
"I don't believe she has but ferryman and Brietta think she has".

Ferryman and Brietta have posted between them that the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence.
The judge ruled that the reopening of the case due to the emergence of new evidence was not proved.
Not proved  =  not shown beyond doubt.
Ferryman stated the only reason a case can be reopened is if there is new evidence.
It would then follow that if the case has been reopened then it is self-evident and proved beyond doubt there is new evidence as there is no other mechanism by which the case may be reopened.
If the case has been reopened and the judge says it has not been proved the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence then if follows that there is a mechanism by which the case may be reopened other than new evidence.
So if ferryman and Brietta are right the judge is wrong.
If the judge is right Ferryman and Brietta are wrong.
Faites vos jeux.
The whole fol de rol starts on about page 37 of this thread.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 05:45:48 PM
I claimed no such thing.
I neither posted she stated nor was saying. I posted:
"I don't believe she has but ferryman and Brietta think she has".

Ferryman and Brietta have posted between them that the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence.
The judge ruled that the reopening of the case due to the emergence of new evidence was not proved.
Not proved  =  not shown beyond doubt.
Ferryman stated the only reason a case can be reopened is if there is new evidence.
It would then follow that if the case has been reopened then it is self-evident and proved beyond doubt there is new evidence as there is no other mechanism by which the case may be reopened.
If the case has been reopened and the judge says it has not been proved the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence then if follows that there is a mechanism by which the case may be reopened other than new evidence.
So if ferryman and Brietta are right the judge is wrong.
If the judge is right Ferryman and Brietta are wrong.
Faites vos jeux.
The whole fol de rol starts on about page 37 of this thread.
Or perhaps that new evidence was simply never presented in court in order to prove the claim categorically as it would be part on an on-going investigation and therefore subject to judicial secrecy!  Really, it's not that difficult to work out is it?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ferryman on December 12, 2015, 06:00:47 PM
You're on the wrong thread again, ex DCI Redwood has absolutely nothing to do with SY and the Maddie inquiry now.  Old news Dave.  Until the truth is known about Maddie's disappearance all bets are off!

I must have missed what DCI wall said to contradict what Andy Redwood said?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 12, 2015, 06:18:19 PM
I must have missed what DCI wall said to contradict what Andy Redwood said?

Or support any of his statements.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 12, 2015, 06:22:07 PM
the only official statement from SY is McCanns not suspects
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 12, 2015, 07:00:51 PM
Or perhaps that new evidence was simply never presented in court in order to prove the claim categorically as it would be part on an on-going investigation and therefore subject to judicial secrecy!  Really, it's not that difficult to work out is it?
You seem to be having an inordinate amount of trouble with it
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 12, 2015, 07:45:16 PM
You seem to be having an inordinate amount of trouble with it

The only one unable to see the wood for the trees appears to be your good self.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 12, 2015, 08:10:00 PM
The only one unable to see the wood for the trees appears to be your good self.

maybe it "appears" that way to you, but here are the facts

- There is no evidence that SY finding new "evidence" led to the reopening of the case

- The judge decreed it was "not proven"

You either support the judge's comments or you do not, which is it?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 09:19:17 PM
You seem to be having an inordinate amount of trouble with it
I admit that trying to make head or tail of some of your posts does prove a challenge at times, perhaps a more straight forward, honest approach to posting and less of the wise guy stuff might help the more mentally challenged such as myself?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 09:21:16 PM
How would the court be able to judge whether new evidence had led to the re-opening of the case?  Was anyone from Op Grange or PJ questioned in court about it?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 12, 2015, 09:25:56 PM
How would the court be able to judge whether new evidence had led to the re-opening of the case?  Was anyone from Op Grange or PJ questioned in court about it?

if they were not then the mccanns had no case to say otherwise...ie UNPROVEN speaks for itself
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 09:28:21 PM
Apart from the fact that we have bee led to believe that the PJ would only re-open the case if new evidence was presented.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 09:38:05 PM
So, we must believe the PJ re-opened the investigation despite the fact there was no new evidence because...?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 12, 2015, 09:47:56 PM
So, we must believe the PJ re-opened the investigation despite the fact there was no new evidence because...?

who knows?

The Portuguese attorney general at the time cited the dead tractor driver, SY were NOT involved at all as per Briettas beliefs, you join the dots, I never proclaimed I knew WHY the judge said what she did but she did and tbh Im more inclined to trust  a judge than an internet know it all because at the end of the day if a judge is wrong  a higher judge will make a call
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 12, 2015, 10:43:44 PM
How would the court be able to judge whether new evidence had led to the re-opening of the case?  Was anyone from Op Grange or PJ questioned in court about it?

If as we are led to believe the only mechanism for reopening the case is new evidence appearing then if the case is reopened it can only be for reasons of new evidence appearing QED. But the judge rules otherwise ?
OP Grange are not relevant in this instance as they have no authority in Portugal.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 12, 2015, 11:34:29 PM
If as we are led to believe the only mechanism for reopening the case is new evidence appearing then if the case is reopened it can only be for reasons of new evidence appearing QED. But the judge rules otherwise ?
OP Grange are not relevant in this instance as they have no authority in Portugal.
The judge ruled unproven, which techncally it is, as whatever new evidence there may have been has yet to be divulged.  She could have assumed, but that would have made an ass out of her and you, or whatever the saying is.. 8(0(*
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 13, 2015, 11:43:06 AM
John's post that new information has come to light...that could blow the case apart....and that this information has been passed to the parents...surely this is just more confirmation that the parents are not suspects
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on December 13, 2015, 11:45:41 AM
John's post that new information has come to light...that could blow the case apart....and that this information has been passed to the parents...surely this is just more confirmation that the parents are not suspects

Is it?  What exactly has been said?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 13, 2015, 11:48:19 AM
Is it?  What exactly has been said?

watch this space
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 02:23:47 PM
The judge ruled unproven, which techncally it is, as whatever new evidence there may have been has yet to be divulged.  She could have assumed, but that would have made an ass out of her and you, or whatever the saying is.. 8(0(*

Or it could be that what you have been led to believe is erroneous?
I love your gratuitous insults Alf; I consider them a result  8(>((
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 02:26:25 PM
Or it could be that what you have been led to believe is erroneous?
I love your gratuitous insults Alf; I consider them a result  8(>((
Bless you.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 02:27:09 PM
The judge ruled unproven, which techncally it is, as whatever new evidence there may have been has yet to be divulged.  She could have assumed, but that would have made an ass out of her and you, or whatever the saying is.. 8(0(*

Or it could be what you have been led to believe is erroneous.

Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 04:24:51 PM
Perhaps one of our Portuguese legal experts (Montclair perhaps?) can tell us whether or not cases which have been shelved can be re-opened despite the absence of any new evidence, and if so, on what basis they WOULD be re-opened?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 13, 2015, 04:38:47 PM
who knows?

The Portuguese attorney general at the time cited the dead tractor driver, SY were NOT involved at all as per Briettas beliefs, you join the dots, I never proclaimed I knew WHY the judge said what she did but she did and tbh Im more inclined to trust  a judge than an internet know it all because at the end of the day if a judge is wrong  a higher judge will make a call
I have wondered why the two areas to the east of Luz were inspected by OG in June 2014.  A possible angle, for which I have no actual evidence, is that tractorman's phone was active in Luz that night, combined with the water treatment station out there.

That could also be the driver for the Portuguese investigation i.e. having another look at the phone records and finding such use.  The trigger would be finding out what tractorman's phone number was, so if any of you bods who have followed the case know roughly when this came to light, we might be a step forward.  Or not.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 05:56:26 PM
Perhaps one of our Portuguese legal experts (Montclair perhaps?) can tell us whether or not cases which have been shelved can be re-opened despite the absence of any new evidence, and if so, on what basis they WOULD be re-opened?

Just chucking this in the ring like:
Would the Portuguese police be allowed, under their laws, to interview "suspects" on behalf of a foreign police force in what was an archived case? Or would it need to be reopened in order to provide that facility?
The case was reopened in Portugal pretty soon after The Met announced they were moving into "the investigation stage".
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 06:28:37 PM
Just chucking this in the ring like:
Would the Portuguese police be allowed, under their laws, to interview "suspects" on behalf of a foreign police force in what was an archived case? Or would it need to be reopened in order to provide that facility?
The case was reopened in Portugal pretty soon after The Met announced they were moving into "the investigation stage".
We were told at the time (can't provide the cite but it was a rather disgruntled PT spokesperson I believe) that the PJ had already been working on the investigation (quietly and without any fanfare for months before the Met made their own announcement) and it had nothing whatsoever to do with the Met's own investigation - or am I making this up??
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 13, 2015, 06:29:21 PM
Just chucking this in the ring like:
Would the Portuguese police be allowed, under their laws, to interview "suspects" on behalf of a foreign police force in what was an archived case? Or would it need to be reopened in order to provide that facility?
The case was reopened in Portugal pretty soon after The Met announced they were moving into "the investigation stage".

It seems the PJ requested the reopening of the case;

A spokesman for the Attorney General's office said: "The Public Ministry has determined the reopening of the inquiry relating to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann following a request from the Policia Judiciaria."

This request seems to have come from the team in Porto who had been reviewing the case. These officers were not involved with helping the UK Police, that was;

the group of six Portuguese officers based in Faro who have been assisting the Metropolitan Police.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic21243.html
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 06:34:56 PM
It seems the PJ requested the reopening of the case;

A spokesman for the Attorney General's office said: "The Public Ministry has determined the reopening of the inquiry relating to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann following a request from the Policia Judiciaria."

This request seems to have come from the team in Porto who had been reviewing the case. These officers were not involved with helping the UK Police, that was;

the group of six Portuguese officers based in Faro who have been assisting the Metropolitan Police.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic21243.html
Thank you.  That being the case, what possible reason would there have been for requesting the re-opening of the case if no new evidence had come to light?  Just bored were they?  Solved all the other crimes and thought they'd give this one another go?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 06:44:41 PM
Sounds like plenty of scuttlebutt but not much one can stick a reliable handle on!
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 06:49:56 PM
Sounds like plenty of scuttlebutt but not much one can stick a reliable handle on!
Which part are you struggling with? 
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 13, 2015, 06:59:40 PM
Thank you.  That being the case, what possible reason would there have been for requesting the re-opening of the case if no new evidence had come to light?  Just bored were they?  Solved all the other crimes and thought they'd give this one another go?

The article mentioned new leads etc., but with no direct quote.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 07:06:04 PM
The article mentioned new leads etc., but with no direct quote.
Direct quote or no, do you think it likely that the PJ would decide to re-open the investigation with no new leads?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 07:14:59 PM
Which part are you struggling with?
Mostly "who did what with which and to whom" not to mention when.
We are led to believe that two years ago or so new evidence came to light which enabled the reopening of the case in Portugal. That time was a bit "leaky"  yet we don't know what that fresh evidence was. After two years or so it has not resulted in an arrest (yet).
One could be forgiven for thinking it was an expedient to allow the reopening of the case to allowThe Met to have "persons of interest" interviewed on their behalf by the PJ.
Dunno! but it might might alleviate the tedium  8(>((
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 07:32:54 PM
Mostly "who did what with which and to whom" not to mention when.
We are led to believe that two years ago or so new evidence came to light which enabled the reopening of the case in Portugal. That time was a bit "leaky"  yet we don't know what that fresh evidence was. After two years or so it has not resulted in an arrest (yet).
One could be forgiven for thinking it was an expedient to allow the reopening of the case to allowThe Met to have "persons of interest" interviewed on their behalf by the PJ.
Dunno! but it might might alleviate the tedium  8(>((
might might it?  Looks a bit  to me that like you're of the opinion that the Met are pulling the PJ's strings, is that likely to be the case in your view?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 13, 2015, 07:50:13 PM
Direct quote or no, do you think it likely that the PJ would decide to re-open the investigation with no new leads?

They had been reviewing the case for 2 years, I think it was. It seems reasonable to assume they found new lines of inquiry during that time.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 13, 2015, 08:06:49 PM
They had been reviewing the case for 2 years, I think it was. It seems reasonable to assume they found new lines of inquiry during that time.
Yes I would have thought so too.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: mercury on December 13, 2015, 08:38:04 PM
I have wondered why the two areas to the east of Luz were inspected by OG in June 2014.  A possible angle, for which I have no actual evidence, is that tractorman's phone was active in Luz that night, combined with the water treatment station out there.

That could also be the driver for the Portuguese investigation i.e. having another look at the phone records and finding such use.  The trigger would be finding out what tractorman's phone number was, so if any of you bods who have followed the case know roughly when this came to light, we might be a step forward.  Or not.

maybe this thread will help, or not, as you say


http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3144.0
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 13, 2015, 11:03:23 PM
might might it?  Looks a bit  to me that like you're of the opinion that the Met are pulling the PJ's strings, is that likely to be the case in your view?

Not at all.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: faithlilly on December 13, 2015, 11:25:57 PM
I'm interested in why John Hill and, I believe, his wife were questioned by SY. Wasn't he one of the first  holiday representatives on the scene and also wasn't he  insistent that there was nothing to say it was an abduction'?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Brietta on December 13, 2015, 11:46:13 PM
Direct quote or no, do you think it likely that the PJ would decide to re-open the investigation with no new leads?

Oh look ... lots and lots of quotation marks.


Prosecutor reopens investigation Maddie case
 
Imprimir Partilhar por email
10/24/2013 - 12:58

The prosecutor announced the reopening of the inquiry into the disappearance of British child Madeleine McCann after the Judicial Police have introduced new elements.

A note from the Attorney General's Office (PGR) said that the Public Ministry (MP) ordered the reopening of the investigation concerning the disappearance of the minor Madeleine McCann, according to the criminal procedure law that "the investigation can only be reopened if new elements proof that invalidate the reasons given by the MP in the order of filing "of the case.

The PGR also clarifies that the reopening of the investigation comes following a proposal of the PJ and given the "presentation of new evidence-based elements that justify further research."

They are not revealed what new evidence provided by the PJ to the MP, limiting the PGR to say that in criminal investigations taking place in Portimao, "was requested to the competent investigating judge postponement of access to the file by objectively indispensable term the conclusion of the investigation, on the grounds that it imposes the judicial secrecy regime. "

The PGR announced the July 21, 2008 the public prosecutor closed the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and raise the status of accused parents of minor English and Robert Murat (British who lived in the Algarve), pointing out that could reopen the case case arose "new evidence", which now has occurred.

The 04 October, heads of Scotland Yard in London reported that the PJ had already formed a new team to work on research lines identified by British police about the child's disappearance.

At the time, it was learned that a group of six agents from Faro delegation was formed to assist the British unit responsible for "Operation Grange" the Metropolitan Police, which is reviewing all the clues related to the case after
the intervention of Prime British Prime Minister David Cameron.

Madeleine McCann disappeared a few days before to four years, 3 May 2007, the room where he slept along with two twin brothers in an apartment of a tourist village in the Algarve while her parents dined with a group of friends at a nearby restaurant .

Portugal was one of 31 countries to the respective authorities a letter rogatory was sent with a request for assistance concerning elements that British police want to see clarified, related persons or telephone data.

The chief inspector Andy Redwood detective said then that the British police is trying to find the owners of mobile phones identified as having been in the area and time of disappearance.
In June, British police announced the existence of "38 persons of interest" who wanted to question, among which several Portuguese.
"These are people who were in the disappearance spot radius and from whom there is reason to be suspicious. A little more than circumstantial issues is necessary," said Redwood.

At 12 initially identified British joined yet another three, which are already being investigated, but that the inspector believes that "are likely to be eliminated" soon the list.

Scotland Yard, working on the case a year ago, is confident of finding relevant, "new information" based on 40,000 documents and clues gathered by the police of Portugal, United Kingdom and eight different companies of private detectives.
Algarve First: Lusa

http://www.algarveprimeiro.com/d/maddie-pj-do-porto-forca-reabartura-do-caso-/1055-1
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 08:13:31 AM
Lovely, thanks Brietta 8((()*/
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 08:25:02 AM
if you think about it ...it's highly likely that the abductor used a mobile phone in luz that night...just trace all the phones which it appears to be what SY are doing
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 08:41:38 AM
if you think about it ...it's highly likely that the abductor used a mobile phone in luz that night...just trace all the phones which it appears to be what SY are doing

What abductor ?

 8**8:/:
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 08:45:17 AM
I'm interested in why John Hill and, I believe, his wife were questioned by SY. Wasn't he one of the first  holiday representatives on the scene and also wasn't he  insistent that there was nothing to say it was an abduction'?

Donna Hill was conspicuous by her absence on 3rd May.
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 08:54:12 AM
if you think about it ...it's highly likely that the abductor used a mobile phone in luz that night...just trace all the phones which it appears to be what SY are doing


Why do you think it highly likely?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 14, 2015, 12:13:45 PM
Oh look ... lots and lots of quotation marks.


Prosecutor reopens investigation Maddie case
 
Imprimir Partilhar por email
10/24/2013 - 12:58

The prosecutor announced the reopening of the inquiry into the disappearance of British child Madeleine McCann after the Judicial Police have introduced new elements.

A note from the Attorney General's Office (PGR) said that the Public Ministry (MP) ordered the reopening of the investigation concerning the disappearance of the minor Madeleine McCann, according to the criminal procedure law that "the investigation can only be reopened if new elements proof that invalidate the reasons given by the MP in the order of filing "of the case.

The PGR also clarifies that the reopening of the investigation comes following a proposal of the PJ and given the "presentation of new evidence-based elements that justify further research."

They are not revealed what new evidence provided by the PJ to the MP, limiting the PGR to say that in criminal investigations taking place in Portimao, "was requested to the competent investigating judge postponement of access to the file by objectively indispensable term the conclusion of the investigation, on the grounds that it imposes the judicial secrecy regime. "

The PGR announced the July 21, 2008 the public prosecutor closed the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and raise the status of accused parents of minor English and Robert Murat (British who lived in the Algarve), pointing out that could reopen the case case arose "new evidence", which now has occurred.

The 04 October, heads of Scotland Yard in London reported that the PJ had already formed a new team to work on research lines identified by British police about the child's disappearance.

At the time, it was learned that a group of six agents from Faro delegation was formed to assist the British unit responsible for "Operation Grange" the Metropolitan Police, which is reviewing all the clues related to the case after
the intervention of Prime British Prime Minister David Cameron.

Madeleine McCann disappeared a few days before to four years, 3 May 2007, the room where he slept along with two twin brothers in an apartment of a tourist village in the Algarve while her parents dined with a group of friends at a nearby restaurant .

Portugal was one of 31 countries to the respective authorities a letter rogatory was sent with a request for assistance concerning elements that British police want to see clarified, related persons or telephone data.

The chief inspector Andy Redwood detective said then that the British police is trying to find the owners of mobile phones identified as having been in the area and time of disappearance.
In June, British police announced the existence of "38 persons of interest" who wanted to question, among which several Portuguese.
"These are people who were in the disappearance spot radius and from whom there is reason to be suspicious. A little more than circumstantial issues is necessary," said Redwood.

At 12 initially identified British joined yet another three, which are already being investigated, but that the inspector believes that "are likely to be eliminated" soon the list.

Scotland Yard, working on the case a year ago, is confident of finding relevant, "new information" based on 40,000 documents and clues gathered by the police of Portugal, United Kingdom and eight different companies of private detectives.
Algarve First: Lusa

http://www.algarveprimeiro.com/d/maddie-pj-do-porto-forca-reabartura-do-caso-/1055-1

I wonder who the other five were?
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: G-Unit on December 14, 2015, 12:38:27 PM
I wonder who the other five were?

I've gt four;

CRG
Metado 3
Halligen
Alpha whatsit (Dave Edgar)
Title: Re: DCI Redwood, "The McCanns & their friends are not suspects"
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 14, 2015, 01:25:15 PM
I've gt four;

CRG
Metado 3
Halligen
Alpha whatsit (Dave Edgar)

Yeah! I forgot CRG because they were probably hired by Mark Warner, but I guess the cops gathered info from them.