UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on September 09, 2015, 12:08:36 PM
-
Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance but the PJ were investigating Murat at the time and Tanner said the man she saw was carrying a child towards his house so of course that sighting was given top priority.
77
-
Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance but the PJ were investigating Murat at the time and Tanner said the man she saw was carrying a child towards his house so of course that sighting was given top priority.
"Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance"
Disagree.
What needs to be found is a person apparantly not carrying a child.
It's the most popular rule in the criminal mind Pathfinder: Don't let people see what you're doing.
-
Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance but the PJ were investigating Murat at the time and Tanner said the man she saw was carrying a child towards his house so of course that sighting was given top priority.
Then that is a perfect example of all the eggs going into the one basket.
The PJ may indeed have had an arguido constituted the day prior to the witnesses coming forward but it is not the function of the PJ or any policing body to act as prosecutor ~ judge ~ or jury.
They are tasked with investigating; whether or not that may inconvenience them.
I would be of the opinion that the priority of this and any case involving a missing child ... is the child and the opportunity to find her ... not a conviction at that time.
A report of a man seen carrying a child matching the description of the missing child but walking away from the direction of the prime suspect's residence was worthy of note and investigation; particularly as the witness statement seemed to suggest the PJ were backing the wrong horse.
-
"Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance"
Disagree.
What needs to be found is a person apparantly not carrying a child.
It's the most popular rule in the criminal mind Pathfinder: Don't let people see what you're doing.
Quite. The object of the exercise would be concealment not advertisement of the crime.
-
why do you think wheel a suitcase through a holiday resort would look more suspicious than carrying an uncovered undisguised corpse?
Because open carrying is quicker and not suspicious in that resort with late night creches. This was 10pm at night. Struggling with a heavy suitcase stands out a mile at that time all alone. If you were smart you would use concealment only away from the crime scene. That is where you don't want to be seen carrying a child so of course Tannerman was prime suspect.
-
Quite. The object of the exercise would be concealment not advertisement of the crime.
Precisely.
-
"Any sighting of a man carrying a child is of great importance"
Disagree.
What needs to be found is a person apparantly not carrying a child.
It's the most popular rule in the criminal mind Pathfinder: Don't let people see what you're doing.
Hindsight's a great thing...
In different circumstances, a number of questions might have been helpful (IMO).
- Did you see anyone carrying a child?
- Were YOU or someone you know carrying a child?
- Did you notice anyone carrying / dragging a suitcase or bags of any description?
- After a roundabout general convo and much soothing: was anyone you know expected for dinner / drinks in a bar / evening shift work who was delayed?
- Has anyone you know been behaving in a different way recently?
- (...)
-
Precisely.
Only at the crime scene. If you are moving from a safe distance away then it's not suspicious as it looks like a normal father and daughter returning home from the creche. This is what has fooled everyone. They think it's normal and no abductor would carry a child that far without using a vehicle.
-
Because open carrying is quicker and not suspicious in that resort with late night creches. This was 10pm at night. Struggling with a heavy suitcase stands out a mile at that time all alone.
You seem to be assuming a light weight for your theory, and a much greater "struggling" "heavy" weight for the other theory.
-
Because open carrying is quicker and not suspicious in that resort with late night creches. This was 10pm at night. Struggling with a heavy suitcase stands out a mile at that time all alone. If you were smart you would use concealment only away from the crime scene. That is where you don't want to be seen carrying a child so of course Tannerman was prime suspect.
This is in your opinion. Personally I think the reverse is true. In a holiday resort people expect to see people "struggling" with suitcases (though why pulling a suitcase on wheels should prove so difficult I don't really understand). Conversely, people don't expect to see men carrying corpses around, but perhaps that's just me? Remember this supposed corpse was undisguised and anyone passing it could have reported it as looking exactly like the missing child, and the man carrying it looking exactly like the child's father, in fact that pretty much happened anyway didn't it?! So, why did "Smithman" puruse such an idiotic course of action in your view?
-
Only at the crime scene. If you are moving from a safe distance away then it's not suspicious as it looks like a normal father and daughter returning home from the creche. This is what has fooled everyone. They think it's normal and no abductor would carry a child that far without using a vehicle.
Safe distance? How many metres from the apartment does visible open carrying start in your theory?
-
Safe distance? How many metres from the apartment does visible open carrying start in your theory?
About half-way from crime scene to Smiths sighting. On the opposite side of wasteland to the crime scene location (not in the wasteland).
-
This is in your opinion. Personally I think the reverse is true. In a holiday resort people expect to see people "struggling" with suitcases (though why pulling a suitcase on wheels should prove so difficult I don't really understand). Conversely, people don't expect to see men carrying corpses around, but perhaps that's just me? Remember this supposed corpse was undisguised and anyone passing it could have reported it as looking exactly like the missing child, and the man carrying it looking exactly like the child's father, in fact that pretty much happened anyway didn't it?! So, why did "Smithman" puruse such an idiotic course of action in your view?
Easy answer Time since death could possibly be established if found and she hasn't been found.
-
Easy answer Time since death could possibly be established if found.
With all due respect that is a rubbish answer.
-
With all due respect that is a rubbish answer.
Oh really do you think? Hypothesis: We've found her dumped in the wasteland only a 150 metres away but she's been dead for many hours. Hmmm.....
-
Oh really do you think? Hypothesis: We've found her dumped in the wasteland only a 150 metres away but she's been dead for many hours. Hmmm.....
The question was about the idiotic risk taken by "Smithman" undisguised and carrying the undisguised corpse of (what was soon to become) the missing child whose photo would be circulated throughout the resort and beyond. Your response does nothing to address this point. What you and others are suggesting is utterly nonsensical, unless we are to believe that "Smithman" was behaving completely irrationally or wanted to be id'ed and caught.
-
The question was about the idiotic risk taken by "Smithman" undisguised and carrying the undisguised corpse of (what was soon to become) the missing child whose photo would be circulated throughout the resort and beyond. Your response does nothing to address this point. What you and others are suggesting is utterly nonsensical, unless we are to believe that "Smithman" was behaving completely irrationally or wanted to be id'ed and caught.
What other option did he have if he had to make her disappear. She hasn't been found so it worked however idiotic you think it was.
-
The question was about the idiotic risk taken by "Smithman" undisguised and carrying the undisguised corpse of (what was soon to become) the missing child whose photo would be circulated throughout the resort and beyond. Your response does nothing to address this point. What you and others are suggesting is utterly nonsensical, unless we are to believe that "Smithman" was behaving completely irrationally or wanted to be id'ed and caught.
Is it more ridiculous than an abductor carrying a child past her own father? That was accepted as a fact by some for years.
-
What other option did he have if he had to make her disappear. She hasn't been found so it worked however idiotic you think it was.
I have already put forward an option - and that was to use a suitcase, or at least some attempt at disguising the corpse. Why you should think this less desirable from Smithman's pov is quite beyond me.
-
I have already put forward an option - and that was to use a suitcase, or at least some attempt at disguising the corpse. Why you should think this less desirable from Smithman's pov is quite beyond me.
Speed to where he was getting to. It is quicker to open carry so he risked it. And then he would have to get rid of the bag. If they find that he could be arrested. What is your bag doing here?
-
Is it more ridiculous than an abductor carrying a child past her own father? That was accepted as a fact by some for years.
Yes, it is WAY more ridiculous. If Tannerman had been the abductor he may not have had any idea that the child's father was nearby. In any case, most abductors (particularly those with a sexual motive) are foolhardy risk takers, we know this, it's part of the buzz.
-
Speed to where he was getting to. It is quicker to open carry so he risked it. And then he would have to get rid of the bag. If they find that they could be arrested. What is your bag doing here?
LOL. So, much easier and far less incriminating to get rid of a child's body than a suitcase, is that what you're telling us?
-
Is it more ridiculous than an abductor carrying a child past her own father? That was accepted as a fact by some for years.
Yes and the problem is that after SY realised that first open-carrying sighting was irrelevant, instead of saying "hang on, that is a stupid method anyway, why assume the perp is so stupid, let's look at other methods and timescales", they instead just switched to another open-carrying sighting, equally unlikely to be relevant IMO.
-
LOL. So, much easier and far less incriminating to get rid of a child's body than a suitcase, is that what you're telling us?
You would only need a bag to conceal away from the crime scene. You would not need it after that first move away unless you wanted to incriminate yourself if your bag was found.
-
Speed to where he was getting to. It is quicker to open carry so he risked it. And then he would have to get rid of the bag. If they find that they could be arrested. What is your bag doing here?
"What is your bag doing here?"
-
The question was about the idiotic risk taken by "Smithman" undisguised and carrying the undisguised corpse of (what was soon to become) the missing child whose photo would be circulated throughout the resort and beyond. Your response does nothing to address this point. What you and others are suggesting is utterly nonsensical, unless we are to believe that "Smithman" was behaving completely irrationally or wanted to be id'ed and caught.
Not irrationally. Desperately.
-
You would only need a bag to conceal away from the crime scene. You would not need it after that first move away unless you wanted to incriminate yourself if your bag was found.
And you don't think walking undisguised through town carrying the undisguised corpse of a missing child risks in any way incriminating yourself?
-
And you don't think walking undisguised through town carrying the undisguised corpse of a missing child risks in any way incriminating yourself?
If you haven't got a car then you have to do what you gotta do. This is panic station time.
-
Not irrationally. Desperately.
Lyall - you seem quite normal. Do you think it is rational behaviour to parade undisguised through town with the undisguised corpse of a missing child in your arms? Can you envisage yourself being so desperate as to take a similar course of action? Where was the desperation anyway?
-
If you haven't got a car then you have to do what you gotta do. This is panic station time.
So, Smithman was in a state of abject panic, is that what you're telling us now? That explains the idiotic behaviour then!
-
So, Smithman was in a state of abject panic, is that what you're telling us now? That explains the idiotic behaviour then!
This was planned Alfie but it's not something you ever do.
-
Yes and the problem is that after SY realised that first open-carrying sighting was irrelevant, instead of saying "hang on, that is a stupid method anyway, why assume the perp is so stupid, let's look at other methods and timescales", they instead just switched to another open-carrying sighting, equally unlikely to be relevant IMO.
It is my opinion that the sighting of a child being carried in the immediate vicinity of an apartment from which it was soon to be discovered a child was missing is highly relevant. Particularly as it was reported to the investigating authorities at the earliest opportunity after the event.
The direction being taken by the carrier would appear to have been worthy of close investigation ~ perhaps the distraction of Robert Murat's undoubtedly odd behaviour became a sticking point for investigation beyond the confines of Casa Liliana.
The investigation as a whole seems to me to have been very insular and inward looking. What was the problem about casting the net and broadening the search for Madeleine beyond the confines of the Murat and McCann residences?
-
You would only need a bag to conceal away from the crime scene. You would not need it after that first move away unless you wanted to incriminate yourself if a bag was found.
But you have your perp leaving the bag behind at your first location where it may be found Pathfinder.
You may be interested in these past cases in Europe and N America where a perp has switched from a bag to a visible uncovered carrying:
1.
2.
3.
-
It is my opinion that the sighting of a child being carried in the immediate vicinity of an apartment from which it was soon to be discovered a child was missing is highly relevant. Particularly as it was reported to the investigating authorities at the earliest opportunity after the event.
The direction being taken by the carrier would appear to have been worthy of close investigation ~ perhaps the distraction of Robert Murat's undoubtedly odd behaviour became a sticking point for investigation beyond the confines of Casa Liliana.
The investigation as a whole seems to me to have been very insular and inward looking. What was the problem about casting the net and broadening the search for Madeleine beyond the confines of the Murat and McCann residences?
IMO close investigation was made of the direction taken by child carrier seen by JT.
That IMO is why all the scrubland areas close to the apartment selected by the NPIA for cadaver dog search on 31 May 2007 were basically northeast of the apartment - and much closer areas to the west was ignored - all to fit the direction of the man in the JT sighting IMO
-
Lyall - you seem quite normal. Do you think it is rational behaviour to parade undisguised through town with the undisguised corpse of a missing child in your arms? Can you envisage yourself being so desperate as to take a similar course of action? Where was the desperation anyway? There was no imminent danger of the death being discovered - they had all night to dispose of a body.
If that's what happened then probably the need to have alibis came into the equation. If they weren't involved it also possibly came into the equation.
-
But you have your perp leaving the bag behind at your first location where it may be found Pathfinder.
You may be interested in these past cases in Europe and N America where a perp has switched from a bag to a visible uncovered carrying:
1.
2.
3.
No the bag didn't stay at the first location. The bag would never stay with the body.
-
No the bag didn't stay at the first location. The bag would never stay with the body.
So not one but two incriminating pieces of evidence to be disposed of in separate vortexes swirling about in Praia da Luz never to be seen again.
Your suspect didn't half give himself some problems.
-
This was planned Alfie but it's not something you ever do.
What does that mean?
-
Pathfinder at the location where your theory's transport-by-bag ends and later your open-carrying begins, do you not see, your theory leaves an empty bag at that location.
-
Easy to say that now. Not so easy if the scenario actually happens.
If that's what happened, decisions taken in panic may have very quickly been regretted.
Even in a state of panic (no evidence of any panic in "Smithman" prior to 10pm in evidence btw) self-preservation and a desperate desire not to be found out would be the overriding factor at play, and yet the suggestion is that the complete reverse took place, a bare-faced march through town for some considerable distance carrying an undisguised corpse - not the actions of an otherwise rational man in a panic, but the actions of an idiot or someone who wanted to be caught.
-
You tell us your theory is all based on facts - so kindly tell us when Smithman was seen carrying a bag that evening please?
-
Hang on - two bags?
-
You tell us your theory is all based on facts - so kindly tell us when Smithman was seen carrying a bag that evening please?
Madeleine was not seen leaving the crime scene. No person was seen leaving the crime scene. The only people we know at the crime scene that night were Gerry who last saw Madeleine, Matt who didn't see Madeleine and Kate who raised the alarm that she was gone.
-
Even in a state of panic (no evidence of any panic in "Smithman" prior to 10pm in evidence btw) self-preservation and a desperate desire not to be found out would be the overriding factor at play, and yet the suggestion is that the complete reverse took place, a bare-faced march through town for some considerable distance carrying an undisguised corpse - not the actions of an otherwise rational man in a panic, but the actions of an idiot or someone who wanted to be caught.
Some idiot. If that's what happened, he - abductor or person or persons Madeleine knew - got away with it.
What else could someone without transport do?
-
It's less easy to move quickly if you're carrying a suitcase.
It's also greatly more suspicious if you're seen moving briskly with one. You'd not be intercepted at the time but the day after it would be suspicious to witnesses.
So would a man carrying a blanket.
Both are not common sights late at night.
But a man carrying a child was a common sight.
-
Some idiot. If that's what happened, he - abductor or person or persons Madeleine knew - got away with it.
What else could someone without transport do?
Nothing?
-
Nothing?
That's true 8**8:/: But someone clearly did do something.
-
It's less easy to move quickly if you're carrying a suitcase.
why so? Arent' the weights roughly equivalent and a suitcase can have wheels and / or a handle, unlike a 30kg corpse. Why the need to move quickly anyway? Why wait until the alarm is raised to move the body?
It's also greatly more suspicious if you're seen moving briskly with one. You'd not be intercepted at the time but the day after it would be suspicious to witnesses.
More suspicious than being seen carrying the child who turned out to be missing??
So would a man carrying a blanket.
A child wrapped in a blanket on a chilly night would look more suspicious than an uncovered corpse??
Both are not common sights late at night.
I would venture that a man with a suitcase and / or a child wrapped in a blanket are a more common sight than a man carrying a corpse in PdL.
-
why so? Arent' the weights roughly equivalent and a suitcase can have wheels and / or a handle, unlike a 30kg corpse. Why the need to move quickly anyway? Why wait until the alarm is raised to move the body?
More suspicious than being seen carrying the child who turned out to be missing??
A child wrapped in a blanket on a chilly night would look more suspicious than an uncovered corpse??
I would venture that a man with a suitcase and / or a child wrapped in a blanket are a more common sight than a man carrying a corpse in PdL.
&%+((£ And how would anyone know it was a corpse?
They wouldn't.
-
&%+((£ And how would anyone know it was a corpse?
They wouldn't.
OK - and apart from that? They would know the next morning when they turned on their TVs that a child (looking suspiciously like the sleeping / dead version they saw in the arms of a man looking suspiciously like the bloke doing an appeal for her safe return) had disappeared.
-
OK - and apart from that? They would know the next morning when they turned on their TVs that a child (looking suspiciously like the sleeping / dead version they saw in the arms of a man looking suspiciously like the bloke doing an appeal for her safe return) had disappeared.
But in the first days the nature of the crime wasn't known. (It still isn't over seven years later I would say.) I didn't pay too much attention to the TV early in May 2007, but even so you couldn't avoid the case (I was sick of the massive coverage by the time motormouth Laurie Campbell turned up).
Most of the time they seemed to be talking about Madeleine having left the apartment herself, so I can understand witnesses not putting two and two together quickly.
-
But in the first days the nature of the crime wasn't known. (It still isn't over seven years later I would say.) I didn't pay too much attention to the TV early in May 2007, but even so you couldn't avoid the case (I was sick of the massive coverage by the time motormouth Laurie Campbell turned up).
Most of the time they seemed to be talking about Madeleine having left the apartment herself, so I can understand witnesses not putting two and two together quickly.
I can't understand it at all. The media coverage from word go was suggestive that something suspicious had gone on, not that she'd just gone off by herself. Anyone seeing a child that bore a close resemblance to her, being carried away at night in the arms of a man who bore a close resemblance to her father would have to have been pretty negligent not to have reported it straight away. Oh wait....
-
From 4th May 2007
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2007/05/04/uk-portugal-girl-idUKL0439120620070504
-
From 4th May 2007
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2007/05/04/uk-portugal-girl-idUKL0439120620070504
Yep, the papers were far quicker to declare their opinion of the nature of the incident (some did it instantaneously in fact).
But not everyone reads papers.
(Or watches ITV).
-
I can't understand it at all. The media coverage from word go was suggestive that something suspicious had gone on, not that she'd just gone off by herself. Anyone seeing a child that bore a close resemblance to her, being carried away at night in the arms of a man who bore a close resemblance to her father would have to have been pretty negligent not to have reported it straight away. Oh wait....
Not everyone phones the police immediately, or at all. There's a 0.001% chance I walked past the guys who blew up Manchester just over 12 hours later in 1996, but did I phone the police? No.
(stop giggling now. 'tis a true story).
-
Not everyone phones the police immediately, or at all. There's a 0.001% chance I walked past the guys who blew up Manchester just over 12 hours later in 1996, but did I phone the police? No.
(stop giggling now. 'tis a true story).
Was one of them carrying a bomb in his outstretched arms, walking quickly and avoiding eye contact when you greeted him?
-
If Smithman is the carrier of Madeleine, then he must have been in the apartment so could easily pick up the bag.
-
Was one of them carrying a bomb in his outstretched arms, walking quickly and avoiding eye contact when you greeted him?
Nope, but they were instantly remarkable, and out of place. A man carrying a child in a holiday resort isn't. Hence, perhaps, why their memory wasn't jogged sooner.
-
Nope, but they were instantly remarkable, and out of place. A man carrying a child in a holiday resort isn't. Hence, perhaps, why their memory wasn't jogged sooner.
What did jog them into action then, I wonder...? Wasn't it the fact of Murat being made an arguido? A bit odd that don't you think?
-
If Smithman is the carrier of Madeleine, then he must have been in the apartment so could easily pick up the bag.
But Smithman wasn't seen with a bag was he?
-
But Smithman wasn't seen with a bag was he?
You asked how he could have got hold of the bag.
The hypothesis is that it was used to carry Madeleine on the first part of her journey, not that Smithman was actually seen carrying it.
-
You asked how he could have got hold of the bag.
I did indeed. 8(0(*
-
What did jog them into action then, I wonder...? Wasn't it the fact of Murat being made an arguido? A bit odd that don't you think?
Nearly everything about this case is odd, Alfred. But you maybe answered your own question: hearing Murat's name being mentioned could have jogged their memory.
I don't think that sequence of events is any odder than other aspects of the case.
-
Nearly everything about this case is odd, Alfred. But you maybe answered your own question: hearing Murat's name being mentioned could have jogged their memory.
I don't think that sequence of events is any odder than other aspects of the case.
Why would hearing Murat's name jog their memory about the man they saw carrying the child? What would be the connection between the two events? Murat being made an arguido and 9 individuals suddenly remembering that they saw a man who definitely WASN'T Murat carrying a child through town that night?
-
From Smith's statement:
Urged, states that when he passed this individual, it must have been around 22H00. He did not know at the time that a child had disappeared. He only became aware of the disappearance of the child the next morning, from his daughter in Ireland. She had sent him a message or called him regarding what had happened. At this point he thought that MADELEINE could have been the child he saw with the individual.
So - the very next morning Smith is thinking that he saw the missing child being carried away from the apartment from whence she was taken, but it's not until images of Robert Murat begin to circulate 3 weeks later that he decides to come forward.
Someone explain that satisfactorily please!
-
Why would hearing Murat's name jog their memory about the man they saw carrying the child? What would be the connection between the two events? Murat being made an arguido and 9 individuals suddenly remembering that they saw a man who definitely WASN'T Murat carrying a child through town that night?
They may not have been paying too much attention to the media coverage, as I wasn't. Ok, I hadn't just been in PdL personally, which you'd think would make them pay more attention than me. But you maybe have to consider the hyped TV coverage (if it was the same in Ireland) was counterproductive.
Alternatively, perhaps there was little coverage in Ireland?
If there wasn't, or if they'd been avoiding the hyped media coverage like me, the shock of hearing Murat's name being mentioned would finally demand their attention.
-
From Smith's statement:
Urged, states that when he passed this individual, it must have been around 22H00. He did not know at the time that a child had disappeared. He only became aware of the disappearance of the child the next morning, from his daughter in Ireland. She had sent him a message or called him regarding what had happened. At this point he thought that MADELEINE could have been the child he saw with the individual.
So - the very next morning Smith is thinking that he saw the missing child being carried away from the apartment from whence she was taken, but it's not until images of Robert Murat begin to circulate 3 weeks later that he decides to come forward.
Someone explain that satisfactorily please!
Easily done. For whatever reason many don't want to get involved.
-
Easily done. For whatever reason many don't want to get involved.
OK, nine individuals all decided they didn't want to help in the search for a missing child. Well, OK there are a lot of strange uncaring people in the world I get that, but then why suddenly decide to get involved when Murat's name gets broadcast?
-
OK, nine individuals all decided they didn't want to help in the search for a missing child. Well, OK there are a lot of strange uncaring people in the world I get that, but then why suddenly decide to get involved when Murat's name gets broadcast?
Well they might have said something like - 'We know that guy' and then got to discussing the disappearance and how they saw this guy carrying a child through the streets.
-
Well they might have said something like - 'We know that guy' and then got to discussing the disappearance and how they saw this guy carrying a child through the streets.
So what you seem to be suggesting is - the Smiths were more interested in getting an acquaintance off the hook than in trying to help with the search for a missing kid - 'cos that's how it looks to me anyway.
-
OK, nine individuals all decided they didn't want to help in the search for a missing child. Well, OK there are a lot of strange uncaring people in the world I get that, but then why suddenly decide to get involved when Murat's name gets broadcast?
Motivation perhaps. It's a big deal to phone the police, especially when you're perhaps going to be dealing with the police of three different countries.
Again, consider the hyped media coverage was counterproductive. It's another possible reason why people wouldn't want to get involved.
-
So what you seem to be suggesting is - the Smiths were more interested in getting an acquaintance off the hook than in trying to help with the search for a missing kid - 'cos that's how it looks to me anyway.
That was not my intent. I was merely suggesting that hearing mention of a familiar name might have got them talking about the case.
-
That was not my intent. I was merely suggesting that hearing mention of a familiar name might have got them talking about the case.
How familiar as the name of Murat to the 9 members of the Smith family? This was a man that according to them "They met once in a bar about two years ago". We have Mr Smith's testimony that on the morning following Madeleine's disappearance he believed the child he passed may have been Madeleine but it's only three weeks later when Murat (a man he barely knows) is made an arguido that he decides to come forward. It's a bit bizarre, surely?!
-
I don't know . Some people are good at recalling names.
-
They may not have been paying too much attention to the media coverage, as I wasn't. Ok, I hadn't just been in PdL personally, which you'd think would make them pay more attention than me. But you maybe have to consider the hyped TV coverage (if it was the same in Ireland) was counterproductive.
Alternatively, perhaps there was little coverage in Ireland?
If there wasn't, or if they'd been avoiding the hyped media coverage like me, the shock of hearing Murat's name being mentioned would finally demand their attention.
There was a lot of interest in Ireland as there are many connections with Praia da Luz. It is a holiday destination of choice for holidaymakers many of whom may have property in the area.
Before returning home the Smith family took a bit of an interest in what was going on around them ... to the extent the grandchildren were aware and upset.
“We were looking at all the commotion on Sky News and we really felt quite helpless. We had two grandchildren with us at the time and it had a terrible effect on them – they all wanted to sleep in the same room as us.” - See more at: http://madeleinemccann.org/blog/2014/04/20/2008-january-243-273/#sthash.LuWRvhSZ.dpuf
-
How familiar as the name of Murat to the 9 members of the Smith family? This was a man that according to them "They met once in a bar about two years ago". We have Mr Smith's testimony that on the morning following Madeleine's disappearance he believed the child he passed may have been Madeleine but it's only three weeks later when Murat (a man he barely knows) is made an arguido that he decides to come forward. It's a bit bizarre, surely?!
No, it isn't really. Police appeal for witnesses years later (decades later in some cases). And if any come forward they're welcomed and not quizzed about why they didn't get in touch earlier.
Three weeks is no time at all.
-
No, it isn't really. Police appeal for witnesses years later (decades later in some cases). And if any come forward they're welcomed and not quizzed about why they didn't get in touch earlier.
Three weeks is no time at all.
Whatever. Of course you wouldn't see anything odd in their behaviour at all, whereas if it had been the McCanns failing to recall something until 3 weeks later - well, a whole different kettle of sardines, eh? 8(0(*
-
Whatever. Of course you wouldn't see anything odd in their behaviour at all, whereas if it had been the McCanns failing to recall something until 3 weeks later - well, a whole different kettle of sardines, eh? 8(0(*
Their behaviour might be odd, but so is most of the rest of the case. That's why I keep inviting you to consider the hyperactive media coverage was counterproductive. It was there within hours (before anyone ever gave an official statement in fact), and it shaped this case. It influenced witnesses. It possibly deterred some from ever coming forward.
-
Just some bits and pieces.
Murat was made an arguido on 14 May 2007.
Madeleine did not weigh 30kg. She should have been about half that.
Smithman was not hurrying. He was walking at a normal pace.
There is nothing in the Smith statements to suggest Smithman behaved oddly.
-
Just some bits and pieces.
Murat was made an arguido on 14 May 2007.
Madeleine did not weigh 30kg. She should have been about half that.
Smithman was not hurrying. He was walking at a normal pace.
There is nothing in the Smith statements to suggest Smithman behaved oddly.
I was under the impression (perhaps the wrong one) that the established weight of Madeleine McCann at the time of her disappearance was 28kg?
Re: the Smiths coming forward following the news about Murat being made an arguido - did they wait 12 days after this event before deciding to give statements about what they'd seen, or did it take the Portuguese 12 days to arrange to get statements from them? Whatever, it was at least 2 weeks after Madeleine's disappearance before they decided to come forward.
-
I was under the impression (perhaps the wrong one) that the established weight of Madeleine McCann at the time of her disappearance was 28kg?
Re: the Smiths coming forward following the news about Murat being made an arguido - did they wait 12 days after this event before deciding to give statements about what they'd seen, or did it take the Portuguese 12 days to arrange to get statements from them? Whatever, it was at least 2 weeks after Madeleine's disappearance before they decided to come forward.
"... the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) publishes charts for UK girls aged 2-18, covering both height and weight. (Google it.)
On a UK girl’s 4th birthday (and Madeleine was just days short of this when she disappeared) she should have weighed 12kg if she was very, very tiny, and 16kg if she was average. Madeleine appears to be small, so I don’t think I need to consider what she could weigh if she was heavier than average. ... "
"... If she was smaller than 3 out of 4 girls her age, she should have been a metre.
If she was average height, she should have been around 1m 02cm to 1m 03cm. ..."
The quotes are from my blog, but the underlying source is RCPCH, which anyone can check for themselves.
I don't know what the precise trigger was for the Smiths to come forward. They were all back in Ireland at the time, so arrangements had to be made to fly them back to Portugal.
As to whether their apartment was free or accommodation had to be arranged, I shall not head into speculation.
-
I was under the impression (perhaps the wrong one) that the established weight of Madeleine McCann at the time of her disappearance was 28kg?
Re: the Smiths coming forward following the news about Murat being made an arguido - did they wait 12 days after this event before deciding to give statements about what they'd seen, or did it take the Portuguese 12 days to arrange to get statements from them? Whatever, it was at least 2 weeks after Madeleine's disappearance before they decided to come forward.
Dreams seem to figure at regular intervals in Madeleine's case ... where would we be without them?
In this instance the PJ were not remiss in putting witness statements on the back burner ... particularly as no-one made any until weeks after the event.
**Snip
Initially the Smith family thought nothing more of the encounter - and even the next day when the story broke they still didn't make the connection.
"We were home two weeks when my son rang me up and asked was he dreaming or did we meet a man carrying a child the night Madeleine was taken," said Mr Smith.
"We all remembered the same recollection, and I felt we should report it to the police.
"We've all been beating ourselves up that we should have made the link sooner, if only we'd remembered the next day. But the Portuguese police said you see these things on holiday all the time."
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id162.html
-
What made the Smith family sighting so much more important than any other sighting and worthy of secretly flying family members to Portugal to make statements & engage in a reconstruction?
What information did they initially provide to the Garda that was so interesting, yet became almost an irrelevance to the PJ after 26/5/07 until such time as MS decided it may have been GM he saw?
-
What made the Smith family sighting so much more important than any other sighting and worthy of secretly flying family members to Portugal to make statements & engage in a reconstruction?
What information did they initially provide to the Garda that was so interesting, yet became almost an irrelevance to the PJ after 26/5/07 until such time as MS decided it may have been GM he saw?
Could it be that the PJ thought that having been in such close proximity to the man they said they saw that they would be able to give a good enough description for the PJ to have a chance of locating the person to rule him in or out of their inquiry?
-
What made the Smith family sighting so much more important than any other sighting and worthy of secretly flying family members to Portugal to make statements & engage in a reconstruction?
What information did they initially provide to the Garda that was so interesting, yet became almost an irrelevance to the PJ after 26/5/07 until such time as MS decided it may have been GM he saw?
bit of a totally pathetic question in the circumstances, oh yes, let's fly over auntie Sally in late 2007 who said she saw Madeleine in an airport but was late for her flight so didn't alert it at the time, the silly moo, but let's keep the smith sighting as equally untenable, what are you ON??
-
bit of a totally pathetic question
Try reading it again.
-
In any scenario, openly carrying a visible child through the streets is such a ridiculously stupid method that the JT sighting and the Smith sighting and the Marina sighting and the Alvor sighting can all be ruled out for that reason alone IMO.
So it's back to square one, completely ignore those 4 sightings, and work out how the child left the apartment. Basically there are only three possibilities - one is carrying by some method in which the child is not visible, and the other is woke and wandered.
-
Smithman was not hurrying. He was walking at a normal pace.
Just to make a point: From Aoife Smith's statement, ''The individual's gait was normal, between a fast walk and a run''
Normality is certainly subjective.
-
We did this 2 or 3 weeks ago, but here it is again.
"O caminhar ... era normal, sabendo distinguir o mesmo entre o andar apressado e o correr."
Which Google translates as
"The walk ... was normal, knowing distinguish even among the hurried walk and run."
My Portuguese is a fraction above Google's. So here is my take.
"The walk was normal, knowing to distinguish the same from the hurried walk and the run."
3 folks, Peter, Martin and Aoife, put Smithman as normal. Aoife says normal and distinguishes that from hurried or running.
Smithman was behaving like a normal person. Not like a suspect.
-
We did this 2 or 3 weeks ago, but here it is again.
"O caminhar ... era normal, sabendo distinguir o mesmo entre o andar apressado e o correr."
Which Google translates as
"The walk ... was normal, knowing distinguish even among the hurried walk and run."
My Portuguese is a fraction above Google's. So here is my take.
"The walk was normal, knowing to distinguish the same from the hurried walk and the run."
3 folks, Peter, Martin and Aoife, put Smithman as normal. Aoife says normal and distinguishes that from hurried or running.
Smithman was behaving like a normal person. Not like a suspect.
Thanks Shining. Good work. I agree with you.
Another way to phrase it:
"He was walking normally, not walking hurriedly or running".
-
Basically smithman is a normal dad carrying his sleeping daughter home.
The idea that he wasrunning or almost running is just incorrect forum translation as Shining has shown.
He was walking at normal speed.
Obviously not an english speaker, but is that really so surprising as this was not in England, it was in Portugal.
Most likely a portuguese speaker.
The reason he didn't come forward in response to public appeals is elementary -
There never has been a full public smithman appeal in the correct language and country.
I'm not counting the appeals there have been, which stupidly are in the wrong language and country.
-
Basically smithman is a normal dad carrying his sleeping daughter home.
The idea that he wasrunning or almost running is just incorrect forum translation as Shining has shown.
He was walking at normal speed.
Obviously not an english speaker, but is that really so surprising as this was not in England, it was in Portugal.
Most likely a portuguese speaker.
The reason he didn't come forward in response to public appeals is elementary -
There never has been a full public smithman appeal in the correct language and country.
I'm not counting the appeals there have been, which stupidly are in the wrong language and country.
That seems logical.
-
Basically smithman is a normal dad carrying his sleeping daughter home.
The idea that he wasrunning or almost running is just incorrect forum translation as Shining has shown.
He was walking at normal speed.
Obviously not an english speaker, but is that really so surprising as this was not in England, it was in Portugal.
Most likely a portuguese speaker.
The reason he didn't come forward in response to public appeals is elementary -
There never has been a full public smithman appeal in the correct language and country.
I'm not counting the appeals there have been, which stupidly are in the wrong language and country.
There's a lot of opinion there. He is a normal Dad? He is not an English speaker? He is most likely a Portuguese speaker?
People did phone in to Crimewatch with names so he isn't necessarily Portuguese.
-
Basically smithman is a normal dad carrying his sleeping daughter home.
The idea that he wasrunning or almost running is just incorrect forum translation as Shining has shown.
He was walking at normal speed.
Obviously not an english speaker, but is that really so surprising as this was not in England, it was in Portugal.
Most likely a portuguese speaker.
The reason he didn't come forward in response to public appeals is elementary -
There never has been a full public smithman appeal in the correct language and country.
I'm not counting the appeals there have been, which stupidly are in the wrong language and country.
So if, as SY seem to believe, Smithman is not the Tannerman is it really conceivable that there were two fathers wondering around PDL on the night of the 3rd with children almost identically clothed and with, oddly, bare feet and no covering on a cold night ?
Really ?
-
So if, as SY seem to believe, Smithman is not the Tannerman is it really conceivable that there were two fathers wondering around PDL on the night of the 3rd with children almost identically clothed and with, oddly, bare feet and no covering on a cold night ?
Really ?
Two?
I should think, literally dozens.
That seems to have been the way the Ocean Club complex worked ....
-
So if, as SY seem to believe, Smithman is not the Tannerman is it really conceivable that there were two fathers wondering around PDL on the night of the 3rd with children almost identically clothed and with, oddly, bare feet and no covering on a cold night ?
Really ?
That's possibly why the McCanns thought they might be the same person.
-
Two?
I should think, literally dozens.
That seems to have been the way the Ocean Club complex worked ....
Which night creche takes you past the wasteland to the Smith sighting? Is that a normal route from the creche?
-
That's possibly why the McCanns thought they might be the same person.
But it seems it wasn't so is it really credible there was two men of almost identical descriptions wandering around PDL with almost identical children or is there more to SY's neutralising of Tanner's sighting than meets the eye ?
-
So if, as SY seem to believe, Smithman is not the Tannerman is it really conceivable that there were two fathers wondering around PDL on the night of the 3rd with children almost identically clothed and with, oddly, bare feet and no covering on a cold night ?
Really ?
We were told a few days ago by Pathfinder that men carrying sleeping children through PdL at night was a far more common sight than men carrying suitcases, are you saying this is not the case?
-
But it seems it wasn't so is it really credible there was two men of almost identical descriptions wandering around PDL with almost identical children or is there more to SY's neutralising of Tanner's sighting than meets the eye ?
We were also told by G-Unit yesterday that in order for Tannerman to be Smithman he would have had to stop by a hairdressers between sightings, so not really identical.
-
We were also told by G-Unit yesterday that in order for Tannerman to be Smithman he would have had to stop by a hairdressers between sightings, so not really identical.
Didn't I say *almost* identical Alfie........yep I think I did !!
-
We were told a few days ago by Pathfinder that men carrying sleeping children through PdL at night was a far more common sight than men carrying suitcases, are you saying this is not the case?
SY have investigated the night creche - who left? time? carried home? age? route? etc. That's how they discovered crecheman. But they wouldn't have discovered anyone from the night creche being Smithman to make him number 1 suspect. Simple detective work Alfie.
DCI Redwood said: 'Our focus in terms of understanding what happened on the night of May 3 has now given us a shift of emphasis. We are almost certain that the man seen by Jane Tanner is not Madeleine's abductor.
'It takes us through to a position at 10pm when we see another man who is walking towards the ocean, close by to the apartment, with a young child in his arms.'
-
Madeleine's abductor is, perhaps, more likely to have been the man seen by the Smiths ....
-
There's a lot of opinion there. He is a normal Dad? He is not an English speaker? He is most likely a Portuguese speaker?
People did phone in to Crimewatch with names so he isn't necessarily Portuguese.
Good Morning G.
Yes, so when was it established that 'smithman was not 'English'? more to the point how was it established?
This man may not have been 'running' but if he is walking fast downhill, he could well be walking hurriedly, many people do that.
I agree that he should have, and probably still could, be brought to the attention of the Portugues public.
But carrying a child on a cold night without a jacket or blanket or shoes/slippers is very strange indeed.
I just wonder if Maddie had some kind of accident and was being carried to a health centre of sorts? Possibly hit by a car?
-
Madeleine's abductor is, perhaps, more likely to have been the man seen by the Smiths ....
Don't you think it's a tad coincidental that two *almost* identical fathers were both carrying their *almost* identical daughters in such an exposed manner ( no covering, socks, slippers etc ) on, what we were told, was a night cold enough for Tanner to wear a thick fleece ?
-
Don't you think it's a tad coincidental that two *almost* identical fathers were both carrying their *almost* identical daughters in such an exposed manner ( no covering, socks, slippers etc ) on, what we were told, was a night cold enough for Tanner to wear a thick fleece ?
Yeah, What are the chances? I mean IF parents are taking children to creche early evening, they must surly be aware it will be cold in the evening? taking kids to creché with no shoes , socks, cardigan? weird kinda creché.
Maybe if we found out which creché it was, and ask if this is normal for parents to bring children without shoes n socks etc?....oh and the child was not shaking from the cold?
-
There's a lot of opinion there. He is a normal Dad? He is not an English speaker? He is most likely a Portuguese speaker?
People did phone in to Crimewatch with names so he isn't necessarily Portuguese.
That he is a non-english speaker comes from: 1 this was in Portugal where the native people speak portuguese. 2 even many of the tourists visiting PDL are portuguese. 3 a press report one of the irish group greeted the man in the foreign language english and he did not reply.
-
There's a lot of opinion there. He is a normal Dad? He is not an English speaker? He is most likely a Portuguese speaker?
People did phone in to Crimewatch with names so he isn't necessarily Portuguese.
If the media got it right, one man was named twice, and one of those two calls came from Portugal.
That got me pondering who in Portugal could have come up with a suggested name.
The following is speculation, so bear in mind that my supporting 'evidence' is thin.
It was possible to view Crimewatch in Portugal. At least this matches up with a name coming from Portugal.
Since the programme was broadcast in English, it had to come from someone who was fluent or fairly capable in English. The normal language in Luz is English. The Dutch, Germans and English use, and local Portuguese folks use it.
However, local Portuguese people are geared up for Portuguese TV, not English TV.
So the person calling from Portugal is most likely to be an ex-pat, or someone working out here.
Then the person has to have an interest in the case. Most of the folks who were here at the time have an interest, even if opinion is strongly anti-McCann.
So, someone who is an English-speaker, gets English TV, has an interest in the case, and recognises the e-fit, without naming Gerry McCann.
The e-fit and the sole photo (AFAIK) of Tiago da Silva are attached. Tiago was one of the 11 witnesses interviewed in Dec 2013. He was a maintenance worker in the OC when Madeleine disappeared.
Tiago got touted in the press as having lost the entire set of keys to block 5 shortly before Madeleine disappeared. IMO, this is simply a fabrication.
The other potential reason for interviewing him was if he was named as a match to the e-fit. IF that was what happened, we need an English speaker, with access to English TV, in Portugal, interested in the Madeleine case, who knew Tiago.
The list of 11 witnesses contains at least two such people - John Hill and Donna Hill.
It gets a layer more complex, as we also need a person who was not in Portugal to come up with the same name.
Make up your own mind as to whether he is a Smithman e-fit candidate.
-
That he is a non-english speaker comes from: 1 this was in Portugal where the native people speak portuguese. 2 even many of the tourists visiting PDL are portuguese. 3 a press report one of the irish group greeted the man in the foreign language english and he did not reply.
eh? 1. foreigners also speak Portuguese in Portugal...
2. yup
3. if he was deaf or was anti social, an ignorant so and so, or was an abductor.... why would he reply?
These do not make him a Portuguese person.. lol
-
So if, as SY seem to believe, Smithman is not the Tannerman is it really conceivable that there were two fathers wondering around PDL on the night of the 3rd with children almost identically clothed and with, oddly, bare feet and no covering on a cold night ?
Really ?
The child JT saw did have a blanket on its upper body. She did not recognise it as a blanket because it was mostly obscured by child's legs and the innocent brit tourist's arms and body. Proof is the SY clothing photo of 3 items. What is that third item? Is it a sheet of A4 paper? Is it a folder? Oh it's a blanket.
The child the irish group saw had no blanket on - which indicates that this IMO innocent father was walking only a short distance - I already suggested he may have been walking from his parked car to his home.
-
The child JT saw had a blanket on its upper body. She did not recognise it as a blanket because it was mostly obscured by legs. Proof is the SY clothing photo of 3 items. What is that third item? It's not a sheet of A4 paper, it's not a folder, it's a blanket.
The child the irish group saw had no blanket on - which indicates that this IMO innocent father was walking only a short distance - I already suggested he may have been walking from his parked car to his home.
He didn't want to talk or be easily recognised.
It was the way GM turned his head down which was similar to what the individual did on 3rd May 2007 when we met him. (MS)
-
He didn't want to talk or be easily recognised.
...(snip)
A foreign woman greeted him in a foreign language he did not understand, the man probably thought she was talking to her husband.
People in Portugal speak portuguese.
His face was visible. Sure he sometimes looks downward - he is carrying a child and its dark. I recently completed a "how to not trip over in the dark" course and can tell you there is nothing suspicious about looking at the pavement/kerbs in front of you.
-
The child JT saw did have a blanket on its upper body. She did not recognise it as a blanket because it was mostly obscured by child's legs and the innocent brit tourist's arms and body. Proof is the SY clothing photo of 3 items. What is that third item? Is it a sheet of A4 paper? Is it a folder? Oh it's a blanket.
The child the irish group saw had no blanket on - which indicates that this IMO innocent father was walking only a short distance - I already suggested he may have been walking from his parked car to his home.
JT could NOT identify a blanket or anything else the child was wearing as she only saw the childs feet. The childs feet were not up on the childs upper body covering a blanket????
It was on the Oprah show that Kate n Gerry announced that JT identified Maddie being abducted, by the pyjamas she was wearing that night.(Kate held up similar pyjamas for the cameras) Same JT who could not describe to both police forces what the child was wearing as she could only see bare feet. Funny that eh?
-
Which night creche takes you past the wasteland to the Smith sighting? Is that a normal route from the creche?
It is a route FROM the OC night crèche at 24hr reception that MAY make sense due to the roadworks on Rua Direita at that time.
I don't have enough detail on this to test this, but fortunately it is not important.
There is no part of the Ocean Club in the direction Smithman was heading TO, so he would have to have been non-resident in the OC but using the OC crèche facilities.
As SY appears to have a list of the families using the crèche, his child's name would need to be not on that list.
Of course, an unlikely combo remains. He was a worker in the OC who had to take his child in with him to the crèche, did not register the child (?), carried the child home, and took that route to avoid roadworks. I think I'll run with simpler solutions before I contemplate this one.
-
Don't you think it's a tad coincidental that two *almost* identical fathers were both carrying their *almost* identical daughters in such an exposed manner ( no covering, socks, slippers etc ) on, what we were told, was a night cold enough for Tanner to wear a thick fleece ?
How many children were left in the creche that night? How many were young girls? How would you expect them to get from the creche to their holiday accomodation? How do we even know that the child in Smithman's arms had been in the creche at all? just because JT wore a thick fleece does that mean everyone was? What actually WAS the temperature that evening.? There should be records,,,
-
JT could NOT identify a blanket or anything else the child was wearing as she only saw the childs feet. The childs feet were not up on the childs upper body covering a blanket????
It was on the Oprah show that Kate n Gerry announced that JT identified Maddie being abducted, by the pyjamas she was wearing that night.(Kate held up similar pyjamas for the cameras) Same JT who could not describe to both police forces what the child was wearing as she could only see bare feet. Funny that eh?
I'm not interested in third-hand interpretations from when the parents and their PR man went to Chicago.
Look at the SY photo of innocent crecheman clothing - do you agree that is a blanket?
-
SY have investigated the night creche - who left? time? carried home? age? route? etc. That's how they discovered crecheman. But they wouldn't have discovered anyone from the night creche being Smithman to make him number 1 suspect. Simple detective work Alfie.
DCI Redwood said: 'Our focus in terms of understanding what happened on the night of May 3 has now given us a shift of emphasis. We are almost certain that the man seen by Jane Tanner is not Madeleine's abductor.
'It takes us through to a position at 10pm when we see another man who is walking towards the ocean, close by to the apartment, with a young child in his arms.'
There are 2 problems with Tannerman = Crècheman.
The first is where he is coming FROM, because he is definitely coming from the wrong direction.
The second is where he is going TO, because there is nothing in the OC that is a good fit to where he is heading. He was not seen going in the entrance to block 6, which might have made sense. That means something like block 1, or other parts that are getting ridiculously close to the OC night crèche.
I am not convinced Tannerman = Crècheman.
-
There are 2 problems with Tannerman = Crècheman.
The first is where he is coming FROM, because he is definitely coming from the wrong direction.
The second is where he is going TO, because there is nothing in the OC that is a good fit to where he is heading. He was not seen going in the entrance to block 6, which might have made sense. That means something like block 1, or other parts that are getting ridiculously close to the OC night crèche.
I am not convinced Tannerman = Crècheman.
First, you are correct that he was not walking directly away from MW creche. I suggest maybe he had walked back from creche with another parent as far as that other parent's building, then headed to his own building.
Second - are there any MW buildings in the direction JT saw him walking, beyond block 6? The answer is yes - if you want I will list them.
-
And pathfinder continues to shamelessly churn out unabashed libel against Gerry McCann.
What libel ferryman ?
-
Yeah, What are the chances? I mean IF parents are taking children to creche early evening, they must surly be aware it will be cold in the evening? taking kids to creché with no shoes , socks, cardigan? weird kinda creché.
Maybe if we found out which creché it was, and ask if this is normal for parents to bring children without shoes n socks etc?....oh and the child was not shaking from the cold?
I am aware of only one night crèche in Luz, though this does not constitute proof that there is only one.
IIRC the way it worked was you took your child there and then were expected to stay until the child fell asleep, hence no shoes. One would then, presumably, carry the clothes back on the first return journey, the one without the child. At pick-up time, this would avoid waking the child to dress it, and trying to carry child plus an assemblage of clothing.
I believe the crèche offered blankets if parents thought it was too chilly.
-
I'm not interested in third-hand interpretations from when the parents and their PR man went to Chicago.
Look at the SY photo of innocent crecheman clothing - do you agree that is a blanket?
The point I am making is Tannerman was promoted as the abductor by JT. she could not identify the child or its clothing. And as Shiney points out he is not coming from a creché, by the direction he was walking. A blanket, but no shoes, socks etc? seriously?
-
How many children were left in the creche that night? How many were young girls? How would you expect them to get from the creche to their holiday accomodation? How do we even know that the child in Smithman's arms had been in the creche at all? just because JT wore a thick fleece does that mean everyone was? What actually WAS the temperature that evening.? There should be records,,,
IIRC, Redwood said 8 families with 11 children in the crèche, with no further breakdown.
-
First, you are correct that he was not walking directly away from MW creche. I suggest maybe he had walked back from creche with another parent as far as that other parent's building, then headed to his own building.
Second - are there any MW buildings in the direction JT saw him walking, beyond block 6? The answer is yes - if you want I will list them.
There are such buildings. None of them make sense is the point. The chappie has done a large loop to get back nearly to where he started.
Jane Tanner in her rogatory said it did not make sense that he was coming from the crèche, but it did if he was heading to the crèche.
-
I'm astounded that people are so hung up on the "no shoes and socks" thing. Who risks waking their child up to put shoes and socks on it when it is only being carried outside for a short distance?
-
@ShiningInLuz From your post -"The normal language in Luz is English. The Dutch, Germans and English use, and local Portuguese folks use it."
IMO there are many people living in PDL who speak portuguese and don't speak english.
Many of the GNR officers attending did not speak english - this is easy to prove.
And for example when you go in the laundrette I think you will hear the normal language is portuguese.
-
I'm astounded that people are so hung up on the "no shoes and socks" thing. Who risks waking their child up to put shoes and socks on it when it is only being carried outside for a short distance?
Astounded really?
I clothed my sleeping children many times. nothing bad happened to them. The fact is many Crechés insist on children wearing feet covering for health and safety and hygiene reasons, makes this a very important point. Why would putting shoes or socks on a child on a cold night not be expected?
To Whoever-Thank you for deleting my post-- pathetic really. There was nothing nasty in it.
-
There are such buildings. None of the make sense is the point. The chappie has done a large loop to get back nearly to where he started.
Jane Tanner in her rogatory said it did not make sense that he was coming from the crèche, but it did if he was heading to the crèche.
I already agreed the man was not walking directly away from the MW creche.
But on your second point, which is the direction JT saw the man walking towards - there were several buildings in that direction containing MW/OC accomodation - about 7 buildings near the Milenium, and other buildings on the way to Milenium (on the south side of Rua Ramalhete).
We already have a well-documented example of another tourist walking a circuitous route to get a child to sleep, I don't see why people insist there is some rule saying all parents must walk directly from A to B.
-
Astounded really?
I clothed my sleeping children many times. nothing bad happened to them. The fact is many Crechés insist on children wearing feet covering for health and safety and hygiene reasons, makes this a very important point. Why would putting shoes or socks on a child on a cold night not be expected?
To Whoever-Thank you for deleting my post-- pathetic really. There was nothing nasty in it.
I'm not suggesting anything BAD would happen to them, just that there's not much joy to be had carrying a sleepy crying child through town, hence if I was the parent I would not bother putting shoes and socks on my kid if I was carrying him or her asleep for a short distance outdoors. The warmth of my own body would prevent the child from getting too uncomfortably cold - feet are very often uncovered at night anyway if you have a restless child that kicks the covers off like mine do - it really is no big deal.
-
I'm not suggesting anything BAD would happen to them, just that there's not much joy to be had carrying a sleepy crying child through town, hence if I was the parent I would not bother putting shoes and socks on my kid if I was carrying him or her asleep for a short distance outdoors. The warmth of my own body would prevent the child from getting too uncomfortably cold - feet are very often uncovered at night anyway if you have a restless child that kicks the covers off like mine do - it really is no big deal.
Yes , I get what you're saying Alfie. But The point I was making is there is no reason for them to have their soft shoes ,socks, sandles with socks removed at all. Due to heath and safety and hygeine?
Anyway have a good one... Im off out.
-
Yes , I get what you're saying Alfie. But The point I was making is there is no reason for them to have their soft shoes ,socks, sandles with socks removed at all. Due to heath and safety and hygeine?
Anyway have a good one... Im off out.
Personally I don't think there's anything safe or hygienic about putting a child in a bed or cot with its shoes on. But to settle this one way or another we would need to know what the common practice was in the crèche in PdL in 2007 - anyone here used it?
-
I already agreed the man was not walking directly away from the MW creche.
But on your second point, which is the direction JT saw the man walking towards - there were several buildings in that direction containing MW/OC accomodation - about 7 buildings near the Milenium, and other buildings on the way to Milenium (on the south side of Rua Ramalhete).
We already have a well-documented example of another tourist walking a circuitous route to get a child to sleep, I don't see why people insist there is some rule saying all parents must walk directly from A to B.
Wheeling a child about in a buggy is one thing. Carrying a child on a chilly night on outstretched arms as Tannerman did is another thing. Very difficult over short distances, painful over a long distance.
-
@ShiningInLuz From your post -"The normal language in Luz is English. The Dutch, Germans and English use, and local Portuguese folks use it."
IMO there are many people living in PDL who speak portuguese and don't speak english.
Many of the GNR officers attending did not speak english - this is easy to prove.
And for example when you go in the laundrette I think you will hear the normal language is portuguese.
There isn't a permanent GNR presence in Luz. The nearest GNR station is Lagos.
When I went to gaze at SY investigating the mound, the bored GNR officer who struck up a conversation with me spoke to me only in English.
When I passed the primary school (near the Smithman sighting) a young boy struck up a conversation with me, in good English with a Portuguese accent.
There are typically Portuguese facilities in Luz - Fernando's, the café on Rua Direita, the supermarket on the beach road. Obviously Portuguese people can and do speak Portuguese. However, by far the dominant language spoken in Luz is English, whether in pubs, restaurants, banks, shops etc., to the extent that it is rare to hear Portuguese spoken.
The main exception is August each year, when there is a large influx of tourists from Portugal. Then the dominant language heard when one is out and about is Portuguese.
-
I already agreed the man was not walking directly away from the MW creche.
But on your second point, which is the direction JT saw the man walking towards - there were several buildings in that direction containing MW/OC accomodation - about 7 buildings near the Milenium, and other buildings on the way to Milenium (on the south side of Rua Ramalhete).
We already have a well-documented example of another tourist walking a circuitous route to get a child to sleep, I don't see why people insist there is some rule saying all parents must walk directly from A to B.
I cannot rule out that Crècheman had taken a long, circuitous route, with a lightly-dressed child, for whatever reason. Merely that it appears to be highly unlikely.
Jeremy Wilkins. Do we have any reason to believe that his child was lightly dressed? I would have thought wrapped up warm would be a better way to get a child to sleep.
-
There isn't a permanent GNR presence in Luz. The nearest GNR station is Lagos.
When I went to gaze at SY investigating the mound, the bored GNR officer who struck up a conversation with me spoke to me only in English.
When I passed the primary school (near the Smithman sighting) a young boy struck up a conversation with me, in good English with a Portuguese accent.
There are typically Portuguese facilities in Luz - Fernando's, the café on Rua Direita, the supermarket on the beach road. Obviously Portuguese people can and do speak Portuguese. However, by far the dominant language spoken in Luz is English, whether in pubs, restaurants, banks, shops etc., to the extent that it is rare to hear Portuguese spoken.
The main exception is August each year, when there is a large influx of tourists from Portugal. Then the dominant language heard when one is out and about is Portuguese.
If english is the normal language and it is rare to hear portuguese spoken, I am surprised that the PJ chose to take all statements wherever possible in portuguese.
Let's ask some GNR officers who although they may live some killometers from PDL, are the officers who frequently get sent to PDL whenever there is a crime.
Obviously I have translated into english. The commander of the Lagos GNR station which serves PDL:
"he did not speak to her as he does not speak English well"
-
If english is the normal language and it is rare to hear portuguese spoken, I am surprised that the PJ chose to take all statements wherever possible in portuguese.
Let's ask some GNR officers who although they may live some killometers from PDL, are the officers who frequently get sent to PDL whenever there is a crime.
Obviously I have translated into english. The commander of the Lagos GNR station which serves PDL:
"he did not speak to her as he does not speak English well"
The guy didn't speak Engish well, which suggests he spoke some English.Of course speaking and understanding are two different things. I lived in Germany for five years and they understood a lot of Engish, but preferred mostly not to speak it.
-
@ShiningInLuz
If (forgive me if I'm wrong) you don't speak and understand spoken portuguese, then it is inevitable that every conversation you have had in PDL must have been in English. So if you take as a sample all the people you have conversed with, you will get the apparent result that 100% of people there speak english. Have you never encountered a person there who doesn't speak english?
The real question is - are you sure that every portuguese person living in PDL, and every portuguese person holidaying in PDL, would understand a greeting in english in the street from a stranger like "aah, is she asleep?"
-
I'm astounded that people are so hung up on the "no shoes and socks" thing. Who risks waking their child up to put shoes and socks on it when it is only being carried outside for a short distance?
Surely a child being taken to a night crèche would have socks at the very least and perhaps slippers/shoes on. Tanner certainly thought it was odd that the child she allegedly saw wasn't wearing any.
-
Surely a child being taken to a night crèche would have socks at the very least and perhaps slippers/shoes on. Tanner certainly thought it was odd that the child she allegedly saw wasn't wearing any.
Neither the child being carried by Smithman, nor the child being carried by Tannerman were being taken TO a crèche though were they? Nor is there any law in the universe that states that children going to crèches always wear socks and / or shoes.
-
I'm astounded that people are so hung up on the "no shoes and socks" thing. Who risks waking their child up to put shoes and socks on it when it is only being carried outside for a short distance?
A good post of.common sense.
The child's bare feet in smith sighting mean the child was asleep when picked up.
The child's bare feet and thin clothing in smith sighting mean that the child was being carried only a short distance.
So for example it could be a portuguese dad who has just finished work, picked up his sleeping daughter from a childsitting relative's place, and walked the short distance from there to home.
-
If english is the normal language and it is rare to hear portuguese spoken, I am surprised that the PJ chose to take all statements wherever possible in portuguese.
Let's ask some GNR officers who although they may live some killometers from PDL, are the officers who frequently get sent to PDL whenever there is a crime.
Obviously I have translated into english. The commander of the Lagos GNR station which serves PDL:
"he did not speak to her as he does not speak English well"
The statements are in Portuguese for an obvious reason. The requirement for translators is also obvious.
I don't know how frequently or infrequently GNR officers get sent to Luz. I see them very infrequently, and as an aside, I feel much safer here than I did in England re crime rate, though that of course is purely my opinion.
When do the GNR get sent here?
1. Many bars/restaurants are in mixed premises, of bar below and flats above. Noise complaints from someone trying to sleep above obliges (mandatory) the GNR to turn up to investigate. The method is a drive-past with windows open. If they can hear the noise over the car engine, the establishment gets paid a visit.
Such complaints are frequent, ditto visits. If the GNR come in wearing hats, it's official and sticky times. If they come in with hats under their arms, you ask them if they want a water, and when they say yes, you serve them a white port.
I believe Kelly's got raided for running Bingo. The law here says games of chance with prizes are not permitted. Kelly's was supposedly offering biscuits as prizes. The fines wiped out any profits from the night.
2. The GNR set up a traffic stop at the Mirage, pull cars over and check documentation. On the spot fines.
3. The GNR send multiple officers to Luz every 3rd May. I won't bore you with the minutiae.
4. The only other event I can think of that regularly gets GNR officers is the Luz Triathlon around 25 April each year, but that was not running in 2007.
5. Apart from a traffic fine, the one and only connection between our extended family and the GNR was when two GNR officers turned up on our property looking for an English woman (a previous tenant) who had a record of drink-driving, and who seemed to have inflicted yet more damage on some poor stranger's car. Both officers spoke decent English, but as they were in search of an English woman, it makes sense to send English speakers.
I fully accept that a fair proportion of GNR officers around here do not speak English or find it difficult to speak English.
-
@ShiningInLuz
If (forgive me if I'm wrong) you don't speak and understand spoken portuguese, then it is inevitable that every conversation you have had in PDL must have been in English. So if you take as a sample all the people you have conversed with, you will get the apparent result that 100% of people there speak english. Have you never encountered a person there who doesn't speak english?
The real question is - are you sure that every portuguese person living in PDL, and every portuguese person holidaying in PDL, would understand a greeting in english in the street from a stranger like "aah, is she asleep?"
This I think is a critical point.
I lived in Olhão for 3 months before moving to Luz. Olhão is the largest fishing town on the Algarve. Despite having a lively tourist trade, the town is intrinsically Portuguese, and the bulk of the tourists are Portuguese. Lots of Germans, French and English, but still the majority were Portuguese.
I do not look Portuguese, but it was normal for people everywhere in Olhão to try Portuguese first, then go for English. The ladies in the supermarket never bothered with this. The would simply yak 10 to the dozen in Portuguese and I would smile and nod my head, and I loved it.
I'm not sure I like the idea of calling Luz "Little Britain", but it is dominated by Irish and English people, with Portuguese in the minority.
I have had roughly one conversation per year in Portuguese, with a Portuguese person, who spoke little or no English. The issue is that they prefer to converse in their decent English rather than my poor heard/spoken Portuguese.
I am adding 3 more intrinsically Portuguese places to the list in Luz. NECI is a major charity here handling children with learning disadvantages. I would plump for the staff talking to the parents and children in Portuguese.
Next, the Luz social club on Rua Direita is a place where I would expect Portuguese to be the dominant language.
Third, my grandchild goes to a rather decent school just around the corner from his home. From day 1, the staff talked to him only in Portuguese, and as under 5s are learning machines, he has done better with the language than any of us. Mind you, he gets frustrated when we cannot keep up with him. Plus, as the children at the school come from many countries, he is picking up Spanish, French etc.
"Aah, is she asleep?" Whether this would be understood or not, I cannot say. It certainly sounds nothing like the Portuguese equivalent. I would question whether it happened, given that it is not mentioned in the original statements.
Who supposedly said this? Is it Mary?
-
Neither the child being carried by Smithman, nor the child being carried by Tannerman were being taken TO a crèche though were they? Nor is there any law in the universe that states that children going to crèches always wear socks and / or shoes.
What was it Tanner said about the parent carrying the child not being a very good parent because the child's feet weren't covered ? Logically it is more likely than not that any caring parent would, on a cold night, cover their child's feet going 'to' and but especially coming 'from' the night crèche. The fact that two parents allegedly didn't on that very night is odd to say the least.
-
What was it Tanner said about the parent carrying the child not being a very good parent because the child's feet weren't covered ? Logically it is more likely than not that any caring parent would, on a cold night, cover their child's feet going 'to' and but especially coming 'from' the night crèche. The fact that two parents allegedly didn't on that very night is odd to say the least.
In your and JT's opinion. How charming that the pair of you have something in common - a shared concern for the welfare of the feet of small children being taken to and from night creche.
-
What was it Tanner said about the parent carrying the child not being a very good parent because the child's feet weren't covered ? Logically it is more likely than not that any caring parent would, on a cold night, cover their child's feet going 'to' and but especially coming 'from' the night crèche. The fact that two parents allegedly didn't on that very night is odd to say the least.
To be fair, Jane said;
‘Oh a bit of a bad parent like us, you know, that kid’s obviously being taken home’ or whatever.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm
She said that because they used to carry their kids in a blanket and their feet would fall out and get cold too.
Of course the person she saw letting it's child's feet get cold hadn't left it's child alone and vomiting in their apartment like she did, so not quite such a bad parent.
-
To be fair, Jane said;
‘Oh a bit of a bad parent like us, you know, that kid’s obviously being taken home’ or whatever.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm
She said that because they used to carry their kids in a blanket and their feet would fall out and get cold too.
Of course the person she saw letting it's child's feet get cold hadn't left it's child alone and vomiting in their apartment like she did, so not quite such a bad parent.
The person JT saw could quite possibly have been a child abductor/paedophile - but, hey, still not as bad a parent/person as any of the Tapas group.
-
The person JT saw could quite possibly have been a child abductor/paedophile - but, hey, still not as bad a parent/person as any of the Tapas group.
I have no opinion on whether or not the Tapas group were bad people. Given the fact that they said they left their children alone each evening they clearly weren't the best parents.
-
To be fair, Jane said;
‘Oh a bit of a bad parent like us, you know, that kid’s obviously being taken home’ or whatever.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm
She said that because they used to carry their kids in a blanket and their feet would fall out and get cold too.
Of course the person she saw letting it's child's feet get cold hadn't left it's child alone and vomiting in their apartment like she did, so not quite such a bad parent.
From the Panorama programme shown in November 2007 :
'JANE: Well I could see.. I could tell it was a child, and I could see the feet and... feet and the bottom of the pyjamas, and I just thought that child's not got any shoes on because you could see the feet, and it was quite a cold night in Portugal in May it's not actually that warm, and I'd got a big jumper on, and I can remember thinking oh that parent is not a particularly good parent, they've not wrapped them up.'
-
In your and JT's opinion. How charming that the pair of you have something in common - a shared concern for the welfare of the feet of small children being taken to and from night creche.
Absolutely and I've also got the same Habitat dining table as the McCanns. We're almost kindred spirits !
-
Absolutely and I've also got the same Habitat dining table as the McCanns. We're almost kindred spirits !
How disturbing that you even know what sort of table the McCanns eat their dinners off at home...
-
How disturbing that you even know what sort of table the McCanns eat their dinners off at home...
If you invite the media into that most private of places, your home, it's not hard for those viewing to see what table you eat from Alfie dear.
-
Could we get back On Topic, Please.
-
If you invite the media into that most private of places, your home, it's not hard for those viewing to see what table you eat from Alfie dear.
Yes, a big mistake on their part IMO, giving people like you an opportunity to ogle and criticise, though no doubt they are deeply gratified that their dining table at least meets with your approval (presumably).
-
I ask again. Could we get back on Topic, please.
-
@ Pegasus
I haven't found anything so far to indicate that Amaral was busy searching wherever Smithman went after the sighting. His main preoccupation at the time seems to have been trying to get Martin to return to PT to make a statement that he thought Smithman might have been Gerry.
From this interview at least, he wasn't interested in the fact that other family members didn't agree with him. I can't possibly think why...
May 19, 2014
MADDIE: SEVEN YEARS ON – A CMTV SPECIAL (Second Half)
Back to the studio
(P) We return now to the conversation with Gonçalo Amaral – one of our guests in tonight’s special edition of the CMTV dedicated to Maddie’s Case.
(addressing GA) Gonçalo Amaral, please correct me if I am wrong. When you were very close to collect the testimony of this Irish person – who allegedly identified Gerry McCann – you were, suddenly, removed from the investigation.
(GA) That is correct. We already had permission from the police Directorate-General for him to travel to Portugal and we were already dealing with his travelling and other arrangements.Then, suddenly, I was relocated to Faro (another PJ jurisdiction).
Afterwards, my colleague, who took over the case (Paulo Rebelo) decides the testimony of this witness was not relevant to the investigation. He did look into it thought. Afterwards a contact was made with an Irish liaison officer in Madrid who later went over there and brought his (Smith) testimony from Britain – in other words, they found another way (second-hand) to collect his testimony.
(P): But after speaking with the Irish officer, he contradicts himself…
(GA): Who contradicts himself?
(P): This Irish gentleman.
(GA: No, there is no contradiction. When he spoke to us, he was sure the person he saw was Gerald McCann but then, when he makes his statements to the British police, he tells them he is only 85 or 90% sure. The question then becomes one of chance and percentage.
In addition, we have to bear in mind the manner in which he (Smith) identifies the man. He does not say he is sure the sighting was of a certain person because of its physiognomy. He identifies him by observing his gait and carriage, the child and other details so, in terms of strict evidence, the Smith’s sighting may not have been decisive.
Nonetheless, in terms of the investigation, it was an important element that could have helped us to understand things further; to get to the bottom of this case – (adding with irony) at least until someone else came forward to “clarify” this sighting as well!
https://zizipresscuts.wordpress.com/page/5/
-
What a fibber. 85 or 90% Certain? This is an outright lie.
-
What a fibber. 85 or 90% Certain? This is an outright lie.
Could he not just have misremembered as the McCanns and their friends, we are told by your good self amongst others, do ?
-
Could he not just have misremembered as the McCanns and their friends, we are told by your good self amongst others, do ?
So, finally - do you accept that individuals can misremember stuff? And that this can account for most if not all of the discrepancies that you hold dear to your heart as proof of McCann malevolence?
-
Could he not just have misremembered as the McCanns and their friends, we are told by your good self amongst others, do ?
Sorry. I thought he was in charge at some point. Did he not make a note of what his prime witness actually said?
-
What a fibber. 85 or 90% Certain? This is an outright lie.
Unless someone translated something badly of course. @)(++(*
-
Unless someone translated something badly of course. @)(++(*
Difficult with figures. No, he was just fibbing.
-
Difficult with figures. No, he was just fibbing.
Well, there was quite a discussion about someone bleeding for 4 5 minutes or 45 minutes as I recall. Also about whether David Payne was in G5A at 1700 or not.
-
So, at last we're all agreed - misremembering and/or mistranslations are valid explanations for discrepancies and odd statements. Consensus at last, let's remember this day!
-
Well, there was quite a discussion about someone bleeding for 4 5 minutes or 45 minutes as I recall. Also about whether David Payne was in G5A at 1700 or not.
Oh, you mean he meant eight and a half percent to nine percent. Okay. I'll go along with that.
-
List all missing people in PDL 3 May 2007 wearing long sleeves.
Next.
-
So, at last we're all agreed - misremembering and/or mistranslations are valid explanations for discrepancies and odd statements. Consensus at last, let's remember this day!
So you agree that Amaral could have misremembered parts of Martin Smith's statement ? Perhaps you'll tell that to Eleanor.
-
So you agree that Amaral could have misremembered parts of Martin Smith's statement ? Perhaps you'll tell that to Eleanor.
I'll agree to that if you'll agree to what I wrote above - do you?
-
Gonçalo Amaral: This is a contradiction that goes beyond contradiction! (the denotation and connotation of the word).
According to a certain family testimony, there was an 80% probability the man they saw was him – and this is a already a figure which has a British variable on top (a figure that has been doctored).
At first, the family was quite sure that the man who was carrying the child in his arms was this person but, once they were questioned over there – in a rather informal manner it seems then, they lost that certainty and gave the sighting an 80% probability that it was the father - and a 60% it could have been Madeleine.
What I would like to add is; we have repeatedly spoken here about (the hour of the sighting of Martins Smith being at) 22:00, but we do not know (for sure) if it was at 22:00 hours. A reconstruction would have to deal with that. There are only three moments that we know with some certainty, happen at a precise time.
One is when the child leaves the crèche or, for that matter, a family member (mother) collects her at 17:30 hrs.
The other is the Irish family payment (of their bill) at the Dolphin restaurant. They made that payment with a debit card at 21:27 hours but – you have to bear in mind that after they left the restaurant they went to a bar (…)
And the third, was a phone call made to the GNR (National Republican Guard) at 22:47 hours. Everything else is just chitchat – exactly because the precise times are not known.
For example, in the case of Jeremy (Wilkins) it is not known how long his conversation (with Gerry McCann) lasted. It is not known how long that Irish family stayed in that bar after leaving the restaurant. They say they left around 22:00, but it is not known if it was at 22:05, 22:10, 22:15 or 22:20 PM.
A while ago we spoke of Pamela Fenn – an elderly lady who lived in the apartment above (the McCanns’) – and who has since passed away. Now, this lady only hears the commotion in the apartment below at 22:30 hours. (In other words), she places the moment of the all scene – in which the mother purportedly finds her child missing, not at 22 hours (as the mother does) but at 22:30 hours! This person (Pamela Fenn) is no longer with us but her testimony is .
https://zizipresscuts.wordpress.com/page/6/
-
It is not known how long that Irish family stayed in that bar after leaving the restaurant. They say they left around 22:00, but it is not known if it was at 22:05, 22:10, 22:15 or 22:20 PM.
Simple for SY to ask the irish witnesses how many till purchases they made at Kellys and so estimate better time of sighting
-
Simple for SY to ask the irish witnesses how many till purchases they made at Kellys and so estimate better time of sighting
There was only one at 9:39 and have no doubt I will be right. 9:27 Dolphin receipt. Leave at 10 then meet Smithman the mute watchman.
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P12/12_VOLUME_XIIa_Page_3277.jpg)
-
There was only one at 9:39 and have no doubt I will be right. 9:27 Dolphin receipt. Leave at 10 then meet Smithman the mute watchman.
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P12/12_VOLUME_XIIa_Page_3277.jpg)
Uh huh ... a receipt from Kelly's bar. Wonder whose receipt it might be.
-
There was only one at 9:39 and have no doubt I will be right. 9:27 Dolphin receipt. Leave at 10 then meet Smithman the mute watchman.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P12/12_VOLUME_XIIa_Page_3277.jpg
Agreed 21:39 is definitely them. Whether the next transactions shortly after 21:39 are them too is something SY could easily find out.
-
Agreed 21:39 is definitely them. Whether the next transactions shortly after 21:39 are them too is something SY could easily find out.
How do you know it is definitely them?
-
How do you know it is definitely them?
21:39 is very probably them because they paid bill at Dolphin nearby at 21:27
-
The 21.39 bill is the only one near to 10 pm large enough to be them, none before or after IMO too it was that group
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
P. 3277-3280
-
The 21.39 bill is the only one near to 10 pm large enough to be them, none before or after IMO too it was that group
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
P. 3277-3280
IMO it was pay when you get drinks, not a tab.
In addition to 21.39, isn't it possible for 21.46 21.49 or 21.50 might be them too?
-
IMO it was pay when you get drinks, not a tab.
In addition to 21.39, isn't it possible for 21.46 21.49 or 21.50 might be them too?
Everything is possible ... but it has not been established that anything on the till roll can definitely be associated with the Smith family. Neither has it been established that anyone saw the Smith family in that location at the relevant time.
According to the sales it looks as if the staff weren't knee deep in customers demanding attention ... but no-one remembers seeing a large family group consisting of adults and young children.
-
“After returning from the beach we did the Irish version of Crimewatch -'Crimecall'. There are a lot of Irish tourists in and around Praia da Luz and although the awareness of Madeleine's disappearance in Ireland is extremely high, we want to ensure that everyone is aware of the appeal and we want the Irish public to come forward with photographs of people who they do not know who were in and around Praia da Luz in the 2 weeks leading up to the 3rd May. The address to upload photographs is: to www.madeleine.ceopupload.com. We have also asked for people to contact their local police if they have seen a man matching the description of the suspect carrying a child seen around the time of Madeleine’s abduction. He is 30-40 years, 1.70-1.80m (5’7”-11”), caucasian and was wearing a dark jacket, beige or mustard coloured trousers with dark shoes. No major news on the investigation front- we still believe it is just a single phone call away.
GM ‘blog’ 9 June
Yes Gerry the Smith family of nine are Irish. Were you looking for them @)(++(*
-
“After returning from the beach we did the Irish version of Crimewatch -'Crimecall'. There are a lot of Irish tourists in and around Praia da Luz and although the awareness of Madeleine's disappearance in Ireland is extremely high, we want to ensure that everyone is aware of the appeal and we want the Irish public to come forward with photographs of people who they do not know who were in and around Praia da Luz in the 2 weeks leading up to the 3rd May. The address to upload photographs is: to www.madeleine.ceopupload.com. We have also asked for people to contact their local police if they have seen a man matching the description of the suspect carrying a child seen around the time of Madeleine’s abduction. He is 30-40 years, 1.70-1.80m (5’7”-11”), caucasian and was wearing a dark jacket, beige or mustard coloured trousers with dark shoes. No major news on the investigation front- we still believe it is just a single phone call away.
GM ‘blog’ 9 June
Yes Gerry the Smith family of nine are Irish. Were you looking for them @)(++(*
So just to clarify - Gerry put out an appeal on his blog for people to come forward to identify the person that you believe was Gerry himself? Now, perhaps you could tell us why he would do that?
-
So just to clarify - Gerry put out an appeal on his blog for people to come forward to identify the person that you believe was Gerry himself? Now, perhaps you could tell us why he would do that?
I would never say such dreadful things on a public forum about Gerry so I better wait for the right time @)(++(*
-
I would never say such dreadful things on a public forum about Gerry being a spitting image of the efit with no alibi so I better wait for the right time @)(++(*
We know exactly what you're thinking but it's a shame you're unable to see the complete illogicality of someone appealing for people to come forward to ID himself in the disposal of his own daughter's body.
-
We know exactly what you're thinking but it's a shame you're unable to see the complete illogicality of someone appealing for people to come forward to ID himself in the disposal of his own daughter's body.
What was Brian Kennedy doing then?
-
We know exactly what you're thinking but it's a shame you're unable to see the complete illogicality of someone appealing for people to come forward to ID himself in the disposal of his own daughter's body.
who is we?? do you speak for all of us now??
-
who is we?? do you speak for all of us now??
don't Tasmanians understand the English language...streuth
-
don't Tasmanians understand the English language...streuth
It is a notable characteristic of some mccann supporters using the royal 'we'.
I have heard it is a treatable condition. 8(>((
-
And the Royal We is going to start deleting in a minute.
-
What was Brian Kennedy doing then?
I don't care what Brian Kennedy was doing, what was Gerry doing asking people to ID himself perpetrating the crime of the century? Is he mad?
-
who is we?? do you speak for all of us now??
Yes I do, unless you believe I'm the only person on this forum who knows what Pathfinder is getting at.
-
And the Royal We is going to start deleting in a minute.
Has we been bad ? @)(++(*
-
Has we been bad ? @)(++(*
Not quite, yet. But you know what We means.
-
Not quite, yet. But you know what We means.
Oh yes.
-
So back to Smithman then. Now where were we?
-
I don't care what Brian Kennedy was doing, what was Gerry doing asking people to ID himself perpetrating the crime of the century? Is he mad?
Know your enemy because knowledge is power and that's how you control things. It's not just Gerry, there's CR and all the others working for them. You either attack or cower and hide. Attack is the best form of defence because people don't expect it if you are guilty. If you hide they attack so you take the initiative and turn the tables.
Several weeks later, Jeremy Wilkins received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organisation employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objections to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
-
Know your enemy because knowledge is power and that's how you control things. It's not just Gerry, there's CR and all the others working for them. You either attack or cower and hide. Attack is the best form of defence because people don't expect it if you are guilty. If you hide they attack so you take the initiative and turn the tables.
Several weeks later, Jeremy Wilkins received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organisation employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objections to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
So, say as a result of Gerry's appeal for info re: the Smith sighting I come forward with information that helps to establish it was Gerry wot dunnit,how does that help Gerry exactly? Do you think he's then going to hire an assassin to have me bumped off or what?
-
So back to Smithman then. Now where were we?
In the same kin kindergarten as usual as it's the weekend?
-
So just to clarify - Gerry put out an appeal on his blog for people to come forward to identify the person that you believe was Gerry himself? Now, perhaps you could tell us why he would do that?
He was referring to Tannerman.
-
He was referring to Tannerman.
He was here. Was Tannerman seen anywhere else?
For instance was this man seen anywhere else in or near the town with a child, or what appeared to be a child? Which direction was he heading in? Did he have a vehicle? (GM 26 May 2007)
-
He was referring to Tannerman.
How does the description of the man on Gerry's blog differ substantially from the description given by the Smiths? If you are right and Gerry is Smithman and Smithman resembles the description given on Gerry's blog then perhaps you can explain why Gerry was appealing for people to come forward to say where he had been spotted that evening?
-
How does the description of the man on Gerry's blog differ substantially from the description given by the Smiths? If you are right and Gerry is Smithman and Smithman resembles the description given on Gerry's blog then perhaps you can explain why Gerry was appealing for people to come forward to say where he had been spotted that evening?
The description was already in the public domain therefore how could he avoid promoting it without it seeming suspicious ?
You are obviously far less wily than Gerry.
-
The description was already in the public domain therefore how could he avoid promoting it without it seeming suspicious ?
You are obviously far less wily than Gerry.
Of course he could, don't be absurd. In any case let's not forget who first put the description out there - JT who you believe was doing Gerry's bidding in the first place! %&5%£
-
Of course he could, don't be absurd. In any case let's not forget who first put the description out there - JT who you believe was doing Gerry's bidding in the first place! %&5%£
He couldn't be Smithman if he was claiming it was Tannerman. Remember Jane saw him talking to Jes at the time. Wake up Alfie.
-
Both Tannerman and Smithman could be red herrings. Just because there were two sightings of men carrying a child that night, at around the relevant time, doesn't mean that they are the only possibilities.
Whoever took her out of that apartment (assuming that she didn't do so on her own) could have done so moving west. Or could have temporarily moved her into a different apartment in the block or to another building close by.
-
Both Tannerman and Smithman could be red herrings. Just because there were two sightings of men carrying a child that night, at around the relevant time, doesn't mean that they are the only possibilities.
Whoever took her out of that apartment (assuming that she didn't do so on her own) could have done so moving west. Or could have temporarily moved her into a different apartment in the block or to another building close by.
My money is on Tannerman because of when he was seen ... dictating against that is that he was seen suggesting that something went disastrously wrong for him to have been openly carrying a kidnapped child.
Misty had a theory at one time that who would look twice at a laundry hamper being moved into a laundry van ... a normal occurrence which no-one would have noticed and if they did wouldn't think it at all suspicious.
-
My money is on Tannerman because of when he was seen ... dictating against that is that he was seen suggesting that something went disastrously wrong for him to have been openly carrying a kidnapped child.
Misty had a theory at one time that who would look twice at a laundry hamper being moved into a laundry van ... a normal occurrence which no-one would have noticed and if they did wouldn't think it at all suspicious.
Like the laundry hamper idea, but much more common, no-one would think twice about a tourist carrying a large luggage bag. But both these ideas fail in the middle of the night. You would need to carry your laundry hamper or luggage bag in the daytime, at a time when it seemed so completely normal that you could walk straight past people and they would have no idea.
-
My money is on Tannerman because of when he was seen ... dictating against that is that he was seen suggesting that something went disastrously wrong for him to have been openly carrying a kidnapped child.
Misty had a theory at one time that who would look twice at a laundry hamper being moved into a laundry van ... a normal occurrence which no-one would have noticed and if they did wouldn't think it at all suspicious.
The GNR (?) asked if people had noticed anything suspicious related to the disappearance of a child. If so, they were apparently invited to give a statement to the PJ, if not, they moved on. Some also checked in some dwelling for "any sign of the minor".
The GNR did the best they could, but they simply weren't trained for this sort of situation.
What, as a PT local, an expat, or a tourist would have appeared suspicious in this little tourist resort?
A thorough interview by trained officers might have led somewhere in the early days. Not the GNR's fault.
-
Like the laundry hamper idea, but much more common, no-one would think twice about a tourist carrying a large luggage bag. But both these ideas fail in the middle of the night. You would need to carry your laundry hamper or luggage bag in the daytime, at a time when it seemed so completely normal that you could walk straight past people and they would have no idea.
I find it quite feasible that she could have been quickly hidden (either alive or not) nearby and transported elsewhere during the day or a bit later.
-
My money is on Tannerman because of when he was seen ... dictating against that is that he was seen suggesting that something went disastrously wrong for him to have been openly carrying a kidnapped child.
Misty had a theory at one time that who would look twice at a laundry hamper being moved into a laundry van ... a normal occurrence which no-one would have noticed and if they did wouldn't think it at all suspicious.
Even though those bastions of right thinking i.e. SY have smoked him?
-
I find it quite feasible that she could have been quickly hidden (either alive or not) nearby and transported elsewhere during the day or a bit later.
What do you mean by during the day or a bit later?
-
What do you mean by during the day or a bit later?
That someone could have hisdden her during the night and moved her further away during daylgiht on 4 May or later.
Media eyes were on the T9. Who would have noticed anyone else carrying a bin sack anywhere?
-
He couldn't be Smithman if he was claiming it was Tannerman. Remember Jane saw him talking to Jes at the time. Wake up Alfie.
you've lost me. The convolutions are so knotted it's hard to keep track. Let me see if I can unpick it.
Gerry put out an appeal for Tannerman. Tannerman was dressed the same as Smithman so Gerry's description did for both of them. In effect you believe he was describing himself. JT did not actually see anyone apart from Gerry and Jez but Gerry says she was never there thus cancelling out his own alibi. Have I got that right?
-
you've lost me. The convolutions are so knotted it's hard to keep track. Let me see if I can unpick it.
Gerry put out an appeal for Tannerman. Tannerman was dressed the same as Smithman so Gerry's description did for both of them. In effect you believe he was describing himself. JT did not actually see anyone apart from Gerry and Jez but Gerry says she was never there thus cancelling out his own alibi. Have I got that right?
There had to be a certain congruity between the two men to force a link.
As I said not nearly as wily as Gezza !
-
Like the laundry hamper idea, but much more common, no-one would think twice about a tourist carrying a large luggage bag. But both these ideas fail in the middle of the night. You would need to carry your laundry hamper or luggage bag in the daytime, at a time when it seemed so completely normal that you could walk straight past people and they would have no idea.
I think you and Misty share a crime writer's devious mind set ... if I remember correctly she refined this to include a very short term stay in another apartment ... with laundry basket and van going about normal duty and time scale.
(Just thought ... and hasten to add this is purely a hypothetical statement which does not imply or suggest that any particular individual is identified as being this person).
-
There had to be a certain congruity between the two men to force a link.
As I said not nearly as wily as Gezza !
So then Gerry was in effect appealing for people to come forward to ID himself - how wily is that?!
What a bloody fool the man clearly is after all. *&*%£
-
Even though those bastions of right thinking i.e. SY have smoked him?
They are the professionals and if they say they have "smoked him" then smoked he is.
I am the amateur and like all of us amateurs ... have a certain liberty to speculate.
I think there may be an element of that in all of us ... just as there are those who will not give up on their preconceived ideas and prejudices, I prefer my preconceived prejudice on Tannerman and Smithman to the SY version.
-
They are the professionals and if they say they have "smoked him" then smoked he is.
I am the amateur and like all of us amateurs ... have a certain liberty to speculate.
I think there may be an element of that in all of us ... just as there are those who will not give up on their preconceived ideas and prejudices, I prefer my preconceived prejudice on Tannerman and Smithman to the SY version.
So ok for others to discount SY's abduction focus then.
-
So then Gerry was in effect appealing for people to come forward to ID himself - how wily is that?!
What a bloody fool the man clearly is after all. *&*%£
But he was talking to Jez so it couldn't have been him, could it ?
Tanner sees Gezza talking to Jez but more importantly the abductor. Approximately 45 minutes later the same man ( hence almost the same description, clever huh ! ) is seen by the Smiths carrying a child. Therefore Gezza can't be the man seen by, allegedly, Tanner and the Smiths. And that is why Gezza felt secure publicising Smithman's description ! Brilliantly devious huh ?
-
But he was talking to Jez so it couldn't have been him, could it ?
Tanner sees Gezza talking to Jez but more importantly the abductor. Approximately 45 minutes later the same man ( hence almost the same description, clever huh ! ) is seen by the Smiths carrying a child. Therefore Gezza can't be the man seen by, allegedly, Tanner and the Smiths. And that is why Gezza felt secure publicising Smithman's description ! Brilliantly devious huh ?
Brilliant - except that one of the people who came forward claimed they were 60-80% sure the person they saw was Gerry -d'oh!!!
-
They are the professionals and if they say they have "smoked him" then smoked he is.
I am the amateur and like all of us amateurs ... have a certain liberty to speculate.
I think there may be an element of that in all of us ... just as there are those who will not give up on their preconceived ideas and prejudices, I prefer my preconceived prejudice on Tannerman and Smithman to the SY version.
As do the Mccanns for some reason...they still have Tannerman primely placed on their website alongside the Australian woman (whoby the way was tracked down and eliminated) but Smthman references and efits are hard to find...and on their Portuguese site, nowhere to be found...how curious, do you have an explanation for this? dOnt you find that a sighting on the night at the right sort of time is a stone that should be turned but seemingly they can't be bothered??
oH BTW if you prefer your preconceived prejudices to SY then do you really have any right to applaud them each time they sneeze? on any other matter? Whilst denigrating the PJ, hypocrisy perchance? Or confusion
-
Brilliant - except that one of the people who came forward claimed they were 60-80% sure the person they saw was Gerry -d'oh!!!
Different time, different location, so who knows ?
-
Different time, different location, so who knows ?
I think you're missing the point but never mind.
-
Brilliant - except that one of the people who came forward claimed they were 60-80% sure the person they saw was Gerry -d'oh!!!
Unfortunate but hey Gezza had made sure it couldn't be proved to be him so no harm done huh !
-
So ok for others to discount SY's abduction focus then.
If you say so ... absolutely nothing to do with me.
As I said ... "They are the professionals and if they say they have "smoked him" then smoked he is."
-
As do the Mccanns for some reason...they still have Tannerman primely placed on their website alongside the Australian woman (whoby the way was tracked down and eliminated) but Smthman references and efits are hard to find...and on their Portuguese site, nowhere to be found...how curious, do you have an explanation for this? dOnt you find that a sighting on the night at the right sort of time is a stone that should be turned but seemingly they can't be bothered??
oH BTW if you prefer your preconceived prejudices to SY then do you really have any right to applaud them each time they sneeze? on any other matter? Whilst denigrating the PJ, hypocrisy perchance? Or confusion
Perhaps it would be appropriate to consider answering a post by saying, "Know what ... I totally disagree with what you are saying because ..." rather than embark on a personal attack ... it might be of more interest.
-
Perhaps it would be appropriate to consider answering a post by saying, "Know what ... I totally disagree with what you are saying because ..." rather than embark on a personal attack ... it might be of more interest.
I did not attack you, I asked some questions, if youare referring to "preconceived prejudices"I was only repeating your own words off from your own stance,if yu are referring to "hypocrisy" it was an inference with a question mark, and a bit rich if so, to make a big deal when so many of your posts denigrate other posters, now, would you mind responding to the substance my post? Or not?
-
I think you're missing the point but never mind.
I think you are because whoever Smithman was he knew he was seen by an Irish group if he heard them. Making out Tannerman is the same person could rule you out and this was months before his name was said. They've been trying to connect those two sightings as being the same person from the start.
-
I did not attack you, I asked some questions, if youare referring to "preconceived prejudices"I was only repeating your own words off from your own stance, now, would you mind responding to the substance my post? Or not?
Perhaps you would care to have another look at your post and consider how you have phrased your ... questions ... and consider the tone you habitually use when responding to my posts.
I find it unnecessarily aggressive ... perhaps you are unaware of this ... but now I have pointed it out to you, it would be appreciated if you would address it.
-
Perhaps you would care to have another look at your post and consider how you have phrased your ... questions ... and consider the tone you habitually use when responding to my posts.
I find it unnecessarily aggressive ... perhaps you are unaware of this ... but now I have pointed it out to you, it would be appreciated if you would address it.
nO more than your surreptiously aggressive accusatory denigrating posts, now, you wouldn't be avoiding the issue of my questions would you? If my tone is responsible then I am so terribly sorry and I promise to be good and kind n gracious in future...how about any answers now? Or will it be another NO/denial
&%+((£
-
Unfortunate but hey Gezza had made sure it couldn't be proved to be him so no harm done huh !
How did he manage that then? Who was his alibi for the time of the Smith sighting?
-
How did he manage that then? Who was his alibi for the time of the Smith sighting?
Keep up Alfie old chap.
Connect Smithman and Tannerman and if Tanner saw Tannerman at the same time as seeing Gezza there's his alibi.
-
Keep up Alfie old chap.
Connect Smithman and Tannerman and if Tanner saw Tannerman at the same time as seeing Gezza there's his alibi.
No, that was 40 minutes earlier, do keep up yourself.
-
Here is the legal definition of the word alibi for those who don't understand what the word actually means:
1.
Law. the defense by an accused person of having been elsewhere at the time an alleged offense was committed.
Where was Gerry at the time of the Smithman sighting? Where is his alibi, folks? The police were satisfied that he was at the Tapas bar at the time, but you guys know better, right?
-
Another insult to add to the first insult. How many more from you this evening?
I'll accept that you can't argue against my previous posts and therefore have to turn this into something else. Fair play I'd probably do the same rather than argue against something there is no argument against.
So shall we start again ? The McCanns have said that they think Smithman and Tannerman are the same man. Tanner saw Gezza at the same time as she saw Tannerman so Smithman, being the same man as Tannerman, could be Gezza. Simple enough our will you need the crayon version ?
-
I'll accept that you can't argue against my previous posts and therefore have to turn this into something else. Fair play I'd probably do the same rather than argue against something there is no argument against.
So shall we start again ? The McCanns have said that they think Smithman and Tannerman are the same man. Tanner saw Gezza at the same time as she saw Tannerman so Smithman, being the same man as Tannerman, could be Gezza. Simple enough our will you need the crayon version ?
I don't get thisFaith, if Tanner saw a Mr X, the fact that Gerry being seen by Tanner at the same time talking to Jez and not being Mr X is sufficient to say Smithman being identical to Mr x was not Gerry (that's if Mr X was the same man as Smithman)
*&*%£
confusing, sorry if I intruded into a convo and missed some point
-
I don't get thisFaith, if Tanner saw a Mr X, the fact that Gerry being seen by Tanner at the same time talking to Jez and not being Mr X is sufficient to say Smithman being identical to Mr x was not Gerry (that's if Mr X was the same man as Smithman)
*&*%£
confusing, sorry if I intruded into a convo and missed some point
Not a problem Mercury.
The McCanns pushed the idea from the beginning that Smithman was almost identical to Tannerman and therefore they were one and the same. Of course Gerry was aware that there was every possibility the one or more of the Smiths may identify him so what better way to alibi himself than to be seen at the same time as Tannerman ( and Smithman if we are to believe the McCanns ).
It wasn't an ideal plan but when you're desperate !
-
I'll accept that you can't argue against my previous posts and therefore have to turn this into something else. Fair play I'd probably do the same rather than argue against something there is no argument against.
So shall we start again ? The McCanns have said that they think Smithman and Tannerman are the same man. Tanner saw Gezza at the same time as she saw Tannerman so Smithman, being the same man as Tannerman, could be Gezza. Simple enough our will you need the crayon version ?
I honestly don't think you really understand what an alibi is, and why the cockamamie convoluted plot you've imagined above would ever pass muster as a decent alibi as far as the police are concerned. In fact it appears it was such an embarrssing attempt at concocting an alibi that even Gerry turned his back on it, quite literally!! @)(++(*
Smithman was (according to you) in the process of hiding a body. What is Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting? Does he have one or not? JT's sighting is not it.
-
Not a problem Mercury.
The McCanns pushed the idea from the beginning that Smithman was almost identical to Tannerman and therefore they were one and the same. Of course Gerry was aware that there was every possibility the one or more of the Smiths may identify him so what better way to alibi himself than to be seen at the same time as Tannerman ( and Smithman if we are to believe the McCanns ).
It wasn't an ideal plan but when you're desperate !
so Tanner lied?
-
so Tanner lied?
Excellent question.... 8((()*/
-
And there we have our third insult of the evening. Crayons, shoelaces, you'll be telling me to go sit on the potty next.
I honestly don't think you really understand what an alibi is, and why the cockamamie convoluted plot you've imagined above would ever pass muster as a decent alibi as far as the police are concerned. In fact it appears it was such an embarrssing attempt at concocting an alibi that even Gerry turned his back on it, quite literally!! @)(++(*
Smithman was (according to you) in the process of hiding a body. What is Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting? Does he have one or not? JT's sighting is not it.
If you link Tannerman and Smithman ( as the McCanns did ) Tanner becomes his alibi. Of course it wasn't perfect, Jez not seeing Tanner was totally unbelievable but hey needs must and all that.
-
so Tanner lied?
No Mercury she 'misremembered' 8(0(*
-
No Mercury she 'misremembered' 8(0(*
How does Redwood's revelation moment work in your theory?
-
How does Redwood's revelation moment work in your theory?
It doesn't.
-
No Mercury she 'misremembered' 8(0(*
Ah, I think I get it now, though she must be a dumb bitch to even go there, specially seeing as how the Mccanns screwed her over in the documentary , oh well
-
If you link Tannerman and Smithman ( as the McCanns did ) Tanner becomes his alibi. Of course it wasn't perfect, Jez not seeing Tanner was totally unbelievable but hey needs must and all that.
It's up to the police to do the linking, not the McCanns. The plot you believe they concocted is so full of holes as to be utterly preposterous.
An alibi is about establishing the defendant being elsewhere WHEN THE CRIME WAS BEING COMMITTED, not where he was 40 minutes earlier. When the alleged crime of hiding a child's body was being witnessed what was Gerry's alibi?
-
No Mercury she 'misremembered' 8(0(*
Is that another word for lied?
-
Ah, I think I get it now, though she must be a dumb bitch to even go there, specially seeing as how the Mccanns screwed her over in the documentary , oh well
Do you believe JT is a dumb bitch then? Does Faithlilly's theory sit well with you? Does it all make perfect, logical sense?
-
It doesn't.
So you think JT invented a sighting of someone wearing near-identical clothing to Smithman, then 6 years down the line the sighting turned out to be real, clothes and all? Or don't you believe Crecheman's story either?
-
It's up to the police to do the linking, not the McCanns. The plot you believe they concocted is so full of holes as to be utterly preposterous.
An alibi is about establishing the defendant being elsewhere WHEN THE CRIME WAS BEING COMMITTED, not where he was 40 minutes earlier. When the alleged crime of hiding a child's body was being witnessed what was Gerry's alibi?
I'm not sure Alfie but did the police ever link Smithman and Tannerman or was that just the McCanns ?
-
So you think JT invented a sighting of someone wearing near-identical clothing to Smithman, then 6 years down the line the sighting turned out to be real, clothes and all? Or don't you believe Crecheman's story either?
No I don't think Tanner invented anything misty and no I don't believe Chrechman was there.
-
I'm not sure Alfie but did the police ever link Smithman and Tannerman or was that just the McCanns ?
Who cares what the McCanns linked, I am looking at this from the perspective of the investigation. It is not up to the McCanns to decide what the alibi is, it's up to the police. So, for the 3rd or 4th. time of asking what was Gerry"s alibi for the time of the Smith signting?
-
No I don't think Tanner invented anything misty and no I don't believe Chrechman was there.
those two sentences contradict each other. Please explain further.
-
I'm not sure Alfie but did the police ever link Smithman and Tannerman or was that just the McCanns ?
Andy Redwood (DCI Ret'd) fragged Tannerman then said Smithman was a person of interest that makes he thinks they were two different people I think!
-
Andy Redwood (DCI Ret'd) fragged Tannerman then said Smithman was a person of interest that makes he thinks they were two different people I think!
Go to the top of the class Alice and crayons all round 8(0(*
Not only did SY not link Tannerman and Smithman but neither did the PJ, or as far as we know, any official boy. Nope it seems it was only the McCanns. Kinda gets you wondering why huh ?
-
Go to the top of the class Alice and crayons all round 8(0(*
Not only did SY not link Tannerman and Smithman but neither did the PJ, or as far as we know, any official boy. Nope it seems it was only the McCanns. Kinda gets you wondering why huh ?
I'm wondering if you're ever going to answer my question about Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smiths sighting, and doing so without resorting to childish insults.
-
I'm wondering if you're ever going to answer my question about Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smiths sighting, and doing so without resorting to childish insults.
I answered it many moons ago Alfie and to quote Kate 'she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned'
-
I answered it many moons ago Alfie and to quote Kate 'she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned'
Could you kindly direct me to the post then?
-
Could you kindly direct me to the post then?
I direct you to my last answer.
-
I direct you to my last answer.
&%+((£ neither your last post nor indeed any of your posts answers my question which is: what was Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting, but never mind - I realise it's a question you are for some reason unwilling to answer so I shan't ask again.
-
&%+((£ neither your last post nor indeed any of your posts answers my question which is: what was Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting, but never mind - I realise it's a question you are for some reason unwilling to answer so I shan't ask again.
I understand. I wouldn't want to make myself appear foolish either.
-
I understand. I wouldn't want to make myself appear foolish either.
Agreed - it was foolish of me to think I could ask you a direct question and expect a non-evasive answer - you'd have thought after months of debating with you that I would have learned by now! Silly me.
-
&%+((£ neither your last post nor indeed any of your posts answers my question which is: what was Gerry's alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting, but never mind - I realise it's a question you are for some reason unwilling to answer so I shan't ask again.
Faith doesn't understand what an independent witness is, Alfred ...
-
Agreed - it was foolish of me to think I could ask you a direct question and expect a non-evasive answer - you'd have thought after months of debating with you that I would have learned by now! Silly me.
The 'foolish' kicked in when you pretended you didn't understand my answer and simply asked the same question again and again.
-
Faith doesn't understand what an independent witness is, Alfred ...
Faith does ferryman. Accepted I didn't learn it through a FOI request but understand it nonetheless. If I also didn't understand that your post was in order to cover your own misunderstanding I may even believe you are harassing me 8(0(*
-
Faith does ferryman. Accepted I didn't learn it through a FOI request but understand it nonetheless. If I also didn't understand that your post was in order to cover your own misunderstanding I may even believe you are harassing me 8(0(*
Have you yet found where anyone commented on Gerry's absence from the table?
Or where there is a record in the files of efforts to find Gerry to tell him what had happened, including where he was when found and who found him?
-
Have you yet found where anyone commented on Gerry's absence from the table?
Or where there is a record in the files of efforts to find Gerry to tell him what had happened, including where he was when found and who found him?
Gerry was in the tapas bar at the time of the alarm ( around 10.13 according to the man himself ) just not before at the time of the Smith sighting so why would anyone comment on his *absence*.
-
Gerry was in the tapas bar at the time of the alarm ( around 10.13 according to the man himself ) just not before at the time of the Smith sighting so why would anyone comment on his *absence*.
So you've shifted your ground from the days when you protested that no "independent" witnesses saw Gerry at the table at the point of Kate's alert?
Progress (of sorts!)
-
The 'foolish' kicked in when you pretended you didn't understand my answer and simply asked the same question again and again.
I'm sorry faith, but I fully understood what you were trying to get at - the problem is - your logic is warped, not only that but you failed time and again to answer the question of what Gerry's alibi was AT THE TIME of the Smith sighting, not 40 minutes earlier. I can't really make it any plainer than that.
-
Gerry was in the tapas bar at the time of the alarm ( around 10.13 according to the man himself ) just not before at the time of the Smith sighting so why would anyone comment on his *absence*.
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
Whilst this was happening, her colleague tried to find out and confirmed that a child by the name of Madeleine McCann had disappeared and that they were about to begin the "missing child procedure".
After this, the "missing child procedure" was initiated, which consists of an organised search, spread over different areas of the complex. The witness immediately helped in the searches, whilst her colleague Charlotte remained at the crêche, looking after the other children that were there and waiting for the arrival of the last parents, after which she also began searching.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
-
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
Whilst this was happening, her colleague tried to find out and confirmed that a child by the name of Madeleine McCann had disappeared and that they were about to begin the "missing child procedure".
After this, the "missing child procedure" was initiated, which consists of an organised search, spread over different areas of the complex. The witness immediately helped in the searches, whilst her colleague Charlotte remained at the crêche, looking after the other children that were there and waiting for the arrival of the last parents, after which she also began searching.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
Oh dear, don't you start - Faithlilly will start to feel as if she's being ganged up on.
-
Oh dear, don't you start - Faithlilly will start to feel as if she's being ganged up on.
What do you mean? Gerry was at the table until 10:13 when Kate returned from her check whilst everyone else was out searching. That's what his timeline claims. Matt said Kate left at 9:50 not 10:03. A big discrepancy of 13 minutes.
-
What do you mean? Gerry was at the table until 10:13 when Kate returned from her check whilst everyone else was out searching. That's what his timeline claims. Matt said Kate left at 9:50 not 10:03. A big discrepancy of 13 minutes.
Why did you post a quote putting the time of the alert at pre-10.05pm when Faithlilly is convinced the alarm was not raised until nearly quarter past then?
-
8@??)(
So you've shifted your ground from the days when you protested that no "independent" witnesses saw Gerry at the table at the point of Kate's alert?
Progress (of sorts!)
No I haven't but if you can give me the name of one I'm all ears.
-
I'm sorry faith, but I fully understood what you were trying to get at - the problem is - your logic is warped, not only that but you failed time and again to answer the question of what Gerry's alibi was AT THE TIME of the Smith sighting, not 40 minutes earlier. I can't really make it any plainer than that.
Then end of conversation Alfie.
-
Then end of conversation Alfie.
Indeed it is. Never mind, you know you're right and that's the main thing. ?{)(**
-
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
Whilst this was happening, her colleague tried to find out and confirmed that a child by the name of Madeleine McCann had disappeared and that they were about to begin the "missing child procedure".
After this, the "missing child procedure" was initiated, which consists of an organised search, spread over different areas of the complex. The witness immediately helped in the searches, whilst her colleague Charlotte remained at the crêche, looking after the other children that were there and waiting for the arrival of the last parents, after which she also began searching.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
Is there something that nails down where Amy Tierney was?
I have seen that she was working at a desk in the Tapas area.
This puts her several hundred metres away in OC main reception.
Where was she?
-
The nanny Amy said she saw the window and shutters open so she must have been there before Gerald pulled them down which was quite early on iirc
-
Is there something that nails down where Amy Tierney was?
I have seen that she was working at a desk in the Tapas area.
This puts her several hundred metres away in OC main reception.
Where was she?
http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/AMY-ELLEN-TIERNEY.htm
Amy Tierney
Date: 2007-05-06
Place: P da L
Occupation: Head of the Baby Club and Mini Club
Place of Work: Ocean Club
She comes to the process as a witness.
As she does not understand Portuguese and is of English nationality she is assisted by the interpreter Robert Murat who accompanies her during the questioning.
When asked, the witness confirms that she has been in Portugal since the 18th March 2007 having come to Portugal to work in this tourist resort.
She confirms that she works as head of the Baby Club and Mini Club, the former being for children aged up to eleven months and the latter for children aged between three and five.
She confirms that Madeleine is known by her as frequenting the Mini Club, as she was aged almost four.
When questioned about Madeleine's behaviour, the witness says that she is a shy girl but very intelligent for her age, she tended to play with older children, the witness describes her attitude and behaviour as perfectly normal.
The witness confirms that she also knows Madeleine's parents as they would go to fetch her from the club, but she adds that it was normally Madeleine's father who did this.
When questioned, the witness states that she has not noted anything abnormal in the relation between the child and the parents.
The hours of the club are from 09.00 to 12.30 and from 14.30 to 17.30, the club is closed on Sundays on that day it only offers the dinner service.
When questioned, she says that if the guests wish so they can request services from the "Staff" who would look after the children from 19.30 to 23.30, however Madeleine's parents never did this although the service is free.
She confirms that, on the night of the disappearance she was on duty and immediately went to the bedroom to see if the girl was hiding. She saw that the shutter was raised and that the window was partially open. It was then that she began to look in the wardrobes to see if the girl was hiding.
The first idea that occurred to her was that the girl could have left by her own means, however after checking that the window was open and the shutter raised she asked the parents whether Madeleine's shoes were there, to which they replied that they were, these facts led her to think that Madeleine could have been taken by someone.
However there was a bed against the window, which could have enabled the girl to climb up onto it and then up to the window, the witness thinks it would not be possible as she would not be able to open the shutters and even if she had done so she would have fallen outside as the window is too high for a child of that age to be able to descend without falling.
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn't know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.
After having searched the apartment and verified that the girl was not there, the outside searches were begun.
The witness confirms that the girl's father went to the reception to call the police as soon as her disappearance was noticed and that twenty minutes had passed. The GNR took 30 – 35 minutes to arrive.
She says that at no moment did she notice anyone behaving strangely as concerns the children or anything that appeared at all suspicious to her.
She adds that the staff looking after the children were eleven employees, who worked in shifts regarding the hours from 19.30 to 23.30.
The witness remembers that upon entering the bedroom at the time of the disappearance, she saw that the bed that the two babies were sleeping (reparou que a cama que os dois bebes encontravam-se a dormir) and she saw that the bedclothes of the bed near the window were rumpled as if someone had been sitting there, that the bedclothes of Madeleine's bed had been pushed back and that on top of the bed was a small child's blanket and a cuddly toy.
She states that the distance between the apartment and the restaurant where Madeleine's parents were was 30 seconds by foot away but that there was no visual contact with the back window of the bedroom where Madeleine was. From the restaurant just the front window of the apartment could be seen.
The witness does not remember any element that could be useful to the investigation
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Later on, she was apparently at the Tapas Reception
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/AMY-ELLEN-TIERNEY-1.htm
Witness Statement
Date : 2008-04-17
Time. 10.00
Place: Praia da Luz
Name: Amy Tierney
Has made previous statements in May last year.
Given that she does not speak Portuguese, Silvia Batista acted as interpreter.
When questioned and shown the photographs referred to in the previous statements, depicting the English girl, on 'Kodak Xtra Life ' paper, 10 x 15, she said they were printed on her printer, also of Kodak brand.
When on the night of 3rd May, at about 24.00, she was at her desk at the Tapas bar, inside the resort, when at a certain time, one of the friends of the McCann couple, Russell, asked for a USB memory stick reader, in order to print photographs of Madeleine. Immediately the deponent replied that she did not have an USB reader, but that she had a printer with this hardware, which could read from memory sticks.
She went to her room and returned to the Tapas with the printer where she printed out 20 to 30 photographs of the girl, using her own paper, in 10x15 format mentioned previously. The memory stick containing the photos belonged to the McCann couple, and came from their camera.
She thinks that all of this took place at about 24.00 on 3rd May 2007. She presumes that she handed all of the photos to Russell, who distributed some to those present, the rest would be for the police authorities.
As regards her printer, she says that it is no longer in her possession as it is now with her boyfriend in France, she says, after consultation, and in accordance with her previous statements, that is was a 'Kodak', model Easy Share G60, of thermal ink transfer, with continuous tonality.
In annex, is documentation about the printer, describing its technical characteristics, which she recognises as being identical to her printer.
No more is said. She signs the statement together with the interpreter.
-
OK,
First statement a few days after does not nail where Amy was.
Second statement, roughly a year later, and she is at a desk in the Tapas.
Is that roughly it? Or am I getting the wrong end of the stick?
-
The witness confirms that the girl's father went to the reception to call the police as soon as her disappearance was noticed and that twenty minutes had passed. The GNR took 30 / 35 minutes to arrive. (Amy T)
Gerry went to reception at 10:35/40. They didn't start the lost child procedure until 10:20 so Amy wasn't at 5A before that time. She arrived at around 10:30 IMO and she saw the window open &%+((£ The GNR arrive 30/35 minutes later as she said in her statement at around 11.05.
-
OK,
First statement a few days after does not nail where Amy was.
Second statement, roughly a year later, and she is at a desk in the Tapas.
Is that roughly it? Or am I getting the wrong end of the stick?
She was at the desk at around 2400 hrs. I assume she was out searching during the previous hour & will endeavour to find a statement from someone who was with her.
-
OK,
First statement a few days after does not nail where Amy was.
Second statement, roughly a year later, and she is at a desk in the Tapas.
Is that roughly it? Or am I getting the wrong end of the stick?
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEANNE-DANIELLE-WAGSTAFF.htm
*snipped*
On the night of the disappearance she was not working and had gone to a bar with colleagues. When she was heading for the bar from home at about 22.30 she saw her colleague Amy in the garden with a torch, searching for something.
She immediately asked what was happening and was told that a girl had disappeared. At first she thought it was a joke, but then she also began to search. She say that she searched everywhere.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SARA-ELIZABETH-WILLIAMSON.htm
*snipped*
On 3rd May at about 22.30 after having left the apartment where she was living, near to the resort, together with two of her colleagues, Leanne and Kirsty, she met her colleague Amy. She was informed by Amy that Madeleine had disappeared and that she was trying to look for her. For this reason, the witness together with her colleagues joined in the search.
In the search carried out with her colleagues from the OC other individuals (tourists, locals, property owners) also participated.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KIRSTY-MARYAN.htm
*snipped*
That on the 03 of May, 200, at around 22h30, after having left the apartment where she is living, close to the establishment mentioned, together with two more colleagues, also residents there, whose name are Leanne and Sarah, she found her colleague Amy. That during their discussion she was informed that Madeleine McCann had disappeared and that they were looking for her. For this reason, together with her colleagues, they also began searching for Madeleine McCann;
. That during the search she carried out, together with her colleagues (employees of the Ocean Club) others were also participating from the establishment ion question;
-
If they had gone out about half an hour earlier they might have seen smithman or the irish witnesses.
-
If they had gone out about half an hour earlier they might have seen smithman or the irish witnesses.
It would have been helpful if they had seen the Irish family. It would have been even more helpful if someone had obtained the CCTV tape from Estrela da Luz on the morning of the 4th.
-
It would have been helpful if they had seen the Irish family. It would have been even more helpful if someone had obtained the CCTV tape from Estrela da Luz on the morning of the 4th.
Absolutely. If it hadn't picked Smithman up it would have confirmed the time of the sighting when the family returned.
-
"Questioned, she responds that she knows the time that they left."
-
The witness confirms that the girl's father went to the reception to call the police as soon as her disappearance was noticed and that twenty minutes had passed. The GNR took 30 / 35 minutes to arrive. (Amy T)
Gerry went to reception at 10:35/40. They didn't start the lost child procedure until 10:20 so Amy wasn't at 5A before that time. She arrived at around 10:30 IMO and she saw the window open &%+((£ The GNR arrive 30/35 minutes later as she said in her statement at around 11.05.
When Amy was in G5A a 'female friend' was there with GM and KM. That must be either Fiona or Dianne. Neither of them saw an open window or open shutters.
as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there
http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/AMY-ELLEN-TIERNEY.htm
-
It would have been helpful if they had seen the Irish family. It would have been even more helpful if someone had obtained the CCTV tape from Estrela da Luz on the morning of the 4th.
Their apartment block was on west side of Rua Escola Primeira IMO so if they had gone out a bit earlier they would have seen smithman and the irish group.
-
When Amy was in G5A a 'female friend' was there with GM and KM. That must be either Fiona or Dianne. Neither of them saw an open window or open shutters.
as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there
http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/AMY-ELLEN-TIERNEY.htm
That would be Fiona. Dianne was back at the Payne's apartment watching the kids.
-
"Questioned, she responds that she knows the time that they left."
They came on holiday for about 10 days, having returned to Ireland on 9 May 2007. (She is not absolutely certain of the day).
-
OK,
First statement a few days after does not nail where Amy was.
Second statement, roughly a year later, and she is at a desk in the Tapas.
Is that roughly it? Or am I getting the wrong end of the stick?
Not sure what you are looking for Shining or if this has already been posted. My apologies if it has.
22.05-22.20 Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)
22.05 J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy)
so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.
I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.
Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm
-
Not sure what you are looking for Shining or if this has already been posted. My apologies if it has.
22.05-22.20 Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)
22.05 J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy)
so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.
I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.
Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm
Based on the above, can we safely say the alarm was raised by Kate before 10.13pm?
-
They came on holiday for about 10 days, having returned to Ireland on 9 May 2007. (She is not absolutely certain of the day).
Yes because some of her family left the next morning so she remembered that night. They had a last night out even though Peter's pregnant wife wasn't feeling too well.
-
Based on the above, can we safely say the alarm was raised by Kate before 10.13pm?
I believe so. I might add that Russ was still eating his re-cooked meal brought to him around 9.50-55(I will check this out) which he left half eaten (I will find the waiters state) when Kate gave the alert.
-
Yes because some of her family left the next morning so she remembered that night. They had a last night out even though Peter's pregnant wife wasn't feeling too well.
I am of the opinion the more recent event of the day of her own departure would have been easily remembered by one with such power of recall that the buttons on the trousers of a passing stranger had been noticed.
Particularly when one remembers that there was nothing of especial interest about the night of the 3rd of May as far as she and her family were concerned. To the extent that it was a fortnight after the event that one of them raised the issue and realised that unlike the characters in soap operas ... they had not been dreaming.
I am not at all intrigued as to why this inquisitive, observant child with the ability to soak up information at a passing glance was ignorant of the activities taking place just a few paces down the road and throughout the remaining five or six days of her holiday.
We do know that they were aware of the commotion going on ...
**Snip
“We were looking at all the commotion on Sky News and we really felt quite helpless. We had two grandchildren with us at the time and it had a terrible effect on them – they all wanted to sleep in the same room as us.” - See more at: http://madeleinemccann.org/blog/2014/04/20/2008-january-243-273/#sthash.MxykJtfN.dpuf
... and as Mr Smith said ... “We’ve all been beating ourselves up that we should have made the link sooner, if only we’d remembered the next day. But the Portuguese police said you see these things on holiday all the time.” - See more at: http://madeleinemccann.org/blog/2014/04/20/2008-january-243-273/#sthash.MxykJtfN.dpuf
-
Based on the above, can we safely say the alarm was raised by Kate before 10.13pm?
As you well know Alfie the statements of eyewitnesses were all over the place with signs of commotion after the alert ranging from 9.30 to 10.30.
Tell me while you are so keen to accept every word that comes from Gerry's mouth as sacrosanct why are you so determined to undermine him in this ?
-
As you well know Alfie the statements of eyewitnesses were all over the place with signs of commotion after the alert ranging from 9.30 to 10.30.
Tell me while you are so keen to accept every word that comes from Gerry's mouth as sacrosanct why are you so determined to undermine him in this ?
@)(++(*
Equally I could ask you why you believe Gerry McCann to be a despicably mendacious specimen in all aspects apart from this one particular aspect of his statement?
As there is no one else claiming that they were still sat at the table at nearly quarter past 10, I'm of the opinion that Gerry must be mistaken, you on the other hand prefer to believe that the 8 others are all mistaken but Gerry is telling the truth on this one and only occasion - how very bizarre!
-
Faithlilly - your theory is dependent on Gerry blithely contradicting others' evidence that gives him an alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting. If this is what you genuinely believe then don't you think this is a little bit idiotic of him?
-
It would have been helpful if they had seen the Irish family. It would have been even more helpful if someone had obtained the CCTV tape from Estrela da Luz on the morning of the 4th.
Estrela da Luz has 9 gated entrances monitored by 10 CCTV cameras, all pointed at the INSIDE of the complex. There is probably a further CCTV at main reception, but I cannot be certain of that. If there is, it is inside reception.
Each of the gated entrances is operated by a key code, or by an electronic swipe card. Madeleine had neither, so she could not get into Estrela on her own. All of the gated entrances have large signs up saying CCTV is in operation, so an abductor would have to have been way beyond dumb to first enter with Madeleine, then exit with Madeleine.
That cuts it down to getting a timing for the Smith sighting. This did not even surface until something like 3 weeks after Madeleine disappeared, so until then the Estrela CCTV was unimportant.
Here we are into a numbers game. A total of 10 entrances, and a total of 11 cameras. Does one really believe that just one of these was missed, and that the Smiths used that particular one?
I can't prove it, but I would suggest that CCTV was never picked up for any of the Estrela cameras. Further, it is quite probable that by the time the Smiths came forward, the Estrela tapes from 3 May had been recycled.
Is anyone aware of an entry in the files to the effect that a batch of tapes had been picked up from Estrela?
-
Faithlilly - your theory is dependent on Gerry blithely contradicting others' evidence that gives him an alibi for the time of the Smithman sighting. If this is what you genuinely believe then don't you think this is a little bit idiotic of him?
He blithely contradicted his own witness live on camera, at a stroke decimating her credibility, so why not ?
-
...
22.05 J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy)
so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
...
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.
...
Thanks, Anna, that's the bit I was looking for. I've been working through the first 2hours after Kate raised the alarm and I knew Amy was in action early on but I couldn't work out how or when she became aware of the situation.
I don't think Gerry went to reception to request a police phone call. The gist seems to be that Matthew went, but did not press receptionist Helder Luis into actually making an early call, thus valuable time went by.
-
@)(++(*
Equally I could ask you why you believe Gerry McCann to be a despicably mendacious specimen in all aspects apart from this one particular aspect of his statement?
As there is no one else claiming that they were still sat at the table at nearly quarter past 10, I'm of the opinion that Gerry must be mistaken, you on the other hand prefer to believe that the 8 others are all mistaken but Gerry is telling the truth on this one and only occasion - how very bizarre!
Not so Alfie. I think Gerry often tells the truth, a lie is often less obvious when surrounded by it.
-
I am of the opinion the more recent event of the day of her own departure would have been easily remembered by one with such power of recall that the buttons on the trousers of a passing stranger had been noticed.
Particularly when one remembers that there was nothing of especial interest about the night of the 3rd of May as far as she and her family were concerned. To the extent that it was a fortnight after the event that one of them raised the issue and realised that unlike the characters in soap operas ... they had not been dreaming.
I am not at all intrigued as to why this inquisitive, observant child with the ability to soak up information at a passing glance was ignorant of the activities taking place just a few paces down the road and throughout the remaining five or six days of her holiday.
We do know that they were aware of the commotion going on ...
**Snip
“We were looking at all the commotion on Sky News and we really felt quite helpless. We had two grandchildren with us at the time and it had a terrible effect on them – they all wanted to sleep in the same room as us.” - See more at: http://madeleinemccann.org/blog/2014/04/20/2008-january-243-273/#sthash.MxykJtfN.dpuf
... and as Mr Smith said ... “We’ve all been beating ourselves up that we should have made the link sooner, if only we’d remembered the next day. But the Portuguese police said you see these things on holiday all the time.” - See more at: http://madeleinemccann.org/blog/2014/04/20/2008-january-243-273/#sthash.MxykJtfN.dpuf
Aoife wouldn't necessarily remember the date she went home (not memorable to a kid) but she would remember the night out at the restaurant and bar and seeing a young kid being carried at that late hour. Her testimony is the only one that connects to the Dolphin restaurant receipt time so she is a credible witness.
Regarding the 3rd of May, 2007, she went, with all her family, to eat at the Dolphin restaurant, which is close to Kelly's Bar. When they left the restaurant, around 21H30, they headed toward Kelly's Bar. They stayed there for about 30 minutes.
— Around 22H00, they left Kelly's Bar. The group headed, on foot, for their apartment.
— Questioned, she responds that she knows the time that they left because her father and her brother decided to leave early that night.
-
He blithely contradicted his own witness live on camera, at a stroke decimating her credibility, so why not ?
He did? Perhaps we all come to different conclusions.
All I understood from that sequence was that they had different (fleeting) recollections of details and stood by them.
-
He blithely contradicted his own witness live on camera, at a stroke decimating her credibility, so why not ?
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do. Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice. On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity. Now. Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things. Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert. You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.
Why would he do that Faithlilly? Think!!
-
He did? Perhaps we all come to diferent conclusions.
All I understood from that sequence was that they had different (fleeting) recollections of details and stood by them.
It is there in black and white Carana. Gerry contradicted both Tanner ( on camera) and Jez by placing himself on the wrong side of the road during the talk.
Why didn't Gerry, when faced with the recollections of two different witnesses, one his friend, simply accept that he could have been wrong ?
Why was it so important that he was on the right side of the road rather than the left ?
-
It is there in black and white Carana. Gerry contradicted both Tanner ( on camera) and Jez by placing himself on the wrong side of the road during the talk.
Why didn't Gerry, when faced with the recollections of two different witnesses, one his friend, simply accept that he could have been wrong ?
Why was it so important that he was on the right side of the road rather than the left ?
Perhaps (like you) he always has to be right?
-
Perhaps (like you) he always has to be right?
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
-
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
What did he say in his statements to the fuzz?
-
Aoife wouldn't necessarily remember the date she went home (not memorable to a kid) but she would remember the night out at the restaurant and bar and seeing a young kid being carried at that late hour. Her testimony is the only one that connects to the Dolphin restaurant receipt time so she is a credible witness.
Regarding the 3rd of May, 2007, she went, with all her family, to eat at the Dolphin restaurant, which is close to Kelly's Bar. When they left the restaurant, around 21H30, they headed toward Kelly's Bar. They stayed there for about 30 minutes.
— Around 22H00, they left Kelly's Bar. The group headed, on foot, for their apartment.
— Questioned, she responds that she knows the time that they left because her father and her brother decided to leave early that night.
Aoife remembered the date perfectly well ... it was the day that defeated her.
The fact that the following morning none of the Smith family recalled the event of the man carrying a child in the dark in the near vicinity of the place from where a child had vanished is something else.
The fact recall didn't occur for a fortnight is also a bit of a puzzlement.
I didn't know that until relatively recently. I thought the Smiths had reported their sighting to the PJ immediately; which actually might have helped the investigation in its early stages.
The place was heaving with GNR and their dogs, the PJ, search parties ... not to mention the media and their equipment ... plus terrified Smith grandchildren following the event on TV.
They received at least one phone call from Ireland where the event was big news. Yet no-one remembered.
Isn't memory a mysterious thing though.
The fact that Aoife 'saw' long sleeves and 'remembered' the time which you have incorporated into your theory ... does not exactly make her the witness of the century when you take into consideration the things which didn't immediately spring to the front of her mind at any time from the 4th to the 9th May.
-
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
Well perhaps Gerry is even more pig-headed than you. BTW, I'm rather disappointed you haven't seen fit to comment on my earlier post of 12.25pm today. On reflection, and considering the illogicality of Gerry destroying his own perfectly good alibi, might you concede that certain elements of your theory may in fact be wrong - combined recall being (as you say) perhaps more reliable that the recall of one individual?
-
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do. Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice. On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity. Now. Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things. Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert. You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.
Why would he do that Faithlilly? Think!!
It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.
Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)
Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.
Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).
Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.
He returns back to the restaurant.
Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.
Does that ring true and realistic?
-
It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.
Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)
Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.
Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).
Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.
He returns back to the restaurant.
Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.
Does that ring true and realistic?
No - not unless all those who gathered to put the timeline together shortly after Madeleine's disappearance are in on it. Does that ring true and realistic?
-
What did he say in his statements to the fuzz?
Nothing in May 4th and arguido as far as I an see, apartment side in combined timeline and opposite side on 10th May.
-
Is it not fair to say that the only way that Gerry could possibly be Smithman is if all or at least the majority of the members of the Tapas group were covering for him?
-
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
I might be tempted to, unless instructed to rely only on my own recollection.
My recollection of an event could have been that I'd seen someone in blue. Someone else thought that they'd seen someone in mauve or even dark green.
Should I change my recollection to coincide with theirs (perhaps they are right after all), or stick to my own recollection (even if it's not accurate, and others have different recollections)?
-
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do. Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice. On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity. Now. Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things. Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert. You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.
Why would he do that Faithlilly? Think!!
All the rest of the group ? Really ? While most said the helpfully ambiguous 'around 10' Tanner states that she first heard Kate and Fiona between 10-10.15'. So no consensus there. and certainly no bar against the actual time of the alert being 'around 10.13'.
-
I might be tempted to, unless instructed to rely only on my own recollection.
My recollection of an event could have been that I'd seen someone in blue. Someone else thought that they'd seen someone in mauve or even dark green.
Should I change my recollection to coincide with theirs (perhaps they are right after all), or stick to my own recollection (even if it's not accurate, and others have different recollections)?
If another eyewitness had also said that they had seen the same person in mauve I'm sure you would have.
-
All the rest of the group ? Really ? While most said the helpfully ambiguous 'around 10' Tanner states that she first heard Kate and Fiona between 10-10.15'. So no consensus there. and certainly no bar against the actual time of the alert being 'around 10.13'.
So you are choosing to disregard their combined efforts to construct a timeline (shortly after Madeleine went missing when events were freshest in their minds) as a work of fiction are you? And the witness statement of Amy Tierney too?
You are choosing to believe Gerry is giving the correct time in his May 10th statement for one reason only - and that is to make your cherished theory work. Isn't that a bit silly Faithlilly? What happened to "bowing to combined recollection"? Please give a reason in your opinion for Gerry's insane decision to destroy his own alibi.
-
So you are choosing to disregard their combined efforts to construct a timeline (shortly after Madeleine went missing when events were freshest in their minds) as a work of fiction are you? And the witness statement of Amy Tierney too?
You are choosing to believe Gerry is giving the correct time in his May 10th statement for one reason only - and that is to make your cherished theory work. Isn't that a bit silly Faithlilly? What happened to "bowing to combined recollection"? Please give a reason in your opinion for Gerry's insane decision to destroy his own alibi.
The combined timeline says '22.00 ( approx ) which is of no help at all and I'm really not sure what you mean by Amy Tierney.
-
The combined timeline says '22.00 ( approx ) which is of no help at all and I'm really not sure what you mean by Amy Tierney.
Perhaps you can point out where it says "approx." on the hand-written timelines?
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id261.html
ETA: this is what I meant about Amy Tierney - not her statement actually but others working with her (from Anna's earlier post):
22.05-22.20 Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)
22.05 J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy)
so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.
I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.
Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm
-
Perhaps you can point out where it says "approx." on the hand-written timelines?
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id261.html
ETA: this is what I meant about Amy Tierney - not her statement actually but others working with her (from Anna's earlier post):
22.05-22.20 Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)
22.05 J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.
22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy)
so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.
I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.
Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm
This is the combined timeline created by all the main protagonists and says Kate left the table at '22.00 (approx )'.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TIME_LINE_3_MAY_07.htm
-
This is the combined timeline created by all the main protagonists and says Kate left the table at '22.00 (approx )'.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TIME_LINE_3_MAY_07.htm
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?
Here we have a tangible piece of evidence in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.
10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.
However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.
When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi?
My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy.
You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.
Over to you.
-
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?
Here we have a tangible piece of evidence in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.
10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.
However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.
When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi?
My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy.
You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.
Over to you.
Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.
-
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?
Here we have a tangible piece of evidence in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.
10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.
However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.
When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi?
My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy.
You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.
Over to you.
Gerry had no idea what the waiting staff would say so best to stick to the truth, approx would just have to make things suitably obscure.
-
Gerry had no idea what the waiting staff would say so best to stick to the truth, approx would just have to make things suitably obscure.
That's a bit lame for you Faithlilly. Why is it that you have chosen on this one particular matter to disregard combined recollection (within hours of the event) in favour of the recollection of one man seven days after the event, when earlier you said you would bow to combined recollection?
No need to answer - it's actually not hard to work out why. It's because you need Gerry to be accurate on this one particular matter in order for your theory to work, never mind what any other witness says. Can't you see how warped that logic is? Of course you can't.
ETA: which member of staff verified that the alarm was raised at nearly 10.15pm?
-
Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.
Sorry, not following your train of thought there at all.
-
Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.
True! one of the only independent testimonies to time was that of Jez Wilkins who said he met Gerry between 20:45 and 21:45 and chatted for about 3 minutes or so. He would never be drawn into narrowing down the time span.
-
True! one of the only independent testimonies to time was that of Jez Wilkins who said he met Gerry between 20:45 and 21:45 and chatted for about 3 minutes or so. He would never be drawn into narrowing down the time span.
When did he say that?
Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?
-
When did he say that?
Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?
Look in here.
You will find it if you persevere.
-
Look in here.
You will find it if you persevere.
I've just re-read his statements and his rogatory and he doesn't put an hour long time window on the meeting as far as I can see. Nor can I see any refusal to be more specific. Perhaps I missed it so a link would be good, or a quote from a statement...?
-
When did he say that?
Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?
Here Alfred is the answer to both your questions
"... I met Gerry on the road between 20h45 and 21h15. I am aware of the importance of this hour and am also aware that the media announced our meeting time as 21h05. Even if this were correct, I have no idea from where such information originated. It is not possible to give you a more exact time ..."
Source: rogatory 8th Apr 2008 http://www.mccannfiles.com/id327.html
-
I've just re-read his statements and his rogatory and he doesn't put an hour long time window on the meeting as far as I can see. Nor can I see any refusal to be more specific. Perhaps I missed it so a link would be good, or a quote from a statement...?
You are right just testing ( 8(0(* ) it should have read 20:45 to 21:15. (ie quarter to nine to quarterpast nine in the evening civilian time)
Edited due to crap keyboard skills ?{)(**
-
It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.
Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)
Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.
Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).
Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.
He returns back to the restaurant.
Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.
Does that ring true and realistic?
Obviously that theory is impossible.
But I am impressed that you have taken the time to actually read and understand his theory. Some people who say they are Amaral supporters do not seem to do that, and so we see put forward theories which contradict Amaral's theory in many ways, abandoning his hypothesis that the child walked from the bedroom to the lounge, and proposing a discovery time far earlier and even more ridiculous than the time proposed by Amaral IMO.
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?
Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm. There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once.
The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him. Is this likely? I don't think so.
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?
Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm. There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once.
The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him. Is this likely? I don't think so.
In addition, one only has to compare the obviously mistaken Smith and McCuskey statements to add another very compelling reason why that particular identification was entirely wrong ... why the notion has persisted is just one of the mysteries associated with Madeleine's case.
-
In addition, one only has to compare the obviously mistaken Smith and McCuskey statements to add another very compelling reason why that particular identification was entirely wrong ... why the notion has persisted is just one of the mysteries associated with Madeleine's case.
Mr McClusky identified Kate too! Silly man.
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?
Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm. There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once.
The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him. Is this likely? I don't think so.
As a generic statement, I fear not (in response to what I underline).
But all sensible people who follow these events closely long ago have, for precisely the reasons you so clearly set out above ....
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?
Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm. There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once.
The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him. Is this likely? I don't think so.
Not everyone contributed to the timeline written on the night. In the timeline handed in to the PJ on the 10th of May everyone did and it is ambiguous as to the time of the alert, using 'approx' to suggest there was no true consensus.
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman? ... (snip)
IMO yes, because of clothing - the irish group saw a man in white or light beige trousers and a child with long sleeves - but the missing child was wearing short sleeves and her father was wearing blue jeans.
It is very easy now for SY to confirm the blue jeans by simply asking the T7.
To make GM into the man seen by the irish group requires THREE clothing changes
1. A change just before sighting from blue jeans to white trousers.
2. A change just before sighting from short sleeve pyjama top to long sleeved top.
3. A change immediately after sighting from white trousers back to blue jeans.
Sherlock Holmes wouldbe appalled by such flagrant changing of facts to fit an incorrect theory.
-
Not everyone contributed to the timeline written on the night. In the timeline handed in to the PJ on the 10th of May everyone did and it is ambiguous as to the time of the alert, using 'approx' to suggest there was no true consensus.
David Payne and Rusell O'Brien put together the handwritten timelines, both putting the time of alarm being raised at 10pm, the subsequent later timeline in which all contributed also has the time of the alarm being raised at 10pm, with the caveat "Times shown are approximate, but accurate to the best of our knowledge". I don't know what you mean by "no true consensus" as it is crystal clear that the consensus view of the time the alarm was raised was 10pm. If there was no true consensus on the timing of events that night then no collaboration on a timeline would be possible - it would be 9 different timelines.
I know you're rooting for a later alarm time Faithlilly, but apart from Gerry himself (unaccountably destroying his own alibi) not one other member of the Tapas group claims that they were still seated at the table as late as 10.13pm.
-
The timeline handed to PJ on 10th May was typed by ROB, with all 7 of the T7 present, on a laptop bborrowed from tennis coach GJ, and then checked by the 2 parents, this was all done on approx May 7th/8th. No other people were involved in writing it - no translators, no "hugh" secret agents. It was then handed on a memory stick (via an LP liaison officer) to the PJ on May 10th at Portimao. The text we see is the original english. There are no translation errors. Therefore it is a very accurate record of the timeline according to the T9.
-
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?
Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm. There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once.
The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him. Is this likely? I don't think so.
I don't know. It sounds though that you wish to be the arbiter and your will must prevail.
-
IMO yes, because of clothing - the irish group saw a man in white or light beige trousers and a child with long sleeves - but the missing child was wearing short sleeves and her father was wearing blue jeans.
It is very easy now for SY to confirm the blue jeans by simply asking the T7.
To make GM into the man seen by the irish group requires THREE clothing changes
1. A change just before sighting from blue jeans to white trousers.
2. A change just before sighting from short sleeve pyjama top to long sleeved top.
3. A change immediately after sighting from white trousers back to blue jeans.
Sherlock Holmes wouldbe appalled by such flagrant changing of facts to fit an incorrect theory.
Wouldn't he just!
-
David Payne and Rusell O'Brien put together the handwritten timelines, both putting the time of alarm being raised at 10pm, the subsequent later timeline in which all contributed also has the time of the alarm being raised at 10pm, with the caveat "Times shown are approximate, but accurate to the best of our knowledge". I don't know what you mean by "no true consensus" as it is crystal clear that the consensus view of the time the alarm was raised was 10pm. If there was no true consensus on the timing of events that night then no collaboration on a timeline would be possible - it would be 9 different timelines.
I know you're rooting for a later alarm time Faithlilly, but apart from Gerry himself (unaccountably destroying his own alibi) not one other member of the Tapas group claims that they were still seated at the table as late as 10.13pm.
The clue is '22.00 APPROX'. If you look hard enough you will find it.
-
Obviously that theory is impossible.
But I am impressed that you have taken the time to actually read and understand his theory. Some people who say they are Amaral supporters do not seem to do that, and so we see put forward theories which contradict Amaral's theory in many ways, abandoning his hypothesis that the child walked from the bedroom to the lounge, and proposing a discovery time far earlier and even more ridiculous than the time proposed by Amaral IMO.
Thank you for that, Pegasus.
Appreciated.
-
The clue is '22.00 APPROX'. If you look hard enough you will find it.
The bigger clue is 22.00, not 22.10, and definitely not 22.15 APPROX.
-
If the alarm was raised at 10.13 Faithlilly, could you please explain why it took Russell at least 20 minutes to take two bites of his dinner, which was re-served to him shortly after his return to table at appox 9.45pm?
-
If the alarm was raised at 10.13 Faithlilly, could you please explain why it took Russell at least 20 minutes to take two bites of his dinner, which was re-served to him shortly after his return to table at appox 9.45pm?
Perhaps 9.45 was wrong. Did somebody sign him in ?
-
Perhaps 9.45 was wrong. Did somebody sign him in ?
An awful lot of people would have to be wrong to make Gerry right, wouldn't they?
-
If the alarm was raised at 10.13 Faithlilly, could you please explain why it took Russell at least 20 minutes to take two bites of his dinner, which was re-served to him shortly after his return to table at appox 9.45pm?
After he arrived back at the restaurant, the cook cooked him a fresh steak, so you need to allow time for cooking it.
-
After he arrived back at the restaurant, the cook cooked him a fresh steak, so you need to allow time for cooking it.
How many minutes?
-
How many minutes?
5 to 10 minutes Alfred
-
Yes, the waiter will need to notice Russell's arrival at the table and then persuade the chef to cook another steak for this pain-in-the-arse late arrival. The chef will then deliberately burn it to a crisp. Easily 10 minutes.
-
Yes, the waiter will need to notice Russell's arrival at the table and then persuade the chef to cook another steak for this pain-in-the-arse late arrival. The chef will then deliberately burn it to a crisp. Easily 10 minutes.
ROTF!
-
Yes, the waiter will need to notice Russell's arrival at the table and then persuade the chef to cook another steak for this pain-in-the-arse late arrival. The chef will then deliberately burn it to a crisp. Easily 10 minutes.
So steak served at 10pm at the latest, two bites later and the alarm is raised at...?
-
For those who think smithman is relevant here is a theory from an ordinary person in the street in PDL that smithman immediately after the sighting may have gone
"... in the garden of that abandoned villa ..."
This is at is at the sighting junction, there's a gate, and according to an interview but not in files PJ went there.
-
For those who think smithman is relevant here is a theory from an ordinary person in the street in PDL that smithman immediately after the sighting may have gone
"... in the garden of that abandoned villa ..."
This is at is at the sighting junction, there's a gate, and according to an interview but not in files PJ went there.
Things may have changed since 2007, but on my recent tour, that gate was securely locked, requiring a key to open it.
If that was the state in 2007, then we are speculating about a key-holder or someone clambering over the top, roughly on the basis of nearby-abandoned-property, of which there are many in that area.
-
Yes, the waiter will need to notice Russell's arrival at the table and then persuade the chef to cook another steak for this pain-in-the-arse late arrival. The chef will then deliberately burn it to a crisp. Easily 10 minutes.
"I then waited for a period of time, you know, sort of five or ten minutes while they quickly, you know, it was sort of thin steak so I’d imagine quickly grilled or fried, erm, fried up a meal of that." (ROB)
-
Things may have changed since 2007, but on my recent tour, that gate was securely locked, requiring a key to open it.
If that was the state in 2007, then we are speculating about a key-holder or someone clambering over the top, roughly on the basis of nearby-abandoned-property, of which there are many in that area.
Thanks ShiningInLuz. By "that gate was securely locked" (recently), do you mean the gate within a gate on Rua 25 Abril? Or the little garden gate on west side of Trav Das Eschadhinas?
-
"I then waited for a period of time, you know, sort of five or ten minutes while they quickly, you know, it was sort of thin steak so I’d imagine quickly grilled or fried, erm, fried up a meal of that." (ROB)
It was grilled, not fried.
-
Looking down stepped lane from Rua 25Abril
Restaurant (dolphin)
Bar (not kelly)
Gardengate? (of old building in foreground)
-
Things may have changed since 2007, but on my recent tour, that gate was securely locked, requiring a key to open it.
If that was the state in 2007, then we are speculating about a key-holder or someone clambering over the top, roughly on the basis of nearby-abandoned-property, of which there are many in that area.
I'm not sure which property is being referred to. Is it the derelict place with some kind of one-time barn / granary building that Mike Tesko seems to have got into?
-
I'm not sure which property is being referred to. Is it the derelict place with some kind of one-time barn / granary building that Mike Tesko seems to have got into?
The building discussed here, as mentioned by Mr Amaral in an interview, is at the smith sighting junction.
MT investigated mainly a different building, near the church.
-
"I then waited for a period of time, you know, sort of five or ten minutes while they quickly, you know, it was sort of thin steak so I’d imagine quickly grilled or fried, erm, fried up a meal of that." (ROB)
So, based on Rob and the Tapas Restaurant staff testimonies the alarm can't have been raised any later than 10pm right?
-
Thanks ShiningInLuz. By "that gate was securely locked" (recently), do you mean the gate within a gate on Rua 25 Abril? Or the little garden gate on west side of Trav Das Eschadhinas?
Gate marked G in your later photo.
-
So, based on Rob and the Tapas Restaurant staff testimonies the alarm can't have been raised any later than 10pm right?
No way - he only had a couple of bites of his steak when Kate came running.
"He was about to serve the respective plate he was told to hold the food back for a few minutes, and that it was about 15 minutes before the guest (Russell) returned, at about 21.45. Dinner would end at about 21.45, a few minutes later the witness looked at the table and saw that there was nobody there and one of his colleagues told them that all the guests had left the table in a hurry. In any case, he remembers having heard shouts from the direction of Madeleine's parents' apartment."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RICARDO-A-D-L-OLIVEIRA.htm
-
Gate marked G in your later photo.
Thanks. I wonder if it was locked in 2007. IMO smithman was an innocent father with daughter and was just going home, possibly to one of the few residences with entrances on the stepped lane or very near.
If however he was a perp, as he turned into the stepped lane, straight ahead is the lit dolphin restaurant, and even closer ahead and left is calheta bar possibly with outdoor tables. Even if he turns right into R Salg he might be seen if there is anyone at those outdoor tables. So assuming he goes not as far as that, and also assuming that he has no entry to any building, then there is only that gate.
-
Thanks. I wonder if it was locked in 2007. IMO smithman was an innocent father with daughter and was just going home, possibly to one of the few residences with entrances on the stepped lane or very near.
If however he was a perp, as he turned into the stepped lane, straight ahead is the lit dolphin restaurant, and even closer ahead and left is calheta bar possibly with outdoor tables. Even if he turns right into R Salg he might be seen if there is anyone at those outdoor tables. So assuming he goes not as far as that, and also assuming that he has no entry to any building, then there is only that gate.
I don't know if it was locked or unlocked in 2007.
However, Portugal works as follows. If you secure the perimeter, whether plot or house, then people are not legally allowed to breach such a perimeter. If you do NOT secure the perimeter, then people are entitled to enter your plot/property and help themselves.
We hit this a few years back when an unfenced villa we were in was first invaded by folks collecting carob beans, then we had the joy of waking up on a Sunday morning to the sound of hunters with shotguns. The fact that the latter were hunting before the hunting season opened, and the group was so close to the villa that the law prohibits the discharge of firearms did not deter them. They tramped through the owner's English garden and proclaimed that a brother was in charge of the local PJ.
As far as I could tell from ageing, the lock was on the gate in 2007, and securely locked makes sense. But I wasn't here in 2007.
-
I don't know if it was locked or unlocked in 2007.
However, Portugal works as follows. If you secure the perimeter, whether plot or house, then people are not legally allowed to breach such a perimeter. If you do NOT secure the perimeter, then people are entitled to enter your plot/property and help themselves.
We hit this a few years back when an unfenced villa we were in was first invaded by folks collecting carob beans, then we had the joy of waking up on a Sunday morning to the sound of hunters with shotguns. The fact that the latter were hunting before the hunting season opened, and the group was so close to the villa that the law prohibits the discharge of firearms did not deter them. They tramped through the owner's English garden and proclaimed that a brother was in charge of the local PJ.
As far as I could tell from ageing, the lock was on the gate in 2007, and securely locked makes sense. But I wasn't here in 2007.
Thanks. That building contains two seperate properties. Semidetached. IIRC Mr Amaral in a press report was photographed on R.25Abril in front of the gate within gate which leads to garden of the west half
-
No way - he only had a couple of bites of his steak when Kate came running.
"He was about to serve the respective plate he was told to hold the food back for a few minutes, and that it was about 15 minutes before the guest (Russell) returned, at about 21.45. Dinner would end at about 21.45, a few minutes later the witness looked at the table and saw that there was nobody there and one of his colleagues told them that all the guests had left the table in a hurry. In any case, he remembers having heard shouts from the direction of Madeleine's parents' apartment."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RICARDO-A-D-L-OLIVEIRA.htm
All of his meal had been eaten apart from some steak.
How would dinner end at 21.45 when the waiter had only taken the orders about 9.30?
-
All of his meal had been eaten apart from some steak.
How would dinner end at 21.45 when the waiter had only taken the orders about 9.30?
They were serving main dishes at 9:30 that's why Matt and Russell left at 9:25 to do checks but Russell didn't return until 9:45. Everyone else had finished their main dishes. All of his meal eaten except for steak? Cite?
"Russell came back to table and err they’d actually cooked him a fresh steak and he was just starting to tuck into it when err Kate had obviously gone back to check on the children, came running in you know, as far as I can recollect she said you know she’s gone, Gerry, Madeleine’s gone, screaming you know.”
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DIANE-WEBSTER-2.htm
-
As I recall, Jane had returned to their apartment by this time to relieve Russell, so assuming that the main course was served at 9.30, she must have either bolted her food or gone without in order for Russel to be back at the table by 9.45
-
They were serving main dishes at 9:30 that's why Matt and Russell left at 9:25 to do checks but Russell didn't return until 9:45. Everyone else had finished their main dishes. All of his meal eaten except for steak? Cite?
"Russell came back to table and err they’d actually cooked him a fresh steak and he was just starting to tuck into it when err Kate had obviously gone back to check on the children, came running in you know, as far as I can recollect she said you know she’s gone, Gerry, Madeleine’s gone, screaming you know.”
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DIANE-WEBSTER-2.htm
The waiter also said that he can't be certain how long Russell was gone.
All that was left on his plate according to the waiter was a piece of the steak, so he had eaten what ever had accompanied the steak on his plate.
-
Processos Volume II
Pages 258 to 260
Joaquim Jose Moreira Baptista
Occupation: Waiter
Place of Work: Tapas Bar, OC
Time/Date: 18H50 2007/05/06
Portuguese National
Comes to the process as a witness. He has worked as a waiter at the Tapas restaurant since 12th Feb 2007. His shift is from 16.00 - 24.00 except for Saturdays when he works from 11.30 to 19.00. The clients who frequent the restaurant are mainly English tourists staying at the OC resort.
When asked he says that he clearly recalls the appearance of the girl's parents, he does not know their names, together with a group of English tourists who generally accompanied them, as for almost a week prior to the disappearance they would dine practically every day in the Tapas restaurant. On the occasions he saw the group dining at the restaurant he never saw the children.
When asked, he says he does not remember ever having seen Madeleine's face, which only happened when he saw her photograph after the disappearance.
When asked, he said that during dinner the men from the group would leave the table, returning to the table a few minutes later. The witness says that he does not know where they went. These absences would last for about 15 minutes. He cannot say with what regularity these absences occurred.
The witness remembers these occurrences well as would often have to take a plate of food requested by one of them back, due to the guest's absence, when he would find that the guest was not at the table when he came to serve the food.
When questioned, the witness says that he remembers on Thursday 3rd May, on the day of the disappearance, that the parents went to dine at the restaurant with the usual people. He cannot be precise, but the witness says that the group arrived between 20.00 and 21.00. He remembers there being about 9 people in total. He states that he received the food orders from the group.
Later, between 22.00 and 22.30, when the witness was in the kitchen, he was informed by a colleague that in the meantime a client had entered the restaurant shouting and that afterwards the whole English had left in a panic. The witness' colleague told him that this individual had said that a child had disappeared. A few minutes later the witness noticed great agitation, with many people everywhere searching for the child.
From information that was coming out, the witness learned that the child was a girl, the daughter of one of the English couple and that she had been in a room nearby.
When asked, the witness says that at the time he was working in the restaurant and referring to the days before the disappearance, he never noticed anything unusual. He said that he was never asked about the habits of the English group nor any questions concerning children. He says that on the day of the disappearance from the time he arrived at work, he did not notice anything unusual.
When asked, he says that at the end of the evening the area surrounding the Tapas is quiet with little circulation of people.
He has no comments as to the motive for the disappearance.
No more is said. Read, ratifies, signs.
-
He was in the kitchen when informed so he doesn't know the time they left the table. And that doesn't mention anything about only steak being left on his plate?
-
He was in the kitchen when informed so he doesn't know the time they left the table. And that doesn't mention anything about only steak being left on his plate?
The diner and the employee both probably avoided mentioning vegetables on purpose, imagining incorrectly that no armchair detective would be skilled enough detect this huge culinary discrepancy.
-
He served Russell and shortly thereafter, he was alerted to strange movements in the restaurant perimeters. He refers to the movements of two men from said group? David Payne and Matthew, who appeared to be searching the gardens the areas near the bar. The witness went to the esplanade zone and saw that the table that had previously been occupied by nine adults was now occupied only by the older woman, called Dianne Webster. It was also at this time that he saw that Russell's food was only half eaten and that the others had all finished their dinner.
David Payne and Matthew were nervously searching the area.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RICARDO-A-D-L-OLIVEIRA.htm
-
He served Russell and shortly thereafter, he was alerted to strange movements in the restaurant perimeters. He refers to the movements of two men from said group? David Payne and Matthew, who appeared to be searching the gardens the areas near the bar. The witness went to the esplanade zone and saw that the table that had previously been occupied by nine adults was now occupied only by the older woman, called Dianne Webster. It was also at this time that he saw that Russell's food was only half eaten and that the others had all finished their dinner.
David Payne and Matthew were nervously searching the area.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RICARDO-A-D-L-OLIVEIRA.htm
You still need to allow time after he arrives back at the restaurant, for the cook to grill a fresh steak.
-
You still need to allow time after he arrives back at the restaurant, for the cook to grill a fresh steak.
Russell said as little as 5 minutes. So let's say 7 minutes for a thin steak which makes it 9:52 when he got his dinner. Kate returned only minutes later. Alarm time would be 9:55 not 10pm.
-
Russell said as little as 5 minutes. So let's say 7 minutes for a thin steak which makes it 9:52 when he got his dinner. Kate returned only minutes later. Alarm time would be 9:55 not 10pm.
7 minutes is reasonable. Your calculations assume that 9.45 is accurate to the minute.
-
Not surprisingly, I'm confused.
Jane left the table about 9.15 (not sure why). Sees Tannerman en route.
Russell leaves with Matt and goes to his apartment at about 9.30, so does Jane return to get something to eat, or are they both in their apartment together until say 9.45, with Jane remaining until after 10 ?
-
Not surprisingly, I'm confused.
Jane left the table about 9.15 (not sure why). Sees Tannerman en route.
Russell leaves with Matt and goes to his apartment at about 9.30, so does Jane return to get something to eat, or are they both in their apartment together until say 9.45, with Jane remaining until after 10 ?
Jane leaves the table a second time after wolfing down her main course - 9:38. They were together in the apartment for 5 minutes. Russell is back at the table at 9:45 but Jane is still in the apartment when the alarm was raised.
-
Jane leaves the table a second time after wolfing down her main course - 9:38. They were together in the apartment for 5 minutes. Russell is back at the table at 9:45 but Jane is still in the apartment when the alarm was raised.
So much for them all having a nice relaxed evening with friends, then @)(++(*
-
So much for them all having a nice relaxed evening with friends, then @)(++(*
If they'd all been truly selfish and neglectful then they'd have had just that, and no one would have known about Madeleine's disappearance until they'd all turned in for the night at the earliest.
-
If they'd all been truly selfish and neglectful then they'd have had just that, and no one would have known about Madeleine's disappearance until they'd all turned in for the night at the earliest.
I fail to see the connection between the tapas meal and the alleged sighting of Smithman. The only meal timings of any consequence here are surely those of the Smith family and anyone else dining in that area who may have also witnessed a man carrying a child.
The most interesting time being immediately after they had passed each other when pieces of the jigsaw could be slotted in, such as the direction he took and perhaps his destination or entry to a vehicle.
-
I fail to see the connection between the tapas meal and the alleged sighting of Smithman. The only meal timings of any consequence here are surely those of the Smith family and anyone else dining in that area who may have also witnessed a man carrying a child.
The most interesting time being immediately after they had passed each other when pieces of the jigsaw could be slotted in, such as the direction he took and perhaps his destination or entry to a vehicle.
Did anything turn up in the media (not the statements) about how the Smith group was strung out?
That might give use more info about where Smithman came from and where Smithman went.
-
So who was it that was missing for half an hour?
Ref Svetlana and Joacqum's statements
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS-EMPLOYEES.htm
SVETLANA
------- STARIKOVA VITORINO (Russian citizen, with the telephone No "96635 ####) - kitchen assistant:
- Said that, yesterday, one individual, purportedly the father of the missing, left the dinner table where a group of friends (in number 8 or 9), for about 30 minutes. After having returned, a woman whom she believed to be his wife, also left the table, there having passed a few moments, all the guests left the table in question, except one elderly lady, who told her [Svetlana's] colleagues that that child had disappeared.
JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA (residing at Rua Ilha Terceira, no. 15, Lagos, Telephone No 91 277 ####) - table employee [waiter].
- Of the group of 8/9 British citizens who dined at the restaurant last night, as usual, of which the parents of missing were part (he didn't know them) he noticed that two individuals left the table, of the male gender.
- The first to leave was about 40/45 years old (tall, skinny, white complexion, with large [a full head of] hair of color gray) and the period of his absence was about 15 minutes, being that they had to [re-]heat his food, which had cooled;
The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child;
-
Did anything turn up in the media (not the statements) about how the Smith group was strung out?
That might give use more info about where Smithman came from and where Smithman went.
The best source for how the irrsh group were strung out is the set of photos taken by the PJ when they visited PDL with 3 of the irish group on 26 May 2007 - the photos are marked with the positions where each witness was when he/she passed sthe man. The man IMO definitely turned into Trav Das Escadhinas.
-
The best source for how the irrsh group were strung out is the set of photos taken by the PJ when they visited PDL with 3 of the irish group on 26 May 2007 - the photos are marked with the positions where each witness was when he/she passed sthe man. The man IMO definitely turned into Trav Das Escadhinas.
Nope the man went towards the church (Rua 25 de Abril) using the right apartments side path (where he passed behind Aoife) and hidden behind vehicles.
(http://s12.postimg.org/rgeqb7dlp/cars.jpg)
-
A correction.
The best source for how the irish group were strung out is the set of photos taken by the PJ when they visited PDL with 3 of the irish group on 26 May 2007 - the photos are marked with the three exact positions the man was at when each of these three witnesses passed him.
Look at the position labelled "A" this is where the man was when the 3rd of these three witnesses saw him. When she sees the man, he has just crossed Rua 25 Abril is on the south (closest to the sea) pavement of Rua 25 Abril. IMO this indicates almost certainly that the man then turned right into Trav Das Escadhinas.
-
A correction.
The best source for how the irish group were strung out is the set of photos taken by the PJ when they visited PDL with 3 of the irish group on 26 May 2007 - the photos are marked with the three exact positions the man was at when each of these three witnesses passed him.
Look at the position labelled "A" this is where the man was when the 3rd of these three witnesses saw him. When she sees the man, he has just crossed Rua 25 Abril is on the south (closest to the sea) pavement of Rua 25 Abril. IMO this indicates almost certainly that the man then turned right into Trav Das Escadhinas.
There were 9 eye witnesses in total to pass not 3. Where was Mary's position?
-
This is why I was interested in whether there was any information on positions outside the statements.
I'd like to know where Mary was, where the 2 young children were, and where two children of about Aoife's age were.
-
This is why I was interested in whether there was any information on positions outside the statements.
I'd like to know where Mary was, where the 2 young children were, and where two children of about Aoife's age were.
I don't know those answers, but from the statements, witnesses SS and PS were walking together.
-
I don't know those answers, but from the statements, witnesses SS and PS were walking together.
It's obvious where some were if he was the perp and went around them. They were blocking the quickest route and he would have to pass them close in a lighter area. He passed the first witnesses in a dark area.
-
It's obvious where some were if he was the perp and went around them. They were blocking the quickest route and he would have to pass them close in a lighter area. He passed the first witnesses in a dark area.
The red circle labelled "A" is where the man was when witness AS saw him.
The camera is roughly where witness AS was.
-
The red circle labelled "A" is where the man was when witness AS saw him.
The camera is roughly where witness AS was.
Where was she seconds before that spot? Hidden from him. If he didn't know she was suddenly going to appear then he got a surprise and moved a bit quicker @)(++(*
-
Where was she seconds before that spot? Hidden from him. If he didn't know she was suddenly going to appear then he got a surprise and moved a bit quicker @)(++(*
Viewed from the top of the lane of steps, here is the path of the man across the junction
-
Viewed from the top of the lane of steps, here is the path of the man across the junction
That is incorrect.
-
That is incorrect.
"a letra A indica onde AS viu o suspeito"
-
"a letra A indica onde AS viu o suspeito"
"The deponent remembers that upon reaching the top of the stairs, she looked to her left and saw a man (1) with a female child (2) in his arms, walking along the pavement of Rua 25 de Abril. He was walking in her direction at a distance of, give or take, two metres."
(http://s9.postimg.org/pxxwg0n3z/aoifeposition.jpg)
Walking along the pavement not crossing the road in front of her. He went away and around the witnesses and Aoife (age 12) appeared from behind the wall.
-
"...upon reaching the top of the stairs, she looked to her left and saw a man ... walking along the pavement of Rua 25 de Abril. He was walking in her direction at a distance of, give or take, two metres. The witness crossed to the other side of Rua 25 de Abril ..." (AS statement)
He was on the south (closest to the sea) pavement of R 25 Abr, to the witness's left.
-
I've just posted that part from her statement. He was on the pavement. He had already crossed the road further back from where Aoife saw him when she suddenly appeared from behind the wall. This means he went away from eye witnesses and I betcha he didn't expect her to appear.
-
That is incorrect.
Do you agree the man was at "A" when AS saw him?
-
Do you agree the man was at "A" when AS saw him?
When she got to the top of the steps she looked left and saw him heading towards her along the pavement so he should be around that spot. Smithman is the number one suspect who took Madeleine. Have no doubt about that - all evidence leads to him and not the child leaving on her own without any trace.
-
When she got to the top of the steps she looked left and saw him heading towards her along the pavement so he should be around that spot. Smithman is the number one suspect who took Madeleine. Have no doubt about that - all evidence leads to him and not the child leaving on her own without any trace.
Good so we agree he has changed his course to avoid colliding with the people walking opposite direction, but how are you sure he did not then go down stepped lane? His last reported position as stated by AS allows him to go either your way or down stepped lane.
-
Where was she seconds before that spot? Hidden from him. If he didn't know she was suddenly going to appear then he got a surprise and moved a bit quicker @)(++(*
Or slowed down a bit to avoid colliding? Two metres is very close (and a reason for believing "long sleeves")
-
Or slowed down a bit to avoid colliding? Two metres is very close (and a reason for believing "long sleeves")
That 12 year old witness is credible with the times she gave to the police. I don't think he went down those brightly lit narrow steps when it was safer the other darker way behind parked vehicles. His destination took him to the church then probably to the sea/rocks/beach.
— She was wearing light trousers, white or light pink, that may have been pyjamas. She does not remember if they were patterned as it was dark. The material was lightweight/thin and could have been cotton.
— She also had a light top, with long sleeves. She did not see it well because the individual had his arms around the child. She is not sure if the child's top was the same colour as her trousers, saying only that it was very light. The fabric was the same as the trousers.
-
That 12 year old witness is credible with the times she gave to the police. I don't think he went down those brightly lit narrow steps when it was safer the other darker way behind parked vehicles. His destination took him to the church then probably to the sea/rocks/beach.
— She was wearing light trousers, white or light pink, that may have been pyjamas. She does not remember if they were patterned as it was dark. The material was lightweight/thin and could have been cotton.
— She also had a light top, with long sleeves. She did not see it well because the individual had his arms around the child. She is not sure if the child's top was the same colour as her trousers, saying only that it was very light. The fabric was the same as the trousers.
So you think continue east on Rua 25 because it was darker and shielded by parked cars that way. But then when he goes from end of Rua 25 to church, wouldn't he be seen by people sitting outside Bull?
-
So you think continue east on Rua 25 because it was darker and shielded by parked cars that way. But then when he goes from end of Rua 25 to church, wouldn't he be seen by people sitting outside Bull?
I think somebody other that the Smiths must have seen him but you can't see his face from the Bull and it only takes seconds to get over that road.He didn't have to go past the actual pub.
(http://s15.postimg.org/vc394zrnv/thebull.jpg)
-
I think somebody other that the Smiths must have seen him but you can't see his face from the Bull and it only takes seconds to get over that road.He didn't have to go past the actual pub....
From the smith sighting the shore west of the fort is closer and less visible so why travel to your area of rocks?
-
From the smith sighting the shore west of the fort is closer and less visible so why travel to your area of rocks?
He didn't know the place so he used a simple less used route where he couldn't get lost.
-
He didn't know the place so he used a simple less used route where he couldn't get lost.
How many minutes' walk is that from 5a?
-
He didn't know the place so he used a simple less used route where he couldn't get lost.
Ok you're saying the person (I don't agree with your identification) didn't know the streets, fair enough.
-
How many minutes' walk is that from 5a?
5 minutes as a guess.
-
Ok you're saying the person (I don't agree with your identification) didn't know the streets, fair enough.
Amaral said a witness went missing from the files who had seen him on the beach. That was Amaral not me.
-
Amaral said a witness went missing from the files who had seen him on the beach. That was Amaral not me.
Did Amaral specify that witness was a UK citizen on a dark beach after 10pm on his/her own?
-
Did Amaral specify that witness was a UK citizen on a dark beach after 10pm on his/her own?
Yes there were more than one UK person alone on the dark beach after 10pm. Searching. For example reportedly (newspaper not files) two witnesses at about midnight saw a man searching and shouting her name at the topside of the beach to the east of Paraiso. Obviously one of the group searching.
-
He didn't know the place so he used a simple less used route where he couldn't get lost.
The route may be simple, but it is very definitely not less well used.
Rua 25 de Abril and Rua Direita are collectively known as the M537. This dates to a time when the main road from Burgau (west) to Lagos (east) went straight through the heart of Luz (centre). You can see this on Google maps. This was presumably before the N125 to the north.
I'd wager a bucket load of money that at the time the route was two-way. It makes no sense otherwise.
However, let us stick to the more relevant time. Here (photo) are the traffic signs immediately west and north of Rua 25 de Abril. What does ones beady eyes pick out?
Do you notice that 1) traffic from the west heading for Luz is directed to head down along 25 de Abril?
Do you notice that 2) the sign is not about how to get to the beach? That it says nothing about the praia? That it simply says, if you want Luz, then turn right?
Rua 25 de Abril is NOT a quiet backstreet in Luz. It is a MAJOR part of the Luz 1-way system. It is busy and it was busy in May 2007.
Please let me make it clear. I do NOT think that anyone driving down 25 de Abril at 10pm on that night would have given a single thought about a man with a child in his arms.
But the character of Luz has to be understood to progress this case. Luz was NOT quiet that night. It was NOT (as claimed by Amaral) closed for the evening.
If Smithman went along 25 de Abril, he fluked it.
-
Thanks Shining for bringing some local knowledge to the subject. Agreed Rua 25 Abril was not deserted - the parking spaces there were usually mostly taken. But on one small point, I claim my bucketful of money (I will PM you my bank account details and Euros are fine) because this part of Rua 25 Abr was already oneway eastbound, at least on 26 May 2007 it was, and I have a photo to prove it. But that simply adds additional proof of what you say, that it was not a deserted sidelane. (Source http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P6/06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1621.jpg lower photo, the permanent one way sign on a pole roughly where smithman was when AS saw him)
-
Thanks Shining for bringing some local knowledge to the subject. Rua 25 Abril was not deserted - the parking spaces there were usually mostly taken. But on one small point, I claim my bucketful of money (I will PM you my bank account details) because this part of Rua 25 Abr was already oneway eastbound (at least on 26 May 2007 it was) and I have a photo to prove it. But that simply adds additional proof of what you say, that it was not a deserted sidelane. (Source http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P6/06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1621.jpg lower photo the one way sign on a pole roughly where smithman was when AS saw him)
Please PM your bank details ASAP. I sense a large withdrawal coming on. I was talking about when the N125 did not exist, before the 1-way system had been invented. %£&)**#
Now, turning from the frivolous (that was me above) to the serious. I have just noticed one important reason why ANY photo of Luz from around that time is vitally important. So if you have a photo from 26/05/2007, please do us all a favour. Back it up. Then save it to cloud. Then secure it elsewhere.
That photo has, due to a recent change, become extremely valuable. If you have any others from the time, they have likewise increased in value.
This is sounding a bit too much like Antiques Road Show, but that is the pace of technology.
-
BTW if smithman had continued west along Rua 25 Abril towards the church he would have been visible from the windows of the chinese restaurant (red sign in lower photo) http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P6/06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1621.jpg
-
The route may be simple, but it is very definitely not less well used.
Rua 25 de Abril and Rua Direita are collectively known as the M537. This dates to a time when the main road from Burgau (west) to Lagos (east) went straight through the heart of Luz (centre). You can see this on Google maps. This was presumably before the N125 to the north.
I'd wager a bucket load of money that at the time the route was two-way. It makes no sense otherwise.
However, let us stick to the more relevant time. Here (photo) are the traffic signs immediately west and north of Rua 25 de Abril. What does ones beady eyes pick out?
Do you notice that 1) traffic from the west heading for Luz is directed to head down along 25 de Abril?
Do you notice that 2) the sign is not about how to get to the beach? That it says nothing about the praia? That it simply says, if you want Luz, then turn right?
Rua 25 de Abril is NOT a quiet backstreet in Luz. It is a MAJOR part of the Luz 1-way system. It is busy and it was busy in May 2007.
Please let me make it clear. I do NOT think that anyone driving down 25 de Abril at 10pm on that night would have given a single thought about a man with a child in his arms.
But the character of Luz has to be understood to progress this case. Luz was NOT quiet that night. It was NOT (as claimed by Amaral) closed for the evening.
If Smithman went along 25 de Abril, he fluked it.
I know it was quiet that night from the few Kelly's bar receipts, statements and lack of witnesses seeing the man. SY on CW released the efits to get any witnesses to come forward. I don't think you have many people walking the streets after 10 on a Thursday night unless you are out drinking. Jes saw nobody on the streets except Gerry. He went down Rua 25 de Abril mostly hidden behind cars. He got to the church then probably went to the rocks. He was seen on that beach.
-
I know it was quiet that night from the few Kelly's bar receipts, statements and lack of witnesses seeing the man. SY on CW released the efits to get any witnesses to come forward. I don't think you have many people walking the streets after 10 on a Thursday night unless you are out drinking. Jes saw nobody on the streets except Gerry. He went down Rua 25 de Abril mostly hidden behind cars. He got to the church then probably went to the rocks. He was seen on that beach.
The full OC guest records show that many more tourists were staying at OC than are on the MW guest lists.
And that is only one company. Add the large Estrela complex and the large St James complex and numerous tourist flats in other buildings and many rented villas and it adds up to a lot of tourists.
Many tourists go out for a meal most evenings (for example see the irish groups statements).
-
The full OC guest records show that many more tourists were staying at OC than are on the MW guest lists.
And that is only one company. Add the large Estrela complex and the large St James complex and numerous tourist flats in other buildings and many rented villas and it adds up to a lot of tourists.
Many tourists go out for a meal most evenings (for example see the irish groups statements).
And yet there is only the one sighting of Smithman and one of Tannerman
-
And yet there is only the one sighting of Smithman and one of Tannerman
I find that interesting too.
-
I know it was quiet that night from the few Kelly's bar receipts, statements and lack of witnesses seeing the man. SY on CW released the efits to get any witnesses to come forward. I don't think you have many people walking the streets after 10 on a Thursday night unless you are out drinking. Jes saw nobody on the streets except Gerry. He went down Rua 25 de Abril mostly hidden behind cars. He got to the church then probably went to the rocks. He was seen on that beach.
Jes Wilkins saw Jane Tanner, 'rasta man' and Leon and his girlfriend.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS-ROGATORY.htm
-
Jes Wilkins saw Jane Tanner, 'rasta man' and Leon and his girlfriend.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS-ROGATORY.htm
Rasta man was heading to the restaurant aka Michael James Sperrey. He was booked in at 9 the time Jes saw him. Jane was seen early at 8:30. Smithman was seen after 10pm unless your drinking I can't see many walking the streets at that time as a lack of witnesses prove.
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_608.jpg)
-
The full OC guest records show that many more tourists were staying at OC than are on the MW guest lists.
And that is only one company. Add the large Estrela complex and the large St James complex and numerous tourist flats in other buildings and many rented villas and it adds up to a lot of tourists.
Many tourists go out for a meal most evenings (for example see the irish groups statements).
Evidence proves otherwise. If there were many out then he would be seen by many and you would have to out in the streets in that 5 minute window of carrying time.
-
Evidence proves otherwise. If there were many out then he would be seen by many.
If there were many out and was seen by only 9 then he was walking a very short distance.
-
If there were many out and was seen by only 9 then he was walking a very short distance.
No he wasn't walking a short distance from 5A to the beach (500 metres but he ran the first stage so he wasn't slow) but I don't think many use the route around the wasteland in the dark. Do you think people are hanging round there in the cold and dark to watch people go past.
-
No he wasn't walking a short distance from 5A to the beach (500 metres but he ran the first stage so he wasn't slow) but I don't think many use the route around the wasteland in the dark. Do you think people are hanging round there in the cold and dark to watch people go past.
At 15 degrees C no thermals required and lots of people do walk along streets after sunset. There were other people on R Escola that night, later than the irish group. It's a populated area.
-
Rasta man was heading to the restaurant aka Michael James Sperrey. He was booked in at 9 the time Jes saw him. Jane was seen early at 8:30. Smithman was seen after 10pm unless your drinking I can't see many walking the streets at that time as a lack of witnesses prove.
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_608.jpg)
He didn't have dreadlocks though, did he. Strange this couple weren't interviewed, they were supposed to be there at 9pm, so should have been around for a while after that.
-
At 15 degrees C no thermals required and lots of people do walk along streets after sunset. There were other people on R Escola that night, later than the irish group. It's a populated area.
15 degrees C is positively balmy in my neck of the woods ... one father had no problem carrying his daughter around barefooted and without a blanket. Maybe there were two of them?
-
It was 5.45 p.m. when the team left the Ocean Club: Rebelo and one inspector then walked into the direction of the Praia da Luz belvedere - walking past the church - where they stood in observation for approximately five minutes. But they did not walk the fastest path, choosing instead to walk down several pedestrian streets of the village.
Correio da Manha - 30 October 2007
-
He didn't have dreadlocks though, did he. Strange this couple weren't interviewed, they were supposed to be there at 9pm, so should have been around for a while after that.
That booking is ticked but no table number, maybe they decided to takeaway instead?
-
He didn't have dreadlocks though, did he. Strange this couple weren't interviewed, they were supposed to be there at 9pm, so should have been around for a while after that.
Agreed it is strange. Easy to rule out and ask him if he had a band. It points to the Sperry's - blonde hair caucasian man.
I saw a man that was coming from the road and was headed to the reception. I believe that he was with a woman but I cannot be precise of any detail about her. It was a tall Caucasian man, with blonde hair in 'rasta style' tied with a band instead of free flowing.
-
Widow with vital clues was never questioned, 18 August 2007
A second witness spotted the man minutes later rushing past the church in the resort and heading to the sea front.
The dark-haired man was wearing white trousers and a dark jacket.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id331.html
a British tourist who said she saw the girl's...... to walk the beach at night. The revelation was made by the former PJ coordinator Gonçalo Amaral, who adds that the data of the witness disappeared.
"We tried to recover this testimony and the documents that were in the British sphere and simply disappeared. Still do not know who this person is and where it is," said Goncalo Amaral.
-
I know it was quiet that night from the few Kelly's bar receipts, statements and lack of witnesses seeing the man. SY on CW released the efits to get any witnesses to come forward. I don't think you have many people walking the streets after 10 on a Thursday night unless you are out drinking. Jes saw nobody on the streets except Gerry. He went down Rua 25 de Abril mostly hidden behind cars. He got to the church then probably went to the rocks. He was seen on that beach.
I know that Kelly's was quiet that night, from the receipts, therefore agreed.
In fact it I would describe it as dead. Q1 Why was it dead? Q2. If it was dead, why didn't the Smith 9 group in Kelly's stand out like a blazing beacon?
Jes was in an area of Luz that had few commercial establishments, and by that time, those were closed. There wasn't zero traffic or zero people, but it was quiet, much like most residential areas by 9:15.
Luz was not closed and there is no reason to believe it was quiet in general. The photo attached is a graphic of what was going on in Luz on 3 May 2007, re commercial establishments and facilities. The map works from around 8:30pm to around 10:30pm. If you wind it back to earlier, then things like the supermarkets were open whilst the cinema was closed. If you wind it forward to later, then things like the convenience stores shut down.
Please don't ask for detail. It took me around 8-10 posts to build this up at ShiningInLuz. The mind-numbing detail is over there, so if you need more, please visit my blog.
On 3 May 2007 around 10pm in the vicinity of the Smith sighting, Luz was lit up like a Christmas tree.
If Smithman went SE on Rua 25 de Abril, he fluked it. Or he's just an innocent person.
-
He took the safest route because if he took that other direct road to the church he definitely would be seen. Rua 25 de Abril has a Chinese restaurant but he was on the opposite side and hidden behind vehicles in the dark. It would only take him a few minutes to get to the rocks from there.
Pics Time 9:14pm Date Monday 7 June 2010 - Can you see anyone?
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4926896653_2dcb6bdbc8_z.jpg)
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4926896491_32f52472de_z.jpg)
-
Time 9:22pm Can you see anyone walking the streets? Smithman many not be seen anyone in a minute window from the church to the rocks but I think there would be someone who did.
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4926900927_7a7d8a6ba8_z.jpg)
-
Time 9:22pm Can you see anyone walking the streets? Smithman many not be seen anyone in a minute window from the church to the rocks but I think there would be someone who did.
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4926900927_7a7d8a6ba8_z.jpg)
You're going to have to come up with a solid source for the time.
1) The convenience store is closed. It shut at 10:30pm, not by 9:22.
2) The cars up and down either side of the street. The only residence on that side is the one attached to the Fortaleza, thus they are visitors, but to what?
So, you've got 5 restaurants in that area, a convenience store closed an hour early, and a bunch of cars that seem to be for evening diners. On top of that it is Monday 7th, not Thursday 3rd. Still quite a way to go.
-
You're going to have to come up with a solid source for the time.
1) The convenience store is closed. It shut at 10:30pm, not by 9:22.
2) The cars up and down either side of the street. The only residence on that side is the one attached to the Fortaleza, thus they are visitors, but to what?
So, you've got 5 restaurants in that area, a convenience store closed an hour early, and a bunch of cars that seem to be for evening diners. On top of that it is Monday 7th, not Thursday 3rd. Still quite a way to go.
Yes to get from the church to the rocks involves walking between 5 restaurants - on right the Forteleza, and on left Chaplins, Marujo, Atlantico, Pashmina. So there are many people out for a meal and drinks then walking home, or driving, as ShiningInLuz points out many of those parked cars are of diners. Also some are of restaurant staff. BTW the Irish group had on previous nights dined at both the Marujo and Chaplins.
-
You're going to have to come up with a solid source for the time.
1) The convenience store is closed. It shut at 10:30pm, not by 9:22.
2) The cars up and down either side of the street. The only residence on that side is the one attached to the Fortaleza, thus they are visitors, but to what?
So, you've got 5 restaurants in that area, a convenience store closed an hour early, and a bunch of cars that seem to be for evening diners. On top of that it is Monday 7th, not Thursday 3rd. Still quite a way to go.
Those pics were taken in June and the streets are dead. I've checked all his photos - the streets are deserted on that route at night. 3 May was a Thursday not a weekend. It is indeed possible but I think a few would have seen him. He is not hanging around, he is moving quickly to his destination which IMO was out of sight and away from street lights i.e. the beach/rocks.
9:18
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4927493964_4e0ab4b437_z.jpg)
-
Those pics were taken in June and the streets are dead. I've checked all his photos - the streets are deserted on that route at night. 3 May was a Thursday not a weekend. It is indeed possible but I think a few would have seen him. He is not hanging around, he is moving quickly to his destination which IMO was out of sight and away from street lights i.e. the beach/rocks.
So do you think Forteleza, Chaplins, Marujo, Atlantico, and Pashmina were all closed that night?
-
So do you think Forteleza, Chaplins, Marujo, Atlantico, and Pashmina were all closed that night?
He is a good distance away from Chaplins behind a hedge. Most people will be inside not outside waiting for Smithman to quickly move past. It's a very short distance from the church to the rocks.
People behind hedge not seen from Chaplins
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4945568383_9c4c901dc2_o.jpg)
-
Those pics were taken in June and the streets are dead. I've checked all his photos - the streets are deserted on that route at night. 3 May was a Thursday not a weekend. It is indeed possible but I think a few would have seen him. He is not hanging around, he is moving quickly to his destination which IMO was out of sight and away from street lights i.e. the beach/rocks.
9:18
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4927493964_4e0ab4b437_z.jpg)
My sincere apologies. When you said Mon 7 I mis-interpreted it as Monday 7 May 2007. I missed the fact that it is Monday 7 June 2010, which changes things totally.
So, the convenience store went bust at some time with debts of €70m. I wish I could run up a tab like that. I have no precise idea when it went bankrupt, merely that the shop in question sat empty for a couple of years, before emerging as a chemist.
May 2007 must have been pretty close to the top of the bubble. I would have thought June 2010 was pretty close to as bad as it got.
If so, we have two completely non-comparable situations. Boom 2007 v bust 2010. Does this tell us anything about Madeleine's case?
-
The block of restaurants south of church were chaplins, marujo, atlantico (all were open in may 2007, for example the irish party dined at two of them), and what was the 4th (not the current restaurant but what was it in 2007)?
Almost all diners going to or from these 4 restaurants would pass in front of the church main entrance. Also people would be coming and going from the flats above these restaurants.
-
8 August 2007
Drogheda Independent
A Drogheda family who may hold vital clues as to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann have hit out at media distortion of evidence that they have given to Portuguese police. Maple Drive man Martin Smith, his wife and his children had just left the Kelly bar, which is located approximately 400 metres from the McCanns' apartment at the Ocean Club between 9.50-10pm on the night Madeleine disappeared. They returned to Ireland the next day, and because the reported abduction times didn't originally match, they never had cause to examine their journey that night.
As it emerged that Madeleine was abducted around the same time, one of the family members had a flashback of the moment some time later and encouraged the others to jog their memory.
They remembered passing a man walking towards the beach with a child in his arms. Other than his approximate height and the fact that he was wearing beige clothes they cannot be more specific than that. We are annoyed at how vague our description is, said the family member.
The family contacted the Portuguese police and flew back over to give evidence.
However, contrary to media reports, Mr Smith had not seen chief suspect Robert Murat in a bar the evening that Madeleine was abducted.He definitely didn't see him on the night in question, said a family member.
The family are also mystified at reports that he knows Mr Murat. They met once in a bar about two years ago. My dad would only know Mr Murat by sight, said the family member. However, from what he knows, he can say that the man who was carrying the child was not Robert Murat.
-
@Pathfinder http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4945568383_9c4c901dc2_o.jpg
the area near the drain outlet which is under that pergola thing is the only place on this bit of shore concealed from view so isn't that the obvious choice for your theory's concealor?
-
@Pathfinder http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/fl/4945568383_9c4c901dc2_o.jpg
the area near the drain outlet which is under that pergola thing is the only place on this bit of shore concealed from view so isn't that the obvious choice for your theory's concealor?
I would head straight to the rocks and hide something underneath.
(http://s16.postimg.org/n4sspmd7p/underrocks.jpg)
-
I would head straight to the rocks and hide something underneath.
(http://s16.postimg.org/n4sspmd7p/underrocks.jpg)
Eddie searched the beach.
-
Eddie searched the beach.
Eddie concentrated on the Rocha Negra side of the beach. I don't know how much time was spent on the church side rocky area and sea water could possibly affect it. That would be a temporary hiding spot until it can be moved to a safer place. The drains would have been examined.
-
I would head straight to the rocks and hide something underneath.
http://s16.postimg.org/n4sspmd7p/underrocks.jpg
Where exactly on the shore is the this photo you posted? http://s16.postimg.org/n4sspmd7p/underrocks.jpg
-
Eddie concentrated on the Rocha Negra side of the beach. I don't know how much time was spent on the church side rocky area and sea water could possibly affect it. That would be a temporary hiding spot until it can be moved to a safer place. The drains would have been examined.
But Eddie can locate miniscule remains of a 100 yr old corpse, hidden in a rockface, from a considerable distance on a beach, as shown in Jersey. You think that Grime, accompanied by the PJ, didn't search the beach thoroughly?
-
(snip)... The drains would have been examined.
Probably only at the outlets on the shore.
But the airflow in those large diameter stormwater drains would be uphill IMO.
-
Where exactly on the shore is the this photo you posted? http://s16.postimg.org/n4sspmd7p/underrocks.jpg
The rocky area opposite the church. I'm not saying it's that exact rock but that's the kind of place where you could temporarily and quickly hide.
-
But Eddie can locate miniscule remains of a 100 yr old corpse, hidden in a rockface, from a considerable distance on a beach, as shown in Jersey. You think that Grime, accompanied by the PJ, didn't search the beach thoroughly?
Not that part and it was low tide at 10pm on 3 May so most of the rocky area was accessible.
-
Not that part and it was low tide at 10pm on 3 May so most of the rocky area was accessible.
Yes if any hypothetical concealor chooses which part of this your rocky area to go to, it's obvious to choose the one part which is concealed from view, I will try to find you a photo.
-
http://youtu.be/InJLmyakzeE?t=20m26s from 20m26s to 21m20s several experts visit this rocky area including drain outlet
-
http://youtu.be/InJLmyakzeE?t=20m26s from 20m26s to 21m20s several experts visit this rocky area including drain outlet
An excellent documentary given that it was made prior to the FSS results being released, a pity in a way it hadn't been delayed till then.
It would have been very interesting to see what their opinion of the results would have added to the programme.
"I've got water and I've got a confined space, and I've got people trained in both" Gary Lig ... former Senior Search Advisor ... West Yorkshire Police, said as he inspected disused wells on the outskirts of Praia da Luz.