UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 04:31:34 PM

Title: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 04:31:34 PM
Something that is seldom mentioned (AFAIK) is that, apparently, Amaral launched his own private investigation & put a team together to investigate the case.Does anyone know what happened to that one?

http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/04/amaral-and-former-policemen-are.html

Amaral and former policemen are investigating the "Maddie" case Jornal de Notícias
 
Former coordinator reveals that Portuguese, Spanish, English and Germans are working with him
 
by Alexandra Serôdio
30 April 2009
Thanks to Joana Morais for translation
 
A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense.
 
The former Judiciária coordinator told JN that the result will be communicated to the Attorney General.
 
Restlessness and curiosity were heavy and the bitter taste of a "precocious and political" archiving left them "brooding" on a solution. The words are from Gonçalo Amaral – the first head of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann – who reveals that the group of investigators, that is made up by Portuguese, Spanish, English and Germans, wants to "know the truth".
 
"We have been talking, exchanging ideas, trying to understand what happened, discussing possibilities and thinking about the entire process", the former coordinator of the Polícia Judiciária's Criminal Investigation Department in Portimão reveals. Despite refusing to reveal what is being done on the field and in what form, he asserts that "this investigation is not to arrange for evidence against the McCann couple".
 
"We want to contribute for the truth to be known and in that way, for justice to be made. If there are guilty people, they must stand before justice. This is a right that assists any citizen in this country, to fight for justice to be done in every case", Gonçalo Amaral sustained, stressing that "it's not only the courts, the policemen and the judges that fight for justice, anyone can do it".
 
Asserting that this investigation does "not intend to persecute anyone", the former coordinator stresses the need to understand "what could have been done back then and what can be done now". Always in an attempt to "find the truth and to understand what really happened to Madeleine". Opting not to reveal major details, Gonçalo Amaral says that the group is made of retired policemen, who investigate "at their own expense" and "without the use of funds".
 
What is established will then be put into a "well based document" that will be delivered to the Attorney General, with the request to reopen the process that has been archived since July 21, 2007.
 
"The criminal investigation was abruptly interrupted, before it even got halfway. There is still a lot to be investigated that may even lead nowhere, but it may lead to other paths and to the truth", the former coordinator advances, asking for "political courage" to those who have the power to "reopen the process".
 
"If the Attorney General's mailbox was flooded with, for example, three million requests to reopen the process, I believe the case might be reopened", the investigator stated.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id233.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 04:35:52 PM
Something that is seldom mentioned (AFAIK) is that, apparently, Amaral launched his own private investigation & put a team together to investigate the case.Does anyone know what happened to that one?

http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/04/amaral-and-former-policemen-are.html

Amaral and former policemen are investigating the "Maddie" case Jornal de Notícias
 
Former coordinator reveals that Portuguese, Spanish, English and Germans are working with him
 
by Alexandra Serôdio
30 April 2009
Thanks to Joana Morais for translation
 
A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense.
 
The former Judiciária coordinator told JN that the result will be communicated to the Attorney General.
 
Restlessness and curiosity were heavy and the bitter taste of a "precocious and political" archiving left them "brooding" on a solution. The words are from Gonçalo Amaral – the first head of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann – who reveals that the group of investigators, that is made up by Portuguese, Spanish, English and Germans, wants to "know the truth".
 
"We have been talking, exchanging ideas, trying to understand what happened, discussing possibilities and thinking about the entire process", the former coordinator of the Polícia Judiciária's Criminal Investigation Department in Portimão reveals. Despite refusing to reveal what is being done on the field and in what form, he asserts that "this investigation is not to arrange for evidence against the McCann couple".
 
"We want to contribute for the truth to be known and in that way, for justice to be made. If there are guilty people, they must stand before justice. This is a right that assists any citizen in this country, to fight for justice to be done in every case", Gonçalo Amaral sustained, stressing that "it's not only the courts, the policemen and the judges that fight for justice, anyone can do it".
 
Asserting that this investigation does "not intend to persecute anyone", the former coordinator stresses the need to understand "what could have been done back then and what can be done now". Always in an attempt to "find the truth and to understand what really happened to Madeleine". Opting not to reveal major details, Gonçalo Amaral says that the group is made of retired policemen, who investigate "at their own expense" and "without the use of funds".
 
What is established will then be put into a "well based document" that will be delivered to the Attorney General, with the request to reopen the process that has been archived since July 21, 2007.
 
"The criminal investigation was abruptly interrupted, before it even got halfway. There is still a lot to be investigated that may even lead nowhere, but it may lead to other paths and to the truth", the former coordinator advances, asking for "political courage" to those who have the power to "reopen the process".
 
"If the Attorney General's mailbox was flooded with, for example, three million requests to reopen the process, I believe the case might be reopened", the investigator stated.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id233.html

Never heard anything after that.

It fizzled out.

Was he too busy with defending himself and later being convicted of a criminal offence to concentrate on it?  Were the other cops involved Almeida (also on trial at the time and later convicted) and Cristovao (currently on trial for very serious offences)?

It would be nice if Joana Morais updated us on this.

She could at the same time update us on the state of that Amaral fund as well, another thing that came and went. It would be interesting to know what happened to the money so generously donated.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mo Stache on June 03, 2013, 04:40:33 PM
"A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense." How is that allowed, if the McCann's were told that it was against Portuguese law to have PI's investigating a case in Portugal. If this group of policemen are 'former' then that makes them citizens doing a private investigation, not so?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 04:42:31 PM
"A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense." How is that allowed, if the McCann's were told that it was against Portuguese law to have PI's investigating a case in Portugal. If this group of policemen are 'former' then that makes them citizens doing a private investigation, not so?

Possibly it was OK as it was after the archival of the process?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mo Stache on June 03, 2013, 04:46:27 PM
"A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense." How is that allowed, if the McCann's were told that it was against Portuguese law to have PI's investigating a case in Portugal. If this group of policemen are 'former' then that makes them citizens doing a private investigation, not so?

Possibly it was OK as it was after the archival of the process?
Could be.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 05:06:02 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 05:10:42 PM
"A group of former policemen from Portugal and other countries, which includes Gonçalo Amaral, is investigating the Maddie case at their own expense." How is that allowed, if the McCann's were told that it was against Portuguese law to have PI's investigating a case in Portugal. If this group of policemen are 'former' then that makes them citizens doing a private investigation, not so?

LOL, would that be Cristoavo's security company, Mo? I'm surprised he didn't send someone to the bank, or put spy camera's up.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 05:15:14 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?

What was his take on the outcome, amaraltheofficeboy?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 03, 2013, 05:19:26 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?

I have absolutely no recollection of any outcome other than various spoutings by pals (and perhaps himself) in the PT TV Guide and on matinée PT TV chat shows.

 
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 05:19:43 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?

What was his take on the outcome, amaraltheofficeboy?

the missing pink blanket would solve the case - he was perfectly serious.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 05:21:03 PM
he wanted to get on to Oprah
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 03, 2013, 05:28:03 PM


the missing pink blanket would solve the case - he was perfectly serious.

Was't Sargento the one who kept talking in ominous tones about a supposedly missing pink blanket - which, in fact, had been given to the PT dogs to try to locate her?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 03, 2013, 05:41:20 PM
Paulo Reis and associates were also supposed to crack the case.

On cell phone calls:

 More on the deleted call records
Where Was Kate McCann? (*)
Thursday, 4 December 2008
By Paulo Reis and associates

(*) This report is a result of cooperation with a leading international investigative firm that is in the closing stages of an 18 month intensive investigation that is expected to reopen the case in Portugal and to start new proceedings in the UK.

http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html



There were others... Some were so bizarre that I'm not sure that they're even still online.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 05:58:14 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?

What was his take on the outcome, amaraltheofficeboy?

the missing pink blanket would solve the case - he was perfectly serious.

But in his book, Amaral say's, The pink blanket is also really tidy, almost folded. Pointing to it on the bed.


(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_p305OiLZRCU/SlpU4vAsTDI/AAAAAAAAFnY/lOnWerZZZ-4/s400/bedroom3.jpg)

So IF, it was missing, shouldn't he be asking the forensic chappies?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 06:13:41 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

I am serious about this - he appeared on many TV shows to report this outcome.

didn't he even write to some US show to try to get on to explain?

What was his take on the outcome, amaraltheofficeboy?

the missing pink blanket would solve the case - he was perfectly serious.

But in his book, Amaral say's, The pink blanket is also really tidy, almost folded. Pointing to it on the bed.

(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_p305OiLZRCU/SlpU4vAsTDI/AAAAAAAAFnY/lOnWerZZZ-4/s400/bedroom3.jpg)

So IF, it was missing, shouldn't he be asking the forensic chappies?
Or those GNR chappies?

Didn't they get hold of it to use when their sniffer dogs needed something to sniff?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 06:14:59 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 03, 2013, 06:25:31 PM
Somehow, I don't think he read the files before giving his considered professional opinion.
Neither had he actually understood the conversation on Oprah's.

Details, details...


Paulo Sargento: «Public Ministry Cannot Dismiss the Blanket’s Disappearance»

Paulo Sargento, the psychologist which usually comments on the TV aspects related to the Maddie case, explained to «SP» the importance that this blanket had to the British child : “The blankets, toys, and other objects acquire a special meaning for children at early stages of their lives. Dr. Winnicot, a famous paediatrician, conceived a designation of transitional objects (most times, plush toys, small blankets, diapers, etc...) which attain some special characteristics to children. Has I have been saying, this objects that the paediatrician adjectived of transitional, are invested of a particular passion by the children, even some addiction (in the sense of affective dependency), since they possess symbolic characteristics of security, comfort, care and other qualities which emanate from the maternal figure.”

For Paulo Sargento, the thesis that Gonçalo Amaral revealed at first hand to «SP» that the blanket could have been used in a funerary ceremony at the Luz chapel “is very interesting”.

And he adds: “In reality, when the McCanns went to Oprah’s Show [video excerpt here], the blanket was mentioned. At a given moment, when Oprah tells Kate that she heard her mention a blanket several times, Kate argued that a mother who misses a child always wants to know if she is comfortable, if she is warm, and added, referring to Maddie, that sometimes she asked herself if the person who had taken her would cover her up with her little blanket (but the blanket was on the bed after Maddie, supposedly, disappeared!!!).

Well, that blanket is missing. Nobody knows where it is. But, this brief dialogue between Oprah and Kate is bizarre and looks like a slip. It seems that blanket is a word that shouldn’t have emerged under that circumstance because it didn’t find a meaning that would fit into the conversation, and the justification was very confusing”.

For Paulo Sargento, this piece of data should have been investigated without any prejudice, taking into view the possibility of someone within the Church keeping a prudent silence about the matter: “The Catholic Church follows a divine saying, that is sometimes applied to Zeno of Cyprus: “If God gave us two ears and one mouth, it was because we are meant to listen twice as much as we talk.”

The Catholic Church has had the capacity to remain silent, to keep secrets and to transform them into myths”. The psychologist has no doubts: “The disappearance of one object from the frame of a crime scene cannot be dismissed this lightly. The decisions lie in the hands of the Prosecutor and the Public Ministry”.


http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/07/maddies-blanket-missing-from-ocean-club.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 03, 2013, 06:28:54 PM
Paulo Reis and associates were also supposed to crack the case.

On cell phone calls:

 More on the deleted call records
Where Was Kate McCann? (*)
Thursday, 4 December 2008
By Paulo Reis and associates

(*) This report is a result of cooperation with a leading international investigative firm that is in the closing stages of an 18 month intensive investigation that is expected to reopen the case in Portugal and to start new proceedings in the UK.

http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html



There were others... Some were so bizarre that I'm not sure that they're even still online.

That's an interesting link,  thanks Carana

Has any of that phone analysis been verified in the police files  ?   

(  particularly the part  about Kate using her phone in the apartment at the time Mrs Fenn says she heard crying  ) 
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 06:29:34 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm

Well he found it for this, Gilet, Mrs B.

Around 3.25 .

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 06:30:32 PM
but but I remember him wanting to go on Oprah to tell about the pink blanket
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 06:32:54 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm

Well he found it for this, Gilet, Mrs B.

Around 3.25 .

Isn't that just part of the mock up of a reconstruction that Amaral did for the cameras?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 06:41:47 PM
Paulo Reis and associates were also supposed to crack the case.

On cell phone calls:

 More on the deleted call records
Where Was Kate McCann? (*)
Thursday, 4 December 2008
By Paulo Reis and associates

(*) This report is a result of cooperation with a leading international investigative firm that is in the closing stages of an 18 month intensive investigation that is expected to reopen the case in Portugal and to start new proceedings in the UK.

http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html

There were others... Some were so bizarre that I'm not sure that they're even still online.

Getting this far was enough, Carana.

"However, both Jane Tanner and Russell O’Brien have stated that he did not go to the Tapas Bar on the “Quiz Night” (ie Tuesday 1st May 2007), but had stayed in their room looking after his sick daughter. Jane Tanner took his dinner to the room; thus explaining the unused plate setting. Russell O’Brien was not asked by either the Policia Judiciaria or Leicestershire Police whether he had heard Madeleine crying"!

More BS, from him. He changed his tune, to suit. Remember him saying, "There is no way Madeleine's parents were involved?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 06:47:43 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 03, 2013, 06:49:28 PM
Paulo Reis and associates were also supposed to crack the case.

On cell phone calls:

 More on the deleted call records
Where Was Kate McCann? (*)
Thursday, 4 December 2008
By Paulo Reis and associates

(*) This report is a result of cooperation with a leading international investigative firm that is in the closing stages of an 18 month intensive investigation that is expected to reopen the case in Portugal and to start new proceedings in the UK.

http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html



There were others... Some were so bizarre that I'm not sure that they're even still online.

That's an interesting link,  thanks Carana

Has any of that phone analysis been verified in the police files  ?   

(  particularly the part  about Kate using her phone in the apartment at the time Mrs Fenn says she heard crying  )

I can't remember offhand. When I checked I didn't find anything odd at all.

In another article (also around 5 years ago), "associates" were also waiting for a bombshell report that they had independently initiated  a forensic analysis of the creche signatures. This led to much excitement at the time that the signatures had been forged.

Depending on the source of mythology, this was supposed to be a handwriting analysis and/ or an ink analysis.

I've never heard anything since.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 06:50:16 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm

Well he found it for this, Gilet, Mrs B.

Around 3.25 .

Isn't that just part of the mock up of a reconstruction that Amaral did for the cameras?

It is supposedly,  Madeleine McCann - The Truth of the Lie - Goncalo Amaral's documentary (1 of 6).

I'm just saying the blanket didn't go missing, the way he was insinuating.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 06:50:46 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm

Well he found it for this, Gilet, Mrs B.

Around 3.25 .

That blanket sure gets around then, I think it was even referred to as the long awaited "Ace up the Sleeve" that somehow never seem to materialize.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 06:52:04 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?

It makes you laugh when they come up with such ludicrous ideas in their desperation to put the McCanns to shame.

In reality they are thoroughly embarrassing themselves with their own ignorance.



Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: DCI on June 03, 2013, 06:53:59 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?

 @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

Yeah! And know their name. He was in ca·hoots with Levy, thats enough to make you use the nutter bin. OMOOC!

Thursday, 4 December 2008

By Paulo Reis and associates

(*) This report is a result of cooperation with a leading international investigative firm that is in the closing stages of an 18 month intensive investigation that is expected to reopen the case in Portugal and to start new proceedings in the UK.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 06:54:23 PM
are you mocking amaral??????????

 
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on June 03, 2013, 06:56:31 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?

triangulation in the modern World

(but we're not in the modern World are we?)
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 07:03:01 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?


triangulation in the modern World

(but we're not in the modern World are we?)

Not in 2007 though, the mobile networks were diabolical in those areas back then.

ETA & btw triangulation by this lot? Have you read it? It's a laughable. http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 07:44:26 PM
Excuse me, but who on earth can determine EXACTLY where a person is when speaking on a mobile phone? AFAIK that's impossible, you can only ping a mobile to the nearest mast, surely nobody is daft enough to think every apartment in the block had their own mobile phone mast?


triangulation in the modern World

(but we're not in the modern World are we?)

Not in 2007 though, the mobile networks were diabolical in those areas back then.

ETA & btw triangulation by this lot? Have you read it? It's a laughable. http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.uk/2008/12/more-on-deleted-call-records.html

Having read that nonsense I suspect Reis became embarrassed and withdrew and the leading international investigative firm simply went out of business.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: TTSOFAFM on June 03, 2013, 09:20:45 PM
the outcome was the pink blanket

You forgot the stamp.
But the burning question is this, did he find the pink blanket and the buy the stamp before finding the deep freezer?

And if anyone thinks I am being sarcastic.. here is Amaral going on about the freezer..

Quote
GA: If we take into account that, if we consider the traces that were found in the car boot…

JP: … which are in fact…

GA: … which are in fact from the little girl. In order to justify that bodily fluid as the lab says, it could only have been preserved and conserved in the cold because otherwise it would have been…

JP: That means that…

GA: … in an advanced state of decomposition, at least it’s a hypothesis. Therefore it’s a question of a deep freezer, or something similar, and there we had to search for it and that was what we were doing. This means, the contacts that they had, where they went, where they were seen… There are people who say that they were seen entering an apartment block near the cemetery in Praia da Luz. At that point in time we weren’t able to detect which apartment they entered, who lived there, because it’s also a bit complicated because you have to understand it’s a tourist area and often it’s not known who the apartment belongs to.

JP: Of course, of course…

GA: Who lives there, for how long they live there, so all of that was being worked upon. To try to understand the support…

JP: If someone discovered a deep freezer in the area and…

GA: If it was actually a deep freezer, it doesn’t exist anymore now.

http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2008/09/little-girl-died-in-that-apartment.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 03, 2013, 10:57:16 PM
But it never was missing - it was given to Portuguese Dog handler.

The just talked to some colleagues from the PJ and asked for a piece of clothing that Madeleine had worn or used recently. They were given a pink/orange blanket that the child had been covered with in her bed.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm
Never missing, yes, just offered to dogs in hope they would follow the scent. And one did on that fateful night.
GA wasn't there anyway and had he read Winnicott he would have guessed CC was a kind of transitional object for Mrs McCann (see the rosaries CC had around).
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 03, 2013, 11:01:10 PM
freezer, it doesn’t exist anymore now.
Do you really have to post this ? Bad taste really if not ridiculous.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: TTSOFAFM on June 03, 2013, 11:03:13 PM
freezer, it doesn’t exist anymore now.
Do you really have to post this ? Bad taste really if not ridiculous.
Amaral's words not mine. And I agree his words are in bad taste.  Especially as we now know Madeleine's DNA/Bodily Fluids were NOT in the hired car.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 03, 2013, 11:09:41 PM
freezer, it doesn’t exist anymore now.
Do you really have to post this ? Bad taste really if not ridiculous.

Why are you stating that the content of Goncalo Amaral's own book is bad taste and ridiculous?

Do we not have a right (maybe even a duty) to read his book and to reflect on its contents?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 03, 2013, 11:17:29 PM
I find the suggestion that a body was kept hidden for weeks and then transported in a hire car to be most unlikely

Just as I find it unlikely that an abductor would  be walking the streets of PDL with a child he had snatched from her bed almost an hour before still in his arms

Both scenarios are unlikely,  but then,  neither is impossible I suppose
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 11:21:34 PM
There is quite a difference between the two scenarios though, there is not one scintilla of evidence of the first one but quite a large group of people did witness someone carrying a child of the same age as Madeleine in the area.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 03, 2013, 11:25:09 PM
There is quite a difference between the two scenarios though, there is not one scintilla of evidence of the first one but quite a large group of people did witness someone carrying a child of the same age as Madeleine in the area.

Yes I know

What I find unlikely is the McCann's suggestiion that it was the  same man Jane Tanner saw almost an hour before

As I say though,  it's not impossible  ...  none of the scenarios suggested have been proven to be impossible
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 03, 2013, 11:29:41 PM
No, but I repeat, there is no evidence whatsoever of the first scenario whatsoever but there are witness statements suggesting the second one may possible.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 03, 2013, 11:50:51 PM
There is quite a difference between the two scenarios though, there is not one scintilla of evidence of the first one but quite a large group of people did witness someone carrying a child of the same age as Madeleine in the area.

Yes I know

What I find unlikely is the McCann's suggestiion that it was the  same man Jane Tanner saw almost an hour before

As I say though,  it's not impossible  ...  none of the scenarios suggested have been proven to be impossible

I think there are just too many striking similarities between the man seen by the Smiths and the man JT saw for it to be two different men and too different little girls.  The fact that neither JT nor the Smiths knew of one anothers descriptions is very pertinent imo.     

There is no evidence at all to back up Amaral's 'fridge' theory.


Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 12:01:52 AM
JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.
The pink blanket dog and the towel sniffer dogs didn't follow JT carrier, nor the Smith carrier. That's weird.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 12:02:50 AM
There is quite a difference between the two scenarios though, there is not one scintilla of evidence of the first one but quite a large group of people did witness someone carrying a child of the same age as Madeleine in the area.

Yes I know

What I find unlikely is the McCann's suggestiion that it was the  same man Jane Tanner saw almost an hour before

As I say though,  it's not impossible  ...  none of the scenarios suggested have been proven to be impossible

I think there are just too many striking similarities between the man seen by the Smiths and the man JT saw for it to be two different men and too different little girls.  The fact that neither JT nor the Smiths knew of one anothers descriptions is very pertinent imo.     

There is no evidence at all to back up Amaral's 'fridge' theory.

Amaral's theory, however unevidenced, has not been proven to be impossible

Just as the abductor theory, equally unevidenced,   has not been proven impossible either
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 12:09:23 AM
Well, feel free to provide a credible or even possible scenario that fits in with Amaral's theory. We have been waiting for it a long time.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 12:09:39 AM
There is quite a difference between the two scenarios though, there is not one scintilla of evidence of the first one but quite a large group of people did witness someone carrying a child of the same age as Madeleine in the area.

Yes I know

What I find unlikely is the McCann's suggestiion that it was the  same man Jane Tanner saw almost an hour before

As I say though,  it's not impossible  ...  none of the scenarios suggested have been proven to be impossible

I think there are just too many striking similarities between the man seen by the Smiths and the man JT saw for it to be two different men and too different little girls.  The fact that neither JT nor the Smiths knew of one anothers descriptions is very pertinent imo.     

There is no evidence at all to back up Amaral's 'fridge' theory.

Amaral's theory, however unevidenced, has not been proven to be impossible

Just as the abductor theory, equally unevidenced,   has not been proven impossible either

The claim that the fridge theory for which there is no evidence and the abduction theory are "equally unevidenced" is ridiculous.

It is a fact that there is no evidence at all for the fridge theory.

It is a fact that there is clear evidence of a possible abductor. There are a number of witnesses who have all testified to seeing a child being carried away from the vicinity of the apartment within an hour or so of the disappearance.

Neither of these possible abductors has ever come forward.

Suggesting that the two theories are "equally unevidenced" is simply not telling the truth and is utterly ridiculous.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 12:10:21 AM

JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.

She knew it wasn't a baby being carried, and so did the Smiths.

She saw that the child was wearing light coloured pajamas, and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child was not covered by a blanket and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child's feet were bare - and so did the Smiths.

Both JT and the Smiths said the man did not look like a tourist.

And then there are all the other similarities regarding the man himself.

Far too many for it to be a coincidence IMO.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: muratfan on June 04, 2013, 12:10:39 AM
Well, feel free to provide a credible or even possible scenario that fits in with Amaral's theory. We have been waiting for it a long time.

Do I have time to put the kettle on
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 12:15:59 AM
Well, feel free to provide a credible or even possible scenario that fits in with Amaral's theory. We have been waiting for it a long time.

Do I have time to put the kettle on

Two sugars for me please Muratfan.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 12:17:14 AM

JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.

She knew it wasn't a baby being carried, and so did the Smiths.

She saw that the child was wearing light coloured pajamas, and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child was not covered by a blanket and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child's feet were bare - and so did the Smiths.

Both JT and the Smiths said the man did not look like a tourist.

And then there are all the other similarities regarding the man himself.

Far too many for it to be a coincidence IMO.

Why do people state that this man (or even these men) are not evidence of a possible abductor?

It is stretching the bounds of reason to suggest as they do that neither of them could have anything to do with the case.  Even more so when after the worldwide publicity neither has ever come forward to eliminate themselves.

It is perfectly clear from the statements in the files (the actual evidence) that this/these men were potential abductors of a child about the age of Madeleine McCann (right time frame, right size child).  It is even very likely that both JT and the Smiths saw the same man as the descriptions are so similar in a number of ways.

Why anti-McCann posters deny this as evidence of a possible abductor is a puzzle to all sensible people who can immediately see its relevance to the inquiry.  It just makes them look as if they are unwilling to accept what is in the real evidence (the files) and you have to wonder why that is.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 12:22:46 AM

JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.

She knew it wasn't a baby being carried, and so did the Smiths.

She saw that the child was wearing light coloured pajamas, and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child was not covered by a blanket and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child's feet were bare - and so did the Smiths.

Both JT and the Smiths said the man did not look like a tourist.

And then there are all the other similarities regarding the man himself.

Far too many for it to be a coincidence IMO.

Why do people state that this man (or even these men) are not evidence of a possible abductor?

It is stretching the bounds of reason to suggest as they do that neither of them could have anything to do with the case.  Even more so when after the worldwide publicity neither has ever come forward to eliminate themselves.

It is perfectly clear from the statements in the files (the actual evidence) that this/these men were potential abductors of a child about the age of Madeleine McCann (right time frame, right size child).  It is even very likely that both JT and the Smiths saw the same man as the descriptions are so similar in a number of ways.

Why anti-McCann posters deny this as evidence of a possible abductor is a puzzle to all sensible people who can immediately see its relevance to the inquiry.  It just makes them look as if they are unwilling to accept what is in the real evidence (the files) and you have to wonder why that is.

Indeed - they are ignoring the witness statements of 4 people - 3 of whom were completely independent witnesses who didn't even know the McCanns.



Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 12:23:19 AM

JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.

She knew it wasn't a baby being carried, and so did the Smiths.

She saw that the child was wearing light coloured pajamas, and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child was not covered by a blanket and so did the Smiths

She saw that the child's feet were bare - and so did the Smiths.

Both JT and the Smiths said the man did not look like a tourist.

And then there are all the other similarities regarding the man himself.

Far too many for it to be a coincidence IMO.

Why do people state that this man (or even these men) are not evidence of a possible abductor?

It is stretching the bounds of reason to suggest as they do that neither of them could have anything to do with the case.  Even more so when after the worldwide publicity neither has ever come forward to eliminate themselves.

It is perfectly clear from the statements in the files (the actual evidence) that this/these men were potential abductors of a child about the age of Madeleine McCann (right time frame, right size child).  It is even very likely that both JT and the Smiths saw the same man as the descriptions are so similar in a number of ways.

Why anti-McCann posters deny this as evidence of a possible abductor is a puzzle to all sensible people who can immediately see its relevance to the inquiry.  It just makes them look as if they are unwilling to accept what is in the real evidence (the files) and you have to wonder why that is.

Well not me ...  I certainly acknowledge that the two men seen carrying a child by witnesses that night  is evidence of  a  'possible' abductor

In just the same way that the alerts by a cadaver dog in the apartment where a missing child was last seen is evidence of her  'possible' death 

No theory is any more evidenced than another
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 12:27:54 AM
JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.
The pink blanket dog and the towel sniffer dogs didn't follow JT carrier, nor the Smith carrier. That's weird.

Granted, but a little girls feet are usually much daintier and often plumper with tiny toes, than a little boys.  Finer bones.

The human mind clocks these tiny details without even knowing it .. and so determines the probable sex.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 12:34:52 AM
There is a huge difference between a POSSIBLE scenario & an IMPOSSIBLE scenario, if known facts are taken into account. Amaral's version is of the second variety.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 12:57:59 AM
There is a huge difference between a POSSIBLE scenario & an IMPOSSIBLE scenario, if known facts are taken into account. Amaral's version is of the second variety.

That just won't do Mrs B

There is nothing  to say Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

(  Just as there is nothing to say the McCann's abductor theory is  'impossible'  )
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 01:02:15 AM
Yes, it's totally impossible actually, unless you expect people to evaporate into thin air.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 01:04:55 AM
There is a huge difference between a POSSIBLE scenario & an IMPOSSIBLE scenario, if known facts are taken into account. Amaral's version is of the second variety.

That just won't do Mrs B

There is nothing  to say Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

(  Just as there is nothing to say the McCann's abductor theory is  'impossible'  )

If you can put forward a credible theory of how the McCanns 'dunnit' in the way Amaral is purporting  - then I will be more than happy to consider it with an open mind - and that's a promise.






Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 01:05:56 AM
Icabod, if you, or anyone, can make a sensible suggestion as to how the McCanns could have dunit (ie an abduction or anything else) then I am all ears

,,,and I promise you I will analyse what you are saying, if it has a hope of being correct


So far nobody has made anything like a decent suggestion to indicate the McCanns dunit ... or were involved in any way.

Come on lets have your ideas
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 01:07:50 AM
There is a huge difference between a POSSIBLE scenario & an IMPOSSIBLE scenario, if known facts are taken into account. Amaral's version is of the second variety.

That just won't do Mrs B

There is nothing  to say Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

(  Just as there is nothing to say the McCann's abductor theory is  'impossible'  )

If you can put forward a credible theory of how the McCanns 'dunnit' in the way Amaral is purporting  - then I will be more than happy to consider it with an open mind - and that's a promise.

Yes, so will I & that's a promise too.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:09:15 AM
Yes, it's totally impossible actually, unless you expect people to evaporate into thin air.

That is your personal belief and opinion  ...  to which you are perfectly entitled  ..  but is not  proof that Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

There is nothing, in fact,  in the way of evidence, that you can produce to prove that Amaral's theory is 'impossible'

...  nothing at all 
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 01:14:38 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:17:02 AM

No theory is any more evidenced than another

So what is the evidence EQUAL to AT LEAST FOUR WITNESSES for the fridge theory? You said there was equal evidence. What is it?

And with regard to the dogs you seem to be forgetting completely that it was the expert dog handler Grime himself who said very clearly that no evidential reliabilty could be placed on their alerts without forensic confirmation. As there was no forensic confirmation then no the evidence of the dog alerts is by Grime's reckoning not unreliable.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 01:20:01 AM
Yes, it's totally impossible actually, unless you expect people to evaporate into thin air.

That is your personal belief and opinion  ...  to which you are perfectly entitled  ..  but is not  proof that Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

There is nothing, in fact,  in the way of evidence, that you can produce to prove that Amaral's theory is 'impossible'

...  nothing at all

I think you're missing the point Icab, which is that Amaral cannot produce a shred of evidence to prove his theory IS possible.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:20:50 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:21:19 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:22:09 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven

What evidence for the fridge EQUAL to four witnesses exists for the fridge?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:25:53 AM
Yes, it's totally impossible actually, unless you expect people to evaporate into thin air.

That is your personal belief and opinion  ...  to which you are perfectly entitled  ..  but is not  proof that Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

There is nothing, in fact,  in the way of evidence, that you can produce to prove that Amaral's theory is 'impossible'

...  nothing at all

I think you're missing the point Icab, which is that Amaral cannot produce a shred of evidence to prove his theory IS possible.

Not missing the point at all Benice  ...  I am fully aware that there is no  'hard evidence'  that proves Amaral's theory is correct 

Just as there is no  'hard evidence'  that proves the McCann's theory is correct

The 'point'  is that neither theory can be  disproven
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 01:27:23 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven

Amarals theory is unproven because he can't prove it  - as he does not have an iota of evidence.  Nothing.  Zilch.
 
The sightings are proven because we have the the witnesses statements which prove them - and they ARE evidence of a possible abduction.

How can you say they are both the same?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:28:23 AM
Yes, it's totally impossible actually, unless you expect people to evaporate into thin air.

That is your personal belief and opinion  ...  to which you are perfectly entitled  ..  but is not  proof that Amaral's theory is  'impossible'

There is nothing, in fact,  in the way of evidence, that you can produce to prove that Amaral's theory is 'impossible'

...  nothing at all

I think you're missing the point Icab, which is that Amaral cannot produce a shred of evidence to prove his theory IS possible.

Not missing the point at all Benice  ...  I am fully aware that there is no  'hard evidence'  that proves Amaral's theory is correct 

Just as there is no  'hard evidence'  that proves the McCann's theory is correct

The 'point'  is that neither theory can be  disproven

If there is no "hard evidence" which supports the fridge theory then what "soft" evidence is there?

Actually I think you are wrong and that witnesses (particularly independent) witnesses if not "hard" evidence are considered as pretty dammed good evidence.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:32:45 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven

Amarals theory is unproven because he can't prove it  - as he does not have an iota of evidence.  Nothing.  Zilch.
 
The sightings are proven because we have the the witnesses statements which prove them - and they ARE evidence of a possible abduction.

How can you say they are both the same?

It is really interesting watching posters pushing these bizarre unrealistic claims as far as they can.

Icabodcrane is deliberately avoiding the issue.

There is clear, good evidence of a possible abductor. Namely the witnesses, at least four excellent witnesses mostly entirely independent of the family.

There is absolutely not one item of evidence in favour of the fridge theory. And he is avoiding at all costs the demands for him to say what this nothingness actually is in his mind.

Yet he bizarrely claims that this nothingness (he has had plenty of opportunity to say what it is but has not done so) is equal to four living witnesses who saw the person who was carrying a child and has never been identified.

It makes you laugh actually at the effort needed by them to keep pushing NOTHINGNESS as evidence.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:33:02 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven

Amarals theory is unproven because he can't prove it  - as he does not have an iota of evidence.  Nothing.  Zilch.
 
The sightings are proven because we have the the witnesses statements which prove them - and they ARE evidence of a possible abduction.

How can you say they are both the same?

That's not true Benice   

The McCann's have the fact that two men were seen carrying a child that night

Amaral has the fact that a cadaver dog alerted in the apartment where the missing child was last seen

Both pieces of evidence are  questionable ...  but both exist 
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:34:40 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.



Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:36:44 AM
No, I think pretty much both the AG & Scotland Yard have dismissed Amaral's bonkers "theory". Mainly because it simply isn't consistent with known facts, which is a pretty persuasive reason to dismiss it IMO.

Amaral's theory is unproven  (  I don't think it has ever been refered to as  'bonkers'  by any official source though ) 

...  in the same way the McCann's theory is unproven

Amarals theory is unproven because he can't prove it  - as he does not have an iota of evidence.  Nothing.  Zilch.
 
The sightings are proven because we have the the witnesses statements which prove them - and they ARE evidence of a possible abduction.

How can you say they are both the same?

That's not true Benice   

The McCann's have the fact that two men were seen carrying a child that night

Amaral has the fact that a cadaver dog alerted in the apartment where the missing child was last seen

Both pieces of evidence are  questionable ...  but both exist

So Grime says the alerts are not to be relied upon and yet you give the dog alerts equal credence to four or more independent witnesses to a potential abductor.

Clearly you are one clever fellow. You know better than the dog handler himself.

But dog alerts do not evidence the fridge. What is the evidence for the FRIDGE?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:38:27 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: registrar on June 04, 2013, 01:47:14 AM
Amaral turned his (then) fat bottom in his bed after he was made co-ordinator of the case

No need to rush down to Luz - that'll keep

It was only when Amaral saw the juggernaut of international media hit Luz - literally scores of trucks with satellite dishes, a little local affair - suddenly turning global!

That's when the man started panicking

And the wonder dogs were the last resort to save his reputation - to ill effect as we know

Macho bevaviour is rife in these parts - and NO -  Goncalo was not going to be outdone by a pretty, blonde English doctor of medicine,

not being a great fan of Kate - that book was ill-advised at best

But Amaral DID meet his match in her 

Good on you Kate
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:50:10 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory

Nor can you match the witnesses with anything whatsoever that supports a fridge.

Witnesses do not equal your blank nothingness.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 01:51:13 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.


Wow, I can't wait.

Well you'll have to

I am not convinced by Amaral's theory

Nor am I convinced by the McCann's abductor theory

This is not a question of black or white  ...  there is a grey area inbetween,  and that is where I'm lodged
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:55:33 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.


Wow, I can't wait.

Well you'll have to

I am not convinced by Amaral's theory

Nor am I convinced by the McCann's abductor theory

This is not a question of black or white  ...  there is a grey area inbetween,  and that is where I'm lodged

But there is absolutely no equality between a fridge that nobody has ever seen except the wholly discredited Goncalo Amaral who was dismissed from the case and is desperate to salvage his reputation (according to him) and four or more witnesses who actually saw a living human being carrying a child from the very location where a child went missing not more than a few minutes prior to there sighting.

Anyone who claims the level of evidence between those is delusional (IMO of course).

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: registrar on June 04, 2013, 01:57:51 AM
the 'fridge' is SOOOO 2007

get over it
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 02:00:56 AM
Rubbish reply.
You are an anti first and formost.
You try to tread a fine line sometimes but your agenda is here for everyone to see.

Well,  you're wrong there

Anyway, I'm off to watch The Voice  ( recorded the knock out shows ) 

Goodnight all
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 02:06:41 AM

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory
That's pretty fair.
The two theories have a common point : a child carrier.
GA might think that JT saw him later than 21h10, but he believes the Smith family no doubt.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 02:17:04 AM

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory
That's pretty fair.
The two theories have a common point : a child carrier.
GA might think that JT saw him later than 21h10, but he believes the Smith family no doubt.

But there is still no evidence of a fridge.

Sheer desperation.

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 02:25:57 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 02:37:22 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?

Why forget the crucial part of Amaral's theory? Can you not make it fit?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sika on June 04, 2013, 07:01:39 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.
I've noticed that also.

I don't really know why they are tolerated on here. It gets more like Tesko Towers every day.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 08:25:52 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?

Why forget the crucial part of Amaral's theory? Can you not make it fit?

It's indeed a crucial part of Amaral's theory - he makes that very clear here - where he also lines out the "sedation by Calpol" part of his theory. http://www.elmundo.es/elmundo/2008/09/06/internacional/1220677421.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 04, 2013, 08:52:44 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?

It's wasn't just a working hypothesis for Amaral, though.


"The cadaver was frozen"

Correio da Manhã - What do you think happened to the body?

Gonçalo Amaral – Everything indicated that the body, after having been at a certain location, was moved into another location by car, twenty something days later. With the residues that were found inside the car, the little girl had to have been transported inside it.

How can you state that?

Due to the type of fluid, we policemen, experts, say that the cadaver was frozen or preserved in the cold and when placed into the car boot, with the heat at that time [of the year], part of the ice melted. On a curb, for example, something fell from the trunk's right side, above the wheel. It may be said that this is speculation, but it's the only way to explain what happened there.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id139.html
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 04, 2013, 08:54:33 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.
I've noticed that also.

I don't really know why they are tolerated on here. It gets more like Tesko Towers every day.

LOL
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Chinagirl on June 04, 2013, 08:56:21 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?

It's wasn't just a working hypothesis for Amaral, though.


"The cadaver was frozen"

Correio da Manhã - What do you think happened to the body?

Gonçalo Amaral – Everything indicated that the body, after having been at a certain location, was moved into another location by car, twenty something days later. With the residues that were found inside the car, the little girl had to have been transported inside it.

How can you state that?

Due to the type of fluid, we policemen, experts, say that the cadaver was frozen or preserved in the cold and when placed into the car boot, with the heat at that time [of the year], part of the ice melted. On a curb, for example, something fell from the trunk's right side, above the wheel. It may be said that this is speculation, but it's the only way to explain what happened there.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id139.html

Indeed, Carana.  And this is one of the stupidest comments I have ever heard from an adult, never mind a senior police officer!

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 09:14:01 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory

I can't disprove that Madeleine wasn't whisked away by air balloon, or by aliens - but common sense tells me that isn't what happened.   

With respect Icab - IMO that is what is lacking in your 'argument' - i.e. the application of simple 'common sense'.   

Something which I have noticed is invariably absent in most Sceptics' assertions at every level of this case.




 

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: registrar on June 04, 2013, 09:35:57 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory

I can't disprove that Madeleine wasn't whisked away by air balloon, or by aliens - but common sense tells me that isn't what happened.   

With respect Icab - IMO that is what is lacking in your 'argument' - i.e. the application of simple 'common sense'.   

Something which I have noticed is invariably absent in most Sceptics' assertions at every level of this case.

Let's deal with this post point by point

'common sense' is not as common as all that, it's a rare commodity

That's the pattern and it goes like a red thread through all these forums - be sceptical of G&K and their child care arrangements -

And get browbeaten by DM reading minnies - telling you not be ghastly to the poor suffering parents

They are suffering - no doubt they are - but they invoked a PR machine within less of 24 hours of Madeleine's disappearance - which they themselves called 'Team McCann'

They created that monster - let's not have tiny tears purleeze
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 09:41:56 AM
Perhaps it would be an interesting exercise to use known statements from Amaral to piece together exactly WHAT his theory consist of & compare that to known facts, witness statements, info etc from the case files?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 04, 2013, 09:45:00 AM
Forget the freezer, just a work hypothesis obviously, and let's concentrate on what joins both theories, the child carrier. Any doubt about his existence ?

It's wasn't just a working hypothesis for Amaral, though.


"The cadaver was frozen"

Correio da Manhã - What do you think happened to the body?

Gonçalo Amaral – Everything indicated that the body, after having been at a certain location, was moved into another location by car, twenty something days later. With the residues that were found inside the car, the little girl had to have been transported inside it.

How can you state that?

Due to the type of fluid, we policemen, experts, say that the cadaver was frozen or preserved in the cold and when placed into the car boot, with the heat at that time [of the year], part of the ice melted. On a curb, for example, something fell from the trunk's right side, above the wheel. It may be said that this is speculation, but it's the only way to explain what happened there.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id139.html

Indeed, Carana.  And this is one of the stupidest comments I have ever heard from an adult, never mind a senior police officer!

He and his team mates seem to have had selective reading syndrome.

With the residues that were found inside the car, the little girl had to have been transported inside it.

10-Processo 10 - 2615 to 2616
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2615
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2616

Letter dated 11 September regarding FSS report received by PJ
on on 4 September from Leicester Police, citing 15/19 matches of Madeleine DNA
profile

This serves to add [to the case file] a laboratory examination report prepared
in England, written in English and translated into Portuguese, delivered to this
police force on 4 September 2007 by English police officer Stuart Prior.

This laboratory report tells about the examinations made of two trace evidence
recoveries, one behind the living room sofa in apartment 5A and the other in the
boot area of the vehicle used by the McCann family, hired [by them] from the end of May this year.

In some of these recoveries (samples) DNA was found whose components are also
found in the profile of Madeleine McCann.

With respect to the trace evidence recovered behind the sofa all the confirmed
DNA components coincide with corresponding components in the DNA profile of
Madeleine McCann.

In the sample collected in the boot area of the vehicle, 15 of the identified
DNA components coincide with the corresponding components in the DNA profile of
Madeleine McCann, this of [having] 19 components.


Portimao, 11 September 2007
Inspector
Joao Carlos


---
 See also Madeleines DNA
10- Processo 10 - VOLUME Xa; PDF page 123-124; Case file pages 2617-2618.
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2617
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2618
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2619
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2620
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2621
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2622
10VOLUME_Xa_Page_2623

Task Portugal
From: "Prior Stuart" <Stuart.Prior@leicestershire.pnn.police.uk>
To: "Task Portugal" <Task.Portugal@leicestershire.pnn.police.uk>
Sent: 04 September 2007 10:14
Subject: FW: Op Task - in Confidence

From: Lowe, Mr J R [mailto:John.Lowe@fss.pnn.police.uk
Sent: 03 September 2007 15:01
To: stuart.prior@leicestershire.pnn.police.uk
Subject: Op Task - In Confidence

Stuart

Firstly, here are the last three results you are expecting

An incomplete DNA result was obtained from cellular material on the swab 3a. The swab contained very little information and showed low level indications of DNA from more than one person. However, all of the confirmed DNA components within this result match the corresponding components in the DNA profile of Madeline McCann. LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.

There is no evidence to support the view that Madeline MCCann contributed DNA to the swab 3B.

A complex LCN DNA result which appeared to have originated from at least three people was obtained from cellular material recovered from the luggage compartment section 286C 2007 CRL10 (2) area 2. Within the DNA profile of Madeline McCann there are 20 DNA components represented by 19 peaks on a chart. At one of the areas of DNA we routinely examine Madeleine has inherited the same DNA component from both parents; this appears therefore as 1 peak rather than 2, hence 19 rather than 20. Of these 19 components 15 are present within the result from this item; there are 37 components in total. There are 37 components because there are at least 3 contributors; but there could be up to five contributors. In my opinion therefore this result is too complex for meaningful interpretation/inclusion.

Why - ...

Well lets look at the question that is being asked

"Is there DNA from Madeline on the swab "

It would be very simple to say "yes" simply because of the number of components within the result that are also in her reference sample.

What we need to consider, as scientists, is whether the match is genuine and legitimate; because Madeline has deposited DNA as a result of being in the car or whether Madeline merely appears to match the result by chance. The individual components in Madeline's profile are not unique to her, it is the specific combination of 19 components that makes her profile unique above all others. Elements of Madeline's profile are also present within the the profiles of many of the scientists here in Birmingham, myself included. it's important to stress that 50% of Madeline's profile will be shared with each parent. It is not possible in a mixture of more than two people, to determine or evaluate which specific DNA components pair with each other. Namely, we cannot separate the components out into 3 individual DNA profiles.

Therefore, we cannot answer the question: is the match genuine or is it a chance match.

The same applies to any result that is quoted as being too complex for meaningful inclusion/interpretation

What questions will we never be able to answer with LCN DNA profiling -

When was the DNA deposited -
How was the DNA deposited -
What body fluid(s) does the DIVA originate from -
Was a crime committed -

These, along with all other results, will be formalised in a final report

Please don't hesitate to contact me if you require any further assistance

kind regards
John
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Carana on June 04, 2013, 09:49:56 AM
Perhaps it would be an interesting exercise to use known statements from Amaral to piece together exactly WHAT his theory consist of & compare that to known facts, witness statements, info etc from the case files?

I think that would make for a very interesting thread, Mrs B. Or perhaps several.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 10:06:50 AM

I can't disprove that Madeleine wasn't whisked away by air balloon, or by aliens - but common sense tells me that isn't what happened.   

With respect Icab - IMO that is what is lacking in your 'argument' - i.e. the application of simple 'common sense'.   

Something which I have noticed is invariably absent in most Sceptics' assertions at every level of this case.
Benice, the "alien" hypothesis doesn't seem operative, common sense or not. The child carrier wasn't green nor blue nor yellow, just a human being walking like you and me, carrying a child everybody thought was his.
Gonçalo Amaral doesn't deny the existence of this man !
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 10:19:46 AM

I can't disprove that Madeleine wasn't whisked away by air balloon, or by aliens - but common sense tells me that isn't what happened.   

With respect Icab - IMO that is what is lacking in your 'argument' - i.e. the application of simple 'common sense'.   

Something which I have noticed is invariably absent in most Sceptics' assertions at every level of this case.
Benice, the "alien" hypothesis doesn't seem operative, common sense or not. The child carrier wasn't green nor blue nor yellow, just a human being walking like you and me, carrying a child everybody thought was his. Gonçalo Amaral doesn't deny the existence of this man !

 carrying a child everybody thought was his.   Just a minority of very vocal and rather nasty minded peeps think this Anne.  Most people do NOT as is shown by opinion poll
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 10:20:54 AM
everybody who saw him, obviously.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 10:24:25 AM
The alien abductor could have been a shape-shifting lizard - it's a theory that simply cannot be disproved.

Yes, true & since Bennett & his fans seemingly now have taken up permanent residency at  David Icke's Conspiracy Central HQ, the likelihood of that theory popping up is higher than ever before.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 10:24:56 AM
Perhaps it would be an interesting exercise to use known statements from Amaral to piece together exactly WHAT his theory consist of & compare that to known facts, witness statements, info etc from the case files?

I think that would make for a very interesting thread, Mrs B. Or perhaps several.

Excellent idea.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 10:29:03 AM
everybody who saw him, obviously.

Would you kindly point out where in Aoife or Peter Smith's statements this information appears, I cannot seem to find it?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 10:33:13 AM
everybody who saw him, obviously.
You are obviously very desperate Anne to make such untrue assertions.  Prove it.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Benice on June 04, 2013, 10:34:30 AM
I would also like someone to put even a half-hearted theory together which works with Amaral's fridge scenario.

I notice that he never managed to put one together. Odd that as it was the crux of his theory.

But lets see the anti McCann posters try instead.

No anti has ever put a credible theory together.
Strange that.

Not even the great Goncalo himself has ever put a theory forward which makes any sense of the fridge.

Not just strange but blinking incredible as its his theory.

Anyway I am sure Icabodcrane is just teasing and is about to post up both the EVIDENCE for the fridge and a credible theory how it all happened.

I have no intention, means, or inclination to  'prove' Amaral's theory

My point is,  that you can't  disprove it

In the same way that those who question the McCanns cannot disprove the abductor theory

I can't disprove that Madeleine wasn't whisked away by air balloon, or by aliens - but common sense tells me that isn't what happened.   

With respect Icab - IMO that is what is lacking in your 'argument' - i.e. the application of simple 'common sense'.   

Something which I have noticed is invariably absent in most Sceptics' assertions at every level of this case.

Let's deal with this post point by point

'common sense' is not as common as all that, it's a rare commodity

That's the pattern and it goes like a red thread through all these forums - be sceptical of G&K and their child care arrangements -

And get browbeaten by DM reading minnies - telling you not be ghastly to the poor suffering parents

They are suffering - no doubt they are - but they invoked a PR machine within less of 24 hours of Madeleine's disappearance - which they themselves called 'Team McCann'

They created that monster - let's not have tiny tears purleeze

If common sense was such a rare commodity - then IMO the human race would have been extinct long ago.

Sorry Registrar, but I don't see the relevance of the rest of your post to mine. 

p.s. what or who is DM please?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Angelo222 on June 04, 2013, 11:13:51 AM
JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.
The pink blanket dog and the towel sniffer dogs didn't follow JT carrier, nor the Smith carrier. That's weird.

It isn't weird in the least Anne.  Madeleine never touched the ground, she was always about 4 foot above it.  Sniffer dogs cannot follow an air scent unless the trail is hot.  Too much time had transpired before the dogs were brought in.  In the end they followed Madeleine's scent down the road to a point opposite the secondary reception, a route she would have walked in order to get to the mini club.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 11:34:11 AM
The below may be of interest re. the Portuguese dogs used

His dog's speciality is patrolling (Maintenance of Public Order) although the dog also has some training in "tracking".


http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLOS-LACAO.htm
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Angelo222 on June 04, 2013, 11:49:21 AM
My own opinion of amaral is that his theory is bonkers.  He thought he had his perps and was gleefully awaiting the forensics to charge them when his entire world collapsed and he was forced to back pedal pronto with his waggly tail dangling behind.  We know that Amaral was a bully and a thug from his prosecution.  He stood back and allowed that poor woman to be beaten and then tried to pass it off as an accident.  He tried to get Kate to cop a plea but she wasn't having any of it.  Had ther not have been such a media interest in the case undoubtedly Kate would have ended up with black eyes and bruises as well.

Amaral's theory is bullshit, pure and simple.  The silly drunk is stuck with it now though so he is dammed if he does and dammed if he doesn'(.  Karma IMO!!   

PS Dogs can only track a cold trail if the persons feet touch the ground.  Ever see Cool Hand Luke?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 12:03:15 PM
JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.
The pink blanket dog and the towel sniffer dogs didn't follow JT carrier, nor the Smith carrier. That's weird.

It isn't weird in the least Anne.  Madeleine never touched the ground, she was always about 4 foot above it.  Sniffer dogs cannot follow an air scent unless the trail is hot.  Too much time had transpired before the dogs were brought in.  In the end they followed Madeleine's scent down the road to a point opposite the secondary reception, a route she would have walked in order to get to the mini club.

Angelo, you have got that in a nutshell 8((()*/.  Exactly my thoughts, but better put.

Even the dogs that were used a few days afterwards followed that same air trail we are told, yet it had been very gusty, the dogs were ground scent dogs ... and Madeleines actual feet had trodden some of that pathway the very day she was abducted

Sorry to use bad language but the PT dogs trails are Boll**.  At best it is a dog 'cock up' and at worst, a false trail was laid.

It is my belief that either

1)  A false trail was left
2)  The dogs were not really scent trail dogs
3)  The trail the dogs showed was the route that the lifter took, probably as he was approaching the apartment prior to the abduction ... and the scent was picked up from Madeleines cuddle blanket which the lifter had handled

The fact that Madeleines towel was supposedly used for the second scent trail done later (several days later?) does rather point to some interference by ?PJ. 

Cos what is certain is that no dog would follow such an air scent several days later, when his expertise is ground scent and Madeleine had walked across certian sectors of that route the very day she went missing


PT dogs = Bo***x

QED

Please correct me if I have any facts wrong.  Thanks
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: TTSOFAFM on June 04, 2013, 01:34:41 PM
Section B of the Archiving Dispatch mentions the use of the tracker dogs and states that they were not up to the challenge as they are trained to work more in rural areas than urban or populated areas.

http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

Quote
At 08.00 the GNR Search and Rescue sniffer dog team came into action, searches were begun from the resort in the direction of the beach, covering a 2 km area; in Praia da Luz 300m radius searches were made as well searches of abandoned houses, wells and waste land, the radius subsequently being expanded to 600m including the verges of the EN 125 motorway.
 
Subsequently an attempt was made to reconstruct the route taken by Madeleine by giving the dogs a blanket/towel used by her, but the results were not significant, given that the dogs are more trained for use in rural areas rather than urban or populated areas, the existence of more odours in the air making it impossible for the tracker dog to identify/locate the “target smell”.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:41:07 PM
Section B of the Archiving Dispatch mentions the use of the tracker dogs and states that they were not up to the challenge as they are trained to work more in rural areas than urban or populated areas.

http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

Quote
At 08.00 the GNR Search and Rescue sniffer dog team came into action, searches were begun from the resort in the direction of the beach, covering a 2 km area; in Praia da Luz 300m radius searches were made as well searches of abandoned houses, wells and waste land, the radius subsequently being expanded to 600m including the verges of the EN 125 motorway.
 
Subsequently an attempt was made to reconstruct the route taken by Madeleine by giving the dogs a blanket/towel used by her, but the results were not significant, given that the dogs are more trained for use in rural areas rather than urban or populated areas, the existence of more odours in the air making it impossible for the tracker dog to identify/locate the “target smell”.

Oh dear. So Amaral managed to muster photographers who forgot to take the most important photos, fingerprint experts who he says were not really expert and now dogs who were not up to the task.

Did the Portuguese have any decent resources to use in this case or was everything sub-standard?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 01:41:54 PM
everybody who saw him, obviously.

Would you kindly point out where in Aoife or Peter Smith's statements this information appears, I cannot seem to find it?
Are you suggesting they thought they saw an abductor ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 01:45:00 PM
everybody who saw him, obviously.

Would you kindly point out where in Aoife or Peter Smith's statements this information appears, I cannot seem to find it?
Are you suggesting they thought they saw an abductor ?

I doubt anyone at the time of their sighting thought they saw an abductor.

Firstly, they had no idea a child had been abducted so that suspicion would not have been in their minds.

Secondly, at least some of them actually tell us they thought it was a man carrying his own child maybe back from the creche.

And thirdly if they thought it was an abductor don't you think they would have done something at the very moment they saw him?

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 01:54:33 PM
JT didn't see a little girl, but legs.
The pink blanket dog and the towel sniffer dogs didn't follow JT carrier, nor the Smith carrier. That's weird.

It isn't weird in the least Anne.  Madeleine never touched the ground, she was always about 4 foot above it.  Sniffer dogs cannot follow an air scent unless the trail is hot.  Too much time had transpired before the dogs were brought in.  In the end they followed Madeleine's scent down the road to a point opposite the secondary reception, a route she would have walked in order to get to the mini club.
Sorry, Angelo, but this isn't true. You don't have to touch the ground for molecules to fall down from your body on the ground according to gravity principle.
The first dog, the one who "spoiled" the crime scene with its hairs because, by norm, the tracker dog must start from the last point where the missing person was seen, in this case Madeleine's bedroom, well this first dog, Numi, a patrol dog with a bit of tracking training, didn't hesitate and turned around the G5, whereas its colleague, a pure patrol dog, didn't react at all.
This occurred about 4 hours after Madeleine had gone.
The following day, Rex, an expert sniffer dog from the GNR national school, followed the same track as Numi, 24 hours after Madeleine had gone. A third dog from the GNR school followed also the same route (but could have followed Rex track in case of hesitation, see how GNR handlers are honest !).
Then Rex was sent on the trail 8 days after and again did the same route.
The only way to make sure the child wouldn't have left scent was to wrap her or put her in a holdall for example. We know the carrier didn't.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 02:01:04 PM
everybody who saw him, obviously.

Would you kindly point out where in Aoife or Peter Smith's statements this information appears, I cannot seem to find it?
Are you suggesting they thought they saw an abductor ?

No, I'm asking you to clarify your below statement & my question was where exactly in the statements of the above witnesses do they state that they thought it was "his child" - I simply can't seem to find that.

"The child carrier wasn't green nor blue nor yellow, just a human being walking like you and me, carrying a child everybody thought was his. "
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 02:12:11 PM
everybody who saw him, obviously.

Would you kindly point out where in Aoife or Peter Smith's statements this information appears, I cannot seem to find it?
Are you suggesting they thought they saw an abductor ?

No, I'm asking you to clarify your below statement & my question was where exactly in the statements of the above witnesses do they state that they thought it was "his child" - I simply can't seem to find that.

"The child carrier wasn't green nor blue nor yellow, just a human being walking like you and me, carrying a child everybody thought was his. "
There you are, Mrs B :
He (Martin S) notes that it is normal to see people carrying children, especially during the holiday season. This individual was walking the downward path, in the opposite direction. He is not aware where this person was headed. He only saw him as they passed each other. He assumed it was a father and daughter and thought nothing more of it.
The carrier was too old to be an elder brother and too young to be a grand father, hence Martin S "assumed it was a father". What's interesting is that Martin S saw no abnormality in the carrier's behaviour, nothing violent or weird, this is why he "thought nothing more of it".
I find it positive : the carrier wasn't a monster.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 02:14:18 PM
My own opinion of amaral is that his theory is bonkers.  He thought he had his perps and was gleefully awaiting the forensics to charge them when his entire world collapsed and he was forced to back pedal pronto with his waggly tail dangling behind.  We know that Amaral was a bully and a thug from his prosecution.  He stood back and allowed that poor woman to be beaten and then tried to pass it off as an accident.  He tried to get Kate to cop a plea but she wasn't having any of it.  Had ther not have been such a media interest in the case undoubtedly Kate would have ended up with black eyes and bruises as well.

Amaral's theory is bullshit, pure and simple.  The silly drunk is stuck with it now though so he is dammed if he does and dammed if he doesn'(.  Karma IMO!!   

PS Dogs can only track a cold trail if the persons feet touch the ground.  Ever see Cool Hand Luke?

Seriously, are you citing a movie as evidence?
Is there any actual scientific evidence that this is the case?


Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 02:16:19 PM
So when did Mr. Smith become "everybody"? I can't see any of the OTHER witnesses stating they thought that & THAT was my question.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 02:20:48 PM
My own opinion of amaral is that his theory is bonkers.  He thought he had his perps and was gleefully awaiting the forensics to charge them when his entire world collapsed and he was forced to back pedal pronto with his waggly tail dangling behind.  We know that Amaral was a bully and a thug from his prosecution.  He stood back and allowed that poor woman to be beaten and then tried to pass it off as an accident.  He tried to get Kate to cop a plea but she wasn't having any of it.  Had ther not have been such a media interest in the case undoubtedly Kate would have ended up with black eyes and bruises as well.

Amaral's theory is bullshit, pure and simple.  The silly drunk is stuck with it now though so he is dammed if he does and dammed if he doesn'(.  Karma IMO!!   

PS Dogs can only track a cold trail if the persons feet touch the ground.  Ever see Cool Hand Luke?

Seriously, are you citing a movie as evidence?
Is there any actual scientific evidence that this is the case?

According to the files, the Portuguese dogs were tracker dogs though, not air sniffing dogs. I've been looking for any credible source where it states they are able to track people who are being carried by others, but I can't seem to find any. How much skin cells are likely to fall to the ground if a small person is being carried by another person? Isn't it more likely cells get attached to the person carrying?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 02:34:29 PM
So when did Mr. Smith become "everybody"? I can't see any of the OTHER witnesses stating they thought that & THAT was my question.
Jane T had this feeling too, otherwise she would have alerted, wouldn't she have ?  Or do you doubt her ? BTW Jane T is the only person I saw sobbing in this mysterious case. Everybody who saw the carrier thought he was a normal person carrying most likely his child, none of them found him weird and predator like. These people can't be blamed.
Have you already carried other people's children in the middle of the night, Mrs B ?
Kids, when sleeping, want their dad or mum, nobody else. Unless they're sedated of course.

Now, if you have a link to one of the 1 + 5 witnesses stating he/she doubted the carrier was a father, please kindly send it !
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 02:39:46 PM
How much skin cells are likely to fall to the ground if a small person is being carried by another person? Isn't it more likely cells get attached to the person carrying?
The carrier had shoes, the child none.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 02:45:04 PM
It is YOU who have stated "everybody" thought the carrier was the father, is it not? I have not stated that at all. I agree that Mr. Smith apparently made that comment, but as far as I can see, NOBODY else did.

& I'm sorry but I'm not even getting the point about the carrying other people's sleeping children. If that was Madeleine that was seen by the Smith group, nobody AFAIK has suggested that she would be sleeping a natural sleep, without first having been subdued in one way or the other.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 02:47:31 PM
How much skin cells are likely to fall to the ground if a small person is being carried by another person? Isn't it more likely cells get attached to the person carrying?
The carrier had shoes, the child none.

So how much of those skin cells would have attached themselves to the clothes of the person carrying the child? Is there a study somewhere we can check?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: gilet on June 04, 2013, 02:51:52 PM
How much skin cells are likely to fall to the ground if a small person is being carried by another person? Isn't it more likely cells get attached to the person carrying?
The carrier had shoes, the child none.

So how much of those skin cells would have attached themselves to the clothes of the person carrying the child? Is there a study somewhere we can check?

I am led to believe the evidence may be in the film "Cool Hand Luke".
Not that, personally, I put much credence in fiction but...

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 03:01:26 PM
How much skin cells are likely to fall to the ground if a small person is being carried by another person? Isn't it more likely cells get attached to the person carrying?
The carrier had shoes, the child none.

So how much of those skin cells would have attached themselves to the clothes of the person carrying the child? Is there a study somewhere we can check?
The legs were described as limp.
Have you an idea about the way to sedate a close to 4yrs old in a nutshell ?
A thread could be opened on this topic.
The sniffer dogs always choose the fresher track.
What about the route around the building ? Madeleine followed it 2 ? days before.
The sniffer dogs seem to indicate she left the flat. Not compatible with Jane T's sighting but eventually with the Smith's sighting.
Just a possibility.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 03:10:13 PM
Can you please provide some cites for your claims about tracker dogs in ref. to carrying other people, or isn't there any? I've honestly been looking but I simply can't find any that state what you claim.

& yes, I have a fairly good idea of how to sedate children & adults in a closed environment - something quite frequently done by burglars in our area, unfortunately.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 03:33:50 PM
Can you please provide some cites for your claims about tracker dogs re to carrying other people, or isn't there any? I've honestly been looking but I simply can't find any that state what you claim.

& yes, I have a fairly good idea of how to sedate children & adults in a closed environment - something quite frequently done by burglars in our area, unfortunately.
I'll try to find some serious article mentioning this, Mrs B. I had a long talk with a friend of friends who is a handler in France, as, like you, thought a carried person wouldn't liberate sufficient molecules to the ground or rather the carried person's scent would be mixed up with the carrier's scent. But he denied it.
Burglars do sedate people ? You don't mean stun guns ? Can you please inform us ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 03:43:42 PM
Can you please provide some cites for your claims about tracker dogs re to carrying other people, or isn't there any? I've honestly been looking but I simply can't find any that state what you claim.

& yes, I have a fairly good idea of how to sedate children & adults in a closed environment - something quite frequently done by burglars in our area, unfortunately.
I'll try to find some serious article mentioning this, Mrs B. I had a long talk with a friend of friends who is a handler in France, as, like you, thought a carried person wouldn't liberate sufficient molecules to the ground or rather the carried person's scent would be mixed up with the carrier's scent. But he denied it.
Burglars do sedate people ? You don't mean stun guns ? Can you please inform us ?

No, they're much more efficient, they use gas generally.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Eleanor on June 04, 2013, 04:12:30 PM
Can you please provide some cites for your claims about tracker dogs re to carrying other people, or isn't there any? I've honestly been looking but I simply can't find any that state what you claim.

& yes, I have a fairly good idea of how to sedate children & adults in a closed environment - something quite frequently done by burglars in our area, unfortunately.
I'll try to find some serious article mentioning this, Mrs B. I had a long talk with a friend of friends who is a handler in France, as, like you, thought a carried person wouldn't liberate sufficient molecules to the ground or rather the carried person's scent would be mixed up with the carrier's scent. But he denied it.
Burglars do sedate people ? You don't mean stun guns ? Can you please inform us ?

http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/gang-mata-e-fere-idosos-em-rou
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 04:15:00 PM

No, they're much more efficient, they use gas generally.
Gas ? You mean like the desflurane ? Gosh, but isn't that dangerous ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 04:18:39 PM

No, they're much more efficient, they use gas generally.
Gas ? You mean like the desflurane ? Gosh, but isn't that dangerous ?

Of course it's dangerous, victims may never wake up again, but criminals don't seem to think that matters much.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 04:34:11 PM

Of course it's dangerous, victims may never wake up again, but criminals don't seem to think that matters much.
Are you sure ? I mean not about the risk taken, but about this kind of gas ? How can burglars get that sort of stuff ? Not possibly on the Web. Where ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 04:43:56 PM
Yes, I'm quite sure, but as I'm NOT part of the itinerant criminal gangs who rob people where I live, I don't know how they get hold of what they use, but apparently it's not that difficult.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Puffin on June 04, 2013, 04:46:41 PM
Yes, I'm quite sure, but as I'm part of the itinerant criminal gangs who rob people where I live, I don't know how they get hold of what they use, but apparently it's not that difficult.
Anything, legal or illegal, can be obtained if you know where to go and who to ask and, of course, if you have the money.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: muratfan on June 04, 2013, 04:56:59 PM
http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/gang-mata-e-fere-idosos-em-roubos



Abrantes: Two crimes at a distance of 800 meters clash population
Gang kills and injures elderly thefts
Umbelina Ignatius, 83, was intoxicated with ether and died yesterday in hospital at dawn. At the same time, neighbor couple was also beaten

A group of robbers raided two houses where seniors live, in the early morning of yesterday and the day before yesterday - having caused the death of a woman, intoxicated with ether, and a couple serious injuries. The two houses are 800 meters apart in Chainça, Abrantes.
The first attack, at dawn yesterday, was the home of two elderly sisters. Umbelina and Maria do Carmo Ignatius, 83 and 90, were asleep when the hooded men broke down the door and entered the house. The youngest resisted the robbers and was attacked with a rag with ether. Went into cardiopulmonary arrest and eventually did not resist, at night, in the Hospital de Castelo Branco.
Still looking for redo population Chainça from the shock caused by the death of Ignatius Umbelina since another violent attack occurred in the same village, the home of Laurinda and Luis Pereira, 77 and 78 year-old former emigrants in France.
Little was after 2:00 a.m. yesterday when four masked men entered the victims' house, at a time when the elderly walked the walk. Was brutally assaulted with a broomstick and punch and kick, into unconsciousness.
"He was dead in a pool of blood and covered in clothes," he said yesterday at the CM son, Rui Gonçalves. At the same time, the elder was gagged and hands tied, without leaving the bed. Still struggled for half an hour with the assailants who fumbled however everything.
When the CM found, stole a pair of gold earrings and 200-300 euros to the elderly couple. Already in the house of the two sisters have not stolen anything. In both situations, acted early, masked and gloved, and chose elderly were violent. The two crimes are investigated by PJ de Leiria
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 04:58:16 PM
Yes, I'm quite sure, but as I'm part of the itinerant criminal gangs who rob people where I live, I don't know how they get hold of what they use, but apparently it's not that difficult.
Anything, legal or illegal, can be obtained if you know where to go and who to ask and, of course, if you have the money.

Of course & it's no big secret either, they've been using this method for years. Every summer there are new cases.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 04:59:38 PM
Yes, I'm quite sure, but as I'm part of the itinerant criminal gangs who rob people where I live, I don't know how they get hold of what they use, but apparently it's not that difficult.
Well, this is the first time I read this. Do you think the risk of killing can ever be worth the stolen stuff (because such an attack has to be premeditated) ? A killing burglar goes to jail forever and forever has to live with the idea he/she killed someone.
I admit they use ether or chloroform which have immediate but short effects (though they're not benign if incorrectly administrated, to begin with the administrator), but gas !
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 05:05:16 PM
Surely you're not telling me that robbery is an unusual motive for killing people? It happens all of the time & all over the world.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: muratfan on June 04, 2013, 05:13:01 PM
Err Anne... you seem to have missed my big post about other crimes where the victims have been knocked out using   ether
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Eleanor on June 04, 2013, 05:18:14 PM
Err Anne... you seem to have missed my big post about other crimes where the victims have been knocked out using   ether

And the link to the article in Portuguese.  But that shouldn't be a problem for Anne Guedes.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 05:21:22 PM
Err Anne... you seem to have missed my big post about other crimes where the victims have been knocked out using   ether
I didn't miss it, muratfan, death was a side-effect in this case. Please don't make me say what I didn't ! Death wasn't intended.
Ether isn't gas. It has a very short (but radical) effect. I have an idea you could get it at the chemist shop, now probably no more, may be in specialized vet shops.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 05:23:34 PM
Err Anne... you seem to have missed my big post about other crimes where the victims have been knocked out using   ether

And the link to the article in Portuguese.  But that shouldn't be a problem for Anne Guedes.
Wasn't "my" Portuguese dubious yesterday, Eleanor ?
I read the article. No gas.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Eleanor on June 04, 2013, 05:29:25 PM
Err Anne... you seem to have missed my big post about other crimes where the victims have been knocked out using   ether

And the link to the article in Portuguese.  But that shouldn't be a problem for Anne Guedes.
Wasn't "my" Portuguese dubious yesterday, Eleanor ?
I read the article. No gas.

I didn't say anything about Gas.  It was sedation, which doesn't have to be Gas.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: muratfan on June 04, 2013, 05:38:21 PM
I didn't miss it, muratfan, death was a side-effect in this case. Please don't make me say what I didn't ! Death wasn't intended.
Ether isn't gas. It has a very short (but radical) effect. I have an idea you could get it at the chemist shop, now probably no more, may be in specialized vet shops.

Oh so a death is okay then if they used during a robbery, God you are strange
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 05:43:15 PM
http://www.history.com/topics/ether-and-chloroform

Ether can come as liquid or gas

Dint think it is used any more but as a child I was anesthetized several times using chloroform.  Horrible smell
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 05:47:47 PM
I didn't miss it, muratfan, death was a side-effect in this case. Please don't make me say what I didn't ! Death wasn't intended.
Ether isn't gas. It has a very short (but radical) effect. I have an idea you could get it at the chemist shop, now probably no more, may be in specialized vet shops.

Oh so a death is okay then if they used during a robbery, God you are strange
Who is God ? You mean Godot ?
And please don't translate me erroneously.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 05:48:12 PM
If Chloroform was used then it could be one of the reasons to account for the window being open.  To rid the place of the smell
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 05:52:03 PM
There are loads about these type of robberies - these are only some examples. I'm quite surprised that not everybody is aware of it.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1302917/Gassed-beds-Riviera-robbers-Terrifying-ordeal-British-tourists-falling-victim-Mediterranean-gang-crimewave.html

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1560520/Beware-sleeping-gas-gang-caravanners-told.html

http://metro.co.uk/2011/08/12/brazen-thieves-use-sleeping-gas-to-sedate-victims-in-luxury-spain-homes-111590/

http://www.theolivepress.es/spain-news/2009/08/14/nerja-sleeping-gas-robbery/

Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: icabodcrane on June 04, 2013, 05:55:37 PM
If Chloroform was used then it could be one of the reasons to account for the window being open.  To rid the place of the smell

Why would an abductor care whether or not the smell of chloroform lingered ?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Eleanor on June 04, 2013, 06:06:52 PM
If Chloroform was used then it could be one of the reasons to account for the window being open.  To rid the place of the smell

Why would an abductor care whether or not the smell of chloroform lingered ?

He wouldn't have wanted to be overcome himself.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 06:10:00 PM
It wouldn't but it would be in their interest to create a flow of air to disperse volatile gas in order not to be affected themselves.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: sadie on June 04, 2013, 06:10:37 PM
If Chloroform was used then it could be one of the reasons to account for the window being open.  To rid the place of the smell

Why would an abductor care whether or not the smell of chloroform lingered ?

He wouldn't have wanted to be overcome himself.

As you know, Icabod, there are several other additional reasons that the window might have been opened.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 06:40:27 PM
There are loads about these type of robberies - these are only some examples. I'm quite surprised that not everybody is aware of it.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1302917/Gassed-beds-Riviera-robbers-Terrifying-ordeal-British-tourists-falling-victim-Mediterranean-gang-crimewave.html

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1560520/Beware-sleeping-gas-gang-caravanners-told.html

http://metro.co.uk/2011/08/12/brazen-thieves-use-sleeping-gas-to-sedate-victims-in-luxury-spain-homes-111590/

http://www.theolivepress.es/spain-news/2009/08/14/nerja-sleeping-gas-robbery/
I can't find nothing serious in the French media about those gangs. Victims think they were gassed because they woke up dizzy, vomiting, etc. No specific gas is named. Anyhow gas in the air takes time to work, it wasn't the modus operandi in Madeleine's case.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Eleanor on June 04, 2013, 06:44:33 PM
There are loads about these type of robberies - these are only some examples. I'm quite surprised that not everybody is aware of it.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1302917/Gassed-beds-Riviera-robbers-Terrifying-ordeal-British-tourists-falling-victim-Mediterranean-gang-crimewave.html

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1560520/Beware-sleeping-gas-gang-caravanners-told.html

http://metro.co.uk/2011/08/12/brazen-thieves-use-sleeping-gas-to-sedate-victims-in-luxury-spain-homes-111590/

http://www.theolivepress.es/spain-news/2009/08/14/nerja-sleeping-gas-robbery/
I can't find nothing serious in the French media about those gangs. Victims think they were gassed because they woke up dizzy, vomiting, etc. No specific gas is named. Anyhow gas in the air takes time to work, it wasn't the modus operandi in Madeleine's case.

A double negative does not make for good translating.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 06:45:46 PM
Sorry, but you think they'd tell you what gas was used & how to get hold of it? Of course, that'd be helpful for other gangs who weren't up to speed yet, but hardly likely. Anyway, there are warning on pages of several countries' foreign departments so yes, it happens.

Also, what do you know about the MO in Madeleine's case? Like the rest of us, you weren't there.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 06:55:06 PM
Sorry, but you think they'd tell you what gas was used & how to get hold of it? Of course, that'd be helpful for other gangs who weren't up to speed yet, but hardly likely. Anyway, there are warning on pages of several countries' foreign departments so yes, it happens.

Also, what do you know about the MO in Madeleine's case? Like the rest of us, you weren't there.
Apparently, as you said yourself, those gases are easy to find, then those who use them wouldn't learn nothing.
Mrs B, are you kidding with "like the rest of us, you weren't there" ?
Somebody was.
The modus operandi is interesting, don't you think ? I've no idea what it was, but it wasn't gas : no device, no mask, no time.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 07:01:02 PM
Mrs B, are you kidding with "like the rest of us, you weren't there" ?
Somebody was.


Pardon? Like the rest of us, as in posters on this forum, surely, you are not suggesting that any of the members were in that room?
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 07:36:33 PM
Mrs B, are you kidding with "like the rest of us, you weren't there" ?
Somebody was.


Pardon? Like the rest of us, as in posters on this forum, surely, you are not suggesting that any of the members were in that room?
Come on, Mrs B. ! You first suggested that I had nothing to say about the MO because "I wasn't there". It seems it wasn't as obvious as that, since you felt like saying it. Hence my "are you kidding ?"
No, I wasn't in that room (but I'm interested in the MO)
No, I don't suspect anyone.
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 07:38:20 PM
Mrs B, are you kidding with "like the rest of us, you weren't there" ?
Somebody was.


Pardon? Like the rest of us, as in posters on this forum, surely, you are not suggesting that any of the members were in that room?
Come on, Mrs B. ! You first suggested that I had nothing to say about the MO because "I wasn't there". It seems it wasn't as obvious as that, since you felt like saying it. Hence my "are you kidding ?"
No, I wasn't in that room (but I'm interested in the MO)
No, I don't suspect anyone.

Phew, just wanted to make sure, I know I misunderstood you once before. Just didn't want to repeat the mistake :)
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: AnneGuedes on June 04, 2013, 07:43:12 PM
Mrs B, are you kidding with "like the rest of us, you weren't there" ?
Somebody was.


Pardon? Like the rest of us, as in posters on this forum, surely, you are not suggesting that any of the members were in that room?
Come on, Mrs B. ! You first suggested that I had nothing to say about the MO because "I wasn't there". It seems it wasn't as obvious as that, since you felt like saying it. Hence my "are you kidding ?"
No, I wasn't in that room (but I'm interested in the MO)
No, I don't suspect anyone.

Phew, just wanted to make sure, I know I misunderstood you once before. Just didn't want to repeat the mistake :)
It's all right, Mrs B. I'm sorry you misunderstood me once before, I had no idea of this. Sometimes I don't express myself clearly. I can even confess that sometimes I don't understand my own writings (not on this forum and in French) !
Title: Re: Amaral's OWN Private Investigation
Post by: Mrs. B on June 04, 2013, 08:02:42 PM
Not a problem, most likely partly my error as well.