Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 12:19:02 PM
Title: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 12:19:02 PM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
124
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: jassi on January 25, 2018, 12:37:57 PM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy. Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
Only if and when someone else is convicted. IMO
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 25, 2018, 12:38:44 PM
No. IMO their efforts to minimise blame have just made matters worse.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 12:40:40 PM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
Kate McCann had already answered the 'simple' questions asked when she was interviewed as a witness over a time span of thirteen hours immediately prior to being constituted arguida. As a witness her function was to provide information which may have helped Madeleine's case.
As an arguida ... the case was against her and nothing at all to do with helping Madeleine. Her legal right was to maintain silence ... she exercised that right and in my opinion that was a very sensible decision to take.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 12:47:17 PM
Neither Kate or Gerry McCann refused to attend a reconstituion: as arguidos they could not.
Letter from R. Alves regarding K. McCann's willingness to participate in the reconstruction Public Ministry of Portimao
Case Section Case 201/07 GALGS Dear Sir Public prosecutor
Kate Marie Healy arguida in the case referred to above, having been notified (page 3947) expresses her availability to participate in the reconstruction of the events on the second of the dates suggested, in other words on the 15 and 16th of next May. Her husband, Gerry McCann has also already expressed his availability.
Rogerio Alves Lawyer (Sent by email)
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 12:50:40 PM
Kate McCann had already answered the 'simple' questions asked when she was interviewed as a witness over a time span of thirteen hours immediately prior to being constituted arguida. As a witness her function was to provide information which may have helped Madeleine's case.
As an arguida ... the case was against her and nothing at all to do with helping Madeleine. Her legal right was to maintain silence ... she exercised that right and in my opinion that was a very sensible decision to take.
Do you not think that as the mother of a missing tot she should have put the needs of her child before that of herself and cooperated fully with the investigators. Any idiot can remain silent but in doing so she gained the condemnation of the police and the public at large.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 12:51:59 PM
Neither Kate or Gerry McCann refused to attend a reconstituion: as arguidos they could not.
Letter from R. Alves regarding K. McCann's willingness to participate in the reconstruction Public Ministry of Portimao
Case Section Case 201/07 GALGS Dear Sir Public prosecutor
Kate Marie Healy arguida in the case referred to above, having been notified (page 3947) expresses her availability to participate in the reconstruction of the events on the second of the dates suggested, in other words on the 15 and 16th of next May. Her husband, Gerry McCann has also already expressed his availability.
Rogerio Alves Lawyer (Sent by email)
They and their friends made no attempt to do so and that is what counts. They should all have been arrested and charged imo.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 12:52:19 PM
Do you not think that as the mother of a missing tot she should have put the needs of her child before that of herself and cooperated fully with the investigators. Any idiot can remain silent but in doing so she gained the condemnation of the police and the public at large.
Is this another 48 questions thread.... Kate was absolutely right not to answer the questions IMO as, we have already discussed at length
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 12:55:30 PM
Asfiac.... The vast majority don't suspect the mccanns... It's just a small group on the net... Imo
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 12:56:35 PM
Do you not think that as the mother of a missing tot she should have put the needs of her child before that of herself and cooperated fully with the investigators. Any idiot can remain silent but in doing so she gained the condemnation of the police and the public at large.
What? I doubt very much that sharing a cell with Leonor Cipriano would have advanced Madeleine's case by very much.
The investigators were not investigating Madeleine's case. They were building a case against Kate. One of the building blocks of which was her arguida status without a shred of evidence to support it.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: kizzy on January 25, 2018, 12:57:41 PM
IMO No -- far, far to many things don't sit right with an abduction,and not one miniscule of evidence to say maddie was abducted. etc etc
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 01:00:02 PM
They and their friends made no attempt to do so and that is what counts. They should all have been arrested and charged imo.
The first person to wonder at the value of a reconstitution was not a member of the tapas 7, but Jes Wilkins.
Email Jes Wilkins reply to reconstruction (English) From : Jes Wilkins (<email address quoted>) Sent : 16th April 2008 To : Prior Stuart Subject : Re : Re-enactment questions
Thanks Stuart, As discussed with your colleagues last week I still feel reluctant to agree to thisfor a number of reasons including family and work commitments, the likelyhood of media intrusion and a lack of information about anything tangible or constructive that is likely to be achived by doing this. I am happy to discuss further if necessary. Jes
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 01:09:08 PM
IMO No -- far, far to many things don't sit right with an abduction,and not one miniscule of evidence to say maddie was abducted. etc etc
The McCanns have never made any attempt to build bridges with the Portuguese police. Any normal parent of a missing kid would be over there constantly encouraging the local police but not the McCanns. They're too busy building their careers in the medical industry.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: jassi on January 25, 2018, 01:09:53 PM
What? I doubt very much that sharing a cell with Leonor Cipriano would have advanced Madeleine's case by very much. The investigators were not investigating Madeleine's case. They were building a case against Kate. One of the building blocks of which was her arguida status without a shred of evidence to support it.
There are two aspects of the case. One was to find Madeleine, the second was to find the perpetrator. Therefore questioning the McCanns was perfectly legitimate in my opinion.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 01:12:51 PM
There are two aspects of the case. One was to find Madeleine, the second was to find the perpetrator. Therefore questioning the McCanns was perfectly legitimate in my opinion.
And if the police in the UK and Portugal were doing their job correctly there would be many more questions about the issues I outlined in my op. Finding Madeleine has become a distraction now to other issues.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 01:15:22 PM
And if the police in the UK and Portugal were doing their job correctly there would be many more questions about the issues I outlined in my op. Finding Madeleine has become a distraction now to other issues.
You are simply quoting your own opinion as fact.... IMO you are totally wrong
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 01:19:21 PM
The McCanns have never made any attempt to build bridges with the Portuguese police. Any normal parent of a missing kid would be over there constantly encouraging the local police but not the McCanns. They're too busy building their careers in the medical industry.
The bridges have been built if the reopening of Madeleine's case on the recommendation of the Policia Judiciria is anything to go by.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 01:21:40 PM
I don't see any evidence that the mccanns have not fully cooperated with the present investigation
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 25, 2018, 01:21:58 PM
Kate McCann had already answered the 'simple' questions asked when she was interviewed as a witness over a time span of thirteen hours immediately prior to being constituted arguida. As a witness her function was to provide information which may have helped Madeleine's case.
As an arguida ... the case was against her and nothing at all to do with helping Madeleine. Her legal right was to maintain silence ... she exercised that right and in my opinion that was a very sensible decision to take.
Yes and the questions only went up to before her check on the night. She was made arguido to start answering questions about her check on the night, finding her daughter missing and raising the alarm. What happened from her check and she refused to answer. Nice one Kate.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Eleanor on January 25, 2018, 01:49:20 PM
Right. Apply for a European Arrest Warrant. Difficult because there was no evidence against them.
Eventually return them to Portugal as Arguidos, with a right to silence. They won't have to answer questions.
That won't have gone well, if at all.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 01:54:38 PM
You are simply quoting your own opinion as fact.... IMO you are totally wrong
My opinion is irrelevant to the facts as we currently know them. There is far too much secrecy in this case, the McCanns are evasive about their involvement post disappearance and that is sinister. You cannot deny the existence of secret reports, hidden accounts etc.. Had it not been for Redwood and the Spanish police raid on Metodo 3's offices in Barcelona the existence of two hidden e-fits attributable to the Smith family would have remained secret too.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 01:54:48 PM
My opinion is irrelevant to the facts as we currently know them. There is far too much secrecy in this case, the McCanns are evasive about their involvement post disappearance and that is sinister.
All your opinion and rubbish... Imo
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 02:01:25 PM
You are making accusations with no basis.... What evidence is there fire either of those... None
Had Portuguese nationals who were key witnesses refused to cooperate in a reconstitution they would have been charged with obstruction and perverting the course of justice. The fact that the tapas group were not Portuguese nationals should have not made any difference. They were all in contempt imo and exhibited a flagrant disregard for Maddie.
No wonder the McCanns own children are questioning them.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 25, 2018, 02:13:06 PM
Yes and she was told she could harm the investigation.
Yet she spent years persecuting G A, with excuse, he harmed the investigation.
post imo
No, Kate was told no such thing. She was asked if she was aware she was harming the investigation.
What exactly was being investigated though? Madeleine or Kate? Well it sure wasn't Madeleine.
I think it may be time to consider who exactly is being 'persecuted' by whom here. In my opinion authoring a book making all sorts of ill informed suggestions which are not evidence based as Amaral did, aimed at impugning the parents of a missing child is the gold standard in persecution.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: jassi on January 25, 2018, 02:13:58 PM
Had Portuguese nationals who were key witnesses refused to cooperate in a reconstitution they would have been charged with obstruction and perverting the course of justice. The fact that the tapas group were not Portuguese nationals should have not made any difference. They were all in contempt imo.
Personally I think they are all beyond contempt.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 25, 2018, 02:15:28 PM
Asfiac.... The vast majority don't suspect the mccanns... It's just a small group on the net... Imo Just as, some still suspect the, US govt we're behind 911 so some will always suspect the mccanns. I doubt it bothers, them that much now
Except that, as we found out from Kate, the twins have their internet usage supervised.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 02:19:21 PM
Had Portuguese nationals who were key witnesses refused to cooperate in a reconstitution they would have been charged with obstruction and perverting the course of justice. The fact that the tapas group were not Portuguese nationals should have not made any difference. They were all in contempt imo and exhibited a flagrant disregard for Maddie.
No wonder the McCanns own children are questioning them.
Suspects as arguidos do not have to answer any questions so your statement is wrong..
More opinion as regards their children
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 02:25:42 PM
Had Portuguese nationals who were key witnesses refused to cooperate in a reconstitution they would have been charged with obstruction and perverting the course of justice. The fact that the tapas group were not Portuguese nationals should have not made any difference. They were all in contempt imo and exhibited a flagrant disregard for Maddie.
No wonder the McCanns own children are questioning them.
FindMadeleine Website - The proposed reconstruction: The suggestion of a reconstruction of our movements and other key witnesses at the crime scene and/or surrounding area in the early days following Madeleine's abduction was declined by the PJ as 'not usual' for Portugal. When the PJ finally requested a reconstruction to take place in 2008, Gerry and I were still arguidos and as such would have attended for a reconstruction.
Some key witnesses (including some of our friends) declined to attend the planned reconstruction as they were not convinced of the aims and usefulness of it. In particular, as the reconstruction was not to be shown to the media (and hence the general public), they did not feel it would help to find Madeleine. Had the intention been to show it to the general public, it may have 'jogged' memories and encouraged people to come forward with information.
It should be added that other key witnesses were not invited to attend. (note other key witnesses like the waiters, other guests at the restaurant) http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077838/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2023
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 02:31:41 PM
Except that, as we found out from Kate, the twins have their internet usage supervised.
The children have to be protected from the vile content of many internet sites. I find that it is necessary that innocent children require that protection against the poisonous attacks on their family an absolute disgrace.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 25, 2018, 02:38:03 PM
The children have to be protected from the vile content of many internet sites. I find that it is necessary that innocent children require that protection against the poisonous attacks on their family an absolute disgrace.
Well, there would be no poisonous attacks, if people didn't suspect the McCanns.
But, evidently, some do.
The Police have the power to make it all go away, simply by showing the world this abduction evidence, that they most definitely have, which proves beyond question the McCanns complete non involvement in Madeleines disappearance.
I'm at a loss to understand why the nice people at Scotland Yard don't want to help the McCanns in this way.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 02:45:36 PM
Well, there would be no poisonous attacks, if people didn't suspect the McCanns.
But, evidently, some do.
The Police have the power to make it all go away, simply by showing the world this abduction evidence, that they most definitely have, which proves beyond question the McCanns complete non involvement in Madeleines disappearance.
I'm at a loss to understand why the nice people at Scotland Yard don't want to help the McCanns in this way.
Scotland Yard are currently doing their utmost to help Kate and Gerry to find out what happened to Madeleine.
In what way would it advance Madeleine's very active case by publishing their evidence to satisfy the curiosity of a few malcontents and of course alert any perpetrator who might be interested. In my opinion your suggestion that they should is superbly devoid of basic common sense.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 25, 2018, 02:50:51 PM
Scotland Yard are currently doing their utmost to help Kate and Gerry to find out what happened to Madeleine.
In what way would it advance Madeleine's very active case by publishing their evidence to satisfy the curiosity of a few malcontents and of course alert any perpetrator who might be interested. In my opinion your suggestion that they should is superbly devoid of basic common sense.
Who said anything about advancing the case?
Not me.
I was talking about ending public suspicion & those vicious troll attacks, you so resent.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Eleanor on January 25, 2018, 02:54:40 PM
Scotland Yard are currently doing their utmost to help Kate and Gerry to find out what happened to Madeleine.
In what way would it advance Madeleine's very active case by publishing their evidence to satisfy the curiosity of a few malcontents and of course alert any perpetrator who might be interested. In my opinion your suggestion that they should is superbly devoid of basic common sense.
Several of the comments on this Thread are.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 03:25:58 PM
I was talking about ending public suspicion & those vicious troll attacks, you so resent.
Please don't try to deflect the thread ... it isn't working.
The level of suspicion directed against Kate and Gerry is in my opinion minimal when taking the real world into consideration.
The reopening of Madeleine's investigation allowed the scales to drop from many eyes both here and in Portugal and most certainly worldwide. However the investigation into her case works out, in my opinion in future most thinking people will consider the last few years and put anything other than that into the compartment marked 'conspiracy theories'.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 25, 2018, 03:36:37 PM
Please don't try to deflect the thread ... it isn't working.
The level of suspicion directed against Kate and Gerry is in my opinion minimal when taking the real world into consideration.
The reopening of Madeleine's investigation allowed the scales to drop from many eyes both here and in Portugal and most certainly worldwide. However the investigation into her case works out, in my opinion in future most thinking people will consider the last few years and put anything other than that into the compartment marked 'conspiracy theories'.
Well, obviously, when Maddie turns up alive & well or her abductor is tried & convicted, all previous theories will be disregarded. But alas, when the current investigation ends & no one is bought to justice,as is most likely, there will still be that dark corner of the internet, however small, suspecting the McCanns & posting vile theories..... And I have absolutely no problem with that.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: kizzy on January 25, 2018, 03:37:38 PM
IMO, why was he allowed in the room with her, an then when made arguidos, was allowed to speak to each other after gmccann had been interviewed, before hers.
The mccans and two of their friends were taken from Praia da Luz at around 10 am for the statements to be taken.
gmccann was first. He was interviewed alone.
When his statement was completed Kate followed.
Unusually Gerry was permitted to remain in the interview room, whilst kmccann was interviewed and her statement was taken.
He was permitted to sit behind her and she states that from time to time he “would place a hand on my shoulder or give me a reassuring squeeze”.
Physical contact of this sort may be reassuring. It can also be a very effective method of communication. imo
Think the below video, odd shows 6 secs in where gmcann hand on her shoulder, moves when she is speaking.
Well, obviously, when Maddie turns up alive & well or her abductor is tried & convicted, all previous theories will be disregarded. But alas, when the current investigation ends & no one is bought to justice,as is most likely, there will still be that dark corner of the internet, however small, suspecting the McCanns & posting vile theories..... And I have absolutely no problem with that.
Yup me too 8((()*/
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 03:49:27 PM
Well, obviously, when Maddie turns up alive & well or her abductor is tried & convicted, all previous theories will be disregarded. But alas, when the current investigation ends & no one is bought to justice,as is most likely, there will still be that dark corner of the internet, however small, suspecting the McCanns & posting vile theories..... And I have absolutely no problem with that.
I have no problem either and I doubt the mccanns have.....
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Eleanor on January 25, 2018, 03:56:38 PM
I have no problem either and I doubt the mccanns have.....
Water of a Duck's Back by now, I should think. Boring and repetitive. And besides, it keeps the search going. Ten years on, Madeleine is still front page news. That in itself is remarkable.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Robittybob1 on January 25, 2018, 03:58:32 PM
Water of a Duck's Back by now, I should think. Boring and repetitive. And besides, it keeps the search going. Ten years on, Madeleine is still front page news. That in itself is remarkable.
It may be remarkable. It certainly seems non-productive.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 25, 2018, 04:31:12 PM
I have no problem either and I doubt the mccanns have.....
Apparently, the McCanns, as recently as August, find the trolling to be 'shocking, striking and quite hard to get your head round.'....aswell as.... 'so awful and upsetting.'
Water of a Duck's Back by now, I should think. Boring and repetitive. And besides, it keeps the search going. Ten years on, Madeleine is still front page news. That in itself is remarkable.
Not as remarkable, as all the publicity, and still nothing to show for it.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Robittybob1 on January 25, 2018, 04:44:56 PM
I don't see any evidence that the mccanns have not fully cooperated with the present investigation
It seems the present investigation consists of a cop pushing memos around with the odd edict emerging from time to time. In my view, Operation Grange hit a stone wall the moment Redwood returned from his dig in Praia da Luz empty handed.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: John on January 25, 2018, 05:22:00 PM
Well, there would be no poisonous attacks, if people didn't suspect the McCanns.
But, evidently, some do.
The Police have the power to make it all go away, simply by showing the world this abduction evidence, that they most definitely have, which proves beyond question the McCanns complete non involvement in Madeleines disappearance.
I'm at a loss to understand why the nice people at Scotland Yard don't want to help the McCanns in this way.
Its what the police call keeping their options open.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Erngath on January 25, 2018, 05:22:48 PM
Please don't try to deflect the thread ... it isn't working.
The level of suspicion directed against Kate and Gerry is in my opinion minimal when taking the real world into consideration.
The reopening of Madeleine's investigation allowed the scales to drop from many eyes both here and in Portugal and most certainly worldwide. However the investigation into her case works out, in my opinion in future most thinking people will consider the last few years and put anything other than that into the compartment marked 'conspiracy theories'.
Conspiracy theories? Are you disputing my opening post which is based on facts? If you do maybe you can explain away all the irregularities.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: John on January 25, 2018, 05:32:08 PM
FindMadeleine Website - The proposed reconstruction: The suggestion of a reconstruction of our movements and other key witnesses at the crime scene and/or surrounding area in the early days following Madeleine's abduction was declined by the PJ as 'not usual' for Portugal. When the PJ finally requested a reconstruction to take place in 2008, Gerry and I were still arguidos and as such would have attended for a reconstruction.
Some key witnesses (including some of our friends) declined to attend the planned reconstruction as they were not convinced of the aims and usefulness of it. In particular, as the reconstruction was not to be shown to the media (and hence the general public), they did not feel it would help to find Madeleine. Had the intention been to show it to the general public, it may have 'jogged' memories and encouraged people to come forward with information.
It should be added that other key witnesses were not invited to attend. (note other key witnesses like the waiters, other guests at the restaurant) http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077838/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2023
Their friends would do whatever they privately told them to do. They did not want the media - watch the videos below of the McCanns talking about it.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 06:05:24 PM
Conspiracy theories? Are you disputing my opening post which is based on facts? If you do maybe you can explain away all the irregularities.
I've asked the question on another thread regarding the accusation against Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3.
I've had a good look and outwith blogs inimical to the McCann family I can find no reference to such an event.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 25, 2018, 06:09:07 PM
Well I know we all have different views on this.
Personally, I can't see any reason in Rebelo-day for wanting one, except to tick boxes on procedures to hand it all to the magistrate / prosecutor.
You don't actually need people present these days to work out forensic timelines or anything else. They'd had the keys long enough to verify a door potentially slamming. Why would you need the person in question actually there? Either it was possible or it wasn't.
They'd tried to get through the window to see if that was possible. There's no particular for the parents of a missing child having to be there while attempting to simulate that possibility.
The timeline isn't complicated to work out in terms of possibilities. They'd made a best guess of the times, according to their recollections of the sequence of events and whatever baseline time they were using.
There was no way on earth of determining why Gerry & Jez didn't see Jane, nor hear her flipflops. How do you scientifically determine what those two guys, deep in conversation actually perceived that night? I might have heard her flipflopping up, but it doesn't mean that they did. They did go back and all that came out of that was that they didn't agree on where exactly they were standing.
What I haven't personally seen is that Gerry (and Russell, from memory) mentioned that a date had been leaked to the media. If that's accurate, that would be the other leak I was trying to remember under Rebelo's watch - but I don't recall having seen it in the media, and it may have been off the record and got leaked via the media grapevine from there.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Brietta on January 25, 2018, 06:20:43 PM
Personally, I can't see any reason in Rebelo-day for wanting one, except to tick boxes on procedures to hand it all to the magistrate / prosecutor.
You don't actually need people present these days to work out forensic timelines or anything else. They'd had the keys long enough to verify a door potentially slamming. Why would you need the person in question actually there? Either it was possible or it wasn't.
They'd tried to get through the window to see if that was possible. There's no particular for the parents of a missing child having to be there while attempting to simulate that possibility.
The timeline isn't complicated to work out in terms of possibilities. They'd made a best guess of the times, according to their recollections of the sequence of events and whatever baseline time they were using.
There was no way on earth of determining why Gerry & Jez didn't see Jane, nor hear her flipflops. How do you scientifically determine what those two guys, deep in conversation actually perceived that night? I might have heard her flipflopping up, but it doesn't mean that they did. They did go back and all that came out of that was that they didn't agree on where exactly they were standing.
What I haven't personally seen is that Gerry (and Russell, from memory) mentioned that a date had been leaked to the media. If that's accurate, that would be the other leak I was trying to remember under Rebelo's watch - but I don't recall having seen it in the media, and it may have been off the record and got leaked via the media grapevine from there.
From: Russell O'Brien, Sent: 23rd May 2008, To: Prior Stuart, Subject: RE: Re-enactment Dates
Dear Stuart,
We gather that Rachel has already contacted you saying they won't be returning for any re-enactment. Once again, it seems an academic matter if there is not going to be 100% attendance.
Furthermore, we think it is hard to imagine a productive return to Portugal whilst Kate and Gerry remain arguidos.
Secondly, the Prosecutor astonishingly referring to them as 'offenders' in their letter implies they are already considered to be guilty, and will be treated as such by the police and press.
Furthermore the leaking of the date even before your email completely contradicts the letter's pretence to secrecy for the re-enactment. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 25, 2018, 06:28:53 PM
From: Russell O'Brien, Sent: 23rd May 2008, To: Prior Stuart, Subject: RE: Re-enactment Dates
Dear Stuart,
We gather that Rachel has already contacted you saying they won't be returning for any re-enactment. Once again, it seems an academic matter if there is not going to be 100% attendance.
Furthermore, we think it is hard to imagine a productive return to Portugal whilst Kate and Gerry remain arguidos.
Secondly, the Prosecutor astonishingly referring to them as 'offenders' in their letter implies they are already considered to be guilty, and will be treated as such by the police and press.
Furthermore the leaking of the date even before your email completely contradicts the letter's pretence to secrecy for the re-enactment. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm
Thanks Brietta. It doesn't actually say leaked to the media - as in being published. It may well have been an off-the-record tip-off that got leaked via the grapevine then.
I have no recollection of having read that in the media in advance, unless I simply missed it.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 06:33:50 PM
Their friends would do whatever they privately told them to do. They did not want the media - watch the videos below of the McCanns talking about it.
It has always been excuses excuses and more excuses. Let's face it, the reconstruction had little to do with finding Maddie but everything to do with getting to the truth.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on January 25, 2018, 06:42:40 PM
It has always been excuses excuses and more excuses. Let's face it, the reconstruction had little to do with finding Maddie but everything to do with getting to the truth.
It is worth remembering, that they paid money to a company to 'keep them in the media'. I am of the opinion that they wanted to control the media. There was a really good opportunity to iron out the very rough edges it was all there -warts an all to be analysed -the problem was/is the story just doesn't cut it as far as window abductions go, in the time scale being offered.
They all knew they would be ruined and this has always been about them and their reputations! IMHO
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 06:43:00 PM
It has always been excuses excuses and more excuses. Let's face it, the reconstruction had little to do with finding Maddie but everything to do with getting to the truth.
More opinion presenteD as fact....the reconstruction was basically to try and implicate the mccanns and had nothing to do with the search for Maddie The tapas were wise to ignore it..imo
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 06:47:32 PM
I've asked the question on another thread regarding the accusation against Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3.
I've had a good look and outwith blogs inimical to the McCann family I can find no reference to such an event.
Could I suggest a few starting questions for SY.
1. Who engaged Marcos Correia? 2. What was Marcos Correia's brief? 3. Who funded Marcos Correia? 4. How much did the Madeleine Fund pay Marcos Correia?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 06:49:12 PM
More opinion presenteD as fact....the reconstruction was basically to try and implicate the mccanns and had nothing to do with the search for Maddie The tapas were wise to ignore it..imo
Maybe you haven't noticed yet but it is the polices job to look into ALL options. The McCanns don't have any right to obstruct that duty.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 06:54:19 PM
1. Who engaged Marcos Correia? 2. What was Marcos Correia's brief? 3. Who funded Marcos Correia? 4. How much did the Madeleine Fund pay Marcos Correia?
We have had this discussion before and I explained to you this would be the job of the pj....who obviously aren't interested....not SY. You said you were going to contact the PJ with your information..have you...looks like you havent
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on January 25, 2018, 07:13:44 PM
Can you please give a cite for your claims that all theories were investigated and the McCanns were declared innocent of all suspicion. Can you name ALL the theories investigated- without being banned lol
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Lace on January 25, 2018, 07:14:01 PM
It is worth remembering, that they paid money to a company to 'keep them in the media'. I am of the opinion that they wanted to control the media. There was a really good opportunity to iron out the very rough edges it was all there -warts an all to be analysed -the problem was/is the story just doesn't cut it as far as window abductions go, in the time scale being offered.
They all knew they would be ruined and this has always been about them and their reputations! IMHO
Yes they paid money to keep Madeleine in the news so that the public wouldn't forget her, so what? What window abduction are you talking about?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Lace on January 25, 2018, 07:16:28 PM
We have had this discussion before and I explained to you this would be the job of the pj....who obviously aren't interested....not SY. You said you were going to contact the PJ with your information..have you...looks like you havent
Looks can be deceiving. My approach has been to the PJ.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 07:22:26 PM
Once in a blue moon press briefings are meaningless. SY are not in the habit of revealing what they are really up to.
You can dream the parents are not ruled out but in reality what both SY and the OH have said along with all the other evidence confirms that the parents are not suspected by either police force
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 07:26:10 PM
Can you please give a cite for your claims that all theories were investigated and the McCanns were declared innocent of all suspicion. Can you name ALL the theories investigated- without being banned lol
Appears the highest Court in Portugal disagree with davel. 8)-)))
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on January 25, 2018, 07:26:44 PM
Yes they paid money to keep Madeleine in the news so that the public wouldn't forget her, so what? What window abduction are you talking about?
Why would the public want to remember her on a daily basis, she wasn't royalty or anything. I suspect they wanted to keep her on the news to get sympathy and money for their fund.
Window abduction-The one the parents are selling.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 07:26:57 PM
You can dream the parents are not ruled out but in reality what both SY and the OH have said along with all the other evidence confirms that the parents are not suspected by either police force
Madeleine's disappearance isn't the only potential crime going on in this case. I could mention half a dozen more but then I'd have to elaborate and I'm not going to do that just yet. I will leave it in the hands of the Portuguese and Spanish police to investigate.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Lace on January 25, 2018, 07:30:25 PM
Why would the public want to remember her on a daily basis, she wasn't royalty or anything. I suspect they wanted to keep her on the news to get sympathy and money for their fund.
Window abduction-The one the parents are selling.
'to get sympathy and money for their fund'. One of the things that parents of a missing child want to do is to keep their child in the public eye, 'don't forget about me' is on the posters isn't it? So you think it was for money, yet it took a large amount of money to do it, unbelievable.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 07:30:57 PM
'to get sympathy and money for their fund'. One of the things that parents of a missing child want to do is to keep their child in the public eye, 'don't forget about me' is on the posters isn't it? So you think it was for money, yet it took a large amount of money to do it, unbelievable.
Well the ole business mantra is you gotta spend money to make money, they got paid for their interviews and I see no profit and loss account being produced by the transparent accounts. Unless the McCanns have a different understanding of transparent that the dictionary and the many readers here.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 25, 2018, 07:48:11 PM
Well the ole business mantra is you gotta spend money to make money, they got paid for their interviews and I see no profit and loss account being produced by the transparent accounts. Unless the McCanns have a different understanding of transparent that the dictionary and the many readers here.
So you know for definite they were paid for interviews do you?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 25, 2018, 08:21:24 PM
Well the ole business mantra is you gotta spend money to make money, they got paid for their interviews and I see no profit and loss account being produced by the transparent accounts. Unless the McCanns have a different understanding of transparent that the dictionary and the many readers here.
Did they?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 25, 2018, 08:28:28 PM
Everyone who has followed the case knows, what's gone on... What rubbish Facts
Amaral has been found guilty of perjury and amaral lost his, case, against Correia.. Are you, aware of that
Amaral's civil case against Correia is of little consequence as was his minor lie to the court in what was a misguided effort to protect his officers. There is a much bigger picture here and it is only a matter of time before it all comes out.
The op asks, do past events tell their own story, I believe they certainly do.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 26, 2018, 08:24:33 AM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
61
they tell the story the reader decides they tell....kate didnt answer 48 questions because imo she was advised not to because the questions were designed to make her incriminate herself and possibly be wrongfully arrested....thats what it tells me. Much of what you have posted is your opinion but you seem to think its fact
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on January 26, 2018, 01:12:40 PM
When was the last time the MET or the PJ made a public appeal to find Madeleine?
As far as I know, it was 2013 on Crimewatch.
Apart from that they went digging in the dirt with cadaver dogs.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Eleanor on January 26, 2018, 01:15:02 PM
They're not making much effort to search for a live child, that's the point.
Pushing papers around & asking burglars if they killed her.
No appeals, no new age progression.
Past events tell their own story.
You don't know what they are searching for. For all you know they could know where she is already.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 26, 2018, 06:04:05 PM
A reminder.
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 26, 2018, 06:09:47 PM
There are far too many secrets in this case as I have already highlighted and until a full impartial investigation into ALL aspects of it is undertaken I cannot see that changing.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 26, 2018, 07:07:00 PM
There are far too many secrets in this case as I have already highlighted and until a full impartial investigation into ALL aspects of it is undertaken I cannot see that changing.
All your opinion and totally wrong in mine
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Robittybob1 on January 26, 2018, 07:58:36 PM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
61
In the OP you appear to quote from the Archiving report but the words in quotations are not from it, What is the actual sentence in the archiving report that allows you to paraphrase it as "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" please?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: John on January 26, 2018, 11:17:30 PM
In the OP you appear to quote from the Archiving report but the words in quotations are not from it, What is the actual sentence in the archiving report that allows you to paraphrase it as "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" please?
The actual extract:
"We believe that the main damage was caused to the McCann arguidos, who lost the possibility to prove what they have protested since they were constituted arguidos: their innocence towards the fateful event; the investigation was also disturbed, because said facts remain unclarified."
"We believe that the main damage was caused to the McCann arguidos, who lost the possibility to prove what they have protested since they were constituted arguidos: their innocence towards the fateful event; the investigation was also disturbed, because said facts remain unclarified."
"We believe that the main damage was caused to the McCann arguidos, who lost the possibility to prove what they have protested since they were constituted arguidos: their innocence towards the fateful event; the investigation was also disturbed, because said facts remain unclarified."
It is a complex idea and in the end I felt the only way to do it justice was to quote the whole section: "E - About the Interest of the Reconstitution
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstitution of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts , the following very important details, among others:
1 - The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
2 - The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
3 - The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
4 - What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. - the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings - and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy - at around 10 p.m.;
5 - The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.
In this sense, the legal procedures were followed, according to the norms and conventions that are in force, and the appearance of the witnesses was requested, inviting them to be present inclusively appealing to solidarity with the McCann couple, as it is certain that since the beginning they adhered to that process diligence.
Nevertheless, despite national authorities assuming all measures to render their trip to Portugal viable, for unknown motives, after the many doubts that they raised about the necessity and opportunity of their trip were clarified several times, they chose not to attend, which rendered the diligence inviable.
We believe that the main damage was caused to the McCann arguidos, who lost the possibility to prove what they have protested since they were constituted arguidos: their innocence towards the fateful event; the investigation was also disturbed, because said facts remain unclarified." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm
The rest of the Tapas group refused to attend in order to help the PJ remove any doubt of the McCann couple's innocence". I had to read that several times. Were they out to prove the McCanns innocent?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 27, 2018, 04:17:48 AM
snip The rest of the Tapas group refused to attend in order to help the PJ remove any doubt of the McCann couple's innocence". I had to read that several times. Were they out to prove the McCanns innocent?
My understanding is that the T7 (and Jez) felt that they were going to get hassled by the media again, and the T7 (or at least some of them) were suspicious about what the purpose actually was and were worried that they could be stitched up.
Declining to go wasn't taken well by the prosecutor who expressed his disapproval.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 27, 2018, 10:51:04 AM
And an unprecedented amount of money being spent on a missing child case. That tells it's own story IMO 8(0(*
A missing UK child in a foreign country, with huge media interest, brownie points for politicians, a very suspect case involving some members of the same team...
Madeleine was young, pretty and white. A sad fact is that if she'd been a brown, unphotogenic, male adolescent, the case masy not have attracted the same amount of attention, and therefore less effort. That is something that I do find unfair, but not because there was so much help to help find Madeleine, but that every missing kid (or even an adult in suspected non-voluntary disappearance cases) should be afforded the same.
There was a case a few years ago of a family trying to find a missing black UK 13-year-old girl... and the press was barely interested. They then decided to make a media storm out of it using the key-word Maddie and the media then latched onto it. As a result of the attention, the girl was eventually found, alive, a few weeks after that.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 27, 2018, 04:43:28 PM
Well the head of the ACED - Association Against Exclusion for Development; wrote a damning piece, what was his name, oh yes Marcos Aragão Correia.
Some may say a conflict of interest.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Carana on January 27, 2018, 05:43:39 PM
Well the head of the ACED - Association Against Exclusion for Development; wrote a damning piece, what was his name, oh yes Marcos Aragão Correia.
Some may say a conflict of interest.
The first I'd heard of him was when he got himself into the media stating that he was suing the PT postal service because a registered letter (or whatever they're called) hadn't been acknowledged by the McCanns.
Lots of PT papers have gone bust over the years, so I might find it difficult to find that one.
From memory, and logically, that would have been some time prior to his dam search.
ETA:
Em Novembro de 2007, Aragão Correia processou judicialmente os Correios de Portugal (CTT) por estes não terem entregue pessoalmente uma carta registada que enviou para o casal McCann. http://www.dnoticias.pt/impressa/hemeroteca/diario-de-noticias/360386-advogado-marcos-aragao-passa-testemunho-no-caso-joana-NPDN360386#
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own stor
Post by: kizzy on January 28, 2018, 04:21:10 PM
I'm inclined to agree with you. I think that had they not taken him to court, he and his book would likely have faded away, unnoticed. As it is, the UK media have been only too happy to give him publicity, becoming increasing bold each time the McCanns were defeated.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: John on January 28, 2018, 04:44:11 PM
There have been a number of official suspects or arguidos in this case including expat Robert Murat, Russian national Sergey Malinka and Maddie's parents, Kate and Gerry McCann. None of them have come out of this smelling of roses for one reason or another.
Let me say firstly that it is by no means unusual for the parents of a missing child to attract suspicion since most child abduction cases do involve persons known to the child. In this case however there are other peripheral events which leave many questions still to be answered. Those events include the refusal by Kate McCann to answer the simplest questions when formally interviewed, the voluntary non participation by the parents and their friends in a reconstruction of the events on the night Maddie disappeared, the savage attack on certain Portuguese police officers and the detective who led the original investigation. Then there was the Oakley International debacle involving fraudster Kevin Halligen which saw a secret Report and e-fits withheld from the public. Add to this the murky business involving the Madeleine Fund and the Spanish private detective agency Metodo 3 and a certain pattern begins to develop.
The Archive Report issued back when the original enquiry was shelved for lack of evidence stated that the parents had "failed to demonstrate their non involvement" and the Portuguese Supreme Court has more recently been forced to make the unprecedented declaration that the parents have not been cleared.
The Madeleine Fund itself has attracted much criticism. Far from being the transparent Company it was initially set up to be to handle donations from the public, it has morphed into something else with accounts and payments shrouded in secrecy.
Are all these events interrelated or is there more to this than meets the eye?
I don't know about interrelated but they certainly aren't the norm in cases of claimed child abduction.
Your first point I agree with, none of the arguidos have come out of this saga smelling of roses. Both Murat and Malinka have had their private business splattered all over the national press in several countries. The allegations against them both aside from the Madeleine case have been very unsavoury.
Your second point concerning the apparent lack of cooperation is also valid to some extent. This seldom happens in real child abduction cases, the parents of a missing child are normally pro active and pro police. I personally struggle to comprehend why one of the McCanns wasn't at all times fully involved in searches and other police activities. The police usually have a problem keeping parents away from certain activities but no such difficulty in this case. Even when one of the parents did attend a briefing at police HQ the detective in charge commented upon his odd behavior.
The failure to answer simple questions is an odd one admittedly. That said, it is the right of any arguida to do so but I fail to see how that approach could in any way assist the police who were after all trying to find out what happened to her daughter. All very odd!
The private detectives sagas are very odd too. Employing one PI firm who turned out to be rogues is just bad luck but employing two is just unheard of. Most of us here know the background to Oakley International and Método 3 so there is no point in me going through it all again. Safe to say however that secret e-fits and secret reports are not conducive with full and frank disclosure.
The Portuguese Courts have made their thoughts on the case abundantly clear, unfortunately, none of it has brought us any closer to finding Madeleine McCann or bringing to justice anyone involved in her disappearance.
Taking all of the above into consideration one couldn't be faulted for wondering just what the hell was going on?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 28, 2018, 05:07:01 PM
I don't know about interrelated but they certainly aren't the norm in cases of claimed child abduction.
Your first point I agree with, none of the arguidos have come out of this saga smelling of roses. Both Murat and Malinka have had their private business splattered all over the national press in several countries. The allegations against them both aside from the Madeleine case have been very unsavoury.
Your second point concerning the apparent lack of cooperation is also valid to some extent. This seldom happens in real child abduction cases, the parents of a missing child are normally pro active and pro police. I personally struggle to comprehend why one of the McCanns wasn't at all times fully involved in searches and other police activities. The police usually have a problem keeping parents away from certain activities but no such difficulty in this case. Even when one of the parents did attend a briefing at police HQ the detective in charge commented upon his odd behavior.
The failure to answer simple questions is an odd one admittedly. That said, it is the right of any arguida to do so but I fail to see how that approach could in any way assist the police who were after all trying to find out what happened to her daughter. All very odd!
The private detectives sagas are very odd too. Employing one PI firm who turned out to be rogues is just bad luck but employing two is just unheard of. Most of us here know the background to Oakley International and Método 3 so there is no point in me going through it all again. Safe to say however that secret e-fits and secret reports are not conducive with full and frank disclosure.
The Portuguese Courts have made their thoughts on the case abundantly clear, unfortunately, none of it has brought us any closer to finding Madeleine McCann or bringing to justice anyone involved in her disappearance.
Taking all of the above into consideration one couldn't be faulted for wondering just what the hell was going on?
all this is just a rehash of things taht have been discussed over and over...the original investigation led by amaral completely misunderstood the evidence and thought the mccanns had covered up an accident...Kate told all she knew re the disappearance but was advised to stop answerring questions because the pj were simply looking for something they could use to arrest her...what was going on was a police force who simply didnt have a clue imo...hence the involvement now of SY...something else that is almost unheard of...
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: kizzy on January 28, 2018, 05:21:27 PM
all this is just a rehash of things taht have been discussed over and over...the original investigation led by amaral completely misunderstood the evidence and thought the mccanns had covered up an accident...Kate told all she knew re the disappearance but was advised to stop answerring questions because the pj were simply looking for something they could use to arrest her...what was going on was a police force who simply didnt have a clue imo...hence the involvement now of SY...something else that is almost unheard of...
So does this mean because it has been discussed over and over on here, that's it solved - done an dusted.
IMO its the past events, that was then, and still now, unnatural not believable.
No matter how many times they are discussed, does not make them believable. or is it some don't like them being discussed.
[Edited to remove hints of goading.]
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: John on January 28, 2018, 05:30:41 PM
all this is just a rehash of things taht have been discussed over and over...the original investigation led by amaral completely misunderstood the evidence and thought the mccanns had covered up an accident...Kate told all she knew re the disappearance but was advised to stop answerring questions because the pj were simply looking for something they could use to arrest her...what was going on was a police force who simply didnt have a clue imo...hence the involvement now of SY...something else that is almost unheard of...
I believe the point being made is if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
The Portuguese have primary ownership of this case and always will have which limits SY's involvement.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 28, 2018, 05:31:15 PM
I believe the point being made is if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
The Portuguese have primary ownership of this case and always will have which limits SY's involvement.
The point is that if you THINK it walks like a duck then everything follows... It's just opinion
The mccanns did cooperate with the pj until it became clear the pj were just trying to implicate them.... Then they did the right thing to cease cooperation.... All my opinion
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: barrier on January 28, 2018, 05:41:28 PM
The point is that if you THINK it walks like a duck then everything follows... It's just opinion
The mccanns did cooperate with the pj until it became clear the pj were just trying to implicate them.... Then they did the right thing to cease cooperation.... All my opinion
If the Arguido's interviewed in the presence of SY officers had any sense they probably went the same route.imo
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Robittybob1 on January 28, 2018, 05:42:48 PM
The point is that if you THINK it walks like a duck then everything follows... It's just opinion
The mccanns did cooperate with the pj until it became clear the pj were just trying to implicate them.... Then they did the right thing to cease cooperation.... All my opinion
"I believe the point being made is if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck" either that or Jane Tanners description of a man carrying a child due to her False Memory Syndrome. In Kate's opinion at least one of them was a tosser.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: barrier on January 28, 2018, 05:47:40 PM
"I believe the point being made is if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck" either that or Jane Tanners description of a man carrying a child due to her False Memory Syndrome.
Move on,the Tanner sighting according to Redwood is almost certainly a fellow brit taking his child home(place of sleep),not how some would would like it"almost certainly an abductor"
Do past events tell their own story,yes when some won't except SY have almost certainly ruled various persons out.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 28, 2018, 05:57:03 PM
"I believe the point being made is if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck" either that or Jane Tanners description of a man carrying a child due to her False Memory Syndrome. In Kate's opinion at least one of them was a tosser.
it looks like JT was absolutely right...IMO she saw a man carrying a child
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Robittybob1 on January 28, 2018, 06:30:30 PM
A missing UK child in a foreign country, with huge media interest, brownie points for politicians, a very suspect case involving some members of the same team...
Madeleine was young, pretty and white. A sad fact is that if she'd been a brown, unphotogenic, male adolescent, the case masy not have attracted the same amount of attention, and therefore less effort. That is something that I do find unfair, but not because there was so much help to help find Madeleine, but that every missing kid (or even an adult in suspected non-voluntary disappearance cases) should be afforded the same.
There was a case a few years ago of a family trying to find a missing black UK 13-year-old girl... and the press was barely interested. They then decided to make a media storm out of it using the key-word Maddie and the media then latched onto it. As a result of the attention, the girl was eventually found, alive, a few weeks after that.
Missing white woman syndrome coupled with a PM who would sell his soul for a soundbite that pitched him into the news. Stay close enough to take most credit but not too close you cannot deny all responsibility when the fit is in the shan.
Iraq and Tone and I paraphrase cos I can't be a***d to look up the proper quote but it goes a little bit like mi dearios [if you remember your Rambling Sids]. "This is no time for soundbites but I feel the hand of history is on us"...... @)(++(*
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 28, 2018, 07:53:24 PM
it looks like JT was absolutely right...IMO she saw a man carrying a child
She could well have done so but where and when is undetermined. She also claimed to have slid past Gerry chatting to Jez and both men say she was mistaken. Then there was the flawed identification of Murat whom some among her group thought was seen near the McCann's apartment the night Maddie went missing. All of this adds up to one big bunch of confused people. As the title of my thread suggests, past events do tell their own story.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: sadie on January 29, 2018, 12:01:58 AM
She could well have done so but where and when is undetermined. She also claimed to have slid past Gerry chatting to Jez and both men say she was mistaken. Then there was the flawed identification of Murat whom some among her group thought was seen near the McCann's apartment the night Maddie went missing. All of this adds up to one big bunch of confused people. As the title of my thread suggests, past events do tell their own story.
In the same way as past events with Amaral? Do they tell their own story ?
BTW, What's this flawed identification bit about? Jane did not identify Murat.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 29, 2018, 12:17:27 AM
In the same way as past events with Amaral? Do they tell their own story ?
BTW, What's this flawed identification bit about? Jane did not identify Murat.
Isn't that why the police went to the bother of setting up a covert observation whereby Tanner could watch Murat walk across the same road she had seen the man carrying a child. Did she not claim Murat had a gait similar to the man?
Murat normally wears spectacles but the mystery man didn't do so.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: sadie on January 29, 2018, 12:33:17 AM
Isn't that why the police went to the bother of setting up a covert observation whereby Tanner could watch Murat walk across the same road she had seen the man carrying a child. Did she not claim Murat had a gait similar to the man?
Murat normally wears spectacles but the mystery man didn't do so.
I dont recall anything about Murat having a similar gait to th eman. Please could you tell me where I can find that. TY
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 29, 2018, 03:56:47 PM
I dont recall anything about Murat having a similar gait to th eman. Please could you tell me where I can find that. TY
Amaral's version of events which is reproduced in his book...
JANE TANNER FORMALLY RECOGNISES ROBERT MURAT
Before the search, we want to assure ourselves that Jane Tanner recognises him as the individual she saw on the night of the disappearance. She is sitting inside an unmarked car, whose tinted windows allow her to see out without being spotted. The vehicle is parked at the exact spot where she was on the night of May 3rd. Robert Murat, anonymous amongst plain clothes police officers, goes up the road in the same way as the alleged abductor. Jane Tanner is adamant: it certainly is Robert Murat that she saw that night. She definitely recognises his way of walking. But does he resemble the description she painted previously?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 29, 2018, 04:05:56 PM
Amaral's version of events which is reproduced in his book...
JANE TANNER FORMALLY RECOGNISES ROBERT MURAT
Before the search, we want to assure ourselves that Jane Tanner recognises him as the individual she saw on the night of the disappearance. She is sitting inside an unmarked car, whose tinted windows allow her to see out without being spotted. The vehicle is parked at the exact spot where she was on the night of May 3rd. Robert Murat, anonymous amongst plain clothes police officers, goes up the road in the same way as the alleged abductor. Jane Tanner is adamant: it certainly is Robert Murat that she saw that night. She definitely recognises his way of walking. But does he resemble the description she painted previously?
amaral also says in his book that in Jersey Eddie discovered a cadaver underneath a concrete slab...which is plainly untrue so i dont think we can totally accept what amaral says in his book
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: faithlilly on January 29, 2018, 04:12:31 PM
amaral also says in his book that in Jersey Eddie discovered a cadaver underneath a concrete slab...which is plainly untrue so i dont think we can totally accept what amaral says in his book
Bob Small, the British police officer, was also involved in van incident. Has he disputed what Amaral said ?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 29, 2018, 04:15:22 PM
Has he confirmed it..... Grime hasn't disputed the dog claim I doubt small has read the book
You think he wouldn't have got to find out even if he hadn't read the book ? Really ?
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 29, 2018, 04:55:13 PM
The account in Dr Kate McCann’s book ‘madeleine’ (pp. 134-6)
“…we went round to see Fiona and David. Fiona told us she’d seen Robert Murat outside Apartment 5A on the night of Madeleine’s disappearance. Then I began to feel panicky. It had belatedly begun to dawn on me that it probably wouldn’t be good news at all if someone living as close as Robert Murat was involved. As Fiona and David speculated I became more an more anxious. I didn’t want to hear it. Within the space of a couple of hours I went from feeling cautiously optimistic to very, very low. Another long, dark night followed.
It later transpired that on the evening before Murat was taken in for questioning, the police had summoned Jane to a mysterious rendezvous in the car park next to the Millennium area, refusing to say why they wanted to see her and insisting she told no-one. Their behaviour seemed so sinister that she was quite scared.
Russell walked her to the car park. On the way they passed Casa Liliana [home of Robert Murat], just as Murat was returning to his villa in his van. He stopped to speak to Russ, whom he must have seen around, eager to tell him what he and his mother were doing to find Madeleine. Jane, who had never met Murat, was not taking much notice. She was just anxious to get going and for this cloak-and-dagger meeting to be over with. When Russell managed to extricate them, Murat said he needed to be off, too, mentioning that the police wanted to see him.
From the car park Jane was driven round to a nearby street, where a PJ officer asked her to get into the back of a van disguised to resemble a refrigerated delivery vehicle (‘Like Sooty’s van’, she told us). The police took her straight back to the Ocean Club. They had wanted to park at the point where she’d seen the man and child on 3 May but there was another car there and they had to stop further down the road. She was instructed to look out of the window and tell the police whether she could identify anyone crossing the junction of Rua Dr Gentil Martins and Rua Dr Agostinho da Silva as the person she had seen that night. Three men walked by. Two of then looked nothing like the figures she had described: one was blond and tall and the other too fat. The third could have been him, but at that distance she couldn’t make him out properly and unfortunately, just as he crossed the road, he was obscured by the car in the space the police had wanted, which chose that moment to pull out.
The police moved the van to the car park opposite the Ocean Club entrance to try to give Jane a better look at the third man, but here he was walking along a path and her sightline was blocked by foliage. By now the van windows were steaming up, too. She told the police she could not be sure either way. One of the officers made a phone call to check whether she needed to sign a statement to this effect but then informed her it wouldn’t be necessary.
When Murat appeared on the TV news the next day, Russell pointed him out as the man who had stopped to talk to then outside Casa Liliana the previous evening. Jane was concerned that he might have been picked up purely as the result of the amateurish identity parade in which he unwittingly participated. Like Fiona, Russell declared he’d seen Murat outside Apartment 5A on the evening of 3 May, as, they discovered, had Rachael.
Jane phoned Detective Chief Superintendent Bob Small. She told him she’d encountered Murat before her rendezvous with the PJ and mentioned that Russell and Rachael had said they’d noticed him outside our flat on the night Madeleine vanished, on case either piece of information was important. Although at that stage it didn’t appear to our friends to be noteworthy for Murat to have been nearby when Madeleine was abducted - he lived juts along the road , after all, and there was no reason why he shouldn’t have been there - the police took further statements from Fiona, Russell and Rachael.
It was perhaps telling that Jane had not been required to sign anything, since the absence of documentary evidence to the contrary allowed claims to be made later that she had identified Murat as the man she’d seen on 3 May. This was completely untrue. Jane would’ve loved to have been able to make a definite identification, because it might have helped the investigation, but the fact is she couldn’t. The set-up was so inadequate that he was unable even to recognise Murat as the man she had met half an hour earlier, let alone say with any certainty that he was the one she had seen ten days before.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 29, 2018, 05:17:57 PM
The account in Dr Kate McCann’s book ‘madeleine’ (pp. 134-6)
“…we went round to see Fiona and David. Fiona told us she’d seen Robert Murat outside Apartment 5A on the night of Madeleine’s disappearance. Then I began to feel panicky. It had belatedly begun to dawn on me that it probably wouldn’t be good news at all if someone living as close as Robert Murat was involved. As Fiona and David speculated I became more an more anxious. I didn’t want to hear it. Within the space of a couple of hours I went from feeling cautiously optimistic to very, very low. Another long, dark night followed.
It later transpired that on the evening before Murat was taken in for questioning, the police had summoned Jane to a mysterious rendezvous in the car park next to the Millennium area, refusing to say why they wanted to see her and insisting she told no-one. Their behaviour seemed so sinister that she was quite scared.
Russell walked her to the car park. On the way they passed Casa Liliana [home of Robert Murat], just as Murat was returning to his villa in his van. He stopped to speak to Russ, whom he must have seen around, eager to tell him what he and his mother were doing to find Madeleine. Jane, who had never met Murat, was not taking much notice. She was just anxious to get going and for this cloak-and-dagger meeting to be over with. When Russell managed to extricate them, Murat said he needed to be off, too, mentioning that the police wanted to see him.
From the car park Jane was driven round to a nearby street, where a PJ officer asked her to get into the back of a van disguised to resemble a refrigerated delivery vehicle (‘Like Sooty’s van’, she told us). The police took her straight back to the Ocean Club. They had wanted to park at the point where she’d seen the man and child on 3 May but there was another car there and they had to stop further down the road. She was instructed to look out of the window and tell the police whether she could identify anyone crossing the junction of Rua Dr Gentil Martins and Rua Dr Agostinho da Silva as the person she had seen that night. Three men walked by. Two of then looked nothing like the figures she had described: one was blond and tall and the other too fat. The third could have been him, but at that distance she couldn’t make him out properly and unfortunately, just as he crossed the road, he was obscured by the car in the space the police had wanted, which chose that moment to pull out.
The police moved the van to the car park opposite the Ocean Club entrance to try to give Jane a better look at the third man, but here he was walking along a path and her sightline was blocked by foliage. By now the van windows were steaming up, too. She told the police she could not be sure either way. One of the officers made a phone call to check whether she needed to sign a statement to this effect but then informed her it wouldn’t be necessary.
When Murat appeared on the TV news the next day, Russell pointed him out as the man who had stopped to talk to then outside Casa Liliana the previous evening. Jane was concerned that he might have been picked up purely as the result of the amateurish identity parade in which he unwittingly participated. Like Fiona, Russell declared he’d seen Murat outside Apartment 5A on the evening of 3 May, as, they discovered, had Rachael.
Jane phoned Detective Chief Superintendent Bob Small. She told him she’d encountered Murat before her rendezvous with the PJ and mentioned that Russell and Rachael had said they’d noticed him outside our flat on the night Madeleine vanished, on case either piece of information was important. Although at that stage it didn’t appear to our friends to be noteworthy for Murat to have been nearby when Madeleine was abducted - he lived juts along the road , after all, and there was no reason why he shouldn’t have been there - the police took further statements from Fiona, Russell and Rachael.
It was perhaps telling that Jane had not been required to sign anything, since the absence of documentary evidence to the contrary allowed claims to be made later that she had identified Murat as the man she’d seen on 3 May. This was completely untrue. Jane would’ve loved to have been able to make a definite identification, because it might have helped the investigation, but the fact is she couldn’t. The set-up was so inadequate that he was unable even to recognise Murat as the man she had met half an hour earlier, let alone say with any certainty that he was the one she had seen ten days before.
So in Kate's, account Jane claims, not to have, identified Murat from the, van
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: Angelo222 on January 29, 2018, 06:10:06 PM
So in Kate's, account Jane claims, not to have, identified Murat from the, van
Seems so but then if she did say that he walked a bit like the mystery man then that is what the PJ picked up on. I agree though, hardly an identification.
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: sadie on January 30, 2018, 12:12:30 AM
Amaral's version of events which is reproduced in his book...
JANE TANNER FORMALLY RECOGNISES ROBERT MURAT
Before the search, we want to assure ourselves that Jane Tanner recognises him as the individual she saw on the night of the disappearance. She is sitting inside an unmarked car, whose tinted windows allow her to see out without being spotted. The vehicle is parked at the exact spot where she was on the night of May 3rd. Robert Murat, anonymous amongst plain clothes police officers, goes up the road in the same way as the alleged abductor. Jane Tanner is adamant: it certainly is Robert Murat that she saw that night. She definitely recognises his way of walking. But does he resemble the description she painted previously?
As Davel says, we cant trust Amarals statements. There is no record of Jane mentioning Murats gait at all, in fact Jane signed no statement about it either AFAWK.
Thanks you Angelo for doing the honourable thing and posting the piece below which confirms that Jane did not identify Murat as Tannerman
The account in Dr Kate McCann’s book ‘madeleine’ (pp. 134-6)
[ The police took her straight back to the Ocean Club. They had wanted to park at the point where she’d seen the man and child on 3 May but there was another car there and they had to stop further down the road. She was instructed to look out of the window and tell the police whether she could identify anyone crossing the junction of Rua Dr Gentil Martins and Rua Dr Agostinho da Silva as the person she had seen that night. Three men walked by. Two of then looked nothing like the figures she had described: one was blond and tall and the other too fat. The third could have been him, but at that distance she couldn’t make him out properly and unfortunately, just as he crossed the road, he was obscured by the car in the space the police had wanted, which chose that moment to pull out.
The police moved the van to the car park opposite the Ocean Club entrance to try to give Jane a better look at the third man, but here he was walking along a path and her sightline was blocked by foliage. By now the van windows were steaming up, too. She told the police she could not be sure either way. One of the officers made a phone call to check whether she needed to sign a statement to this effect but then informed her it wouldn’t be necessary. -snip-
-snip- It was perhaps telling that Jane had not been required to sign anything, since the absence of documentary evidence to the contrary allowed claims to be made later that she had identified Murat as the man she’d seen on 3 May. This was completely untrue. Jane would’ve loved to have been able to make a definite identification, because it might have helped the investigation, but the fact is she couldn’t. The set-up was so inadequate that he was unable even to recognise Murat as the man she had met half an hour earlier, let alone say with any certainty that he was the one she had seen ten days before.[/b]
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: faithlilly on January 30, 2018, 12:21:22 AM
As Davel says, we cant trust Amarals statements. There is no record of Jane mentioning Murats gait at all, in fact Jane signed no statement about it either AFAWK.
Thanks you Angelo for doing the honourable thing and posting the piece below which confirms that Jane did not identify Murat as Tannerman
But...but...but what about Amaral pointing to the alleyway ? You said we could trust that statement ! Geez Sadie you sure know how to confuse a girl !
Title: Re: Do past events tell their own story?
Post by: pathfinder73 on January 30, 2018, 12:24:50 AM
As Davel says, we cant trust Amarals statements. There is no record of Jane mentioning Murats gait at all, in fact Jane signed no statement about it either AFAWK.
Thanks you Angelo for doing the honourable thing and posting the piece below which confirms that Jane did not identify Murat as Tannerman
Reply “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
Reply “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.