UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on November 22, 2015, 05:24:02 PM

Title: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on November 22, 2015, 05:24:02 PM
Introduced from another thread.


snip

... I suspected at the time it, when all other information became known, that it was to protect their reputation and to prevent being charged with child abandonment- to save face etc.

There was indeed a great fear among some members of the tapas 9 in the beginning that their parenting methods would come under intense scrutiny and possibly even attract charges of a sort.  In the event we all know what happened with that particular dragon being well and truly put to bed.

28
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 22, 2015, 07:39:10 PM
There was indeed a great fear among some members of the tapas 9 in the beginning that their parenting methods would come under intense scrutiny and possibly even attract charges of a sort.  In the event we all know what happened with that particular dragon being well and truly put to bed.

I don't think that even entered their heads John -  as they all knew that Mark Warner was a company which offered the Listening Service as some had used it before  - and when they realised it wasn't offered at that site - they simply decided to mirror it themselves.     If it's legal for MW to do  - then obviously  it's legal for the parents.    In fact the group's method was superior IMO as they could actually go into the apartments rather than just listen at doors.

Almost the first thing the group did was to write down their child checking times which they handed to  the police.   That doesn't sound to me like people who were worried that they had done something illegal.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on November 22, 2015, 08:06:24 PM
I don't think that even entered their heads John -  as they all knew that Mark Warner was a company which offered the Listening Service as some had used it before  - and when they realised it wasn't offered at that site - they simply decided to mirror it themselves.     If it's legal for MW to do  - then obviously  it's legal for the parents.    In fact the group's method was superior IMO as they could actually go into the apartments rather than just listen at doors.

Almost the first thing the group did was to write down their child checking times which they handed to  the police.   That doesn't sound to me like people who were worried that they had done something illegal.

I don't agree Benice, they were very publicly ridiculed and vilified from the outset over their child-care arrangements.  It is well documented that the Portuguese police considered whether neglect charges should be brought against them but in the end the absence of intent decided it.  According to the PJ report they were negligent in their duty of care towards a minor but since it wasn't intentional they weren't prosecuted.

And you would have us believe that didn't concern them?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 22, 2015, 08:15:53 PM
I don't think that even entered their heads John -  as they all knew that Mark Warner was a company which offered the Listening Service as some had used it before  - and when they realised it wasn't offered at that site - they simply decided to mirror it themselves.     If it's legal for MW to do  - then obviously  it's legal for the parents.    In fact the group's method was superior IMO as they could actually go into the apartments rather than just listen at doors.

Almost the first thing the group did was to write down their child checking times which they handed to  the police.   That doesn't sound to me like people who were worried that they had done something illegal.
I go the opposite way.  If the priority was writing down the child checking times, I'd wonder why.  To me, it sounds like worried people.  Please note, I did say TO ME.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 22, 2015, 08:35:06 PM
I don't agree Benice, they were very publicly ridiculed and vilified from the outset over their child-care arrangements.  It is well documented that the Portuguese police considered whether neglect charges should be brought against them but in the end the absence of intent decided it.  According to the PJ report they were negligent in their duty of care towards a minor but since it wasn't intentional they weren't prosecuted.

And you would have us believe that didn't concern them?

Why should they be concerned - they hadn't broken any laws - as confirmed by the Portuguese AG. 

 As I said before -  if it was legal for Mark Warner and other companies, hoteliers etc etc to operate the listening service, then how can it be illegal for the actual parents to do the same thing ?     If it was illegal then every other parent who has done the same either by signing up for the service, or providing it themselves must all be guilty.    That's thousands and thousands of people we are talking about - not to mention those parents who still do the same (but only on holiday) and those who use baby alarms (but only on holiday) when they leave their children asleep and go to dinner.

For some reason (which I find unfathomable) these childcare arrangements are obviously legally acceptable in the Holiday/Tourism business. - whereas if parents did the same at home - it would be severely frowned upon.

The practice should be banned IMO.


   

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 22, 2015, 08:40:00 PM
I go the opposite way.  If the priority was writing down the child checking times, I'd wonder why.  To me, it sounds like worried people.  Please note, I did say TO ME.

IIRC one reason was to get the times down before they forgot them and when they did hand it to the police officer who was there with them -  he apparently said .... 'That's what we want' - or words to that effect.  (from memory).
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 22, 2015, 08:52:04 PM
Leaving 3 very young children in an unsecured apartment isn't intentional? Personally there's no excuse for that abnormal behaviour in light of what happened. It's amazing how many of these unsolved cases had unlocked doors - Sabrina Aisenberg, Eloise Worledge.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 22, 2015, 11:23:35 PM
Leaving 3 very young children in an unsecured apartment isn't intentional? Personally there's no excuse for that abnormal behaviour in light of what happened. It's amazing how many of these unsolved cases had unlocked doors - Sabrina Aisenberg, Eloise Worledge.


"Personally there's no excuse for that abnormal behaviour in light of what happened."  Isn't hindsight a wonderful thing?

Two year old Lyndon Albers was seen by her parents appx 3.00am who reported her missing at 7.00am. That puts them right in the frame as far as opportunity and the last to see Lyndon goes.

Thankfully she was found before she could be subject to more harm, but if that had not happened and a cadaver dog had alerted in her bedroom to whatever??, I think her parents could well have been subjected to traumatic court appearances.  Certainly the police chief was leaving nothing to chance.

The first thing the police chief did was get a search warrant for the house which was treated as a crime scene.  That was at a time when the "crime was unknown" ... but it was known that a child was missing.
What wasn't known was if she left the house of her own volition or if she had been abducted.

I find it interesting that the report states that the abduction was not a random crime and further investigation is continuing ... it will be interesting to see what the evidence turns up.

However despite the trauma to their child and the trauma of her abduction at least Lyndon's parents have been spared the maelstrom Madeleine McCann's parents have been subjected to.  But for Mr and Mrs Crosby the situation could have been so different.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 23, 2015, 08:47:06 PM
Leaving 3 very young children in an unsecured apartment isn't intentional? Personally there's no excuse for that abnormal behaviour in light of what happened. It's amazing how many of these unsolved cases had unlocked doors - Sabrina Aisenberg, Eloise Worledge.

Good spot.

Re the "intent" , even though they took a risk IMO, there was no intent to harm, so not  culpable in Portuguese law...English law may well have been alot different

Maybe someone knows the answer to the question, why people are happy to do the home alone thing abroad but not at home

Odd

IMHO

I also watched the documentary where Gerry Mccann said his wife was always overprotective and he was more laissez faire with the kids, and after the abduction it changed for him, ....if leaving three toddlers alone out of sight and hearing with unlocked door is overprotective then not sure what not just normally protective could mean!!


 &%+((£

The staging article is very fascinating, thanks LP

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on November 23, 2015, 09:29:50 PM
I go the opposite way.  If the priority was writing down the child checking times, I'd wonder why.  To me, it sounds like worried people.  Please note, I did say TO ME.

And me and many,many other people. The reasons being; there wasn't any organised times or schedules that they stuck to. In fact it was all very ad hoc .as and when. 'what ever' attitude.  They did manage to rearrange the time line, which was good luck, and they almost had us believing there was an abduction done within minutes of these so called 'checking' episodes. They had it so tight unbelievable was soon discarded to scientifically proved bloody impossible. (man/men jemmying a window- grabs child- gets out without leaving a trace)..and she slept right through all that?

On two points.

Re parents not breaking the law- well how smug are they? all happy to say it wasn't their fault, they committed no crime... blah blah

Re "In fact the group's method was superior IMO as they could actually go into the apartments rather than just listen at doors".  So  Superior their daughter 'disappeared' ,how many 'abductions'  under the far less superior 'listening' services ? do we have data?
Well of course we don't have data the parents said they felt it safe, what do they know as intelligent doctors mmm

Well that quote can go down as one of those quotes which deem to deflect responsibility.  It is  right up there with Maddie came to no harm.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 23, 2015, 09:35:28 PM
Mistaken, I dont know what the other Tapas group did but the Mccanns checking was NOT superior by going into the apartment  seeing as they they only went in to do an auditory and NOT physical check
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on November 23, 2015, 10:11:09 PM
Why should they be concerned - they hadn't broken any laws - as confirmed by the Portuguese AG. 

 As I said before -  if it was legal for Mark Warner and other companies, hoteliers etc etc to operate the listening service, then how can it be illegal for the actual parents to do the same thing ?     If it was illegal then every other parent who has done the same either by signing up for the service, or providing it themselves must all be guilty.    That's thousands and thousands of people we are talking about - not to mention those parents who still do the same (but only on holiday) and those who use baby alarms (but only on holiday) when they leave their children asleep and go to dinner.

For some reason (which I find unfathomable) these childcare arrangements are obviously legally acceptable in the Holiday/Tourism business. - whereas if parents did the same at home - it would be severely frowned upon.

The practice should be banned IMO.

Sorry for not replying sooner Benice.

The question of breaking any laws was not determined until several months after Madeleine disappeared if I recall correctly and as I previously posted, it was only then determined by the Attorney General in his Archive Report.  During that period the uncertainty of what was about to happen must have been extremely concerning for Madeleine's parents since a child neglect related conviction would have destroyed their careers back in the UK.  My personal view is that they were extremely lucky to get away with a social workers review of their circumstances.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 23, 2015, 10:32:53 PM
no brainer
Nearest barrister near the fund...sorted

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 23, 2015, 11:44:31 PM
Why should they be concerned - they hadn't broken any laws - as confirmed by the Portuguese AG. 

 As I said before -  if it was legal for Mark Warner and other companies, hoteliers etc etc to operate the listening service, then how can it be illegal for the actual parents to do the same thing ?     If it was illegal then every other parent who has done the same either by signing up for the service, or providing it themselves must all be guilty.    That's thousands and thousands of people we are talking about - not to mention those parents who still do the same (but only on holiday) and those who use baby alarms (but only on holiday) when they leave their children asleep and go to dinner.

For some reason (which I find unfathomable) these childcare arrangements are obviously legally acceptable in the Holiday/Tourism business. - whereas if parents did the same at home - it would be severely frowned upon.

The practice should be banned IMO.



It is not just a matter of local law and the efficacy of baby listening services. It is a matter of what one finds acceptable regardless of where one is geographically although that will have an effect on ones decision making process. Also potential repercussions under the laws of ones own country should things go wrong will need to be considered.
But, pretty much as I posted elsewhere on this topic, here is the problem.
"Maintain the safety of your child(ren) for a period of three hours in a foreign country where your apartment is not in a secure building or compound and may be accessed from public highways on two sides".
You may also wish to have a meal within the specified time frame.
Sort out a solution with which you will be content. The solution selection process also should include what price you are prepared to pay should your decision go belly up.
I can imagine people being apprehensive under the circumstances of this case particularly as at face value the attitude seems to have been "oh well we will probably get away with it".
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 24, 2015, 01:24:23 AM
An inconsistency from witness Fiona Payne who knows Kate the best out of their group of friends about leaving the apartment unsecured.

"I mean, I was a bit surprised, I mean, Kate, you were asking about what they're like as parents, and they're certainly not, erm, paranoid parents, what I would call paranoid parents, you know, but they're very, very careful parents. Erm, you know, I've got friends who are very laid back and, you know, I wouldn't be surprised, erm, for them to feel happy doing that sort of thing. But it did surprise me a bit with Kate, because I think, you know, she is, between her and Gerry, they are very different, she is very cautious, Gerry, erm, you know, is probably more sort of happy to, tut, relax and go with the flow and that sort of thing, Kate is very, very much more cautious. So, you know, I think, as I said earlier, I think that was something she wasn't quite happy with'".

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 24, 2015, 07:44:19 AM
Peer pressure could have had an impact. The others were happy to leave the kids, well one had a baby monitor and another seemed to spend more time in he apartment. The desire not to miss out on a friends night out can be very strong.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 24, 2015, 10:49:00 AM

So do you think everyone from humble beginnings love their reputations more than their children?  Or is that just the McCanns?    Can you suggest anything from their lives before that holiday which even hinted they were social climbers.     According to people who knew them - they were just normal loving parents - who rarely went out once they had a family.

Peddling to work on a pushbike as Gerry does - hardly seems to fit in with a desperate desire to be recognised 'socially'  - a craving for which  (according to some)  - is so important to them that they wouldn't think twice about getting rid of one of their children - if they inconveniently got in the way of their  'progress' up the social ladder.

I've never heard such nonsense  -and as usual not a shred of evidence to support it.

I certainly think because they had struggled so hard and sacrificed so much to gain their social standing the destruction of their lives, and that of their remaining children,  as the result of a terrible misjudgement would certainly have been a driving force behind what happened next.

As to the bike, I don't see your point. Doesn't Boris Johnson ride a bike to work too ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 24, 2015, 12:41:10 PM
SUSAN HEALY: Well I have to say that I'm surprised that Kate and Gerry left their children at all and I've thought about it a lot because they're such caring parents and I think - why?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 24, 2015, 11:24:11 PM
Introduced from another thread.


There was indeed a great fear among some members of the tapas 9 in the beginning that their parenting methods would come under intense scrutiny and possibly even attract charges of a sort.  In the event we all know what happened with that particular dragon being well and truly put to bed.

15

At the end of the day John the issues are not all about the childcare  arrangements in this case
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 25, 2015, 08:59:06 AM
The McCann's made an error of judgement,  for which they have been investigated.   Madeleine disappeared because someone took her,   and that is something the McCann's could never have predicted. 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 25, 2015, 09:05:23 AM
Most parents are 'not there' when their child disappears.  They can be taken in seconds.

Sara Payne
April Jones
Ben Needham

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 25, 2015, 09:07:22 AM
The McCann's made an error of judgement,  for which they have been investigated.   Madeleine disappeared because someone took her,   and that is something the McCann's could never have predicted.

Some person(s) removed her from the apartment.

Cause, UNDETERMINED.

Don't lose sight of that.

As to predictions, the mccanns thought that socializing was far more important than looking after their children, and their safety.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 25, 2015, 09:22:09 AM
Most parents are 'not there' when their child disappears.  They can be taken in seconds.

Sara Payne
April Jones
Ben Needham

...and how many of them were asleep at night?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 25, 2015, 09:34:11 AM
...and how many of them were asleep at night?
relevance?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 25, 2015, 09:38:47 AM
...and how many of them were asleep at night?

You would have thought Madeleine would be the safest,  asleep in her bed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 25, 2015, 10:16:40 AM
Of course strictly speaking there's no proof that the patio door and the bedroom window  were unlocked.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on November 25, 2015, 11:13:37 AM
Of course strictly speaking there's no proof that the patio door and the bedroom window  were unlocked.

Kate made a point of bringing the issue of the unlocked patio door open into conversation while at the tapas restaurant shortly before Maddie's disappearance was discovered.  How about that for coincidence?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 25, 2015, 11:39:54 AM
Kate made a point of bringing the issue of the unlocked patio door open into conversation while at the tapas restaurant shortly before Maddie's disappearance was discovered.  How about that for coincidence?

The apartment was locked every time they went out in the daytime, including during the day on 3rd May. How strange to lock it when there was no-one in, but leave it unlocked when vulnerable infants were in there alone.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on November 25, 2015, 11:39:17 PM
For information.

Please note that the off-topic posts from this thread have been moved.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6822.msg288579#msg288579
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 25, 2015, 11:58:27 PM
The apartment was locked every time they went out in the daytime, including during the day on 3rd May. How strange to lock it when there was no-one in, but leave it unlocked when vulnerable infants were in there alone.

Apparently most  burglaries were durng the day when hoidaymakers were out...still you dnt leave your three  toddlers alone in an unlocked apartment do you?

Or lie about it as kate mccann lied
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on November 26, 2015, 12:04:18 AM
Apparently most  burglaries were durng the day when hoidaymakers were out...still you dnt leave your three  toddlers alone in an unlocked apartment do you?

Or lie about it as kate mccann lied

You don't leave them alone regardless.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 26, 2015, 12:10:07 AM
You don't leave them alone regardless.
Most protective sane parents wouldnt
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 26, 2015, 03:04:01 AM
Most protective sane parents wouldnt

Do you know how many protective sane parents have lost their babies to cot bumper deaths?
http://www.foxnews.com/health/2015/11/24/more-infant-deaths-blamed-on-crib-bumpers.html

Are the parents & authorities who condone the continued use of bumpers more or less negligent than the McCanns & their form of childcare?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 26, 2015, 07:17:59 AM
Do you know how many protective sane parents have lost their babies to cot bumper deaths?
http://www.foxnews.com/health/2015/11/24/more-infant-deaths-blamed-on-crib-bumpers.html

Are the parents & authorities who condone the continued use of bumpers more or less negligent than the McCanns & their form of childcare?

There's no negligence involved in buying a cot bumper. A parent expects such things to be tested and to be safe. We all know it's dangerous to leave small children home alone. Deciding to do so is negligent, even if nothing happens to the children.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 07:23:08 AM
There's no negligence involved in buying a cot bumper. A parent expects such things to be tested and to be safe. We all know it's dangerous to leave small children home alone. Deciding to do so is negligent, even if nothing happens to the children.

in your opinion
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 26, 2015, 09:09:00 AM
in your opinion

My correct opinion. Things that could happen when leaving three children under 5 alone.

1. Hysterical crying.
2. Sickness.
3. Getting out of bed and going into other rooms.
4. Finding dangerous substances in the kitchen such as cleaning products, knives.
5. Turning taps on in bathroom.
6. Finding and taking medicines.
7. Fire.
8. Messing with electric plugs.
9. Climbing and falling.
10. Tripping and hurting themselves.

None of which seems to have occurred to these parents.




Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 26, 2015, 09:17:10 AM
My correct opinion. Things that could happen when leaving three children under 5 alone.

1. Hysterical crying.
2. Sickness.
3. Getting out of bed and going into other rooms.
4. Finding dangerous substances in the kitchen such as cleaning products, knives.
5. Turning taps on in bathroom.
6. Finding and taking medicines.
7. Fire.
8. Messing with electric plugs.
9. Climbing and falling.
10. Tripping and hurting themselves.

None of which seems to have occurred to these parents.

....but they did exhibit 'responsible parenting skills'. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 26, 2015, 09:19:36 AM
Do you know how many protective sane parents have lost their babies to cot bumper deaths?
http://www.foxnews.com/health/2015/11/24/more-infant-deaths-blamed-on-crib-bumpers.html

Are the parents & authorities who condone the continued use of bumpers more or less negligent than the McCanns & their form of childcare?

Irrelevant
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 09:45:36 AM
Irrelevant

OF COURSE ITS RELEVANT
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 26, 2015, 10:14:28 AM
My correct opinion. Things that could happen when leaving three children under 5 alone.

1. Hysterical crying.
2. Sickness.
3. Getting out of bed and going into other rooms.
4. Finding dangerous substances in the kitchen such as cleaning products, knives.
5. Turning taps on in bathroom.
6. Finding and taking medicines.
7. Fire.
8. Messing with electric plugs.
9. Climbing and falling.
10. Tripping and hurting themselves.

None of which seems to have occurred to these parents.

Apparently neither did any of  the above occur to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner - knowing they were being regularly checked.   Not to mention those parents who rely on  baby alarms as childminders and so don't physically check at all.

It seems to me that when it comes to the McCanns - then some sceptics have decided that 100% 'perfect' parenting is the only standard of care that they will accept from them.      That's a very tall order considering there is no such thing as a perfect parent or a perfect human being.

If parents listed all the things which could go wrong regarding their children's safety re whatever it was they had decided to do during the day   - they would never leave their sides 24/7  - and they certainly would never put them in a car.

The never-ending attempts by some to single out the McCanns from the rest of us - and constantly berrate them for not being perfect parents or perfect human beings is both illogical and irrational IMO.

No different IMO  to blaming a parent if the child they were transporting in their car was killed by the actions of some drunken driver crashing into them.    We all know that hundreds of children are killed in cars every year - but that doesn't stop us using them to transport our own children - even at times when it would be just as easy to walk.     Does that make us irresponsible or neglectful parents?  Of course it doesn't.

Parents get it wrong all the time -  it's called 'being human'.    Fortunately the great majority of mistakes made don't end up in tragedy - but some do and that's how it will continue.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 26, 2015, 10:20:01 AM
Apparently neither did any of  the above occur to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner - knowing they were being regularly checked.   Not to mention those parents who rely on  baby alarms as childminders and so don't physically check at all.

It seems to me that when it comes to the McCanns - then some sceptics have decided that 100% 'perfect' parenting is the only standard of care that they will accept from them.      That's a very tall order considering there is no such thing as a perfect parent or a perfect human being.

If parents listed all the things which could go wrong regarding their children's safety re whatever it was they had decided to do during the day   - they would never leave their sides 24/7  - and they certainly would never put them in a car.

The never-ending attempts by some to single out the McCanns from the rest of us - and constantly berrate them for not being perfect parents or perfect human beings is both illogical and irrational IMO.

No different IMO  to blaming a parent if the child they were transporting in their car was killed by the actions of some drunken driver crashing into them.    We all know that hundreds of children are killed in cars every year - but that doesn't stop us using them to transport our own children - even at times when it would be just as easy to walk.     Does that make us irresponsible or neglectful parents?  Of course it doesn't.

Parents get it wrong all the time -  it's called 'being human'.    Fortunately the great majority of mistakes made don't end up in tragedy - but some do and that's how it will continue.

....and what about the millions and millions of parents, who would have never done what the mccanns did ?

Do they get a look in ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 26, 2015, 10:39:03 AM
Apparently neither did any of  the above occur to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner - knowing they were being regularly checked.   Not to mention those parents who rely on  baby alarms as childminders and so don't physically check at all.

It seems to me that when it comes to the McCanns - then some sceptics have decided that 100% 'perfect' parenting is the only standard of care that they will accept from them.      That's a very tall order considering there is no such thing as a perfect parent or a perfect human being.

If parents listed all the things which could go wrong regarding their children's safety re whatever it was they had decided to do during the day   - they would never leave their sides 24/7  - and they certainly would never put them in a car.

The never-ending attempts by some to single out the McCanns from the rest of us - and constantly berrate them for not being perfect parents or perfect human beings is both illogical and irrational IMO.

No different IMO  to blaming a parent if the child they were transporting in their car was killed by the actions of some drunken driver crashing into them.    We all know that hundreds of children are killed in cars every year - but that doesn't stop us using them to transport our own children - even at times when it would be just as easy to walk.     Does that make us irresponsible or neglectful parents?  Of course it doesn't.

Parents get it wrong all the time -  it's called 'being human'.    Fortunately the great majority of mistakes made don't end up in tragedy - but some do and that's how it will continue.

The car comparison was one of Kate McCann's excuses wasn't it? All parents take risks and make mistakes; as you say, they're only human. Some, like the McCanns, take risks that are so lacking in sense the mind boggles. Leaving children asleep in a hotel room and using a listening service is one thing. Not even wondering why a listening service isn't on offer is something else.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 26, 2015, 11:50:45 AM
The car comparison was one of Kate McCann's excuses wasn't it? All parents take risks and make mistakes; as you say, they're only human. Some, like the McCanns, take risks that are so lacking in sense the mind boggles. Leaving children asleep in a hotel room and using a listening service is one thing. Not even wondering why a listening service isn't on offer is something else.

I would automatically think it was because it was impractical because of the layout of the site  - or because there were not enough members of staff to be able to offer the service etc.   Having no 'listening service' on offer certainly would not make me think there was some sinister reason for it  - and that I'd better go and find out what it was.  Once again IMO you are allowing hindsight to colour your views.

As a matter of interest was a reason ever offered by MW  - before the holiday as to why they did not offer this service at this particular complex?

Could you explain why the McCanns alone have been singled out for such vicious condemnation for doing what thousands of other parents have done before them on holiday.    Why do you think the listening service is still on offer  - anywhere?    The only reason I can think of is because there is still a demand for it by parents - even though they are fully aware of what happened to Madeleine.     If anyone deserved criticism for ' lacking in sense to a mind boggling degree' -  then it's those parents IMO.       And yet to hear sceptics talk  - it is as if none of those other parents even exist let alone deserve criticism - only the McCanns.    As I said - illogical and irrational IMO.

 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 26, 2015, 11:56:51 AM
Apparently neither did any of  the above occur to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner - knowing they were being regularly checked.   Not to mention those parents who rely on  baby alarms as childminders and so don't physically check at all.


Baby Alarms are a red herring, I don't believe there is a consensus that vilifies them in the same way as occasional checks.

You need to provide some evidence to your claim that none of the list applied to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 26, 2015, 12:19:59 PM
I would automatically think it was because it was impractical because of the layout of the site  - or because there were not enough members of staff to be able to offer the service etc.   Having no 'listening service' on offer certainly would not make me think there was some sinister reason for it  - and that I'd better go and find out what it was.  Once again IMO you are allowing hindsight to colour your views.

As a matter of interest was a reason ever offered by MW  - before the holiday as to why they did not offer this service at this particular complex?

Could you explain why the McCanns alone have been singled out for such vicious condemnation for doing what thousands of other parents have done before them on holiday.    Why do you think the listening service is still on offer  - anywhere?    The only reason I can think of is because there is still a demand for it by parents - even though they are fully aware of what happened to Madeleine.     If anyone deserved criticism for ' lacking in sense to a mind boggling degree' -  then it's those parents IMO.       And yet to hear sceptics talk  - it is as if none of those other parents even exist let alone deserve criticism - only the McCanns.    As I said - illogical and irrational IMO.

I know nothing about listening services, but I wouldn't be surprised if they are 'at your own risk' as the children are clearly unsupervised. The McCanns made a bad decision whichever way you spin it.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 26, 2015, 12:45:33 PM
I would automatically think it was because it was impractical because of the layout of the site  - or because there were not enough members of staff to be able to offer the service etc.   Having no 'listening service' on offer certainly would not make me think there was some sinister reason for it  - and that I'd better go and find out what it was.  Once again IMO you are allowing hindsight to colour your views.

As a matter of interest was a reason ever offered by MW  - before the holiday as to why they did not offer this service at this particular complex?

Could you explain why the McCanns alone have been singled out for such vicious condemnation for doing what thousands of other parents have done before them on holiday.    Why do you think the listening service is still on offer  - anywhere?    The only reason I can think of is because there is still a demand for it by parents - even though they are fully aware of what happened to Madeleine.     If anyone deserved criticism for ' lacking in sense to a mind boggling degree' -  then it's those parents IMO.       And yet to hear sceptics talk  - it is as if none of those other parents even exist let alone deserve criticism - only the McCanns.    As I said - illogical and irrational IMO.

 


What is clear cut is that anyone leaving young children by themselves should never behave like that, whether the mccanns or anyone else.

There is no such thing as zero risk, but commonsense can prevail.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 26, 2015, 01:03:01 PM
Apparently neither did any of  the above occur to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner - knowing they were being regularly checked.   Not to mention those parents who rely on  baby alarms as childminders and so don't physically check at all.

It seems to me that when it comes to the McCanns - then some sceptics have decided that 100% 'perfect' parenting is the only standard of care that they will accept from them.      That's a very tall order considering there is no such thing as a perfect parent or a perfect human being.

If parents listed all the things which could go wrong regarding their children's safety re whatever it was they had decided to do during the day   - they would never leave their sides 24/7  - and they certainly would never put them in a car.

The never-ending attempts by some to single out the McCanns from the rest of us - and constantly berrate them for not being perfect parents or perfect human beings is both illogical and irrational IMO.

No different IMO  to blaming a parent if the child they were transporting in their car was killed by the actions of some drunken driver crashing into them.    We all know that hundreds of children are killed in cars every year - but that doesn't stop us using them to transport our own children - even at times when it would be just as easy to walk.     Does that make us irresponsible or neglectful parents?  Of course it doesn't.

Parents get it wrong all the time -  it's called 'being human'.    Fortunately the great majority of mistakes made don't end up in tragedy - but some do and that's how it will continue.

There is a fundamental flaw in the car argument. We have a society where travel by motor car is pretty much essential unless one wishes to walk or use public transport which also carries risk. So one has little choice in the matter of travel although it carries risk  and it is bordering on impossible not to travel (in the broader sense of the word).
Leaving kids alone locked in or not locked in unattended while one has a meal some distance away is a conscious choice over which one has total control.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 26, 2015, 01:38:34 PM
Baby Alarms are a red herring, I don't believe there is a consensus that vilifies them in the same way as occasional checks.

You need to provide some evidence to your claim that none of the list applied to any of those thousands and thousands of other parents who - when on holiday - decided to leave their children alone and asleep and go to dinner.

Using a baby alarm entails leaving your children alone in their rooms unattended for lot longer periods than checking on them every 30 mins or so.    IMO a baby alarm would not stop a determined intruder from getting in - particularly if they were forewarned by parents who advertise the fact that their children are alone elsewhere- by having the baby alarm in full view on a bar/table etc for all to see.

It's common knowledge that listening services have operated in various holiday venues both here and abroad for decades.     It's obvious that unless there was a substantial demand for it - it would never have lasted such a long time.      IMO 'thousands' is a conservative estimate.   It's probably millions by now. 

Anyone who thinks that as long as their parents are present - children don't ever come to grief by way of the list of dangers submitted by G-Unit - is being completely unrealistic IMO. 

 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 26, 2015, 01:50:36 PM
Using a baby alarm entails leaving your children alone in their rooms unattended for lot longer periods than checking on them every 30 mins or so.    IMO a baby alarm would not stop a determined intruder from getting in - particularly if they were forewarned by parents who advertise the fact that their children are alone elsewhere- by having the baby alarm in full view on a bar/table etc for all to see.

It's common knowledge that listening services have operated in various holiday venues both here and abroad for decades.     It's obvious that unless there was a substantial demand for it - it would never have lasted such a long time.      IMO 'thousands' is a conservative estimate.   It's probably millions by now. 

Anyone who thinks that as long as their parents are present - children don't ever come to grief by way of the list of dangers submitted by G-Unit - is being completely unrealistic IMO.

As usual you have missed the point, a parent being present or using a monitor allows the parent to understand when the child is disturbed or active. As long as the parent isn't too distant then they can be with the child in short order. Hotels are now using technology to provide monitor like systems for listening. The days of Butlins style listening is well past especially in this country.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 26, 2015, 02:01:08 PM
As usual you have missed the point, a parent being present or using a monitor allows the parent to understand when the child is disturbed or active. As long as the parent isn't too distant then they can be with the child in short order. Hotels are now using technology to provide monitor like systems for listening. The days of Butlins style listening is well past especially in this country.

Why doesn't anyone have a go at the other friends who also left their children alone?

I really don't see the point of this thread at all.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 02:44:51 PM
As usual you have missed the point, a parent being present or using a monitor allows the parent to understand when the child is disturbed or active. As long as the parent isn't too distant then they can be with the child in short order. Hotels are now using technology to provide monitor like systems for listening. The days of Butlins style listening is well past especially in this country.

Hotels have been using this technology for the last 20 yrs
I used it using a room to reception intercom
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 26, 2015, 02:50:52 PM
As usual you have missed the point, a parent being present or using a monitor allows the parent to understand when the child is disturbed or active. As long as the parent isn't too distant then they can be with the child in short order. Hotels are now using technology to provide monitor like systems for listening. The days of Butlins style listening is well past especially in this country.

If the presence of a parent guaranteed safety -  then there would be no parents rushing their kids to hospital after a nasty fall or having taken pills not meant for them.  No children drowning in baths or garden pools, no children suffering burns/scalds, falling down stairs or out of windows and no cot deaths.    All these things have happened whilst  parents have been present in the home.

IMO a baby alarm is the most dangerous form of childcare when on holiday- particularly as anyone around with evil intent will  know whose children are alone - because they will see the baby alarm sitting there advertising the fact.

The principle of a listening service is the same everywhere.     It involves leaving children asleep alone in their rooms while the parents go elsewhere without them.  For years  - thousands of people have used it with no ill effects and some still do.    The only criminal here IMO is the intruder who took advantage of this well established and long accepted system of childcare -  to abduct a child.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 26, 2015, 03:26:48 PM
If the presence of a parent guaranteed safety -  then there would be no parents rushing their kids to hospital after a nasty fall or having taken pills not meant for them.  No children drowning in baths or garden pools, no children suffering burns/scalds, falling down stairs or out of windows and no cot deaths.    All these things have happened whilst  parents have been present in the home.

IMO a baby alarm is the most dangerous form of childcare when on holiday- particularly as anyone around with evil intent will  know whose children are alone - because they will see the baby alarm sitting there advertising the fact.

The principle of a listening service is the same everywhere.     It involves leaving children asleep alone in their rooms while the parents go elsewhere without them.  For years  - thousands of people have used it with no ill effects and some still do.    The only criminal here IMO is the intruder who took advantage of this well established and long accepted system of childcare -  to abduct a child.

Ah, yet again, mantra time.

Keep pushing abduction in the vain hope more will believe it.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 26, 2015, 07:42:30 PM
Why doesn't anyone have a go at the other friends who also left their children alone?

I really don't see the point of this thread at all.
I suspect if a child of one of the other friends had gone missing there would have been a lot of flack directed at them instead of the McCanns.  After all, it took longer to walk to the front of block 5 than it did to nip into the rear of 5A.

The thread title is not McCann specific, nor is the OP.

The difficulty faced by those trying to understand what went on is that the child checking arrangements look weird.

The T9 found out there was not an MW listening service in Luz.  Some of them decided on a DIY listening system.  The trip organiser took a baby monitor that worked despite the decision on the DIY system.  If he had been further away from an OC restaurant, and most of the OC is further away, his monitor would have been useless.  The other couple taking a monitor seems to have decided theirs was out of range.

The 6 adults doing the checking did not manage to work out that listening at all 3 ground floor flats with a rota meant the kids would be checked every 10 minutes. So why a loose listening system when it was dead easy to have a tighter one that still left the adults lots of time to relax?

The McCanns left the patio door unlocked. When did that start?  Was Luz so family friendly that it began on the first Tapas night, the Sunday, or were the McCanns taking the long route.  Was there a fire hazard then or not?

Did anyone else nearby make a similar choice?  That is, to exit by the patio door and leave their children on their own.  How about Raj Balu, on the ground floor of block 6?  Nipping out the back way would have shortened any check.

If we had a bit of clarity on some of this, it might be possible to narrow down the list of possibilities.  If an opportunistic abductor used the open patio door, his window of opportunity starts when he was able to twig a) that the McCanns were eating out regularly b) that the patio door was being left open c) that there were kids to snatch.

The longer it takes to twig a and b, the shorter the time the man has to work in, and the less likely someone first chanced upon the situation, then took the opportunity.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 26, 2015, 07:55:55 PM


IMO a baby alarm is the most dangerous form of childcare when on holiday- particularly as anyone around with evil intent will  know whose children are alone - because they will see the baby alarm sitting there advertising the fact.



What, you mean like the Mccanns telling complete strangers they were leaving their kids alone on a nightly basis?

How stupid /blase/lapse can one be?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 26, 2015, 08:08:38 PM
What, you mean like the Mccanns telling complete strangers they were leaving their kids alone on a nightly basis?

How stupid /blase/lapse can one be?

That much I agree with. It was one thing to leave the children alone, but to almost advertise the fact in an unfamiliar neighbourhood has always puzzled me.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 26, 2015, 08:17:56 PM
That much I agree with. It was one thing to leave the children alone, but to almost advertise the fact in an unfamiliar neighbourhood has always puzzled me.

Cool. There is a limit to what they can be excused for under the umbrella of "naive"... Its a paternal/maternal instinct to safeguard your kids, and not behave in a way that potentially endangers them.See? This is just an example of something people question, you know, us little evil trolls etc etc
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 09:24:34 PM
Cool. There is a limit to what they can be excused for under the umbrella of "naive"... Its a paternal/maternal instinct to safeguard your kids, and not behave in a way that potentially endangers them.See? This is just an example of something people question, you know, us little evil trolls etc etc

so tell me ...why did the mccanns leave the children...did they just not care
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 26, 2015, 09:31:51 PM
so tell me ...why did the mccanns leave the children...did they just not care
Obviously seeing as they not only left three toddlers to their own devices, told total strangers they were alone, left doors unlcked, how sad can you get? As a parent that is...give it up, even experienced barristers are a laughing stock here for sayng they behaved responsibly..... They were laisse faire before and after...kate mccann says in her book it was the least of their worries...nice
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on November 26, 2015, 09:47:48 PM
so tell me ...why did the mccanns leave the children...did they just not care

Apparently, so it would seem. They chose to ignore their 3 year old daughter, who seemed to think leaving them alone was a bad idea, as she spoke to her parents about being left alone  at night when she /Sean were crying...

That would be the daughter who 'disappeared' after sharing her fears, the parents totally ignored her and went out and lef them alone AGAIN. 

Now go on, let's hear the parents defence on that one?

 That was THE most shocking, and distressing part of this story that moved me to tears.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 09:49:09 PM
Apparently, so it would seem. They chose to ignore their 3 year old daughter, who seemed to think leaving them alone was a bad idea, as she spoke to her parents about being left alone  at night when she /Sean were crying...

That would be the daughter who 'disappeared' after sharing her fears, the parents totally ignored her and went out and lef them alone AGAIN. 

Now go on, let's hear the parents defence on that one?

 That was THE most shocking, and distressing part of this story that moved me to tears.

so you think the McCanns simply didn't care about their children...anyone agree
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 26, 2015, 09:50:53 PM
Obviously seeing as they not only left three toddlers to their own devices, told total strangers they were alone, left doors unlcked, how sad can you get? As a parent that is...give it up, even experienced barristers are a laughing stock here for sayng they behaved responsibly..... They were laisse faire before and after...kate mccann says in her book it was the least of their worries...nice

so you  think the McCannns were aware of all the dangers and simply didn't give a toss
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 26, 2015, 09:58:53 PM
so you  think the McCannns were aware of all the dangers and simply didn't give a toss

They thought they knew better, and exhibited an arrogance which led to the results we know.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on November 26, 2015, 10:05:34 PM
so you think the McCanns simply didn't care about their children...anyone agree

Yup, Im with little Maddie on this one.  She didn't want to wake up and find no adult there!

Parents knew the children didn't want to be left alone at night so ignored them and went out to wine and dine as they always did.  Oh does this make me  the baddie now  sheeesh  can those parents not take any responsibility?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 26, 2015, 10:23:58 PM
so you think the McCanns simply didn't care about their children...anyone agree

They said they did, and others praised their relationships with their children and their performance as parents. We can only judge by what we have been told about the holiday.  There were no family activities, and an evening meal with friends was so desirable that they left their children alone in an unlocked apartment every evening.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 04:21:19 PM
They said they did, and others praised their relationships with their children and their performance as parents. We can only judge by what we have been told about the holiday.  There were no family activities, and an evening meal with friends was so desirable that they left their children alone in an unlocked apartment every evening.

are you too timid to answer the question
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 27, 2015, 04:35:25 PM
are you too timid to answer the question

My answer is they appeared to put their wants and needs before those of their children. That doesn't mean they didn't care about them, but imo they cared about themselves more. 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 04:38:42 PM
My answer is they appeared to put their wants and needs before those of their children. That doesn't mean they didn't care about them, but imo they cared about themselves more.

so you think they were not concerned about the safety of the children
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 27, 2015, 04:42:45 PM
so you think they were not concerned about the safety of the children

Please stop telling me what I think. Kate McCann allegedly expressed concern at the restaurant on 3rd May. That was it - a conversation but no action.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 04:48:29 PM
Please stop telling me what I think. Kate McCann allegedly expressed concern at the restaurant on 3rd May. That was it - a conversation but no action.

im asking but you are unwilling to answer because you understand how stupid it would be to say they did not care about their children
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 27, 2015, 04:54:10 PM
If the McCanns did not care about the safety of their children and put their own comfort and happiness above that of their kids, then can someone tell me why they bothered to check on them at all?   Why not leave them completely unattended for hours with no checks?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 27, 2015, 04:59:23 PM
If the McCanns did not care about the safety of their children and put their own comfort and happiness above that of their kids, then can someone tell me why they bothered to check on them at all?   Why not leave them completely unattended for hours with no checks?

I believe that some people think that is what they did
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 05:00:38 PM
If the McCanns did not care about the safety of their children and put their own comfort and happiness above that of their kids, then can someone tell me why they bothered to check on them at all?   Why not leave them completely unattended for hours with no checks?

How man times did either of them actually see all their children that night or on any other ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 27, 2015, 05:05:10 PM
im asking but you are unwilling to answer because you understand how stupid it would be to say they did not care about their children

My observations tell me that there was a ranking. Adults first, children second.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 05:06:28 PM
My observations tell me that there was a ranking. Adults first, children second.

do you think they did not care about the safety of their children...simple question
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 27, 2015, 05:06:50 PM
I believe that some people think that is what they did
really?  Who believes that then?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 27, 2015, 05:08:46 PM
They probably prefer to remain anonymous  *&*%£ 8(0(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 27, 2015, 05:10:48 PM
They probably prefer to remain anonymous  *&*%£ 8(0(*
why, cos they're a bit embarrassed to admit it?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 27, 2015, 05:11:42 PM
You would have to ask them.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 27, 2015, 05:23:28 PM
You would have to ask them.
except I don't know who they are because you won't tell me.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 27, 2015, 05:27:39 PM
except I don't know who they are because you won't tell me.

No - can't tell you, as they remain anonymous.  Indeed, I have no idea of the identity of anybody on any of the various fora is.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 27, 2015, 05:38:13 PM
No - can't tell you, as they remain anonymous.  Indeed, I have no idea of the identity of anybody on any of the various fora is.
OK, be deliberately obtuse if it amuses you, you know I wasn't asking for their RL ids, fgs.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 05:58:31 PM
If the McCanns did not care about the safety of their children and put their own comfort and happiness above that of their kids, then can someone tell me why they bothered to check on them at all?   Why not leave them completely unattended for hours with no checks?

It's called attempting to mitigate the risk.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 06:31:58 PM
It's called attempting to mitigate the risk.

So you think the McCanns knew they were putting their children at serious risk
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 06:40:09 PM
So you think the McCanns knew they were putting their children at serious risk

Why check if it was totally safe?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 06:43:31 PM
Why check if it was totally safe?

if a child is crying...they may be distressed but still safe...next
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 27, 2015, 06:53:32 PM
if a child is crying...they may be distressed but still safe...next

Let 'em cry for 30 minutes. Mum or Dad will arrive to comfort them.........eventually. Sometimes it's difficult to recognise the people described by their relatives.

I had a conversation with Kate regarding care of the children in particular, leaving the children to cry until exhaustion and Kate and I both agreed that this was not correct and that the attention should be placed on calking them down. As parents, Kate and Gerry did not let their children cry.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANNET-KENNEDY.htm
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 06:57:30 PM
Let 'em cry for 30 minutes. Mum or Dad will arrive to comfort them.........eventually. Sometimes it's difficult to recognise the people described by their relatives.

I had a conversation with Kate regarding care of the children in particular, leaving the children to cry until exhaustion and Kate and I both agreed that this was not correct and that the attention should be placed on calking them down. As parents, Kate and Gerry did not let their children cry.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANNET-KENNEDY.htm

so were the mccanns not concerned about the safety of their children....did they realise the risks and simply not care
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 07:01:52 PM
so were the mccanns not concerned about the safety of their children....did they realise the risks and simply not care

Why does it have to be black and white. Of course they were concerned about the safety of their children, they were also concerned about going out for an evening with their friends. They failed to get the right balance when weighing those concerns.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 07:05:01 PM
Why does it have to be black and white. Of course they were concerned about the safety of their children, they were also concerned about going out for an evening with their friends. They failed to get the right balance when weighing those concerns.

well I think failing to get the right balance is different to "shit parents". They did not realise the danger the children were in...that's it. They actually thought what they were doing was safe
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 07:10:17 PM
well I think failing to get the right balance is different to "shit parents". They did not realise the danger the children were in...that's it. They actually thought what they were doing was safe

It is probable that the relative attraction of staying in with the kids and going out with the friends impacted the decision.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 27, 2015, 07:14:29 PM
well I think failing to get the right balance is different to "shit parents". They did not realise the danger the children were in...that's it. They actually thought what they were doing was safe

Some suggest that it is only with hindsight that it's possible to realise that it wasn't safe to leave three small children home alone. Believe it or not, there are many people who would have made that decision before the event, not afterwards. If you are referring to 'abduction' there is no evidence that it happened. There were plenty of other lesser dangers to worry about when leaving children. Not one of those occurred to those parents. Was it a lack of knowledge about small children or a lack of awareness of what can happen or just happy to let them cry/wander/mess about in other rooms/fall etc?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 07:19:06 PM
Some suggest that it is only with hindsight that it's possible to realise that it wasn't safe to leave three small children home alone. Believe it or not, there are many people who would have made that decision before the event, not afterwards. If you are referring to 'abduction' there is no evidence that it happened. There were plenty of other lesser dangers to worry about when leaving children. Not one of those occurred to those parents. Was it a lack of knowledge about small children or a lack of awareness of what can happen or just happy to let them cry/wander/mess about in other rooms/fall etc?

I would say that they thought it was safe
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 07:51:42 PM
I would say that they thought it was safe

Bull.

They locked the apartment during the day, and claimed they left it unlocked at night.

Explain that.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 07:53:07 PM
Bull.

They locked the apartment during the day, and claimed they left it unlocked at night.

Explain that.

I just have...as they were not far away they thought it was safe
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 27, 2015, 08:00:24 PM
Shades of Dick Emery here.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:01:21 PM
I just have...as they were not far away they thought it was safe

No you haven't.

Now explain LOGICALLY why you would lock the apartment during the day, when it is more visible, and leave it unlocked at night, when clearly in poor lighting conditions, any 'intruder' e.g. burglar, would be less obvious.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 27, 2015, 08:06:46 PM
Just watched the penultimate episode of Friends, first aired in 2004.
Rachel is shown leaving her toddler Emma alone, sleeping, in Joey's apartment while she went across the hall to Monica & Chandler's apartment for a farewell party. She did have a baby monitor.
It seems leaving a child alone in an apartment is OK with the US public.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:08:56 PM
Just watched the penultimate episode of Friends, first aired in 2004.
Rachel is shown leaving her toddler Emma alone, sleeping, in Joey's apartment while she went across the hall to Monica & Chandler's apartment for a farewell party. She did have a baby monitor.
It seems leaving a child alone in an apartment is OK with the US public.

Oh dear. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+

Now I have seen it all........
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 27, 2015, 08:16:07 PM
Oh dear. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+

Now I have seen it all........

What's your problem? Viewed by millions around the world so please provide links to viewer complaints about the childcare portrayed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:23:39 PM
What's your problem? Viewed by millions around the world so please provide links to viewer complaints about the childcare portrayed.

They are fictional characters.

You should provide the links where it says people followed the 'advice' on friends in REAL LIFE.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 08:25:00 PM
What's your problem? Viewed by millions around the world so please provide links to viewer complaints about the childcare portrayed.

It's a Strawman argument. Who is criticising across the hall with a baby monitor?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:26:15 PM
What's your problem? Viewed by millions around the world so please provide links to viewer complaints about the childcare portrayed.

Oh, by the way, were these characters out on the lash, drinking and eating, whilst their 'children' were unprotected ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 08:27:52 PM
No you haven't.

Now explain LOGICALLY why you would lock the apartment during the day, when it is more visible, and leave it unlocked at night, when clearly in poor lighting conditions, any 'intruder' e.g. burglar, would be less obvious.

did the mccanns think it was safe,....simple question...I say they did
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 08:33:00 PM
did the mccanns think it was safe,....simple question...I say they did

Because they wanted to go out with their friends they decided it was safe enough. IMO.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 27, 2015, 08:34:27 PM
What's your problem? Viewed by millions around the world so please provide links to viewer complaints about the childcare portrayed.

It is a well known fact how zero tolerance operates in America as regards chlldcare...so to say they and also mllions worldwide think it is perfectly fine is overegging.....it was after all a kind of slapstick comedy not a drama and Im sure Rachel in any case armed wth the monitor, and presumably also not  leaving doors open, and not being half a football pitch away, was quite marginally on the better equipped side to act if something went wrong.Non? Whatever next. End of the day the parents made their own choices they seemed happy with, the childcare issue has been done to death, but it serves no one to try and promote it as a great idea to leave toddlers home alone, you know that, I know that, and so do most people, whatever they say.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 27, 2015, 08:37:18 PM
It's a Strawman argument. Who is criticising across the hall with a baby monitor?

Post #35 lists all the serious things which can apparently happen if a child is left on its own, monitor or no monitor.
A baby monitor is only as efficient as its specification.
Strangely, being on the premises or using a baby monitor does not prevent an infant suffocating to death from a cot bumper, unseen & unheard because regular checks weren't being carried out.
In essence - the McCann children were not really at any greater risk of injury or death with or without the parents being on the premises. Abduction, however.................................

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:38:11 PM
did the mccanns think it was safe,....simple question...I say they did

Your view is irrelevant.

The McCann's were arrogant and thought they knew better.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 27, 2015, 08:39:31 PM
Your view is irrelevant.

The McCann's were arrogant and thought they knew better.

and your view is irrelevant...so that's about it
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:40:55 PM
and your view is irrelevant...so that's about it

Where's Madeleine ? 8)-)))
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 27, 2015, 08:45:15 PM
They are fictional characters.

You should provide the links where it says people followed the 'advice' on friends in REAL LIFE.

There was a haircut which influenced millions of women :)
Seriously, though - many thoughts & actions can be consciously or unconsciously influenced by something seen on TV and Friends was a major feature to a generation of young women.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 27, 2015, 08:48:54 PM
Post #35 lists all the serious things which can apparently happen if a child is left on its own, monitor or no monitor.
A baby monitor is only as efficient as its specification.
Strangely, being on the premises or using a baby monitor does not prevent an infant suffocating to death from a cot bumper, unseen & unheard because regular checks weren't being carried out.
In essence - the McCann children were not really at any greater risk of injury or death with or without the parents being on the premises. Abduction, however.................................

Taken to the logical if absurd conclusion, they should have left the kids in Leicestershire, saved a lot of hassle. Now if you have some sensible arguments?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 27, 2015, 08:50:57 PM
There was a haircut which influenced millions of women :)
Seriously, though - many thoughts & actions can be consciously or unconsciously influenced by something seen on TV and Friends was a major feature to a generation of young women.

You mean the 'group' mentality ?


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 27, 2015, 10:10:42 PM
How man times did either of them actually see all their children that night or on any other ?

Gerry Mccann says he never looked in on his kids but just the once on the whole hoiday on the 3 rd May because the door seemed more open.

Kate Mccann doesnt tell us if she too didnt feel the need just to look in on her three toddlers on a nightly basis but on the Thursday check did say was tempted just to turn around and go back to the restaraunt, but the door was more open so she decided to look. Whether that is an admission if a habit or not is unknown I suppose.....

Who checks on their kids but actually doesnt?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 08:25:01 AM
Post #35 lists all the serious things which can apparently happen if a child is left on its own, monitor or no monitor.
A baby monitor is only as efficient as its specification.
Strangely, being on the premises or using a baby monitor does not prevent an infant suffocating to death from a cot bumper, unseen & unheard because regular checks weren't being carried out.
In essence - the McCann children were not really at any greater risk of injury or death with or without the parents being on the premises. Abduction, however.................................

So in your opinion there's no point in parents staying in to look after small children? As long as the pub's nearby they can go out and nip back every half hour to check on the kids? If it's more convenient they can leave a door unlocked also. I wonder how that would go down with the police and Social Services in the UK. After all, the parents are checking every half hour, what's to complain about? They're just as safe as if their parents were in the house with them.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 08:30:33 AM
So in your opinion there's no point in parents staying in to look after small children? As long as the pub's nearby they can go out and nip back every half hour to check on the kids? If it's more convenient they can leave a door unlocked also. I wonder how that would go down with the police and Social Services in the UK. After all, the parents are checking every half hour, what's to complain about? They're just as safe as if their parents were in the house with them.

the Portuguese found no case to answer and you have only your opinion to say it would have been different in the UK........
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 08:44:57 AM
the Portuguese found no case to answer and you have only your opinion to say it would have been different in the UK........


Madeleine 'disappeared'.

A consequence of the mccanns 'responsible parenting skills'..........................
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 08:51:21 AM

Madeleine 'disappeared'.

A consequence of the mccanns 'responsible parenting skills'..........................

Almost every young child that disappears could have been prevented by the carer being more vigilant
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 08:55:52 AM
Almost every young child that disappears could have been prevented by the carer being more vigilant

However, 'disappearances' don't have to be the result of 'abduction' from an unknown person or persons.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 08:58:33 AM
However, 'disappearances' don't have to be the result of 'abduction' from an unknown person or persons.

sometimes it's impossible to have an intelligent discussion
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:00:33 AM
sometimes it's impossible to have an intelligent discussion

It is, with someone who is in the mccann camp.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 09:01:46 AM
It is, with someone who is in the mccann camp.



I'm not in any camp
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:05:09 AM
So in your opinion there's no point in parents staying in to look after small children? As long as the pub's nearby they can go out and nip back every half hour to check on the kids? If it's more convenient they can leave a door unlocked also. I wonder how that would go down with the police and Social Services in the UK. After all, the parents are checking every half hour, what's to complain about? They're just as safe as if their parents were in the house with them.

I have said this before but I will repeat it.

What about people who go camping?    I have seen people leave children asleep in tents and go and meet other parents and have a barbeque.   So what about these children?    No locks on tents.

I am not saying that I think it was right to leave the children,  I wouldn't have done so.   Though it seems that whilst people are on holiday in holiday resorts they do things which they may not normally do.   The McCann's had baby sitters when they went out at home,  yet didn't when they were on holiday.

They felt safe as it was a family friendly holiday destination.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:07:28 AM
It is, with someone who is in the mccann camp.

Camp?  for goodness sake Stephen I thought this was a forum for debate not some silly 'my gang'  school ground game.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 28, 2015, 09:08:18 AM
Whatever gave you that foolish idea?  @)(++(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:09:56 AM
Camp?  for goodness sake Stephen I thought this was a forum for debate not some silly 'my gang'  school ground game.

This is no game.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 09:14:00 AM
the Portuguese found no case to answer and you have only your opinion to say it would have been different in the UK........

i assume you agree with misty then. No point in staying in with young children because they are no safer than if you go out?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 09:17:15 AM
i assume you agree with misty then. No point in staying in with young children because they are no safer than if you go out?

the mccanns considered the children were safe...no one has yet disagreed on that...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 09:20:44 AM
I have said this before but I will repeat it.

What about people who go camping?    I have seen people leave children asleep in tents and go and meet other parents and have a barbeque.   So what about these children?    No locks on tents.

I am not saying that I think it was right to leave the children,  I wouldn't have done so.   Though it seems that whilst people are on holiday in holiday resorts they do things which they may not normally do.   The McCann's had baby sitters when they went out at home,  yet didn't when they were on holiday.

They felt safe as it was a family friendly holiday destination.

It makes you wonder why all the other parents didn't do the same, instead of paying for baby-sitters, carting their kids to the night cheche, taking them to dinner with them or staying in. Did they see danger which the McCanns failed to notice in that family friendly holiday destination?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:21:54 AM
the mccanns considered the children were safe...no one has yet disagreed on that...

That doesn't add up.

Never did.

The mccanns locked the apartment in the day, and 'claimed' it was unlocked at night.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 09:25:42 AM
the mccanns considered the children were safe...no one has yet disagreed on that...

I didn't ask what the McCanns thought, I asked if you agreed with misty.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 09:26:13 AM
I have said this before but I will repeat it.

What about people who go camping?    I have seen people leave children asleep in tents and go and meet other parents and have a barbeque.   So what about these children?    No locks on tents.

I am not saying that I think it was right to leave the children,  I wouldn't have done so.   Though it seems that whilst people are on holiday in holiday resorts they do things which they may not normally do.   The McCann's had baby sitters when they went out at home,  yet didn't when they were on holiday.

They felt safe as it was a family friendly holiday destination.

I agree that people make different decisions on holiday, though obviously not always sensible. As long as the kids are very near, within good hearing/seeing distance, it is a sensible decision. Yes, kids have gone missing in these circumstances but you can't have them by your side all the time. As I said in previous posts, I think they weighed up the danger of leaving them vs the desire to go out and made the wrong choice.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:42:58 AM
It makes you wonder why all the other parents didn't do the same, instead of paying for baby-sitters, carting their kids to the night cheche, taking them to dinner with them or staying in. Did they see danger which the McCanns failed to notice in that family friendly holiday destination?

Could be because they were not as far from their apartment as the other families?    It took under a minute to get to their apartment.   Also the patio doors were reached by going up steps and through two gates,  so maybe they thought it would be too risky for anyone to attempt it.

I wouldn't have left the children alone,    I am trying to understand why the McCann's did.    I still think it was because as they said 'so quiet' it seemed so safe to them.

By the way I don't think I would leave my children in a tent to go over to a barbeque either,  they didn't check on their children.   Anyone could have sneaked into a tent and abused their child or abducted one of them.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:46:58 AM
Could be because they were not as far from their apartment as the other families?    It took under a minute to get to their apartment.   Also the patio doors were reached by going up steps and through two gates,  so maybe they thought it would be too risky for anyone to attempt it.

I wouldn't have left the children alone,    I am trying to understand why the McCann's did.    I still think it was because as they said 'so quiet' it seemed so safe to them.

By the way I don't think I would leave my children in a tent to go over to a barbeque either,  they didn't check on their children.   Anyone could have sneaked into a tent and abused their child or abducted one of them.

So why was the apartment locked in the day, and not at night ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:47:20 AM
I agree that people make different decisions on holiday, though obviously not always sensible. As long as the kids are very near, within good hearing/seeing distance, it is a sensible decision. Yes, kids have gone missing in these circumstances but you can't have them by your side all the time. As I said in previous posts, I think they weighed up the danger of leaving them vs the desire to go out and made the wrong choice.

There you have said what many have said in defence of the McCann's  'you can't have them by your side all of the time'    also they said their normal routine would have been disrupted had they had taken them to the crèche.  The McCann's said they didn't think their children would sleep with all the comings and going in the crèche so they thought they would let them sleep in the apartment and check on them at intervals.   They thought they were doing what was best for their children and as they thought it was so quiet and friendly it was ok to leave them.   Which turned out to be a very bad decision which they have said themselves.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:48:51 AM
So why was the apartment locked in the day, and not at night ?

Maybe because they thought being so close they were keeping an eye on the place.   Also it made it easier for them to go and check on them and quicker,  if the patio doors were locked they would have had to walk around to the front door which took longer.   
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 28, 2015, 09:49:52 AM
It makes you wonder why all the other parents didn't do the same, instead of paying for baby-sitters, carting their kids to the night cheche, taking them to dinner with them or staying in. Did they see danger which the McCanns failed to notice in that family friendly holiday destination?

The fact that there was a  Missing Child Procedure in place at the OC would confirm that other people's children also went missing from time to time.    The only difference being  - those other missing children were found.

It would seem that the McCanns were not the only parents to have made an error of judgement whilst on holiday at the OC.   Trying to portray them as 'unique' when it came to childcare arrangements - in order to justify 8 years of 'bashing' -  is unfair  IMO.    Other parents also got it wrong at times. 




Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:53:50 AM
Gerry Mccann says he never looked in on his kids but just the once on the whole hoiday on the 3 rd May because the door seemed more open.

Kate Mccann doesnt tell us if she too didnt feel the need just to look in on her three toddlers on a nightly basis but on the Thursday check did say was tempted just to turn around and go back to the restaraunt, but the door was more open so she decided to look. Whether that is an admission if a habit or not is unknown I suppose.....

Who checks on their kids but actually doesnt?

If you have children mercury,  you will know yourself that if you go right into the bedroom and up to the bed of your child to look at them,  they are likely to wake up.

I don't for one moment blame the McCann's for not going into the room,   if I check on my kids I go to the door look and  listen,   I always leave the doors  open a bit too.   Obviously if there is a noise I will go in.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:56:40 AM
Maybe because they thought being so close they were keeping an eye on the place.   Also it made it easier for them to go and check on them and quicker,  if the patio doors were locked they would have had to walk around to the front door which took longer.

Completely illogical.

What difference would a few seconds make in walking.

After all, what's more important, your personal possessions, or your children ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:56:51 AM
The fact that there was a  Missing Child Procedure in place at the OC would confirm that other people's children also went missing from time to time.    The only difference being  - those other missing children were found.

It would seem that the McCanns were not the only parents to have made an error of judgement whilst on holiday at the OC.   Trying to portray them as 'unique' when it came to childcare arrangements - in order to justify 8 years of 'bashing' -  is unfair  IMO.    Other parents also got it wrong at times.

Their childcare arrangements were far from 'unique' Benice.

Trying to betray them as so as you say is just an excuse to 'bash the McCann's'   the sights I've seen on holiday would beggar belief.   

I have seen people drunk out of their minds in the DAY with young children in tow,   parents going to sleep on sun loungers whilst their young children play in the pool etc. etc.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 09:58:04 AM
Completely illogical.

What difference would a few seconds make in walking.

After all, what's more important, your personal possessions, or your children ?

I give you a reason why the McCann's probably left the patio doors open Stephen,  they were closest to them it was quicker,   obviously if a burglar had entered their personal possessions would have been taken too.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:02:22 AM
I give you a reason why the McCann's probably left the patio doors open Stephen,  they were closest to them it was quicker,   obviously if a burglar had entered their personal possessions would have been taken too.

It isn't a logical reason.

It makes no sense, now or then.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 10:04:13 AM
If you have children mercury,  you will know yourself that if you go right into the bedroom and up to the bed of your child to look at them,  they are likely to wake up.

I don't for one moment blame the McCann's for not going into the room,   if I check on my kids I go to the door look and  listen,   I always leave the doors  open a bit too.   Obviously if there is a noise I will go in.

Yes Lace, of course, if you say so, it must be right and true for all
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 10:12:26 AM
It isn't a logical reason.

It makes no sense, now or then.

It isn't logical for you to say they thought more of their possessions than their children either,   their possessions would have been there to have been taken as well as the children,  so stop trying to paint a nasty picture of the McCann's.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 10:13:04 AM
Yes Lace, of course, if you say so, it must be right and true for all

I am saying it is what I would do.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:17:38 AM
It isn't logical for you to say they thought more of their possessions than their children either,   their possessions would have been there to have been taken as well as the children,  so stop trying to paint a nasty picture of the McCann's.

I don't need to.

Their actions speak louder than words.

Commonsense would tell you that you minimize risk to your childrens safety.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 10:20:16 AM
I don't need to.

Their actions speak louder than words.

Commonsense would tell you that you minimize risk to your childrens safety.


They have admitted that they made a bad decision Stephen for which they are paying dearly,  what else do you want?

I don't think anything would be enough for you though,  you just enjoy going over and over it again and again.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:26:42 AM

They have admitted that they made a bad decision Stephen for which they are paying dearly,  what else do you want?

I don't think anything would be enough for you though,  you just enjoy going over and over it again and again.

You are trying to make excuses for supposedly intelligent people.

It was not rational behaviour.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 10:28:25 AM
You are trying to make excuses for supposedly intelligent people.

It was not rational behaviour.

Even intelligent people make mistakes Stephen,  no one is perfect {except maybe you?}
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 10:30:55 AM
You are trying to make excuses for supposedly intelligent people.

It was not rational behaviour.

the bottom line is that the mccanns do not give a toss what you or others think about them....they are intelligent enough to move on...which they have
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:35:57 AM
the bottom line is that the mccanns do not give a toss what you or others think about them....they are intelligent enough to move on...which they have

Madeleine hasn't.

....and they do give a toss, otherwise why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 10:37:36 AM
Could be because they were not as far from their apartment as the other families?    It took under a minute to get to their apartment.   Also the patio doors were reached by going up steps and through two gates,  so maybe they thought it would be too risky for anyone to attempt it.

I wouldn't have left the children alone,    I am trying to understand why the McCann's did.    I still think it was because as they said 'so quiet' it seemed so safe to them.

By the way I don't think I would leave my children in a tent to go over to a barbeque either,  they didn't check on their children.   Anyone could have sneaked into a tent and abused their child or abducted one of them.

I think you have it there.
They were lulled into a false sense of security because of the proximity of the accommodation.

They were less than a minute away.

I never timed myself going to check on my children but I think it probably took me at least a minute to go from A to B.

Once they were down ... I wasn't popping in every half hour to check on them unless one had been unwell ... so theoretically I could have put them to bed and not looked in on them until four hours later when I retired to mine.
Time enough, if someone had taken it upon themselves to invade the property for them to be in the next county or on the waves with one of the children.

Whatever the perceived inadequacy of her parents' child care in Luz ... Madeleine met the 'perfect storm' by coming up against a police force who lost many hours of the golden hour of her disappearance in their failure to deal with the fact she might have been abducted.

That gives an indication of how outlandish the notion of a predator was for professionals and therefore how unlikely it would have been for parents to factor it into their thinking at that time ... although no longer.

It is also surprising that professional thinking either dismissed out of hand the home invasions resulting in the assault of British holidaymakers' children or they did not know about them??
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:39:11 AM
I think you have it there.
They were lulled into a false sense of security because of the proximity of the accommodation.

They were less than a minute away.

I never timed myself going to check on my children but I think it probably took me at least a minute to go from A to B.

Once they were down ... I wasn't popping in every half hour to check on them unless one had been unwell ... so theoretically I could have put them to bed and not looked in on them until four hours later when I retired to mine.
Time enough, if someone had taken it upon themselves to invade the property for them to be in the next county or on the waves with one of the children.

Whatever the perceived inadequacy of her parents' child care in Luz ... Madeleine met the 'perfect storm' by coming up against a police force who lost many hours of the golden hour of her disappearance in their failure to deal with the fact she might have been abducted.

That gives an indication of how outlandish the notion of a predator was for professionals and therefore how unlikely it would have been for parents to factor it into their thinking at that time ... although no longer.

It is also surprising that professional thinking either dismissed out of hand the home invasions resulting in the assault of British holidaymakers' children or they did not know about them??

Illogical.

A few extra seconds walking would make no difference.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 10:42:18 AM
I am saying it is what I would do.

I am positive that you would not leave your back door open with three toddlers indoors whllst  nipping to your local pub bar or restaraunt on an evening Lace
Why did the rest of the group not do the same? Leave their doors open for less walking and why did they make sure their front doors were also locked?

You cant have your cake and eat it, either you thnk it was OK or you thnk it was a repeated mistake
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 10:46:24 AM
Madeleine hasn't.

....and they do give a toss, otherwise why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?

Give the full cite for "why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?".  Thanking you in anticipation of  your usual quickstep away from backing up your assertions
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 28, 2015, 10:47:45 AM
I am positive that you would not leave your back door open with three toddlers indoors whllst  nipping to your local pub bar or restaraunt on an evening Lace
Why did the rest of the group not do the same? Leave their doors open for less walking and why did they make sure their front doors were also locked?

You cant have your cake and eat it, either you thnk it was OK or you thnk it was a repeated mistake

The McCann's front door was locked.

The McCann's were closer than the friends to the Tapas Bar.

Why did the McCann's have baby sitters whilst at home?   They didn't leave the children alone when they went out at home did they?

As I have said,  they thought it was safe to do so,  a bad decision nothing else,  it doesn't mean in any way they didn't love their children.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 10:50:43 AM
Give the full cite for "why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?".  Thanking you in anticipation of  your usual quickstep away from backing up your assertions

Leverson Inquiry as you well know.

Don't be foolish.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 10:55:11 AM
I am positive that you would not leave your back door open with three toddlers indoors whllst  nipping to your local pub bar or restaraunt on an evening Lace
Why did the rest of the group not do the same? Leave their doors open for less walking and why did they make sure their front doors were also locked?

You cant have your cake and eat it, either you thnk it was OK or you thnk it was a repeated mistake

No-one has claimed it was not "a repeated mistake" ... why it is taking you and others over eight years of angst about it might also be a mistake as far as personal equilibrium is concerned.

The Drs McCann who live with Madeleine's disappearance every single day of their lives are coping and have managed to make a useful contribution to their family, to society and to the daughter Kate was screaming that they had let down ... by ensuring she is being looked for.

Can you direct me to a web site set up to excoriate the person who kidnapped Madeleine ... or is that opprobrium reserved solely for the victims of the crime.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 11:00:08 AM
Leverson Inquiry as you well know.

Don't be foolish.

I have requested a cite.

You stated that they admitted they had people monitoring the internet for them.  I wish to see exactly where you think they said that.

"Leveson" does not do it.

You have never been able to produce a cite to substantiate any claims you make ... go on ... surprise me.  Break the habit of a posting lifetime and ... corroborate your allegation.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 11:01:54 AM
the bottom line is that the mccanns do not give a toss what you or others think about them....they are intelligent enough to move on...which they have

i will assume you agree with misty then. There is no reason to stay in with small children because they are just as safe if you go out and nip back to check on them every half hour. Amazing! Someone should tell the NSPCC that their advice is wrong when they say small children should never be left home alone. Intelligent people can disregard their advice of course, because they know better.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 11:04:43 AM
i will assume you agree with misty then. There is no reason to stay in with small children because they are just as safe if you go out and nip back to check on them every half hour. Amazing! Someone should tell the NSPCC that their advice is wrong when they say small children should never be left home alone. Intelligent people can disregard their advice of course, because they know better.

I have done this in the past...I would not do it now...the only real risk as far as i am concerned is abduction
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:08:38 AM
Leverson Inquiry as you well know.

Don't be foolish.

Didn't Michael Wright also comment on monitoring the internet during his evidence in Lisbon ?

Here it is :

'
ID - asks if the witness can name some of these forums.
MW The 3 Arguidos and Madeleine Foundation. He says Tony Bennett invited Gonçalo Amaral to do conferences in the UK. These forums were full of speculation focused on GA's conclusions. People said those conclusions must be true because GA had been in charge of the initial investigation.
ID - When?
MW – Activity was increased and heavy in March/April 2009.
ID - Did the McCanns learn about these forums? How?
MW They learned through me, the family members who monitored the activity and their support group. I wondered whether it was worse to let them know or not to. I didn't want to add up to their pain, but a significant change happened. There were several instances of threats to kidnap the twins on the 3 Arguidos site. Then I couldn't but speak. There was a chat where a poster suggested someone should kidnap a twin to get to the truth.'
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 11:18:03 AM
Madeleine hasn't.

....and they do give a toss, otherwise why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?

You have made the statement. You say it is from Leveson ... may we have sight of the quote to which you refer.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:21:05 AM
You have made the statement. You say it is from Leveson ... may we have sight of the quote to which you refer.

Michael Wright admitted that he and 'the McCann's support group' monitored the internet when giving evidence in Lisbon. Is his word not good enough ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 28, 2015, 11:37:27 AM
I am positive that you would not leave your back door open with three toddlers indoors whllst  nipping to your local pub bar or restaraunt on an evening Lace
Why did the rest of the group not do the same? Leave their doors open for less walking and why did they make sure their front doors were also locked?

You cant have your cake and eat it, either you thnk it was OK or you thnk it was a repeated mistake

IMO mercury - it's because people have a different mindset when on holiday to the one they have at home - proved by the fact that most parents IMO who use the listening method of childcare on holiday -  would not dream of doing the same at home.   In fact I think they would be horrified at the suggestion.

It's my firm opinion that the main reason why those parents are lulled into a false sense of security - is because who would believe that a reputable holiday company or hoteliers etc would dream of advertising a service which was potentially dangerous to children?     The fact that they do offer this service is therefore proof  in itself to parents (psychologically speaking) - that it must be safe and IMO that is the most compelling reason for parents to believe that it is.

I know the service wasn't offered at the OC club - but members of the group had used it before - and that again would only serve to reassure the McCanns even more that it was safe.

There are other reasons why people have different attitudes when on holiday - but when it comes to the listening method of childcare - the above are the most predominant IMO.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 11:42:10 AM
Madeleine hasn't.

....and they do give a toss, otherwise why would they admit they have people 'monitoring' the internet for them ?

do you really think Drs McCann care what poeple like you think...

 @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: lordpookles on November 28, 2015, 11:46:44 AM
do you really think Drs McCann care what poeple like you think...

 @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

No idea what the McCanns think. Do you though Dave? You always allude to having some kind of personal acquaintance  8(*(  I assume you are trolling...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 11:58:06 AM
I have done this in the past...I would not do it now...the only real risk as far as i am concerned is abduction

You have also gone out and left three children under 5 years of age alone? If so, I'm not surprised that the only risk you can think of is abduction. You were extremely lucky you didn't find out the hard way that it isn't the only risk!
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 12:13:23 PM
do you really think Drs McCann care what poeple like you think...

 @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

The mccanns do care what people think.

Otherwise, they would not have handed the dossier to the Police.

Meanwhile brietta, at some point in the next few days I will listen to the mccanns unedited evidence at the inquiry and her reference to Mr. Wright.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 01:25:27 PM
If you have children mercury,  you will know yourself that if you go right into the bedroom and up to the bed of your child to look at them,  they are likely to wake up.

I don't for one moment blame the McCann's for not going into the room,   if I check on my kids I go to the door look and  listen,   I always leave the doors  open a bit too.   Obviously if there is a noise I will go in.

Problem is, if you don't look and just listen, you tend to listen from further and further away. It is where a monitor is better.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 01:30:09 PM
I have done this in the past...I would not do it now...the only real risk as far as i am concerned is abduction

Sort of Reductio ad Absurdum in reverse.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 01:56:29 PM
Sort of Reductio ad Absurdum in reverse.

i would not to worried that one of the children might roll out of bed and die from the fall
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 28, 2015, 02:00:58 PM
Sort of Reductio ad Absurdum in reverse.

it's my opinion...but it seems you do not accept other posters can hold valid opinions if they differ from yours
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 02:30:10 PM
it's my opinion...but it seems you do not accept other posters can hold valid opinions if they differ from yours


Coming from you Dave, that is a classic. %&5%£
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 06:28:01 PM
So in your opinion there's no point in parents staying in to look after small children? As long as the pub's nearby they can go out and nip back every half hour to check on the kids? If it's more convenient they can leave a door unlocked also. I wonder how that would go down with the police and Social Services in the UK. After all, the parents are checking every half hour, what's to complain about? They're just as safe as if their parents were in the house with them.

Most of the hazards you listed - just as likely to happen while the parents are in the house, & considerably more probable during waking hours than sleeping hours.
Most parents go to bed to sleep  & don't check their children for 8 hours overnight. Does their mere presence prevent a woke & wandered scenario or little Billy going downstairs & playing with dad's toolkit beside the plug socket - or is it 24/7 vigilance which prevents it?
I'm not advocating leaving young children home alone -far from it - but as far as safety is concerned when a child is supposed to be sleeping, I see precious little difference in any foreseeable risk if vigilance is not exercised.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 06:41:26 PM
Most of the hazards you listed - just as likely to happen while the parents are in the house, & considerably more probable during waking hours than sleeping hours.
Most parents go to bed to sleep  & don't check their children for 8 hours overnight. Does their mere presence prevent a woke & wandered scenario or little Billy going downstairs & playing with dad's toolkit beside the plug socket - or is it 24/7 vigilance which prevents it?
I'm not advocating leaving young children home alone -far from it - but as far as safety is concerned when a child is supposed to be sleeping, I see precious little difference in any foreseeable risk if vigilance is not exercised.

I think you underestimate a parents ability to identify when their child is getting up to mischief even if they are asleep. You always tend to sleep with one ear open.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 06:48:35 PM
I think you underestimate a parents ability to identify when their child is getting up to mischief even if they are asleep. You always tend to sleep with one ear open.

Some do, some don't. Are those who don't considered negligent?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 06:50:33 PM
Most of the hazards you listed - just as likely to happen while the parents are in the house, & considerably more probable during waking hours than sleeping hours.
Most parents go to bed to sleep  & don't check their children for 8 hours overnight. Does their mere presence prevent a woke & wandered scenario or little Billy going downstairs & playing with dad's toolkit beside the plug socket - or is it 24/7 vigilance which prevents it?
I'm not advocating leaving young children home alone -far from it - but as far as safety is concerned when a child is supposed to be sleeping, I see precious little difference in any foreseeable risk if vigilance is not exercised.

So why don't you advocate leaving them home alone? According to you it makes no difference whether the parents are there or not.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:01:29 PM
So why don't you advocate leaving them home alone? According to you it makes no difference whether the parents are there or not.

I'm looking at it from a negligence factor/risk assessment point of view, not a maternal point of view.
How tightly you wrap the cotton wool depends on many factors.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:05:05 PM
I'm looking at it from a negligence factor/risk assessment point of view, not a maternal point of view.
How tightly you wrap the cotton wool depends on many factors.

Problem is, the constant mantra that what they did was reasonable drives a lot of the antagonism.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 07:10:07 PM
Problem is, the constant mantra that what they did was reasonable drives a lot of the antagonism.

You mean that truth (confirmed by barristers in family law) antagonises you?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 07:10:30 PM
Problem is, the constant mantra that what they did was reasonable drives a lot of the antagonism.

It also drives the nause rating and sense of the ridiculous.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:11:48 PM
You mean that truth (confirmed by barristers in family law) antagonises you?

I rest my case.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:20:11 PM
Problem is, the constant mantra that what they did was reasonable drives a lot of the antagonism.

It's reasonable versus negligent mantra.
Do sleeping parents whose child wake & wanders onto the street in the middle of the night face negligence charges? No, not normally.
Do nursery staff who fail to spot a child in their care has wandered away from the premises face negligence charges?
Yes, normally.
The action of the child is the same - yet one form of care is deemed reasonable whilst the other is deemed negligent.

So McCanns/Tapas 7 versus parents who used Child Listening Services. Reasonable or negligent?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 07:22:25 PM
You mean that truth (confirmed by barristers in family law) antagonises you?

Did they have names or were they baristas, will o' the wisps or water kelpies as seems to be prevalent in this case.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:23:25 PM
It's reasonable versus negligent mantra.
Do sleeping parents whose child wake & wanders onto the street in the middle of the night face negligence charges? No, not normally.
Do nursery staff who fail to spot a child in their care has wandered away from the premises face negligence charges?
Yes, normally.
The action of the child is the same - yet one form of care is deemed reasonable whilst the other is deemed negligent.

So McCanns/Tapas 7 versus parents who used Child Listening Services. Reasonable or negligent?

Negligent tends to be a legal concept.

The choice is reasonable or not.

Your last point, it would depend on the listening service.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 07:31:13 PM
It's reasonable versus negligent mantra.
Do sleeping parents whose child wake & wanders onto the street in the middle of the night face negligence charges? No, not normally.
Do nursery staff who fail to spot a child in their care has wandered away from the premises face negligence charges?
Yes, normally.
The action of the child is the same - yet one form of care is deemed reasonable whilst the other is deemed negligent.

So McCanns/Tapas 7 versus parents who used Child Listening Services. Reasonable or negligent?

Let's try it no names no pack drill.
Do you think it reasonable of responsible adults to leave three children under the age of 4 alone in a strange building while dining some distance away, making only sporadic checks on the children's welfare?
The answer is yes or no.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 07:32:47 PM
I'm looking at it from a negligence factor/risk assessment point of view, not a maternal point of view.
How tightly you wrap the cotton wool depends on many factors.

What's the difference? Are mothers too careful or not careful enough?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 07:34:05 PM
Let's try it no names no pack drill.
Do you think it reasonable of responsible adults to leave three children under the age of 4 alone in a strange building while dining some distance away, making only sporadic checks on the children's welfare?
The answer is yes or no.

Building strange or otherwise, so long as they are settled and being checked on regularly (from a short distance away) yes.

If it is the middle of the day, they are wide awake and doing stuff, maybe different ....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 28, 2015, 07:34:31 PM
So why don't you advocate leaving them home alone? According to you it makes no difference whether the parents are there or not.

Parents being at home does not guarantee the safety of their children - in fact sometimes it can be the parent who - even if inadvertently -  can cause a dangerous situation for them.    Children left unattended in the bath for instance.

Of course small children should not be left alone in the home, but I do think that a child left fast asleep in their bed - even though unattended -  is in far less danger than some people here are advocating. 

Terrible, evil crimes are committed against children every day of the week.    Leaving a happy well loved child asleep unattended, but being checked on regularly,  is not one of them IMO.   


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:35:36 PM
Building strange or otherwise, so long as they are settled and being checked on regularly (from a short distance away) yes.

If it is the middle of the day, they are wide awake and doing stuff, maybe different ....

It's the defence of the indefensible that raises questions.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 07:37:29 PM
Building strange or otherwise, so long as they are settled and being checked on regularly (from a short distance away) yes.

If it is the middle of the day, they are wide awake and doing stuff, maybe different ....

I said sporadic because that it was it was according the T7 timeline and statements.
Define regularly.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:37:44 PM
Negligent tends to be a legal concept.

The choice is reasonable or not.

Your last point, it would depend on the listening service.

Parents sleeping, child wanders, parents have no knowledge until waking hours later (child found by kindly motorist)
= no negligence

Parents 60+ metres away, checking half-hourly, discover child missing = negligent (according to some)

 Lack of vigilance whilst sleeping is reasonable but sporadic lack of vigilance whilst waking is negligent.
Negligence is a failure to do something, not a reasonable attempt to exercise care.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 07:40:38 PM
I think you underestimate a parents ability to identify when their child is getting up to mischief even if they are asleep. You always tend to sleep with one ear open.

If children are of a mind to rise from their beds and leave the house while the parents sleep be assured they are perfectly capable of doing so.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 07:43:39 PM
It's the defence of the indefensible that raises questions.

Defending Amaral is a struggle, I agree ...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:44:55 PM
Parents sleeping, child wanders, parents have no knowledge until waking hours later (child found by kindly motorist)
= no negligence

Parents 60+ metres away, checking half-hourly, discover child missing = negligent (according to some)

 Lack of vigilance whilst sleeping is reasonable but sporadic lack of vigilance whilst waking is negligent.
Negligence is a failure to do something, not a reasonable attempt to exercise care.

First case = negligence. How does a child get out of a house, don't they lock the doors.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:46:42 PM
What's the difference? Are mothers too careful or not careful enough?

A careful mother would not send her child to nursery in case of sexual abuse or random gunmen.
A careful mother would not let her child ride a bike or use roller skates.
A careful mother would not leave her child with someone who had recently had a heart attack.
A careful mother would not leave her child with a stranger teenage babysitter.
A careful mother would never let her child walk to school unaccompanied.
A careful mother would never let her child go on a foreign school trip on a coach.

As I said - how tight do you wrap the cotton wool?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:48:44 PM
First case = negligence. How does a child get out of a house, don't they lock the doors.

Yale locks only require a turn of the knob. Not every house has triple-locked front doors.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 07:49:27 PM
A careful mother would not send her child to nursery in case of sexual abuse or random gunmen.
A careful mother would not let her child ride a bike or use roller skates.
A careful mother would not leave her child with someone who had recently had a heart attack.
A careful mother would not leave her child with a stranger teenage babysitter.
A careful mother would never let her child walk to school unaccompanied.
A careful mother would never let her child go on a foreign school trip on a coach.

As I said - how tight do you wrap the cotton wool?
                                                                  8@??)(
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:50:10 PM
A careful mother would not send her child to nursery in case of sexual abuse or random gunmen.
A careful mother would not let her child ride a bike or use roller skates.
A careful mother would not leave her child with someone who had recently had a heart attack.
A careful mother would not leave her child with a stranger teenage babysitter.
A careful mother would never let her child walk to school unaccompanied.
A careful mother would never let her child go on a foreign school trip on a coach.

As I said - how tight do you wrap the cotton wool?

I think you are confusing careful with paranoid.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 07:51:13 PM
It's the defence of the indefensible that raises questions.

Well clearly there are some on here who are content to pay a very high price should their decision go belly up rather than mitigate the risk of the unknown and uncertainty at the kick off.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 07:52:50 PM
I think you are confusing careful with paranoid.

The McCanns didn't want to leave their child with a  stranger of a baby-sitter......were they paranoid?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 07:53:00 PM
Negligent tends to be a legal concept.

The choice is reasonable or not.

Your last point, it would depend on the listening service.

The legal concept was addressed on their return to Rothley.  Why should it still be an issue with some eight years down the line?


**Snip
• The McCanns received a rare piece of good news - they were told they will not lose custody of their two-tear-old twins.
The couple had been terrified that British social workers - prompted by Portuguese allegations that the couple harmed Madeleine - would take away Sean and Amelie.
Two social workers spent an hour with the McCanns last Thursday, during which they asked the couple about their childcare techniques.
A family spokesman confirmed that social services do not consider the twins to be in danger.
She said: "The family went to social services to make sure they were being seen as responsible parents. Social services have contacted the family since then and said it went very well."
Asked whether the children were safe from being taken away, she said: "It is no longer a threat".

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-482136/Smiling-Kate-McCann-told-social-services-WONT-lose-twins.html#ixzz3sokdCDgq



Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 07:55:48 PM
It's reasonable versus negligent mantra.
Do sleeping parents whose child wake & wanders onto the street in the middle of the night face negligence charges? No, not normally.
Do nursery staff who fail to spot a child in their care has wandered away from the premises face negligence charges?
Yes, normally.
The action of the child is the same - yet one form of care is deemed reasonable whilst the other is deemed negligent.

So McCanns/Tapas 7 versus parents who used Child Listening Services. Reasonable or negligent?

When you pay a nursery for childcare they break their legal contract with you if they let a child wander off.
You don't normally pay for a listening service, but as it's part of the facilities on offer, I would expect a legal contract to exist. However, the service is contracted only to listen at agreed intervals. If they listen and hear nothing the contract is fulfilled, even if a child is quietly choking to death behind the door.

The McCanns and their friends had duties to their chilfren, as do all parents. One of these is protect and maintain the child. UK law says  it’s an offence to leave a child alone if it places them at risk.
https://www.gov.uk/law-on-leaving-your-child-home-alone


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:57:17 PM
The legal concept was addressed on their return to Rothley.  Why should it still be an issue with some eight years down the line?


**Snip
• The McCanns received a rare piece of good news - they were told they will not lose custody of their two-tear-old twins.
The couple had been terrified that British social workers - prompted by Portuguese allegations that the couple harmed Madeleine - would take away Sean and Amelie.
Two social workers spent an hour with the McCanns last Thursday, during which they asked the couple about their childcare techniques.
A family spokesman confirmed that social services do not consider the twins to be in danger.
She said: "The family went to social services to make sure they were being seen as responsible parents. Social services have contacted the family since then and said it went very well."
Asked whether the children were safe from being taken away, she said: "It is no longer a threat".

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-482136/Smiling-Kate-McCann-told-social-services-WONT-lose-twins.html#ixzz3sokdCDgq

There isn't a legal issue, I don't think anyone said there was. Just because something is not illegal doesn't make it right.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 07:59:20 PM
The McCanns didn't want to leave their child with a  stranger of a baby-sitter......were they paranoid?

Either that or maybe they didn't want to pay for a baby sitter?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:00:57 PM
Yale locks only require a turn of the knob. Not every house has triple-locked front doors.

Door chains
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 08:03:59 PM
When you pay a nursery for childcare they break their legal contract with you if they let a child wander off.
You don't normally pay for a listening service, but as it's part of the facilities on offer, I would expect a legal contract to exist. However, the service is contracted only to listen at agreed intervals. If they listen and hear nothing the contract is fulfilled, even if a child is quietly choking to death behind the door.

The McCanns and their friends had duties to their chilfren, as do all parents. One of these is protect and maintain the child. UK law says  it’s an offence to leave a child alone if it places them at risk.
https://www.gov.uk/law-on-leaving-your-child-home-alone

What good is a legal contract with a nursery if your child ends up under the wheels of a lorry? What good is a legal contract with a listening service if your child sets fire to the locked apartment & dies? Does your duty as a parent cease when you have entrusted your child's care to a stranger whose only credentials are a written contract & whose responsibilities are far less than expected of you?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 08:08:22 PM
Door chains

Piece of cake for a 3 year old, unless up high & well out of reach.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:10:53 PM
What good is a legal contract with a nursery if your child ends up under the wheels of a lorry? What good is a legal contract with a listening service if your child sets fire to the locked apartment & dies? Does your duty as a parent cease when you have entrusted your child's care to a stranger whose only credentials are a written contract & whose responsibilities are far less than expected of you?

Can I ask a couple of simple question?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the night of the disappearance?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the previous nights?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 08:12:54 PM
There isn't a legal issue, I don't think anyone said there was. Just because something is not illegal doesn't make it right.

You raised it.
I was responding to that part of your post where you commented ... "Negligent tends to be a legal concept."
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:15:29 PM
You raised it.
I was responding to that part of your post where you commented ... "Negligent tends to be a legal concept."

Misty brought negligence into the discussion, I was talking about reasonableness.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 08:18:01 PM
Can I ask a couple of simple question?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the night of the disappearance?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the previous nights?

They made decisions which seemed right for them at the time.
They made the same decisions as their friends, door issue aside.
Their decisions would not have been the same as my decisions.
As "the crime remains undetermined" it is not possible to say if their decisions determined Madeleine's fate.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 08:25:42 PM
The legal concept was addressed on their return to Rothley.  Why should it still be an issue with some eight years down the line?


**Snip
• The McCanns received a rare piece of good news - they were told they will not lose custody of their two-tear-old twins.
The couple had been terrified that British social workers - prompted by Portuguese allegations that the couple harmed Madeleine - would take away Sean and Amelie.
Two social workers spent an hour with the McCanns last Thursday, during which they asked the couple about their childcare techniques.
A family spokesman confirmed that social services do not consider the twins to be in danger.
She said: "The family went to social services to make sure they were being seen as responsible parents. Social services have contacted the family since then and said it went very well."
Asked whether the children were safe from being taken away, she said: "It is no longer a threat".

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-482136/Smiling-Kate-McCann-told-social-services-WONT-lose-twins.html#ixzz3sokdCDgq

So that's one bungling and incompetent barrister, a pseudo-'expert' in family law, who said the McCanns' behaviour was within bounds of normal parenting, and now duffer social services-types who say the same.

Where are the real experts, the social services-types who traverse these boards, to set the record straight and tell us all that the parents were incompetent, remiss negligent parents, who ought to have banged up -- for negligence at the very least?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:26:37 PM
They made decisions which seemed right for them at the time.
They made the same decisions as their friends, door issue aside.
Their decisions would not have been the same as my decisions.
As "the crime remains undetermined" it is not possible to say if their decisions determined Madeleine's fate.

So why wouldn't you have made the same choice as them?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 08:26:49 PM
Can I ask a couple of simple question?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the night of the disappearance?

Did the McCanns make the right decision in leaving the kids on the previous nights?

With the benefit of hindsight he answer to your question is self evident.

Perhaps you would consider mine ...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 08:30:16 PM
With the benefit of hindsight he answer to your question is self evident.

Perhaps you would consider mine ...
  • If the Drs McCann had been aware of break ins in the apartments in particular those which had occurred in block A ... would they have been as seduced by the quiet and family friendly atmosphere as they obviously were?
  • If the Drs McCann had known about the home invasions and the assaults on British children ... might they have reconsidered taking their children on holiday to the Algarve?
  • Should there not have been a duty of care on someone to ensure they had all the information to hand to allow them to make an informed decision about their child care arrangements?

The McCann's had no commonsense.

They could have hired a babysitter.

They could have dined at the apartment.

They locked the apartment in daytime, but not at night.

They left the children for extended periods with their attention elsewhere.

and on and on .......
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 08:34:51 PM
The McCann's had no commonsense.

They could have hired a babysitter.

They could have dined at the apartment.

They locked the apartment in daytime, but not at night.

They left the children for extended periods with their attention elsewhere.

and on and on .......

Does that mean you have abandoned: the McCannsdunsomethingdreadfultoMadeleineandcovereditup?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 08:37:06 PM
Does that mean you have abandoned: the McCannsdunsomethingdreadfultoMadeleineandcovereditup?

I never said that ferryman.

Try to stop lying.

It would help.

If you can.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:38:18 PM
With the benefit of hindsight he answer to your question is self evident.

Perhaps you would consider mine ...
  • If the Drs McCann had been aware of break ins in the apartments in particular those which had occurred in block A ... would they have been as seduced by the quiet and family friendly atmosphere as they obviously were?
  • If the Drs McCann had known about the home invasions and the assaults on British children ... might they have reconsidered taking their children on holiday to the Algarve?
  • Should there not have been a duty of care on someone to ensure they had all the information to hand to allow them to make an informed decision about their child care arrangements?

The answer to your first 2 points is self evident. Regarding your third point, it is incumbent on anyone visiting an area to research the area and work out what they need to do keep safe. In any holiday resort you expect a certain amount of break ins and as many of the assaults don't appear to have been reported until much later then not a lot of information to be imparted.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 08:40:54 PM
The McCann's had no commonsense.

They could have hired a babysitter.

They could have dined at the apartment.

They locked the apartment in daytime, but not at night.

They left the children for extended periods with their attention elsewhere.

and on and on .......

Yes they could have ... but the fact remains that they did not. 

The holiday company did not advertise that they could expect their child to be kidnapped or I am sure they would have made different decisions.

What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 08:46:26 PM
So why wouldn't you have made the same choice as them?

I wouldn't have made the same choice because at the ages of the McCann children
a) my daughter was extremely mischievous
b) my son often took over an hour to go to sleep & would often wake
c) I wouldn't have felt comfortable leaving them alone
d) I'm not one for bowing to peer pressure, I do what's right for me & mine.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 28, 2015, 08:49:24 PM
I wouldn't have made the same choice because at the ages of the McCann children
a) my daughter was extremely mischievous
b) my son often took over an hour to go to sleep & would often wake
c) I wouldn't have felt comfortable leaving them alone
d) I'm not one for bowing to peer pressure, I do what's right for me & mine.

I would agree with you.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 08:49:44 PM
What good is a legal contract with a nursery if your child ends up under the wheels of a lorry? What good is a legal contract with a listening service if your child sets fire to the locked apartment & dies? Does your duty as a parent cease when you have entrusted your child's care to a stranger whose only credentials are a written contract & whose responsibilities are far less than expected of you?

When we pay others to supply a service that's what they must do. In the 'nursery' case they didn't fulfill the contract and you could definitely sue them for negligence. In the 'listening' case they were contracted to listen, not firewatch, so not so simple. It might come down to how the child managed to set fire to the apartment. Did the parents leave matches or a lighter accessible to the child? That may be the parent's fault then.

In the end, it is up to parents to think about the safety of their children and to decide what risks they're prepared to take. Suing a nursery will give financial compensation but won't bring the child back, it's too late for that.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 08:56:22 PM
Misty brought negligence into the discussion, I was talking about reasonableness.

That which is not negligent is neither unreasonable; negligence, by definition, is also unreasonable.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 08:57:47 PM
Yes they could have ... but the fact remains that they did not. 

The holiday company did not advertise that they could expect their child to be kidnapped or I am sure they would have made different decisions.

What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.

It doesn't matter what happened or didn't happen in the resort before they arrived, the safety of their children was their responsibility, no-one else's. Leaving small children home alone in an unlocked apartment was a very irresponsible thing to do no matter what the excuse.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 08:58:05 PM
When we pay others to supply a service that's what they must do. In the 'nursery' case they didn't fulfill the contract and you could definitely sue them for negligence. In the 'listening' case they were contracted to listen, not firewatch, so not so simple. It might come down to how the child managed to set fire to the apartment. Did the parents leave matches or a lighter accessible to the child? That may be the parent's fault then.

In the end, it is up to parents to think about the safety of their children and to decide what risks they're prepared to take. Suing a nursery will give financial compensation but won't bring the child back, it's too late for that.

The parents weighed up the risks & came down on the side of taking sole responsibility for their children's welfare. Why berate them for that?
Just imagine the chaos, had the McCanns been suing MW Listening Service in the light of Amaral's thesis.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 09:00:34 PM
It doesn't matter what happened or didn't happen in the resort before they arrived, the safety of their children was their responsibility, no-one else's. Leaving small children home alone in an unlocked apartment was a very irresponsible thing to do no matter what the excuse.

Adults with an inclination to abduct children have a primary responsibility to curb their inclination(s)
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 28, 2015, 09:02:14 PM
Yes they could have ... but the fact remains that they did not. 

The holiday company did not advertise that they could expect their child to be kidnapped or I am sure they would have made different decisions.

What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.

I am quite aghast that you could have written that second sentence.

It seems you do not function in the real world at all.

Simply staggering.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 09:06:34 PM
The parents weighed up the risks & came down on the side of taking sole responsibility for their children's welfare. Why berate them for that?
Just imagine the chaos, had the McCanns been suing MW Listening Service in the light of Amaral's thesis.

The parents didn't even think about it, according to the mother, because 'it felt so safe' (although she expressed concern to her friends that evening). They made a bad decision and allegedly lost a child because of it. Why should I not say so?

Not possible to sue a listening service unless they could prove that screaming or other alarming sounds were ignored at the actual moment of listening. The listening service would have had an obligation only to listen.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 28, 2015, 09:10:42 PM
Adults with an inclination to abduct children have a primary responsibility to curb their inclination(s)

There is no proof that Madeleine was abducted, and even if she was, her safety is not the responsibility of the criminal, it is the responsibility of her parents. If all criminals curbed their inclinations we wouldn't need a Police Force or any Courts.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 09:13:59 PM
The parents didn't even think about it, according to the mother, because 'it felt so safe' (although she expressed concern to her friends that evening). They made a bad decision and allegedly lost a child because of it. Why should I not say so?

Not possible to sue a listening service unless they could prove that screaming or other alarming sounds were ignored at the actual moment of listening. The listening service would have had an obligation only to listen.

I'm almost lost for words that you consider an official child listening service is only responsible for listening & nothing else. Had the checker noticed open shutters & window - no legal responsibility? Had the checker noticed someone coming out of one of the apartment doors - no legal responsibility?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 09:56:48 PM
There is no proof that Madeleine was abducted, and even if she was, her safety is not the responsibility of the criminal, it is the responsibility of her parents. If all criminals curbed their inclinations we wouldn't need a Police Force or any Courts.

Criminals have no responsibility for their own actions?

Of course.

Silly me ....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 10:24:34 PM
The parents weighed up the risks & came down on the side of taking sole responsibility for their children's welfare. Why berate them for that?
Just imagine the chaos, had the McCanns been suing MW Listening Service in the light of Amaral's thesis.

There was no listening service in PdL.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 28, 2015, 10:35:21 PM
I am quite aghast that you could have written that second sentence.

It seems you do not function in the real world at all.

Simply staggering.

It's all to do with the "nothing to do with me pal" syndrome. Why would it not be everyone elses fault?
Why should you take responsibility for your own actions? That notion is totally unacceptable  8(>((
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 10:39:57 PM
There was no listening service in PdL.

I know - hence my use of the word "imagine".
Supposing there had been one, instead of the Tapas checking service......and the only legal responsibility the service had was to listen & report noise, nothing else.....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 10:44:09 PM
It's all to do with the "nothing to do with me pal" syndrome. Why would it not be everyone elses fault?
Why should you take responsibility for your own actions? That notion is totally unacceptable  8(>((

I myself prefer the ' a big boy did it and ran away' explanation. You not only don't have to rake the blame but you can also get someone you don't like into trouble at the same time. Two birds with one accusation so to speak !
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 10:45:03 PM
I know - hence my use of the word "imagine".
Supposing there had been one, instead of the Tapas checking service......and the only legal responsibility the service had was to listen & report noise, nothing else.....

But there wasn't one so what would be the point ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 10:50:10 PM
But there wasn't one so what would be the point ?

It would be a test of "reasonable childcare"& whether Amaral still felt the parents were responsible for covering up any accident Madeleine may have fallen victim to in the apartment.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 10:58:18 PM
I know - hence my use of the word "imagine".
Supposing there had been one, instead of the Tapas checking service......and the only legal responsibility the service had was to listen & report noise, nothing else.....

Noone least of all GU suggested that nannies on a listening services round would not be required to contact parents or report anythng unusual such as open windows doors or shutters....or anything else that they saw which might give them cause for concern, it goes without saying

& Ferryman, GU did not say crimnals are not responsible for ther actions...read the post again! Unless you are deliberately misrepresenting it!
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 11:07:48 PM
Noone least of all GU suggested that nannies on a listening services round would not be required to contact parents or report anythng unusual such as open windows doors or shutters....or anything else that they saw which might give them cause for concern, it goes without saying

& Ferryman, GU did not say crimnals are not responsible for ther actions...read the post again! Unless you are deliberately misrepresenting it!

What goes without saying? If the checker sees a man coming out of the front door of the apartment he/she is employed to listen at, he/she is contractually obliged to report the incident or challenge the man?
Would the checker be obliged to report the altered state of a window & shutter which could only be opened from the inside?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 28, 2015, 11:11:12 PM
I am quite aghast that you could have written that second sentence.

It seems you do not function in the real world at all.

Simply staggering.

Yet you do not appear to be aghast at the actions of a criminal.  I reiterate had the Drs McCann and their companions been aware that British children were being assaulted in their beds as their parents slept or that the apartments in their block had been subject to burglaries ... they might have altered their child care arrangements or not holidayed in the Algarve at all.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:11:48 PM
It would be a test of "reasonable childcare"& whether Amaral still felt the parents were responsible for covering up any accident Madeleine may have fallen victim to in the apartment.

Not sure I'm following your logic here misty. It is thought provoking though that if there had been a listening service in PdL and if the McCanns had used it assuming Madeleine was abducted her disappearance may have been detected a full 45 minutes earlier ( listening services usually check every 15 minutes ) if Tannerman had been the abductor. In fact the MW nanny may have caught Tannerman exiting the apartment through the bedroom window as that is more than likely where she would have 'listened'.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 11:19:48 PM
What goes without saying? If the checker sees a man coming out of the front door of the apartment he/she is employed to listen at, he/she is contractually obliged to report the incident or challenge the man?
Would the checker be obliged to report the altered state of a window & shutter which could only be opened from the inside?

Im not sure why you are even asking this question..YES, it goes without saying
,perhaps it is not written on a Moses tablet, but a nanny as well as anybody else would be obliged to check up on anything abnormal seen if responsible in any way for "checking on kids"

Perfect strangers and non responsible passers by do it all time...do you really believe any nanny would do nothing if confronted with a worrysome situation?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 28, 2015, 11:20:51 PM
Noone least of all GU suggested that nannies on a listening services round would not be required to contact parents or report anythng unusual such as open windows doors or shutters....or anything else that they saw which might give them cause for concern, it goes without saying

& Ferryman, GU did not say crimnals are not responsible for ther actions...read the post again! Unless you are deliberately misrepresenting it!

and even if [Madeleine] was [abducted,or worse], her safety is not the responsibility of the criminal ...

[G-Unit]

Responsibility of an abductor/assailant doesn't extend further than restraining instinct to harm.

But it certainly extends to that ....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 11:22:34 PM
and even if [Madeleine] was [abducted,or worse], her safety is not the responsibility of the criminal ...

[G-Unit]

Responsibility of an abductor/assailant doesn't extend further than restraining instinct to harm.

But it certainly extends to that ....

You are twisting what was said.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:23:20 PM
and even if [Madeleine] was [abducted,or worse], her safety is not the responsibility of the criminal ...

[G-Unit]

Responsibility of an abductor/assailant doesn't extend further than restraining instinct to harm.

But it certainly extends to that ....

But I thought Gerry said that there is no evidence that Madeleine has come to any harm ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 11:25:13 PM
Yes they could have ... but the fact remains that they did not. 

The holiday company did not advertise that they could expect their child to be kidnapped or I am sure they would have made different decisions.

What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.

Care to elucidate your final sentence?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 11:28:22 PM
Not sure I'm following your logic here misty. It is thought provoking though that if there had been a listening service in PdL and if the McCanns had used it assuming Madeleine was abducted her disappearance may have been detected a full 45 minutes earlier ( listening services usually check every 15 minutes ) if Tannerman had been the abductor. In fact the MW nanny may have caught Tannerman exiting the apartment through the bedroom window as that is more than likely where she would have 'listened'.

Any MW service would have operated on a routine schedule rather than the randomly-timed Tapas checking of 3rd May. If this was a planned abduction, a MW checking service would have made it easier for an abductor not to be caught and may well have resulted in the window & shutter not being left open, thus deflecting eventual suspicion onto MW staff.
It would certainly have altered the course of the police investigation.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 11:37:29 PM
Im not sure why you are even asking this question..YES, it goes without saying
,perhaps it is not written on a Moses tablet, but a nanny as well as anybody else would be obliged to check up on anything abnormal seen if responsible in any way for "checking on kids"

Perfect strangers and non responsible passers by do it all time...do you really believe any nanny would do nothing if confronted with a worrysome situation?

What I am trying to establish is - in that situation, would MW Listening service be legally liable for any loss of or injury to any child whom they had been asked to regularly check upon? Had the McCanns sued MW, what effect would GA's thesis (that Madeleine had been overdosed & had a fatal accident which the McCanns then covered up) have had on any decision regarding the extent of any liability on the part of MW childcare? Would the MW childcare have been considered more or less reasonable & responsible than the routine the Tapas group undertook?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:38:11 PM
Any MW service would have operated on a routine schedule rather than the randomly-timed Tapas checking of 3rd May. If this was a planned abduction, a MW checking service would have made it easier for an abductor not to be caught and may well have resulted in the window & shutter not being left open, thus deflecting eventual suspicion onto MW staff.
It would certainly have altered the course of the police investigation.

But there was no listening service and so hey,ho back to reality.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 28, 2015, 11:41:04 PM
What I am trying to establish is - in that situation, would MW Listening service be legally liable for any loss of or injury to any child whom they had been asked to regularly check upon? Had the McCanns sued MW, what effect would GA's thesis (that Madeleine had been overdosed & had a fatal accident which the McCanns then covered up) have had on any decision regarding the extent of any liability on the part of MW childcare? Would the MW childcare have been considered more or less reasonable & responsible than the routine the Tapas group undertook?

Sorry misty I must have missed the post where you explained why any of this mattered.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 28, 2015, 11:46:37 PM
Sorry misty I must have missed the post where you explained why any of this mattered.

It's about reasonable childcare & why it would appear there may be less legal responsibility attached to a professional childcare service (which can be sued should your child lose limb or life) than the moral duty a parent has.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 28, 2015, 11:47:58 PM
What I am trying to establish is - in that situation, would MW Listening service be legally liable for any loss of or injury to any child whom they had been asked to regularly check upon? Had the McCanns sued MW, what effect would GA's thesis (that Madeleine had been overdosed & had a fatal accident which the McCanns then covered up) have had on any decision regarding the extent of any liability on the part of MW childcare? Would the MW childcare have been considered more or less reasonable & responsible than the routine the Tapas group undertook?

I think you are creating your own academic problems here. Officially the authorities have said they did fail in their duty of care though there was, obviously, no intent to harm.
Now,
Had a listenng service been on offer, and it was carried out and everything seemed fine, as it normally is, why would MW be liable? If a MW nanny had seen a potential worrysome sign and did nothng about it, then maybe. I dont know, Im not a lawyer.
Not even sure why we are all discussing this issue any more....views are settled....no consensus, pointless waste of time,hey ho
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 29, 2015, 12:07:27 AM
I think you are creating your own academic problems here. Officially the authorities have said they did fail in their duty of care though there was, obviously, no intent to harm.
Now,
Had a listenng service been on offer, and it was carried out and everything seemed fine, as it normally is, why would MW be liable? If a MW nanny had seen a potential worrysome sign and did nothng about it, then maybe. I dont know, Im not a lawyer.
Not even sure why we are all discussing this issue any more....views are settled....no consensus, pointless waste of time,hey ho

We are discussing it still as "parental negligence" is the 8+ years mantra of the sceptic community & used as the go-to sole reason which determined Madeleine's fate.
If the record is considered boring, please disable the stylus (you know who).
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 29, 2015, 12:15:04 AM
The McCann's front door was locked.

The McCann's were closer than the friends to the Tapas Bar.

Why did the McCann's have baby sitters whilst at home?   They didn't leave the children alone when they went out at home did they?

As I have said,  they thought it was safe to do so,  a bad decision nothing else,  it doesn't mean in any way they didn't love their children.


Im not sure where you get your information that the front door was locked, all I have read in their statements is one if them said they werent sure, the other one said it was unlikely they locked it. And no, I never said they did not love their kids.
No-one has claimed it was not "a repeated mistake" ... why it is taking you and others over eight years of angst about it might also be a mistake as far as personal equilibrium is concerned.

The Drs McCann who live with Madeleine's disappearance every single day of their lives are coping and have managed to make a useful contribution to their family, to society and to the daughter Kate was screaming that they had let down ... by ensuring she is being looked for.

Can you direct me to a web site set up to excoriate the person who kidnapped Madeleine ... or is that opprobrium reserved solely for the victims of the crime.
1. yes, Clarence Mitchell tried to pass it off as a single mistake on a single night on the Jon Gaunt show until he was pulled up on the lie because Gaunt had done his research. Please dont ask for a cite as it used to exist but has been, as many Mccann related videos, pulled!


2)Please do not presume/assume/state this issue has flled me with angst for  8 years...what are you on? In actual fact, I was posting early on that the issue had been done to death and got slagged off for sayng so! Most comments I make are that it is not  a good idea to promote the idea that its fine to leave toddlers home alone...even Lace and Benice posted they wouldnt do it in the UK but on holiday it seems fine, everythngs relaxed, etc etc, and though I understand the holiday atmosphere is different, I dont personally  see it as an excuse to do any different than you do at home, though many do but 99 per cent of the time nothing terrible happens

3) Sorry I have no links to any imaginary abductor excoriating sites...even some of the most rabid pro mccann sites do not do much excoriating of them...except if  people who dont share their views! Out of all the possibie two dozen or so abductors we have been presented with, which one do you reckon everyne should start excoriating?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on November 29, 2015, 12:19:48 AM
We are discussing it still as "parental negligence" is the 8+ years mantra of the sceptic community & used as the go-to sole reason which determined Madeleine's fate.
If the record is considered boring, please disable the stylus (you know who).

Unfortunately you are starting to sound like Alfred...there is, for the umpteenth time, no such borg, called, the "sceptic community".... It is a term maliciously created...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 07:41:08 AM
Yet you do not appear to be aghast at the actions of a criminal.  I reiterate had the Drs McCann and their companions been aware that British children were being assaulted in their beds as their parents slept or that the apartments in their block had been subject to burglaries ... they might have altered their child care arrangements or not holidayed in the Algarve at all.

You really are very slow in this regard..............

CRIME UNKNOWN.

Meanwhile, children are the victims of crime all around the world.

and burglaries occur all around the world.

Time to take your head out of the sand.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 07:45:09 AM
I'm almost lost for words that you consider an official child listening service is only responsible for listening & nothing else. Had the checker noticed open shutters & window - no legal responsibility? Had the checker noticed someone coming out of one of the apartment doors - no legal responsibility?

What are you talking about? I was replying to your post about the McCann suing a listening service. Open windows and exiting people weren't mentioned in your post. Obviously they would report an open window or someone exiting with a child. Equally obviously anyone abducting a child would do it between 'checks', just as they allegedly did on 3rd May. If they agreed to check say every 15 minutes, there would have been plenty of time.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 08:01:01 AM
Yes they could have ... but the fact remains that they did not. 

The holiday company did not advertise that they could expect their child to be kidnapped or I am sure they would have made different decisions.

What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.

As to the following statement by you.........

'What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.'

You need help, and I mean help, typing statements such as that.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 08:10:28 AM
We are discussing it still as "parental negligence" is the 8+ years mantra of the sceptic community & used as the go-to sole reason which determined Madeleine's fate.
If the record is considered boring, please disable the stylus (you know who).

How to keep children safe from abduction;

1. Stay in with them.
2. Lock doors and windows.
3. Pay a baby-sitter.

If your child is still abducted you are not responsible, you did everything that could be expected of you.

How to make it easy for a would-be abductor;

1. Leave your children home alone in an unlocked apartment.
2. Tell people you've left them alone.
3. Check on them at half hour intervals.

Have you done everything that could be expected of you? If not, you have to take some of the responsibility for what happened. You haven't committed a crime, that was the abductor, but you didn't take reasonable care to protect your children.

Look at it this way; If you are burgled the Police will advise you how to make your home more secure. They will point out that locking doors and windows is vital to protect your property. They know it's the burglar who committed the crime, but they will still advise you to make your home secure in order to foil the burglar in future. They expect you to take some action to protect your property. No-one expects the burglar to 'curb his inclination' to burgle.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 29, 2015, 08:10:56 AM
As to the following statement by you.........

'What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.'

You need help, and I mean help, typing statements such as that.

Demonisation.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 08:27:17 AM
Yet you do not appear to be aghast at the actions of a criminal.  I reiterate had the Drs McCann and their companions been aware that British children were being assaulted in their beds as their parents slept or that the apartments in their block had been subject to burglaries ... they might have altered their child care arrangements or not holidayed in the Algarve at all.

That sounds like a very unrealistic expectation to me. How many holiday companies would elect to frighten their guests by telling them to beware of child molesters roaming the resort? That would ensure lots of bookings wouldn't it? That's assuming the holiday company even knew.

Basic security measure aren't rocket science. Lock doors and windows, stay in with children or pay a baby-sitter. Simple but effective most of the time.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 08:40:35 AM
How to keep children safe from abduction;

1. Stay in with them.
2. Lock doors and windows.
3. Pay a baby-sitter.

If your child is still abducted you are not responsible, you did everything that could be expected of you.

How to make it easy for a would-be abductor;

1. Leave your children home alone in an unlocked apartment.
2. Tell people you've left them alone.
3. Check on them at half hour intervals.

Have you done everything that could be expected of you? If not, you have to take some of the responsibility for what happened. You haven't committed a crime, that was the abductor, but you didn't take reasonable care to protect your children.

Look at it this way; If you are burgled the Police will advise you how to make your home more secure. They will point out that locking doors and windows is vital to protect your property. They know it's the burglar who committed the crime, but they will still advise you to make your home secure in order to foil the burglar in future. They expect you to take some action to protect your property. No-one expects the burglar to 'curb his inclination' to burgle.
Then by your high standards you would have to lay a certain amount of responsibility at the feet of the parents or guardians of Ben Needham, the Soham girls, Lesley Ann Down, thr child abducted from the bath, April Jones, Sarah Payne, etc etc etc for not locking their children up in their homes and for failing to keep them safe from harm.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 29, 2015, 08:49:44 AM
That sounds like a very unrealistic expectation to me. How many holiday companies would elect to frighten their guests by telling them to beware of child molesters roaming the resort? That would ensure lots of bookings wouldn't it? That's assuming the holiday company even knew.

Basic security measure aren't rocket science. Lock doors and windows, stay in with children or pay a baby-sitter. Simple but effective most of the time.

So we can endorse a maxim of profit before safety (from a commercial organisation that promotes family holidays)

But we must castigate parents who adopt a model of vigilance for safeguarding their children the equivalent of that that has been offered by such companies themselves (and that narrowly failed to thwart an abduction).

I see.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 08:51:45 AM
That sounds like a very unrealistic expectation to me. How many holiday companies would elect to frighten their guests by telling them to beware of child molesters roaming the resort? That would ensure lots of bookings wouldn't it? That's assuming the holiday company even knew.

Basic security measure aren't rocket science. Lock doors and windows, stay in with children or pay a baby-sitter. Simple but effective most of the time.
So we can endorse a maxim of profit before safety (from a commercial organisation that promotes family holidays)

But we must castigate parents who adopt a model of vigilance for safeguarding their children the equivalent of that that has been offered by such companies themselves (and that narrowly failed to thwart an abduction).

I see.

What abduction ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on November 29, 2015, 09:00:31 AM
At least the sceptics have abandoned theMcCannsdunsomethingdreadfultoMadeleineandcovereditup Progress of sorts, I suppose.

We now just have to persaude them that real experts in the field (see an earlier post by Brietta), who insist that there was nothing culpable, either, about the parenting of the McCanns or their friends, actually know what they are talking about.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 09:05:59 AM
At least the sceptics have abandoned theMcCannsdunsomethingdreadfultoMadeleineandcovereditup Progress of sorts, I suppose.

We now just have to persaude them that real experts in the field (see an earlier post by Brietta), who insist that there was nothing culpable, either, about the parenting of the McCanns or their friends, actually know what they are talking about.

The 'experts' have found nothing.

They clearly only investigated abduction, and nothing else.

Quite remarkable, since the crime remains unknown.

As for culpable, they were.

MADELEINE DISAPPEARED, when they were displaying 'responsible parenting skills'.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 09:08:19 AM


MADELEINE DISAPPEARED, when they were displaying 'responsible parenting skills'.

thank you for admitting it
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 09:19:38 AM
thank you for admitting it

I was being sarcastic, hence the quotation marks.

It wasn't responsible, and they weren't looking after their children.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 09:23:23 AM
Then by your high standards you would have to lay a certain amount of responsibility at the feet of the parents or guardians of Ben Needham, the Soham girls, Lesley Ann Down, thr child abducted from the bath, April Jones, Sarah Payne, etc etc etc for not locking their children up in their homes and for failing to keep them safe from harm.

Did any of them leave the children home alone?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 09:29:16 AM
Did any of them leave the children home alone?
What's that got to do with what you wrote?  You gave 3 golden rules for parents to prevent their children from abduction.  Each of the parents or guardians I cited broke one or more of those rules.   So what responsibility do you lay at their feet for their children's fate? 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 29, 2015, 09:31:52 AM
That sounds like a very unrealistic expectation to me. How many holiday companies would elect to frighten their guests by telling them to beware of child molesters roaming the resort? That would ensure lots of bookings wouldn't it? That's assuming the holiday company even knew.

Basic security measure aren't rocket science. Lock doors and windows, stay in with children or pay a baby-sitter. Simple but effective most of the time.

But they did know about the monster who targeted UK children in their own beds whilst their parents were in the next room.   The british consul said that it had been discussed at the monthly meetings held by Tour operators.   MW also knew about the burglaries that had taken place at the OC.

Deciding to keep that from the public could only be on the grounds that to warn their clients could damage their profits.   Is that acceptable?

If they had increased their security by installing CCTV to compensate for deciding not to publicise those events - then they might have had a leg to stand on imo.    But they did nothing - not even attempt to warn people about  even the possibility of burglaries.     I'm pretty sure that if only one small burglary- (even one described as a failed attempt)  had been mentioned at the Welcome Meeting - people would have had a completely different mindset to the one they ended up with - which was that they were in an extremely safe environment and could go away, relax and enjoy their holiday.

I have often wondered whether the great amount of assistance given to the McCanns by MW  was based on the realisation that their decision to keep clients in the dark - especially regarding the dangerous intruder mentioned above - may well have contributed to the tragedy which followed.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 09:34:17 AM
So we can endorse a maxim of profit before safety (from a commercial organisation that promotes family holidays)

But we must castigate parents who adopt a model of vigilance for safeguarding their children the equivalent of that that has been offered by such companies themselves (and that narrowly failed to thwart an abduction).

I see.

I never used the word 'endorse'. The history of commerce tells us that the main aim of commercial organisations is profit. Health and Safety has  never been a high priority historically or we wouldn't need the laws which exist. Commercial organisations are what they are and always have been; ways to make money.

There are no listening services advertised which leave doors unlocked as far as I know. Nor do they operate in unsuitable locations as far as I know. So the parents DID NOT adopt a model offered by any holiday company as far as I know.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 09:34:43 AM
But they did know about the monster who targeted UK children in their own beds whilst their parents were in the next room.   The british consul said that it had been discussed at the monthly meetings held by Tour operators.   MW also knew about the burglaries that had taken place at the OC.

Deciding to keep that from the public could only be on the grounds that to warn their clients could damage their profits.   Is that acceptable?

If they had increased their security by installing CCTV to compensate for deciding not to publicise those events - then they might have had a leg to stand on imo.    But they did nothing - not even attempt to warn people about  even the possibility of burglaries.     I'm pretty sure that if only one small burglary- (even one described as a failed attempt)  had been mentioned at the Welcome Meeting - people would have had a completely different mindset to the one they ended up with - which was that they were in an extremely safe environment and could go away, relax and enjoy their holiday.

I have often wondered whether the great amount of assistance given to the McCanns by MW  was based on the realisation that their decision to keep clients in the dark - especially regarding the dangerous intruder mentioned above - may well have contributed to the tragedy which followed.

Children go missing in all countries.

So what is your point ?

The mccanns had the responsibility of taking care of their own children,  AND  THAT WASN'T THE RESPONSIBILITY OF MW.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 09:41:45 AM
What's that got to do with what you wrote?  You gave 3 golden rules for parents to prevent their children from abduction.  Each of the parents or guardians I cited broke one or more of those rules.   So what responsibility do you lay at their feet for their children's fate?

The things I said referred only to the McCann case. I'm not going to deal with every case that ever happened.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 09:46:30 AM
The things I said referred only to the McCann case. I'm not going to deal with every case that ever happened.
So only the McCanns should have abided by your high standards of childcare to prevent abduction, everyone else is exempt or irrelevant.  I see.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 09:54:26 AM
So only the McCanns should have abided by your high standards of childcare to prevent abduction, everyone else is exempt or irrelevant.  I see.

It's not about abduction.

It's about taking care of your children.



Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 29, 2015, 10:02:02 AM
So only the McCanns should have abided by your high standards of childcare to prevent abduction, everyone else is exempt or irrelevant.  I see.

Thus it has been for the last 8 years.     

Everyone can be guilty of human error - except the McCanns.   
Everyone can have human flaws - except the McCanns.
We can all make mistakes -  but not the McCanns.   
Nobody is perfect.   But that doesn't include the McCanns who must display 100% perfect parenting at all times.

Totally irrational IMO. 

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on November 29, 2015, 10:07:14 AM
Thus it has been for the last 8 years.     

Everyone can be guilty of human error - except the McCanns.   
Everyone can have human flaws - except the McCanns.
We can all make mistakes -  but not the McCanns.   
Nobody is perfect.   But that doesn't include the McCanns who must display 100% perfect parenting at all times.

Totally irrational IMO.

Most of the others have properly admitted their flaws, errors and mistakes and have been forgiven by the court of public opinion.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 10:15:03 AM
But they did know about the monster who targeted UK children in their own beds whilst their parents were in the next room.   The british consul said that it had been discussed at the monthly meetings held by Tour operators.   MW also knew about the burglaries that had taken place at the OC.

Deciding to keep that from the public could only be on the grounds that to warn their clients could damage their profits.   Is that acceptable?

If they had increased their security by installing CCTV to compensate for deciding not to publicise those events - then they might have had a leg to stand on imo.    But they did nothing - not even attempt to warn people about  even the possibility of burglaries.     I'm pretty sure that if only one small burglary- (even one described as a failed attempt)  had been mentioned at the Welcome Meeting - people would have had a completely different mindset to the one they ended up with - which was that they were in an extremely safe environment and could go away, relax and enjoy their holiday.

I have often wondered whether the great amount of assistance given to the McCanns by MW  was based on the realisation that their decision to keep clients in the dark - especially regarding the dangerous intruder mentioned above - may well have contributed to the tragedy which followed.

Please note that it was the retired British Consul who told Kate McCann about the monthly meetings. Did the incumbant have those meetings also? She didn't say.

So it's Mark Warner's fault now? Are we all so naive that we need telling to safeguard our belongings and our children? Did these innocent lambs live in the real world or in some imaginary world where everyone is kind and no-one commits crimes? Did these so-called intelligent people never read the newspapers or watch the news?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 10:21:24 AM
So only the McCanns should have abided by your high standards of childcare to prevent abduction, everyone else is exempt or irrelevant.  I see.

Forgive me if I'm mistaken but I thought we were discussing the McCann's childcare arrangements? i dread to think what you think is acceptable if you think that staying in, locking doors and windows or hiring a baby-sitter are 'high standards of childcare'. I thought they were everyday common sense actions. The alternatives are going out, not locking doors and windows and not hiring a baby-sitter. How many people (apart from you and the McCanns) see that as acceptable childcare arrangements?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 10:32:42 AM
Thus it has been for the last 8 years.     

Everyone can be guilty of human error - except the McCanns.   
Everyone can have human flaws - except the McCanns.
We can all make mistakes -  but not the McCanns.   
Nobody is perfect.   But that doesn't include the McCanns who must display 100% perfect parenting at all times.

Totally irrational IMO.

What is irrational is people endlessly making excuses for people they don't know. These people said they left their children in a vulnerable situation night after night and when one of them disappeared they said she had been abducted. There is no proof that they left their children in a vulnerable situation. There is no proof that she was abducted. If people choose to believe them, fine, but as yet that doesn't make any of it true. If it is true they displayed a lack of knowledge of responsible parenting in my opinion, which I am entitled to hold and to express.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 10:39:10 AM
What is irrational is people endlessly making excuses for people they don't know. These people said they left their children in a vulnerable situation night after night and when one of them disappeared they said she had been abducted. There is no proof that they left their children in a vulnerable situation. There is no proof that she was abducted. If people choose to believe them, fine, but as yet that doesn't make any of it true. If it is true they displayed a lack of knowledge of responsible parenting in my opinion, which I am entitled to hold and to express.

its the fact that SY believe them that is important...not what a few posters on the net think
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 10:40:35 AM
What is irrational is people endlessly making excuses for people they don't know. These people said they left their children in a vulnerable situation night after night and when one of them disappeared they said she had been abducted. There is no proof that they left their children in a vulnerable situation. There is no proof that she was abducted. If people choose to believe them, fine, but as yet that doesn't make any of it true. If it is true they displayed a lack of knowledge of responsible parenting in my opinion, which I am entitled to hold and to express.

it is not irrational to support people you do not know...yours is a totally irrational statement
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 11:29:19 AM
Unfortunately you are starting to sound like Alfred...there is, for the umpteenth time, no such borg, called, the "sceptic community".... It is a term maliciously created...

I thought it was term created by folk who do not understand standard deviation and distribution 8(>((
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 11:38:20 AM
Forgive me if I'm mistaken but I thought we were discussing the McCann's childcare arrangements? i dread to think what you think is acceptable if you think that staying in, locking doors and windows or hiring a baby-sitter are 'high standards of childcare'. I thought they were everyday common sense actions. The alternatives are going out, not locking doors and windows and not hiring a baby-sitter. How many people (apart from you and the McCanns) see that as acceptable childcare arrangements?
I was commenting on your 3 golden rules of advice to the forum on how to ensure your child isn't abducted.  I was under the impression that your golden rules applied to everyone, not just the McCanns and their supporters, which is why I asked you if you held other parents of abducted children responsible for their kids' fates who had not abided strictly by your 3 golden rules.  It seems you don't want to answer this question, understandable I guess.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 29, 2015, 11:40:53 AM
But they did know about the monster who targeted UK children in their own beds whilst their parents were in the next room.   The british consul said that it had been discussed at the monthly meetings held by Tour operators.   MW also knew about the burglaries that had taken place at the OC.

Deciding to keep that from the public could only be on the grounds that to warn their clients could damage their profits.   Is that acceptable?

If they had increased their security by installing CCTV to compensate for deciding not to publicise those events - then they might have had a leg to stand on imo.    But they did nothing - not even attempt to warn people about  even the possibility of burglaries.     I'm pretty sure that if only one small burglary- (even one described as a failed attempt)  had been mentioned at the Welcome Meeting - people would have had a completely different mindset to the one they ended up with - which was that they were in an extremely safe environment and could go away, relax and enjoy their holiday.

I have often wondered whether the great amount of assistance given to the McCanns by MW  was based on the realisation that their decision to keep clients in the dark - especially regarding the dangerous intruder mentioned above - may well have contributed to the tragedy which followed.

Do you have a cite for the British consul discussing apartments being broken into with the tour operators?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 11:42:24 AM
Most of the others have properly admitted their flaws, errors and mistakes and have been forgiven by the court of public opinion.
The McCanns have also admitted their error of judgment but it seems some members of the jury in the court of public opinion refuse to acknowledge or hear that.  They prefer to continue to judge harshly, and their appetite for harsh judgment seems insatiable.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 11:43:43 AM
I thought it was term created by folk who do not understand standard deviation and distribution 8(>((
Would you disagree with the term McCann supporter community?  If so, please explain your grounds for disagreeing with this term.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 29, 2015, 11:54:35 AM
The McCanns have also admitted their error of judgment but it seems some members of the jury in the court of public opinion refuse to acknowledge or hear that.  They prefer to continue to judge harshly, and their appetite for harsh judgment seems insatiable.

i think Gerry has certainly come to terms with his part in his daughter's disappearance. I'm not sure if that's equally true of Kate.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 12:07:09 PM
The McCanns have also admitted their error of judgment but it seems some members of the jury in the court of public opinion refuse to acknowledge or hear that.  They prefer to continue to judge harshly, and their appetite for harsh judgment seems insatiable.
There would be no need to refer to their lack of judgement at all if some people didn't insist on making excuses for them ad infinitum. Chicken and egg? Did they fully admit their mistake?

That night runs over and over in my mind and I'm sure people will learn from our mistake, if you want to call it that.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id16.html

Yes, Dr McCann it was a huge mistake in my opinion. If I could ask you a question it would be 'what would you call it, if not a mistake'?

We also have to remember that there are other issues in this case. The childcare arrangements are just one of them.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 12:10:44 PM
i think Gerry has certainly come to terms with his part in his daughter's disappearance. I'm not sure if that's equally true of Kate.
How would you know?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 29, 2015, 12:18:15 PM
How would you know?

The same way as you profess to, from their public statements.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 12:30:45 PM
Would you disagree with the term McCann supporter community?  If so, please explain your grounds for disagreeing with this term.

Come again?
Did you really mean what you said?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 01:05:30 PM
Come again?
Did you really mean what you said?
Yes I really did, so...?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 01:11:02 PM
There would be no need to refer to their lack of judgement at all if some people didn't insist on making excuses for them ad infinitum. Chicken and egg? Did they fully admit their mistake?

That night runs over and over in my mind and I'm sure people will learn from our mistake, if you want to call it that.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id16.html

Yes, Dr McCann it was a huge mistake in my opinion. If I could ask you a question it would be 'what would you call it, if not a mistake'?

We also have to remember that there are other issues in this case. The childcare arrangements are just one of them.
And round and round in circles we go, it wasn't that long ago we had a discussion about this very issue, it really is too boring to go over it again for the umpteenth time, suffice it to say it's obvious that you get great pleasure from judging the McCanns by their action in Pdl in 2007, and will it seems continue to gain pleasure from it for years to come.  I, on the other hand, take no pleasure from reading the incessant harping on about the parents of a missing child, and whilst I acknowledge that what they did in Pdl was foolish and unwise, I am able (somehow, I don't know how!) to come to terms with it and get on with my life without the need to constantly refer to it.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 01:12:27 PM
The same way as you profess to, from their public statements.
I have no idea if Kate or Gerry have come to terms with anything at all, that is a private matter for them to know.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 29, 2015, 01:29:09 PM
And round and round in circles we go, it wasn't that long ago we had a discussion about this very issue, it really is too boring to go over it again for the umpteenth time, suffice it to say it's obvious that you get great pleasure from judging the McCanns by their action in Pdl in 2007, and will it seems continue to gain pleasure from it for years to come.  I, on the other hand, take no pleasure from reading the incessant harping on about the parents of a missing child, and whilst I acknowledge that what they did in Pdl was foolish and unwise, I am able (somehow, I don't know how!) to come to terms with it and get on with my life without the need to constantly refer to it.

Can I suggest Alfie that if you find boring people who have decided that the McCanns style of parenting lacked vigour then you stop reading and posting on forms where debate is not stifled and perhaps try a forum that is more supportive of the couple ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 01:54:48 PM
And round and round in circles we go, it wasn't that long ago we had a discussion about this very issue, it really is too boring to go over it again for the umpteenth time, suffice it to say it's obvious that you get great pleasure from judging the McCanns by their action in Pdl in 2007, and will it seems continue to gain pleasure from it for years to come.  I, on the other hand, take no pleasure from reading the incessant harping on about the parents of a missing child, and whilst I acknowledge that what they did in Pdl was foolish and unwise, I am able (somehow, I don't know how!) to come to terms with it and get on with my life without the need to constantly refer to it.

If you acknowledge that they acted in a foolish and unwise matter then my posts aren't directed at you. I am addressing those who seem to think the McCann's actions in PdL were reasonable, the fault of Mark Warner, just like advertised 'listening services' etc. If you think I get pleasure from having to repeat myself over and over you are way off the mark. I do it because others, unlike you, insist that they were not foolish and unwise.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 29, 2015, 02:42:30 PM
As to the following statement by you.........

'What do you think they should do about it at this remove ... I doubt their opening a vein would satisfy you.'

You need help, and I mean help, typing statements such as that.

You did not answer the question ... what do you think should be done about a decision, which does not affect you in the slightest, made over eight years ago?

Give it some very serious thought when pontificating about people who you have decided need "help" and exactly who may best qualify to come into that category.

"Cyberbullicide" ~~~ see, it even has its own word ... is a huge problem as a any cursory internet search will demonstrate. The family of a missing child have been and continue to be cyber assaulted ... and this without let-up for over eight years ???

What do you consider the more outrageous ... my remark pointing out what have been outcomes for a lot of people who have been cyberbullicided.  Or those who continue to cyber bully the Drs McCann with their parenting skills as a tool in the box? http://steinhardt.nyu.edu/appsych/opus/issues/2011/spring/cyberbullicide
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 02:53:21 PM
If you acknowledge that they acted in a foolish and unwise matter then my posts aren't directed at you. I am addressing those who seem to think the McCann's actions in PdL were reasonable, the fault of Mark Warner, just like advertised 'listening services' etc. If you think I get pleasure from having to repeat myself over and over you are way off the mark. I do it because others, unlike you, insist that they were not foolish and unwise.
I think most people acknowledge they were unwise, perhaps the dogmatic and repetitive insistence on repeating this criticism ad nauseam causes some polarization of views and a desire to defend those who appear to have been picked on more than they really deserved for the last nearly 9 years?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 02:58:54 PM
You did not answer the question ... what do you think should be done about a decision, which does not affect you in the slightest, made over eight years ago?

Give it some very serious thought when pontificating about people who you have decided need "help" and exactly who may best qualify to come into that category.

"Cyberbullicide" ~~~ see, it even has its own word ... is a huge problem as a any cursory internet search will demonstrate. The family of a missing child have been and continue to be cyber assaulted ... and this without let-up for over eight years ???

What do you consider the more outrageous ... my remark pointing out what have been outcomes for a lot of people who have been cyberbullicided.  Or those who continue to cyber bully the Drs McCann with their parenting skills as a tool in the box? http://steinhardt.nyu.edu/appsych/opus/issues/2011/spring/cyberbullicide
 

What I choose to do is absolutely nothing to do with.

You said that to me the other day, when I asked you if you are posting on here on behalf of the mccanns.

Then again I am a tax payer whose money is being used in the investigation. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on November 29, 2015, 03:04:05 PM
I have no idea if Kate or Gerry have come to terms with anything at all, that is a private matter for them to know.

That is exactly so Alfred,   it is a private matter for them to know.    No one can imagine  what they are still going through.   

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on November 29, 2015, 03:04:49 PM
 

What I choose to do is absolutely nothing to do with.

You said that to me the other day, when I asked you if you are posting on here on behalf of the mccanns.

Then again I am a tax payer whose money is being used in the investigation. 8**8:/:

Backtracked on the "help" issue I see ... however in a civilised society there are those of us who have no objection at all to chipping in our small pittance to search for a missing child.  With any luck we may even achieve real justice for Madeleine as a result.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 29, 2015, 03:25:37 PM
Do you have a cite for the British consul discussing apartments being broken into with the tour operators?
I would have been a lot more long-winded about asking the same question, so  8@??)(
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 03:56:51 PM
Do you have a cite for the British consul discussing apartments being broken into with the tour operators?

According to Kate McCann in her book (Page 295) the British consul told her on 4th May about intruders getting into bed with children. That would be Bill Henderson then. She then says she 'got in touch with the retired British consul for the Algarve' who told her he had regular meetings with Tour Operators at which crime was one of the subjects discussed. One of those meetings took place in August 2006, he said. I assume the retired consul was the same Bill Henderson, as he retired in August 2007, having been in the post since September 2005. The passage in the book doesn't really read as if she was talking about the same person, but it must have been.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on November 29, 2015, 04:30:51 PM
According to Kate McCann in her book (Page 295) the British consul told her on 4th May about intruders getting into bed with children. That would be Bill Henderson then. She then says she 'got in touch with the retired British consul for the Algarve' who told her he had regular meetings with Tour Operators at which crime was one of the subjects discussed. One of those meetings took place in August 2006, he said. I assume the retired consul was the same Bill Henderson, as he retired in August 2007, having been in the post since September 2005. The passage in the book doesn't really read as if she was talking about the same person, but it must have been.

Ah just Kate. I thought as much.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 29, 2015, 04:42:15 PM
According to Kate McCann in her book (Page 295) the British consul told her on 4th May about intruders getting into bed with children. That would be Bill Henderson then. She then says she 'got in touch with the retired British consul for the Algarve' who told her he had regular meetings with Tour Operators at which crime was one of the subjects discussed. One of those meetings took place in August 2006, he said. I assume the retired consul was the same Bill Henderson, as he retired in August 2007, having been in the post since September 2005. The passage in the book doesn't really read as if she was talking about the same person, but it must have been.
OKey dokey.  Do we have an idea of what, precisely, was going on here?

Intruders targeting British children?  Or just children?

Burglars?

Tour operators?  Did any other tour operator issue a warning about child assaults, British children at risk on the Algarve, or burglaries?

I am trying to get my head round what MW should or have not should have done, and what the British Consul should or should not have done.

AFAIK, Aug 2006 was before MW bought the OC.  If correct, MW had no reason to know about this briefing.

If the British Consul knew about child assaults, or burglaries, should he have insisted that tour operators informed tourists?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on November 29, 2015, 04:54:41 PM
Can a British consul insist on anything ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 05:10:12 PM
Ah just Kate. I thought as much.
Meaning...?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 29, 2015, 05:40:02 PM
Can a British consul insist on anything ?
Yup, of course he can.

As to whether he gets it or not ...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on November 29, 2015, 05:44:31 PM
Backtracked on the "help" issue I see ... however in a civilised society there are those of us who have no objection at all to chipping in our small pittance to search for a missing child.  With any luck we may even achieve real justice for Madeleine as a result.

Back tracing on what exactly ?

and you are searching for Madeleine, on a keyboard ?

Real justice for Madeleine ?

Do you enjoy typing cliches ?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 07:09:46 PM
Would you disagree with the term McCann supporter community?  If so, please explain your grounds for disagreeing with this term.

As a generic term it's good enough the same way "sceptic community" is good enough as a generic term.
What has to be recognised is that within the "generic community" there will be all makes and shapes.
A bit like "corvid" as a generic term; it covers the crow family but only a kin idiot would think a jackdaw and jay were the same thing.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 07:37:55 PM
As a generic term it's good enough the same way "sceptic community" is good enough as a generic term.
What has to be recognised is that within the "generic community" there will be all makes and shapes.
A bit like "corvid" as a generic term; it covers the crow family but only a kin idiot would think a jackdaw and jay were the same thing.
right, so you agree that "sceptic" community is a legitimate generic term, despite feigning surprise / indignation / contempt when it has been used on here before.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 07:40:21 PM
Can I suggest Alfie that if you find boring people who have decided that the McCanns style of parenting lacked vigour then you stop reading and posting on forms where debate is not stifled and perhaps try a forum that is more supportive of the couple ?
I said I find the repetitive groundhog day circular arguments boring. 

You really do seem quite desperate for me to stop posting here, as you are always suggesting that I leave or shut up, any particular reason why?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 07:53:48 PM
OKey dokey.  Do we have an idea of what, precisely, was going on here?

Intruders targeting British children?  Or just children?

Burglars?

Tour operators?  Did any other tour operator issue a warning about child assaults, British children at risk on the Algarve, or burglaries?

I am trying to get my head round what MW should or have not should have done, and what the British Consul should or should not have done.

AFAIK, Aug 2006 was before MW bought the OC.  If correct, MW had no reason to know about this briefing.

If the British Consul knew about child assaults, or burglaries, should he have insisted that tour operators informed tourists?

According tho the newspapers later it was just British children that smelly man liked. No other nationalities attracted him. Negotiations to buy the Ocean Club began after a visit to the site by one of the partners early in 2006. It took a year to complete the negotiations, so they were concluded after January 2007, according to Crossland.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBIN_CROSSLAND.htm

So Mark Warner were 'the new kids on the block' in 2007. The Ocean Club may have attended the meetings, as may Thomas Cook and Jonathan Markson. No-one has ever said they issued warnings to their customers to keep an eye on either their children or their belongings.

Did the consulate inform anyone contacting them about the dangers of the Algarve? We don't but know but again, no one has ever said they did.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 07:54:03 PM
right, so you agree that "sceptic" community is a legitimate generic term, despite feigning surprise / indignation / contempt when it has been used on here before.

What I object to is the not infrequent suggestion all the "sceptic community" are some how deficient in intelligence empathy or whatever simply because they are sceptics. Standard distribution will not support that notion. So we are left with:
"are those who suggest such things incredibly intelligent people who are taking the p**s or idiots who really mean it ?". Same end result; they can't be taken seriously  8(>((
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 07:56:25 PM
What I object to is the not infrequent suggestion all the "sceptic community" are some how deficient in intelligence empathy or whatever simply because they are sceptics. Standard distribution will not support that notion. So we are left with:
"are those who suggest such things incredibly intelligent people who are taking the p**s or idiots who really mean it ?". Same end result; they can't be taken seriously  8(>((

perhaps if you actually understood the posts you would realise no one has ever said that....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 07:59:40 PM
perhaps if you actually understood the posts you would realise no one has ever said that....

You usual tactic I see.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 08:02:00 PM
I said I find the repetitive groundhog day circular arguments boring. 

You really do seem quite desperate for me to stop posting here, as you are always suggesting that I leave or shut up, any particular reason why?

Perhaps you would feel more comfortable in an environment where everyone agrees with you ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 08:04:27 PM
You usual tactic I see.

if the usual tactic is to point out that what you are saying is untrue...then you must be posting a lot of untruths...I'll leave you to decide
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 08:13:11 PM
Perhaps you would feel more comfortable in an environment where everyone agrees with you ?
I'm very comfortable here thank you, it's others who find me an uncomfortable presence - their problem. 8(>((
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 08:17:38 PM
I'm very comfortable here thank you, it's others who find me an uncomfortable presence - their problem. 8(>((

You must be kidding?
How could anyone find your presence uncomfortable?
Spoil us Alf and tell us how that can be?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 08:21:28 PM
The way posters in the sceptic community rattle on about free speech then try to get me banned when I upset their precious little souls makes me think its the sceptic community who would prefer to post where no one disagrees with them

I did notice you were given a red card a while back but presumably that was down to your behaviour rather than that of others?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 08:24:58 PM
I did notice you were given a red card a while back but presumably that was down to your behaviour rather than that of others?

what behaviour...it seems those who rattle on about free speech on here don't realise what it actually means
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 29, 2015, 08:28:35 PM
if the usual tactic is to point out that what you are saying is untrue...then you must be posting a lot of untruths...I'll leave you to decide

In the context of your post to which I responded your post above does not make sense.
Would you like to have another go?......no extra charge
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 08:29:28 PM
In the context of your post to which I responded your post above does not make sense.
Would you like to have another go?......no extra charge

makes sense to me...you have another go
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 08:37:40 PM
You must be kidding?
How could anyone find your presence uncomfortable?
Spoil us Alf and tell us how that can be?
I replied and guess what?  My response was removed!
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 08:39:19 PM
What I object to is the not infrequent suggestion all the "sceptic community" are some how deficient in intelligence empathy or whatever simply because they are sceptics. Standard distribution will not support that notion. So we are left with:
"are those who suggest such things incredibly intelligent people who are taking the p**s or idiots who really mean it ?". Same end result; they can't be taken seriously  8(>((
I replied to this too, also removed.  Guess someone want you to have the last word Alice.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 29, 2015, 08:42:09 PM
what behaviour...it seems those who rattle on about free speech on here don't realise what it actually means

It seems that some highly intelligent and educated people can't work out what we are or are not allowed to say on this forum. Either that or they have contempt for the rules and those who provide the site for us.

As with the McCann's childcare arrangements, some people think they know best when they clearly don't.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 29, 2015, 08:47:21 PM
It seems that some highly intelligent and educated people can't work out what we are or are not allowed to say on this forum. Either that or they have contempt for the rules and those who provide the site for us.

As with the McCann's childcare arrangements, some people think they know best when they clearly don't.
you think you know best don't you?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on November 29, 2015, 08:49:20 PM
It seems that some highly intelligent and educated people can't work out what we are or are not allowed to say on this forum. Either that or they have contempt for the rules and those who provide the site for us.

As with the McCann's childcare arrangements, some people think they know best when they clearly don't.

As far as childcare is concerned, many are happy to follow the rules laid down by those who purport to know best, ie, government/social services. Their rules are often sadly lacking & frequently abused by their preachers.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on November 29, 2015, 08:49:25 PM
It seems that some highly intelligent and educated people can't work out what we are or are not allowed to say on this forum. Either that or they have contempt for the rules and those who provide the site for us.

As with the McCann's childcare arrangements, some people think they know best when they clearly don't.

the McCanns childcare arrangement are their business and not yours.....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on November 30, 2015, 09:59:45 AM
Please note that it was the retired British Consul who told Kate McCann about the monthly meetings. Did the incumbant have those meetings also? She didn't say.

So it's Mark Warner's fault now? Are we all so naive that we need telling to safeguard our belongings and our children? Did these innocent lambs live in the real world or in some imaginary world where everyone is kind and no-one commits crimes? Did these so-called intelligent people never read the newspapers or watch the news?

I didn't say it was MW's fault - kindly do not put words in my mouth.    I said the tour operator may have thought  that their decision to keep their customers in complete ignorance about a child abuser potentially in the area - may have contributed to the end result  -  because IMO even had the smallest warning been given -  about recent burglaries for instance -  it could well have been enough to tip the balance and for parents to make different choices.      But that info was kept from them and so they remained in the dark and completely re-assured that they were in child friendly,safe environment and largely on the strength of that imo- made the choices they did..   

IMO having made that decision (obviously for reasons of profit) to keep quiet  - the tour operator should have at least increased the security at the OC to compensate for it.

It's clear that the child abuser(s) in question - quickly came to the mind of the British Consul as he told  K&G about those cases on the 4th May.  I see no reason why the tour operator would not have had similar thoughts and just as quickly.  Hence my wondering whether the huge amount of help they gave the McCanns was in some way related to that decision to keep schtum.   Although of course  - it could well be that the same help would have been provided in any case.  It was just a thought.

In my own experience people do not go on holiday expecting terrible things to happen to them and permanently thinking the worst of everyone and viewing every situation with suspicion all of the time.  Quite the opposite.

However, with respect G-Unit - and my apols if I'm wrong - but your 'signature' which reads   ''Assume nothing,  Believe nobody,   Check everything''  leads me to believe that you do exactly that.        That's fair enough - your choice - but IMO it's unfair to assume that people who see things differently to you - are automatically wrong and so deserve years of unrelenting criticism.   

AIMHO
   
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 30, 2015, 10:48:06 AM
I didn't say it was MW's fault - kindly do not put words in my mouth.    I said the tour operator may have thought  that their decision to keep their customers in complete ignorance about a child abuser potentially in the area - may have contributed to the end result  -  because IMO even had the smallest warning been given -  about recent burglaries for instance -  it could well have been enough to tip the balance and for parents to make different choices.      But that info was kept from them and so they remained in the dark and completely re-assured that they were in child friendly,safe environment and largely on the strength of that imo- made the choices they did..   

IMO having made that decision (obviously for reasons of profit) to keep quiet  - the tour operator should have at least increased the security at the OC to compensate for it.

It's clear that the child abuser(s) in question - quickly came to the mind of the British Consul as he told  K&G about those cases on the 4th May.  I see no reason why the tour operator would not have had similar thoughts and just as quickly.  Hence my wondering whether the huge amount of help they gave the McCanns was in some way related to that decision to keep schtum.   Although of course  - it could well be that the same help would have been provided in any case.  It was just a thought.

In my own experience people do not go on holiday expecting terrible things to happen to them and permanently thinking the worst of everyone and viewing every situation with suspicion all of the time.  Quite the opposite.

However, with respect G-Unit - and my apols if I'm wrong - but your 'signature' which reads   ''Assume nothing,  Believe nobody,   Check everything''  leads me to believe that you do exactly that.        That's fair enough - your choice - but IMO it's unfair to assume that people who see things differently to you - are automatically wrong and so deserve years of unrelenting criticism.   

AIMHO
 
I don't know about G-Unit, but the concept I am struggling with is the British Consul having this level of information.

Does one report a burglary to the British Consul?  Presumably one does when one needs the support the consulate provides, otherwise (the majority of times) presumably not.

Does one report a child sexual assault or an attempted child sexual assault to the BC?  I just can't see this in the majority of circumstances.

Judging by the purported increase discovered by OG after public appeals, around a third of cases had not been reported to any authority.

How does the BC get this info?  And if he really did have it, surely a safeguard stronger than talking to tour companies was required?

As for MW, the only theft I know of that might have been reported to them was one instance after the tourists turned up. Not knowing the details of the case, I have no idea whether this was an actual burglary, or whether the tourists left the key under the door (as per the Paynes) or left the patio door unlocked.

Equally, I have nothing concrete about what safety precautions were recommended.  Presumably these did not go as far as - don't leave your key under the mat - or - don't leave your patio door unlocked.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on November 30, 2015, 01:23:02 PM
That is an interesting point, SIL. Although Kate McCann referred to this problem in her book, the UK newspapers only really reported it in 2014. According to them a lone intruder sexually assaulted 5 girls between the ages of 7 and 10 in four incidents the Algarve between 2004 and 2006. Most of the premises which were entered were villas, presumably booked through companies which provided villas. They mostly took place between 2am and 5am.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve

It seems likely that the tour operators were notified and brought it up at the meetings. Of course Mark Warner wouldn't have attended any of them, they only arrived in 2007.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 30, 2015, 03:00:51 PM
That is an interesting point, SIL. Although Kate McCann referred to this problem in her book, the UK newspapers only really reported it in 2014. According to them a lone intruder sexually assaulted 5 girls between the ages of 7 and 10 in four incidents the Algarve between 2004 and 2006. Most of the premises which were entered were villas, presumably booked through companies which provided villas. They mostly took place between 2am and 5am.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/19/madeleine-mccann-police-intruder-girls-algarve

It seems likely that the tour operators were notified and brought it up at the meetings. Of course Mark Warner wouldn't have attended any of them, they only arrived in 2007.
There was continuity between staff at the OC pre and post-takeover.  One would assume someone senior with good English would attend e.g. John Hill if he was there early enough or Crossland.  The issue is - was such a thing known and raised?

It looks like Kate did get an early heads-up from the consul for the Algarve, Bill Henderson.

If the info was passed to holiday operators, and if that included the OC, then some form of guidance should have been in place  I wonder what Thomas Cook told their arrivals?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 30, 2015, 03:10:04 PM
I don't know about G-Unit, but the concept I am struggling with is the British Consul having this level of information.

Does one report a burglary to the British Consul?  Presumably one does when one needs the support the consulate provides, otherwise (the majority of times) presumably not.

Does one report a child sexual assault or an attempted child sexual assault to the BC?  I just can't see this in the majority of circumstances.

Judging by the purported increase discovered by OG after public appeals, around a third of cases had not been reported to any authority.

How does the BC get this info?  And if he really did have it, surely a safeguard stronger than talking to tour companies was required?

As for MW, the only theft I know of that might have been reported to them was one instance after the tourists turned up. Not knowing the details of the case, I have no idea whether this was an actual burglary, or whether the tourists left the key under the door (as per the Paynes) or left the patio door unlocked.

Equally, I have nothing concrete about what safety precautions were recommended.  Presumably these did not go as far as - don't leave your key under the mat - or - don't leave your patio door unlocked.
Perhaps British nationals sought assistance from the British Consul as they felt their claims were not being taken seriously by the Portuguese authorities...?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 30, 2015, 06:41:11 PM
Perhaps British nationals sought assistance from the British Consul as they felt their claims were not being taken seriously by the Portuguese authorities...?
Whether that is what actually happened or not, it is the most likely explanation so far.

Possibly it was taken up upon return the UK to make sure it was investigated, and the diplomatic channel was the main way to discuss this with Portuguese authorities.

We still don't know anyone in the OC/MW set-up was included in the people informed.  Unless that has come out somewhere?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 30, 2015, 07:02:18 PM
Looking at the Grauniad link posted this smacks of a rerun of the smelly bin man routine.
The Mirror headlines at the time were on about SY going to Portugal to make 6 arrests or some such similar sort of animile  @)(++(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on December 01, 2015, 04:42:30 PM
I didn't say it was MW's fault - kindly do not put words in my mouth.    I said the tour operator may have thought  that their decision to keep their customers in complete ignorance about a child abuser potentially in the area - may have contributed to the end result -  because IMO even had the smallest warning been given -  about recent burglaries for instance -  it could well have been enough to tip the balance and for parents to make different choices.      But that info was kept from them and so they remained in the dark and completely re-assured that they were in child friendly,safe environment and largely on the strength of that imo- made the choices they did..   

IMO having made that decision (obviously for reasons of profit) to keep quiet  - the tour operator should have at least increased the security at the OC to compensate for it.

It's clear that the child abuser(s) in question - quickly came to the mind of the British Consul as he told  K&G about those cases on the 4th May.  I see no reason why the tour operator would not have had similar thoughts and just as quickly.  Hence my wondering whether the huge amount of help they gave the McCanns was in some way related to that decision to keep schtum.   Although of course  - it could well be that the same help would have been provided in any case.  It was just a thought.

In my own experience people do not go on holiday expecting terrible things to happen to them and permanently thinking the worst of everyone and viewing every situation with suspicion all of the time.  Quite the opposite.

However, with respect G-Unit - and my apols if I'm wrong - but your 'signature' which reads   ''Assume nothing,  Believe nobody,   Check everything''  leads me to believe that you do exactly that.        That's fair enough - your choice - but IMO it's unfair to assume that people who see things differently to you - are automatically wrong and so deserve years of unrelenting criticism.   

AIMHO
 

You suggest MW MAY have contributed to the end result? what result would that be? Yet you do not suspect the parents behaviour had any fault at all? ( your fellow supporters are claiming the parents are innocent)- but MW may not be so innocent? and may have contributed to a claimed 'abduction'  oh ok then.



Abduction? was there a history of kidnapping/abduction in the area? NO.

Again in YOUR OPINION, you claim the smallest of warning could have prevented the claimed 'abduction'  How about two qualified doctors who are given exceptional specialist training in child protection-  then claiming of being unaware that leaving children alone at night in a strange country was in keeping with such training?
EVEN after one of the children complained about it (the 'abducted one'). Even when the British Government trained them in child protection they ignored that HUGE elephant in the room. but  you and your opinion will indeed carry weight to others who seek to leave their children alone.

text in blue
Seriously? well that blows the cat out the window, becuse we are told by many on here that it was just like sitting in the garden and lots of people do it.

They and THEY alone are reponsible for their daughters saftey, or as it turns out LACK OF IT.



Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 01, 2015, 05:33:55 PM
I didn't say it was MW's fault - kindly do not put words in my mouth.    I said the tour operator may have thought  that their decision to keep their customers in complete ignorance about a child abuser potentially in the area - may have contributed to the end result  -  because IMO even had the smallest warning been given -  about recent burglaries for instance -  it could well have been enough to tip the balance and for parents to make different choices.      But that info was kept from them and so they remained in the dark and completely re-assured that they were in child friendly,safe environment and largely on the strength of that imo- made the choices they did..   

IMO having made that decision (obviously for reasons of profit) to keep quiet  - the tour operator should have at least increased the security at the OC to compensate for it.

It's clear that the child abuser(s) in question - quickly came to the mind of the British Consul as he told  K&G about those cases on the 4th May.  I see no reason why the tour operator would not have had similar thoughts and just as quickly.  Hence my wondering whether the huge amount of help they gave the McCanns was in some way related to that decision to keep schtum.   Although of course  - it could well be that the same help would have been provided in any case.  It was just a thought.

In my own experience people do not go on holiday expecting terrible things to happen to them and permanently thinking the worst of everyone and viewing every situation with suspicion all of the time.  Quite the opposite.

However, with respect G-Unit - and my apols if I'm wrong - but your 'signature' which reads   ''Assume nothing,  Believe nobody,   Check everything''  leads me to believe that you do exactly that.        That's fair enough - your choice - but IMO it's unfair to assume that people who see things differently to you - are automatically wrong and so deserve years of unrelenting criticism.   

AIMHO
 

But you do seem to be saying that in your opinion Mark Warner made a conscious decision not to warn their clients abut recent crimes in the area so as not to harm their profits.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on December 01, 2015, 05:59:28 PM
But you do seem to be saying that in your opinion Mark Warner made a conscious decision not to warn their clients abut recent crimes in the area so as not to harm their profits.

Indeed, and how was MW to protect children from stupidity.  The parents locked their belonings away, even though they were not informed of pick pockets operating in the area. They also locked their apartments during the day, even thugh they were not warned of burglaries- So let's here it for the: no locking the doors at night because it felt safe?
1. 2. 3..
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 01, 2015, 06:08:26 PM
Indeed, and how was MW to protect children from stupidity.  The parents locked their belonings away, even though they were not informed of pick pockets operating in the area. They also locked their apartments during the day, even thugh they were not warned of burglaries- So let's here it for the: no locking the doors at night because it felt safe?
1. 2. 3..

It was and is the parents responsibility.

Not MW.

All that is visible is the blame game by the mccanns and their cohorts.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on December 01, 2015, 06:15:33 PM
It was and is the parents responsibility.

Not MW.

All that is visible is the blame game by the mccanns and their cohorts.

Don't be so harsh Stephen, Blaming others is seen as a coping mechanism... *giggles*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 09:18:53 AM
Indeed, and how was MW to protect children from stupidity.  The parents locked their belonings away, even though they were not informed of pick pockets operating in the area. They also locked their apartments during the day, even thugh they were not warned of burglaries- So let's here it for the: no locking the doors at night because it felt safe?
1. 2. 3..

When they went out during the day it would be for longer than 30 minutes at a time wouldn't it?   

Were they warned about burglaries?   cite please.

I am saying I agree with them not locking the doors,  but they felt safe because as they say were only down the road and checking regularly on the children.

As I have said before I have seen  parents go camping and leave their children alone in tents to go off to barbeques further away than the McCann's were.   For some reason when some people are on holiday they tend to forget their usual fears and take risks which they would never take at home.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 02, 2015, 09:30:43 AM
When they went out during the day it would be for longer than 30 minutes at a time wouldn't it?   

Were they warned about burglaries?   cite please.

I am saying I agree with them not locking the doors,  but they felt safe because as they say were only down the road and checking regularly on the children.

As I have said before I have seen  parents go camping and leave their children alone in tents to go off to barbeques further away than the McCann's were.   For some reason when some people are on holiday they tend to forget their usual fears and take risks which they would never take at home.

Do you have a cite for the tents and BBQs?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 02, 2015, 09:33:01 AM
Do you have a cite for the tents and BBQs?
Oh please.  Lace is talking about her own personal experience, but as it happens a child was removed from a tent in her uncle's back garden and abducted and murdered, would you like a cite for that?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 02, 2015, 09:41:52 AM
When they went out during the day it would be for longer than 30 minutes at a time wouldn't it?   

Were they warned about burglaries?   cite please.

I am saying I agree with them not locking the doors,  but they felt safe because as they say were only down the road and checking regularly on the children.

As I have said before I have seen  parents go camping and leave their children alone in tents to go off to barbeques further away than the McCann's were.   For some reason when some people are on holiday they tend to forget their usual fears and take risks which they would never take at home.

Burglaries happen all over the world, so that reference to being warned is irrelevant.

Essentially you are passing the buck to MW, and that won't wash.

and likewise, if they felt so 'safe' , why not leave the doors unlocked during the daytime ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 02, 2015, 09:47:44 AM
When they went out during the day it would be for longer than 30 minutes at a time wouldn't it?   

Were they warned about burglaries?   cite please.

I am saying I agree with them not locking the doors,  but they felt safe because as they say were only down the road and checking regularly on the children.

As I have said before I have seen  parents go camping and leave their children alone in tents to go off to barbeques further away than the McCann's were.   For some reason when some people are on holiday they tend to forget their usual fears and take risks which they would never take at home.

Did they feel safe?

Kate, I think, had done something that she wasn't quite happy with, in leaving the doors unlocked. And that is something again that she is going to beat herself up about for a long time to come because, you know, you, you like think that you acted on your instincts and I think her instinct was that that was something she wasn't really happy to do'.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 10:35:52 AM
Burglaries happen all over the world, so that reference to being warned is irrelevant.

Essentially you are passing the buck to MW, and that won't wash.

and likewise, if they felt so 'safe' , why not leave the doors unlocked during the daytime ?

I was merely asking Miss Token Identity if she had proof that the McCann's were warned about burglaries as I cannot imagine any holiday resort warning people that there had been burglaries as that would put people off staying at their holiday resort.

I explained why they thought it was 'safe'  in their eyes to leave the door open at night and not in the daytime Stephen.    They were away longer in the daytime,  plus there were more people around.   They said it was very quiet at night and felt so safe.    They shouldn't have left the children alone in my opinion,  but they made a decision to do so.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 02, 2015, 10:39:01 AM
I was merely asking Miss Token Identity if she had proof that the McCann's were warned about burglaries as I cannot imagine any holiday resort warning people that there had been burglaries as that would put people off staying at their holiday resort.

I explained why they thought it was 'safe'  in their eyes to leave the door open at night and not in the daytime Stephen.    They were away longer in the daytime,  plus there were more people around.   They said it was very quiet at night and felt so safe.    They shouldn't have left the children alone in my opinion,  but they made a decision to do so.

That IMO is an irrational argument.

Burglaries or what ever you want to call them take place at night as well. Why would any one want to make the risk greater by leaving the doors unlocked ?

Would you leave your doors unlocked at night ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 10:39:57 AM
Do you have a cite for the tents and BBQs?

No,   I didn't make a video of it Stephen,  or take photo's.

I am merely pointing out the risks people make whilst on holiday.    The tent was their canvas 'house'  really when they were on holiday,   yet they left their small children alone in it to go to a barbeque there are no locks on the tent and a child could easily get out or someone get in.   At home no doubt this family would not leave their children alone at home with the doors unlocked to go out for a couple of hours,  but they did on holiday.  For some reason when people are on holiday at a family holiday resort,  they tend to take risks.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 10:40:52 AM
That IMO is an irrational argument.

Burglaries or what ever you want to call them take place at night as well. Why would any one want to make the risk greater by leaving the doors unlocked ?

Would you leave your doors unlocked at night ?

See my later post.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 10:42:12 AM
That IMO is an irrational argument.

Burglaries or what ever you want to call them take place at night as well. Why would any one want to make the risk greater by leaving the doors unlocked ?

Would you leave your doors unlocked at night ?

As a matter of fact Stephen I seem to recall a OC employee saying that many of the holiday makers didn't lock their doors during the day.   I will try and find it,  but not now as I have other things to do.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 02, 2015, 10:42:31 AM
I was merely asking Miss Token Identity if she had proof that the McCann's were warned about burglaries as I cannot imagine any holiday resort warning people that there had been burglaries as that would put people off staying at their holiday resort.

I explained why they thought it was 'safe'  in their eyes to leave the door open at night and not in the daytime Stephen.    They were away longer in the daytime,  plus there were more people around.   They said it was very quiet at night and felt so safe.    They shouldn't have left the children alone in my opinion,  but they made a decision to do so.

Miss taken identity didn't say they were warned about burglaries if you look again. Kate wasn't so sure about the decision she made according to Fiona.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 02, 2015, 10:45:09 AM
See my later post.

'Feeling safe' is the cliche used by the mccanns to excuse their actions.

Now as I recall, it was first said the apartment was locked, which then became 1 door unlocked.

Can you explain why ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 02, 2015, 10:53:35 AM
I have found the statement by the cleaner saying that many left their apartment doors open during the day and got robbed,  they must have also felt safe.   I wonder who the burglars were and if the police took finger prints. -



Witness statement

Celeste Da Conceicao Antao da Silva

 Date/Time: 2007/05/07 12H40
 Cleaner
 Portuguese

 Concerning the issue of the process said;
 . That she comes to the process as a witness; and as a worker of the apartments in the Ocean Club establishment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, but more precisely, in the Garden Section and in Beach 12, since 1985;
 . States that her functions are with the cleaning sector exclusively in the aforementioned apartments, so that on the 03 of May 2007, she was working in those apartments;
 . Questioned, she states that she has not direct contact with the guests of the other apartments with the exception of when she is told by her supervisor to help in other apartments, but this happens rarely;
 . Questioned, she states that she does not know the parents of Madeleine, nor the child;
 . States, that she remembers well, that during the time she has been employed that she is aware of some robberies in the interior of the apartments because the guests have left their doors open, and she has seen apartments with open doors before and has shut them herself;
 . States further that she has no knowledge of strange individuals or unknown persons who she came across in the interior or exterior of the establishment for the time she has worked there;
 . Questioned, responds that she has never been asked about the resort workings and more concretely regarding the type of guests who frequent the place;
 . States that on the 3rd of May of the present year, she arrived as normal at 10H00 at the resort, left at 13H30 for lunch, as is normal in the laundry area, and began work again at 14H30 until 18H00;
 . In this period, she does not remember having seen any individual or vehicle which caught her attention;
 . At around 18H00, she left work and went home and in the same fashion, did not see or had any knowledge of anything abnormal in the exterior of the resort;
 . She heard about the events the following day, Friday, through communication with a colleague of hers;
 . That she has nothing more to add to the statement that could be considered relevant to the discovery of facts;
 . And nothing further was said. She has read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it;
 . The document is duly signed by me, Armenio Pontes, an Inspector with this Policia Judiciaria.
   
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on December 02, 2015, 11:10:21 AM
I have found the statement by the cleaner saying that many left their apartment doors open during the day and got robbed,  they must have also felt safe.   I wonder who the burglars were and if the police took finger prints. -



Witness statement

Celeste Da Conceicao Antao da Silva

 Date/Time: 2007/05/07 12H40
 Cleaner
 Portuguese

 Concerning the issue of the process said;
 . That she comes to the process as a witness; and as a worker of the apartments in the Ocean Club establishment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, but more precisely, in the Garden Section and in Beach 12, since 1985;
 . States that her functions are with the cleaning sector exclusively in the aforementioned apartments, so that on the 03 of May 2007, she was working in those apartments;
 . Questioned, she states that she has not direct contact with the guests of the other apartments with the exception of when she is told by her supervisor to help in other apartments, but this happens rarely;
 . Questioned, she states that she does not know the parents of Madeleine, nor the child;
 . States, that she remembers well, that during the time she has been employed that she is aware of some robberies in the interior of the apartments because the guests have left their doors open, and she has seen apartments with open doors before and has shut them herself;
 . States further that she has no knowledge of strange individuals or unknown persons who she came across in the interior or exterior of the establishment for the time she has worked there;
 . Questioned, responds that she has never been asked about the resort workings and more concretely regarding the type of guests who frequent the place;
 . States that on the 3rd of May of the present year, she arrived as normal at 10H00 at the resort, left at 13H30 for lunch, as is normal in the laundry area, and began work again at 14H30 until 18H00;
 . In this period, she does not remember having seen any individual or vehicle which caught her attention;
 . At around 18H00, she left work and went home and in the same fashion, did not see or had any knowledge of anything abnormal in the exterior of the resort;
 . She heard about the events the following day, Friday, through communication with a colleague of hers;
 . That she has nothing more to add to the statement that could be considered relevant to the discovery of facts;
 . And nothing further was said. She has read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it;
 . The document is duly signed by me, Armenio Pontes, an Inspector with this Policia Judiciaria.
   

Interesting.

Thanks, Lace
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 02, 2015, 11:41:22 AM
I have found the statement by the cleaner saying that many left their apartment doors open during the day and got robbed,  they must have also felt safe.   I wonder who the burglars were and if the police took finger prints. -



Witness statement

Celeste Da Conceicao Antao da Silva

 Date/Time: 2007/05/07 12H40
 Cleaner
 Portuguese

 Concerning the issue of the process said;
 . That she comes to the process as a witness; and as a worker of the apartments in the Ocean Club establishment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, but more precisely, in the Garden Section and in Beach 12, since 1985;
 . States that her functions are with the cleaning sector exclusively in the aforementioned apartments, so that on the 03 of May 2007, she was working in those apartments;
 . Questioned, she states that she has not direct contact with the guests of the other apartments with the exception of when she is told by her supervisor to help in other apartments, but this happens rarely;
 . Questioned, she states that she does not know the parents of Madeleine, nor the child;
 . States, that she remembers well, that during the time she has been employed that she is aware of some robberies in the interior of the apartments because the guests have left their doors open, and she has seen apartments with open doors before and has shut them herself;
 . States further that she has no knowledge of strange individuals or unknown persons who she came across in the interior or exterior of the establishment for the time she has worked there;
 . Questioned, responds that she has never been asked about the resort workings and more concretely regarding the type of guests who frequent the place;
 . States that on the 3rd of May of the present year, she arrived as normal at 10H00 at the resort, left at 13H30 for lunch, as is normal in the laundry area, and began work again at 14H30 until 18H00;
 . In this period, she does not remember having seen any individual or vehicle which caught her attention;
 . At around 18H00, she left work and went home and in the same fashion, did not see or had any knowledge of anything abnormal in the exterior of the resort;
 . She heard about the events the following day, Friday, through communication with a colleague of hers;
 . That she has nothing more to add to the statement that could be considered relevant to the discovery of facts;
 . And nothing further was said. She has read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it;
 . The document is duly signed by me, Armenio Pontes, an Inspector with this Policia Judiciaria.
   

So robberies took place between 1985 and 2007 due to guests leaving doors open. Open or just unlocked? Seems all the Ocean Club/Mark Warner clients were daft.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on December 02, 2015, 11:47:01 AM
So robberies took place between 1985 and 2007 due to guests leaving doors open. Open or just unlocked? Seems all the Ocean Club/Mark Warner clients were daft.

Just a way of enabling all the swinging  8(0(*

I notice also that the cleaner's statement actually said some, not many robberies.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 02, 2015, 11:49:43 AM
So robberies took place between 1985 and 2007 due to guests leaving doors open. Open or just unlocked? Seems all the Ocean Club/Mark Warner clients were daft.

I'll drink to that!
I am struggling to understand what I perceive to be a rationale of "If someone does not warn me of burglars it is their fault if I don't take action and I am burgled". For a household insurance policy to be valid one must lock doors,windows and set the alarm. For a holiday insurance to be valid one must take all reasonable precautions to prevent loss. Leaving doors open/unlocked when one is out is a dumb idea period.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 02, 2015, 11:50:04 AM
Just a way of enabling all the swinging  8(0(*

I notice also that the cleaner's statement actually said some, not many robberies.

Ahh that's OK then.

Dear me.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 02, 2015, 11:56:25 AM
Ahh that's OK then.

Dear me.

How many burglaries occur in your area ?

This use of a 'burglar' threat is a red herring and completely irrelevant.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 02, 2015, 11:59:34 AM
I'll drink to that!
I am struggling to understand what I perceive to be a rationale of "If someone does not warn me of burglars it is their fault if I don't take action and I am burgled". For a household insurance policy to be valid one must lock doors,windows and set the alarm. For a holiday insurance to be valid one must take all reasonable precautions to prevent loss. Leaving doors open/unlocked when one is out is a dumb idea period.
Whatever anyone else may have said about the matter, I don't recall the McCanns ever holding the OC responsible for the disappearance of their child. 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 02, 2015, 12:00:59 PM
Whatever anyone else may have said about the matter, I don't recall the McCanns ever holding the OC responsible for the disappearance of their child.
Neither do I nor was I suggesting it.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 02, 2015, 12:04:57 PM
Neither do I nor was I suggesting it.
I know that, but I thought the point worth making anyway, as it has been known for some people to mistake the views of some supporters with those of the McCanns' themselves.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Anna on December 02, 2015, 12:08:20 PM
I have found the statement by the cleaner saying that many left their apartment doors open during the day and got robbed,  they must have also felt safe.   I wonder who the burglars were and if the police took finger prints. -



Witness statement

Celeste Da Conceicao Antao da Silva

 Date/Time: 2007/05/07 12H40
 Cleaner
 Portuguese

 Concerning the issue of the process said;
 . That she comes to the process as a witness; and as a worker of the apartments in the Ocean Club establishment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, but more precisely, in the Garden Section and in Beach 12, since 1985;
 . States that her functions are with the cleaning sector exclusively in the aforementioned apartments, so that on the 03 of May 2007, she was working in those apartments;
 . Questioned, she states that she has not direct contact with the guests of the other apartments with the exception of when she is told by her supervisor to help in other apartments, but this happens rarely;
 . Questioned, she states that she does not know the parents of Madeleine, nor the child;
 . States, that she remembers well, that during the time she has been employed that she is aware of some robberies in the interior of the apartments because the guests have left their doors open, and she has seen apartments with open doors before and has shut them herself;
 . States further that she has no knowledge of strange individuals or unknown persons who she came across in the interior or exterior of the establishment for the time she has worked there;
 . Questioned, responds that she has never been asked about the resort workings and more concretely regarding the type of guests who frequent the place;
 . States that on the 3rd of May of the present year, she arrived as normal at 10H00 at the resort, left at 13H30 for lunch, as is normal in the laundry area, and began work again at 14H30 until 18H00;
 . In this period, she does not remember having seen any individual or vehicle which caught her attention;
 . At around 18H00, she left work and went home and in the same fashion, did not see or had any knowledge of anything abnormal in the exterior of the resort;
 . She heard about the events the following day, Friday, through communication with a colleague of hers;
 . That she has nothing more to add to the statement that could be considered relevant to the discovery of facts;
 . And nothing further was said. She has read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it;
 . The document is duly signed by me, Armenio Pontes, an Inspector with this Policia Judiciaria.
   

A few more...

Thefts /burglaries

All of the following are excerpts:-


 Nuno Goncalo Marques Vincente Dos Ramos Bernardo
Date: 2007/05/06
Occupation: Waiter


But he says there are frequent thefts from the apartments, he does not know how they occur nor who could be responsible. He has no further information.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic9.html




Witness Testimony of Nuno Filipe Guerreiro Da Conceicao
Date of Diligence: 2007.05.06
Time: 20H50
Locale: Praia da Luz
Executing Officer: Pedro Florindo, Inspector
Profession: Maintenance Technician
Place of work: Ocean Club Resort, Praia da Luz, Lagos

• He states that the break-ins to the apartments are common, especially
for burglary purposes,
and that some are the result of clients leaving their doors open.
• Questioned, he states that according to what he remembers, he did not observe any abnormal movements by any individual that would indicate s/he was preparing to commit a criminal act.
• And nothing more was said. He reads and finds it in
 conformity.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post178.html#p178


Name: JOHN ELLIOT HILL


He has been employed by the Ocean Club since March 2006 and has no knowledge of any untoward situation involving Ocean Club users or in the village itself, other than some damage and minor thefts.



Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 02, 2015, 12:10:35 PM
I know that, but I thought the point worth making anyway, as it has been known for some people to mistake the views of some supporters with those of the McCanns' themselves.

I doubt Drs McCann are daft enough to share some of the views of some of their supporters.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 02, 2015, 02:13:24 PM
Oh please.  Lace is talking about her own personal experience, but as it happens a child was removed from a tent in her uncle's back garden and abducted and murdered, would you like a cite for that?

If you are offering one.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 02, 2015, 02:22:46 PM
If you are offering one.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Sophie_Hook
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 02, 2015, 03:06:36 PM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Sophie_Hook

The day Sophie was taken from a tent in her uncle's back garden a man in Peterhead did the same to two little girls who thankfully were not murdered.

**Snip
A MASKED man raped two terrified little girls after using a knife to rip open the side of the tent where they were spending the night in a back garden. He then abducted them ...
http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/12079282.Abductor_had_attacked_before_Masked_man_raped_two_girls_twice/
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 02, 2015, 10:00:52 PM
The day Sophie was taken from a tent in her uncle's back garden a man in Peterhead did the same to two little girls who thankfully were not murdered.

**Snip
A MASKED man raped two terrified little girls after using a knife to rip open the side of the tent where they were spending the night in a back garden. He then abducted them ...
http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/12079282.Abductor_had_attacked_before_Masked_man_raped_two_girls_twice/

Ripped open a tent. The same can't be said for that neat tidy bed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 02, 2015, 10:56:22 PM
Ripped open a tent. The same can't be said for that neat tidy bed.

There you have it.

If 'simulating' a home invasion why not at least put some effort into making it look convincing.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 02, 2015, 11:31:34 PM
No,   I didn't make a video of it Stephen,  or take photo's.

I am merely pointing out the risks people make whilst on holiday.    The tent was their canvas 'house'  really when they were on holiday,   yet they left their small children alone in it to go to a barbeque there are no locks on the tent and a child could easily get out or someone get in.   At home no doubt this family would not leave their children alone at home with the doors unlocked to go out for a couple of hours,  but they did on holiday.  For some reason when people are on holiday at a family holiday resort,  they tend to take risks.

Ive been on holiday with my young kids...I did NOT feel that it was safe to leave them all alone in an unlocked apartment at night whilst I was away and couldnt see or hear because I was on holiday or because of the resort...so your argument is a bit skewed..there are always rogue elements...I actually knew the place I went to my parents lived  there in the summer, it WAS safe from years of experience, but I still would not leave them, and the Mccanns knew NOTHNG.....they TOOK A RISK IMO...is being on holiday a defence? If something happens to your kids that you might be held culpable for?

Do remember the Mccanns have said theyve done NOTHING wrong and the only guilt they feel is that they were not there AT THE MOMENT Madeline was abducted
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 02, 2015, 11:34:52 PM
Ive been on holiday with my young kids...I did NOT feel that it was safe to leave them all alone in an unlocked apartment at night whilst I was away and couldnt see or hear because I was on holiday or because of the resort...so your argument is a bit skewed..there are always rogue elements...I actually knew the place I went to my parents lived  there in the summer, it WAS safe from years of experience, but I still would not leave them, and the Mccanns knew NOTHNG.....they TOOK A RISK IMO...is being on holiday a defence? If something happens to your kids that you might be held culpable for?

I have been on holiday with my children...at the time I felt is was safe to leave them asleep.. I did...they are grown up now...one studied medicine at Leicester... I would NOT  do it now
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 03, 2015, 01:46:49 AM
I have been on holiday with my children...at the time I felt is was safe to leave them asleep.. I did...they are grown up now...one studied medicine at Leicester... I would NOT  do it now

Childcare so called arrangements have zilch to do with
 further education. So yr post is void........ I See the ghost post striker has struck here too

Happy ghost strking evening, night night dear ghost its normally  eleanor who deletes what she doesnt personally like, biased mod but might not have been her tonight

 @)(++(*

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 03, 2015, 09:28:48 AM
I have been on holiday with my children...at the time I felt is was safe to leave them asleep.. I did...they are grown up now...one studied medicine at Leicester... I would NOT  do it now

Did you leave them sleeping in an unlocked apartment?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 10:43:49 AM
Did you leave them sleeping in an unlocked apartment?

no...locked ...but a fair bit further away than the mccanns were
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Admin on December 03, 2015, 12:23:43 PM
Members must stay on topic otherwise posts will be deleted.

Admin
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: pathfinder73 on December 03, 2015, 12:25:28 PM
There you have it.

If 'simulating' a home invasion why not at least put some effort into making it look convincing.

It was convincing to prove she didn't leave by herself but taken away asleep from the bed like Smithman seen with a sleeping child.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 03, 2015, 12:27:04 PM
Ive been on holiday with my young kids...I did NOT feel that it was safe to leave them all alone in an unlocked apartment at night whilst I was away and couldnt see or hear because I was on holiday or because of the resort...so your argument is a bit skewed..there are always rogue elements...I actually knew the place I went to my parents lived  there in the summer, it WAS safe from years of experience, but I still would not leave them, and the Mccanns knew NOTHNG.....they TOOK A RISK IMO...is being on holiday a defence? If something happens to your kids that you might be held culpable for?

Do remember the Mccanns have said theyve done NOTHING wrong and the only guilt they feel is that they were not there AT THE MOMENT Madeline was abducted

I'm sorry I should have said SOME people.

I too have been on holiday and wouldn't leave my children alone either.

Though you must admit that some DO feel safe enough to leave their children,  I have witnessed it myself as I have said.

The McCann's have also said that they would NEVER leave their children alone again,   and that people would now not leave their children after what happened to them.    They wish they could turn the clock back,  but they can't the only thing they can do is try and find Madeleine.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 03, 2015, 01:37:06 PM
It was convincing to prove she didn't leave by herself but taken away asleep from the bed like Smithman seen with a sleeping child.

The Drs McCann were dining about forty five seconds away from their children.  Not a tremendous distance.  If, however they had chosen instead to dine with their friends on the balcony of 5A ... a distance of maybe  ten seconds away from the children's bedroom ... it would still have been possible for an intruder to enter the property and take Madeleine.  The assaults on children while their parents were on the premises confirm the possibility.

If they had chosen to dine on the patio the probability is that they would not have checked on the children until they were getting ready to retire for the night.
Which would have meant the alarm being raised anything up until two hours later than it was, not that it mattered as no-one with influence seemed to have heard of the 'golden hours'.

That would lead to an interesting scenario apropos Mr Smith's powers of recall both a fortnight after the event and on the occasion of the McCann family's return.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 03, 2015, 01:54:09 PM
The Drs McCann were dining about forty five seconds away from their children.  Not a tremendous distance.  If, however they had chosen instead to dine with their friends on the balcony of 5A ... a distance of maybe  ten seconds away from the children's bedroom ... it would still have been possible for an intruder to enter the property and take Madeleine.  The assaults on children while their parents were on the premises confirm the possibility.

If they had chosen to dine on the patio the probability is that they would not have checked on the children until they were getting ready to retire for the night.
Which would have meant the alarm being raised anything up until two hours later than it was, not that it mattered as no-one with influence seemed to have heard of the 'golden hours'.

That would lead to an interesting scenario apropos Mr Smith's powers of recall both a fortnight after the event and on the occasion of the McCann family's return.

Abduction or no abduction, had the McCanns dined on their patio they would not have been at fault. They are at fault because they left 3 small children alone in an unlocked apartment.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 03, 2015, 02:02:08 PM
Abduction or no abduction, had the McCanns dined on their patio they would not have been at fault. They are at fault because they left 3 small children alone in an unlocked apartment.

I wonder about street parties,  such as New Year,  a lot of people go out into the street and celebrate the New Year with neighbours,  I wonder if they leave their doors unlocked?    They certainly leave their children alone in their houses.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 02:05:54 PM
Abduction or no abduction, had the McCanns dined on their patio they would not have been at fault. They are at fault because they left 3 small children alone in an unlocked apartment.
In your opinion.... Abduction.  .... Definitely the abductor to blame
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 03:20:33 PM
In your opinion.... Abduction.  .... Definitely the abductor to blame

Here we go again. .....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 03:21:54 PM
Here we go again. .....

are you thinking I may have changed my mind
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 03:41:28 PM
are you thinking I may have changed my mind

No, your mantra is and always will be , abduction.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 04:08:36 PM
No, your mantra is and always will be , abduction.

as long as that's where the evidence points.....which it does according to SY
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Anna on December 03, 2015, 04:10:47 PM
No, your mantra is and always will be , abduction.

Would you be happier, Stephen, if her disappearance was described as "Taken" rather than "abducted", or do you think she walked out in her bare feet and fell down a bottomless hole, never to be found?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 03, 2015, 04:21:27 PM
Abduction or no abduction, had the McCanns dined on their patio they would not have been at fault. They are at fault because they left 3 small children alone in an unlocked apartment.
Why not?  You would still have blamed them for not checking in on their kids, or for drinking whilst in charge of the kids, for not being attentive enough to hear the abductor coming and going, you or someone would probably still be suggesting they'd sedated their kids, or for making the whole thing up in the first place, etc etc etc, etc  etc etc
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 03, 2015, 04:25:57 PM
I wonder about street parties,  such as New Year,  a lot of people go out into the street and celebrate the New Year with neighbours,  I wonder if they leave their doors unlocked?    They certainly leave their children alone in their houses.

We aren't talking abut other people in all the wide variety of situations you're wracking your brains to come up with. We're talking abut one couple in one situation who did what no other parents in the self-same situation did, and did it over and over again.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 05:13:04 PM
as long as that's where the evidence points.....which it does according to SY

What evidence ?

Try to answer the question and not divert.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 03, 2015, 05:17:08 PM
Why not?  You would still have blamed them for not checking in on their kids, or for drinking whilst in charge of the kids, for not being attentive enough to hear the abductor coming and going, you or someone would probably still be suggesting they'd sedated their kids, or for making the whole thing up in the first place, etc etc etc, etc  etc etc

In my opinion they would indeed have been castigated.

For a start the situation would have been the same.  The adults would have been outside and the children would have been the only occupants of the apartment.  Although probably not being checked at all until it was time for the parents to retire.

It would also have put their friends in an invidious position.  All sorts of innuendo and accusation has been slung at them ... imagine if they had been in close proximity wjthout the benefit of independent witnesses to vouch for their whereabouts.  Conspiracy Theory Land would have gone into overdrive.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 05:18:32 PM
Would you be happier, Stephen, if her disappearance was described as "Taken" rather than "abducted", or do you think she walked out in her bare feet and fell down a bottomless hole, never to be found?


Would you be happier Anna if I typed 'accidental death' every other post.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 03, 2015, 05:19:19 PM
We aren't talking abut other people in all the wide variety of situations you're wracking your brains to come up with. We're talking abut one couple in one situation who did what no other parents in the self-same situation did, and did it over and over again.

Wrong,  the friends did the same as the McCann's.

I am coming up with situations where children are left alone in houses whilst their parents party,   it does go on you know.

Remember the final statement was that there was 'no intent'  unless you want to argue with the Portuguese?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Anna on December 03, 2015, 05:27:20 PM

Would you be happier Anna if I typed 'accidental death' every other post.

She was either taken or walked, whether it was accidental death or not. Those who believe that she was taken, including SY are entitled to say what they believe. You are also entitled to say what you believe, as long as it is not libellous.
Even if an accidental death was the case, she would still have been taken from 5A.
 
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 05:33:08 PM
What evidence ?

Try to answer the question and not divert.
The evidence that redwood said caused SY to believe Maddie was taken by a stranger
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on December 03, 2015, 05:48:20 PM
That was a few years ago and may have been discounted as the investigation progressed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 03, 2015, 05:58:31 PM
Wrong,  the friends did the same as the McCann's.

I am coming up with situations where children are left alone in houses whilst their parents party,   it does go on you know.

Remember the final statement was that there was 'no intent'  unless you want to argue with the Portuguese?

The McCann family were ripped apart when their daughter vanished from the bed where they had left her sleeping.

Scotland Yard detectives having reviewed all the available evidence in the case are convinced she was the victim of stranger abduction.

That person was given a 'get out of jail free' card at the time ... and seldom has received a word of criticism in the intervening period.  Yet he - she - they - are undoubtedly the star of the show.

If there was inadvertent opportunity ... there was absolutely no compunction for anyone to act on it and steal an innocent child.

The question of whether or not the abduction was planned or was opportunistic could have been determined at the time had the individual who appeared to so many independent witnesses to have been staking out the apartment been tracked down and ruled in or out.

He wasn't. 
Yet that particular investigative failure is overlooked when there are whipping boys available who can be castigated for whatever  perceived annoyance takes precedence.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 06:21:33 PM
That was a few years ago and may have been discounted as the investigation progressed.

it means the evidence was there then
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 03, 2015, 06:49:08 PM
Wrong,  the friends did the same as the McCann's.

I am coming up with situations where children are left alone in houses whilst their parents party,   it does go on you know.

Remember the final statement was that there was 'no intent'  unless you want to argue with the Portuguese?

The McCanns did more - left a door unlocked.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 07:09:09 PM
The evidence that redwood said caused SY to believe Maddie was taken by a stranger

That was a belief.

They have found NOTHING.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 07:10:55 PM
That was a belief.

They have found NOTHING.

redwood said based on the evidence...you obviously didn't listen...and don't ask me what evidence they had to make this decision...ask SY
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 07:27:58 PM
redwood said based on the evidence...you obviously didn't listen...and don't ask me what evidence they had to make this decision...ask SY


I listened alright.

He found nothing, and that remains the situation.

Certainly no forensic evidence for abduction, and as to having disappeared from the apartment, it is not the only explanation.

Then we have the mcxcanns. Locked the apartment during the daytime, then said they left it open at night, after saying it was locked.

I know what I call that...............
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 07:39:47 PM

I listened alright.

He found nothing, and that remains the situation.

Certainly no forensic evidence for abduction, and as to having disappeared from the apartment, it is not the only explanation.

Then we have the mcxcanns. Locked the apartment during the daytime, then said they left it open at night, after saying it was locked.

I know what I call that...............

The situation remains the McCanns are not suspects
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 07:42:02 PM
The situation remains the McCanns are not suspects

The mccanns remain the last known people to have seen her alive.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 07:43:29 PM
The mccanns remain the last known people to have seen her alive.

You do not know that
We have been through the same thing before
You've forgotten
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 03, 2015, 07:46:23 PM
You do not know that
We have been through the same thing before
You've forgotten

No I haven't.

If you intend to keep repeating ad infintum the mccanns supporter mantra, then me and others will remind you and your compatriots, and those who read this forum, that the 'abduction' scenario is dead in the water.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 03, 2015, 10:35:33 PM
The Drs McCann were dining about forty five seconds away from their children.  Not a tremendous distance.  If, however they had chosen instead to dine with their friends on the balcony of 5A ... a distance of maybe  ten seconds away from the children's bedroom ... it would still have been possible for an intruder to enter the property and take Madeleine.  The assaults on children while their parents were on the premises confirm the possibility.

If they had chosen to dine on the patio the probability is that they would not have checked on the children until they were getting ready to retire for the night.
Which would have meant the alarm being raised anything up until two hours later than it was, not that it mattered as no-one with influence seemed to have heard of the 'golden hours'.

That would lead to an interesting scenario apropos Mr Smith's powers of recall both a fortnight after the event and on the occasion of the McCann family's return.

The point is that being withn immediate hearing and sight distance is of importance rather than how long it might take to get to the apartment....I am sure yiu nust have grasped this basic point....which was, dont forget, at the very least 30 minutes intervals in which time any manner of thngs may have happened...and the parents or other carers  wouldnt have a clue.....then again, we are told it was every 30 but there seemed to be going on a kind of musical chairs...5/10 minutes after one returned, another one got up to check

 &%+((£

99 per cent of the time nothing bad happens to kids but parents do have a responsiblity to minimise the possibility...it seems to me they took too many risks not just a small single one and you can call it Mccann bashing instead , feel free

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 03, 2015, 10:46:05 PM
The point is that being withn immediate hearing and sight distance is of importance rather than how long it might take to get to the apartment....I am sure yiu nust have grasped this basic point....which was, dont forget, at the very least 30 minutes intervals in which time any manner of thngs may have happened...and the parents or other carers  wouldnt have a clue.....then again, we are told it was every 30 but there seemed to be going on a kind of musical chairs...5/10 minutes after one returned, another one got up to check

 &%+((£

99 per cent of the time nothing bad happens to kids but parents do have a responsiblity to minimise the possibility...it seems to me they took too many risks not just a small single one and you can call it Mccann bashing instead , feel free

The fly in the ointment of their childcare arrangement was that they hadn't factored the kidnapper you have singularly failed to mention into the equation.

Parents probably give such an eventuality a lot of thought nowadays.  Is there any reason why they would have in 2007?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 03, 2015, 10:51:02 PM
The fly in the ointment of their childcare arrangement was that they hadn't factored the kidnapper you have singularly failed to mention into the equation.

Parents probably give such an eventuality a lot of thought nowadays.  Is there any reason why they would have in 2007?

Yes.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 03, 2015, 10:53:02 PM
The fly in the ointment of their childcare arrangement was that they hadn't factored the kidnapper you have singularly failed to mention into the equation.

Parents probably give such an eventuality a lot of thought nowadays.  Is there any reason why they would have in 2007?

Or seemngly not factored in anything else potentially going wrong and purleese dont tell me parents of helpless toddlers or older kids were not wired into dangers, even if just feared, in 2007 ! compared to 2015

You don't always read posts properly do you


Eta:

if they felt  so safe and happy with their decision why did Kates best mate Fiona Payne say she wasnt happy leaving the back door open? And whlst you are at it, please explain why Kate was said to be not happy on that evening but happy the previous evenngs they had decided to leave the back door unlocked? Any ideas?

Finally why did Kate Mccann say if Madeleine had not been abducted, the thought of her "crying incident" would NEVER had crossed her mond again post Thursday morning when it is a fact, at least according to all her female friends, that she mentioned it BEFORE the "abduction"

Its ok if you cant multitask, a separate post for each question will suffice

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 11:02:09 PM
Or seemngly not factored in anything else potentially going wrong and purleese dont tell me parents of helpless toddlers or older kids were not wired into dangers, even if just feared, in 2007 ! compared to 2015

You don't always read posts properly do you


Eta:

if they felt  so safe and happy with their decision why did Kates best mate Fiona Payne say she wasnt happy leaving the back door open? And whlst you are at it, please explain why Kate was said to be not happy on that evening but happy the previous evenngs they had decided to leave the back door unlocked? Any ideas?

Finally why did Kate Mccann say if Madeleine had not been abducted, the thought of her "crying incident" would NEVER had crossed her mond again post Thursday morning when it is a fact, at least according to all her female friends, that she mentioned it BEFORE the "abduction"

Its ok if you cant multitask, a separate post for each question will suffice

you would need to ask kate to get the answer and the fact they are not suspects means SY are happy with all they have said
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 03, 2015, 11:31:19 PM
Yes.

Hmmmm ... they should have realised that Luz was crawling with degenerates who might take it upon themselves to enter a residence and make off with a child???
I would have said that prior to 3rd May 2007 ... that would not have entered anyone's reasoning ... the situation changed immediately Madeleine's abduction became front page news.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 03, 2015, 11:35:11 PM
Hmmmm ... they should have realised that Luz was crawling with degenerates who might take it upon themselves to enter a residence and make off with a child???
I would have said that prior to 3rd May 2007 ... that would not have entered anyone's reasoning ... the situation changed immediately Madeleine's abduction became front page news.

1 Was it?
2 Why?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 03, 2015, 11:38:35 PM
1 Was it?
2 Why?

I remember an earlier comment from Gerry...don't ask me for a cite I don't have one but I do have a good memory....he said that Luz seemed like a 50's british seaside resort...safe...how wrong he was
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 03, 2015, 11:42:30 PM
I remember an earlier comment from Gerry...don't ask me for a cite I don't have one but I do have a good memory....he said that Luz seemed like a 50's british seaside resort...safe...how wrong he was

I don't see the relevance.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 04, 2015, 12:35:40 AM
I remember an earlier comment from Gerry...don't ask me for a cite I don't have one but I do have a good memory....he said that Luz seemed like a 50's british seaside resort...safe...how wrong he was
Don't know how Gerry would have any idea about how it was in a British seaside resort before he had been born.

Then came the 60s, Saville, and all the crap that went with that.  Was that 2007, or did the 'news' break later?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 04, 2015, 12:39:02 AM
Don't know how Gerry would have any idea about how it was in a British seaside resort before he had been born.

Then came the 60s, Saville, and all the crap that went with that.  Was that 2007, or did the 'news' break later?

It was like in his own back garden...lol... a 50s garden I suppose

 &%+((£
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 09:40:56 AM
Or seemngly not factored in anything else potentially going wrong and purleese dont tell me parents of helpless toddlers or older kids were not wired into dangers, even if just feared, in 2007 ! compared to 2015

You don't always read posts properly do you


Eta:

if they felt  so safe and happy with their decision why did Kates best mate Fiona Payne say she wasnt happy leaving the back door open? And whlst you are at it, please explain why Kate was said to be not happy on that evening but happy the previous evenngs they had decided to leave the back door unlocked? Any ideas?

Finally why did Kate Mccann say if Madeleine had not been abducted, the thought of her "crying incident" would NEVER had crossed her mond again post Thursday morning when it is a fact, at least according to all her female friends, that she mentioned it BEFORE the "abduction"

Its ok if you cant multitask, a separate post for each question will suffice

As we have no idea what the conversation was about between Kate and Fiona no one can say why she mentioned the door was open and that she had been worried about leaving it open but Gerry said it would be fine.   Maybe the topic had never arisen on any other evening.

Kate mentioned the crying incident on the day Madeleine mentioned it.   If Madeleine hadn't been abducted then Kate would probably have never mentioned it again.    Madeleine made a fleeting remark,  she didn't cry and demand an answer,  she asked then went off to play,  so it really wasn't worrying her or she wouldn't have gone off to play like she did.   

I believe the crying incident was on the Tuesday night when Amelie woke cyring waking Sean and then Madeleine then the Daddy Daddy that Mrs. Fenn heard was Madeleine calling for Gerry.   Madeleine then went in to the McCann's bedroom just as they were going to see to the twins.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 09:42:39 AM
It was like in his own back garden...lol... a 50s garden I suppose

 &%+((£

I have friends and relatives with 50m gardens,  they really aren't rare,  ours is large too.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 09:58:27 AM
I have friends and relatives with 50m gardens,  they really aren't rare,  ours is large too.

My back garden and my neighbour's are the smallest two in the street being long and narrow. That is of the ones which haven't built one sometimes two new properties in the bottom half ... the neighbour on the other side has a four car garage, a gymnasium and a hot tub in theirs. My house and my other neighbour's is built on what was their tennis court.
Large gardens are not a rarity. I have paced the distance from my garage to the back door and it exceeds the eighty odd steps from the tapas restaurant to apartment 5A.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 04, 2015, 10:07:16 AM
As we have no idea what the conversation was about between Kate and Fiona no one can say why she mentioned the door was open and that she had been worried about leaving it open but Gerry said it would be fine.   Maybe the topic had never arisen on any other evening.

Kate mentioned the crying incident on the day Madeleine mentioned it.   If Madeleine hadn't been abducted then Kate would probably have never mentioned it again.    Madeleine made a fleeting remark,  she didn't cry and demand an answer,  she asked then went off to play,  so it really wasn't worrying her or she wouldn't have gone off to play like she did.   

I believe the crying incident was on the Tuesday night when Amelie woke cyring waking Sean and then Madeleine then the Daddy Daddy that Mrs. Fenn heard was Madeleine calling for Gerry.   Madeleine then went in to the McCann's bedroom just as they were going to see to the twins.

According to Gerry that incident happened in the early hours of the morning. Are you really suggesting Mrs Fenn called her friend in the early hours to discuss a child crying in the apartment below ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 04, 2015, 10:09:22 AM
I have friends and relatives with 50m gardens,  they really aren't rare,  ours is large too.

I think Mercury meant the 1950s Lace.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 04, 2015, 10:12:14 AM
Early 20th century Garden Cities had plenty of houses with 50m back gardens where small orchards at the end of them. That however is not the issue.
I don't recall having to go down a flight of steps, into a public highway, through a complex reception, slalom in and out bed chairs by a swimming pool and then have an entrance experience into the dining area. All to get from my back door to the apple tree as it were.
The notion it was like "eating in your back garden" is manifestly daft.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on December 04, 2015, 10:22:09 AM
Chances are that you wouldn't eat at the far end of a garden anyway, but rather nearer the house.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 11:11:46 AM
An interesting snippet, if true;

Despite the risk of break-ins, there was no extra advice for holidaymakers to be on their guard. Mark Warner sends customers security advice with their travel brochure, but the only recommendation is that valuables are left at reception.
John Follain in Praia da Luz, Mark MaCaskill and Jon Ungoed-Thomas
May 13, 2007http://www.mccannfiles.com/id86.html
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 11:37:57 AM
I remember an earlier comment from Gerry...don't ask me for a cite I don't have one but I do have a good memory....he said that Luz seemed like a 50's british seaside resort...safe...how wrong he was

I think I have it, but Gerry didn't say it. It was Olga Craig in the Sidney Morning Herald;

The village may be in Portugal, six kilometres from Lagos on the Algarve's south-western coast, but it could just as easily be south-east England in the 1950s.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id86.html
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 11:50:55 AM
According to Gerry that incident happened in the early hours of the morning. Are you really suggesting Mrs Fenn called her friend in the early hours to discuss a child crying in the apartment below ?



After midnight Kate says in her statement,  which could mean that Mrs. Fenn rang her friend when she first  heard the crying.

It couldn't have been the Wednesday as Kate was sleeping in the childrens bedroom that night.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 04, 2015, 12:18:40 PM
I think I have it, but Gerry didn't say it. It was Olga Craig in the Sidney Morning Herald;

The village may be in Portugal, six kilometres from Lagos on the Algarve's south-western coast, but it could just as easily be south-east England in the 1950s.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id86.html

Sort of a bit like this:
http://www.francisfrith.com/uk/brightlingsea
http://www.oldukphotos.com/essex-frinton-on-sea.htm

Or then on the other hand nothing like it.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 12:24:04 PM
Sort of a bit like this:
http://www.francisfrith.com/uk/brightlingsea
http://www.oldukphotos.com/essex-frinton-on-sea.htm

Or then on the other hand nothing like it.

Lol, you can just see the similarities....not.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 12:43:32 PM


After midnight Kate says in her statement,  which could mean that Mrs. Fenn rang her friend when she first  heard the crying.

It couldn't have been the Wednesday as Kate was sleeping in the childrens bedroom that night.

Not the only example of Kate disagreeing with Mrs Fenn. She said in her book that she and Fiona made 'short and to the point' answers to Mrs Fenn on 3rd May. Mrs Fenn said she spoke only to Gerry.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 01:48:16 PM
Not the only example of Kate disagreeing with Mrs Fenn. She said in her book that she and Fiona made 'short and to the point' answers to Mrs Fenn on 3rd May. Mrs Fenn said she spoke only to Gerry.

Elderly do get confused
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: insider on December 04, 2015, 01:51:08 PM
Not the only example of Kate disagreeing with Mrs Fenn. She said in her book that she and Fiona made 'short and to the point' answers to Mrs Fenn on 3rd May. Mrs Fenn said she spoke only to Gerry.

Given what had transpired two nights earlier when Mrs Fenn was so distressed by Madeleine's crying that she had to phone her friend for advice, she must have thought to herself what sort of parents would leave three toddlers alone in such circumstances.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 01:53:43 PM
Elderly do get confused

Kate isn't that old surely??
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 02:00:52 PM
Kate isn't that old surely??

you are getting confused
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 02:03:03 PM
it seems no one would even consider that perhaps Mrs Fenn did get things wrong
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 04, 2015, 02:04:53 PM
Elderly do get confused

To the contrary.

Mrs. Fenn came across as an astute and caring person.


....and we know what kate mccann and her 'friend' thought about Mrs. Fenn.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 04, 2015, 02:06:01 PM
it seems no one would even consider that perhaps Mrs Fenn did get things wrong

You mean like the major blunders of the mccanns ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 02:07:49 PM
you are getting confused

Not as much as you are.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 02:19:32 PM
it seems no one would even consider that perhaps Mrs Fenn did get things wrong

Mrs Fenn was not interviewed until the 20th August.  At least they got round to her eventually.  The police did not interview Mr and Mrs Moyes on the floor above who had been out and about at the relevant time on the 3rd May, who had joined the search for Madeleine and who possibly might have seen something of interest.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 02:46:24 PM
Kate isn't that old surely??

There is evidence that she got confused, however. Were the bedroom curtains found open or closed? Was Madeleine's eye publicised or not made much of? Did she express concern about leaving the patio door unlocked or never think twice about her childcare arrangements?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 03:03:23 PM
There is evidence that she got confused, however. Were the bedroom curtains found open or closed? Was Madeleine's eye publicised or not made much of? Did she express concern about leaving the patio door unlocked or never think twice about her childcare arrangements?

Oft you will find that those who cannot accept responsibility for their own failings have no difficulty blaming others like the f.....g tosser, tweedle dum and tweedle dee.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 03:05:44 PM
There is evidence that she got confused, however. Were the bedroom curtains found open or closed? Was Madeleine's eye publicised or not made much of? Did she express concern about leaving the patio door unlocked or never think twice about her childcare arrangements?

we would need to know exactly what kate said at her interview. Unfortunately we do not have a verbatim account.....just a  summary of what she said which was then translated into portuguese
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 03:09:27 PM
Elderly do get confused

What a patronising statement. Was she deaf as well, I wonder? Perhaps it was tinnitus.

She also refers to the day of the 1st May 2007, when she was at home alone, at approximately 22.30 she heard a child cry, and that due the tone of the crying seemed to be a young child and not a baby of two years of age or younger. Apart from the crying that continued for approximately one hour and fifteen minutes, and which got louder and more expressive, the child shouted ?Daddy, Daddy?, the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below. At about 23.45, an hour and fifteen minutes after the crying began, she heard the parents arrive, she did not see them, but she heard the patio doors open, she was quite worried as the crying had gone on for more than an hour and had gradually got worse.

When questioned, she said that she did not know the cause of the crying, perhaps a nightmare or another destabilising factor.
As soon as the parents entered the child stopped crying.
That night she contacted a friend called EDNA GLYN, who also lives in Praia da Luz, after 23.00, telling her about the situation, who was not surprised at the childs crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm

what a pity that neither parent thought to ask Mrs Fenn if she saw or heard anything on 3rd May when she spoke to them over the balcony.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 03:11:15 PM
What a patronising statement. Was she deaf as well, I wonder? Perhaps it was tinnitus.

She also refers to the day of the 1st May 2007, when she was at home alone, at approximately 22.30 she heard a child cry, and that due the tone of the crying seemed to be a young child and not a baby of two years of age or younger. Apart from the crying that continued for approximately one hour and fifteen minutes, and which got louder and more expressive, the child shouted ?Daddy, Daddy?, the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below. At about 23.45, an hour and fifteen minutes after the crying began, she heard the parents arrive, she did not see them, but she heard the patio doors open, she was quite worried as the crying had gone on for more than an hour and had gradually got worse.

When questioned, she said that she did not know the cause of the crying, perhaps a nightmare or another destabilising factor.
As soon as the parents entered the child stopped crying.
That night she contacted a friend called EDNA GLYN, who also lives in Praia da Luz, after 23.00, telling her about the situation, who was not surprised at the childs crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm

what a pity that neither parent thought to ask Mrs Fenn if she saw or heard anything on 3rd May when she spoke to them over the balcony.

It is not patronising it's a fact
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 03:13:05 PM
What a patronising statement. Was she deaf as well, I wonder? Perhaps it was tinnitus.

She also refers to the day of the 1st May 2007, when she was at home alone, at approximately 22.30 she heard a child cry, and that due the tone of the crying seemed to be a young child and not a baby of two years of age or younger. Apart from the crying that continued for approximately one hour and fifteen minutes, and which got louder and more expressive, the child shouted ?Daddy, Daddy?, the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below. At about 23.45, an hour and fifteen minutes after the crying began, she heard the parents arrive, she did not see them, but she heard the patio doors open, she was quite worried as the crying had gone on for more than an hour and had gradually got worse.

When questioned, she said that she did not know the cause of the crying, perhaps a nightmare or another destabilising factor.
As soon as the parents entered the child stopped crying.
That night she contacted a friend called EDNA GLYN, who also lives in Praia da Luz, after 23.00, telling her about the situation, who was not surprised at the childs crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm

what a pity that neither parent thought to ask Mrs Fenn if she saw or heard anything on 3rd May when she spoke to them over the balcony.

does Mrs Fenn speak Portuguese...do we know how accurate her statement is.....what happened to your check everything...believe nobody. It seems to believe anything which criticises the McCanns...without question
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 04, 2015, 03:16:30 PM
Oft you will find that those who cannot accept responsibility for their own failings have no difficulty blaming others like the f.....g tosser, tweedle dum and tweedle dee.

Croatian Proverb (allegedly):
"The hunchback sees the hump of others -- never his own".
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 03:21:50 PM
we would need to know exactly what kate said at her interview. Unfortunately we do not have a verbatim account.....just a  summary of what she said which was then translated into portuguese

Fortunately we do have copies of the 'Look for me' posters showing the 'fleck' in her eye and the Piers Morgan interview where Kate McCann says they never made much of it.  8(0(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 03:23:10 PM
Fortunately we do have copies of the 'Look for me' posters showing the 'fleck' in her eye and the Piers Morgan interview where Kate McCann says they never made much of it.  8(0(*

much of what you say is out of context
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 03:27:06 PM
much of what you say is out of context

Surely you mean post?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 03:30:47 PM
does Mrs Fenn speak Portuguese...do we know how accurate her statement is.....what happened to your check everything...believe nobody. It seems to believe anything which criticises the McCanns...without question

This was done to death on another thread.  Mrs Fenn heard Maddie crying for well over an hour for her daddy on the Tuesday night which put the regular checking claim firmly in the invention bin.  Choosing who to believe is not problematic for anyone who has read through the files, since Mrs Fenn had no alternative motive for recalling what she did whereas the parents and tapas 9 had much to lose.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 03:36:47 PM
It is not patronising it's a fact

If Mrs Fenn heard a child in distress over a prolonged period

(a)  there is no evidence whose child it was and no evidence it was a McCann child
(b)  why did no one else hear it? The Wilkins family for example.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 04, 2015, 03:46:12 PM
It is not patronising it's a fact

Well dave, if your claims are to be believed, then you are in your mid sixties, so we should then treat you in the same way you categorised Mrs. Fenn ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 03:49:26 PM
If Mrs Fenn heard a child in distress over a prolonged period

(a)  there is no evidence whose child it was and no evidence it was a McCann child
(b)  why did no one else hear it? The Wilkins family for example.

the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm

The Wilkins were in another block???

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 04, 2015, 04:20:59 PM
the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm

The Wilkins were in another block???

Mrs Fenn had had families with young children staying in the apartments around her in the days preceding Madeleine's disappearance.
The only way of corroborating her statement is from her phone records & a statement from Edna Glyn, neither of which we have.
In the circumstances, & in the interests of sanity, it's probably best to leave this aspect of the investigation alone.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 04:39:55 PM
This was done to death on another thread.  Mrs Fenn heard Maddie crying for well over an hour for her daddy on the Tuesday night which put the regular checking claim firmly in the invention bin.  Choosing who to believe is not problematic for anyone who has read through the files, since Mrs Fenn had no alternative motive for recalling what she did whereas the parents and tapas 9 had much to lose.

Mrs. Fenn did not say she heard Madeleine she said she heard a child crying.

I don't understand what you mean when you say the parents and the Tapas 9 had much to lose.   Kate did not have to tell the police about Madeleine asking why they didn't come the night her and Sean were crying,  she did though,  she was honest about it,  she must have known it would sound bad for her and Gerry when she told the police.   So I don't get the idea that they lie to say that Madeleine wasn't crying.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 05:34:24 PM
Mrs Fenn was interviewed over 3 months after the event...I would be concerned how accurate her account was...particularly as to the exact day the alleged crying happened
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 05:34:40 PM
Mrs. Fenn did not say she heard Madeleine she said she heard a child crying.

I don't understand what you mean when you say the parents and the Tapas 9 had much to lose.   Kate did not have to tell the police about Madeleine asking why they didn't come the night her and Sean were crying,  she did though,  she was honest about it,  she must have known it would sound bad for her and Gerry when she told the police.   So I don't get the idea that they lie to say that Madeleine wasn't crying.

Do stop obfuscating Lace, this has been dealt with in great depth previously and I for one am not going to revisit those facts other than to point out that Maddie and her two siblings were the only children whom Mrs Fenn could have heard.  Add to this the fact that the other children were either being monitored using a baby intercom or had at least one parent with them rendering it most unlikely that they cried and yelled daddy for over an hour.  And that doesn't even include Kate McCanns own claim that Maddie asked her why she and daddy didn't come when she cried.  She had to divulge that to police because she had already told one of her friends about it and no doubt they would have told them.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 05:40:10 PM
Do stop obfuscating Lace, this has been dealt with in great depth previously and I for one am not going to revisit those facts other than to point out that Maddie and her two siblings were the only children whom Mrs Fenn could have heard.  Add to this the fact that the other children were either being monitored using a baby intercom or had at least one parent with them rendering it most unlikely that they cried and yelled daddy for over an hour.  And that doesn't even include Kate McCanns own claim that Maddie asked her why she and daddy didn't come when she cried.  She had to divulge that to police because she had already told one of her friends about it and no doubt they would have told them.


I'm not in the slightest convinced that maddie cried for an hour and 15 mins...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 05:41:44 PM
Mrs Fenn was interviewed over 3 months after the event...I would be concerned how accurate her account was...particularly as to the exact day the alleged crying happened

We know the exact day because she telephoned her friend exasperated.  The next evening she went out to her friend to get away from a repeat of it. The following evening Maddie disappeared.

So the crying for over an hour was on the Tue night 1st May 2007 and Maddie disappeared on the Thur night.  On the Tue night the McCanns had a very late night out with some the tapas group and Mrs Fenn was very clear that shortly after hearing the patio sliding door opening and closing the crying stopped.  Shit parenting I believe I previously called it Dave!!
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 05:44:49 PM
Mrs Fenn had had families with young children staying in the apartments around her in the days preceding Madeleine's disappearance.
The only way of corroborating her statement is from her phone records & a statement from Edna Glyn, neither of which we have.
In the circumstances, & in the interests of sanity, it's probably best to leave this aspect of the investigation alone.

Probably should be put into the same box as the mysterious couple who allegedly 'entered the apartment to comfort Madeleine' ... as one does ???
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 05:45:41 PM
We know the exact day because she telephoned her friend exasperated.  The next evening she went out to her friend to get away from a repeat of it. The following evening Maddie disappeared.

So the crying for over an hour was on the Tue night 1st May 2007 and Maddie disappeared on the Thur night.

has her friend confirmed the date
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 04, 2015, 06:20:11 PM
We know the exact day because she telephoned her friend exasperated.  The next evening she went out to her friend to get away from a repeat of it. The following evening Maddie disappeared.

So the crying for over an hour was on the Tue night 1st May 2007 and Maddie disappeared on the Thur night. On the Tue night the McCanns had a very late night out with some the tapas group and Mrs Fenn was very clear that shortly after hearing the patio sliding door opening and closing the crying stopped.  Shit parenting I believe I previously called it Dave!!

I believe you've got that wrong Angelo.   The night when the group stayed later than usual was on Wednesday 2nd May.    It was on Tuesday 1st May when Mrs Fenn heard a child crying.   


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 04, 2015, 06:22:01 PM


After midnight Kate says in her statement,  which could mean that Mrs. Fenn rang her friend when she first  heard the crying.

It couldn't have been the Wednesday as Kate was sleeping in the childrens bedroom that night.

Lace what 80 year old do you know would call anyone after midnight and how do you explain that she phoned her friend because of the length of time the child had been crying and the fact the distress of the child was escalating ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 06:31:52 PM
The bottom line is the children should never have been left alone for any time greater than a few minutes.  The McCanns were bloody lucky all three didn't disappear.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 04, 2015, 06:36:55 PM
The bottom line is the children should never have been left alone for any time greater than a few minutes.  The McCanns were bloody lucky all three didn't disappear.

Getting your facts right is quite important too  IMO.   Otherwise myths are born.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 06:45:50 PM
Lace what 80 year old do you know would call anyone after midnight and how do you explain that she phoned her friend because of the length of time the time the child had been crying for and the fact the distress of the child was escalating ?

Was she 80?

Anyway I didn't say she called anyone after midnight I said she could have called her friend when she first heard the crying.

I don't for one minute imagine it was Madeleine crying for that length of time,   it is much more likely that Mrs. Fenn first heard Amelie crying,  which then woke Sean,  crying off and on  over a period of time,  then the Daddy was Madeleine calling Gerry.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 04, 2015, 06:47:43 PM
Probably should be put into the same box as the mysterious couple who allegedly 'entered the apartment to comfort Madeleine' ... as one does ???

Ive not seen that statement in the files. Do you have a cite ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 04, 2015, 06:48:45 PM
The bottom line is the children should never have been left alone for any time greater than a few minutes.  The McCanns were bloody lucky all three didn't disappear.

Greater than a few minutes,  I don't agree with the McCann's  leaving the children, but you have to leave children in their beds asleep at night otherwise they won't sleep.   You go downstairs so you are leaving them.

Children were abused in their beds by an intruder whilst their parents were there in the apartments, this person could have taken any one of those children.

Did anyone investigate these assaults?  how did this person get in to the apartments?   Why wasn't Amaral informed about these assaults,  maybe he would then have wondered how this person had got in and whether a key could have been used to enter 5a.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 07:05:24 PM
The bottom line is the children should never have been left alone for any time greater than a few minutes.  The McCanns were bloody lucky all three didn't disappear.

At least you accept Maddie disappeared
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Angelo222 on December 04, 2015, 08:08:26 PM
At least you accept Maddie disappeared

 8@??)( @)(++(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 04, 2015, 08:33:44 PM
As we have no idea what the conversation was about between Kate and Fiona no one can say why she mentioned the door was open and that she had been worried about leaving it open but Gerry said it would be fine.   Maybe the topic had never arisen on any other evening.

Kate mentioned the crying incident on the day Madeleine mentioned it.   If Madeleine hadn't been abducted then Kate would probably have never mentioned it again.    Madeleine made a fleeting remark,  she didn't cry and demand an answer,  she asked then went off to play,  so it really wasn't worrying her or she wouldn't have gone off to play like she did.   

I believe the crying incident was on the Tuesday night when Amelie woke cyring waking Sean and then Madeleine then the Daddy Daddy that Mrs. Fenn heard was Madeleine calling for Gerry.   Madeleine then went in to the McCann's bedroom just as they were going to see to the twins.

Yes, we do know what was said as it is in not only in  Fiona Payne's rogatory interview but in her other two friends' rogatories too.

Why are you bringing in the Tuesday night reported crying? It has nothing to do with it. You seem to either not have understood what I posted or are confused, I will try again.

KM has related (on TV) that Madeleine had asked on Thursday morning "where were you when Sean and I cried" ...referring to the night before, ie the Wednesday.

She then went on to say that if Madeleine had not been abducted, then that comment would never have crossed her mind again. Madeleine was found missing at 10 pm on Thursday. KM related the incident early on at dinner on Thursday to her friends...ergo....it did cross her mind before Madeleine was abducted.
That's it.

Curious?, contradictiry or nit picking? Choice is yours.








Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 04, 2015, 08:46:26 PM
Probably should be put into the same box as the mysterious couple who allegedly 'entered the apartment to comfort Madeleine' ... as one does ???

That is some of the papers for you or what they have been told, or a mishmash of both or total fabrication by them or others and  certainly not in the same box ...a mysterious couple is not in the same ball park as a named witness with a statement, honestly!

The very fact that the possiblity or probability that Madeleine was crying, and not checked on as stated, bringing certain quarters out in hives, that they will go to any length to make it almost a myth, is interesting in itself.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 09:22:00 PM
That is some of the papers for you or what they have been told, or a mishmash of both or total fabrication by them or others and  certainly not in the same box ...a mysterious couple is not in the same ball park as a named witness with a statement, honestly!

The very fact that the possiblity or probability that Madeleine was crying, and not checked on as stated, bringing certain quarters out in hives, that they will go to any length to make it almost a myth, is interesting in itself.

Dr McCann said Madeleine had asked why she didn't come when she and Sean were crying ... it is hardly a myth ... and of all the statements Dr McCann has made it is worth noting this one is believed by the unbelievers.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 04, 2015, 09:27:53 PM
Dr McCann said Madeleine had asked why she didn't come when she and Sean were crying ... it is hardly a myth ... and of all the statements Dr McCann has made it is worth noting this one is believed by the unbelievers.

So you're a belieber then. %#&%%5
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 04, 2015, 09:34:25 PM
Dr McCann said Madeleine had asked why she didn't come when she and Sean were crying ... it is hardly a myth ... and of all the statements Dr McCann has made it is worth noting this one is believed by the unbelievers.


Madeleine was heard crying on Tuesday 1st by an independent witness. She wasn't heard crying on Wednesday 2nd.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 09:47:54 PM


Madeleine was heard crying on Tuesday 1st by an independent witness. She wasn't heard crying on Wednesday 2nd.

one witness....is this witness reliable....how accurate is the summary of her statement
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 04, 2015, 09:49:16 PM
one witness....is this witness reliable....how accurate is the summary of her statement

Are you saying she lied ?

She had no reason to.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 04, 2015, 09:56:35 PM
Are you saying she lied ?

She had no reason to.

we don't know what she said...we only have the summary of the Portuguese intepreter
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 04, 2015, 10:11:35 PM
Dr McCann said Madeleine had asked why she didn't come when she and Sean were crying ... it is hardly a myth ... and of all the statements Dr McCann has made it is worth noting this one is believed by the unbelievers.

What are you talking about? I was responding to your post comparing Mrs Fenns statement to a paper story about a mysterious couple...and that should be put in the same box!!!....the myth creating is right there.....did your  iq suddenly go down since last time I was logged in?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 04, 2015, 11:20:28 PM
What are you talking about? I was responding to your post comparing Mrs Fenns statement to a paper story about a mysterious couple...and that should be put in the same box!!!....the myth creating is right there.....did your  iq suddenly go down since last time I was logged in?

It must be recognised that a statement taken four months down the line from anyone must be considered suspect.
Particularly since it is neither a verbatim, visual or audio recording which was written down by an interpreter.

There is absolutely no evidence the crying child Mrs Fenn heard was Madeleine nor is there any corroboration of the event.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 04, 2015, 11:42:27 PM
It must be recognised that a statement taken four months down the line from anyone must be considered suspect.
Particularly since it is neither a verbatim, visual or audio recording which was written down by an interpreter.

There is absolutely no evidence the crying child Mrs Fenn heard was Madeleine nor is there any corroboration of the event.

Why would anyone need corroboration of the event ? Are you going to treat Kate's open window in the same way ? Did anyone see it open before Kate's check ?

Once the files were released Mrs Fenn had every opportunity to retract her statement or correct the parts she felt didn't accurately portray what she said. She chose not to do that. The McCanns could have asked for her to be questioned again in April 2008 to clarify what she had told the police. They chose not to. Her niece in her rogatory statement could also have mentioned that her aunt had been misquoted in her statement and was pretty peeved about it. She didn't do that.

Can you give any reason why none of the above happened other than that Mrs Fenn told the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 05, 2015, 08:32:37 AM
Why would anyone need corroboration of the event ? Are you going to treat Kate's open window in the same way ? Did anyone see it open before Kate's check ?

Once the files were released Mrs Fenn had every opportunity to retract her statement or correct the parts she felt didn't accurately portray what she said. She chose not to do that. The McCanns could have asked for her to be questioned again in April 2008 to clarify what she had told the police. They chose not to. Her niece in her rogatory statement could also have mentioned that her aunt had been misquoted in her statement and was pretty peeved about it. She didn't do that.

Can you give any reason why none of the above happened other than that Mrs Fenn told the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
you could ask the same question of all the witnesses who gave statements which we now know are confused, inaccurate, mistranslated etc
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 08:37:29 AM
you could ask the same question of all the witnesses who gave statements which we now know are confused, inaccurate, mistranslated etc


Which witnesses are you referring to ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 08:59:10 AM
Why would anyone need corroboration of the event ? Are you going to treat Kate's open window in the same way ? Did anyone see it open before Kate's check ?

Once the files were released Mrs Fenn had every opportunity to retract her statement or correct the parts she felt didn't accurately portray what she said. She chose not to do that. The McCanns could have asked for her to be questioned again in April 2008 to clarify what she had told the police. They chose not to. Her niece in her rogatory statement could also have mentioned that her aunt had been misquoted in her statement and was pretty peeved about it. She didn't do that.

Can you give any reason why none of the above happened other than that Mrs Fenn told the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

You are making an assumption that Mrs Fennn and her niece have read the files on the net...most unlikely..
You don't know what Mrs Fenn said because we do not have a verbatim statement
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:03:26 AM

Which witnesses are you referring to ?

It seem s Murat holds the record for the number of inconsistencies and changes of statement and I don't believe he was involved
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:16:16 AM
It seem s Murat holds the record for the number of inconsistencies and changes of statement and I don't believe he was involved
 


....and how many inconsistencies  are there with the mccanns and the rest of the group ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:17:10 AM
 


....and how many inconsistencies  are there with the mccanns and the rest of the group ?

we  don't know because we do not have verbatim statements
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:21:52 AM
we  don't know because we do not have verbatim statements

So nothing the mccanns or their associates have said can be trusted ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:27:30 AM
So nothing the mccanns or their associates have said can be trusted ?

you are confusing what they said with what was written down
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: jassi on December 05, 2015, 09:34:53 AM
you are confusing what they said with what was written down

Surely that can't be trusted either, due to translation issues.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:36:42 AM
Surely that can't be trusted either, due to translation issues.
The way the statemnets have been recorded introduces a huge margin for error
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:39:38 AM
you are confusing what they said with what was written down

Not at All.

It is well documented that the mccanns version of events has changed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:41:08 AM
Not at All.

It is well documented that the mccanns version of events has changed.

no it isn't
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:46:55 AM
no it isn't

 &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:47:43 AM
Not at All.

It is well documented that the mccanns version of events has changed.

where is it well documented
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:50:59 AM
where is it well documented

Let's start with the rather crucial......

Locked apartment, which then became unlocked.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:56:29 AM
Let's start with the rather crucial......

Locked apartment, which then became unlocked.

your source is the unreliable non verbatim twice translated statements..absolute rubbish
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 10:10:58 AM
you could ask the same question of all the witnesses who gave statements which we now know are confused, inaccurate, mistranslated etc

Mrs Fenn shows no sign of being confused. Nor has she ever claimed her statement was mistranslated or inaccurate so not sure what your point is. As to inaccurate or mistranslated statements in general can you cite the witnesses, apart from Kate McCann, who have claimed this  or is it rather like your claim of knowing the names of thousands of suspects who were named while being investigated yet when asked to provide cites gave just one, Cliff Richard.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 10:12:17 AM
your source is the unreliable non verbatim twice translated statements..absolute rubbish

No dave it isn't. &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 05, 2015, 10:31:00 AM
Yes, we do know what was said as it is in not only in  Fiona Payne's rogatory interview but in her other two friends' rogatories too.

Why are you bringing in the Tuesday night reported crying? It has nothing to do with it. You seem to either not have understood what I posted or are confused, I will try again.

KM has related (on TV) that Madeleine had asked on Thursday morning "where were you when Sean and I cried" ...referring to the night before, ie the Wednesday.

She then went on to say that if Madeleine had not been abducted, then that comment would never have crossed her mind again. Madeleine was found missing at 10 pm on Thursday. KM related the incident early on at dinner on Thursday to her friends...ergo....it did cross her mind before Madeleine was abducted.
That's it.

Curious?, contradictiry or nit picking? Choice is yours.

Children get confused with days and it could be she remembered the Tuesday night when Amelie woke Sean and then her,   it also makes sense to me as she says 'Sean and me were crying',    Mrs Fenn said she heard a child crying,   I wouldn't be surprised if that was Amelie,   followed by Sean over a period of time and then Madeleine is woken and cries Daddy.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 11:22:29 AM
Children get confused with days and it could be she remembered the Tuesday night when Amelie woke Sean and then her,   it also makes sense to me as she says 'Sean and me were crying',    Mrs Fenn said she heard a child crying,   I wouldn't be surprised if that was Amelie,   followed by Sean over a period of time and then Madeleine is woken and cries Daddy.

So do OAP get confused with days too Lace ? And how do you explain Mrs Fenn saying the crying stopped after she heard the patio door opening ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 11:40:01 AM
So do OAP get confused with days too Lace ? And how do you explain Mrs Fenn saying the crying stopped after she heard the patio door opening ?

without knowing exactly what Mrs Fenn said.....without knowing what leading questions were asked to arrive at her statement...everything is speculation. The one thing we know is that the McCanns are not considered suspects
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 11:53:13 AM
Isn't it interesting that Robert Murat, who you would think may have had a few scores to settle with the PJ, never once suggested his statement was not exactly what he said and equally never intimated that any of the interviews where he translated where conducted in less than a professional manner with all the answers of witnesses written down as spoken.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 12:00:56 PM
Isn't it interesting that Robert Murat, who you would think may have had a few scores to settle with the PJ, never once suggested his statement was not exactly what he said and equally never intimated that any of the interviews where he translated where conducted in less than a professional manner with all the answers of witnesses written down as spoken.

As he spoke fluent Portuguese it is not surprising... And it is not surprising he didn't criticise his own translations
What is surprising is that he was used as an official translator by the police....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 12:10:23 PM
Isn't it interesting that Robert Murat, who you would think may have had a few scores to settle with the PJ, never once suggested his statement was not exactly what he said and equally never intimated that any of the interviews where he translated where conducted in less than a professional manner with all the answers of witnesses written down as spoken.

 Re: The deleted Daily Express articles in chronological order

   

MADDY POLICE: WE NEED MORE TIME

Tuesday May 15,2007
Julia White
 

*snipped*
Gaynor de Jesus, who went to school with Murat and has been working for news organisations as a translator, said she thought Murat was 32.

She said: “He was a quiet guy and very friendly. His mum has helped running a stall at the scene trying to get information about the missing girl.

“She is an ex-pat widow, who married a Portuguese man. She had taken it upon herself to gather information regarding the case from the police if local people, or holidaymakers, felt uncomfortable talking to officers themselves.

“I was quite surprised by him saying he was an official translator for the police because he did not speak Portuguese fluently. But the police seemed to confirm what he was saying was true.”
 

 MADDY SUSPECT: I'M A SCAPEGOAT
Wednesday May 16,2007
By David Piditch and Matt Drake in Praia da Luz                                                   
*snipped*
Veronica Fennell, 46, who worked with Murat and Ms Wulczuch at Remax, said: “Robert was always a bit of a ‘try-hard’ – he wanted to be the focus of attention.

“We had coffee together on Sunday. He told me he had been working as a translator for the police and had signed a secrecy agreement.

“The subject of Madeleine came up and we discussed the various theories. Robert has not been around Praia da Luz much recently but he does pop back to see his mother quite a lot. He has had several business ventures which have not come to much.

“He is not much of an estate agent or even translator. When we needed things translated at Remax I used to do it and not Robert because I’m not sure he was up to scratch. That’s what surprised me about him saying he was a police translator.”
                                              ------------------------------------------------------------
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic247-10.html?sid=b60dbe32ccc1c25ffab329391fa98492



2 independent opinions, so not a very good translator after all.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 12:16:16 PM
Re: The deleted Daily Express articles in chronological order

   

MADDY POLICE: WE NEED MORE TIME

Tuesday May 15,2007
Julia White
 

*snipped*
Gaynor de Jesus, who went to school with Murat and has been working for news organisations as a translator, said she thought Murat was 32.

She said: “He was a quiet guy and very friendly. His mum has helped running a stall at the scene trying to get information about the missing girl.

“She is an ex-pat widow, who married a Portuguese man. She had taken it upon herself to gather information regarding the case from the police if local people, or holidaymakers, felt uncomfortable talking to officers themselves.

“I was quite surprised by him saying he was an official translator for the police because he did not speak Portuguese fluently. But the police seemed to confirm what he was saying was true.”
 

 MADDY SUSPECT: I'M A SCAPEGOAT
Wednesday May 16,2007
By David Piditch and Matt Drake in Praia da Luz                                                   
*snipped*
Veronica Fennell, 46, who worked with Murat and Ms Wulczuch at Remax, said: “Robert was always a bit of a ‘try-hard’ – he wanted to be the focus of attention.

“We had coffee together on Sunday. He told me he had been working as a translator for the police and had signed a secrecy agreement.

“The subject of Madeleine came up and we discussed the various theories. Robert has not been around Praia da Luz much recently but he does pop back to see his mother quite a lot. He has had several business ventures which have not come to much.

“He is not much of an estate agent or even translator. When we needed things translated at Remax I used to do it and not Robert because I’m not sure he was up to scratch. That’s what surprised me about him saying he was a police translator.”
                                              ------------------------------------------------------------
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic247-10.html?sid=b60dbe32ccc1c25ffab329391fa98492



2 independent opinions, so not a very good translator after all.

So confirmation that the PJ used translators who had poor translation skills
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 12:28:05 PM
I thought translation errors had been done to death with no examples that proved anything untoward a few moths ago.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 12:32:37 PM
I thought translation errors had been done to death with no examples that proved anything untoward a few moths ago.

Those quotes cast a few shadows on previous discussions.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 12:36:00 PM
I thought translation errors had been done to death with no examples that proved anything untoward a few moths ago.

Everything has "been done to death" wonder why you only complain when the issue doesn't fit your prejudice. 

However one learns something new every day.
I was under the impression Robert Murat was a top notch translator ... thanks to Misty's post above we now know this is not the case.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 12:39:58 PM
I thought translation errors had been done to death with no examples that proved anything untoward a few moths ago.

then you thought wrong...how can we know how accurate the translations are if we do not have the originals
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 12:49:43 PM
Re: The deleted Daily Express articles in chronological order

   

MADDY POLICE: WE NEED MORE TIME

Tuesday May 15,2007
Julia White
 

*snipped*
Gaynor de Jesus, who went to school with Murat and has been working for news organisations as a translator, said she thought Murat was 32.

She said: “He was a quiet guy and very friendly. His mum has helped running a stall at the scene trying to get information about the missing girl.

“She is an ex-pat widow, who married a Portuguese man. She had taken it upon herself to gather information regarding the case from the police if local people, or holidaymakers, felt uncomfortable talking to officers themselves.

“I was quite surprised by him saying he was an official translator for the police because he did not speak Portuguese fluently. But the police seemed to confirm what he was saying was true.”
 

 MADDY SUSPECT: I'M A SCAPEGOAT
Wednesday May 16,2007
By David Piditch and Matt Drake in Praia da Luz                                                   
*snipped*
Veronica Fennell, 46, who worked with Murat and Ms Wulczuch at Remax, said: “Robert was always a bit of a ‘try-hard’ – he wanted to be the focus of attention.

“We had coffee together on Sunday. He told me he had been working as a translator for the police and had signed a secrecy agreement.

“The subject of Madeleine came up and we discussed the various theories. Robert has not been around Praia da Luz much recently but he does pop back to see his mother quite a lot. He has had several business ventures which have not come to much.

“He is not much of an estate agent or even translator. When we needed things translated at Remax I used to do it and not Robert because I’m not sure he was up to scratch. That’s what surprised me about him saying he was a police translator.”
                                              ------------------------------------------------------------
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic247-10.html?sid=b60dbe32ccc1c25ffab329391fa98492



2 independent opinions, so not a very good translator after all.

Were these articles perhaps deleted because Murat sued the Express for libel and won substantial damages ?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/1585037/Madeleine-McCann-suspect-Robert-Murat-sues-British-media-for-libel.html
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 01:01:51 PM
Is this the same Daily Express that the McCanns sued ?

Yes it is, Faith. But not all the words in every removed article were libellous.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 01:18:26 PM
Everything has "been done to death" wonder why you only complain when the issue doesn't fit your prejudice. 

However one learns something new every day.
I was under the impression Robert Murat was a top notch translator ... thanks to Misty's post above we now know this is not the case.

One could ask you the self same question.
Since 2011 The Met have been going through the files and presumably have had the relevant documents professionally translated, have accepted some, binned others as one would, leaving punters on that tinternet to argue the toss about the efficacy of translation and criticise the skills of the translators according to ones prejudices.
My point earlier being there is already a 19 page thread on the topic on here why play groundhog day which as your posts have demonstrated is anathema to you.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 01:33:13 PM
Were these articles perhaps deleted because Murat sued the Express for libel and won substantial damages ?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/1585037/Madeleine-McCann-suspect-Robert-Murat-sues-British-media-for-libel.html

I don't recall it being the reports of his translation skills which formed part of his action against the Express (and the CdM).
He was educated at the International School & then went to live in the UK at the age of 16, where he remained for many years.
Tasmin Silence (age 12) was being educated at the International School at the time of her interview but still chose to have an interpreter present during her interview.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/T_M_S_AGE_12.htm
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 01:42:47 PM
The translation issue seems to have been raised in an attempt to discredit Mrs Fenn's statement. It's a well-established pattern now. Anything which is detrimental to the McCann story is either mistranslated or the witnesses were confused or they didn't know what time it was and so on...................
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Eleanor on December 05, 2015, 01:50:20 PM

Stay On Topic, Please.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 01:56:35 PM
The translation issue seems to have been raised in an attempt to discredit Mrs Fenn's statement. It's a well-established pattern now. Anything which is detrimental to the McCann story is either mistranslated or the witnesses were confused or they didn't know what time it was and so on...................

As I pointed out several pages back, there is no corroboration of Mrs Fenn's statement detailing her version of the truth as she heard it.
The sceptics want her statement to be totally accurate so as to provide further proof of what awful, uncaring parents the McCanns really are & must therefore be capable of far worse crimes.
The supporters merely accept that Madeleine did cry one night, but the date, duration & intensity are questionable & inconsistent with Mrs Fenn's statement.
Then you have to factor in Mrs Fenn, on camera, stating that she didn't even know the family were occupying 5a that week........
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on December 05, 2015, 02:06:41 PM
without knowing exactly what Mrs Fenn said.....without knowing what leading questions were asked to arrive at her statement...everything is speculation. The one thing we know is that the McCanns are not considered suspects

That certainly is wide open to interpretation.  If by that you mean suspect in the disappearance of their daughter then unless you are part of the Portuguese or British investigation teams or have access to inside information I suggest such a claim is unverifiable and most definately premature given that the case has not yet been determined.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 02:29:22 PM
As I pointed out several pages back, there is no corroboration of Mrs Fenn's statement detailing her version of the truth as she heard it.
The sceptics want her statement to be totally accurate so as to provide further proof of what awful, uncaring parents the McCanns really are & must therefore be capable of far worse crimes.
The supporters merely accept that Madeleine did cry one night, but the date, duration & intensity are questionable & inconsistent with Mrs Fenn's statement.
Then you have to factor in Mrs Fenn, on camera, stating that she didn't even know the family were occupying 5a that week........

I don't know whether Drs McCann are awful uncaring parents or not. They certainly left 3 children under the age of four unattended in an apartment in unfamiliar surroundings for prolonged periods of time. However you dress that up it was not the smartest of moves. Mrs Fenn's input to that is largely irrelevant. Even were she to rival Pinocchio in lies and fabricated tales it would not alter the fact of the children being left unattended.
As far as committing worse "crimes" is concerned human beings of all intellects and social standing are capable of anything. Like most on this forum I have no basis for opinion of what anyone will and will not do but am not naive enough to be shocked by peoples deeds.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on December 05, 2015, 02:42:23 PM
In unfamiliar surroundings ...

How familiar do the surroundings of a bed you are left to sleep in have to be?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 02:44:51 PM
I don't know whether Drs McCann are awful uncaring parents or not. They certainly left 3 children under the age of four unattended in an apartment in unfamiliar surroundings for prolonged periods of time. However you dress that up it was not the smartest of moves. Mrs Fenn's input to that is largely irrelevant. Even were she to rival Pinocchio in lies and fabricated tales it would not alter the fact of the children being left unattended.
As far as committing worse "crimes" is concerned human beings of all intellects and social standing are capable of anything. Like most on this forum I have no basis for opinion of what anyone will and will not do but am not naive enough to be shocked by peoples deeds.

Mrs Fenn's input was highly relevant. It called into question the true length of time between any checks the parents stated they undertook.
Children can be left to cry alone even when parents are in attendance.
Why was Mrs Fenn so sure the parents were out during the crying episode? Mrs Fenn didn't know anything about the childcare arrangements - did she?? The closing of the patio door could have been a babysitter leaving for all she knew.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 03:12:32 PM
The translation issue seems to have been raised in an attempt to discredit Mrs Fenn's statement. It's a well-established pattern now. Anything which is detrimental to the McCann story is either mistranslated or the witnesses were confused or they didn't know what time it was and so on...................

Assume nothing, believe nobody, check everything.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 03:13:43 PM
That certainly is wide open to interpretation.  If by that you mean suspect in the disappearance of their daughter then unless you are part of the Portuguese or British investigation teams or have access to inside information I suggest such a claim is unverifiable and most definately premature given that the case has not yet been determined.

it is verified by Redwood's statement
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 03:25:54 PM
Assume nothing, believe nobody, check everything.


So when did Redwood and Co. , do that with the mccanns and Co.  ? &%&£(+
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 03:31:26 PM

So when did Redwood and Co. , do that with the mccanns and Co.  ? &%&£(+

look on the appropriate thread
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: John on December 05, 2015, 03:44:43 PM
it is verified by Redwood's statement

That's old hat now Dave.  These things tend to change over time in any live and active enquiry.  Madeleine's parents were the last people known to have seen her before her disappearance and as such will always form an integral part of the investigation.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 03:50:09 PM
That's old hat now Dave.  These things tend to change over time in any live and active enquiry.  Madeleine's parents were the last people known to have seen her before her disappearance and as such will always form an integral part of the investigation.

It isn't old hat...Redwood stated that it was the opinion of SY that Madelieine was the victim of a criminal act by a stranger...I don't see they would have spent 11 million investigating in Portugal if the parents were suspects...they would rule them out first...any suggestion that the McCanns are back in the frame is pure speculation based on no evidence
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on December 05, 2015, 03:54:46 PM
That's old hat now Dave.  These things tend to change over time in any live and active enquiry.  Madeleine's parents were the last people known to have seen her before her disappearance and as such will always form an integral part of the investigation.

It's only old hat if anything has come to light since Redwood made that statement to change that position.

Is there anything in the public domain to suggest that anything has come to light?

If not, the position is the same, with the McCanns (still!) not suspects.

Has anything come to light?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 03:57:20 PM
It isn't old hat...Redwood stated that it was the opinion of SY that Madelieine was the victim of a criminal act by a stranger...I don't see they would have spent 11 million investigating in Portugal if the parents were suspects...they would rule them out first...any suggestion that the McCanns are back in the frame is pure speculation based on no evidence

Wrong thread.

OFF TOPIC.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 03:57:48 PM
It's only old hat if anything has come to light since Redwood made that statement to change that position.

Is there anything in the public domain to suggest that anything has come to light?

If not, the position is the same, with the McCanns (still!) not suspects.

Has anything come to light?

OFF TOPIC.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 04:00:40 PM
Wrong thread.

OFF TOPIC.

I was replying to John's post...so if it's off topic take it up with him
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 04:07:40 PM
In unfamiliar surroundings ...

How familiar do the surroundings of a bed you are left to sleep in have to be?

I was thinking more macro rather than your micro.
But even at your micro level the bed was hardly familiar.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 05, 2015, 04:09:21 PM
That certainly is wide open to interpretation.  If by that you mean suspect in the disappearance of their daughter then unless you are part of the Portuguese or British investigation teams or have access to inside information I suggest such a claim is unverifiable and most definately premature given that the case has not yet been determined.

How can the clear statement that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' possibly be open to interpretation?    No change to that position, or even even a hint of a change has been forthcoming.    The 'diligences' being explored by both police forces have no connection to the McCanns.   The McCanns are being kept informed of proceedings.

Unless you are a massive conspiracy theorist I don't see how anyone can place any other interpretation on that statement from the chief investigating officer as it could not be more more crystal clear and unequivecal if it tried. 

Wishful thinking doesn't count.


Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 04:14:12 PM
How can the clear statement that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' possibly be open to interpretation?    No change to that position, or even even a hint of a change has been forthcoming.    The 'diligences' being explored by both police forces have no connection to the McCanns.   The McCanns are being kept informed of proceedings.

Unless you are a massive conspiracy theorist I don't see how anyone can place any other interpretation on that statement from the chief investigating officer as it could not be more more crystal clear and unequivecal if it tried. 

Wishful thinking doesn't count.


Your last sentence epitomizes the 'abduction' theory.

NOTHING FOUND.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 04:23:18 PM
How can the clear statement that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' possibly be open to interpretation?    No change to that position, or even even a hint of a change has been forthcoming.    The 'diligences' being explored by both police forces have no connection to the McCanns.   The McCanns are being kept informed of proceedings.

Unless you are a massive conspiracy theorist I don't see how anyone can place any other interpretation on that statement from the chief investigating officer as it could not be more more crystal clear and unequivecal if it tried. 

Wishful thinking doesn't count.

I think there are a lot of massive conspiracy theorists on here
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 04:31:28 PM
I think there are a lot of massive conspiracy theorists on here

No.

However, people can see the obvious. 8((()*/
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Eleanor on December 05, 2015, 04:41:03 PM

Topic. Please.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 04:49:42 PM
Mrs Fenn's input was highly relevant. It called into question the true length of time between any checks the parents stated they undertook.
Children can be left to cry alone even when parents are in attendance.
Why was Mrs Fenn so sure the parents were out during the crying episode? Mrs Fenn didn't know anything about the childcare arrangements - did she?? The closing of the patio door could have been a babysitter leaving for all she knew.

So you believe Mrs Fenn's input of events on 1st May 2007 materially affected the fact that three children under the age of four were left unattended in an apartment on 3rd May 2007?
How precisely?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 04:55:24 PM
So you believe Mrs Fenn's input of events on 1st May 2007 materially affected the fact that three children under the age of four were left unattended in an apartment on 3rd May 2007?
How precisely?

it affects how long they were left ....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 05, 2015, 04:56:13 PM
Mrs Fenn shows no sign of being confused. Nor has she ever claimed her statement was mistranslated or inaccurate so not sure what your point is. As to inaccurate or mistranslated statements in general can you cite the witnesses, apart from Kate McCann, who have claimed this  or is it rather like your claim of knowing the names of thousands of suspects who were named while being investigated yet when asked to provide cites gave just one, Cliff Richard.
Mrs Fenn showed signs of being confused when she said to the media she hadn't even spoken to the police when clearly she had! 

You were not talking about witnesses who had claimed that their words had been mistranslated or misconstrued, you were asking why witnesses whose words may have been mistranslated or misconstrued hadn't come forward after the case had been archived to clarify matters to the public.  Why you think they would or should do this I have no idea, but as you are well aware there are many examples of muddled statements from many witnesses, which could only be explained by mistranslation, misunderstanding or misremembering.

Finally, if you wish to resurrect an old argument, I'm happy to do so on the appropriate thread, or should I not hold my breath, (like I gave up waiting for you to cite the law which forbids the police to name suspects prior to charging them. 8(0(* )
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 05:05:07 PM
it affects how long they were left ....

Namely the half hour 'checks' were fictional  and never verified independently.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 05:10:27 PM
Namely the half hour 'checks' were fictional  and never verified independently.

and never disproved
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 05:17:34 PM
and never disproved

Irrelevant.

The 'checks' amount to hearsay.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 05:20:07 PM
it affects how long they were left ....

Mrs Fenn's statement relating to events on 1st May 2007 cannot possibly affect the length of time the children were unattended on 3rd May 2007. The timings on 3rd May are the only ones relevant to the investigation into disappearance.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 05:24:35 PM
Irrelevant.

The 'checks' amount to hearsay.

you don't understand what hearsay means
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 05:27:52 PM
you don't understand what hearsay means

Oh I do.

So tell me dave, on the evening of her disappearance, after Madeleine's parents went to go drinking, when did they actually see her that night ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 05:38:19 PM
Mrs Fenn's statement relating to events on 1st May 2007 cannot possibly affect the length of time the children were unattended on 3rd May 2007. The timings on 3rd May are the only ones relevant to the investigation into disappearance.

An overall picture was being painted.

Swingers ... alcohol consumption ... children left without being checked.  Everything to do with the childcare arrangements of the party has been subjected to the closest scrutiny and expanded on.
Out of the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children ... the Drs McCann are singled out and criticised for off loading their children to kid's clubs and crèches.

That rather says it all.

I don't need a cite.  Pick a thread ... any thread ... of the forum and check out what some members have to say about it all.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 05:44:14 PM
An overall picture was being painted.

Swingers ... alcohol consumption ... children left without being checked.  Everything to do with the childcare arrangements of the party has been subjected to the closest scrutiny and expanded on.
Out of the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children ... the Drs McCann are singled out and criticised for off loading their children to kid's clubs and crèches.

That rather says it all.

I don't need a cite.  Pick a thread ... any thread ... of the forum and check out what some members have to say about it all.


Well the whole point was, that were not looking after their children in those 5 evenings. 8)-)))
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 05:48:23 PM

Well the whole point was, that were not looking after their children in those 5 evenings. 8)-)))

Their standard of childcare exceeded the legal requirements of a child listening service. Do you consider it reasonable to have to pay for childcare, within the cost of your holiday package, which falls short of the sceptic community's version of acceptable standards?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 05:54:38 PM
Their standard of childcare exceeded the legal requirements of a child listening service. Do you consider it reasonable to have to pay for childcare, within the cost of your holiday package, which falls short of the sceptic community's version of acceptable standards?

What childcare ?

They left the children in insecure accomodation whilst they drank and ate.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:00:21 PM
What childcare ?

They left the children in insecure accomodation whilst they drank and ate.

What difference would it have made if the patio door had been locked? The bedroom window appeared to be the point of entry. Would definite evidence of forced entry reduce or remove liability from a child security provider?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 05, 2015, 06:02:58 PM
I thought translation errors had been done to death with no examples that proved anything untoward a few moths ago.
(https://45.media.tumblr.com/bbfe89f9bcff427854744b3229bb7b97/tumblr_mn8fveYr8D1rk0k2jo1_500.gif)
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 06:03:15 PM
Their standard of childcare exceeded the legal requirements of a child listening service. Do you consider it reasonable to have to pay for childcare, within the cost of your holiday package, which falls short of the sceptic community's version of acceptable standards?

Are there any legal requirements for a child listening service? I've never heard of any which leave one and a quarter hours between checks, which is what these parents did according to Mrs Fenn. Unless, of course, someone was present when the child cried.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 06:08:25 PM
What difference would it have made if the patio door had been locked? The bedroom window appeared to be the point of entry. Would definite evidence of forced entry reduce or remove liability from a child security provider?

The bedroom window appears to be the point of entry ? 8**8:/:

Really ?

So when has there been independent verification it was open before 10 pm ?

and no fingerprints other than mccann have been identified.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 06:08:34 PM
An overall picture was being painted.

Swingers ... alcohol consumption ... children left without being checked.  Everything to do with the childcare arrangements of the party has been subjected to the closest scrutiny and expanded on.
Out of the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children ... the Drs McCann are singled out and criticised for off loading their children to kid's clubs and crèches.

That rather says it all.

I don't need a cite.  Pick a thread ... any thread ... of the forum and check out what some members have to say about it all.

There is no doubt that they left their children unattended and left them at kids clubs and so on. There is no doubt they dined in company without their children and consumed alcohol. That much is well documented and proven. The swingers bit was made up by the press or the Portuguese judiciary, your view on by whom dependent  on whether the school you went to played cricket or conkers. The "the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children" did not have children who vanished without trace on their holiday. That may well part way explain why the Drs McCann came under close scrutiny and those other parents didn't.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 06:10:07 PM
(https://45.media.tumblr.com/bbfe89f9bcff427854744b3229bb7b97/tumblr_mn8fveYr8D1rk0k2jo1_500.gif)

Blimey I thought for a minute we were up for re runs of Callan.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:13:18 PM
Are there any legal requirements for a child listening service? I've never heard of any which leave one and a quarter hours between checks, which is what these parents did according to Mrs Fenn. Unless, of course, someone was present when the child cried.

Mrs Fenn said no such thing. She merely said she heard a child crying & calling for her daddy, and the crying continued for 75mins. How could she possibly have known that no adult was in attendance & that the sound of the patio doors was caused by the parents returning?
What are the responsibilities of a child-listening service? Is it just to listen, as you have previously stated? What is the legal extent of their liability to safeguarding the children left in their care? Is it more or less than the responsibility displayed by the Tapas group?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:14:27 PM
The bedroom window appears to be the point of entry ? 8**8:/:

Really ?

So when has there been independent verification it was open before 10 pm ?

and no fingerprints other than mccann have been identified.

Why did you fail to answer my first question?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 06:15:27 PM
I don't recall it being the reports of his translation skills which formed part of his action against the Express (and the CdM).
He was educated at the International School & then went to live in the UK at the age of 16, where he remained for many years.
Tasmin Silence (age 12) was being educated at the International School at the time of her interview but still chose to have an interpreter present during her interview.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/T_M_S_AGE_12.htm

She was 12 misty !!
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 06:18:33 PM
Why did you fail to answer my first question?

There is nothing to answer as regards that.

Can you provide unequivocal evidence to show that anyone did enter the apartment ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 06:24:56 PM
As I pointed out several pages back, there is no corroboration of Mrs Fenn's statement detailing her version of the truth as she heard it.
The sceptics want her statement to be totally accurate so as to provide further proof of what awful, uncaring parents the McCanns really are & must therefore be capable of far worse crimes.
The supporters merely accept that Madeleine did cry one night, but the date, duration & intensity are questionable & inconsistent with Mrs Fenn's statement.
Then you have to factor in Mrs Fenn, on camera, stating that she didn't even know the family were occupying 5a that week........

Do you have a cite for that Misty or is it a myth ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 05, 2015, 06:27:29 PM
Do you have a cite for that Misty or is it a myth ?
I'm not Misty, but I just happened upon this, glad to be of service.
Pamela Fenn, 81, lives above the apartment where Madeleine disappeared and is reported to have told police she heard Madeleine screaming below.


But yesterday she broke her silence to say it was "absolute rubbish" she had made any such claims to police. Mrs Fenn said: "I didn't even know that family was in there."


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-481485/Madeleines-mother-quizzed-Portuguese-police.html#ixzz3tTLO4Zfm
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 06:29:26 PM
Mrs Fenn showed signs of being confused when she said to the media she hadn't even spoken to the police when clearly she had! 

You were not talking about witnesses who had claimed that their words had been mistranslated or misconstrued, you were asking why witnesses whose words may have been mistranslated or misconstrued hadn't come forward after the case had been archived to clarify matters to the public.  Why you think they would or should do this I have no idea, but as you are well aware there are many examples of muddled statements from many witnesses, which could only be explained by mistranslation, misunderstanding or misremembering.

Finally, if you wish to resurrect an old argument, I'm happy to do so on the appropriate thread, or should I not hold my breath, (like I gave up waiting for you to cite the law which forbids the police to name suspects prior to charging them. 8(0(* )

As I asked misty, have you a cite for Mrs Fenn's denial ?

As to the older debate, I have provided guidelines which are obviously rigid enough for the police. Why they aren't for you heaven alone knows.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:29:54 PM
She was 12 misty !!

She was brought up in Portugal & conducted the interview in Portuguese but still chose to have an interpreter present. That showed that she wasn't entirely fluent in Portuguese.
How fluent do you think RM was in Portuguese after leaving the country at 16 & spending best part of the next 15 years in the UK?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 05, 2015, 06:31:17 PM
As I asked misty, have you a cite for Mrs Fenn's denial ?

As to the older debate, I have provided guidelines which are obviously rigid enough for the police. Why they aren't for you heaven alone knows.
Point 1) see above
Point 2) You made the claim that police naming suspects was against the law, but refuse to acknowledge that you were wrong.  Never mind.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:41:37 PM
@Faithlilly
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFHbkbBh5BM
From 1.16 .
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 06:47:35 PM
There is nothing to answer as regards that.

Can you provide unequivocal evidence to show that anyone did enter the apartment ?

I am to assume from your first sentence that the unlocked patio door was an irrelevance in your opinion.

Plenty of people legitimately entered the apartment, Stephen. It's is finding evidence of the one who entered & left with Madeleine that is causing the problem.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 06:51:06 PM
I am to assume from your first sentence that the unlocked patio door was an irrelevance in your opinion.

Plenty of people legitimately entered the apartment, Stephen. It's is finding evidence of the one who entered & left with Madeleine that is causing the problem.

No kidding.

Then there is absolutely no evidence whatsoever, that a non-legitimate person ever did.

Is there ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 07:04:15 PM
No kidding.

Then there is absolutely no evidence whatsoever, that a non-legitimate person ever did.

Is there ?

I refer you back to your original question as the perpetrator remains unknown but could have legitimately left evidence at the scene.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 07:06:16 PM
I refer you back to your original question as the perpetrator remains unknown but could have legitimately left evidence at the scene.

No such evidence has been found.

Why in the singular, by the way ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 07:13:09 PM
No such evidence has been found.

Why in the singular, by the way ?

There is plenty of evidence and that is what SY & the PJ have been working through.
Only one person was required to enter the apartment & carry Madeleine out. There are, imo, others who were involved in what happened before & after she was removed from 5a.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 07:18:31 PM
There is plenty of evidence and that is what SY & the PJ have been working through.
Only one person was required to enter the apartment & carry Madeleine out. There are, imo, others who were involved in what happened before & after she was removed from 5a.

Really ???

Forensic evidence ???

Yet they have come up with nothing.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 07:22:54 PM
Really ???

Forensic evidence ???

Yet they have come up with nothing.

We know nothing about anything which may or may not have been uncovered.
Back to childcare - or are you just going to wish us all a Merry Christmas & depart until there is something concrete for you to comment on?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 07:25:01 PM
We know nothing about anything which may or may not have been uncovered.
Back to childcare - or are you just going to wish us all a Merry Christmas & depart until there is something concrete for you to comment on?

Well, there's a novel response.

Now can you tell me what the mccanns did, can be considered as 'childcare' ?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 07:29:54 PM
Well, there's a novel response.

Now can you tell me what the mccanns did, can be considered as 'childcare' ?

Their children had been fed at high tea. The parents bathed them, clothed them for bed, gave them a bedtime drink read them a story and tucked them up in bed for the night. They closed the bedroom to, then left the children to sleep, checking them regularly.
 Is that different to any normal parent?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 07:34:54 PM
(https://45.media.tumblr.com/bbfe89f9bcff427854744b3229bb7b97/tumblr_mn8fveYr8D1rk0k2jo1_500.gif)

I think that's Redwood's 'light bulb moment'.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 07:41:11 PM
Their children had been fed at high tea. The parents bathed them, clothed them for bed, gave them a bedtime drink read them a story and tucked them up in bed for the night. They closed the bedroom to, then left the children to sleep, checking them regularly.
 Is that different to any normal parent?

You mean leaving by themselves, unprotected in unlocked accomodation, whilst they went out to eat and drink ?

Do you think, normal loving parents do that ?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 07:44:28 PM
What difference would it have made if the patio door had been locked? The bedroom window appeared to be the point of entry. Would definite evidence of forced entry reduce or remove liability from a child security provider?

There is no evidence that anyone entered via the window. There isn't even any evidence that the window was ever open. I don't know what the legal liabillity of 'a child security provider' is. What sort of security?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 08:01:39 PM
There is no evidence that anyone entered via the window. There isn't even any evidence that the window was ever open. I don't know what the legal liabillity of 'a child security provider' is. What sort of security?

Kate's testimony is evidence ....
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 08:03:21 PM
I think that's Redwood's 'light bulb moment'.

ridiculing redwood because you do not like what he said
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 08:09:49 PM
You mean leaving by themselves, unprotected in unlocked accomodation, whilst they went out to eat and drink ?

Do you think, normal loving parents do that ?

All children should be left by themselves to sleep if they are fit & well.

So, the unlocked door is actually an issue for you. It would have been unlocked if the parents had dined on the patio. The bedroom would have been out of sight, as would the bedroom window.
It's really just a question of "how far is too far?" as there certainly is no evidence of any other form of sustained neglect.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 08:12:12 PM
There is no evidence that anyone entered via the window. There isn't even any evidence that the window was ever open. I don't know what the legal liabillity of 'a child security provider' is. What sort of security?

Child security = the type of security you say the parents failed to provide when the children were in bed, asleep.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ferryman on December 05, 2015, 08:13:00 PM
I'm not Misty, but I just happened upon this, glad to be of service.
Pamela Fenn, 81, lives above the apartment where Madeleine disappeared and is reported to have told police she heard Madeleine screaming below.


But yesterday she broke her silence to say it was "absolute rubbish" she had made any such claims to police. Mrs Fenn said: "I didn't even know that family was in there."


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-481485/Madeleines-mother-quizzed-Portuguese-police.html#ixzz3tTLO4Zfm
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

For a while, I was utterly convinced by that.

But there are a couple of points to note.

The first is that Mrs Fenn was interviewed by Joao Carlos, a fundamentally honest cove, certainly interested in getting at the truth of what happened to Madeleine.

The second is that there is a separate video (somewhere) of a hairdresser-type blabbing to reporters (no doubt for a fee) of what Mrs Fenn said to the PJ.

Piecing it all together, I think Mrs Fenn blabbed to hairdresser-type; hairdresser-type blabbed the rest of-the-world and rest-of-the world descended on Mrs Fenn for a follow-up story.

Mrs Fenn, aghast and realising the (potential) implications of breaching Portuguese secrecy laws, clammed up and denied everything.

I haven't, always, but I (now) incline to the view that Joao Carlos' report is a broadly accurate rending of what Mrs Fenn said ...
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 08:13:08 PM
All children should be left by themselves to sleep if they are fit & well.

So, the unlocked door is actually an issue for you. It would have been unlocked if the parents had dined on the patio. The bedroom would have been out of sight, as would the bedroom window.
It's really just a question of "how far is too far?" as there certainly is no evidence of any other form of sustained neglect.

ARE YOU FOR REAL ?


 &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 08:16:13 PM
Difficult to find anything about legal liability, but here's one;

Baby listening A baby listening service is available; this service in no way allows parents to relinquish responsibility for their children. While using this service parents must monitor their children at all times. Watergate Bay Hotel cannot be held responsible for any failures of the baby listening equipment. - See more at: http://www.watergatebay.co.uk/stay/book-online/booking-terms/#sthash.t9Ou0FWz.dpuf
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 08:17:53 PM
ARE YOU FOR REAL ?


 &%&£(+ &%&£(+ &%&£(+

Please state which points you disagree with & your reasons for doing so.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 08:20:52 PM
Difficult to find anything about legal liability, but here's one;

Baby listening A baby listening service is available; this service in no way allows parents to relinquish responsibility for their children. While using this service parents must monitor their children at all times. Watergate Bay Hotel cannot be held responsible for any failures of the baby listening equipment. - See more at: http://www.watergatebay.co.uk/stay/book-online/booking-terms/#sthash.t9Ou0FWz.dpuf

So they're not really offering anything more than holding the baby monitor for you...............you're still expected to scurry back & forth checking your child every half hour........
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 08:22:33 PM
All children should be left by themselves to sleep if they are fit & well.

So, the unlocked door is actually an issue for you. It would have been unlocked if the parents had dined on the patio. The bedroom would have been out of sight, as would the bedroom window.
It's really just a question of "how far is too far?" as there certainly is no evidence of any other form of sustained neglect.

Your attempts to defend these parents get more bizarre every time you post. It's wrong to leave children home alone end of.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 08:32:07 PM
Children get confused with days and it could be she remembered the Tuesday night when Amelie woke Sean and then her,   it also makes sense to me as she says 'Sean and me were crying',    Mrs Fenn said she heard a child crying,   I wouldn't be surprised if that was Amelie,   followed by Sean over a period of time and then Madeleine is woken and cries Daddy.

Fiona said she thought it was the Wednesday, Rachel said Kate told her it was the Wednesday and Jane said Kate thought she probably didnt awake and was just saying it! The point is, it doesnt matter what day it was, the point is, that Kate said the conversation with Madeleine would never have crossed her mind again had Madeleine not been abducted, but it obviously did, and my question was why did she very emphatically state that it would not have. As I said, curious, contradictory or nit picking.
Watch from 1 minute

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 08:36:16 PM
Difficult to find anything about legal liability, but here's one;

Baby listening A baby listening service is available; this service in no way allows parents to relinquish responsibility for their children. While using this service parents must monitor their children at all times. Watergate Bay Hotel cannot be held responsible for any failures of the baby listening equipment. - See more at: http://www.watergatebay.co.uk/stay/book-online/booking-terms/#sthash.t9Ou0FWz.dpuf

I have stayed at this hotel and raised the point before. The listening service is designed so parents can eat at Jamie olivers 15 which is out of the hotel and across the otherside of a large car park. The restaurant does not allow children after 7pm so parents are told they can leave their children asleep in their room and reception will listen on the room intercom. How can you possibly monitor your children when you are not even in the building
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 08:55:08 PM
There is no doubt that they left their children unattended and left them at kids clubs and so on. There is no doubt they dined in company without their children and consumed alcohol. That much is well documented and proven. The swingers bit was made up by the press or the Portuguese judiciary, your view on by whom dependent  on whether the school you went to played cricket or conkers. The "the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children" did not have children who vanished without trace on their holiday. That may well part way explain why the Drs McCann came under close scrutiny and those other parents didn't.

I see.  It is the fact that the Drs McCann were the victims of the most heinous crime imaginable which uniquely allows the scrutiny of their childcare arrangements by some.

That all the eggs of that scrutiny are in the basket of the discarded thesis of parental involvement which declines any mention of those responsible for abducting Madeleine McCann seems extraordinary.
As is the total failure to recognise the evidence led investigations and searches for those responsible for Madeleine's abduction presently being carried out by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 09:03:53 PM
All children should be left by themselves to sleep if they are fit & well.

So, the unlocked door is actually an issue for you. It would have been unlocked if the parents had dined on the patio. The bedroom would have been out of sight, as would the bedroom window.
It's really just a question of "how far is too far?" as there certainly is no evidence of any other form of sustained neglect.

Do you not understand the basic concept of within sight and hearing in a secure dwelling? By your logic if they had been 30 miles away it would be ok if they had a private helicopter to hand and could be there in a minute every half an hour to check!!

Put this scenario to any judge ie leaving three toddlers left to their own devices, NOT older kids/teengers who understand dangers, and you would get a right bloody scolding! As well as laughed out.

Ps

Do you know the ages that baby listening services cater for? And in what physical  circumstances?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:10:23 PM
I see.  It is the fact that the Drs McCann were the victims of the most heinous crime imaginable which uniquely allows the scrutiny of their childcare arrangements by some.

That all the eggs of that scrutiny are in the basket of the discarded thesis of parental involvement which declines any mention of those responsible for abducting Madeleine McCann seems extraordinary.
As is the total failure to recognise the evidence led investigations and searches for those responsible for Madeleine's abduction presently being carried out by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria.

You do not know they were the victims. That is your belief.................

However, Madeleine was.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:12:25 PM
You do not know they were the victims. That is your belief.................

However, Madeleine was.

I'm sure they are victims...based on everything I have seen and read
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:14:00 PM
I'm sure they are victims...based on everything I have seen and read

No , just a belief.

CRIME UNKNOWN.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 09:16:29 PM
You do not know they were the victims. That is your belief.................

However, Madeleine was.

So in your opinion having your daughter abducted does not make them victims ... no surprise there.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:18:03 PM
So in your opinion having your daughter abducted does not make them victims ... no surprise there.

I was waiting for that mantra.

Abduction has not been proved, as has any other scenario.

Try to keep up.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 09:19:14 PM
I was waiting for that mantra.

Abduction has not been proved, as has any other scenario.

Try to keep up.

I asked you to substantiate the accusation you made against me.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 05, 2015, 09:19:42 PM
Fiona said she thought it was the Wednesday, Rachel said Kate told her it was the Wednesday and Jane said Kate thought she probably didnt awake and was just saying it! The point is, it doesnt matter what day it was, the point is, that Kate said the conversation with Madeleine would never have crossed her mind again had Madeleine not been abducted, but it obviously did, and my question was why did she very emphatically state that it would not have. As I said, curious, contradictory or nit picking.

As is normal in this case the story changed;

Kate. 4th May;

She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.

Gerry. 4th May;

Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

Fiona 2008;

'Sean and I woke up and we were crying mummy and where were you''.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm

Kate's book Page 62;

why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night?

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Mr Gray on December 05, 2015, 09:21:40 PM
As is normal in this case the story changed;

Kate. 4th May;

She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.

Gerry. 4th May;

Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

Fiona 2008;

'Sean and I woke up and we were crying mummy and where were you''.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm

Kate's book Page 62;

why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night?

as normal you compare a direct quote from kate to the badly translated statements
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 09:31:10 PM
How can the clear statement that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects or persons of interest' possibly be open to interpretation?    No change to that position, or even even a hint of a change has been forthcoming.    The 'diligences' being explored by both police forces have no connection to the McCanns.    The McCanns are being kept informed of proceedings.

Unless you are a massive conspiracy theorist I don't see how anyone can place any other interpretation on that statement from the chief investigating officer as it could not be more more crystal clear and unequivecal if it tried. 

Wishful thinking doesn't count.

That is the answer to your opening question.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 09:42:17 PM
As is normal in this case the story changed;

Kate. 4th May;

She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.

Gerry. 4th May;

Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

Fiona 2008;

'Sean and I woke up and we were crying mummy and where were you''.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm

Kate's book Page 62;

why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night?

Judging from their form and attitude to date it wouldnt surprise me if the Mccanns didnt care about making things clear...they never have much...its always someone elses fault
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: misty on December 05, 2015, 09:49:42 PM
If you can't see that by now, you never will.

It is unbelievable what some people will do to defend the mccanns, in the face of simple logic.

Your excuses will never wash.

So the question is therefore, why do you post on here.................

Apologies - I had to leave my laptop alone for a while - rather like fit & well children being left to sleep alone in their bedrooms - while I was in another room. But could I see or hear the laptop/children from that other room or were they unsupervised & alone? Oh, and my front door was open.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: stephen25000 on December 05, 2015, 09:51:59 PM
Apologies - I had to leave my laptop alone for a while - rather like fit & well children being left to sleep alone in their bedrooms - while I was in another room. But could I see or hear the laptop/children from that other room or were they unsupervised & alone? Oh, and my front door was open.

Yet another absurd, and all too predictable response to defend the indefensible.


.......and were you out for hours, eating and drinking ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 05, 2015, 10:25:11 PM
@Faithlilly
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFHbkbBh5BM
From 1.16 .

Not sure how this proves your point misty. Mrs Fenn says that it's all rubbish. That she has never spoken to a journalist. She is obviously talking about newspaper reports and not what was in her statement.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 05, 2015, 11:27:39 PM
I see.  It is the fact that the Drs McCann were the victims of the most heinous crime imaginable which uniquely allows the scrutiny of their childcare arrangements by some.

That all the eggs of that scrutiny are in the basket of the discarded thesis of parental involvement which declines any mention of those responsible for abducting Madeleine McCann seems extraordinary.
As is the total failure to recognise the evidence led investigations and searches for those responsible for Madeleine's abduction presently being carried out by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria.

I am glad you do see but you seem unable to counter facts I have posted, except with your own speculations and opinions.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 11:36:58 PM
I am glad you do see but you seem unable to counter facts I have posted, except with your own speculations and opinions.

Thats  the rub, ive had the same problem lol

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 05, 2015, 11:49:45 PM
I am glad you do see but you seem unable to counter facts I have posted, except with your own speculations and opinions.

It is a fact however unpalatable you and others may find it to be that the original thesis is not one being 'worked' by either Scotland Yard or the Policia Judiciaria as neither of the Drs McCann nor any of their companions feature in the investigation ... apart from the Drs McCann being kept up to date with the progress of the case.

It is a fact that the theory of accidental death has been discarded as it has been affirmed that SY are investigating abduction by a stranger.

It is a fact that people have been interviewed under the auspices of the PJ as persons of interest and as arguidos none of whom are known to the Drs McCann or their friends.

It is a fact that the Drs McCann have been traduced for over eight years with every tool in the box used as a weapon against them ... in particular their child care arrangements in which Mrs Fenn inadvertently found herself having a more than unwelcome walk on part.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 05, 2015, 11:52:48 PM
It is a fact however unpalatable you and others may find it to be that the original thesis is not one being 'worked' by either Scotland Yard or the Plolicia Judiciaria as neither of the Drs McCann nor any of their companions feature in the investigation ... apart from the Drs McCann being kept up to date with the progress of the case.

It is a fact that the theory of accidental death has been discarded as it has been affirmed that SY are investigating abduction by a stranger.

It is a fact that people have been interviewed under the auspices of the PJ as persons of interest and as arguidos none of whom are known to the Drs McCann or their friends.

It is a fact that the Drs McCann have been traduced for over eight years with every tool in the box used as a weapon against them ... in particular their child care arrangements in which Mrs Fenn inadvertently found herself having a more than unwelcome walk on part.


Poor, very poor

Sorry to but in btw


 @)(++(*
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 09:15:48 AM
Fiona said she thought it was the Wednesday, Rachel said Kate told her it was the Wednesday and Jane said Kate thought she probably didnt awake and was just saying it! The point is, it doesnt matter what day it was, the point is, that Kate said the conversation with Madeleine would never have crossed her mind again had Madeleine not been abducted, but it obviously did, and my question was why did she very emphatically state that it would not have. As I said, curious, contradictory or nit picking.
Watch from 1 minute


I know what Kate said mercury.   

Madeleine disappeared AFTER Kate had mentioned it to Fiona,   don't you get that?   AFTER.   Kate said if Madeleine hadn't disappeared the remark would never have crossed her mind again,   so she would never have wondered about the remark if Madeleine hadn't disappeared as it was a fleeting remark that was soon forgotten about by Madeleine.

As to the day Madeleine was crying with Sean,  how could it have been the Wednesday when Kate was there in the room with them?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 10:22:48 AM
I know what Kate said mercury.   

Madeleine disappeared AFTER Kate had mentioned it to Fiona,   don't you get that?   AFTER.   Kate said if Madeleine hadn't disappeared the remark would never have crossed her mind again,   so she would never have wondered about the remark if Madeleine hadn't disappeared as it was a fleeting remark that was soon forgotten about by Madeleine.

As to the day Madeleine was crying with Sean,  how could it have been the Wednesday when Kate was there in the room with them?

Just to be logical;

Madeleine asked her parents where they were, then moved on. A passing remark which Kate said she wouldn't have ever thought about if Madeleine hadn't disappeared. But she did think about it before Madeleine disappeared; she told her friends about it before the disappearence.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 10:51:55 AM
Just to be logical;

Madeleine asked her parents where they were, then moved on. A passing remark which Kate said she wouldn't have ever thought about if Madeleine hadn't disappeared. But she did think about it before Madeleine disappeared; she told her friends about it before the disappearence.

You beat me to it G. As to it not being Wednesday night, is it not also logical to assume Madeleine cried while her parents were out.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 11:13:46 AM
Just to be logical;

Madeleine asked her parents where they were, then moved on. A passing remark which Kate said she wouldn't have ever thought about if Madeleine hadn't disappeared. But she did think about it before Madeleine disappeared; she told her friends about it before the disappearence.

Yes and Madeleine disappeared so Kate mentioned what Madeleine had said to them to the police,   if she hadn't disappeared she wouldn't have mentioned the comment.  That is what I believe Kate McCann means.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 11:17:03 AM
You beat me to it G. As to it not being Wednesday night, is it not also logical to assume Madeleine cried while her parents were out.

Yes it is logical to assume that Madeleine cried while the McCann's were out,  but some seem to believe that Madeleine cried for the length of time that Mrs. Fenn said she did,  even making a video with a child crying and saying this is what happened to Madeleine and that she asked her parents why didn't you come when I was crying,  when in actual fact she said 'when Sean and me were crying'   so that video has no bearing what so ever on what happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:18:21 AM
Yes and Madeleine disappeared so Kate mentioned what Madeleine had said to them to the police,   if she hadn't disappeared she wouldn't have mentioned the comment.  That is what I believe Kate McCann means.

But she did mention it, and before Madeleine disappeared.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 06, 2015, 11:19:58 AM
I know what Kate said mercury.   

Madeleine disappeared AFTER Kate had mentioned it to Fiona,   don't you get that?   AFTER.   Kate said if Madeleine hadn't disappeared the remark would never have crossed her mind again,   so she would never have wondered about the remark if Madeleine hadn't disappeared as it was a fleeting remark that was soon forgotten about by Madeleine.

As to the day Madeleine was crying with Sean,  how could it have been the Wednesday when Kate was there in the room with them?


I agree Lace - IMO Basically  Kate is saying that if they had woken up on the morning of 4th May in the normal way and nothing untoward had happened  - then they would just have carried on with their day as usual  - and what Madeleine had said the previous morning would never had been thought about again - as nothing would have happened to cause them to think about it again.

It was only AFTER Madeleine had been taken and BECAUSE she had been taken -  that the comment took on a possible significance which it didn't have at the time she said it to them - and so they decided to tell the PJ.  And that was the point that Kate was trying to get across IMO.     

The fact that she talked to her friends during dinner on the night before would be of no relevance to that point she was making during the interview- as that took place BEFORE Madeleine disappeared and was in a completely different context.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 11:21:50 AM
Yes it is logical to assume that Madeleine cried while the McCann's were out,  but some seem to believe that Madeleine cried for the length of time that Mrs. Fenn said she did,  even making a video with a child crying and saying this is what happened to Madeleine and that she asked her parents why didn't you come when I was crying,  when in actual fact she said 'when Sean and me were crying'   so that video has no bearing what so ever on what happened to Madeleine.

You are confusing two nights Lace. We are talking about the Wedneday night. Mrs Fenn heard a child crying on the Tuesday night. Two different nights, two different times, it would seem, that MadeleineBeas left alone to cry. Not sure what the video has to do with it.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 11:47:26 AM
Yes and Madeleine disappeared so Kate mentioned what Madeleine had said to them to the police,   if she hadn't disappeared she wouldn't have mentioned the comment.  That is what I believe Kate McCann means.

So talking to her friends about it doesn't count? I wonder why....

Kate made sure she told the police on 4th May;

 She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

So did Gerry;

referring to an episode on the morning of the 3rd May, when Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

I expect the translator didn't grasp the difference between 'Sean and I' and 'the twins'.

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 11:51:25 AM
So talking to her friends about it doesn't count? I wonder why....

Kate made sure she told the police on 4th May;

 She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

So did Gerry;

referring to an episode on the morning of the 3rd May, when Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

I expect the translator didn't grasp the difference between 'Sean and I' and 'the twins'.

I don't believe Madeleine cried at all on the Wednesday night,   I believe it was the Tuesday night Madeleine was talking about.

No child of almost four would cry for the length of time Mrs. Fenn said she heard her crying,   if it had been Madeleine then she would surely have shouted Daddy sooner or have gone into their bedroom.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 11:55:04 AM
You are confusing two nights Lace. We are talking about the Wedneday night. Mrs Fenn heard a child crying on the Tuesday night. Two different nights, two different times, it would seem, that MadeleineBeas left alone to cry. Not sure what the video has to do with it.

The video has everything to do with it.    A video was made of a child screaming and crying making out that is what Madeleine would sounded like,   the video is linking the 'why didn't you come when I cried'   to the Tuesday night when Mrs. Fenn said she heard crying.

It was a nasty cruel thing to do making that video as the maker had no idea what night Madeleine had been talking about.   Wednesday night Kate McCann was in the bedroom with the children.   Tuesday night Amelie woke up and woke Sean and Madeleine, that is probably the crying that Mrs. Fenn heard.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 06, 2015, 11:59:49 AM
So talking to her friends about it doesn't count? I wonder why....

Kate made sure she told the police on 4th May;

 She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

So did Gerry;

referring to an episode on the morning of the 3rd May, when Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

I expect the translator didn't grasp the difference between 'Sean and I' and 'the twins'.

Kate did make sure she told the police about what Madeleine said as she was linking the stain on Madeleine's top with what she said,   wondering if someone had tried to sedate her on the Wednesday night and failed.

The translator could have got confused especially if Kate had mentioned the Tuesday night too when the twins woke up,  or maybe she just said she has twins and that confused him/her.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 06, 2015, 12:23:47 PM
The video has everything to do with it.    A video was made of a child screaming and crying making out that is what Madeleine would sounded like,   the video is linking the 'why didn't you come when I cried'   to the Tuesday night when Mrs. Fenn said she heard crying.

It was a nasty cruel thing to do making that video as the maker had no idea what night Madeleine had been talking about.   Wednesday night Kate McCann was in the bedroom with the children.   Tuesday night Amelie woke up and woke Sean and Madeleine, that is probably the crying that Mrs. Fenn heard.

You're tying yourself in knots Lace. Mrs Fenn heard the crying on the Tuesday. She is quite clear on that. Kate believed Madeleine's comment was about the Wednesday night as she thoight that an intruder had perhaps entered the apartment the night before Madeleine disappeared and waking her.


This is what Gerry said in his arguido interview about the night Madeleine came through to his bedroom :

'
'--- When asked, he says that on one night, he cannot say which, Madeleine slept in his room in his bed. He thinks it might have been shortly after their arrival at the apartment. Madeleine came to his room saying that Amelie was crying and she couldn't sleep. He thinks that he hadn't heard crying before, and was alerted to this by Madeleine. He does not know if he or his wife comforted Amelie. That night Madeleine slept in his bed.'

Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 12:31:30 PM
Kate did make sure she told the police about what Madeleine said as she was linking the stain on Madeleine's top with what she said,   wondering if someone had tried to sedate her on the Wednesday night and failed.

The translator could have got confused especially if Kate had mentioned the Tuesday night too when the twins woke up,  or maybe she just said she has twins and that confused him/her.

Kate didn't mention the Tuesday. This is what she said;

gemeos tinham chorado


twins had been crying

After having read the deed, she confirms it, ratifies it and signs it with the interpreter.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

Gerald's statement says the same and he signed also.

No mentin of stains, no mention of Madeleine crying, no mention of Tuesday.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Benice on December 06, 2015, 12:38:42 PM
So talking to her friends about it doesn't count? I wonder why....

Kate made sure she told the police on 4th May;

 She reports only one episode where, on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

So did Gerry;

referring to an episode on the morning of the 3rd May, when Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.

I expect the translator didn't grasp the difference between 'Sean and I' and 'the twins'.

Personally I prefer to take what Kate said herself in person during that interview, than rely on multi-translated statements which would originally have been made up of much longer conversations  -  much of which would not be included in the shortened summarised version of the interview that we see -  and so we don't know everything that was said.       

Also these are statements which apparently were  inaccurate enough by the time they had been translated back and forth by amateurs -   that it was deemed necessary to have them professionally translated.     Even the translators themselves have commented more than once on the difficulties encountered trying to achieve accurate translations.

If you want to regard them as completely accurate - that's your prerogative.   IMO only verbatim statements can be relied upon with any confidence when it comes to accuracy. 




Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: G-Unit on December 06, 2015, 01:11:58 PM
Personally I prefer to take what Kate said herself in person during that interview, than rely on multi-translated statements which would originally have been made up of much longer conversations  -  much of which would not be included in the shortened summarised version of the interview that we see -  and so we don't know everything that was said.       

Also these are statements which apparently were  inaccurate enough by the time they had been translated back and forth by amateurs -   that it was deemed necessary to have them professionally translated.     Even the translators themselves have commented more than once on the difficulties encountered trying to achieve accurate translations.

If you want to regard them as completely accurate - that's your prerogative.   IMO only verbatim statements can be relied upon with any confidence when it comes to accuracy.

I think you need to stop casting aspersions on the translators. I have taken the original Portuguese text which was translated from English by a professional translator. Both witnesses agreed with and signed their statements.

We had a thread on mistaken translations which revealed nothing at all.

The parents changed their account of what their daughter said and I can find no record of them saying their first statements were wrongly translated.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 06, 2015, 03:56:02 PM
Not sure how this proves your point misty. Mrs Fenn says that it's all rubbish. That she has never spoken to a journalist. She is obviously talking about newspaper reports and not what was in her statement.

If you look at the quote in the mail, it is fairly obvious that Mrs Fenn's denial is to do with her supposedly saying she heard Madeleine crying. She didn't know the family below so how could she have known she was called Madeleine.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 06, 2015, 04:07:33 PM
It is a fact however unpalatable you and others may find it to be that the original thesis is not one being 'worked' by either Scotland Yard or the Policia Judiciaria as neither of the Drs McCann nor any of their companions feature in the investigation ... apart from the Drs McCann being kept up to date with the progress of the case.

It is a fact that the theory of accidental death has been discarded as it has been affirmed that SY are investigating abduction by a stranger.

It is a fact that people have been interviewed under the auspices of the PJ as persons of interest and as arguidos none of whom are known to the Drs McCann or their friends.

It is a fact that the Drs McCann have been traduced for over eight years with every tool in the box used as a weapon against them ... in particular their child care arrangements in which Mrs Fenn inadvertently found herself having a more than unwelcome walk on part.

My original post said:
"There is no doubt that they left their children unattended and left them at kids clubs and so on. There is no doubt they dined in company without their children and consumed alcohol. That much is well documented and proven. The swingers bit was made up by the press or the Portuguese judiciary, your view on by whom dependent  on whether the school you went to played cricket or conkers. The "the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children" did not have children who vanished without trace on their holiday. That may well part way explain why the Drs McCann came under close scrutiny and those other parents didn't."

It is somewhat difficult to work out how your post above follows on from that.
Perhaps you will be kind enough to elucidate?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 06, 2015, 05:59:33 PM
My original post said:
"There is no doubt that they left their children unattended and left them at kids clubs and so on. There is no doubt they dined in company without their children and consumed alcohol. That much is well documented and proven. The swingers bit was made up by the press or the Portuguese judiciary, your view on by whom dependent  on whether the school you went to played cricket or conkers. The "the thousands (possibly millions) of parents and children who have and continue to enjoy holidays with attractions catering for adults and children" did not have children who vanished without trace on their holiday. That may well part way explain why the Drs McCann came under close scrutiny and those other parents didn't."

It is somewhat difficult to work out how your post above follows on from that.
Perhaps you will be kind enough to elucidate?


First post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291286#msg291286

Second post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291294#msg291294

Third post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291337#msg291337

Fourth post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291429#msg291429

Fifth post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291447#msg291447

Sixth post in the conversation
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6811.msg291529#msg291529


You are having difficulty for the simple reason the post to which I was replying was the fifth one in which you posted ...

"I am glad you do see but you seem unable to counter facts I have posted, except with your own speculations and opinions."

 ... and not as you ... imply ... the third post which you have reposted.

So not at all difficult to work out " ... how your post above follows on from that." for the very simple fact that it does not.

Whatever your game is take note ... I am not playing it.  I find it devious and to be truthful very creepy indeed.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 06, 2015, 06:53:51 PM
If you look at the quote in the mail, it is fairly obvious that Mrs Fenn's denial is to do with her supposedly saying she heard Madeleine crying. She didn't know the family below so how could she have known she was called Madeleine.
I would have thought that during the 4th or 5th of May she would have become aware that the incident was in 5A, that it involved a family called the McCanns, and that it involved a 3 year old girl called Madeleine.

It might have taken a bit longer to drip through that the McCanns had twins, and that there were other families in the party, also with young children.  But not much longer, surely.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 06, 2015, 07:41:24 PM
I would have thought that during the 4th or 5th of May she would have become aware that the incident was in 5A, that it involved a family called the McCanns, and that it involved a 3 year old girl called Madeleine.

It might have taken a bit longer to drip through that the McCanns had twins, and that there were other families in the party, also with young children.  But not much longer, surely.

If I remember correctly, she was a resident and probably didn't take much notice of transient holiday makers. I don't think her statement mentioned Madeleine.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 06, 2015, 08:05:16 PM
If I remember correctly, she was a resident and probably didn't take much notice of transient holiday makers. I don't think her statement mentioned Madeleine.
By 4 May 2007, her home was behind a GNR cordon, the place was bedecked with police tape and festooned with the media.

If she didn't twig there was something afoot she was very odd indeed.

Plus, we would have to believe that none of her friends or family got on the phone to her to discuss the rumpus in her neck of the woods.

Her statement does not mention Madeleine.  It is to the effect that a child was crying on the floor below her, and that child was not of 2 years age or younger.

If she did not know about the twins and their age when she gave the statement, I shall eat my hat.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 06, 2015, 08:11:46 PM
By 4 May 2007, her home was behind a GNR cordon, the place was bedecked with police tape and festooned with the media.

If she didn't twig there was something afoot she was very odd indeed.

Plus, we would have to believe that none of her friends or family got on the phone to her to discuss the rumpus in her neck of the woods.

Her statement does not mention Madeleine.  It is to the effect that a child was crying on the floor below her, and that child was not of 2 years age or younger.

If she did not know about the twins and their age when she gave the statement, I shall eat my hat.

You seem to be expecting a witness to state something she couldn't possible state for certain? Whether she suspected that it was Madeleine is immaterial.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 06, 2015, 09:07:45 PM
You seem to be expecting a witness to state something she couldn't possible state for certain? Whether she suspected that it was Madeleine is immaterial.
Don't know why you've reached this conclusion, when what I said was the opposite.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 06, 2015, 11:01:27 PM
I know what Kate said mercury.   

Madeleine disappeared AFTER Kate had mentioned it to Fiona,   don't you get that?   AFTER.   Kate said if Madeleine hadn't disappeared the remark would never have crossed her mind again,   so she would never have wondered about the remark if Madeleine hadn't disappeared as it was a fleeting remark that was soon forgotten about by Madeleine.

I get that, I bleedin posted it to start with, it seems you dont get a few thngs


She did wonder about the remark before the abduction and said to her friend that because of the remark she was wondering if it was a good idea to leave the back door open so Madeleine could go find them if she woke up again.....but Gerry tells us the back door was left open after a couple nights in the holiday, so that didnt make sense either...anythng else?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 07, 2015, 12:29:22 PM
I get that, I bleedin posted it to start with, it seems you dont get a few thngs


She did wonder about the remark before the abduction and said to her friend that because of the remark she was wondering if it was a good idea to leave the back door open so Madeleine could go find them if she woke up again.....but Gerry tells us the back door was left open after a couple nights in the holiday, so that didnt make sense either...anythng else?

NO
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 01:06:25 PM
NO

Care to elaborate lace ?
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Lace on December 07, 2015, 03:14:52 PM
Care to elaborate lace ?

Not really,  don't know why some posters need to be so rude.

It's getting boring now,  she said he said,  so what?   They left the patio doors open end of.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 04:19:04 PM
Not really,  don't know why some posters need to be so rude.

It's getting boring now,  she said he said,  so what?   They left the patio doors open end of.

"What's done cannot be undone" Lady Macbeth (Act 5, scene 1, 68).  I too am finding the time warp thing tiresome, then I'm not too sure that isn't the name of the game.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 07, 2015, 04:32:52 PM
"What's done cannot be undone" Lady Macbeth (Act 5, scene 1, 68).  I too am finding the time warp thing tiresome, then I'm not too sure that isn't the name of the game.

I thought the game was stating that everything is boring, being repeated or pointless rather than address the genuine questions. Seems to be happening a lot recently.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 07:01:11 PM
I thought the game was stating that everything is boring, being repeated or pointless rather than address the genuine questions. Seems to be happening a lot recently.

What are the genuine questions, Slarti?

The McCann childcare arrangements for example have been known from the first and while nothing can be really cast in tablets of stone regarding them ... what is left to question?
If you are not fed up with reinventing slurs on the Drs McCann and their friends ... it may surprise you that I for one find it tedious.

Time surely to up the game and indulge in some serious and informative discussion at which posters like Lordpookles excel.  LP can discuss ... can argue without rancour ... and very often has an interesting opinion to express which is very often at variance with mine.

That is the value of this forum.  Civilised discussion where different points of view are expressed. There may be those who abhor that, I don't know, but some of the downright rudeness creeping into posts does none of us any favours.

If I had wanted to join a McCann bashing forum I would have been spoilt for choice ... I am dismayed when I see it here.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: slartibartfast on December 07, 2015, 11:27:29 PM
What are the genuine questions, Slarti?

The McCann childcare arrangements for example have been known from the first and while nothing can be really cast in tablets of stone regarding them ... what is left to question?
If you are not fed up with reinventing slurs on the Drs McCann and their friends ... it may surprise you that I for one find it tedious.

Time surely to up the game and indulge in some serious and informative discussion at which posters like Lordpookles excel.  LP can discuss ... can argue without rancour ... and very often has an interesting opinion to express which is very often at variance with mine.

That is the value of this forum.  Civilised discussion where different points of view are expressed. There may be those who abhor that, I don't know, but some of the downright rudeness creeping into posts does none of us any favours.

If I had wanted to join a McCann bashing forum I would have been spoilt for choice ... I am dismayed when I see it here.

... As others dismay when seeing a McCann worshiping forum.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 11:30:41 PM
... As others dismay when seeing a McCann worshiping forum.

Not sure how Brietta intends to take part in some interesting discussion if she ignores everyone who disagrees with her. Ah well perhaps for a supporter it's safer that way !
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: Eleanor on December 07, 2015, 11:35:39 PM

CARE ARRANGEMENTS.
Title: Re: The childcare arrangements or lack of them reviewed.
Post by: mercury on December 12, 2015, 10:59:53 PM
CARE ARRANGEMENTS.

care arrangements entailed leaving  three toddlers on their own and front and back door unlocked..you asked i answered

 8((()*/


some care hey?

I think  the minimum we can say is the mccanns werent arsed